Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
22—29
Copyright ©1986 by The American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
Abstract. Sera from 48 children and adolescents (2—15years of age), residing in a malaria
holoendemic area of Liberia were investigated for specificities and isotypes of anti-P.
falciparum antibodies. No clear-cut relationship to the development of clinical immunity
was found when the overall antibody activities to total parasite antigens were determined
by enzyme-linkedimmunosorbent assay(ELISA).Although therewas a certainriseof
1gM, total IgG- and IgG2 antibody activities, this was most pronounced at ages when a
clinical but nonsterile immunity is already present. When the sera were investigated by
immunoprecipitation of 35S-methionine labeled parasite polypeptides, the total number of
parasite antigens precipitated was similar at all ages. Analysis by indirect immunofluores
cence (IFA), registering antibodies to intracellular parasite antigens, revealed no age
dependent changes in antibody titers. In contrast, when the sera were assayed by a novel
IFA, specific for a restricted number of parasite antigens in the membrane of infected
erythrocytes, the frequency of positive sera as well as the anti-P. fakiparum titers rose in
parallel with the development of clinical immunity. Thus, theseantigensappearedto be
important inducers of protective immune responses and may be suitable candidates for a
vaccineagainsttheasexualblood stagesof P.fakiparum.
In highly endemic malarious areas, a relative ical immunity (age, spleen size, parasite densities)
clinical immunity is normally acquired by the with the occurrence of antibodies of different iso
age of 5 years and severe malaria becomes less types or P. fakiparum specificities. Sera from 48
frequent. A fully developed but nonsterile im children or adolescents, aged 2—15 years and
munity is generally present by 10 years of age living in a holoendemic area of Liberia, were
and Plasmodium fakiparum malariaisusually assayed for anti -P.fakiparum antibodies by sev
kept at subpatent levels in adults. Serum anti eral different methods. Using a novel immuno
bodies isolated from immune donors living in fluorescence assay,@'7 we found a positive cor
The Gambia have a protective capacity when relation between the development of clinical
injected into children acutely infected with P. immunity and the appearance of antibodies di
fakiparum.―2 Similarly, passive transfer of an rected against P. fakiparum antigens in the
tibody via the placenta has been suggested to membrane of infected erythrocytes.
protect newborns against the disease.3
Dissection by recently developed techniques
of the humoral response in clinically immune MATERIALS AND METHODS
individuals ascompared tothatinnonimmunes
Parasites
may be expected to provide further insights in
the protective capacities of different anti-P. fal The Tanzanian strain F32 ofPlasmodiumfal
ciparum antibodies. In this study we have at ciparum, isolated in 1978, was used for all the
tempted to correlate different parameters of din tests. The parasites were cultivated in red blood
cells (RBC), blood group 0, at a hematocrit of
Accepted 3 July 1985. 5%.
22
ANTI-P. FALCIPARUMANTIBODIESAND CLINICALIMMUNITY 23
Immunoprecipitation
ofparasiteantigens
Anti-P.falciparumELISA
Ring stage dominated P. fakiparum cultures
A trophozoite-schizont-enriched antigen frac were labeled until late schizont stage with 355W
tion, obtained by centrifugation on a Percoll gra methionine, solubilized and precipitated with 10
dient, was used as antigen as described previ @dundiluted test serum and a polyvalent rabbit
ously.9 For post-coating, plates were incubated anti-human immunoglobulin serum. The precip
5 hr at room temperaturewith 0.25% gelatin itated antigen antibody complexes were analyzed
instead of 2% bovine serum albumin as this fur by sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel
ther decreased the background. All sera were electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) under reducing
tested at dilutions 1:1,000, 1:5,000 and 1:25,000. conditions and fluorographed.'2
1gM antibodies were assayed with a goat anti
human 1gM preparation conjugated with alkaline
phosphatase (ALP) (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Statistical analysis
Louis, Missouri). IgG antibodies were assayed
with ALP-conjugated rabbit antibodies specific Spearman's rank correlation test was used. P
for the Fc fragment of human immunoglobulin values >0.05 were considered insignificant.
24 WAHLGRENET AL
A low.There
was
asignificant
increase
in1gManti
P.fakiparum activity with increasing age (r=
2.0
0.66, P = 8.9 x l06). IgG antibodies to P. fal
ciparum were present in all 48 sera. There was
1.5 also an age-dependent increase in antibody ac
o tivity but the statistical significance of this cor
relation was less pronounced (r = 0.38, P = 1.1 x
1.0
10_2; Fig. lB).
0 8 C@@O IgG1and IgG3antibodies'°
werepresentin al
0.5 00 o most all sera (46/48 and 47/48, respectively) and
o showed a similar rise with age as the total IgG
c&@@
antibodies. However, this age correlation was not
5 lo 15 statisticallysignificant(r = 0.27,P = 7.5 x 10-2
YEARS for IgG, and r = 0.28, P = 6.0 x 10-2 for IgG3,
respectively). In contrast, IgG2 antibodies which
>2.0 were detectable in 75% of the samples (29/38;
10 samples excluded because of lack of serum)
2.0
rose with age similarly to what was seen for 1gM
(r= 0.69,P = 3.6 x l0@).IgG4 antibodies were
1.5 present in 50% of the samples available for test
0
0 0 O ing(18/38). Elevated activities were seen in some
0
1.0 0 0 O children younger than 4 years as well as in some
08 o 0 O 8 adolescents, and there was no increase with age
0 O 0
@ 00 o O (r=0.l3,P=4.6 x 10').
O 0 ° @o8
0.5 In individual donors, there was no correlation
00 o8
0 0 between parasite densities and the 0D405 for total
IgG, IgG,, IgG3 and IgG4 antibodies, respective
5 10 15 ly. However, a weak negative correlation was
YEARS
found for 1gM and IgG2 (r = 0.243; r = 0.246,
FIGURE 1. ELISA values of sera (diluted 1/1,000; respectively).
ordinate 0D@5) of children and adolescents (abscissa,
age in years) in the P.fakiparum ELISA. A. 1gM reac
tivity; B. IgG reactivity. Immunoprecipitation of355-methionine-labeled
P. falciparum polypeptides
RESULTS
To establish whether or not there was a major
ELISA difference in the antigens recognized by the anti
P. fakiparum antibodiesoccurringat different
Allvaluesareexpressedasthetestvalueminus ages, serum samples were reacted with 35S-me
background (i.e., incubation buffer). The 0D@5 thion.ine-labeled parasite extracts, precipitated
for sera of healthy Swedish blood donors at the with rabbit anti-human immunoglobulin and
dilutions presented varied between 0—0.05(1gM, subjected to SDS-PAGE and autofluorography.
IgG), 0—0.075 (IgG,, IgG3, IgG4) and 0—0.1for The results of a representative experiment are
IgG2. shown in Figure 2. In general, all sera precipi
tated some 20 parasite derived polypeptides of
Antibodyisotypes different apparent molecular weights. The major
antigens seen were of M@195,000 d, 150,000 d,
1gM antibodies9 were present in 42/48 sera 140,000 d, 129,000 d, 118,000 d, 90,000 d,
tested (0D405 > 0.1). Figure 1 shows the age 80,000 d and 50,000 d, respectively. Antibodies
dependent changes of these antibodies at serum to these antigens were present at all ages
dilutions of 1:1,000. Similar results were ob between 2—12years and there was no signif
tained when the sera were tested at dilutions of icant age-dependent difference in the intensity of
1:5,000 or 1:25,000 although the readings ob the signals seen on the fluorographs. Identical
mined at these dilutions were frequently rather banding patterns but slightly stronger signals were
@
YEARS
t2: ,@5
12 IC
@
195@
@
‘iì!'-@t3 @;;@6
;4@9 -r
@,,
129,,...
118
V ‘
5
obtained with the sera from the 8 adolescent boys, the adolescent sera these titers were very high
aged 15 years (not shown). However, as seen (Fig. 3). Furthermore, for the 43 donors inves
from Figure 2, the frequency of sera having a tigated, there was a significant negative correla
generally reduced activity in this test was higher tion between parasitemia and antibody titers in
in the younger age groups than in the 8—12-year this assay (r = 0.43, P = 6.9 x l0@). As seen
old children. from Figure 4, parasite densities > 100/mm3
blood were rarely found in donors whose anti
Antibodies to P. falciparum antigens in the body titers were >1:80 and none or very few
membrane of inftcted erythrocytes parasites were found in donors of high titered
sera. In addition, children with elevated anti
With sera diluted 1:20, this test detects an body titers to the parasite antigens in the eryth
tibodies against parasite antigens in the mem rocyte surface rarely had enlarged spleens. Rath
brane of infected erythrocytes, primarily those er, spleen size appeared to be negatively correlated
containing ring stages and early trophozoites. The to antibody titer. The proportion of positive sera
predominant antibody recognizes an antigen of ( 1:20) as a function of spleen size according to
Mr 155,000 d. Intraerythrocytic parasites or non Hackett is shown in Figure 5.
infected erythrocytes are not stained.4'5
The frequency of sera giving positive immu Antibodies to intracellular parasites
nofluorescence in this test rose significantly with
age. Thus, for the 43 sera available, the propor These were assayed in an IFA using parasitized
tion of positive sera (at dilutions 1:20) was erythrocytes as above but without fixation. All
29%, 50% and 88% in the age groups 2—5,6—9 43 sera tested contained parasite staining anti
and 10-15 years, respectively. The frequency of bodies with titers ranging from 1:320 to >1:
positive sera from Liberian adults from the same 10,240. However, there was no age-dependent
areas is also approximately 90%.@ The endpoint change in antibody levels (Figure 3). Moreover,
titers of the test sera also showed a significant there was no age-dependent correlation between
age-dependent increase (43 sera available for parasitemia and antibody titers, or between the
testing, r = 0.56, P = 2.2 x l0@). In some of latter and spleen size (data not shown).
26 WAHLGRENET AL
>1024C A
p2560 0
5120
0
1280 0 0 0 128( 0
0 00 8 0
320 320
00 00 00
000 00 0
80 0 0
0 80 0 0
20 0 000 0 0
Neg CO 000 0 000000 00 20 0 000 0
5 10 15 Neg 0000 @CO0 0 =
YEARS
100 io2
>10240 0 00
B
FIGURE 4. Relationship between reciprocal IFA ti
00
5210 00000 00000 0 ters (ordinate) to GA-fixed and air dried infected RBC
000 00 00 0 00 00 and parasite densities (abscissa, number of parasites!
1280 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 mm3 of blood).
00 0 0
320 0 0
This antigen is poor in methionine and therefore Vaccines. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold
not detected in immunoprecipitation experi Spring Harbor.
7. Franzén,L., and Wahlgren, M., 1985. Malaria
ments performed with 35S-methionine-labeled diagnosis: Parasitological and serological tests.
parasite extracts.5'6 In this respect it resembles PostgraduateDoctor, 8: 386—392.
the heat stable S-antigens described by other in 8. Bjorkman, A., Hedman, P., Brohult, J., Willcox,
vestigators.24 However, it appears to lack the ma M., Diamant, I., Pehrsson, P. 0., Rombo, L.,
jor serological variation characteristic for these and Bengtsson, E., 1985. Different malaria con
trol activities in an area of Liberia. Effects on
parasite components.6 malariometric parameters. Ann. Trop. Med.
The relevance of these parasite antigen(s) for Parasit., 79: 239—246.
in vivo protection against P. fakiparum malaria 9. Wahlgren, M., Berzins, K., Perlmann, P., and
is supported by the present findings showing both Björkman, A., 1983. Characterization of the
a marked increase in the frequency of antibody humoral immune response in Plasmodium fa/
ciparum malaria. I. Estimation of antibodies to
containing sera and antibody titers in parallel P. fakiparum or human erythrocytes by means
with the acquisition of clinical immunity. Do of micro ELISA. C/in.Exp. ImmunoL, 53: 127-
nors whose sera contained elevated levels of an 134.
tibodies to these antigens consistently had low 10.Wahlgren,M., Berzins, K., Perlmann,P.,and
Persson, M., 1983. Characterization of the hu
parasite counts and spleens of small or moder moral immune response in P/osmodiumfakip
ately enlarged size, suggesting that their immune arum malaria. II. IgG subclass levels of anti P.
system successfully handled the malaria pressure fa/ciparum antibodies in different sera. C/in.
to which they were exposed.'3 Taken together Exp. ImmunoL, 54: 135—142.
11. Lundgren, K., Wahlgren, M., Berzins, K., Troye
with previous findings@―8these results suggest Blomberg,M., Perlmann, H., and Perlmann, P.,
that P1' 155 and possibly other parasite antigens 1983. Monoclonal, parasite and anti RBC an
in the membrane of infected erythrocytes may tibodies produced by stable EBV-transformed B
be considered as prime candidates for a vaccine cell lines from malaria patients. /. Immunol,,
131: 2000—2003.
against the asexual blood stages of P.fakiparum.
12. Holder, A. A., and Freeman, R. R., 1982. Bio
synthesis and processing of a P/asmodium fa/
ciparum schizont antigen recognized by im
mune serum and a monoclonalantibody. J. Exp.
REFERENCES Med., 156: 1528—1538.
13. Bjorkman, A. Holoendemic malaria and the ef
1.Cohen,S.,McGregor,I.A.,andCarrington,
S.P., fects of chemotherapy, 1985. Thesis, Karolinska
1961. Gamma-globulin and acquired immu Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
nity to human malaria. Nature, 192: 733—737. 14. Jayawardena, A. N., 1981. Immune responses in
2. McGregor, I. A., Carrington, S. P., and Cohen, S., malaria. Pages 85—136 in J. M. Mansfield, ed.,
1963.TreatmentofEastAfrican P.fakiparum Parasitic Diseases, Volume 1. Marcel Dekker
with West African-globulin. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Inc., New York.
Med. Hyg., 57: 170—179. 15. Spiegelberg,H. L., 1974. Biologicalactivities of
3. Edozien, J. C., Gilles, H. M., and Udeozo, I. 0. immunoglobulins of different classes and sub
K., 1962. Adult and cord blood gamma-glob classes. Adv. Immuno/., 19: 259—294.
ulin and immunity to malaria in Nigerians. 16. Morell, A., Skvaril, F., Hitzig, W. H., and Bar
Lancet, 2: 95 1—955. andun, S., 1972. IgG subclasses:Development
4. Perlmann, H., and Wahlgren, M., 1983. IgG-an of the serum concentrations in normal infants
tibodies specific for the altered surface of P/as and children. J. Pediatr., 80: 960—964.
modium fakiparum malaria infected erythro 17. Yount, W. J., Donner, M. M., Kunkel, H. G., and
cytes. Scand. J. Immunol.. 18: 71. Kabat, E. A., 1968. Studies on human anti
5. Perlmann, H., Berzins,K., WahlgrenM., Carlsson, bodies. VI. Selectivevariation in subgroup com
J., Björkman,A., Patarroyo, M. E., and Perl position and geneticmarkers. J. Exp. Med., 127:
mann, P., 1984. Antibodies in malarial sera to 633—646.
antigens in the membrane of erythrocytes in 18. Wâhlin,B., Wahlgren, M., Perlmann, H., Berzins,
fected with early asexual blood stages of P/as K., Björkman,A., Patarroyo, M. E., and Perl
modiumfalciparum. J. Exp. Med., 159: 1686- mann, P., 1984. Human antibodies to a M@
1704. 155,000 P/asmodium fakiparum antigen effi
6. Wahlgren, M.,Berzins, K.,Perlmann, H.,Wâh!in, ciently inhibit merozoite invasion. Proc. NatL
B., Carlsson, J., Björkman,A., Perlmann, P., Acad. Sci. USA, 81: 7912—7916.
McNicols, L-A., Dame, J. B., and McCutchan, 19. Voller, A., and O'Neill, P., 1975. Immunofluo
T. F., 1985. Pf 155, a vaccine candidate for rescence method suitable for large-scale appli
protection against asexual stages of Plasmodium cation to malaria. BulL W.H.O., 45: 524—529.
falciparum malaria. Pages 5 1-56 in R. Lerner 20. Draper, C. C., Leiijveld, J. L. M., Matola, Y. G.,
and R. Chanock, Eds., Modern Approaches to and White, 0. B., 1972. Malaria in the Pare
ANTI-P. FALCIPARUM ANTIBODIES AND CLINICAL IMMUNITY 29
area of Tanzania. IV. Malaria in the human pop mune response to malaria before, during and
ulation 11 years after the suspension of residual after the application of control measures: A lon
insecticide spraying, with special reference to the gitudinal study in the West African savanna.
serological findings. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. BulL W.H.O., 56: 579—600.
Hyg., 66: 905—912. 23. Perkins, M., 1984. Surface proteins of Pla.smo
21. McGregor, I. A., Williams, K., Voller, A., and diumfalciparum merozoite binding to the eryth
Billewicz, W. Z., 1965. Immunofluorescenceand rocyte receptor, glycophorin. J. Exp. Med., 159:
the measurement of immune response to hy 788—789.
perendemic malaria. Trans. R. Soc. Trop.Med. 24. Wilson, R. J. M., McGregor, I. A., Hall, P., Wil
Hyg., 59: 395—414. liams, K., and Bartholomew, R., 1969. Anti
22. Comille-Brögger, R., Mathews, H. M., Storey, J., gens associated with Plasmodium fakiparum
Ashkar, T. S., Brögger,S., and Molineaux, L., infections in man. Lancet, 1: 20 1—205.
1978. Changing patterns in the humoral im