Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
BlackwellArticle
Original
Science, Ltd
Abstract This study investigated intradermal test reactions to extracts of six species of mites in 150 dogs with
atopic dermatitis. At least one positive reaction was seen in 120 animals (80%). Dermatophagoides farinae
attracted the highest number of positive reactions (108 dogs, 90% of dogs and 72% of atopic dogs showing positive
reactions). Positive reactions to other mites were not uncommon, with many dogs testing positive for Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (32% of dogs tested), Acarus siro (35%), Tyrophagus putrescentiae (30%), Glycyphagus
domesticus (27%) and Lepidoglyphus destructor (23%). Sensitivity to D. farinae alone occurred commonly (57%
of cases), but multiple sensitivities were seen frequently with the other mites. Cases of sensitivity to only one mite
were also seen: D. pteronyssinus (five cases), T. putrescentiae (one case) and G. domesticus (one case). Further studies are needed to appreciate more clearly the precise role played by the different species of mite in canine atopic
dermatitis.
Keywords: allergy, atopic dermatitis, intradermal test reactions, mites.
INTRODUCTION
Atopic dermatitis is a complex syndrome, the aetiopathogenesis of which is still poorly understood.1
Various causal factors have been identified. In man,
genetic abnormalities, impaired barrier function of
the epidermis (in particular the stratum corneum),
immune system disorders and abnormal reactions to
common environmental substances (aeroallergens,
foods and perhaps even haptens) have been suggested.1,2 The situation is the same in the dog.35 The
role played by bacterial, fungal and psychological
factors is important but is still poorly understood in
both species.15 Although the extent to which allergic
mechanisms are involved in the pathogenesis of this
dermatosis is disputed,2 most authors agree that it is
considerable. In this context, mites are strongly suspected of being involved in provoking and/or exacerbating lesions of atopic dermatitis, in both man and
dogs.19 This is corroborated by positive allergy tests,
and by the good response to avoidance measures in
man10 and specific desensitization in the dog.
In the human allergy field, forage mites, as well as
pyroglyphid mites, have been shown to play an important role in the development of allergic asthma.11 Studies have also been carried out to investigate the most
common sensitivities in atopic dogs.4,6,7 It is now well
known that D. farinae is the most common source of
allergens commonly provoking positive reactions in
Correspondence: E. Bensignor, Dermatology Referral Service,
Veterinary Clinic, 17 bvd des Filles du Calvaire, 75003 Paris, France.
E-mail: emmanuel.bensignor@wanadoo.fr
2002 Blackwell Science Ltd
40
Pruritus
Appearance and distribution of lesions:
face and /or limbs
lichenification of the hock and /or cranial carpus
chronic dermatitis
Predisposed breed or familial history
scrapings, and trial acaricidal therapy where appropriate (ivermectin; Ivomec, 0.300 mg kg1 SC twice
at a 14-day interval). Rigorous flea control was also
systematically undertaken for every case (using an
adulticide and insect growth regulator).
Whenever bacterial pyoderma and/or Malassezia
dermatitis were present (diagnosed by clinical examination and cytology), animals were given specific treatment (antibiotics; cefalexin, Rilexine, 30 mg kg1
orally twice daily and/or systemic antifungals; ketoconazole, Ketofungol, 10 mg kg1 orally once daily) in
association with a twice weekly application of a 3%
chlorhexidine shampoo for 3 weeks prior to being
included in the study. Only animals that were still pruritic, and had lesions compatible with atopic dermatitis
after resolution of infection, were recruited.
All animals were fed a restricted diet consisting of
novel proteins (horse meat or fish) and one source of
vegetables (potatoes or semolina), for between 4 and
8 weeks (on average 6 weeks).18 Only animals showing
no marked reduction in pruritus and skin lesions after
this food trial were recruited.18
In every case, drugs were withheld prior to intradermal testing in accordance with recommendations
in the literature (antihistamines 1 week, oral corticosteroids 3 weeks, injectable corticosteroids 16 months).18
Intradermal tests
The test allergens were house dust mites or forage mites,
commonly identified as causal agents in both animal
and human allergy. Extracts of D. farinae, D. pteronyssinus,
T. putrescentiae, A. siro, G. domesticus and L. destructor
were used. These extracts were used in concentrations
previously demonstrated not to be irritant (1000 UI mL1
for D. farinae and D. pteronyssinus, 0.1% for other mites),
by the absence of positive reaction after challenging
10 healthy dogs (privately owned dogs not suffering
from any disease). These extracts were supplied by
Isotec Laboratories (BP 220-10 av. Ampre, F-78051,
St Quentin en Yvelines, France). In order to validate
reactions to the other extracts, two controls were also
used: a positive control (histamine phosphate 0.01%)
and a negative control (phenolated physiologic diluent).
Intradermal tests were conducted in accordance
with standard protocols,18 if necessary for nervous
animals under general anaesthetic, previously demonstrated not to interfere with intradermal testing in
dogs (atropine/tiletamine/zolazepam).18 Animals were
clipped carefully over the thorax, and injection sites
marked with indelible ink. Each allergen (0.05 mL) was
2002 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 13, 39 44
RESULTS
Epidemiological data
One hundred and fifty dogs, of various ages (average
3.8 years) and breeds, were included in the study. No
sex predilection was observed. No breed predilection
could be determined because of the lack of a reference
population.
Interpretation of skin tests
Interpretation of the skin test was possible in all cases.
No adverse reactions associated with the skin tests
were seen. No difference in reactions was seen in the
anaesthetized vs. nonanaesthetized dogs.
Positive reactions to at least one of the mites tested
were seen in 120 animals (80% of cases). No positive reactions to any mite were seen in 30 animals (20%). Results
of all positive intradermal tests are shown in Fig. 1.
Dermatophagoides farinae was the species of mite
eliciting the highest number of positive reactions: 108
dogs (72% of atopic dogs and 90% of positive dogs)
Number of
positive cases
Percentage (%)
T
A
L
G
T and A
L and A
L and G
T and L
T, A and L
T, A and G
A, L and G
T, A, L and G
5
3
0
1
13
3
1
2
6
1
6
15
9
5
0
2
23
5
2
4
11
2
11
26
41
Number of
positive cases
Percentage (%)
T
G
T and A
T and L
T, L and A
A, L and G
A, L, G and T
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
25
DISCUSSION
This study increases our understanding of house
dust mite and forage mite sensitivity in atopic dogs.
Sensitivity to these sources of allergens was extremely
common in our sample of atopic dogs. Eighty per cent
of animals tested showed at least one positive reaction
to one of these mites. This finding is in line with data in
the French literature,4,6,7 and confirms the importance
of mite sensitivity (house dust and forage) in canine
atopic dermatitis (CAD). The high incidence of positive reactions to mites in atopic dogs can probably be
explained in part by the conditions in which pet animals are kept (for example, humid flats, excessive heating, bedding).
The importance of the pyroglyphid mite, D. farinae,
was also, as expected, reaffirmed.4 7,19 This was the
source of allergens most frequently giving positive
reactions (almost 75% of cases). Ninety per cent of
dogs with positive reactions to mites were sensitive to
D. farinae. Other species were involved a lot less frequently. It is worth noting, however, that positive reactions to these other mite species were seen in over a
quarter of CAD cases, which is far from negligible.
These data are different from those published in
human allergology, in which D. pteronyssinus is the
main allergen in asthmatic patients.1,2 This difference
has not yet been explained, but may be linked to variations in epitopes between the different species of
mites, and/or between major allergens in man and dog,
as already demonstrated for D. farinae.20
Sensitivity to D. farinae alone occurred commonly,
in 62% of cases. Sensitivity to D. pteronyssinus alone
2002 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 13, 3944
42
CONCLUSION
This study increases our knowledge of environmental
allergen sensitivity patterns in the atopic dog. Results
confirm the necessity of a thorough allergy investigation, involving testing with allergenic extracts appropriate to the individual history of the patient, whenever
hyposensitization is needed. Further studies using
atopic patch tests are needed to allow the role of environmental allergens in the development of atopic dermatitis to be evaluated more fully.3134 Further studies
are also needed to determine the major allergens and
the epitopes responsible for sensitization to forage
mites, and to better appreciate the importance of crossreactions between different species of mites in the dog.
REFERENCES
1. Cousin, F., Vincent, L., Sauret, V. et al. Physiopathologie.
In: Crickx, B., ed. La Dermatite Atopique. Montrouge:
John Libbey Eurotext, 2000: 716.
2. Kanny, G. La place de lallergie dans la dermatite
atopique. In: Crickx, B., ed. La Dermatite Atopique.
Montrouge: John Libbey Eurotext, 2000: 3348.
3. Scott, D.W., Miller, W.H., Griffin, C.E. Muller and Kirks
Small Animal Dermatology, 6th edn. Philadelphia: W.B.
Saunders, 2000.
4. Prlaud, P. Allergologie Canine, 2nd edn. Paris: Masson,
1999.
5. Reedy, L.M., Miller, W.H., Willemse, T. Allergic Skin
Diseases of Dogs and Cats, 2nd edn. Philadelphia: W. B.
Saunders, 1997.
6. Carlotti, D.N., Costargent, F. Analyse statistique de tests
cutans positifs chez 449 chiens atteints de dermatite
allergique. Pratique Mdicale et Chirurgicale de lAnimal
de Compagnie, 1992; 27: 5368.
7. White, S.D., Bourdeau, P. Latopie chez le chien: donnes
actualises. Point Vtrinaire, 1995; 27: 191201.
8. Griffin, C.E. Canine atopic disease. In: Griffin, C.E.,
Rosenkrantz, W.A., McDonald, J.M., eds. Current Veterinary Dermatology. St Louis: Mosby Year Book, 1993:
99120.
9. Beltrani, V. The role of dust mites in atopic dermatitis.
Allergy Clinical Immunology International 1997; 9: 37
40.
10. Tan, B.B., Weald, D., Strickland, I. et al. Double blind
controlled trial effect of house dust mite allergen avoidance on atopic dermatitis. Lancet, 1996; 347: 1518.
11. Deblay, F., Casel, S., Mbazoa-Amougou, C. Atopie et
environnement domestique. Revue Franaise Dallergologie 2000; 40: 11018.
12. Sture, G.H. Canine atopic disease. The prevalence of
intradermal skin testing at two sites in the North and
South of Great Britain. Veterinary Immunology and
Immunopathology 1995; 44: 293308.
13. Vollset, I. Immediate type hypersensitivity in dogs
induced by storage mites. Research in Veterinary Science
1970; 40: 1237.
14. Noli, C. Spcificit de lallergie aux acariens de la
poussire de maison chez le chien. Pratique Mdicale
et Chirurgicale de lAnimal de Compagnie 1998; 33:
30514.
43
Rsum Cette tude sest intresse aux rsultats des intradermoractions avec des extraits de six acariens des
poussires ou de stockage chez 150 chiens prsentant une dermatite atopique. 120 animaux (80%) ont prsent
au moins une raction positive. Les sensibilisations Dermatophagoides farinae sont les plus frquentes (108
chiens, soit 90% des chiens positifs et 72% des chiens atopiques). Les ractions positives aux autres acariens ne
sont pas rares (respectivement 32%, 35%, 30%, 27% et 23% des chiens positifs pour Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus, Acarus siro, Tyrophagus putrescentiae, Glyciphagus domesticus et Lepidoglyphus destructor). Les monosensibilisations D. farinae sont frquentes (57% des cas), mais les polysensibilisations sont trs frquentes pour
les autres acariens. Il existe cependant des cas de monosensibilisation D. pteronyssinus (5 cas), T. putrescentiae
(1 cas) et G. domesticus (1 cas). Des tudes supplmentaires sont ncessaires pour apprcier plus prcisment
le rle jou par ces diffrentes espces dacariens dans la dermatite atopique canine.
Resumen Este estudio investig las reacciones de la prueba intradrmica a los extractos de seis especies de caros
en 150 perros con dermatitis atpica. Al menos una reaccin positiva fue detectada en 120 animales (80%). Dermatophagoides farinae fue el que produjo un nmero superior de reacciones positivas (108 perros, 90% de los perros y el 72% de los perros atpicos mostrando reacciones positivas). Las reacciones positivas a otros caros no
fueron infrecuentes, con muchos perros positivos a Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (32% de los perros testados),
Acarus siro (35%), Tyrophagus putrescentiae (30%), Glycyphagus domesticus (27%) y Lepidoglyphus destructor
(23%). La sensibilidad nicamente a D. farinae fue frecuente (57% de los casos), pero se vieron a menudo sensibilidades mltiples en los otros caros. Tambin se vieron casos de sensibilidad a un solo caro: D. pteronyssinus
(cinco casos), T. putrescentiae (un caso) y G. domesticus (un caso). Se necesitan ms estudios para apreciar con
mayor claridad el papel que juegan las diferentes especies de caro en la dermatitis atpica canina.
Zusammenfassung Diese Studie untersuchte die intradermalen Testreaktionen gegen Extrakte von 6 Milbenspezies bei 150 Hunden. Bei 120 Hunden (80%) wurde zumindest eine positive Reaktion gesehen. Dermatophagoides farinae zeigte die hchste Anzahl von positiven Reaktionen (108 Hunde, 90% der Hunde und 72% der
2002 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 13, 3944
44