Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Steven E. Crow
VCA Sacramento Veterinary Referral Center and VCA Highlands Animal Hospital, CA, USA
__________________________________________________________________________________
*Correspondence: Steven E. Crow, DVM. VCA Sacramento Veterinary Referral Center, 9801 Old Winery Place, Sacramento, CA
95827, USA; Tel: (916) 362-3111
VCA Highlands Animal Hospital, Cancer Treatment Center, 3451 Elkhorn Blvd, North Highlands, CA 95660, USA; Tel: (916) 3322845; e-mail: steve.crow@vcamail.com
Key words: Chemoimmunotherapy, canine lymphoma tumor vaccines, canine lymphoma tumor vaccines, Canine
Abbreviations: complete response, (CR); monoclonal antibodies, (MAb); non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, (NHL); overall response rate,
(ORR); radioimmunoconjugates, (RICs); radioimmunotherapy, (RIT)
Received: 10 March 2008; electronically published: June 2008
Presented in the Theilen Tribute Symposium at UC Davis 31 st May- 1st June 2008.
Summary
Despite numerous clinical trials with drugs that reliably induce remission, cure for most cases of canine lymphoma
has continued to elude veterinary oncologists over the last 40 years. Results of various chemotherapy protocols are
remarkably similar, and no breakthrough drugs have been discovered. Although trials employing biological
response modifiers have been few in number and small in size, results of those studies are reason for optimism.
Favorable outcomes with tumor vaccines in canine lymphoma and monoclonal antibodies in human non-Hodgkin
lymphoma support the need for additional studies of immunotherapeutic interventions in this common and
devastating disease.
I. Introduction
Lymphoma is the most common neoplasm of the
canine hemolymphatic system. It represents approximately
4.5% of all canine neoplasms and 15% of all malignant
neoplasms. Canine lymphoma (CL) is usually rapidly
fatal, resulting in death within one to three months of
diagnosis (Squire et al, 1973). Temporary remission of
clinical signs without treatment is rare. Most CL cases are
high or intermediate histologic grade; less aggressive, lowgrade lymphoma represents less than 5% of all CL cases
reported (Squire et al, 1973; Schwartz 1988; Rosenberg
1991; Teske et al, 1994). Treatment of CL has been a topic
of great interest for veterinary oncologists for almost 40
years. The principal mode of medical management has
been chemotherapy (Rosenthal 1990; Jeglum and
Steplewski, 1996) but various attempts at immunotherapy
(biological response modification) have produced results
that rival or surpass outcomes with drugs alone (Table 1)
(Crow et al, 1977, 1996; Theilen et al, 1977; Weller et al,
1980; Jeglum et al, 1986, 1988; Jeglum and Steplewski,
1996).
Crow: Chemoimmunotherapy for canine lymphoma: tumor vaccines and monoclonal antibodies
maintained complete remission throughout induction were
then injected intramuscularly with either tumor vaccine,
consisting of acetoacetylated tumor cell wall proteins
suspended in complete Freund's complete adjuvant
(Figure 1), or placebo. Individual vaccine was produced
for each test dog from its own lymphoma cells. Tumor cell
membrane protein alterations and immunoadjuvant were
designed to abrogate blocking antibody formation and to
induce cell-mediated immunity (Harris and Copeland,
1964; Eilber and Morton, 1970; Smith and Adler, 1970;
Sjogren et al, 1971; Currie and Basham, 1972; Thompson
Table 1. Comparison of chemotherapy only to chemoimmunotherapy protocols for treatment of intermediate and high
grade canine lymphoma.
Reference/Study
Theilen et al, 1977
Crow et al, 1977
Weller et al, 1980
Jeglum et al, 1988
Jeglum, Steplewski 1996
Crow et al, 1996
Chemotherapy only
Median survival (days)
138 (n=47)
196 (n=9)
NR
180 (n=30)
NR
NR
Chemoimmunotherapy
Median survival (days)
341(n=20)
336 (n=12)
334 (n=32)
305 (n=56)
410 (n=215)
301 (n=85)
182
Figure 2. First remission duration for dogs receiving chemotherapy and placebo compared to dogs treated with chemotherapy and
autogenous tumor vaccine. Reproduced from Crow et al, 1977 with kind permission from Cancer.
Figure 3. Survival duration for dogs receiving chemotherapy and placebo compared to dogs treated with chemotherapy and autogenous
tumor vaccine. Reproduced from Crow et al, 1977 with kind permission from Cancer.
B. Human
Therapeutic options for human beings with NHL
have improved over the past 20 years, but almost all
patients with low-grade lymphoma and approximately
50% of patients with high-grade lymphoma eventually die
of their disease, regardless of the regimen used. Thus,
there is a continuing need for novel therapeutic options.
Two such strategies are unconjugated MAb and MAb
conjugated
to
radionuclides,
i.e.,
targeted
radioimmunotherapy (RIT).
183
Crow: Chemoimmunotherapy for canine lymphoma: tumor vaccines and monoclonal antibodies
184
II. Discussion
Many studies of combination chemotherapy
protocols for canine lymphoma have been reported in the
last four decades (Brick et al, 1968; Madewell, 1972;
MacEwen et al, 1981; Cotter, 1983; Brooks et al, 1987;
Carter et al, 1987; Cotter and Goldstein, 1987; MacEwen
et al, 1987; Rosales et al, 1988; Postorino et al, 1989;
Rogers, 1989; Greenlee et al, 1990; Rosenthal, 1990;
Rosenthal and MacEwen, 1990; Klein, 1991; Ogilvie et al,
1991; Price et al, 1991; Stone et al, 1991; Hahn et al,
1992; MacEwen et al, 1992; Novotney et al, 1992; Keller
et al, 1993; Vail, 1993; Dobson and Gorman, 1994;
Matherne et al, 1994; Moore et al, 1994; Ruslander et al,
1994), but little progress has been made in the overall
survival of dogs with this common malignancy. Novel
approaches, including whole body hyperthermia, halfbody radiation therapy (Laing et al, 1989), continuous low
dose chemotherapy (Rosenthal, 1990; Ogilvie et al, 1991),
bone marrow transplantation (Rosenthal, 1990) and
nutritional intervention (Williams, 1988) have been
attempted, but case accessions have been quite small in
most trials.
In retrospect, it is disappointing that evaluation of
CL/MAb 231 by independent investigators was not
completed prior to its commercial release. Questions of
binding sensitivity and specificity as well as retention of
efficacy with continued passage remained unanswered
when production was discontinued, presumably for
financial considerations.
Anecdotally, during the last 34 years I have
personally treated more than 1900 dogs with intermediate
or high grade multicentric lymphoma (stages III-V) using
various combination chemotherapy protocols. Only 18
dogs have been cured, i.e., survived longer than three
years and died free of any signs of lymphoma. All but two
of those dogs never relapsed after the initial induction
chemotherapy. Interestingly, seven of the 18 dogs were
treated with CL/MAb 231 and five dogs received either
Freund's complete adjuvant or autogenous tumor vaccine
injections.
Unfortunately, the search for magic potions (drugs)
has been surprisingly unfruitful over the last three decades.
The documented success of therapeutic monoclonal
antibodies for human non-Hodgkins lymphoma, clearly
highlights the opportunity that was missed by veterinary
oncologists. It is my hope that the new generation of
veterinary oncologists will look again at immune targeting
and immunomodulation as possible paths toward cure of
this devastating cancer.
References
Benjamini E, Scibienski RJ (1974) Immunochemical approaches
to immunotherapy. Proceedings XI International Cancer
Congress 1, 327-332.
Benjamini E, Theilen GH, Torten J, Fong S, Crow SE, Henness
AM (1976) The use of tumor vaccines in immunotherapy of
canine lymphosarcoma. Ann NY Acad Sci 277, 305-312.
Brick J0, Roenigk WS, and Wilson GP (1968) Chemotherapy of
malignant lymphoma in dogs and cats. J Am Vet Med Assoc
1153, 47-52.
185
Crow: Chemoimmunotherapy for canine lymphoma: tumor vaccines and monoclonal antibodies
Laing EJ, Fitzpatrick PJ, Binnington AG, Norris AM, Mosseri A,
Rider WD, Binnington AG, Baur A, Valli VE (1989) Halfbody radiotherapy in the treatment of canine lymphoma. J
Vet Intern Med 3, 102-108.
MacEwen EG, Brown NO, Patnaik AK, Hayes AA, Passe S
(1981) Cyclic combination chemotherapy of canine
lymphosarcoma. J Am Vet Med Assoc 178, 1178-1181.
MacEwen EG, Hayes AA, Matus RE, Kurzman I (1987)
Evaluation of some prognostic factors for advanced
multicentric lymphosarcoma in the dog: 147 cases (19781981). J Am Vet Med Assoc 190, 564-568.
MacEwen EG, Rosenthal RC, Fox LE, Loar AS, Kurzman ID
(1992) Evaluation of L-asparaginase: polyethylene glycol
conjugate versus native L-asparaginase combined with
chemotherapy: a randomized double-blind study in canine
lymphoma. J Vet Intern Med 6, 230-234.
Madewell, BR (1972) Chemotherapy for canine lymphosarcoma.
Am J Vet Res 36, 1525-1528.
Marcus R (2005) Use of 90Y-ibritumomab tiuxetan in nonHodgkin's lymphoma. Semin Oncol 32 (suppl), 36-43.
Matherne CM, Satterfield WC, Gasparini A, Tonetti M, Astroff
AB, Schmidt RD, Rowe LD, DeLoach JR (1994) Clinical
efficacy and toxicity of doxorubicin encapsulated in
glutaraldehyde-treated erythrocytes administered to dogs
with lymphosarcoma. Am J Vet Res 55, 847-853.
Moore AS, Ogilvie GK, Ruslander D, Rand WS, Cotter SM,
Getzy DM, LHeureux DA, Dennis RA (1994) Evaluation of
mitoxantrone for the treatment of lymphoma in dogs. J Am
Vet Med Assoc 205, 1903-1905.
Novotney CA, Page RL, Macy DW, Dewhirst MA, Ogilvie GK,
Withrow SJ, McEntee MC, Heidner GL, Allen SA, Thrall
DE (1992) Phase I evaluation of doxorubicin and wholebody hyperthermia in dogs with lymphoma. J Vet Intern
Med 6, 245-249.
Ogilvie GK, Vail DM, Klein MK, Powers BE, Dickinson K
(1991) Weekly administration of low-dose doxorubicin for
treatment of malignant lymphoma in dogs. J Am Vet Med
Assoc 198, 1762-1764.
Postorino NC, Susaneck SJ, Withrow SJ, Macy DW, Harris C
(1989) Single agent therapy with Adriamycin for canine
lymphosarcoma. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc 25, 221-225.
Prager MD, Baechtel FS (1973) Methods for modification of
cancer cells to enhance their antigenicity. Methods Cancer
Res 9, 339-400.
Price GS, Page RL, Fischer BM, Levine JF, Gerig TM (1991)
Efficacy and toxicity of doxorubicin/cyclophosphamide
maintenance
therapy in dogs with
multicentric
lymphosarcoma. J Vet Intern Med 5, 259-262.
Rogers KS (1989) L-asparaginase for treatment of lymphoid
neoplasia in dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc 194, 1626-1630.
Rosales C, Jeglum KA, Obrocka M, Steplewski Z (1988)
Cytolytic activity of murine anti-dog lymphoma monoclonal
antibodies with canine effector cells and complement. Cell
Immunol 115, 420-28.
Rosenberg MP, Matus RE, Patnaik AK (1991) Prognostic factors
in dogs with lymphoma and associated hypercalcemia. J Vet
Intern Med 5, 268-271.
Rosenthal RC (1990) The treatment of multicentric canine
lymphoma. Vet Clin North Am: Small Anim Pract 20,
1093-1104.
Rosenthal RC, MacEwen EG (1990) Treatment of lymphoma in
dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc 196, 774-781.
Ruslander D, Moore AS, Gliatto JM, LHeureux D, Cotter SM
(1994) Cytosine arabinoside as a single agent for the
induction of remission in canine lymphoma. J Vet Intern
Med 8, 299-301.
Steven E. Crow
186