Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
2014 - 2019
2014/2153(INI)
11.12.2014
DRAFT REPORT
on European Energy Security Strategy
(2014/2153(INI))
Committee on Industry, Research and Energy
Rapporteur: Algirdas Saudargas
PR\1039978EN.doc
EN
PE541.614v01-00
United in diversity
EN
PR_INI
CONTENTS
Page
MOTION FOR A EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT RESOLUTION.............................................3
EXPLANATORY STATEMENT............................................................................................12
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
2/15
having regard to the Commission communication entitled Energy efficiency and its
contribution to energy security and the 2030 framework for climate and energy policy
(COM(2014)0520),
having regard to the Commission communication entitled Short term resilience of the
European gas system. Preparedness for a possible disruption of supplies from the East
during the autumn and winter of 2014/2015 (COM (2014)0654),
having regard to the Commission communication entitled Making the Internal Energy
Market Work and the accompanying working documents (COM(2012)0663),
having regard to Regulation (EU) No 347/2013 of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 17 April 2013 on guidelines for trans-European energy infrastructure and
repealing Decision No 1364/2006/EC and amending Regulations (EC) No 713/2009,
(EC) No 714/2009 and (EC) No 715/2009,
having regard to Regulation (EU) No 1316/2013 of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 11 December 2013 establishing the Connecting Europe Facility, amending
Regulation (EU) No 913/2010 and repealing Regulations (EC) No 680/2007 and (EC)
No 67/2010,
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
3/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN
having regard to Directive 2012/27/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 25 October 2012 on energy efficiency, amending Directives 2009/125/EC and
2010/30/EU and repealing Directives 2004/8/EC and 2006/32/EC,
having regard to Directive 2009/33/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 23 April 2009 on the promotion of clean and energy-efficient road transport vehicles,
having regard to Directive 2010/31/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 19 May 2010 on the energy performance of buildings,
having regard to the report from the Commission to the European Parliament, the
Council and the European Economic and Social Committee entitled Implementation of
the Communication on Security of Energy Supply and International Cooperation and of
the Energy Council Conclusions of November 2011 (COM(2013)0638),
having regard to the report by the Council of the European Union of 12 December 2013
on the progress on the completion of the EU internal energy market in the follow-up to
the European Council of 22 May 2013,
having regard to the public hearing on the European Energy Security Strategy organised
by the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy on 5 November 2014,
having regard to the future proposal on the Energy Union, due in the first quarter of
2015,
having regard to the report of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (A80000/2014),
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
4/15
A.
whereas the EUs prosperity and security require a rational use of energy and a stable,
affordable and sustainable energy supply;
B.
whereas significant progress has been made in strengthening the EUs energy security
over the last years; whereas, however, the EU still imports 53 % of its total energy
consumption and a number of Member States are still dependent on a single external
source of supply which impedes Europes economic growth and endangers national and
EU security;
C.
whereas 61 % of gas consumed in the European Union is used in buildings and 75% of
these are residential buildings; whereas any interruptions in gas supply leading to
inadequate heating puts at risk the health and wellbeing of a large proportion of EU
citizens;
D.
whereas the EUs external energy bill represents more than EUR 1 billion per day
EUR 400 billion in 2013 and more than one fifth of total EU imports;
E.
whereas in the context of the crisis in Ukraine the issue of ensuring a reliable natural gas
supply is more important than ever;
F.
whereas from the experience of 2006 and 2009, when Russia cut off gas supply to
Ukraine, it is clear that the disruptions experienced in some of the central and eastern
European Member States evidenced the risks existing to security of energy supply;
G.
whereas the so called winter package of USD 4.6 billion was agreed on 30 October
2014 and is being implemented, securing gas supply for Ukraine and also for EU
Member States;
H.
whereas the Member States have committed themselves to the completion of the
internal energy market by 2014 and to the elimination of the EUs energy islands by
2015;
I.
whereas the Commission has drawn up the list of energy infrastructure projects of
common interest to be implemented by 2020, and the EUs multiannual financial
framework for 2014-2020 contributes to their funding under the Connecting Europe
Facility and the Investment Plan;
J.
whereas improved energy efficiency has partially decoupled economic growth from
energy consumption over the last decade, and this process needs to continue;
K.
whereas the EUs gas imports can be reduced by 2.6 % for every additional 1 % in
energy savings according to the Commission;
L.
whereas at their summit on 24 October 2014 the Heads of State and Government agreed
on a binding renewable energy target at EU level for 2030 of at least 27 % and an
indicative target at EU level of at least 27 % energy efficiency improvement, and also
endorsed a binding EU target of a reduction of at least 40 % in domestic greenhouse gas
emissions by 2030 compared to 1990;
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
5/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN
M.
whereas better interconnection levels for electricity and gas will increase energy
security while balancing supply and demand between the Member States;
N.
whereas the external dimension of EU energy policy needs more coherence and is not
yet able to contribute to playing its full role in terms of security of energy supply and
the Unions competitiveness;
O.
whereas an energy security strategy must include actions to moderate energy demand
and equally effective actions to overcome major and imminent disruptions, as well as
solidarity and coordination mechanisms to protect and strengthen energy generation,
transmission and distribution infrastructure and interconnectors; whereas this
infrastructure must be capable of handling variable renewables, and be built into a fully
integrated and well-functioning internal energy market as an essential part of an Energy
Union with diversified external supplies;
2.
Notes that equal energy security, competitiveness and sustainability in a fully integrated
energy market constitute the main pillars for the creation of an Energy Union, which
can be achieved by pooling resources, connecting networks, ensuring unified energy
market regulation and establishing unified negotiating positions vis--vis third
countries;
3.
Notes that the 2014 crisis in Ukraine and the results of the stress tests carried out by the
Commission should lead to further acceleration of the completion of the internal market,
including the integration of existing energy islands, and to the updating of risk
assessments, preventive action plans and emergency situation plans;
4.
Emphasises that, as the gas stress tests carried out by the Commission demonstrated,
particular attention needs to be paid to the most vulnerable Member States;
5.
6.
Emphasises that the Energy Union, in addition to ensuring security of supply, should
adopt a comprehensive approach focusing on key pillars such as achievement of a fully
integrated internal energy market, moderation of energy demand, decarbonisation of the
energy mix, and research and innovation;
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
6/15
INTERNAL DIMENSION
Moderating energy demand
7.
Recalls that the moderation of energy demand through energy efficiency is triply
crucial, impacting positively on the EUs energy security, competitiveness and
sustainability;
8.
Notes that the EU is not yet on track to meet its commitment of saving 20 % of energy
(371 Mtoe) by 2020, and that over one third of reduced energy consumption is actually
attributable to lower levels of economic activity;
9.
Stresses that energy demand in the building sector is responsible for about 40 % of
energy consumption in the EU and a third of natural gas use, and that it is therefore
necessary to speed up renovation of buildings in order to reduce energy demand while
encouraging greater involvement of the European Investment Bank and promoting
energy services for which EU funds can complement national financing schemes;
10.
Acknowledges that the role of local authorities of European cities in increasing energy
efficiency through cogeneration, modernisation of district heating systems, increasing
the use of cleaner public transport, encouraging more active travel models and
renovation of buildings is also undoubtedly an important contribution to energy
independence;
11.
Notes that improved vehicle performance standards and fuel efficiency are crucial for
both reducing EU oil dependency and cutting greenhouse gas emissions, and therefore
calls on the Commission to continue and accelerate its efforts in this field;
12.
13.
14.
Notes the importance of integrating the planning of energy demand and supply, in order
to achieve cost-optimal security of supply and avoid unnecessary or over-dimensioned
infrastructure investments and stranded costs;
15.
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
7/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN
Stresses that a long-term strategy for developing indigenous energy sources should be
further promoted in the EU;
17.
18.
Considers that any energy source that might contribute to energy security in the Union
should be taken into account and developed in full compliance with environmental
requirements;
19.
20.
Believes that the development of renewable energy sources with the objective of 20 %
by 2020 and at least 27 % by 2030 is essential, taking into consideration energy costs;
stresses the importance of developing smarter energy grids and new energy storage
solutions for the integration of renewables;
21.
Calls on the Commission to introduce common standards for smart grids, since they
ensure a stable supply and free flow of energy across borders and contribute to energy
security;
22.
Notes that a more decentralised energy system, with power sources being placed closer
to the point of usage, diminishes the risk of attacking vulnerable infrastructure and
simultaneously provides business opportunities for small and medium-sized enterprises;
calls on the Commission and the Member States, therefore, to facilitate further
development of local renewable energy sources and of local distribution networks;
Stresses that effective use of research and technological innovations fosters the
leadership of European industry and contributes to the main EU energy policy goals,
including security of supply, competitiveness and sustainable development of energy
production, transportation and consumption;
24.
Calls on the Member States to seek for better interaction and coordination of national
and European research programmes among themselves and with the Commission,
especially in the fields of energy and construction, in order to ensure that priority is
given to common challenges such as increasing energy efficiency and reducing
greenhouse gas emissions;
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
8/15
25.
Stresses that the commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions must not undermine
the EU economys global competitiveness; considers, therefore, that a complex
approach to climate change and competitiveness is needed;
26.
Calls on the Commission and the Member States to make full use, for the purposes of
increased energy security and the transition to a low-carbon economy, of the
possibilities allowed for financing energy projects through state aid, as well as the
financial instruments available through the European Regional Development Fund,
Horizon 2020, the European Neighbourhood Policy Instrument, and the investment
facilities of the European Investment Bank and the European Bank for Reconstruction
and Development and public and private intermediaries;
27.
28.
Calls on the Commission and the Member States to increase IT security and the
protection of strategic energy infrastructures which provide crucial services for
consumers;
Calls for the development of well-integrated and competitive regional electricity and
gas markets including, where necessary, capacity markets covering all parts of the
Union; demands that the Commission act decisively against all instances of anticompetitive behaviour and barriers to market entry and exit;
30.
Believes that one of the most important factors of the completion of a transparent, wellfunctioning and fully integrated gas and electricity market is the full implementation of
the Third Energy Package;
31.
32.
33.
Stresses the need for electricity stress tests to continue until the dependence of Member
States control of transmission systems on third countries operators is fully eliminated
and synchronous operation within the European Continental Networks is implemented;
34.
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
9/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN
35.
Calls for the Projects of Common Interest (PCI) adopted in 2013 to be executed without
delay;
36.
Stresses the need for regional cooperation to be strengthened throughout the EU, as
energy security issues can be resolved more effectively and energy can be produced and
consumed more rationally at the regional level; notes that the Baltic Energy Market
Interconnection Plan, which aims to integrate the countries of the Baltic Sea region into
the EU energy infrastructure networks, is an excellent example of regional cooperation;
37.
Emphasises that energy must be made affordable to all citizens of the EU; considers that
avoiding unnecessary consumption, efficiency improvements and sustainable energy
investment, particularly in buildings, would enable many households to escape energy
poverty;
EXTERNAL DIMENSION
Diversifying external supply
38.
Stresses that dependence on one single supplier of energy resources, with the resulting
lack of competition, can impede economic growth and endanger security at national and
EU level, and that, therefore, all projects for diversifying energy suppliers must be
implemented consistently;
39.
Stresses that the EUs energy diversification must prioritise those projects that diversify
not only routes but also sources and must meet all requirements of EU law; emphasises
that the diversification of routes must be directed towards reliable suppliers;
40.
Expresses the opinion that Russia can no longer be considered a reliable partner as it
explicitly questions EU law, including at the World Trade Organisation, and uses
energy supply for political purposes; stresses, therefore, that more attention should be
concentrated on the development and further expansion of the gas supply infrastructure
with Norway, the Southern Gas Corridor and the Mediterranean gas hub;
41.
42.
Calls on the Commission and the Member States to increase their efforts towards the
implementation of strategic energy infrastructure projects; believes the existing
infrastructure needs to contribute to regional integration;
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
10/15
43.
Affirms the overarching principle of solidarity between all Member States; stresses that
energy security of supply is a matter of collective action and concerns all Member
States, despite differing scales of vulnerability to supply shocks; stresses that no
Member State shall by its action or inaction jeopardise the security of another Member
State or of the EU as a whole;
44.
Emphasises that the Energy Community could be an effective instrument for raising
pan-European energy security; stresses that its enforcement mechanism and institutional
set-up should be further enhanced in order to strengthen investment stability; believes
the Energy Community can be useful for purposes of associating candidate countries
and potential candidates with the EU solidarity mechanisms; stresses that this should
result in a better consolidated European energy neighbourhood policy;
45.
Calls on the Member States to strengthen the legal capacities of the Energy Community
Secretariat in order to ensure swift and efficient implementation of the EU energy
acquis in the Energy Community countries; stresses the need to boost the energy
security not only of the EU, but of Europe as a whole;
46.
47.
Takes the view that the main condition for the creation of the future European Energy
Union is the completion of an integrated EU internal energy market, which requires full
implementation of the Third Energy Package and the existence of a strong external
dimension for an EU energy policy that is based on close coordination of positions and
speaking with one voice with third countries;
48.
Highlights the need to enhance the EUs ability to speak with one voice in order to
deliver a more coherent energy diplomacy in partner countries and in multilateral fora;
notes in this regard that the mandatory participation of the Commission as an observer
in negotiations for intergovernmental agreements, as well as both ex ante and ex post
evaluation of the negotiated agreements, should be required in order to minimise the
possibility of non-conformity with EU law;
49.
Fully agrees with the European Council that a reliable and transparent governance
system should be developed to help ensure that the EU meets its energy policy goals,
with the necessary flexibility for Member States and on a basis of full respect for their
freedom to determine their energy mix;
50.
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
11/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN
51.
Stresses that a regular review of the implementation of the European Energy Security
Strategy must be ensured, and that the annual progress assessment of the Strategy must
be carried out having regard to the relevant challenges to energy security; calls on the
Commission to submit annual reports on the state of play of the European Energy
Security Strategy;
52.
Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council, the Commission and the
Member States of the Energy Community.
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
12/15
EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
Introduction
The outbreak of the crisis in Ukraine has reminded the European Union of the importance of
energy security and its crucial role in confirming Europes strong political and economic
position. The vulnerability of the energy market in the context of geopolitics has made energy
policy as one of the strategic priorities in foreign affairs. Therefore, the European Union
needs to develop an energy policy based on close coordination of positions and speaking with
one voice.
The European Commission has outlined the main challenges in the energy sector in its
Communication on a European Energy Security Strategy and now there is a need of political
impulse from the European Parliament to outline the framework for an improved energy
security. The current report will also address the Commissions Communication on Energy
efficiency and its contribution to energy security and the 2030 framework for climate and
energy policy, Communication on Progress towards completing the internal energy market
and the Communication on The short term resilience of the European gas system. All these
documents reflect the current situation in the EU energy market.
Whereas there has been a significant progress towards strengthening the EUs energy security
over the last years, the EU still faces a number of challenges such as instability in regions
delivering energy, fragmented internal market and a changing climate. The EU imports 53 %
of its total energy consumption and many Members States are still dependent on a single
external source of supply which impedes Europes economic growth and endangers national
and EU security.
The Rapporteur perceives the strategy not as a short term action plan but as a long term
strategy which identifies strategic objectives in relation to Europes energy security.
Therefore the report includes actions to moderate energy demand, actions to increase
indigenous energy production and to develop energy technologies, further actions to build a
fully integrated and well-functioning internal energy market as well as solidarity and
coordination mechanisms.
A European Energy Union for European Energy Security
As the new Commission has taken office, a new concept of Energy Union is emerging and
needs to be clarified and developed. The new portfolio of the Vice-President on Energy Union
was established in order to underline the need of common energy policy. The European
Parliament should be seen as an intermediary in defining the steps towards the creation of
Energy Union. The Rapporteur believes that the European Energy Security Strategy should be
an integral part of the broader, emerging concept of Energy Union and would encourage the
new Commission to continue working in this direction.
In addition to security of supply the Energy Union should be developed following a
comprehensive approach by focusing on key pillars, such as the completion of a fully
integrated internal energy market, moderation of energy demand, decarbonisation of the
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
13/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN
energy mix and research and innovation. Energy policy based on close coordination of
positions and speaking with one voice with third countries is the basis for the existence of
Energy Union, therefore collective purchasing of gas should be considered.
Moderating energy demand
The moderation of energy demand through energy efficiency is crucial for the EUs energy
security, competitiveness and sustainability. Energy efficiency positively affects such areas as
energy supply, energy poverty, energy prices, industrial productivity, employment and
resource management. However, despite this enormous potential, the European Union is not
yet on track to meet its commitment of saving 20 % of energy by 2020. Therefore, EU should
speed up efforts to significantly enhance energy efficiency beyond 2020 as existing
instruments are not sufficient.
Local authorities of European cities could significantly contribute to energy efficiency
through cogeneration, modernisation of district heating systems, increasing the use of cleaner
public transport, encouraging more active travel models and renovation of buildings.
Increasing indigenous energy production and developing energy technologies
In order to reduce energy dependence the EU has to increase its indigenous energy production
and to develop energy technologies. It is stressed in the report that a long-term strategy is
necessary to develop indigenous energy sources within the European Union. The EU should
consider the development of any energy source that might contribute to EUs energy security.
New energy technologies could help to decrease energy dependence, to diversify and
consolidate supply options, to optimise energy network infrastructure and to increase
efficiency of energy consumption.
A well-functioning Internal Energy Market
A well-functioning internal energy market ensures the participation of different energy
suppliers which may offer reliable services at lower prices. Europe is well underway towards
the completion of the internal energy market. However, further efforts are needed to develop
interconnections and remove bottlenecks to ensure competitive and well-integrated regional
energy markets. The Rapporteur welcomes the European Councils opinion that priority
should be given to solve the problem of inadequate interconnections of Member States with
the European gas and electricity networks and to ensure synchronous operation of Member
States within the European Continental Networks. This would help to reach the target of 15 %
minimum level of interconnection between Member States. Moreover, there is an urgent need
for effective and consistent implementation and application of the provisions set out in the
Third Energy Package.
External dimension of EU energy policy
With regard to the current geopolitical situation Russia can no longer be treated as a reliable
partner as it explicitly questions EU law and uses energy for political purposes. Therefore it is
highly necessary to diversify energy routes and sources and especially to make sure that
routes are directed towards reliable suppliers.
Since regional integration is a key element for energy security the EU has to increase its
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-00</Version>
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
EN
14/15
<PathFdR>PR\1039978EN.doc</PathFdR>
00</Version>
15/15
PE<NoPE>541.614</NoPE><Version>v01-
EN