Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
SEMINAR
Peritoneal tuberculosis
La tuberculose pritonale
A. Guirat a,, M. Koubaa b, R. Mzali a, B. Abid a, S. Ellouz c, N.
Affes a, M. Ben Jemaa b, F. Frikha a, M. Ben Amar a, M.I. Beyrouti
a
Summary
The peritoneum is one of the locations outside the most common pulmonary
tuber- culosis. Peritoneal tuberculosis poses a public health problem in endemic regions of
the world. The phenomenon of migration, the increased use of immunosuppressive therapy
and the epi- demic of AIDS have contributed to a resurgence of this disease in regions where
it was previously controlled. The aim of this review is to expose the clinical, biologic end
radiologic futures of the peritoneal tuberculosis and to present the methods of diagnosis and
treatment. The diag- nosis of this disease is difcult and still remains a challenge because of
its insidious nature, the variability of presentation and limitations of available diagnostic
tests. The disease usually presents a picture of lymphocytic exudative ascites. There are
many complementary tests with variable sensitivities and specicities to conrm the diagnosis
of peritoneal tuberculosis. Isola- tion of mycobacteria by culture of ascitic uid or histological
examination of peritoneal biopsy ideally performed by laparoscopy remains the investigation
of choice. The role of PCR, ascitic adenosine deaminase, interferon gamma and the
radiometric BACTEC system can improve the diagnostic yield. An antituberculous treatment
with group 1 of the WHO for 6 months is sufcient in most cases.
2010 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
Rsum Le pritoine est lune des localisations extrapulmonaire les plus frquentes de
la tuberculose. La tuberculose pritonale pose un problme de sant publique dans certaines rgions endmiques du monde. Le phnomne de migration, lutilisation plus
frquente dimmunosuppresseurs et lpidmie du sida ont contribu une rapparition de
cette maladie dans les rgions o elle tait prcdemment contrle. Le but de cette mise
au point est de dgager les particularits cliniques, biologiques et radiologiques de la
tuberculose pritonale et de prsenter les moyens de diagnostic et les modalits
thrapeutiques. Le diagnostic de cette maladie est difcile et demeure un d en raison de
sa nature insidieuse, de la variabilit
0399-8320/$ see front matter 2010 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.gcb.2010.07.023
Peritoneal
61
tuberculosis
A. Guirat et61al.
Introduction
Described for the rst time in 1843 [1], peritoneal tuberculosis (PT) is due to the development of Kochs Bacillus
(KB) in the peritoneum. It is a disease that poses a public
health problem in endemic areas. The PT risks to evolve
into complications such as septicemia, acute intestinal
occlu- sion and infertility in women. The diagnosis of this
disease is a challenge; the absence of specic clinical
signs, the lack of paraclinical tests with high predictive
value and the pauci-bacillary nature of this disease make
the diagnosis of tuberculosis often based on histological
study of biopsies of peritoneum performed ideally by
laparoscopy.
Pathogenesis
Pathogenic agent
PT is caused by several species of Gram-positive bacteria
known as Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (M. tuberculosis, M. africanum, M. bovis, M. caprae, M. microti, M.
pinnipedi. . .). They are united in the same unit for genetic
similarities reasons. These bacteria belong to the family of
Mycobacteriacea and the order of Actinomycetales: they
are characterized by a thick wall, which is rich in fat giving
them special dyeing properties and a relative resistance to
many antiseptics (soda, acid, detergent. . .). The
mycobacterium is 2 to 5 microns in length, very sensitive
to heat but resis- tant to cold and desiccation, colored red
by the fuchsin, not discolored by nitric acid or alcohol
from where the nomina- tion of acid-fast bacillus-resistant
(AFB). It grows in aerobic strictly between 35 and 37 C on
enriched media including that of Lowenstein-Jensen [2].
Atypical mycobacteria are bacteria present in the
environment and usually non-pathogenic, but which may
be
responsible
for
peritoneal
mycobacteriosis.
Mycobacteruim avium complex is the most common cause
of mycobacterio- sis in immunosuppressed patients (AIDS)
[3,4].
Modes of contamination
Mycobacteria can infect the peritoneum by different
mech- anisms:
hematogenous spread of bacilli from a primary
pulmonary site of tuberculosis infection to secondary
foci such as
Epidemiology
In recent years, there has been an increase in the total
number of new cases of tuberculosis. The World Health
Orga- nization (WHO) has estimated that the number of
new cases of PT disease in 2007 was about 9.27 million.
This repre- sents an increase from 9.24 million cases in
2006, 8.3 million cases in 2000 and 6.6 million cases in
1990. Most of the esti- mated cases in 2007 were recorded
in Asia (55%) and Africa (31%), a small proportion of cases
in the Eastern Mediter- ranean Region (6%), the European
Region (5%) and Region of the Americas (3%). Of the 9.27
million new cases in 2007, an estimated 1.37 million (15%)
were suffering from AIDS, 79% of these patients came from
the African Region and 11% of the Southeast Asia Region
[17].
The PT remains a public health problem in endemic
areas. It represents 1% to 2% of all localizations of
Peritoneal
62
tuberculosis
tuberculosis [18] and
localizations [1921]. It
A. Guirat et62al.
31%
to
58%
of
abdominal
Contributing factors
Abdominal distension
Abdominal tenderness
Constipation
Diarrhea
Clinical Signs
Ascites
Abdominal pains
Isolated fever
Hepatomegaly
Splenomegaly
Frequency (%)
35100
[2932,35,38,43,47,95,103]
49100
[6,27,30,31,35,38,43,47,103]
5276.1
[27,29,30,35,38,43,47,50,103,104]
62.573 [38]
47.7 [22]
7.131 [32,35,3840,44,99]
4.71.4
[22,29,30,39,40,44,99,103]
2.38.2
[22,29,36,40,44,72,94,99,105,106]
2.34.3
[22,29,36,47,94,99,105]
CA-125 determination
Some authors have found that rates of CA-125 were high
in both serum and ascites in the majority of patients with
exudative ascites whatever the etiology [53,54]. Other
stud- ies have reported high levels of this marker in both
serum and ascites of patients with PT [55,56] and can
therefore be confused with ovarian carcinoma at an
advanced stage. Thus, a high rate of CA-125 should always
evoke PT in differ- ential diagnosis of ovarian carcinoma
mainly among women living in endemic areas. In addition,
the nding of a high CA125 in ascites rich in proteins in a woman may lead to a
false diagnosis of ovarian cancer and tuberculosis
underrate.
Moreover, several studies have noted that under
quadru- ple anti-tubercular drugs, after histological
conrmation of the PT diagnosis, the rate of CA-125
decreased gradually and returned to normal even after 1 to
2 months on average [22,53,54,56,57]. Thus, the
determination of CA-125 seems useful for evaluating the
therapeutic response of PT. This feature remains to be
conrmed by prospective studies.
Immunological tests
Tuberculin skin test (TST)
The TST is testing cell memory response to mycobacterial
antigens. It explores the capacity of memory lymphocytes in the patient after stimulation with these antigens,
to secrete cytokines (IFN-gamma especially) responsible
Table 2
Sensitivity, specicity and threshold values of ADA in some studies reported in the literature.
Series
Voigt et al. [107]
Bhargava et al. [108]
Ribera et al. [109]
Soliman et al. [110]
Sathar et al. [68]
Brant et al. [111]
Burgess et al. [60]
El Abkari et al. [24]
Riquelme et al. [63]
Sharma et al. [112]
Dewivedi [113]
Year
1989
1990
1991
1994
1995
1995
2001
2006
2006
2006
2008
Number
41
87
86
50
93
44
178
123
264
119
49
Sensitivity (%)
100
100
100
94.4
96
100
94
96
100
97
100
Specicity (%)
96
97
97
100
96
92
92
98
97
94
96.6
Value (U/L)
112.6
36
40
28
30
31
30
39
58
33
Radiological explorations
Abdominal ultrasounds
Abdominal ultrasound can evoke some signs in favor of PT
but cannot conrm diagnosis [74], and can follow the evolution under treatment. The ascites is the most frequent
ultrasound sign (45% to 100% of cases) [75,76]. It is free in
most cases and appears as trans-sonic images in which the
bowel loops oat. Ascites may take echogenicity related to
its exudative nature [77]. Sometimes, the ascites is partitioned, which is an argument in favor of its tubercular
origin and could predict technical difculties during diagnostic laparoscopy. Other signs suggestive of PT can be
highlighted, such as the thickening of the peritoneum, the
clumping of bowel loops side by side each other or to the
anterior abdominal wall [78], peritoneal nodules that are
the equivalent of granulations sitting at the visceral and
parietal peritoneum [75,78,79], adhesions visualized as
hypoechoic linear structures in thin strips and oating in
the tuberculosis peritoneal effusion [78,80], and the deep
lymph nodes often described as hypoechoic multiple
masses and sometimes conuent [75,76,80]. All these
echographic signs taken sep- arately have no diagnostic
value in the PT. On the contrary, their association should
suggest the diagnosis [75]. How- ever, the problem of
differential diagnosis with peritoneal carcinomatosis
remains.
Figure 1
Free high-density ascites with thickening of the
pari- etal peritoneum (arrow).
Percutaneous biopsy
Liver biopsy
A granulomatous liver disease may be associated with peritoneal involvement in varying proportions ranging from 25%
to 48% [38,72,95]. For some authors, liver biopsy must be
systematic face to any suspicion of PT, it would provide,
in some cases, the only evidence of tuberculous etiology
without resorting to invasive procedures [96].
Peritoneal biopsies
This is a new minimally invasive method with little or no
complications and could allow to obtain very good results.
Vardareli et al. [47] reported 19 cases of PT with ascites
(bro-adhesive forms excluded) of which 18 were diagnosed by peritoneal biopsy under percutaneous radiological
guidance. Thus, this method could avoid the drawbacks
of surgery, and preliminary results seem very encouraging.
Studies on a larger scale trials will help to conrm the
contri- bution of this new diagnostic procedure.
Treatment
The treatment of PT is medical. The delay in initiating
treat- ment may increase mortality. Chow et al. [35]
reported a signicant deterioration in clinical status of
over 80% of
Conclusion
PT remains a common public health problem in endemic
regions of the world. The diagnosis of this disease is
difcult
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Pr Ben Amar
Mohamed (benammed@yahoo.fr) and Mrs Ahlem Fendri
(ahlem fendri@yahoo.fr) for their precious help in the
translation of the manuscript and for her constant support.
References
[1] Dineen P, Homan WP, Grafe WR. Tuberculous peritonitis:
43 years experience in diagnosis and treatment. Ann Surg
1976;184:71722.
[2] Truffot-Pernot C. Mycobacterium tuberculosis. EMC biologie
clinique; 2005 [90050220].
[3] Huh JJ, Panther LA. Mycobacterium avium complex peritonitis in an AIDS patient. Scand J Infect Dis 2001;33:9368.
[4] Un-In Wu. Peritonitis due to Mycobacterium avium complex
in patients with AIDS: report of ve cases and review of the
literature. Int J Infect Dis 2009;13:28590.
[5] Mehta JB, Dutt A, Harvill L, Mathews KM. Epidemiology of
extrapulmonary tuberculosis. A comparative analysis with
pre-AIDS era. Chest 1991;99:11348.
[6] Singh MM, Bhargava AN, Jain KP. Tuberculous peritonitis. An evaluation of pathogenetic mechanisms, diagnostic
procedures and therapeutic measures. N Engl J Med
1969;281:10914.
[7] Lacut JY, Dupon M, Paty MC. Tuberculoses extrapulmonaires
: revue et possibilits de diminution des dlais
dintervention thrapeutique. Med Mal Infect 1995;25:304
20.
[8] Lazarus AA, Thilagar B. Abdominal tuberculosis. Dis Mon
2007;53:328.
[9] Rasheed S, Zinicola R, Watson D, Bajwa A, McDonald PJ.
Intra- abdominal
and
gastrointestinal tuberculosis.
Colorectal Dis
2007;9:77383.
[10] De Backer AI. Vascular involvement secondary to
tuberculosis of the abdomen. Abdom Imaging 2005;30:714
8.
[11] Marshall JB. Tuberculosis of the gastrointestinal tract and
peritoneum. Am J Gastroenterol 1993;88:98999.
[12] Tang LC, Cho HK, Wong Taam VC. Atypical presentation
of female genital tract tuberculosis. Eur J Obstet Gynecol
Reprod Biol 1984;17:3556