Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
By
Ray Tjahjadi
DISSERTATION
DOCTOR OF EDUCATION
Educational Leadership
in the
of the
Approved:
Committee in Charge
2009
i
UMI Number: 3375534
Copyright 2009 by
Tjahjadi, Ray
INFORMATION TO USERS
The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy
submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations
and photographs, print bleed-through, substandard margins, and improper
alignment can adversely affect reproduction.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized
copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion.
UMI
UMI Microform 3375534
Copyright 2009 by ProQuest LLC
All rights reserved. This microform edition is protected against
unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code.
ProQuest LLC
789 East Eisenhower Parkway
P.O. Box 1346
Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346
Copyright by
Ray Tjahjadi
2009
Dedication
Ma, for you I nurture knowledge and share it with all human beings.
Acknowledgements
This study would not be completed without the tireless efforts and timely
statistical analysis, did not let me stray from my dissertation process. There are
encouragement, and availability from the start to the end of this study.
McNeil who shared his scholarly wisdom in educational curriculum with me, and
who always reminds me that every person in this world is entitled to learn. Dr.
Unruh and Dr. McNeil's belief of "no boundary in learning" will always inspire me
Title Page i
Copyright Page ii
Dedication iii
Acknowledgement iv
Table of Contents v
1. Introduction 1
2. Literature Review 7
Assessment Technology 40
Simulation Technology 43
3. Methodology 52
Research design 52
Participants 53
Hypotheses 54
Instrumentation 55
Independent Variables 56
Dependent Variables 57
v
Procedures 58
Statistical Analysis 59
4. Finding 60
Descriptive Statistics 60
Statistical Tests 64
5. Discussion 69
Simulation Technology 77
Assessment Technology 81
Further Research 87
References 90
VI
List of Tables
Table 1: MANOVA 59
Table 2: Student Enrollment and Percentage of Financial Aid Recipients ... .60
VII
List of Figures
VIM
Ray Tjahjadi
April 2009
Educational Leadership
Educational Technology
Abstract
Vs f
'JGJD
I. Philip Young^ Ed. Dl^Dissertaioh\Chair
this study.
assessment technology. The targeted participants for this study are 999
XX
The findings from this study indicate that community colleges' executives,
deans, and faculty members are in agreement about the value of technology
competency, and congruence exists in the value of simulation technology and the
the faculty members and the executives. The faculty members fail to agree with
the deans about the perceived value of value of simulation technology as well as
X
1
Chapter 1
Introduction
In his 1997 State of the Union address, President Clinton outlined a 10-
point plan for improving education in the USA, which included connecting every
classroom and library to the Internet by the year 2000 and helping all students
make much of an impact on learning unless teachers are trained to make the
Association, the National PTA, the National Education Association, the American
Education, 2007).
learning outcomes (Cradler, McNabb, & Freeman, 2002; Edwards, Cordray, &
California Virtual Campus, 2007; Rovai, Ponton, Wighting, & Baker, 2007; U. S.
eleven years later since Clinton's 1997 State of the Union address, the infusion
to produce new methods for improving teaching and learning (Bok, 2003).
2007).
Education leaders and teachers are pressed to assess and to evaluate the
knowledge and skills required for 21 st century citizens and to produce new
Smolin & Lawless, 2007). Current college students demonstrated fluency in using
the Internet and the information technology than their previous generations
(Jones, Johnson-Yale, Perez, & Schuler, 2007; Zhang, 2002), a condition that
institutions must adjust their leadership to blend their technology resources with
Information Programs, 2006) causes the shifting of the learning structure from a
et. al, 2007) where online students engage dynamically in activities to complete
their required tasks by using technology (Cradler et. al, 2002; Office of
centered to student centered will be successful likely if the teachers who use the
and (c) to display high-level commitment and integrity for the vision and
objectives.
guide in this study to investigate the consensus about the value of educational
frame (Bolman & Deal, 2003) asserts that people and organizations are
interdependent and that congruence must exist between an organization and its
faculty members.
Berthental, & Lawless, 2007), and two specific educational technologies useful
2007; Haertel, Means, & Penuel, 2007; Pellegrino et. al, 2007; Recesso & Orrill,
specific skills related to specific learning units (Pellegrino et. al, 2007; Grabe &
items for this research are adopted from University of Tennessee (Oh & French,
2004) and Texas A&M University (Jones, Lindner, Murphy, & Dooley, 2002)
The sample for this study (n=154) was selected at random from 1,045
From the selected 999 targeted community colleges, 333 were selected at
neutral, 4 = agree, and 5 = strongly agree). Collected data were analyzed using
technology at community colleges across the nation. Findings from this study
technology at their institution. A limitation of this study is that it fails to take the
community colleges surveyed in this study that may be unfit for technology
evaluation.
7
Chapter 2
Literature Review
have merged and have impacted traditional practices in education. This blending
(Wikipedia, 2007).
outcomes (Cradler et.al, 2002; Edwards, Cordray, & Dorbolo, 2000; Office of
delivery (McKenzie, 1999; Rovai, Ponton, Wighting, & Baker, 2007), and faculty
et. al, 2007). Therefore, it is important for schools to have both their faculty and
have been done mostly on K-12 schools or 4-year universities, and broad
general, research across multiple community colleges is very limited due to the
lack of a reliable funding base (Cohen & Brawer, 1996). The absence of research
education, and recently, to offering remedial courses for those who are
community colleges is the motive of this research. This research investigates the
literature reviewed in this study focuses on three areas: (1) the benefits of
There are many theories and many opinions about the purpose of
education, one opinion states that the purpose of education is to form good
citizenship by allowing young people to learn and to teach them how to utilize
their intellectual minds as well as how to acquire facts to satisfy their curiosity,
and schools are the institutions delegated to meet the purpose of education by
9
replicating facts and problems as well as their solutions of the larger society in a
White, Van Scotter, Hartoonian, and Davis (2007) argued that the only
unfortunately, the current education that Americans find now is different than the
core purpose of education. Schools are focused on skill building, data analysis,
and job preparation where job training has replaced civic education (White, Van
Scotter, Hartoonian, & Davis, 2007). Regardless various opinions about the
students enrolleld among 18 schools improved their SAT-9 scores as the result
standards. In a study across nine states assessing the impact of Jasper software
than those students who failed to follow a similar protocol (Cradler et. al, 2002).
computer and displays the questions on a projector screen in the classroom, and
summarized, stored, and displayed back to the students in real time. (The Ohio
instantly and to allow alteration of the lecture accordingly (Washington and Lee
their level of understanding for course material relative to their peers. Surveys of
CPS use in introductory geosciences courses were conducted between 2001 and
1. More than half of the students surveyed (65% - 77%) indicated that CPS
courses.
This study showed that CPS helps students to learn better in a technology-
In the fall of 2005, a large-scale pilot study involving 1,940 students and
showed that students were more engaged with their classes and achieved higher
retention levels after using the clickers than before using the clickers. Using the
device helped 74% of the students to understand important lecture points and to
identify study areas that they needed to spend more time on. From 16
critical thinking. Working in tandem with information technology, the Internet has
changed the delivery of many courses that are traditionally offered in physical
12
classrooms at specific times. Learners now have the option of taking online
courses on the Web (Shelly, Cashman, & Vermaat, 2003). As a result, students
their course projects, students become more critical in their thinking than the
students who failed to use the Internet for completing their course projects
(Cradler et. al, 2002; Office of Information Technology, 2006). Rovai, Ponton,
Wighting, and Baker (2007) conducted a comparative study of 353 students from
university courses. Using a three-way MANOVA, they found that online students
possess stronger intrinsic motivation than traditional students who attend regular
students in the courses they took. Educational technology has helped this college
to offer online courses as well as hybrid courses and broadens student access to
offered by the college, and the offering of online courses has grown from two in
1996 to 26 plus four hybrid courses. Unfortunately, many senior faculty members
13
between younger students who are computer oriented and senior faculty, the
marketing courses, stated: "Every product, every service will die if it is not re-
die" (Bradley, 2006, p. 8). The situation faced by Orange County Community
College is faced also by the California Community Colleges. It was projected that
distance education, via the Internet, would count for 20% of student enrollment at
shown in Figure 1.
25 -|
„ 20 -pk
Enrollment: 1998-04
a. 5 > y 1
0-"
1998 2004 2016
14
community colleges, is the full responsibility of faculty who teach the courses
(Fresno City College, 2007; Maricopa Community College District, 2007; Monroe
Community College, 2007). Because faculty members are the sole entity in
offering 1,500 free online courses through its OpenCourseWare (OCW) Web site.
Five years later, the Web site became an international group acquiring 50 plus
educational institutions from U.S., Africa, Asia, South America, and Europe. MIT
"Through MIT OCW, educators and students everywhere can benefit from the
academic activities of our faculty and join a global learning community in which
knowledge and ideas are shared openly and freely for the benefit of all." (U. S.
problem sets and solutions, exams, lecture notes, and videotapes lectures. By
2008, MIT plans to offer 1,800 free online courses, and Yale University
announced that it would offer free video-recorded lectures from its seven liberal
MIT's OCW Web site shows the significant role of the Internet and of educational
for allowing all learners to engage equally in the learning process, including those
for learning-disabled students to help them building skills as well as to help them
with Disabilities Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. Today, most
or a learning disability can take online courses via the Internet by using their
diversed world to students and exposes them to global events (Dede, 2007).
16
Internet and American Life Project (Jones et. al, 2007). All survey participants
used the Internet for information searching, and about 78% of them
communicated about their courses using electronic mail and instant messaging.
Although the educational technology makes plagiarism easy to do, 96% of the
College students are taking advantages of "Web 2.0 technology" (p. 39)
for social networking and for video sharing. It is expected that college graduates
will continue to use the Internet technology heavily in the future (Jones et. al,
2007,), a typical trait of a 21 s t century worker (Dede, 2007). One may conclude
workforce of 21 s t century.
2007; Czubaj, 2002). The next section examines the factors impacting the
schools should consider the total cost of ownership (TCO) that addresses the
computers. School leaders must be aware that the Internet can fail to
resources provide lesson plans and user interfaces that are reliable and
a. Assessment: Along with benefits, new technology can bring stress and
disappointment.
working.
should not put too many demands on teachers. Stability allows change
e. Drag: Other areas may suffer because so many resources are going to
the network.
one technician for every 50-75 users, while schools often have only
of computers. Schools will use what comes free with the computer
because so much was spent buying the system that nothing is left to get
systems.
being sought. Public relations efforts are necessary so the schools can
technology.
problem solving, skill building, and learning tools. The evaluation of educational
Technology plan
problems such as "Get them to work 100% of the time," "Took more time to figure
Technology, 2006). One conclusion can be derived from these comments that
may lie with the competency of the students and of the faculty, and the
and must be retrained to use the technology (King-Sears & Evmenova, 2007).
students who use educational technology in taking online courses, the learning
learning where students must learn to become self-directed rather than passive
receptors of knowledge (Rovai et. al, 2007). Shifting the learning structure from
documents as evidence, a conclusion can be derived that faculty are the primary
force in integrating educational technology for curriculum and for course delivery,
technology.
achieved either by recruiting new faculty who are competent in the use of
for technology to reach its potential for enhancing learning. Many community
colleges may face a difficulty in allocating the fund required to finance effective
the University of New Mexico from 2003 to 2005. In this study, the Technology
23
Beliefs and Competencies Survey, which has 0.96 reliability of Cronbach Alpha,
was used to collect data from volunteer teachers who attended the University of
2006). These studies show that many hours are needed to provide adequate
Using the faculty contract of the State Center Community College District
their faculty, then they need to increase their faculty-salary fund at least by 8%.
According to McKenzie (2002), funding is the primary barrier for most schools in
the United States to provide an acceptable level of technology training for their
teachers.
Most schools fail to offer enough training to teachers due to the funding
shortage (McKenzie, 2002) so it will make more sense for community colleges to
when selecting and when hiring new faculty (Arvey & Faley, 1992).
students. Students have the option of taking online courses over the Internet,
which removes the time barrier and the distance barrier for those who are unable
to attend traditional classes. Using computers and the Internet, online students
and hands-on exercises. (Cradler et. al, 2002; Office of Information Technology,
2006).
capitalize on the benefits offered by educational technology (Rovai et. al, 2007).
teaching between the teachers who received technology training and those who
failed to receive technology training. The participants of this study were 400
the other two hundred were excluded from the 7-day training. Di Benedetto
(2004) used a MANOVA to analyze data from the participants, and she found
that there was no significant difference between those teachers who received
technology training and those who failed to receive technology training in regard
hoc ANOVA was conducted even though the MANOVA test failed to reveal
and those who failed to receive technology training with respect to student-
centered learning and to the utilization of technology skills. One conclusion that
can be extracted from this study is that technology training fails to change the
where the program may focus on quantity of interactions between teachers and
teachers and technology rather than on the quality of interactions. One of the
reasons may be teachers are excluded from the activities of developing their
technology-training program, then the training result may shift from quantity to
26
at the University of Alabama, Rice and Miller (2001) conducted a study to access
strongly agree. The results of the study indicated three areas of serious concern:
(1) the participants prefer to see structural schemes for identifying who should be
included in technology planning and decision making, (2) the participants indicate
administrative technology planning, and (3) the participants strongly believe that
the faculty senate should have a technology body that will allow the involvement
of faculty in establishing planning procedures and initiatives (Rice & Miller, 2001).
The second and third concerns of Rice and Miller's (2001) study indicated
elementary and 150 secondary school teachers. After completing the training,
27
the survey indicated that teachers were concerned about lack of teachers'
improve student learning based on three conditions: (1) teachers must embrace
course contents, (2) teachers need to shift their teaching practices from teacher-
Office of Information Technology, 2006; Rice & Miller, 2001; Rovai et. al, 2007).
employees' life at work, schools, cities, and/or countries by transforming the way
28
immigrants, poverty, and many others. To face these challenges, these leaders
must nurture a leadership that opposes status-quo environments, and they must
section for the utilization of educational technology that will foster student
learning.
units where the problems occur, and gains from the transactional changes
usually have short life. Transformational leadership, on the other hand, initiates
(2008), the leadership of school administration would make sure that the new
contract will allow the school to operate effectively and efficiently by maintaining
the administration's authority and rights. On the other hand, the leadership of a
teacher union would prefer that the new contract will protect and will increase the
securities as well as the opportunities for union members that include salary, job
making sure that teachers are paid and provided with benefits that conform to the
that will help these instructors to improve students' learning outcomes by utilizing
agencies. Bennis and Nanus (1997) stressed the importance for leaders to build
staff that can compensate for their weaknesses and to set a standard of
greatness (Bennis & Nanus, 1997). For public organizations, such as schools,
bureaucracy where personal rules are forced on others as well as ignoring the
voice of the people. This situation may transform leaders into guardians of
people, a situation that could suppress the democracy at our public institutions
(Dahl, 1989). Another drawback of Bennis and Nanus' fourth strategy is that it
solving it. Double-loop learning is inquiry-based learning, and it requires the use
focus on the magnitude of the immediate effect for the solutions that they applied
to the problems. These professionals are quick to be defensive when faced with
their own failure because they are embarrassed. Being defensive prevents many
professionals from learn from their own failures, and the deficiency of learning
This fear of failure may play a significant role in US' public educational
reforms, such as Ronald Reagan's A Nation at Risk (Tyack & Cuban, 1995) and
No Child Left Behind, were made by federal or state leaders, who acted as the
democracy, "For the People and By the People," has been violated by these
The fear of failure and the fear of being embarrassed for making mistakes
Democracy is not working in our public schools, the entities that are supposed to
nurture the democracy. We need to put the democracy back into our public
(2004) by doing several tasks: (1) to convince people that we are the co-creators
32
partnerships between government and citizens, and (3) to change our civic
basis of sharing ideas and of working together among local members (Boyte,
2004). Putting the democracy back into our schools as suggested by Boyte
of integrating technology into education that are created locally to solve local
continuous and democratic dialog will satisfy the three conditions for improving
student learning through the use of educational technology. These three conditions
developing and in delivering their course contents, (2) teachers need to shift their
by utilizing the benefits of educational technology that will elevate the problem-
solving skills of students, and (3) teachers are included in developing technology
instructors.
various accredited colleges within the State of North Carolina. They identified five
factors that prevent faculty from using educational technology in their classroom:
(1) fear of change, (2) fear of time commitment, (3) fear of appearing
incompetent, (4) fear of failure, and (5) fear of having to move backward to go
resources and support, (2) effective technology training for teaching and
technology expertise (Robert et. al, 2007). To have faculty to adopt educational
technology in their teaching, community colleges should remove the five negative
factors from their faculty and provide them with the five sources of positive
encouragement.
34
frame assumes that (1) organizations are to serve human needs, (2) people and
organizations are interdependent, and (3) a fit must exist between organizations
and their people; people experience satisfying work and organizations benefit
from the talents and from the energy of their people (Bolman & Deal, 2003).
These assumptions are important for this study because the study is to measure
and to stimulate them to apply for the vacant positions (Young, 2008). To be
successful in recruiting the right people for the right jobs, organizations must
develop effective recruitment that includes the projection of long- and short-term
staffing needs and considers the condition of the labor market. Recruitment is a
and to hiring of applicants (Young, 2008). Organizations must plan, apply, and
monitor the recruitment program to attract qualified applicants to apply for job
Personal computers and electronic equipment are less expensive and have more
features each day; product improvements are made in months rather in years.
During the same period of time, educational systems have failed to make
educational leaders can learn valuable lessons from their business counterparts
alive in their respective industry. Educational systems, on the other hand, are
36
less successful than businesses in blending their technology resources with their
human resources to produce new methods for improving teaching and learning
(Bok, 2003).
based system as the catalyst for various work flows such as reporting and
educational systems.
scanning of current trends constantly as well as inputs from those who use the
online shopping that uses technology to project the profile of its customer and
their preferences. Books offered and sold on Amazon's Web site come with
Wiggins and McTighe (2006) who suggest that curriculum design must begin with
37
Because teachers know the most about their students, they must be involved in
in education technology.
on lateral coordination (Bolman & Deal, 2003) that is designed for complex jobs
significant roles in this design for capturing, storing, and sharing information
the lateral coordination design (Bolman & Deal, 2003) and to foster a social
fabrics among their faculty that will encourage sharing of technology expertise
(Robert et. al, 2007). The symbolic frame presents the importance of
This situation is consistent with one of the theories presented by Senge et al. that
"every organization is a product of how its members think and interact" (Senge,
whole picture of their organization and must update constantly their management
and products (Bok, 2003) such as the development of academic curricula that will
(Bolman & Deal, 2003) of technology sharing will elevate community colleges'
being fear of failure (Argyris, 1991) and because thoughts are focused on the
(McKenzie, 1999).
One of three conditions for improving student learning through the use of
(2003) presented a mandate by the Clinton Administration that all teachers must
39
be trained to integrate Internet technology into the curriculum, and he found that
veteran teachers failed to infuse technology into their subject areas, while pre-
(Williams, 2003). Community colleges should use this finding to adjust their
into course curricula and academic services for those students who fail to have
commonly in the forms of course syllabus and of teaching the course (Posner,
(Bradley, 2006; Cradler et. al, 2002; Dede, 2007; Jones et. at, 2007; Office of
Information Technology, 2006; Payne, M. D. & Sachs, R., 1994; Rovai et. al,
40
curricula.
organizational structure (Bolman & Deal, 2003) to foster a social fabrics among
their faculty that will encourage sharing of technology expertise (Robert et. al,
2007) by engaging trust within the organization (Bennis & Nanus, 1997).
activities to support the learning units being learned (Pellegrino et. al, 2007), and
learning specific skills related to specific learning units (Grabe & Grabe,
computations, and visualization (Grabe & Grabe, 2007; Haertel, et. al,
them and to communicate with their teachers (Grabe & Grabe, 2007;
Haertel, et. al, 2007; Pellegrino et. al, 2007; Recesso & Orrill, 2008).
incorporate texts, graphics, video, and audio (Grabe & Grabe, 2007;
technology as well as into simulation technology (Grabe & Grabe, 2007; Haertel,
et. al, 2007; Jones et. al, 2008). Both communication technology and multimedia
technology are used also by teachers for non-learning purposes such as sending
and receiving electronic mails and visiting multimedia Web pages that could
influence their perception about the value of these technologies. Because this
teacher perspective rather than from student perspective and because of the two
al, 2007). The next section is to examine each of the three topics that may affect
Assessment technology
organize learning and knowledge subjects for meeting the challenges of creating
technology can be utilized to bring real facts and problems through the use of
that will help teachers to identify the mastery-learning levels of their students,
from beginner level to proficient level (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, 2000).
43
report card intended for those outside the classroom, and this assessment fails to
report the details of the summary information such as the reasons for specific
grades recorded in the report card. On the hand, formative assessment presents
feedback for those who engage in the learning process inside the classroom as
well as provides a measure about student performance for a given learning unit
(Starkman, 2006).
to teachers about the understanding of their students about a subject matter, and
the concerned subject matter. (Bransford et. al, 2000; Haertel et. al, 2007). By
assess and can improve their understanding about the subject being collaborated
students with opportunities for improving their thinking as well as for allowing
them to see their progress over a time period, and the assessment can be
government on the moon for a group of people who just settle there (Bransford
(Bransford et. al, 2000; Haertel et. al, 2007; Starkman, 2006; The Ohio State
to sub-sequent learnings that will follow the matters being assessed, and
al, 2007).
diagnosis feature that evaluates students' assessment answers and provides the
students and their teachers with the explanation for various specific diagnoses
quickly (Haertel et. al, 2007). In Bransford et. al's (2000) example of creating a
democratic government on the moon, Facets software will provide the students
complete view of their students' knowledge level for the topic being assessed.
the students to memorize standardized answers that include key terms and
the fact is the simulation software interactively assesses each of the detailed
responses given by the students for capturing their reasoning. The simulation
45
software provides the students with feedback that helps the students to view their
level of understanding of electrical circuit and, at the same time, it allows the
teacher to tailor the next lesson for meeting the current-knowledge state of
Simulation technology
Four of best practices (Tomel, 2003) of the new standards for teaching
and for learning in America's schools specify that learning must be reflective,
student centered, challenging, and experential. These four practices will allow
be responsible for their own learning (Tomel, 2003). "Simulation is the imitation of
a process, skill, or knowlegde to be learned" (Recesso & Orrill, 2008. p. 85), and
elements of realistic experiences" (Grabe & Grabe, 2007. p. 408) that will support
(SIDD) software involving nine female students and two male students with the
average of 23 years, Desrochers, House, and Seth (2001) found that SIDD and a
lecture on clinical strategies increased the test scores of the participants on the
subject compared to the control group who received the lecture only. The tests
on clinical strategies were administered before the lecture, after the lecture, after
using SIDD, and a few weeks after the lecture. The lecture failed to impact both
the experimental group's test score and the controls group's test score about
clinical strategies, and the exposure to SIDD increased the test scores of the
experimental group while the test score of the control group remained the same
lecture alone (Brant, Hooper, & Sugrue, 1991; Desrochers et. al, 2001; Grabe &
Grabe, 2007). Grabe and Grabe (2007) pointed four benefits of integrating
the orbiting path of planets around the sun, or (3) the drifting of
game that assigns the player as a city major who is responsible for building a city
industrial, and by enforcing city ordinances. Player's decisions and action in this
game are recorded and responded with feedbacks that are built based on the
evaluation (Recesso & Orrill, 2008). Simulation software will help teachers to
learning progress.
improve student learning depends on the availability of and the support of the
knowledge of the teachers for integrating the technology in their curricula and in
their teaching. At community colleges, presidents and deans must devise and
methods and products (Bok, 2003) such as academic curricula that will improve
student learning.
Teachers teach "the way they were taught" (p. 61), and, if they failed to
experience educational technology in their education, most likely that they will fail
teachers to address and adapt these changes is a must to satisfy demands for
quality learning as well as school accountability (Vrasidas & Glass, 2007). The
courses.
stimulate them to apply for the vacant positions (Young, 2008). To be successful
in recruiting the right people for the right jobs, organizations must develop
effective recruitment that includes the projection of long- and short-term staffing
needs and considers the condition of the labor market. Recruitment is a strategic
49
program to attract qualified applicants to apply for job openings (Winter, 1996;
independent variables: (1) job mobility, (2) recruiter background, and (3)
more self-efficacy in using the Internet and the information technology than the
older generation (Jones et. al, 2007; Zhang, 2002). To avoid a technology
mismatch between college students and their faculty, it is critical for community
50
community colleges and their teaching applicants (Winter & Mu, 2002).
being fear of failure because ideas are exchanged freely (Argyris, 1991).
simulation technology.
The literature reviewed in this study shows that the benefits of educational
teaching because they are responsible to develop their courses, to teach their
courses, and to access their students' performance (Fresno City College, 2007;
51
Chapter 3
Methodology
Research design
base (Cohen & Brawer, 1996) and is caused also by community colleges' various
remedial courses for those who are unprepared for higher education (Wolfle &
Robertshaw, 1982). This research was designed to collect and to analyze data
from community colleges across the United States and to answer the following
research questions:
Education Sciences (2), 2008). This study uses one-way MANOVA to test for
Participants
toward technology aspects and potentials (Jones et. al, 2002). To assure an
54
conducted to determine the sample size for an alpha of 0.05 level. Using the
medium effect size of Cohen's convention, a sample size of 150 is needed for
this study (Cohen, 1988) with equal representation among participants sampled
at random.
community college in the United States had the same chance to be included in
the study (Huck, 2004). From the selected community colleges (n= 999), 333 are
identified at random as the the targeted-dean participants, and 333 are chosen at
Hypotheses
The three research questions in this study are set forth to measure the
Instrumentation
adopted from two different surveys: (1) a modified version of the National
Tennessee' study of preservice teachers' perception (Oh & French, 2004) and (2)
technology value, and technology support at Texas A&M University (Jones et. al,
examined the content validity of the first survey (Oh & French, 2004). The second
survey's Cronbach's Alpha was established at .84 (Jones et. al, 2002).
formulated. The first section of the survey requests the participant to respond to
seven questions related to their gender, to their year of birth, to their level of
financial aid in fall 2007 semester, and to their current position. Using a five-
56
5 = strongly agree), the participants are asked to rate their opinion about the
in the third section (i.e. simulation technology), and in the fourth section (i.e.
assessment technology).
Within the second section of the survey, the participants are asked to
for community colleges' faculty members. The third section of the survey asks
technology in teaching and in learning. All participants are asked in the fourth
A pilot study (n=25) was conducted to measure the content validity and
the reliability of the instrument in June 2008 using a cross impact matrix (Young,
Rinehart, & Place, 1989). The result of the pilot study was reviewed by a panel
of experts. It was determined by the panel that the instrument possesses content
validity, that is, the survey measures what it is intended to measure (Huck, 2004).
(See Appendix A for the example of printed version of the survey questionnaire).
Independent variables
There is one independent variable with three levels and three dependent
variables in this study. The levels of independent variable includes three position
a) Executive administrators are the individuals who are on the top level of
organizational structure and who are responsible for making strategic and
presidents.
Dependent variables
This study examines the perceived value of three dependent variables: (a)
problems as well as will reduce the educational cost, and assessment technology
Procedures
and email in the first week of September 2008 when the fall semester of 2008
had started and when targeted participants were not in the hectic mode of
questionnaire immediately. Reminder emails were sent out in the third week of
September 2008 to thank those who completed the survey and to remind and
Both the cover letter via U.S. mail and the email explain the focus of and
the purpose of the study as well as the significance of the data collected from the
was included in the cover letter of U.S. mail and was included also in the email to
member, and findings of the study will be useful for other communtiy colleges in
America. It is explained in the cover letter of the mail as well as in the email that
the survey only will take less than 10 minutes to complete, and the participant
would remain anonymous (See Appendix B for the example of cover letter).
the completed survey questionnaire via the U.S. mail. An appreciation note is
59
included in the questionnaire for the participants' time in completing the survey.
As an incentive to increase the return rate of the survey, the appreciation note
offered feedback about finding of the study to the participants if they entered their
spreadsheet and used as the inputs for the statistical analysis of this study.
Composite scores were calculated for each of the responses in the spreadsheet.
SPSS statistical software was used to analyze the collected data and to produce
Statistical analysis
The statistical analysis for this study is done using one-way MANOVA on
three by three matrices as shown in Table 1. Each of the nine cells contains the
mean of perceived value for the dependent variables from the study participants.
Table -\. MA NO VA
Executive
Administrators
Deans
Faculty
60
Chapter 4
Finding
Descriptive Statistics
copy returned using the stamped self-addressed envelope. The returned data
the smallest enrollment is 800 students (n = 2), the largest enrollment is 60,000
students (n = 1), and the average enrollment is 11,313 students. The average
percentage of students receiving some sort of financial aid is about 56% with a
standard deviation of 18.41%, and one community college responded that 100%
of their students are financial aid recipients. Table 2 shows the statistics of
Std.
N Range Minimum Maximum Mean Deviation
Student
154 59200 800 60000 11313.01 10092.99
Enrollment
Financial
Aid 154 94.00% 6.00% 100.00% 56.10% 18.41%
Recipients
The average age of respondents is 52.91 years with the youngest one being 30
the respondents hold a master's degree. Only six of the respondents hold a
educational level grouped by their job position, sex, and educational level.
Educational Level
Master
degree Bachelor
with degree
some with some
graduate graduate
Doctoral course Master course Bachelor
Position Sex degree work degree work degree Total
Executive Female 16 4 0 0 0 20
Male 18 8 0 0 0 26
Dean Female 14 8 3 0 0 25
Male 16 7 4 1 0 28
Faculty Female 10 17 6 2 0 35
Male 3 11 3 1 2 20
Total 77 55 16 4 2 154
teaching experience, and two male deans indicated that they do not have any
years.
cocoio^fooc^coio^r^u^tf)i^coco^c\ic\icoco^cr><r}iou3^^coocDioOT
C ^cNcdodT-'oo^todcjJco^ocviu^o^aJcrJirlcviirJ^ir)
CD T-T-T-T-T-(\JCvlCOCOCO^Tl-^ininCDCDNSNCOOOOOOOCOOOCOa)C3>0)0)C3)C350
o
0
Q_
CD
.>
'-4—»
e E
CD
CD Ocr>0>C35Cq05OTCT>C£)CJ)cr>COC35CV|lOiqiOCJ5 o > ^ c \ j o q o > c 3 i c v | c r ) C T > a > o > c o c o o ) < r 5 c q c p c £ > c p c p
-£
o c v:scoirico^-:coT-:T-:T-:T: co^ "c\i
0
CD
o
CD
.2 Q_
O
c CMCMCDCOTj-COCOCDT-COMCJJCOmNNSCDCOT-iOOJCDCOmcOCOCOCO T - co CM T - -q-
.o o
c
•S CD
.CO
Dl
Q CD
c
CD
Cr CO
i_ c\ico^incDi^oo<3)OT-cNoo"«j'incDr^.coc3>OT-cNico^-ir)N.coT-
CD OCslCO^lOCDNOOO) ^X-T-T-X-T-T-T-CSICNCN<NCN|<NCVJC\ICNCN00COCOCOC000COCO-S1-
0
>-
.Q
CD
64
N 154
Mean 17.84
Median 18.00
Mode 20
Range 41
Minimum 0
Maximum 41
Statistical Tests
To make sure that the sample data in this study come from the same
with the null hypothesis specifying that all respondents (i.e. executives, deans,
and faculty members) differ only due to sampling fluctuation (Huck, 2004). The
chi-square test failed to produce a significant difference (x2(2) = 1.36, p <= 5.99)
Reliability of the survey responses for this study is assessed for internal
consistency, and the computed Cronbach's alpha coefficient indicates that the
reliability of the responses to be .82 for the second section (i.e. technology
competency), to be .81 for the third section (i.e. simulation technology), and to be
.88 for the fourth section (i.e. assessment technology). These findings with the
65
sample data are consistent with the pilot study (n = 25) conducted in June 2008,
the computed Cronbach's alpha values indicate that the survey is reliable (Huck,
2004; Aron & Aron, 2003). Table 8 shows the survey's reliability as well as the
number of items comprising each of the composite scores, and Table 9 displays
Wilks' Lambda (F = 4.752, p < 0.05) indicates that one or more significant
differences exist among the means for the three group classification—community
members.
66
The result of the multivariate test for this study is shown in Table 10.
2.21, df = 2, p > 0.05). The second null hypothesis and the third hypothesis are
Source DF SS MS F
Between groups 2 281.18 140.59 12.58*
Within groups 151 1687.16 11.17
Total 153 1968.34
*p<05
67
Source DF SS MS F
Between groups 2 180.37 90.19 10.33*
Within groups 151 1318.17 8.73
Total 153 1498.54
*p<05
subject test, a post hoc test is conducted to investigate the likely reason for
rejecting the second null hypothesis and the third null hypothesis. A Fisher's
differences among the three group classifications (Huck, 2004). The result of
Fisher's LSD procedure, as shown in Table 13 and Table 14, confirms the result
members.
members.
The findings from this study indicate that community colleges' executives,
deans, and faculty members are in agreement about the value of technology
competency, and congruence exists in the value of simulation technology and the
the faculty members and the executives. The faculty members fail to agree with
the deans about the perceived value of value of simulation technology as well as
Chapter V
Discussion
increase student learning outcomes (Cradler et al., 2002; Edwards et al., 2000;
competency for 21st's century workers (Dede, 2007). The infusion of educational
technology to U. S. public schools and colleges has been slow (Smolin &
resources with human resources to produce new methods for improving teaching
with human resources to be effective (Bok, 2003). Jones et al. (2007) and Zhang
70
(2002) point out that current college students are technologically more advance
technology into their teaching to avoid a technology mismatch between them and
students. Educators need to assess the knowledge and skills required for 21 st
century citizens and to innovate new learning approaches that will be appropriate
centered learning (i.e. self-directed learning) (Rovai et. al, 2007) where online
students engage with their teacher to complete required learning tasks by using
plans for their organizations (Ham, 1997; McKenzie, 1999; Rice & Miller, 2001).
activities to support the learning units (Pellegrino et al., 2007), and two specific
educational technologies useful for this purpose are simulation technology and
assessment technology.
computations, and visualization (Grabe & Grabe, 2007; Haertel, et al, 2007;
instructional units (Grabe & Grabe, 2007; Haertel et al, 2007; Pellegrino et al,
college level on educational technology (Cohen & Brawer, 1996) is the motive of
(2003) assert that people and organizations are interdependent and that
72
this model, community college educators (i.e. executives, deans, and faculty
technology.
community college faculty members (mean = 23.39 vs. 20.16, p < .05; see Table
members (mean = 23.40 vs. 20.16, p < .05; see Table 9). Also, Community
college faculty members are significantly different in their perceived value about
(mean = 20.28 vs. 17.84, p < .05; see Table 9) and deans (mean = 19.89 vs.
future research.
73
Technology Competency
etal.,2007).
the highest potential rating, and the score of 12 reflects the lowest potential
technology at their institutions (see Table 10 for the descriptive statistics of this
attribute to the possibility that community colleges have removed successfully the
(2007). In their study at various accredited colleges within the State of North
among accounting faculty members: (1) fear of change, (2) fear of time
commitment, (3) fear of appearing incompetent, (4) fear of failure, and (5) fear of
education (Bradley, 2006), and in allowing all learners, including those with
(Payne & Sachs, 1994); community college educators must work together to
keep suppressing the five technology fears among community college faculty
members.
resources and support, (2) effective technology training for teaching and
Because faculty members are the parties responsible for utilizing available
include faculty members in developing technology plans, including the one that
McKenzie, 1999; Office of Information Technology, 2006; Rice & Miller, 2001;
Rovai et. al, 2007). To ensure an effective planning process, community college
leaders should promote lateral coordination (Bolman & Deal, 2003) that utilizes
developing their technology plan. The leadership at community college level must
must maintain an on-going and a concise communication with their faculty during
changes (Argyris, 1991; Burns, 2003; Dahl, 1989; Leithwood & Jantzi, 1999;
www.nwlink.com, 2006). This situation is consistent also with one of the theories
76
Simulation Technology
Four best practices listed in the new standards for teaching and for
learning in America's schools advocate that learners reflect on, debrief about,
environment where learners are responsible for their own learning (Tomel, 2003).
where teachers act as conductors in orchestrating their lessons (Grabe & Grabe,
2007; Recesso & Orrill, 2008). Desrochers, House, and Seth (2001) found that
increased the test scores of the participants on the subject matter when
alone (Brant, Hooper, & Sugrue, 1991; Desrochers et. al, 2001; Grabe & Grabe,
2007). Grabe and Grabe (2007) pointed out four benefits of integrating simulation
lectures such as (1) the flowing of electrons in an electrical circuit, (2) the
orbiting path of planets around the sun, or (3) the drifting of continents
overtime.
dissecting a virtual frog on the computer screen or by flying a jet using a flight
(Grabe & Grabe, 2007. p. 126) as well as in six knowledge levels of Bloom's
evaluation (Recesso & Orrill, 2008). Studies indicate that simulation software will
apply to their understanding about specific learning units, and it was expected
college faculty members are not in agreement with their executive administrators
(mean difference = -3.23, p < . 0 5 ; see Table 13) as well as with their deans
(mean difference = -2.23, p < . 0 5 ; see Table 13) about the value of
(mean difference = 1.00, p > .05; see Table 13). Considering that both executive
community college faculty members and their administrators, this difference may
be attributed to one or both of the following two reasons. The first reason is that
teachers teach "the way they were taught" (p. 61), and, if they failed to
experience educational technology in their education, most likely that they will fail
educational technology in their education, would likely to maintain the status quo
of their teaching. This status quo of teaching assumes that faculty members are
the central figure in a classroom to assure a quality student learning, and faculty
79
(Guskin, 1994).
additional challenges to faculty members who will incorporate the technology into
1999).
integrate into group activities (Brown, 1999). Due to this challenge, faculty
simulation technology into their lesson plans. Without proper support and
create difficulty for many colleges and universities to share classrooms among
(i.e. executives and deans) may be rooted in the challenges pointed by Brown
and deans must devise and must implement a strategic plan to acquire and to
simulation technology into their courses as well as to share their experience with
faculty members to address these changes (Vrasidas & Glass, 2007) and to
Assessment Technology
tool as well as an indicator for helping teachers to measure the mastery level of
specific time such as the grades recorded on a report card. This assessment
the hand, formative assessment presents feedback for those who engage in the
student performance for a given learning unit (Garrison & Ehringhaus, n.d;
Starkman, 2006).
knowledge, and the result of each of the practices helps teachers to formulate
subject matter, and the feedback can be used to improve and to enhance
students' understanding of the subject matter (Bransford et. al, 2000; Haertel et.
with the information to reach the next learning goals (Garrison & Ehringhaus,
students can assess and can improve their understanding about the subject
being examined (Bransford et. al, 2000). Assessment technology elevates the
amount and the quality of feedback by allowing students and teachers to interact
electronically and efficiently (Bransford et. al, 2000; Haertel et. al, 2007;
skills as well as for allowing them to observe their progress over time. The
format. For example, students may be asked to discuss and to report about
explanation for various specific diagnoses (Haertel et. al, 2007). In Bransford et.
83
technology. On the contrary, through a Fisher's LSD post hoc procedure, this
study found that community-college faculty members are not in agreement with
their executive administrators (mean difference = -2.45, p < .05; see Table
14) as well as with their deans (mean difference = -2.05, p < . 0 5 ; see Table
technology (mean difference = .40, p > .05; see Table 15). Similar to the finding
in this study is a significant topic for further studies. In the meantime, using the
literature reviewed in and the data collected by this study, a discussion will offer
their courses.
Those faculty members who learn using technology during their education
have a tendency to utilize technology in their teaching, and these individuals are
willing to learn more about technology (Adcock, 2008). The statistics for faculty
age in this study show that the average faculty age is 52.4 years, the median
faculty age is 56 years, and the mode faculty age is 56 years (See Table 4). With
more than 70% of the faculty members being 50 years or older (see Table 5), it is
reasonable to suggest that many of faculty participants in this study did not use
the years of 1979 and 1984, when they were between 19 years old and 26 years
old, and when personal computers and educational technology were in early
stage.
integrating multimedia (i.e. images, texts, sounds) in the feedback provided to the
acceptable level of technology training for their teachers is the lack of funding
favor applicants based on their technology competency when selecting and when
hiring new faculty (Arvey & Faley, 1992). Because faculty members are
hire new faculty members who are capable of integrating educational technology
in their courses, and these new faculty members may stimulate existing non-
the academic senate representing faculty members, the classified staff, and the
college, including the decision related to the planning and the implementation of
appropriate educational technology that will support and will improve student
learning. This study suggests that the academic senates of community college
members.
people think and learn (Argyris, 1991; Burns, 2003; Dahl, 1989; Leithwood &
members share ideas and work together (Boyte, 2004) to harvest various
Further Research
hoped that the findings of this study will help community colleges in developing
One limitation of this study is that it fails to take into consideration the
"one size fits all" approach in planning and developing technology training
provide specific data about the success and the failure of educational technology
boards to adjust their policies related to the planning and funding of educational
responses given in this study. Using the data collected in this study, a study to
technology, and assessment technology) with age, with sex, and with teaching
88
data would help community colleges to alter their technology culture at their
campuses.
89
References
Aron, A. & Aron, E. N. (2003). Statistics for Psychology, 3rd Edition. Upper Saddle
Bennis, W. & Nanus, B (1997). Leaders: The strategies for taking charge
Brant, G., Hooper, E., & Sugrue, B. (1991). Which comes first—the simulation or
http://www.ccleague.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=3359
Chambers, H.E. (2001). Finding, hiring and keeping peak performers: Every
Cohen, A.M. & Brawer, F.B. (1996). The American Community College, 3rd
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Hillsdale,
NJ: Erlbaum.
Cradler, J., McNabb, M., Freeman, M., & Burchett, R. (2002, May). How does
Dahl, R. A. (1989). Democracy and its critics. New Haven: Yale University Press.
the National Society for the Study of Education, Part II (pp.11-38). Maiden,
Desrochers, M. N., House, A. M., & Seth, P. (2001). Supplementing lectures with
from
http://www.iste.org/Content/NavigationMenu/Research/NECC_Research_
Paper_Archives/NECC_2005/DiBenedetto-April-NECC05.pdf
http://www.co.monterey.ca.us/eqopp/faqs.htm.
http://www.fresnocitycollege.edu/senate/curriculum.html.
93
Galbraith, J. R., Lawler III, E. E., & Associates (1993). Organizing for the future:
The new logic for managing complex organizations. San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass Publisher.
http://www.nmsa.org/Publications/WebExclusive/Assessment/tabid/1120/
Default.aspx.
Haertel, G. D., Means, B., & Penuel, W. (2007). Technology tools for collecting,
practice for teachers and teacher educators. The 106th year-book of the
National Society for the Study of Education, Part II (pp. 103-132). Maiden,
Huck, S. W. (2004). Reading Statistics and Research, 4th Edition. Boston, MA:
Jones, D. A., Shultz, J. W., & Chapman, D. S. (2006). Recruiting through job
Jones, E. T., Lindner, J. R., Murphy, T. H., & Dooley, K. E. (2002). Faculty
Administration, 5(1).
Jones, S., Johnson-Yale, C , Perez, F. S., & Schuler, J. (2007). The Internet
Blackwell Publishing.
15, 131-165.
95
www.fno.org/sum99/reluctant.html.
http://itc.utk.edu/technology/documents/ClickerFinalReport.pdf.
Office of Management and Budget (2008). The budget for fiscal year 2009.
http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/fy2009/pdf/appendix/edu.pdf.
http://ejite.isu.eduA/olume3No1/Oh.htm.
2/shared.htm.
from
http://www.eric.ed.gov.hmlproxy.lib.csufresno.edu/ERICDocs/data/ericdoc
s2sql/content_storage_01/0000019b/80/13/da/cb.pdf
Pellegrino, J. W., Goldman, S. R., Berthental, M., & Lawless, K. (2007). Teacher
education and technology: Initial results from the "What Works and Why"
Blackwell Publishing.
Posner, G. J. (2004). Analyzing the curriculum (3rd. ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-
Hill.
Reeves, D. B. (2002). The daily discipline of leadership: How to improve student
CA: Jossey-Bass.
http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/UN/UNPAN02181
4.pdf.
Company.
Review, 4, 94-97.
Ruffins, P. (2007). The secrets behind their success. Diverse: Issues in Higher
Education, 24(14).
Senge, P., Cambron-McCabe, N., Lucas, T., Smith, B., Dutton, J., & Kleiner, A.
parents, and everyone who cares about education. New York, NY:
Doubleday.
for the Study of Education, Part //(pp. 1-10). Maiden, MA: Blackwell
Publishing.
http://web.ebscohost.com.hmlproxy.lib.csufresno.edu/ehost/detail?vid=3&
hid=114&sid=96568e62-18c2-4a31-b253-
7401801258b6%40sessionmgr104.
fiscal years 2006-07; 2007-08; 2008-09 between SCCCD and state center
Publishing
99
Tyack, D., & Cuban, L, (1995). Tinkering toward utopia: A century of public
english/2006/December/200612010935031 CJsamohT0.756817.html.
http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d07/tables/dt07_235.asp?referrer=repo
rt.
http://nces.ed. gov/programs/digest/d07/tables/dt07_256.asp?referrer=repo
rt.
http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d07/tables/dt07_183.asp?referrer=repo
rt.
100
White, W. E., Van Scotter, R., Hartoonian, H. M., & Davis, J. E. (2007). The
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_technology.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education.
http://www.findarticles.eom/p/articles/mi_m0FCG/is_3_30/ai_108836885.
3-16.
25,639-651.
101
for whites and blacks. Equity & Excellence in Education, 19(3), 68-71.
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/content~content=a746923966~db=alh
order=page.
from http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/leader/leadcon.html.
Young, I. P., Rinehart, J. S., & Place, A. W. (1989). Theories for teacher
Education, 5, 329-336.
SA N D SD
http://cctechvalues.net
Confidentiality of your participation will be treated with the utmost respect. If you
would like to receive a summary and implications of the results of this research,
please send an email to ray.tiahjadi@scccd.edu.
Thank you for your time and significant contribution to this research. They are
greatly appreciated.
Sincerely,
Ray Tjahjadi
Information Systems Faculty
The North Centers, Reedley College
State Center Communtiy College District