Analytical assessment of the rates, terms and conditions for standby service Focus on combined heat and power (CHP) applications Identify opportunities for improvement in selected utility standby tariffs Estimate the economic impact of the suggested tariff improvements on a selected set of proxy CHP customers 2 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Standby Service Defined Set of electric utility products for customers with on- site, non-emergency generation Provides a utility backstop for on-site generation facilities Important factor in determining the economics of CHP applications relative to utility full requirements service or purchasing power from a competitive supplier 3 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Illustration of a Self-Generators Purchase Requirements D e m a n d Supplementary Power Standby Power Plant Requirement Generation Time Forced Outage: Backup Power Planned Outage: Maintenance Power Planned Outage (Coinciding with Plant Shutdown) 4 Typical Standby Rate Structure Capacity reservation charge As-used capacity and energy charges Maintenance capacity charge Facility charges 5 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Standby Rates Best Practices Allocation of Utility Costs Generation, transmission, and distribution charges should be unbundled Generation reservation demand charges should be based on the utilitys cost and the forced outage rate of customers generators on the utilitys system Higher-voltage delivery charges should recognize load diversity 6 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Standby Rates Best Practices Appropriate Incentives Pro-rated daily demand charges Daily maintenance demand charges -- discounted Customer Options Interruptible standby service option Customers should be able to procure standby service from the open market 7 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Analytical Process Selected Jurisdictions and Tariffs State Utility Tariff(s) Arkansas Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Standby Service Rider Colorado Public Service Company of Colorado Schedule PST Schedule TST New Jersey Jersey Central Power & Light Company Rider STB Ohio AEP-Ohio Power Company Schedule SBS Schedule OAD-SBS Utah Rocky Mountain Power Schedule 31 8 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Analytical Process Description of Analytical Methods Economic analysis performed for each utility standby tariff analyzed Selection of customer usage characteristics Discussions with state regulatory commission staff State customer databases Small, medium and large non-residential customers 9 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Analytical Process Modeling Methods Customized Microsoft Excel spreadsheet Key model inputs Load factor Peak demand Generating unit net capability and outage hours Utility rates for standby and supplemental service and applicable tariff riders Costs modeled under existing and modified standby rates 10 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Analytical Process Development of Tariff Modifications Reviewed the standby tariff components Evaluated against best practices in standby rate design Identified tariff adjustments 11 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Common Tariff Recommendations Generation, reservation and daily demand charges Seasonal and on/off-peak charges Scheduled maintenance daily demand charge Dedicated distribution investment charge Load diversity for transmission and shared distribution Interruptible option Open market standby if available 12 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. State Specific Recommendations Arkansas EAIs SSR Tariff More rate transparency Better price signals Increased flexibility Better clarity 13 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. State Specific Recommendations Colorado PSCos Schedules PST and TST The Grace Energy Hours provision should be eliminated and replaced with a generation reservation fee and a daily demand charge Charges developed based on common tariff recommendations 14 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. State Specific Recommendations New Jersey JCP&Ls Rider STB Scheduled maintenance hours should be allowed for all standby customers, irrespective of when the customer commenced service Standby service should be available to all customer- generators regardless of the availability factor of their generating unit Standby tariffs should be concise and easily understandable 15 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. State Specific Recommendations Ohio Ohio Powers Schedules SBS and OAD-SBS Two separate rate zones Separate standby rates for bundled and choice customers Eliminate menu of forced outage rates for bundled customers 16 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. State Specific Recommendations Utah RMPs Schedule 31 Currently no reservation generation charge Daily on-peak backup charges Excess power charge > $40 per kW Single customer limit 10 MW 17 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Conclusion Standby rates can benefit from a reassessment to enhance their effectiveness for CHP applications Existing rates, terms and conditions can be modified Better match utility costs Provide clearer price signals Provide improved incentives for the operation of self- generation units Enhance flexibility for customers 18 The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc. Questions ? 19 We would like to thank the Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the United States Department of Energys Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy for their support and involvement in this project. The Regulatory Assistance Project and Brubaker & Associates, Inc.