Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 1
VOTER GUIDE - League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund U. S. Congress Michigan District 8 Primary Election: August 5, 2014 You may VOTE in ONLY ONE PARTYS PRIMARY either Republican or Democratic for ALL partisan offices on ballot. Candidates are ordered below within each office by party with Republicans preceding Democrats. Candidates on the ballot: 2 Republicans and 4 Democrats
Duties: Representatives share the responsibility with Senators for enactment of the nation's laws as provided in the U.S. Constitution. Laws that require payment of taxes are initiated in the House of Representatives. Qualifications: A Representative must be at least 25 years of age and a U.S. Citizen for at least 7 years. There are 435 Representatives based on Congressional districts reapportioned after each census. Michigan has 14 districts as of 2012. Term: 2 years VOTE for ONE (1).
Mike Bishop, Republican
Campaign Website: www.electmikebishop.com
Occupation / Current Position: Chief Legal Officer and General Counsel, International Bancard Corporation
Education: Juris Doctorate of Law Michigan State University DCL (1993) B.A. in History/Psychology University of Michigan (1989) Real Estate Brokers License Curry Management Institute (1994) Qualifications / Experience: Chief Legal Officer and General Counsel International Bancard Corporation (2013 present) Senior Attorney Clark Hill PLC (2011 2012) Adjunct Professor of Law Thomas M. Cooley Law School (2011 present) Senior Attorney Simon, Galasso & Frantz, PLC (2004-2010) Senior Attorney Booth Patterson PC (1993-2004) MI House of Representatives (1998-2003) Michigan Senate (2003-2011)
Questions: 1. PRIORITIES: What are your top three national legislative priorities? Why did you select them? A: Healthcare - The number one concern on the minds of families and businesses in the district is the rising cost of healthcare. We need to work on reforms that will make healthcare affordable and accessible, and not by mandating a government-managed marketplace. Jobs - My top priority is getting Michigans economy moving again so the private sector can create jobs. I believe one of the biggest challenges facing Michigan is uncertainty. Debt and Deficit - Its time to stop the out- of-control spending policies in Washington, D.C. and halt government expansion. We need to curb spending and begin paying down our debt.
2. ECONOMY: What should the federal government do to strengthen the national economy, reduce unem- ployment, and address the widening income gap? A: I believe that the fiscal policies of Washington, D.C. are out of control. I do not think the massive expansion of government and huge amount of new debt American taxpayers have been forced to take on in recent years will help our economy grow or create jobs. The Presidents fiscal policies have paved the way for unsustainable spending in Washington while borrowing even more from countries like China. The first step to economic recovery is to stop out-of-control spending and begin to pay down the deficit and the debt so employers in Michigan and across America can borrow the money they need to grow and create jobs.
3. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT: What steps would you propose to secure Americas energy needs while protecting our water, air and land? A: I believe we must do much more to expand all sources of American energy and create an all-of-the- above energy policy. While the debate over energy issues has often been heated, I believe that it also presents an opportunity for America to innovate, rather than regulate, our way to a cleaner more secure and affordable energy future. We must have a new energy policy in this country that focuses on safely using American innovation and American natural resources to U.S. Congress Michigan District 8 Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 2
create millions of jobs, bring down the cost of energy and make America independent from overseas oil.
4. MONEY IN ELECTIONS: Do you support the Disclose Act, which would require disclosure by outside groups of large campaign contributions and expenditures? Why or why not? A: I do not support the Disclose Act, simply as a matter of fairness. I wholeheartedly agree we need campaign finance reform. However, for whatever reason, there has not been the political will in Washington DC to get done what needs to get done. I bring up fairness because this version of the Disclose Act, like the first version, still has exemptions. Organizations that meet certain criteria in terms of membership and the number of states in which they operate would not have to disclose their donors. To me, this is not acceptable. Disclosure must be across the board, with no exceptions.
5. IMMIGRATION: What specific changes, if any, would you propose to current immigration policy? Please explain. A: I believe that Congress must take action to address our failing immigration system. It is evident that we have a broken system that undermines existing laws and threatens our national security. It is time to replace ineffective policies with real reforms. I believe this requires a massive response that allows America to control its own borders, reform federal work laws, and provide local law enforcement with the resources they need to protect local communities. We can and must do better to improve our legal immigration system for future generations. I will not support any measure that threatens our national security.
6. HEALTH CARE: What changes, if any, should be made to federal health care policies or programs? Please explain. A: The number one health care concern on the minds of families and small businesses is the rising cost of health care. Congress should begin working on step-by-step, bipartisan solutions that would actually lower healthcare costs. These solutions include expanding access to Health Savings Accounts, and allowing small businesses to pool resources to purchase health insurance for their employees. We should do this not by mandating an expensive government-managed marketplace, but by forcing insurers to actually compete for their customers in the open marketplace, across state lines much like we do now for auto insurance. Tom McMillin, Republican
Campaign Website: www.tom4michigan.com
Occupation / Current Position: State Representative, CPA
Education: Bachelor's degree from University of Michigan in Accounting/Economics Qualifications / Experience: State Representative, Chairman of House Oversight and of Joint Committee on Administrative Rules, former Oakland County Commissioner, Auburn Hills Mayor and City Councilman and School Board President of Prevail Academy Charter School, former Consultant and part- time Chief Financial Officer for a variety of clients. Husband and father of three and new grandpa.
Questions: 1. PRIORITIES: What are your top three national legislative priorities? Why did you select them? A: 1. Eliminate the federal deficit and reduce the national debt. It is unconscionable that we continue to lay horrendous debt on our children and grandchildren. 2. Eliminate Obamacare. This horrible taking of our liberty must be repealed. We must restore the ability to individuals to control their own healthcare. 3. Return authority to the states. The federal government should not be deciding health care, welfare, education, land management, labor policy and many other areas for all 50 states. The way these would best be handled in Vermont, Wyoming, California, Florida and Michigan, etc are all different.
2. ECONOMY: What should the federal government do to strengthen the national economy, reduce unem- ployment, and address the widening income gap? A: The way to strengthen the economy and reduce unemployment is to reduce burdensome regulations on job providers and make the tax code much simpler and less burdensome. Most regulation policy decisions should be made at the state level and tax policy needs to be more predictable and taxes lower. The way to reduce an income gap is to increase job opportunities, make America more competitive through lower regulations. Also reduce corporate welfare than only benefits the well-connected wealthy.
U.S. Congress Michigan District 8 Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 3
3. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT: What steps would you propose to secure Americas energy needs while protecting our water, air and land? A: Allow projects like the Keystone pipeline, while protecting property rights. Allow increased leasing of federal lands for exploration and production. Encourage free market alternative energy development by reducing any regulations that are impediments.
4. MONEY IN ELECTIONS: Do you support the Disclose Act, which would require disclosure by outside groups of large campaign contributions and expenditures? Why or why not? A: Campaign finance laws have been largely ineffective. We need to focus on eliminating the power in Washington. Big money is given in campaigns, because there are big payoffs - due to the power and excessive spending in Washington. Eliminating corporate welfare handouts to companies like Solyndra, that just turn around and see their executives give big donations to campaigns, will help take big money out of politics. Large contracts, the ability to crush competition through selective regulations - these areas of crony capitalism are what drive the money problems in politics. Power must be removed from Washington.
5. IMMIGRATION: What specific changes, if any, would you propose to current immigration policy? Please explain. A: We need to secure our borders. States should be allowed to enforce immigration law when the federal government fails to exercise their responsibility. We need to end Americas attractive draw for illegal immigration by eliminating governmental benefits, such as, welfare, in state tuition, food stamps, housing subsidies and free medical benefits for people here illegally. Eliminate US citizenship for "anchor babies", where non-citizens come into America illegally in order to have their child on American soil, thereby giving them citizenship.
6. HEALTH CARE: What changes, if any, should be made to federal health care policies or programs? Please explain. A: Repeal ObamaCare. Return authority to the states to decide health care policy and tort reform. We only need to look at how the federal government treats our veterans at VA hospitals to know that the federal government cannot do healthcare right. Make sure insurance can be sold across state lines to enhance competition and lower premiums. Institute more consumer choice and individual authority over health care decisions, where possible.
Ken Darga, Democrat
Campaign Website: www.darga4congress.com
Occupation / Current Position: Served as Michigans State Demographer until retiring to run for Congress.
Education: Graduate degrees from the University of Michigan in Economics and in Social Policy & Administration Qualifications / Experience: A state demographer is a numbers guy who serves as liaison to the U.S. Census Bureau and provides data and analysis to state agencies, policy-makers, and other users of economic and demographic statistics. Served as a health care economist in the Michigan Department of Management and Budget prior to becoming state demographer. Authored two books on policy issues involving the U.S. Census.
Questions: 1. PRIORITIES: What are your top three national legislative priorities? Why did you select them? A: (1) Bringing back factories (2) Restoring prosperity (3) Protecting and strengthening Social Security. Bringing back factories is a national security issue as well as a jobs issue. Someday our factories will be converted to military purposes in a crisis. If they are on the wrong side of the ocean, however, they will be converted to someone elses military purposes. While nations on the other side of the ocean build military hardware at a rate the world has never seen before, we will be seeking new sources for light bulbs and computer equipment and other items that our economy cannot function without.
2. ECONOMY: What should the federal government do to strengthen the national economy, reduce unem- ployment, and address the widening income gap? A: We can bring back factories by eliminating the business taxes that drive jobs away and replacing them with taxes that provide incentives to bring jobs back. My strategy for bringing back prosperity is safe stimulus. Simple changes in the way we create money and the way we control inflation will make it possible to U.S. Congress Michigan District 8 Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 4
stimulate our economy without increasing the governments debt burden or risking excessive inflation. More factories and more prosperity will lead to higher income for workers. Other steps to close the income gap include raising the minimum wage, strengthening the earned income credit, and tax reform.
3. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT: What steps would you propose to secure Americas energy needs while protecting our water, air and land? A: (1) Establish new taxes on fuels and pollution, with all revenues used for per-capita tax credits and credits for businesses and individuals that adopt energy-saving measures. These credits would neutralize increases in the cost of living and the cost of doing business that the new taxes would otherwise cause. (2) Replace many existing energy subsidies with pay-as-you-save loans for businesses and households that adopt efficient energy technologies. This would improve our environment at no long-term cost to the government. (3) Establish bonding requirements for activities like fracking that entail environmental risks.
4. MONEY IN ELECTIONS: Do you support the Disclose Act, which would require disclosure by outside groups of large campaign contributions and expenditures? Why or why not? A: I support the Disclose Act because voters have a right to know which organizations are seeking to influence candidates and elections. I also believe that organizations should not be allowed to spend or contribute money for political purposes unless it was freely contributed to the organization for political purposes. Corporations are responsible to customers, workers, and shareholders, so ordinary corporate funds should not be used for political purposes that their customers, workers, and shareholders have not agreed to support.
5. IMMIGRATION: What specific changes, if any, would you propose to current immigration policy? Please explain. A: Immigrants contribute to Americas economy and culture and help preserve the solvency of our Social Security system. Our immigration policy has generally been successful at keeping the number of new immigrants at a reasonable and sustainable level. There should be a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants who have paid their tax liabilities and shown that they can be good citizens. We should also prioritize deportation of serious criminals over persons with clean criminal records, those with immediate family members who are U.S. citizens, and those who entered the U.S. as children.
6. HEALTH CARE: What changes, if any, should be made to federal health care policies or programs? Please explain. A: I propose a publicly administered option with high copays that would compete with conventional coverage on the insurance exchanges. This option would be available to employer groups as well as individuals. Copays would be calculated on a sliding scale and payments that do not encourage cost-efficiency (such as deductibles and the employee share of premiums) would be replaced by payments into personal health savings & loan accounts for covering copays. The high copays would encourage economical choices, and some of the savings would be used to help patients with high expenditures to repay loans to their accounts.
Susan Grettenberger, Democrat
Campaign Website: GrettenbergerforCongress.com
Occupation / Current Position: Professor/Director of Social Work, Central Michigan University, Mt. Pleasant, MEA member Education: PhD, Social Work, and MPA, Public Administration, Michigan State University, MSW, Social Work, University of Illinois, Chicago, BA, Education/Psychology, Albion College Qualifications / Experience: Susan has many roles and identities including social worker, adoptive mom of four, professor, neighbor, lesbian, proud union member. Her varied experience in universities, nonprofits, and with the State of Michigan, as an administrator, a social worker, an evaluator and an educator, allowed her to accomplish goals with wide- ranging constituencies. This will serve her well in the halls of Congress.
Questions: 1. PRIORITIES: What are your top three national legislative priorities? Why did you select them? A: Protecting working families by assuring they have good paying green jobs, strengthening education, and protecting the environment. Working families in Michigan are hurting and deserve a fair chance at a good life. We can do that. I teach young adults, and U.S. Congress Michigan District 8 Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 5
there are many young people in the next generation of my family. As a parent, an aunt and a professor, I know we can do better than we have been to make sure the next generations have a world where they can succeed and be happy. They deserve to have access to a good education and jobs when they finish school. They deserve a world with clean water and air. We all do.
2. ECONOMY: What should the federal government do to strengthen the national economy, reduce unem- ployment, and address the widening income gap? A: The economy is fueled by consumer spending. When working people make enough to pay their bills and have extra money, they spend it. When they spend money, employers create jobs. Increasing the minimum wage reduces the income gap which so harms working families. And by asking corporations to pay their fair share and reducing loopholes for the wealthiest Americans, we could fund critical public projects such as infrastructure repair (roads, bridges, sewer, water systems). This would create good jobs while enhancing public safety, protecting the environment and protecting the structures needed to grow the economy.
3. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT: What steps would you propose to secure Americas energy needs while protecting our water, air and land? A: America needs a combination of incentives and requirements to reduce use of fossil fuels, reduce pollution, increase energy efficiency through new technologies and increase use of renewable energy sources. More expensive energy can still be affordable if we use less of it. Tax rewards for companies who develop new technologies or are energy efficient should replace tax breaks for moving jobs to countries which have fewer environmental protections. Tax breaks should be renewed for people buying efficient autos and increasing fuel efficiency in their homes. We need to encourage sustainable energy production.
4. MONEY IN ELECTIONS: Do you support the Disclose Act, which would require disclosure by outside groups of large campaign contributions and expenditures? Why or why not? A: Yes, I support legislation to assure disclosure of large contributions in order to make clear when there could be parties influencing elections through campaign contributions and expenditures. It is important for all parties to be able to evaluate whose interests may be influencing soon-to-be-elected or current elected officials and, therefore, policies. Transparency and accountability are important for democracy to flourish. The voters have a right to know.
5. IMMIGRATION: What specific changes, if any, would you propose to current immigration policy? Please explain. A: The United States is the country it is because of immigrants. Immigrants and guest workers, such as farm workers from Mexico, typically provide labor for jobs that would not be filled otherwise. They contribute to the economy in significant ways. Undocumented laborers are often exploited by employers as they have no protection, and those workers, too, are often making a contribution to the economy. While we should not encourage illegal immigration, we should have a path to legal status and even citizenship for those whose sole illegality is being in the country. That path could include some penalties.
6. HEALTH CARE: What changes, if any, should be made to federal health care policies or programs? Please explain. A: Health care access is a fundamental right. This is done through access to affordable insurance. We must refine the Affordable Care Act to assure that all people have insurance while protecting people's jobs and the stability of smaller businesses. This will require careful and objective assessment of the strengths and problems of the current policy, and bipartisan efforts to solve problems. Possible improvements include negotiating prescription costs and increasing prevention efforts. Public programs such as health care for veterans must be efficient, effective and timely. Healthy people are productive employees.
Education: Political Science/PreLaw Degree- Michigan State University Juris Doctor Degree- Detroit College of Law (now MSU College of Law) Qualifications / Experience: Local leader for good government. Successfully lead petition drives to amend city charters with pro-people and pro-taxpayer U.S. Congress Michigan District 8 Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 6
initiatives. Licensed to practice law in Michigan, Florida, and the US Virgin Islands. Successful small- business owner. Former President of State Bar of Michigan Consumer Law Section. Life-long resident of the District. Speaks English and some Spanish.
Questions: 1. PRIORITIES: What are your top three national legislative priorities? Why did you select them? A: Initiating an American Renaissance; Being a statesman (and encouraging stateswomen) to answer the call of duty and bring a sense of responsibility and progress back to politics, rather than typical partisan bickering and lack of progress; Ensuring that government is structured to improve the quality of lives of its citizens, and that it is a force for good, never for evil, and that our government works for, of, and by the People. I chose these as my top three priorities, themes of my campaign, because it is what is most needed in politics. We are not thinking and planning long-term or generationally.
2. ECONOMY: What should the federal government do to strengthen the national economy, reduce unem- ployment, and address the widening income gap? A: Raise the minimum wage; Build the DRIC/NITC/ New Detroit Bridge and invest in other infrastructure projects that provide a public benefit; We need to build the next generation electrical and internet grids; Eliminate the Cuban embargo, create jobs; Legalize, Tax, and Regulate cannabis for adults and farm industrial hemp; Eliminate barriers of entry by eliminating non- health and safety regulations and also structuring free trade deals to benefit American workers; Promote education through free or reduced college tuition along the lines of the organization Redeeming Americas Promise; Rebuild the Space Program.
3. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT: What steps would you propose to secure Americas energy needs while protecting our water, air and land? A: Support massive investments in solar technology. The US must lead in alternative energies from solar, wind, tidal, wave, geothermal and other non- greenhouse gas, non-polluting sources. I support EPA regulations on pollution, raising the federal gas tax, instituting a carbon and/or pollution tax; strong enforcement of the Clean Air and Water Acts, including private rights of actions for citizens to litigate against polluters; re-forestation projects and the Endangered Species Act; protection of oceans and coral reefs, and enforcement mechanisms against overfishing and waste dumping. I oppose Great Lakes drilling.
4. MONEY IN ELECTIONS: Do you support the Disclose Act, which would require disclosure by outside groups of large campaign contributions and expenditures? Why or why not? A: I am doing my best to raise as little money as possible and run a true constituent-oriented campaign. I lead by example rather than talking points. Everyone complains about money in politics but each party is focused on raising as much money as possible. Its a vicious cycle that has contributed to the political tomfoolery we now suffer and has lead to Americas decline because politicians are more focused on dialing for dollars and the next short election cycle than on good policy and statecraft. I will support efforts to create transparency in electoral spending and appropriate limits on contributions.
5. IMMIGRATION: What specific changes, if any, would you propose to current immigration policy? Please explain. A: I support immigration and believe that we are all members of the human family with an inalienable and inherent right to freedom of travel, trade, commerce, and free association. I oppose militarizing the border and I oppose deportations of anyone but fugitives or wanted criminals. I believe immigration is good for the economy and that emotional scare tactics should not prevail us from reason. Economic data indicates that immigrants are a positive for communities regardless if they are laborers or high-tech workers. I oppose E-verify and oppose a National ID card but support reasonable immigration control.
6. HEALTH CARE: What changes, if any, should be made to federal health care policies or programs? Please explain. A: We spend the most dollars in total per any country on healthcare; it is a bigger percentage of our GDP; we spend more per-person; and we get worse results and are more unhealthy than other similarly situated countries. Thats economic fact and is the consensus from which we must start in looking for solutions. In general I support the Affordable Care Act as a step in the right direction by increasing coverage for many Americans and reducing costs. Where there are problems with the ACA, I will work to improve them. I will listen to anyone who has good ideas on improving healthcare and always consider alternatives. U.S. Congress Michigan District 8 Copyright League of Women Voters of Michigan Education Fund 7
Eric Schertzing, Democrat
Campaign Website: www.ericforcongress.com
Occupation / Current Position: Ingham County Treasurer and Land Bank Chair
Education: Bachelor of Arts degree from Michigan State Universitys James Madison College (JMCD 85) and a Masters of Public Administration from Western Michigan University (00). Qualifications / Experience: Eric has been Ingham County Treasurer since 2000. Prior he served 8 years as Chief Deputy Drain Commissioner and 9 years as Special Assistant to Congressman Bob Carr (D-MI). In 2005, Eric led the creation of the Ingham County Land Bank, the second in Michigan, and serves as Chair. He is a leader in the tri-county area for foreclosure prevention and consumer financial literacy.
Questions: 1. PRIORITIES: What are your top three national legislative priorities? Why did you select them? A: One, we need to invest in our nations infrastructureour roads, bridges, schools--all the building blocks our economy and prosperity depend on. Two, we need to address college affordability crisis and rein in student loans that stop young people from buying houses and achieving the American Dream. Three, we need to strengthen Social Security, which is the bedrock of security for our seniors, now and in the future.
2. ECONOMY: What should the federal government do to strengthen the national economy, reduce unem- ployment, and address the widening income gap? A: Women deserve equal pay for equal work. I also believe we need to raise the federal minimum wage, which has not kept pace with the rate of inflation over time. Work should pay enough to keep people out of poverty. I support a tax structure that incentivizes companies that keep jobs in America--not outsourcing jobs overseas. And we need to invest in infrastructure that supports our economy and leads to strong growtha great education system for our kids is part of that. Right now the system favors Wall Street and the ultra-wealthy, and that's wrong. I will always fight for Michigan workers and families.
3. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT: What steps would you propose to secure Americas energy needs while protecting our water, air and land? A: Our biggest priorities should be improving energy efficiency and investing in renewable energy sources like wind and solar. Those investments will make us more energy secure and keep prices down long-term. We have no more important responsibility to our children and grandchildren than protecting the water, air and land we all depend on to live healthy lives.
4. MONEY IN ELECTIONS: Do you support the Disclose Act, which would require disclosure by outside groups of large campaign contributions and expenditures? Why or why not? A: Yes, I believe in transparency in campaign financing. People have a sense that the system is rigged against them, and how can they know unless we can see whos funding what? Washington is dysfunctional, and a big reason for that is Republicans in Congress putting themselves and their special-interest campaign contributors ahead of average Americans. They say sunlight is the best disinfectant--what's been going on in Washington could use a lot more sunlight.
5. IMMIGRATION: What specific changes, if any, would you propose to current immigration policy? Please explain. A: As with almost any of the big issues facing us, this Congress has failed to act. I will look for a bipartisan solution that strengthens our border security and that makes absolutely sure that those who broke the law pay a penalty, learn English and go to the back of the line. We need to modernize our immigration policy to strengthen the economy and keep families together.
6. HEALTH CARE: What changes, if any, should be made to federal health care policies or programs? Please explain. A: It is my priority that folks have access to high quality, affordable healthcare. If you have a doctor you like, you should be able to see that doctor. If you have a preexisting condition, that shouldnt prevent you from obtaining affordable insurance. I think it's great that kids can stay on their parents' insurance until they're 26. The rollout of the affordable care act was frustrating and disappointing, but what we cannot do is go backward with repeal and put the insurance companies back in charge. I will work with both sides on fixes that can lower costs and improve access.