Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Brussels
The Low Countries in 1787
hunt3_ch19.qxd 10/26/07 11:44 PM Page 589
for Jews and Protestants (in this resolutely Catholic
area), and suppressed monasteries. His reorgani-
zation of the administrative and judicial systems
eliminated many offices that belonged to nobles
and lawyers, sparking resistance among the upper
classes in 1788.
Upper-class protesters intended only to defend
historic local liberties against an overbearing gov-
ernment. Nonetheless, their resistance galvanized
democrats, who wanted a more representative gov-
ernment and organized clubs to give voice to their
demands. At the end of 1788, a secret society formed
armed companies to prepare an uprising. By late
1789, each province had separately declared its in-
dependence, and the Austrian administration had
collapsed. Delegates from the various provinces de-
clared themselves the United States of Belgium, a
clear reference to the American precedent.
Once again, however, social divisions doomed
the rebels. When the democrats began to challenge
noble authority, aristocratic leaders drew to their
side the Catholic clergy and peasants, who had
little sympathy for the democrats of the cities. Every
Sunday in May and June 1790, thousands of peas-
ant men and women, led by their priests, streamed
into Brussels carrying crucifixes, nooses, and pitch-
forks to intimidate the democrats and defend the
church. Faced with the choice between the Austrian
emperor and our current tyrants, the democrats
chose to support the return of the Austrians under
Emperor Leopold II (r. 17901792), who had suc-
ceeded his brother.
Polish Patriots. A reform party calling itself the
Patriots also emerged in Poland, which had been
shocked by the loss of a third of its territory in the
first partition of 1772. The Patriots sought to over-
haul the weak commonwealth along modern west-
ern European lines and looked to King Stanislaw
August Poniatowski (r. 17641795) to lead them.
A nobleman who owed his crown solely to the du-
bious honor of being Catherine the Greats discarded
lover but who was also a favorite correspondent of
the Parisian salon hostess Madame Geoffrin, Poni-
atowski saw in moderate reform the only chance
for his country to escape the consequences of a
centurys misgovernment and cultural decline.
Ranged against the Patriots stood most of the aris-
tocrats and the formidable Catherine the Great,
determined to uphold imperial Russian influence.
Pleased to see Russian influence waning in
Poland, Austria and Prussia allowed the reform
movement to proceed. In 1788, the Patriots got their
golden chance. Bogged down in war with the
Ottoman Turks, Catherine could not block the sum-
moning of a reform-minded parliament, which
eventually enacted the constitution of May 3, 1791.
It established a hereditary monarchy with some-
what strengthened authority, ended the veto power
that each aristocrat had over legislation, granted
townspeople limited political rights, and vaguely
promised future Jewish emancipation. Abolishing
serfdom was hardly mentioned. Within a year, how-
ever, Catherine II had turned her attention to
Poland and engineered the downfall of the Patriots.
590 Chapter 19 The Cataclysm of Revoluti on 17891799
Revolution
T E R MS O F H I S T O R Y
R
evolution had previously meant cyclical change that brought life
back to a starting point, as a planet makes a revolution around
the sun. Revolutions could come and go, by this definition, and
change nothing fundamental in the structure of society. After 1789,
revolution came to mean a self-conscious attempt to leap into the fu-
ture by reshaping society and politics and even the human personal-
ity. A revolutionary official analyzed the meaning of the word in 1793:
A revolution is never made by halves; it must either be total or it will
abort. . . . Revolutionary means outside of all forms and all rules. In
short, revolution soon had an all-or-nothing meaning; you were either
for the revolution or against it. There could be no in between.
Revolution still has the same meaning given it by the French rev-
olutionaries, but it is now an even more contested term because of its
association with communist theory. In the nineteenth century, Karl
Marx incorporated the French Revolution into his new doctrine of
communism. In his view, the middle-class French revolutionaries had
overthrown the monarchy and the feudal aristocracy to pave the way
for capitalist development. In the future, the proletariat (industrial
workers) would overthrow the capitalist middle class to install a com-
munist government that would abolish private property. Since Marx-
ists claimed the French Revolution as the forerunner of the communist
revolution in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, it was perhaps
inevitable that those who opposed communism would also criticize
the French Revolution.
The most influential example of this view is that of the French
scholar Franois Furet. An ex-communist, Furet argued that the
French Revolution can be seen as the origin of totalitarianism because
it incarnated what Furet calls the illusion of politics, that is, the be-
lief that people can transform social and economic relationships
through political revolution. The French revolutionaries became to-
talitarian, in Furets view, because they wanted to establish a kind of
political and social utopia (a perfect society), in which reason alone
determined the shape of political and social life. Because this dream
is impossible given human resistance to rapid change, the revolution-
aries had to use force to achieve their goals. In other words, revolu-
tion itself was a problematic idea, according to Furet. Revolution as a
term remains as contested as the events that gave rise to it.
hunt3_ch19.qxd 10/26/07 11:44 PM Page 590
Origins of the French Revolution,
17871789
Many French enthusiastically greeted the Ameri-
can experiment in republican government and
supported the Dutch, Belgian, and Polish patriots.
But they did not expect the United States and the
Dutch Republic to provide them a model. Mon-
tesquieu and Rousseau, the leading political theo-
rists of the Enlightenment, taught that republics
suited only small countries, not big ones like
France. After suffering humiliation at the hands of
the British in the Seven Years War (17561763),
the French had regained international prestige by
supporting the victorious Americans, and the
monarchy had shown its eagerness to promote re-
forms. In 1787, for example, the French crown
granted civil rights to Protestants. Yet by the late
1780s, the French monarchy faced a serious fiscal
crisis caused by a mounting deficit. It soon pro-
voked a constitutional crisis of epic proportions.
Fiscal Crisis. Frances fiscal problems stemmed
from its support of the Americans against the
British in the American War of Independence.
About half of the French national budget went to
paying interest on the debt that had accumulated.
In contrast to Great Britain, which had a national
bank to help raise loans for the government, the
French government lived off relatively short-term,
high-interest loans from private sources including
Swiss banks, government annuities, and advances
from tax collectors.
For years the French government had been
trying unsuccessfully to modernize the tax system
to make it more equitable. The peasants bore the
greatest burden of taxes, whereas the nobles and
clergy were largely exempt from them. Tax collec-
tion was also far from systematic: private contrac-
tors collected many taxes and pocketed a large
share of the proceeds. With the growing support
of public opinion, the bond and annuity holders
from the middle and upper classes now demanded
a clearer system of fiscal accountability.
In a monarchy, the rulers character is al-
ways crucial. Many complained that Louis XVI
(r. 17741792) showed more interest in hunting
or in his hobby of making locks than in the prob-
lems of government. His wife, Marie-Antoinette,
was blond, beautiful, and much criticized for her
extravagant taste in clothes, elaborate hairdos, and
supposed indifference to popular misery. When
confronted by the inability of the poor to buy
bread, she was reported to have replied, Let them
eat cake. The Austrian bitch, as underground
writers called her, had been the target of an increas-
ingly nasty pamphlet campaign in the 1780s. By
1789, the queen had become an object of popular
hatred. The kings ineffectiveness and the queens
growing unpopularity helped undermine the
monarchy as an institution.
Faced with a mounting deficit, in 1787 Louis
submitted a package of reforms to the Assembly
of Notables, a group of handpicked nobles, cler-
gymen, and officials. When this group refused to
The Revoluti onary Wave, 17871789 591 17891799
Louis XVI: French King (r. 17741792) who was tried and found
guilty of treason; he was executed on January 21, 1793.
Marie-Antoinette: Wife of Louis XVI and queen of France who
was tried and executed in October 1793.
Queen Marie-Antoinette (detail)
Marie-Louise-lizabeth Vige-Lebrun painted this portrait of the
French queen Marie-Antoinette and her children in 1788. The
eldest son, Louis (not shown in this detail), died in 1789. When
he died, her second son (on her lap here), also called Louis,
became heir to the throne. Known to supporters of the monarch
as Louis XVII, he died in prison in 1795 and never ruled. Vige-
Lebrun fled France in 1789 and returned only in 1805. ( Chateau
de Versailles, France/ The Bridgeman Art Library.)
hunt3_ch19.qxd 10/26/07 11:44 PM Page 591
endorse his program, the king presented his pro-
posals for a more uniform land tax to his old
rival the parlement of Paris. When it too refused,
he ordered the parlement judges into exile in
the provinces. Overnight, the judges (members of
the nobility because of the offices they held) be-
came popular heroes for resisting the kings
tyranny; in reality, however, the judges, like the
notables, wanted reform only on their own terms.
Louis finally gave in to demands that he call a
meeting of the Estates General, which had last met
175 years before.
The Estates General. The calling of the Estates
General electrified public opinion. Who would de-
termine the fate of the nation? The Estates Gen-
eral was a body of deputies from the three estates,
or orders, of France. The deputies in the First Es-
tate represented some 100,000 clergy of the
Catholic church, which owned about 10 percent of
the land and collected a 10 percent tax (the tithe)
on peasants. The deputies of the Second Estate rep-
resented the nobility, about 400,000 men and
women who owned about 25 percent of the land,
enjoyed many tax exemptions, and collected
seigneurial dues and rents from their peasant ten-
ants. The deputies of the Third Estate represented
everyone else, at least 95 percent of the nation. In
1614, at the last meeting of the Estates General,
each order had deliberated and voted separately.
Before the elections to the Estates General in 1789,
the king agreed to double the number of deputies
for the Third Estate (making them equal in num-
ber to the other two combined), but he refused to
mandate voting by individual head rather than by
order. Voting by order (each order would have one
vote) would conserve the traditional powers of the
clergy and nobility; voting by head (each deputy
would have one vote) would give the Third Estate
an advantage since many clergymen and even
some nobles sympathized with the Third Estate.
As the states censorship apparatus broke
down, pamphleteers by the hundreds denounced
the traditional privileges of the nobility and clergy
and called for voting by head rather than by or-
der. In the most vitriolic of all the pamphlets, What
Is the Third Estate?, the middle-class clergyman
Abb (Abbot) Emmanuel-Joseph Sieys charged
that the nobility contributed nothing at all to the
nations well-being; they were a malignant disease
which preys upon and tortures the body of a sick
man. In the winter and spring of 1789, villagers
and townspeople alike held meetings to elect
deputies and write down their grievances. The ef-
fect was immediate. Although educated men dom-
inated the meetings at the regional level, the
humblest peasants voted in their villages and burst
forth with complaints, especially about taxes. As
one villager lamented, The last crust of bread has
been taken from us. The long series of meetings
raised expectations that the Estates General would
help the king solve all the nations ills.
These new hopes soared just at the moment
France experienced an increasingly rare but always
dangerous food shortage. Bad weather had dam-
aged the harvest of 1788, causing bread prices to
soar in many places in the spring and summer of
1789 and threatening starvation for the poorest
people. In addition, a serious slump in textile pro-
duction had been causing massive unemployment
since 1786. Hundreds of thousands of textile work-
ers were out of work and hungry, adding another
volatile element to an already tense situation.
When some twelve hundred deputies jour-
neyed to the kings palace of Versailles for the
opening of the Estates General in May 1789, many
readers avidly followed the developments in news-
papers that sprouted overnight. Although most
nobles insisted on voting by order, the deputies of
the Third Estate refused to proceed on that basis.
After six weeks of stalemate, on June 17, 1789, the
deputies of the Third Estate took unilateral action
and declared themselves and whoever would join
them the National Assembly, in which each deputy
would vote as an individual. Two days later, the
clergy voted by a narrow margin to join them. Sud-
denly denied access to their meeting hall on June
20, the deputies met on a nearby tennis court and
swore an oath not to disband until they had given
France a constitution that reflected their newly de-
clared authority. This tennis court oath ex-
pressed the determination of the Third Estate to
carry through a constitutional revolution. A few
days later, the nobles had no choice but to join too.
July 14, 1789: The Fall of the Bastille. At first,
Louis appeared to agree to the new National
Assembly, but he also ordered thousands of sol-
diers to march to Paris. The deputies who sup-
ported the Assembly feared a plot by the king and
high-ranking nobles to arrest them and disperse
the Assembly. Everyone is convinced that the ap-
proach of the troops covers some violent design,
one deputy wrote home. Their fears were con-
firmed when, on July 11, the king fired Jacques
Necker, the Swiss Protestant finance minister and
the one high official regarded as sympathetic to the
deputies cause.
592 Chapter 19 The Cataclysm of Revoluti on 17891799
Estates General: A body of deputies from the three estates, or
orders, of France: the clergy (First Estate), the nobility (Second
Estate), and everyone else (Third Estate).
hunt3_ch19.qxd 10/26/07 11:44 PM Page 592
The popular reaction in Paris to Neckers dis-
missal and the threat of military force changed the
course of the French Revolution. When the news
spread, the common people in Paris began to arm
themselves and attack places where either grain or
arms were thought to be stored (Map 19.1). A
deputy in Versailles reported home: Today all of
the evils overwhelm France, and we are between
despotism, carnage, and famine. On July 14, 1789,
an armed crowd marched on the Bastille, a forti-
fied prison that symbolized royal authority. After
a chaotic battle in which a hundred armed citizens
died, the prison officials surrendered.
The fall of the Bastille (an event now com-
memorated as the French national holiday) set an
important precedent. The common people showed
themselves willing to intervene violently at a cru-
cial political moment (see The Third Estate Awak-
ens, at right). All over France, food riots turned
into local revolts. The officials in one city wrote of
their plight: Yesterday afternoon [July 19] more
than seven or eight thousand people, men and
women, assembled in front of the two gates to the
city hall. . . . We were forced to negotiate with
them and to promise to give them wheat . . . and
to reduce the price of bread. Local governments
were forced out of power and replaced by commit-
tees of patriots loyal to the revolutionary cause.
The kings government began to crumble. To re-
store order, the patriots relied on newly formed
National Guard units composed of civilians. In
The Revoluti onary Wave, 17871789 593 17891799
Fall of the Bastille
The Bastille prison is shown here
in all its imposing grandeur.
When the fortresss governor
Bernard Ren de Launay sur-
rendered on July 14, 1789, he
was marched off to city hall. The
gathering crowd taunted and
spat at him, and after he lashed
out at one of the men nearest
him, he was stabbed, shot, and
then beheaded. The head was
displayed as a trophy on a pike
held high above the crowd. Royal
authority had been successfully
challenged and even humiliated.
(The Granger Collection, New York.)
The Third Estate Awakens
This print, produced after the fall of the Bastille (note the heads on
pikes outside the prison), shows a clergyman (First Estate) and a noble
(Second Estate) alarmed by the awakening of the commoners (Third
Estate). The Third Estate breaks the chains of oppression and arms
itself. In what ways does this print draw attention to the social conflicts
that lay behind the political struggles in the Estates General? (Runion des
Muses Nationaux/ Art Resource, NY.)
For more help analyzing this image, see the visual activity for this
chapter in the Online Study Guide at bedfordstmartins.com/hunt.
hunt3_ch19.qxd 10/26/07 11:44 PM Page 593
Paris, the Marquis de Lafayette, a hero of the Amer-
ican War of Independence and a noble deputy in
the National Assembly, became commander of the
new National Guard. One of Louis XVIs brothers
and many other leading aristocrats fled into exile.
The Revolution thus had its first heroes, its first
victims, and its first enemies.
Review: How did the beginning of the French Revolu-
tion resemble the other revolutions of 17871789?
From Monarchy to Republic,
17891793
Until July 1789, the French Revolution followed a
course much like that of the protest movements in
the Low Countries. Unlike the Dutch and Belgian
uprisings, however, the French Revolution did not
come to a quick end. The French revolutionaries
first tried to establish a constitutional monarchy
based on the Enlightenment principles of human
rights and rational government. This effort failed
when the king attempted to raise a counterrevolu-
tionary army. When war broke out in 1792, new
tensions culminated in a second revolution on
August 10, 1792, that deposed the king and estab-
lished a republic in which all power rested in an
elected legislature.
The Revolution of Rights and Reason
Before drafting a constitution, the deputies of the
National Assembly had to confront growing vio-
lence in the countryside. Peasants made up 80 per-
cent of the French population but owned only
about 50 percent of the land. Most could barely
make ends meet but still had to pay taxes to the
state, the tithe to the Catholic church, and a host
of seigneurial dues to their lords, whether for us-
594 Chapter 19 The Cataclysm of Revoluti on 17891799
0 500 1,000 meters
0 2,500 5,000 feet N
S
E W
Seine R.
S
e
i
n
e
R
.
BLVD. DES ITALIENS
R
U
E
S
T
. H
O
N
O
R
R
U
E
D
E
R
I
C
H
E
L
I
E
U
R
U
E
M
O
N
T
M
A
R
T
R
E
R
U
E
S
T
.
D
E
N
I
S
R
U
E
S
T
.
M
A
R
T
I
N
R
U
E
D
U
T
E
M
P
L
E
R
U
E
S
T
. A
N
T
O
IN
E
R
U
E
S
T
.
J
A
C
Q
U
E
S
R
U
E
D
E
N
F
E
R
R
U
E
D
E
L
A
H
A
R
P
E
R
U
E
D
E
V
A
U
R
IG
A
R
D
R
U
E DE
S
V
R
E
S
Jacobin
Club
Place de la
Rvolution
Htel des
Invalides
cole
Militaire
Wall of the
Farmers General
St.
Sulpice
St. Germain
des Prs
Luxembourg
Place
Ste. Genevive
(Pantheon)
Sorbonne
Tuileries
Palace
Palais
Royal
Louvre
Notre Dame
Cathedral
The Temple
Bastille
C
h
a
m
p
s
d
e
M
a
r
s
Wall of the
Farmers General
Pont de
la Concorde
Pont
Royal
Pont
Neuf
Pont au
Change
le de
la C
it
le
S
t. L
o
u
is
MAP 19. 1 Revolutionary Paris, 1789
The French Revolution began with the fall of the Bastille prison on July 14, 1789. The huge fortified
prison was located on the eastern side of the city in a neighborhood of working people. Before
attacking the Bastille, crowds had torn down many of the customs booths located in the wall of the
Farmers General (the private company in charge of tax collection), and taken the arms stored in the
Htel des Invalides, a veterans hospital on the western side of the city where the upper classes lived.
During the Revolution, executions took place on the square or Place de la Rvolution, now called
Place de la Concorde.
hunt3_ch19.qxd 10/26/07 11:44 PM Page 594
ing the lords mills to grind wheat
or to ensure their ability to give
their land as inheritance to their
children. Peasants greeted the
news of events in 1789 with a
mixture of hope and anxiety. As
food shortages spread, they feared
that the beggars and vagrants
crowding the roads might be part
of an aristocratic plot to starve
the people by burning crops or
barns. In many places, the Great
Fear (the term used by historians
to describe this rural panic)
turned into peasant attacks on
aristocrats or on the records of
peasants dues kept in the lords chteau. Peasants
now refused to pay dues to their lords, and the per-
sistence of peasant violence raised alarms about
the potential for a general peasant insurrection.
The End of Feudalism. Alarmed by peasant un-
rest, the National Assembly decided to make
sweeping changes. On the night of August 4, 1789,
noble deputies announced their willingness to give
up their tax exemptions and seigneurial dues. By
the end of the night, amid wild enthusiasm, dozens
of deputies had come to the podium to relinquish
the tax exemptions of their own professional
groups, towns, or provinces. The National Assem-
bly decreed the abolition of what it called the feu-
dal regime that is, it freed the remaining serfs
and eliminated all special privileges in matters of
taxation, including all seigneurial dues on land. (A
few days later the deputies insisted on financial
compensation for some of these dues, but most
peasants refused to pay.) Peasants had achieved
their goals. The Assembly also mandated equality
of opportunity in access to government positions.
Talent, rather than birth, was to be the key to suc-
cess. Enlightenment principles were beginning to
become law.
The Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen.
Three weeks later, the deputies drew up the Dec-
laration of the Rights of Man and Citizen as the
preamble to a new constitution. In words reminis-
cent of the American Declaration of Indepen-
dence, whose author, Thomas Jefferson, was in
Paris at the time, it proclaimed, Men are born and
remain free and equal in rights.
The Declaration granted freedom
of religion, freedom of the press,
equality of taxation, and equality
before the law. It established the
principle of national sovereignty:
since all sovereignty rests essen-
tially in the nation, it said, the
king derived his authority hence-
forth from the nation rather than
from tradition or divine right.
By pronouncing all men free
and equal, the Declaration imme-
diately created new dilemmas.
Did women have equal rights
with men? What about free blacks
in the colonies? How could slavery be justified if
all men were born free? Did religious toleration of
Protestants and Jews include equal political rights?
Women never received the right to vote during the
French Revolution, though Protestant and Jewish
men did. Women were theoretically citizens under
civil law but without the right to full political par-
ticipation. (See Document, The Rights of Minori-
ties, page 597.)
Some women did not accept their exclusion,
viewing it as a betrayal of the promised new or-
der. In addition to joining demonstrations, such as
the march to Versailles in October 1789, women
wrote petitions, published tracts, and organized
political clubs to demand more participation (see
A Womens Club, below). In her Declaration of the
From Monarchy to Republi c, 17891793 595 17891799
Great Fear: The term used by historians to describe the French
rural panic of 1789, which led to peasant attacks on aristocrats
or on seigneurial records of peasants dues.
Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen: The preamble to
the French constitution drafted in August 1789; it established
the sovereignty of the nation and equal rights for citizens.
Area of Great Fear revolts
0 200 400 kilometers
0 200 400 miles
ATLANTIC
OCEAN
Loire R
.
English Channel
R
h
n
e
R
.
Sein
e
R
.
FRANCE
SWISS
CONFED.
AUSTRIAN
NETHERLANDS
SPAIN
E
S
Sein
e
R
.
G
a
r
o
n
n
e
R
.
Loire R
.
R
h
n
e
R
.
Paris
E
S
Sein
e
R
.
Loire R
.
R
h
n
e
R
.
Garonne R.
Paris
n
e
R
.
Po R.
R
h
i
n
e
R
.
D
a
n
u
be
R
.
GREAT
BRITAIN
FRENCH
REPUBLIC
GERMAN
STATES
AUSTRIAN
EMPIRE
Corsica
Sardinia
SPAIN
PRUSSIA
Batavian
Republic
1795
Helvetic Republic
1798
Austrian Netherlands
(Belgium) 1795
Parma
Piedmont
Savoy
1792
Nice
1792
Papal
Territories
1791
Venice
1797
Cisalpine
Republic
1797
Ligurian
Republic
1797
Tuscany
Roman
Republic
1798
Neapolitan
Republic
1799
P
Y
R
E
S
A
L
P
S
Paris
Rome
Marseille
Venice
Mainz
Siena
KINGDOM OF
POLAND
RUS S I A
P RUS S I A
AUSTRIAN
EMPIRE
Warsaw
Vilnius
Cracow
1793
1795
1795
1793
1795
Danzig
Knigsberg
Riga
Berlin
Kiev