Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
SUMMARY
This study was conducted during the period between December 2006 and
May 2007, to identify the major skin diseases of ruminants from the Oromia
region. A total of 584 cattle, 377 sheep and 295 goats of both sexes (811
females and 445 males) divided in young and adult animals (266 and 990
respectively) were examined. The overall prevalences for skin diseases were
15.41% (90 cases) in cattle and 25% (168 cases) in small ruminants, males
or young animals being significantly more susceptible in the 3 species studied.
In cattle, skin diseases were mainly due to ectoparasites (77/90 cases) which
infested males and young animals in a significantly privileged way whereas
ectoparasitism was responsible for only 44.6% cases in affected small ruminants
and was notably low in goats (prevalence: 7.78%). The main ectoparasites
identified in the Oromia area were ticks (Ambylomma, Boophilus and
Hyalomma) in cattle and in sheep (respective prevalences: 6.34% and
4.77%), lice (Damalina and Linognathus) (respective prevalences: 3.94% in
cattle and 6.40% in small ruminants) and Demodex at a lesser extend (1.88%
in cattle and 1.19% in small ruminants). Pediculosis preferentially affected
young ruminants (p < 0.05) and bovine crossbreeds (p < 0.001). Other skin
diseases were scarcely observed in cattle (prevalence: 2.20%) contrary to
the small ruminants (93/168 cases) in which the infection risk was increased
for males and young animals (particularly young sheep). While lumpy skin
disease was rare in cattle, the pox virus prevalences were relatively high in
sheep (10.34%) and in goats (12.88%). Contagious ecthyma was registered
in 1.79% small ruminants and the dermatophilosis prevalence remained low,
ranged from 0.53% in goats to 1.20% in cattle. This study demonstrates that
skin diseases are among the most important health constraints of ruminants
in the Oromia region leading to important economic losses and they urgently
require some control interventions.
RSUM
Partie II : Prvalences des maladies majeures de la peau chez les bovins,
ovins et caprins la clinique vtrinaire dAdama, rgion Oromie, Ethiopie
Cette tude a t mene entre Dcembre 2006 et Mai 2007 afin didentifier
les principales maladies cutanes des ruminants de la rgion dOromie. Pour
cela, 584 bovins, 377 ovins et 295 caprins des 2 sexes (811 femelles et 445
mles) diviss en jeunes et en adultes (266 et 990 respectivement) ont t
examins. La prvalence globale des maladies cutanes a t de 15.41 % (90
cas) chez les bovins et de 25 % chez les petits ruminants (168 cas), les mles
et les jeunes tant significativement les plus souvent affects dans les 3
espces tudies. Chez les bovins, les ectoparasites ont t principalement
responsables des lsions cutanes (77 cas sur 90) et ont infest de faon privilgie les mles et les jeunes, alors que les cas dectoparasitisme se sont
avrs moins frquents chez les petits ruminants (44.6 % des cas) et particulirement chez les chvres (prvalence : 7.78 %). Les principaux ectoparasites identifis dans la rgion dOromie ont t les tiques (Ambylomma,
Boophilus et Hyalomma) chez les bovins et les moutons (avec des prvalences de 6.34 % et 4.77 % respectivement), les poux (Damalina et
Linognathus) (3.94 % chez les bovins et 6.40 % chez les petits ruminants)
et Demodex un moindre degr (1.88 % chez les bovins et 1.19 % chez les
petits ruminants). La pdiculose a prfrentiellement affect les jeunes de
faon gnrale (p < 0.05) et les bovins issus de croisements (p < 0.001). Les
autres maladies cutanes nont t que ponctuellement rencontres chez les
bovins (prvalence : 2.20 %) contrairement aux petits ruminants (93 cas sur
168) chez lesquels le risque infectieux tait augment chez les mles et les
jeunes (surtout les jeunes moutons). Alors que la Lumpy skin disease a t
rarement diagnostique chez les bovins, la prvalence des pox virus sest
rvle relativement leve chez les ovins (10.34 %) et chez les caprins
(12.88 %). Les cas decthyma contagieux ont reprsent 1.76 % des cas observs
chez les petits ruminants et la prvalence de la dermatophilose est reste
relativement faible allant de 0.53 % chez les chvres 1.20 % chez les
bovins. Cette tude dmontre que les maladies cutanes constituent un problme majeur de sant chez les ruminants dans la rgion dOromie entranant
de lourdes pertes conomiques et quelles ncessitent urgemment la mise en
place de procdures de contrle.
Introduction
456
ANIMALS
Between December 2006 and May 2007, a total of 584
cattle, 377 sheep and 295 goats brought to the Adama
Veterinary clinic were subjected to detailed examination for
the presence of skin lesions and ectoparasites. The history,
breed and sex were recorded. The age of the animals was
estimated using the definition formulae described by AIELLO
and MAYS [1]. Animals were divided into two groups according to their age, namely young (less than or equal to 1 year
old) and adult animals (above 1 year old).
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
The data thus obtained was analyzed using Intercoded
STATA (Version 7) software. The Chi-square (X2) test was
used to assess differences in the prevalences of skin diseases
among breed, sex and age groups. In all cases, 95% confidence intervals and p < 0.05 were set for significance [2].
Results
PREVALENCES OF SKIN DISEASES IN CATTLE
The overall prevalence of skin diseases in cattle was
15.41% (90 cases): all animals were mono-infected and ectoparasites were responsible for 77 cases (13.18%) while 2.2%
(13 cases) was attributed to other skin diseases. The major
skin diseases occurring in cattle were infestation by ticks
(6.34%), pediculosis (3.94%), demodicosis (1.88%) and dermatophilosis (1.20%) in order of decreased prevalence
(Table I). No case of parafilariasis was diagnosed within the
cattle. The major identified species were Boophilus,
Amblyomma and Hyalomma species and Damalina bovis and
Linognathus spp for ticks and lice infestations respectively.
The common infestation sites of Damalina bovis were the
shoulder, neck, sides and back while infestation with
Revue Md. Vt., 2008, 159, 8-9, 455 - 461
Total
Males
(n = 225)
Ectoparasites
13.18 (77) 17.78 (40)
Psoroptes
0.68 (4)
1.78 (4)
Sarcoptes
0.34 (2)
0.89 (2)
Demodex
1.88 (11)
2.22 (5)
Ticks
6.34 (37) 8.00 (18)
Pediculosis
3.94 (23) 4.89 (11)
Others
2.20 (13)
3.56 (8)
Dermatophilosis
1.20 (7)
2.67 (6)
Lumpy skin disease 0.68 (4)
0.89 (2)
Photosensitization 0.34 (2)
0.00 (0)
Overall
15.41 (90) 21.33 (48)
457
Sex
Females
p
Young
(n = 359)
(n = 94)
10.31 (37) < 0.05 21.28 (20)
0.00 (0)
2.13 (2)
0.00 (0)
1.06 (1)
1.67 (6)
NS
1.06 (1)
5.29 (19) NS
7.45 (7)
3.34 (12) NS
9.57 (9)
1.39 (5)
NS
4.26 (4)
0.28 (1)
NS
3.19 (3)
0.56 (2)
0.00 (0)
0.56 (2)
1.06 (1)
11.70 (42) < 0.01 25.33 (24)
Age
Adult
P
(n = 490)
11.63 (57) < 0.05
0.41 (2)
0.20 (1)
2.04 (10) NS
6.12 (30) NS
2.86 (14) < 0.05
1.84 (9) NS
0.82 (4) NS
0.82 (4)
0.20 (1)
13.47 (66) < 0.01
Cross
(n = 60)
15.00 (9)
1.61 (1)
1.61 (1)
0.00 (0)
0.00 (0)
11.29 (7)
0.00 (0)
0.00 (0)
0.00 (0)
0.00 (0)
15.00 (9)
Breed
Local
P
(n = 524)
12.98 (68) NS
0.52 (3)
0.19 (1)
2.11 (11) NS
7.09 (37) NS
3.07 (16) < 0.001
2.48 (13) NS
1.34 (7) NS
0.77 (4)
0.38 (2)
15.46 (81) NS
458
Total
Ectoparasites
13.79 (52)
Psoroptes
1.06 (4)
Demodex
1.33 (5)
Ticks
4.77 (18)
Pediculosis
6.63 (25)
Others
12.73 (48)
Dermatophilosis
0.53 (2)
Pox virus disease 10.34 (39)
Contagious ecthyma 1.86 (7)
Overall
26.33 (100)
often diagnosed in young goats (p < 0.10) (Table III) and this
tendency was confirmed at the level of the whole population:
indeed, the proportion of young diseased animals was significantly higher (X2 = 5.52, p < 0.05) (Table IV). No effect of
sex or age on the contagious ecthyma prevalence in the overall
population of small ruminants was detected (Table IV).
Sex
Males (n = 117) Females (n = 260)
16.24 (19)
12.69 (33)
1.70 (2)
0.77 (2)
1.71 (2)
1.15 (3)
5.13 (6)
4.62 (12)
7.69 (9)
6.15 (16)
16.24 (19)
11.15 (29)
0.85 (1)
0.38 (1)
12.82 (15)
9.23 (24)
2.56 (3)
1.54 (4)
32.48 (38)
23.85 (62)
p
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
Young (n = 85)
18.82 (16)
1.18 (1)
1.18 (1)
5.88 (5)
10.59 (9)
20.00 (17)
1.18 (1)
15.29 (13)
3.53 (3)
38.82 (33)
Age
Adult (n = 292)
P
12.33 (36)
NS
1.03 (3)
1.37 (4)
4.45 (13)
NS
5.48 (16)
NS
10.62 (31)
< 0.05
0.34 (1)
8.90 (26)
NS
1.37 (4)
22.95 (67)
< 0.01
Skin diseases
Ectoparasites
Psoroptes
Demodex
Pediculosis
Others
Dermatophilosis
Pox virus disease
Contagious ecthyma
Overall
Total
7.78 (23)
0.68 (2)
1.02 (3)
6.10 (18)
15.25 (45)
0.68 (2)
12.88 (38)
1.69 (5)
23.05 (68)
Sex
Males (n = 103) Females (n = 192)
7.77 (8)
7.81 (15)
0.00 (0)
1.04 (2)
1.94 (2)
0.52 (1)
5.83 (6)
6.25 (12)
20.39 (21)
12.50 (24)
1.94 (2)
0.00 (0)
16.50 (17)
10.94 (21)
1.94 (2)
1.56 (3)
28.16 (29)
20.31 (39)
p
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
Young (n = 87)
10.34 (9)
0.00 (0)
0.00 (0)
10.34 (9)
21.84 (19)
1.16 (1)
18.60 (16)
2.33 (2)
32.18 (28)
Age
Adult (n = 208)
6.73 (14)
0.96 (2)
1.44 (3)
4.32 (9)
12.5 (26)
0.48 (1)
10.53 (22)
1.44 (3)
19.23 (40)
P
NS
< 0.10
< 0.10
< 0.10
< 0.05
Skin diseases
Total
Ectoparasites
11.16 (75)
Psoroptes
0.89 (6)
Demodex
1.19 (8)
Ticks
2.68 (18)
Pediculosis
6.40 (43)
Others
13.84 (93)
Dermatophilosis
0.60 (4)
Pox virus disease 11.46 (77)
Contagious ecthyma 7.79 (12)
Overall
25.00 (168)
Sex
Males (n = 220) Females (n = 452) p
12.27 (27)
10.62 (48)
NS
0.91 (2)
0.88 (4)
NS
1.82 (4)
0.88 (4)
NS
2.72 (6)
2.65 (12)
NS
6.82 (15)
6.19 (28)
NS
18.18 (40)
11.73 (53)
< 0.05
1.36 (3)
0.22 (1)
14.55 (32)
9.96 (45)
< 0.1
2.27 (5)
1.42 (7)
NS
30.45 (67)
22.35 (101)
< 0.05
Age
Young (n = 172) Adult (n = 500)
14.53 (25)
11.11 (50)
0.58 (1)
1.00 (5)
0.58 (1)
1.40 (7)
2.91 (5)
2.60 (13)
10.47 (18)
5.00 (25)
20.93 (36)
11.40 (57)
1.16 (2)
0.40 (2)
16.86 (29)
9.60 (48)
2.91 (5)
1.40 (7)
35.47 (61)
21.40 (107)
P
NS
NS
NS
NS
< 0.05
< 0.01
< 0.05
NS
< 0.001
Discussion
This study revealed that skin diseases caused by parasites,
bacteria and viruses were common in and around Adama
town in ruminants: their overall prevalences were 15.41%,
26.33% and 23.05% in cattle, sheep and goats respectively.
These relative high frequencies would be associated with
nutritional and climatic stress following repeated drought. As
different flocks of animals come in close contact at available
communal watering and grazing sites (contact points) because
of the feed scarcity, the establishment and spread of ectoparasite infestations and bacterial / viral infections were favoured.
The prevailing poor veterinary services, improper application
of acaricides by non-professionals could also amplified this
endemic situation. Furthermore, young animals were significantly more frequently affected than adults (p < 0.01 in cattle
and in sheep, p < 0.05 in goats and p < 0.001 in the overall
small ruminants) probably because of their low acquired
resistance compared to adults. A significant association with
sex was also observed, the prevalence being higher in males than
in females in cattle (p < 0.01) and in small ruminants (p < 0.05).
This observation requires further study in order to explain
the sex differences in the prevalence of different skin diseases.
By contrast, local and cross breeds which share the same
environment seemed to be equally affected by skin diseases,
suggesting that local breeds have not developed a specific
genetic resistance towards skin diseases.
Among skin diseases, the prevalence of ectoparasite infestations in the present study was important in cattle and sheep
(13.18% and 13.80% respectively) contrary to goats
(7.80%). Furthermore, male and young cows presented a
significantly higher risk for ectoparasites than females and
adults. Although higher ectoparasite prevalences were observed
in the Wolaita Soddo area in small ruminants (68.69% and
28.43% in sheep and goats respectively), it was also reported
that ectoparasitism was significantly more frequent in sheep
than in goats [27]. But, the higher susceptibility of females,
especially of female sheep towards ectoparasites evidenced
in the Southern Ethiopia [27] was not confirmed here, in the
Oromia region.
The main ectoparasites were ticks (Ambylomma,
Hyalomma and Boophilus species) in cattle and in sheep
(respective prevalences: 6.34% and 4.77%) and lice
(Damalina bovis, Damalina ovis, Damalina caprae and
Linognathus spp) in cows and in small ruminants (3.94% in
cattle, 6.63% in sheep and 6.10% in goats). The main tick
attachment sites were ventral abdomen, sternum, under the
tail, scrotum in males and udder in females and the tick
infestation prevalence was not significantly influenced by
sex, age or breed. MOREL [16] reported the presence of
these three genera of ticks in Ethiopian sheep. The same ticks
and lice species have been identified in the previous study
conducted in the Wolaita Soddo region [27] except that
Rhipicephalus genus was more abundant and the Hyalomma
genus was scarcely observed. This might be difficult to
explain but we assume that it could be due to agro-ecological
difference in tick species distribution between Wolaita
Soddo and the Oromia area. Moreover, small ruminants from
the Southern Ethiopia were highly infested by ticks (31.78%
and 18.63% in sheep and goats respectively) compared to
Revue Md. Vt., 2008, 159, 8-9, 455 - 461
459
sheep (4.77%) and goats (0%) in the present study. The relatively low prevalence rate of tick infestation might be due to
the dry season period during which the study was conducted
whereas humidity and prolonged sunlight favour the survival
and reproduction of ticks in low land areas [18]. However,
this result is relatively greater than that reported by HAFFIZE
[13] (1.71% in goats and 0.93% in sheep). Tick infestation
was not encountered in goats during this study. Another notable
difference between the Wolaita Soddo and Oromia regions
was noticed for pediculosis: a high prevalence was noticed in
sheep (25.70%) and this disease was not diagnosed in goats
from the mountainous area whereas similar infestation rates
were observed in sheep and goats in the present study
(6.63% and 6.10% respectively). This discrepancy might be
attributed due to the higher small ruminants density in
Wolaita Soddo than in the present study site. However, the
pediculosis prevalences observed in the present study were
in agreement with previous reports of HAFFIZE [13] and
REGASA [20]. The risk for this skin disease was significantly increased in cattle crossbreeds (p < 0.001) and in
young ruminants (in cattle and in small ruminants, p < 0.05).
By contrast, no significant sexual predisposition was evidenced
as previously reported [20, 27]. It is admitted that tick infestation predisposes to other skin diseases. For example, it was
proved that Ambylomma variegatum efficiently transmitted
Dermatophilus congolensis in cattle [6].
Demodicosis was registered at prevalence rates of 1.88%
in cattle, 1.33% in sheep and 1.02% in goats. The demodicosis
prevalences previously reported in cattle ranged from 0.42%
in the Nekemte region [20] to 1.63% in the Wolaita Soddo
region [10]. In our previous report in Wolaita Soddo, 0.98%
prevalence of mange in goats and 0% in sheep were reported
[27]. The frequencies of Demodex in sheep and goats were
0.80% and 1.37% respectively in the central Ethiopia [13],
0.84% and 0.99% in the Eastern Ethiopia [11], 0.4% and
0.81% in Nigeria [12]. No significant effect of sex, breed and
age on the demodicosis prevalences in cattle and in small
ruminants was observed in the present study in accordance
with the works of CHALACHEW [10] and of HAFFIZE
[13]. Only few cases of sarcoptic (2 cases in cows) and psoroptic manges (4 in cattle and 6 in the whole small ruminant
population) were diagnosed in the present study and the prevalence of the psoroptic mange seemed to be independent of
sex or of age in the overall small ruminants. These findings
are relatively similar to that reported by others [10, 13, 19].
As far as bacterial, viral and endoparasite infections are
concerned, the main skin diseases were the dermatophilosis
in the 3 species studied (the prevalences were 1.20%, 0.53%
and 0.68% in cattle, sheep and goats respectively), the contagious ecthyma (1.79%, 12 cases) and the pox virus disease
(11.46%, 77 cases) in small ruminants whereas the lumpy
skin disease was rarely observed in cattle (0.68%, 4 cases).
No documented report of lumpy skin disease is available
except the only report of BISHAWIRED [5] which showed a
prevalence rate of 27.91% in and around Wolliso (Southwest
Oromia). No parafilariosis was diagnosed in all ruminants in
this study and meanwhile there is no documented report yet
on parafilariosis of cattle in Ethiopia. Besides, 2 cases of
photosensitization which could be associated with the extreme
sun radiation in the area were also observed in cattle in the
460
References
1. - AIELLO S.E., MAYS A.: The Merk veterinary manual, 8th ed. Merck
and Co, Inc, White house station, NJ, USA, 1998, pp. 131-133.
2. - AGRAWA B.L.: Basic statistics, 3rd ed., B.L. AGRAWAL (ed.), New
age Int. 1(p) limited publications, 1996.
3. - AMARE D.: Streptothricosis and its prevalence in cattle in and
around Bahir Dar. DVM Thesis, Addis Ababa University, Faculty
Veterinary Medicine. Debre Zeit, Ethiopia, 1985.
4. - BERHANU D., WOLEMESKEL M.: Bovine dermatophilosis and its
influencing factor in central Ethiopia. J. Vet. Med., 1999, 46, 593 597.
5. - BISHAWIRED S.: Out break of lumpy skin disease in and around
Wolliso. DVM Thesis. Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Addis Ababa
University, Debre Zeit, Ethiopia, 1991.
6. - BUXTON A., FRASER G.: Animal microbiology. Black well scientific publications Ltd Edinburgh. 1987, pp. 698.
7. - CARTER G.R.: Diagnostic procedures in veterinary bacteriology and
mycology, 4th ed., C.C. THOMAS (ed.), Illinois, USA. 1984, pp. 431-436.
8. - CARTON W.W., Mc-GAVIN M.D.: Special veterinary pathology, 2nd
ed., L.L. DUNCAN (ed.), Mosby, 1995, pp. 89-101.
9. - CSA: Central Statistical Authority, Federal democratic Republic of
Ethiopia, Central Statistical investigatory, Statistical abstract, 2001.
10. - CHALACHEW N.: Study on skin diseases in cattle, sheep and goat
in and around Wolayta Soddo, Southern Ethiopia. DVM Thesis,
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Addis Ababa University, Debre
Zeit, Ethiopia, 2001.
11. - GASHEW J.: Preliminary survey of mange mites in black head
Ogaden Sheep, goats and Pigs in the administrative region of
Hararghe. DVM Thesis, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Addis
Ababa University, Debre Zeit, Ethiopia, 1986.
12. - GEORGE J.B.O., OGUNLEYE J., OTABO S., ADEDIMINIYI B.:
Louse and mange infestations in domestic animals in Northern
Nigeria. Trop. Anim. Hlth. Prod., 1992, 24 (2), 121-124.
13. - HAFFIZE M.: Study on skin disease of small ruminants in central
Ethiopia. DVM Thesis, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Addis
Ababa University, Debre Zeit, Ethiopia, 2001.
14. - JONES T.C., HUNT R.D., KING N.W.: Veterinary pathology, 6th
ed., WILLIAMS and WILKINS (eds), Baltimore, Maryland, USA,
1997, pp. 817-872.
15. - KASSA B., BISRAT M., ASEGEDECH S., AFRICA J.: Control of
Ekeke skin defects in sheep by insecticides and shearing. EVA
proceeding 12th annual conference. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 1998,
pp.104-109.
16. - MOREL P.C.: Study on Ethiopian ticks (Acarida, Ixodida) Republic
of France, ministry of Foreign Affairs, French Veterinary Mission,
Qddis Ababa, 1980, pp.332.
17. - NMSA: National Metrology service Agency, Addis Ababa Ethiopia
of control of sheep and Goat skin diseases for improved for improved quality of hides and skin, 13-14 Feb, 2000, FAO, Addis Ababa.
18. - PANGUI L.J.: Mange in domestic animals and methods of control.
Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 1994, 13 (4), 1227-1243.
19. - RADOSTITIS O.M., BLOOD D.C., GRAY C.C.: Veterinary
Medicine. A textbook of the diseases of cattle of cattle, sheep, pigs, goats
and Horses, 8th ed., BAILLIERE, TINDALL and CASSELL (eds),
Ltd 24-28 oval road, London NW 17 DX, England, 1994, pp. 534-560.
20. - REGASA C.: Preliminary study on major skin diseases of cattle
coming to Nekemte Veterinary Clinic, Western Ethiopia. DVM
Thesis, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Addis Ababa University,
Debre Zeit, Ethiopia, 2003.
Revue Md. Vt., 2008, 159, 8-9, 455 - 461
461
26. - WOLDEMESKEL M.: Dermatophilosis: A threat to livestock production in Ethiopia. Dtsch. Tierazti. Wschr., 2000, 107, 144-146.