Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Hegeler Institute is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Monist.
http://www.jstor.org
FACTSANDMENTALSYMBOLS.
from Dr.
IPERCEIVE
Vol.
I of The Monist,
a material
endeavors
important
question
difference
exists
opinion
character.
of special
As
us
between
I was
not
on
an
successful
in
to assume
ion
is merely
(1863), which
one.
The
and
apparent
that
supposition
can
be
adjusted
our
by
difference
a
precise
and
of opin
agreement
in question
I must
subsequently
to one
another
in the
same
person.
No more
"body,"
"matter,"
Objects
gated.
the inviolability
"atom,"
were
etc.,
were
come
by,
was
not
investi
of which
given
and with which
labors.
that
deed,
two
the
way, however,
MENTAL
AND
FACTS
were
departments
appeared
SYMBOLS.
an
I99
in some
connected
insoluble
riddle ; as
The
way.
to
it yet appears
Dubois-Reymond.
and
into
them
put
consistent
connection
the view
one
with
another.
that Nature
to arrive
our
the artificial
conception.
assumes
knowledge
monistic
supportable
It is unnecessary
place
in
these
monadic
theories
as
contradistin
guished from the facts that deserve knowledge, and how poorly such
As a fact, em
theories satisfy in the long run a vigorous mind.
with
ployment
this
soon
effected
very
latently
present.*
* A Greek
percussion
cumbrous
the
appearance
was
in my
of my
better
artifice
case
the means
conviction,
that
already
were
philosopher
knowledge,
it be in a modified
to the motion
of
contention
that in physics everything can be reduced
than improper draft on the future.
is, taken at its best, a more
particles
to the solution of burning special ques
Utterances
of this kind afford no assistance
value as the utter
tions, but only confound, and have about the same explanatory
The
tation.
smallest
ances
philosophy
of Oken which
prescribe
for example
with
the
THE
200
MONIST.
with
follow
(a fluid)
the
This
same
idea
of conduction
phenomena
compensation.
established
of a constant
Black's
and
who
that passes
quantity
successors
of heat-substance
prevented
on
no
They
every savage knows, that heat isproduced
follows
by friction. By the help of his undulatory theory Huygens
of the reflexion and refraction of light.
with ease the phenomena
the factwhich
longer mark
The
The
the other hand, undisturbed by theories, perceives at once.
on
a
at
conductors
with
distance
charged
conception of fluids acting
electricity facilitates our view of the behavior of the objects charged,
but it stood in the ivay of the discovery of the specific inductive ca
pacity, which was reserved for the eye of Faraday undimmed by
any
traditional
theories.
a division of zero-quantities
greatest ease the course of the creation of the world by
a and ? a (o= 4- a ? a).
into +
indeed appear simpler at first
The motion
of a single body as a totality does
of attempts at a physical
other
than
any
process, and this is the justification
glance
monadic
monadic
on which
of a motive
and of an
illusion
similar
to that
for a moment
are
us assume
endowed
very near
physical
with
to my present
considerations.
one, aside
rejects meta
FACTS
AND
MENTAL
20I
SYMBOLS.
nevertheless,
our
own
same
conceptions
lead
demonstrate,
experience
as
may,
us
classical
astray.
and
examples
For
theory,
in
Only
theoretical
Then
facts,
conception
the theoretical
of which
conical
further
conception
refraction,
than
may
circular
between
we
ourselves
a fact and
postulate.
its
and
of new
Hertz's
electric waves
and
sines
Every
THE
202
MONIST.
=
as a kind of geometrical model that imitates inform
sin^/sin/?
In this sense,
the refraction of light and takes itsplace in our mind.
elec
I take it, all the theoretical conceptions of physics?caloric,
molecules,
light-waves,
tricity,
atoms,
and
energy?must
be
regarded
cised
the
from
facts
themselves.
to me, how
instances were not lacking that demonstrated
was
was
which
much greater the confusion
produced by the direct
transference of theories, methods, and inquiries that were legitimate
But
in physics,
eye,
notices
problem
point
The
entire theory of the psychological
space-sensations.
world by the projection of sensations out
origin of the "external"
is founded in my opinion on a mistaken transference of a
wards
nate
FACTS
AND
MENTAL
SYMBOLS.
203
solved.
unconsciously
sation.
be
so
perceived.
I have chosen
as
render
it clear
what
confusion
unnecessary
or mode
in one
serviceable
domain,
into
examples,
is caused
by
the
of thought which
such
care
is valid
another.
I read re
ethnographer
"This
tribe of people deeply de
cently the following sentence:
of
cannibalism."
the
itself
practise
By its side lay the
by
graded
same
an
The
book of
subject.
English
inquirer who deals with the
In the work
of a celebrated German
islanders eat
latter simply puts the question why certain South-Sea
human beings, finds out in the course of his inquiries that our own
ancestors
also
were
once
cannibals,
and
comes
to
understand
the
THE
maxim
MONIST.
of the ethnographer
lustre of unprepossession
by which we
; but
in the mouth
so gladly discover
the true inquirer. But a step further and we will say, " Man must
not be descended
from monkeys/'
"The
earth shall not rotate,"
<(Matter
not
to
fill
space," "Energy must be con
ought
everywhere
I believe that our procedure differs from that
stant," and so on.
and noble
ourselves.
And what
result of research
is there that
new
situation.
unnecessary
one.
The
way
it has
arisen
is
to
analogous
that
in
which
example, when
I establish
current of
Amp?re develops
10^ cubic centimetres oxyhydrogen gas at oQ C.
mm
and 760
mercury pressure in a minute, I am easily disposed to
attribute to the objects defined a reality wholly independent of my
sensations.
But
termined to conduct
definite measured
trial magnetism
being given, shall turn the magnetic
centre a certain angular distance out of the meridian.
sity of terrestrial magnetism must have been disclosed
needle
The
at its
inten
by a definite
AND
FACTS
MENTAL
SYMBOLS.
205
is no
gas
oxyhydrogen
less
intricate.
The
whole
statement,
so
sim
C . .
by A
fact rests therefore on such a connection.
elements?elements
sense
I denote
that
no
further
resolution
has
much
neither
console
me
before
nor
deceive
me
with
respect
to my
ignorance.
there was
Long
ceived that the behavior
ences
THE
the
sensation
This
green.
MONIST.
can
last
actually
from
is produced
thing
chemical
as
appear
something
processes,
currents,
clear
addition
described
yellow (E) of a sodium flame takes the place of the sun, the green
If the chlorophyl granules be re
(A) will pass into brown (E).
moved,?an
operation
ments,?the
are physical
certain
representable
like
the
preceding
one
by
ele
process
on my
retina.
There
is
nothing
to prevent
me
in
* The
: To what kind of nervous processes
is
following is a legitimate question
can be solved only by
added.
the sensation green to be mentally
Such questions
inquiry, and not by a reference in a general way to motion and electric cur
special
our remaining
rents.
How disadvantageous
satisfied with such general conceptions
is, can be seen from the fact that inquirers have been repeatedly on the brink of
we have made,
the specific energies, one of the greatest acquisitions
abandoning
to discover
any difference in the currents of dif
they were unable
simply because
as early as 1863 in my lectures on psycho
I was impelled
ferent sensory nerves.
to call attention
physics
can conceal
themselves
kinds of nervous
processes
in relief
and places
but one feature of the process?the
of energy though a transverse section.
passage
A current in diluted sulphuric acid is something entirely different from a current in
copper. We must therefore also expect that a current in the acoustic nerve is some
thing entirely
different
in a current.
from a current
Current
is an abstraction
AND
FACTS
from physically
principle
in exactly
from
same
the
MENTAL
as
cases
in the
X
207
on my own eye
this process
investigating
manner
it to its elements
reducing
SYMBOLS.
set
previously
. . . If this were
Y Z.
and
forth,
not
possible
element,
physical
The
in
Now
vestigations.
its
its
our.
to
attention
on X
dependence
C D
. . . it
Y Z
the
one
or
to
the
other
form
of
identity.
simply
is a
., A
is
sensation.
rect
upon
dependence
the
sensory
of my
sphere
dependence.
no duality, but
consciousness
every
conviction
session
everywhere
sensation
of
portion
there
this
The
to physical
physicist
bodies
no
only,
it
him,
is true,
must
be
the second
is given,
which
something
sensa
from
different
;
the
from
sensation
physical
prepossession
sensations
accepts
psychologist
I find
says:
diferent
entirely
it a mysterious
prepos
physical
The
something
To
to
of
But what
Physis
pear
Or
be
declaration.
corresponds
conformably
tion.
must
of
transference
the motions
I deal with.
objects
the
of psychology.
and
therefore
physical
but
from
solely
so,
does
it is now
the whole
I believe
ignated
for me
they
siderations
* It
B
can
which
is the
them as mere
one
C.
latter
. . are
never
are
transitoriness
appearances
is the
all based
For
and
be
is intangible.
that
fallacious
me
the
case
that so easily
permanent
hodies.
by
their
the body
11nn f(A
and
any
con
existence.*
leads us
I have
des
given,
away
on
circle
elements
indubitably
volatilised
in every
with
other
on
rest
of sense-perceptions
as contrasted
the
case.
immediately
afterwards
after
now
and
involved
reasoning
the
that
by A
the
to regard
repeatedly
that per
of sight
of illu
in space, temperature,
and so forth. The supposed
of
constancy
position
. . or the constancy of the
is the constancy of the union of A, B, C.
egua
B,R C.\
the
monist.
To
of A
relations
. ?. .
remain
only
to
be
ascertained.
This
.)
o.
orientation
negative
restrict
myself,
moreover
for
the
avoidance
intentionally
here,
of
pseudo-problems.
to the question
of
research
Mach.
sense