Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ZhXdWZgiV
YV9jhig|a^V' VheZhhdVhYd EjcYd 9ci^\d
ckZcX^YVh
YZfjZ a\Q\` dh X^hcZh
ZgVb WgVcXdh)
=hiVZgVjbV
Zhi^dc|kZaedg hZgVWhdajiVbZciZXdc[^gbVYV
edg Zk^YcX^Vh
ZeVgVg(hZ
Xdb d eg^bZ^gdX^hcZcZ\gV edYZ iZgh^YdjbV
iZgZhhVciZ
eVgVVa\jch dgc^iad\dh $ZdjigVh eZhhdVh
ciZ egZdXjeVYVhXdb VXdadgV~d
Ydhe|hhVgdh%'bVh c~d
* V^bedgi}cX^VYZhhV
]^hig^V)=aVh^beaZhbZciZ ^ajhigV
~d hZkZgV
cd VegZcY^oVYd
edg bZ^d YZdWhZgkVZh
dj
Z V[gV\^a^YVYZ
YZcdhhd Xdc]ZX^bZcid)MbV c^XV
edYZ ^ckVa^YVg
jbV V[^gbV~ddg^\^cVYV
eZaVZm^hicX^V
YZX^hcZhWgVcXdh)
LjYd fjZ hZegZX^hV
YZjb c^Xd
AgV
$fjZ iVbWb' eZad fjZ hZ^' bj^id [Z^d%)!
HUR;aaN_QVN[
LhHJD+EO
r
-LSN/ N/HRO
d ^beVXid
Yd VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa
DYIL\kjV
=IYKMSVCKPQSL
BM]QZjVDlKUQKI
=IYQV@QUV
!!
+@MN6@FF@L
;AH(:J9KAD) ;9L9DG?9x9G(F9(>GFL=
KAF<A;9LG F9;AGF9D <GK =<ALGJ=K <= DANJGK' JB)
L,/3D
LVaZW'FVhh^b
9 a\^XVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd5 d ^beVXid Yd VaiVbZciZ
^begdk|kZa *FVhh^b F^X]daVhLVaZW6
igVYj~d YZEVg(
XZadKX]^aY)( J^d YZBVcZ^gd5
6R`aGRYYR_&
,**2(
LgVYj~d YZ5L]Z :aVX` KlVc
AK:F 423(30(213/(-,-(0
DN_N6R[\Va AN[QRYO_\a&
bZ T_RT\ R[a_R_\ZN[\`
,) AcXZgiZoV
$LZdg^V
YV^c[dgbV~d%( 9heZXidhhdX^V^h)
-) HgZk^h~d)Y'Lijad)
;<<5 ++.)0/
;<M5 ++2
;deng^\]i
Lijad dg^\^cVa
L@= :D9;C KO 9F
a -++2 WnFVhh^b F^X]daVhLVaZW)
;VeV5 KZchZ<Zh^\c
=Y^idgV~dZaZigc^XV5
9WgZj#hKnhiZb
LdYdh dh Y^gZ^idhgZhZgkVYdh)
Hgd^W^YV
VgZegdYj~d'
cd idYd dj Zb eVgiZ' hZb Vjidg^oV~d egk^Vedg ZhXg^id
YVZY^idgV'hZ_VbfjV^h [dgZb dh bZ^dh ZbegZ\VYdh)
<^gZ^idhZmXajh^kdhYZejWa^XV~dZb ac\jV edgij\jZhV
eVgVd :gVh^aVYfj^g^YdheZaV
=<ALGJ9 :=KL K=DD=J DL<9)
JjV 9g\Zci^cV' ,2,' eVgiZ' K~d ;g^hik~d
J^d YZBVcZ^gd'JB ( -+4-,(.3+
fjZ hZgZhZgkVVegdeg^ZYVYZa^iZg|g^VYZhiVigVYj~d
;=5Z:37
8RhLOHO
KdWgZ
VeajbV\Zb Ydhe|hhVgdh
? ^bR c\Po [l\ `NOR
9e]R_a` R !aR_[\` cNgV\`!
5]_R[QR[Q\ N N]_R[QR_
Mb cdkd i^ed YZ^c\gVi^Y~d
9 k^YV bj^id ZhigVc]V
HaVi~dZd cZgY
;]Vid YZbV^heVgVhZZhXgZkZg
VgZheZ^id
G eg^cX^eVa
,0
,0
+1
+2
,*
-,
-.
-/
-0
-2
AN]N QRPN]pabY\`
8+:</ =5) + +6<3,3,L37</-+
8:7-=:+57;
>+43.+\`/;
,2
./
=5,/:<7
/-7&
7= -757
-BPgTULO=M) 7 BPRFNEJXBEO
EF UM DeTJDOFMPgRJDO
9cVidb^V YZjb ;^hcZ FZ\gd
G\O_RSNgR_\ R`]R_NQ\
!DN_Np`\!RcN]\_NQ\
5 [\VaRR`a_RYNQN
@^hig^VZ d iZgXZidYVdeVX^YVYZ
BV[TbnZ `NOR\ ^bR R`aj NP\[aRPR[Q\
-4
.,
.,
-.
-/
-0
.1
.2
5 <V`aq_VN
[l\ `R N__N`aN&
Qj `NYa\`
EbR_VQ\QVj_V\35 <V`aq_VN
N[QN]N_N a_j`
9QbPNml\RZ bZ ajeV
9\adbZgVYdh
C[QR n \ `U\d4
.XTQR]\V`
? ]NYNc_l\ QNV[QR]R[Qo[PVN
:VYq`\S\ QRYVZb`V[R
-BPgTULO<RfS)7 FSPFDULBEOR
F B PROSTJTUTB
G bZa]dg $e^dg%XdchZa]d
;j^YVYd Xdb d ZhXVa|kZa
? NQcR[a\QNR`PNYNOVYVQNQR
=hXVaVW^a^YVYZ
Z \adWVa^oV~d
N^V\Zchcd EZY^dXg^hi~d
? R`a_N[U\]Np` Q\ 9ea_RZV`al\
? 9ea_RZV`al\ R\ P\[URPVZR[a\
=[aR[`\ RZ\QR_NQ\
5 aV_N[VN
Q\ NPVQR["aR
-BPgTULO9UBTRO)5JLF UM EJBS$OU DOMO NcO SFRUM TROUWB
;dbd VegZcYZgXdb d eZgj
H_RV[NQ\]N_N`R_PUNa\
G 7V`[RBRT_\ R`aj _RYNPV\[NQ\
N\ P\[URPVZR[a\
MbV WgZkZ
]^hig^VYd egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd
GReab`&
\ #V[SRYVgZR[aR$
RZ]p_VP\
5YTNgRY
? PnaVP\&
NZVT\ QN_RYVTVl\
Bl\ ^bR_\ `R_bZ ]R_b
9YR`^bR_RZ cVcR_[\ ARQV\P_V`al\
-BPgTULO-JNDO) -ONGJRMBdcODOJSBNFNIUMB
BRZ a\Q\` \` O\\TYR``l\ g\\TYR`
D_\cN`
=be^g^hbd cZ\Vi^kd
7\[aN[Q\ Nana_o`
JV \ba_\ AV[V cR_ZRYU\
BRZ abQ\
8R c\YaNN\ ARQV\P_V`al\
-BPgTULO;FJS)+ GBLaDJB
NBRRBTJVB
KdWgZVhXVjhVhYVb^c]V gZ_Z^~dVXVjhVh
<^k^Y^cYdXgZWgdh
VdbZ^d
IZ ]\bP\ ZNV`QRQ\]NZV[N
5 _RT_NQR5[Q_Rf BVX\YNfRcVPU
IZ Z\Q\ ZRYU\_QRZ\__R_
JZXdgYVZh
YZXd^hVh
c~d ZmViVbZciZeVhhVYVh
5 [N__NaVcN
Q\ Y\bP\
BN__NaVcN
R aR_N]VN
=hiVgZggVYdXdb egZX^h~d^c[^c^iV
7Vo[PVNVZ]N_PVNY
G hZchVX^dcVa
Z d ;^hcZ FZ\gd
7RTbRV_N
N\ 7V`[RBRT_\
5 Na_Nml\Q\ `R[`NPV\[NY
Gh ViVa]dh
7bVQNQ\P\Z \ Pn_RO_\
7\Z\ RcVaN_
NSNYjPVN
[N__NaVcN
**
**
"!"
"!%
"!'
"!)
"!)
""!
"""
""#
""%
,-0
,,0
""'
,,4
"#!
"##
"#$
"#'
"#)
,-4
"$!
"$"
"$$
"$$
,./
,.0
"$'
,.3
-BPgTULO7JTO)+ SORTF
JNGBLgVFL
EF 1JBDOMO -BSBNOVB) 7
PROCLFMBEB FVJEfNDJBSJLFNDJOSB
9 ]^hig^VYdhVYdgVYdgZh
V[d\VYdh
G XZb^ig^dYZaZigVh#
7\Z\ SVPN_ZVYV\[j_V\ RZ QRg]N``\`
MbV VXVYZb^V
YZ\^c|hi^XVeVgVgVidh
JVn` ]R_cR_`\
Cba_N` N]YVPNmsR`
\PbYaN`
5 Rc\Ybml\ Q\ P\_]\ QR[NQNQ\_
G fjZ kdX k Z d fjZ kdX c~d k
AnQVP\`
9 egdiZ~d YZiZ[adc YZ?^VXdbd ;VhVcdkV
!G\b bZN ]R``\N ^bR P\__R _V`P\`!
Kdj jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd5 G k^hVcige^Xd
G !]\_^bo! `b]R_SVPVNY
,/,/-
"%&
"%(
"%*
"&"
"&"
"&#
"&$
"&&
"&'
"&*
"'"
"'%
-BPgTULO6OVF) + GBLaDJB
LiEJDBOU B JNDFRTFXB
EO NFRE
Ldcn ?dgYjX]d
>\U[ QRS\_N Q\ 6_\\XYf[
9abdd cd aV\d ;dbd
5 V[PR_aRgNQ\ [R_Q
5]\`aN[Q\ P\Z \` QNQ\` R__NQ\`
=cXZggVcYdVHVgiZMb
? `b]R_SVPVNY
cRZ U a\[N
8V`ak[PVN Q\` ]_VZN aN`
"''
"''
"')
"(!
"(#
"(%
"('
"('
"()
")"
")#
87./57;
8:/>/:
")$
")%
"))
")*
")*
"*#
"*$
"*&
,42
,43
"**
#!$
#!&
#!(
#!*
#"!
-,.
#"%
#"'
#"'
#")
##"
###
##$
##(
##(
##*
#$$
#$&
#$(
#$(
#%!
#%$
-BPgTULO.OXF) /PJSTFMODRBDJB$
UM SONIO
A\[`VRb_ QRA\[aNVT[R& R]V`aRZ\P_NaN
9]V`aRZ\P_NPVN
G eVhhVYdYd eVhhVYdZ d [jijgd Yd eVhhVYd
D_RQVml\&R__\` QR]_RQVml\ RSRYVPVQNQR
<RYR[\` R N` ]_\SRPVN`_RcR_`N`
? QR__RaVZR[a\Q\ PbO\ QRTRY\
ANV` bZN cRg&V[S\_ZNml\ V[P\Z]YRaN
? ^bR RYR`PUNZNZ QRP\[URPVZR[a\
#%&
#%'
#%(
-/3
#&!
#&"
#&"
-0.
*-,
CE=dB;?
-BPgTULO<RFXF)+PFLLFS$
O PJNTOR$
OUO QUF VODf GBXSF NcO
SOUCFRPRFVFR*
;dchZa]dh h~d WVgVidh'
bj^id WVgVidh
GRWN
a\Y\ [\` YbTN_R`PR_a\`
9`aRWN
]_R]N_NQ\
9 ^Y^V
Yd VX^YZciZ
edh^i^kd
J\YNaVYVQNQR
R_V`P\QR7V`[RBRT_\
5 R`a_NanTVN
WVgWZaa
!BV[TbnZ `NOR[NQN!
5 T_N[QRN``VZRa_VN
8+:</ <:^;) 7; -3;6/;
-36A/6<7;
-02
-02
#&*
#&*
#'!
#'"
#'"
#'#
#'(
ARQV\P_VQNQR
Q\b_NQN
? R__\QRQRb`
D\V[PN_n_bZ\ N\ `NYcNZR[a\
9YVZV[N[Q\V[SYbo[PVN`
V[Wb`aN`
!C` ;_RT\` N aR_VNZQRVSVPNQ\!
5]R[N` !`VZ)[l\!& ]\_ SNc\_
IZ S_N[Po`Q\ 6_\\XYf[
5 PNbQNY\[TN
"
;Y\ONYVgNml\V[To[bN
JZkZghZh
eVgVadc\Z Yd =migZb^hi~d
8R`VTbNYQNQR
9ea_RZV`al\ RN _RT_N2*),*
;_NZN Rj_c\_R`
7\Z\ OROR_
PNSn]\QR `R_`RTb_\
5Z\_ ]\_ PR_aRgN`
7\Z\ ]_\c\PN_ PNaj`a_\SR`
.+.
$!%
$!&
$!&
$!&
$!'
D_R``b]\`VmsR`P\[S\_aN[aR`
!5 bOV^uVQNQR
QNTNb``VN[N!
-BPgTULO.FXFSSFJS)+ FSTeTJDB
EB BLFBTORJFEBEF
-2.
#($
#(&
#((
#()
#(*
#)!
#)#
#)%
#)'
G edZiV YVVaZVidg^ZYVYZ
G eaVidc^hbd Ydhig^}c\jadh
5 TR\ZRa_VNQN[Nab_RgN
:_NPaNYVQNQR
IZN NO\_QNTRZcV`bNYQ\ 9ea_RZV`al\)ARQV\P_V`al\
Dn_\YN`N\` ]\_P\`
9 a\^XVYVVaZVidg^ZYVYZ
[gVXiVa
$Xdb jb Vk^hd%
? ]_\OYRZNQ\ YVZVaR
`b]R_V\_
7bVQNQ\P\Z N]_RPV`l\
FRcV`VaN[Q\N]\mN Q"jTbN
8N _R]_R`R[aNml\U _RNYVQNQR
EV^h jbV kZo' Xj^YVYdXdb dh egZk^hdgZh
G ?Vjhh^Vcd Zd EVcYZaWgdi^Vcd
? NbZR[a\ QNQVZV[bVml\
G ZN[QRYO_\aVN[\
? ^bR QRcR`R_YRZO_NQ\
.+-
$!(
$"$
$"%
.7 /?<:/53;<[7
-BPJTULO-BTORXF).O 5FEJODRJSTcO
BO /WTRFMJSTcO$
F EF VOLTB
BO 5FEJODRJSTcO
? Zb[Q\ n V[Wb`a\
? RSRVa\
ANaRb`
@p[TbNS_N[PN
=QnVN`
RP\[ajTV\`
F^c\jb
'(
-BPgTULO.FXFSSFTF)7S LOUDOS
EF 4ODKF$OUDURVBS
NB GORMB
EF SJNONOSLUHBRFS
FRRBEOS
5]R[N` PV[^uR[aNN[\`
5 a_NVml\Q\ R`P_Vab_j_V\
EbNY^bR_bZ ]\QR `R_]_R`VQR[aR
ANV` U\__\_
7\[SV_ZNml\
>d^ VeZcVhjb ;^hcZ FZ\gd
7\Z\
!]_\cN_! P\V`N`
$"'
$"'
$"*
$#!
$#"
$#$
$#%
$#(
$$!
$$"
$$"
$$$
$$%
$$&
$$(
$$*
$%!
$%"
$%#
.//
./2
./3
./3
-BPgTULO.FXOJTO)+ JNDFRTFXB
EO JMPOSTOR
9 [Va|X^V
aY^XV
gZk^h^iVYV
9[P\[a_R \ VZ]\`a\_
C` SVYq`\S\` ]\QRZ `R_]R_VT\`\` ]N_N N `\PVRQNQR4
? ]_\OYRZN QN]_jaVPN
IjVcidh O^ii\ZchiZ^ch edYZb YVcVgcV XVWZV
YZjb Va[^cZiZ8
C[QR R`aj D\]]R_ ^bN[Q\ c\Po ]_RPV`NQRYR4
? OV`]\ R \ N[NYV`aN
ANV` SjPVYQ\ ^bR `R ]R[`N3 G ]_\OYRZN QNQRPV`l\ `\O \
.0-
$&#
$&$
.0/
$&&
.00
.02
.03
8:_4717
PRaVPV`Z\
8+:</ 9=+<:7)
035
$'$
.10
$''
+./
+HRBEFDJMFNTOS
.14
1LOSSaRJO
.20
6OTBS
.3,
,JCLJOHRBGJB
%!*
gNEJDFRFMJSSJVO
/0,
;OCRFO BUTOR
%&*
9ciZh YVYZhXdWZgiV
YV9jhig|a^V' VheZhhdVhYd 9ci^\d EjcYd ZhiVkVb
XdckZcX^YVhYZ fjZ a\Q\` dh X^hcZhZgVb WgVcXdh)=hiV ZgVjbV XgZcV
^cfjZhi^dc|kZa edg hZgVWhdajiVbZciZ Xdc[^gbVYVedg Zk^YcX^VhZbe(
g^XVh)
<ZeVgVg(hZXdb d eg^bZ^gd X^hcZcZ\gd edYZ iZg h^YdjbV hjgegZ(
hV^ciZgZhhVciZeVgVVa\jch dgc^iad\dh $ZdjigVh eZhhdVhZmigZbVbZciZ
egZdXjeVYVhXdb VXdadgV~dYdh e|hhVgdh%'bVh c~d VfjZ Zhi| V^b(
edgi}cX^V YZhhV]^hig^V)=aVh^beaZhbZciZ ^ajhigVjbV a^b^iV~d hZkZgV
cd VegZcY^oVYdedg bZ^d YZdWhZgkVZh
dj ZmeZg^cX^Vh
Z V[gV\^a^YVYZ
YZcdhhd Xdc]ZX^bZcid) MbV c^XVdWhZgkV~dedYZ ^ckVa^YVg
jbV V[^g(
bV~d dg^\^cVYVeZaVZm^hicX^V
YZb^a]ZhYZX^hcZhWgVcXdh)LjYd fjZ
hZegZX^hV
YZjb c^Xd e|hhVgd cZ\gd $fjZ iVbWb' eZad fjZ hZ^' bj^id
[Z^d%)
=j igVchedgid ZhhVfjZhi~d a\^Xd([^adh[^XV
eVgVjbV gZVa^YVYZ
Zb(
eg^XVfjZ bZ iZb dWXZXVYd
YZhYZV^c[}cX^V)G fjZ X]VbVbdh Vfj^ YZ
9 Y^hhZb^cV~dYZiZaZ[dcZhXZajaVgZh
Xdb X}bZgVhegdedgX^dcdj(bZ jbV kVhiVXdaZ~d
YZ[did\gV[^VhYZX^hcZhcZ\gdh Zck^VYVh
edg aZ^idgZhk^V_VciZh)
Fd ai^bd FViVa'gZXZW^
iVb(
Wb jbV XV^mV
YZk^c]d ;^hcZ FZ\gd $fjZ c~d bZj [Vkdg^id%'jbV [^iVYZkYZd $c~d
Vhh^hidVkYZdh%Z Yd^ha^kgdh)HgZ[^gdVh[didh)
; CbaYVR_
gZegZhZciVdh YVYdhZheg^dhZb jbV VbdhigV ZhiVihi^XV)
$F) Q\ F(H($
G [l\ RcR[a\ YZVa\d VbeaVbZciZ ZheZgVYdiVbWb jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd) GWhZgkZfjZ' h^bZ(
ig^XVbZciZ' VdXdggcX^VYZjb ZkZcid VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa Zfj^kVaZciZ{ c~d(qXdggc(
X^VYZjb ZkZcid VaiVbZciZegdk|kZa)
5 V[PN]NPVQNQR
QR`R ]_RcR_ djia^Zgh VZ]YVPN[N V[PN]NPVQNQR
QR`R]_RcR_
\ Pb_`\ QNUV`aq_VN&
YVYVVeVgi^X^eV~dYZiV^hZkZcidh cV Y^c}b^XV Ydh
VXdciZX^bZcidh)
Fd ZciVcid V\^bdh Xdgcd hZ[hhZbdh XVeVoZh
YZegZkZgZkZcidh ]^hig^(
Xdh'dj' V^cYVe^dg' Xdgcd hZ[hhZbdh XVeVoZh
YZbjYVg d Xjghd YV]^hi(
YV)HgdYjo^bdh egd_ZZhYZY[^X^ihYVegZk^YcX^VhdX^Va
Z YZegZdh YZ
eZigaZd eVgVYVfj^ Vig^ciV Vcdh' hZb eZgXZWZg
fjZ c~d edYZbdh egZk(
adhcZb bZhbd eVgVd egm^bd kZg~d( cdhhdh ZggdhYZegZk^h~dXjbjaV(
i^kdh eVgVZkZcidh edai^XdhZ ZXdcb^Xdh h~d i~d \g^iVciZhfjZ egZX^hdbZ
WZa^hXVg
eVgViZg XZgiZoVYZfjZ c~d Zhidj hdc]VcYd hZbegZ fjZ dWhZgkd
d gZ\^higdZbeg^Xd) G fjZ hjgegZZcYZciZ c~d VbV\c^ijYZ YZcdhhdh
ZggdhYZegZk^h~d'bVh h^b cdhhV[VaiVYZXdchX^cX^V
YZaV)
Ahhd V^cYVbV^h
egZdXjeVciZ fjVcYd cdh ZckdakZbdh Zb Xdc[a^idhbdgiV^h5Vh\jZggVh h~d
[jcYVbZciVabZciZ ^begZk^hkZ^h$Zc~d hVWZbdhY^hhd%)
<Zk^Yd VZhhV^c(
XdbegZZch~d YVhXVYZ^Vh
XVjhV^hZcigZ edai^XVZ VZh'edYZbdh Y^heV(
gVg[VX^abZciZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh \gVVh{ ^\cdg}cX^VV\gZhh^kV
( Xdgcd jgcV
Xg^VcVfjZ Wg^cXV
Xdb VeZigZX]dhYZjb aVWdgVig^d
^c[Vci^aYZfjb^XV)
9 ^cXVeVX^YVYZ
YZhZ [VoZgegZk^hZh
Zb VbW^ZciZhhj_Z^idh Vd ;^hcZ
FZ\gd' Va^VYV
{ VjhcX^V \ZgVaYZ XdchX^cX^VYZhhVXdcY^~d' h^\c^[^XV
fjZ XZgidhegd[^hh^dcV^h'VeZhVgYZ VXgZY^iVgZbhZgZmeZgih'cV kZgYVYZ
c~d d h~d) ;db WVhZ
Zb hZj gZ\^higd Zbeg^Xd' ZaZhc~d hVWZbbV^h hdWgZ
Vegeg^V |gZV YZZhijYdh Yd fjZ VedejaV~d \ZgVa'bVh h~d bj^id bZ(
a]dgZh Zb cVggVg( dj' V^cYVe^dg' Zb ^begZhh^dcVg Xdb bdYZadh bViZ(
b|i^Xdh Xdbea^XVYdh)=aZhiVbWb h~d bV^h ^cXa^cVYdhV jhVg \gVkViVh)
;dgcd dh ;^hcZh FZ\gdh h~d ^begZk^hkZ^h'egZX^hVbdhcdh V_jhiVgg hjV
Zm^hicX^V
$Zb kZo YZ' ^cdXZciZbZciZ' iZciVg egZk(adh%)=m^hiZb bj^iVh
Xd^hVh
fjZ edYZbdh [VoZghZcdh XdcXZcigVgbdh cd Vci^Xdc]ZX^bZcid dj
cd fjZ c~d hVWZbdh)=cigZ bj^idh djigdh WZcZ[X^dh'
kdX edYZ hZegZeV(
gVgeVgVXdaZX^dcVg
;^hcZh FZ\gdh hZgZcY^e^idhdh$Ydi^ed edh^i^kd%bVm^(
b^oVcYd VZmedh^~dVZaZh)FV kZgYVYZ'Zb Va\jch XVbedh ( Xdgcd d YV
YZhXdWZgiV
X^Zci[^XV
Z d YZ^ckZhi^bZcidh YZg^hXd(' d YZhXdc]ZX^Ydd[Z(
gZXZjbV gZXdbeZchV YZhegdedgX^dcVa'_| fjZ' i^e^XVbZciZ' iZb(hZ edjXd
VeZgYZgZ bj^id V\Vc]Vg Xdb jb ZkZcid gVgd)NZgZbdh fjZ' Xdcig|g^d g
hVWZYdg^V
YVhX^cX^Vh
hdX^V^h'
fjVhZ cZc]jbV YZhXdWZgiV'
cZc]jbV iZX(
cdad\^V ^bedgiVciZ' [d^ [gjid YZegd_Zidh ZYZeaVcZ_VbZcid ( [dgVb VeZ(
cVh ;^hcZh FZ\gdh) 9 ZhigVi\^VeVgVdh YZhXdWg^YdgZh
Z ZbegZZcYZYdgZh
XdciVgbZcdh Xdb jb eaVcZ_VbZcid ZhigjijgVYd' [dXVa^oVg
cd b|m^bd
YZ ZmeZg^bZciV~d Z gZXdc]ZXZgVhdedgijc^YVYZh fjVcYd ZaVhhjg\Zb)
HdgiVcid Y^hXdgYdYdh hZ\j^YdgZh YZEVgm dj YZ9YVb Kb^i]5 d bdi^kd
eZad fjVa d a^kgZ(XdbgX^d[jcX^dcV edgfjZ ZaZeZgb^iZ fjZ VheZhhdVh
iZc]Vb hdgiZ' \gVVhV iZciVi^kVhZ ZggdhYZ XVg|iZgV\gZhh^kd'Z c~d edg
XdcXZYZggZXdbeZchVh dj !^cXZci^kdh! eZaViXc^XV)HdgiVcid VZhigVi\^V
ZmeZg^bZciVg
d b|m^bd edhhkZaZ iZciVgXdaZX^dcVg
d bV^dg cbZgd
edhhkZaYZdedgijc^YVYZhYZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh)
#?A7=67=6>
B 3?A7=67A
Essa
lgica
foda!
e bj^id ig^hiZeZchVghdWgZ
VheZhhdVhfjZ [dgVb bVaigViVYVh
eZaV]^hi(
=hiZ jb a^kgdhdWgZ^cXZgiZoV6
eVgVd Vjidg' jb ZkZcid gVgd R^bVcNYRV
^cXZgiZoV)
=hhVYZXaVgV~d
edYZ eVgZXZg[dgiZ ( fjZ egZX^hVbdhZhijYVg
eg^cX^eVabZciZ dh ZkZcidh gVgdhZZmigZbdh eVgVfjZ hZ_VedhhkZaYZX^[gVg
dh ZkZcidh Xdbjch (' bVh ZhXaVgZd(bZVhZ\j^g) =m^hiZb YjVh [dgbVh
edhhkZ^hYZhZVWdgYVg
[ZcbZcdh) 9 eg^bZ^gV ZmXaj^gd ZmigVdgY^c|g^d
Z XdcXZcigVg(hZcd !cdgbVa!) G ZmVb^cVYdgYZ^mVYZaVYdVh!eZXja^V(
g^YVYZh!Z ZhijYV XVhdhXdbjch) 9 hZ\jcYV VWdgYV\Zb Xdch^YZgVg
fjZ
eVgVfjZ hZedhhV XdbegZZcYZg jb [ZcbZcd cZXZhh|g^daZkVgZb Xdc(
iV eg^bZ^gd dh ZmigZbdh ( ZheZX^VabZciZhZ' Xdbd d ;^hcZ FZ\gd' ZaZh
XVggZ\VgZbjb Z[Z^idXjbjaVi^kd ZmigVdgY^c|g^d)
=j c~d bZ ^bedgid eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ Xdb d Xdbjb) KZkdX fj^hZg
qV
cd~d Yd iZbeZgVbZcid' YVi^XVZ YVZaZ\}cX^VeZhhdVaYZjb
Vb^\d' cZXZhh|g^ddWhZgk|(AdhdWVhegdkVZhYZX^gXjchi}cX^VhhZkZgVh
AcVd hdWd Wg^a]dgdhVYdcdgbVa YVk^YVXdi^Y^VcV)
e edhhkZa VkVa^Vg
d
eZg^\d gZegZhZciVYdedg jb Xg^b^cdhd ZmVb^cVcYd(hZVeZcVhd fjZ ZaZ
[VoZb jb Y^VP\ZbZ4 HdYZbdh XdbegZZcYZg VhVYZhZb aZkVgbdh Zb
Xdch^YZgV~d
VhYdZcVh^cXdcigda|kZ^hZ VhZe^YZb^Vh8
FV kZgYVYZ'
d
cdgbVa XdhijbV hZg^ggZaZkVciZ)
IjVhZ ijYd cV k^YVhdX^Va
egdYjo^Yd edg X]dfjZh Z hVaidhgVgdh
bVh XdchZfZciZh6ZcfjVcid fjVhZ ijYd fjZ ZhijYVYdhdWgZVk^YV
hdX^Va
XZcigVYdcd !cdgbVa!' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZXdb bidYdh YZYZYj(
~d Yd i^ed !XjgkVhcV [dgbV YZh^cd! fjZ c~d gZkZaVbegVi^XVbZciZ
cVYV)Hdgfj8 HdgfjZ VXjgkVcV [dgbV YZh^cd^\cdgV\gVcYZhYZhk^dh'
hZcYd^cXVeVo
YZa^YVg
Xdb ZaZh'ZV^cYV
Vhh^b[VoXdb fjZ cdh h^ciVbdh
Xdc[^VciZhYZiZgbdh YdbVYd V ^cXZgiZoV)
KZj VeZa^YdcZhiZ a^kgd V
?gVcYZ>gVjYZAciZaZXijVa
$?A>( ?gZViAciZaaZXijVa
>gVjY( cV h^\aV
Zb ^c\ah%)
Fd XdbZd YVgZkdaiV_jYV^XV
cd eg^bZ^gdhXjadYZcdhhVZgV'WdVeVgiZ
YV^gVYdh_jYZjh [d^\ZgVYV
eZaV^ch^hicX^V
YdhgdbVcdh Zb XdadXVg
jbV
Zhi|ijV YZ;Va\jaV Zb hZj iZbead Zb BZgjhVabZb igdXVYVXdadXV~d
YZjbV Zhi|ijV Yd YZjh_jYZj QV]lZ] cdh iZbeadh gdbVcdh) Gh gdbV(
cdh c~d eZgXZWZgVb
fjZ d fjZ dh _jYZjh $Zdh bdcdiZhiVh aZkVci^cdh
hjWhZfZciZh%
fjZg^Vb Y^oZgedg QRb` ZgVVWhigVid'
Zckdak^VijYd Z c~d
i^c]V cVYVVkZgXdb V'gZegZhZciV~dVcigdedbg[^XVZ ZmXZhh^kVbZciZ
]jbVcV fjZ dh gdbVcdh i^c]Vb Zb bZciZ fjVcYd Y^o^VbQRb`( ;g^i^(
XVbZciZ'd YZjh_jYZj c~d hZegZhiVkVVgZegZhZciVZh
h^bWa^XVh)
<V
bZhbV [dgbV' d fjZ bj^iVh eZhhdVhgdijaVb Z Vd fjZ Vig^WjZbkVadg
Xdbd hZcYd!YZhXdc]ZX^Yd!'
!^begdk|kZa! dj !^cXZgid!c~d gZegZhZciV
VbZhbV Xd^hV
eVgVb^b ( c~d jbV XViZ\dg^V
egZX^hV
YdXdc]ZX^bZc(
id' jbV |gZV[R_QVSVPNQN&
Zh^b d dedhid Y^hhd5
VVjhcX^V$Za^b^iVZh%
Yd Xdc]ZX^bZcid) e d Xdcig|g^d ZmVidYd Xdc]ZX^bZcid6YZkZg(hZ(^V
VegZcYZgV hZZk^iVgjhVg(iZgbdh [Z^idheVgVd Xdc]ZX^bZcid V [^b YZ
YZhXgZkZg
hZj dedhid)
(
G fjZ X]Vbd YZ]YNa\[V`Z\& Zb [jc~d YVh^Y^Vh
$ZYVeZghdcVa^YV(
YZ%Yd [^ahd[dHaVi~d' cdhhViZcYcX^VVXdc[jcY^gbdh d bVeV Xdb
d iZgg^ig^d'V XdcXZcigVgbd(cdhZb ![dgbVh! ejgVh Z WZb YZ[^c^YVh'
hZ_VbZaVhdW_Zidh'Xdbd ig^}c\jadh' dj cdZhhdX^V^h'
Xdbd jide^Vh
$hdX^ZYVYZh
XdchigjYVhVeVgi^gYZjb eaVcd Yd fjZ ![VohZci^Yd!%'Vi
bZhbd cVX^dcVa^YVYZh)
IjVcYd ZhhVh^Y^Vh
Z XdchigjXidhXdcX^hdh]V(
W^iVbcdhhVhbZciZh' YVbdheg^dg^YVYZ
VZaZhZb [VXZYZdjigdh dW_Zidh
9 WZhiV
cZhiZa^kgdc~d VeZcVhVXjgkVcV [dgbV YZh^cd Z d ZhiVihi^Xd
fjZ Zc\VcVVh^egeg^d' cZb d VXVYb^Xd
eAV
idc^[^XVYd
fjZ egZX^hV
YZ
iZdg^Vh
eVgVhZVjid(Zc\VcVg( bVh h^b d ^bejahd YZhZ![dXVa^oVg!
cd
fjZ [VohZci^YdeVgVch) N^kZgZb cdhhd eaVcZiV']d_Z' gZfjZg bj^id
bV^h^bV\^cV~dYdfjZ hdbdh [Z^idheVgViZg);VgZXZbdhYZ^bV\^cV~d
ZVgZeg^b^bdh cdh djigdh)
GWhZgkZ
fjZ' cd a^kgd'c~d gZXdggdVdbidYd WZhi^Va
YZgZjc^g!egd(
kVhXdggdWdgVi^kVh!
hZaZi^kVh)
Hdg bdi^kdh fjZ Zmea^Xd
cd ;Veijad 0'
X]Vbd d ZmXZhhd
YZZmZbeadhYZZbe^g^hbd ^c\cjd ( hjXZhhZh
YZ
VcZYdiVhhZaZX^dcVYVh
eVgVZcXV^mVgZb(hZ
Zb jbV ]^hig^Vc~d Xdchi^(
ijZb egdkVh)IjVafjZg eZhhdVfjZ egdXjgZedg Xdc[^gbVZh
ZcXdcigVg|
jb cbZgd hj[^X^ZciZYZaVh
eVgVZc\VcVgVh^egeg^d( ZiVbWb' hZb
Yk^YV'VhZjhXdaZ\Vh5
9 ^Y^V
Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd WVhZVYV
cVZhigjijgV YV
VaZVidg^ZYVYZ
cV gZVa^YVYZ
Zbeg^XV)
JZhjb^cYd5 cZhiZZchV^d$eZhhdVa%'
Xdggdg^hXdh
ZYZXaVgd'
XdcigVbj^(
idh YZcdhhdh ]|W^idh YZeZchVbZcid' fjZ d bjcYd Ydb^cVYd eZad
ZmigZbd' eZad YZhXdc]ZX^Yd
Z eZad bj^id ^begdk|kZa $^begdk|kZa hZ(
\jcYd cdhhd Xdc]ZX^bZcid XdggZciZ%
( Z fjZ eVhhVbdhd iZbed idYd
Zckdak^YdhZb b^cX^Vh'XdcXZcigVYdh
cd Xdc]ZX^YdZcd fjZ hZgZeZiZ)
Ahhd^bea^XVcV cZXZhh^YVYZ
YZhZji^a^oVgd ZkZcid ZmigZbdXdbd edcid
YZeVgi^YV'Z c~d igVi|(AdXdbd jbV ZmXZ~d
fjZ YZkZhZgkVgg^YV
eVgV
WV^md
Yd iVeZiZ)LVbWb [Vd VVaZ\V~dbV^hdjhVYV$Z^cXbdYV%YZ
fjZ' VeZhVg
Yd egd\gZhhdZ YVZmeVch~dYd Xdc]ZX^bZcid' d [jijgd hZg|
XVYV
kZobZcdh egZk^hkZa'
ZcfjVcid iVcid VcVijgZoV]jbVcV fjVcid Vh
Y # ""
"
)
;aZc;aVh hdX^V^h
eVgZXZbXdche^gVg
eVgVZhXdcYZg
YZch ZhhV^Y^V)
LVbWb Zbe^g^hbd ^c\cjd VegZhZciVg'Xdb d dW_Zi^kdYZhjhiZciVg Va\jb Vg\jbZcid'
hg^ZhYZX^iVZh
Xdc[^gbVig^VhZZadfZciZh YZVjidg^YVYZh
bdgiVh) Hdg bZ^d YZeZhfj^hV'
hZbegZ edhhkZaZcXdcigVgVa\jb fjZ [ZojbV YZXaVgV~d
hdcdgV fjZ Xdc[^gbV hZj edc(
id YZk^hiV( Z' Zb idYd ie^Xd' edhhkZa ZcXdcigVg djigd eZchVYdg bdgid fjZ Y^hhZ
ZmViVbZciZd Xdcig|g^d) IjVhZ idYVhVhX^iVZh
jhVYVhedg b^b fjZ c~d h~d YZQd\^ :ZggV
h~d YZeZhhdVhYZfjZb Y^hXdgYd)
* *S7/+/+1/47.,*
7= $,*,
-/,$1/#*,0
#$ )%!$'(&
$"&
2#);%#$G&0
%
ZhXg^idg
M5cWZgiq
=Xd'eqgiZcXZ{fjZqVXaVhhZ
gZhig^iV
YZVXVYb^(
XdhfjZ hVdZcXaXadeZYa;dh'
eZgXZeiakdhZ cVYVZciZY^VciZh)
=aZ
Ydcd YZjbV kVhiVW^Wa^diZXV
eZhhdVa$fjZ Xdcib XZgXV
YZ.+
b^a a^kgdh%
Z Y^k^YZ
dh k^h^iVciZh
Zb YjVhXViZ\dg^Vh5
dh fjZ gZV\Zb Xdb5
!\ Vj)#KtA\cdgZ]_\>R``\_R
'p6
Q\aa\_R=Xd'fjZ W^Wa^diZXV
d hZc]dg iZb IjVc(
idh YZhhZh
a^kgdhd hZc]dg _| aZj8!' Z dh djigdh ( jbV b^cdg^V bj^id
eqfjZcV (' fjZ ZciZcYZb fjZ jbV W^Wa^diZXV
eVgi^XjaVg
c~d jb Vec(
qA;ZeVgVZaZkVg
d egeg^d Z\d' Zh^b jbV [ZggVbZciVYZeZhfj^hV)D^kgdh
aAYdh
h~dbj^id bZcdh kVa^dhdh
fjZ dhc~d(a^Ydh)9 W^Wa^diZXV
YZkZXdciZg
iVcid QN`P\V`N`^bR c\Po [l\ `NORfjVcid hZjh gZXjghdh[^cVcXZ^gdh
iVmVh
]^ediZX|g^VhZ d VijVabZciZ gZhig^idbZgXVYdYZ^bkZ^ha]Z eZcqa^iVb
XdadXVg
cZaV)NdX VXjbjaVg| bV^hXdc]ZX^bZcid Z bV^ha^kgdh{ bZY^(
YVfjZ [dg ZckZa]ZXZcYd'Z d cbZgd XgZhXZciZ
YZa^kgdhc~d(a^YdhcVh
egViZaZ^gVh
da]Vg| eVgVkdXVbZVVYdgVbZciZ)
FV kZgYVYZ'
fjVcid bV^h
NdXhdjWZg'bV^dgZhhZg~dVhe^a]VhYZa^kgdhc~d(a^Ydh)NVbdh X]VbVg
ZhhVXdaZ~dYZa^kgdhc~d(a^YdhYZN[aVOVOYV\aRPN(
Fh iZcYZbdh VigViVgd Xdc]ZX^bZcid Xdbd jbV egdeg^ZYVYZ
eZh(
hdVaqjZ YZkZhZgegdiZ\^YVZ YZ[ZcY^YV)
=aZ jb dgcVbZcid fjZ cdh
eZgb^iZ hjW^gcV ]^ZgVgfj^VhdX^Va)
9hh^b' ZhhViZcYcX^VV d[ZcYZgV
hZch^W^a^YVYZ
YVW^Wa^diZXV
YZ=XdXdcXZcigVcYd(hZ
cd Xdc]ZX^Yd jbV
eVgX^Va^YVYZ
]jbVcV fjZ hZZhiZcYZ{hcdhhVhdeZgVZh
bZciV^h)9h eZh(
O +8:/6.3A+.7
=5 -]<3-7
./
/58g:3-7
VAL@HN@
$ G @MJ@FCI
L@NLIPFMIL
$ 7O?I J<MM<VM@L
@QJFD>VP@F$
6@G$
JL@A<F@
KVT V GINILDMN<
:><ON@FIM<G@HN@;
&3 CDMN[L/<
HWI ZM<LL<MN<#
@F<?V
M<FNIM
$ .L< <FBI NWIDH@MJ@L<?I
$ -ILGDH?I JIL ,- CIL<M
#
JL Xdb d dW_Zi^kd
YZZk^iVg!d[ZcYZg!dj ^cXdbdYVgdh djigdh)
YZYdhZfj(
'
) $
V^kZX^Yd
Zc~d bZ ^bedgiVkVXdb d fjZ bZjh eV^h ZbZj
cg
=j ZhiVkV
Z
)
Vb VbZj gZheZ^id( d fjZ dh YZ^PGM
Xdb WVhiVciZ
bZYd YZ
Vkd%
eZchVk
)#
)
'
' YZ[dgbV fjZ Zj c~d edY^VbZ eZgb^i^gkdaiVgVigVh'cZb bZhbd
'LLF
LH% # h j i^kZhhZ
dXjaiVYdVeVgi^X^eV~d
cV gZWZa^~d
$Xdbd bj^idh
e^hXVg)Z Z
'
Zjh [^oZgVb%Z [dhhZYZhXdWZgid'
Zb kZo YZhZgVWZgiVbZciZ
Vb^\dh b
iZc]d XZgiZoV
YZfjZ iZg^Vh^YdigViVYdXdbd jbV dkZa]V
[^ Yd g'
YZhVV
)
)
)
g
#
gdjeVh
c~d(XdckZcX^GcV^h
eVgVYZhV[^Vg
XdhbZi^;VbZciZ
Ki^
N
cZ\gV) Z
)
#YVYZ d fjZ dh X^Zci^hiVh
hdX^V^h
Z ZXdcdb^hiVhX]VbVb YZ
V Vji dc
(
)
)U
!h^cVa^oV~d
WVgViV!
( jbV Xd^hV'ZegdkVgiZgY^hedh^VdeVgVigVch(
[dgbVg d fjZ VXgZY^iV
Zb V~d djigV WZb Y^[ZgZciZ)
EZj i^d eViZgcdc~d [^Xdjbj^id ^cXdbdYVYdXdb b^c]Vh ^Y^Vh
ed(
ai^XVh
$ZaVh
kb Z k~d%6bVh [^Xdj jaigV_VYdfjZ Zj Vhji^a^oVhhZ
Xdbd
YZhXjaeV
eVgVkZhi^g(bZbVa)HVgV
ZaZ'Vd[ZchVbdgiVa ZgVVYZhZaZ\}cX^V
edg eVgiZYZjb bZbWgd egm^bd YV[Vba^V)
G Xdc]ZX^bZcideWa^Xd
YZb^c]V XVeijgViZkZdjigd \gVcYZWZcZ[(
X^d5
eZgb^i^j(bZ Zk^iVg
dh h^cV^h
ZmiZgcdhigVY^X^dcV^h
YZgZWZaY^V
VYdaZh(
XZciZ)<ZhXdWg^
fjZ bj^id bV^hZ[^X^ZciZ
V\^gXdbd jb Wdb gVeVoZhZg
!gVod|kZa!hZkdX egdkVgZhiVgY^hedhidV^gVab YZbZgVkZgWdggV\^V)
NdXedYZhZYVgVdajmd YZhZgXdb^hZgVi^kd'
^begjYZciZ ZXdgih'YZhYZ
fjZ' dXVh^dcVabZciZ'
fjVcYd bZcdh ZheZgVgZb'bVh YZbdYd XdbeaZiV(
bZciZ _jhi^[^X|kZa'
kdXegdXZhhVg
Va\jb dj ViVXVg
jb ^c^b^\d' hdbZciZ
eVgVbdhigVgfjZ edYZ[VoZgd fjZ hZZheZgVYZkdX)
9
-3A3LB> 7E3?>A36>
G !eVgVhd!a^WVch
ZkVedgdj gZeZci^cVbZciZ' YZed^hYZVa\jch i^gdhZ
WdbWVh
YZbdgiZ^gd)9a\jch bZhZhVehbZj Ze^hY^dcV eg^h~d'YZed^h
YZfjVhZ ,. hXjadhYZXdZm^hicX^V
ic^XVcdi|kZa' jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd' k^c(
Yd Yd cVYV'igVch[dgbdj d eVgVhdZb ^c[Zgcd)LZkZ^cX^djbV \jZggV
X^k^a
[ZgdoZcigZXg^hi~dhZ bjjabVcdh' ^cXaj^cYddh gZ[j\^VYdheVaZh(
i^cdh' fjZ [^XVgVbYd aVYdYdh bjjabVcdh) 9 ajiV [d^ WgjiVa'_| fjZ
VhodcVhYZXdbWViZ[^XVkVbcd XZcigdYVX^YVYZ
Z fjZ VbV^dg eVgiZ
YdhXdbWViZh
dXdgg^V
Zb |gZVhgZh^YZcX^V^h
$b^c]V ZhXdaV
[^XVkV
VedjXVh
XZciZcVhYZbZigdh YVodcV YZ\jZggV%)G Xdc[a^idYjgdj bV^h YZjbV
YXVYV
Z bZ^V)F~d hZgZ^bj^id YZhXg^i^kd)
HdYZhZgfjZ V^ckZc~d YV
eakdgVZ YVhVgbVhYZ[d\d iZc]V igVch[dgbVYdd fjZ' cV edXVYVh
ZheVYVh'
iZg^Vh^YdVeZcVhjbV h^ijV~dYZiZch~d Zb jbV Zhe^gVa
YZjb
Xdc[a^id^cXdcigda|kZabdk^Yd edg gZiVa^VZh)
9ab YVYZhigj^~d[h^XV
$fjZ hZgZkZadj[|X^aYZhZggZkZgi^YV
Xdb
Va\jch ZbegZ^iZ^gdhbdi^kVYdh'edai^XdhhjWdgcVYdhZ edgiVYdgZhYZi(
ijadh ^c\cjdh%' V\jZggVgZbdkZj WdVeVgiZYVXVbVYV
ZmiZgcV
YZhd[^h(
i^XV~dfjZ [^oZgV
YVhX^YVYZh
aZkVci^cVh
jb XZcigdXdcicjd YZ\gVcYZ
gZ[^cVbZcid^ciZaZXijVa
YjgVciZ. b^a Vcdh)Gh Xg^hi~dh
k^c]Vb YZ^mVcYd
VgZ\^~dYZhYZ
d eZgdYdYdhdidbVcdh ( dh fjZ [dgVb eVgVd GX^YZciZ
VYdiVgVbcdbZh dX^YZciV^h
Z ^chZg^gVb(hZ
cV hdX^ZYVYZ)
G mdYdVj(
bZcidj) G cbZgd YZeZhhdVhVXjaijgVYVh
XV^jVWV^md
Yd ckZaXgi^Xd)
<Z gZeZciZ'd aj\Vg idgcdj(hZ jb k|Xjd) =kVh~d^ciZaZXijVa
Va\d Y^[(
X^aYZhZgZkZgiZg
Z eVgiZYd Vci^\d gZ[^cVbZcidedYZ ZhiVgeZgY^YV
eVgV
hZbegZ)
9 ]^hig^V deVXV)
NdX k dh gZhjaiVYdh'bVh c~d k d gdiZ^gdfjZ egd(
Yjo ZkZcidh' d \ZgVYdgYV]^hig^V)@| jbV ^cXdbeaZijYZ [jcYVbZciVa
)
eg~d YdhZkZcidh'_| fjZ c~d hZk d fjZ Zhi| edg YZcigdYVb|(
cVeZgXZ"S"
)
dgcd dh bZXVc^hbdh [jcX^dcVb) G fjZ X]Vbd YZ\ZgVYdgYZ
fjbV' X*)
L
X
^hig^Xdh Y^[ZgZciZ
Ydhegdecdh ZkZcidh' VbZhbV adgbV fjZ
]
ZkZcidK
)
*
(
YdhYZjhZhc~d edYZb hZgaAYVh
hdbZciZ VigVkZh
YVdWhZgkVVd
VhbZc i ZK
)#
XZA#idh
e bj^id egdk|kZa fjZ kdX hZBV
Zc\VcVYdhdWgZVhbiZc(
YZhZjh a# )
ZhYZaZh)
* )'
' )
)
=hhVYhXdcZm~dZ hAb^aVg
V YA[ZgZcV
ZcigZ V XdbAYVfjZ hZkZ cV
bZhVYd gZhiVjgVciZZ d egdXZhhdfjZ hZedYZ dWhZgkVg
cV Xdo^c]V)$FV
ai^bVkZofjZ [^ojb O_b[PUZb XZgidgZhiVjgVciZ
X]^chcV;VcVaKigZZi'
cVeVgiZWV^mV
YZEVc]ViiVc' k^jb gVidhV^cYdYVXdo^c]V)%
9 bZciZ ]jbVcV V[a^\^YV
edg igh bVaZhfjVcYd ZcigVZb XdciVid
Xdb V]^hig^V'd fjZ X]Vbd YZaR_PRa\QN\]NPVQNQR(
=aZhh~d5
V) V^ajh~dYVXdbegZZch~d'dj Xdbd idYdh VX]VbfjZ hVWZbd fjZ
Zhi| VXdciZXZcYd
Zb jb bjcYd fjZ bV^hXdbea^XVYd$dj VaZV(
ig^d%Yd fjZ eZgXZWZb6
W)VY^hidg~dgZigdheZXi^kV'
dj Xdbd edYZbdh VWdgYVg
Vhhjcidh hd(
bZciZ Vehd [Vid' Xdbd hZZhi^kZhhZbZb jb ZheZa]dgZigdk^hdg$V
]^hig^VeVgZXZ
bV^hXaVgV
Zdg\Vc^oVYV
cdh a^kgdhYZ]^hig^VYdfjZ
cVgZVa^YVYZ
Zbeg^XV%'
Z
X)VhjeZgkVadg^oV~d
YV^c[dgbV~d [VXijVaZ VYZ[^X^cX^V
YZeZhhdVh
Xdb Xdc]ZX^bZcidh egd[jcYdh Z bj^id ZhijYd' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ
fjVcYd Xg^VbXViZ\dg^Vh
( fjVcYd !eaVidc^[^XVb!)
3
+:=8DJ<
B347
YXVYVh
YZed^h%)
;dcijYd' fjVcYd Zj eZg\jciVkV VZaZhZVXdciZXZg^V
d
bZhbd Xdb d cdhhd Xdc[a^id'ZaZgZhedcY^V5
!F~d' XaVgd
fjZ c~d) 9fj^
Y^[ZgZciZ6
hZbegZ [d^Y^[ZgZciZ)!
<Z XZgiV
[dgbV' d fjZ ZaZYZiZXiVkV
cdh
djigdh c~d eVgZX^V
Vea^X|kZa
Vh^egeg^d)
9 XZ\jZ^gVVZhhVYjgV~dfjZ V[a^\Zdh Zm^aVYdh
YZbZ^V(^YVYZ
jbV
YdZcVWVhiVciZ
Y^hhZb^cVYV)
EV^hiVgYZ'fjVcYd YZX^Y^
Zk^iVgV dWhZh(
h~d Yd Zm^aVYd
Xdb Vhegeg^VhgVoZh$VhgVoZhYdhZm^aVYdh
eZcZigVb
jb edjXd egd[jcYVbZciZ YZbV^hZb hjVheZghdcVa^YVYZh%'
ZhijYZ^a^(
iZgVijgVYZZma^d
_jhiVbZciZ eVgVZk^iVgVhVgbVY^a]Vh
YZjbV cdhiVa(
\^V VgYZciZZ dWhZhh^kV)
Gh Zm^aVYdh
eVgZX^VbiZg hZigVch[dgbVYdZb
eg^h^dcZ^gdh
YVegeg^VbZbg^V YZhjV dg^\Zb ^Ya^XV
( hZciVkVb(hZ
_jcidh Xdb djigdh eg^h^dcZ^gdh
YdeVhhVYd
Z [VaVkVbhdWgZ
d Vci^\d eVh'
Z Xdb^Vb Xdb^YVigVY^X^dcVa
ZcfjVcid jb edjXd YZbh^XV[daXag^XV
idXVkVVd[jcYd) AbV\^cVkVbXVjhVa^YVYZh
Xdci^cjVbZciZ' \ZgVcYdh^(
ijVZhVaiZgcVi^kVh
fjZ edYZg^VbiZgVXdciZX^Yd
ZZk^iVYdiV^hgjeijgVh
]^hig^XVh'
Xdbd !KZd m| c~d i^kZhhZ
cdbZVYd VfjZaZ^cXdbeZiZciZeVgV
d XVg\dYZeg^bZ^gd(b^c^higd' V^cYVZhiVgVbdha|!) =gVXdbd hZVgje(
ijgV ]^hig^XV
i^kZhhZjbV XVjhVZheZX[^XV
ZVXVi|higd[ZejYZhhZiZgh^Yd
Zk^iVYV
Xdb VgZbd~d QN^bRYNXVjhVZheZX[^XV)
9hh^b' ^cYV\jZ^VidYVh
VheZhhdVhfjZ k^k^Vb[dgVYd eVhYZdg^\Zb fjZ ejYZ ZcXdcigVghdWgZ
d XdbedgiVbZcid fqZ i^c]Vb YjgVciZ d Zma^d)
IjVhZ idYdh V\Zb YV
bZhbV [dgbV)
Gjk^bdh ^cXdci|kZ^h]^hig^VhhdWgZgZ[j\^VYdhXjWVcdhXdb bVaVh
V^cYV
eVgX^VabZciZ
VggjbVYVhfjZ [dgVb eVgVE^Vb^ cVYXVYV
YZ,41+
eVgVeVhhVg
!VeZcVhVa\jch Y^Vh!YZed^hYV^chiVjgV~dYdgZ\^bZ YZ>^YZa
;Vhigd) Gjk^bdh d bZhbd hdWgZgZ[j\^VYdh^gVc^VcdhZb HVg^hZ Ddc(
YgZhfjZ [j\^gVb YVJZeWa^XV
Aha}b^XV
Zb ,423 VX]VcYdfjZ VVjhcX^V
c~d hZg^V
bV^hYd fjZ jbVh [g^Vh
XjgiVh)9a\jch V^cYV
Zhi~dV\jVgYVcYd
eZad gZidgcd' bV^h YZjb fjVgid YZhXjadYZed^h)Ej^idh gjhhdh fjZ
eVgi^gVbZb ,4,2' Xdbd d ZhXg^idg
NaVY^b^g
F VWd`dk'^chiVaVgVb
(hZZb
:Zga^b' iVakZoV[^b YZZhiVgWVhiVciZ
egm^bdh eVgVjb gZidgcd g|e^Yd)
G egeg^d FVWd`dk eVhhdj Vk^YVidYVZb aVgZh
iZbedg|g^dh' iVcid cV
^cY^\cX^V
fjVcid cd ajmd' k^kZcYdhZjhai^bdh Y^Vh
cd ]diZa EdcigZjm
HVaVXZ'
cd aV\d?ZcZkV)
@Vk^V' XaVgd'XZgiVYdhZYZeZchVbZcid fj^bg^Xd Zb idYdh Zh(
hZhZggdhYZegZk^h~d'VXZ\jZ^gVYVZheZgVcV'bVh ]Vk^ViVbWb jb
egdWaZbVYZXdc]ZX^bZcid) 9 Y^c}b^XVYd Xdc[a^ida^WVch
[dgVeViZc(
)
i ) #MegZk^hkZa
bVh V^cYVVhh^bVgVX^dcVa^oV~d
YVheZhhdVhVd
iZgcZcZ
#
gZgcdh ZkZcidhYZbdchigVkVjbV XdchiVciZ5fjVhZ idYdhfjZ hZ
ZmVgcaaaV
i kVb eVgZX^Vb
XdckZcX^Ydh
YZfjZ XdbegZZcYAVbd fjZ ZhiVkV
agcedgV
[^XVkVbXdb(
cYd ) ;VYVcdkd Y^VigVo^VVXdciZX^bZcidhfjZ
VXdciZXZ
)
ZciZ [dgVYVhegZk^hZh'
bVh ZaZhc~d XdchZ\MaVbXdbegZZcYZg
eaZiVgc
sY
sY
U dh i^c]Vb egZk^hid)Ej^id Yd fjZ VXdciZXZjiZcV KAd XdcKaZ(
``
(
"&
Yd XdbeaZiVbZciZ adjXd Zb gZaV~dVdeVhhVYd)
EVh cVd eVgZ;AV
iVd
q6jXdQR]\V` YdhZkZcidh)=hhVeaVjh^W^a^YVYZ
gZig8heZXi^kV
\ZgVqb YZh(
Xdcid cV gVg^YVYZ
ZcV XdcXZe~dYd ZkZcid)EVAKiVgYZ'YZeVgZA
Xdb V
bZhbV ^ajh~dYZXdbegZZch~d cd hjXZhhdYZcZ\X^dhZ Zb bZgXVYdh
+
[^cVcXZ^gdh)
% ':BCMA:3=I>
(&3AA3BC3!6H B3;C>B
j^ Z Va^[dgVb WVhiVciZZhXaVgZXZYdgZh'
eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ VfjZaZh hdWgZ
Vf
)ia
X
XgZcV[gVcXZhVYZfjZ @a Zg ZgVjb aZcdbZcd igVchAidcd' d fjZ Zm(
Va^XVkV
V [VaiVYZegZeVgd YV>gVcV Z hjV g|e^YV XVe^ijaV~dhjWhZfZc(
H =b cZc]jb
bdbZcid
VZmiZch~dgZVaYVYZkVhiV~d[d^ Xdch^YZgVYV
iZ)
edhhkZa)
))')'
)
9eZhVg YZiZgbdh jbV bZbcV VaiVbZciZ bhiVkZa' jb YaVcd d[ZgZ(
XZ[Vidh ^cYZakZ^hgZ\^higVYdhbV^h dj bZcdh ^bZY^ViVbZciZ6Vhh^b' ZaZ
Zgb^iZ V [^mV~dYZjbV eZgXZe~d c~d(gZk^hVYVZ cdh ]VW^a^iV
V Zhij(
qVgbdh cd [jijgd dh ZkZcidh YZcigd YZhZj egeg^d XdciZmid) <Z cdkd' d
bidYd egdedhid YZYZhXg^~dYd ZkZcid fjZ ZgV^bedgiVciZ' c~d hjV
ZmZXj~d)FV kZgYVYZ' egdk|kZa fjZ K]^gZgZ hZjh ZY^idgZhiZc]Vb igV(
eVXZVYdjb edjXd' _| fjZ d a^kgd[d^ ejWa^XVYdZb ,4/, Z fjZ ZY^idgZh'
eZad fjZ bZ Y^oZb' Zhi~d cd gVbd YZd[ZgZXZgiZmidh Vd \gVcYZ eWa^Xd'
c~d cd YZd[ZgZXZggZigVidh[^^hZ ^hZcidh YZY^hidgZhgZigdheZXi^kVhYV
edhijgV Ydh VjidgZh) $IjVcYd Y^\d !igVeVXZVg!'gZ[^gd(bZ { gZbd~d'
cd bdbZcid
YVejWa^XV~d'YZ ZaZbZcidh fjZ VXVWVgVb
c~d hZcYd gZ(
aZkVciZhVd fjZ VXdciZXZj' gZhjaiVcYd Zb jbV Vbea^V~d YV^bedgi}c(
X^VYVfjZaZhfjZ edYZb ^ciZgZhhVgVd eWa^Xd)e kZgYVYZfjZ d egdXZhhd
ZY^idg^Va
edYZ hZghZkZgVbZciZ YZijgeVYdg' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ fjVcYd YZ(
h^\cVb eVgVd Vjidg jb !Wdb ZY^idg!)%9^cYV Vhh^b' ZcXdcigVg d a^kgd
YZ K]^gZg[dgcZXZj(bZ jbV ^cij^~d hdWgZdh bZXVc^hbdh YV]^hig^V)
HdYZ(hZhjedg fjZ VheZhhdVhfjZ k^kZgVb d XdbZd YVKZ\jcYV ?jZggV
EjcY^Va i^kZgVb Va\jbV cd~d YZfjZ Va\d \gVcY^dhd ZhiVkVVXdciZXZc(
Yd) <Z [dgbV Va\jbV5
G Y^|g^d YZ K]^gZggZkZadj(hZ jb egd\gVbV YZigZ^cVbZcid hdWgZV
Y^c}b^XVYV^cXZgiZoV)
=j fjZg^V hZg[^ahd[d' hZb hVWZg
cV edXVd fjZ V
bV^dg^VYdh [^ahd[dhegd[^hh^dcV^h[Vo^VeVgV\Vc]Vg Vk^YV)=b kZo Y^hhd'
3
HZgXZW^
iVbWb YjgVciZ V\jZggV cd DWVcdfjZ dh _dgcVa^hiVh
iZcYZb VhZ
V\adbZgVg c~d cZXZhhVg^VbZciZZb idgcd YVhbZhbVh de^c^Zh'bVh Xdb
''! Q"S
Zb idgcd Ydh bZhbdh eVYgZh
YZVc|a^hZ)9ig^WjZb VbZhbV
[gZfjZcX
))!#
Y!Y
Va#
)! X^VVdh bZhbdh XdcBjcidh YZ;AgXjchiVc;aVhZ AN Zb V gZ )&
^bedgiVc
)'
U
)
bZhbVh XViZ\dg^Vh
( bVAKjbV bVb[ZhiVVd Yd eaVidbhbd' d
YVYZcVh
)
W#
`
# YZY^k^Y^g
V gZVa^YVYZ
Zb [dgbVh WZb YZ[^)aaaYVh)
G fjZ Jd Zgi >AK
YZhZBG
')
Y#
' )
i A
!#dgcVa^hbd YZ]diZa# VjbZcidj Vb VbVAKd XdciV\AGbZc V)
X]VbV YZ B
!Y
^c^X^VabZciZ dh B#dgcVa^hiVh
XdcKAYZgVkVb
d DAWVcdeVgiZ d
=cfjVc id '
#)!)
)
i dj KZB#V
DZkVcZ'
' Yd EZYaiZggVcZddcZciVa' ZaZV\dgV
'
'hZidgcdj' gZeZciA(
iAkZhhZigVchedgiVYd
cVbZc i Z' HVgiZYd Gg^ZciZ EY^d ' Xdbd ) hZ Va\jZb
)'
)
' eVgVbV^h eZgid YVhVgZ^Vh
YV9g|WAVKVjYAiV)
9 ^a]VYZ;]AegZ' fjZ
d eVAK
)!
[^XVVedjXd bZcdh YZ,++ fj^abZigdh YVbb]V k^aVcd FdgiZ Yd DAWVcd'
ZXdb Xdb^YV'^\gZ_VhZ ]|W^idh fjVhZ ^Yci^Xdh'idgcdj(hZ eVgiZYq =jgd(
VYZjbV ]dgV eVgVdjigV $XaVgdfjZ' hjWhZfZciZbZciZ' dh cViANGK
Zb
qbWdh dh aVYdhidgcVgVb(hZ XdcY^X^dcVYdh%)
=cfjVcid' cd eVhhVYd'[dgV
[Z^iVjbV Y^hi^c~d ZcigZ d fjZ ZgVXdch^YZgVYd
bZY^iZgg}cZd Z c~d(bZ(
Y^iZgg}cZd$edg ZmZbead' ZcigZ d VoZ^iZZ VbVciZ^\V%' cV YXVYV
YZ ,42+
ZhhVY^hi^c~deVhhdj YZgZeZciZ VhZgZcigZ =jgdeV Z c~d(=jgdeV) ;db d
^ha~hZeVgVcYddh Yd^haVYdh'c~d hZhVW^V
dcYZ XdadXVg
dh Xg^hi~dh$dj _j(
YZjh%VgVW[dcdhcVi^kdh cZhhV]^hig^VidYV) ;ViZ\dg^oVZhh~d ^bedg(
iVciZheVgVdh ]jbVcdh' bVh idgcVb(hZ eVida\^XVhfjVcYd VXViZ\dg^V
i^YVXdbd YZ[^c^i^kV'^beZY^cYd fjZ VheZhhdVhXdch^YZgZbVkV\jZoV YVh
[gdciZ^gVh'bj^id bZcdh gZk^hVg
VhXViZ\dg^Vh)
G eg^cX^eVabdi^kd Y^hhd[d^
d Xdci|\^d) KZkdX hZaZX^dcVhhZ
XZb _dgcVa^hiVh
fjZ eZchVhhZb edg XdciV
egeg^VZ[dhhZb XVeVoZh
YZkZg[VidgZh^hdaVYdhjch Ydh djigdh' iZg^VjbV
XZciZcVYZde^c^ZhY^hi^ciVh)EVh d egdXZhhdYZ[VoZgXdb fjZ ZhhVheZh(
hdVhgZedgiVhhZb Zb jb h g^ibd [Zo Xdb fjZ VY^bZch~d Yd kdajbZ YZ
de^c^Zh[dhhZXdch^YZgVkZabZciZgZYjo^YV( Vhde^c^ZhXdckZg\^gVb Z
ZaZhjhVkVb dh bZhbdh ^iZch Xdbd XVjhVh)Hdg ZmZbead' V[VhiVcYd(cdh
edg jb ^chiVciZ Yd DWVcd'idYdh dh gZegiZgZhgZ[ZgZb(hZ { YXVYV
YZ
,43+ Xdbd !Vcdh ZmigVdgY^c|g^dh!eVgi^cYd Yd eg^cXe^d YZ fjZ ]Vk^V
Va\d ZheZX^[^XVbZciZ
Y^hi^cid cZhhVYXVYV)
<jgVciZ VWda]VYVAciZgcZi
cd [^b YVYXVYV
YZ ,44+' dh _dgcVa^hiVhXdcXdgYVgVbfjZ ^cY^XVYdgZh
bVajXdh Zmea^XVkVb
VfjVa^YVYZYZXdbeVc]^Vh hZb kVadgXj_VhVZhid(
YdhYZhZ_VkVbVch^dhVbZciZ XdbegVg5
((((
>^fjZ^ dWXZXVYd)
FVfjZaZ bdbZcid'
XdbZXZ^ V idbVg XdchX^cX^V
Yd bZj dW_ZidYZZhijYd ( d RcR[a\ _R`bYaN[aRNYaNZR[aRVZ]_\cjcRY( =
c~d ZgVb VeZcVhdh ZmZXji^kdhXdgedgVi^kdhWZb kZhi^YdhZ XVggZ\VYdh
YZ iZhidhiZgdcV fjZ XdhijbVkVb hZgZc\VcVYdh edg ZhhVhdgiZ XdcXZc(
igVYV'bVh iVbWb eZhhdVhbj^id ZhijYVYVh)LVaeZgXZe~d igVch[dgbdj
bZj ;^hcZ FZ\gd YZjb egdWaZbVYZeZhhdVhfjZ ib hdgiZ dj VoVgcdh
cZ\X^dh Zb jb egdWaZbVYZXdc]ZX^bZcid Z X^cX^V)
E^c]V ^Y^V fjZ
Va\jch gZhjaiVYdhX^Zci[^Xdhc~d h~d VeZcVh^ciZ^h cV k^YVgZVa'edg hj(
WZhi^bVgZb d ^beVXid Yd VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa $dj edg aZkVgZb(cdh
V ^\cdg|(Ad%' bVh fjZ bj^idh YZaZhiVbWb edYZb ZhiVg'cV kZgYVYZ'
Xg^VcYd;^hcZh FZ\gdh) F~d h~d VeZcVhZggdhiVmdcb^Xdh fjZ edYZb
gZegdk|(Ad cV VjaVYZdgc^idad\^V) ;dbZXZ^ VeZgXZWZg
VhXdchZfcX^Vh
YZhhV^Y^V)
'
)
) aVidhcVggVYdh)9 Ze^hiZbdad\^V' V [^adhd[^VYV]^hig^V Z V
Y fjZ dq gZ
)#
d !
WjhXVb XdbegZZcYZg kZgYVYZh'^ckZhiA\VcYddh bZXVbhbdh
iaXV
ZhiViaK
) #Y7
) Zb fjZh i(dZh
Z hZeVgVcYdV gZ\jaVg^YVYZYV Xdb;A
Zc;aV
jZ Vh\ZgVb
(#
f)
)
L YVhZhhVhY^hX^ea^cVh
a^YVbXdb VfjZhiVd Yd fjZ hZhVWZ'hd
]AhizgAXVh)d
)
)
U
XdcigVYVhZb egY^dh Y^[ZgZciZh'edg VKKAb
YAoZg)
fjZ hVdZc
'
?3;3EAI> 63 :=67?7=6K=5:3
XZhh|g^dh
fjVigd hZ\jgVcVheVgVAZk|(AdZbWdgV'=aZZhiVkV
^gVYdedg Zj
ZhiVgcd fjZ ZaZXdch^YZgVkV
hZj !iZgg^ig^d!)IjZb \dhiVg^VYZVWVcYd(
cVgiVaVbW^ZciZ8;dbeVgZ(d Xdb Vabddh cd gZ[Z^ig^d
hZb \gVVYZ
jbV jc^kZgh^YVYZ
Xdb egd[ZhhdgZhZYjXVYdhY^hXji^cYdVbV^h gZXZc(
iZ ^cig^\VYZeVgiVbZciVa)
9hh^b' eZgbVcZX^cd gVbd fjVci^iVi^kd Z YVh
deZgVZh
[^cVcXZ^gVh
$V^cYV
Zhidj a|%'bVh dg\Vc^oZ^(bZeVgV[VoZgedj(
fjhh^bd igVWVa]d'
edgb ^ciZchd $ZY^kZgi^Yd%'
XdcXZcigVg(bZhdbZciZ
cdh VheZXidh
bV^hiXc^Xdh'cjcXV eVgi^X^eVg
YZ!gZjc^Zh!YZcZ\X^dh'
Zk^iVgVXdbeVc]^V YZ!gZVa^oVYdgZh!
Z YZeZhhdVhfjZ jhVb iZgcd Zc~d
aZb a^kgdhZi^gVgjb Vcd hVW|i^Xd
VXVYV
igh' Zb bY^V'eVgVegZZcX]Zg
aVXjcVhcV b^c]V XjaijgV[^adh[^XV
Z X^Zci[^XV)
HVgVYZhi^aVg
aZciVbZciZ
b^c]V c^XV^Y^V'
Zj fjZg^VhZgjb SYj[Rb_&jb bZY^iVYdg egd[^hh^dcVa'
hZciVg(bZZb XV[h'eVhhVgd iZbed hZb [VoZgcVYV'YZha^\VYd
YZZhXg^(
kVc^c]VhZ YZZhigjijgVhYZdg\Vc^oVZh'
Ydgb^g d fjVcid egZX^hVg'
aZg
kdgVobZciZ Z c~d YZkZgZmea^XV~d
cZc]jbV Vc^c\jb) =j fjZg^VhZg
YZ^mVYd
Zb eVoeVgVXdchigj^g'VeZfjZcdh eVhhdh'jb h^hiZbVYZeZchV(
bZcid WVhZVYd
cVb^c]V ^Y^V
Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd)
9 \jZggV cd DWVc7
Z VfjZWgVYV:dahV YZ,432 eVgZX^Vb[ZcbZcdh
^Yci^Xdh)>^XdjWk^deVgVb^b fjZ fjVhZ idYdhi^c]Vb jb edcid XZ\d
bZciVa fjZ dh ^beZY^VYZgZXdc]ZXZg
d eVeZaYZiV^hZkZcidh5ZgVXdbd hZ
c~d [dhhZb XVeVoZh
YZkZgZhhZh
bVhidYdciZhdj Xdbd hZZhfjZXZb YZaZh
gVe^YVbZciZ)
9 gZhedhiVZhiVkVYZWV^md
Yd bZj cVg^o5ZgVbZN(PRTbRV_N
eh^Xda\^XV'
iVakZoVibZhbd W^da\^XV)
? egdWaZbVc~d ZhiVkV
cVcVij(
gZoVYdhZkZcidhZh^b cVbVcZ^gVfjZ dh eZgXZWVbdh)
;dcXajd ZhiZegZaY^d
VjidW^d\g|[^Xd
Xdb V]^hig^VVhZ\j^g'=j c~d i^(
c]V jbV ZheZX^Va^YVYZ
YZ[^c^YV
$[dgVYdbZj igVWVa]d
Xdbjb%' Zc~d YZhZ(
_VkV
cZc]jbV) IjVcYd' Zb XdfjZi^h'eZg\jciVkVb(bZ d fjZ [Vo^V
eVgV
\Vc]VgVk^YV'Zj [^XVkV
iZciVYdVgZhedcYZg!Kdj jb RZ]V_V`aNPnaVP\Zjb
YRVa\_'SYj[Rb_&
Va\jb XdbegdbZi^Yd V ZmeadgVg
bj^id egd[jcYVbZciZ
jbV ^Y^V!'
bVh idgcVkVVhXd^hVh
bV^hh^beaZhY^oZcYdfjZ ZgVbdidg^hiV
YZa^bjh^cZ)
;ZgiV kZo' Zb jb kd igVchVia}ci^Xd'
gZXZW^
jb b]T_NQReVgVVeg^(
bZ^gVXaVhhZ'
dcYZbZ hZciZ^VdaVYdYZjbV hZc]dgVedYZgdh{'fjZ kZhi^V
gdjeVh XVgVh'
ZhiVkVXdWZgiV
YZdjgd Z_^Vh'Xdb^VXVhiVc]Vh
Xdci^cjV(
)
Z $iYkZoZhi^kZhhZ
[VoZcYdjbV Y^ZiVYZedjXdh XVgWd^YgVidh%
Z^c(
bZci
'
,
=
#
A#
Y#(
) # b WZWZg
hdbZciZ |\jV bbZgV NaVc'ZcfjVcid AVVZ aVdZjgd(
KaKiaV
Z
[^
Y #' '
! Yd KNYYGa_RRa
>\b_[NY(=aV a;VkViZciVc d ba;AVgjbV XdckZghV
Zb
eZaV
'
A#
A#
$
[g
9%Y
##,
bZ [gVcXhgj^b' ed^h qj fjZ Zj aqjq akgG Zb VcXZh d KG;AG
(&
" *5+H^ZggZ
:djgYaZj (
\d( NQ
GK+,
fjZ' agdbXVbZciZ'igViVkV
YVhbVgXVhYZ
' i^c ~d hdX^Va)
Ac[dgbZ^(a]Z$Zb b\aZh%fjZ ZgVbdidchiV YZ]bjhbZ'
YaK
!YZViahhabd
)!
")! ) Mb
'aaaKaK
' i#b Yd#dg\ja]dhVbZciZ fjZ hd' Y#'
b\aV' XVggdh
bkZ
#A9
egZkVaZXZj
YjgVciZidYd d kd ( Z VeZhVg
YZXdchZ\j^g
KA
Zc;a#d\Z#A^Yd
hZci^gViZch~d' ejYZ aZgZb eVo)
)
O -3;6/
6/1:7
./
>/>1/63+
T>OFIM>IL$?@$LIM<MMO>@MMI
$ 5VTV 9@PB@HD<
?@DQ<
LM><M<LKVT ADF[MIAIM
$ .O ?DMM@
I ]VKm
@| X^cXdVcdh' Qi56k\Zc^V
F^`daVnZkcVCgVhcdkVZgVjbV gdbVcX^hiV
dWhXjgV
Z V^cYV
c~d(ejWa^XVYV'
Xdb jb eVhhVYd
^cXdbjb) =aVZgVjbV
cZjgdX^Zci^hiV
^ciZgZhhVYV
Zb [^adhd[^V
$hZjhigheg^bZ^gdhbVg^YdhZgVb
[^ahd[dh%
ZXdadXdjZb hjV iZ^bdhVXVWZV
[gVcXd(gjhhV
fjZ ZmegZhhVg^V
hjVheZhfj^hVhZ ^Y^Vh
Zb [dgbVid a^iZg|g^d)9YdgcVkVVhiZdg^VhXdbd
]^hig^VhZ Vhb^hijgVkVXdb idYVhdgiZYZXdbZci|g^dh VjidW^d\g|[^Xdh)
=aVZk^iVkV
VhegZkVg^XVZh
_dgcVahi^XVh
YVc~d([^X~dcVggVi^kV
XdciZb(
edg}cZV$!=b jbV bVc]~ XaVgV
YZVWg^a'
Bd]c Kb^i] YZ^mdjhjVXVhV
)))!%)
<^|ad\dh Zb ac\jVh ZhigVc\q^gVh
ZgVbhZbegZ ZhXg^idh
cd ^Y^dbVdg^\^(
cVa'Xdb igVYjZh
^chZg^YVh
Xdbd aZ\ZcYVhYZ[^abZh)QZk\Zc^VgZXjhV(
kV(hZVigVYjo^geVgVjb ^c\ah gj^b XdckZghVh
fjZ i^c]Vb VXdciZX^Yd
Zb jb ^iVa^Vcd
gj^b)#
FZc]jb ZY^idgYVg^V
ViZc~d V ZaV'h fjZ' cVfjZaZ bdbZcid' ]V(
k^VVa\jb ^ciZgZhhZ
cdh gVgdhX^Zci^hiVh
fjZ XdchZ\j^Vb hZZmegZhhVg
Zb
[gVhZh
hZb^XdbegZZchkZ^h)
9a\jch ZY^idgZh
XdcXdgYVgVb
Zb XdckZghVg
) Ba, QZk\Zc^V6
ZheZgVqVbfjZ ZaVVbqqjqZqZhhZZ k^ZhhZV5hXgZkZq
jb
qq
dejaVgYZX^cXAV
hdWgZ
VXdcK;AZc;aV
) =aViZkZViZcVdhj[^;AZciZ
]kgd HXZWZg
YZXVgiVh
Y#
' ( ZXdbZciVcdh
*# GaZcKANGK
D(
!
VXdgiZh^V
ZgZ%ZAVG
dXV(
VgV
g
Z
)#
,
Y
')
#A9#
H'
# b kZoYd V^cYV
bVAKbhj iVciZZ ZegZ;aViAkd
KA
ZcXaG)
KaGcVAh
Z
'
=Y^idgZh
[^XVkVbXdq[jhdh Xdb d bVcjhXci'd) =a5cZb qZhbd Xdchq(
'
edcYZg{ eg^bZAgV
eZg\jciV fjZ a]Z [VRAVb5e jb aAkgdYZ[^XVd
\MaVgZh
'!'
GMc}d([^X#}d8!LVbedjXd XdchZ\MAV
gZhedcqZgV5 HVgVqjZb d ,)Akgd
NQ^ ZhXg^id!'cdh [dgbja|g^dh YZegdedhiV YZaAkgdeVgVZYAidgZh)
<AhhZ(
gqb(A]Z!NdX egZX^hV
XdbegZZcYZgfjZb hZj eWa^Xd!Z !9bVYdgZh
ZhXgZkZb
eVgVh^egeg^dh'egd[^hh^dcV^h
ZhXgZkZbeVgVdh djigdh!) LVb(
Wba]ZY^hhZgVb
fjZ ZgVcZXZhh|g^d
ZcfjVYgVg(hZZb jb \cZgd ZheZX(
[^Xd'edgfjZ !D^kgVg^Vh
c~d \dhiVb YZhZgXdc[jcY^YVhZegZX^hVbhVWZg
Zb fjVa egViZaZ^gV
jb a^kgdYZkZhZgXdadXVYd!)
Mb ZY^idgVXgZhXZcidj
Xdbd XVjiZaV5
!Ahhd'XVgV
Vb^\V' kZcYZg|VeZcVhYZoXe^Vh'^cXaj^cYdVh
XdbegVYVh
edg hZjhZm(bVg^Ydh
Z[Vb^a^VgZh)!
;^cXd VcdhVciZh'ZaVeVgi^X^eVgV
YZjbV d[^X^cV
YZgZYV~d[VbdhVZ
hVgV
YZa| cVjhZVYV)
!=hXgZkZg
WZb! eVgZX^V
h^\c^[^XVg
dWZYZXZg
VgZ\gVh
VgW^ig|g^Vh
fjZ ]Vk^VbhZidgcVYdYd\bVh' Xdb d gZ[dgdXdc[^gbVig^d
YdfjZ X]VbVbdh YZ!ZmeZg^cX^V!)
Gh ZhXg^idgZh
fjZ Xdc]ZXZjZhiVkVb
VegZcYZcYd
VbZa]dgVg^cXdgedgVcYdd fjZ ZgVXdch^YZgVYd
hjXZhhd5
id(
YdhiZciVkVb ^b^iVg]^hig^VhfjZ i^c]Vb VeVgZX^Yd
Zb ZY^Zh
Vci^\Vh
Yd HURBRd L\_XR_' hZb eZgXZWZg
fjZ WdVeVgiZYd fjZ cdkd' edg
YZ[^c^~d'c~d edYZhZgbdaYVYdVeVgi^gYZZY^Zh
Vci^\VhYd HURBRd
L\_XR_(HVgV
QZk\Zc^V'VibZhbd V^Y^V
YZjb !Xdcid! ZgVjb XdcXZ^id
WVhZVYd
Zb ^b^iVZh)
G ^chigjidg YVd[^X^cV'\Zci^abVh YZY^hXjghd[^g(
bZ' Y^hhZ
VZaVfjZ hZj XVhdZgVXdbeaZiVbZciZhZb ZheZgVcV)
QZk\Zc^VVXVWdj
XdadXVcYd
d bVcjhXg^id XdbeaZid YZhZj eg^cX^eVa
a^kgd'5 Ga\_f \S FRPb_`V\[&cVOZW)9a^' ZcXdcigdj jb eZfjZcd eWa^Xd'
fMZ^cXajVd eZghe^XVo
egdeg^Zi|g^dYZjbV eZfjZcV ZYZhXdc]ZX^YV
ZY^(
i8gV'fjZ jhVkVXjadhYZVgbV~dXdg(YZ(gdhV
Z [VaVkV
jb gjhhd eg^b^(
iAkd$XdckZcX^Yd
YZfjZ ZgV[ajZciZ%)= d[ZgZXZjejWa^X|(AV
Z XdcXdgYdj
;db VXdcY^~dYZbVciZg d iZmidXdbeaZiVbZciZ ^ciZ\gVa)= d[ZgZXZj
MbV[gV~dYdkVadg(eVYg~d
eV\d eZadhY^gZ^idh
VjidgV^hZb gZig^Wj^~d
{
gZhig^~d
ZY^idg^Va(i^c]V bj^id edjXd VeZgYZg)
QZk\Zc^VVXZ^idj'jbV
NZofMZcVd
( ib#] VZhXda]V)
9 Qqk\Zc^VaZkdj X^cXdVcdheVgVhZgegdbdk^YVYVXViZ\dg^V
YZ!Z\d(
XZcicXV^c_jhi^[^XVYV'
iZ^bdhVZYZY^[X^a
igVid! eVgVVYZ!eZghZkZgVciZ'
YZiZgb^cVYV'
Zh[dgVYV
Z YZjbV ^cYZeZcYcX^V
[Zgdo!)Hd^hd a^kgdeZ(
\dj [d\d aZciVbZciZ'id#gcVcYd(hZ
jb Ydh\gVcYZhZZhigVc]dhhjXZhhdhYV
]^hig^VYVa^iZgVijgV'
kZcYZcYdb^a]ZhYZXe^VhZ Xdcfj^hiVcYdd fjZ
hZX]VbVYZVXaVbV~d
Xgi^XV)
<ZhYZZci~d' VeZfjZcV ZY^idgV
idgcdj(hZ
jbV \gVcYZXdgedgV~d'Xdb jbV gZXZeX^dc^hiV
!ZYjXVYV!
fjZ gZXZWZ
dh
k^h^iVciZh
fjZ ZcigVb cd ZhXg^ig^d
XZcigVa)
G a^kgd[d^igVYjo^YdeVgVfjV(
gZciVac\jVh $^cXajh^kZ
d [gVcXh%)
NdXk V[did YZQZk\Zc^VZb idYdhdh
aj\VgZh)=aV Xdch^YZgVYV
Ve^dcZ^gVYZVa\dX]VbVYd=hXdaV
;d^cX^YZciZ)
9\dgV' ZY^idgZh
ib jbV iZdg^VfjZ Y^ofjZ !bdidg^hiVhYZXVb^c]~d fjZ
aZb a^kgdhc~d aZb a^kgdhZhXg^idh
eVgVbdidg^hiVhYZXVb^c]~d! ZYZ[Zc(
YZb fjZ !aZ^idgZhYZiZhiVbZhXg^idgZh
fjZ iZciVb V\gVY|(Adh!)
9XZ^iV(hZ
V\dgVfjZ jb iZmidX^Zci[^Xd
edhhVZhXdcYZg
ig^k^Va^YVYZh
dj ^ggZaZk}cX^Vh
edg bZ^d YZZfjVZhZ YZ_Vg\Zh6
VegdhVXd^cX^YZciZ'
Vd ZmedgjbV
^Y^V
Zb [dgbVid Xgj' eZgb^iZfjZ ZaVhZ_V
_ja\VYVeZadeWa^Xd)
@d_Z'QZk\Zc^VYZ^mdjYZXVhVg
Xdb [^ahd[dh$ZaZhVg\jbZciVb YZ(
bV^h%ZhZZhXdcYZYV^begZchV)FVhhVaVh
YZVjaV'VXVYb^Xdh
YVa^iZgV(
ijgV Y^hXjiZbVhY^kZghVh
e^hiVhfjZ ^cY^XVkVb
V^cZk^iVW^a^YVYZ
Yd cdkd
Zhi^ad)9 Y^hi^c~dZcigZ[^X~dZc~d([^X~d Xdch^YZgVYV
VgXV^XV
YZbV^h
eVgVhjedgiVg dh YZhV[^dh
YVhdX^ZYVYZ
bdYZgcV)=gVZk^YZciZfjZ egZX^(
h|kVbdh gZbZY^Vg
V[gV\bZciV~d ZcigZVgiZZX^cX^V)
<Zed^h Yd [Vid' d
iVaZcidYZaV
ZgVWn^d)
Ej^idh YdhZY^idgZh
fjZ Xdc]ZXZjbV^h iVgYZXjaeVgVb(cVedg c~d
i(AdhegdXjgVYd'XdckZcX^Ydh
YZfjZ iZg^Vbk^hid^bZY^ViVbZciZd b(
g^idYZhZj igVWVa]d)
<Zcigd YZedjXdh Vcdh' jb VXVYb^Xd
a^iZg|g^dZh(
XgZkZg|d ZchV^d!<Z CjcYZgVVCgVhcdkV!'bdhigVcYd Xdbd VhhZbZc(
iZhYZhjV dWgV
edYZb hZgZcXdcigVYVh
Zb CjcYZgV( jb egZXjghdgfjZ
XdbW^cVkV
ZchV^dXdb bZiVXdbZci|g^d $QZk\Zc^VcjcXV aZj CjcYZgV'
bVh k^j VkZgh~dX^cZbVid\g|[^XVYZjb YZhZjh a^kgdh( c~d ]Vk^VXd(
bZci|g^dh cd [^abZ%)#
Mb VqVYb^XdegdZb^cZciZ YZbdchigVg| Xdbd V
^c[ajcX^VYZ?gZ\dgn :ViZhdc' fjZ ^c_Zidj XZcVh
VjidW^d\g|[^XVh
Zb hZjh
iZmidhYZeZhfj^hV VXVYb^XV'
k^hkZaZb idYVhVhe|\^cVh $QZk\Zc^V
cjcXV djk^j [VaVg
Zb :ViZhdc%)
? a^kgdYZQZk\Zc^V jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd)
(@n[\S? DYmZ
6I=L@< ?DA@L@HX<
>LZND><
@HNL@
@MJ@>OF<?IL@M
ZJLIMNDNON<M
$ 0OMNDX<%
DHEOMNDX<
Z ,DMH@M
3@BLIM$
7@ILD<
?I >IHC@>DG@HNI
Z L@H?<J@MMI<F
$ 5ILKO@d .Q$
NL@GDMNWI
HWI d G@FCILFOB<LJ<L<
hZPDMDN<L#
@Q>@NI%
N<FP@R%
hZkdX AIL OG
P@H>@?IL
9 VhXZch~d
YZQZk\Zc^VYdhedgZhVd hjeZgZhigZaVid
edhhkZaZb jb
c^XdVbW^ZciZ'fjZ X]Vbd YZ=migZb^hi~d)&
=b WgZkZ'VegZhZciVgZ^
V
Y^hi^c~dXZcigVa
ZcigZVegdkcX^V\ZgVYdgV
YZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh Yd =migZ(
b^hi~d Z VegdkcX^VXdbedgiVYV'igVcf^aVZ hZb hjgegZhVhYd EZY^d(
Xg^hi~d)
'
5/427:
"837:# -76;/427
(((
9dh aZ^idg
)
)
;
)
ZhfjZ egdXjgVgVb edg QZk\ZbV CgVhcdkVcd ?dd\aZ' aVbZcid Y^oZgfjZ Z V
$d [^A;aVabZi
%
)
)
c Z jbV eZghdcV\Zb [^XiaXaV)
kZaZb hjVhYZXaVgVZh!'
XdcigVY^oZcYd
V^Y^V
Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd' jbV kZo
fjZ VgZVa^YVYZ
Zbeg^XVc~d !Zfj^a^WgVYV!
ZhjV egeg^VkZgh~dYZ!gV(
odVW^a^YVYZ!
c~d XdggZhedcYZ
{ YZ[^c^~dXdckZcX^dcVa)
KZg\Zcj^cVbZc(
iZ Zbeg^Xd gZ[aZi^g
VgZVa^YVYZ
d bV^h[^ZabZciZedhhkZa6hZg]dcgVYd
^bea^XVZb c~d iZbZg VVeVgcX^V
ZVhXdchZfcX^Vh
YZhZgZhigVc]d)FV
egm^bVkZofjZ jbV eZhhdV^cXdbdYVgkdXXdb XdchZa]dhYZhcZXZhh|(
g^dh'aZbWgZVZaVXdb \qci^aZoVYd YZhi^cdYd bdc\Z fjZ AkVc'd LZgg(
kZa'bVcYdj bViVgedg iZgYVYdXdchZa]dh^cYZhZ_|kZ^h
$ZbdgVa^oVYdgZh%)
Ahhd[jcX^dcVXdbd jbV XjgVYZXjgid egVod)
=b gZigdheZXid'd XdchZa]dbV^h ^bedgiVciZ [d^ gj^b' bVh iVbWb
[d^' eVgVYdmVabZciZ'
d bV^hXdchZfZciZ'ed^hbZ [ZoZmeadgVg
Xdb bV^h
egd[jcY^YVYZ
VY^c}b^XVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd) =aZ[d^YVYdVb^b fjVcYd Zj
i^c]V -- Vcdh'Zb jbV iVgYZYZ[ZkZgZ^gd'
cd XdggZYdg
Yd ZY^[X^d
YZc(
bZgd .)/++ YVOVacji KigZZi'cV>^aVYa[^V'
dcYZZj k^k^V)
Mb ZhijYVciZcd
hZ\jcYd Vcd YVO]Vgidc Y^hhZ(bZfjZ Zj YZkZg^V
ZhXda]Zg
jbV egd[^hh~d
fjZ [dhhZ!ZhXVa|kZa!'
dj hZ_V'jbV egd[^hh~dcV fjVa c~d hZ eV\d edg
]dgV Z' edgiVcid' c~d hZZhi| hj_Z^id{ha^b^iVZh
Yd kdajbZ YZigVWVa]d)
=gVjbV bVcZ^gVbj^id h^beaZhYZY^[ZgZcX^Vg
egd[^hhZh
Z' VeVgi^gYV'
\ZcZgVa^oVg
jbV hZeVgV~d
ZcigZi^edhYZ^cXZgiZoV
(aZkVcYd(bZ Vd\gVc(
YZegdWaZbV[^adh[^Xd'
d egdWaZbVYV^cYj~d' fjZ d cdbZ iXc^XdYd
;^hcZ FZ\gd) G XdchZa]deZgb^i^j(bZ igVch[dgbVgd ;^hcZ FZ\gd YZjb
^beVhhZa\^XdZb jbV hdaj~d YZ[|X^a^beaZbZciV~d' VabYZ'Xdbd kZ(
gZbdh cdh egm^bdhXVeijadh'WVhZ|(Ad
cViZmijgVYVgZVa^YVYZ
Zbeg^XV)
;dbd jb XdchZa]deVgVb^c]V XVggZ^gV
XdcYjo^j(bZ ViV^h^Y^Vh
hd(
WgZVcVijgZoVYV^cXZgiZoV8
9a\jbVh egd[^hhZh'
Xdbd YZci^hiVh'
Xdchja(
idgZhdj bVhhV\^hiVh
egd[^hh^dcV^h'
c~d h~dZhXVa|kZ^h5
Zm^hiZ
jb a^b^iZVd
cbZgd YZeVX^ZciZh
dj Xa^ZciZh
fjZ hZedYZViZcYZg
Zb jb YVYdeZgdYd
YZiZbed) KZkdX jbV egdhi^ijiV'kdXigVWVa]V
edg ]dgVZ$\ZgVabZciZ%
gZXZWZ
edg ]dgV)9ab Y^hhd'ha5aV
egZhZcV$VXgZY^id%
cZXZhh|g^V
eVgVd
hZgk^degZhiVYdedg kdX)KZVWg^g
jb gZhiVjgVciZ[^cd' kdX' cV bZa]dg
YVh]^eiZhZh'iZg| VXVhV
hZbegZX]Z^V$Vc~d hZgfjZ VWgV
[gVcfj^Vh%)
FZh(
hVhegd[^hhZh'
c~d ^bedgiV d fjVcid VgZbjcZgV~d hZ_V
VaiV'VgZcYVZhi|
hj_Z^iV{ \gVk^YVYZ)
G [VijgVbZcid YZeZcYZbV^hYZZh[dgdhXdcicjdh
Yd fjZ YVfjVa^YVYZ
YVhYZX^hZh)
9ab Yd bV^h' jb i^ed YZigVWVa]d
VaiVbZciZegZk^hkZa5
ZaZhd[gZg|kVg^VZh'
bVh c~d Vedcid YZidgcVgV
gZcYVYZjb c^XdY^VbV^hh^\c^[^XVi^kV
Yd fjZ VYd gZhidYZ#
hjV k^YV)
=b djigVheVaVkgVh'
ZaZc~d hZg|bdk^Yd edg ;^hcZhFZ\gdh) QZk\Zc^VF^(
(, ZkcVc~d iZg^Vh^YdXVeVoYZVigVkZhhVg
d VW^hbdZcigZZmXajYV
Z
`d Vn' VhjegZbV YVcd^iZeVgVd Y^VhZadhhZ
X
Y
#Va#
XdciV dgVdj ZheZ;a AhiV
Zb
]ZgGac
) )
'
]gc^Vh$bVhiVbWb c~d qZcVhAYdjbq ZmXaMaYV%)'
U
GjigVhegd[^hhZh
eZgbAiZb fjZ kdXZVXgZhXZciZ
oZgdhVhjV egdYjVd
$Z{ hjV gZcYV%'
XVhdhZ_VXdbeZiZcqZ' Xdb edjXd dq cZc]jb Zq[dgd
ZmigV)
9\dgV' hZcYdegZ\j^dhd' XdchAYZgVcYd
VegZ\MaVjbV fjVa^YVYZ'
Z Vch^dhdedg a^WZgVg
d b|m^bd edhhkZaYd bZj Y^VeVgVbZY^iVgZ aZg'
X]Z\jZ^^bZY^ViV
$bVhZggdcZVbZciZ%
VjbV XdcXajh~d)KZeVgZ^
VeZhhdV
YZ!^Y^Vh!'fjZ kZcYZjb egdYjid ^ciZaZXijVa
Zb [dgbV YZjbV igVchV(
~d dj jb igVWVa]d'
YVeZhhdVYZ!igVWVa]d!'fjZ a]ZkZcYZd igVWVa]d)
KZkdX jbV eZhhdVYZ^Y^Vh'
c~d cZXZhh|g^d
igVWVa]Vg
bj^id' VeZ(
cVheZchVg^ciZch^kVbZciZ)NdX [Vod bZhbd igVWVa]d
egdYjo^cYd XZb
dj b^a jc^YVYZh)FVh igVchVZh
YZfjVcih' d bZhbd kdajbZ YZigVWV(
a]d gZVa^oVYd
iVcid cV XdbegV YZXZb XdiVhfjVcid cV YZ,++ b^a' dj
bZhbd , b^a]~d YZXdiVh)e d bZhbd iZaZ[dcZbV'VbZhbV XdbejiV(
~d' d bZhbd YdXjbZcid aZ\Va'd bZhbd \Vhid YZcZjg}c^dh' d bZhbd
ZbeZc]d Zb kZg^[^XVg
hZVigVchV~dZhi| XdggZiV)
9ab Yd bV^h' kdX
edYZigVWVa]Vg
Zb hjV WVc]Z^gV
dj Zb jb WVgZb JdbV) HdYZjhVghjV
^c[ajcX^VXdbd hjWhi^ijiVeVgVd igVWVa]d:Zb' YZkdVYb^i^gfjZ ZhiVkV
jb edjXd ZggVYdhdWgZd igVWVa]d
YZdeZgVYdg5
kdX c~d edYZ [Vo(Ad
cVWVc]Z^gV'
bVh' fjVcYd [Z^idYVbVcZ^gVXZgiV'
egdedgX^dcVWVhiVciZ
iZbed a^kgZ)
9 bZhbV egdeg^ZYVYZ
Vea^XV
(hZVVgi^hiVh
YdgVbd [dcd\g|[^Xd dj Vid(
gZhYZX^cZbV5kdX YZ^mV
fjZ dh Zc\Zc]Z^gdhYZhdb Zdh egd_ZX^dc^hiVh
[VVb d igVWVa]d6
c~d cZXZhh|g^dZhiVgegZhZciZZb idYVhVhVegZhZc(
iVZh
eVgVYZhZbeZc]VghZj eVeZa)K^b^aVgbZciZ'jbV ZhXg^idgV
[Vod
bZhbd Zh[dgdeVgVVigV^g
jb c^XdaZ^idgdj eVgVXVeijgVgXZciZcVhYZ
b^a]ZhYZaZ^idgZh)
B)C) Jdla^c\' VjidgVYdha^kgdhYZ@VggnHdiiZg'c~d
egZX^hV
ZhXgZkZg
cdkVbZciZ XVYV
a^kgdhZbegZ fjZ Va\jb YZhZ_V
a(Ad)
EVh d bZhbd c~d kVaZeVgVjb eVYZ^gd5
ZaZegZX^hV
VhhVg
XVYV
e~d eVgV
hVi^h[VoZg
XVYV
Xa^ZciZ
VY^X^dcVa)
9hh^b' V Y^hi^c~dZcigZ ZhXg^idg
Z eVYZ^gd'ZheZXjaVYdg
Z bY^Xd'
[gVjYVYdg
Z egdhi^ijiV' jbV bVcZ^gVi^aYZhZdWhZgkVg
d bjcYd YVh
Vi^k^YVYZh)
=aVhZeVgV
Vhegd[^hhZh
Zb fjZ edhhkZaVXgZhXZciVg
oZgdh{
KMV
gZcYV'hZb cZc]jb igVWVa]d
VbV^h'YVhegd[^hhZh
Zb fjZ cZXZhh|(
g^dVXgZhXZciVg
igVWVa]d
ZiZbed $YjVhXd^hVh
Xj_Vhd[ZgiVhh~da^b^iVYVh%
( Zb djigVheVaVkgVh'
Vhegd[^hhZh
hj_Z^iVh
{ \gVk^YVYZ)
(
iZ <Zh^\jVaYVYZhZm^hiZb' bVh Y^\Vbdh fjZ h~d Z\QR_NQN`(
gZdXjeVg )
'
' #
H U Y ( Zm^hiZZhXVaVW^a^YVYZ'
c~d ]| Xdbd YdWgVgd cjbZgd bVm,bd
9b VcVd
!
#
cV eaVi^VhZb fjZ hZ_VcZXZhhVcdXVciVgYjVh kZoZh)
YZeZhhdVh
'
#
(
#YZgZ
d Z[Z^idYVeg^bZ^gV\gVkV~d bjha;Va' jbV aaakZcVd
cKa
9\dgV' Xd
!
'
#
'
YMRA#M
jb \gVcYZ kdajbZ YZaaaBjhiAV)
FdhhV XVeV;AYVYZ
YZgZ(
fjZ bigd
!
# gZeZi^gVijVZheZgbAiZ(bZ djkAg Zb bZj aVeide ]dgVh YZ
egd YMRagZ
!
#'
!
YZ([jcYd Yd e^Vc^hiVNaVY^b^g@dgdlaio $fjZ ZhiVYZ[^aaaiAkV(
bMKa;V
"NN
Y#
#
bZciZ bdgid% idXVcYd dh D_RYtQV\`YZJVX]bVqaaad ' Zb kZo d bMKA(
#\gVYd$fjZ V^cYVZhi| k^kd%'gZYjoAYdV\dgV V YVgVjaVhYZ
Xd gjhhd Zba
'
e^Vcd VXg^VcVhZb \ZgVahZb iVaZcid eqg 'jb kVadgegm^bd Yd hVa|cd
bc^bd' @dgdl^io' VeZhVgYZbdgid' ZhiVi^gVcYdd igVWVa]dYZhhZedWgZ
]dbZb) HgZ[^gddjk^g NaVY^b^g@dgdl^io dj 9gi]jg JjW^chiZ^c Vd Xjhid
YZMK" ,+'44 d ;< VeV\Vg MK" 4'44 edg djigV \gVkV~d YZjb bh^Xd
YZhXdc]ZX^Yd$bVh bj^id iVaZcidhd%[dgbVYd eZaVBj^aa^VgY
KX]dda dj
eZad ;dchZgkVig^d YZHgV\V)KZkdX eZg\jciVg Vb^b edg fjZ ZhXda]d
@dgdl^io' gZhedcYZgZ^fjZ edg XVjhVYVdgYZb' Yd g^ibd dj YVeV^m~d'
fjVcYd' cV kZgYVYZ'YZkZZm^hi^gjbV aZ\^~d YZeZhhdVhYZfjZb cjcXV
djk^ [VaVg'Z YZfjZb cjcXV djk^gZ^ [VaVg( VfjZaVhfjZ c~d X]Z\Vb Vd
eVaXd'bVh fjZ edYZb idXVg^\jVabZciZ WZb)
9a\jbVh eZhhdVhVXgZY^iVb^cdXZciZbZciZ fjZ d egdXZhhdYV^c_jhi^(
V XdbZdj Xdb d \gVbd[dcZ' hZ\j^cYd Va\^XVfjZ VXVWd
YZVegZhZc(
iVg)=j Y^hXdgYd)=hidj XdckZcX^YdYZ fjZ d egdXZhhdXdbZdj bj^id'
bVh bj^id VciZh' Xdb cdhhd <F9' fjZ \jVgYV ^c[dgbVZhhdWgZfjZb
hdbdh Z eZgb^iZ(cdh gZeZi^gcdhhV VijV~d hZb fjZ egZX^hZbdh ZhiVga|
\gVVh{ Y^hhZb^cV~d YZcdhhdh \ZcZh VigVkhYVh\ZgVZh)9 Zkdaj~d
R`PNYjcRY3
d <F9 fjZ kZcXZ$edg hdgiZ dj edg kVciV\Zb YZhdWgZk^kc(
X^V%
^g| hZgZegdYjo^g' Xdbd jb a^kgdXVbeZ~d YZkZcYVhdj jb Y^hXdYZ
hjXZhhd' Z eVhhVg| V hZgjc^kZghVa)Gjigdh <F9h YZhVeVgZXZg~d)
9eZcVh
Xdch^YZgZVY^[ZgZcVZcigZ ch' ]jbVcdh $ZmXaj^cYddh ZXdcdb^hiVh [^(
cVcXZ^gdhZ ]dbZch YZcZ\X^dh%'Z djigdh hZgZhk^kdh cd eaVcZiV)
9ab Y^hhd' VXgZY^idfjZ V \gVcYZ igVch^~d cV k^YVhdX^Vac~d kZ^d
Xdb d \gVbd[dcZ' bVh h^b fjVcYd Va\jb iZkZ V\gVcYZ edgb ^c_jhiV
^Y^VYZ^ckZciVg d Va[VWZid'
eZgb^i^cYd(cdh VgbVoZcVg^c[dgbV~d ZgZ(
egdYjo^(AV)=hhVigVch^~d VXZaZgdj(hZV^cYVbV^h fjVcYd djigd ^ckZcidg
iZkZV^Y^VV^cYVbV^h eZg^\dhVZ ^c_jhiV YZXg^Vg
jbV \g|[^XV' egdbdkZc(
Yd iZmidhVab YZ[gdciZ^gVhZY^heVgVcYdd fjZ VXVWdjhZigVch[dgbVcYd
Zb jbV ZXdad\^VYd i^ed !d kZcXZYdgaZkVijYd!) EVh d fjZ ]Vk^VYZi~d
/ 147,+4LA+\[7
=hhVY^hi^c~dZcigZd ZhXVa|kZa
Z d c~d(ZhXVa|kZa
eZgb^iZ fjZ [VVbdh
jbV Y^[ZgZcX^V~d
XaVgV
ZcigZYjVhkVg^ZYVYZh
YZ^cXZgiZoVh'
Yd^hi^edh
YZVaZVidg^ZYVYZh)
:g^cfjZbdh Xdb d hZ\j^ciZ ZmeZg^bZcidbZciVa5hjedc]V fjZ kdX
gZcVb^a eZhhdVhZhXda]^YVh
VaZVidg^VbZciZ
ZcigZVedejaV~d \ZgVaZ[VV
Xdb fjZ [^fjZb aVYdVaVYdZb jb Zhi|Y^d)NdXedYZVi^cXaj^g[gVcXZ(
hZh$bVh'edg [Vkdg'c~d bj^idh' Zb Xdch^YZgV~d
Vdhdjigdh bZbWgdh Yd
\gjed%' bZbWgdh YVE|[^V' c~d(bZbWgdh YVE|[^V ZkZ\ZiVg^Vcdh)
HZchZcV eZhhdVbV^heZhVYV
fjZ Xdch^\V^bV\^cVgZ VXgZhXZciZ(V
Vd
\gjed YZVbdhigV\Zb) HgZhjb^cYd fjZ ZhhVeZhhdVeZhZd ig^eadYVb(
Y^V'Va\dZb idgcd YZ,3+ V-.+ fj^adh' ZaVgVgVbZciZgZegZhZciVg|bV^h
Yd fjZ jbV [gV~dbj^id eZfjZcV Yd eZhd YVedejaV~d ^ciZ^gV$cZhhZ
XVhd'XZgXV
YZ+'0 edg XZcid%)
NdXedYZ hZgV^cYV
bV^hV\gZhh^kd)
KZ'YZcigdYdha^b^iZhW^da\^Xdh
edhhkZ^h'kdXZhXda]ZhhZ
d hZg]jbVcd bV^heZhVYdcd eaVcZiV$fjZ V^c(
YVedhhVhZgX]VbVYdYZ]jbVcd%' ZaZc~d gZegZhZciVg^V
bV^hYdfjZ' Y^(
\Vbdh' +'1 edg XZcidYd idiVa'jb VjbZcid bj^id YZhegZokZa)
= hZkdX
i^kZhhZ,+ b^a eZhhdVh'VXdcig^Wj^~dYZaZhZg^V
fjVhZ ^ch^\c^[^XVciZ)
FV egdkcX^Vjie^XVYd EZY^dXg^hi~d'
ZkZcidheVgi^XjaVgZh
c~d Xdc(
ig^WjZb bj^id ^cY^k^YjVabZciZ
( h XdaZi^kVbZciZ)
HdhhdYZ[^c^gVaZ^
hjegZbV YdEZY^dXg^hi~d
YVhZ\j^ciZ bVcZ^gV5EbN[Q\ NNZ\`a_N n T_N['
QR&
[R[UbZ ReRZ]YN_V`\YNQ\NYaR_N_jQRZ\Q\ `VT[VSVPNaVc\
\ NT_RTNQ\\b \
a\aNY(9 bV^dg dWhZgkVn~d
eZgbVcZXZg|cdi|kZa' bVh XdchZfZciZbZciZ
^ch^\c^[^XVciZ
eVgVd gZhjaiVYd[^cVa)
HZ\VgZ^ZbegZhiVYddjigd ZmZbeadYd bZj Vb^\d :gjXZ ?daYWZg\5
hZj Xdchjbd XVag^Xd)
GWhZgkZ
d fjVcid kdXXdchdbZ Zb jb Vcd ( hZ
[dg XaVhh^[^XVYd
Xdbd ]jbVcd' hZg| Va\d Zb idgcd YZ3++ b^a XVadg^Vh)
FZc]jb Y^V^hdaVYd'cZb bZhbd d <^VYZ9~d YZ?gVVhcV XVhV
YZ
hjV i^V(Vk'gZegZhZciVg|jbV eVgXZaV
\gVcYZYd idiVa)EZhbd fjZ kdX
iZciVhhZhZbViVgYZiVcid XdbZg' VhXVadg^Vh
^c\Zg^YVh
cZhhZY^Vc~d V[Z(
iVg^Vbbj^id hZj Xdchjbd VcjVa)
(
hZZj Y^hhZhhZ
VkdX fjZ edhhkZaZcXdcigVgVa\jb fjZ eZhZ
9\dgV'
)
YZidcZaVYVh
dj iZb XZciZcVh
YZfj^abZigdh YZVaijgV'kdXZed(
b^MBVgZh
)
) ) i^[^XVg
eZg[Z^iVbZciZjb ZmVbZYZbZj adWd[gdciVa'dj hj\Zcg
YZcV BMhVhhVhhZ
( X)aZciaXV)
"NQEVh cVd
& ZiVd^VXZmX
%& '(! ^a A#
VZhXgZkZg
[^XVd
MagkV(
fjZ
Zj
e
#YY
) U migZbVhXdb jb i^ed Y^[ZgZciZ
YZfjVcia V Zh'ZZ#)AKKGfjZ VWdg(
cVdZhZ
YVgZbdhVhZ\j^g)
)
9
'
HVgV
Z[Z^idYZXdbeVgV~d'Xdch^YZgZ
d eVig^bc^d afj^Yd YVhb^a eZh(
hdVhfjZ kdXZc[^aZ^gdjcd Zhi|Y^d)9Y^X^dcZVZaVh
VeZhhdVbV^hg^XV
fjZ
hZedhhVZcXdcigVgcd eaVcZiV( Y^\Vbdh fjZ hZ_V
:^aa?ViZh' [jcYVYdg
YVE^Xgdhd[i)HgZhjbV fjZ hZj eVig^bc^d afj^Yd hZ_V
egm^bd YZ3+
W^a]Zh
YZYaVgZh
( Xdb d XVe^iVa
idiVaYdhdjigdh hdbVcYd Zb idg(
cd YZedjXdh b^a]Zh)IjVcid YVg^fjZoVidiVaZaZgZegZhZciVg^V8
KZg^Vb
44'4 edg XZcid8FV kZgYVYZ'
idYdhdh djigdh gZegZhZciVg^Vb
c~d bV^hYd
fjZ jb ZggdYZVggZYdcYVbZcideVgVhZj eVig^bc^d afj^Yd' VkVg^V~d
YZhjV XVgiZ^gV
YZiijadh eZhhdVacd ai^bd hZ\jcYd) HVgV
fjZ d eZhd YZ
jbV eZhhdVgZegZhZciZ
jbV eVgXZaV
^\jVa' ZaVegZX^hVg^V
eZhVg-. b^a]Zh
YZfj^adh
LZciZcdkVbZciZ Xdb' Y^\Vbdh' kZcYVhYZa^kgdh)=c[^aZ^gZ
b^a ZhXg^(
idgZh$dj eZhhdVh^beadgVcYdeVgVhZgZbejWa^XVYVh'
bVh fjZ hZY^oZb
ZhXg^idgZh
Zb kZo YZ\Vgdch%Z Xdc[^gVd kdajbZ YZkZcYVhYZhZjh a^(
kgdh)=ci~d VXgZhXZciZ
VZhXg^idgV
k^kVfjZ $VijVabZciZ%
edhhj^ d bV^dg
cbZgd YZaZ^idgZh)
B)C) Jdla^c\' VjidgVYVhg^ZYZ@VggnHdiiZg'Xdb
XZciZcVhYZb^a]ZhYZa^kgdhkZcY^Ydh)=aVb^c^b^oVg| dh djigdh b^a
ZhXg^idgZh
fjZ' Y^\Vbdh' hdbVb XdaZi^kVbZciZ
Va\jbVh XZciZcVhYZb^(
a]VgZhYZaZ^idgZh'
cd b|m^bd)
LZciZ iVbWb Xdb X^iVZh
VXVYb^XVh
$VbZc~d Vjb VXVYb^Xd
edg djigd VXVYb^Xd
Zb jbV ejWa^XV~d
[dgbVa%'gZ[ZgcX^Vh
cV bY^V'
gZcYV'iVbVc]d YZZbegZhVhZVhh^bedg Y^VciZ);]VbZbdh ZhhVh
fjZh(
iZh
YZ`\PVNV`&
ed^hh~d[Z^iVh
eZad]dbZb' Zb XdcigVhiZXdb VhfjZhiZh
[h^XVh'
Xdbd d Y^}bZigdYZX^cijgVh)
B\ 9ea_RZV`al\&N` QR`VTbNYQNQR`
`l\ aN[aN`^bR bZN t[VPN \O`R_cNml\
]\QR ReR_PR_bZ VZ]NPa\ QR`]_\]\_PV\[NY `\O_R \ NT_RTNQ\\b `\O_R \ a\aNY(
HdgiVcid' ZcfjVcid eZhd' VaijgVZ ^c\Zhi~d YZXVadg^Vh
eZgiZcXZbVd
EZY^dXg^hi~d'
Vg^fjZoVc~d eZgiZcXZ)IjVhZ idYVhVhfjZhiZhhdX^V^h
h~d
9eZhVgYZZhhVY^hi^c~d$ZcigZd EZY^dXg^hi~d
Z d =migZb^hi~d%
edhhj^g
\gVkZhgVb^[^XVZh
iVcid cV_jhi^VhdX^Va
fjVcid cVY^c}b^XVYdhZkZc(
idh' kZ_VbdhhjV Vea^XV~d
eVgVd Xdc]ZX^bZcid' fjZ dcYZZhi| VbV^dg
eVgiZYZhZj kVadg)KZjb bVgX^Vcdk^ZhhZ
g LZggVZVWgVVhhZ
ViVgZ[V
YZ
bZY^gV VaijgVYVhXg^VijgVh
YZhiZeaVcZiV[Za^o'ZaZedYZg^VeVgVgXdb
hZ\jgVcVZb XZb ]jbVcdh eVgVfjZ i^kZhhZ
jbV WdV^Y^V
YZhjV VaijgV
bY^V)KZkdXk^kZcd EZY^dXg^hi~d'
edhhkZa[^XVg
hVi^h[Z^id
Xdb d fjZ
bZY^j ( YZhYZ
fjZ hZiZc]V XZgiZoV
YZfjZ d fjZ [d^ bZY^YdkZc]V Yd
EZY^dXg^hi~d)
LVbWb edYZ[^XVg
hVi^h[Z^id
Xdb \ ^bR N]_R[QRb VeVgi^g
YZhhZh
YVYdh)
9 XdchZfcX^VZe^hiZbda\^XV
fjZ Xdb VVaZVidg^ZYVYZ
YdEZY^dXg^hi~d
c~d ]\``pcRY" iZgjbV hjgegZhVZb [dgbV YZ;^hcZ F Z(
\gd' YZbdYd fjZ jb c^XdZkZcidedhhVYdb^cVgjb [ZcbZcd) D_VZ\&
dh XZbeg^bZ^gdhY^Vh
YZkZbgZkZaVg
ijYd fjZ kdXegZX^hV
hVWZg
hdWgZ
dh
YVYdh)
GRP\[Q\&bZhbd fjZ iZc]V jbV hjgegZhV'Xdbd k^bdh cd XVhdYd
]jbVcd bV^heZhVYdYdbjcYd' ZaVc~d hZg^V
XdchZfZcX^Va)
KZZhi^kZg
a^YVcYd
Xdb fjVci^YVYZhYd =migZb^hi~d'kdXiZg| Y^[^Xja(
YVYZ
Zb XVaXjaVg
VbY^VVeVgi^gYZfjVafjZg VbdhigV\Zb' ed^hZaVedYZ
YZeZcYZgYZbV^hYZjbV c^XVdWhZgkV~d)
9 ^Y^V
c~d bV^hY^[X^a
Yd
=c[Vi^od VeVaVkgV
]\``pcRY edgfjZ VX]VcXZYZhhVhdXdggcX^Vh' i^e^XVbZciq' YVdgYZb YZ
jb Zb bj^idh ig^a]ZhYZig^a]Zh
( c~d hZX]Z\V bV^h eZgid Yd ^bedhhkZa)
'
d
XjZ aKK+)
) Y hegdedgX^dcVa)
FZhhZbjcYd'
9#
(=C7=B> &<>67A36>
dcYZYZkZbdhhjedgiVgVi^gVc^V
Yd XdaZi^kd'Yd gdi^cZ^gd'Yd Wk^dZ Yd
D347<3!% )"&H&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&
=MLQVKYQZ[jV
7^[YMTQZ[jV
7ZKISh]MS'
>jV&MZKISh]MS'
SMI[VYQMLILMTVLMYILI
V\ LV [QWV)'
3SMI[VYQMLILMQU[MUZI#I[l Z\WMYQU[MUZI$
V\ LV [QWV*'
? TIQZ ![nWQKV!
V\ l OQOIU[MV\ IUjV% V\
ZMRI%
UjV M^QZ[M
\T TMTJYV [nWQKV'
FMUKMLVYMZ
SM]IT \TI
WMX\MUI NI[QI LV
J?SV%
7^MTWSV0
V WqJSQKV
LM \T KIU[VY LM
oWMYIIU[MZ LV OYITVNVUM'
7NMQ[VZ
LV [QWV!? ]MUKMLVYSM]I X\IZM
[\LV!'
? WqJSQKV
LM \T IY[QZ[I%PVRM'
F\SUMYh]MS
IV 5QZUM>MOYV'
C\RMQ[V
{ OYI]QLILM%
>jV M^QZ[MTYMZ[YQkpMZ
NnZQKIZ
I \T
UqTMYV'
5VYYMZWVULM
#OMYISTMU[M$
I X\IU[QLILMZ
NnZQKIZ'
@VY
M^MTWSV0
WMZV%
5VYYMZWVULM
I UqTMYVZ%
@VY
M^MTWSV0
I
YQX\M_I%
? TIQZ WYo^QTVWVZZn]MS
LV
X\M I YMISQLILMWVLMVNMYMKMY
MZWVU[IUMITMU[MLM QO\ISLILM \[oWQKI'
qUQKI
y UMKMZZhYQV
T\Q[V [MTWV WIYI X\M ZM
ZIQJI V X\M MZ[h IKVU[MKMULV'
DQYIUQI
LV KVSM[Q]V'
DQYIUQI
LV IKQLMU[IS'
8hKQS
LM ZMNI_MYWYM]QZpMZ
I WIY[QY
LV X\M
6QNnKQS
LM ZMWYM]MY
I WIY[QY
LM QUNVYTIkpMZ
ZMVJZMY]I M LM MZ[MULm&;IZ
IV X\M UjV ZM LV WIZZILV'
VJZMY]I'
3 PQZ[oYQI
ZMIYYIZ[I%
7]MU[VZZjV LQZ[YQJ\nLVZ
LM IKVYLV KVT I
!5\Y]I UI NVYTI LM ZQUV!b#I 9;8$ V\ Z\IZ
]IYQIkpMZ%
3 LQZ[YQJ\QkjV
V\ NMQ[IWVY5QZUMZ
!KQU_MU[VZ!
TIULMSJYV[QIUVZ
#KQMU[QNQKITMU[M
[YI[h]MQZ$V\ WVY5QZUMZ
>MOYVZ[V[ISTMU[M QU[YI[h]MQZ'
6OLJL@M<%
MOLJL@M<
$ 2YNI?IM MIADMND><?IM
J<L< <JL@H?@L
KVT V AONOLI
$ 6@Q$
NOM
@MN<P<
M@GJL@
{ AL@HN@
$ * D?YD<
JLDH>DJ<F
HWI M@L
OG NLIOQ<$ 8<GIM
HIMGO?<L J<L< d 2@?DI>LDMNWI%
hZ>IHM@BODLGIM
@H>IHNLV$/I
d fjZ
Hdgjb WgZkZ
bdbZcid' VciZhYZhZgZXdbedg' kdX kZg| Xdc[jh~d Zb
hZj gdhid)
;dc[Zhhd iZg YZhZckdak^Yd
jb \dhid ^cXdgg^\kZaedg ZhhZi^ed YZ
igVkZhhjgVYjgVciZ bZj eg^bZ^gd VXVbeVbZcid YZ[g^Vh)
AcigdYjo^YV
cV cVg^cVYZjb XVbe^hiVVYdgbZX^Yd'jbV eZcV ^cYjo^Vjb e}c^Xd
gZeZci^cd) HVhhZ^
eVgiZYV^c[}cX^VegVi^XVcYd
kVg^VZh
YVigVkZhhjgV5
Zb kZoYZjbV eZcV[^cV'edYZ(hZZcgdaVgVedciV YZjb aZcd YZeVeZa
eVgVidgc|(Ad adc\d Z[^cd) HgVi^fjZ^jb edjXd Xdb bZj ^gb~d bZcdg)
MbV igVkZhhjgV^\jVabZciZ Z[Zi^kVhZg^V
XdadXVg
jb XjWdYZ\Zad YZc(
igd YV\daV YZjbV eZhhdVfjVcYd ZaVbZcdh Zhi^kZgZheZgVcYd( Zb
jb _VciVgd[^X^Va'
edg ZmZbead)L^kZfjZ eVgVgXdb ZhhVhigVkZhhjgVh
{
bZY^YVfjZ VkVcVkV
cVk^YVVYjaiV'dWk^VbZciZ'bVh hdj Xdb [gZfc(
X^VVi^c\^Yd^ckdajciVg^VbZciZedg iVa^bV\Zb fjVcYd Zhidj XdbeaZ(
iVbZciZ Zc[Vhi^VYd
Xdb eZhhdVhYZcZ\X^dhYZVeVgcX^V
hg^V$YZiZg(
cdh ZhXjgdhZ bZciZh eVYgdc^oVYVh%
iZdg^oVcYd'Zmea^XVcYd
Xd^hVh
dj
[VaVcYdhdWgZZkZcidh VaZVig^dh
Xdb bj^idh !edgfjh! cV XdckZghV)
;dcXZcigd(bZ Zb jb YZaZh
Z ^bV\^cd d XjWdYZ\Zad YZhXZcYd
edg hjVh
XdhiVh( hZg^V
bZcdh ZaZ\VciZ'bVh' Xdb XZgiZoV'
bV^h ZheZiVXjaVg'
hZ
XdadXVhhZ
jb XVbjcYdc\d k^kd edg YZcigdYV\daV' ZheZX^VabZciZ
hZV
eZhhdVhZci^gXXZ\Vh
Z Zhi^kZgjhVcYd \gVkViV'd fjZ WadfjZVg^V
V gdiV
YZ[j\V Yd gdZYdg)t'
LgVkZhhjgVh
edYZb hZgXdcYZhXZcYZciZh)
DZbWgd(bZ Yd XdbZd YV
b^c]V XVggZ^gV
cd bZgXVYd'fjVcYd i^c]V XZgXV
YZ-0 VcdhZd Y^c]Z^gd
XdbZVkVVk^g[VX^abZciZ)
=j eZ\VkVi|m^h' Z hZd bdidg^hiV [VaVhhZ
jb
^c\ah W|h^XdZ eVgZXZhhZ
ZheZX^VabZciZ
YZeg^b^Yd'Zj YVkVV ZaZjbV
cdiV YZ,++ YaVgZh
Xdbd \dg_ZiV'h eVgVYVg(a]Zjb eZfjZcd hjhid Z
hZci^gegVoZgXdb VhjgegZhV)=j dWhZgkVkV
ZcfjVcid d bdidg^hiVYZhYd(
WgVkV
VcdiV Zda]VkVeVgVZaVXdb XZgid\gVj YZXdchiZgcV~d$, b^a]~d
YZYaVgZh
hZg^V
XZgiVbZciZbZa]dg' bVh ZhiVkV
Vab YZbZjh gZXjghdh%)
=gViVbWb jb ZmeZg^bZci{]ZYdc^hiVh^beaZh5hZci^V(bZWZbedg [V(
oZgd Y^VYZVa\jb Xdb Vc^c]Vg^VYZ,++ YaVgZh)
=c[^b' YZ^mZ^
YZ[VoZg
^hhd6idYdhcdh idgcVbdh bZhfj^c]dh ZXVaXja^hiVh
fjVcYd cdhhVg^fjZoV
VjbZciV ZXdbZVbdh VaZkVgY^c]Z^gdVhg^d)
F~d egZX^hd
YZbj^iV V_jYV
YdYZhi^cdeVgViZgZcigZiZc^bZcidZb aVg\V
ZhXVaV5
VgZVa^YVYZ
d[ZgZXZ
gZk^hZh
[dgVYVh
YZXgZcVh
Zb jb g^ibd bj^id
VqZaZgVYd)
Ej^iVh YZaVh
h~dWVhiVciZ
ZheZiVXjaVgZh)
FV kZgYVYZ'
idYd Zb(
gZZcY^bZcidYVWjhXV
YZXdc]ZX^bZcidWVhZ^V(hZ
Zb eZ\VgVhVWZYdg^V
HdckZcX^dcVa
ZXgZcVh
X^Zci[^XVh
VXZ^iVh
Z Zhi^a]V|(AVh
Xdb cdkVhegdkVh
qdcigV(^cij^i^kVh'
hZ_V
Zb ZhXVaV
b^XgdhXe^XV
$idYVYZhXdWZgiV
X^Zci[^XV
jbV iZciVi^kV
YZegdYjo^gjb b^Xgd;^hcZFZ\gd%dj Zb \gVcYZZhXVaV
$Xdbd Xdb VgZaVi^k^YVYZ
YZHd^cXVg
ZYZ=^chiZ^c%)
Gh X^Zci^hiVh
edYZb
ZhiVg
cd gV^cdYZg^gYdhegZYZXZhhdgZh'
bVh Zb k^gijYZYZjbV gZYZYZY^h(
edh^Zh
bZciV^h]jbVcVh edjXdh eZgXZWZb
fjZ Va\jb g^g|YZhjVhXgZc(
Vhcd [jijgd $YZXZeX^dcVciZbZciZ
egm^bd%)FZhhZXVhd'bZjh aZ^idgZh
Z
Zj ZhiVbdhg^cYdYd ZhiVYd]_R`R[aRYd Xdc]ZX^bZcidhdX^Va)
Gh [^\jgZh
c~d egZhhZciZbVX]Z\VYV
YVgZk^h~d
^cZk^i|kZaYZhZj igVWVa]d'
d fjZ h^\c^(
[^XV
fjZ' \ZgVabZciZ'kdXedYZVXgZY^iVg
fjZ ZaZhiZg~djbV hjgegZhV)
d hjeZg[^ahd[d:ZgigVcYJjhhZaa VegZhZciVjbV
kVg^V~dZheZX^VabZc(
iZ im^XV
Yd bZj X]dfjZ YZhjgegZhVZb hjV ^ajhigV~dYd fjZ eZhhdVh
Zb hZj gVbd X]VbVb YZHgdWaZbV
YZAcYj~d dj HgdWaZbV
YZ;dc]Z(
X^bZcid AcYji^kd $Xdb aZigVhbV^hXjaVhYZk^Ydg hZg^ZYVYZ%
( XZgiV(
bZciZ d bV^dgYZidYdhdh egdWaZbVhcVk^YV);dbd Y\TVPNZR[aRedh(
hkZa^gbdh YZ^chi}cX^Vh
ZheZX[^XVh
ViVaXVcVgbdh
XdcXajhZh
\ZgV^h8
;dbd hVWZbdhd fjZ hVWZbdh8
;dbd hVWZbdhfjZ d fjZ dWhZgkVbdh
VeVgi^gYZXZgidhdW_Zidh
Z ZkZcidh hj[^X^ZciZeVgVfjZ iZc]Vbdh VXV(
eVX^YVYZ
YZYZhXdWg^g
hjVh djigVh egdeg^ZYVYZh8
=hhVhh~d VgbVY^a]Vh
ZbWji^YVhZb fjVafjZg i^ed YZXdc]ZX^bZcid VYfj^g^Ydedg bZ^d YV
dWhZgkV~d)
AbV\^cZjb eZgj fjZ Va^bZciVYdY^Vg^VbZciZ)
;VYVgZ[Z^~dhZgk^(
YVgZ[dgVg|VXgZcVYde|hhVgdYZfjZ VgZ\gV\ZgVaYVk^YV hZgVa^bZc(
iVYdY^Vg^VbZciZ
edg bZbWgdh Vb^\|kZ^h YVgVV]jbVcV fjZ !oZaVb
edg hZj bZa]dg ^ciZgZhhZ!'Xdbd Y^g^V
jb edai^Xd)FV iVgYZYVfjVgiV(
[Z^gV
fjZ VciZXZYZ
d <^VYZ9~d YZ?gVVh'Va\dV[R`]R_NQ\VXdciZXZg|
Vd
eZgj) =aZZhiVg|hj_Z^idVjbV gZk^h~dYZhjVhXgZcVh5
G gZhiVciZYd XVeijadYZa^cZVg|
d egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd Zb hjV
[dgbV dg^\^cVa5
Xdbd edYZbdh hVWZg
d [jijgd' YVYdd Xdc]ZX^bZcidfjZ
((((((
#!
u)
2
q
3+
1+
%!!
'!!
<A9K
EY0U
WMY\IU[MZ M LMWVQZ
LV 6QI LM 3kjV LM 9YIkIZ' 3 PQZ[oYQI
LM \T WYVKMZZV
IV SVUOVLM )'(() LQIZ
UIV SPMLQGUILI ZVJYMV X\M IKVU[MKMYh I ZMO\QY'
7ZZI WYVRMkjVQUVKMU[M
LV N\[\YV I WIY[QY
LV WIZZILV
WVLMZMYIWSQKILI I X\ISX\MY KVQZI'
]\`a\ ;dc[jcY^g
Nd dj gZegZhZciVi^kdYd [jijgd
XdbegZZcYZg d ;^hcZ FZ\gd)
Vc^XVXVjhVYZcdhhV ^cXVeVX^YVYZ
YZ
cd fjZ hZidgcdj
d cVj(
e^hXVg
YZda]dh' hZb cZc]jb Vk^hd$bV^h'bj^id bV^hhdWgZ
^hhdcd ;V(
eijad ,2%5
#
Yj#gVg
YXVYVh)
<Z bdYd \ZgVa';^hcZhFZ\gdh edh^i^kdhaZkVbiZbed eVgV
VegZhZciVg
hZjh Z[Z^idh'ZcfjVcid dh cZ\Vi^kdhVXdciZXZbbj^id gVe^YV(
bZciZ ( bj^id bV^h[|X^aZ bj^id bV^hg|e^Yd YZhigj^gfjZ Xdchigj^g)
$<jgVciZ V\jZggVa^WVcZhV'
VXVhV
YZbZjh eV^hZb 9b^djc Z VXVhV
YZ
bZj VkZb jbV k^aVegm^bV[dgVb YZhigjYVh
Zb edjXVh]dgVh' Y^cV(
b^iVYVh
edg ^c^b^\dh YZbZj VkfjZ XdcigdaVkVbV|gZV)>d^cZXZhh|g^d
2
b^a kZoZhbV^hiZbed ( Yd^hVcdh( eVgVgZXdchigj(AVh)
=hhVVhh^bZig^V
Zb ZhXVaVh
iZbedgV^hZmea^XV
VY^[^XjaYVYZ
Zb hZgZkZgiZg
d iZbed)%
YZg^hXdh
$kZgZbdhfjZ [VkdgZdjb i^ed V\gZhh^kd
YZZmedh^~dVg^hXdh%5
ijYd fjZ bdhigVgZ^ Xdbd Zk^iVgVigVkZhhVg
VgjV QR\YU\` cR[QNQ\`(
9XVWdYZVegZhZciVg
d egdWaZbVYd;^hcZ FZ\gd Zb hjV [dgbV ]^hig^XV5
VY^[^XjaYVYZ
XZcigVaYZhZ\ZcZgVa^oVg
VeVgi^gYV^c[dgbV~d Y^hedc(
kZa'dj YZhZVegZcYZgXdb d eVhhVYd'd Xdc]ZX^YdZ d k^hid)LVbWb
VegZhZciZ^
V a^hiVYVfjZaVhfjZ' VXgZY^id'
h~d Vh[^\jgVh ]^hig^XVh
bV^h
gZaZkVciZh)
HdYZ(hZkZgfjZ cdh ZmigZbVbZciZXdckZc^ZciZhjedg fjZ k^kZbdh
cd EZY^dXg^hi~d)
Hdgfj8 HdgfjZ ^hhdeZgb^iZfjZ ZmXajVbdhVhhjgegZ(
hVhYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd G egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd dj c~d Zm^hiZ
dj iZb
edjXV ^bedgi}cX^V'hZkdXk^kZcd EZY^dXg^hi~d)
LVahjedh^~d XdcYjo bV\^XVbZciZVdegdWaZbVYV^cYj~d' fjZ YZh(
YZKZmijh=be^g^XjhkZb V[a^\^cYdV]^hig^VYdeZchVbZcid) G ZhiVihi^(
XdedYZa^kgVg(hZ
YVZe^hiZbdad\^V)
U
IjZb cdh YZgVF~d k^kZbdh cd EZY^dXg^hi~d'
edgiVcid d ;^hcZ FZ(
\gd egZX^hV
YZjbV bZciVa^YVYZ
Y^[ZgZciZ)
;dbd c~d edYZbdh kVggZgd
egdWaZbVeVgVWV^md
Yd iVeZiZ'egZX^hVgZbdh
Zmeadg|(AdbV^hegd[jcYV(
bZciZ) =hhVc~d jqV Y^[^XjaYVYZ
iZgb^cVa( Z edYZbdh VibZhbd
cdh WZcZ[^X^Vg
Xdb ZaV)
9\dgV' Zm^hiZbdjigdh iZbVhfjZ hjg\Zb YZcdhhVXZ\jZ^gV
Zb gZaV~d
Vd;^hcZ FZ\gd5
V)Fh cdh XdcXZcigVbdhZb hZ\bZcidh eg(hZaZX^dcVYdh
Yd k^hidZ
\ZcZgVa^oVbdh
VeVgi^gYZaZh
eVgVd c~d(k^hid5d ZggdYVXdc[^gbV(
~d)
W)Fh cdh Zc\VcVbdh Xdb ]^hig^VhfjZ hVX^Vb
cdhhVhZYZeaVic^XV
edg eVYgZh
Y^hi^cidh5
V[Va|X^V
cVggVi^kV)
X)Fh cdh XdbedgiVbdh Xdbd hZ? ;^hcZ FZ\gd c~d Zm^hi^hhZ5
VcV(
ijgZoV]jbVcV c~d egd\gVbVYVeVgV;^hcZh FZ\gdh)
Y) G fjZ kZbdh c~d cZXZhhVg^VbZciZ
ijYd fjZ Zhi| a|) 9 ]^hig^V
dXjaiVdh ;^hcZh FZ\gdh YZch Z igVchb^iZ(cdhjbV ^Y^V
ZggcZV
VXZgXV
YVhegdWVW^a^YVYZh
YZiV^hZkZcidh5ZhhV VY^hidg~dYVZk^(
YcX^V
h^aZcX^dhV)
<^hXji^gZ^XVYV
jb Ydhedcidh cdh X^cXdXVeijadhhZ\j^ciZh)=ci~d'
cV XdcXajh~dYVHVgiZMb' bdhigVgZ^Xdbd' cV eg|i^XV'h~d d ZR`Z\
ie^Xd)
-BPgTULO-JNDO
-7603:5+\[7
-73;+
6/62=5+
.O N@HCIN<HN<M
JLIP<M$ 5I?@G RIIB&@MM@L
"UM]M_MZ$=IIB&@M)$ ,ILLI=I$
L<XWI >IDM<H@HCOG<$ * D?YD<
YZ5IJJ@L
dh#eg^bZ^gdh
b^a Y^Vh
YdeZgj $bVhc~d d X]dfjZ Ydb^ah^bdeg^bZ^gd%
Y^(
g^V'ZXdggZiVbZciZ'
fjZ [l\ Uj RcVQo[PVN
YVedhh^W^a^YVYZ
YZ\gVcYZhZkZc(
idK'dj hZ_V'
YZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh) ;dcijYd' kdXegdkVkZabZciZXdc[jcY^g^V
ZhhV
YZXaVgV~d'
ZheZX^VabZciZ
hZc~d egZhiVg
bj^iV ViZc~d'Xdb VYZXaVgV(
~d YZfjZ ]| RcVQo[PVN
QR[R[UbZN ]\``VOVYVQNQR
YZ;^hcZhFZ\gdh)9eZhVg
YZcVkZgYVYZ
hZg\gVcYZ'VY^hi}cX^V
a\^XVZcigZVhYjVhV[^gbVZh
eVgZ(
XZg|bj^id eZfjZcV Zb hjVbZciZ' YZ[dgbV fjZ jbV edhhVhZg[VX^abZciZ
hjWhi^ijYV
eZaVdjigV)<Vfj^ VYZoY^Vh'
hZ[dg XVeVo
YZVdbZcdh aZbWgVg
Veg^bZ^gVYZXaVgV~d'
kdXegdkVkZabZciZgZiZg|VhZ\jcYVkZgh~d'bZcdh
egZX^hV
( fjZ ]| ]_\cN` QR[R[UbZ 7V`[R BRT_\( ;]Vbd ZhhVXdc[jh~d YZ
[Va|X^V
YZ^YV(Z(kdaiV'
ed^hZhhVh
YZXaVgVZh
c~d h~dV[aR_PNZOVjcRV`(
LVaXdc[jh~d ZcigZVhYjVhYZXaVgVZh
WVhZ^V(hZ
Zb jb Zggda\^Xd
ig^k^Va'
bj^id ig^k^Va
$bVhXgjX^Va%
( bVh c~d hdbdh ^bjcZh VZggdha(
\^XdhZ ig^k^V^h'
iVbedjXd h~degd[ZhhdgZhZ eZchVYdgZh
eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ
^bjcZh VZaZh$ZfjVZhXdbea^XVYVh
c~d iZcYZb VXdVW^iVg
[Za^obZciZ
Xdb XaVgZoV
bZciVa%)9 bZcdh fjZ cdh XdcXZcigZbdhbj^id' egdk|(
kZafjZ' ^ckdajciVg^VbZciZ'h^bea^[^fjZbdh d egdWaZbVedgfjZ cdhhVh
bZciZh d [VoZbgdi^cZ^gVbZciZhZb fjZ cdh YZbdh XdciV)
AhhdbZgZXZjb ZmVbZbV^hegd[jcYd)
Ej^iVh eZhhdVhXdc[jcYZb VYZXaVgV~d
!idYdh dh iZggdg^hiVh
h~dbj(
jabVcdh! Xdb !fjVhZ idYdh dh bjjabVcdh h~d iZggdg^hiVh!)
Kjedc]V
fjZ Veg^bZ^gVYZXaVgV~d
hZ_V
kZgYVYZ^gV'
fjZ 44 edg XZcidYdhiZggdg^hiVh
hZ_VbbjjabVcdh) Ahhdh^\c^[^XVg^V
fjZ XZgXV
YZVeZcVh+'++, edg XZcid
YdhbjjabVcdh h~diZggdg^hiVh'
_| fjZ ]| bV^hYZ, W^a]~dYZbjjabV(
cdh ZhdbZciZ' Y^\Vbdh' ,+ b^a iZggdg^hiVh'
jb Zb XVYV
,++ b^a)HdgiVcid'
d Zggda\^Xd[VoXdb fjZ kdX $^cXdchX^ZciZbZciZ%
VjbZciZ Zb fjVhZ
0+ b^a kZoZhVhX]VcXZh
YZjb bjjabVcd ZhXda]^Yd
VdVXVhd
$Y^\Vbdh'
ZcigZVh^YVYZh
YZ,0 Z0+ Vcdh%hZgiZggdg^hiV
G aZ^idgedYZ kZgcV [Va|X^V
YZ^YV(Z(kdaiV
V ^c_jhi^VYdh ZhiZgZi^(
edh ( b^cdg^VhZb |gZVhjgWVcVhcdh =hiVYdhMc^Ydhib hd[g^YdXdb
^Yci^XV
Xdc[jh~d5bZhbd fjZ VbV^dg^VYdh Xg^b^cdhdhkZc]V YZhZj
hjW\gjed ic^Xd'VbV^dg^VYZhZj hjW\gjed ic^Xdc~d YZXg^b^cdhdh'
bVh ZaZhV^cYVhd[gZb Y^hXg^b^cV~d
edg eVgiZYZeZhhdVhfjZ YZkZg^Vb
iZgbV^hY^hXZgc^bZcid)
!=j cjcXV fj^h Y^oZgfjZ dh XdchZgkVYdgZh
h~d\ZgVabZciZWjggdh)=j
fj^h Y^oZgfjZ eZhhdVhWjggVhh~d \ZgVabZciZXdchZgkVYdgVh!'
gZXaVbdj
XZgiV
kZoBd]c KijVgiE^aa)y jb egdWaZbVXgc^Xd5
hZkdXY^o{heZhhdVh
fjZ VX]VkZYd hjXZhhd cZb hZbegZ iVaZcid' ZaVhVX]Vb fjZ kdX Zhi|
Y^oZcYdfjZ cjcXV iVaZcid' bVh hZbegZ hdgiZ)
Fdhhd bVfj^c| g^dYZYji^kd' VfjZaZ fjZ jhVbdh cV k^YVXdi^Y^VcV'
c~d
[d^ [Z^ideVgVjb VbW^ZciZXdbea^XVYdcd fjVa jbV YZXaVgV~d
VaiZgVYV
YZ bdYd h^\c^[^XVi^kdfjVcYd hjV Xdchigj~d aZkZbZciZ bdY^[^XVYV)
;dch^YZgZ fjZ Zb jb VbW^ZciZeg^b^i^kd c~d ]| jbV Y^[ZgZcVbVgXVc(
iZ ZcigZ VhYZXaVgVZh
N ZNV\_VNQ\` N``N``V[\` `l\ N[VZNV` `RYcNTR[`Z N
ZNV\_VNQ\` N[VZNV` `RYcNTR[``l\ N``N``V[\`( =m^hiZjb ZggdVfj^' bVh ZaZ
fjVhZ hZb ^bedgi}cX^V) FdhhVh ^cij^ZhZhiVihi^XVh
c~d ZkdajgVb eVgV
jb ]VW^iViZb fjZ iV^hhji^aZoVhedhhVb [VoZg\gVcYZ Y^[ZgZcV)
[Z^idhi^e^XVbZciZZb eVX^ZciZh
fjZ YZhZ_Vb
hVWZg
hZZhi~dXjgVYdhdj hZ
]| !gZXdggcX^V!)
$FVkZgYVYZ'
gZXdggcX^V
jb iZgbd ZggcZd6ZaVh^\c^[^(
XVh^beaZhbZciZfjZ d igViVbZcidc~d bVidj idYVhVhXajaVh
XVcXZgdhVh
Z
fjZ ZhhVh
XajaVh
bVa^\cVhc~d YZiZXiVYVh
XdbZVgVbVhZbjai^ea^XVgYZh(
XdcigdaVYVbZciZ)%
F~d k^|kZa'cd ZhiVYdVijVaYViZXcdad\^V'ZmVb^cVg
XVYV
XajaV
YdeVX^ZciZ
eVgVhVWZg
hZidYVhh~dc~d(bVa^\cVh'YZ[dgbV fjZ
d bY^XddWib jbV VbdhigVZhXVcZVcYd
d XdgedXdb d b|m^bd edhhkZa
YZegZX^h~d)
=ci~d' ZaZ[VojbV hjedh^~d VXZgXV
YdfjZ c~d k^j) MbV kZo'
[^fjZ^X]dXVYd
fjVcYd jb bY^XdY^hhZ
eVgVb^b YZed^hYZjb X]ZX`(je
YZX}cXZg
YZgdi^cV5!HVgZYZhZegZdXjeVg'iZbdh Zk^YcX^V
YZXjgV)!!Hdg
fj8!' eZg\jciZ^) !=m^hiZZk^YcX^V
YZfjZ HWI Uj X}cXZg!'[d^ VgZhedhiV)
!;dbd kdXhVWZ8!'
eZg\jciZ^) =aZgZhedcYZj5!G `PN[ YZj cZ\Vi^kd)!9^c(
YVVhh^b'ZaZXdci^cjVkVVcYVcYdedg VY^oZcYd(hZ
bY^Xd
Mb VXgc^bd jhVYd cV a^iZgVijgV
bY^XV F=<' fjZ h^\c^[^XV
FZ(
c]jbV =k^YcX^V
YZ<dZcV) F~d Zm^hiZ
iVaXd^hVXdbd =F<' =k^Yc(
X^VYZFZc]jbV <dZcV) 9^cYVVhh^b'b^c]V ZmeZg^cX^V
Zb Y^hXjhhZh
hdWgZZhhVfjZhi~d Xdb bj^idh bY^Xdh'bZhbd VfjZaZhfjZ ejWa^XVb
igVWVa]dh
hdWgZdh gZhjaiVYdhdWi^Ydh'bdhigdj fjZ bj^idh YZha^oVb
cV
[Va|X^V
YZ^YV(Z(kdaiV
YjgVciZVXdckZghV)
Fd bZ^d YVVggd\}cX^V
X^Zci[^XV
Ydh Vcdh ,41+' bY^Xdhda]VkVb
Xdb YZhYbeVgVd aZ'^iZ
bViZgcd' Xdch^YZgVcYd(d
Va\deg^b^i^kd' Xdbd
hZejYZhhZhZggZegdYjo^YdeZadhaVWdgVig^dh
( hZb eZgXZWZg
fjZ d aZ^(
iZ bViZgcd edYZ ^cXaj^gXdbedcZciZh iZ^hfjZ edYZg^VbiZgZajY^YdV
XdbegZZch~d X^Zci[^XV
YZaZh(' jbV Xdc[jh~d h^beaZhZcigZ Nb`o[PVN
QR RcVQo[PVN
Ydh WZcZ[X^dh
Yd aZ^iZbViZgcd Xdb RcVQo[PVN
QR Nb`o['
PVNYdhWZcZ[X^dh
$bV^hjb XVhdYZeaVidc^hbd' ed^h!c~d [Vo^V
hZci^Yd!
VbVbZciVg fjVcYd edYZgVbdhh^beaZhbZciZ jhVgbVbVYZ^gVh%)
Ej^(
iVheZhhdVheV\VgVbd egZd YZhhV
^c[ZgcX^V
^c\cjV5 YZhXdWg^j(hZ
fjZ
dh fjZ c~d [dgVb VbVgcZciVY8hcV ^c[}cX^VXdgg^Vbjb g^hXdbV^dg YZ
hd[gZgjbV hg^ZYZegdWaZbVhYZhVYZ'^cXaj^cYdbV^dg X]VcXZYZYZ(
hZckdakZgXZgidhi^edh YZX}cXZg
( YZkZ]VkZgVa\jch cjig^ZciZhcZXZhh|(
g^dhcd aZ^iZbViZgcd fjZ V^cYV
cdh ZajYZb)9ab Yd bV^h'dh WZcZ[X^dh
{h b~Zh fjZ VbVbZciVb iVbWb [dgVb ^\cdgVYdh'Xdbd VgZYj~d Yd
g^hXdYZX}cXZgYZbVbV)
G bZhbd dXdggZjXdb VhVb\YVaVh5
VZmigV~d
YZVb\YVaVh
edYZaZ(
kVgVjbV ^cX^YcX^V
bV^dgYZX}cXZg
YZ\Vg\VciV'bVh YjgVciZYXVYVh
dh
bY^XdhcjcXV hjheZ^iVgVbfjZ ZhhZiZX^Yd
!^ci^a!ejYZhhZgZVabZciZiZg
jbV ji^a^YVYZ
fjZ ZhXVeVkV
{ YZiZX~d)
G bZhbd Xdb V[^WgV
Va^bZciVg
ZcXdcigVYV
Zb [gjiVhZkZ\ZiV^h5
cVYXVYV
YZ,41+' bY^XdhVXdch^YZgV(
gVb ^ci^aedgfjZ c~d k^gVb fjVafjZg Zk^YcX^V
^bZY^ViV
YZhjV cZXZh(
h^YVYZ'
ZXdb ^hhdXg^VgVb
jbV \ZgV~dbVacjig^YV)<ZhXdWg^j(hZ
fjZ Vh
[^WgVh
VijVb cV Y^b^cj^~d Yd g^ibd YZVWhdg~d
YZVXVgZh
cd hVc\jZ
Za^beVd VeVgZa]d^ciZhi^cVa
YZXajaVh
eg(XVcXZgdhVh)
FV kZgYVYZ'
VbZ(
Y^X^cV
XVjhdj bj^idh YVcdhcd YZXdggZg
YV]^hig^Vedg XdciVYZhhZ
i^ed
h^beaZhYZXdc[jh~d YZYji^kV)
F~d Zhidj Y^oZcYdfjZ bY^Xdhc~d YZkVbiZghjVhXgZcVh'hdbZc(
iZ fjZ Va\jch i^edh YZXgZcVhYZ[^c^i^kVh
Z [ZX]VYVh
YZkZb hZgZk^iVYdh
( ZgV^hhdfjZ EZcdYdid Z hjV ZhXdaV
eVgZX^Vb
ZhiVgYZ[ZcYZcYdXdb
hZj i^ed YZbZY^X^cV
Xi^Xd(Zbeg^XV
fjZ Zk^iVkV
iZdg^oVZh)
9 bZY^X^cV
bZa]dgdj ( bVh bj^idh i^edh YZXdc]ZX^bZcid' c~d)
Xdbd VViZgg^hhV\Zb
YZjb ]dbZb cV ajV Z d XgZhX^bZcidZXdcb^Xd
Yd hXjadPPA) e edhhkZaZcXdcigVgbj^iVh !XdcigVegdkVh!eVgVdh edc(
idh Xdci^YdhcZhiZa^kgd'Z VbZa]dg YZaVh
fjZ _dgcV^hh~dZmXZaZciZh
cV
egZk^h~dYZ]dg|g^dh #YZ
X^cZbVZYZiZVigd)NZ_Vh' egZk^dciZb fjZ d hda
cVhXZg^V
]d_Z' ZZaZcVhXZj
G eg^bZ^gd VXdcXZWZg
ZhhVVhh^bZig^Vc~d [d^ HZ^gXZ
cZb HdeeZg) =b ,323' d [^ahd[dN^X(
idg :gdX]VgY bZcX^dcdj V^bedgi}cX^V Yd Zbe^g^hbd cZ\Vi^kd Xdbd hZ[dhhZjbV fjZhi~d
YZ[ZcY^YV
eZadh Zbe^g^hiVhXdbd V[dgbV bV^h hVjY|kZa YZhZgZVa^oVg
cZ\X^dh ( dh Vci^(
\dh VXdbegZZcY^Vb ^bea^X^iVbZciZ) D^kgdhZh\diVYdhegdedgX^dcVb bj^iVh hjgegZhVh)
GWk^VbZciZ'c~d [|X^a![Vah^[^XVg!'
dj hZ_V'V[^gbVgfjZ Va\dZhi| Zg(
gVYdXdb XZgiZoV
VWhdajiV)
AbeZg[Z^Zh
cd bidYd YZiZhiV\Zb edYZb
VegZhZciVg
jb !c~d! 5fj^kdXVYd)G)bY^XdfjZ egdqjgq XajaVq
qVcXZ(
gdhVhedYZiZgjb Zfj^eVbZcid YZ[ZiijdhdfjZ XVjhZ^ajhdZhY)ZdiaX)V'
dj
edYZg^VhZgjb ZXdcdb^hiVfjZ ji^a^oVVXjgkVcV 5dgbV YZh)bd Yah[Vq(
VYdYZbY^Xd)MbV iZhiZbjc]V dXjaVgYZjb XcbZ edYZcVZhiVgW)Z(
WVYV)
AN` \ PN`\ P\[aV[bN `R[Q\ ^bR c\Po `NOR\ ^bR R`aj R__NQ\P\Z ZIYa\
ZNV` PR_aRgN
Q\ ^bR \ ^bR `NOR^bR R`aj PR_a\(LdYVhVheZVhYZ^c[dgbV~d
c~d h~dYZ^\jVa^bedgi}cX^V)
HdeeZg^cigdYjo^j d bZXVc^hbdYZXdc_ZXijgVh
ZgZ[jiVZh'
fjZ [jc(
X^dcVYVhZ\j^ciZ bVcZ^gV5kdX [dgbjaV jbV Xdc_ZXijgV$Zk^YZciZ%
Z
XdbZV VegdXjgVgeZaVdWhZgkV~d
fjZ egdkVg| fjZ kdX Zhi| ZggVYd)
=hhV VVaiZgcVi^kV
eVgVcdhhVWjhXVedg ^chi}cX^Vh
Xdc[^gbVig^Vh)
KZ
kdX eZchVfjZ ZhhViVgZ[V
[|X^a'[^XVg|YZXZeX^dcVYd
( edjXdh ]jbV(
cdh edhhjZb V]VW^a^YVYZ
cVijgVaYZ[VoZg^hhd);dc[Zhhd fjZ c~d hdj jb
YZaZh6
^hhdc~d bZ dXdggZcVijgVabZciZ)
"-,0*,+-
*01 0.2/
;^Zci^hiVhXd\c^i^kdhZhijYVgVbcdhhViZcYcX^VcVijgVaVegdXjgVghd(
bZciZ edg XdggdWdgVZh6
ZaZhX]VbVb ZhhVkjacZgVW^a^YVYZ
VdZggdYV
XdggdWdgV~d
YZ cVn` P\[SV_ZNaq_V\( =m^hiZbVa\jch ZmeZg^bZcidhfjZ
YZbdchigVb fjZ VheZhhdVhhZXdcXZcigVbVeZcVhcdh a^kgdha^YdhcV
W^Wa^diZXV
YZMbWZgid=Xd)HdYZ(hZiZhiVgjbV gZ\gVZheZX[^XV
Y^gZiV(
bZciZ' dWhZgkVcYd
Vh^chi}cX^VhZb fjZ [jcX^dcV' dj ^cY^gZiVbZciZ'
XdcXZcigVcYd(hZ
cVhZb fjZ c~d [jcX^dcV);dbd k^bdh VciZg^dgbZciZ'
^chi}cX^Vh
c~d(Xdc[^gbVig^Vhh~d bj^id bV^hedYZgdhVhcd ZhiVWZaZX^(
bZcid YVkZgYVYZ)
9^cYVVhh^b'iZcYZbdh Vc~d iZg XdchX^cX^V
YZhhV
egdeg^ZYVYZ))
)
G eg^bZ^gdZmeZg^bZcidfjZ Xdc]Zd Zb idgcd YZhhZ[ZcbZcd [GA
[Z^ideZad eh^Xad\dH) ;) OVhdc) =aZVegZhZcidj {h XdWV^Vh
VhZfc(
X^VYZigh cbZgdh -' /' 1 Z eZY^j(A]ZhfjZ VY^k^c]VhhZbV gZ\gVfjZ
V \ZgVkV)G bidYd YZVY^k^c]V~dZgVegdYjo^g djigVh hZfcX^VhY6
igh cbZgdh' {h fjV^h d ZmeZg^bZciVYdg
gZhedcYZg^V
!h^b! dj !c~d# '
YZeZcYZcYdhZVhcdkVhhZfcX^VhZgVbXdch^hiZciZh
Xdb VgZ\gV)MbV
kZo Xdc[^VciZhXdb VhgZhedhiVh'VhXdWV^Vh
YZkZg^Vb[dgbjaVi VgZ\gV)
$GWhZgkZ
Vh^b^aVg^YVYZ
Yd ZmeZg^bZcidXdb VY^hXjhh~dcd ;Veijad ,
d edcid
cVg^bNV`Vig^Wjidh
^g~d\ZcZgVa^oVg)
EdhigZ V[did\gV[^VYZVa\jb dWZhdV
jbV Xg^VcV
Z eZV(a]ZfjZ YZhXgZkV
d gZhidYVedejaV~d5ZaV$egdkVkZa(
bZciZ%c~d X]Z\Vg|{ XdcXajh~dYZfjZ idYdh dh bZbWgdh YVig^Wdib
egdWaZbVh
YZeZhd)EVh ZaVgZhedcYZg^V
Y^[ZgZciZbZciZV\ZcZgVa^oVZh
ZckdakZcYdVXdgYVeZaZ)KZkdXbdhigVg{ Xg^VcV
eZhhdVhYZeZaZZhXjgV
ZeZY^g(a]ZfjZ YZhXgZkV
dh djigdh bZbWgdh YVig^Wd'ZaVegZhjb^g| fjZ
ZaZhiVbWb ib eZaZZhXjgV)
9hh^b' eVgZXZ
fjZ hdbdh YdiVYdhXdb ^chi^cidh ^cYji^kdh ZheZX[^(
XdhZ ZaVWdgVYdh
fjZ cdh \j^Vb) ;dcig|g^d { de^c^~d Yd \gVcYZ<Vk^Y
@jbZ' Z{ YVigVY^~dZbeg^XVWg^i}c^XV'
YZfjZ ZhhVP_R[mNcRZ Q\ P\`'
abZR&edgfjZ ZaZhhjejc]Vb fjZ VegZcYZbdh\ZcZgVa^oVZh
hdbZciZ V
eVgi^gYVZmeZg^cX^V
Z YZdWhZgkVZh
Zbeg^XVh'[d^ YZbdchigVYdedg
bZ^d YZZhijYdh Yd XdbedgiVbZcid ^c[Vci^afjZ cVhXZbdhZfj^eVYdh
Xdb jb bZXVc^hbdbZciVa fjZ [VoXdb fjZ \ZcZgVa^oZbdh`RYRaVcNZR['
aRVeVgi^gYZcdhhVhZmeZg^cX^Vh
$dj hZ_V'fjZ VYfj^g^bdhhZaZi^kVbZciZ
d VegZcY^oVYd
^cYji^kd Zb Va\jch Ydbc^dh' bVh eZgbVcZXZbdhXi^Xdh
Zb djigdh%)9d [VoZgbdh^hhd'c~d ZhiVbdhVegZcYZcYdVigVkh
YZbZgdh
b^a Y^VhZ h^b cdh WZcZ[^X^VcYd'
\gVVh{ Zkdaj~d' Yd VegZcY^oVYd
YZ
cdhhdhVcXZhigV^h
( fjZ hZ^c[^aigdjZb cdhhVW^dad\^V)
= edYZbdh iZgVegZcY^Yd
ZggVYd
YZcdhhdhVcXZhigV^h)
=heZXjadVfj^ fjZ
egdkVkZabZciZ]ZgYVbdhdh ^chi^cidhVYZfjVYdheVgVVhdWgZk^kcX^V
cV
gZ\^~dYdh?gVcYZhDV\dhYVw[g^XV
Gg^ZciVa'YZdcYZ egZhjb^kZabZciZ
k^Zbdh' bVh fjZ iV^h^chi^cidhh~dXZgiVbZciZbVa(VYVeiVYdh
VdVbW^ZciZ
eh(Va[VWZid'
^ciZchVbZciZ^c[dgbVX^dcVa
ZZhiVi^hi^XVbZciZ
XdbeaZmdYd
egZhZciZ)
FV kZgYVYZ'
cdhhd VbW^ZciZ jb edjXd bV^hXdbeaZmdYd fjZ ch
$ZcdhhVh^chi^ij^Zh%
eVgZXZbdheZgXZWZg)
;dbd8 G bjcYd bdYZgcd'
hZcYdd =migZb^hi~d' Ydb^cVYdedg ZkZcidhgVgdh( bj^id gVgdh)=aZ
edYZVegZhZciVg
jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd YZed^hYZb^a]VgZhZb^a]VgZhYZX^hcZh
WgVcXdh
YZ[dgbV fjZ egZX^hVbdh
gZiZgcdhhd_ja\VbZcid edg bV^hiZbed
Yd fjZ hdbdh ^cXa^cVYdh
V[VoZg);dbd Y^hhZ
cd ;Veijad .' ^bedhhkZa
( W^dad\^XVbZciZ
^bedhhkZa( YZeVgVg(hZ
Xdb jb ]jbVcd Xdb Va\j(
bVh XZciZcVh
YZfj^abZigdh YZVaijgV'Zci~d cdhhVh^cij^ZhZmXajZbZh(
hZhZkZcidh)EVh VhkZcYVhYZjb a^kgddj VbV\c^ijYZ YZZkZcidhhdX^V^h