Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Abstract
Eccentric exercise has been shown to have a measurable effect on the force–length relationship (FLR), as peak force is shifted to
longer muscle lengths following exercise. Recently, this shift in the FLR has been proposed as a ‘‘simple, reliable indicator’’ for
assessing contractile element damage following eccentric exercise. However, eccentric exercise causes fatigue and damage, and there
is evidence that fatigue alone may also cause a shift in the FLR. The purpose of this paper was to assess the role of fatigue on the
FLR (as measured by a torque–joint angle relationship) following isometric and eccentric exercise in the New Zealand white (NZW)
rabbit. Six NZW rabbits were divided into two groups for eccentric or isometric contractions of the hindlimb dorsiflexor muscles.
Pre- and post-exercise torque–joint angle relationships were measured, and the shift from the pre- to the post-exercise relationship
was measured as the change in joint angle at which peak torque was produced. Eccentric exercise resulted in a rightward shift of
seven degrees; isometric exercise, which is thought to not cause damage, resulted in a shift of four degrees. Furthermore, torque
production was reduced to a greater extent at short compared to long muscle lengths for the eccentric and isometric exercise,
resulting in a post-exercise torque–joint angle relationship that was altered in shape. We conclude from these results, that the shift in
peak torque may not be a simple and reliable indicator of muscle damage, but is caused by a combination of damage and post-
exercise fatigue.
r 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0021-9290/$ - see front matter r 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jbiomech.2004.08.013
ARTICLE IN PRESS
T.A. Butterfield, W. Herzog / Journal of Biomechanics 38 (2005) 1932–1937 1933
This rightward shift of the FLR following eccentric nerves, superior to the gastrocnemius and distal to the
contractions has been observed in a variety of studies branching of the sciatic nerve. In this manner, all
and muscle preparations, including human plantarflex- dorsiflexors of the tibiotarsal joints were stimulated
ors (Whitehead et al., 1998; Jones et al., 1997), and effectively. Following implantation, the skin was stapled
hamstrings (Brockett et al., 2001), single toad fibers closed.
(Jones et al., 1997), single frog fibers (Morgan et al.,
1996), and individual motor units from the cat medial 2.3. Exercise and measurement protocol
gastrocnemius (Brockett et al., 2002). In each of these
studies, the shift was associated with contractile element 2.3.1. Eccentric exercise, group 1
damage. In addition, histological findings post-exercise Rabbits were placed supine in a stereotaxic frame
supported the concept of contractile element injury with the knee at 901 flexion (full extension=01). The
within the muscle following eccentric exercise (Jones et foot was strapped to a servo-motor footplate (Parker
al., 1997), although the possible contribution of fatigue Hannifin Corporation, Irwin, PA, USA) and ankle
on the FLR was not considered. movement was controlled via computer (Motion Plan-
Unlike eccentric contractions, isometric exercise does ner, Rohnert Park, CA, USA). The tibiotarsal
not produce extensive contractile element damage (Koh joint angle was set at 901 (full extension=1801) which
and Brooks, 2001), and presents a unique model to served as the reference angle for the remainder of
study the effects of fatigue on the FLR in the absence of the experiment. The peroneal nerve cuff leads were
muscle injury. Although previous studies have assessed attached to a stimulator (Grass S8800, Astro-Med
the effects of fatigue on the force–length relationship, Inc., Longueil, QC, Canada), and the a-motoneuron
the use of single fibers (Yeung et al., 2002a, b) or lack of threshold was determined (pulse duration=0.1 ms,
direct comparison to the post eccentric exercise FLR frequency=150 Hz).
(Cutlip et al., 2004) leaves the contribution of fatigue to First, a pre-exercise, isometric torque–joint angle
the rightward shift of the FLR following eccentric relationship was determined by supramaximally stimu-
exercise unclear. Therefore, the purpose of this study lating (3 a-motoneuron threshold voltage, pulse dur-
was to directly test the hypothesis that fatigue con- ation=0.1 ms, frequency=150 Hz, train duration=
tributes to the rightward shift in the FLR of the ankle 2000 ms) the dorsiflexor muscles, beginning at a
dorsiflexors in New Zealand white rabbits following tibiotarsal angle of 551 and progressing in 51 increments
eccentric exercise. to 1551. To limit the potential effects of creep of passive
elements at long muscle lengths, the foot was parked at a
551 joint angle (short muscle length) between isometric
2. Materials and methods contractions. Therefore, following each isometric con-
traction, the foot was returned passively to a dorsiflexed
2.1. Experimental design position (551 tibiotarsal angle) for 2 min of rest between
contractions.
Eight skeletally mature NZW rabbits (5.670.2 kg, The exercise protocol consisted of eccentric contrac-
Riemens, St. Agatha, Ontario, Canada) were divided tions performed from a tibiotarsal angle of 70–1051 of
into two study groups for measurement of a pre-exercise plantar flexion at 701 s 1(3 a-motoneuron threshold
and post-exercise torque–joint angle relationship. voltage, pulse duration=0.1 ms, frequency=150 Hz,
Group one consisted of five rabbits (nine hindlimbs) train duration=500 ms). Each stretch-shortening cycle
subjected to eccentric exercise. Group two consisted of lasted 1000 ms. Stimulation started at the onset of
three rabbits (six hindlimbs) subjected to an equivalent plantar flexion and ceased at the end of the eccentric
isometric exercise. All procedures were approved by the exercise (1051), resulting in an eccentric exercise of
Animal Care Committee of the University of Calgary. 500 ms duration. Immediately following the eccentric
contraction, the foot was passively returned to the 701
2.2. Surgical procedure starting position at 701 s 1(500 ms passive shortening).
To induce muscle injury associated with eccentric
Rabbits were tranquilized with 0.18 ml (10 mg/ml) contractions, it has been shown that greater than one
acepro-25 (MTC Pharmaceuticals, Cambridge, ON, contraction is required when working within the
Canada) and held under anesthesia with 1.5% isoflur- physiologic range of motion (Cutlip et al., 2004;
ane, 0.6 L/min N2O and 0.8 L/min O2. An incision was Gosselin and Burton, 2002). Therefore, the exercise
made on the posterior aspect of the right and left protocol consisted of five sets of ten eccentric contrac-
hindlimbs, anterior to the sciatic vein, and the biceps tions, with 2 min rest between sets. Immediately after the
femoris and semimembranosis were separated exposing eccentric protocol, a post-exercise torque-joint angle
the peroneal nerve. Nerve cuff stimulating electrodes relationship was measured in a manner identical to the
were secured over the right and left common peroneal pre-exercise relationship. However, the rest between
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1934 T.A. Butterfield, W. Herzog / Journal of Biomechanics 38 (2005) 1932–1937
isometric contractions was reduced to 30 s to limit the expressed as a percent decrease from the pre-exercise
recovery from fatigue during measurement of the FLR values. All statistical analyses were performed using
post-exercise. Therefore, the foot was returned to a SPSS version 11.5 (SPSS Incorporated, Chicago, IL,
dorsiflexed position (551 tibiotarsal joint angle) between USA). For all parameters measured, means7SE are
contractions, but for only 30 s of rest before moving to reported. Statistical significance was set at po0.05, and
the next joint angle. analyzed using Student’s paired, or independent, t-tests.
1.1
1.0 R2 = 0.98
R2 = 0.99
0.9
1.2
0.8
0.7
1.0 0.6
0.5
Joint Torque [Nm]
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160
Tibiotarsal Joint Angle [degrees]
Fig. 1. Torque–angle relationship for NZW dorsiflexors before (J) and after () a bout of eccentric exercise. Note the apparent shift to the right in
peak force production (from 100 to 1051) and the change in shape of the torque-joint angle relationship following exercise. Torque production
following eccentric exercise was significantly reduced compared to pre-exercise values at all joint angles tested (po0.001). Values are mean7SE
(n=9). Inset. Normalized torque–angle relationship. Here the rightward shift and counterclockwise rotation are evident. Data were fitted with a
second-order polynomial to calculate the angle of peak torque production pre-exercise (981) and post-exercise (1041).
1.1
1 2 2
R = 0.98 R = 0.99
0.9
0.8
1.6
0.7
1.4 0.6
0.5
1.2 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140
Joint Torque [Nm]
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160
Tibiotarsal Joint Angle [degrees]
Fig. 2. Torque–angle relationship for NZW dorsiflexors before (J) and after () a bout of isometric exercise. Note the apparent lack of rightward
shift in peak force production (1051). Torque production following isometric exercise was significantly reduced compared to pre-exercise values at all
joint angles tested (po0.001). Values shown are mean7SE (n=6). Inset. Normalized torque-angle relationship. Here the rightward shift and
counter-clockwise rotation are evident. Data were fitted with a second order polynomial to calculate the angle of peak torque production pre-exercise
(1011) and post-exercise (1051).
similar to that seen following isometric exercise (Fig. 3), Gauthier, A.P., Faltus, R.E., Macklem, P.T., Bellemare, F., 1993.
but increased in magnitude for the eccentric compared Effects of fatigue on the length-tetanic force relationship of the rat
diaphragm. Journal of Applied Physiology 74, 326–332.
to the isometric protocol. Thus, we concluded that
Gosselin, L.E., Burton, H., 2002. Impact of initial muscle length on
metabolic changes are implicated in the altered shape of force deficit following lengthening contractions in mammalian
the ascending limb of the FLR following eccentric skeletal muscle. Muscle Nerve 25, 822–827.
exercise. This, in conjunction with the use of curve Jones, C., Allen, T., Talbot, J., Morgan, D.L., Proske, U., 1997.
fitting to predict the peak of the FLR, although well Changes in the mechanical properties of human and amphibian
accepted (Wood et al., 1993; Jones et al., 1997; Talbot muscle after eccentric exercise. European Journal of Applied
Physiology and Occupational Physiology 76, 21–31.
and Morgan, 1998; Whitehead et al., 1998), may Katz, B., 1939. The relation between force and speed in muscular
produce the rightward shift due to fatigue. contraction. Journal of Physiology 96, 45–64.
Koh, T.J., Brooks, S.V., 2001. Lengthening contractions are not
required to induce protection from contraction-induced muscle
injury. American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory Integrative and
5. Conclusion Comparative Physiology 281, R155–R161.
Morgan, D.L., 1990. New insights into the behavior of muscle during
We demonstrated that a rightward shift in the FLR active lengthening. Biophysical Journal 57, 209–221.
following exercise may be partially attributed to the Morgan, D.L., Allen, D.G., 1999. Early events in stretch-induced
muscle damage. J.Appl.Physiol 87, 2007–2015.
effects of fatigue. Although it is well accepted that Morgan, D.L., Claflin, D.R., Julian, F.J., 1996. The effects of repeated
contractile element damage plays an important role in active stretches on tension generation and myoplasmic calcium in
the altered mechanical properties of muscle following frog single muscle fibres. Journal of Physiology 497 (Part 3),
eccentric contractions, the role of fatigue with respect to 665–674.
the shift in peak force production seems to have been Talbot, J.A., Morgan, D.L., 1996. Quantitative analysis of sarcomere
non-uniformities in active muscle following a stretch. Journal of
overlooked. Based on the current results, fatigue may be
Muscle Research and Cell Motility 17, 261–268.
responsible for up to 50% of the measured rightward Talbot, J.A., Morgan, D.L., 1998. The effects of stretch parameters on
shift in peak torque production following eccentric eccentric exercise-induced damage to toad skeletal muscle. Journal
exercise. Therefore, the shift in peak torque is not of Muscle Research and Cell Motility 19, 237–245.
necessarily a simple and reliable indicator of muscle Warren, G.L., Lowe, D.A., Hayes, D.A., Karwoski, C.J., Prior, B.M.,
Armstrong, R.B., 1993. Excitation failure in eccentric contraction-
damage.
induced injury of mouse soleus muscle. Journal of Physiology 468,
487–499.
Whitehead, N.P., Allen, T.J., Morgan, D.L., Proske, U., 1998.
References Damage to human muscle from eccentric exercise after training
with concentric exercise. Journal of Physiology 512 (Part 2),
Balnave, C.D., Allen, D.G., 1995. Intracellular calcium and force in 615–620.
single mouse muscle fibres following repeated contractions with Whitehead, N.P., Morgan, D.L., Gregory, J.E., Proske, U., 2003.
stretch. Journal of Physiology 488 (Part 1), 25–36. Rises in whole muscle passive tension of mammalian muscle after
Brockett, C.L., Morgan, D.L., Gregory, J.E., Proske, U., 2002. eccentric contractions at different lengths. Journal of Applied
Damage to different motor units from active lengthening of the Physiology 95, 1224–1234.
medial gastrocnemius muscle of the cat. Journal of Applied Whitehead, N.P., Weerakkody, N.S., Gregory, J.E., Morgan, D.L.,
Physiology 92, 1104–1110. Proske, U., 2001. Changes in passive tension of muscle in humans
Brockett, C.L., Morgan, D.L., Proske, U., 2001. Human hamstring and animals after eccentric exercise. Journal of Physiology 533,
muscles adapt to eccentric exercise by changing optimum length. 593–604.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 33, 783–790. Wood, S.A., Morgan, D.L., Proske, U., 1993. Effects of repeated
Cutlip, R.G., Geronilla, K.B., Baker, B.A., Kashon, M.L., Miller, eccentric contractions on structure and mechanical properties of
G.R., Schopper, A.W., 2004. Impact of muscle length during toad sartorius muscle. American Journal of Physiology 265,
stretch-shortening contractions on real-time and temporal muscle C792–C800.
performance measures in rats in vivo. Journal of Applied Yeung, E.W., Balnave, C.D., Ballard, H.J., Bourreau, J.P., Allen,
Physiology 96, 507–516. D.G., 2002a. Development of T-tubular vacuoles in eccentrically
Endo, M., 1972. Stretch-induced increase in activation of skinned damaged mouse muscle fibres. Journal of Physiology 540, 581–592.
muscle fibres by calcium. Nature-New Biology 237, 211–213. Yeung, E.W., Bourreau, J.P., Allen, D.G., Ballard, H.J., 2002b. Effect
Fowles, J.R., Sale, D.G., MacDougall, J.D., 2000. Reduced strength of eccentric contraction-induced injury on force and intracellular
after passive stretch of the human plantarflexors. Journal of pH in rat skeletal muscles. Journal of Applied Physiology 92,
Applied Physiology 89, 1179–1188. 93–99.