Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
2
)
d = A
1
A
1
Tan
-1
B
1
B
1
B
1
B
1
17
As two separate equations are proposed for ascending and descending
portions of the stress-strain curve
0 0.85
Mc = b (nd /)
2
1 d + 2 d }
0
0
The moment of resistance offered by steel (Ms) can be determined by
Ms = Ts (d-nd) = st x Ast (d-nd)
Knowing the values of and n, theoretical curvature () can be
determined using the relationship = (/nd). Using the above developed
procedure the moment-curvature relationships are plotted as shown in
the fig 1.10.1
Fig.1.10.1 Experimental and Theoretical M- plots for
Beam UR & OR of M2S-mix
18
1.11 DURABILITY STUDIES OF LOW, MEDIUM AND HIGH GRADE
SCC MIXES WITH GGBS AND RHA.
Apart from strength studies a detailed experimental investigation is done
on the acid durability of self-compacting concrete (SCC) prepared with
and without admixtures. The cubes are immersed for30 days, 45days, 60
days, 75 days and 90 days in Sulphuric acid (H2SO4), Sodium Sulphate
(Na2SO4) and Hydrochloric acid (HCl) solutions separately. Weight and
compressive strength losses, ADF & AAF are the main properties
investigated. The table 1.11.1 shows the Acid durability and Acid attack
factors for M20 SCC mixes and the fig.1.11.1 shows the graph between
acid durability factor and days of immersion in H2SO4.
Table 1.11.1 Acid Durability & Acid Attack Factors for different SCC Mixes
No. of
days of
immersion
Immersion in H2SO4
M20 M20 GGBS M20 GGBS- RHA
Sr ADF AAF Sr ADF AAF Sr ADF AAF
30 98.65 32.88 0.35 98.78 32.92 0.29 99.00 33.00 0.21
45 94.78 47.39 0.71 96.85 48.43 0.46 97.70 48.85 0.35
60 90.51 60.34 1.53 94.87 63.24 0.91 95.48 63.65 0.95
75
85.80 71.50 2.89 91.81 76.50 1.85 94.70 78.92 1.42
90 83.57 83.57 2.91 89.60 89.60 2.58 93.60 93.60 1.98
Sr - Relative Strength, Acid Durability Factors - ADF, Acid Attack Factors - AAF.
19
Fig.1.11.1 Acid Durability Factor and Days of immersion of
M20 grade SCC mixes in H2SO4 Acid
1.12 CONCLUSIONS
1. The addition of RHA to GGBS mixes has shown improved performance
in terms of strength and durability in all grades of SCC.This is due to
the presence of highly reactive silica in GGBS and RHA.
2. Studies indicated that there is a good compatibility between mineral
combinations GGBS and RHA along with the chemical admixtures
such as SP and VMA when used in SCC.
3. The Bolomeys empirical expression can be used to predict the
strength efficiency of the GGBS and RHA in SCC at different
percentage of replacement levels.
4. The strength efficiency factor k of GGBS in SCC mixes at 28 days
was found to be between 0.7 to 1.8. The strength efficiency factor k for
normal concrete mixes were reported to be between 0.7 to 1.3 by
20
K.Ganesh Babu and V.Sree Rama Kumar [37],which shows the
strength efficiency factors are slightly higher for SCC mixes with
GGBS.
5. Similarly experimental studies on efficiency of GGBS and RHA
combination in SCC confirmed the enhanced performance in terms of
both strength and durability aspects with respect to performance of
GGBS alone in SCC.
6. Based on the stress-strain curves of SCC mixes with and without steel
confinement it is observed that the stress-strain pattern is to be
almost similar. But the GGBS-RHA mixes have shown improved
stress values. It is observed that for higher grades of concrete with
increase in stress there was decrease in strain.
7. Empirical equations for the stress-strain response of SCC mixes
have been proposed in the form of Y = Ax/ (1+Bx
2
), where x is
normalized strain and Y is normalized stress. The same empirical
formula is valid for both ascending and descending portions with
different values of constants.
8. It is observed that there is an increase in the peak compressive
strength for different SCC mixes made with GGBS and RHA mixes.
The increase is due to high reactivity of RHA with GGBS
9. Addition of GGBS and RHA control the initiation of micro cracks,
improve the first crack load, the ultimate load and ductility of SCC
21
specimens under flexure. They are also effective in resisting
deformation at all stages of loading from first crack to failure.
10. Load deflection behaviour for all SCC beams is observed to be similar
except the increased values of loads at ultimate and at first crack due
to addition of GGBS and RHA to SCC mixes.
11. Theoretical moment-curvature relationships for SCC and beams
followed similar pattern as that of experimental values. The only
difference noticed is the values of theoretical moments calculated are
lesser than the experimental values. But the variation is very less,
thus theoretical values of moments almost coincide with experimental
values. This shows a good correlation between them.
12. The Acid durability factors (ADF) were found to be more in SCC made
with GGBS and RHA in three grades. The Acid Attack Factors (AAF)
has shown that the GGBS and RHA mixes are more resistant for acid
attack.
13. The strength loss and weight loss observed to be less in mixes with
GGBS and RHA.
1.13. SOME IMPORTANT REFERENCES
1. Ahmadi, Alidoust Development of Mechanical Properties of SCC
containing Rice Husk Ash Proceedings of World Academy of Science,
Engineering and Technology Volume 23 August 2007 .
22
2.AnniePeter.J,Lakshmanan.N, Devadas Manoharan.P, Rajamane.N.P&
Gopalakrishnan.S Flexural Behaviour Of RC Beams Using Self
Compacting Concrete. The Indian Concrete Journal, June 2004, PP
66-72.
3. D.R.Seshu & K.Ramesh Constitutive behaviour of confined fibre
reinforced concrete under axial compression cement and concrete
composites, 2003, pp 343-350.
4. K.Ganesh Babu and V. Sree Rama Kumar, Efficiency of GGBS in
concrete, Cement and Concrete Research Volume 30, Issue 7, July
2000, Pages 1031-1036.
5. Mehta. P.K., Properties of Blended Cements made from Rice Husk
Ash, American Concrete Institute Journal, Sept. 1977.
6. Nan Su, Kung-Chung Hsu, His-Wen Chai A simple mix design
method for self-compacting concrete Cement and Concrete
Research 31 (2001) 17991807.
7. N.R.D. Murthy, D.R.Seshu and M.V.S.Rao, Constitutive behaviour
of fly ash concrete with steel fibres in ordinary grade IE (I) Journal-
CV, Aug 2007,pp41-46.
8. Okamura Hajime & Ouchi Masahiro Self Compacting Concrete.
Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology, Vol 1, April 2003, pp 5-14.
23
9. Okamura, H. and Ouchi, M. "Effect of super plasticizer on self-
compactability of fresh concrete," Transportation Research Record,
No.1574, Dec.1997, pp.37-40.
10. Pap worth,F. and Radcliffe, R. (1994), High-Performance Concrete-
the concrete future, Concrete International, V. 16, No. 10, pp. 39-44.
11. Ravindra Gettu Application of Self-Compacting Concrete: Recent
experience and challenges that remain Proceedings of International
Conference on Advances in Concrete & Construction,ICACC-2008, 7-9
Feb., 2008, Hyderabad, pp 58-71.
12.Seshagiri Rao.M.V., Janardhana.M. Rao.K.R.M, Ravindra Kumar.
High ly Ash Concrete with RHA as an admixture.1999.Vol.80.Journal
of Institution of Engineers, (India).pp.57-63.
13. Seshagiri Rao.M.V and Rama Rao.G.V. High performance RHA fiber
reinforced concrete with chicken mesh wire fibers. Proceedings of the
International Conference on Recent Trends in Concrete Technology
and Structures.Coimbatore.2003, pp 381-393.
14. SureshBabu.TMechanical properties and stress- strain behaviour
of self compacting concrete with and without glass fibres Asian
journal of civil engineering (building and housing) vol. 9, no. 5 (2008)
pages 457-472.
15.The European Guidelines for Self Compacting Concrete
Specification, Production and Use Feb 2002 and May 2005.
24
LIST OF PUBLICATIONS OF THE AUTHOR RELATED TO THE
PRESENT WORK
NATIONAL JOURNALS (PUBLISHED)
1. Utilization of Solid Waste Material in Self Compacting Concrete.
Environmental Pollution Control Journal Vol 13, No.1 (2009) pages 44-47.
2. Study on the Strength Characteristics of SCC with GGBS and RHA as
mineral admixtures The IUP Journal of Structural Engineering Vol.III No 3,
July 2010 pages 35-46.
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCES
1. Strength Characteristics of High Volume Fly Ash Concrete
ICCE-2001, 23-25 July 2008, pp 120-125, International Conference on
Civil Engineering held by Department of Civil Engineering, IISC Bangalore.
2. Study of Low Medium and High Strength Self Compacting Concrete with
different Admixtures as Replacement of Cement. accepted for 7th
International Symposium on Cement & Concrete, ISCC-2010 and the
International Conference on Advance in Concrete Technology and
Sustainable Development, May 9-12, 2010, in Jinan, P. R. China
NATIONAL CONFERENCES
1. Impact of Concrete Materials on Climate and its Management Proceedings
of National Conference on Climate Change Abatement: Role of Civil
Engineers, 23
rd
and 24
th
October, 2009, Institution of Engineers (India), A P.
pp 77-81.