Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Daniel Roettger
Dr. Tebbetts
Exam Two
This passage, derived from Voltaire’s Candide, tells a fraction of the Old Woman’s
story. Her life, as explained earlier in the work, was posh and elegant, as she was the
daughter of a Pope. However, the murder of her fiancé, the capture of her ship, the
grotesque killing of her mother (which she witnessed firsthand), and her subsequent
enslavement rendered this once beautiful virgin a hideous hag. In this passage, the Old
Woman recollects her first experience in captivity, in which she was searched for jewels
in rather inappropriate places by more inappropriate means. This passage, as does the
work as a whole, shows the attempt to conform people in spite of the individualistic
mindset of the era, as well as show this process does not, after all, make for the best of all
The efforts to conform people and quell the individualistic spirit, whether it was
by inquisitors or pirates, beckon a large chunk of the work. The pirates who overtook the
Old Woman’s ship began to strip their captives with great haste and vigor. After the
captives were “promptly stripped as naked as monkeys,” the group in entirety, sparing no
maid nor her mother, was completely searched. This strip and subsequent search, to me,
symbolize the attempt by leading institutions of the time to take the ideal of individualism
away from the people. By removing their clothes and whatever may lie below them, the
pirates, or whoever is in control of the people, are able to remove their identity, just as
thieves, according to Dante, are able to take a person’s identity. Furthermore, by using
Roettger 2
the simile “as monkeys,” Voltaire shows taking the individualism from the people
demeans them more and makes them feel bestial rather than human. This search clearly
shows the intentions of the pirates – they wanted their captives equally inferior and
unable to hide any loot they may have. By taking the identity of the people, the pirates
were able to make their captives subordinate, for they had nothing but their naked,
defenseless, weak, feminine bodies. Furthermore, if the captives could hide their loot, it
would impede the grafting of their captives – their literal intention – a practice the pirates
surely did not want. The Old Woman, astonished by the “energy [those] gentleman put
into stripping people,” found their processes a bit strange. Yet the fervor the pirates
stripped their captives with only furthers my point that their goal was to remove
individualism and pride while they still had control over their captives. Once again
retreating to the Church example: support for the Catholic Church waned as the
quell this anti-Catholic revolution in the North, the Popes turned to draconian measures –
the Inquisition – while they could still exert their will over the land. Here, the pirates,
fearing the loss of their beautiful, precious commodities, quickly removed the will and
their fingers in a place where [they] women only admit a syringe,” continue this violating
process. The Old Woman, by calling the stripping, searching, and violating measure an
“international [law] that has never been questioned,” shows the process, in its brutish
This brutish yet socially accepted method of demeaning people detracts from
Pangloss’ reasoning that this is the “best of all possible worlds,” especially for moral law.
Roettger 3
By modern standards, rape, murder, incest, and kidnapping are condemned, even by death
in some places; by their standards, if God somehow, obscurely willed it, it was hunky-
dory. In the passage, the capture, stripping, and searching of women in their private parts
is hardly part of a perfect world. Yet this practice is unquestioned and thus accepted
because, to them, God created the world. And if God created the world, the Almighty
must have created it with perfection in mind. Therefore, by the transitive property, the
world must be perfect and all institutions thereof must be as well. This is why this
barbaric practice was both tolerated and endorsed by “the genteel people who swarm the
seas.” (This is my impression of Pangloss.) Furthermore, the Old Woman’s captors, “the
very religious knights of Malta, never overlook[ed] this ceremony” of searching for
diamonds in a person’s, well, person. Is it not appalling that, in this world that claims to
be of perfect moral character, religious zealots pry their way into women’s bodies while
committing thievery? From this example alone, it is clear Voltaire despises Pangloss’
lack of reason and satirically supplants it with his own. It is Voltaire’s objective to show
the flaws in the reasoning that the world was perfect and all institutions thereof were
perfect. Voltaire believed these institutions, including the equally barbaric Church, were
Throughout Candide, these themes are evident. In the land of Eldorado, the
group of people in constant agreeance. In Spain, the Inquisitor kills those who challenge
the authority of the Catholic Church in an effort to remove individualism from the
people. The Prussian Army, in yet another example, recruits only those taller than five-
Roettger 4
feet five-inches to create physical conformity. Throughout the book, and the world,
according to Voltaire, forces seek to conform the masses for order but rather than create
order, the forces create calamity. For example, the Spanish Inquisition, in an effort to
create religious conformity, kills all non-Catholics, creating a bloody landscape. The
Muslims did the same. The Prussians, in order to govern the world, did the same by
burning the Baron’s castle to take away its individualism and power, to make a power
vacuum to be filled by the Prussians. All these killings do nothing to create a social law
rather than, as Cacambo said, Social Darwinism. Natural law, as Rousseau suggested,
creates individualistic savages, who some force sees as a threat and exterminates
accordingly. In this mindless world of killing, there can be more moral code or law. The
moral code, according to the passage, is the capture of women and inappropriate search
of their privates. If that was truly law, what a hypocritical and unsound world we would
live in.
Voltaire’s intention though the passage was to discredit the ideals of those who
believed individualism was the bane of civilization. Though, as I earlier stated, this
message appears often and vehemently in the passage, it appears throughout the work
with the same tone. Voltaire believed in individualism and believed a world lacking it
would be a world of mindless, gullible zombies. If the people were to thrive, they must
assert their will over authorities not though anarchy, as Martin might have suggested, but
through rational reason. If we lose ourself, our individualism, what are we, Voltaire
questioned. We must use reason rationally to determine moral law pursuant to our