Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
MEDICAL TOURISM
Assoc. Prof Dr Ghazali Musa (MBBS, PhD)
Marketing Department
Faculty of Business and Accountancy
University Malaya
CONTENT
Introduction
Definition of medical tourism
Travel motivations of medical tourism
Medical tourism in Malaysia
Competitor Analysis: Singapore, Thailand and
India
Empirical study of medical tourism in Kuala
Lumpur: motivation, satisfaction and
consumption behaviour
Issues and challenges
How to go global?
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
DEFINITION
DEFINITION
TRAVEL MOTIVATIONS
Key Motivators
Cost
Sub-Motivators
(1) Lower cost in overseas
(2) Higher cost in home country
(3) Favorable exchange rates
(4) Relatively affordable international air travel
Time
Regulation
Tourism
Information
MALAYSIA
Medical
MALAYSIA: GOVERNMENT
INITIATIVES
MALAYSIA: QUALITY
Quality: most of the private medical centers have
achieved certification for internationally
recognized quality (e.g. ISO 9002) or the
Malaysian Society for Quality of Health (MSQH)
(APHM, 2008).
Joint Commission International (JCI) is an
important factor for medical tourism related
agencies to recommend overseas healthcare
centers to their customers
Quality: 8 JCI accredited hospitals in the
country (JCI, 2011), located mainly Kuala
Lumpur (6) and one each in the island city of
Penang and Kuching.
MALAYSIA-BRAIN DRAIN
COMPETITORS ANALYSIS
Thailand, Singapore and India
THAILAND: DEVELOPMENT
THAILAND: PROMOTION
.
The
SINGAPORE
The top medical tourism destinations in Asia, Singapore Tourism Board (2010)
itself claimed Singapore as the Asias leading medical hub in 2009.
Singapore is targeting to attract 1 million patients by 2012, with expected
revenue between US$1.6 to 1.8 billion.
Top markets: Indonesians, Malaysians, Chinese, Middle Eastern, and
Japanese. The majority of its European and American patients are residents
who live in Asia (Connell, 2006).
Quality: 18 hospitals and medical centers in Singapore that obtained JCI
accreditation (JCI, 2011).
Quality: Compete on top notch quality instead of price; key competitive
advantages are excellence in quality, trustworthiness, safety, and international
accreditation.
Offer high quality and complex medical treatments: neurosurgical procedures
and liver and heart transplants; (separation of the Nepalese twins, heart and
liver transplant, the first percutaneous aortic valve replacement, and the
worlds first operation for a rare ectopic pregnancy with a single incision
exclusively through the belly button).
The drawback: the most expensive, but Connell (2006) reported that Singapore
has considered of setting its rates on par or slightly below Thailand
SINGAPORE
The
SINGAPORE
Ministry
INDIA
INDIA
17 JCI accredited hospitals (JCI, 2011). The majority in New Delhi and
Mumbai.
World- renowned for medical studies: 229 recognized medical colleges in 2010,
producing almost 34,000 medical graduates yearly
INDIA
EMPIRICAL STUDY IN KL
Objectives of the study
To identify the demographic profile of inbound
health tourists in Kuala Lumpur.
To explore travel motivation (pull factors) among
inbound health tourists in Kuala Lumpur.
To determine healthcare consumption and
spending behaviour among inbound health
tourists in Kuala Lumpur.
The determine the satisfaction of medical tourists
To examine the influences of demographic profile
on travel motivation, satisfaction and spending
behaviour among inbound health tourists in
Kuala Lumpur.
METHODOLOGY
Max
(MYR)
Sum
(MYR)
Mean
(MYR)
150
107, 000
1, 127,840
12, 259.13
35
36, 800
355, 618
3, 743.35
Accommodation
100
59, 000
267, 050
3, 256.71
Organized tours
200
15, 000
63, 200
2, 747.83
60
35, 000
215, 420
2, 504.88
Miscellaneous
50
50, 000
87, 300
2, 494.29
25
50, 000
146, 885
1, 650.39
Entertainment
50
10, 000
47, 870
1, 087.95
Domestic
transportation
Total Expenditure
15
10, 000
53, 146
617.98
250
427, 500
2, 818, 640
26, 844.19
Spending Components
Healthcare services
International airfares
Shopping
RESULTS
RESULTS
RESULTS
Health tourists travel on average with two other people. 2008 medical
tourism related tourists could have been as high as one million in Malaysia.
The average length of stay among respondents was 15 days while the average
spending as stated earlier was MYR 26, 844.19. Might have contributed MYR
9 billion to the Malaysian economy in 2008.
Combination of purposeful and convenience sampling higher spending
tourists in Kuala Lumpur.
Kuala Lumpur may also have attracted the middle-upper income health
tourists as compared with lower-middle income health tourists in Penang
(Ormond, 2011).
All these impressive figures however clearly demonstrate that health tourism
is indeed a high yield industry.
Tourists of European descent spent a considerably higher amount while
in Malaysia compared with shorter distance travellers from other Asian
countries.
Female respondents spent three times more than males in total
expenditure.
Females spent more in the expenditure components of healthcare services,
international airfares, accommodation and domestic transportation.
RESULTS
ACCESSIBILITY
Visa (ease of visa and length)
Transportation link: external (inbound) and
internal (domestic)
Any effort to ease tourists movement (e.g. inhouse travel agencies)
Information accessibility: websites (content,
features, functionality etc.)
Increase products and services offered. The product must be high yield, ground
breaking medical treatment and procedures.
Among high yield medical treatment that is discovered by this study is cosmetic
surgery. Further exploration needs to be carried out in developing new treatments
which are not yet available in certain countries such as stem cell therapy.
Perhaps effort should be carried to develop the expertise which requires patient to
stay longer for chronic illnesses such as medical and orthopedic rehabilitation and
cancer treatment and disability rehabilitation. Longer stay translates to bigger
spending among health tourists.
Perhaps more products and services could be designed to cater for pediatric patients
as well as elderly patients. Pediatric patients are more likely to come with their
parents. While elderly people are often having chronic illnesses, have more time and
money to spend for their medical treatment.
Malaysia should avoid getting involved in controversial practices, which may tarnish
the image of the country, such as the provision of assisted suicide and illegal organ
trades. The cultural sensitivity such as sex change operation may also have to be
considered
THANK YOU