Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
July 2014
Prepared by Andrea Raickovic for the OSCE Mission to Bosnia and Herzegovina
contents
Case Background ...................................................................................................................1
1. The Importance of Gender-Sensitive Analysis of Post-Disaster Needs
2. Research Preparation and Methodology for Post-Disaster Needs of Women and Men,
Boys and Girls
2.1 The Relevance of Conducting a Preliminary Assessment of Pre-Disaster Gender
Vulnerabilities......................................................................................................................2
2.2 Researching Post-Disaster Gender Sensitive Needs: Data Collection Methods............3
3. Assessing and Documenting Post-Disaster Impacts on Gender-Sensitive Needs.......5
3.1 Post Disaster Gender Differential Demographic/Household and Housing Data..6
3.2 Gender-Sensitive Post-Disaster Economic Data..7
3.3 Gender-Sensitive Post-Disaster Health Data....9
3.4 Gender-Sensitive Post-Disaster Education Data.......11
3.5 Gender Differential Post-Disaster Allocation of Resources Analysis.........12
3.6 Gender Differential Analysis of Post-Disaster Division of Labour...12
3.7 Gender Differential Post-Disaster Relief Response and Reintegration Data....13
Works Consulted........15
Abstract
The purpose of this document is to serve as a guiding tool for assessing
the gender differential needs and capabilities of Bosnia and Herzegovinas
recent flood affected population in a post-disaster setting. By collecting
and analysing gender-sensitive qualitative and quantitative data, the impact on gender roles, relations, vulnerabilities and needs of women, men,
boys and girls will be more clearly identified. These revelations will in turn
shed light on various shortcomings of the existing recovery and reconstruction programmes, and will help anticipate future needs and possible
response gaps.
A Gender-Sensitive Post-Disaster
Needs Assessment Framework
Case Background
For general background information regarding the floods on the territory of
Bosnia and Herzegovina starting on 13 May 2014, please refer to the following reports: UN BiH Flood Disaster Situation Report , UN International Humanitarian Assistance to BiH Report 18/06/2014
volved disaster agencies in voicing the affected populations gender differential needs. This method is more demanding in terms of resources and
time; however when well thought of, it is highly efficient in identifying the
affected populations post-disaster needs, existing programme shortcomings and potential reconstruction mechanisms.
Table 1.
Type of Data
Demographic/Household
Data
Economic Data
In the baseline analysis, the evaluator should focus on Bosnia and Herzegovinas socio-economic status and conditions, with an emphasis, if possible, on chosen post-disaster sample sites. The main focus out to be
placed on the status of women and gender relations. The following qualitative and quantitative data could be included and documented (dependant
on availability):
Health Data
Indicators
- Total households
- Household heads by gender
- Dependency index (below 15 years
and over 65 years)
- Total and differentiated household
income
- Vulnerable group status
- Level of poverty by gender, age and
household headship
- Roles and responsibilities of family
members (CEDAW reports can serve
as excellent sources)
- Formal sector: job, income, employment and unemployment levels
- Informal sector: activities, by gender
- Access, control and use of resources:
who owns (controls) and who has access (uses)
- Household food security: consumption
patterns, responsibility for household
food security
- Birth rate, death rate
- Womens fertility rate
- Common health problems of women
by age and vulnerability group status
- Common health problems of men by
age and vulnerability groups status
- The number of health facilities by type
- Number of users of health facilities by
gender and age
- Responsibilities assigned to house-
Education Data
and disaggregating the data whenever possible. As a result, primary research and data collection will serve as the key in determining the affected
populations gender differential needs in the post-disaster phase. This is
why it will be extremely important to conduct carefully designed and thorough primary research on the chosen terrain, which is most representative
of the affected regions needs and problems.
Indicator
Socio-Demographic and
Housing Data
In order to get a full understanding and recording of the differential gendered impacts, where possible, the data should be disaggregated by: gender, age, household headship, ethnicity, religion, and vulnerability group
status (i.e. is the interviewee homeless, living below poverty line, a single
mother etc.?).
Data Source
Economic Data
Health Data
Post-Disaster Allocation
of Resources
Post-Disaster Division of
Labour
Table 3.1
Household Indicators
Number of elderly
men and women
living alone
The average family
size of affected population
Average dependency ratio (under 15
years and older than
65 years)
Table 3.2
The data should be disaggregated by gender and age of household head. The evaluator should also conduct a vulnerability
analysis of the affected individuals in question (e.g. is it a
household with a big family, living below poverty line, are its
members farm workers, does it consist of only women/single
mothers, minorities, seniors living alone etc.)
-
as above
as above
as above
Qualitative Data
The following questions should be selected on a site relevance basis and
formulated for use in surveys such as household questionnaires, for individual and group gender-sensitive consultations, and for discussions with
the involved disaster relief and reconstruction agencies. Some questions
are best suited for women only. When working with the affected population, the evaluator should aim to document each respondents gender,
age, and vulnerability group status where possible and applicable.
1. Describe the relief and reconstruction efforts of the community,
NGOs, IGOs, including governmental agencies response to the
disaster and the level of satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Describe
the individual response offered (disaggregated by gender).
2. What resources were provided for the care of women and girls,
and to what extent were they able to meet their needs?
3. What are the main gender-sensitive housing demands in the chosen research site and what proportion comes from women?
4. Are there noticeable changes in the relations between men and
women and their typical roles and responsibilities?
5. What factors (e.g. environmental, economic, political, infrastructural) played a role in the affected populations decision to leave
their home (disaggregated by gender)? Was the decision made
solely by the household head and if so, were they a man or a
woman?
6. What factors (e.g. environmental, economic, political, infrastructural) are influencing the displaced individuals decision to return or
not return home? Are there existing differences in responses according to age and gender?
the evaluator should note the extent of damage to agricultural production assets were they completely destroyed, damaged yet capable of production, or in need
of repair?
Qualitative Data
5. What are the needs and demands of local authorities in responding to employment and livelihood needs of affected women and
men by type of sector?
6. What are the main informal economic activities undertaken (important to document by gender, age and vulnerability status where
possible)? To what extent and in what way has the informal economic sector been impacted?
the evaluator should take care not to record predisaster cases of malnutrition
households that
were unable to
reach the nearest
medical/sanitation
facility by gender
and age of household head, including
vulnerable group
status
Qualitative Data
The following questions should be selected on a site relevance basis and
formulated for use in surveys such as household questionnaires; for individual and group gender-sensitive consultations; and for discussions with
the involved disaster relief and reconstruction agencies. Some questions
are best suited for women only. When working with the affected population, the evaluator should aim to document each respondents gender,
age, and vulnerability group status where possible and applicable.
gender specific (e.g. special care for pregnant women)? How have
the relevant authorities and disaster response agencies responded
to such shortages? What could be done to improve the response
of the relevant authority in the future?
4. Are medical facilities within accessible reach of households and
the entire community? Were there transportation services organised for those incapable of reaching medical facilities?
5. Have the victims of gender-based violence and sexual assault
sought out safe shelter, legal and medical aid and from whom?
Are relevant agencies available and capable of responding to such
needs in the given community (e.g. NGOs and Gov. bodies dealing with womens issues, safe houses etc.)? If not, what needs to
be done to ensure their accessibility and operation?
6. Are there any existing mechanisms which help to identify at riskindividuals of gender-based violence? Which agency is responsible for such efforts? What could be done to help the relevant authorities in dealing with such individuals?
7. Are there any mechanisms in place for dealing with gender-based
violence, sexual assault and general post-disaster psychological
consequences? If so, how effective are they?
8. Have women received adequate sanitation and hygienic products
(e.g. sanitary napkins, tampons, deodorants, razors etc.)?
If so, which agencies provided them? Were there any shortages?
10
Percentage (%) of
schools requiring a
total rebuild
Percentage (%) of
schools/learning
spaces (re)opened
Percentage (%) of
teachers by gender,
trained on disasterrelated health and
protection topics
Percentage (%) of
schools with mechanisms for reporting
on incidents of
abuse and sexual
harassment
Qualitative Data
The following questions should be selected on a site relevance basis and
formulated for use in surveys such as household questionnaires, for individual and group gender-sensitive consultations with relevant parties, and
for discussions with the involved disaster relief and reconstruction agencies. Some questions are best suited for women only. When working with
the affected population, the evaluator should aim to document each re-
11
spondents gender, age, and vulnerability group status where possible and
applicable.
1. List the main obstacles which are preventing boys and girls from
attending schools (important to document differences in attendance obstacles by gender, age and vulnerable group status).
2. What mechanisms and resources are necessary to ensure that
boys and girls attend school in the post-disaster period?
3. Are there programmes within the educational system which aim to
raise awareness regarding violence against women?
4. Are there programmes within the educational system which educate students on general health matters?
5. What kind of help should be provided to local authorities so that
they can best respond to the needs of women and girls in an educational setting?
In order to prepare for the analysis the evaluator should construct a list of
the main resources in question, specific to their chosen research site.
Such resources will mainly be tied to the infrastructure, housing and the
agricultural sector. For example, when working with affected farmers the
resource list should include: agricultural land, agricultural land tenure, livestock, crops, agricultural equipment, water sources etc.
Once the evaluator has constructed a list of main resources, they should
document who controls and has access to them in a gender disaggregated
manner, including the impact of the disaster on both factors. Furthermore,
any difference in quality of resources of women and men should also be
noted, including changes in the workload of both genders in the postdisaster period.
12
Qualitative Data
The following questions should be selected on a site relevance basis and
formulated for use in surveys such as household questionnaires, for individual and group gender-sensitive consultations, and for discussions with
the involved disaster relief and reconstruction agencies. Some questions
are best suited for women only. When working with the affected population, the evaluator should aim to document each respondents gender,
age, and vulnerability group status where possible and applicable.
1. Do women and vulnerable individuals hold leadership positions in governance structures (at the lowest relevant level)?
2. What are the access patterns to general social services of women, men
and vulnerable groups? What obstacles to access are present for each
category?
Number of elected
officials by gender
3. Discuss the roles of political and religious leaders during the disaster
and post disaster-phase.
4. What are the main changes in community norms and practices in the
post-disaster period that influence the roles and relations between men
and women?
5. Have any post-disaster reconstruction agencies or relevant governmental sectors initiated programmes to assess and address the different needs
of men, women, boys and girls? If so, what are they and how effective
have they proven to be thus far?
Name of district, city, sub-region, country:
6. Has the affected population been receiving adequate and accurate information regarding the status of their homes, property and livelihoods,
including family members and the relief and reconstruction benefits programmes available for their use? Which agency (governmental and non-
13
14