Order On Prenda Appeal

"# $%&
'#($&) *$+$&, -./0$ .1 233&+4,

5.0 $%& *&6&#$% -(07/($
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"#$% &''()& *+, &-&.(/
0123456778 9781: ;<=6<=:41<">
!"#$%&$''>
()
:"43<"? 59143> *& #"%>
+*'*%,#%&-.//*""**-0

:@@A*B #C 6:D0 8DEE?> F<3" 547707> *+, 6:D0 3:"59717=>
.//*""#%&-)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:@@A*B$ CG#H IJA D+KIA, 5I*IA$ 8K$IGKLI ;#MGI C#G IJA
5#MIJAG+ 8K$IGKLI #C 1BBK+#K$%
"#% &/ ;N ))((O P !" #$%&'() *+&,-.> 12,3*0 *+, /$0'1 2" 34&51650
45$*' 12,3*%
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:=2D78 :6=10 Q> /)&-
&
P 87;1878 FD0? '&> /)&-
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

&
"#% &''()& R*$ *GSMA, TAC#GA IJK$ @*+AB% "#% &-&.(/ R*$ $MTHKI
IA, I# IJA $*HA @*+AB @MG$M*+I I# 1+IAG+*B <@AG*IK+S 6G#LA,MGA .UTV% 4JA
@*+AB L#+LBM,A, IJ*I #G*B *GSMHA+I R*$ M++ALA$$*GW K+ IJA B*IIAG L*$A>
RJKLJ K$ $MTHKIIA, #+ IJA TGKAC$ K+ *LL#G,*+LA RKIJ EA,% =% :@@% 6%
'-U*VU/VUC).
Case: l3-380l Document: 34 Filed: 07/3l/20l4 Pages: 24
/ "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
YAC#GA Z<<8> 45$*' 12,3*> *+, [:""7 *+, 5?[75> 4$672$&
12,3*-%
Z<<8> 45$*' 12,3*% 4JA CKG$I GMBA #C J#BA$> *LL#G,K+S I# *+
#B, $*WK+S> K$ I# $I#@ ,KSSK+S% 4JA IR# *@@A*B$ TAC#GA M$
TGK+S IJ*I I# HK+,> C#G GA*$#+$ IJ*I RKBB TAL#HA *@@*GA+I%
4JA CKG$I> "#% &''()&> L#HA$ I# M$ CG#H IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI\$
#G,AG SG*+IK+S * H#IK#+ C#G *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ *+, L#$I$ M+,AG
/( D%5%;% ] &O/Q CKBA, TW 5Y; 1+IAG+AI 5AG^KLA$> 00; U,_T_*
:4X4V> ;#HL*$I ;*TBA ;#HHM+KL*IK#+$> 00; UL#BBALIKÂBW
ÌJA 156$aV> *+, :+IJ#+W 5HKIJ> ,ACA+,*+I$ K+ IJA M+,AGBW
K+S BKIKS*IK#+% 4JA #G,AG KH@#$A, b#K+I *+, $AÂG*B BK*TKBKIW
C#G IJA CAA$ *S*K+$I 6*MB 8MCCW> F#J+ 5IAABA> *+, 6*MB 3*+$
HAKAG% 4JAW J*Â *@@A*BA, CG#H IJ*I #G,AG% 4JAW ,K, +#I>
J#RAÂG> CKBA * H#IK#+ AKIJAG I# LB*GKCW IJA +*IMGA #C IJA $*+L
IK#+$ #G I# $I*W IJA #G,AG% 1+$IA*,> IJAW $KH@BW ,K, +#I @*W%
4JA ,ACA+,*+I$ IJA+ H#Â, C#G *+ #G,AG I# $J#R L*M$A RJW
*@@ABB*+I$ $J#MB, +#I TA JAB, K+ L#+IAH@I C#G IJAKG C*KBMGA I#
@*W> #G K+ IJA *BIAG+*IKÂ C#G KHHA,K*IA L#+IAH@I% :CIAG *
JA*GK+S> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI C#M+, IJ*I IJAW J*, C*KBA, I# @*W
*+, IJ*I IJAGA R*$ +# AcLM$A C#G IJAKG TAJ*^K#G% 1I IJM$ JAB,
IJAH K+ LK^KB L#+IAH@I *+, #G,AGA, IJAH I# @*W &)d #C IJA
#GKSK+*B $*+LIK#+$ *R*G, I# L#ÂG IJA ,ACA+,*+I$\ *,,KIK#+*B
L#$I$ C#G IJA L#+IAH@I BKIKS*IK#+% 1I *B$# *$$A$$A, * ,*KBW CK+A>
K+ L*$A @*WHA+I R*$ +#I C#GIJL#HK+S% 4JA $AL#+, *@@A*B
TAC#GA M$> "#% &-&.(/> K$ CG#H IJA L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,K+S%
7
8
0KSJI$@AA, 9A,K* #@AG*IA$ #+BK+A @#G+#SG*@JW $KIA$%
<MG $I#GW TASK+$ RJA+ KI TG#MSJI $MKI K+ 5I% ;B*KG ;#M+IW>
1BBK+#K$> *S*K+$I #+A F#J+ 8#A ,ACA+,*+I> K,A+IKCKA, #+BW
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ '
IJG#MSJ JK$ 16 *,,GA$$% U:+ 16> #G 1+IAG+AI 6G#I#L#B> *,,GA$$
K$ IJA +MHTAG *$$KS+A, I# * @*GIKLMB*G ,A^KLA #+ IJA 1+IAG
+AI%V 8#A\$ 16 *,,GA$$ R*$ *BBASA,BW *$$#LK*IA, RKIJ IJA M+
B*RCMB ^KARK+S #C 0KSJI$@AA,\$ L#+IA+I> H*,A @#$$KTBA TW IJA
M$A #C * RK,ABW $J*GA,> `J*LeA,a @*$$R#G,% 0KSJI$@AA, IJA+
K,A+IKCKA, *@@G#cKH*IABW .>.)) #IJAG$ UIJG#MSJ IJAKG 16 *,
,GA$$A$ #+BWV *$ *BBASA, `L#L#+$@KG*I#G$a K+ * RK,AGA*LJK+S
$LJAHA I# $IA*B @*$$R#G,$ *+, L#+IA+I% 4JA #+BW L#+$@KG*I#
GK*B *LI *BBASA, R*$ IJA M$A #C IJA $*HA @*$$R#G,% 4JA+> C#B
B#RK+S RJ*I $AAH$ I# TA *@@ABB*+I$\ 89,2- 9/*6#%,$> $AA> *)3)>
.: ;9",$%3-0 <<4 () +9*- =>=?@A> Qf/ E%', OO)> OO' U8%;% ;KG%
/)&-V> 0KSJI$@AA,> *LIK+S *B /#6&*> $AGÂ, $MT@#A+*$ #+ IJA
156$ URJKLJ *I IJ*I @#K+I RAGA +#+@*GIKA$V C#G IJA @AG$#+*B
BW K,A+IKCK*TBA K+C#GH*IK#+ #C A*LJ #C IJA .>.)) *BBASA, L#
L#+$@KG*I#G$> +#+A #C RJ#H J*, TAA+ b#K+A, *$ @*GIKA$% 4JA
156$ GACM$A, I# IMG+ #ÂG IJA K+C#GH*IK#+ *+, K+$IA*, CKBA, *
H#IK#+ I# gM*$J *+, C#G * @G#IALIKÂ #G,AG%
4JA $I*IA IGK*B L#MGI ,A+KA, IJA 156$\ H#IK#+> *+, $# IJA
156$ $#MSJI *@@ABB*IA GA^KAR% :I IJA $*HA IKHA> 8MCCW L*BBA,
*+ *II#G+AW GA@GA$A+IK+S IJA 156$ *+, GAgMA$IA, IJA +*HA
*+, IKIBA #C A*LJ AH@B#WAA RJ# ,ALK,A, IJ*I *+ 156 R#MB,
+#I L#H@BW RKIJ IJA $MT@#A+*$% 5IAABA IJA+ $MTHKIIA, *+
*CCK,*^KI $I*IK+S IJ*I IJA 156 *II#G+AW GACM$A, I# @G#^K,A IJ*I
K+C#GH*IK#+% 4JA 1BBK+#K$ 5M@GAHA ;#MGI MBIKH*IABW GMBA,
IJ*I IJA IGK*B L#MGI AGGA, TW GACM$K+S I# gM*$J IJA $MT@#A+*$%
0KSJI$@AA, GA$@#+,A, TW *HA+,K+S KI$ L#H@B*K+I #+ :MSM$I
'> /)&/> *+, C#GH*BBW +*HK+S *$ L#L#+$@KG*I#G @*GIKA$ IJA
156$ *+, M+K,A+IKCKA, `L#G@#G*IA GA@GA$A+I*IKÂ$a #C IJA
156$% 4JA L#H@B*K+I @*K+IA, RKIJ * TG#*, TGM$Jh KI *BBASA,
AÂGWIJK+S CG#H +ASBKSA+LA> I# ^K#B*IK#+$ #C IJA ;#H@MIAG
EG*M, *+, :TM$A :LI> &( D%5%;% ]] &)') *+, &)')USV> I# ,A
LA@IKÂ @G*LIKLA$ *+, *K,K+S *+, *TAIIK+S% `F#J+ 8#A>a K+ IJA
- "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
*HA+,A, L#H@B*K+I> TAL*HA :+IJ#+W 5HKIJ% 4JA+> KS+#GK+S
IJA C*LI IJ*I IJA 1BBK+#K$ 5M@GAHA ;#MGI J*, bM$I GAbALIA, KI$
GAgMA$I C#G IJA $*HA K+C#GH*IK#+> 0KSJI$@AA, K$$MA, +AR
$MT@#A+*$ $AAeK+S IJA @AG$#+*BBW K,A+IKCK*TBA K+C#GH*IK#+ #C
5HKIJ\$ @MG@#GIA, .>.)) L#L#+$@KG*I#G$%
<+ :MSM$I O> /)&/> IJA 156$ GAH#Â, IJA L*$A I# IJA 8K$
IGKLI ;#MGI C#G IJA 5#MIJAG+ 8K$IGKLI #C 1BBK+#K$% 5AA /( D%5%;%
] &--.UTVU'V% 0KSJI$@AA, KHHA,K*IABW CKBA, *+ AHAGSA+LW
H#IK#+ K+ *,^*+LA #C IJA G#MIK+A =MBA /.UCV L#+CAGA+LA> $AA
E78% =% ;1N% 6% /.UCV> *$eK+S IJA CA,AG*B L#MGI I# #G,AG IJA 156$
I# @G#,MLA IJA $*HA `L#L#+$@KG*I#G$\a @AG$#+*BBW K,A+IKCK*
TBA K+C#GH*IK#+% :I IJA $*HA IKHA> 3*+$HAKAG $MTHKIIA, *
H#IK#+ C#G /69 5#7 ($7* *,HK$$K#+i JA ,K, +#I K,A+IKCW * B*R
CKGH #+ IJA C#GH% 5IAABA A+IAGA, *+ *@@A*G*+LA K+ RJKLJ JA
BK$IA, JK$ CKGH *$ 6GA+,* 0*R% 4JA CKGH *CCKBK*IK#+$> J#RAÂG>
IMG+A, #MI I# TA @G#^K$K#+*B> I# @MI KI eK+,BW% :I IJA AHAG
SA+LW H#IK#+ JA*GK+S> 5IAABA K,A+IKCKA, JK$ CKGH *$ 5IAABA
3*+$HAKAG 600;> 8MCCW $*K, IJ*I JA R*$ RKIJ 6GA+,* 0*R>
*+, 3*+$HAKAG R*$ RKIJ $#HAIJK+S L*BBA, :B@J* 0*R EKGH%
5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG *+, 6GA+,* *GA BK$IA, *I IJA $*HA $IGAAI
*,,GA$$> &.& "#GIJ ;B*Ge 5IGAAI> K+ ;JKL*S#> K+ ,KCCAGA+I
$MKIA$%
:,,GA$$K+S IJA ,K$L#ÂGW H#IK#+ *I IJA AHAGSA+LW JA*G
K+S> 5IAABA $@#eA *I BA+SIJ *T#MI IJA ,KGA +AA, C#G IJA GA
gMA$IA, K+C#GH*IK#+% D+L#+^K+LA,> IJA ,K$IGKLI bM,SA ,A+KA,
IJA H#IK#+> $I*IK+S K+ @*$$K+S IJ*I JA R*$ `$eA@IKL*B *T#MI
J#R IJK$ L*$A L#MB, AÂG TA @MI #+> TMI HW CAAI *GA +#I $AI K+
$I#+A #+ KI% 1\Â $AA+ $#HA L*$A$ IJ*I ,K,+\I B##e I## J#I *I
IJA $I*GI IJ*I S#I TAIIAG RKIJ IKHA% 4JK$ H*W TA #+A #C IJ#$A
L*$A$%a 8ACA+,*+I$ IJA+ $MTHKIIA, T#IJ * H#IK#+ I# ,K$HK$$
*+, * H#IK#+ I# $I*W ,K$L#ÂGW @A+,K+S * GMBK+S #+ IJA C#G
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ f
HAG H#IK#+% 1+ "#ÂHTAG /)&/> 3*+$HAKAG $MTHKIIA, * H#
IK#+ I# RKIJ,G*R RKIJ#MI K+,KL*IK+S RJKLJ CKGH JA R*$ RKIJi
K+ 9*GLJ /)&'> 5IAABA RKIJ,GAR%
4JK$ R*$ +#I IJA #+BW L*$A 8MCCW> 5IAABA> *+, 3*+$HAKAG
J*, *I IJA IKHA% ZJKBA IJA H#IK#+ I# ,K$HK$$ R*$ @A+,K+S K+
IJA 5#MIJAG+ 8K$IGKLI #C 1BBK+#K$> * L#MGI K+ IJA ;A+IG*B 8K$
IGKLI #C ;*BKC#G+K* JAB, * JA*GK+S C#G IJA Ac@GA$$ @MG@#$A #C
Ac@B#GK+S IJA G#BA IJK$ IGK#> #@AG*IK+S #CIA+ *$ `6GA+,* 0*R>a
@B*WA, K+ $#HA M+,AGBWK+S L#@WGKSJI K+CGK+SAHA+I BKIKS*IK#+%
4J*I JA*GK+S ,K, +#I S# RABB C#G IJAHi $*+LIK#+$ RAGA KH
@#$A, #+ *BB IJGAA U*H#+S #IJAG$V *+, IJA H*IIAG GACAGGA, I#
* ^*GKAIW #C $I*IA *+, CA,AG*B *MIJ#GKIKA$% 5AA C%3*%2$&D =E
<<4 () 195% +9*> "#% &/L^('''> /)&' Z0 &(O(.'' U;%8% ;*B%
9*W .> /)&'V% E#G #MG @MG@#$A$ IJA GABA^*+I C*LI K$ IJ*I IJA
,K$IGKLI L#MGI IJAGA C#M+, IJ*I 5IAABA> 3*+$HAKAG> *+, 8MCCW
#R+A, *+, L#+IG#BBA, 6GA+,* 0*R% 4JA L#MGI RA+I #+ I# $*W
IJ*I IJAW
,AH#+$IG*IA, j*k RKBBK+S+A$$ I# ,ALAKÂ +#I bM$I jIJ*Ik
;#MGI> TMI #IJAG L#MGI$ RJAGA IJAW J*Â *@@A*GA,%
j4JAKGk GA@GA$A+I*IK#+$ *T#MI IJAKG #@AG*IK#+$> GAB*
IK#+$JK@$> *+, CK+*+LK*B K+IAGA$I$ J*Â ^*GKA, CG#H
CAKS+A, KS+#G*+LA I# HK$$I*IAHA+I$ I# #MIGKSJI BKA$%
YMI IJK$ ,ALA@IK#+ R*$ L*BLMB*IA, $# IJ*I IJA ;#MGI
R#MB, SG*+I jIJAKGk A*GBW,K$L#ÂGW GAgMA$I$> IJAGATW
*BB#RK+S jIJAHk I# K,A+IKCW ,ACA+,*+I$ *+, Ac*LI $AI
IBAHA+I @G#LAA,$ CG#H IJAH%
C,) *I l'% :CIAG IJA $J#RL*M$A #G,AG R*$ A+IAGA, K+ IJA ;A+
IG*B 8K$IGKLI #C ;*BKC#G+K* TMI TAC#GA *+W $*+LIK#+$ RAGA KH
@#$A,> 8MCCW> 5IAABA> *+, 3*+$HAKAG U*B#+S RKIJ #IJAG$ CG#H
6GA+,*V TAS*+ ^#BM+I*GKBW I# ,K$HK$$ $KHKB*G L*$A$ CKBA,
*LG#$$ IJA L#M+IGW> K+LBM,K+S IJA #+A +#R TAC#GA M$% E#MG
. "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
IAA+ ,*W$ *CIAG IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI SG*+IA, 0KSJI$@AA,\$ H#IK#+
C#G ^#BM+I*GW ,K$HK$$*B> ,ACA+,*+I 5HKIJ CKBA, * H#IK#+ C#G
*II#G+AW\$ CAA$ M+,AG EA,% =% ;K^% 6% f-U,VU/V *+, /( D%5%;%
] &O/Q% 8MCCW CKBA, * GA$@#+$Ai 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG ,K, +#I%
1+ <LI#TAG> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI SG*+IA, 5HKIJ CAA$ *+, L#$I$
@MG$M*+I I# $ALIK#+ &O/Q% 4JA #G,AG G*+ b#K+IBW *+, $AÂG*BBW
*S*K+$I A*LJ *@@ABB*+I% 4*eK+S K+I# *LL#M+I T#IJ IJA GAL#G,
K+ IJA L*$A TAC#GA KI *+, IJA GMBK+S$ K+ #IJAG ,K$IGKLI$> IJA
L#MGI C#M+, IJ*I IJA BKIKS*IK#+ *S*K+$I 5HKIJ `$H*LeA, #C
TMBBWK+S @GAIA+$A%a 4JA L#MGI $*K, IJ*I KI$ ,ALK$K#+ I# KH@#$A
$*+LIK#+$ R*$ @*GIKLMB*GBW K+C#GHA, TW IJA AHAGSA+LW H#
IK#+ C#G ,K$L#ÂGW% 4JA +AcI ,*W> 3*+$HAKAG CKBA, * H#IK#+ I#
^*L*IA #G GAL#+$K,AG> *+, * CAR ,*W$ B*IAG 5IAABA *+, 8MCCW
,K, IJA $*HA% 3*+$HAKAG *+, 5IAABA *BBASA, IJ*I RJKBA 8MCCW
GALAKÂ, +#IKLA IJ*I $*+LIK#+$ RAGA TAK+S $#MSJI> IJAW ,K,
+#I%
:CIAG IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI SG*+IA, CAA$ *+, L#$I$ C#G 5HKIJ>
IJA 156$ CKBA, * H#IK#+ GAgMA$IK+S IJA $*HA% 3*+$HAKAG *+,
5IAABA #@@#$A, IJA H#IK#+> *+, $# IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI JAB, *
JA*GK+S I# ,A*B RKIJ T#IJ IJA H#IK#+ I# GAL#+$K,AG IJA CAA$
*R*G,A, 5HKIJ *+, IJA +AR 156 H#IK#+% <+ "#ÂHTAG /Q>
/)&'> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI ,A+KA, IJA H#IK#+ I# GAL#+$K,AG
URJKLJ J*, TAA+ CKBA, #+ TAJ*BC #C *BB IJGAA *@@ABB*+I$V *+,
*R*G,A, *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ I# IJA 156$% :@@A*B "#% &''()& C#B
B#RA,%
9
=) F9&$7* #%, G//96&2%$&D &9 H* ;*#6,
5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG L#+IA+, IJ*I IJAKG ,MA @G#LA$$
GKSJI$ RAGA ^K#B*IA, TAL*M$A IJAW +AÂG GALAKÂ, @G#@AG +#
IKLA #C 5HKIJ\$ H#IK#+ C#G $*+LIK#+$% 4JA GAL#G,> J#RAÂG>
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ Q
,#A$ +#I $M@@#GI IJAH% EKG$I> *$ IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI L#+LBM,A,>
AÂ+ KC RA *$$MHA IJ*I IJAW ,K, +#I J*Â +#IKLA #GKSK+*BBW>
IJ*I ,ACALI R*$ LMGA, RJA+ IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI SG*+IA, GAJA*G
K+S #+ IJA $*+LIK#+$ K$$MA% 1+,AA,> K+ IJAKG TGKAC$ TAC#GA IJK$
L#MGI> 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG $AAH I# L#+LA,A *$ HMLJ% 4JAKG
L#H@B*K+I J*$ $JKCIA, I# #+A C#LM$K+S #+ IJA *,AgM*LW #C
IJAKG #@@#GIM+KIW I# 6*-/9%,% 1I K$ I## B*IA I# LJ*+SA IJA#GKA$>
J#RAÂG> *+, K+ *+W AÂ+I> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI L#GGALIBW GMBA,
IJ*I RJ*IAÂG @G#LA,MG*B CB*R IJAGA H*W J*Â TAA+ R*$ CMB
BW L#GGALIA, TW *CC#G,K+S * +AR #@@#GIM+KIW C#G * JA*GK+S%
EK+*BBW> IJAW GALAKÂ, *,AgM*IA +#IKLA K+ IJA CKG$I @B*LA%
8MA @G#LA$$ GAgMKGA$ `+#IKLA mGA*$#+*TBW L*BLMB*IA,> M+
,AG *BB IJA LKGLMH$I*+LA$> I# *@@GK$A K+IAGA$IA, @*GIKA$ #C IJA
@A+,A+LW #C IJA *LIK#+ *+, *CC#G, IJAH *+ #@@#GIM+KIW I#
@GA$A+I IJAKG #TbALIK#+$%\a I%$&*, J&#&*- .$6 :2%,-0 C%7) () K-
/$%9-#> ffO D%5% /.)> /Q/ U/)&)V ULKIK+S L2""#%* () 4*%&6#" ;#%
9(*6 M#%N O P62-& 49)> ''O D%5% ').> '&- U&Of)VV% :LIM*B +#IKLA
K$ +#I GAgMKGA,% C,) ZA *GA +#I I*BeK+S JAGA *T#MI $AG^KLA #C
@G#LA$$> RJKLJ @G#LAA,$ M+,AG * H#GA GA$IGKLIKÂ $AI #C GMBA$%
5AA E78% =% ;1N% 6% -% 1+$IA*,> IJA H#IK#+ C#G $*+LIK#+$ R*$
#+A $IA@ K+ *+ #+S#K+S @KALA #C BKIKS*IK#+% 2KÂ+ IJA LB#$A
L#++ALIK#+$ *H#+S IJA B*RWAG$> KI R*$ GA*$#+*TBA C#G IJA
L#MGI I# L#+LBM,A IJ*I $AG^KLA #+ 8MCCW R#MB, $MCCKLA I# SKÂ
+#IKLA I# 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG *$ RABB% 4JA TAJ*^K#G A*LJ
#+A ,K$@B*WA, IJG#MSJ#MI IJK$ BKIKS*IK#+ M+,AG$L#GA, IJAKG
#+S#K+S GAB*IK#+$JK@ *+, L#HHM+KL*IK#+h IJAW M$A, #+A *+
#IJAG\$ ;9_7;E B#SK+ K+C#GH*IK#+> CKBA, H#IK#+$ #+ TAJ*BC #C
A*LJ #IJAG> *+, $MTHKIIA, $MT$I*+IK*BBW $KHKB*G ,#LMHA+I$%
1I K$ *B$# R#GIJ +#IK+S IJ*I EA,AG*B =MBA #C ;K^KB 6G#LA
,MGA fUTVU/VUYVUKV @AGHKI$ BA*^K+S +#IKLA *I * @AG$#+\$ #CCKLA
RKIJ * LBAGe #G $#HA#+A K+ LJ*GSA> #G AÂ+ K+ * L#+$@KLM#M$
( "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
@B*LA% 8MCCW GALAKÂ, +#IKLA> JA R*$ K+ LJ*GSA #C 6GA+,*
0*R> *+, IJAGA R*$ A^K,A+LA IJ*I T#IJ 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG
RAGA R#GeK+S C#G 6GA+,* *$ RABB% ZJKBA *@@ABB*+I$ JMCC IJ*I
IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI `RJ#BBW SB#$$jA,k #ÂG IJA C*LI IJ*I 3*+$
HAKAG +#IKLA, JK$ *@@A*G*+LA K+ IJA L*$A C#G :B@J* 0*R
EKGH> +#I 6GA+,* 0*R>a IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI J*, *H@BA GA*$#+
I# CK+, IJA 6GA+,*_:B@J* ,K$IK+LIK#+ KBBM$#GW *I TA$I> CG*M,M
BA+I *I R#G$I% 4R# ,*W$ #'&*6 5IAABA H#Â, I# RKIJ,G*R CG#H
IJK$ L*$A> JA ,ALB*GA, K+ *+#IJAG *LIK#+ IJ*I JA R*$ `#C L#M+
$AB RKIJ IJA B*R CKGH> 6GA+,* 0*R> 1+L%a *+, IJ*I 3*+$HAKAG
R*$ `*B$# #C L#M+$AB I# IJA CKGH%a 8ALB*G*IK#+ #C F#J+ 5IAABA>
C%3*%2$&D =E <<4 () 195% +9*> ;*$A "#% /h&/L^)('''<8Z
F;> 7;E "#% (' nn &> - U;%8% ;*B% CKBA, 9*G% (> /)&'V% :+, IJK$
K$ I# $*W +#IJK+S #C IJA C*LI IJ*I *I BA*$I #+LA 3*+$HAKAG K+
,KL*IA, $% &5$- 7#-* IJ*I JA R*$ #C L#M+$AB I# 6GA+,*%
1+ $A@*G*IA @G#LAA,K+S$ K+ IJA ;A+IG*B 8K$IGKLI #C ;*BKC#G
+K*> 8MCCW> 5IAABA> *+, 3*+$HAKAG A*LJ I##e IJA EKCIJ K+$IA*,
#C *+$RAGK+S IJA L#MGI\$ gMA$IK#+$ *T#MI *II#G+AW HK$L#+
,MLI *+, IJA GAB*IK#+$JK@ TAIRAA+ 6GA+,* *+, #IJAG @#IA+
IK*B $JABB L#H@*+KA$% 5AA C%3*%2$&D =E <<4> /)&' Z0 &(O(.''>
*I l/ +%'% 5AA *B$# F#A 9MBBK+> `FM,SA $H*$Jh 6GA+,*\$ @#G+
IG#BBK+S ,*W$ *GA #ÂG>a :G$4ALJ+KL* U:@GKB /> /)&'V> *^*KB*TBA
*I JII@h__*G$IALJ+KL*%L#H_IALJ@#BKLW_/)&'_)-_@GA+,*@#G+
IG#BB$LB*HM@*$IJAKG@B*+$LGMHTBAK+*+B*L#MGIG##H_
U*BB RAT$KIA$ LKIA, K+ IJK$ #@K+K#+ RAGA B*$I ^K$KIA, #+ FMBW '&>
/)&-V% 4JA EKCIJ :HA+,HA+I> J#RAÂG> `,#A$ +#I C#GTK, *,
ÂG$A K+CAGA+LA$ *S*K+$I @*GIKA$ I# LK^KB *LIK#+$ RJA+ IJAW
GACM$A I# IA$IKCW K+ GA$@#+$A I# @G#T*IKÂ A^K,A+LA%a M#B&*6 ()
!#"8$3$#%90 -/f D%5% ')(> '&( U&OQ.Vi $AA *B$# <#J#""* M#%N <#N*
Q$*R () J*32H#%> f- E%', '(Q> 'O) UQIJ ;KG% &OOfV%
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ O
: gMKLe B##e *I @MTBKLBW *^*KB*TBA ,#LMHA+I$ $M@@#GI$
IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI\$ CK+,K+S IJ*I $AG^KLA #+ 8MCCW *B$# *LL#H
@BK$JA, $AG^KLA #+ 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG% 1+ KI$ *@@BKL*IK#+
C#G *MIJ#GKo*IK#+ I# IG*+$*LI TM$K+A$$ K+ EB#GK,*> 5IAABA
3*+$HAKAG> * 9K++A$#I* L#G@#G*IK#+> BK$IA, KI$ H*KBK+S *,
,GA$$ *$ &.& "% ;B*Ge 5I% "#% '/))> ;JKL*S#> 10 .).)&% 6*MB
3*+$HAKAG K$ BK$IA, *$ 9*+*SAG *+, JK$ *,,GA$$ K$ BK$IA, *$
&&&& 0K+L#B+ =,%> 5MKIA -))> K+ 9K*HK YA*LJ> EB#GK,*% 5AA
JII@h__$A*GLJ%$M+TKo%#GS_1+gMKGW_;#G@#G*IK#+5A*GLJ_5A*GLJ
=A$MBI8AI*KB_7+IKIW"*HA_C#GBH&&)))))-Q(-LO)-,O,,
T)L.-)O.TLA/--Q.,.CCQ()C_5IAABAd/)3*+$HAKAG_6*SA&%
1+IAGA$IK+SBW> &.& "% ;B*Ge 5I% 5MKIA '/)) K$ *B$# BK$IA, *$
IJA @GK+LK@*B @B*LA #C TM$K+A$$ C#G 6GA+,* 0*R> 1+L%> K+ KI$
/)&& *@@BKL*IK#+ C#G *MIJ#GKo*IK#+ I# IG*+$*LI TM$K+A$$ K+
EB#GK,*% 1I$ GASK$IAGA, *SA+I> 9*Ge 0MIo> M$A$ IJA $*HA 9K
*HK YA*LJ *,,GA$$ *$ 3*+$HAKAG ,K, K+ IJA 5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG
*@@BKL*IK#+% 5AA JII@h__$A*GLJ%$M+TKo%#GS_1+gMKGW_
;#G@#G*IK#+5A*GLJ_5A*GLJ=A$MBI8AI*KB_7+IKIW"*HA_C#G@
C&&)))))-f&.'Lf)-/'*fTA'-TCOTC--'.C'QL/OCOLL_6GA+,*
d/)0*R_6*SA&% 5AA *B$# 8ALB*G*IK#+ #C YGAII 0% 2KTT$ 5M@
@#GIK+S 9#IK#+ C#G 1+,KL*IKÂ =MBK+S> C%3*%2$&D =E <<4 ()
+9*> ;*$A "#% /h&/L^)('''<8Z> 8#L% /-)/> nn &/p&' U`1
*LLA@IA, 3*+$HAKAG\$ #CCAG I# R#Ge *I 5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG q 1
R#GeA, *I 5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG 600; *+, KI$ $MLLA$$#G> 6GA+,*
0*R> 1+L%> CG#H B*IA 9*GLJ /)&& M+IKB B*IA EATGM*GW /)&'%aV%
:B@J*\$ L#++ALIK#+ I# 5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG *+, 6GA+,* $J#R$
M@ K+ * $A*GLJ C#G 5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG #+ 9K++A$#I*\$ TM$K+A$$
CKBK+S $KIA% 4JAGA> 5IAABA 3*+$HAKAG BK$I$ KI$ GASK$IAGA, *,
,GA$$ *$ () 5% (IJ 5I% rO)) ."/5# <#R :$68> 9K++A*@#BK$> 9"
ff-)/% 5AA JII@h__HTB$@#GI*B%$#$%$I*IA%H+%M$_YM$K+A$$_5A*GLJ
8AI*KB$sCKBK+S2MK,tQAO').Q(O.,-A)&&*((.))&ALO-CCAQC%
5AA *B$# 8KA4G#BB8KA> `8#R+ IJA =*TTKI 3#BA p 6GA+
&) "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
,*_5IAABA_3*+$HAKAG Z#+,AGB*+,>a UEAT% /(> /)&/V> *^*KB*TBA
*I JII@h__,KAIG#BB,KA%L#H_/)&/_)/_/(_,#R+IJAG*TTKIJ#BA
@GA+,*$IAABAJ*+$HAKAGR#+,AGB*+,_%
0KIIBA H#GA +AA, TA $*K,% ZA *GA ,K$*@@#K+IA, IJ*I IJA
*@@ABB*+I$\ #R+ *II#G+AW> 8*+KAB F% N#ABeAG> R*$ AKIJAG M+*
TBA #G M+RKBBK+S I# IABB M$ *I #G*B *GSMHA+I *T#MI IJA @GALK$A
GAB*IK#+$JK@ TAIRAA+ 6GA+,* *+, :B@J* 0*R> ,A$@KIA KI$ GAB
A^*+LA C#G IJA K$$MA$ #+ *@@A*B% "# H*IIAGh RA J*Â A+#MSJ
I# L#+LBM,A RKIJ L#+CK,A+LA IJ*I +#IKLA I# 8MCCW R*$ GA*$#+
*TBW L*BLMB*IA, I# *@@GK$A 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG #C IJA @A+
,A+LW #C IJA H#IK#+% E#G IJA KLK+S #+ IJA L*eA> RA *,, IJ*I
IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI *B$# C#M+, IJ*I 5IAABA GALAKÂ, *LIM*B +#IKLA
^K* AH*KB% 5HKIJ $A+I +#IKLA I# IJA AH*KB *,,GA$$ IJ*I 5IAABA
$J*GA, RKIJ 8MCCW% ZJKBA 8MCCW *GSMA$ IJ*I *CIAG JA RKIJ
,GAR CG#H IJA L*$A JA ,K, +#I GALAKÂ IJ#$A AH*KB$> IJA ,K$
IGKLI L#MGI ,K, +#I CK+, JKH I# TA LGA,KTBA% ZA J*Â +# GA*$#+
I# M@$AI IJ*I *$$A$$HA+I%
S) G//96&2%$&D &9 H* ;*#6,
5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG *B$# *GSMA IJ*I IJAW RAGA +AÂG
SKÂ+ *+ #@@#GIM+KIW I# TA JA*G, #+ 5HKIJ\$ H#IK#+% <+LA
*S*K+> IJA GAL#G, TABKA$ IJAKG *$$AGIK#+% :$ RA J*Â +#IA,>
IJAW J*, *,AgM*IA +#IKLA #C IJA JA*GK+S% 8MCCW $MTHKIIA, *
HAH#G*+,MH K+ #@@#$KIK#+ I# 5HKIJ\$ H#IK#+> TMI 5IAABA
*+, 3*+$HAKAG ,K, +#I% "#+AIJABA$$> IJA L#MGI S*Â *BB IJGAA
*@@ABB*+I$ *+#IJAG #@@#GIM+KIW I# TA JA*G, #+ IJA H*IIAG
*CIAG IJAW $MTHKIIA, H#IK#+$ I# ^*L*IA #G GAL#+$K,AG IJA #G
,AG SG*+IK+S 5HKIJ\$ GAgMA$I C#G *II#G+AW$\ CAA$% YAC#GA IJA
GAJA*GK+S> 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG T#IJ $MTHKIIA, TGKAC$ K+
#@@#$KIK#+ I# ;#HL*$I\$ CAA$% 4JAW LJ#$A +#I I# $MTHKI *,,K
IK#+*B TGKAC$ U*@*GI CG#H RJ*I R*$ @GA$A+IA, K+ IJA H#IK#+ I#
^*L*IA #G GAL#+$K,AG KI$ABCV #+ *+W #IJAG *$@ALI #C IJA #G,AG%
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ &&
:I IJA JA*GK+S 3*+$HAKAG Ac@B*K+A, K+ ,AI*KB RJW JA
IJ#MSJI IJ*I $*+LIK#+$ $J#MB, +#I TA KH@#$A, *S*K+$I JKHi
5IAABA $@#eA *$ RABB% 4JK$ H#GA IJ*+ $MCCKLA, *$ *+ #@@#G
IM+KIW I# TA JA*G,%
E) CJ!-T L9&$9%- '96 :**-
1+ *,,KIK#+ I# LJ*BBA+SK+S IJA *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ C#G 5HKIJ>
*@@ABB*+I$ *B$# *GSMA IJ*I IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI AGGA, TW SG*+IK+S
CAA$ I# IJA 156$% 8MCCW *GSMA$ JA R*$ +#I SKÂ+ *+ #@@#G
IM+KIW I# GA$@#+, I# IJA 156$\ GAgMA$I> *+, *BB IJGAA *GSMA
IJAW RAGA +#I SKÂ+ *+ #@@#GIM+KIW I# GA$@#+, I# IJA CAA
KIAHKo*IK#+%
#) +2''DT- G//96&2%$&D &9 U*-/9%,
ZJKBA 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG $MTHKIIA, IKHABW HAH#G*+
,* K+ #@@#$KIK#+ I# IJA 156$\ H#IK#+$> 8MCCW ,K, +#I% 3A *$
$AGI$ IJ*I JA R*$ +#I SKÂ+ *+ #@@#GIM+KIW I# GA$@#+, TA
L*M$A IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI GMBA, #+ IJA H#IK#+$ TAC#GA IJA IKHA
I# GA$@#+, Ac@KGA, M+,AG IJA L#MGI\$ B#L*B GMBA$% 4JK$ *GSM
HA+I K$ CGK^#B#M$% 8MCCW ,#A$ +#I LKIA *+W B#L*B GMBA C#G IJK$
@#K+I> *+, J*, JA I*eA+ IJA IKHA I# B##e *I IJA GMBA$> JA
gMKLeBW R#MB, J*Â GA*BKoA, IJ*I IJAGA R*$ IKHA I# GA$@#+,%
4JA 156$ ABALIG#+KL*BBW CKBA, IJAKG H#IK#+$ #+ "#ÂHTAG (>
/)&'% 4JA B#L*B GMBA$ *BB#R &Q ,*W$ C#G *+W GA$@#+$A I# ABAL
IG#+KL*BBW CKBA, H#IK#+$% 5AA 58100= Q%&USVi 58100= f%&ULV%
4JA GMBA$ @G#^K,A IJ*I `jCk*KBMGA I# CKBA * IKHABW GA$@#+$A I# *
H#IK#+ H*W> K+ IJA ;#MGI\$ ,K$LGAIK#+> TA L#+$K,AGA, *+ *,
HK$$K#+ #C IJA HAGKI$ #C IJA H#IK#+%a 58100= Q%&USV% 8MCCW
J*, M+IKB "#ÂHTAG /f> /)&'> I# $MTHKI JK$ GA$@#+$A> TMI JA
,K, +#I CKBA *+WIJK+S% 4JA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI SG*+IA, IJA 156$\ H#
IK#+ #+ "#ÂHTAG /Q> /)&'% 8MCCW J*, *+ #@@#GIM+KIW I# GA
$@#+,i JA $KH@BW LJ#$A +#I I# AcAGLK$A KI%
&/ "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
H) :** $&*8$V#&$9%
:BB IJGAA *@@ABB*+I$ *B$# *GSMA IJAW RAGA +#I SKÂ+ *+
#@@#GIM+KIW I# GA$@#+, I# T#IJ 5HKIJ *+, IJA 156$\ CAA KIAH
Ko*IK#+ *+, RAGA @GAbM,KLA, TW IJK$ *BBASA, #HK$$K#+% <+LA
*S*K+> IJAW HK$$ IJA H*Ge% 4JAW J*, * CMBB #@@#GIM+KIW I#
GA$@#+, I# 5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+ TMI LJ#$A I# C#LM$ #+ #IJAG
K$$MA$% ZKIJ GA$@ALI I# IJA 156$\ KIAHKo*IK#+> IJAW *GA L#GGALI
IJ*I IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI AGGA, RJA+ KI GMBA, I## gMKLeBW> TMI RA
L#+LBM,A IJ*I IJK$ AGG#G R*$ J*GHBA$$%
5HKIJ CKBA, JK$ KIAHKo*IK#+ #+ "#ÂHTAG (> /)&'i JA
*,,A, * +#IKLA IJ*I JA R#MB, G*K$A IJA KIAHKo*IK#+ *I IJA
"#ÂHTAG &' JA*GK+S% <+ "#ÂHTAG &)> 3*+$HAKAG CKBA, *
+#IKLA #C K+IA+IK#+ I# CKBA * GA$@#+$A I# 5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+ #+
#G TAC#GA "#ÂHTAG //% <+ "#ÂHTAG &/> IJA L#MGI $A+I *
"#IKLA #C 5IGKeK+S> RJKLJ GAgMKGA, 5HKIJ I# GACKBA JK$
KIAHKo*IK#+ RKIJ * L#GGALIA, $KS+*IMGA TB#Lei 5HKIJ L#H@BKA,
IJ*I $*HA ,*W% <+ "#ÂHTAG &'> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI JAB, *
GAJA*GK+S #+ IJA H*IIAG #C 5HKIJ\$ CAA$ *+, *+ K+KIK*B JA*GK+S
#+ IJA 156$\ GAgMA$I C#G CAA$% <+ "#ÂHTAG /f> IJA ,K$IGKLI
L#MGI #G,AGA, IJA ,#LeAI IAcI I# TA H#,KCKA, I# ,A$LGKTA
,ACA+,*+I$\ "#ÂHTAG &/ GA$MTHKIIA, KIAHKo*IK#+ *$ *
$M@@BAHA+I I# IJA H#IK#+ C#G $*+LIK#+$% 4JA L#MGI ,K, +#I
K+,KL*IA *+W LJ*+SA K+ IJA ,A*,BK+A C#G * GA$@#+$A% 4JA L#MGI
IJA+ K$$MA, KI$ GMBK+S CK+,K+S IJA CAA$ GA*$#+*TBA #+
"#ÂHTAG /QPCKÂ ,*W$ #'&*6 IJA ,*IA TW RJKLJ 3*+$HAKAG
J*, @G#HK$A, JK$ GA$@#+$A I# 5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+% ZJKBA
*@@ABB*+I$ L#+IA+, IJ*I IJA L#MGI GA$AI IJA GA$@#+$A ,A*,BK+A
#+ "#ÂHTAG /f RJA+ KI LJ*G*LIAGKoA, 5HKIJ\$ GA$MTHKIIA,
KIAHKo*IK#+ *$ * $M@@BAHA+I> IJAW SKÂ M$ +# K+,KL*IK#+ RJW
IJK$ $J#MB, TA $#% YAW#+, IJA C*LI IJ*I IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI
+AÂG *LIM*BBW GA$AI IJA ,A*,BK+A> IJAGA R*$ +# LJ*+SA I# IJA
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ &'
$MT$I*+LA #C 5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+% 9#GA#ÂG> *@@ABB*+I$ L#MB,
+#I J*Â GABKA, #+ IJ*I "#ÂHTAG /f LJ*G*LIAGKo*IK#+>
TAL*M$A IJAKG ,A*,BK+A I# $MTHKI IJAKG #@@#$KIK#+ R*$ IJ*I
$*HA ,*W% 1+ $J#GI> *@@ABB*+I$ J*, *H@BA #@@#GIM+KIW I# TA
JA*G, #+ *+W gMA$IK#+$ GAB*IA, I# 5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+ #C CAA$%
4JA IKHA IJA L#MGI S*Â C#G GA$@#+$A$ I# IJA 156$\ KIAHK
o*IK#+ R*$ $J#GIAG IJ*+ IJA &Q ,*W$ L*BBA, C#G TW IJA B#L*B
GMBA$% :4X4 ,K, +#I CKBA KI$ KIAHKo*IK#+ M+IKB "#ÂHTAG &fi
;#HL*$I\$ CKBK+S R*$ AÂ+ B*IAG> "#ÂHTAG //% 4JA ,K$IGKLI
L#MGI GMBA, #+ IJA $MTHK$$K#+$ #+ "#ÂHTAG /Q> bM$I &/ *+,
CKÂ ,*W$ B*IAG% 4JA L#MGI\$ #G,AG +#IA, IJ*I 8MCCW> 3*+$HAK
AG> *+, 5IAABA J*, +#I CKBA, GA$@#+$A$ I# IJA $@ALKCKL KIAHKo*
IK#+% 1I RA+I #+ I# Ac@B*K+ IJ*I KI C#M+, * GA$@#+$A M++ALA$
$*GW TAL*M$A> *CIAG J*^K+S GA^KARA, IJA KIAHKo*IK#+$> KI L#+
LBM,A, IJ*I IJA KIAHKoA, CAA$ RAGA GA*$#+*TBA% ZA L*+ *$
$MHA IJ*I KI R*$ AGG#G C#G IJA L#MGI I# *LLABAG*IA IJA IKHA C#G
GMBK+S RKIJ#MI K+C#GHK+S IJA @*GIKA$ #C IJA GA^K$A, $LJA,MBA%
"AÂGIJABA$$> *+W $MLJ AGG#G R*$ J*GHBA$$% :@@ABB*+I$ J*Â
+#I SKÂ+ M$ *+W GA*$#+ I# TABKAÂ IJ*I IJA 156$\ KIAHKo*IK#+
R*$ M+GA*$#+*TBA% 1+,AA,> K+ C#LM$K+S #+ IJA AGG#G$ K+
J8$&5\$ CAA$> *@@ABB*+I$ *GSMA IJ*I 5HKIJ\$ CAA$ *GA M+GA*$#+
*TBA RJA+ L#H@*GA, I# IJA CAA$ GAgMA$IA, TW ;#HL*$I% ZA
$AA +# GAÂG$KTBA AGG#G JAGA%
7) P$8*"$%*-- 9' &5* CJ!-T L9&$9%
:@@ABB*+I$ +AcI LJ*BBA+SA IJA 156$\ H#IK#+ #+ IJA SG#M+,
IJ*I IJAW ,AB*WA, I## B#+S TAC#GA CKBK+S KI% 4JAW *GA L#GGALI
IJ*I H#IK#+$ M+,AG $ALIK#+ &O/Q HM$I +#I TA M+GA*$#+*TBW
,AB*WA,% G(*6%$&* P6#%-/) 49) () 45$) C%,2-) P$6* 49)> .OQ E%/,
Q(O> QO' UQIJ ;KG% &O('V% YMI IJAW @M$J IJA @#K+I I## C*G RJA+
IJAW *$$AGI IJ*I IJA ,AB*W ,KÂ$IA, IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI #C bMGK$
,KLIK#+ #ÂG IJAKG H#IK#+% 1+ G(*6%$&*> IJA L*$A #+ RJKLJ IJAW
&- "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
GABW> *+ *@@A*B #C IJA bM,SHA+I R*$ @A+,K+S> *+, AKSJI
H#+IJ$ AB*@$A, TAIRAA+ IJA CKBK+S #C IJA +#IKLA #C *@@A*B
*+, IJK$ L#MGI\$ *CCKGH*+LA #+ *@@A*B% 8MGK+S IJ*I @AGK#,>
bMGK$,KLIK#+ J*, $JKCIA, CG#H IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI I# IJA L#MGI #C
*@@A*B$% :CIAG IJK$ L#MGI *CCKGHA,> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI SG*+IA,
*II#G+AW$\ CAA$ @MG$M*+I I# $ALIK#+ &O/Q% C,) *I QO/% ZA JAB,
IJ*I IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI R*$ RKIJ#MI bMGK$,KLIK#+ I# GMBA #+ IJA
H#IK#+ C#G L#$I$ *+, *II#G+AW$\ CAA$% 4JA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI J*,
+#I GA$AGÂ, bMGK$,KLIK#+ #ÂG IJK$ K$$MA *CIAG IJA +#IKLA #C
*@@A*B R*$ CKBA,i IJA $I*IMIA ,K, +#I BA*Â bMGK$,KLIK#+ K+ IJA
,K$IGKLI L#MGI C#G IJK$ @MG@#$Ai *+, +# H#IK#+$ L#+LAG+K+S
IJA L*$A RAGA ,KGALIA, I# AKIJAG IJK$ L#MGI #G IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI
,MGK+S IJA AKSJI H#+IJ$ IJA *@@A*B #+ IJA HAGKI$ R*$ @A+,
K+S% C,)
4JA LKGLMH$I*+LA$ JAGA *GA A+IKGABW ,KCCAGA+I% YAIRAA+
IJA IKHA IJA L*$A R*$ ^#BM+I*GKBW ,K$HK$$A, I# IJA IKHA RJA+
IJA 156$ CKBA, IJAKG H#IK#+ C#G $*+LIK#+$> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI GA
I*K+A, bMGK$,KLIK#+i +# *@@A*B R*$ @A+,K+S% 5HKIJ H#Â, C#G
$*+LIK#+$ #+ :@GKB f> /)&'> *+, IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI #GKSK+*BBW
SG*+IA, JK$ H#IK#+ #+ <LI#TAG ')> /)&'% :@@ABB*+I$ H#Â,
C#G GAL#+$K,AG*IK#+ K+ B*IA <LI#TAG *+, A*GBW "#ÂHTAG> *+,
*I IJ*I @#K+I IJA 156$ H#Â, C#G *II#G+AW$\ CAA$% 1I R*$ M@ I#
IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI I# ,ALK,A> K+ KI$ ,K$LGAIK#+> RJAIJAG IJ*I
H#IK#+ R*$ IKHABW% 4JA L#MGI L#+LBM,A, IJ*I KI R*$> *+, RA
$AA +# *TM$A #C ,K$LGAIK#+ K+ IJ*I GMBK+S%
W) L*6$&-
:@@ABB*+I$ +AcI IJG#R * ^*GKAIW #C *GSMHA+I$ GAS*G,K+S
IJA $MT$I*+IKÂ GMBK+S *S*K+$I IJA R*BB> RKIJ IJA J#@A IJ*I
#+A HKSJI $IKLe% "#+A ,#A$%
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ &f
4JA L#MGI #G,AGA, IJA KH@#$KIK#+ #C *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ M+,AG
$ALIK#+ &O/Q CG#H IJA K+LA@IK#+ #C IJA $MKI% 4JA $I*IMIA GA*,$
*$ C#BB#R$h
:+W *II#G+AW #G #IJAG @AG$#+ *,HKIIA, I# L#+,MLI
L*$A$ K+ *+W L#MGI #C IJA D+KIA, 5I*IA$ #G *+W 4AGGKI#
GW IJAGA#C RJ# $# HMBIK@BKA$ IJA @G#LAA,K+S$ K+ *+W
L*$A M+GA*$#+*TBW *+, Âc*IK#M$BW H*W TA GAgMKGA,
TW IJA L#MGI I# $*IK$CW @AG$#+*BBW IJA AcLA$$ L#$I$> Ac
@A+$A$> *+, *II#G+AW$ CAA$ GA*$#+*TBW K+LMGGA, TA
L*M$A #C $MLJ L#+,MLI%
<MG GA^KAR #C CAA *R*G,$ M+,AG $ALIK#+ &O/Q K$ #+BW C#G
*TM$A #C ,K$LGAIK#+% X#"&*6 () :$96*%V9> (-) E%/, -/Q> -'' UQIJ
;KG% &O((V% 5*+LIK#+$ *GA @G#@AG KC IJA *II#G+AW `J*$ *LIA, K+
*+ #TbALIKÂBW M+GA*$#+*TBA H*++AG TW A+S*SK+S K+ * $AGK#M$
*+, $IM,KA, ,K$GAS*G, C#G IJA #G,AGBW @G#LA$$ #C bM$IKLA q #G
RJAGA * LB*KH jK$k RKIJ#MI * @B*M$KTBA BAS*B #G C*LIM*B T*$K$
*+, B*LeK+S K+ bM$IKCKL*IK#+%a C,) UK+IAG+*B gM#I*IK#+ H*Ge$
*+, LKI*IK#+$ #HKIIA,V% YA*GK+S IJ*I $I*+,*G, K+ HK+,> RA
L#+$K,AG RJAIJAG IJA L#MGI *TM$A, KI$ ,K$LGAIK#+ TW KH@#$
K+S CAA$ C#G IJA A+IKGA L#MG$A #C IJK$ BKIKS*IK#+ *+, TW H*eK+S
BK*TKBKIW b#K+I *+, $AÂG*B%
#) :**- '698 C%7*/&$9%
0KSJI$@AA,\$ $MKI *S*K+$I IJA 156$ R*$ @GAHK$A, #+ IJA
+#IK#+ IJ*I TAL*M$A IJA 156$ LJ*BBA+SA, *@@ABB*+I$\ $MT@#A
+* #C IJA @AG$#+*BBW K,A+IKCK*TBA K+C#GH*IK#+ #C 5HKIJ\$ .>.))
`L#L#+$@KG*I#G$>a IJAW $#HAJ#R TAL*HA @*GI #C * @MG@#GI
A, @B#I I# $IA*B 0KSJI$@AA,\$ L#+IA+I% 1C IJAGA R*$ *+W L#+
LAK^*TBA HAGKI K+ IJ*I IJA#GW> IJA+ @AGJ*@$ CAA$ R#MB, J*Â
TAA+ K+*@@G#@GK*IA% YMI IJAGA R*$ +#I%
&. "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
;#M+I 1 *BBASA, IJ*I IJA 156$ ^K#B*IA, IJA ;#H@MIAG
EG*M, *+, :TM$A :LI U;E::V> &( D%5%;% ]] &)') *+, &)')USV>
TW C*KBK+S I# @GAÂ+I J*LeK+S% 4JA #+BW *BBASA, *$$K$I*+LA I#
J*LeAG$> J#RAÂG> R*$ IJA LJ*BBA+SA I# IJA $MT@#A+*% :$ Ac
@*+$KÂ *$ IJA ;E:: K$> $AA <GK+ 5% [AGG> Q#32*%*-- 45#""*%3*-
&9 &5* 498/2&*6 :6#2, #%, .H2-* .7&> O- 91""% 0% =7N% &f.&>
&f.'p.f U/)&)V> IJK$ K$ * CGK^#B#M$ LJ*GSA%
;#MGI 11 *BBASA, IJ*I IJA 156$ RAGA M+bM$IBW A+GKLJA, TA
L*M$A IJAW L#BBALIA, $MT$LGKTAG CAA$ CG#H @A#@BA RJ# M$A,
IJA K+IAG+AI I# S*K+ KBBAS*B *LLA$$ I# 0KSJI$@AA,\$ RAT$KIA% 4#
IJK$ ,*W> IJA *@@ABB*+I$ J*Â @G#^K,A, +# $M@@#GI C#G IJA
K,A* IJ*I AÂGW IKHA *+ K+IAG+AI M$AG ,#A$ $#HAIJK+S M+B*R
CMB #+BK+A> IJA M$AG\$ 156 K$ M+bM$IBW A+GKLJA, TAL*M$A KI L#+
IK+MA$ GALAK^K+S $MT$LGKTAG CAA$ CG#H IJA H*BAC*LI#G% 4JA B*R
K+ C*LI K$ I# IJA L#+IG*GW% 5AA &Q D%5%;% ] f&/U*V U* `$AG^KLA
@G#^K,AG $J*BB +#I TA BK*TBA q C#G K+CGK+SAHA+I #C L#@WGKSJI
TW GA*$#+ #C IJA @G#^K,AG\$ IG*+$HKIIK+S> G#MIK+S> #G @G#^K,
K+S L#++ALIK#+$ C#Ga H*IAGK*B ,K$IGKTMIA, TW #IJAG$ #+ KI$
+AIR#GeV%
;#M+I 111 *BBASA$ IJ*I IJA 156$ RAGA HAHTAG$ #C * LK^KB
L#+$@KG*LW I# J*Le *+, $IA*B CG#H 0KSJI$@AA, TAL*M$A IJA
156$ $M@@#$A,BW e+AR #C IJA *BBASA, J*LeK+S *+, WAI @G#
IALIA, IJA F#J+ 8#A$ TW LJ*BBA+SK+S IJA $MT@#A+*% ;#M+I 111
*B$# IJG#R$ K+ *+ *LLM$*IK#+ IJ*I IJA 156 L#G@#G*IA GA@GA
$A+I*IKÂ$ RAGA L#L#+$@KG*I#G$% 4JA$A *$$AGIK#+$ *GA MIIAGBW
RKIJ#MI BAS*B HAGKI% 4JA L#H@B*K+I B*Le$ AÂ+ IJA H#$I GM
,KHA+I*GW *BBAS*IK#+ #C *SGAAHA+I IJ*I R#MB, $*IK$CW CA,AG*B
@BA*,K+S $I*+,*G,$% 1+ *,,KIK#+> * $AG^KLA @G#^K,AG ,#A$ +#I
GK$e TAL#HK+S * L#L#+$@KG*I#G AÂGW IKHA KI LJ*BBA+SA$ *
$MT@#A+*% 4# *GSMA IJ*I LJ*BBA+SK+S * $MT@#A+* H*eA$ IJA
156$ L#L#+$@KG*I#G$ K+ * CKLIK#+*B L#@WGKSJI K+CGK+SAHA+I
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ &Q
GK+S K$ CGK^#B#M$% :@@ABB*+I$\ IJA#GW K$ *BB IJA H#GA #MIG*
SA#M$ SKÂ+ IJA C*LI IJ*I IJA 1BBK+#K$ 5M@GAHA ;#MGI gM*$JA,
* CM+LIK#+*BBW K,A+IKL*B *TM$KÂ $MT@#A+*%
;#M+I 1N *BBASA$ IJ*I IJA 156$ ^K#B*IA, IJA 1BBK+#K$ ;#+
$MHAG EG*M, *+, 8ALA@IKÂ YM$K+A$$ 6G*LIKLA$ :LI> (&f 10;5
] f)f_/> TW A+S*SK+S K+ IJA ,ALA@IKÂ @G*LIKLA #C *BB#RK+S
KBBAS*B *LLA$$ I# @B*K+IKCC\$ #+BK+A L#+IA+I% 9#GA IJ*+ IJK$>
J#RAÂG> K$ +AA,A, I# $I*IA * LB*KH M+,AG IJA 1BBK+#K$ $I*IMIAh
KI GAgMKGA$ Ù&V * ,ALA@IKÂ *LI #G @G*LIKLA TW IJA ,ACA+,*+Ii
U/V IJA ,ACA+,*+I\$ K+IA+I IJ*I IJA @B*K+IKCC GABW #+ IJA ,ALA@
IK#+i *+, U'V IJA #LLMGGA+LA #C IJA ,ALA@IK#+ ,MGK+S * L#MG$A
#C L#+,MLI K+^#B^K+S IG*,A #G L#HHAGLA%a U9H$%-9% () P9D9&#
L9&96 46*,$& 496/)0 QQf "%7%/, Of&> O.) U1BB% /))/V% 4JA :LI *B
$# L#ÂG$ M+C*KG L#+,MLI% C,) 0KSJI$@AA,\$ L#H@B*K+I C*KB$ I#
@B*LA IJA ,ACA+,*+I$ #+ +#IKLA #C J#R IJAW H*W J*Â ^K#B*I
A, IJK$ $I*IMIA%
;#M+I$ N *+, N1 *GA $KHKB*GBW HAGKIBA$$% 4JAW *BBASA IJ*I
IJA 156$ *K,A, *+, *TAIIA, 5HKIJ *+, IJA IJ#M$*+,$ #C F#J+
8#A$ TW CKSJIK+S IJA $MT@#A+*$% 4JAW *B$# *$$AGI> $#HARJ*I
L#+IG*,KLI#GKBW> IJ*I IJA 156 L#G@#G*IA GA@GA$A+I*IKÂ$ *LIA,
#MI$K,A IJA $L#@A #C IJAKG AH@B#WHA+I RJA+ IJAW JAB@A,
RKIJ IJ*I *K,K+S *+, *TAIIK+S% 4JA$A LB*KH$ *GA T*$ABA$$%
4JA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI $KHKB*GBW ,K, +#I *TM$A KI$ ,K$LGAIK#+ K+
*R*G,K+S *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ I# 5HKIJ CG#H IJA K+LA@IK#+ #C IJA
$MKI% 0KSJI$@AA, G*K$A, T*$ABA$$ LB*KH$ *+, @GA$$A, C#G *
HAGKIBA$$ ÀHAGSA+LWa ,K$L#ÂGW JA*GK+S% 4JA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI
C#M+, IJ*I IJA BKIKS*IK#+ `$H*LeA, #C TMBBW @GAIA+$A%a :I IJA
"#ÂHTAG &'> /)&'> JA*GK+S #+ CAA$> IJA L#MGI L#MB, +#I J*Â
TAA+ H#GA LBA*Gh KI $I*IA, IJ*I *@@ABB*+I$ RAGA A+S*SA, K+
`*TM$KÂ BKIKS*IK#+ q $KH@BW CKBK+S * B*R$MKI I# ,# ,K$L#ÂGW
I# CK+, #MI KC W#M L*+ $MA $#HAT#,W% 4J*I\$ bM$I MIIAG +#+
&( "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
$A+$A%a ZA $AA +# +AA, I# TAB*T#G IJA @#K+I% 4JA GAL#G, *H
@BW $M@@#GI$ IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI\$ L#+LBM$K#+$> *$ #MG ,K$LM$
$K#+ #C IJA L*$A IJM$ C*G ,AH#+$IG*IA$% 4JAGA R*$ +# *TM$A #C
,K$LGAIK#+ K+ IJA L#MGI\$ ,ALK$K#+ I# SG*+I AKIJAG IJA 156$ #G
5HKIJ CAA$ C#G IJA A+IKGA L*$A%
H) 19$%& #%, J*(*6#" <$#H$"$&D
ZA +#R IMG+ I# IJA gMA$IK#+ RJAIJAG IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI
*TM$A, KI$ ,K$LGAIK#+ K+ J#B,K+S *@@ABB*+I$ b#K+IBW *+, $AÂG
*BBW BK*TBA C#G IJA CAA$ *R*G,A,% :@@ABB*+I$ TASK+ TW *$$AGI
K+S IJ*I IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI HK$*@@BKA, $ALIK#+ &O/Q TW J#B,K+S
IJAH ^KL*GK#M$BW BK*TBA C#G A*LJ #IJAG$\ *LIK#+$% 4JAW *GA HK$
I*eA+% ZJKBA KI K$ IGMA IJ*I $ALIK#+ &O/Q BK*TKBKIW K$ ,KGALI> $AA
4"#$H96%* () X$-,98> -&- E%', Q&f> Q/- UQIJ ;KG% /))fV> *+ #G,AG
J#B,K+S @*GIKA$ b#K+IBW *+, $AÂG*BBW BK*TBA C#G L#$I$ #'&*6 ,A
IAGHK+K+S IJ*I A*LJ #+A K$ K+,K^K,M*BBW BK*TBA K$ * CK+,K+S #C
,KGALI BK*TKBKIW%
"AcI> IJAW L#+IA+, IJ*I :L C%,2-&6$*-0 C%7) () 4$&$796/
46*,$& J*6($7*-0 C%7)> .&- E%', ''f UQIJ ;KG% /)&)V> $I*+,$ C#G IJA
@G#@#$KIK#+ IJ*I * B*RWAG L*++#I TA JAB, GA$@#+$KTBA C#G
,#LMHA+I$ IJ*I TA*G *+#IJAG\$ +*HA TMI +#I JK$ #R+% :LC0
J#RAÂG> ,#A$ +#I $I*+, C#G $MLJ * TG#*, @G#@#$KIK#+% 4JAGA>
RA M@JAB, $*+LIK#+$ *S*K+$I *+ *II#G+AW> TMI RA C#M+, IJ*I
IJAW L#MB, +#I TA BA^KA, *S*K+$I IJA L#@WGKSJI $@ALK*BK$I GA
I*K+A, TW @B*K+IKCC\$ @GK+LK@*B L#M+$AB% 4JA L#@WGKSJI $@ALK*B
K$I> RA $*K,>
$AAH$ I# J*Â TAA+ $*+LIK#+A, C#G H*eK+S IJA HK$
I*eA #C *SGAAK+S I# JAB@ * L*GABA$$ B*RWAG jk RJ# @MI
JK$ +*HA I# CGK^#B#M$ *+, H*BKLK#M$ ,#LMHA+I$ q
jTkMI #C L#MG$A jIJA L#@WGKSJI $@ALK*BK$Ik R*$ +#I A+
S*SA, *$ * $AL#+,IKAG GA^KARAG q j3kA R*$ A+S*SA,
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ &O
I# JAB@ jIJA *II#G+AWk SAI JK$ TA*GK+S$ K+ L#@WGKSJI
B*R% 4J*I jIJA L#@WGKSJI $@ALK*BK$Ik C*KBA, *I IJK$ I*$e
,#A$ +#I H*eA JKH GA$@#+$KTBA C#G ,#LMHA+I$ IJ*I
TA*G jIJA *II#G+AW\$k +*HA TMI +#I JK$ #R+%
C,) *I '-)% 4JA ,ACA+,*+I J*, *GSMA, IJ*I IJA L#@WGKSJI $@A
LK*BK$I $J#MB, TA BK*TBA TAL*M$A JA ,K, +#I /6*(*%& IJA BA*,
*II#G+AW CG#H CKBK+S M+GA*$#+*TBA *+, Âc*IK#M$ ,#LMHA+I$%
ZA GAbALIA, IJ*I GA*$#+K+S *+, L#HHA+IA, IJ*I `j$kALIK#+
&O/Q ,#A$ +#I GAgMKGA AÂGW B*RWAG RJ# CKBA$ *+ *@@A*G*+LA
I# GA^KAR *+, ÂI AÂGW @*@AG CKBA, TW AÂGW #IJAG B*RWAG%a
C,) *I '-&%
4JA GABA^*+I gMA$IK#+ IJM$ GAB*IA$ I# IJA $L#@A #C GA$@#+
$KTKBKIW M+,AGI*eA+ TW A*LJ K+,K^K,M*B *II#G+AW% 1+ #MG L*$A>
IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI C#M+, IJ*I RJKBA 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG
RAGA +#I BK$IA, #+ AÂGW L#MGI ,#LMHA+I> IJA A^K,A+LA
$J#RA, IJ*I IJAW RAGA `K+ L*J##I$a RKIJ 8MCCW *+, R#GeA,
RKIJ JKH I# M$A IJA bM,KLK*B $W$IAH C#G * BAS*BBW HAGKIBA$$
LB*KH% 4JAKG ACC#GI$ $AAH I# J*Â L#+IK+MA, K+ IJK$ L#MGI%
ZJKBA T#IJ 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG +#R L#+IA+, IJ*I IJAW
$J#RA, M@ K+ IJK$ L*$A #+BW *CIAG IJA CA,AG*B @G#LAA,K+S$
RAGA M+,AGR*W> IJA GAL#G, $J#R$ IJ*I T#IJ RAGA *B$# K+
^#BÂ, K+ IJA $J*,#R$ #C IJA $I*IA L#MGI @G#LAA,K+S$% 5IAABA
L*BBA, :4X4\$ L#M+$AB *T#MI IJA $MT@#A+*$> *+, JA *@
@A*GA, *+, *GSMA, *S*K+$I IJA 156$\ H#IK#+ I# gM*$J *+,
H#IK#+ I# $I*W% 3*+$HAKAG *@@A*GA, *I * L#+CAGA+LA TAC#GA *
H*SK$IG*IA bM,SA *+, R*$ IJA $#BA $KS+*I#GW #C IJA &)@*SA
#@@#$KIK#+ I# IJA 156$\ H#IK#+ C#G IJA $I*W #C ,K$L#ÂGW%
ZJKBA 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG K+$K$I IJ*I IJAW J*, #+BW HK+K
H*B *LIK^KIW RKIJ IJK$ L*$A> IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI ,K, +#I *TM$A KI$
,K$LGAIK#+ RJA+ KI C#M+, #IJAGRK$A%

/) "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
77
ZA IMG+ +#R I# L*$A "#% &-&.(/> IJA *@@A*B CG#H IJA #G
,AG J#B,K+S 8MCCW> 5IAABA> *+, 3*+$HAKAG K+ LK^KB L#+IAH@I
*+, CK+K+S A*LJ #+A #+AIJKG, #C &)d #C ,ACA+,*+I$\ L#$I$
$IAHHK+S CG#H IJA CKG$I *@@A*B%
8
:$ RA +#IA, *I IJA #MI$AI> *CIAG IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI #G,AGA,
*@@ABB*+I$ I# @*W IJA $ALIK#+ &O/Q $*+LIK#+$ RKIJK+ &- ,*W$
#C IJA #G,AG> IJAW C*KBA, I# ,# $#% :$ * GA$MBI> ,ACA+,*+I$
$MTHKIIA, * b#K+I H#IK#+ C#G L#+IAH@I> #G K+ IJA *BIAG+*IKÂ>
C#G *+ #G,AG I# $J#R L*M$A RJW IJAW $J#MB, +#I *BB TA JAB,
K+ L#+IAH@I% :I IJA $J#RL*M$A JA*GK+S> A*LJ *@@ABB*+I *,
HKIIA, IJ*I JA J*, +#I @*K, *+W @*GI #C IJA $*+LIK#+$% "#+A
IJABA$$> *@@ABB*+I$ *GSMA, IJ*I L#+IAH@I R*$ M+*^*KB*TBA
TAL*M$A IJA $*+LIK#+$ #G,AG $J#MB, TA GAS*G,A, *$ * H#+AW
bM,SHA+I *+, IJM$ $#HAIJK+S IJ*I K$ +#I A+C#GLA*TBA
IJG#MSJ L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,K+S$% 1+ IJA *BIAG+*IKÂ> IJAW
LB*KHA, *+ K+*TKBKIW I# @*W% 4JA L#MGI IJ#MSJI IJA $*+LIK#+$
#G,AG R*$ AgMKI*TBA *+, A+C#GLA*TBA TW M$A #C L#+IAH@I
@#RAG% Y*$A, #+ *@@ABB*+I$\ LB*KHA, K+*TKBKIW I# @*W> IJA ,K$
IGKLI L#MGI #G,AGA, A*LJ I# $MTHKI * CK+*+LK*B $I*IAHA+I CG#H
* LAGIKCKA, @MTBKL *LL#M+I*+I IJ*I ÂGKCKA, JK$ *$$AGIA, B*Le #C
GA$#MGLA$% :BIJ#MSJ IJA CK+*+LK*B $I*IAHA+I$ RAGA $MTHKI
IA,> IJAW #@A+A, 6*+,#G*\$ Y#c% :II*LJA, I# A*LJ CK+*+LK*B
$I*IAHA+I R*$ * T#HT$JABB BAIIAG CG#H *@@ABB*+I$\ LAGIKCKA,
@MTBKL *LL#M+I*+I $I*IK+S IJ*I *@@ABB*+I$ J*, ÀBALIA, I#
#HKI $MT$I*+IK*BBW *BB #C IJA ,K$LB#$MGA$ GAgMKGA, TW SA+AG*B
BW *LLA@IA, *LL#M+IK+S @GK+LK@BA$%a "#I $MG@GK$K+SBW> IJA ,K$
IGKLI L#MGI C#M+, IJA $I*IAHA+I$ K+$MCCKLKA+I I# A$I*TBK$J *+
K+*TKBKIW I# @*W% 1I *B$# I##e +#IKLA IJ*I IJA$A $*HA *II#G+AW$
J*, @#$IA, B*GSA T#+,$ K+ #IJAG L*$A$% 1+ L#+bM+LIK#+ RKIJ
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ /&
IJA C*KBMGA AÂ+ I# HA+IK#+ IJA$A #IJAG L*$A$> IJA L#MGI $*R
IJK$ *$ *+ *IIAH@I I# KH@A,A KI$ *TKBKIW I# H*eA *+ *LLMG*IA
*$$A$$HA+I #C IJAKG LMGGA+I *TKBKIW I# @*W%
4JA L#MGI C#M+, IJ*I *@@ABB*+I$ J*, RKBBCMBBW ^K#B*IA, IJA
$*+LIK#+$ #G,AG *+, H*,A +# ACC#GI I# L#H@BW% 4JA H*S+K
IM,A #C J*GH R*$ $KS+KCKL*+I> KI *,,A,> @*GIKLMB*GBW *$ IJA
M+,AGBWK+S L*$A R*$ T*$ABA$$ *+, * HK$M$A #C IJA L#MGI$%
:,,KIK#+*BBW> IJA L#MGI C#M+, *@@ABB*+I$ I# J*Â H*,A HK$
GA@GA$A+I*IK#+$ *+, @GA$A+IA, `J*BCIGMIJ$a *I IJA $J#R
L*M$A JA*GK+S> $J#RK+S LBA*G ,K$GA$@ALI C#G IJA L#MGI% 4*eK+S
*BB #C IJK$ K+I# *LL#M+I> IJA L#MGI $*+LIK#+A, *@@ABB*+I$ K+ IJA
*H#M+I #C &)d #C IJA #GKSK+*B $*+LIK#+ *+, #G,AGA, IJA $MH
I# TA ,K^K,A, AgM*BBW *H#+S IJAH% 1I *B$# $AI M@ * $LJA,MBA
#C *,,KIK#+*B CK+A$ KC IJAW C*KBA, I# L#H@BW%
9
<MG GA^KAR> *$ TAC#GA> K$ C#G *TM$A #C ,K$LGAIK#+% 5AA .2
&9&*75 P*75-) <! () C%&*36#" U*-*#675 O +*() 496/)> -OO E%', Q'Q>
Qf& UQIJ ;KG% /))QV% 4# $MLLAA, #+ * L#+IAH@I @AIKIK#+> ,A
CA+,*+I$ J*, I# ,AH#+$IG*IA TW LBA*G *+, L#+^K+LK+S A^K
,A+LA IJ*I IJA *@@ABB*+I$ ^K#B*IA, IJA Ac@GA$$ *+, M+AgMK^#
L*B L#HH*+, #C * L#MGI #G,AG% C,) YG#eA+ ,#R+ K+I# KI$ ABA
HA+I$> IJA A^K,A+LA J*, I# $J#R IJ*I U&V IJA #G,AG $AI C#GIJ
*+ M+*HTKSM#M$ L#HH*+,i U/V *@@ABB*+I$ ^K#B*IA, IJ*I
L#HH*+,i U'V *@@ABB*+I$\ ^K#B*IK#+ R*$ $KS+KCKL*+Ii *+, U-V
*@@ABB*+I$ C*KBA, I# I*eA $IA@$ GA*$#+*TBW *+, ,KBKSA+IBW I#
L#H@BW RKIJ IJA #G,AG% 5AA $,)Y $AA *B$# :P4 () P62,*#2> fQO
E%', Qf-> Q.' UQIJ ;KG% /))OV ULKIK+S !6$8# P*N CC0 <<4 () Z"*6NT-
!"#-&$7 C%,2-)0 M)Q)> f/f E%', f-/ UQIJ ;KG% /))(V% ZA I*eA IJA
ABAHA+I$ K+ IMG+%
// "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
4JA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI\$ #GKSK+*B #G,AG R*$ M+*HTKSM#M$% 4JA
L#MGI H*,A LBA*G IJ*I KI R*$ KH@#$K+S $*+LIK#+$ @MG$M*+I I#
/( D%5%;% ] &O/Q *+, Ac@BKLKIBW L#HH*+,A, *@@ABB*+I$ I# @*W
RKIJK+ &- ,*W$% :@@ABB*+I$ IGW I# A^*,A KI TW *GSMK+S IJ*I
IJAW IJ#MSJI IJA #G,AG R*$ C#G * H#+AW bM,SHA+I% YMI IJK$
R*$ +AKIJAG @GK^*IA +#G @MTBKL BKIKS*IK#+ *S*K+$I IJA *II#G
+AW$% ZJ*I R*$ *I $I*eA R*$ IJA L#MGI\$ @#RAG I# S#ÂG+ KI$
T*G% :$ $ALIK#+ &O/Q U*+, C#G IJ*I H*IIAG /( D%5%;% ] &.f&V GA
CBALI> L#MGI$ J*Â IJA *MIJ#GKIW> IJG#MSJ L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,
K+S$> I# $*+LIK#+ *II#G+AW$ *+, I# A+C#GLA IJAKG #G,AG$% 5AA
4"*(*"#%, ;#$6 4"$%$70 C%7) () !2$3> &). E%', &.f> &.. UQIJ ;KG%
&OOQV U`D$A #C IJA L#+IAH@I @#RAG K$ *+ *@@G#@GK*IA R*W I#
A+C#GLA * $*+LIK#+ C#G HK$L#+,MLI> RJKLJ K$ +#I *+ #G,K+*GW
H#+AW bM,SHA+I%aVi ."/*6% () <$*H> && E%', .(O> .O) UQIJ ;KG%
&OO'V U`j=MBA &&k ,KGALI$ IJA KH@#$KIK#+ #C $*+LIK#+$ C#G M+
@G#CA$$K#+*B L#+,MLI K+ BKIKS*IK#+> *+, RJKBA IJA C#GH #C
$*+LIK#+ K$ #CIA+ *+, R*$ JAGA *+ #G,AG I# @*W *II#G+AW$ CAA$
I# IJA #@@#+A+I K+ IJA BKIKS*IK#+> KI K$ $IKBB * $*+LIK#+> bM$I *$
*+ #G,AG #C GA$IKIMIK#+ K+ * LGKHK+*B L*$A K$ * $*+LIK#+ AÂ+
RJA+ KI ,KGALI$ IJ*I @*WHA+I TA H*,A I# * @GK^*IA @AG$#+
G*IJAG IJ*+ I# IJA S#ÂG+HA+I%aV% 4JA H#+AWbM,SHA+I ,A
CA+$A SAI$ *@@ABB*+I$ +#RJAGA%
:@@ABB*+I$ +AcI *GSMA IJ*I IJAGA K$ +# A^K,A+LA IJ*I IJAW
,K, %9& $MT$I*+IK*BBW L#H@BW RKIJ IJA #G,AG> #G *I BA*$I I*eA
GA*$#+*TBA *+, ,KBKSA+I $IA@$ I# ,# $#% 4JK$ @#$KIK#+ KS+#GA$
IJA GAL#G,% :I IJA $J#RL*M$A JA*GK+S *@@ABB*+I$ H*,A LBA*G
IJ*I IJAW J*, +#I @*K, *+WIJK+S *+,> RJA+ gMA$IK#+A, *T#MI
@*WHA+I> IJAW +AÂG @#K+IA, I# *+W $IA@ K+ IJ*I ,KGALIK#+%
4JAW ABALIA, K+$IA*, I# ,ACA+, #+ IJA SG#M+, IJ*I IJAW RAGA
M+*TBA I# @*W% 1+*TKBKIW I# @*W K$ K+,AA, * ^*BK, ,ACA+$A K+
L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,K+S$> C% 6* U*-9267* P*75) 496/)> ./- E%',
'Q.> '(Q UQIJ ;KG% /)&)V> TMI IJA gMA$IK#+ R5*&5*6 IJA $*+L
"#$% &''()& X &-&.(/ /'
IK#+$ RAGA @*K, K$ ,KCCAGA+I CG#H IJA gMA$IK#+ R5D @*WHA+I
R*$ +#I H*,A% 4JA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI R*$ A+IKIBA, I# *+$RAG IJA
CKG$I #+A K+ IJA +AS*IKÂ> SKÂ+ *@@ABB*+I$\ *,HK$$K#+ #+ IJA
GAL#G, IJ*I IJAW J*, +AKIJAG @*K, IJA GAgMKGA, *H#M+I I# ,A
CA+,*+I$ +#G @#$IA, * $M@AG$A,A*$ T#+,%
:@@ABB*+I$ +AcI *GSMA IJ*I AÂ+ KC LK^KB L#+IAH@I HKSJI
J*Â TAA+ @G#@AG> IJ*I R*$ +#I IJA IW@A #C L#+IAH@I KH
@#$A, *S*K+$I IJAH% 4JAW MGSA IJ*I IJA CK+A KH@#$A, R*$
LGKHK+*B K+ +*IMGA *+, IJAW *GA IJAGAC#GA A+IKIBA, I# * $A@*
G*IA @G#$ALMIK#+ *+, CMBB ,MA @G#LA$$% ZA $AA +#IJK+S JAGA>
J#RAÂG> IJ*I R#MB, bM$IKCW LJ*G*LIAGKoK+S IJA$A CK+A$ *$
LGKHK+*B% ;K^KB L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,K+S$ H*W TA AKIJAG L#AGLKÂ
#G GAHA,K*B% 5AA I%$&*, J&#&*- () +9R*""> /fQ E%', .O-> .OO UQIJ
;KG% /))&V% 4JAW *GA `,A$KS+A, AKIJAG I# L#H@AB IJA L#+IAH
+#G K+I# L#H@BK*+LA RKIJ *+ AcK$IK+S L#MGI #G,AG #G I# L#H
@A+$*IA IJA L#H@B*K+*+I C#G B#$$A$ $M$I*K+A, *$ * GA$MBI #C
IJA L#+IMH*LW%a C,) 4JK$ CK+A R*$ GAHA,K*B% 1I R*$ @*K, I# IJA
,ACA+,*+I$> $AA ;$7N- 9% M*5#"' 9' :*$97N () :*$97N> -(f D%5% ./->
.'/ U&O((V> *+, KI L#GGA$@#+,A, I# IJA *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ *+,
L#$I$ K+LMGGA, TW ,ACA+,*+I$ ,MGK+S IJA L#MG$A #C BKIKS*IK+S
IJA L#+IAH@I H#IK#+% 4JA C*LI IJ*I IJA L#MGI LJ#$A * CK+A
AgM*B I# &)d #C IJA #GKSK+*B $*+LIK#+ RKIJ#MI L#+$MBIK+S TKBB
K+S $I*IAHA+I$ ,#A$ +#I L#+ÂGI IJK$ K+I# * CK+A C#G LGKHK+*B
L#+IAH@I% 5AA K(#%- () 4$&D 9' K(#%-&9%> O-& E%/, -Q'> -QQ UQIJ
;KG% &OO&V%
:@@ABB*+I$\ GAB*IA, *GSMHA+I IJ*I IJA L#MGI\$ K+*TKBKIWI#
@*W *+*BW$K$ R*$ *+ *TM$A #C ,K$LGAIK#+ K$ AgM*BBW M+*^*KB
K+S% ZJAGA ÌJAGA J*$ TAA+ +# ACC#GI *I AÂ+ @*GIK*B L#H@BK
*+LA RKIJ IJA L#MGI\$ #G,AG> IJA K+*TKBKIWI#@*W ,ACA+$A GA
gMKGA$ * $J#RK+S #C * mL#H@BAIA K+*TKBKIW\ I# @*Wai *@@ABB*+I$
`J*, IJA TMG,A+ #C A$I*TBK$JK+S mLBA*GBW> /"#$%"D> *+, 2%8$-
/- "#$% &''()& X &-&.(/
&#N#H"D\ IJ*I mL#H@BK*+LA K$ $8/9--$H"*%\a C% 6* U*-9267* P*75)
496/)> ./- E%', *I '(Q ULKIK+S ;2H*6 () L#6$%* L$,"#%, M#%N> f&
E%', f> &) U/, ;KG% &OOfVV%
llllllllllllllllllllll
:@@ABB*+I$\ TMG,A+ K+ A*LJ #C IJA$A @G#LAA,K+S$ R*$
JKSJ *+, IJA GAL#G, $M@@#GI$ IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI\$ J#B,K+S$
IJ*I IJAW ,K, +#I HAAI KI% :+W *GSMHA+I$ IJ*I RA J*Â +#I
,K$LM$$A, ,# +#I HAGKI $A@*G*IA *IIA+IK#+% ZA :EE1=9 IJA #G
,AG #C $*+LIK#+$ KH@#$A, *S*K+$I *@@ABB*+I$ K+ "#% &''()&%
ZA *B$# :EE1=9 IJA #G,AG K+ "#% &-&.(/ J#B,K+S *@@ABB*+I$
K+ LK^KB L#+IAH@I *+, KH@#$K+S IJA $I*IA, CK+A% ;#$I$ #C *@
@A*B *GA I# TA I*cA, *S*K+$I *@@ABB*+I$ b#K+IBW *+, $AÂG*BBW%
5AA E78% =% :66% 6% 'OU*V%

Order On Prenda Appeal

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Order On Prenda Appeal

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

"# $%&

'#($&) *$+$&, -./0$ .1 233&+4,

Você também pode gostar