Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
In the matter of
A Shocking Tax
1
Mediation Plan On Behalf Of DeskZone Inc
STRONG POINTS
The wording of the mail circulated does not specifically impute the illegality of Arcadia
Offices SARL (Arcadia)s tax practices, but merely alludes to the questionable ethics
of a profit-shifting company.
It is a factual statement that Arcadia does not pay taxes in Montrovia, and thus the
defence of justification can be applied against the defamation allegations. Most (but
not all) companies indulge in similar practices (legal, but whose morality is a matter of
public debate). The exception clause in no way highlights Arcadias actions as falling
within the same. The defence of justification is applicable against the defamation
allegations because it is a factual statement that Arcadia does not pay taxes in
Montrovia, and the morality of the same is a public domain debate. Furthermore, most
WEAK POINTS
Considering that Arcadia and DeskZone are primary competitors in the concerned
market, the statements can easily be construed to be malicious.
2
Mediation Plan On Behalf Of DeskZone Inc
While payment of the projected damages is not impossible, it would place immense
government tenders.
DeskZone is willing to issue a clarification regarding the statement, which should ease
out the situation, for the statement if made a tad bit clearer would clearly have no
defamatory content.
Avoiding litigation is crucial given DeskZones intent to expand into other markets, and
government contract.
Further, we believe that this event playing out publicly and degenerating into the sort of
situation in which both parties suffer a loss of goodwill is to be avoided at all costs.
DeskZone cannot compromise their image of being a strong company for the sake of
3
Mediation Plan On Behalf Of DeskZone Inc
Given the sensitive nature of the issue involved, which impacts the credibility of both
parties, DeskZone is keen to avoid litigation and to avoid a cash settlement unless
4
Mediation Plan On Behalf Of DeskZone Inc
5
Mediation Plan On Behalf Of DeskZone Inc