| 1 P a g e

TAX FRAUD EVIDENCE ON 5046 S GREENWOOD AVE

We will start this journey with the latest PIN # for 5046 S Greenwood Ave which is 20-11-115-037-0000. Now once again
as noted by the CCRD PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000 does not exist. When I keyed in that PIN # at www.ccrd.info this was
my result yet again as of 05/22/2011: No record found for this criteria or your search has timed out, please narrow
down your search criteria and try again Click here to go back.
As per my National Property Search which was completed on 03/14/2011 Harvey Wineberg was listed as the owner of
PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000 as of tax year 2010. Now one could say that there could have been a clerical error creating an
erroneous notation, however, why would an erroneous notation remain on file for six years.

On April 20
th
of this year WND reported, The 2009 records show Wineberg paid taxes on the property totaling
$25,742.31, paid in two installments of $12,351.04 and $13,391.27.
Wineberg told WND in a telephone interview that he simply pays the tax bills he receives on the Obama
property. He said he has no idea whether others are paying taxes on the property or whether the amounts he is
paying agree with the amounts Obama reports on his personal IRS income-tax filings.
Note that the PIN associated with Wineberg's ownership, 20-11-115-037-0000, is different than Stuart's.

Read more: Why do 3 supporters own Obama's home?
http://www.wnd.com/?pageId=289501#ixzz1N6bXTkdw
The following two pages will show and I will also describe the anomalies that I discovered in connection as to what is
recorded with the Treasurers Office in Cook County and use that evidence against what I consider to be an ambiguous
anomaly against Obamas taxes for 2009.
The first graphic on page (2) is what the Cook County Treasurers results are when PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000 is used for
information on the taxes paid for said PIN #. Please note that neither the Obamas, William Miceli, nor the Northern
Trust Co. Trust # 10209 are mentioned as the property tax payers of 5046 S Greenwood Ave., Chicago, IL 60615.
When I asked my contact at the Assessors office about this she said, That he could either be the owner or just the
individual who is paying the taxes on the property. Now when she said that she could not tell with any clarity if he was
the owner, I asked her why, she then referred me to the CCRD. It was the CCRD who told me that PIN # 20-11-115-037-
0000 does not exist as per their records.
On pages (3, 4) is the information from the Cook County Assessors Office as it Pertains to PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000.

| 2 P a g e

Cook County Property Tax and Payment Information

Printed copies of this information may not be used as a tax bill.
Payments must be submitted with original tax bill.
Property Index Number (PIN): 20-11-115-037-0000
View Prior Tax Year Information
2010 Tax Year Information - Payable in 2011
Tax Year: 2010 Tax Type: Current Tax Volume: 254 PCL: 2-09
Property Location
5046 S GREENWOOD AVE
CHICAGO, IL 60615-2806

(To update contact the Cook County Assessor's Office at 312-443-7550.)
Mailing Information Exemption Information
HARVEY WINEBERG
180 N LASALLE ST #2200
CHICAGO, IL 60601-2610
To update your mailing information click here.
To request a duplicate tax bill click here.
Exemptions do not become effective until the 2nd installment.

For last year's exemption data please scroll down to 2009 taxes due in 2010.
To check if you received exemptions on previous tax years, click here.
Tax Payment Information
Installment Tax Amount Billed Tax Due Date Last Payment Received Date Received

1st $14,158.27 04/01/2011 $14,158.27 03/17/11

Balance Due: $0.00


The balance due, including any penalty, is as of: 5/22/2011
Payments processed are posted through: 5/20/2011
View Current Tax Year Information
2009 Tax Year Information - Payable in 2010
Tax Year: 2009 Tax Type: Current Tax Volume: 254 PCL: 2-09
Property Location
5046 S GREENWOOD AVE
CHICAGO, IL 60615-2806

(To update contact the Cook County Assessor's Office at 312-443-7550.)
Mailing Information Exemption Information
HARVEY WINEBERG
180 N LASALLE ST #2200
CHICAGO, IL 60601-2610
To update your mailing information click here.
To request a duplicate tax bill click here.
Homeowner Exemption Received: NO
Senior Citizen Exemption Received: NO
Senior Freeze Exemption Received: NO
If you are entitled to an exemption you did not receive, click here.
To check if you received exemptions on previous tax years, click here.
Tax Payment Information
Installment Tax Amount Billed Tax Due Date Last Payment Received Date Received

1st $12,351.04 03/02/2010 $12,351.04 03/02/10

2nd $13,391.27 12/13/2010 $13,391.27 11/20/10

Balance Due: $0.00


The balance due, including any penalty, is as of: 5/22/2011
Payments processed are posted through: 5/20/2011

| 3 P a g e


5046 S Greenwood Ave

PIN 20-11-115-037-0000

Property
Appeals
Exemptions
Certificate Of Error

Property Details
This property is currently being reviewed by the Assessors Office for possible improvements.

City

Chicago

Township

Hyde
Park

NBHD.

20

Taxcode

70001

Class
2-09


Assessed Valuation

2010
Assessor Certified
Assessment
2009
Board of Review
Certified
Land Assessed Value 43,369 43,369
Building Assessed Value 121,715 121,715
Total Assessed Value 165,084

165,084

Property Characteristics
Estimated 2010 Market Value

1,650,840
Estimated 2009 Market Value 1,650,840
Description Two or More Story Residence, Any Age, 5,000 Sq. Ft. & Over
Residence Type Two Story
| 4 P a g e

Use Single Family
Apartments None
Exterior Construction Masonry
Full Baths 6
Half Baths 0
Basement
1
Full and Unfinished
Attic Partial and Living Area
Central Air Yes
Number of Fireplaces 3
Garage Size/Type
2
4 car detached
Age: 87
Land Square Footage 12,047
Building Square Footage 6,243
Assessment Pass Assessor Certified
1
Excluded from building square footage, except apartment
2
Excluded from building square footage

This is what we know so far:
1. Barack and Michelle Obama do not own 5046 S Greenwood Ave., Chicago, IL 60615. The house is actually
owned by The Northern Trust Co. Trust # 10209, a trust that the Obamas did not create as a private trust to
purchase the home.
2. Currently, Willaim Miceli is not the owner as well even though it has been reported to be so. However, as per a
2005 assessment for the 06/2005 sale of 5046 S Greenwood Ave he was listed as the owner / purchaser.
3. PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000 does not exist at the CCRD and with no explanation as to why.
4. PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000, however, does exist at the Cook County Treasurers Office as of 05/22/2011
5. PIN # 20-11-115-037-0000, however, does exist at the Cook County Assessors Office as of 05/22/2011
How many layers / RED FLAGS so far?
Now let us discuss the Obamas 2009 and 2010 Taxes (which will be included in my blog as PDFs) as they pertain to the
property taxes The Obamas claimed for their home. Pages 5 will show certain discrepancies that I view as more
ambiguous anomalies that need to be explained. The graphics on page 5 are going to be from the Obamas 2009 1040
U.S. Individual Income Tax Return Page 3, line 6. The second graphic is going to be from the Obamas Illinois
Department of Revenue 2009 Schedule ICR page 57, Section A, line 4a. On line 4a you will notice that the PIN # for the
home that they are claiming has been redacted. The third graphic is from their Federal Income Tax Return Line 6
Schedule A, Itemized Deductions. See how convoluted all this is.
Please not who one of the partners in the firm which did the Obamas taxes for 2009 and 2010.


| 5 P a g e


Fig 1

$22,456 as noted oh their 2009 Federal Income Tax Return.

Fig 2

$22,456.00 as noted on their IL tax return. Note that the PIN # has been redacted. Why?

Fig 3

$25,742 as noted on their 2010 Federal Income Tax Return.

Note that on his 2010 IL Tax Return the property tax information in not included. Why? Is it because they would have to
redact the same information as they did in 2009?

Now how many layers have we gone over today? The answer is six and that is just on the Obamas taxes alone. Now
remember that we are all innocent until proven guilty. Can anyone explain to me my mistakes if any?
Q: Why are the Obamas not listed as the owners or taxpayers for 5046 S Greenwood Ave?
Q: Why is Trust # 10209 not listed at the owner or taxpayer for 5046 S Greenwood Ave?
Q: If there is a clerical error why has it not been addressed for six years?
Q: Why was the PIN # redacted on Obamas 2009 IL tax return?
Q: Why is the Obamas real estate taxes not listed on their 2010 IL tax return? Is it because they would have to redact
the PIN # again as they did in 2009?