Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
19,
No.8
EDITORIAL/Guest
Editorial
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR ...........................
NEWS
ATHEISTS ORGANIZE
Colorado . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ; . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Oregon
Anne Gaylor Files Lawsuit
Unitarians Debate Atheism
Baptists Bar Blacks from Schools
IRS Investigates Ministers
Carter Envoy to Vatican
FEATURE ARTICLES
"Stop Teasing Men"- The Simonson Saga/Speakingfor Women:
Anne Gaylor
August, 1977
2
3
14
4
;6
7
11
12
15
16
WarrenShibles
19
Patrick Owens
27
28
23
, ........
18
22
Name
Address
City, State, & Zip
RENEWAL
_
ON THE COVER
Gerald Tholen is the Director of the
Houston-Galveston
(Texas) Chapter of
American Atheists. Assisting him in that
effort is his wife, Gloria, who is just as avid
an Atheist as he.
.
Gerald Tholen was born on January 30,
1929, in Galveston Texas, and "with the
Texas Gulf Coast Marshes in my blood" he
claims to be and is one of our persistent,
thoroughly self-educated, most determined
Directors.
Immediately after high school, and upon
the death of his father, (who was killed in
the historic Texas City Explosion in 1947),
he entered into the family business, a paint
and floorcovering (as well as a quality picture framing) establishment in LaMarque,
Texas, and he has been gaining a reputation
for excellent and fair trade for that firm
since, that is during the last thirty years.
His favorite pastime - duck hunting has led him to be very conscious of the
value of conservation and rationality.
"Sportsmen, by their own desire, must safeguard our country's wildlife and its habitats
or that wildlife will vanish forever." He has,
in this pursuit, become an efficient retriever
trainer who has educated several "duck
dogs" highly regarded by the Coast Salt
Marsh hunters. Duck hunting inspired him
to oil painting of wildlife and two of his
oils, exquisitely detailed and almost photographic in detail, hang in the American
Atheist Center.
Gerald is one of those persons who, if
there is need, will. be found supervising
the activity. He is, for example, currently
the president of Bayou Vista Property
Owners' Association an organization that
supervises community action in the subdivision where his family resides. He is also
a trustee on the committee which secured a
new sanitary sewer system for the community. His current activity has resulted
in successfully reaching an agreement with
the Galveston County Road Dept. for that
entity to accept ownership of the streets in
his suburb. Up to 1977 the streets were
maintained on a privately supported basis.
In his capacity of American Atheist
Chapter Director he has, through earnest
communication, letter, telephone and visit,
managed a precedent-setting breakthrough
of Atheist acceptance in the newsmedia of
his area.
We urge any of you who are resident in
the area of Houston-Galveston to contact
this fine chapter, and its Director, the
address being "American Atheists, HoustonGalveston Chapter, P. O. Box 307, LaMarque, Texas, 77568" and the telephone
number is (713) 935-9531.
ATHEIST
discredit or destroy. Time spent at the Center helping reorganize to a higher point of efficiency will be an education in
itself. And please, try to contribute as much as you can financially. Everyone knows the high costs of doing anything nowadays and the Center has to pay for merchandise and services
just the same as everyone else.
If you've been disillusioned or disappointed by religious
encroachment
in the past I hope you will all realize the point
of the saying "You win some - you lose some". It's true that
at this point in history we're not "winning them all" but
let's remember not too long ago we didn't "win any".
To any-one now who holds the feeling that he or she has to
carefully hide the fact that they are Atheists I can only say
you're only kidding yourself. That part of our "revolution"
has already been won by those who were courageous enough
to openly fight for our rights in a "free" society. Your own
personal emancipation
in your home town depends on your
desire to rid yourself of a!1V further intimidation by your
friends, relatives, and associates. It's time for you to have heart
to heart talks with anyone, anytime and let them know that
you no longer intend to hide in the shadows and that you do
not need any further religious advice or domination. "Letters
to the editor" in your local newspapers commenting on the
irrelevance of religious "guidance" of your community will be
both rewarding and interesting. Perhaps you will find it more
constructive to initiate an Atheist radio or TV series both of
which are available through the national Center. It is equally
important for you to contact your local Chapter and offer
your participation.
Keep in mind, there are NO miracle
workers; there are only people. Your chapter directors need
your support. The Center needs your support. If you do your
part to break the 'enigma of religious mind control now your
children won't have to do so much of your work later.
It seems ironic, indeed, that loyal people who only wish to
further ideals based on reality would be overjoyed to receive
a helpful check for 22.9 dollars when we read of an evangeli
cal supernaturalist
who has at his disposal 22.9 MILLION dollars which he apparently doesn't even need. I think it's time
we put our claim to being RATIONAL into practical use.
How can we expect our frontline people to advertise, acquire,
and publish our materials with noticeable effect in the face of
such overwhelming odds. There are so many projects which we
have all been informed of so many times. These items continue
to wait for financing and can only be actuated by our support.
I am wondering, right now, if any reader of this article has
ever been in a situation that required him to beg for help. Most
of us have probably never been in such a position. Begging is
not something that a person can do with a great deal of self
respect or pride. It leaves a lasting mark on those who unavoidably
must resort to such methods
of existence. I
personally cannot offer you a life after death or a "choice lot
in heaven" - all I have to offer in return for your help is a
pledge to continue to help all Atheist causes in our country.
Madalyn O'Hair doesn't need to make such a pledge because
she has, for years, displayed to all of us that Atheism in Ameri
ca is her life's work. So now I am begging, on behalf of every
sincere Atheist in our country, please lend a hand.
We have a beautiful and efficient National Center, a network of Atheist Chapters, a great deal of national recognition,
and many sincere people eager to make progress. It would
take about ten minutes of your time to sit down and write a
small note of encouragement
to Dr. O'Hair - and don't for
get to include a check for even a small amount to help offset
the costs that are ever present at the Center.
-GERALD
THOLEN
Dear Editor:
I am a recent subscriber to your
monthly magazine. I read the periodi
cal from cover to cover and enjoy
every word.
For many years I have been an admirer of yours and the "cause."
Currently I am an officer in the
United States Army and very much
oppose the chaplaincy program in the
military.
Just recently our division was
assembled together to hear our commander speak about safety on the
highways and within the performance
of military duties. After the talk he
called upon the division chaplain to
offer prayer for safety of military
personnel. We were asked [ordered]
to stand and remove our head gear.
I could not remove my hat but, indeed, I stood and stood tall. I looked
on as the others bowed their heads in
prayer. My action was noticed. My
action is not expected of an officer.
But I just could not do it. I just
wanted to share with you the experience that many military Atheists must
undergo to be accepted wholely into
the military community.
This, of
course, is no isolated incident.
I was "born" a Roman Catholic.
My parents were Catholic, my eldest
sister was a Franciscan Nun for nine
years. At the age of five I was a
"curandera" a healer because of my
first name, Juanita, or John of Saint
Juan (St. John). Upon my first communion at the age of seven I was
asked to kiss the crucifix which I
refused because I did not believe in
Jesus as god.
In 1969 I converted to Judaism.
I believed I needed a religion and
since Jews do not accept Jesus as
Christ this would be perfect for me. I
went to Temple regularly but grew
more and more silent when I had to
call upon god for every human happening. I gulped when I had to extoll
his name. I hesitate in spelling "god"
with a capital "G".
Now, in 1977 I have given up
Judaism and other organized religions.
Before 1969 I proclaimed myself a
nonbeliever in 'god'. I am Atheistic.
I'm not sure I am an Atheist-yet.
I
know there is no god to assist human-
The news which fills one half of the magazine is chosen to demonstrate, month after month, the dead reactionary hand of religion. It dicta
good habits, sexual conduct, family size, it censures cinema, theater, television, even education. It dictates life values and lifestyle. Religion
politics and, always, the most authoritarian and reactionary politics. We editorialize our news to emphasize this thesis. Unlike any other
zine or newspaper in the United States, we are honest enough to admit it.
Atheist Heritage
To The Editor:
In the U.S.A. the freedom of
religion includes the freedom from
religion. Separation of Church and
State is supposedly an American
ideal, as expressed in our Constitution.
Fourteen years ago the American
Atheist Association was formed by
a group with Madalyn Murray
Q'Hair as president and an office
in Austin, Texas. There had never
been an attempt to organize
Atheists as such before.
There had never been an attempt
to make them proud of their heritage, which includes the mental
attitude that acceptsthe supremacy
of reason and aims at establishing
a system of philosophy and ethics
verifiable by experience, independent of all arbitrary assumptions
of authority or creeds. It declares
that the cosmos is devoid of imminent conscious purpose; that it is
governed by its own inherent,
immutable and impersonal law;
that there is no supernatural interference in human life; that manfinding his resourceswithin himself
-can and must create his own
ATHEISM
****
*
I **"
'*
*
.: LOST *
** IT **
*"*- **
AUGUST. 1977/AMERICAN
ATHEIST
St. Vincent De P
Postmark Spurs
Lawsuit by
Anne Gaylor
Atheist
Anne Gaylor
suit against
the U.S.
Service for stamping
called a religious me
postcards
she mailed in
May in Madison.
In a complaint fil
Federal Court, Ms. Gay
founder of the Freedom
Religion Foundation,
.
Constitutional
rights are
violated by a postal
tion that says, "Help the
of St. Vincent De Paul
Needy."
She said the gover
supporting
a religious
whose business incl
tions to an anti-abortion
zation.
Ms. Gaylor said her
be free from having
messages placed on her
property and her ri;rt
dom of thought willbe
if the practice contin
Names as defe
Madison
postmaster
Whitmore;
Postmaster
Benjamin Bailar and
Postal Service.
Whitmore said any
tion may petition
Service in Washi
postage cancellation
sage is of national .
related to the
of the people.
If permission is
organization buys a
die for the Postal
more said.
The St. Vincent
ciety was granted
and another cancel
used soon in Mad'
cize a cardio-pul
tation course at
Hospital, he said.
Because so many
made, the Madison
uses each message
a year, he said.
Foundation Attacks
West Virginia Senate for
Religious Arrogance
(Madison, Wisconsin) The Wisconsin based
Freedom From Religion Foundation today attacked the West Virginia Senate for "religious
arrogance" and a "blatantly stupid" violation of
separation of state and church.
The West Virginia Senate overwhelmingly
approved a resolution which said that Jesus may
be shown only as "expressly presented by the Holv '
Bible or by the teachings of Christian theology."
Some state senators had noted that the resolution
violated constitutional guarantees of free speech.
"While many Americans are Christians who
believe in the Biblical portrayal of Jesus, obviously there are many others who are not Christians and do not share these beliefs," said Anne
Gaylor, president of the Wisconsin based group.
"West Virginia is blithely writing off the freedoms
of those who do not accept the divinity or the
historicity of Jesus-who see him as a mythical
figure."
Ms. Gaylor pointed out that the Constitution is
a godless document.
"It was purposely written to be a godless document," she said. "The only references to religion in the Constitution are exclusionary, because
our founding fathers had an abiding distrust
of religion in government."
Ms. Gaylor asked West Virginians who support
freedom of speech to see that this "mischiefmaking religious manifesto" is rescinded.
pregnant prior to living with him until "god" instructed him not to do so.
I agree that everyone should read the Bible so
they will be informed as to just how good a book it
really is.
RALPH B. SHIRLEY
in this country."
McElderry said he agreed that church-operated
businesses and properties outside the church
should be taxed like any other business, but he
favored retaining tax-exempt status for the
churches themselves.
In the case of churches and many educational
institutions, he said, the power to tax is the power
to destroy.
Regarding her arguments about separation of
church and state, McElderry said it may be desirable, in theory, but in practice it is impossible to
divorce American government from Judeo-Christian principles.
McElderry said the checks and balances system
is an example of a governmental mechanism that
evolved out of a religious belief of the depraved
nature of mankind. "This principle is shot through
the Constitution and the laws of every state in
the union."
Some listeners observed that Atheists have become so organized they practically constitute a
religion in themselves.
"The Internal Revenue Service views us as an
educational institution,"
Ms. Conrad replied.
"Atheism is a philosophy of life. If you accept that
attitudes and beliefs are a religion, perhaps we are,
but it is free from theism."
"As Atheists, we do not impose upon you our
particular philosophy. We support one thing: Freedom of conscience. We will go to court with you
to support what you believe, but we do not want
to pay our tax money to support your belief."
By WEBB GARRISON
Outraged clergymen attacked Ben Franklin
for his invention of the lightning rod - until
lightning smashed into a church where gunpowder
was stored, setting off an explosion that killed
more than 3,000 people.
The men of the cloth argued that use of "Franklin's rods" challenged both the Holy Scriptures
and the will of god, causing natural disasters that
were actually divine punishment.
Franklin erected a lightning rod on his Philadel-
----'
Philadelphia, 1767
doctor.
Eventually her condition stabilized and she was
able to walk with crutches until she adjusted to
having a left leg three inches shorter than the right
and a stiff hip joint.
The infection flared up several times during
Mrs. Sutton's life, the last time in March. This
time, although the Suttons had long accepted
medical treatment, it was too late, her husband
said.
She died at the Thomas Hospital.
Keith Sutton didn't know his wife 32 years ago
when the infection, later diagnosed as osteomylitis, began its fatal work although they lived in the
same small community.
But he knows that he, too, refused medical
treatment at that age, as did his parents.
He was reared, as his wife-to-be was, believing
literally the passagein James 5 that states: "Is any
sick among you? Let him call for the elders of the
church and let them pray over him, anointing him
with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer
of faith shall save the sick, and the Lord shall
raise him up, and if he have committed sins, they
shall be forgiven."
Sutton says he began to change his mind about
the meaning of that passage at 18 when stricken
with acute appendicitis. He drove himself to a hospital where emergency treatment saved his life.
Already he was beginning to question the scripture quoted by church leaders as a prohibition
against medical care.
lilt is the sickness of the soul, not of the flesh,
the Bible is talking about," Sutton said. "People
are dying because of the false teaching that the
Scripture means the prayer of the faithful alone
will cure the sick."
Sutton's belief in the traditional teachings of the
70-member congregation at Fay weakened again
several years later after his marriage and while his
wife was expecting their second child.
At one of the congregation's nightly "purgings,"
Sutton said a self-proclaimed prophet stood,
pointed to Sutton's father and accused him of
stealing.
The prophesy was backed by other "prophets"
of the church, and Sutton's father was faced with
the decision of admitting the theft and asking for
forgiveness in order to remain in the congregation, or to deny the charge and be "separated"
from the church until he repented.
Sutton's father denied the accusation. He left
the congregation and his wife and son followed.
All three became outcasts.
Teacher Awarded Up to
$50,000
AUGUST, 1977/AMERICAN
ATHEIST -13
CULVER
Mrs.
Conrad
was
reared as a Reform Jew,
but
gradually
drifted
from a belief in religion
or in a supernatural being
such as god.
She believes persons in
any religion are "indoctrinated into it, whether
they're Moonies or Presbyterians. "
She will soon publish a
book, called "Pillars of
Religion: Ignorance, Indoctrination and Inadequacies."
. "Any intell igent person who has studied and
JANE CONRAD
who contends there is a
Atheist leader.
god has been brainwashed," she said. Those who reject evolution also
are brainwashed, she contends.
Such "brainwashing stifles their intellectual
growth," she said, adding that many people "die
intellectually the day they get out of school."
Mrs. Conrad, a widow with two married daughters and four grandchildren, earned her bachelor's
degree three years ago in political science from
Metropol itan State College.
She has worked as a secretary, a writer and for
various causes, such as low-cost housing and fairnessin mobile-home laws.
"I'm not a kook," she said. "1 live a nice good,
grandmotherly life. I have not debts, I don't smoke
or drink or run around. I work in my garden. But
I try also to keep up on what's going on around
me."
She beli'eves "there is much more morality in
Atheism than in any religion. The church is the
CARTER
NAMES
ENVOY TO
VATICAN
me."
CS~alttnCf
fA,tomn,'
rilUU 'it ~t()/t
has said,
A woman has to live in fear and cover up her
head.
She has to dress in Purdah and lock herself in
cages,
And this kinky judge in Madison is from the
Middle Ages.
CHORUS
The judge took his position, the judge he
wouldn't budge,
So we've got out this petition and we're going to
dump the judge.
paper
19 University of Wisconsin Law School Faculty
Members
131 teachers and staff members of Madison West
High School
The Minneapolis Tribune
Capitol Chapter of the ACLU
Committee Against Racism
Legal Association of Women
Women's International
League for Peace and
Freedom
Rape Crisis Center
Madison Association of School Principals
Dane County Project on Rape
Commencement
speakers at the University of
Wisconsin
Women's Transit Authority
Northeast Side Community Health Center
Young Socialist Alliance
Dane County Advocates for Battered Women
University of Wisconsin Teaching Assistants
Association
Women Organized for Action
The "Archie Must Go" Coalition
The Dane County Committee to Recall Judge
Simonson, and
over 27,000 private Dane County citizens.
As this is being written (mid-July) the drive for
signatures for the recall election has been successful. Almost 28,000 signatures have been gathered,
with only 21,049 required. After the filing of the
petitions on July 26, if there are no court challenges, Simonson has 10 days to resign. If not, his
name will appear on the ballot in a special election
the first week in September, along with the names
of others who have declared. Although it is technically possible for Simonson to win again if the
anti-Simonson vote is fragmented among too many
candidates, somehow we feminists don't think that
will happen. The first candidate to announce for
Simonson's post is a woman. If elected, and we'll
do our best to see that she is, she will be the first
women elected to a county judgeship in the state.
Regardless of what happens, we feminists believe we have made our point - that sexist remarks
from the bench are made at great, great jeopardy.
If anyone would like up-to-date information on the
recall or would like to help us in our effort to
make history by replacing a flakly, sexist judge
with a capable woman judge, please contact me:
Anne Gaylor, 726 Miami Pass, Madison, Wisconsin,
53711, phone (608) 238-3338.
Atheists, please note: In justifying his light
(Continue on page 32.)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Bible Contradictions,
Bible Absurdities,
Bible Atrocities,
Unfulfilled Prophecies and Broken
Bible Immoralities, Indecencies, and
Obscenities.
It will confound,
confuse and obfu
Bible believer. It is just what it was propose
an effective instrument to destroy, utterly,
"belief" in the Bible. There is no way that th
can propose
answers to these irrefutab
citations.
Someone had suggested to us, via letter,
put out a book titled "God versus God"
how god contradicted
himself constantly.
and Ball beat us to this by almost 100 y
work is so good, so exhaustive, that we
do it all over again.
The sturdy volume is 176 pages, paperba
should buy half a dozen to send to your s
Christian friends.
Yes! I want
copies of The Bible Handbook for Atheists at $3.95 per copy. PI
enclosed $
. (Make checks or money order payable to: AMERICAN ATHE
P. O. Box 2117, Austin, Texas, 78768.) Or charge to my:
o VISA
o MASTERCHARGE
Name
No.,
Date Expires
Signature,
'--
AUGUST,
Address,
City
State
7ip,
-L
1977/AMERICAN
ATHEIST
- 18
___'"
_
_
please add 5%
SHIBLES' CORNER
~arren shihles
The Catholic Schools Teach Dogma, Separatism, Bias
The church-state issue is not that state is biased
against religion but that religion,
especially
Catholic religion, is prejudiced against all other
beliefs and is not willing to allow them. The
government by allowing church school in place of
public school is thereby supporting such religious
bias and discrimination.
Father Jeremiah
Crowley (excommunicated)
wrote The Parochial School, A Curse to The
Church-A Menace to The Nation in 1904. He said:
1) Parochial schools lead to bigotry. 2) The Catholic Church is protected by public non-sectarian
education. 3) Catholics send children to Catholic
schools out of fear. 4) Catholics try to undermine
public schools and infiltrate them with Catholic
teachers and members of the board. Catholic
schools teach authoritarianism, discrimination, and
separatism. Canon 1374 "Catholic children may
not attend
non-Catholic,
neutral,
or mixed
schools ... " "As for Catholic parents, the Council
calls to mind their duty to entrust their children to
Catholic schools, when and where this is possible,
to support such schools to the extent of their
ability ... " Vatican II. "To this concept of a
Catholic school, all schools dependent
on the
Church must conform as far as possible ... "
Outlines of Vatican II.
Canon 1372 "From childhood, all the faithful
must be reared so that they are taught nothing
contrary to faith and morals, but so that religious
and moral training have the primary place." The
stress is on training when the child is young and
most susceptible to dogma. Canon 1374 "Catholic
children should not frequent non-Catholic, neutral,
or mixed schools, i.e., such as are open also to nonCatholics."
Commentary
1935. If Catholic
children do not qualify for Catholic schools due to
intelligence or emotional immaturity they are sent
to public schools. Catholics can then force their
brightest students into Catholic schools.
Emmett
McLoughlin
(ex-priest)
says that
Catholic schools exist not because of desire or need
but because Canon law and Papal encyclicals force
their existence. Parents have no choice in texts or
say in school teaching. They are forced [on pain of
hell] to send children to Catholic schools and may
AUGUST. 1977/AMERICAN
ATHEIST -19
~--------------------------------------------------------------------
-Gerald Tholen
THOUGHTS OUT OF SEASON: HAIL, SATAN!
Of all the divinities, living or dead,
That mankind has worshipped in deepest dread,
The one I shall ever revere the most
Is not the Son, nor the Holy Ghost,
Nor the Father, of whom the Catholics boast
As the One who seduced the Virgin fair
To whom the prelates address each prayer.
No, frankly, the one I most respect
Is Satan, despised by the ssved-elect,
Slaving away in the fiery lakes,
Among bel/owing dragons and hissing snakes,
Torturing souls-for the Lord's mistakes.
He is slandered and cursed in a thousand ways,
While Jehovah listens to songs of praise.
"For what?" you ask. Excuse my slam!
For creating souls that He knew He'd damn,
Ages before He slew the Lamb
(Or, as some say, His only Son),
Then once this Fatherly deed was done,
A few, who believed that Three made One,
Were saved from the Devil's base design
(A part, of course, of that Plan Divine),
By making a gestural, cross-like sign.
Isn't Satan part of the Father's plan
To save a tiny remnant of man?
Didn't he open our very first school
In Eden, by teaching Eve to rule
-MEPHISTOPHELES
EVOLUTION
The
Building
Fund
Barometer
1306 N. Orleans
Bowling Green, OH. 43402
Dear Bergman:
You neglect to note if you are an Atheist, or I
Christian who is "very much interested" in our
work. Both subscribe to the magazine and will, we
are certain, be in contact with you to send magazines your way.
Dear Editor:
The recent news indication from The Daily
Express of London, England, that Prince Charles
intends to marry a Roman Catholic Princess, Marie
Astrid of Luxembourg is a setback to forward
thinking people in the Western World.
She is to bring her female offspring up under the
Roman Catholic faith and her male offspring up
under the Protestant faith.
It is quite clear that the Church of England'
really strongly Catholic oriented anyway-but sucli1
a marriage will open the door to the hordes 0
Vatican religious propagandists.
As an Atheist, I have written Prince Charles
condemn such a merger. If Prince Edward co
not have his Wallis Warfied Simpson, then Prin
Charles should be denied the flagrant backw
step his marriage will create.
One wonders why the world is so rotten w
the disease of Roman Catholicism flares its u
sickness into the heart of the British Palace.
How can the world get rid of this religi
cancer?
Atheists must continue to do battle.
A. L. Pang
Oakville, On
do everything.
He was the second best tennis
player in town. He taught himself touch typing
and was doing sixty words a minute in six months.
It took no more time to become the second best
pool player in town (Bumps Winters was best). He
won the state oratorical contest, sold a story to
the American Legion magazine when he was 17
and one to the Saturday Evening Post when he
was 18. He was a year older than I. Dean Johnson
was a couple of years older still. He was the most
successful actor in the high school and could draw
like an angel. They were both snotty kids and I
probably should have beat them up but they lived
in houses with plumbing and were smart besides. I
was immensely flattered to be tolerated by them,
even if they did always insult me.
We gathered at an unfashionable
place, Mr.
Larson's grocery and soda fountain, and spent
hours wrangling over religion, philosophy
and
everything
else under the sun. Mr. Larson, a
middle-aged man with two loutish sons roughly our
age, was originally my ally in the religious wars.
"Hey Crail, you think you know so much,"
Mr. Larson would jeer. "Who made us if god
didn't?"
"Who made god?" Crail would respond.
Crail had read a biography of Clarence Darrow.
He attacked us with all the arguments Darrow had
used on William Jennings Bryan in the Scopes
trial:
"You believe that all the animals were drowned
in the flood, Mr. Larson?"
"It's in the Bible, young man."
"Even the fish, Mr. Larson?"
My faith vanished under such onslaughts, but
I did not admit this to Crail or Johnson. They were
much too unkind to permit my joining them.
Mr. Larson spoke often of life's mysteries. "Tell
me, Owens, why is it there is no sound in the
woods when you're not there to hear it?" he would
shout. He was a Scandinavian nationalist. "Hey,
Crail, you think you are so smart, who is the
greatest violinist who ever lived?"
"Paderewski,"
Crail would say, baiting Mr.
Larson.
"Hah, you think you are so smart. The greatest
violinist was Ole Bull."
"Never heard of him."
"What, you never heard of Ole Bull? Young
man" (Mr. Larson would here rise to a thunderous
crescendo that was absurd and hilarious because
AUGUST,
1977/AMERICAN
ATHEIST
- 27
THINK AHEAD!
~
The Eighth Annual American Atheist Convention will be held in San Francisco, California in April of 1978. Contact the convention
coordinator,
John I. Mays, for information
on how you can prepay your expenses with
monthly payments.
We are expecting hundreds of people more
than attended the Chicago '77 convention.
Please contact us early so we will be able to
reserve the correct number of rooms.
For information write to:
John I. Mays, Convention Coordinator
American Atheists
P. O. Box 2117, Austin, Texas 78768
The Freudian
Interpretation
of Religion
I
I
By NEIL KRESSEL
Although many of Sigmund Freud's theories
are no longer accepted by the scientific community, his statement on religion must still be reconciled with modern man's religious thought.
Freud described religion as "the universal obessionalneurosis
of humanity (which) like the obsessional neurosis of children arose out of the
Oedipus complex, out of the relation to the
father." He further pointed out that "If this view
is right, .is to be supposed that a turning-away
from religion is bound to occur with the fatal
inevitability of a process of growth, and that we
find ourselves in the middle of that phase of
development." Therefore, an evaluation of Freud's
psychoanalytical
interpretation
is of the utmost
significance for those who wish to understand the
origins and historical development of religion as
well as for those who are interested in the validity
of its tenets.
If we are to carry our investigation to a successful fruition, our analysis must necessarily touch
upon several disciplines. Freud realized that a
complete understanding of religion could not be
accomplished by means of a purely psychological
approach. In his book, Totem and Taboo, Freud
states,
There are no grounds for fearing that psychoanalysis ... will be tempted to trace the origin
of anything so complicated as religion to a
single source. Only when we can synthesize will
it be possible to arrive at the relative importance
of the part played in the genesis of religion by
the (psychoanalytical) mechanism.
In light of the fact that Freud's psychoanalytical
theory was only one aspect of his thought on religion, it is necessary to determine the underlying
philosophical
and theological framework within
which he was operating.
A flood of methodological objections may be
raised from the outset of any such integration of
philosophy,
theology,
and psychology. Many
psychologists who were contemporaries of Freud
claimed that psychology was an empirical science
b
fi
al
sI
n
b
p
hl
SJ
of Religion)
are needed for propagation. The fact that certain well established psychiatric
mechanisms
are utilized in religion does not in any sense
imply that the latter is neither genuine nor
divine. It may be argued here that I am begging
the question and that the psychiatric mechanisms involved in organized religion are essentially abnormal. But there is no clear line of demarcation between the neurotic and the illusory
category we call the normal.
This argument
is essentially
an extension of
Freud's realization that religions are illusions and
not delusions. Freud's psychoanalytical
approach
to religion is not a proof of the invalidity of
religious doctrines.
As has been previously stated, Freud's psychoanalytical theory can only be understood as one
aspect of a broader, multi-faceted philosophy of
religion.
The philosophical
system of which
Freud's theory is a part is that of the rationalistic
materialists. This school maintains that the only
world is the physical world and that reason is the
tool with which one must study the world. Freud
states that "the primacy of reason lies, it is true,
in a distant, distant future but probably not in an
infinitely distant one." Ethics can be derived from
humanism and are thought to be free from any
independent
metaphysical
entity such as god.
Thus, Freud's theory is vulnerable to all attacks
which may be thrust upon this thought system.
For instance, religious believers claim that reason
is not man's major tool with which he may determine the secrets of the cosmos. Their system is
based, on the other hand, on revelation and belief.
Such critics would find the underlying rationalism
of Freud's system inadequate.
Another major philosophical objection to the
Freudian interpretation
of religion is set forth by
those who believe that reason will never attain
hegemony
over the passions. In other words,
Freud's sytem is inextricably linked to his psychological development.
The line of distinction between thought and emotion is artificial. The philosophy of rationalistic materialism is accepted by
many as viable but it is not free from philosophical
problems.
Freud's theory of religion is not the only one to
make use of psychoanalytical methods and it is
interesting as well as didactice to view lung's
theory
in contradistinction
to Freud's. While
C. G. lung and Sigmund Freud were both pioneers in the field of psychoanalysis, their religious backgrounds and attitudes were quite different. lung starts his investigation by stating that
AUGUST, 1977/AMERICAN
ATHEIST
- 31
of Religion)
(The Catholic Schools Teach Dogma, Separatism, Bias, continued from page 21.)
or observe sexual objects yet we force a single religion on them in a brain-wash manner. We do not
even teach philosophy, (or much critical thinking)
yet in primary schools yet Catholicism is thrust on
children in kindergarten and earlier. Children often
say they wouldn't go to church or church schools
but they only go because their parents force them
to go. Non-Catholic
students
are sometimes
required to attend Catholic schools because no
public school is nearby.
0
("Stop Teasing Men" -The Simonson Saga, continued from page 17.)
sentence of the rapist, Simonson repeatedly mentioned the young man's church affiliation. And
we, who are tuned to such things, could not help
but notice that many, many elements of the
Madison community had been heard from, but the
churches were strangely silent. One Baptist congregation
embraced
the Simonson philosophy
publicly and completely, hardly surprising, since
sexism has always been a cornerstone of religion,
especially the fundamentalist
faiths. But even
"liberal"
churches" refrained
from criticizing
Simonson. After all, one must remember, paradise itself was lost because of Temptress Eve.
0
MOVING?
If you are planning a change of address, please notify
AMERICAN ATHEIST, giving both your old address and
your new address, as well as both your OLD AND NEW ZIP
CODES. This will enable us to process the change more
quickly and not interrupt your subscription. Please allow
six weeks for change to become effective. If possible, please
include old label off of your magazine envelope.
Why I Am An Atheist
This is the original sound track of
The records are no longer available
subject matter deals with the total
as Dr. O'Hair's personal philosophy
Two (2) hours listening time
the two LP record set produced by Dr. Madalyn Murray O'Hair in 1965.
but they are reproduced in their entirety on these cassette tapes. The
effort to remove prayer from public schools in the United States as well
of Atheism.
$14.95
Murray
SET3
SET4
PROGRAMS:
436-Joseph Lewis on
437--lngersoll on The
438-lngersoll on The
439-lngersoll on The
1 Hour
PROGRAMS:
440-lngersoll
on The Holy Bible, Part IV
441-lngersoll
on The Holy Bible, Part V
442-lngersoll
on The Holy Bible, Part VI
443-Robert
G. Ingersoll on Superstition
1 Hour
Robert G. Ingersoll
Holy Bible, Part I
Holy Bible, Part II
Holy Bible, Part III
$10.00
$10.95
$11.95
actual size
Order any of the above today from:
AMERICAN
ATHEISTS
P. O. Box 2117
Austin, Texas 78768
$10.00