Fossil Tracks from the Green River Formation (Eocene) near Soldier Summit, Utah
Author(s): Mounir T. Moussa
Source: Journal of Paleontology, Vol. 42, No. 6 (Nov., 1968), pp. 1433-1438 Published by: SEPM Society for Sedimentary Geology Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1302292 . Accessed: 13/09/2014 23:03 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. . SEPM Society for Sedimentary Geology is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of Paleontology. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions JOURNAL OF PALEONTOLOGY, V. 42, NO. 6, P. 1433-1438, PLS. 177, 178, 1 TEXT-FIG., NOVEMBER 1968 FOSSIL TRACKS FROM THE GREEN RIVER FORMATION (EOCENE) NEAR SOLDIER SUMMIT, UTAH MOUNIR T. MOUSSA University of Puerto Rico, Mayagiiez ABsTRAcT-Numerous well-preserved bird, mammal, and insect-larva? tracks were dis- covered in the lowermost part of the delta facies of the Green River Formation (middle Eocene) in the Soldier Summit area, Utah. The beds containing the fossil tracks occur about 900 feet above the base of the Green River. This fossil-track horizon is an excellent marker horizon that can be easily recognized, traced, and mapped. It lies about 55 feet above the base of the delta facies of the Green River. The association of the tracks of many organisms permits a better understanding of the physical environment that prevailed in the area at the time of deposition of the track-bearing sediments. The area was probably a near-shore shelf area of the Eocene Uinta Lake that frequently became an emergent mudflat. Paleontologi- cally, the preservation of the tracks provides a record of an organic community that is not known from the conventional skeletal remains in this area. The level to which animal tracks may be classified taxonomically depends upon the group represented, the geologic age of the tracks, the tracking conditions, and the variations resulting from differences among the indi- viduals of a particular species. Ichnites are of limited usefulness in animal identification. They usually are identifiable only at the higher taxonomic levels of class or order; however, they can be a potential means of identification at the generic or even at the specific level. Study and comparison of both Recent and fossil tracks may provide criteria whereby specific or generic differences may be recognized. INTRODUCTION THE PURPOSE of this paper is to report the discovery of a fossil-track horizon in the Green River Formation (middle Eocene) near Soldier Summit, Utah, and to discuss its strati- graphic, environmental, and paleontologic sig- nificance. The first recorded discovery of fossil tracks in the Green River Formation was made in 1956 when numerous bird tracks were found in a dolomitic limestone bed in upper Timber Creek in the SEi sec. 19, T. 5 S., R. 9 W., Uinta Basin Special Meridian, Utah (Curry, 1957, p. 43). Curry reported the discovery and discussed the significance of fossil tracks in the lower Cenozoic rocks of the Uinta Basin. Many other exceptionally well-preserved fossil tracks -bird, mammal, and insect-larva tracks-simi- lar to those described by Curry but belonging to a different stratigraphic horizon were discov- ered by the writer in 1962 in the Green River Formation during the course of a detailed geo- logic mapping of the Soldier Summit Quadran- gle, Utah. This horizon was first observed in sec. 17, T. 10 S., R. 8 E., Salt Lake Meridian. Later this horizon proved to be a readily recog- nizable and persistent marker. This fossil-track horizon is here referred to as the "Soldier Sum- mit fossil-track horizon." STRATIGRAPHY Most of the map area (Text-fig. 1) is under- lain by the Green River Formation. The forma- tion is more than 5,800 feet thick, and it in- cludes a diversity of lithologic types including claystone, limestone, dolomite, marlstone, sand- stone, siltstone, and oil shale. The Green River is conformably underlain by the variegated silt- stones and sandstones of the Colton Formation (lower Eocene). In the western part of the area the Colton intertongues extensively with the Green River Formation, and immediately west of the map area the Colton becomes indis- tinguishable from the Green River Formation. The Green River Formation is conformably overlain by flakly and platy brown shale, shaly marlstone, and marlstone of the saline facies of the Uinta Formation (middle and upper Eo- cene). The Soldier Summit area is part of the south- western edge of the Uinta Basin. In the western part of the basin no formal stratigraphic subdi- visions of the Green River Formation have, so far, been proposed for the entire thickness of the formation, and the formation also has been much less studied than in other parts of the basin. In addition, the terminology in current usage is not uniform, and there is a wide varia- tion in the stratigraphic meaning of the names assigned to the subdivisions of the formation due to considerable divergence in the manner of selecting the stratigraphic boundaries of the various units. In the Soldier Summit area, the Green River Formation is divided from top to bottom into the following units: Evacuation Creek and Par- achute Creek Members (undifferentiated), delta facies, second lacustrine facies, fluviatile facies, and basal lacustrine facies. The three basal units are grouped under the informal name "basal member of the Green River Formation" (Moussa, 1965). 1433 This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions MOUNIR T. MOUSSA TEXT-FIG. 1-Geologic map of the Soldier Summit area of Utah, showing the outcrop of the Soldier Summit fossil-track horizon. Stratigraphically, the Soldier Summit fossil- track horizon is about 900 feet above the base of the Green River Formation, and it lies in the lowermost part of the delta facies. In the Sol- dier Summit Quadrangle, the track-bearing hori- zon has been traced from the eastern boundary of the quadrangle westward over an outcrop distance of more than 25 miles (Text-fig. 1). The Timber Creek track horizon, according to Curry (1957), is 4,150 feet above the base of the Green River Formation, and it lies in the upper part of the Parachute Creek Member or in the lower part of the Evacuation Creek Member. Curry (1957, p. 43) indicated that the Timber Creek track horizon was traced as far as sec. 9, T. 10 S., R. 7 E., Salt Lake Meridian EXPLANATION OF PLATE 177 Fossil tracks in the Green River Formation. FIr. 1-Bird tracks of at least two species, X0.34. 2-Trackways of more than one bird, XO.11. All tracks were probably made by one species. 3-Bird tracks showing a well-defined hind toe, X0.60. Some tracks do not show the hind toe; they probably belong to a different species, or they may belong to the same species as the one having the hind toe except that the tracking conditions were different. In the latter possibility the hind toe did not register because the mud was drier. The numerous zigzag-shaped tracks were probably made by insect larvae. 4-A very rare example of a bird track on a ripple-marked surface, X0.57. Figure is of reverse impres- sions of track and ripple marks. 1434 This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions JOURNAL OF PALEONTOLOGY, V. 42 PLATE 177 Mounir T. Moussa "A~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~, ,* ' ..... -'-,. ' , i"- .., I rA I 1 I ?c,~~~~... ?:li $.... ~;i:~i ::,' ,/:,. .:..~?-"~~~~ '. ~. ? P - ri .:.'-? ,: ..... :; I---:: Al,~~~~~~~~~~~, ? ~ ~ ~ ~ ? ~ s .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~7 .? . . '..:.-..'.,-:'' ..-~~~i ;r...~ ,? . ,.,, ml,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~v / '~ .' "~":.I';"i . _ , -... . .. .-:'~,,. ..~; ':iii I i i ,ii! ! it~l ! : i : i ~ : : i :i:i~;ii! lli i:! ! : :. ~] i l l i 1 i 3 I; 'I, , l t.1-r c . J ~' ' '~~, '. 1 .., - .;. l ~ . 1! ! .,.-??, This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions JOURNAL OF PALEONTOLOGY, V. 42 -' PLATE 178 Mounir T. Moussa -6 $ 5'),. b I 1 / Lr at j P. A*i -. W , /A- ,; T (ri" 1 ' | S\'\t' {-.; ;I, -i -i 2 ?-c" : 1. .? ,' i-???i :LJ = '*;rb_a eC 5 .se v ,:r 'Cr- .i7j ./i ,I . e? : ;1 _?;; t;? ?L r- ..? re TirI . .L4, c -'i ?,4 -'? - :I-':;?3r* "r?-dik.iC i->? YCy' k.?Ct ,f-r m f P' _*6i. .. , t. le.. .. I ' \ . . , - ..- - _ - ' r This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions GREEN RIVER FORMATION, UTAH in the Soldier Summit area. During the present work, however, the writer failed to detect any track-bearing rocks in the above-mentioned lo- cality. In a few places in the Soldier Summit Quadrangle, however, the weathered rubble of the upper part of the Green River Formation contains sparse, badly preserved bird tracks, but none was detected in outcrop. The fossil tracks of the Soldier Summit track horizon occur in thin-bedded, greenish-gray to gray limestone that weathers to a distinctive buff or cream color. The limestone breaks down into thin slabs having characteristically smooth bedding planes. The slabs form a conspicuous rubble on the underlying greenish-gray marl- stone. This track-bearing limestone is a distinc- tive lithologic type in the Green River Forma- tion; in fact, it is unique in appearance of out- crop. Once the eye is familiarized with the ap- pearance of the outcrop, the track-bearing hori- zon is easy to recognize even from a distance and is difficult to confuse with other beds. The Soldier Summit track horizon contains three track-bearing limestone beds which are in- terbedded with light-brown to gray and brown- ish-gray marlstone. The lowermost track-bear- ing bed lies 55 feet above a conspicuous, bench- forming oil-shale bed. This oil-shale bed is con- sidered as the top of the basal member of the Green River Formation. It is worth noting that the description of the lithologic association of the Soldier Summit track horizon, particularly with respect to the presence of the oil-shale bed, is almost identical to that given by Curry (1957) for the Timber Creek track horizon. The alternation of limestone and marlstone, Curry (1957, p. 46) believed, may be a result of rhythmic deposition. Curry also believed that the occurrence of an oil-shale below the track- bearing beds may indicate that "oil-shale and track beds are the terminal members of a deep- to shallow-water cycle of deposition, and that they represent a cyclothem of tens of thousands of years duration." DESCRIPTION OF FOSSIL TRACKS Bird tracks.-Bird tracks (P1. 177, figs. 1-4; P1. 178, figs. 1, 3, 5) are one of the common types of tracks in the Soldier Summit fossil- track horizon, and they occur in large numbers. The bird tracks are probably those of wading and swimming birds, are of different types, and they show a considerable range in size. Some tracks show a partly developed web, and most of them show a hind toe. According to R. L. Zusi of the U.S. National Museum (written communication, 1965), the bird tracks shown in Plate 177, figure 3, and Plate 178, figures 3 and 5, "are almost certainly sandpipers, and perhaps plovers, of at least three species. One could thus assign them to the order Charadriiformes, sub- order Charadrii, and probably to the family Scolopacidae (plus Charadriidae ?)." Mammal tracks.-The Soldier Summit fossil- track horizon also contains mammal tracks (P1. 178, fig. 2) which appear to have been made by three-toed mammals; however, these are ex- tremely rare and have been found at three lo- calities only. One locality in the western wall of the canyon of White River in the NEiNEI sec. 16, T. 10 S., R. 8 E., has yielded many well-pre- served mammal tracks (John F. Shroder, per- sonal communication, 1965). According to Clay- ton Ray of the U.S. National Museum (written communication, 1965), "It appears that the tracks were made either by a small, three-toed horse, EXPLANATION OF PLATE 178 Fossil tracks in the Green River Formation. FIG. 1-Largest bird track so far known from the Soldier Summit fossil-track horizon, X0.57. 2-Mammal tracks, those of a three-toed horse or tapiroid mammal, X0.26. 3-A bird track that shows a partially developed web, X0.33. The lower left corner shows probable rain- drop impressions. 4-Tracks probably made by insect larvae, which vary in form from an irregular line to a remarkable regular zigzag pattern, X0.67. At least five varieties can be recognized, and the figure shows other identifiable impressions. 5-Numerous tracks of sandpiper-like birds on one slab of rock, all of them probably belonging to one species only, X0.23. 1435 This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions MO UNIR T. MO USSA or perhaps a tapiroid, although it would be dif- ficult to identify them with a specific genus. However, on the assumption that one or the other of the above categories is correct, the genera Orohippus and Helaletes, respectively, are suggested." Insect-larva ? tracks.-Perhaps the most inter- esting tracks are those of some invertebrate, most probably insect larvae (PI. 178, fig. 4). These trails, commonly associated with bird tracks, occur in great profusion although they may escape notice, and in most examples close inspection is needed to see them. They are of different shapes and they vary in form from an irregular line to a remarkably regular zigzag (PI. 178, fig. 4). The identification of these trails as larva tracks is based on the similarity between the zigzag-shaped trails and those shown by Tarr (1935, P1. 136, fig. 2) from the Champlain Formation of late Pleistocene age in the Connecticut River valley. The trails from the Champlain Formation were described earlier by Emerson (1899, p. 720), who identified them as the trails of the larvae of the dipterous insect Chironomus motilator. Emerson's identification in turn was based on similarity with tracks de- scribed from Sweden and Finland. The nature of the tracks, however, could not be regarded as certain. Opinions of many ento- mologists were requested, and a query as to the probable organism involved was published (Moussa, 1966). It seems unlikely that the tracks were made by chironomid larvae (W. W. Wirth, J. E. Sublette, L. L. Curry, R. H. Whit- sel, and J. H. Mundie, written communications). According to Sublette, Whitsel, and Mundie, it might be that the zigzag-shaped tracks were made by ceratopogonid larvae. Mundie ex- plained that "Ceratopogonid larvae make vigor- ous figure-of-8 movements when free-swimming and when moving over wet substrates," and he concluded that possibly, when the track-bearing sediments were drying out, ceratopogonid larvae wriggled through the mud leaving tracks which persisted. Mundie, however, "would not insist that ceratopogonids are necessarily the correct explanation." Mundie further asked if it is pos- sible that the tracks were made by the trail of an animal whose footprints are not showing, and whether tadpoles or even lizards would make such tracks. That at least some of the tracks may have been made by another animal is not unlikely; the zigsag-shaped and related tracks are almost always associated with some impression (P1. 178, fig. 4) that may possibly be the claws of an animal. STRATIGRAPHIC SIGNIFICANCE The Soldier Summit fossil-track horizon was traced without interruption from the eastern boundary of the map area (Text-fig. 1) west- ward to the mouth of the canyon in the SEi sec. 24, T. 10 S., R. 6 E. (The horizon has not been traced eastward, but most likely it extends several miles to the east also.) The oil-shale bed below the track-bearing horizon crops out on the eastern side of U.S. Highway 6-50 opposite the mouth of Starvation Creek. Westward, the track-bearing beds could not be located. How- ever, few scattered tracks were found on the ridge between Starvation Creek and Clear Creek in secs. 24 and 23, T. 10 S., R. 6 E. At one locality at the mouth of Tie Fork, a lime- stone bed that has all the characteristics of the track-bearing beds crops out near the bottom of the canyon; this bed, however, does not bear any tracks. As a marker horizon, the track horizon is cer- tainly invaluable. The facility with which the track horizon could be recognized, traced, and mapped stands in evidence for this conclusion. It is doubtful that any other bed in the Green River Formation in the Soldier Summit area could be so easily traced and mapped. This, to- gether with its position above the assigned top of the basal member of the Green River Forma- tion, has proved to be invaluable in correlating the lower part of the Green River. ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE The association of the tracks of a number of organisms is significant, as several conclusions can be derived regarding the physical environ- ment that existed at the time when the tracks were made. The tracks are probably more sig- nificant in reconstructing the paleogeographical conditions than are the conventional skeletal re- mains. Mud cracks and probable rain-drop impressions are common features in the track- bearing horizon, and very rarely the rocks are ripple marked (P1. 177, fig. 4). The ripple marks are of the oscillation type. The area was probably a part of a near-shore shelf area of the Eocene Uinta Lake, and at that time the lake was apparently characterized by a rapidly vacillating water level. Whether the fluctuation of the water level in Uinta Lake was periodic, for example, seasonal, can not be inferred. It is certain, however, that from time to time during the period of deposition of the sediments of the track-bearing beds, the area became a mudflat. The beds carrying the fossil tracks are thinly laminated (P1. 177, fig. 2), and 1436 This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions GREEN RIVER FORMATION, UTAH most of the laminae bear fossil tracks. Each lamina represents a period of submergence fol- lowed by a period of emergence. The sediment forming a lamina was deposited when the area was submerged. The following recession of the lake left the area as a mudflat. The tracks were formed on this emergent mudflat which probably was partially dry and firm enough to walk upon without miring. The presence of mud cracks sub- stantiates this conclusion. If the mud were soft the details of the feet would have been lost. Tracks on a ripple-marked surface would have been obliterated if the surface were submerged. It must be remembered that the texture of the sediment was also an important factor in the preservation of the tracks. A fine-grained sur- face was needed for recording the details of the tracks; coarse-grained material certainly would have blurred the impressions. Tracks are there- fore extremely rare on sandy surfaces, and where found they were blurred by the coarse- ness of the recording sediments. PALEONTOLOGIC SIGNIFICANCE The preservation of the bird tracks, together with the mammal and insect-larva? tracks, pro- vides a fascinating record of an extinct organic community that once thrived along the south- western edge of the Eocene Uinta Lake. In this part of the stratigraphic section, at least in the area where the tracks are found, this community is so far unknown and will most likely remain unknown from skeletal remains. Here is an in- teresting and unusual record of several species of at least three classes of animals that would have been a remarkable contribution to our un- derstanding of Eocene life in the Uinta Basin. Unfortunately, none of the animals represented could be identified with a particular species or even with a genus. The preservation of tracks of animals whose skeletal remains are unknown raises the impor- tant question: What is the level of taxonomic information obtainable from animal tracks? In some examples it is even difficult to ascertain whether the animal that made the tracks is a vertebrate or an invertebrate. Such is true for the tracks here tentatively designated as insect- larva? tracks. As far as this writer has learned, there is no record of similar tracks that may be attributed to a Recent organism with certainty. Their association with other animal tracks and their occurrence in great profusion leave no doubt regarding their organic origin. In the event that the tracks in question could be as- signed to a given class of animals, the geologic age of the tracks and the group that is repre- sented are important factors in determining the level of taxonomic classification. The level of taxonomic classification is also dependent on the tracking conditions and on the variations result- ing from individual differences. We should ex- pect that some tracks will be virtually impossi- ble to identify even with a given order. Others may possess distinctive characteristics that may be identified with a given species. For Recent birds, for example, Urner (as referred to by Hickey, 1943, p. 179-189) has shown that some shore birds can be identified from their tracks. And as Zusi (written communication, 1965) in- dicated "in late Pleistocene material one might attempt specific identification of a distinctive print with more confidence than from a single broken bone." Zusi further wrote that "the fact is that diagrams of bird tracks such as those re- produced in Hickey are practically non-existent, and we are thus badly hampered in this type of identification." Perhaps the limited usefulness of ichnites for taxonomic classification may account for their neglect. It seems, however, that their limited usefulness is in part due to their neglect. Ich- nites are undoubtedly excellent tools in recon- structing paleogeographical conditions. A great deal more can be learned about the life of the past if we advance our understanding of the an- imals that made the tracks. Ichnites may prove to be a tool for identification at the generic or even at the specific level. A collective endeavor on the part of both the biologist and the paleon- tologist to report the tracks of both Recent and fossil organisms is certainly needed. Studying and comparing of both recent and fossil tracks may provide criteria whereby specific or generic differences may be recognized. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to express my deep appreciation to Drs. Harry D. Goode and William Lee Stokes, both of the Department of Geology, University of Utah, for their criticism of an early version of the present manuscript. I am also grateful to the many individuals who provided information regarding the identification of the fossil tracks; they are Richard L. Zusi, U.S. National Museum; Willis W. Wirth, U.S. Department of Agriculture; James E. Sublette, Department of Biological Sciences, Eastern New Mexico Uni- versity; L. L. Curry, Department of Biology, Central Michigan University; Richard H. Whit- sel of Belmont, California; J. H. Mundie, Fish- eries Research Board of Canada; and Clayton E. Ray, U.S. National Museum. Thanks are also due Dr. W. Wiilker, University of Freiburg, 1437 This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions MOUNIR T. MOUSSA Germany, and William Olkowski, Division of Parasitology, University of California (Berke- ley). The photographs reproduced in the Plates were taken by Dr. Peter B. Stifel; he also brought to my attention the paper by W. A. Tarr (1935). The University of Puerto Rico at Mayagiiez contributed $55 toward the cost of publication of this article. REFERENCES CURRY, H. D., 1957, Fossil tracks of Eocene verte- brates, southwestern Uinta Basin, Utah, in Inter- mtn. Assoc. Petroleum Geologists, Guidebook 8th Ann. Field Conf., Guidebook to the geology of the Uinta Basin, p. 42-47, 12 figs. EMERSON, B. K., 1899, Geology of old Hampshire County, Mass.: U.S. Geol. Survey, Mon. 29,790 p. HICKEY, J. J., 1943, A Guide to bird watching: New York, Oxford Univ. Press, 243 p. (reprinted 1963, New York, Doubleday, 295 p.) MOUSSA, M. T., 1965, Geology of the Soldier Sum- mit quadrangle, Utah (Ph.D. dissertation): Salt Lake City, Utah Univ., 129 + A63 p., 32 figs. , 1966, Insect tracks: Entom. Soc. America, Bull., v. 12, p. 377. TARR, W. A., 1935, Concretions from the Champlain Formation of the Connecticut River Valley: Geol. Soc. America, Bull., v. 46, p. 1493-1534, Pls. 135- 145, 2 figs. MANUSCRIPT RECEIVED SEPTEMBER 25, 1967 1438 This content downloaded from 114.76.94.66 on Sat, 13 Sep 2014 23:03:46 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions