Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
concrete buildings
A rational approach to providing adequate support
during each stage of construction
This article describes a rational
approach which will provide sufficient support for each stage of construction and a description of the
insufficient conditions that resulted in building collapses at Boston in
1971 and at Baileys Crossroads, near
Alexandria, Virginia in 1972. A summary is provided with bibliography
of studies of the problem since
1949.
BY JACOB FELD
CONSULTING ENGINEER
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
Support for
minimizing deflection
and preventing failure
Nearby garage under construction collapsed, probably due to shock wave from
apartment building.
An evaluation of number
of floors to be shored
These requirements are minimal.
They are often not sufficient to provide enough support to pre ve n t
plastic yield and permanent deflection. A rather simple evaluation can
be made of the total number of floor
levels that must be connected with
shores to provide proper support.
This begins with several reasonable
assumptions based on accepted
empirical relationships of strength
A recent failure
At Baileys Cro s s ro a d s, near
Alexandria, Virginia on March 2,
1972, after the concrete in the third
of four sections of the twenty-fourth
floor of a 26-story apartment building had been completed, a sequential failure occurred which stripped
a length of about 80 feet all the way
to foundation level. The building
split right down the middle leaving
two towers 24 and 23 stories high.
An internally supported crane fell
on the rubble; it was not operating
at the time.
The building was about 60 feet
wide and 386 feet long, of flat plate
design utilizing lightweight conc re t e. A stair and elevator core was
surrounded by concrete walls which
remained intact; it bounded one
edge of the failure area. Slabs were
eight inches thick, columns generally of constant size, and the design
was the same as that of two similar
26-story apartments in the same
complex that were already occupied. Construction of a fourth similar building had been started and
had reached the second floor.
Between the third and fourth
buildings and completely separated
from them is a 295- by 350-foot
four-level garage having a post-ten-
Age,
Type I
Type III
weeks
cement
cement
100
100
85
100
70
90
50
75
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
Carrying capacity
in terms of dead load
2.00
2.33
2.67
3.00
3.33
3.67
4.00
Casting rate,
floors per week
Type of
cement
I
III
3
2
3
2
3
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
I
III
5
4
4
3
4
3
4
2
3
2
3
2
3
2
I
III
7
5
6
4
5
4
5
3
4
3
4
3
3
3
back-propped. Yet no unusual condition was noted and the work progressed. In the week prior to the collapse, work was speeded up and the
combined age of the two supporting
floors dropped to 19 days. On March
2, the day of the failure, it was only
14 days. At that time the twentythird floor in the section was four
days old and the twenty-second was
ten days old. Concrete test cylinder
strengths at seven days age for these
two floors were 2290 and 2280 psi,
respectively. There is also some report of shoring removal under the
twenty-third floor between the time
that placement ended, (11:50 a.m.)
and time of collapse (2:20 p.m.) but
with low March temperatures and
the age of the supporting floors,
there was not sufficient carrying capacity for the newly placed slab. Design strength of the concrete was
stated as 3000 psi.
Earlier failures
The same phenomenon of delayed action occurred some years
ago in a Newark, New Jersey garage
failure, where the shores gave way
after the floor finishing was completed and after they had been carrying the full load for several hours
without incident. It is difficult to
reach a logical explanation for this
delay in action, unless one assumes
a plastic strain phenomenon in
shear failure. The writer has found
nothing in the literature to substantiate such an assumption and his
experience with concrete beam and
slab testing has given no clue.
On January 25, 1971 in Boston a
similar domino sequence of failure
ended in total collapse of part of the
building and a venetian-blindshaped cover on the remainder. The
concrete apartment house that
failed was 16 stories of flat plate design, 58 by 168 feet in area with slabs
712 inches thick, and all stories plus
the roof level had been successfully
completed in spite of severe winter
conditions. The roof level was completed in December, almost six
weeks before the collapse. The roof
slab was nine inches thick and designed to carry a penthouse area
not enter the wall. Full strength concrete would not have sheared. Certainly some shoring for one or more
floors might have held the fresh
concrete until the deep beams became self-supporting and until the
boilers could be moved to their
proper location, thereby relieving
the roof slab of the high
loadings.
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Nielsen, Knud E.C., Investigation of Load Distribution Between Reinforced Concrete Floor Slabs
and their Formwork. (Preliminary Report) Meddelanden NR19, Swedish Cement and Concrete
Research Institute, 1949.
Nielsen. Knud E.C., Loads on Reinforced Concrete Floor Slabs and Their Deflections During
Construction, Swedish Cement and Concrete Institute, Royal Institute of Technology, 1950.
Eriksson, Folke; Hansen, Torben; and Holst,
Hans, Determination of Form Removal Times,
Swedish State Commission for Building Research, 1962. (Translated into English by Building
Research Institute, Report 83, 1966).
Propped Floors in Multistory Flat Plate Construction, Construction Review, Volume 37, November 1964, pages 16-20.
Blakey, F.A. and Beresford, F.D., Stripping of
Formwork for Concrete in Buildings in Relation to
Structural Design, Civil Engineering Transactions, Institution of Civil Engineers, Australia, T-4,
1965, pages 92-95.
Kondo, Motoki, Theoretical Study on Faster
Stripping of Form Shores, Takenaka Technical
Research Report, Number 1, April 1966, pages
35-55 (in Japanese).
Feld, Jacob, Reshoring of Concrete Buildings,
Engineering News Record, October 6, 1966,
pages 33-34.
Taylor, P.J., Effects of Formwork Stripping Time
on Deflections of Flat Slabs and Plates, Australia
Civil Engineering and Construction, February 6,
1967, pages 31-35.
Ho, Ka-cheung, Preliminary Investigation into
Shoring System, University of Ottawa, Department of Civil Engineering, September 1970.
Agarwal, R.K. and Gardner, Noel J., Form and
Shore Requirements for Multistory Flat Slab Type
Buildings, paper presented at Formwork Symposium of American Concrete Institute, Atlantic City,
New Jersey, March 1973.
PUBLICATION #C740243
Copyright 1974, The Aberdeen Group
All rights reserved