Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
AD NUMBER
AD009708
CLASSIFICATION CHANGES
TO:
unclassified
FROM:
confidential
LIMITATION CHANGES
TO:
Approved for public release,
unlimited
distribution
FROM:
Controlling DoD Organization... Naval
Ordnance Systems Command, Washington,
DC.
AUTHORITY
USNOL ltr,
1974
29 Aug
UNCLTASSIFIfED
DIR 52-00.10
"UCLASSIFIED
DISCLAIMER NOTICE
THIS DOCUMENT IS BEST QUALITY
PRACTICABLE. THE COPY FURNISHED
TO DTIC CONTAINED A SIGNIFICANT
Reproduced
...
6.
..
Jy
1~$N(LIZ!!
~~~
_~
,,
.
!/,,
....
.v
7x,
Fir
"......'.
g.
'
a"
!At
Sf/
-,
.*~.
' .
.''
i$.s#
"
I8,
0,
#..
"
.
.t"p.~
.!);"
+T
'a'.b
...
**
..
..
'V
'-
-.
..
-e"'
'
.4
r
A
T~~1~T
T1~ !T~E
C.JX.LOSIVES
Ft).1-
-IJ
.7
'ASC01OiNT
AIN 0 LAST
SECU"Y INFORMATION
Ott
:"
.i
Report 2r53
WORD91
Ti-- EFc'CT OF
S. _Vr,.iL CASE ON T 'rm AIR BLAST
FROM HIGH EXPLOSIVES
Prepared
E.
by:
M. Fisher
Approved by:
ABSTRACT:
C. J. Aronson
Deputy Chief,
Explosion Effects Division
Research Laboratories
hae been revised
new more
theoretical
reasolnso an t-by give
and experimental considerations
able predictions of the air blast from ,teel cased charges.
W'., I +U I
W'W
where
in the ratio of the bare charge equivalent weight
to the actual charge weight and M is the ease to charge
Sweight ratio; M' is equal to r for all weapons with a-metal
jof
pulse.
To obtain results that correlate with peak pressure
the right side of the above rormula is multiplied by 1.19.
Explosives
NAVAL Research
ORDNANCE Department
LABORATORY
White Oak, Maryland
SU.S.
CONPIMNTIAL
SECURITY INFORMATION
--
---
:,S'.-:
,,:
!,
'0 '"
.. -rI
*.
19 Februar-I 1953
"
oatop.eted,
and
pres4ents rivised equations based on both experimental
moro casodoaonable
asteel
enable
which
weapons.
con~idarition=
from
pav~amteterz
theoretical
blait
air
of
Srodlotionz
This worrk was performed urdor NOL task Re2c-2l.
L I
EUIARD L. WOODYARD
Captain, USN
Comman.nder
By direction
CONFIDMTI'AL
SECURITY IIfORMATION
-.
--
INFORNIATION
-SECURITY
HV
CONFI"DENTIAL
page
Introduction
Derivatio;1
0.i
,with
PAo*Formula
and CoMrpar*Io
of Rles"Ib3
Epiiet.
.
.. on .
il
Derivation cf Ne
nula
of Resu.tc withE.iperinent
..
J,
Figure 2.
Weapons ....
Figure 1.
-
*i
4.
Figure 5.
I,'Lor
"7
PiFgure 1.
SCased
11
ComparisonZ
...
IILLUVi'RATIONS
: j
~i
.C.......u...
! i
II
IVu
Figre.
..
1. 1~ach
Pigurv
1Fitu.
9.
..
12
13
.1
15
'
. 16
19
"
bTNTWeapons
Table 11
11
18
Region .
. ..
. . .4.4.17
Radial Distance for Cast TNT in Far
F
8.
Table I
10
CONT IDINTIAL
,,ECVRI 'Y INPORMATION
i.
.1......C
.. 6
IAL
N, I W
...
.,,
...... . .,
***tO*r
* fl~~1
MAT~O~
I
*
1.
~a:,.i
~hm
*I
4
~iwt,;O~1
orcti o
IRTHODUM.rIOM
:',
hi.
audn~
n cnsl
eir.
M~avlor
ti'i
~
o.dz:~i
r~cojw-.r7' th.,Lt tJM
tor. no L'ater
!vy
hv~E
.rA uitmri4 the case is
%A~da, th~s.)
oIZ4 %'."
010o
:apon preducets air blast. The
awiunt of this air' bleat ahould b3 I-.%o~n for the o
ua'iuut4n
of the value of tha wd;aoon Lai or.-4-,)rison vtiti ch~
of dir*rerent dmeAn P-d in t!-.'
of a w-aoe'?73 a ua
Iag~iit
a srp.*Oiflo tar7,t.
t)v2u-s
~~2.
it
43 vilopjL
Feuo In ref-crne
(a)
on
~hbi:%
"
iof
v1
rw
ex.
~.~
E~.ULTS WITH~~*
rodc
ac aOtekYoi n
SECUITYINFORMATION
40
01
CO TDoEhNTIAL
NAvoaZ Report 2753
" "
c~lfl~~lc~end cha~ria
V i
16
It
t'nd
.,r
(1),
outnen,,jrW
tinGoia,3
See"Ykinctia
enery, o
king
t5 .on
j 2 to the total klnetia
tsI
be
fr.ction
tne to
fra,;~e~nt3
ooltei.
Into
-ano thu
of the total
(2)
C
belonging to the
kinetic ens-rgy
The fraction of the burat
is thus
has
case
the
after
1
Sl
-
I--
sismo
(3)
the fraction of
This was ,.ult:L.2ed, by 1.8 to account for the
case
and The
gasea
to
bal.rninS
cnerry
case.
the total detonation
the
of
rupture
of
at the tim-a
as kirtatic
ennry
uf
the blast.
W1, relative
to tho
w0
9
.8
+-
was
The above equation herein referred to as Pano's formulathe
checked roughly in reference (a) by showing that when
distanceu from all types of bombs are. reduced by the oube
2
CONFIDENTIAL
"SECURITY INFORMATION-
S-"l
_ - ..
40P
."-
Cry ?YZI'TIAL
NAVQ3;. )Vti...rt n753
data
p1.
The : W13 !7rund to b4 tru-3 for pcLt~
V~o1aluc al well ad thO diIA-Wilce
when tj-j ro:!it!.va iz
tl-- r-ruc'd by
tvlith the
and I1,
Pvv
p4
st:*n i
1W
Ii
______
0.8
71(Peno roznaula)
1W
I
Experimental
work
and Scal4
n;, Laws
___________
I1&-11
Purpose
Bombs
.3
____
1.09
1xb 0.9k
0.58
peak Pressure
Positive InpuQlse
09
Positive Impulce
0._________
*;-
NAVORLReort 2753
tI
7.in the Nevn1 Ordnance
c)
experlmonft, r-efer~ncO
brOy~IO-UAOtn'
jis calu.acc(
to bo 0.31
hchI
0.91
prr'rS
for ponit~ve IinpuIse and 1.C)3 tor
ojii8ijhe6~10.1~~
,3,AO
~bl.ed
g,%)olo
e'Loae to Ceju1. of
(iota,
M1~,
rd~ola
p~ p-~Ju~-..ad CZ1C1
:;teel cn"e-Lrc
the
611c"'
t--nc',Bto
dm
rThls
II.
I en~d
for i{zc-1 is
ivapons8.
- eo'v1ting In close
An equation was dev.eloped for
~ei"rzl aust1.ptie
by
ri~i.'nt
expa
sare;etwitn
the tiT- of rup8
thst nearly all tha eas aolecules
ttn
wi-tt%a
shall
cylindrical
a
In
travel
cr..e
the
ture of
~d aQG.PMile
7 eq~ual to the 1-r !r/"Ilt V&:-OcitzT.
equati.on
enargy
kinetic
tho
tion vaj T.At into e'quatn
becesoa
atthe tima or rupture
S.
*
11vel.o'-Ity
X .2
whic
yi-lde
waed7,h
bar
a W
MV+.8
chrg
toratak
yexpeivaente
cng
1.of:~r!S
ratta
0.50
+
II
*.V_
M ea
.2
n.
...
*9.
it
by
~ W1.3city, V
Ii
Ii
C:'n;'-GO
to ci-00
Riti,
VS/o0.
C
,T n
38
~
3oi-lw, a .Prjlue for E, total k1*rvtic emr:y
~'~~ nts :.rAd exp1oalon producta at th~e t14.2 of rutura, of
Ut ~j9 :59 1tOr'VJ ;r -r.'3 or 53 por cent :X the tot-,IJ 2jtsnho
-. ::
If
-1-
t:1i-3
0.4
0?tc
Purpo~tj
.8
with Scnl.i--nta
Ln
ultei
(1o3U
1
0,81
Piercing_
In aqu~-
(7)
067eipna
Equntluat(7)n M)
1UO-
cant 13 uvo
0.93
___~
ArmoU
of 53 Pr-
+ 0.53
of ouation (7))
! 678
Wo053rek
anttscaling Law1
(10.9 M')-
0.07
Pi!
~~
01
rCOWTVIPENTAL
UAVORD Repo'rt 2753
Ol' is
Sis
values Of
For all
ch!-re 'welght ratio leas than ore.
For example, M'
ti3n one uue M' equal to one.
'tt
equnl to 0.23 for light CM.ed wean;os3and o-,e for ivemi
?'ultiply equation (8) by 1.19 to
ai-.or piercins weons.
This in eas*ence Implies that
for peak pres3ure.
ottain
the percentaie of detcnatlon er.vgy ccnvort,!d Into kinptic
ener=y is .i-ectly proportional to the percentaga of r.ctal
an ratio or one or Srdator,
hcavin
t-u. to a
Sw
The tzble below 3ho'1,s the 8grraement or aquu'ion (8) with
valoes obt3lned from e:,cri,#Pnt and the scaling laws.
SCthe
.~,
Work
Laws
Peak pressu~re
ll1.09
';03
,S
0.95
0.9O
0.91
Positive I:,nilse
Pilk FresaJ'te
0.$0
0.80
?o!,ltive
0.46
0.53
Paink Peseure
0.38
0.45
?illtive
pl.ercing
,crFs
~.Exporimzntal
and Scalniig
"~
' It
Ctized
Armor
I
I;'pulse
rMpulee
"
CONFrIENTIAL
S3CURITY INFORMATION
p.o
CONFIDENTIAL
NAVORD aeport 2753
COtUT,USION3
rf,
12.
It is concluded thnt thn Cormulae developed fvom Vi.netic
ren,:r
e
tobt,,btions at the t!n-e of rupture correlate best
Thertfore to predict poaitive imwish i)o0uitivo i';guloe date.
Vuln4 r.;ult
th- new formulae devell'ed in this report can be
The ayperizantal data indicate that
ujcd without modification.
to prliuict peak prea3ure results the formulae uhould be multiplied by the factor 1.19.
13. The teble below nhc';o the form.nulze to U-e that be!t agree
with ox; rLvgnl work ard ooallng law results for predicting
Case Type
*Li1ht Case
*General Purpose
Positive Impuls
S:
Peak ;:cszura
Svrni Armor
Pier,
1-ng1
_____
.n
W17~#
l.
#W
08
S"
l
ip
ui'
F,I
-'
1,
i7
"CONPIDENTIAL
SECURITY IDWORMATIOW
,-- -
S--'-
0."
11d
*
U. FarO,
1of 3
c
Air Bla--"portt 2-74
by
rstu,
wqrQjq Stc~a. Caz1(a jjc..L j~a
1rk.
Cjirov.k.
it.
A10)vrt
Gizoa;
r~t~v',r
ij::o~a3.ccria an~d I
Ce)imrvon
otJ~
-P
(d)
V*10n4IuAi
Lfzave Cur'roo
Air Uvi
jj~O~Orf
I
1xjrkQ1O4 &M
3. 1I ?ihr Co..-nta
SEMT INOIOTO
nf~to
.44
C0O4FIDENLIAL
*
TABLE 1
PF~k Pressure Data From Steel Caaed TINT Weapons
Peak
2ressure
Distance
(PsI I
(rt)
c/l
2.9
U.oz
U:)Q
tj,3uu
ZQ.S
4,000 1b LC Bomb
!4,o0
lie Bomb
4,000 lb LC Bomb
3.15
6.23
3.09
300
211
Z=0
3362
3362
3362
40
-.
2,5
3230
1.02
1.27
0.06
6 Depth Charge
0.82
0.82
0.82
16.39
6.23
3.10
90
130
0.77
0.77
300
300
2,000 lb OP Bomb
2.04
204.8
o.64
1117
2,000 lb GP Bomb
2,000 lb a? Bomb
lb G? nomb
500 lb
OP Bomb
500 lb
lb O?
OP Bomb
Boub
00lGPBm
2.27
3.97
2.99
-42.8
165.o
0.64
1117
1117
558
A5
869
523
0.94
267
265
151
312
0.99
0.5T
1.17
1 .11
Weapon
Dtscription
1U.)Q
ILO
U
IC
'
50M
MLC
1K 6 Depth Charge
mK 6 Depth Charge
#imean
S1,000
I '500
3.05
1. 82
12.
163.8
M.?! 300
o.64
0.65
W'
WWe7
47
TA9
331
271
267
26T
1.iO
0.90
1.09
0.84
f.80
0.78
0.65
o.65
0.65
5.7
129.7
167.3
9.7
9.3
0.65
267
",0
3.23
2.02
76.3
97.9
0.65
0.65
55
55
543.7
Mean
2.18
166.2
0.36
556
262
O.A7
2.22
136.5
038
320
148
0.46
2.55
108.:4
0.38
161
105
0.65
Mean
0.53
100
Bonb
100 lb
lb n?
a? Bomb -
O0
Note:
1.07
0.79
0.91
All
weapons fired slightly above groud to avoid
oratering.
C/, .'arge to weight ratio of cylinrioal section of weapon.
WO is calculated by scaling up bare charge data.
Peak Pressure values are averages of a nt,tber of trials.
I9
MMtIDEMTAL
II
. . . .
. . .
. . ,
. . ..
..
.. . . . .
, ,,0
' i
CoNpiDE4TIAL
NAVOPD Report 2753
poait.$ve
TABLIZ1
Cased TNT Weapons
irapulse Data FrQ.'a Ste*,
positive
rmpulse
pO~i~.Ve
weapon
73.2
T
10,00,0 lb LW BoM
30
151.3
55.1
44,000 lb W) Bomb
1O.
4,(00 lb LO -omb
62..
lb IX onr00
SIB 119.7
a.9
it
C Blab
S4,C00
?MiC
6 Mptb Ch
-2.66
2,(0CO Ib OG ,utb g6.o5
59.62
2,,)00 lb G? Dorb
Ib G? liomb
l0
g,0
1,000 1b OP !omb
5:000
lb O?
m-.b
28.2
51'29.7
LC --b
lb OP
500 lb
OP?130mb
IOO Ib 0? Bomb
1"5.02
9,20.50
'
bMan B.
0.32
.382
0.
0.2282
0:82
7050
3362
3362
j362
0.77
0.77
3,62
300
300
2 04.8
0o 6 4
1117
79.5
120.0
0,64
0.64
1117
1117
149 .8
60.0
129.6
23.6*
Wh'e
-) --
~'~
Weaon
eigh t
ETHe
TTW
e7h Char~ge
t" pare
fT
o1e~isht
D'.Itance
165.b
0.65
0.65
0.92
60
3-60
0.12
3176e)
3180
3835
262
213
0.95
0.87
0.71
0.6
L68
558
39*
26%
168
2G7
65
o.65
2bT
267
16.05
59.7
129.7
76.%
o,65
55
20.12
11.93
163.2
297,2
0,36
.%56
556
232.
52.5
,
0.76
0.11
0.11
0.99
o.63
0.80
.6
0,41
0.45
or weapon.
to avoid craterinf;.
ol ~ 9rOunddilection
sht11
rslio ebove
tired
rwed~h
All weepons
Mote:
i HoelAl
weap-e'on
twao'
ecif
to weight ratio of cyllnr4~iOsl
ct~ar
eharge data.
CA(W
is calcultted by s5ain, up barc
i
of &
positive LqpqLlss Is an average
mmaber of trIals.
COerPFDFWrIAt,
4
~SICMUITY
INC1RNATION
......................................................
COI14FIDENTIAL
NAVORD REPORT 2753
rIG. I
COMPAPISON OF EQUATIONS FORl FINDING THE EFFECTIVE
BARE. CH1ARGE WEIGHT OF A STEEL CASED WEAPON
2-~
I,'1
I.
I+_
.AN
0.
V.0.2
II_
'CkY
itji
T
I-
2j.L.
~
1 T"'MTTAL
WEIGHT
WEIGHT
MEVALWEIGT
4MOcr~
SEMAURTY INFORMATIO14
ICHARGE
CONFIQcENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL
FIG. 2
PEAK PRESSURE VS REDUCED RADiAL DISTANCE
FOR CAST TNT IN FAR MACH REGION
:7
....
i:>DETERMINED
BY FANO EQUATION
x SA+P BOMBS
IO~
-
XP BARE CHG.OATA
REFLECTION GOEFFICIENT ul
_____
7--
. . . . . ..................
44
... ....
ui
:::
~i.JL
7 8-9 10a
~301
LI
...
~.....~
2.
CONFIDENTIAL
40
(FT/LBO)
50
ii
CONFIDENTIAL
NAVORD REPORT 2753
A1
FIG. 3
REDUCED RADIAL DISTANCE
VS
PEAK PRESSURE
FOR CAST TNT IN FAR MACH REGION
~'
20
LL
OFICE~
7*'
ftt.1'1.IN
ix
..
..
Itn
a9120
30
01)050
FI.
4
11III
c-TW'FOR
STEEL CASED
WEAPONS LOETERAINED
BY' TME FyiLLOWING
A
.
EQUATION'
-:0.47+
-I+
~...
~X
0 L.C.
8CM8
G.P.
BOMOq
S.A.P. 90101
IEX P.
0.6t
S6
2ECURITY
INFORMATION
7689 1020
3
40
REDUCED RRaDIAL DISTANCE R/W'l/3 (FT/gIto3J
14
GONFIOEN'rAL
CONFIDENTIAL
FIG. 5
PEAK PRESSURE VS REDUCED0 RADIAL DISTANCE
CAST TNT IN FAR MACH REGION
4FOR
20.
ii
WEAPONS DETERMINEO
fQJATiON'
'I
0 L.C. BOMS
I~
7j+G.F
.A.F? BOMB3
IX
1'1-.-
-7.--.
BOM
BARE CHARGE DATA
-7'
11I
LzI
2.............
78a910
20
'/130
SECURITY
INFORMATION
1
CONFI')ENTIAL
3(FT/lb
1340
50
.177-7
L
7-.
I:EQUATIO.N
0-L(; BOMS
+-GP 80MB
w.;.
DATA
REFLEcrioN ZZ)=EFF!CIENT*1.8
SEURT
, ;0RMTA~wwow,%&
CV'.-I0ENTIAL
.-
0*
~NAVOiRD REPORT
2753
FIG. 7
REDUCED POSITIVE !MPULSE VS REDUCED RADIAL
DISTANCE FOR CAST. TN"T !N FAR MACH REGION
A7K1 TI 77
SYTHE
iI
~EXP-
LI
'
UZ I+
....
.....
z ._
30
6789 0
SECURITY7
INFORMATION*
FwgL--~j
- ..
40
10
11
FIG. 8
REDUCED POSJTIVE i..,tPULSE VS REDUCED RAMiAL DISTAN~CE
FOR CAST TNT IN FAR MACH REGION
F!
~DETERMINEo rROM
FOLLOW'10 I(;
LCG'BOMB
X SAP Some
II
REFLECTION COEFFICIENr,..e
-7
0.1
II-T
IREDUCED
I
SECURITY
INFORM ATIO0N
SE~T j !IFORMATION
~RT 253
FIG. 9
REOUCE:0 rO$'"-71E 1:0PULSE vqs REDOUCED IHADIAL DISTANCE
1'()
F7':ThW'FOR
JSTEEL CASM. WEAPONS3
DETEMINED FR~OM FOLLOWING
.:v7
1-
~~~EQUATIOttIMA-~
*77-
Ii
u ?-J
.-
Ii
k44
SECILRI1
REDCE
INFRMAIO
RAIA
__TN-
fW
/6.
r-
INFORMATION
1
N.A.,,On
Report t:753
SDISuTRIBUTION
AD
Copies
or Ordnancee (Rego)
'-Chip?,e
-urea
Chief,
1.
Bureau of Aeronautics
SChie~f,,
SJ.Chief,
2
2
2
of Nava! Research
;"Chief
"C"hief of
I
4
S,
. .Proving
Patterson Field,
Dayton, Ohio
1 [1
' I
'I
Aberdeen
iJC.
r,-
1B684
Cal. 1
Dr. S.
J.
Fraenkel,
Chicago, Illinois
SECURITY INFORMATION
-.
P/
"2753
NAV0RD U47r
DISTRIBUTION
aoffice
Chief of Ordnance,
ATTN:
S--A-.
Princeton,
Comndr
Co~mmander.
....
.7... ---..
Pentagon Bldg.,
Drimmer
B.
Provim'A-'
Naa
. .,rirund,
Naval p
..
Lon Al3moe,
Dahlgren, Virginia
. tltICLaboratory.
New Mexico,
via IIM,
Cal.
Los Aneeles,
Louis, Missouri
Commandmng Officer, Naval Mine Depot, Yorktown, VlrS nla.
1
AITTN: J. Manlcy, R. and D. Diviaion
St.
Cnmmanding Officer,
Cormandiln
General,
-4
::Z
British OHMDT
for distribmtion,
1 .S.
Naval Attache,
London, England
of Induatrial noeearlh
University of Denver, Institute
(Contract NOrd 11541) Denver 10, Colo. via Aunt.
33 0A
-15o68
SECURITV
dh
.T1ON
'ontftrat'i
1
I
,.,"