Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Research and Development Division, Nippon Shokubai Co., Ltd., 5-8, Nishi Otabi-cho, Suita, Osaka 564-8512, Japan
b
Department of Chemical Technology and Heterogeneous Catalysis, University of Technology, RWTH Aachen,
Worringerweg 1, D-52074, Aachen, Germany
Received 6 July 1998; received in revised form 24 September 1998; accepted 5 November 1998
Abstract
A statistical survey of industrial processes using solid acidbase catalysts is presented. The number of processes such as
alkylation, isomerization, amination, cracking, etherication, etc., and the catalysts such as zeolites, oxides, complex oxides,
phosphates, ion-exchange resins, clays, etc., are 127 and 180, respectively. The classication of the types of catalysts into solid
acid, solid base, and solid acidbase bifunctional catalysts gives the numbers as 103, 10 and 14, respectively. Some signicant
examples are described more in detail. On the basis of the survey, the future trend of solid acidbase catalysis and the
fundamental research promising for industrial success are discussed. # 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Industrial processes; Solid acid catalyst; Solid base catalyst; Solid acidbase bifunctional catalyst
1. Introduction
More than three hundreds of solid acids and bases
have been developed for the last 40 years. The surface
properties and the structures have been claried by
newly developed measurement methods using modern
instruments and highly sophisticated techniques. The
characterized solid acids and bases have been applied
as catalysts for various reactions, the role of acidbase
properties for catalytic activities and selectivities
being studied extensively. Now, solid acidbase catalysis is one of the economically and ecologically
important elds in catalysis. The solid acid and base
catalysts have many advantages over liquid Brnstedand Lewis-acid and base catalysts. They are non*Corresponding author.
1
Also corresponding author.
0926-860X/99/$ see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S0926-860X(98)00397-4
400
18
15
13
10
9
8
7
7
6
5
4
4
3
2
1
15
127
Table 2
Types of catalysts used in industrial processes
Zeolites
Oxides, complex oxides
Ion-exchange resins
Phosphates
Solid acids (not specified)
Clays
Immobilized enzymes
Sulfate, carbonate
Sulfonated polysiloxanes
Total
74
54
16
16
7
4
3
3
3
180
74
31
28
7
4
2
2
54
11
9
Phosphates
SrHPO4, LaHPO4, Li3PO4, AlB phosphate, LaPO4, FePO4
Solid phosphoric acid
SAPO-11, SAPO-34
CsBaPO/SiO2
Ba or Ca salt phosphate
H3PO4aniline salt/SiO2
16
7
4
2
1
1
1
Ion-exchange resins
Solid acids (not specified)
16
7
7
6
4
3
3
2
2
2
1
1
3
Clays
Kaolin, pillared clay, bentonite, montmorillonite
Immobilized enzymes
Asparatase, nitrilase, amylase
3
3
401
Table 4
Number of solid acid, base and acidbase bifunctional catalysts in
industrial processes
Solid acid catalysts
Solid base catalysts
Solid acidbase bifunctional catalysts
103
10
14
Total
127
402
Table 5
Alkylation processes
S.No. Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
MobilBadger
UOP/Lummus
CDTECH
ABB Lummus/Unocal/UOP
MobilBadger/Raytheon
b-zeolite
Acid zeolite catalytic distillation
Enichem
CDTECH
Mordenite
Y-zeolite
Acid zeolite catalytic distillation
DOW Chemicals
Lummus
CDTECH Catstill-technology
Three-dimensional dealuminated
mordenite
Table 5 (Continued )
S.No.
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
Transalkylation reactor
diisopropylbenzenebenzene
Dealuminated mordenite
DOW/Kellog
UOP CEPSA, DETAL-technology 1995, 100 000 t/y [73,74], Petresa Petroquimica
at Becancour, Canada 100 000 t/y [76], Quimica
Venoco at Guacara, Venezuela
H-mordenite
Shape selective zeolite combined
with separation
Catalytica
Kureha/NKK/Chiyoda
Zeolite
Rutgerswerke AG
(p) [200]
Dealuminated H-mordenite
DOW Chemicals
Paschim/IPCL
403
404
Table 5 (Continued )
S.No.
9
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
MgO
General Electric
BASF AG
FeVO/SiO2
Asahi Chem.
11
12
K/KOH/Al2O3
Sumitomo Chemical
13
CF3SO3H/SiO2
BF3/g-Al2O3
SbF5/SiO2
Sulfated ZrO2
Solid acid (alkylene catalyst)
fluidized bed
Catalytica/Conoco/Neste Oy
Chevron/CDTECH
Orient Catalyst
UOP
10
Table 6
Isomerization processes
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, Scale
Xylene isomerization!p-xylene
H-ZSM-5
Mobil Oil
C8 aromatic mixture!p-xylene
Pentasil zeolite
Acid zeolite 1-210
Xyclofining-process
UOP ISOMAR technology
Zeolite
JFP/Chevron ELUXYL-process
Toray
H-mordenite
Fe/Mn/sulfated ZrO2
Zeolite
Zeolite
Zeolite
Zeolite
UOP BUTAMER-process,
PENEX-process
Sun Refining
BP-Chemicals, c4-isomer
Huntsman ISOTEX-process
UCC TIP-process
Shell HYSOMER-process
n-C4 ! i-C4
n-C4 0 ! i-C4 0
IFP
Shell/Layondell/CDTECH/Zeolyst
SNAM
Nippon Petrochemical/Nippon Oil
C4 0 ; C5 0 ! i-C4 0 ; i-C5 0
H-ZSM-5
H-ZSM-5 fluidized bed
Zeolite
Mobil/BP/Kellog ISOFIN-process
Mobil/Raytheon MOI-process
Lyondell Petrochemical, ISOM
Plus-process
405
S.No.
406
Table 6 (Continued )
S.No.
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, Scale
Zeolite
Zeolite
Phillips Petrochemical/Texas
Olefins SKIP-process
UOP, PENTESOM-process,
BUTESOM-process
PEMEX
Zeolite
JFP ISO-4-process
Zeolite LPI-100TM
Acid solid
UOP PAR-ISOM-process
Shell
H ion-exchange resin
Exxon
1986 [3]
Na/NaOH/g-Al2O3
Sumitomo Chemical
[6]
Na/NaOH/g-Al2O3
Sumitomo Chemical
[6]
10
Na/NaOH/Al2O3
Sumitomo Chemical
11
K2O/Al2O3
Shell
[137]
12
Li3PO4
ARCO
Zeolite
Table 6 (Continued )
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, Scale
13
Pentasil zeolite
BASF AG
14
SAPO 11
High siliceous pentasil zeolite
Ta-alkoxide/SiO2
UCC
Sumitomo Chemical
Mitsubishi Chemical
15
Pt/Y-zeolite
IdemitsuKosan
S.No.
407
408
Table 7
Dehydration and condensation processes
S.No.
Company
Year, scale
Al2O3
Sulfonic acid resin
Petrobrass
UOP
1980 [19,31]
1981 [3]
DavyMcKee
CsBaPO/SiO2
Nippon Shokubai
ZrO2NaOH
Sumitomo
1986 [33,34]
Nb2O5nH2O
Sumitomo
1987 [35,36]
ZrO2KOH
Koei Chemical
H3PO4aniline salt/SiO2
Nippon Shokubai
H2 O
EtOH !
C2 H4
t-BuOH !H2 O i-C04
Catalyst
1
2
Process
Table 7 (Continued )
S.No.
Process
Company
Year, scale
Mercapto-functionalized
sulfonated polysiloxane
Ion-exchange resin
Ion-exchange resin
Ion-exchange resin
Degussa AG
Chiyoda
Bayer AG
DOW/Kellog
10
DSM-Stamicarbon
11
Degussa AG
[144]
12
Degussa AG
[145,146,150]
** Isobutyraldehyde!diisopropyl
ketone
ZrO2
Chisso
14
** Isobutanol!diisopropyl ketone
ZrO2, ZrO2K2O
Chisso
15
** n-Butanoln-butyraldehyde
!di-n-propyl ketone
ZrO2MgO
Chisso
Air Products
1987 [3,6]
Bayer AG
Deutsche Texaco
[147]
[148]
Pentasil zeolite
Asahi Chemical
[149]
16
17
18
409
13
Catalyst
410
Table 8
Amination processes
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
2MeOHNH3!Me2NH, MeNH2
Nitto
Du Pont
Air Products
Cu, Ni/SiO2Al2O3
Kao
1989 [1]
Air Products
AlSi zeolite
Berol/Nobel
USS
Immobilized asparatase
Tanabe Pharmaceutical,
Mitsubishi Petrochem.
S.No.
S.No.
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
Modified SiO2Al2O3modified
ZSM-5
Koei Chem.
Modified SiO2Al2O3modified
ZSM-5
Koei Chem.
Armor polymer
Nepera
Degussa AG
India [6]
USA [6]
Germany [6]
BASF AG
Pentasil zeolite
Table 8 (Continued )
411
412
Table 9
Cracking processes
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
FCC-processes
e.g. SiO2Al2O3/US-Y
Partially dealuminated Y type
zeolite in SiO2Al2O3
Novel Y/SiO2Al2O3
Ultrastable Y containing RE
oxides and SiO2
Cosmo
China Petro
1990 [2]
1993 [4]
Heavy oil
MgOAl2O3-zeolite
Magna-Cat
Nippon Oil
Valero/Kellog
1990 [2]
Corpus Christi, TX [152]
Heavy fractions
Calcined kaolin
Engelhard/Ashland
Ashland/Davison
Pentasil zeolite
China Petro
Total/IFP
Proprietary
China Petro
H-ZSM-5
Mobil
1986 [3]
S.No.
Table 10
Etherification processes
S.No.
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
i-C04
Ion-exchange resin
IFP
ARCO
SNAM/Ecofuel
MeOH ! MTBE
Ion-exchange resin
SNAM
1996 [29]
Ion-exchange resin
SNAM/Ecofuel
1993 [38]
Ion-exchange resin
IFP/ELF
ANIC/SNAM
Exxon
Neste Oy/Bechtel
DavyMcKee
Ion-exchange resin
Erdoelchemie/Lurgi
2MeOH ! MeOMeH2O
Al2O3
Mobil
AlBPO
Ube
1978 [2]
BP
(p) [5]
Hydrotalcite Mg6Al2O8(OH)2,
ROHfatty alcohols, nnarrow
molecular weight range
Ba or Ca salt/phosphate
Henkel
UCC
LaPO4
Shell
10
Chevron/Neste Oy (Alberta
Envirofuels)
Sabic/Shell (SADAT)
Lummus Crest
CDTECH
413
414
Table 11
Company
Year, scale
ZSM-5
Mobil
[3]
BPUOP Cyclar-process
Zeolitepromoter
UOP
1983 [3]
Metallosilicate
Platforming, Rheniforming,
e.g. Chevron
UOP
R-132 catalyst
Pt L-zeolite
UOP LLR-platforming
Chevron Chem. AROMAX-process
Fe-VIb/zeolite
Idemitsu
1982 [1]
ZSM-5
Mobil
[3]
Lub dewaxing
Wax oilsH2!lower molecular
wt. hydrocarbons
ZSM-5
Zeolite
Mobil
BASF
Naphtha!aromatics
1990 [3]
Catalyst
Table 12
Hydration processes
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
C=CH2O ! EtOH
i-C4' ! t-BuOH
Ion-exchange resin
Sulfonic acid resin
Mitsui Petrochem.
UOP/huels
[1]
1981 [3]
Asahi Chem.
Degussa AG
Acid catalyst
H-ZSM-5
Air Products/DOE
Mobil
(p) [161]
0.5 BPD [162]
MgO
MnO2
Distillers
Reynolds Tobacco
[176]
[177]
Nitrilase immobilized by
polyacrylamide gel into a particle
Nitto
S.No.
415
416
Table 13
Esterification processes
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
Ion-exchange resin
DavyMcKee
Mercapto-functionalized
sulfonated polysiloxane
Degussa AG
Ion-exchange resin
ZSM-5
Mobil MTG-process
Modified ZSM-5
Mobil MTO-process
UOP
1988 [3]
Zeolite
Mobil MOGD-process
[179]
Olefins of MTO!gasoline
Zeolite
Mobil MOG-process
[180]
Tonen
1988 [2]
China Petro
1993 [4]
C03 ! polypropylene
TiO2MgO
Process
3
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
Pentasil zeolite
Mossgas Refinery/Sudchemie
Cyclodimerization Zn
powder/Fe(NO)2Cl liquid
phase, slurry
Dehydrogenation Pd/MgO
gasphase, fixed bed
Cyclodimerization Cu-ZSM-5
zeolite
DOW Chemicals
(p) [184]
Ni on Al2O3 (ALON)
H3PO4/SiO2
Ni-heterogeneous Ziegler-type
catalyst
[185]
UOP Catpoly-process
LS/UOP Octol-process
HU
[186]
Table 13 (Continued )
417
418
Table 14
Disproportionation processes
Process
Company
Year, scale
Zeolite
SiO2-modified ZSM-5
ZSM-5
UOP
Taiwan Styrene
Mobil MSTDP process
1988 [3]
1987, 3000 t/y [18,23]
1989 [12]
19881990 pilot plant [187], Anic-Refinery at
Gela, Italy
Since 1990, >6 units, 1991, 14 000 BPSD [188]
1992, Exxon in Baytown [188], Koch-Refinery
Corpus Christi, Texas
1992 [188], Cepsa at Algericas, Spain
Reliance Industry, India [188]
Mitsubishi Oil [188] at Mizushima, Japan
Zeolite
UOP
1988 [3]
Zeolite
BP
Acid catalyst
ZrO2Cr2O3
Zeolite
Mitsubishi Chem.
Crossfield-Unilever
Zeolite
Crossfield-Unilever
Al2(SO4)3/SiO2
Boron pentasil zeolite
Heterogeneous acid catalyst
Solid acid
SiO2Al2O3
Sumitomo
ANIC/SNAM/ENI
UOP
IFP
SNAM
COH2!middle distillates
Catalyst
Table 15
Miscellaneous processes
S.No.
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
Ion-exchange resin
TiO2SiO2
TS-1 zeolite
Montedipe
Montedipe
Enichem
Solid acid
Olin Eiazzi
Al2O3
Tokuyama Soda
CH3Cl ! gasoline
BP-chemicals
1985 [5]
NO NH3 ! N2 H2O
Zeolite
Aluminosilicate zeolite
WVTiO2
Engelhard
Degussa AG/Lurgi/Lentjes
DeNOx-processes
Cs-zeolite
Merck
1996 [27,144]
Philips Petroleum
419
Alkali-oxide on alumina,
Elf-Atochem
transition metal oxides
Alkali on g-Al2O3 IKT-31-1 Orgsintez-Volga Industrial
catalyst
Conglomerate
420
S.No.
Process
Catalyst
Company
Year, scale
10
DSM
(p) [193]
11
Fe-ZSM-5
Monsanto-Boreskov Institut
12
Pt/Zn-ZSM-5
BP/Mobil
Pilot [195]
13
FePO4
TIT
[196]
14
Immobilized amylase
1988 [2]
15
H-beta-zeolite
Rhone-Poulenc
Table 15 (Continued )
421
422
423
424
Secondary mercaptans are produced from iso-olens and H2S over solid acid catalysts such as ionexchange resins or zeolites. For example, cyclohexylmercaptan is produced from cyclohexene at 2108C,
16 bar, LHSV 0.09 h1 over ion-exchange resin with
9597% selectivity at 92% conversion of the olen.
The service time of the catalyst is more than 1500 h.
For manufacturing 2-butylmercaptan, butene as starting material is better than n-butanol. Using ionexchange resin as catalyst at 1008C and 15 bar,
70% 2-butylmercaptan and 30% butylsulde are
attained at 70% conversion.
For the production of tertiary mercaptans such as
tert-butylmercaptan, tert-octylmercaptan, tert-nonylmercaptan and tert-dodecylmercaptan, the starting
materials are isobutene, di-isobutene, tri-propylene,
and tetra-propylene or tri-isobutene. In the case of
tetra-propylene at 608C, 10 bar and LHSV0.3 h1
using an ion-exchange resin, 100% selectivity for tertdodecylmercaptan are achieved at 96% conversion.
Under quite similar conditions, tert-butylmercaptan is
obtained with 100% selectivity at 98% conversion of
isobutene.
It is expected that shape selective regenerable zeolite catalysts which are also applied commercially in
mercaptan syntheses yield even better results.
3.2. Base catalysis
3.2.1. General electric-process for the production
of 2,6-xylenol
The alkylation of phenol with methanol to 2,6xylenol, a monomer of PPO resin, over MgO is an
old industrial process developed by General Electrics
(cf. Table 5, No. 9) [32]. Since the alkylation of an
aromatic ring with olen or alcohol had been believed
to be catalyzed by acids, the nding of the alkylation
over a basic MgO catalyst was surprising and gave a
great impact to catalysis researchers. The selectivity of
MgO for 2,6-xylenol is more than 90%, which is much
higher than that (17%) of solid acid, SiO2Al2O3 [32].
The reason for the high selectivity is explained by the
difference in the adsorbed state of phenol as shown in
Fig. 1.
According to the IR study, phenol is adsorbed to
dissociate into phenoxide ion and proton in both cases
of MgO and SiO2Al2O3, but the benzene ring plane is
parallel to the catalyst surface in the case of an acidic
425
426
Fig. 2. Side-chain alkylation of o-xylene with butadiene to form o-tolylpentene catalyzed by a solid superbase, Na/K2CO3, as a step in the
synthesis of 2,6-dimethyl naphthalate (2,6-DMNA). (DMN: dimethylnaphthalene; NDA: Naphthalene dicarboxylic acid.)
427
428
429
4. Future trends
430
5. Conclusion
The present survey of industrial application of solid
acidbase catalysis provides the fact that a large
number of various solid acidbase catalysts are used
for more than 100 industrial processes. Zeolites, oxides, complex oxides, ion-exchange resins, and phosphates occupy large percentage of the catalysts. In
particular, the contribution of various zeolites to
industrial application is realized to be the greatest.
The number of processes using solid acid catalysts is
largest at present. However, the signicance of solid
acidbase bifunctional catalysis and solid base catalysis has been pointed out by explaining several
examples of the industrial processes. On the basis
of the survey, future prospects of solid acidbase
catalysis are speculated.
This survey is not sufcient because some of the
catalysts which are used in new practical processes are
proprietary and secret and some of the companies do
not disclose the scales of production and do not want
their processes to become public. For example, a
major chemical company in Europe carries out 10
processes catalyzed by solid acids or bases. But only
two of them are disclosed. Nevertheless, we hope that
this survey will be useful for the catalysis researchers,
in particular, in universities.
6. Appendix
lb
MIL lb
BIL lb
B (bbl)
BPD
BPSD
BPCD
psig
pound
million pounds
billion pounds
barrel
barrels per day
barrels per steam day
barrels per calendar day
pound per square inch gauge (0.068 atm)
bar
MM
MMM
MW
0.987 atm
million
billion
megawatt
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge professors and doctors
(cf. [23,2431]) for providing new information for this
survey. Also the authors like to express their sincere
thanks to Dr. J. Kervennal (Elf-Atochem), Dr. R.
Vanheertum (Degussa AG), Dr. Irv. W. Potts (DOW
Chemical), Prof. Dr. Rosenkranz (Bayer AG) and Dr.
J.P. Lange (Shell Chemicals) for providing information about processes carried out in their companies.
References
[1] M. Misono, N. Nojiri, Recent progress in catalytic
technology, Appl. Catal. 64 (1990) 130.
[2] N. Nojiri, M. Misono, Appl. Catal. A 93 (1993) 103122 A
supplement of Ref. [1].
[3] J.N. Armor, New catalytic technology in the USA during the
1980s, Appl. Catal. 78 (1991) 141173.
[4] E. Min, P. Zhou, Progress in catalytic technology in the
People's Republic of China during the 1980s, Appl. Catal. A
95 (1993) 120.
[5] A. Chauvel, B. Delmon, W.F. Holderich, New catalytic
processes developed in Europe during the 1980s, Appl.
Catal. A 115 (1994) 173217.
[6] W.F. Holderich, New reactions in various fields and
production of specialty chemicals, in: Proceedings of the
10th International Congress on Catalysis, Stud. Surf. Sci.
Catal. 75 (1993) 127163.
[7] K. Tanabe, H. Hattori, T. Yamaguchi, T. Tanaka (Eds.),
AcidBase Catalysis, VCH, Weinheim, 1989.
[8] J.A. Cusumano, New technology and the environment,
CHEMTECH 482 (1992).
[9] Solid acid/base catalyst takes concrete steps, European
Chemical News, 23 September 1991, p. 28, A Report from
Nippon Chemtec. Consulting Inc.
[10] D. Rotman, Alkylates catalysts move forward, Chemicalweek, 10 November 1993, p. 14.
[11] D. Rotman, Catalysis leads the search for cleaner pathways,
Chemicalweek, 6/13 July 1994, pp. 9496.
[12] A. Wood, Mobil cultivates new zeolites to grow process
licensing, Chemicalweek, 17 August 1994, pp. 3435.
[13] G.D. Morris, Solid-acid alkylate catalysts move toward
commercial reality, Chemicalweek, 8 March 1995, p. 12.
[14] Enichem unveils zeolite process, Chemicalweek, 20/27
December 1995, p. 33.
431
432
[116]
[117]
[118]
[119]
[120]
[121]
[122]
[123]
[124]
[125]
[126]
[127]
[128]
[129]
[130]
[131]
[132]
[133]
[134]
[135]
[136]
[137]
[138]
[139]
[140]
[141]
[142]
[143]
[144]
[145]
[146]
[147]
[148]
[149]
433
434
[197] A.K. Uriarte et al., Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 110 (1997) 857
864.
[198] Chemical Week 1 (8) (1997) 11.
[199] A.V. Mashkina, Russ. Chem. Rev. 64(12) (1995) 1131
1147.
[200] DE 33 34 084 assigned to Rutgerswerke AG.