Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
No. 275
Testimony of Ethan Nadelmann, Executive Director, Drug Policy Alliance
April 7, 2015
Good afternoon. I am Ethan Nadelmann, Executive Director of the Drug
Policy Alliance, the nations leading organization advocating alternatives to
the failed war on drugs. I want to thank the Revenue and Economic
Development Committee for the opportunity to address you today and submit
written testimony in favor of the heroin-assisted treatment pilot project that
SB275 would create.
The evidence is in. Heroin-assisted treatment, also known as heroin
maintenance, is a feasible, effective, and cost-saving strategy for reducing
drug use and drug-related harm among long-term heroin users for whom other
treatment programs have failed.1 Permanent heroin maintenance programs
have been established in the United Kingdom, Switzerland, the Netherlands,
Germany, and Denmark, with additional trial programs having been
completed or currently taking place in Spain, Belgium, and Canada.2 Findings
from randomized controlled studies in these countries have yielded
unanimously positive results.3 Heroin-assisted treatment is associated with
decreased illicit drug use, crime, overdose fatalities, and risky injecting, as
well as significant improvements in physical and mental health, employment,
and social relations.4 Given the consistently positive results, heroin-assisted
treatment is not as controversial or radical as it may seem at first blush.
Rather, it is a treatment modality that has gained traction within the scientific
community as a tried-and-true method for dealing with particularly refractory
cases of heroin addiction and the associated harms.
I would like to first highlight the development and history of heroin-assisted
treatment in other countries and review the compelling evidence base that has
been amassed from the international experience before contextualizing the
importance of SB275 within our own country and this state.
TIMELINE AND DEVELOPMENT OF HEROIN-ASSISTED
TREATMENT IN OTHER COUNTRIES
Though heroin has been available by individual prescription in the United
Kingdom since 1926,5 Switzerland opened the first supervised heroin-assisted
treatment centers as part of a clinical study in 1994.6 In 1999, after reviewing
the initial positive results of the Swiss study, the World Health Organization
recommended more randomized clinical trials on heroin maintenance.7
Between 2002 and 2010, the Netherlands,8 Spain,9 Germany,10 Canada11 and
the United Kingdom12 published the results of additional studies showing that
Board Members
Larry Campbell
Christine Downton
Jodie Evans
James E. Ferguson, II
Jason Flom
Ira Glasser
Carl Hart, PhD
Mathilde Krim, PhD
David C. Lewis, MD
Pamela Lichty
Ethan Nadelmann, JD, PhD
Josiah Rich, MD
Rev. Edwin Sanders
Michael Skolnik
George Soros
Ilona Szab de Carvalho
Richard B. Wolf
Honorary Board
Former Mayor
Rocky Anderson
Harry Belafonte
Richard Branson
Former Defense Secretary
Frank C. Carlucci, III
Deepak Chopra
Rep. John Conyers, Jr.
Walter Cronkite
[1916-2009]
Ram Dass
Vincent Dole, MD
[1913-2006]
Former President of the Swiss
Confederation Ruth Dreifuss
Former Surgeon General
Joycelyn Elders
Judge Nancy Gertner (Ret.)
Former Police Chief
Penny Harrington
Former President of the
Czech Republic Vclav Havel
[1936-2011]
Calvin Hill
Arianna Huffington
Former Governor
Gary Johnson
Judge John Kane
Former Attorney General
Nicholas deB. Katzenbach
[1922-2012]
Former Police Chief
Joseph McNamara
[1934-2014]
Former Police Commissioner
Patrick V. Murphy
[1920-2011]
Benny J. Primm, MD
Dennis Rivera
Former Mayor Kurt Schmoke
Charles R. Schuster, PhD
[1930-2011]
Alexander Shulgin, PhD
[1925-2014]
Former Secretary of State
George P. Shultz
Russell Simmons
Sting
Judge Robert Sweet
Former Chairman of the Federal
Reserve Paul Volcker
heroin is more effective than oral methadone for people who have not
benefitted from standard treatments. By 2010, heroin was registered for
maintenance treatment in the United Kingdom, Switzerland, The Netherlands,
Denmark, and Germany.13
The Dutch government supported the rollout of heroin maintenance as regular
addiction treatment alongside other existing interventions in 2004 and, in
December 2006, the Dutch Medicines Evaluation Board approved both
inhalable and injectable heroin as a medicinal product for maintenance
treatment.14 As of July 2011, 650 patients receive heroin-assisted treatment in
17 clinics throughout the country.15 In Switzerland, a national referendum to
permit heroin maintenance passed with 68% of the public vote in 2008.16
There are now 23 facilities in Switzerland providing heroin-assisted treatment,
including two located in prisons, serving nearly 1,500 people.17 Though
Denmark never hosted a clinical trial, the government approved a proposal to
allow heroin-assisted treatment in 2008 based on the overwhelming evidence
from other countries.18 Five heroin maintenance clinics now serve an
estimated 300 people.19 Germanys parliament voted to allow heroin-assisted
treatment in 2009 and it is now available in nine clinics serving approximately
500 patients throughout the country.20 In the United Kingdom, three clinics
remained open after the conclusion of their trial program and currently serve
approximately 100 people.21 In January 2012, the government gave approval
for the roll-out of additional heroin maintenance clinics after the Department
of Health concluded that heroin-assisted treatment is now evidenced as a
clinically-effective second-line treatment . . . .22 Moreover, approximately
500 people in the United Kingdom receive prescription heroin directly from
their physician for maintenance treatment.23
In addition to permanent treatment programs, trial programs are currently
operating in Canada (a second study began in 2011)24 and Belgium (also
began in 2011).25 Luxembourg is considering the implementation of similar
trials.26
KEY RESEARCH FINDINGS
Results from the European and Canadian trials and permanent programs
demonstrate that prescribed pharmaceutical heroin does exactly what it is
intended to do: it reaches a treatment refractory group of addicts by engaging
them in a positive healthcare relationship with a physician, it reduces their
criminal activity, improves their health status, and increases their social tenure
through more stable housing, employment, and contact with family.27
Moreover, these substantial benefits come with improved cost-savings
compared to standard treatments28 and with no negative impacts on the larger
community.29
Ethan Nadelmann
Executive Director
Lindsay LaSalle
Staff Attorney
See, e.g., Fischer, B., Oviedo-Joekes, E., Blanken, P., et al. (2007). Heroin-assisted
treatment (HAT) a decade later: A brief update on science and politics. J Urban Health, 84,
552-62.
2
Strang, J., Groshkova, T. & Metrebian, N. (2012). New heroin-assisted treatment: Recent
evidence and current practices of supervised injectable heroin treatment in Europe and
beyond. European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction Insights. Luxembourg:
Publications.
3
See, e.g., van den Brink, W., Hendricks, V. M., Blanken, P., et al. (2003). Medical
prescription of heroin to treatment resistant heroin addicts: two randomised controlled trials.
British Medical Journal, 327, 310316; Haasen, C., Verthein, U., Degkwitz, P., et al. (2007).
Heroin-assisted treatment for opioid dependence. British Journal of Psychiatry, 191, 5562;
March, J. C., Oviedo-Joekes, E., Perea-Milla, E., Carrasco, F. et al. (2006). Controlled trial of
prescribed heroin in the treatment of opioid addiction. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment,
31, 203211; Oviedo-Joekes, E., Brissette, S., Marsh, D., et al. (2009). Diacetylmorphine
versus methadone for the treatment of opiate addiction. The New England Journal of
Medicine, 361, 777786; Perneger, T. V., Giner, F., del Rio, M. & Mino, A. (1998).
Randomised trial of heroin maintenance programme for addicts who fail in conventional drug
treatments. British Medical Journal 317, 1318; Strang, J., Metrebian, N., Lintzeris, N., et al.
(2010). Supervised injectable heroin or injectable methadone versus optimised oral
methadone as treatment for chronic heroin addicts in England after persistent failure in
orthodox treatment (RIOTT): a randomised trial. Lancet, 375, 18851895.
4
See, e.g., Ferri, M., Davoli, M., & Perucci, C.A. (2005). Heroin maintenance for chronic
heroin dependents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev., 2.
5
Metrebian, N., Carnwath, Z., Mott, J., Carnwath, T., Stimson, G.V., Sell, L. (2006). Patients
receiving a prescription for diamorphine (heroin) in the United Kingdom. Drug Alcohol Rev,
25, 115-21.
6
Rehm, J., Gschwend, P., Steffen, T., Gutzwiller, F., Dobler-Mikola, A. & Uchtenhagen, A.
(2001). Feasibility, safety, and efficacy of injectable heroin prescription for refractory opioid
addicts: a follow-up study. Lancet, 358, 1417-23.
7
Ali, R., Auriacombe, M., Casas, M., Cottler, L., Farell, M., Kleiber, D., Kreuzer, A.,
Ogborne, A., Rehm, J. & Ward, P. (1999). Report of the external panel on the evaluation of
the Swiss scientific studies of medically prescribed narcotics to drug addicts. Geneva: WHO.
8
van den Brink et al. (2003), supra note 3.
9
March, J.C. et al. (2006), supra note 3.
10
Haasen et al. (2007), supra note 3.
11
Oviedo-Joekes et al. (2009), supra note 3.
12
Strang et al. (2010), supra note 3.
13
Strang et al. (2012) supra note 2 at 19, 25.
14
Blanken, P., van den Brink, W., Hendriks, V. M., et al. (2010). Heroin-assisted treatment in
the Netherlands: History, findings, and international context. European
Neuropsychopharmacology, Supplement 2, 105158.
15
Strang et al. (2012), supra note 2 at 149.
16
Id. at 103.
17
Strang et al. (2012), supra note 2 at 104.
18
Id. at 145.
19
Id. at 147.
20
Strang et al. (2012), supra note 2 at 126.
21
Id. at 138.
22
Id. at 143-44.
23
Lintzeris, N., Strang, J., Metrebian, N., et al. (2006). Methodology for the Randomised
Injecting Opioid Treatment Trial (RIOTT): Evaluating injectable methadone and injectable
heroin treatment versus optimised oral methadone treatment in the UK. Harm Reduction
Journal, 3, 28-33.
24
Providence Health Care, Salome,
http://www.providencehealthcare.org/salome/outcomes.html.
25
Demaret, I., Hern, P., Lematre, A. & Ansseau, M. (2011). Feasibility assessment of
heroin-assisted treatment in Lige, Belgium. Acta Psychiatricia, N 111\1, 3-8.
26
Ferri et al. (2005), supra note 4.
27
Small, D. & Drucker, E. (2006). Policy makers ignoring science and scientists ignoring
policy: The medical ethical challenges of heroin treatment. Harm Reduction Journal, 3, 16.
28
Bammer, G., van den Brink, W., Gschwend, P., et al. (2003). What can the Swiss and
Dutch trials tell us about the potential risks associated with heroin prescribing? Drug and
Alcohol Review, 22(3), 363-71; Dijkgraaf, M. G., van der Zanden, B. P., de Borgie, C.A., et
al. (2005). Cost utility analysis of co-prescribed heroin compared with methadone
maintenance treatment in heroin addicts in two randomised trials. BMJ, 330, 1297-1302.
29
Lansier, B., Brochu, S., Bovd, N. & Fischer, B. (2010). A heroin prescription trial: Case
studies from Montreal and Vancouver on crime and disorder in the surrounding
neighbourhoods. International Journal of Drug Policy, 21, 28-35; Miller, P., McKenzie, S.,
Lintzeris, N., Martin, A. & Strang, J. (2010). The community impact of RIOTT, a medically
supervised injectable maintenance clinic in south London. Mental Health and Substance Use:
Dual Diagnosis 3, 248259; Miller, P., McKenzie, S., Walker, J., Lintzeris, N. & Strang, J.
(2011). Investigating the effect on public behaviour of patients of a medical supervised
injectable maintenance clinic. Drugs and Alcohol Today, 11, 204209.
30
Bammer et al., supra note 28; Dijkgraaf et al. (2005), supra note 28.
31
Bammer, supra note 28.
32
Dijkgraaf et al. (2005), supra note 28.
33
Brehmer, C. & Hen, P.X. (2001). Medical prescription of heroin to chronic heroin addicts
in Switzerland - a review. Forensic Science International, 121, 23-26.
34
Haasen, C. (2009). Gesundheitskonomische Begleitforschung (unpublished economic
evaluation report, German heroin-assisted treatment trial).
35
March et al. (2006), supra note 3.
36
Metrebian, N., Shanahan, W., Wells, B. & Stimson, G. (1998). Feasibility of prescribing
injectable heroin and methadone to opiate-dependent drug users: associated health gains and
harm reductions. MJA, 168(12), 596-600.
37
Killias, M. and Rabassa, J. (1997). Less Crime in the Cities Through Heroin Prescription?
Preliminary Results from the Evaluation of the Swiss Heroin Prescription Projects. The
Howard Journal, 36(4).
38
Lbmann, R. & Verthein, U. (2009). Explaining the Effectiveness of Heroin-assisted
Treatment on Crime Reductions. Law and Human Behavior, 33:1.
39
Perneger et al. (1998), supra note 3.
40
Dijkgraaf et al. (2005), supra note 28.
41
Lobmann & Verthein. (2009). Explaining the effectiveness of heroin-assisted treatment on
crime reductions. Law and Human Behavior, 33(1), 8395.
42
Id.
43
Haasen et al. (2007), supra note 3 at 55-62; P., Vincent, M. H., Maarten, W. J., Koeter, Van
Ree, J.M. & van den Brink, W. (2005). Matching of treatment-resistant heroin-dependent
patients to medical prescription of heroin or oral methadone treatment: Results from two
randomized controlled trials. Addiction, 100, 89-95; Franziska, G., Gschwend, P., Schulte, B.,
Rehm, J., & Uchtenhagen, A. (2003). Evaluating long-term effects of heroin-assisted
treatment: The results of a 6-year follow-up. European Addiction Research, 9, 73-79; March
et al. (2006), supra note 3 at 203-211; Oviedo-Joekes et al. 2009, supra note 3.
44
Ferri et al. (2005), supra note 4 at 10.
45
Strang et al. (2010), supra note 3.
46
Rehm et al. (2001), supra note 6.
47
Haasen et al. (2007), supra note 3.
48
Oviedo-Joekes et al. 2009, supra note 3.
49
Blanken, P., Hendriks, V.M., Koeter, M. et al. (2012). Craving and illicit heroin use among
patients in heroin-assisted treatment. Drug Alcohol Depend, 120, 1-3.
50
M., Hendriks, V.M., Van Ree, J.M., van den Brink, J. (2010). Outcome of long-term
heroin-assisted treatment offered to chronic, treatment-resistant heroin addicts in the
Netherlands. Addiction, 105(2), 300-308; Eiroa-Orosa, F.J., Haasen, C., Verthein, U. et al.
(2010). Benzodiazepine use among patients in heroin-assisted vs. methadone maintenance
treatment: Findings of the German randomized controlled trial. Drug Alcohol Depend, 112(3),
226-33; Haasen, C., Eiroa-Orosa, F.J., Verthein, U. et al. (2009). Effects of heroin-assisted
treatment on alcohol consumption: findings of the german randomized controlled trial.
Alcohol, 43(4), 259-64.
51
Perneger et al. (1998), supra note 3; Rehm et al. (2001), supra note 6.
52
Oviedo-Joekes et al. (2007), supra note 1 at 777.
53
Haasen et al. (2007), supra note 3.
54
Rehm et al. (2001), supra note 6.
55
Id.
Strang et al. (2012), supra note 2 at 48-50.
57
Haasen et al. (2007), supra note 3 at 55-62.
58
Rehm et al. (2001), supra note 6.
59
Vertein, U., Bonorden, K., Degkwitz, P., et al. (2008). Long-term effects of heroin-assisted
treatment in Germany. Addiction, 103, 960-966.
60
Lansier et al., supra note 29; Miller et al. (2010, 2011), supra note 29.
61
Lansier et al. (2010), supra note 29.
62
Miller et al. (2010, 2011), supra note 29.
63
Killias, M., Aebi, M.F., Jurist, K. (2000). The Impact of Heroin Prescription on Heroin
Markets in Switzerland. Crime Prevention Studies, 11.
64
Id.
65
National Institute on Drug Abuse. (2014). Drug Facts, available at
http://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/nationwide-trends.
66
National Institute of Drug Abuse. (2014). What is the scope of heroin use in the United
States?, available at http://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/research-reports/heroin/scopeheroin-use-in-united-states.
67
Id.
68
Office of National Drug Control Policy, Nevada Drug Control Update, available at
https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/docs/state_profile_-_nevada.pdf.
69
Office of Public Health Informatics and Epidemiology and Office of Vital Records of the
Division of Public and Behavioral Health, Heroin and Opioid Related Mortality 2008-2012,
available at http://health.nv.gov/PUBLICATIONS/20082012_Heroin_and_Opioid_Related_Mortality_Fast_Facts_e_1.0_2014-03-06.pdf.
70
Chereb, S. (2014, April 5). Heroin use, deaths, on the rise in Nevada. Reno GazetteJournal, available at http://www.rgj.com/story/news/crime/2014/04/05/heroin-use-deathsrise-nevada/7350407/; Kitchen, R. (2014, February 6). Heroin use on the rise in Nevada.
Kolo8 News Now, available at http://www.kolotv.com/home/headlines/Heroin-Use-on-theRise-in-Nevada-243990401.html; Potter, J. (2012, October 2). Drug abuse turning deadlier in
Nevada. 2News, available at http://www.ktvn.com/story/19708773/drug-abuse-turningdeadlier-across-nevada.
56