7/30/2014 Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity - Offshore

http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-70/issue-11/engineering_-construction/learning-the-lessons-of-deepwater-asset-integrity.html 1/6
Stay Connected
Subscribe: Magazine l Newsletters

Home > Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity
Learning the lessons of deepwater asset
integrity
11/01/2010
Past and recent events point to need for careful assessment of materials performance and corrosion protection

Dr. Binder Singh
Wood Group Integrity Management
Dr. Paul Jukes
MCS Kenny
Bob Wittkower
JP Kenny Inc.
Ben Poblete
Cameron
On the July 6, 1988, the worlds worst offshore oil industry disaster occurred on the Piper Alpha platform in the UK sector
of the North Sea. The loss of life was staggering: 167 dead, with 62 survivors, and dozens badly injured. Much has been
written and debated on the incident. The goal here is to examine a new angle on the subject matter, in the context of
Inherently Safe Design, and the allied second tier items of interest. These are the corrosion-related items that have
been accepted as pertinent over the years, but often erroneously perceived with less priority.
This is largely because the subject matter is considered too specialistic, or complex and often requiring costly subject
matter expertise. As a result, corrosion integrity is sometimes dangerously taken off the agenda by non-subject-
appreciative project or even industry leaders. As part of this process, it is necessary to examine the role of corrosion
mechanisms in the root cause analyses of most significant failures, and virtually all loss-of-performance issues.
Offshore
Digital Magazine
Look Inside
Open +
Home Regional Reports Drilling & Completion Field Development Subsea Geosciences Pipelines Production Rigs/Vessels
Deepwater Business Briefs
7/30/2014 Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity - Offshore
http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-70/issue-11/engineering_-construction/learning-the-lessons-of-deepwater-asset-integrity.html 2/6
Piper Alpha before Accident. (Courtesy Wood Group)
The Piper Alpha accident was a monumental event. It is, perhaps, in terms of impact a top-five engineering disaster on
the global scale, considered to be in the same league as Chernobyl, Challenger, Three Mile Island, Flixborough, etc. In
terms of cost, it was also very expensive (estimated at more than $3.4 billion). And in many ways it is historically
comparable to other
high-impact human events, in that people (certainly in the British Isles and the North Sea community) often remember
where they were on the day. In that way, Piper Alpha seems to have uniqueness about it, which may be due to the fact
that it was offshore and involved a heavily manned producing platform. With the benefit of hindsight, we can conclude
that the disaster was de facto man made, in that the original platform had many major design changes made to convert
it into a gathering and distribution hub.
Though not a deliberate act in any way, many human and engineering errors were seen to hideously come into play.
Many studies have looked at that aspect, including the Cullen Report which was published in 1990. This was the
culmination of a thorough two-year inquiry involving many interviews with survivors, families, and subject-matter experts
of the day. The Cullen report has tended to be the mainstay reference source for all new offshore design and
operational guidelines the world over. Some regions have used the findings rigorously whereas others have used them
less in depth. Overall, the report led to the effective dissolution of the prescriptive regulations sanctioned up to that point,
and replaced them with the evolution of the goal-setting integrity regulations in the UK and with derivatives thereof.
On the plus side, the major outcome of the disaster has been far better, safer, and more efficient engineering practices
for the oil industry. And this, in turn, has reinforced the need for Inherently Safe Designs and procedures. These have
been realized by better, more focused research, better applied knowledge management, and a greater sense of public
and industry responsibility by the new generation of engineers and scientists.
Many more offshore, subsea and integrity-related projects and courses have evolved worldwide, largely at contract
research or post-graduate level, much to the advantage and betterment of the industry. This has been promulgated by
the recognition that the design of the asset structure, pipeline, and pressure plant can no longer be based on
projected revenues alone. Yes, the ultimate decision maker or breaker can and often is the commercial sensibility, but a
greater sense of responsibility to the public, and the environment, has fallen into place. This is largely Regulatory-driven,
but one can still discern a good dose of professionalism, merit and worthiness in the arena.
Root causes
Regarding the accident there was, perhaps, no single root cause event that was to blame. Rather, it was a confluence of
many critical factors that were almost the perfect storm. This is often described as the jigsaw or Swiss cheese effect,
whereupon critical events occurring at a certain juncture in time; and as a consequence the failure sequence fell into
place, with tragic results. In reality, integrity management (IM) is far more complex than basic maintenance (a common
misnomer). The parameters affecting IM are non-linear, and have their greatest impact during IM pre-planning, post-
planning, action and reaction, etc. They usually involve the alignment of bad sequences, events or circumstances. They
are invariably all time-dependent and thus multi-dimensional in nature. This has traditionally made IM a difficult subject
to grasp, especially since it transcends both CAPEX and OPEX cost centers.
The Piper Alpha explosion.
The Piper Alpha platform was commissioned in 1976, but was modified to act as a major gas processing and gathering
station. This meant it was handling large amounts of high-pressure gas, with a dispersed plant layout, making
inspection, maintenance and repair difficult. The rapid technology advances of the day, coupled with powerful
commercial pressures, clearly had a lot to do with the event. Regarding the best way forward, it is important to identify all
integrity-related threats, some of which may be discerned as at a secondary level, albeit with the potential to give similar
disastrous results if not taken fully into account. The majority of these are materials performance and corrosion related.
Basin Modeler - Unconventional
Saudi Aramco
Country: Saudi Arabia
A world leader in the production of hydrocarbon
based energy is building a leading "Unconventional
Gas Team" and seeks a basin modeler to contribute
to the teams advancement in unconventional
gas/liquid plays. Applicants with 10-15 years
industry experience and a strong geological and 3D
basin mode...
Geophysical Consultant (Unconventional)
Saudi Aramco
Country: Saudi Arabia
Geophysicists who have experience in identifying
and characterizing shale and tight gas reservoirs
using seismic data. Saudi Aramcos position as a
world leading hydrocarbon finder and producer
offers unique opportunities for Development
Geologists to realize their full technical potential.
Soon, Sa...
Transmission Line Design Engineer
Great River Energy
Country: United States
General SummaryWe are currently looking for a
Transmission Line Design Engineer who will be
responsible for performing engineering, project
management and technical support for transmission
line design projects.Main responsibilities
include:Provide cost-efficient design and project
management fo...
Engineer (Hydro Plant Support Engineer)
Southern Company
Country: United States
JOB SUMMARYThis position serves as a resource for
hydro management by providing technical field
support and troubleshooting. Provides specialized
hydro consultation services and multidisciplinary
technical support for developing and managing
hydro technical requirements and performing
analytical st...
Civil Engineer III- Geotechnical and Dam
Safety #2014-4703
Dominion
Country: United States
Seeking experienced Civil Engineer III to support our
Power Generation fleet to include 20 classified dams
and containment structures. Outstanding
compensation and benefits. Full relocation
package.Keywords: Geotechnical, Dam, Hydro, Civil
Engineer, Dam Safety, Hydraulics, Hydrology, Dam
Current Issue
Oil & Gas Jobs
View more Job Listings >>
7/30/2014 Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity - Offshore
http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-70/issue-11/engineering_-construction/learning-the-lessons-of-deepwater-asset-integrity.html 3/6
The latter is an important point, and necessitates the examination of second tier issues, which usually arise within
lower profile design parameters. Examples include pressure (leak) containment, corrosion analysis, erosion, wear and
tear, inspection, monitoring, pigging, and maintenance. Thus, it is not hard to see that once the Piper Alpha was
converted to its hub status, it became more important to continue producing. As a result, the inspection, maintenance
and corrosion control aspects became less important.
After the disaster it became apparent that the Piper suffered serious corrosion problems, particularly regarding the
condensate pumping systems, which were in fact later determined to be at the heart of the problem on that fateful day.
Essentially, the condensate pumps were under much delayed repair and maintenance schedules. On the fateful day,
the work was underway but incomplete. Thus, the supervisor prepared a permit to work (ptw) for the work to be
continued by the next shift. The pump was temporarily blanked off, and the paperwork was submitted. Unfortunately, the
ptw got mislaid and the next shift erroneously switched on the pump. Since the backup was offline, the blind flange
failed and a massive leak of gas under high pressure was released. A detonation was inevitable. When it happened,
the fire fighting systems failed, other platforms continued to feed into the hub, and the disaster as we know it unfolded.
After the accident, due to the media frenzy of the day, the causes were variously reported over the first year as: metal
fatigue, poor maintenance, inadequate operating procedures, bad work practices, human error, etc. The full report is a
public document, and much educational material, videos/DVDs etc. are readily available for the interested reader. The
Cullen report and other studies have highlighted many reasons for the disaster, the most damning of which were:
Poor plant design (including rapid modifications and changes)
Breakdown of the permit to work system (probably not fully tested under all scenarios)
Bad maintenance management
Inadequate safety auditing, and training procedures
Poor communications (all levels)
Poor emergency management (including with regard to action of surrounding platforms).
The Cullen report made over 106 recommendations, which included in summary:
The transfer of government responsibility for offshore health and safety to the Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
was generally well received.
The establishment of a Safety Case regime (entailing independent verification).
Overall review of legislation, definition of best practices, and better use of loss prevention studies.
Better work force involvement (crucial but sensitive).
Verification and intervention when necessary.
Permit-to-work systems (ideally fail safe and tamper proof).
Systematic approach to safety, responsibility of everyone (senior management and down the line).
Emergency response and incident reporting (effectively by training and changes in attitude and culture).
It has to be said that most of the activities listed above still fall in the grey area of judgment, and in that case best
practices must therefore be interpreted and applied through the identification of safety critical systems and components,
proactive risk analysis, risk reduction, and therefore risk management. There are many other important derivations from
the Cullen report, but without unnecessarily going outside the scope of this article, it is quite clear that management of
change (MOC) is and will continue to be the best tool available in the ever-improving area of knowledge management.
Industry changes
The many ensuing industry changes identified since the disaster have, in fact, taken many years to come to fruition.
Overall, most offshore regions in particular the North Sea, GoM, and Australia have embraced the new culture of
safety. To be sure, there is sometimes a dangerous disconnect between theory and the actual practice of
implementation. The rest of the world
has responded in a slower manner, but with positive results, especially the SE Asia regions and offshore India.
The very heartening implementation of best practices (by choice, not necessarily regulation) has given greater
confidence for the new, challenging deepwater explorations and subsea tie backs in the GoM and the new frontier Arctic
regions. The most notable changes are interpreted as follows:
Changes to offshore asset design, requirements for design review, more latitude for concept creativity, better
rationale for engineering conservatism and pragmatic safety.
New goal-setting legislation; i.e. the Safety Case, and better use of subject matter experts (SMEs).
The goal setting idea replaces the prescriptive method. This has proved to be a step change in offshore safety
and engineering performance.
For the GoM, it has been stated that the regulations conferred by the governing (now former) MMS are fit for purpose.
This suggests the designs are suitable at construction, but the gradual drift of this meaning has evolved to life-cycle
fitness for purpose and this appears to be adopted and embraced by the more recent generation of engineers (typically
5-10 years
experience) as they enter the fray. The subtle debate now ongoing is at the material selection stage. There are two
schools of thought, namely the distinction being made of whether to select carbon steel and then carefully manage the
operational corrosion; or to select the corrosion resistant alloy option with minimal corrosion management. The contrary
arguments are usually cost-center based, with strong opinions tested for CAPEX and OPEX scenarios. In other words,
do we pick materials for immediate fitness for service at fabrication (just build it) or fitness for materials life cycle
performance? The answer is now emerging as a requirement for both, and to that effect the materials engineering
specialist is having an ever-more assertive role to play within the large multidiscipline teams usually engaged on high
capital projects.
Implementation
The implementation of the Cullen report recommendations has, it is believed, shown through various studies that
reportable incidents that impact safety issues in the UK sector have been significantly reduced by some 75% a major
achievement. This clearly means the industry is on the right track, but there are still problems and issues. It is argued
that more attention should and must be made to the secondary tier items such as root cause corrosion mechanisms,
7/30/2014 Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity - Offshore
http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-70/issue-11/engineering_-construction/learning-the-lessons-of-deepwater-asset-integrity.html 4/6
advanced
monitoring and inspection techniques, etc. This aspect is best illustrated by an adaption of the Swiss cheese effect. It
is to this effect that this article is targeted, with the intent that by paying more focused attention to these parameters and
findings, the integrity management discipline will be more substantively improved.
The Cullen report also identified two areas of under-emphasis that may be appropriately reasoned, firstly the industry
tendency to avoid the acceptance of external consultants advice if the recommendations are not supported by more
experienced personnel, often even if the consultation seems logical and safety sensible. The case of the central riser
argument for the Piper Alpha is cited; here evidently the dangerous proximity of the risers to the control and radio room
areas was, in fact, identified, but no action taken (design change, relocation, blast walling, etc). Nowadays, virtually all
new designs insist on the risers being as far away as possible from the accommodations.
The Swiss cheese analogy as applied to materials engineering.
The second point of observation is the concept of addressing root cause effects. The Piper Alpha condensate pump
problems that initiated the whole tragic sequence of events were plagued with corrosion problems, the attendance to
which was seemingly consistently delayed as lower priority. Apparently some platform corrosion issues were left for
over four years. If corrosion management as a recognized discipline had been in place, rather than an ad hoc to-do
item, then again (with the benefit of hindsight), the tragedy could have been avoided. That, unfortunately, is how the
learning and knowledge management process works. And it has to be said that companies today often have very
valuable lessons-learned meetings after major projects are concluded. There is a strong case, and new initiatives,
underway for such formal lesson learning on an ongoing basis.
The use of modern-day corrosion risk assessment techniques are under development and application. It is hoped that
ultimately these will be implemented by the weight of motivation, though in reality some degree of mandatory regulation
may be ultimately required. In almost all major comparable disaster cases, the commonality has been the confluence of
many variables coming into a tragic alignment, sometimes referred as the jigsaw or Swiss cheese effect. The authors
of this article contend that in almost all cases, the loss of materials performance as stimulated by corrosion is the root
cause effect. A close examination of the modes of failure reveals the uncanny role of corrosion dissolution at either the
macro or micro level (whether it be by alloy, embrittlement, crevice corrosion, mixed metal galvanic, etc) the outcome is
the same: severe loss of material properties and/or load carrying capabilities.
The resolution of the corrosion aspect will, therefore, in virtually all cases eliminate the closure of the jigsaw effect,
thereby preventing the failure. On a positive note, the concepts of knowledge management, advanced inspection
techniques, implementation of MOC, and the more newly defined roles and responsibilities for pertinent decision
makers, etc., have all been very instrumental in making this industry safer and better equipped to tackle the challenges
faced ahead. It is strongly argued that one new recommendation that would be instrumental in helping improve this
aspect an order of magnitude would be the mandatory requirement for each asset to submit a clear annual corrosion
integrity statement on the facility, and pertinent (safety critical parts) thereof. The burden for doing this is not high, but the
results would be extremely positive.
Conclusion
The Piper Alpha review has been a work in progress, with many derived findings, conclusions and specifically KPI-
based recommendations, most of which are capable of being tailored to new and existing projects. The most valuable
observation is the need for continued life cycle vigilance, most likely through diligent but limited regulatory control, since
the North Sea experience has shown that over regulation can impose major financial burdens often to the detriment of
the project, and sometimes to the creativity of solutions.
It is important for the future deepwater offshore community to look more closely at new designs and new solutions from
both a materials fabrication and the materials performance basis, especially for safety critical elements such as SCRs,
and pressure containment plant, and potential leak sources at interfaces. Companies must continually re-educate staff
so that lessons learned (and near misses) are not forgotten, and be prepared to look at alternative approaches to
design/operational issues even if they emanate from unconventional sources.
Better cooperation between the CAPEX and OPEX cost centers is vital if full advantage of lessons learned from Piper
Alpha and other disasters are to be realized. In reality, this may take the form of an extended CAPEX commitment.
History has shown that major step change progress is usually made after major disasters and often through non-
7/30/2014 Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity - Offshore
http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-70/issue-11/engineering_-construction/learning-the-lessons-of-deepwater-asset-integrity.html 5/6
DOT 2013: Tubular Bells a fasttrack success for Hess
Nov 21, 2013 The Tubular Bells deepwater spar production platform is scheduled for start-up mid-2014, only
three years from Hess sanction in 2011, making it a successful fast-track project, said Jason Olson, pr...
Surfactant system could lead to enhanced oil recovery
Nov 21, 2013 Surface Active Solutions has teamed with Exilica to develop a chemical surfactant system named
SAS Oil-Rec.
WFS Technologies and Fugro to offer first wireless ROV integration
Jul 29, 2014 WFS Technologies, which delivers underwater wireless instrumentation and control solutions to
offshore oil and gas operations, and Fugro Subsea Technologies, which designs, builds, and delivers the FCV
range of ROVs to its Subsea Services Division, are jointly offering subsea wireless capability on all FCV Work
Class ROVs from 2015 onward.
Eco Atlantic set to acquire interest in block offshore Ghana
Jul 29, 2014 Eco (Atlantic) Oil & Gas Ltd reports that the Parliament of the Republic of Ghana has ratified a
petroleum agreement pursuant to which the company may acquire a 50.51% interest in the Deepwater Cape
Three Points West block, located in the Tano Cape Three Points basin, offshore Ghana, adjacent to Tullow Oil
plcs producing Jubilee oil field.
BOEM calls for 2017 Beaufort Sea lease sale area nominations
Jul 29, 2014 The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has issued a call for information and nominations for a
potential lease sale offshore Alaska.
Apache hits gas at Phoenix South-1
Jul 29, 2014 Carnarvon Petroleum Ltd. reports that gas and indications of associated liquid hydrocarbons were
observed in the Phoenix South-1 well, offshore Western Australia.
CNOOC, Primeline start up Lishui offshore China
Jul 29, 2014 CNOOC has started production from the Lishui 36-1 gas field.

Offshore Topics
Drilling & Completion
Field Development
Subsea
Geosciences
Pipelines
Production
Rigs/Vessels
Deepwater
Business Briefs
Regional Reports
Africa
Asia
Australia & New Zealand
Canada
Latin America
Middle East
North Sea & Europe
Russia
US & Gulf of Mexico
conventional means. The new solution sets, and developments vis-a- vis inherently safer designs will come from a
closer liaison between industry and academia, as exemplified by the JIPs already in place. The powerful role of
academia whether through JIPs or self driven changes in university curricula will be instrumental in the paradigm
shift required and perhaps expected.
Acknowledgment
Based on a paper presented at the Deep Offshore Technology International Conference, held at the George R. Brown
Convention Center in Houston, Texas, February 2-4, 2010; and on a paper presented at the Offshore Technology
Conference, Offshore Integrity Management 20 years onOverview of Lessons Learnt Post Piper Alpha (Paper # OTC-
20051-PP).
More Offshore Issue Articles
Offshore Articles Archives
View Oil and Gas Articles on PennEnergy.com
More Offshore Issue Articles
Offshore Articles Archives
Related Articles
Trending News
7/30/2014 Learning the lessons of deepwater asset integrity - Offshore
http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-70/issue-11/engineering_-construction/learning-the-lessons-of-deepwater-asset-integrity.html 6/6
1455 W. Loop South, STE. 400
Houston, Texas 77027 | (713)
621-9720
Copyright 2013: PennWell
Corporation All Rights Reserved
Home
About Us
Advertise
Contact Us
Subscribe
Terms
Events
RSS
Company News
Special Reports
Resources
Privacy Policy
General
Regional Reports
Drilling & Completion
Field Development
Subsea
Geosciences
Pipelines
Production
Rigs/Vessels
Deepwater
Business Briefs
Topic Centers
Pennwell
View All Pennwell Websites
View All Pennwell Events
Sitemap
Webmaster
PennWell