Minute 79

Minutes of the seventy ninth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held
on 28.12.2013 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 1 of 47
Name of the members who were present in the meeting are as follows: -
1. Prof. (Dr.) Sudarsan Neogi Chairman, SEAC
2. Dr. Kalyan Rudra Member, SEAC
3. Dr. Satya Kinkar Pal Member, SEAC
4. Prof. Bhabatosh Biswas Member, SEAC
5. Prof.(Dr) S.R Roychoudhuri Member, SEAC
6. Dr. Amitava Roy Member, SEAC
7. Dr. Anita Chattopadhyay Gupta Member, SEAC
8. Prof. Jayanta Bhattacharya Member, SEAC
9. Dr. S.Mukherjee, I.F.S. Secretary, SEAC & Member Secretary, WBPCB
In the beginning of the 79
th
meeting of SEAC, which was held on 28.12.2013 at 11:30 hrs at the
Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Bidhan Nagar, the Secretary, SEAC welcome all the members. After
introductory session, five cases were discussed under 'Miscellaneous' section. Seventeen cases were placed
for reconsideration. Four applicants were requested to make their presentation before the committee. Three
out of four applicants appeared before the SEAC for technical presentation on their respective project
proposal, while M/s. Emami Cement Ltd. remain absent.

SESSI ON I

A. Miscellaneous
Discussion on EIA notification, 2006 and several circulars/guidelines issued by MoEF time to time
regarding Environmental Clearance.
The committee members took note of EIA Notification dated 14/09/2006 and its amendments thereafter.
The committee also took note of important office memorandums, circulars and guidelines issued by
MoEF, GoI which have been published time to time.

1. Proposed Township URBANA by M/s. Bengal NRI Complex Limited at 782 & 783,
Anandapur, P.O EKTP, Kolkata 700 107.

Activity:
This was initially a proposal for development of a Township consisting of Residential and Commercial
Complexes. The Residential complex shall comprise of 912 dwelling units in 2 Apartment Towers (5
nos. G+45 & 2 nos. G+40 storied buildings) and 48 bungalows. The Commercial Complex shall
comprise of 2 office towers (2B+G+6 podium +34 storied building & 2B+G+6 podium +26 storied
building).
Chronology:
SEAC has issued PEC for the proposed project on 13.02.2009. The PP has modified the proposal
which has been considered during 59
th
SEAC meeting held on 20.09.2011 and SEAC asked the PP to
deliver a detailed power point presentation on the revised proposal.
During presentation in the 60
th
meeting held on 24.10.2011 the committee has noted that the
construction has started and the matter was communicated to the project proponent vide letter No.
715-2N-82/2008(E) dated 11.11.2011 along with submission of additional information.
The SEAC has recommended Environmental Clearance for the proposed project (Phase-I) during 61
st

meeting held on 29.11.2011.
Page 2 of 47
SEIAA issued a letter to SEAC informing that the built up area of Phase-I of the project is 217811.55
sq.m which as per schedule is treated as 8(b) category. As per S.O 695(E) dated 4
th
April, 2011 and
also the fact that the project is coming up in an environmentally sensitive area, SEIAA feels that
EIA/EMP should be carried out for this project.
The SEAC has scrutinized the issue in the 65
th
SEAC meeting held on 20.03.2012 and recommended
that EIA study to be undertaken for the proposed project. The SEAC, therefore, requested the
proponent to submit the proposed Terms of Reference for EIA studies of the project. Further, the
committee has recommended that since the project is proposed to be located in the fringes of the East
Kolkata Wetlands and the project proponent will be extracting ground water for the above mentioned
project, the expert comments / opinion of East Kolkata Wetlands Management Authority on the above
to be obtained.
Accordingly letter was issued to Chief Technical Officer, East Kolkata Wetlands Management
Authority seeking expert opinion and has received observations of EKWA vide letter dated
03.07.2012.
The case was considered in the 66
th
SEAC meeting held on 25.04.2012. The committee has
recommended that the proponent should submit necessary information in view of the Office
Memorandum (Guidelines for high rise buildings) issued by MoEF vide no. 21-270/2008-IA-III dated
07.02.2012. The project proponent submitted their reply in this regard on 21.05.2012
The PP was requested to present their case and the Terms of Reference (ToR) for EIA EMP study
during 68
th
SEAC meeting held on 14.06.2012. During the said presentation the SEAC discussed and
finalised the ToR for preparation of EIA report and EMP in respect of the said project.
The PP submitted the EIA report and other documents on 21.02.2013. The PP submitted the Executive
Summary of the EIA report of the entire project on 27.02.2013. The PP has obtained permission for
abstraction of groundwater from SWID of 1340 m
3
/day.
The PP has mentioned in the EIA report that a Writ Petition No. E.P.27900 (W) of 2012 has been filed
by the project proponent. As per decision of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Bhopal Gas
Peedith Mahila Udyog Sangathan & Ors. Vs. U.O.I. decided on 19
th
August, 2012 [Writ Petition (C)
No. 50/1998 with IA Nos. 62-63 of 2011 in Civil Appeal Nos. 3187-3188 of 1988], Registry is
directed to transmit the record to the National Green Tribunal, New Delhi, forthwith.
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has reviewed the letters submitted by PP on
21.02.2013, 27.02.2013, 21.03.2013 and 25.03.2013 in the 77
th
meeting held on 26.03.2013. The
SEAC noted that a Writ Petition vide No. 17900 (W) of 2012 was filed by the project proponent in the
Honble High Court, Kolkata. The SEAC is of the opinion that matter is subjudice, however, no
communication was made to project proponent in this regard.
The PP submitted a letter on 26.04.2013 mentioning that they had undertaken EIA study based on
prescribed ToR issued by SEAC and submitted the EIA report for the said study vide their letter dated
20.02.2013 and subsequently PP submitted necessary clarifications with respect to their project
proposal. Further vide the above letter the PP has requested for issuance of Environmental Clearance at
the earliest.
The issue has been discussed in the 78
th
SEAC meeting held on 08.05.2013 and SEAC opined that
since the matter is referred to the NGT, SEAC will wait for necessary directives.
As per Order No. 7 dtd. 24
th
July, 2013 passed by Honble NGT, Principle Bench, New Delhi it has
been mentioned that if the process has already been commenced for the purpose of reappraisal with
SEAC the same shall be expedited because it has been informed that the same was kept in abeyance
due to pendency of the appeal. The appeal is accordingly disposed of with no order as to costs.
The PP has submitted revised salient features of the Phase I & Phase II of the proposed project on
24.12.2013 as under :
Page 3 of 47

Phase I Phase II Total Phase I & 2 As per
sanctioned
plan
Total Land Area : 67966.13 sqm. : 45044.30 sqm. : 113010.43 sqm. : 262760.20
sqm.
Building Profile : Residential
Complex 4 nos.
Towers,
Tower 1 - G+40,
Tower 2 G+45,
Tower 6 G+40,
Tower 7 G+40,
storied buildings and
Residents Activity
Centre & Basement
car parking.
: Residential
Complex 3
nos. Towers,
Tower 3 G+45,
Tower 4 G+40,
Tower 5 G+40,
: Residential Complex
7 nos. Towers,
Tower 1 - G+40,
Tower 2 G+45,
Tower 3 G+45,
Tower 4 G+40,
Tower 5 G+40,
Tower 6 G+40,
Tower 7 G+40,
storied buildings and
Residents Activity
Centre & Basement car
parking.

No. of apartments : 626 nos. : 474 nos. : 1100 nos.
Expected
population
: 4248 : 2771 : 7019 persons
Water requirement 582.05 KLD 449 KLD 1031 KLD
Fresh Water
requirement
: 417.44 KLD
(Operation stage)
: 324.31 KLD
(Operation
stage)
: 741.75 KLD
(Operation stage)

Waste Water
generated
: 468.64 KLD : 362.20 KLD :830.84 KLD
Waste Water
recycled
: 365 KLD : 280 KLD : 645 KLD
Waste Water
discharged
: 10 KLD (TP canal
via Mundapara
Canal)
: 10 KLD (TP
canal via
Mundapara
Canal)
: 20 KLD (TP canal
via Mundapara Canal)

Water source : Total 1340 KLD as per Permit for sinking of New well
(obtained SWID)

Solid waste
disposal
: 1.902 tons per day : 1.459 tons per
day
: 3.362 tons per day
Page 4 of 47
sanctioned
plan
Total Built-up
Area
(as per MoEF
Notfn.)
: 224460.65 sqm.
(area relaxation as
per KMC rule for lift
and stair 6648.30
sqm.)
: 117090.76
sqm. (area
relaxation as per
KMC rule for
lift and stair
49559.80 sqm.)
: 341551.41 sqm. (area
relaxation as per KMC
rule for lift and stair
11604.10 sqm.)
: 329946.51
sqm. (area
relaxation as per
KMC rule for
lift and stairs :
11604.10 sqm.)
Ground Coverage : 8453.80 sqm.
(3.18% of land area)
: 3157.64 sqm.
(1.05% of land
area)
: 11611.44 sqm.
: 11611.44 sqm.
(4.42%) against
permissible
50%
Total Paved Area : 23815.98 sqm.
: 13761.03 sqm.
(5.18% of land
area)
: 37577.01 sqm.

Landscaped Green
Area
: 30831.62 sqm.
(11.62% of land
area)
: 25698.58 sqm.
(9.68% of land
area)
: 56530.20 sqm.

Exclusive Tree
Plantation Area
: 17999 sqm. (6.78%
of land area)
: 10288 sqm.
(3.87% of land
area)
: 28287 sqm. (10.76%
of land area)

Water body Area
(Artificial)
: 2745.41 sqm.
: 1724.92 sqm.
(0.65% of land
area)
: 4470.33 sqm. (1.70%
of land area)

Others (Gas bank,
Transformer Yard,
STP, gas bank,
garbage collection
& reuse)
: 2119.32 sqm.
: 702.13 sqm.
(0.30% of land
area)
: 2821.45 sqm. (1.10%
of land area)

No. of Trees to be
planted
: 1400 nos. : 800 nos. : 2200 nos.
No. of Parking
spaces
: 2387 nos.
(Basement 1 - 1167,
Basement 2 1114 &
Open 106 = Total
2387)
: 2387 nos.
(Covered
2281 & open
106)
Nos. of Solar
Lights
: 20 nos. : 17 nos. : 37 nos.
Total Power
requirement
(demand load)
: 9.723 MW, CESC : 4.005 MW,
CESC
: 13.728 MW, CESC
Page 5 of 47
sanctioned
plan
Backup Power : DG Sets (4x630
KVA, 2x1000 KVA,
2x1250 KVA,
1x1500 KVA) =
8520 KVA
: DG Sets
(1x1000 KVA,
2x1250 KVA) =
3500 KVA
: 12020 KVA

SEAC also taken note of S.O 2559(E) dated 22.08.2013 issued by MoEF.

The case was put up for reconsideration. The SEAC reviewed the case and after detailed discussion, SEAC
opined that since Phase I of the project has already been recommended with a note that construction
activity had already been started and also submitted draft EIA report as per ToR issued by SEAC, the case
may be forwarded to SEIAA for information and opinion.

2. Proposed expansion of Residential Complex 'Vivek Bihar' by M/s. Howrah Mills Company Pvt
Ltd. at premises no. 493/C/A & 493/C/B, G.T Road, P.O+P.S-Shibpur, Ward no.-36, Howrah
Municipal Corporation, Howrah 711 102.

Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of residential complex having 600 nos. of flats (Phase IV-6 Blocks of
G+V storied building, Phase V-22 Blocks of G+V storied building).

Chronology:
The SEAC recommended the project to delist as per MoEF Guidelines in 78
th
meeting held on
08.05.2013. Meanwhile SEAC has received a letter from pp along with revised FORM I, IA and
project report on 30.05.2013.
Salient features of the proposed revised project are
Existing Proposed Total
Land Area 32797.25 sq.m (8.104
acres)
32797.25 sq.m (8.104
acres)
Expected Population 2500 1400 3900
Total Water requirement 416 KLD 203 KLD 619 KLD (HMC
supply)
Domestic water
requirement
342 KLD 192 KLD 534 KLD
Wastewater generated 430 KLD
Wastewater treated 430 KLD
Wastewater recycled Nil
Page 6 of 47
Existing Proposed Total
Wastewater discharged 430 KLD
Rain water harvesting Storage- 2250 KLPA
recharge- 3 wells @
12KLD
Solid waste disposal 1.5 TPD 0.794 TPD 2.31 TPD
Total Built-up Area 67163.406 sq.m 32421.213 sq.m 99584.619 sq.m
Nos. of flats 600 336 936
Ground Coverage 11193.901 sq.m
11193.901 sq.m
Height of the building G+V (18.60 m) vertical 3 nos. floor G+VIII (27.60 m)
Exclusive tree plantation
area
4176.24 sq.m (14.38%
of land area)
9115.694 sq.m
Soft Area (other than
plantation)
5401.49 sq.m (16.47%
of land area)
3556.02 sq.m (10.84%
of land area)
Total Paved area 11.23.21 sq.m (34.22%
of land area)
7950.425 sq.m(24.25%
of land area)
Car parking area (Open &
MLCP)
262.38 sq.m (0.80% of
land area)
981.185 sq.m (2.99%
of land area)
No. of plantation proposed 35 425 460
No. of Parking spaces
proposed
319 nos. (Open-21,
Covered-298)
253 nos. 572 nos. (Covered-
467, MLCP-84, Open-
21.)
No. of solar street light 44 nos.
Total Power requirement 2590 KW , CESC
Backup Power 3x180 KVA 3x180 KVA

The case was put up for reconsideration. During the meeting SEAC scrutinized the submission and
recommended to forward the submission made by the project proponent to the SEIAA for opinion and
necessary action.

3. Proposed expansion of the Residential Complex by Army Welfare Housing Organisation
(AWHO) at Holding No. RGM.AS/534/04, Teghoria VIP Road, Jl. No. 9, Mouza Teghoria,
Jl. No. 5, Mouza Kaikhali, Rajarhat Gopalpur Municipality Ward No. 10 & 11, PO
Airport, PS - Rajarhat, Dist. 24 Parganas (North), Kolkata 700052, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of the Residential Complex of AWHO. The PHASE I of the
residential complex has been sanctioned by Rajarhat Gopalpur Municipality on 23.04.1997 and already
Page 7 of 47
constructed. The PHASE I consists of 234 flats in 16 Residential blocks, Site Office and Security
Room having total built up area 26838.808 sqm. The proposed PHASE II shall consist of 180 flats in 9
Residential blocks and Club having total built up area 30042.77 sqm. The total no. of flats will be 414
and total built up area including both phases will be 56881.58 sqm.

Chronology:
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 65
th
SEAC meeting held on 20.03.2012. The
modified features of the proposed project are as follows: -

PHASE I (Existing) PHASE II (Proposed) Total Project
Total Land Area : 11.713 acres (47400.435 sqm.)
No. of Flats : 234 : 180 : 414
Building Profile : 2 nos. G+3 storied, 15
nos. G+IV storied and 2
nos. single storied
buildings
: 9 nos. G+V storied
and 1 no. G+1 storied
buildings
: 25 nos. Residential
buildings, Site Office,
Security Room & Club.
Expected Population : 1170 (residents), 170
(others) = Total 1340
persons
: 900 (residents), 120
persons
: 2070 (residents), 290
persons
Total Water
requirement
: 220 KLD (Operation
stage)
stage)
stage)
Fresh Water
requirement (existing
borewells & municipal
supply)
: 318 KLD
Wastewater generated : 254 KLD (to be treated in
STP)
Wastewater recycled
(DG cooling, internal
road and pavement
cleaning and
landscaping)
: 101 KLD (to be reused
after treatment in STP)
Wastewater
discharged
: 102 KLD (to be discharged
to municipal drain after
treatment in STP)
Page 8 of 47
PHASE I (Existing) PHASE II (Proposed) Total Project
Solid waste disposal : 0.68 tonnes per day : 0.52 tonnes per : 1.2 tonnes per day (to be
disposed off through
Rajarhat Gopalpur
Municipality)
Total Built-up Area : 26838.808 sqm. : 30042.77 sqm. : 56881.58 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 6736.93 sqm. (14.21 %
of land area)
: 5383.02 sqm. (11.35
% of land area)
: 12119.95 sqm. (25.56 % of
land area)
Internal road &
Pavement
: 5171.21 sqm.(10.90%
of land area)
: : 9275.11 sqm. (19.56% of
land area)
Landscaped Area :15219.97 sqm.(32.10%
of land area)
: : 24430.377 sqm.(49.43% of
land area)
Surface Car parking : 1600 sqm. (3.375% of
land area)
: 2575 sqm. (5.43% of land
area)
Total No. of plantation : 38 : 637 : 675
proposed
: Total 218 nos.
(Covered Parking 90
nos.,
Surface 128 nos.)
: Total 190 nos.
(Covered 112 nos.,
Surface 78 nos.)
: 408 (covered 202, open
206)
Total Power
requirement
: 750 KW, WBSEDCL : 1630 KW,
WBSEDCL
: 2380 KW, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (2 x 250
KVA)
: DG Sets (2 x 250
KVA)
: DG Sets (4 x 250 KVA)

The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following
recommendations in the 65
th
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 12.07.2013 from
the unit is given below :-
However the SEAC recommended the project to delist as per MoEF Guidelines in 78
th
meeting held
on 08.05.2013. SEAC has received response of the pp on 12.07.2013 as follows:-

Directions of the Committee dated 02.04.2012 Response of the Proponent received on
12.07.2013
Registration for the existing borewells to
be obtained from the concerned authority.
The proponent submitted 2 nos. permit for
sinking of new well, i) 25 m
3
/hr for 6 hours
/day and ii) 20 m
3
/hr. for 6 hrs./day. Total
permission obtained for 270m
3
/day
Page 9 of 47
Directions of the Committee dated 02.04.2012 Response of the Proponent received on
12.07.2013
You may also kindly note that as per your
submission the concerned municipality will
collect and finally dispose the solid waste.
The municipality should possess a valid
Municipal Solid Waste Authorization
Certificate.
The proponent has submitted the
concurrence letter issued by the Rajarhat-
Gopalpur Municipality for supply of water,
discharge of treated wastewater and
collection of solid waste.

The case was put up for reconsideration. The SEAC, after scrutinising the documents submitted by the
project proponent and detailed discussion has decided to forward the same to the SEIAA for the opinion
and necessary action.

4. Proposed Residential Complex TEEN KANYA by M/s. Bengal Shelter Housing Development
Ltd. at Plot No. AA/II-B/BLK/4, Action Area II, New Town, Rajarhat, Dist 24 Parganas
(North), PIN 700136, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex (3 blocks of B+G+16 storied buildings, 3
blocks of B+G+13 storied buildings, 2 blocks of G+4 storied buildings) having 387 apartments
alongwith Commercial block (G+2 storied).
Chronology:
During presentation / interaction in the 51
st
SEAC meeting held on 03.02.2011, the committee
realized that the construction work in this project has started without prior permission under the
Environmental Acts. The SEAC forwarded this case to SEIAA for necessary action for violation of
environmental rules and regulations.
The proponent mentioned vide letter dated 17.11.2011, that they have already submitted Rs. 1 lakh as
per the direction of Dept. of Environment, GoWB.
The unit again presented their proposal before SEAC on 61
st
SEAC meeting held on 29.11.2011. The
State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations
in the 61
st
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 27.12.2012 from the unit is given
below :-

Directions of the Committee dated 19.12.2011 Response of the Proponent 27.12.2012
1) The project proponent should have the
provision for installing package STP plant
which can be operated in case the building is
ready for use before the WBHIDCO STP
become functional and the sewer line is
connected to the said project premises.
a) The proponent has submitted a
declaration that possession of the flats in
the Residential Complex
TEENKANYA will be handled over
only after commissioning of the common
sewage treatment plant of Action Area II
by NKDA with drainage connectivity to
the project.
North 24 Pgns. W/S Divn II, P.H.E., Dte.
Vide letter dated 30/08/2010 states that
sewage generated from the project will be
received in sewer line of P.H.E.
Page 10 of 47
2) The revised Rainwater Harvesting plan with
recharge structure design drawing should be
submitted.
b) The proponent has mentioned that
Surface Storage potential of RWH 9.20
lacs ltr. and Sub-surface recharge
potential 12.90 lac ltr. The unit
submitted that storage capacity - 60m
3
in
UG reservoir and 2 nos. recharge wells of
depth 90m and 150 mm dia.
3) A correct and revised area statement should be
submitted. Gridded Master plan of the proposed
project with detailed landuse classification,
infrastructural services etc. and proper area
statement (clearly mentioning Ground
Coverage, Paved Area, Green Area, Waterbody
etc.) should be submitted in larger format.
Existing structures, trees and waterbody, if any,
should be clearly shown in the proposed Master
Plan. The plantation area should be clearly
specified. The total paved area should not
exceed 25% of land area.
c) Gridded Master plan submitted.
Area of the plot 4.942 acre = 20000
sqm.
Proposed Ground Coverage
6986.354 sqm. (34.93% of land area)
Green Area 5022.665 sqm.
Paved Area 3915.968 sqm.
Open Parking Area 540.341 sqm.

4) Detailed calculation of car parking requirement
alongwith provision of the relevant Building
Rules should be submitted.
d) Submitted. Total Parking required 471
nos. The unit proposed 477 nos.
(Covered Parking 471 nos. & Open
Parking 6 nos.)
5) As agreed during presentation written
commitment should be submitted mentioning
that 50% of the peripheral lights (60 solar lights
out of 120 peripheral lights) would be based on
solar power.
e) PP shall install 50% of Peripheral Street
light by solar power.
6) Height clearance from AAI should be
submitted, if applicable.
f) Height clearance from AAI obtained.
7) Detailed and time bound CSR plan should be
submitted.
g) Submitted.

The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has reviewed the letter submitted by the
proponent on 27.12.2012 in the 75
th
meeting held on 30.01.2013. The SEAC made the following
th
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 24.04.2013 from
the unit is given below :
1. The budget allocated towards Corporate
Social Responsibility should amount to at least
2 percent of the total project cost.
1. The proponent has submitted the revised
CSR proposal.

2. Calculation for area statement should be
correctly submitted. Ground coverage, paved
area, green area, service area, open parking
etc. should be clearly mentioned.
2. The proponent has submitted the revised
area statement. However, area statement
is not clear.
Page 11 of 47
3. Number of trees proposed to be planted to be
correctly mentioned based on the exclusive
tree plantation area available for the project.
3. The pp has submitted the revised species
wise plantation list.

The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has reviewed the letter submitted by the
proponent on 24.04.2013 in the 78
th
meeting held on 08.05.2013. The SEAC made the following
th
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 12.06.13 from the
unit is given below :
Directions of the Committee dated
23.05.2013
Response of the Proponent 12.06.2013 & 24.06.13
1) Revised CSR proposal which should
include necessary support for the
underprivileged in the following
category: Health & Poverty reduction,
education sector.
1) The proponent has not submitted the revised CSR
proposal.

2) Revised Area statement (in gridded
layout) clearly showing ground
coverage, extended basement,
exclusive tree plantation area, other
green area, open parking, service area
etc.
The proponent has submitted the revised area
statement mentioning that :
Area of the plot 4.942 acre = 20000 sqm.
Proposed Ground Coverage 6986.354 sqm.
Green Area for plantation 5022.665 sqm.
Paved Area 3638.955 sqm. (18.19% of land
area)
Open Parking Area 540.341 sqm. (2.70% of
land area)
Service area- 809.038 sq.m(4.05% of land area)
Lawn over basement- 3002.647 sq.m (15.01% of
land area)
Total Built Up area (including services & parking)
: 59514.724 sq.m
3) Revised Tree plantation plan. 2) The pp has mentioned that total no of tree
plantation-1477 nos.

The case was put up for consideration. SEAC had taken note of MoEF OM No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II (I)
dated 12.12.2012 and the case was forwarded to SEIAA for necessary action.

5. Proposed Residential Complex "SUNRISE GREENS" by M/s. Bengal Park Chambers Housing
Development Ltd. at Dag No. 3202, JL No. 23, Mouza - Ghuni, PS - Rajarhat, Dist. - 24 Parganas
(N).

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 508 flats (6 blocks of G+16
storied buildings and 1 block of G+8 storied building).

Page 12 of 47
Chronology:
nd
SEAC meeting held on 14.08.2008. The State
Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the
22
nd
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 04.05.2012 from the unit is given below :-

28.08.2008
Response of the Proponent 04.05.2012 & 31.05.2012
1. The concurrence letter from the
appropriate authorities for water
supply, receiving treated wastewater
discharge and collection and final
disposal of solid waste should be
submitted.
1. The pp has submitted permission for ground water
abstraction @78m3/day and application for another
bore well for abstraction of balance ground water.
The pp also submitted No Objection letter issued by
I&W Dept. GoWB for disposal of sewerage to
bagjola khal from STP of the PP.
PP also submitted a letter from RAMKY for
collection of MSW.
2. The car parking break-up calculation
along with the parking area statement
should be submitted.
2. Detail calculation of car parking has been submitted
mentioning Total car parking- 555 nos.(Open-196
& open-359).

After scrutinizing the above letter, the SEAC has issued a letter on 20.06.2012 for submission of
additional clarification. SEAC has also recommended the project to be delisted as per MoEF
guidelines. Meanwhile the PP has submitted clarification along with revised proposal on 03.05.2013 as
below and also submitted a prayer on 26.09.2013 to consider the case:
Salient Features Earlier proposal (as per
presentation)
Revised proposal
Land Area : 30566.50 sqm. : 30566.50 sqm.
Expected Population : 2540 :
Total Water requirement : 381 KLD (Operation stage) :
Fresh Water requirement : 106 KLD (supply by local
authority)
: Permission obtained for tube
well 13m3/hr @ 6 hrs/day &
15m3/hr @3 hrs/day
Wastewater generated : 305 KLD (to be treated in STP) :
Wastewater recycled : 275 KLD (to be reused after
treatment in STP)
:
Solid waste disposal : 1.27 tonne per day (to be disposed
off through local authority)
:
Total Built-up Area : 71688.37 sqm. : 71688.37 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 6322.39 sqm. (20.68% of land
area)
: 7334.6749 sqm. (23.996% of
land area)
Tree plantation Area : 6113.30 sqm. (20% of land area) : 6368.53 sqm. (20.835% of land
area)
Page 13 of 47
Salient Features Earlier proposal (as per
presentation)
Revised proposal
Soft Area : 10051.22 sqm. (32.89% of land
area)
: 8267.355 sqm. (27.047% of land
area)
Paved Area : 7609.22 sqm. (24.89% of land
area)
: 7609.22 sqm. (24.89% of land
area)
Swimming Pool : 470.37 sqm. (1.54% of land area) : 491.621 sqm. (1.54% of land
area)
Service area : 495.1 sq.m (1.6 % of land area)
proposed
: 510 : 555
Total Power requirement : 3000 KVA, WBSEDCL : 3000 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (1no. 100 KVA, 2nos.
750 KVA)
: DG Sets (1no. 100 KVA, 2nos.
750 KVA)

The case was put up for consideration in the 79
th
SEAC meeting held on 28.12.2013 and SEAC, after
detailed discussion, has decided to forward the same to the SEIAA for the opinion and necessary action.

B. Note on Reconsideration Proposals

Industry Sector :-

1. Proposed expansion project for enhancement of production of Unsaturated Polyester Resins by
M/s. Strongbonds Polyseal Pvt. Ltd. at Plot No. 26/C, 26/D/1 & 26/D/2, Kalyani Industrial
Estate Phase I, Block D, Dist. Nadia, Pin 741235, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is an expansion proposal for enhancement of production capacity of Unsaturated Polyester Resins
(UPR) by 690 TPA. The proposed plant will be located adjacent to the existing plant at Kalyani
Industrial Estate. During the 52
nd
SEAC meeting it has been understood by SEAC that the proposed
expansion work has been started before obtaining environmental clearance. The PP has given an
undertaking that they will not continue any work for expansion project before getting all statutory
clearances to SEAC on 13.10.11

Chronology:
The case was recommended by SEAC in the 60
th
SEAC meeting held on 24.10.2011 with condition
that the effluent as well as kettle wash water should be suitably treated in ETP to meet environmental
standards. The effluent should be reused within the plant as much as possible and only the excess flow
is to be discharged after compliance with the environmental standards. Effluent treatment plant should
be monitored on a regular basis.
The Member Secretary, SEIAA noted that there is a lack of clarity regarding effluent treatment unit
(both existing as well as proposed unit) and returned the case to SEAC with a request to get the
clarification on effluent treatment from the project proponent.
Page 14 of 47
The case was placed in the 63
rd
SEAC meeting held on 31.01.2012 and the committee has sought
observation from WBPCB regarding the present status of effluent treatment plant.
The unit was inspected by Board officials on 02.04.2012 and it was observed that the process does not
require any water. Water is by-product generated due to polymerization process which is collected in a
container for pH correction by caustic soda and then evaporated in an evaporator and released through
a stack of ht. 24 m from ground level.
The unit has submitted a letter dated 03.05.2012 mentioning that earlier the unit had biological effluent
treatment plant for treatment of water generated from the process. However, the unit has failed to
maintain the anaerobic bacteria, in most cases it died and instead controlling the oxygen deficiencies it
was actually increasing the BOD and COD level. Therefore, the unit has installed evaporator by
discarding the ETP.
The unit has also proposed to install higher capacity evaporator for the expansion project and
mentioned that as the polymerization reaction is hydrophobic in nature, no water is used to clean the
reactor. Styrene Monomer which is used as raw material and is also a solvent for the product is used
for cleaning.
The solid waste remaining after evaporation is sent to WBWML, Haldia and unit has obtained
hazardous waste authorization from WBPCB for existing plant.
The SEAC has reviewed the letter of the pp submitted on 07.05.2012 in the 67
th
meeting held on
25.04.2012 and made the following recommendations. Subsequent response dated 28.02.2013 from the
unit is given below :-

29.05.2012
Response of the Proponent 28.02.2013
i. A detailed proposal for Effluent
Treatment Plant.
1. The project proponent mentioned that the wastewater
from the reaction chamber is slightly acidic in nature.
Such acidic effluent is initially neutralized using
caustic. Neutralized effluent is then put into an
evaporator (functioning at more than 100C). Water
vapour from the evaporator is released to the
atmosphere through a piping system (comprising of SS
and FRP pipes). Wastewater treatment flow sheet
submitted in this regard.
ii. Analysis report of stack gas
emitted from the evaporator
especially with respect to
composition of volatile
substances for the existing plant.
2. The unit has submitted Chromatogram Plot of organic
compounds present in flue gas. The unit has also
submitted list of organic compounds identified by
GC/MS analysis.
The proponent mentioned that Sludge generated in the
evaporator is hazardous in nature. Such sludge is being
handed over to West Bengal Waste Management Ltd.
for ultimate disposal which is accomplished by
incineration at WBWMLs own facility. The unit has
also submitted application for renewal of Hazardous
Waste Authorization to WBPCB, Authorization was
valid upto 30.04.2012.

Page 15 of 47
The SEAC has reviewed the letter submitted by the pp on 28.02.2013 in the 77
th
meeting held on
26.03.2013. The SEAC has recommended that a detailed proposal for effluent treatment plant to be
submitted.
The unit has submitted the detailed proposal for effluent treatment plant along with the flow diagram
on 14.05.2013. The proposed ETP shall comprise of the following: Reaction Chamber, Settling
Chamber, Sand Filter Bed, Collection pit, Carbon Bed, Biological Chamber followed by another
Carbon Bed.

The case was put up for consideration. SEAC after reviewing the letter submitted by the proponent,
recommended that project proponent should submit waste water characteristics and schematic of the
proposed wastewater treatment system with influent and effluent data and the case was recommended to
SEIAA for taking further necessary action since the proposed expansion of the project has already been
started without obtaining prior environmental clearance.

2. Proposed expansion project for installation of Induction Furnace by M/s. VSP Udyog Pvt. Ltd.
at Jl. No. 58, 65, Banskopa More, Vill. & Mouza Gopalpur, PO - Bamunara, PS Kanksa,
SD Durgapur, Dist. - Burdwan, Pin 713212, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion for installation of Induction Furnace (1x15T) for manufacturing MS
billets (45000 TPA) at the existing plant. The existing and the proposed facilities are as follows :
Installations Existing Capacity Proposed Capacity
Induction Furnace 2x8T (45600 TPA) 1x15T (45000 TPA)
Rolling Mill 80000 TPA

Chronology:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) made the following recommendations in the 56
th

meeting held on 15.07.2011 and the subsequent response from the unit submitted on 18.10.2011, is
given below :-.
Directions of the Committee issued on
22.07.2011
Response of the Proponent dated 18.10.2011
The Rainwater Harvesting proposal
should be revised as advised during the
presentation and submitted to the SEAC.
The proponent has submitted RWH proposal
considering annual rainfall of 1330 mm. The
proponent has proposed to provide storage
capacity of 1107 m
3
approx.
Prior permission is to be obtained for
groundwater abstraction for the existing
project.
The proponent has mentioned that they have
approached the concerned authority for
groundwater permission for existing project.
However, the permission has not yet been
obtained since the concerned officer has been
replaced and the new person has not yet joined.
Species wise plantation list should be
submitted.
The proponent has submitted the list of existing
trees (75) and proposed plantation.
Page 16 of 47
22.07.2011
Specific Corporate Social Responsibility
(CSR) plan with adequate financial
commitment for improvement of
neighbourhood area of proposed project
site should be submitted. Atleast 5% of
the project cost should be utilised for
Corporate Social Responsibility
programmes.
The proponent has submitted the details of CSR
proposal along with financial planning.

The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has reviewed the letter dated 18.10.2011 in the
60
th
meeting held on 24.10.2011 and the committee recommended the project proponent to submit the
prior approval for groundwater abstraction for the existing project.
As per the submission of the unit dated 25.03.2013, unit has submitted the copy of permission for
abstraction of ground water..

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration of the proposal and detailed
discussion, the SEAC recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.

3. Proposed Kharia Clay Mine project by M/s. N. P. Minerals at Patel Nagar, PO Md. Bazar, Dist
Birbhum, PIN 731 231, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for Kharia Clay Mine of Lease area 7.22 ha.
Chronology:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) made the following recommendations in the 77
th

meeting held on 08.05.2013 and the subsequent response from the unit submitted on 13.08.2013, is
given below :-

22.04.2013
Present status of the project to be
submitted.
The proponent has submitted that it is an operating
manual china clay mine since 30.01.1987 within
envisaged production capacity 16000 tonnes of clay.
Current status of mining lease for the
mining activity to be submitted.
The proponent has mentioned that first mining lease
was granted on 04.06.1986 for 20 years. Application
for renewal of next 20 years was submitted to
competent authority before the expiry of the lease.
Project Feasibility Report should be
prepared as per OM issued by MoEF
dated 30.12.2010.
The proponent has submitted project report.

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration and detailed discussion of the
proposal, the SEAC recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.

Page 17 of 47

Construction Sector :-

4. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Anant Shri Sukhramji Trust at 156B, Manicktala Main
Road, KMC Ward No. 32, PS Manicktala, Kolkata 700 054, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex comprising a front residential block of
B+G+23 storied building and a Rear Block of B+G+7 storied building.
Chronology:
The SEAC stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance for the proposed project in the 75
th

Now the unit has submitted the copy of the building plan sanctioned by the KMC for the proposed
project on 02.04.2013, 30.04.2013 & 07.05.2013. The modified features of the proposed project are as
follows: -
As per SCEC dated 27.02.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted
on 02.04.2013
Land Area : 7468.87 sqm. : 7468.87 sqm.
(Land area as per ULCR 7990.00
sqm Gifted land 521.13 sqm.)
Expected Population : Fixed 408 persons, Floating
373 persons
: Fixed 408 persons, Floating 373
persons (no. of tenements 68)
Total water requirement : 84 KLD (during operation) : 84 KLD (during operation)
Fresh water requirement : 84 KLD (KMC supply) : 84 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 62 KLD : 62 KLD
Waste water discharged : 62 KLD (to be discharged to
KMC sewer)
: 62 KLD (to be discharged to KMC
sewer)
Wastewater recycled : NIL : NIL
Solid waste disposal : 265.5 kg. per day (through KMC
disposal system)
: 265.5 kg. per day (through KMC
disposal system)
Total Built-up Area : 28196.31 sqm. (including
parking)
: 28146.59 sqm. (including
parking)
area)
: 3359.06 sqm. (44.97% of land area)
Road Area : 1356.62 sqm. (18.16% of land
area)
: 1356.62 sqm. (18.16% of land area)
Semi Paved Area : 944.81 sqm. (12.65% of land
area)
: 944.81 sqm. (12.65% of land area)
Page 18 of 47
As per SCEC dated 27.02.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted
on 02.04.2013
Total Soft scape Area : 2280.785 sqm. (30.54% of land
area)
: 2280.785 sqm. (30.54% of land
area)
Total Hard scape Area : 1829.025 sqm. (24.49% of land
area)
: 1829.025 sqm. (24.49% of land
area)
Tree Plantation Area : 1808.38 sqm. (24.21% of land
area)
: 1808.38 sqm. (24.21% of land area)
No. of plantation
proposed
: Mandatory Plantation 130 trees,
Compensatory Plantation 35 trees
: Mandatory Plantation 130 trees,
Compensatory Plantation 35 trees
proposed
: 234 (covered 149, open 85) : Front Block 137 (Basement 25,
ground covered 27, ground open 85),
Rear Block-97 (Basement 59, ground
covered 17, first floor 21)
Total Power requirement : 1100 KW, CESC : 1100 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (2x400 KW) : DG Sets (2x400 KW)

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration of the proposal, the SEAC
recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.

5. Proposed Residential Complex UNIMARK RIVIERA by Shri Ajay Banerjee, Sanjay Banerjee
& Malay Kumar Banerjee at Jl. No. - 9, Plot No. 20 & 22, B.G.T Road, Mouza Bhadrakali, PS
Uttarpara, PO Bhadrakali, Uttarpara-Kotrung Municipality, Dist. Hooghly, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex comprising of 5 Blocks of G+11 storied
buildings having 492 nos. residential flats and 01 Commercial Block of G+5 storied building. Block 1
and 2 has commercial area at ground floor and 1
st
floor.

Chronology:
th

Now the unit has submitted the copy of the sanctioned building plan for the proposed project on
19.03.2013. The modified features of the proposed project are as follows: -
As per SCEC dated 27.02.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted on
09.04.2013
Land Area : 22158.31 sqm. : 22158.31 sqm.
Expected Population : 2460 (fixed), 250 (floating), 50
(service)
: 2460 (fixed), 250 (floating), 50
(service)
Total Water requirement : 487 KLD (Operation stage) : 487 KLD (Operation stage)
Page 19 of 47
09.04.2013
Fresh Water requirement : 310 KLD (Municipality supply) : 310 KLD (Municipality supply)
Wastewater generated : 355.2 KLD (to be treated in
STP)
: 355.2 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 176.2 KLD (flushing,
landscaping, car and road
washing)
: 176.2 KLD (flushing, landscaping,
car and road washing)
Wastewater discharged : 161.2 KLD (to be discharged to
municipal drainage)
: 161.2 KLD (to be discharged to
municipal drainage)
Solid waste disposal : 1521 kg. per day (to be
disposed off through Municipal
Waste disposal system)
: 1521 kg. per day (to be disposed off
through Municipal Waste disposal
system)
area)
: 8153.481 sqm. (36.8% of land area)
as per sanctioned plan.
257.41 sqm. (1.16% of land area)
(electrical service spaces, security
gumty and fire pump room. Therefore
total ground coverage is 8410.891
sqm.)
Road Area : 4654.39 sqm. (21.01% of land
area)
: 4654.39 sqm. (21.01% of land area)
Other Green Area : 2119.659 sqm. (9.57% of land
area)
: 2119.659 sqm. (9.57% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation
Area
: 4468.44 sqm. (20.17% of land
area)
: 4468.44 sqm. (20.17% of land area)
Water body : 792.43 sqm. (3.57% of land
area)
: 792.43 sqm. (3.57% of land area)
Open Parking Area : 1712.5 sqm. (7.72% of land
area)
: 1712.5 sqm. (7.72% of land area)
Total Hardscape area : 5510.64 sqm (24.87% of land
area)
: 5510.64 sqm (24.87% of land area)
Total Softscape area : 7444.35 sqm (33.60% of land
area)
: 7444.35 sqm (33.60% of land area)
No. of Parking Spaces
proposed
: 506 (Covered 369, Open 137) : 506 (Covered 369, Open 137)
No. of Trees to be
planted
: 312 nos. : 312 nos.
Page 20 of 47
09.04.2013
Total number of solar
lights
: 50% of the total number of
street lights
: 50% of the total number of street
lights
Daily Power requirement : 2500 KVA, CESC : 2500 KVA, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (1x1000 KVA and
2x500 KVA)
: DG Sets (1x1000 KVA and 2x500
KVA)

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration of the proposal, the SEAC

6. Proposed Residential cum Commercial Complex by M/s. Akhileswar Properties Ltd. at Premises
No. U 131, S.A. Farooque Road (Akra Road), JL No. 78, 79, KMC Ward No. - 139, PS
Metiabruz, Kolkata 700018, Dist. 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential cum Commercial Complex having 252 flats (1
block of B+G+6 storied building, 20.9m from GL). The proposed project will be developed in place of
the existing market. The existing shops (2058 nos.) will be rehabilitated in the proposed project.

Chronology:
th

Now the unit has submitted the copy of the sanctioned building plan sanctioned by KMC for the
proposed project on 15.05.2013. The modified features of the proposed project are as follows: -
16.05.2013
Land Area : 20997.081 sqm. : 20997.081 sqm.
Expected Population : Residential 1260, Others -
7176
: Residential 1260, Others - 7176
Fresh Water requirement : 356 KLD (KMC supply) : 356 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 262 KLD (to be discharged to
KMC sewer after treatment in
Septic tank)
sewer after treatment in Septic tank)
Solid waste disposal : 2.22 tonnes per day (to be
disposed off through KMC)
: 2.22 tonnes per day (to be disposed
off through KMC)
Total Built-up Area : 65169.963 sqm. (including car
parking and service area)
:50871.909 sq.m(Total covered area as
per sanctioned plan)
65169.963 sqm. (including car
parking and service area)
Page 21 of 47
16.05.2013
area)
: 9415.449 sqm. (44.84% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 5140.31 sqm. (24.48% of land
area)
: 5140.31 sqm. (24.48% of land area)
Landscaped Green Area : 6441.32 sqm. (30.68% of land
area)
: 6441.32 sqm. (30.68% of land area)
No. of Plantation : Existing -15, Proposed - 285 : Existing -15, Proposed - 285
proposed
: Cars 406 (Covered - 304, Open
- 102), Trucks 30 (Open)
: Cars 406 (Covered - 304, Open -
102), Trucks 30 (Open)
Total Power requirement : 700 KW, CESC : 700 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (2 x 320 KVA) : DG Sets (2 x 320 KVA)

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration of the proposal the SEAC

7. Proposed Residential Complex by Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority at Plot No. 1/3,
CIT Scheme VII (M), PS Maniktala, PO Kankurgachi, KMC Ward No. 32, Kolkata 700
054, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex comprising of (3 blocks of B+G+27
storied buildings with podium, 2 blocks of G+5 storied buildings and 5 blocks of G+6 storied
buildings), maximum height 102.80m. The project will also comprise of Club house and banquet hall.
Dismantling and demolition of existing old dilapidated buildings will be done by authorities.
Chronology:
th

Now the unit has submitted the copy of the building plan for the proposed project on 28.05.2013. The
modified features of the proposed project are as follows: -

As per SCEC dated 04.06.2012 As per Sanctioned Plan
submitted on 28.05.2013
Total Land Area : 23377.68 sqm.(5.7768 acres) : 23377.68 sqm.(5.7768 acres)
Expected Population : 2659 (fixed), 150 (floating) :
No. of units : Towers 229, Rehabilitation
block 160, Club house - 1,
Banquet Hall - 400
: Towers 229, Rehabilitation
block 160, Club house - 1,
Banquet Hall - 400
Total Water requirement : 442 KLD (Operation stage,
KMC supply)
:
Page 22 of 47
As per SCEC dated 04.06.2012 As per Sanctioned Plan
submitted on 28.05.2013
Wastewater generated : 325 KLD (to be discharged to
KMC sewer)
:
Solid waste disposal : 1.2 tonnes per day (to be
disposed off through municipal
authority)
:
area)
: 8104.25 sqm. (34.67% of land
area)
Area
: 4722.290 sq.m (20.20% of land
area)
: 4722.290 sq.m (20.20% of land
area)
Total paved area : 4870.22 sqm. (20.83% of land
area)
: 4870.22 sqm. (20.83% of land
area)
Total Power requirement : 2850 KVA, CESC : 2850 KVA, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (4x380 KVA, 2x125
KVA)
: DG Sets (4x380 KVA, 2x125
KVA)
proposed
: 580 (Covered-437, Open-143) : 580 (Covered-437, Open-143)
Min. No. of solar street
lights proposed
:50 nos. :50 nos.
Min. No. of plantation
proposed
: 600 nos. : 600 nos.

The case was placed for reconsideration. After careful consideration of the proposal the SEAC

8. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. IPW Containers Pvt. Ltd. & 21 Others at Plot No. 70,
South Sinthee Road, KMC Ward No. 2, Borough I, PS Sinthee, Kolkata 700 030, West
Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of residential complex having 173 nos. of flats (3 blocks of B+8 &
community block G+1 storied).
Salient features of the proposed project are
Land Area : 8741.081 sq.m(2.15 acres)
Land gifted : 127.69 sq.m (1.46% of land area)
Expected Population : 1230 (Permanent-865 & temporary-365)
Total Water requirement : 172 KLD(Operational stage)
Fresh water requirement : 172 KLD
Page 23 of 47
Wastewater generated : 124 KLD
Wastewater treated : Nil
Wastewater recycled : Nil
Wastewater discharged : 124 KLD
Solid waste disposal : 0.6 TPD
Total Built-up Area : 20590.60 sq.m
Ground Coverage : 2605.384 sq.m (29.81% of land area)
Exclusive tree plantation area : 1768.75 sq.m (20.23% of land area)
Total Green Area : 2629.5 sq.m(30.08% of land area)
Paved area : 2039.45 sq.m(23.33% of land area)
Water body : Relocated water body- 1205.5 sq.m (13.79% of land area) as per
letter of Fisheries Department dated. 31.08.2012
No. of plantation proposed : 120 nos.
No. of Solar Street lights
proposed
: 29 nos.
proposed
: 126 nos.
Total Power requirement : 1200 KVA, CESC
Backup Power : 2x500 KVA & 1x125 KVA

Chronology:
th
77
th

22.04.2013
1. Height clearance from competent
authority to be obtained.
1) The height of the buildings will be restricted within
85 feet i.e. 25.5 meters. As per Airport Authority of
India Circular No. AAI/ER/NOC/GENL/711-714
dated 11.10.2007, no NOC is required upto height of
85 feet for the projects above 4 km. from the edge of
Runway Aerial distance of the project from Runway
is more than 5 km. So no height clearance is
required from Airport Authority of India.
2. Number of trees proposed to be
planted to be increased and types of
trees to be planted to be modified as
discussed during the presentation.
2) PP submitted revised tree plantation list for 150 no
of trees.
Page 24 of 47
22.04.2013
3. Revised CSR proposal to be
submitted.
3) The proponent mentioned that the CSR commitment
will be Rs. 15 lakhs for three years. Breakup of CSR
activities submitted.

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration the SEAC recommended stipulated
conditions for environmental clearance for the project with provision of STP and treated wastewater
recycle facility.

9. Proposed Education cum Social Complex by M/s. Acharya Mahapragya Mahashraman
Education & Research Foundation (AMMERF) at Plot No. III A/1, Action Area III, New Town,
PS Kolkata Leather Complex, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of Education cum Social Complex.

Chronology:
Land Area : As per deed- 4.2 acres (17000.80 sq.m)
Expected Population : 4032 persons (during operation)
Total Water requirement : 244 KLD
Fresh water requirement : 208 KLD (WBHIDCO/NKDA supply)
Wastewater treated : 168 KLD
Wastewater recycled : 36 KLD (landscaping and car washing)
Wastewater discharged : 132 KLD (WBHIDCO/NKDA sewer line)
Rain water harvesting : surface storage-100 KL& recharge -3270 KL/ annum.
The PP will install 2 nos. recharge well
Nos. of building blocks : Block 1: Part A- Meditation Centre and Ashrama- G+4
storied, Part B- Educational supporting facilities- G+4
storied, Part C- Old age home/ resting shelter- G+10
storied, Part D- Educational block (school)- G+6 & G+5
storied
Block 2: Residential- G+16 storied and a common
basement
Total Built-up Area : 49709.58 sq.m (including parking)
Exclusive tree plantation area : 3560.75 sq.m (20.94% of land area)
Page 25 of 47
Road/paved area (beyond basement) : 2827.24 sq.m (16.63% of land area)
Semi paved area beyond basement : 77.6 sq.m (0.46% of land area)
Basement (beyond building footprint) : 2490.29 sq.m (14.65% of land area)
Service area : 386.58 sq.m (2.27% of land area)
Total Green Area : 5444.18 sq.m (31.87% of land area)
Total Paved area : 3511.71 sq.m (20.66% of land area)
No. of plantation proposed : 240 nos., Esisting- 1 no tree to be retained.
No. of Solar Street lights proposed : 31 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : Open-5 nos bus., 280 nos car (basement and ground floor
-covered)
Total Power requirement : 3750 KVA- WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets ( 6x500 KVA,)

th
78
th

Depth of recharge well proposed to be
checked.
1. As per the detailed analysis depth of
recharge tube well is 85-97 meter.
CSR proposal to be submitted with focus on
underprivileged community as discussed
during the presentation.
2. CSR proposal submitted.
Car parking calculations to be checked. 3. Car parking calculation submitted.

The case was put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration of the proposal The SEAC
recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.

10. Proposed expansion of the Educational Institute HERITAGE GROUP OF INSTITUTIONS
by Kalyan Bharti Trust at Premises No. 994, Chowbaga Road, Jl. No. 12, Mouza
Madurdaha, KMC Ward No. 108, PS Tiljala, PO East Kolkata Township, Kolkata
700107, Dist. 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of an existing Educational Institution.

Chronology:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) approved Provisional Environmental Clearance
for the proposed project in the 58
th
SEAC meeting held on 19.08.2011.
The project proponent has submitted the copy of the building plans sanctioned by KMC and the
following comparative statement
Page 26 of 47
Existing
Features
(PHASE I)
Expansion
Proposal
(PHASE II)
Total Project as
per provisional
EC issued on
20.09.2011
As per Sanctioned
Plan by KMC
Land Area : 60533.45 sqm. : 60533.45 sqm.
Building Profile : 8 nos.
Institutional
buildings, 1no.
Service block,
1no. Substation
and 2 nos.
Security
Blocks.
: 1 no.
Institutional
building (B+G+6
storied)
: 12 nos. buildings : 12 nos. buildings
Expected
Population
: 5500 : 1450 : 6950 : 6950
Total Water
requirement
: 408 KLD : 170 KLD : 578 KLD
(Operation stage)
: 578 KLD
Fresh Water
requirement
: 287 KLD
(borewell)
: 95 KLD (KMC
supply)
: 382 KLD (KMC
supply)
: 382 KLD (KMC
supply)
Wastewater
generated
: 306 KLD (to be
treated in STP)
: 306 KLD (to be
treated in STP)
Wastewater
recycled
: 193 KLD (to be
reused after
treatment in STP)
: 193 KLD (to be
reused after
treatment in STP)
Wastewater
discharged
: 82 KLD (to be
discharged to
municipal drain
after treatment in
STP)
: 82 KLD (to be
discharged to
municipal drain after
treatment in STP)
Solid waste
disposal
: 2.15 tonnes
per day
: 0.68 tonnes per
day
: 2.83 tonnes per
day (to be disposed
off through local
authority)
: 2.83 tonnes per day
(to be disposed off
through local
authority)
Total Built-up
Area
: 50556.76
sqm.
: 13041.2 sqm. : 63985.16 sqm. : 64074.478 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 12428.84 sqm.
(20.53% of land
area)
: 1885.26 sqm.
(3.11% of land
area)
: 14314.09 sqm.
(23.65% of land
area)
: 14314.09 sqm.
Total Paved Area : 13584.93 sqm.
(22.4% of land
area)
: 13584.93 sqm.
Page 27 of 47
Existing
Features
(PHASE I)
Expansion
Proposal
(PHASE II)
Total Project as
per provisional
EC issued on
20.09.2011
As per Sanctioned
Plan by KMC
Landscaped Green
Area
: 32634.43 sqm.
(53.91% of land
area)
: 32634.43 sqm.
Total No. of
plantation proposed
: 773 : 127 : 900 : 900
No. of Parking
spaces proposed
: Open parking
(Bus 49, Cars
24)
: Open parking (Bus
49, Cars 24)
Total Power
requirement
: 1104 KW, CESC : 1104 KW, CESC
Backup Power (DG
Sets)
: 1x125 KVA &
1x250 KVA
: 1x380 KVA : 1x125 KVA,
1x250 KVA &
1x380 KVA
: 1x125 KVA, 1x250
KVA & 1x380 KVA

The reply dated 25.01.2012 was placed before the SEAC in the 64
th
meeting held on 16.02.2012 and
the committee noted the following and the subsequent response from the unit is furnished below:-
Directions of the Committee, issued on
27.02.2012
Response of the Proponent submitted on
19.03.2012 & 07.05.2012
1) It is not clear whether KMC will supply
water for the entire project or the expansion
project only. Necessary clarifications along
with supporting documents should be
submitted.
KMC assured the pp for supply of portable
water on completion of laying of their
infrastructure in this regard. The pp proposed
that until the availability of required portable
water from KMC groundwater will be
abstracted from existing bore well. Capacity
of the existing bore well 20 m
3
/hr for 3
hours /day.
2) Status of tree plantation for your existing
project including species details.
The pp submitted the details of existing 773
nos. of trees which will be retained in future
also.
3) It is observed that the built up area as per
sanctioned plan by KMC is more than that
for which provisional EC has been issued,
modified area statement and other relevant
details pertaining to the revised built up
should be submitted.
Built-up area is increased due to
rearrangement of architectural plan and
internal spaces of the proposed building.

The reply dated 19.03.2012 and 07.05.2012 was placed before the SEAC in the 69
th
meeting held on
25.07.2012 and the committee noted the permission obtained for drawl of ground water is not adequate
to meet the present water demand. Hence the committee has requested the unit to submit the
permission from the concerned authority for availability of total water demand for whole project and
Page 28 of 47
also referred the case to the Chief Technical Officer, EKWMA regarding the opinion and status of the
site with respect to East Kolkata Wetland.
The unit has submitted their reply on 03.10.2012 along with the permission for ground water
abstraction for 168 KLD. The SEAC has received a opinion of CEO, EKWMA on 24.09.2012.
The PP has again submitted a letter on 26.11.12 mentioning that due to installation of highly water
efficient fixtures and faucets, fresh water consumption will be reduced and will become 267 KLD.
Moreover, as the project is solely institutional in nature and operates generally 8 hrs in a day for 5
days/ week. Thus during weekend days (2 days) total vol. of water abstracted (168x2= 336 KLD) will
be distributed for next 5 days. Therefore daily avg. water availability for 5 days is =168+336/5 = 235
KL approx. Balance water requirement of 267-235=32 KLD which are expecting to be available from
K.M.C supply very soon.

The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has reviewed the letter submitted by the pp on
21.11.2012 in the 73
rd
meeting held on 30.11.2012 and the committee noted the following and the
subsequent response from the unit is furnished below:-
The SEAC has also issued reminder letter as per MoEF guidelines to the PP.
10.12.2012
21.05.2013
1. As the proposed site is just adjacent to
the East Kolkata Wetlands area, the
project proponent is requested to submit
the details in which distance between the
proposed project and East Kolkata
Wetland area boundary is correctly
mentioned.
1) The PP submitted a letter issued by EKWMA
on 20.01.2011 mentioning that the said project
does not fall under EKW area.
2. East Kolkata Wetland is an extremely
important wetlands from ecological and
bio-diversity point of view. Construction
of such tall building is like to have
adverse effects on migration of bird
species. Detail study regarding impact of
the proposed project on the migration of
bird species, fauna to be carried out by an
institute of repute like Wildlife Institute
of India (WII), Bombay Natural History
Society and report to be submitted before
the SEAC.
2) The PP mentioned that there are existing tower
of 7 stories adjacent to the proposed building in
the same campus. The unit requesting to waive
off the report on migratory birds as they
already have existing building of the same
height adjacent to the proposed one.
3. It is noted that there is shortfall in fresh
water supply compared to actual demand.
Project Proponent is requested to provide
specific clarifications to meet up the
shortfall.
3) The PP has obtained permission from SWID
for abstraction of ground water @ 222 m
3
/day.
Though fresh water requirement 382 KLD, pp
will install high water efficient fixtures to
reduce fresh water consumption by 30% i.e.
115 m3/day. Therefore, fresh water
requirement will brought down to 267 m3/day.
Moreover, as the project is solely institutional
in nature and operates generally 8 hrs in a day
for 5 days/ week. Thus during weekend days
(2 days) total vol. of water abstracted (222x2=
Page 29 of 47
10.12.2012
21.05.2013
444KLD) will be distributed for next 5 days.
Therefore daily avg. water availability for 5
days is =222+444/5 = 311 KL approx. Thus the
PP has excess water of (311-267) KLD= 44
KLD.

The case was put up for reconsideration. After carefully considering the submission, the committee noted
that this is an expansion proposal and recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.

11. Proposed Commercial Complex "SOUTHCITY INFRASTRUCTURE TOWER" by M/s.
Southcity Projects (Kolkata) Ltd. at IND 6, Sector K, Nonadanga, PS Tiljala, KMC Ward
No. 108, Kolkata 700107.

Activity:
Initially this was a proposal for construction of a Commercial Complex comprising of 1 block of
B+G+19 storied building.

Chronology:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) granted Provisional Environmental Clearance
for the proposed project during 18
th
The unit has applied for amendment of the Provisional Environmental Clearance. The SEAC granted
the amendment of Provisional Environmental Clearance and again stipulated the conditions for
Environmental Clearance (SCEC) in the 42
nd
SEAC meeting held on 16.03.2010 subject to
submission of original PEC issued by SEAC on 23.05.2008.
The proponent has now submitted to SEAC on 28.05.2012 the copy of the building plans sanctioned
by the KMC on 28.03.2012. The modified salient features of the proposed project as per the
comparative statement submitted by the proponent, are as follows :

As per Stipulated Conditions for
Environmental Clearance dated
12.04.2010
As per KMC Building permit
submitted 0n 28.05.2012
Building Profile : Commercial Complex (1 block of
G+21 storied building) alongwith
MLCP
: Commercial Complex (1 block of
B+G+12 storied building)
alongwith MLCP
Total Land Area as per
deed
: 10117.14 sqm.
: 10117.14 sqm.
Net Land Area
: 2.5 acres (10111.38 sqm.)
: 2.5 acres (10111.38 sqm.)
Expected Population
: 2000 persons
: 2000 persons
Total Water requirement
: 100 KLD (Operation stage)
: 100 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water
requirement
: 60 KLD (KMC supply)
: 60 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated
: 72 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Page 30 of 47

As per Stipulated Conditions for
Environmental Clearance dated
12.04.2010
As per KMC Building permit
submitted 0n 28.05.2012
treatment in STP)
: 40 KLD (to be reused after
treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged
sewer line after treatment in STP)
: 32 KLD (to be discharged to
KMC sewer line after treatment in
STP)
Solid waste disposal : 0.40 tonne per day (to be disposed
off through KMC)
: 0.40 tonne per day (to be
disposed off through KMC)
Total Built-up Area
: 38037.27 sqm.
: 30146.46 sqm.
Ground Coverage
: 3134 sqm. (31% of land area).
: 3469.74 sqm. (34.32% of land
area).
Landscaped Green Area : 2055.64 sqm. (20.33% of land
area).
: 2055.64 sqm. (20.33% of land
area).
Other Soft Area : 2415.13 sqm. (23.89% of land
area).
: 2076.44 sqm. (20.54% of land
area).
Paved Area : 2506.61 sqm. (24.79% of land
area).
: 2509.56 sqm. (24.82% of land
area).
Nos. of Parking spaces
proposed
: 286 : 250 (231 covered, 19 open)
Total No of Trees
proposed to be planted
:150
Total Power
requirement
: 3500 KVA, CESC.
: 3500 KVA, CESC.
Backup Power
: 3 nos. DG Sets each 1250 KVA.
: 3 nos. DG Sets each 1250 KVA.

The PP has submitted the letter dated 18.06.2012 that even though the total built up area has been
reduced, the carpet area for Business use and Banquet work out to be 20118 sq.m. Assuming
population @ 10 sq.m. per person, the expected population still remains about 2000. Thus the
population and water consumption figures remain unchanged. The PP has submitted modified area
statement and also enclosed gridded master plan showing landscaped green area, paved area etc.

The PP has submitted rainwater harvesting proposal as per SEAC guidelines. The reply submitted on
28.05.2012 and 05.07.2012 was considered in the 69
th
SEAC meeting held on 25.07.2012 and the
committee recommended that the source of fresh water required for the project should be specified.
And since the project is located very close to EKW, the opinion of the EKWMA in respect of impact
of the project of the East Kolkata Wetlands to be obtained.

The unit submitted their reply on 05.11.2012 enclosing a permit for sinking of new deep tube
well.SEAC also received observations of CEO,EKWA on 21.09.2012 which are as follows: -
The PP has submitted a letter on 20.05.2013 stating that few large projects in the vicinity have
conducted such study from reputed institutions and have already submitted reports to SEAC and the
proposed project is within 2 KM areal distance of the said large projects and smaller in height
compared to these large projects and hereby requesting not to insist to carry out such studies.
Page 31 of 47

The case was put up for reconsideration. After carefully considering the submission, the committee
recommended that the project proponent should comply with the earlier letter issued by the SEAC.

12. Proposed Commercial Complex "ALCOVE GLORIA" (formerly named as CITY
JUNCTION) by M/s. Amba Highrise Pvt. Ltd. at Premises No. - 403/1, Dakshindari Road,
South Dum Dum Municipality Ward No. 34, PS Lake Town, Kolkata 700 048.

Activity:
This was a proposal for construction of a Commercial Complex (1 block of 2B+LG+G+9 storied
building) comprising of Anchor Stores, Hyper Market, Shops, Multiplex, Food Court, Restaurants
and Hotel (168 rooms).
The above proposal was considered in the 23
rd
SEAC meeting held on 15.09.2008 and 24
th
SEAC
meeting held on 30.09.2008. The Provisional Environmental Clearance was issued on 16.10.2008 for
the proposed Commercial Complex.
The proponent submitted a modified proposal vide letter dated 11.01.2010, for a Residential complex
(1 block of 2B+LG+G+17 storied building) comprising of 250 flats and 16 Commercial units.

Chronology:
The modified proposal has been considered in the 40
th
SEAC meeting held on 22.01.2010 and the State
Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) granted Provisional Environmental Clearance during 40
th

The proponent has submitted the copy of the building plans provisionally sanctioned by the South
Dum Dum Municipality on 08.02.2010. The modified salient features of the proposed project as per
the comparative statement submitted by the proponent, are as follows:
As mentioned in Stipulated
Conditions dated 09.02.2010
As mentioned in sanctioned
plan dated 08.02.2010 and
letter dated 22.05.2013
Land Area : 12914.50 sqm. : 12914.50 sqm.
Building Profile : 250 flats, 16 commercial units (1
Block of 2B+LG+G+17)
: 236 flats, 16 commercial units
(1 Block of 2B+LG+G+17)
Expected Population : 1250 (fixed), 250 (floating) : 1200 (fixed), 250 (floating)
Total Water requirement : 200 KLD : 192 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 120 KLD (SDDM supply) : 112 KLD (Groundwater supply)
Domestic Water
requirement
: 200 KLD : 192 KLD
Wastewater generated : 160 KLD (to be treated in STP,
partly reused and partly discharged
to SDDM sewer line)
: 154 KLD (to be treated in STP,
partly reused and partly
discharged to SDDM sewer line)
treatment in STP)
treatment in STP)
Solid waste disposal : 0.675 TPD (to be disposed off
through SDDM)
: 0.675 TPD (to be disposed off
through SDDM)
Page 32 of 47
As mentioned in Stipulated
Conditions dated 09.02.2010
As mentioned in sanctioned
plan dated 08.02.2010 and
letter dated 22.05.2013
Ground Coverage : 5790 sqm. (44.89% of land area) : 5708.57 sqm. (44.20% of land
area)
Landscaped Green Area : 2582.90 sqm. (20% of land area) : 2582.90 sqm. (20% of land
area)
Other Soft Area : 892.74 sqm. (6.95% of land area) : 892.74 sqm. (6.95% of land
area)
Hard Area : 3226.63 sqm. (24.98% of land
area)
: 3226.63 sqm. (24.98% of land
area)
Artificial Water Body : 422.23 sqm. (3.27% of land area) : 422.23 sqm. (3.27% of land
area)
Nos. of Parking spaces
proposed
: Total - 570, Covered - 525, Open -
45
: Total - 349, Covered - 308,
Open - 41
Proposed no. of tree
Plantation
: 181 nos. :
Total Power requirement : 3500 KVA, CESC : 3500 KVA, CESC
Backup Power : DG sets (2 x 500 KVA, 2 x 630
KVA)
: DG sets (1x350 KVA,1x1010
KVA, 1x450 KVA,1x1250 KVA)
Construction started : : Yes

The case was placed for reconsideration. During the meeting, the SEAC has observed that the project
proponent has already started construction activity for the above project without obtaining prior
Environmental Clearance. The SEAC recommended to forward this case to SEIAA, West Bengal for
taking necessary action in terms of Office Memorandum vide No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II(I) dated
12.12.2012 of MoEF, Govt. of India.

13. Proposed modification of Commercial Complex SPENCER SHOPPING MALL by M/s. CESC
Limited at 33, Syed Amir Ali Avenue, PS Karaya, KMC Ward No. 64, Kolkata 700 017,
West Bengal.

Activity:
This was a proposal for construction of Commercial Complex (3B+G+5 storied) along with MLCP
(4B+G+6 storied) with total Built up area 66142.64 sqm. and obtained EC from SEIAA on 12.08.2008.
SEAC received a letter issued vide memo no. EN/3410/T-II-1/007/2008 dated 13.12.2010 from Sr.
Environment Officer, Department of Environment, GoWB regarding deviation of the project from
approved EC.
Now the unit has applied for modification of above EC with proposal for Commercial Complex
comprising of 1 Block of 2B+G+5 storied shopping mall consisting about 140 retail units, 3 nos. mall
offices, 6 multiplexes and 1 no. 24 seater theatre, 1 food court and 5 restaurants and basement 2 of
commercial block and 3B+G+10 storied MLCP.
Page 33 of 47

Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed modified project are

Features As per EC dated 12.08.2008 Present proposal
Land Area : 13963.34 sqm. : 13963.34 sqm.
Expected Population : 5500 (operational phase) : 6062 (operational phase)
Total water requirement : 207 KLD : 425 KLD
Fresh water requirement : 142 KLD (KMC supply) : 275 KLD (KMC supply)
Domestic Water Requirement : 90 KLD : 208 KLD
Wastewater generated : 72 KLD (to be treated in
STP)
Wastewater recycled : 65 KLD : 150 KLD
Solid waste disposal : 1.65 Tonnes per day
(through KMC)
: 1.82 Tonnes per day (through
KMC)
Total Built-up Area : 66142.64 sqm. (Commercial
- 34716.75 sqm., MLCP
31425.89 sqm.)
: 66817.04 sqm. (Commercial
36309.38 sqm., MLCP
30507.66 sqm.)
Ground Coverage : Commercial 5545.16 sqm.
(39.71% of land area), MLCP
1850.24 sqm. (13.25% of
land area)
: Commercial 5572.21 sqm.
(39.90% of land area), MLCP
1860.74 sqm. (13.33% of land
area)
Landscaped Green area : 3147.33 sqm. (22.54 % of
land area)
: 2828.63sqm(20.26% of land
area)
Paved area : 3421.02 sqm(24.5% of land
area)
:2943.66 sqm (21.08% of land
area)
Utility service : 758.10 sqm (5.43% of land
area)
STP & UGR : 411.663 sqm. (1.945% of
land area)

No. of plantation proposed : 441 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 878 nos. : 864 nos.
Total Power requirement : 4464 KVA, CESC : 4950 KVA
Backup Power : DG Sets (3x1000 KVA) : DG Sets (2x1500 KVA)

th
75
th
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 30.04.2013 from the unit is given below :
Page 34 of 47

11.03.2013
30.04.2013
1. A minimum of 20% of the total land
area for the project should be allocated
as exclusive tree plantation area. Total
number and detailed list of trees to be
planted should be submitted.
1. The proponent has submitted detailed plantation
list having total no. of trees 222.
Ground coverage- 7432.95 sq.m (53.23%)
Paved area- 2943 sq.m (21.08%)
Tree plantation area- 2828.63 sq.m (20.26%)
Utility service- 758.10 sq.m (5.43%)
2. Budget allocated for Corporate Social
Responsibility programme should be at
least 2 percent of the project cost and
should be formulated for the local
community within a radius of about 10
kms around the project site.
2. The proponent has mentioned that total CSR
proposal would be 2% of the project costs.
3. Rain water harvesting recharge
calculations to be checked and
resubmitted.
3. The pp has submitted that volume of surface
storage- 600 cum & subsurface recharge-2550
cum to be done using 11 nos. recharge wells

The case was put up for reconsideration. After carefully considering the proposal, the committee noted
that project proponent has already started construction as per revised proposal. During the said meeting
SEAC had also taken the note of MoEF OM No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II (I) dated 12.12.2012 &
27.06.2013 and recommended that the case is to be forwarded to SEIAA for necessary action.

14. Proposed Amendment of Environmental Clearance for Hotel cum Commercial Complex by M/s.
Kolkata Hotels Limited at 28, Jessore Road, NSCBI Airport, Dum Dum, Dist. - 24 Parganas
(North), Kolkata - 700 052.

Activity
Initially this was a proposal for construction of a 5 star Hotel (238 rooms), Budget Hotel (96 rooms),
Convention Centre and Commercial Complex. The proposed project (2B+G+10 storied building, max.
ht. 41 m) will come up in place of the existing ITDC Airport Hotel having 156 rooms.
SEIAA issued Environmental Clearance for the project on 16.11.2009.

Now the unit has prayed before SEIAA for amendment for EC.Salient features of the modified proposed
project are

Salient Features As per EC issued by SEIAA Amendment of EC proposal
Land Area : 7 acres (28327.60 sqm.) : 7 acres (28327.60 sqm.)
Profile of Building block : 2B+G+10 storied
5 star hotel - 238 rooms
Budget hotel 96 rooms with convention
centre, commercial complex and
multiplex.
: 2B+G+10 storied
5 star hotel - 251 rooms
Budget hotel 356 rooms, retails
within hotel lobby
Expected Population : 7393 persons : 2347 persons
Page 35 of 47
Salient Features As per EC issued by SEIAA Amendment of EC proposal
Fresh Water requirement : 531 KLD (Dum Dum Municipality
supply)
: 623 KLD (Dum Dum
Municipality supply)
Wastewater generated : 593 KLD (to be treated in STP) : 667 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater reused : 470 KLD (to be reused after treatment in
STP)
treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged : 63 KLD (to be discharged to Municipal
drain after treatment in STP)
: 95 KLD (to be discharged to
Municipal drain after treatment in
STP)
Solid waste disposal : 2.6 TPD : 0.935 TPD
Total Built-up Area : 76828 sqm. : 76264.977 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 9914.66 sqm. (35% of land area) : 9765.56 sqm. (34.26% of land
area)
Landscaped Green Area : 10506.11 sqm. (37.1% of land area) : 8084.95 sqm. (28.364% of land
area)
Paved Area : 5851.23 sqm. (20.65% of land area) : 6982.413 sqm. (20.65% of land
area)
Semi Paved Area : 2055 sqm. (7.25% of land area) : 3671.354 sqm. (12.88% of land
area)
No. of Parking Spaces
proposed
: 508 nos. : 502 nos.
Plantation proposed : 425 nos. : 425 nos.
Total Power Requirement : 5.6 MVA, WBSEB : 5.0 MVA, WBSEB
Backup Power : 8510 KVA (1x750 KVA, 1x1010 KVA,
3x1250 KVA & 2x1500 KVA)
: 8510 KVA (1x750 KVA,
1x1010 KVA, 3x1250 KVA &
2x1500 KVA)

The case was put up for reconsideration. After carefully considering the proposal,the committee
recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:-
1. Specific calculations for water requirement, waste water generation and water balance as per
MoEF guidelines.
2. Car parking calculations.
3. Concurrence from AAI for revised proposal

It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary
clarification.

Page 36 of 47
15. Proposed IT Park by M/s. Phoenix Software Ltd. at Jl. No. - 35, Mouza Gangapur, Kolkata
Information Technology Park (KITP), Bantala, PS Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. 24
Parganas (South), West Bengal.

During the 69
th
meeting held on 25.07.2012 and the SEAC had directed the PP to submit the source
and availability of fresh water to be supplied by M/s M L Dalmiya and Co. During the 71
st
meeting
held on 24.09.2012, the reply of the unit submitted on 10.09.2012 was reviewed, the project
proponent has mentioned that M/s. M. L. Dalmiya & Co. Ltd. has already given permission vide
letter under Ref. No. L/40/IT-Park/67 dated 03.08.2011.
During the 71
rd
meeting held on 24.09.2012, the SEAC had noted that source and availability of
fresh water as sought earlier is yet to be submitted. The SEAC had also recommended that specific
proposal regarding management of solid waste to be submitted.
During the 73
rd
meeting held on 30.11.2012, the reply of the unit dated 10.010.2012 and
17.10.2012 was considered and SEAC noted that no specific information regarding source and
availability of fresh water as sought by the committee has been provided. Regarding management
of solid wastes, the PP has mentioned that segregation of waste will be done at source and stored in
separate bins. The PP had undertaken to dispose the MSW generated through agency having valid
authorization from WBPCB. E wastes will be handled as per E waste (Management and Handling)
Rules, 2011.

AND

16. Proposed IT Park by M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. at Jl. No. - 35, Mouza Gangapur,
Kolkata Information Technology Park (KITP), Bantala, PS Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist.
24 Parganas (South).
SEAC has recommended EC in the 67
th
meeting held on 21.05.2012 for M/s. Dhunseri
Petrochem & Tea Ltd. SEIAA has sent a letter to SEAC on 16.08.2012 requesting to study the
water balance in CLC area.
The above matter (M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. & M/s. Phoenix Software Ltd.) was
discussed in the 71
st
meeting held on 24.09.2012, 73
rd
meeting held on 30.11.2012 & 75
th

meeting held on 30.01.2013 and SEAC had opined that once again Director, SWID, GoWB may
be requested to provide the opinion on the status of water availability based on latest water census
in the concerned area. However, no such response received.

The above two cases were considered in the 77
th
SEAC meeting held on 26.03.2013 and the
committee has issued a reminder letter to the SWID for providing opinion as per latest water
census of the area and these two cases have been kept pending due to non-availability of opinion
of SWID.

Further the SEAC has received a letter dated 25.04.2013 issued by the Director, State Water
Investigation Directorate regarding EC in respect to applicants namely M/s Phoenix Software Ltd.,
M/s Dhunseri Petrochem and Tea Ltd., and M/s Cognizant Technology Solutions India (P) Ltd. to
be located at KITP Bantala. The letter mentions that
a) M/s. Dalmiya & Co. has already been entrusted to cater the total water requirement at Kolkata
Leather Complex, Bantala and SWID has already allotted them 26 no. of DTW particularly for
the tannery units of Kolkata Leather Complex.
Page 37 of 47
b) Present requirement of water for these users, mentioned in the letter to be located at KITP,
Bantala is in the tune of 900 m
3
/day.
c) It is proposed that allocation of one more tubewell with the discharge of 90m
3
/h for 10 hrs./day
may be installed in the specific location (i.e. plot 20 or 21) within the campus of Kolkata
Leather Complex to augment the water supply arrangement by M/s. Dalmiya & Co.
d) This tubewell is allocated in addition to 26 nos. of proposed tubewell at Kolkata Leather
Complex.
e) The tubewell may be installed of same size i.e. 300x200 mm with the depth of approx. 200 mt.
bgl.
f) However, M/s. Dalmiya & Co. will be informed by SWID to accommodate the additional
tubewell in their water supply network.
g) M/s. Dalmiya & Co. should apply in Form I at the office of the Geologist & Member
Secretary, DLA of South 24 Parganas & necessary permission in this regard will be provided
by DLA, South 24 parganas as per provisions under GW-Act duly approved by SLA and
Technical Sub-committee.
M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. have submitted a letter to the Member Secretary, WBPCB
on 03.10.2013 informing that M/s M L Dalmiya has already applied to SWID for installation of an
additional tubewell as recommended by SWID. Letter of M/s ML Dalmiya dated 11.09.2013
addressed to the PP in this regard has been enclosed. Copy of TR Form 7 regarding deposit of
requisite fees has been also enclosed.
The case was placed for reconsideration. The SEAC considered the submission by the proponent and
remarks of the SWID. The SEAC recommended and sent the reply of SWID to SEIAA for their
consideration and necessary action.
M/s. Phoenix Software Ltd have submitted a letter to the Member Secretary, WBPCB on
01.11.2013 informing that M/s M L Dalmiya has already applied to SWID for installation of an
additional tubewell as recommended by SWID. Letter of M/s ML Dalmiya dated 11.09.2013
addressed to the PP in this regard has been enclosed. Copy of TR Form 7 regarding deposit of
requisite fees has been also enclosed.
The case was placed for reconsideration. The SEAC considered the submission by the proponent and
remarks of the SWID. The SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance
for M/s. Phoenix Software Ltd.

17. Proposed Residential Complex IDEAL EXOTICA by M/s. Ideal Real Estates Pvt. Ltd. at 21,
Pramatha Choudhury Sarani, KMC Ward No. 81, PS New Alipore, Kolkata 700 053.

Activity:

This is a proposal for construction of Residential Complex having 158 flats (5 blocks of 2B+G+21
storied buildings) and club house.

Land Area : 15363.43 sqm.
Expected Population : 896 persons
Total Water requirement : 138.91 KLD (Operation stage)
Page 38 of 47
Fresh Water requirement : 110.43 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 105.17 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 28.48 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged : 76.69 KLD (to be discharged to KMC sewer after treatment in
STP)
Solid waste disposal : 0.525 tonnes per day (to be disposed off through KMC)
Total Built-up Area : 60672.28 sqm. (including parking)
Ground Coverage : 4116.05 sqm. (26.8 % of land area)
CESC Area : 107.91 sqm. (0.70% of land area)
Road Area : 2530.50 sqm. (16.47% of land area)
Semi Paved Area : 2467.08 sqm. (16.06% of land area)
Plantation Area : 3203.52 sqm. (20.86% of land area)
Other Green Area : 2937.63 sqm. (19.12% of land area)
Total No. of proposed plantation : 266 (existing 41, proposed 225)
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 298 (covered , open )
Total Power requirement : 2.5 MW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (2x500 KVA)

Chronology:
During the presentation in the 59
th
meeting held on 20.09.2011, the SEAC has observed that this
housing project has been proposed in a site which is likely to be contaminated due to past industrial
activity. The SEAC directed vide letter dated 10.10.2011 that the project proponent should first assess
the level and type of remediation required, prepare specific site remediation plan and get the site
remediated properly. The project proponent should also obtain necessary approval from West Bengal
Pollution Control Board after remediation. The SEAC decided that this case would be considered only
after the above actions are satisfactorily executed.
The proponent submitted their reply on 21.11.2011. The proponent has submitted the test results
conducted by National Test House for nickel content only. The project proponent has mentioned that
since the nickel content at site is 10 times lower than the threshold limit, no remediation is necessary.
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has considered the submission of the pp dated
21.11.2011 in the 61
st
meeting held on 29.11.2011. The committee requested the pp to assess the level
of contamination in the proposed site by a competent agency like NEERI and address all the issues
raised in the previous letter dated 10.10.2011.
The pp again submitted a reply on 30.01.2012 mentioning that they have obtained test result through
National Test House, a Govt. of India organisation, it is observed from their report that nickel content
was determined to be 0.05% by mass. The threshold limit for nickel as per Hazardous Waste
(Management & Handling) Rules is 5000 mg/kg which is equivalent to 0.5% by mass. As the nickel
content is 10 times lower than the threshold limit no remediation measures are deemed necessary.
Page 39 of 47
The pp has submitted a reply along with the test report of NEERI on 21.03.2013. They also mentioned
that the nickel content in soil at the abovementioned site is 68.12 mg/kg. by mass. The threshold limit
of nickel as per the Soil Guideline Values (Environment Agency 2009b) for land use for residential
use is 130 mg/kg and the Soil guideline Values for Nickel as per India Standards is 75-150 mg/kg.
Therefore, the nickel content at their proposed site is 55% lower than the threshold limit, hence there
will be no harmful effect.
During the 78
th
meeting held on 08.05.2013 SEAC opined that opinion of Waste Management Cell,
WBPCB to be obtained on the report provided by the pp.
Remarks of WMC of WBPCB on the final report submitted by NEERI for the proposed residential
complex is enclosed in Annexure I.
The name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Ghosh Bose & Associates Pvt. Ltd. The case is
placed for reconsideration. The SEAC considered the submission by the proponent and remarks of the
WMC, WBPCB and recommended that the project proponent should submit the report after incorporating
necessary modifications as suggested by the WMC, WBPCB.
clarification.

C. Note on Technical presentations
Industry Sector:-

1. Proposed project for non-recovery Coke Oven by M/s. GSA Commercial Pvt. Ltd. at J.L no.-
115, Mouza- Amba, Vill Gokulpur, P.O-Samraipur, P.S-Kharagpur, Dist Paschim
Medinipur, Pin 721301, West Bengal.

Activity:
This was a proposal for non-recovery Coke oven unit of capacity-10000 TPM i.e. 120000 TPA.

Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are :
i) Location of the Site - J.L no.-115, Mouza Amba, Vill Gokulpur, P.O-Samraipur, P.S
Kharagpur, Dist Purba Medinipur, Pin 721301(located within the premises of M/s. TATA
Metaliks Ltd.).
ii) Land Area 17 acres.
iii) Greenbelt Development 33% of total land area i.e. 5.61 acres.
iv) Raw Materials Coking coal.
v) Production capacity- Metallurgical Coke-120000 TPA.
vi) Emission sources- Non recovery type coke oven plant (4 batteries having 17 ovens each), Coal
Crushing system, Stack yard.
vii) Emission Control System Two stage Water Scrubber, Cyclone separator with stack of height
30 m from GL to be provided for 17 nos. coke ovens batteries. Stack emission (PM) shall not
exceed 50 mg/Nm
3
. Capacity of WHRB-?
viii) Makeup Water requirement 80 KLD. Source: ground water.
ix) Wastewater quenching wastewater will be recycled after settling and no effluent will be
discharged outside the plant premises. Guard pond will be provided.
Page 40 of 47
x) Solid Waste Coal and Coke fines will be recycled with coal blend. Refractory waste to be used
for low land filling.
xi) Power Requirement 400 KVA from TATA Metaliks Ltd.
xii) Back-up Power Not mentioned.
xiii) CSR- 5% of total project cost (Rs. 5201 lakhs) i.e. Rs 260.05 lakhs.

Name of the Environmental Consultant is not mentioned. After presentation, SEAC recommended ToR
(Annexure II) for conducting draft EIA/EMP reports and the project proponent should submit the final
EIA/EMP before SEAC after conducting public hearing as per EIA notifications and its amendment
thereafter.

2. ToR presentation for proposed stand alone cement grinding unit of capacity-1.50 MTPA and
CPP 10 MW of M/s. Emami Cement Ltd. at Bahadurpur, J.L no. 37, MouzaSitarampur,
Ranipur, Mukundpur & Parrulia, Mejia, Dist-Bankura, Pin- 713336, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for installation of a stand alone Cement Grinding unit (1.5 MTPA) with Coal fired
TPP -10 MW. It is noted that clinker will not be manufactured at the site. The manufacturing process
will involve grinding of Cement Clinker with fly ash and Gypsum.

The project proponent was absent during the meeting. The SEAC recommended that the proposal may be
placed before SEAC on receiving request from the project proponent.

Construction Sector:-

3. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Swastik Projects Pvt. Ltd. at Premises No. 46A/1, Biplabi
Barin Ghosh Sarani (formerly an apportioned portion of Premises No. 46A, Biplabi Barin Ghosh
Sarani), PO Ultadanga, PS Maniktala, KMC Ward No. 14, Kolkata 700 067, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a proposal for Residential Complex comprising of residential block of B+G+ 11 storied
building, community blocks 2 storied and Club. Residential Complex has 185 nos. flats.

Chronology:
Land Area : 9474 sqm.
Expected Population : 1045 (Residents 925, Floating 100, Service Staff 20)
Total water requirement : 160 KLD
Fresh water requirement : 147 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater discharged : 113 KLD (to be discharged to KMC drainage)
Page 41 of 47
Waste water treated : nil
Wastewater recycled : nil
Solid waste disposal : 0.5 Tonnes per day
Total Built-up Area : 21631.19 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 2568.75 sqm. (27.11% of land area)
Area
: 1444.02 sqm. (15.24 % of land area)
Internal Road & Pavement : 1670.76 sqm. (17.64 % of land area)
Existing Waterbody : 2427.97 sqm. (25.63% of land area)
Surface Car parking (Semi
Paved Area)
: 1362.50 sqm. (14.38% of land area)
No. of plantation proposed : 180 nos. (5 nos. trees to be retained)
No. of solar street lights
proposed
: 11 nos. (25%)
proposed
: 181 (covered 72, open 109)
Total Power requirement : 700 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (3x125 KVA)
Rainwater Harvesting : 8 KLD will be collected in existing water body. No recharge
proposed
Corporate Social
Responsibility
: Rs. 9 lakhs

Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was
put up for consideration in the 79
th
SEAC meeting held on 28.12.2013. After carefully considering the
proposal and presentation, the committee recommended that the project proponent should submit the
following:-
1. Proposal for In-house MSW management.
2. Proposal for recycle of waste water to reduce fresh water consumption along with necessary
treatment scheme.
3. Revised CSR proposal.
clarification.

Page 42 of 47

4. Proposed revised proposal for construction of Residential Complex by M/s. Yours Projects Pvt.
Ltd. at Dag No. 2352 & 2353 , Khatian no.-12, J.L No.-13, Holding No. 8, Khudiram Bose Sarani,
Kolkata-700080, Ward No. 21 under Dum Dum Municipality, Dist: North 24 Pgs, West Bengal.

Activity:
This is a revised proposal for construction of residential housing complex having 232 nos. of flats (5
Blocks of B+G+10 storied building.
Chronology:
Land Area
Net Land Area:
: 9376.45 sq.m (of this 998.9 sqm. to be gifted)
8377. 54 sq.m
Expected Population : Total 1316 persons (Residents 1160, Floating 116,
Service Staff 40)
Total Water requirement : 203 KLD (Operation Stage)
Fresh water requirement : 119 KLD (municipality supply)
Domestic Water requirement : 178 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater generated : 142 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 78 KLD (landscaping 59 KLD, Toilet flushing 16 KLD,
Road Cleaning 3 KLD)
Wastewater discharged : 50 KLD to municipality drain
Total Built-up Area : 34285.887 sq.m
Internal Road (100% hard paved) :1223.20 sq.m (13.05% of land area )
Semi Paved area (50% hard paved) : 241.88 sq.m (2.58 % of land area)
Plantation area : 1882.95 sq.m (20.08% of land area)
Services and utilities : 469.48 sq.m (5.01% of land area )
Area gifted to Municipality : 998.91 sq.m (10.65% of land area )
No. of plantation proposed : Proposed - 186 nos., Existing trees - 41 nos., Trees to be
removed - 17 nos., Retained - 24 nos.
No. of Solar Street lights proposed :
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 309 nos. - Covered
Total Power requirement : 1200 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets ( 3x320 KVA)
Page 43 of 47

Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was
put up for consideration in the 79
th
SEAC meeting held on 28.12.2013. After carefully considering the
proposal and presentation, the committee recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance.
Summaries of above decisions are also provided in Table-1.
Table-1 : List of the projects which were placed before the SEAC in the seventy ninth meeting
held on 28.12.2013 at 11:30 hrs. and the Summary Decisions thereof:

A Miscellaneous cases
Sl. No. Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. Discussion on EIA notification, 2006 and several circulars
/ guidelines issued by MoEF time to time regarding
Environmental Clearance.
Discussed and noted
2. M/s. Bengal NRI Complex Limited
Proposed Township URBANA at 782 & 783,
Anandapur, P.O EKTP, Kolkata 700 107.
Forwarded to SEIAA for information and
opinion
3. M/s. Howrah Mills Company Pvt Ltd.
Proposed expansion of Residential Complex 'Vivek Bihar'
at premises no. 493/C/A & 493/C/B, G.T Road, P.O+P.S-
Shibpur, Ward no.-36, Howrah Municipal Corporation,
Howrah-711102.
Forwarded to SEIAA for necessary action
with additional information
4. Army Welfare Housing Organization (AWHO)
Proposed expansion of the Residential Complex at
Holding No. RGM.AS/534/04, Teghoria VIP Road, Jl.
No. 9, Mouza Teghoria, Jl. No. 5, Mouza Kaikhali,
Rajarhat Gopalpur Municipality Ward No. 10 & 11, PO
Airport, PS - Rajarhat, Dist. 24 Parganas (North),
Kolkata 700052, West Bengal.

5. M/s. Bengal Shelter Housing Development Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex TEEN KANYA at Plot
No. AA/II-B/BLK/4, Action Area II, New Town,
Rajarhat, Dist 24 Parganas (North), PIN 700136, West
Bengal.
SEAC has taken the note of MoEF OM
No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II(I) dated
12.12.2012 and forwarded to SEIAA for
necessary action
6. M/s. Bengal Park Chambers Housing Development Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex "SUNRISE GREENS" at
Dag No. 3202, JL No. 23, Mouza Ghuni, PS Rajarhat,
Dist. 24 Parganas (N).

Page 44 of 47
B Cases placed for consideration of Environment Clearance
Sl. No. Name of the unit Summary Decision
1.
M/s. Strongbonds Polyseal Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed expansion project for enhancement of
production of Unsaturated Polyester Resins at Plot No.
26/C, 26/D/1 & 26/D/2, Kalyani Industrial Estate Phase I,
Block D, Dist. Nadia, Pin 741235, West Bengal.
SEAC has taken the note of MoEF OM
No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II(I) dated
12.12.2012 and forwarded to SEIAA for
necessary action.
SEAC further noted that the proponent
must submit waste water characteristics
and schematic of the proposed wastewater
treatment system with influent and effluent
data
2.
M/s. VSP Udyog Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed expansion project for installation of Induction
Furnace at Jl. No. 58, 65, Banskopa More, Vill. &
Mouza Gopalpur, PO Bamunara, PS Kanksa, SD
Durgapur, Dist. Burdwan, Pin 713212, West Bengal.
As the project proponent complied with
recommendations of earlier SEAC
committee meeting dated 24.10.2011, the
proposal is recommended for
Environmental Clearance
3.
M/s. N. P. Minerals
Proposed Kharia Clay Mine project at Patel Nagar, PO
Md. Bazar, Dist Birbhum, PIN 731 231, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental
Clearance with conditions
4.
Anant Shri Sukhramji Trust
Proposed Residential Complex at 156B, Manicktala Main
Road, KMC Ward No. 32, PS Manicktala, Kolkata
700 054, West Bengal.
5.
Shri Ajay Banerjee, Sanjay Banerjee & Malay Kumar
Banerjee
Proposed Residential Complex UNIMARK RIVIERA
at Jl. No. - 9, Plot No. 20, 22B, Mouza Bhadrakali, PS
Uttarpara, PO Bhadrakali, Uttarpara-Kotrung
Municipality, Dist. Hooghly, West Bengal.
6.
M/s. Akhileswar Properties Ltd.
Proposed Residential cum Commercial Complex at
Premises No. U 131, S.A. Farooque Road (Akra Road),
JL No. 78, 79, KMC Ward No. - 139, PS Metiabruz,
Kolkata 700018, Dist. 24 Parganas (South), West
Bengal.
7.
Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority
Proposed Residential Complex at Plot No. 1/3, CIT
Scheme VII (M), PS Maniktala, PO Kankurgachi,
KMC Ward No. 32, Kolkata 700 054, West Bengal.
8.
M/s. IPW Containers Pvt. Ltd. & 21 Others
Proposed Residential Complex at Plot No. 70, South
Sinthee Road, KMC Ward No. 2, Borough I, PS
Sinthee, Kolkata 700 030, West Bengal.
Recommended Stipulated Condition for
Environmental Clearance with provision
for STP and wastewater recycle
Page 45 of 47
9.
M/s. Acharya Mahapragya Mahashraman Education &
Research Foundation (AMMERF)
Proposed Education cum Social Complex at Plot No.
111A/1, Action Area III, New Town, PS Kolkata
Leather Complex, West Bengal.
10.
Kalyan Bharti Trust
Proposed expansion of the Educational Institute
HERITAGE GROUP OF INSTITUTIONS at Premises
No. 994, Chowbaga Road, Jl. No. 12, Mouza
Madurdaha, KMC Ward No. 108, PS Tiljala, PO
East Kolkata Township, Kolkata 700107, Dist. 24
Parganas (South), West Bengal.
Clearance
11.
M/s. Southcity Projects (Kolkata) Ltd.
Proposed Commercial Complex "SOUTHCITY
INFRASTRUCTURE TOWER" at IND 6, Sector K,
Nonadanga, PS Tiljala, KMC Ward No. 108, Kolkata
700107, West Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
12.
M/s. Amba Highrise Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Commercial Complex "ALCOVE GLORIA"
(formerly named as CITY JUNCTION) at Premises No.
- 403/1, Dakshindari Road, South Dum Dum Municipality
Ward No. 34, PS Lake Town, Kolkata 700 048.
Forwarded to SEIAA for information and
necessary action
13.
M/s. CESC Limited
Proposed modification of Commercial Complex
SPENCER SHOPPING MALL at 33, Syed Amir Ali
Avenue, PS Karaya, KMC Ward No. 64, Kolkata
700 017, West Bengal.
Forwarded to SEIAA with reference to
MoEF OM No. J-11013/41/2006-IA.II(I)
dated 27.06.2013 for taking necessary
action.
14.
M/s. Kolkata Hotels Limited
Proposed Hotel cum Commercial Complex at 28, Jessore
Road, NSCBI Airport, Dum Dum, Dist. - 24 Parganas
(North), Kolkata - 700 052.
Asked for Additional clarification
15.
M/s. Phoenix Software Ltd.
Proposed IT Park at Jl. No. - 35, Mouza Gangapur,
Kolkata Information Technology Park (KITP), Bantala,
PS Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. 24 Parganas
(South), West Bengal.
16.
M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd.
Proposed IT Park at Jl. No. - 35, Mouza Gangapur,
Kolkata Information Technology Park (KITP), Bantala,
PS Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. 24 Parganas
(South).
Referred to SEIAA for necessary action
Page 46 of 47
17.
M/s. Ideal Real Estates Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex IDEAL EXOTICA at
21, Pramatha Choudhury Sarani, KMC Ward No. 81, PS
New Alipore, Kolkata 700 053.
Asked for Additional clarification

C
Cases placed for presentation
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1)
M/s. GSA Commercial Pvt. Ltd.
ToR presentation for proposed project for non-recovery
Coke Oven at J.L no.-115, Mouza Amba, Vill
Gokulpur, P.O Samraipur, P.S Kharagpur, Dist
Purba Medinipur, Pin 721301, West Bengal
ToR Recommended
2)
M/s. Emami Cement Ltd.
ToR presentation for proposed stand alone cement
grinding unit of capacity-1.50 MTPA and CPP 10 MW
at Bahadurpur, J.L no. 37, MouzaSitarampur,
Ranipur, Mukundpur & Parrulia, Mejia, Dist-Bankura,
Pin- 713336, West Bengal.
Absent
3)
M/s. Swastik Projects Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex at Premises No. 46A/1,
Biplabi Barin Ghosh Sarani (formerly an apportioned
portion of Premises No. 46A, Biplabi Barin Ghosh
Sarani), PO Ultadanga, PS Maniktala, KMC Ward
No. 14, Kolkata 700 067, West Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
4)
M/s. Yours Projects Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed revised proposal for construction of
Residential Complex at Dag No. 2352 & 2353 ,
Khatian no.-12, J.L No.-13, Holding No. 8, Khudiram
Bose Sarani, Kolkata-700080, Ward No. 21 under
DumDum Municipality, Dist: North 24 Pgs.

The meeting ended with a note of thanks to the Chair.

Page 47 of 47

(Prof. (Dr.) Sudarshan Neogi)
Chairman
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West
Bengal

(Shri Jayanta Bhattacharya)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Dr. Kalyan Rudra)
Member
(Dr. Satya Kinkar Pal)
Member
(Prof. Bhabatosh Biswas)
Member
(Prof. (Dr.) Swadesh Ranjan Raychaudhuri)
Member
(Dr. Anita Chattopadhyay Gupta)
Member
(Dr. Amitava Roy)
Member
(Dr. Arunkanti Biswas)
Member
(Dr. Subrat Mukherjee, I.F.S.)
Secretary

Minute 79

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Minute 79

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Minutes of the seventy ninth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held

Você também pode gostar