INCIDENT/INVESTIGATION Tenaya 02-07-020053 Gainesville Police Department REPORT saa 1 [or | oilizoo7 09:24 S| x FL0010100 Tas Kove Secure [Position of nce Premise Type ToneTieet | 0014012007 02:20. Sun | > |__1200W University Ave, Gainesville FL32601- _| Highway /Sireet/ Roads |_L. (0913012007 0; © [jy] comeimianes (aR 1] Wears Tools puANDGUN hit t| | ened Ey Bar ay > [aime iar Tom | Weapea oaks = 4| 4 Siooting!tirowing A Deadly Missile IntoA Tl | Dwelinghvehicle= 750-19 Eat Br Sart tie ier ay RR RET Banery (aggravated) Tay Ei 7 wo] Fitearm Feature/Auiomatc, Weapon Handgun potvicims 2 | Tipe INDIVIDUAL inj Gunshot, Domestic: VieiovBasnes Nae (Lan Fi, Mie) Visi Rocd Sed Relaiaskip] Reident Sua] NOT y “4 Smee eouy evo Yate C. ‘jee aS 1 12 B ¢ Tone t inesville, FL 32607-- 1) | iapiyerNane Assess, Tosnes Phone MODE Phone (ELECTRICIAN) VR [sake [No Te [coe [== vw (CODES:_V- Viti (Dense V2, Va) _O~ Owner (otartanvicin) R= Reporing Peon (Femara vicia) o | bee INDIVIDUAL Injury: Gunshot T | ose] Name Last Firs aie ¥ Team] Reco Sam] Mier, i |°* | Grass JUStIN DoziER == ea“ so] Oe nl Sh E | v2 3 z | ulac Resident R c : oainesvile,FL32608 a Empiyer Nene Assess anes Phone Hobie Paone 1 [ype INDIVIDUAL injury: v | Nae et Fo Yang Saahy | Rae] © | So | RIRES’SANBRA'C” Gime Rend Soy Bea | ROME SE & Lo alr Resident y Tone Phose > neville, FL 32607- Eapiyer Nene A Tasaen Phot Tobie Fae ToLen SoSuka Ro Reel D= Damped Z-Seied Bo Bumd C~ Comets Foued F=Found (SI = Recover for Other anaicton) Vi coid FH] vane | 01 | orv Propeny Description MaksModch Sel Number saad $00 | acoronacoxowas co's ote 000 re wat, sve FORD Crown ve TEALPTL WPT e Fle | 000 9 wa, sve FORD Crown Via ZEALeTLWH.NSL 8 [Ts To 000 [we mux, ore Gu tise GRP 1100 8 Tete amas 1 rw ee Foto Gen acerca 5 R 1 Y ‘OrseviD§_TALTON, CA, (0598) Teves DH SMITH, B. F (0096) Saperior BAKER, 5.D.(0082), Sa] Coe amne = Case Dispos | Paset Prmicd By GPDOD, San TOT Truss 936%Incident Report Additional Name List Gainesville Police Department (02-07-020053, Victim of [NameCodelt Name (Last, Fest, Middle) Crime? DOB Age RaceSex 1) WI 1 CASON, RANDALL LEE 1 Address Empl/Addr Ymca, Ne 23rd Ave 2) WI 2 ADAMS, ROBERT LORENZO JR Address Bmpvadde West Side Baptist Church, 1000 West Newberry Rd 3) WI 3 TERRY, MAURICE MARSALIS Address Empvadar 4) WI 4 DAVIES, ALAN SPENCER Address Empvader Self 5) WIS PERKINS, DANIEL GREGG NELSON Address Empuadér 6) 10 2 MCCRAY, CLASITT LEONARD Address EmpliAddr The Atrium, 2431 Nw 41st St 7) 10 3 WHITBHEAD, JEREMY JEREMIAN Address EmplAddr Alcon Construction, Gainesville 8) WI 6 HALL WILLIAM R Address Empl/Addr Papa Johns, Sw Archer Rd, Gainesville, Fl 32608 9) WI 7 SONDERGAARD, NIKKIA Address EmpvAddr Olive Garden sume ne vance Men’ sian et “ sacs ms 7 uma ia sate iin , — | | we . vance ROSIN Printed By: GPD6OSO, 0770872013 10:36Gainesville Police Department Incident Report Additional Name List inst sant Samet) EST von aw tose in) WE CASTENEDA ALFREDO aw al rrr , Ea senate . site 3) wr 9 Gan, Asuzr vonanrmoney nar 5 Bilan vents rs se 12) WI 10 — GAINEY, ANTOINETTE ANITA iia 1 rr eonaue UF rs site 13) WI 11 _LESESNE, AMERIA CHARRISCE Address Empvadar Chevron 14) WI 12 JENKINS, SHERA Address Empuaddr None 4S) WI 13. MALL, JENNIFERJ Address Empl/Addr Mite 16) 10 4 PETERSON. RODNEY PATRICK a..." es ape & Mobile 17) 10 5 Juvenile adres i par & Moe 18) 10 6 ‘POUNCEY, JAMES MICHAEL 8 BoM | mpte Of Mobi TOS Printed By: GPD6OSO, 0770872013 10:36Incident Report Additional Name List sane ate rn cone morons ett ane it ase vn secu Sunn aon aye ce pene rr an ve . wa RESINE Printed By: GPD6OSO, 0770872013 10:36INCIDENT/INVESTIGATION REPORT By: GPDE050, 0710/2013 10:36 Page 5 Gainesville Police Department “e cesst 02.07-020053 BRB_L=Lo S=stokn R=Recovered D=Damaged Z=Seizet B=Bured C=Couterse/ Forged F=Found vuce| std Quaniiy | type Measure Supa Type Upto 3 ypesofactiviy 75 | &_| Tomo CONSENTTO SEARCH FORM. > R u & s Assising Ofcom BAKER, S.D. (0082), BERTZYK, S.W. (0750), BOWMAN, T-K.(0741), BYRD, N.A. (0550), CAVETT, M.R. (0697), FERRARA, AM. (0375), GILES, B.T.(0178), GREENE, M.J. (0685), HALLETT, NS. (0585), HINSON, .W.(0748), HOLT, M.D. (0715), ‘Susp Hite Bias Mouvated: Nome (No bias) INCIDENTANVESTIGATION REPORT Narr (cont) OCA: 02-07-020053 Gainesvile Police Department Page S NARRATIVE (©n 9/30/07 I was working in uniform and driving a marked patrol vehicle. At approximately 0300hrs I responded to 1200 W University ‘Ave in reference to a shooting incident ‘The incident occurred at approximately 0220hrs. Witnesses described seeing a black male suspect wearing a green shirt step to the curb on the north side of 1200 W University Ave. The suspect then pulled out a handgun and fired 4-5 shots into a white Crown Victoria, which was facing west in the outside lane and stopped in traffic at W 13th St. The suspect then ran north on foot from the scene through the parking lot of 1250 W University Ave (Holiday Inn). Witnesses advised that after the shots were fired, the driver and back seat passenger of the Crown Victoria exited the vehicle yelling at the shooter. At least onc witness stated that the driver exited the vehicle with a handgun and "racked" the action as he exited. The driver and rear seat passenger both re-entered the vehicle and left the scene driving south on SW 13th St Victim Justin Glass| the driver ofthe Crown Victoria and sustained a non-life threatening gunshot in his right arm. Victim Corey Ssnith 3s the front seat passenger and sustained a life threatening gunshot to the back of his head. Witness Randal Cason| the back seat passenger on the right side and was not injured. Glass drove from the scene directly to ‘Shands UF. Officers arrived on scene and seta perimeter. Officer Byrd located four shell casings in the outside westbound lane at 1200 W University ‘Ave. Sgt Kayes and Officer Byrd cordoned off the crime scene which encompassed a portion of the sidewalk on the north side and the outside westbound lane of 1200 W University Ave. Officer Byrd started a crime scene log. Officer Hallett located an additional shell ceasing in the Crown Victoria at Shands UF. Cason advised me that when the suspect stepped up to the Crown Victoria and started to shoot, there was another black male with him. Cason stated that the second suspect's name was Reggie Nelson. Cason advised that after the shots were fired both suspects ran north through the west side parking lot of the Holiday Inn, Cason advised that the incident was part of an ongoing dispute between the suspects ‘and Cason's brother. Cason advised that there had been a confrontation with the suspects earlier that night ata club downtown. Cason, advised that he believed that she suspects had been driving Nelson's black GMC Tahoe (FL tag GTPSR). Multiple Officers and detectives responded to the scene and Shands UF to interview witnesses, See all supplements. K9 Officer Hope responded to the scene and attempted a track but no suspects were located. Officer Hallett completed a tow sheet for the Crown Victoria and had it placed into secure storage. She also collected the shell casing.Incident Report Suspect List Gainesville Police Department ‘OCA: 02-07-020053 ‘emus (Last, Fs, Nidal) "se Know As ome Adires 1) Nomame * Basins Ale DOB. Aer] Roce] Sex] Eh | Wx [Wa [lor Bye] Skin | Drivers Liomse/Sae_ Sears Mars, Taos oF oer iain urs “Reported Suspect Detail Spee AGe Race | Sex] BB] oe War sy ulm 603-604 230-240 Weapon, Type] Fears Wake Wows Tolar | Cali] pio Travel ¥ Pistol | Automatic Mode of Trav On Foot VeivinakeNdel Dal Soe Color Tear VN Neves Physical Char Wearing a green shirt. Described by witness as looking Hawaiian or Build, Large Hispanic. Build, Muscular 3 | nein Fn al) "Aso Know Ar NELSON, REGGIE LEE ‘MELBOURNE, FL 32935- Dasines Ada BOR Hae | Roce | Sex] Eh | Hie [Wat [Woe] Eye] Skin | Drivers Lisense Se aie | 601 1425732833410 FL Sears, Mars, Taos, oF oer iaiulhing oars ‘Reported Suspect Detail S=P=° ARE el War = Weapon, Type] Festa | Make Mod Color | Caller) Divot Travel Mode of Travel, Veh akeNeT Dal Soe Color Lee VIN Nos Physical hae Witness advised suspect name Reggie Nelson. 7 CSBIBR Printed By: GPDSOSO, 0770372013 1086 Page 6Incident Report Related Vehicle List Gainesville Police Department 02-07-020053 ‘VehVtMakeiModel ‘Syle (Calor ics Decal Vin 1| 1997 FORD, Crown Vie 4D WHE E9OSVE FL 2007 2FALP71W9VK205139 TBR Stas Date ‘Location Evidence 09/30/2007 1600 SW ARCHER RD, GAINESVILLE FL. Condition Value ‘Offense Code | Jurisdiction ‘State # ct FAIR s0.00| 0410 Locally ‘Name (Las Fist, Midaley ‘Also Knowa As| ome Adres Hines, Sandra C GAINESVILLE, FL 32607 Busines Address oa Tee [Rass] SH] ee] War Sess Na, Tatoo oor Siaguiingam Mm | 2 | F | 507| 200 ve Vanvenatonoa oe Cone Teta Det va 2) 1997 FORD, Crown Vie 4D WHI E99SVE FL 2007 2FALP71W9VX205139 TBR Si Daz Tosi Evidence 0973072007, 1600 SW ARCHER RD, GAINESVILLE FL Conon Vase ‘Oem Cae | Hain sue ic FAIR $2,000.00| 0410 Locally ‘Nave (5 Fi, ils ‘bnew Ae Tome Aas Hines, Sandra © GAINESVILLE, FL 3200 Bias Aros Tat] Wot | Sears, Marks, Tatoos, or oter distinguishing fears 507 oo Vanek we Com Celts ees Va 3 | 1997 FORD, Crown Victoa| 4D WHI E99SVE FL 2007 2FALP7IWOVX205139 TBR San Dae Tisiee Impounded 0973072007, 1300 W UNIVERSITY AVE, GAINESVILLE FL Conon vase ‘One Ce | orn soee Nee $0.00 0410 Locally ‘ase (Cs int NN ‘ie Known A Pavers Hines, Sandra C asa Alo 5. Tee [Rane] Sx] er War [Seam Mar, Tatoos oor dating eas Mim, | & | | 507) 200 — FOSETER Piel By. GrDeso, — o792013 1036 Page 7Incident Report Related Vehicle List Gainesville Police Department (02-07-020053 aE eee = 4 2007 GMC, Yukon SUV BLK GTP3R FL 2009 IGKFK63877J310230 os a rm oir ‘a0a07 200 WUNIVERSTY AVE, GANESVILE FL ea as camca [pain oo 7 $0.00. 0410 Locally Ta mah — Teton Resi Lie Fees ‘MELBOURNE, FL 32935- a Se Mm fo = WCSTER Printed By: GPD60SO, 07/03/2013 10:36 Page 8‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: BOWMAN, T. K.(0741) Date/Time: 09/3012007 04:03:22, Sunday Supervisor: ROWE, D. H. (0166) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 00:00:00, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09-30-07, at approximately 0230hrs, I responded to 1600 SW Archer Rd, Shands ER, reference to possible gunshot victims arriving at the hospital. Upon arrival, I observed several black males standing around a white Ford Crown Victoria with medical staff and other officers already on scene. I was to stand by with the vehicle as it was involved in a shooting incident downtown. A very emotional black male, identified as Randall Cason, was screaming, "This is my fault!” Cason explained to me that he and another black male, identified by Cason as Reggie Nelson, had gotten into an altercation downtown. Pet ‘Cason, the shooting was retaliation from that altercation. Cason later explained that a black Chevy Tahoe had been behind their white Ford Crown Victoria as they were stopped ata red light, located at 1300 West University Ave. Reggie Nelson and a "Hawaiian" male,or possibly a hispanic male, approached the passenger side of the white Ford Crown Victoria. The "Hawaiian!" male fired approximately 5 shots into the open front passenger window of the vehicle. Nelson and the other male then fled northbound towards the ‘MeDonalds, located at 501 NW 13th st. I collected Cason’s information, and stood by with the vehicle until forensics arrived. I completed a tow sheet for Ofe. Hallet #585. The tow sheet was turned into the midnight patrol tray. Cason stated the "Hawaiian" male was wearing a green shirt and was possibly a UF student and football player. Investigator Signatures Page 9‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: KERKAU, J. D. (0767) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 04:51:37, Sunday Supervisor: ROWE, D. H. (0166) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 09:50:53, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09/30/2007 at approx 0330 hours, while on uniform patrol I was dispatched to 1600 SW Archer Rd (Shands at UF) +0 assist with person shot incident, Upon arrival, I was directed by Ofe. Hallet (585) to standby the victims vehicle and make sure it was not disturbed by anyone. Ofe. Hallet (585) then gave me her almost completed (except signed) tow sheet to give to the tow truck driver when they arrived. I signed the tow sheet and issued a copy to the University tow truck driver. I then gave the sheet to fe. Bowman (741) who advised that she would turn the tow sheet in. That was the extent of my involvement with the vehicle. then was directed by Sgt. Baker (82) to relieve Ofe. Kennedy (549) who was sitting in Room 2543 (F Space) with victinvCorey Smith. then made contact with Dr. Velat, the neurosurgeon attending to Smith. Dr. Velat advised that at this time Smith was in stable condition. Dr. Velat advised that Smith had received one gun shot near the backileft side of his head. Dr. Velat advised that the bullet/projectile did not penetrate the skull and that it was still in the skull pending surgery. Shortly after, Smith's mother, Sandra Hines arrived at Shands at UF. I then made contact with Hines and informed her of Smith’s stable condition. I then stood by and observed Dr. Velat brief Hines of Smith's condition. Dr. Valet described the "Bone Flap" procedure that he would be performing on Smith. It would involve removing part of the skull to relieve the swelling of Smith's brain, Dr. Velat advised that the surgery was planned for a ‘time of 0800 hours. That was the extent of my involvement in standing by with Smith, Investigator Signatures Page 10‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: BAKER, S. D. (0082) Date/Time: 09/302007 06:26:55, Sunday Supervisor: FERRARA, A. M. (0375) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/01/2007 00:00:00, Monday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09-30-07 at approx 0225 while on routine patrol, I respond to a shots fired call in the 1200 block of W Univ Ave. ‘made contact with two individuals that had witnessed part of the incident at 1250 W Univ. (The Dill Deli). Nikki Sondergaard and William Hall advised that as they were coming into the parking lot, they observed heavy traffic backed up from the NW 13 St traffic light eastbound along Univ Ave. In the curbside lane (North side of the roadway) they saw at least 4 sedan type vehicles in a row, with the first one at the light being a white Ford Crown Victoria. After the sedans there may have be a SUV type vehicle but they were not sure. They said that a door on each side of the Ford ‘was open and it appeared that it was the front doors. At about this time they heard was sounded like fireworks or gunfire (Gor 5 shots). They then saw two B/M’s get out of the Ford and they were very angry. They were yelling and pounding ‘on the roof of the Ford with their fists. Numerous other people in the sedans that were behind the Ford all got out of their vehicles and stated screaming and yelling about a shooting. The two B/M’s then got back into the Ford and drove off westbound, and everyone else behind them did the same. They stated that they did not see anyone flee from the scene on foot or in a vehicle, They then went inside Dill's and GPD officers arrived shortly afterwards. A possible suspect, a large B/M with a lime green shirt (Jeremy J Whitchead), was being detained in handcuffs by Of N Byrd in front of Dill’. I asked Sondergaard and Hall if they believed that he may have been involved in the shooting. ‘They said they did not think so and stated that they thought he had been inside the restaurant before they had entered it. ‘There were also several other patrons of Dill's in the parking lot that had exited after the shooting, They also advised they had seen Whitchead inside eating prior to the shooting, and that he had exited the business after the shooting had ‘occurred. Based on this information I advised Ofc Byrd that Whitehead could be released, and asked that he get the ‘names of some of the patrons that cleared him of any involvement 1 then went to Shands BR and met with Of T Bowman in front of the ER entrance. She had secured the Ford Crown Victoria which had shown up at the ER with two shooting victims (Cory Smith and Justin Glass) and a witness, Randall Cason that had been in the vehicle during the incident. She updated me on the victim's info and briefed me on what Cason had stated to her. I then did a brief interview of Cason to get additional details about the incident. Cason was distraught and emotional, ‘and stated several times that "it should have been him that had been shot and not Cory". I asked Cason why he believed ‘hat it should have been him and he stated that it all started at The Venue, Downtown earlier tonight. ‘Cason first explained that the prior weekend his brother had gotten into an altercation with some UF football players at the Venue. Tonight even though his brother was not at the club, Cason said "he was deep" (slang for having several ‘buddies with him for backup) along with the football players being deep. They confronted each other as a group and ‘Cason said "so what are going to do about this" implying to the past altercation. At this point one of the football players attempted to snatch Cason's gold chain off his neck. The football player was not successful because the chain was thick ‘and then the Venue Bar Staff stepped in and kicked the football players out of the club. Investigator Signatures Page 11‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE ‘One of the involved players was described as a W/M or "Hawaiian" with a lot of tattoos, Besides the Hawaiian, the other football players involved that Cason knew were the "Pouncey twins” and "Reggie Nelson", a Jax Jaguar player. ‘Cason said that they all frequent ‘The Venue, and have also in the past, been involved in altercations with "high schoolers” at the club, He said he personally knows Nelson and at times has considered him a friend, Approx 45 minutes later, when the club closed, Cason and his friends (unnamed) met the same football players in the parking lot of 238 West. There, they were able to talk things out, shake hands, and everyone was "all smiles", At this point he thought it was all over with and they left the area in Cory Smith's Crown Victoria. Smith was in the front right, Justin Glass was driving and Cason was sitting in the back right. All of the vehicle's windows were open and they drove west on Univ Ave from Downtown. Cason advised that when they got to NW 13 St, they were the first car in line, but they were held up by the light. As they were waiting for the light to change, the Hawaiian football player and Reggie Nelson walked up to their car on the right side. Then without saying a work the Hawaiian pointed a small handgun in the front right window and fired five ‘quick shots. Cason saw Smith slump over with blood coming out of the back of his head, at which time the Hewaiian and Nelson took off running towards "McDonalds". Cason then got out of the car and yelled that they had shot his friend. I asked him if he had banged on the roof of the car. He said yes, he did it in a “fit of rage” and then they got back in the car to take Smith to the hospital. At first they ‘were going to go to AGH, but then changed their mind and drove to big Shands. asked Cason twice about Nelson's involvement, and he stated the he was sure it was Nelson who came up to the window and ran off with the shooter. He said that "Nelson did not have the gun, he was just there”. He also said he was sure that the Hawaiian looking guy was a UF football player, but he did not know his name. At this point in the interview, Inv P Nixon arrived at Shands ER. I briefed her on Cason’s statements and she ‘transported him to the station for further questioning. At approx 0400 hrs, Sandra Hines, the mother of Cory Smith arrived at Shands ER. She had received a call from a relative about the shooting. I briefed her on what had occurred to this point, and took her to the trauma wing on the second floor to be near her son. I made arrangements for her to meet with the Charge Nurse and Victim Advocate. 1 also had the mother of Justin Glass, who was being treated in the tenth floor trauma wing, meet with her in the waiting room. Ofe J Kerkau stood by with Mrs. Hines until the arrival of Vietim Advocate. This concluded my involvement in this case. Investigator Signatures Page 12‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department ca: 0207020053 Case Stats: OPEN Case Ming Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator Signature: Page 13,‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: MARTIN, C. J. (0755) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 07:01:01, Sunday Supervisor: ROWE, D.H. (0166) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 00:00:00, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09-30-07 at approximately 024SHRS, I responded to 1200 West University AVE, in reference to shots fired. Upon arrival I took a perimeter position in the 400BLK of NW 13th ST. After the perimeter was broken down I responded to the street in front of 1250 West University AVE. At the direction of Ofe. Byrd(550) I secured the eastern side of the crime scene. The area had already been secured with crime scene tape. This concludes my involvement in this case. Investigator Signatures Page 14‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: BYRD, NA. (0550) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 07:44:35, Sunday Supervisor: ROWE, D. H. (0166) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/01/2007 00:00:00, Monday Contact: Reference: Ei/g Unit Report ‘On 9-30-2007 I was working in uniform, on patrol, and in a marked unit. At about 0224 hrs I responded to 1300 W University AVE reference to a shooting. Dispatch advised that a black male suspect wearing a lime green shirt was last seen running north from the scene. Ofe. Poirot advised that he need assistance reference to a possible suspect at the front of The Dill Deli, 1250 W University ‘Ave. Larrived on scene and saw that Ofe. Poirot had a black male wearing a lime green shirt, Jeremy Whitehead, in a proned position just outside of the entrance to the Dill Deli. I went and assisted Ofe. Poirot by handeuffing Whitehead, then patted Whitehead down for weapons and then sat him up. Whitehead did not have any weapons. I then explained to Whitehead that there was a shooting and the description was a black male wearing a green shirt. Ofe. Holt brought a witness to the scene to do a show up verification on Whitehead. Ofe. Holt told me that Whitehead was not positively identified as the shooter. I then released Whitehead from custody. also spoke with Alfredo Castaneda, a patron at The Dill Deli, who confirmed that Whitehead was in the deli at the ‘time of the shooting and could not have been the shooter. Castaneda said that he did not know Whitehead. I then assisted Sgt. Kays in blocking off the crime scene. ‘The crime scene was the curb side lane of west bound traffic on W University AVE, just to the east of the intersection of NW 13th ST. I located four .380 shell casing at the scene. Three of the shell casings were in the curbside lane and ‘one was within a few inches of the curb, Just west of the shell casings, I located drops of blood on the ground. I placed ‘markers on the ground that next to all items of evidence that I located at scene. I maintained the crime scene integrity until Det. Woodmansee could respond to the scene. I also maintained the crime scene log for those that entered the barricaded crime scene area. ‘When Det. Woodmansee, I assisted him in his processing of the crime scene, I assisted in the crime scene ‘measurements. When all units had cleared the scene, I removed the barricade tape and opened all lanes of traffic on W University AVE, Investigator Signatures Page 15‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Ming Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: HINSON, J. W. (0748) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 08:13:30, Sunday Supervisor: BAKER, $.D. (0082) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/01/2007 02:05:31, Monday Contact: Reference: Supplement (On 9/30/07 at approx 0330 hours while working uniform patrol, I was dispatched to Shands at UF for additional units requested. Upon arrival I was advised by Ofe. Hallett #585 to stay with victim Justin Glass that was located in ER room #4. Glass then relocated to level 10, room 510 where I stayed until approx 0800 hours. I was advised by LT. Ferrara #375 to notify Shands security that I was leaving my post. Glass did not make any statements to me regarding the incident. had no further involvement in this case. Investigator Signatures Page 16‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN (Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: BERTZYK, S. W. (0750) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 17:56:55, Sunday Supervisor: GILES, B.T. (0178) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 00:00:00, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement Upon hearing the call come out that someone had been shot at 1300 W University Avenue I proceeded into the area and began looking for @ suspect. The information provided to us was very limited at the time. I drove around for several ‘minutes but found nothing of value to this case. then went and contacted Set. Giles near the scene who advised that an article search needed to be done to the north of the incident location. I searched the area from 1300 W University Avenue north to the car wash on the comer of NW 13th Street and NW Sth Avenue. The area of focus was provided by witnesses who saw where the shooter ran. The search ended with negative results. Investigator Signatures Page 17‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: KENNEDY, R.J.(0549) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 18:07:56, Sunday Supervisor: LITCHFIELD, B. L. (0441) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 21:25:51, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement (On 9/30/07 at approximately 0225 hours, while on uniform patrol (Downtown Detail), I responded to the area of 1300 \W. University Avenue in reference to a reported person shot call. While enroute, CCC advised the reported involved vietim vehicle, a white Grand Marquis, had left the area, traveling south on SW 13th Street. Due to the nature of the call and the direction of travel of the victim vehicle, I altered my response and went to the Shands @ UF ER. Upon arrival at the ER entrance, I saw a silver Grand Marquis and a white Grand Marquis stopped near the ER entrance. I notified CCC of the vehicles and then went into the ER to gather information. leaned from ER staff there were 2 victims. One victim (Trauma Room #2) had a gunshot wound to the head and the other victim had a gunshot wound to the right upper arm (Trauma Room #4). As VICT #1 was unconscious and being ‘treated by the ER staff, I went to Room #4 and spoke to the second victim, VICT #2 verbally identified himself as Justin Glass IEEE Iass said he and his friends were driving on W. University after leaving Club Venue, Glass said asthe stopped in traffic near the Holiday Inn (1250 WUA), an ‘unknown suspect had approached the vehicle's passenger side. Glass said the suspect fired 5 shots into the vehicle. Glass could not provide any suspect information, When asked to ID VICT #1, Glass could only provide a possible first name of "Courtney". Glass said "Courtney" was the rear right seat passenger in the vehicle. After confirming Glass* injury was non-life threatening, ER staff provided me with the FL DL of VICT #1 who | identified as Corey T. Smith bm 11/18/78. Tealled CCC and provided them with updated information about the status of both victims. I accompanied Smith to CATSCAN where I learned Smith still had the bullet lodged inside of his head. Smith appeared to have been shot in the lower right rear portion of his head. I accompanied Smith to SICU Room #2543 upon his transfer there from the ER at 0315 hours. I was relieved by Ofe. Kerkau at approximately 0445 hours. Investigator Signatures Page 18‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: POIROT, J. M. (0647) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 19:02:52, Sunday Supervisor: LITCHFIELD, B. L. (0441) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 00:00:00, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09-30-07, while on uniform patrol, I responded to 1250 West University Ave. to the report of a person shot. Upon arrival [ was informed that the victims were at the hospital and that the suspect fled on foot North Bound through the "dill deli" parking lot. ‘The description of the suspect being broadcasted on my police radio was a larger black male wearing a green shirt. 1 ‘grabbed my issued shotgun from my trunk and with Ofe. D. Reveille #562 proceeded North to the "dill deli" parking lot. In the parking lot of the deli we observed a large, black male with a lime green shirt. With our weapons in the low ready position we gave verbal commands to the individual to lay on the ground. I announced on the radio we had a subject ‘matching the description on the ground. Ofe. N. Byrd #550 responded and detained the individual in handeuf's. It was later determined the individual was not involved in the incident. I then made contact with a white female who stated she saw a black male with “com rows” in his hair run "like he ‘was scared" North through the parking lot just prior to our arrival. I then assisted Of. J. Hope #429 and his K-9 ‘conduct a search of the area were the suspect was last seen running. We were unable to locate the suspect. I informed Ofe. Green #685 of the witness who made contact with her to get her information, ‘After the scene was secure I was sent in an unmarked car to the "springs complex" on UF campus were UF Football players live. I was to look for a black Chevy Tahoe with FL tag GTP3R. I remained on campus until approx. 0600hours when the suspect vehicle was located in Stoneridge apartments, 3800 SW 34th St. I had no further involvement in this, case, Investigator Signatures Page 19‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: HOLT, M.D. (0715) Date/Time: 09/30/2007 21:48:32, Sunday Supervisor: KAYS, BM. (0443) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 00:00:00, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09/30/07 at approximately 0225 hours while on uniform patrol in a marked vehicle, I was dispatched to the 1300 block of W University Ave in reference to a shooting. As I was responding to the scene I was flagged down by a white male, Alan Davies, at the 100 block of SW 12th St and he told me he had just witnessed the shooting. Davies said he was standing on the sidewalk on the south side of University Ave, just east of 13th St., when he saw a black male walk out of the bushes just north of the sidewalk on the north side of the road, directly across from him. The black male appeared to already have a black semi-auto small caliber handgun in his right hand and approached a white Ford Crown Victoria that was stopped in traffic at a red light. ‘The black male then fired 4-5 shots right at the right front passenger. After firing the shots the suspect turned around and swiftly walked back through the bushes he had just come out of, and then proceeded to sprint north through the Gainesville Downtown Inn parking lot towards McDonalds, 201 NW 13th St. Seconds later Davies said the right side ‘backseat passenger exited the vehicle and began yelling at the suspect saying, "You killed my friend”. The driver of the ‘Crown Victoria then began to exit the vehicle as well. Davies then fled the area and called 911. Davies described the suspect as approximately 5°10", 150-160 pounds and said he was wearing a green polo style shirt. No other description ‘could be provided at the time. Davies remembered seeing a black SUV stopped in traffic in front of the Crown Victoria when the incident occurred but was unable to provide a description of any of the occupants. The Crown Victoria was «also approximately four car lengths back from the traffic light while it was stopped at the red light. | then responded to the Gainesville Downtown Inn with Davies to possibly identify a suspect that had been detained by other officers in the parking lot. Davies said the man detained, who was wearing a similar green shirt, was not the shooter. | was later approached by Daniel Perkins who said he was standing on the NW comer of the intersection of 13th Stand W University Ave when the shooting occurred. Perkins said he didn’t actually sce the shooting but remembered hearing the shots, Perkins said as he was crossing the street towards the Gainesville Downtown Inn he saw a black male in dark colored clothing sprinting north through the parking lot towards McDonalds. No other description could be provided due to Perkins’ distance from the suspect. It wasn't until law enforcement was on scene that Perkins realized a shooting had occurred, so he decided to provide his information then. Perkins also remembered seeing a black SUV tum north ‘onto NW 13th St seconds after he heard the shots and saw the black male running away. A large roll of firecrackers was also thrown out of the window of an unknown vehicle shortly after the shooting, landing on the sidewalk at the comer of 13th St and University Ave. ‘My patrol car was used on the eastern end of the crime scene to help secure it and I remained on scene until it was released by Forensics Investigator Woodmansee (ID 8) at approximately 0540 hours. Investigator Signatures Page 20‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: HALLETT, N.S. (0585) Date/Time: 09/3012007 21:53:24, Sunday Supervisor: LITCHFIELD, B. L. (0441) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 09/30/2007 22:42:33, Sunday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09/30/07 at approximately 0200 hours I was on uniform patrol in a marked patrol vehicle when I responded to 1300 'W University Ave in reference to a shooting. ‘As I was enroute, I received information via the radio that the victim's may already be on their way to Shands. 1 responded to Shands, where upon my arrival, found several B/M individuals standing in the ER ambulance entrance of the hospital. All of the individuals were visibly upset. I contacted a B/M, identified as Maurice Terry, wearing a black and red shorts ensemble, who stated that he was in a car near where the incident took place. Terry stated that he saw a 'B/M, approximately 5°11 wearing all black walk over to the victim's car and fire 5 shots into the passenger side of the vehicle. Terry stated that the suspect then fled through the Holiday Inn parking lot. Terry stated that he did not know the suspect. 1 then made contact with Robert Adams, wearing a purple Polo shirt and jean shorts outfit and his hair was coiffed in ‘medium twists, who stated that he was also in a vehicle near the location of incident. Adams stated that he saw an ‘unknown B/M, wearing all black, walk up to the passenger side of his friend's car and fire 5 rounds into the car. Adams said that the suspect then fled eastbound through the Holiday Inn parking lot and then north through the Mc Donalds parking lot After talking to the two witnesses, I began to photograph the victim's vehicle and victim Glass. The flash card was placed in the locked drop box. I also made contact with the nursing staff and collected the victim's clothing and bed linens, labeled them with the corresponding victim’s personal information and secured them in the trunk of my patrol car. Lalso collected a spent round of ammunition that was found just outside the passenger side door of the victim's vehicle while parked in the ER ambulance parking lanes. I then secured it in the trunk of my patrol car. [also contacted Teletype and requested a flat bed contract tow to the location. When FCL Investigator Woodmansee arrived ‘on scene I turned over all physical evidence that I had collected on scene. When Det Madsen and Lt. Hoffman arrived on scene I spoke with them and provided Det Madsen with the witness information that I had collected, ‘This was the extent of my involvement in this case. Investigator Signatures Page 21‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: GREENE, M. J.(0685) Date/Time: 09/302007 23:41:23, Sunday Supervisor: BAKER, S. D. (0082) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/01/2007 00:00:00, Monday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09/30/07 I responded, reference ALERT, to a call of shots fired at 1300 West University Ave. I parked my car on the West side of the Holiday Inn and proceeded to the entrance of the Dill Deli where Officer Reveille #562 reported he had a B/M matching the description of the shooter detained. When I arrived at the entrance I observed a B/M matching the shooters description sitting on the ground in handcuff. I remained with Of Reveille until it was verified the B/M ‘was not involved with the shooting. Shortly after I was involved in a search of the area for the weapon that was used in the shooting. Ofe Reveille, myself, ‘and another officer searched from West University Ave north through the Holiday Inn parking lot, through the ‘McDonald's property ending at the car was on NW 3rd Ave. There was no evidence and no weapon found during the search, Investigator Signatures Page 22‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: FERRARA, A. M. (0375) Date /‘Time: 09/30/2007 23:42:06, Sunday Supervisor: BAKER, S. D. (0082) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/01/2007 00:00:00, Monday Contact: Reference: Supplement At roughly 0235 hours, I responded to 1300 W. University Ave. from a traffic stop at 3300 W. University Ave. (07-2046). had heard the dispatch of the shooting and subsequent direction of the victim vehicle (southbound on SW 13th ST) and determined that most likely the victims were headed to Shands/UF. I had officers respond to Shands, not only to secure a potential crime scene there, but also to make sure that if any suspects were following the victim vehicle, law enforcement would be able to interdict in any further life-threatening criminal activity. (I learned later that Officer Kennedy and Officer Bowman were at Shands/UF as the victim vehicle pulled up and witnessed a spent shell casing fall from vietim Corey Tevon Smith as Smith was removed ftom the car.) 1 also made sure that CCC contacted the District 2 Command Staff to be aware of the event, as well as the on-call CID supervisor, and FCL. ‘Upon my arrival on scene, I saw that Sgt. Giles and Officer Byrd had discovered the crime scene, which was the westbound curb lane of W. University Ave., roughly 50 feet east of W 13th ST. I noticed that there were shell casings ‘on the ground (4), as well as what appeared to be faint blood droplets. The entire curb lane was sealed with crime scene ‘ape, as was the north sidewalk and south part of the Holiday Inn parking lot. 1 was informed by patrons leaving Dill Deli (unknown involvement) that there was a black male in the parking lot that "wanted to talk to someone high-up." For the next 30 minutes I dealt with what was originally considered an excessive use of force by the officers arriving on scene, but that force was finally determined to be not only well within Department policy, but in complete contradiction to yells of resturant patrons. Lt, Wayne Ash was on scene and appeared to by trying to console two black males in their mid to late 20"s anda black female in her early 50°. Clasitt Leonard McCray stated that he was seated in the rear of the Dill Deli when resturant patrons yelled that there was a black male who got "slammed and hit in the head with a rifle.” McCray attempted to go out of the resturant and determine if his cousin Jeremy J. Whitchead was involved. As McCray came near the main entrance of the Dill Deli, he saw Officer Poirot standing at the entrance with a shotgun, not allowing anyone exit during the arrest of the possible shooting suspect. Whitehead was indeed the person detained by Officer Reveille at riflepoint, and was handcuffed by Officer Nick Byrd. I interviewed Whitehead (who had long-since been released from handcuffs after cleared of any involvement) to determine if excessive force was used during his detainment. Whitehead explained to me that the officers ordered him to the ground and put handcuffs on him. I specifically asked, "Did they force you to the ground? Did they hit you with the rifle? Did they ‘slam’ you at any point?” Whitchead answered, "No." to all of the inquiries. Whitehead was wearing a lime green shirt, just as was dispatched and was simply too close to the crime scene not to be regarded as a possible suspect shooter. Whitchead was checked for any sign of injury and had none. Whitehead asked Investigator Signatures Page 23‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE ‘at least four times whether or not he was in any trouble, and I explained to him he was only going to be listed as in the area and wearing clothing "like" that of the shooter. (I later leamed that Whitehead is on Florida Inmate Release status for sale/delivery of cocaine and most likely wanted to be assured of no violations in this regard.) [ also explained this situation to Whitehead’s mother, who showed up on scene after receiving a call that Whitehead had been "slammed" by police. 1 took no original testimony on scene besides that of Whitehead and McCray. left this crime scene and went to Shands/UF to assist with any needed opportunites there. Upon my arrival, I learned that the driver of the vietim vehicle, Justin Glass, had not had the bullet removed from his upper arm, and the front seat passenger, Corey Smith was in critical guarded condition. ‘The victim vehicle was not on scene, it was brought to secured storage by University Towing, left Shands and reported to GPD headquarters. En route, I was told by Sgt. W. Stout that PIO Lt. Kameg had already been advised of the incident. At GPD, I was asked by Sgt. Baker to have Victim Advocates dispatched to Shands/UF, room 2543 in the trauma wing "I.UL.C.E." unit ‘Besides assisting detectives with the gathering of information for possible suspect shooter identification, I had no further involvement with this incident. Investigator Signatures Page 24‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: FRANKLIN, J.F. (0032) Date/Time: 10/01/2007 06:48:39, Monday Supervisor: FERRARA, A.M. (0375) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/01/2007 00:00:00, Monday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09-30-2007 at approximately 0400 hours, while working in uniform; I responded to the area of Stoneridge Apartments on SW 34th St after Ofc. Hope located the possible suspect vehicle from a shooting. | arrived in the area and assisted the Detective team of Cpl. Schentrup and Ofe. Madsen in surveiling the parked vehicle until daylight. After the surveiling was concluded; I responded to the vehicle and looked into the vehicle for any obvious plain view evidence. I could see an unexpended handgun round in the ashtray through the passenger's front window. Thad no other involvement with the investigation. Investigator Signatures Page 25‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: REVEILLE, D. J. (0562) Date/Time: 10/02/2007 00:18:31, Tuesday Supervisor: ACEVEDO, L. (0263) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/02/2007 00:00:00, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09/30/07 at approximately 0220 hrs while working uniformed party patrol, I responded to 1255 W Univ Ave in reference to shots fired. Upon arrival | immediately deployed my rifle (ALERT) and made contact with Sgt Nabet who was already on scene. Sgt. Nabet informed me that we were looking for a B/M wearing a lime green shirt as the possible shooter. The suspect ‘was last seen fleeing northbound from 1255 W Univ Ave through the Holiday Inn parking lot. Along with Officer Poirot, we began searching the immediate area where the suspect was last seen. After conducting a search of the parking lot at 1250 W Univ Ave, we approached the Dill Deli (same address) to determine whether or not the suspect had centered the business. Just a few feet from the front door Officer Poirot alerted me to a B/M subject matching the suspects description and wearing a lime green shirt approaching me from behind. I immediately turned toward the B/M subject, pointed my rifle at him ( officer safety reasons/armed subject), and gave loud verbal commands for him to lay face down on the ground. The B/M subject only complied after several loud verbal commands had been given. Officer Byrd who was now on scene, rear handcuffed the B/M subject (double locked/checked for proper fit) and assisted him into a sitting position. The subject was released unharmed after a show up provided negative results. Investigator Signatures Page 26‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: DOUGLAS, MM. (0315) Date/Time: 10/03/2007 13:55:19, Wednesday Supervisor: FORSBERG, P.D. (0078) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/04/2007 14:10:01, Thursday Contact: Reference: Follow Up [10/03/2007 13:55, GPD0315, 361, GPD] ‘On 09-30-07 I responded as requested to assist in the investigation. (09-30-07 1120 hours Justin Glass Shands at UF Glass was awake and alert. He had no idea why anyone would shoot at him or any passenger in his vehicle. At approximately 2330 he and Corey Smith were joined at the Venue by Randall Cason. The three left in Glass’ vehicle ‘and were enroute to Smith's cousin Brittany's apartment in Huntington Lakes. Glass was driving with Smith in the front passenger seat and Cason was in the back seat. Traffic was heavy on West University Ave. and they were stopped at he light at 1300 WUA. Glass’ attention was drawn to a carload of females directly to his left when he suddenly heard gunshots over his right shoulder. He turned and said he saw a person in a white T-shirt standing outside ‘the passenger side of his car. Later in the interview he thought perhaps he saw a white flash of some type. It is not clear what Glass saw. He looked to his right to see Smith bleeding profusely and apparently unconcious. Cason was in the backseat yelling, "Oh my God”. Glass attempted to eixt the car but felt great pain in his right arm. He shifted the vehicle to "PARK" and then exited the vehicle. Females in the vehicle directly to his rear were screaming. He re-entered the vehicle and drove to Shands at UF. ‘Based upon information already developed in the investigation I pressed him about his, Cason’s and Smith's behavior in the Venue earlier in the evening, He maintained that there were no disputes in the club with anyone and the three were ‘together the entire time. He claimed no knowledge of any necklace incident and stated that he was unaware of any UF football players in the bar. He did tell me that Reggie Nelson was in the club somewhere but he had no contact with him, Eva Graham, o— Graham is Glass’ mother and was at the hospital. She believed that the shooting had something to do with a gold necklace but knew nothing more specific. I explained to her that I believed that Justin was being untruthful and asked that she encourage his cooperation in this investigation. I was assigned to collect any area surveillance videos. One particular surveillance system at the McDonald's located at 201 NW 13 St. is of particular interest. ‘Ann Smith, Investigator Signatures Page 27CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 0703/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE ‘J-Curt Ine. 331-9803 J-Curt is the parent company of the McDonald's. I had requested the video surveillance from the drive-thru which clearly shows a view all the way to NW 12 Terr. Several requests have yet to yield a response so I requested a subpoena from the SAO. Al businesses in the area were contacted. There are no surveillance systems that cover the vicinity of the shooting. A ‘ideo from the Gate station at 500 NW 13 St. was obtained but the direction of the investigation has shifted. The video from the Downtown Parking Garage is available but as of this writing there is no information which indicates that the victim or suspect was present on 09-30-07. Supplement Investigator Signatures Page 28‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: DOUGLAS, MM. (0315) Date/Time: 10/04/2007 13:39:11, Thursday Supervisor: FORSBERG, P.D. (0078) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/04/2007 14:11:10, Thursday Contact: Reference: Follow Up [10/04/2007 13:39, GPDO315, 361, GPD] Sara aa ‘Ms, Salley retumed Det. Nixon’s call today and I phoned her. Salley stated that she and her boyfriend were waiting in traffic in the right-hand lane two cars behind the victim's. She stated that she first observed the suspect emerge from the bushes on the south side of the Hoilday Inn, walk directly to the victim's vehicle producing a handgun from the rear waistband of this pants. The suspect stood directly beside the victim's vehicle at a distance which Salley described as being about six inches from the interior and fired five times into the vehicle. Salley described this as clearly intentional. ‘The suspect then turned and ran through the bushes northbound through the Holiday Inn parking lot. Salley stated that ‘about ten seconds after the shooting, the driver of the victim's vehicle emerged and began yelling and beating on his cat, Salley said that the vehicles in the area of the shooting scattered, including her. Suspect description: BM 20's 510 med-thin build tight com-row hairstyle wearing a kelly green oversized polo style shirt eyeglasses Salley stated that she did not get a sufficient look at the supect to recognize him or to construct a composite. Supplement Investigator Signatures Page 29‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department 0207020053 oc! Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Offense: HOMICIDE Occurred: 09/30/2007 Investigator: KILMER, M. J. (5636) Date/Time: 10/08/2007 09:51:19, Monday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/15/2007 09:47:42, Monday Contact: Reference: Latent Form GAINESVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT FORENSIC CRIME UNIT LATENT COMPARISON REPORT ‘Complaint as Verified Date of Report ATTEMPTED MURDER 10-03-07 Complainant Address City of Gainesville 1, ANSWER TO: DETECTIVES 2. LATENTS DEVELOPED BY: INVESTIGATORS B.STARR #113 AND M.WOODMANSEE #008 3. LATENTS RECEIVED BY: EXAMINER MELISSA J. KILMER #5636 4, NUMBER OF LATENTS RECEIVED: ‘THIRTY-SEVEN (37) and TWENTY-SEVEN (27) respectively 5. SUBJECT IDENTIFIED: DATE: NELSON, REGGIE, 10-01-07 BREVARD COUNTY S.0. SID# 05996687 6. COMMENTS: AFIS# 071GV5020053 7. IDENTIFICATIONS: +#9 (left ring) from #113 L-1 "Left Front Door I/S Door Handle Back.” Case Report No. 07-2053 Investigator Signatures Page 30‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: KILMER, M. J. (5636) Date/Time: 10/08/2007 09:56:00, Monday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/15/2007 09:47:57, Monday Contact: Reference: Latent Form GAINESVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT FORENSIC CRIME UNIT LATENT COMPARISON REPORT ‘Complaint as Verified Date of Report Case Report No. ATTEMPTED MURDER 10-03-07 07-2053 Complainant Address City of Gainesville 1, ANSWER TO: DETECTIVES 2. LATENTS DEVELOPED BY: INVESTIGATORS B.STARR #113 AND M.WOODMANSEE #008 3. LATENTS RECEIVED BY: EXAMINER MELISSA J. KILMER #5636 4, NUMBER OF LATENTS RECEIVED: ‘THIRTY-SEVEN (37) and TWENTY-SEVEN (27) respectively 5. SUBJECT IDENTIFIED: DATE: PETERSON, RODNEY 10-01-07 ALACHUA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE SID# 06271133 6. COMMENTS: AFIS#'s 071GV3020053 and 071GV4020053 7. IDENTIFICATIONS: #87 and 8 from #113 L-3 "Right Rear Door I/S Door Handle Back." Investigator Signatures Page 31CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Ming Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: SCHENTRUP, M.R. (0423) Date/Time: 10/09/2007 15:37:18, Tuesday Supervisor: FORSBERG, P.D. (0078) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/09/2007 16:07:33, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Supplement 2007-20083 Supplement date: 10-04-07 On Sunday, 09-30-07, at 0340hrs, I was called out from my house and asked to respond to assist with an attempted homicide investigation. Det Patty Nixon was assigned as lead investigator. | arrived at the GPD at about 0420hrs. At 0600hrs, Det Madsen and I responded to Stoneridge Apts, where patrol officers had located Reggie Nelson's, black GMC Denali (GTP3R). Nelson had originally been implicated in the shooting by witness, Randall Cason. We watched the vehicle for a short time, while waiting for Nelson to retum. At 073Shrs, Of Jamie Hope took over watching the vehicle. 0800hrs Shera Jenkins, B/F, ‘Det Madsen and I spoke with Jenkins at Gardenia Gardens, Aptl From CAD, I located a potential witness, Ashley Gainey. Ashley Gainey was not at the apartment, but her cousin, Shera Jenkins was there. Jenkins reported that Ashley Gainey, Ameria Isaac, Antoinette Gainey and she were at the same nightclub, Venue, as the victims. They were also eyewitnesses to the shooting later. Jenkins advised they were ina car about four cars behind the victim when the shooting took place. Jenkins was sitting behind the driver. Jenkins stated that she saw Ameria and Ashley speaking to the shooter as he walked down the sidewalk. She later heard the gunshots. Jenkins described the lone shooter as a B/M, about 25yoa, $-11/ medium build, brown skin, collar length braids and wearing a green shir. She believed she saw the suspect earlier at the Venue. Jenkins did not recognize the suspect as someone she knew. At 1000hrs, I was notified that Reggie Nelson had retumed to his vehicle at Stoneridge Apts. At 1020hrs, I arrived at Stoneridge and spoke with Nelson. | asked for consent to search his truck, which he granted. He signed a consent to search form. I then asked him to return to GPD with me to speak about what occurred last night. He again agreed. 1050hrs Jax, FL, 32256 I spoke with Nelson in the CID area lobby because the interview rooms were full. I audio recorded our conversation. Investigator Signatures Page 32CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department oca: 0207020053 (Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE ‘Nelson reported the following: He arrived at the Venue last night about midnight. He was there with Demettious Webb and Richard Lakes (cousin). Once there, they met up with Rodney Peterson. They saw the Pouncey twins (James and ‘Lashawn) a little later. He cannot distinguish them apart. They were a who Nelson identified by proto, —_ oli Nelson ofan ncdent wher on ofthe vin bad Hirer sted by Randal Cason Later, a lub closed, one of the twins related the same story and pointed to Cason. Nelson went over to speak with Cason, They discussed the stolen necklace and Cason told him the chain had already been given away. Nelson advised they didn’t want any trouble and he left on good terms. Nelson was famitiar with Cason and identified him from a photo. Nelson was parked in the 238 WUA parking lot. Webb, Lakes, Peterson and he left. They drove west down NW 3rd Ave toward NW 13th St. Nelson advised they were not on WUA when the shooting took place. They ended up at Markie Anderson's room on the UF campus. Nelson gave me Rodney Peterson's phone number to corroborate his story. ‘At 112Shrs, Det Patty Nixon joined me. I read Nelson miranda from a pre-written card. He acknowledged each right and agreed to speak. At the time, we believed Nelson may have been covering up some aspect of the shooting. Nelson continued to deny any direct knowledge of the actual shooting. At about 1200hrs, Det Douglas drove Nelson back to Stoneridge and his vehicle was released to him. 120Shrs = Peterson, B/M, | spoke with Peterson by phone. He reported the following: Last night, he met Nelson and Richard Lakes at the Venue. ‘He did not see any conflicts inside the club. Once the club closed, he drove with Nelson and the others in Nelson's vehicle. Peterson described approximately the same route to NW 13th St that Nelson described. He firmly stated that he never lost sight of Reggie Nelson after they left the club. He also said they did not witness the shooting, 1230hrs Det Patty Nixon and I attempted to interview IEE, however, he invoked his right to counsel. 1330hrs - v. - 2 spoke with Gainey by phone also. She reported the following: She was in the car with her sister Antoinette Gainey (river), her cousin Ameria Isaac (front passenger), and Shera Jenkins (rear left passenger). They were on WUA waiting for the light at NW 13th Stin the curb lane. The victim's car was two in front in the same lane. The suspect ‘was walking west on the sidewalk passed their vehicle. Ameria began to talk to him and asked him if he needed a ride. ‘The suspect tured his face away and kept walking. He passed their car and began a slow trot to the victim's car, where he stopped at the passenger window. The suspect fired numerous shots into the car and then fled north through the ‘Holiday Inn parking lot. She described the suspect as a B/M, about 6-1, slim, com rows to collar, brown skin, wearing ‘a green polo and blue jean shorts, She thought she'd be able to recognize him again. Investigator Signatures Page 33CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department oca: 0207020053 (Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE 134Shrs Jennifer J. Mall | Perry, FL 32347 eared of Mall as a potential witness ftom patrol officers. I spoke with her by phone. She advised she was standing ‘on the north side of the Kangaroo Gas Station which is at the corner of WUA and NW 13th St. She saw the suspect approach the car and shoot into the vehicle, He then fled north through the Holiday Inn parking lot. Mall described him as a BM, collar dreds, dark skin, stim and wearing a green polo shirt 1630hrs Det Patty Nixon and I contacted Antoinette Gainey at her residence. She was driving the car that Ashley, Ameria, and Shera were in, She saw the suspect approach the victim’s car and then heard 3-5 gunshots. Gainey gave a similar description as the others, but did not get a good look at the suspect. Det Nixon and I contacted Ameria Isaac at 405 SE 13th Ter, her grandmother's residence. Isaac advised she did briefly dance with the suspect at the Venue earlier in the night, but that she did not know him. She similarly described the suspect, but added he had some chin hair. Isaac stated just before the shooting, the suspect got out of a dark colored car ‘8 couple car lengths in front of them and began to walk westbound. The car then turned north down an alley just east of the Holiday Inn, Isaac’s car passed the walking suspect and then came to a stop. The suspect then passed their car again and she began to speak with him, but he ignored her. The suspect continued and walked up to the vietim’s car ‘and began to shoot into the passenger window. 1800hrs Randall Cason assisted Det Nixon with her re-interview of Randall Cason, Cason rescinded his identification of [i and Reggie Nelson. See Det Nixon's report for further. Supp Page 34‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Ming Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: DALE, C. W. (0442) Date/Time: 10/10/2007 16:36:17, Wednesday Supervisor: FORSBERG, P.D. (0078) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/11/2007 09:16:40, Thursday Contact: Reference: Follow Up (02-07-020053 Homicide / Age, Battery / Shooting in to an Occupied Vehicle Vietims: Corey Smith, Justin Glass 2315 hours Wednesday, October 3rd, 2007 At the request of Sgt. Forsberg #078 I responded to the Holiday Inn at 1250 W. University Ave. to canvass the area in reference to the shooting. I contacted the front desk employee "Nikki" who advised me she was not working this past Saturday night (9/27) but could look at the roster and see who was. I was advised that night the front desk was staffed by "Brian" and security guards "David" and "Nate" would have also been on duty. I was told "David" would be in to work at midnight. | asked if the employee's last names were available but was told everyone is primarily on a first ‘name basis. [inquired about video surveillance for the hotel. "Nikki" stated the hotel currently has no surveillance system anywhere in or around the building, 2325 hours Wednesday, October 3rd, 2007 ‘Demetrice Moorehead aa I went to the Dill Deli restaurant which is attached to the Holiday Inn. I made contact with Demetrice Moorehead who was the only employee currently working who was also present on the night of the shooting. Moorehead said that when the shooting occurred she did not hear anything at all due to the ambient noise in the restaurant. Moorehead said they were unaware anything occurred until someone told her that her boyfriend Jeremy Whitehead was being swarmed by police and made a statement about a shooting. Apparently Whitehead had been wearing a green shirt and was detained as possibly being involved. Moorehead said at that time they went outside and became aware of the incident. ‘Moorehead said she and the other employees had talked about the shooting and no one stated they had been aware of ‘anything until after the fact. ‘Moorehead was asked about suspicious persons matching the suspect description, She advised that there were very few black males in the restaurant prior to the shooting. Moorehead did not recall anyone wearing a green shirt, other than her boyftiend. Moorehead said the restaurant does have video surveillance, however all the cameras point inward to the restaurant itself Tiffany Edney BIF| also talked to Edney, another employee of the Dill Deli, who showed up while I was speaking to Moorehead. Edney ‘confirmed she was working on 9/27 and that she did not see or hear anything until someone came in yelling. Edney said Investigator Signatures Page 35CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department oca: 0207020053 (Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE it was very noisy inside the restaurant and to her knowledge no one was aware of the incident until after the fact. 2345 hours Wednesday, October 3rd, 2007 ‘McDonalds 201 NW 13th St, | spoke to Pittman who is the night crew manager at McDonalds. Pittman said she was working on 9/27 when the shooting occurred, Pittman stated McDonalds locks its doors at 2300 hours and doesn't allow anyone in, serving drive thru traffic only. Pittman said it was extremely busy that night so all of her staff was occupied with cooking and serving. Pittman said to her knowledge no one was aware the shooting had occurred until they saw police swarming the area and asked them what was going on, Pittman had no other information to provide. There were no other employee's working that were present on 9/27. 2355 hours Wednesday, October 3rd, 2007 I made contact with Lavender who is the night security guard at Holiday Inn, Lavender said he was working on the night of the incident and had just relieved the other security guard whom he knows as Nate Hope B/M. Lavender said ‘Hope's ride was parked in the east vehicle breezeway of Holiday Inn picking Hope up, and he had stopped to talk with them. Lavender stated Hope's ride had just pulled off when Lavender heard the gunshots. Lavender stated he made his ‘way back to the front of the hotel but by the time he arrived he saw nothing. Lavender stated he did not see anyone come past him nor was he aware of hearing any vehicle speed from the area. 0010 hours Thursday, October 4, 2007 Krispy Kreme 310 NW 13th St. | I went to Krispy Krome and made contact with Sutton who is an employee there. Sutton said he was working the night ‘of 9/27 and was staffing the front counter with manager Alex Lewis. Sutton said the store was extremely busy that time of night and he could not tell if anyone matching the suspect description might have come in or not. Sutton said he was completely unaware of the shooting until well after it occurred, and did not see or hear anything suspicious in relation to it, Sutton said the store does have video surveillance but he was not sure if it was recorded or not. Sutton stated he was ‘aware the owner could view the video real time from his home if they chose. Alex Lewis was not available to speak to. Investigator Signatures Page 36‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE I drove through the lot of the Swamp Car Wash at 303 NW 13th St. to see if I could find any evidence it has video surveillance, I did not observe anything that appeared to be a camera at the location, ‘There were no other businesses in the general area of the north side of 1200 W. University Ave. or up to the 300 block of NW 13th St. which were open to contact other potential witnesses. Det. Mayo #006 conducted the canvass of the south side of 1200 W. University Ave. Investigator Signatures Page 37‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: STARR, B. (0113) Date/Time: 10/21/2007 15:27:10, Sunday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/23/2007 13:36:45, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Forensic Crime Unit Crime Scene (On September 30, 2007, I was requested to assist with the investigation of an Attempted Murder involving a shooting which occurred at approximately 0200 hrs at 1200 West University Avenue. Investigator Woodmansee is the original Crime Scene Investigator and responded to the scene at the time of the incident. At 1045 hrs, I was requested to respond to Shands @ UF to retrieve a bullet that had been removed from victim Corey Smith. Upon arrival, I made contact with Shands security who escorted me up to the Operating Room in which the victim was being treated. Outside the operating room I made contact with Noelia Williams RN. Williams tumed over to ‘me a plastic container with the fired bullet inside at 1100 hrs. The Dr. treating the victim was identified as Dr. Steve Lewis. After clearing the hospital, I responded to 3800 Southwest Archer Road, Stoneridge apartments, to examine a vehicle believed to have been involved in the incident. Upon arrival, contact was made with Cpl. Clinton. The vehicle in ‘question is a 2007 black Tahoe, 4 door, Florida tag GIPSR. The vehicle is registered to a Reggie Nelson. examined the exterior and interior of the vehicle for latent prints and by consent searched the interior of the vehicle for any evidence related to this case. No items of Physical Evidence were collected. The following latent prints were collected. 113-L-1: Left front door U/S door handle back 113-L-2: Right front door US door handle back 113-L-3: Right rear door I/S door handle back 113-L-4: ‘Thru 113-L-S: Left rear door /S door handle back 113-L-6: Left front door I/S edge 113-L-7: Thru 113-L-10: Right rear door U/S edge 113-L-ll: Thre 113-L-12: Left rear door US edge 113-L-13: Simulated wood trim on dash in front of right front seat 113-L-14: Right front quarter panel above tire 113-L-15: Right front roof post 113-L-16: Right front door O/S below window 113-L-17: Thre 113-L-18: Right front door O/S above door handle Investigator Signatures Page 38‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Right front door O/S below door handle 113-L-23: Right front door O/S rubber trim under window 113-L-24: Right rear door O/S door handle 13-L-25: ‘Thru 113-L-26: Right rear door O/S below door handle 13-L-27; ‘Thru 113-L-28: Right rear door O/S above door handle 113-L-29: ‘Thru 113-L-30: Right side of vehicle behind right rear door 113-L-31: Left front door O/S below door handle 113-L-32: Left front door rubber trim below window 113-L-36: Left rear door O/S above door handle 113-L-37: Right front quarter panel (palm card) ‘The vehicle was left on scene and tumed back over to the owner. I cleared the scene at approximately 1300 lars and transported the latent prints and bullet collected earlier to the Gainesville Police Dept. Forensic Crime Unit. The bullet ‘was placed into my evidence locker in the Forensic Unit and locked with a key lock in which only I have the key to. At 1630 hrs, I responded to University Towing to assist Investigator Woodmansee with the examination of the vehicle the victim was in when shot. See report completed by Investigator Woodmansee for detailed information on the shots, fired and the bullets recovered. I was requested to assist in the examination of the vehicle for latent prints as well. I collected the following latent prints from the white Ford Crown Victoria at University Towing. 113-L-38: Thru 113-L-39: Left rear quarter panel 113-L-40: Thre 113-L-43: Left rear roof post 113-L-44: Thru 113-L-45: Left rear door rear window frame O/S 113-L-46: Left rear door vent window 113-L-47: Left rear door above door handle O/S 113-L-48: Left rear door O/S 113-L-49: Left rear door forward window frame Investigator Signatures Page 39‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE 113-L-50: Thru 113-L-$2: Left front door rear window frame 113-L-53: Thru 113-L-55: Left front door top window frame 113-L-56: Left front door O/S 113-L-57: Thr 113-L-65: Left front quarter panel 113-L-66: Center front of hood Center front of vehicle above grill Right front roof post ‘Right rear door rear window frame Right rear door vent window 113-L-81: Thru 113-L-82: Right rear door above door handle 113-L-83: Thr 113-L-84: Right rear door forward window frame 113-L-85: Right rear door top window frame 113-L-86: ‘Thru 113-L-87: Right rear door U/S edge | cleared the scene at approximately 2045 hrs. The latent prints I collected during the course of this investigation were ‘tumed over to the latent print examiners. The memory cards containing digital photographs of the black Tahoe and the fired bullet were turned over to the Gainesville Police Dept. Photo Lab. The Fired bullet was securely packaged and placed into Property and Evidence identified as item 113-3: Fired bullet from victim Smith, Investigator Signatures Page 40‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: WOODMANSEE, M. D. (0008) Date/Time: 11/10/2007 21:43:44, Saturday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/12/2007 15:58:49, Monday Contact: Reference: Forensic Crime Unit Crime Scene ‘Case Number: 07-20053 / Attempted Murder VEHICLE INFORMATION: 1997 White Ford 4 door Crown Victoria, Fl Tag #E99 SVE VIN: 2FALP71W9VX205139 CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATION: On 9-30-07 at 0240 hours I responded to 1200 West University Ave in reference to processing the scene of a shooting and attempted murder. Upon arrival I contacted Ofe. N. Byrd, who had the roadway blocked with patrol cars, and the area directly east of the intersection of NW 13 Street and West University Ave barricaded with yellow crime scene tape. Ofc. Byrd advised that the victim vehicle had been stopped in traffic in the curb lane back from the intersection of 13 Street and Univ. Ave, several cars back from the intersection, when a subject approached the victim vehicle and fired several shots into the victim’s vehicle, Ofe. Byrd directed me to several casings located in the street along W. University Ave, which had been marked with orange markers. Ofe. Byrd also marked several drips of red fluid which appeared to be blood. I photographed these items using the markers already placed next to them by Ofc. ‘Byrd, I then received a request to respond to Shands Hospital at the University of Florida to process the victim vehicle there. I left the scene secured with Ofe. Byrd and responded to Shands at 0340 hours, where I contacted Ofe. N. Hallett. ‘Ofe. Hallett was standing by with the above listed vehicle, which was parked in the Emergency Room pull through. fe. Hallett advised that she had previously photographed the vehicle, and located items of evidence which had ‘apparently fallen from the vehicle. These items include a hat, pair of sunglasses, and a .380 auto casing, that were located next to the vehicle on the pavement. I collected these items, and then received victim clothing items from Ofe, Hallett at 0354 hours. The clothing items are detailed in the evidence section of this report. Ofe. Hallett advised that she had received these items from Emergency Room staff prior to my arrival. I sealed the doors of the vehicle with evidence tape, and then requested that Ofe. Hallett have the vehicle towed to secure storage for additional processing. Refer to Ofe. Hallett's report for details. At 0430 hours I returned to the initial scene at 1200 West University Ave. to complete processing the scene. Ofe. Byrd had maintained scene integrity, and advised that no one was allowed into the scene while I was assisting Ofe. Hallett. I ‘measured the locations of items within the scene, which included four 380 auto casings, a large roll of Black Cat firecrackers, a Coors Light Beer bottle, and the apparent blood drops left on the conerete and a red toothpick. Ofe. ‘Byrd assisted me in taking measurements of items located within the scene, and I then collected the casings, fire crackers and beer bottle, and collected swabs of the apparent blood. concluded scene investigations at 0510 hours and returned to GPD where I secured the items of physical evidence, and hung the bloody clothing items received from Ofe. Hallett in a secure drying locker. At 1630 hours I returned to duty and contacted Inv. B. Starr at GPD. In. Starr and I responded to University Towing, ‘and Recovery to process the victim's vehicle (listed above). I photographed the interior and exterior of the vehicle, including its contents, Inv, Starr and I located two firearms inside of the vehicle. A black and rusty Smith and Wesson Investigator Signatures Page 41‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE “40 cal mod. 410 pistol was on the right rear floor, partially concealed under the right front seat. The serial number had been obliterated from this pistol by drilling and grinding. A second pistol was found on the left front (drivers) floor, concealed under a black XXL T-shirt with "Skoolin" logo (008-50). This pistol was a Taurus Mod. P 111 Serial # TUK 15705. An NCIC check on this pistol confirmed that it was reported stolen from the Jacksonville Sheriff s Office (case +#04-133618). JSO was notified by phone, and by teletype of the weapon's recovery. I also conducted ATF traces on both firearms. Both weapons had ammunition in the magazines, but had empty chambers at the time of their recovery. Inv. Starr and I also conducted shooting scene reconstructions and projectile recovery. We were able to recover a fired bullet from the right front top door frame, and bullet fragments from the left front seat head rest and seat. Refer to the ‘evidence section of this report for details of the items recovered from the vehicle, PARTICULARS OF CRIME SCENE: ‘The scene consists of the roadway and sidewalk located at 1200 West University Ave. The roadway is five lanes, and the crime scene consists of the sidewalk and north side curb lane of West University Ave, directly east of the ‘intersection with NW 13 St. There are four 380 auto casings in the roadway, a Coors Light beer bottle, and several areas of apparent blood drops. POINT OF ENTRY / POINT OF EXIT: NIA PHYSICAL EVIDENCE: Physical evidence was collected as follows: From the scene at 1200 West University Ave and Shands Hospital; 008-4 Large roll of Black Cat firecrackers 008-5 Coors Light beer bottle 008-6 Swab collected from the mouth of the Coors Light bottle 008-7 Winchester 380 auto casing from Shands Emergency Room 008-8 Winchester 380 auto casing (photo marker #A) 008-9 Winchester 380 auto casing (photo marker #B) (008-10 Winchester 380 auto casing (photo marker #C) 008-11 Winchester 380 auto casing (photo marker #D) 008-12 Blood swab from scene (photo marker #B) 008-13 Blood swab from scene (photo marker #F) 008-14 Piece of tooth pick from scene (photo marker #6) 008-15 Swab of blood from scene (photo marker #1) 008-16 Black cap and sunglasses from Shands ER Clothing and personal items collected from Ofc. Hallett at Shands for Justin Glass: 008-17 Pair of white and gray tennis shoes, 008-18 Pair of black socks 008-19 Pair of gray Fruit of the Loom underwear 008-20 Pair of red Fruit of the Loom boxer shorts 008-21 White tank top shirt Investigator Signatures Page 42‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE (008-22 Pair of black Nike shorts, 008-23 Blue "Royal" jeans shorts with black belt Clothing and personal items collected from Ofc. Hallett at Shands for Corey Smith: 008-24 Pair of black tennis shoes 008-25 Pair of black socks 008-26 Black men’s wallet with Kid Zone visa check card for Barbara Cummings 008-27 Red and white striped boxer shorts 008-28 Gray tank top shirt 008-29 Blue "RMC" jeans shorts size 36 008-30 Bloody Hospital sheets Items were collected from the victim's vehicle as follows: (008-31 Smith and Wesson .40 cal Mod 410 pistol, Serial # obliterated 008-32 Magazine removed ftom Smith and Wesson pistol (008-31) 008-337 rounds .40 cal. R-P ammunition, removed from magazine (008-32) 008-34 Taurus 9mm Mod PT 111, Serial #TUK 15705 (reported stolen to Jax SO) 008-35 Magazine for Taurus 9mm pistol, removed from Taurus pistol (008-34) 008-36 9 rounds 9mm ammunition removed from Taurus magazine (008-35) 008-37 Swab from left side of grip, S & W pistol 008-38 Swab from right side of grip, S & W pistol 008-39 Swab from front of grip, Taurus pistol 008-40 Swab from back of grip of Taurus pistol 008-41 Bullet fragments from drivers seat headrest 008-42 Bullet fragments from driver's seat 008-43 Fired bullet from right front door frame 008-44 Blood swab from right top passenger seat 008-45 Blood swab from right front door below window 008-46 Blood swab from right top drivers seat 008-47 Blood swab from right rear seat 008-48 Blood swab from exterior trunk 008-49 Cellular phone (Alltel) Kyocera from left rear floor 008-50 Black XXL T-Shirt with "Skoolin" logo from left front floor 008-51 Clip board with blood drips, Cason Elect. paperwork inside LATENT PRINTS: Inv. Starr and I examined the vehicle for latent prints, Latent prints were developed and lifted as follows: 008-L-1 to 008-L-2 Exterior right front hood. 008-1-3, Exterior windshield, right front 008-L-4 to 008-L-13 Exterior right front door 008-L-14 to 008-L-15 Exterior right front window 008-L-16 to 008-L-18 Exterior right front door near handle Investigator Signatures Page 43‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN: Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE 008-L-19 Exterior right front window 008-L-20 to 008-L-21 Exterior right front door near handle 008-L-22 to 008-L-23 Interior right front window 008-1-24 Exterior right front door 008-L-25 to 008-L-26 Exterior right front window 008-L-27 Exterior right front fender ‘The firearms and scene items were examined for latent prints at GPD on 10-04-07. Latent prints were developed and lifted as follows: 008-L-28 to 008-L-33 40 cal magazine from S & W pistol (008-31) 008-L-34 to 008-L-35 .40 cal round from S & W magazine 008-L-36 to 008-L-38 Blue Alltel cellular phone (008-49) 008-L-39 to 008-L-46 Coors Light beer bottle (008-5, from scene at 1200 W. Univ, Ave) PHOTOGRAPHS: The scene at 1200 West University Ave was photographed using a digital camera and flash, Ofe. Hallett photographed the vehicle at the Shands ER. I photographed the victim's vehicle again at University Towing using a digital camera and flash, to include the vehicles contents, and the recovery of the projectiles from the vehicle. DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE: Items of physical evidence were packaged and submitted to the Property and Evidence Section. DISCRIPTION OF VICTIM: Victim: Justin Dozier Glass, B/M, Vietim: Corey Travon Smith, B/M| LOCATION AND POSITION OF VICTIM: Both victims were transported to the hospital prior to my arrival. VICTIMS INJURIES: Both victims suffered gunshot wounds, refer to medical reports for additional information. WEAPON USED: ‘Undetermined type of 380 handgun. SKETCHES: To be completed as required. Investigator Signatures Page 44‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department 0207020053 oc! Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Offense: HOMICIDE Occurred: 09/30/2007 Investigator: KILMER, M. J. (5636) Date/Time: 12/05/2007 15:08:56, Wednesday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 12/13/2007 15:27:40, Thursday Contact: Reference: Latent Form GAINESVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT FORENSIC CRIME UNIT LATENT COMPARISON REPORT ‘Complaint as Verified Date of Report ATTEMPTED MURDER 12-05-07 Complainant Address City of Gainesville 1, ANSWER TO: DETECTIVES 2. LATENTS DEVELOPED BY: INVESTIGATORS M.WOODMANSEE #008 and B.STARR #113 3. LATENTS RECEIVED BY: EXAMINER MELISSA J. KILMER #5636 4, NUMBER OF LATENTS RECEIVED: FORTY-SIX (46) and EIGHTY-SEVEN (87) respectively 5. SUBJECT IDENTIFIED: DATE: CASON, RANDALL 02-05-07 CH 56713 ALACHUA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE 6. COMMENTS: VICTIM - ELIMINATION FROM HANDGUNS, 7. IDENTIFICATIONS: Case Report No. 07-20053 #1 (right thumb) from #008 L-28 "40 CAL MAGAZINE FROM S&W PISTOL.” #1 from #008 L-29 ".40 CAL MAGAZINE FROM S&W PISTOL.” Investigator Signatures Page 45‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department ca: 0207020053 Case Stats: OPEN Case Ming Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator Signature: Page 46‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: KAYS, B. M. (0443) Date/Time: 07/24/2008 01:49:43, Thursday Supervisor: KAYS, B.M. (0443) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 01/24/2008 00:00:00, Thursday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 09/30/07, I responded in uniform to the 1200 block of WUA in reference to a shooting. The suspects and victims had already fled the scene. I met with several officers and attempted to determine the actual crime scene. I met with Ofe. Revielle, who smelled gunpowder on the east sidewalk in the unit block of NW 13 ST - west of the west parking lot of the Dill Deli. We searched the area of the sidewalk and the roadway without finding any signs of evidence. Ofe. Holt was with witness Alan Davies, who showed me where the shooting actually occurred. Davies walked me from the south parking lot of the Dill Deli / Holiday Inn to the north sidewalk of WUA. He said that the shooter walked south from the parking lot through the parking lot's bordering landscaping onto the north side walk ‘of WUA approximately 5-7 car lengths east of the NW 13 ST intersection. ‘The shooter approached a car stopped in traffic facing westbound in the curb lane. From the sidewalk, the shooter shot into the car. He then ran back north into the Dill Deli's south parking lot and then north through the west parking lot, ‘towards McDonald's. Set. Giles and I stopped westbound traffic at that location, I cordoned off the scene with yellow crime scene tape. The scene extended approximately 2 cars lengths east of where the shooting was described, ended just short of the NW 13 ST intersection and included the curb lane, the north sidewalk and the south landscaping border of the parking lot (see FLC processing/photographs for exact specifies.) As I was doing this, Sgt. Giles told me he saw small caliber bullet ‘casings in the roadway. fe. N. Bryd started a crime scene log. He saw more bullet casings in the road and north gutter. Ofe. Bertzyk assisted ‘in marking the casings, a beer bottle and blood splatter within the crime scene. Ofe. Woodmansee eventually processed the crime scene. only saw the beer bottle in the roadway. I saw a roll of firecrackers bound further west on the sidewalk. It was unknown if the firecrackers were involved. I do not know if they were collected as evidence. Daniel Perkins approached me in the south Dill Deli parking lot. He told me that he did not see the shooting but heard ‘the multiple gun shots. He was standing from the west. He saw a black male running north through the west Dill Deli parking lot. The black male was yelling something about a shooting and something about a Tahoe (vehicle.) I turned. Perkins over to Ofe. Holt for identification and interviewing. 1 did not interview any else besides what is documented. I did not collect any evidence. I did not photograph anything. Investigator Signatures Page 47‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: WOODMANSEE, M. D. (0008) Date/Time: 07/24/2008 23:53:47, Thursday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 01/28/2008 14:59:44, Monday Contact: Reference: Forensic Crime Unit Crime Scene ‘Case Number: 07-2053 / Homicide (On 12-20-08 I received evidence from Evidence Custodian D. Stanley in reference to submitting the evidence to the FDLE Lab in Tallahassee for Firearms analysis at the request of Det. P. Nixon. Det. Nixon requested that this case be ‘compared to a firearm recovered by the Live Oak Highway Patrol and submitted to the Tallahassee FDLE Lab by FDLE Agent Tfiel. I spoke with Tallahassee FDLE Firearms Examiner Jeff Foggy and he advised that he was familiar with the Live Oak case and to submit the evidence under FDLE # 20060102347. Evidence received was listed as follows: 113-3 Fired bullet from victim Smith 008-7 Winchester 380 casing from Shands ER. 008-8 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-9 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-10 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-11 | Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-41 Bullet fragments from drivers seat head rest 008-42 Bullet fragments from driver's seat 008-43 Fired bullet from right front door frame This evidence was prepared for submission to the Tallahassee FDLE Lab, and returned to the Property and Evidence Section, Investigator Signatures Page 48‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN Case Mg Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: WOODMANSEE, M. D. (0008) Date/Time: 03/13/2008 09:39:43, Thursday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 3/18/2008 14:41:15, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Forensic Crime Unit Crime Scene ‘Case Number: 07-020053 / Attempted Murder (On 2-26-08 I received evidence under case number 08-003824 from Ofe. Delucea #694 for latent print processing. Evidence received was listed as follows: 694-1 Semi-automatic Lorcin Pistol SN 095803 694-2 Magazine for 694-1 694-3. 7 rounds of ammunition from 694-2 This evidence was examined for latent prints using dusting powders and lifting tape. No latent prints were developed. 1 then swabbed the grips of the pistol for potential DNA evidence. ‘The swabs were placed into evidence under case ‘umber 08-003824 as follows: 008-5 Swab R. grip of Lorcen pistol SN 095803 008-6 Swab L. grip of Lorcen Pistol SN 095803 ‘The evidence was turned over to the Property and Evidence Section on 3-6-08. On 3-6-08 I collected this evidence «along with the additional items of evidence from case number 07-020053 listed below: 113-3 Fired bullet from victim Smith 008-7 Winchester 380 casing from Shands ER. 008-8 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-9 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-10 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-11 Winchester 380 casing from scene 008-41 Bullet fragments from drivers seat head rest 008-42 Bullet fragments from driver's seat 008-43 Fired bullet from right front door ‘The three above items under case number 08-003824 and the above items listed from 07-020053 were prepared for submission to the FDLE lab in Jacksonville for firearms analysis at the request of Det. P. Nixon. Det. Nixon requested that the casings, bullets, and bullet fragments from 07-20053 be compared to the firearm submitted under case number 08-003824. This evidence was packaged for submission to the FDLE Lab in Jacksonville and returned to the Property and Evidence Section. Investigator Signatures Page 49‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN (Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: TRAHAN, M. (0097) Date/Time: 07/11/2008 18:45:48, Friday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 07/14/2008 10:03:11, Monday Contact: Reference: Forensic Crime Unit Crime Scene (07-020053.097 ATTEMPTED HOMICD! ‘On 06/15/08, I was contacted by Detective Patty Nixon and was asked if'I could assist the victim in this case Corey Smith B/M, 11/18/78, in the creation a composite of the unknown suspect who shot him in the head. ‘The composite was scheduled for Sunday 6/22/08 at approximately 1700 hrs. On 6/22/08 at 1745 hrs Det. Nixon brought Smith to the Forensic Crime Unit where the suspect composite was created using the E-Fit composite program ‘on a personal computer. The completed composite was printed on a laser printer and signed by Smith and me at 2035 hrs. ‘The following item of physical evidence was collected and placed into the Property and Evidence section: 097-52: Suspect composite. Investigator Signatures Page 50‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 07/03/2013 10:36 Gainesville Police Department coca: 0207020053 Case Status: OPEN (Case Mng Status: ACTIVE, OPEN Occurred: 09/30/2007 Offense: HOMICIDE Investigator: TRAHAN, M. (0097) Date/Time: 08/02/2008 20:56:50, Saturday Supervisor: STOUT, W.R. (0311) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 08/05/2008 08:53:57, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Forensic Crime Unit Crime Scene (07-020053.097 ATTEMPTED HOMICDE: ‘On 07/18/08 at 2300 hrs I was contacted by Detective Patty Nixon in the Forensic Crime Unit at GPD. Det Nixon ‘made arrangements for a witness in this case to create a composite of the subject she saw prior to the shooting incident. (On 07/19/08 at 1735 hrs, Detective Nixon escorted witness Sheena Cooper B/F, 04/02/85 to the Forensic Crime Unit where I assisted Cooper in creating a composite of the subject she saw. The composite was created using the E-Fit ‘composite program on a laptop computer. The completed composite was printed on a laser printer and signed by Cooper and me. ‘The following item of physical evidence was placed into the Property and Evidence section: 097-5 Suspect composite, 07-200S3.097 Investigator Signatures Page 51