How To Win The BSG

2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
Findthispageuseful?UsePaypaltodonateafewbuckstopayfortheserver
HOWTOWINTHEBSG(BSGONLINE)BUSINESSSTRATEGYGAME
ASHORTTUTORIALONBECOMINGACORPORATEBEHEMOTHIN12WEEKSORLESSTHE
EXPERIENCESOFSEVERALHUNDREDTEAMS,INCLUDINGADOZENGLOBALCHAMPIONSANDTOO
MANYTOP20TEAMSTOCOUNT
Note:Sincefirstpublishingthisaccountin2005,Ihavereceivednumerousreplies,accounts
andinquiriesfromotherswhohaveplayedthegameandexcelled,andhaveincludedtheir
suggestionshere.Itwasoriginallywrittenin2005andwaslastupdatedinOctober,2014.
ThispagehasnoconnectionwhatsoeverwithMcGrawHill.Itissimplyonegroupof
studentsprovidinginformationtootherswhocomeafterthem.Everysemester/termsince
thispagewasfirstposted,studentshavewrittentogivetheirowninputontheBSG,andyou
arewelcometogiveusyouradditionsalso.Wewillpostallnewinsights.Pleasedonotthink
thatyouwillautomaticallybecomeglobalchampionsbyfollowingtheadviceonthispage.
That'ssometimesasimplefeat,inregionswhereone'sneighborsaregenerallyboneheads.
It'samuchmoredifficultaffairwheredetachedobservationofthestrategyofone'sopponent
issecondnatureforall.
TheBSGonlinegameisverycomplex,withnumerousvariablesandadeceptivelysimple
frameworkwhichleavesmanystudentsstrugglingtofindastrategycapableofwinningthe
game.Grades,andforthoserelyinguponemployerpaidtuition/bookscostsdependenton
thosegrades,cansufferhorribly.Often,theclassisonlyofferedSpringtermofasenior
year.Flunkit,andyouwillatbestbeafiveyearsenior,andthelikelihoodofnotbeingable
foronereasonoranothertoreturntocompleteadegree,isverygreat.Toacertainextent,
eventhe"winners"ofthisgamearesimplythosewhoseopponentsfindthemselvesmore"at
sea".Moststudentsaresimplygiventheurlofthegame,andtoldtobeginwithverylittle
preliminaryexplanationsonthepartofaprofessor.Ifthatistrueforyou,thenyouhave
comeuponwhatwilllikelybeyourbestresourceforexplainingthegame'smechanismin
everydaylanguage.
Butthispageisnotsuperiortothegamemanual,availableatyour"CorporateLobby"
(althoughthelookofthelobbyshiftsfromyeartoyear)undertheheadingofPlayer's
Manual,whichyoushouldreadthoroughly.Atleasttwice.Ifyourinstructorgivessomefew
http://corvallistoday.com/bsgimages/bsgrev2.html
1/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
prefatoryremarksaboutthegame,listenverycarefullytoyourinstructor'sintroductiontothe
game.Doit,notbecauseyoubelieveheorshehasathoroughknowledgeofthegame.He
orsheusuallydoesNOT.Infact,fewinstructorshaverarelyplayedthegamethemselves
exceptforaninitial"dabbling"whichMcGrawHillused,tosellittothem.Infact,asthegame
goeson,manyofyoumayalreadyhavefoundwhichiswhyyou'rereadingthispagethat
theadvicegivenbyyourinstructorsisarecipeforcatastrophe.Instructorsareoftenas
deludedaboutthenatureofbusinessintheageofglobalization,asarethestudentslearning
thegame.Thoseinstructorsmaybelievethatbycarvingthisorthatnicheout,offeringa
uniqueproductwithhighqualityandlowoverhead,youwillhavebuiltaaprofitable
enterprise.Aswillbeexplainedbelow,a"profitableenterprise"isn'tgoingtocutitinthe
BSG.YouneedtohavetheMOSTprofitableenterprise.Andthat,DearReader,willcostyou
anypersonalcharacteryoumayhavemanagedtoclutchonto,after4yearsinaninstitution
whichisdedicatedtocloningcorporatevalues(youwouldn'tbeplayingthisgameifthat
wereNOTtrue)inyou.Youwillneedtoatleastpretendtosurrenderintegritytowinthis
game.
FIRSTROUND
Onemoretime,thisdoesnotmeanthatyoushouldnotlistentoyourinstructor'sremarks
becauseyoucanbankon50%oftheotherstudentsintheroomfollowingslavishlyany
recommendationsheorshemakes,eveninferentially,inthefollowinground.Andyoucan
makeyourmovesaccordingly.OurinstructorsuggestedraisingS/Qapoint"perhaps",
loweringthepriceadollar"maybe"inRound1.Doinglittleelse.Teamsmadeslight
variationshereandthere.Ofthe6otherteamsintheroom,onlytwo(TeamAandTeamF
intheexamplesbelow)madesome"radicalmove"andraisedthemodelnumbersomewhat,
alongsidechangesinS/Q,andthoseteamsdidwellintheround.ButRound1is,aboveall,
acrapshoot,asyouandyouropponentsfeelthegame,andoneanother,out.And,believe
itornotitisaroundsomechoosetolosedeliberately,tolowerstockpricesforpurchase
thefollowinground).Round1wastheonlyroundmyteam(TeamBbelow)lost
(unintentionally).Ourpricesandthusourprofitmarginswerecomparativelylowandwe
cameinfourthinEPS/ROE.Consequentlyourstockpricetanked(allowingustobuyitback
atbargainpricesthefollowinground,althoughtherearemoreprofitableapproaches),even
thoughwetookthelion'spricesinthemarket.Wetookfourth,andnotlast,place,despite
keepingourmodelnumbersataridiculouslylowlevel.Wedidn'tknowanybetteratthat
point.
ImportantConsiderationsBeforeYouCommencetheGame
McGrawHill'sonlineBusinessStrategyGameisincreasinglyapartofmanybusinessand
businessinformationcourses,worldwide.Thosewhoworkinmodernindustrieswill
recognizeitforwhatitisastrategygame,oneofseveral,suchasGloBus,allwith
remarkablysimilaralgorithms.Asastrategygame,itismostexpertlyplayedbypreteens
whospecializeinstrategygameslikeWOWorStarCraft.Businessmajorswhohavenever
workedinamoderncorporationareapttodopoorlyunlesstheyforgetmuchofwhatthey've
beentaughtinclassandrelyupontheobservationsofteammatesatworkplacesinstead.
Thosewhohaveneitherworkedforamoderncorporation,orspenttimegaming,willbeata
disadvantage.Winnerswillbethosewhofocusonthegamescores,ratherthanupon
"buildingarespectablebusiness".McGrawHilldoesnotrevealthealgorithmusedto
determineOverallScoresbutalittleanalysiswillshowtheindividualcategoriescanbe
dividedinto2categoriesbytheirweightintheoverallperformanceranking(seebelow).
Thewinningstrategyforthegameisasonestudent,andaprofessionalfromalarge
industrialcorporationbasedinTexas,notedentirelysituationalitdependsuponyour
opponents'movesaswellasyourown.Themostsuccessfulcompetitoristhusactually
planningTWOmovesatanygiventimeyourownmove,andthatofyouropponent,and
2/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
devisingmethodsofinducingtheopponenttobelieveheorsheismaking"theirmove"of
theirownvolition.Forthemostpart,thelatterwilllikelybedonebyexampleifyouare
successful,otherswilltrytocopyyourmethods,anditbecomesessentialthentomakeit
appearthattheunderlyingreasonsforyoursuccessarenotasyouknowthemtobe.Thatis
notanunrealsituationintherealbusinessworld.MOSTCEOsareincapableofdevising
originalstrategiesandinsteadspendalifetimetryingtoapeothersor"outape"thosewho
are.Benchmarking,it'scalledintherealbusinessworld.Corporationspayforasetof
statisticsalsosuppliedtoyouintheBSGofindustryaveragesandindustrylowsforcosts.
CEOswillscanacrossthisandsetatargetbelowcompetitors'costs.Onequarter,itwillbe
say,1%.Another,say3%.Infact,youcouldsitachimpatakeyboardwithnumbersonly,
andimitatethemost"brilliant"ofcorporateCEOs.Theproblemwithsuchanapproachis
that,forthenationonly,itimpliesaneverdownwardspiralofwagesandbenefitsasthe
averagekeepsfallinginthewakeoftenthousandsuchdecisionsbytenthousandsuch
chimpanzees.Andofcourse,profitmarginskeepfallingbecauseamongthese"benchmarks
tobeat"areprices.Ifyouropponentsareastute,youwillfindyourprofits/scores(andtheirs)
driftingdownwardeachround.Iftheyareidiots,youwillbecomeaGlobalChampion.So
strikeearlyandstrikehard.
Theusualbusinessmodel,evenformanufacturingcorporations,isWalmart:makeorsell
shoddygoodsatlowprices,withthelowestpossibleshareoftheprofitsmetedoutto
anyonebutmanagersandstockholders.TheidealCEOtodayhasaspirationswhichdiffer
littlefromthevisionsofaplantationowneroftheantebellumDeepSouthwhoreliedon
gangsofslavestoproduceasizableincomeforthemasterinexchangeforabowlofcorn
mush.Andtheendthatliesaheadforhimorherwilllikelydifferlittle.Peoplegenerallywill
recovertheirdignityandlivelihoodsbysomemeans,usuallyinfitsandstarts,sometimesin
cataclysm.Butinthemeantime,themasterwilllivewell,sometimesverywellindeed.That's
yourgoalinthisgame.Livingwell.Andsqueezingotherssoyouandyourmajorstock
holdersmaydoso.Ifyoucandosowithouthesitation,withoutthatmomentaryclutchingdue
toasenseofresponsibilitytoandforoneother,youarelikelytosucceedinthecorporate
worldaswellasinthisgame.Yes,you'recorrectthatIStheclinicaldefinitionofa
sociopath,butatthemoment,thelivelihoodsoftheentireplanetarecontrolledbyan
organizedbandofsociopaths,asisevidencedbythebehaviorofbankingofficialswhohave
donemoreharmtomillionsinthiscountrythananyterroristshavedreamedofdoing,and
yetbelievewithalltheirheartsthattheyarefullyentitledtotheirmilliondollarbonuses.And
thesesociopathscontinuetowalkfree,withwadsofcashintheirpockets.They're
considered"normal",andinfacttheBSGholdsthemuptoyouasrolemodels.
StrategicConsiderations
Disguiseeverysuccessfulmovewithatleast2changes,whichwillleaveyouropponents
unsureofwhichtoemulate.UsecommonbulletinboardstoVERYSUBTLY,becausethere
arethoseintelligentenoughtoguessyourgameifit'soverttolet"slip"somemishintof
thisorthatplan,orslightmisexplanationofpastsuccess.Headleftbeforedoublingback
nextmovetogorightforexample,uppingS/Q(seebelow)onenotch,onemovebefore
droppingit2notchesthefollowinground.Therearemanywaystowinthisgame,andyou
mustbeversatileifyouhaveableopponents.Thispage,asearlyas2009,wasdrawing
some3000hitsdaily180,000hitsamonth,andyoucanbetthatatleastoneisfromoneof
yourcompetitors.Ifseveralare,yourgameisgoingtobecomeverymeanveryquickly
unlessyoumakeitseemasthoughyouarecontinuallychangingyourstrategy.Every
term/semester,Icorrespondwithacoupleofdozenteamsplayingthisgame.Invariably,the
questionarises:whathappensif2ormoreteamsadoptthisstrategy?Theanswerisalso
unchanging:thegamewillgetverygrimforyouindeed,butnotnearlyasgrimasifonlyone
3/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
teamadoptsit,andthatteamisn'tYOURS.
Butneveroverestimateyouropponents:ifyouareawomanplayingmales,asknaive
questions,leadingopponentstobelieveyouareabouttodotheoppositeofwhatyouare
actuallyplanning.Letthemassumeyoursubsequent"error"isbaseduponyour"naivet"or
"hormones"ratherthanbeingabrilliantstrategicmove.Thesameistrueforethnicgroups,
whateverthenature.ThoseofEuropeanancestryinaclassdominatedbyAsiansor
Hispanics,mightplaytothehilttheideaofanignorant,arrogantjackass,whichispretty
muchhowLAandAPseethem,ratherthanofonedoingpiercingandcalculatedanalysis.
ThoseofAsianbackgroundmightplaytotheracismoftheirownEuroopponentsbyposing
asacalculatingmachineincapableofflexibleorganizationorofchangingdirection,by
insistinginpublicforumsonthecorrectnessofaparticularlypoormovebysomeotherteam,
forexample.HispanicsmightplaytotheracismofbothAsianandEuroopponentsby
pretendingtobelazyandunconcernedwithoutcomeswhileshrewdlycalculatingevery
possiblemove.Olderopponentscanplaythesamegamewithyoungerones,thelatter
assumingalackofcomputerandgamingskillsonthepartoftheformer.Findoutthe
prejudicialassumptionsheldbyyouropponentsandactverysubtlyasthoughyouare
meetingtheirexpectations.Leadthembyallusion,byseduction,orbyleavingthemonlyone
choice,upthepathtoCannae,whereyouwillplayaningenioushandandthencutout.Hide
youroccupation,ifneedbeneverletanyoneoutsideyourownteamknowthatyour
livelihood,forexample,comesfromdesigningbusinessstrategygamesforMcGrawHill.
Instead,letdropahintthatyoutinkerwithtoys,withoutbeingtoospecific.If,ontheother
hand,youareaWOWchampbutapianoteacherinyoursparetime,leadyouropponentsto
believethatallyouknowand/orareconcernedwith,isChopin.NeverforgetthatBSGisa
strategygame,anditisonyourstrategy,notyourbusinessskillsexceptinsofarasthey
areweightedbythegameitselfwhichwillyieldyourscores.
Therearemanywaystowinthisgame,butfollowingarethesomelessonslearnedfromour
experience,andfromthosewhohavesubsequentlysentustheirconclusions.Iftheirname
comesup,speakwellofthem.Thefiguresusedarethosefrommyownteam'sexperience,
buttheyarenotthebestseenincorrespondencewithotherstudents.ROEof35%earlyin
thegamearenotuncommonandoneteamfromThailandconsistentlyhitanROEof45
50%inagameof12teams.ROEintherangeof100%isnotrare.
Thegreatestmistakeyoucanmakeinthisgameistotrytorunyourfirmasarational
"business",assumingthatifyoumarketaqualityproduct,keepcostsundercontroland
showamodestprofit,withreasonabledividendsforyourshareholders,goodwagesforyour
employees,andkeepyourcreditclean,thatyouwilldojustfine.WRONG!That'sagreat
formulafora"momandpop"shop,butthefirmswhowinthisgamearethosewhohaveput
the"momandpop"shopsoutofbusiness.Theyarehugemultinationalfirmswhose
stockholdersdon'tcareonewhitaboutdividends,forexampleexceptastheyincrease
ROE/EPS.Multinationalfirmsintherealworldrarelypaydividendseither.Stockholdersin
therealworldareinterestedonlyinthepriceofstock,stockwhichtheyholdforanaverage
ofonlyoneyear,andthensellforatidyprofit.Thefutureofthefirm,beyondthatoneyear,
theyhavenointerestin,andtheyarepreparedtosacrificethefutureofthefirmandits
employeesforthevalueofthestockattheendoftheyear'stime.AnyCEOwhofailsto
sharethatviewwillsoonbeinthesameunemploymentlineasthosewhosejobstheyhave
slashedtofattenthestockprice.Thelengthofyourgame,howevermanyrounds,shouldbe
seenasequivalenttothatyearlongtermintherealworld.Ironically,losingteamswill,atthe
endofthegame,sniffdisappointedlyandpointproudlytotheirsqueakycleancreditrecord,
orsomeother"solidbusinesspractice"whichwascentraltotheirlosingthegameasa
justificationoftheirdecisions.Theywillneverunderstandthatwinningthisgamemeans
consumingeveryassetforthesakeofthecurrentsetofstockholders,andonlyforthem.
"Everyasset"includescredit.Onthispage,youwillfindemphasizedagainandagain:ifyou
4/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
playthisgameforanA+creditandamodestprofit,youWILLLOSETHISGAME.In
declaringyourstrategytoyourprofessor,rememberthis:yourgoalshouldbereturning
maximumvaluetothestockholders(Ifthatmeansholdingabakesaleintheparkinglot,you
shouldbewillingtodoso.Ifitmeansslaughteringandsellingthecarcassesofyour
accountingstaff,doso.)
STEP1
Gotothebsgportal(theappearancechangesfromyeartoyear).Youwillsee"Create
StudentAccount",whichyouwillneedtodothefirsttimeyougotothesite(http://www.bsg
online.com/).Fromthenon,youwillneedonlytologinwithyourusernameandpasswordat
thetopofthepage.Seebelow.
Ifyouarealreadyloggedin,theloginbuttonwillnotbevisibleandinsteadthelink,"Return
toYourCorporateLobby"willappear(remember,theuserinterfacecanvaryfromtermto
term).
OnthispageyouwillfindafewinterestingitemssuchasGlobalTop25,HallofFame,etc.
butforthemostpartyouwillwanttosimply"ReturntoYourCorporateLobby".
THECORPORATELOBBY
Onthe"corporatelobby"page(seebelow),youwillfind3areasmostimportanttoyou.The
firstisyourmessagesanddeadlines.Thesecondisthecurrentexchangerate.Thethirdis
usedcapacityforsaleafteraround.
Thedeadlinesareselfexplanatory.Readthemsincetheyareassignedbyyourinstructor.
Theusedcapacitywillnotapplytothefirstround.Itreferstodecisionsbyotherteamstosell
offcapacityatthebeginningofanewroundandthisinformationwillonlybeavailabletoyou
attheendofaround,whenresultsareavailable.Youwillfinditworthyourwhiletostayup
untiltheseresultsareavailable(usuallyaftermidnight)andsnatchupallusedcapacityinLA
andofteninAPsinceitishalfprice.Seebelow.Purchasedusedcapacityisavailable
immediatelyinthefollowinground.
EXCHANGERATES
Theexchangeratesareusefulinformation,althoughtheyrelatetogeopolitical
developmentsbeyondyourcontrol.Therewasatimewhenthesefluctuationswere
unpredictable,anditwastemptingtoestablishplantsinmostregionssimplyasahedge
againstthem.Thatcanbequiteexpensive.Butcurrencyratesinthegamearebasedonreal
ratesintheworldmarket.BecausetheU.S.nationaldeficitcontinuedtoriseafteritbloated
tripled,actuallyundertheBushadministration(anaveragecommunity's2008shareofthat
indebtednessevenin2005was$2billionforatownof50,000,moredebtthanthecountry
hashithertoaccumulatedthaninitsentirehistory,andtherewereyearsofdeficitsaheadas
thecountrytriedtoleverageoutofthe2ndofBush'srecessionsbyfurtherborrowing)and
personaldebthasshotthroughtheceiling(asthecurrency'spurchasingpowerhas
plunged),youcangenerallydependuponU.S.currencyhavingacumulativelossinvalueif
thethelengthofyourgameissufficientlylong(individualinstructorscansetthelengthat
will).Toacertainextent,thisdebasementoftheAmericancurrencyisdependentupon
5/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
politicaleventsintheU.S.butRepublicanadministrationsofthepast40yearshave
successivelyrunuprecorddeficitsandyetkeepprintingmoneylikegrocerychaincoupons.
Butwitha10trilliondollardebt,theU.S.haspassedthepointofreturnforcurrencystability.
TheObamaadministrationhashaltedtheaccumulationofdebtbutfartoolateinthehistory
ofthecountry'sdebttohavemuchofanimpactoncurrencyrates.
BecausetheindependentFederalReserveBoardregulatestheamountofcashflowing,
throughinterestrates,thetendencyforinflationaeuphemismforyourfallingstandardof
livingthroughthevacuumingupofyourcashforfewergoodsandservicesthrougha
mechanismofrisingpricestooccur,issomewhatkeptincheck.Butinaneraofstaggering
personal(especiallystudent)debt,currencydevaluation(anotherphraseforinflation)is
inevitable.Today,aU.S.dollarisworthlessthanthepostagerequiredtomailitinan
envelopetomanycountries.SinceLyndonJohnson,Democratsontheotherhand,have
tendedtoletpricesreflectanyindebtedness(inflation),andthepoliticalrepercussionshave
beenimmensewhenthesearenotreinedin.TheonetermpresidencyofJimmyCarterwas
theextremeexample.Thereis,since,arecognitiononthepartofDemocratsthatprices
directlyaffectedbythegovernment'soutputofdebtandcurrencymustbecontrolledexcept
intheeventofnationalcatastrophe.NationalcatastropheisaeuphemismforPearlHarbor
or8yearsofcorporateplunderunderRepublicanrule,aswasrecentlyendedin2008.Asa
consequenceboththevalueofthedollar,andinterestratestendtofluctuatelessunder
Democrats,outofselfinterest.Republicanadministrationsfunctionmorelikethe"corporate
raiders"orthemutualfundswhoownyourowncompany,caringlittleaboutthelongterm
affectsastheysiphonofftheresourcesintothepocketsofcorporateraidersoverthevery
shortterm.GeorgeBushwasn'tjokingwhenhetoldagatheringofbillionairesthat"some
peoplecallyoutheelitistrichIcallyoumybase".Andtheendresult,ofRepublicanfortunes
fallingtothelowpointsof,say,theNixonorBushadministration,doesnotleavethem
sleepless.Notonmattressesstuffedwithmillionsofdollarsdonatedbytheirmentors.They
knowAmericansarerestless,willbecomeboredwithmundanelifeunderDemocratsandwill
comeback"formore".Thehumormagazine,theOnion,headlinedthe"election"of
RepublicanGeorgeBush:"Atlast,thislong,unbrokennationalnightmareofpeaceand
prosperityhasended"Asuncomfortableasthismayleaveyou,itisessentialtoyour
understandingofthegame:theAmericandollarwillbetrashedfarmoreseverelyunder
Republicanadministrationthanotherwise.
Theexceptiontothefallingvalueofthedollarisinmomentsoftotalfinancialcollapseinthe
U.S.,whenthemultinationalsfinditnecessarytopulloverseasassetsintotheU.S.inorder
topaydowndebt.Thisisapurelytemporarydevelopmentandwillbefollowedbymorelows
fortheU.S.dollarastheeconomyrecovers,evenslightly.Theselows,ofcourse,translate
intoadeclininglivingstandardforAmericansingeneral,astheyareunabletopurchasethe
samequantitiesofgoodsasheretofore.
Thedollar'svalueisnowatthelowestithasbeeninnearly30years,sincetheReagan
administration.Thismeansyourpricesaregoingtobeveryvolatile:moreexpensiveraw
materials,andfinishedshoesfromLA,NA,andEAwillcostmoreintheUS.Itmeansthe
profitsofyourproductsmadeinplantsabroadwillbelower.Andinelectionyears,theycould
beveryvolatileasthemarketsanticipateresults.
TherelativedropoftheU.S.currency,however,willaffectonlythevalueofthedollarversus
theJapaneseyen/Singaporedollar/Chineseyuanandtheeuro.Thevalueofthedollar
relativetotheBrazilianrealdependsalmostentirelyuponeventsinBrazil,whichare
increasinglylesspromisingthan,say,adecadeago.Thedevelopmentofcivilwarbetween
6/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
thegangs,whodominatetheincreasinglydesperatefavelas(slums),andthearmy,seriously
disturbstherealwhenmajoroutbreakswhichattimesareonthebrinkoflargescale
warfareoccur.ThisfluctuationinBraziliancurrency,uponwhichalltradewithLAinthe
gameisbased,isastrongargument(alongsidelowerwagespaidtoLatinoworkers
comparedtotheU.S.orEuropebymultinationalfirms),forplanningafactoryinLAwitha
capacity,eventually,ofatleast3000.ThecurrentpartyinBrazilistryingtoremedythe
situationsinthefavelas,andthereiscurrentlyanexpansionoftheBrazilianeconomy.It
wouldbedifficulttopredicttheeffectofthisoncurrencyexchangerates.
Donot,then,buildsmallerplantsineveryregiononthepremisethatwidecurrency
fluctuationswilljustifytheinvestment.FocusonlargeplantsinAP/LAandavoidbuildingin
theU.S./EA.Infact,youshouldnotbuildsmallerplantsinANYregion.Anyteamwitha
dreamofbuildingasmallcustomplantturningoutcustomized"nicheshoes",ofverygood
quality,say,willbeveryquicklydisabusedoftheworkabilityofsuchascheme.Thegame,
asdoescorporatereality,shutsoutsmalleroperationswhichdonotfocusonproducinglow
qualitygoodsatverylargefacilitiesi.e.,atthelowestpossiblefixedcostpershoe.Ifyou
can'taffordtobuildthesemegafacilities,youcan'taffordtobeintheshoebusiness.So
borrow,borrowborrow(seebelow),oryourfirmwillsurelydie.
Thisis,ofcourse,areflectionoftheBSG'sobsolescence.Intherealbusinessworldtoday,
thecostsofmaintainingplantcapacity,after40yearsofcorporationsusing"Benchmarks"to
shedcosts(andprofitmargins,incidentally),havecometobecompletelyavoidedby
outsourcingproductiontoothers.AdidasandNikescanbemadeatthesamemanufacturing
plantinAsiaorevenintheCzechRepublic.Factoriesarenotownedbythecorporations
identifiedwithaproduct.Ifmoreproductionisneeded,alargerorderissimplyplaced.This
isanotherpartofthegamewhichisafossilfromanearliereraofdoingbusiness.Today,a
farsightedlargecorporationwhichhasseenprofitsslide,doesnotfocusonlyoncutting
costsandwatchingothersapethem,withsubsequentfallsinprofit.Suchafirmwillinstead
expand(usuallyvertically,tobuy,forexample,afirmspecializingindyesforshoes
subsequentmergingofmarketing,maintenance,informationetc.allowingslighteconomies
ofscale.Moreimportantly,theycreateanewssplashwhichbooststhepriceofstock
slightly.Shareholdersthusseeaslightincreaseintheirprofitwhensellingthestock,andit
reallydoesn'tmatterifthefutureofthefirmisrelinquishedbythesizeofthenewdebttaken
ontobuythefirm.Onlytheshorttermtheperiodbetweenstockpurchaseandsale
matters.)
DECISIONENTRIES
Afterlogginginandchoosing"ClickHereToEnterY...Decisions",youwillbetakentothe
secondaryportalwhereyouwillchoosetheDecisionEntriesPage.
ThispageisactuallytheRESULTofyourmostimportantdecisions.Itisnottheplaceto
enterthem.First,goinsteadtotheFinanceandcashflowpage(youcangetthereusingthe
tabatlowerleftonyourBrandedSalesForecastpage).
THEFINANCEANDCASHFLOWPAGE:BORROWING,STOCKDIVIDENDS
Thisiswhereyouwillborrowmoney.Inthefirstfewrounds,youwillborrowthemaximumin
longterm(10year)loans(usually$250million).Don'tallowyourfiscalconservatismtogetin
thewayofyourwinningthegame.Byfocusingonthosescoreswhicharemostimportant,
youwillinevitablyyieldgroundoncreditratinginallbutthelateroundstothoseneophytes
whoarefocusedonperformingtheirroleasconservativefinancialofficers(CFOs),tothe
detrimentoftheirteam'soverallperformance.Mostinstructorsmakeuseofabulletinboard
7/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
whichyouwillfindworthsnickeringoverattheendofthegame,withlosingteams
congratulatingthemselvesonmaintainingtheirsuperiorcreditratingaswellasadozen
otherdeficienciesintheirgame.Borrowingheavilyisessentialtothewinningofthisgame.
YouwillNOTwinthisgameifyouyourgoalisanA+creditrating.YouSHOULDtrytonever
planforaroundwithacreditratinglessthanB+,althoughyoumayfindthat,inthegame
itself,yourcreditmayfalleventoConanoccasion.Youwillnotbefocusinguponrational
investmentdecisionsbutuponpredatoryones.Sleazebagshouldbecomeyourmiddlename
forthedurationofthegame.Saveyourmoraloutrageandfiscalresponsibilityfortheday
whenyouaredonewithyoursillydegreeandcanmakeyouroutrageknownelsewhere,in
thestreets,inthewayyouliveyourlife.
Inearlyrounds,youwillbeborrowingtoexpandcapacityandupgradeequipment,aswellas
tobuystockback.Inroundone,youshouldtrytoexpandyourstartingcapacityinAP,and
expandthemaximumallowedforanewplantinLA(usually2000capacity,sometimes
1000).Sincenewplantcapacityfor1000isgenerallyintherangeof35million,youwillbe
abletostartanewplantinLAandusetheremaindertoincreasethesizeofyourAPplant
aswellasupgradeforsetupsandbuybacksomestock.Yoursuccessdependsuponyour
productioncapacity.Letmerepeatthat,sinceit'ssoimportantinthegame:yoursuccess
dependsuponyourproductioncapacitywithoneproviso,addedbyastudent/senior
managerinTexas:productioncapacityneedstobehingedon"economyofscale":by
increasingyourcapacityinspecificenvironments,younotonlyincreasetheabilitytosatisfy
anymarketdemand,butalsolowerthecostofyourshoes,sincefixedcostsarespreadover
everlargernumbersofshoes.Thus,asingleplantof8,000inoneregionisvastlysuperior
toplantsof2500ineachof4regions,despitetheseeminginferiorityinnumbers.Eachplant
operatesindependently.Thatis,your4plantsdonotoperateasasingle10,000unitplant,
andfixedcostsarespreadonlyoverthenumberofshoesproducedinaregion.To
understandtheroleoffixedcosts,imaginethatthecostofmaintaining,ataplantoffixed
dimensions,atemperatureof68degreesis$1000,spreadoutover100shoes.Thepriceof
eachshoemustbethensaddledwithanaverageof$10forheatingcosts.If,instead,the
sameplantproduces10,000shoes,eachshoemustbearacostofonedimeforheating.
Thelatterplant'sshoecosts,andthusprices,willreflectcostsnearly$10lessthanthe
former.Thesameistrueoflandscaping,roadmaintenance,powerlines,keepingaCEOin
thestyletowhichheorshehasbecomeaccustomed,etc.
Inround1,yourcreditratingisasgoodasitwilleverbeinthegame.Youwillwantto
borrowextensivelytotakeadvantageofthisrelativelylowinterestrate.Useonlylongterm
(10year)loanswhenpossible.Butborrow.Extensively.Eachround.Therewillbethose
businessmajorswhohaveneverworkedinthecorporateworldwhoarguethatthisrepeated
borrowingsaddlesthecompanywithlongtermdebtswhichwillultimatelydoomitto
extinction.They'reright.Whocares?Yourgame,andthusyourfirmhasalimitedlife
anyway.Pillagingit,isyourkeytosuccess.Whenyouwalkaway,asthestockholdersinthe
financialsectorhavedoneundertheBushadministration,youwilllookoveryourshoulder
andseewhattheydoacarcasswherethefirmoncestood.
Andthisisreality,inasense.IntheAmericanbusinessworldtoday,companyownersare
nolongerthecompanyownersofyourgrandmother'sday.Theydonotgiveahangabout
thelongtermviabilityofthecompany.TheycareonlyaboutthestockpricenextThursday
sotheycansellitonFriday.IfthecompanycollapsesonSaturday,throwingeveryoneelse
outofwork,andallthesmaller,orlatepurchasing,stockholdersintobankruptcycourt,
today's"owners"willyetsleepwell.Legally,acorporatedominatedSupremeCourthas
twicedeclaredthatcorporationsare"individualhumanbeings"andhaveallthe"rights"that
peopledo,withtheownershavingnoresponsibilityfortheirdeedsoftheircreation,orforits
employees'(CEOs')malfeasance.Theirony,ofcourse,isthatmanyoftheselargestock
holdersaregenerallymutualfundswhosecapitalisbeingprovidedbythepensionfundsof
8/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
theveryworkerstobetossedoutoftheirjobsnextweek.They,andweasanation,arethus
committingcollectivesuicidebysquirreling401Kfundsintotheseinstitutions,butthat'sthe
realityofthingstoday.UndertheBushadministration,corporationshadunchallengedrule,
andasaconsequenceof8yearsofsucharegime,themostbasicofhumanneeds
housing,foodandfuelarenowinjeopardyforthecountry.Wehavebeenusedupand
squeezeddry.WemakenothingintheU.S.anymoreandwehavenomoneylefttosiphon
offtothelikesofHalliburton,MonsantoorWachovia.Asaconsequence,itisthewealthof
futuregenerationsdebt,whetherprivateorpublicthattheyarelefttofocusupon.
Besidesmutualfunds,theothermajorplayersintheworldtodayarepooledfundsunderthe
tutelageofasinglepersonalitysuchasWarrenBuffet,andtheyalsohavelittleconcernfor
thefutureofthecompaniestheydivestthemselvesof,aftertakingaprofitonthepriceof
stockoneofthemoreimportantscoresinthegame.That'sreality,andthat'sreflectedin
thegametosomeextent.Buffethimselfseemstobeaverydecentperson,buthe'sworking
agamewhichisnothonest.Andhe'sworkingitverywellindeed.Itis,afterall,currentlythe
onlygameintownforhimtoplay.
Somestudentsobjecttotherealityof"banks"extendingloanstocompaniesexpanding
rapidlyinamarketwherecapacitycanoftengreatlyexceeddemand,asitusuallywill.That
isoflittleconcerntoyou,andthefactofthematteristhatalargecorporationwillalwaysfind
waysofraisingmoneyfromunwittingshillswhenneeded.Itmaybefromissuingvarious
sortsofquestionablenotesbackedbylittlemorethanthe"vision"spewingfromapower
drunkenCEO,orgovernmentbailouts,butitwillcomefromsomewhere.Itmaybefrom
fraud,orfromfromlegislationpassedby"friendly"(corrupt)legislators,granting"taxbreaks".
Forexample,hereinOregon,Abillpassedbythelegislature,ostensiblyintendedtofund
windenergy,allowedWalmarttobuy$40millionintaxcreditswhichallowedthecorporation
toevade$90millionintaxes,givingthema$50millionwindfalltouseforequallyprofitable
investments.SimilarfundingmaycomefromboostingATMfeesoroffshorebanking
schemes(Googleforexample,shipsitsprofitsthroughIrelandtoBermudawithataxrateof
amere2%.That'scalled"moneylaunderingwhengangstersdoit.Whencorporationsdoit,
it'scalled"offshoring".).Infact,ifthebankingpoliciespermittedbytheBushadministration
provednothingelse,theyprovedthatbanksarejustasliabletosacrificethelongterm
viabilityofafirmforprofitsandstockpricesrisingoveraveryshortterm.Likeother
corporationstheyareresponsibleonlytothecurrentcropofshareholders.
Asaconsequence,themoneywillcomefromsomewhere,foraperiodoftime,and
coincidentallythisgamehasafiniteperiodofplay.Inthegame,allsuchsourcesare
collectivelylabeled"thebank".Andtheworstpunishmenttobeincurredforlargedebtshort
ofbankruptcyisincrementalinterestrises,whichhopefullywillbringthecompanytoits
welldeserveddeaththeweekafteryourgameendswithyourwin.Meantime,borrow.
Borrow.Borrow.
Again:inthefirstround,youwillwanttogreatlyincreasecapacityinAPifyoupossiblycan.
StayoutofEA.Oncemore:STAYOUTOFEA.Youwillalsowanttoborrowtoinvestforthe
maximumcapacityallowedinLA,whichinourgamewas1000initially,butwhichcanbe
increasedbyyourprofessor.Ifyoursisa1000limit,thenthefollowinground,theshoesin
LAwillbeveryexpensive,asthefixedcostsoftheplantwillbespreadoverasmallnumber
ofproducts,andprofitmarginswillbethinifyoukeepthepricescompetitive.However,in
subsequentrounds,asothersfollowyouintoLAandsomewillfollowyou(thesheep
instinct,again)youwillhaveafullplantinoperationasthey,inturn,openalimitedfacility
andyouwilltrouncethemintheregion.Thecurrencyfluctuations,andaccompanying
9/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
exchangerates,inLA,canbesovolatilethatthepresenceofalargeplantintheregionis
essential.Andwagesaresooppressivelycheap,andworkingconditionsandenvironmental
lawssoweakandpathetic,thatanLAplantisimmeasurablycheapertooperate.In
subsequentrounds,youarepermittedtoexpandonlyby50%afigurewhichcanbe
adjustedbythepowersthatbe)soRound2,youwilladd50%totheLAregion,andin
Round3,50%again(50%of1000+500inourgame).Atthatpointyourplantisfully
operational,thoughfurtherexpansionisdesirableatleastto3000.InAPand
subsequentlyinLAtooyoumaywanttoexpandcapacityineveryregionby1000each
roundinthebeginning,ifyoucan,afterincreasingAPcapacityinthefirstround.Alwayspick
upusedAP/LAcapacityothersofferforsale.FromthecalculationsofastudentinBangkok,
theidealyouareshootingforearlyistohaveatleasttwicetheaveragemarketshare
averageforateambytheendofthegame,andtwicethecapacityofyournearest
competitorineachregionpreferablyfromthefirstroundforward.Forexample,if6teams
areplaying,thenyouwouldexpectanaverageteamtohave16.7%averagemarketshare.
Youareshootingforcapacitywhichwouldallowyoutohave33%then,ifyouchosetoputit
allinthebrandedmarket.Alternatively,if10teamsareplaying,eachshouldaverage10%of
themarket,andyouareshootingfor20%.Projectedmarketdemandsforfutureyears(which
canbevariedbyindividualinstructors)willprovideyouwiththecapacitynumbersneededto
giveyouthesenumbers.Alwaysplanforaslightlygreatercapacitythanthesenumbers
indicate,sinceactualmarketdemand(whichappearstobedeterminedbyaprobability
algorithmbuiltintothegame)willattimesexceedprojections.Butplantheseincreases
"reasonably",althoughyoucanalwayssellcapacityasyouwillyourNAplantinaglut.
Axiom:Yoursuccessinthegamewillbedirectlylinkedtoyourpracticeofeconomyofscale
andyourbreadthofline(modelnumber:seebelow)aswellaslimitedstockownership.
REPEATTHAT:youwillwinonlyifyouhavealargerplantthanyouropponentinaregion,
haveasmanyormoremodelnumbers,andnomoreorfeweroutstandingsharesofstock
thanyouropponent.
Sayitagain.
Again:inthefirstround,youwillwanttoincreasecapacityinAPifyoupossiblycan.Stayout
ofEAasaproductionsource(althoughtheEAmarketislucrative).Oncemore:STAYOUT
OFEAasamanufacturingsource.ASouthAfricanstudentpointedoutthatthegameis
Eurocentricinthisrespect.ThewagesinBurundi,forexample,havelittletodowiththe
wagesinBritain,yettheEAfactoriesareorientedtowardthelatter.ArgumentsthatAfricais
toosmalltomerititsownregionarefacetious.Thereare1billionAfricans,whichdwarfsNA
insize.AsimilarcontradictionexistsinAP.Japaneseworkersearnwagesfarhigherthan
theMalaysianorVietnameseworkersthegameenvisions(Infact,Japaneseautoworkers
makeadollaranhourmorethanAmericanautoworkers.It'sinthebenefitpackageonlythat
JapaneseautomanufacturershavelowercoststhaninNA,becauseofNationalHealth
Insuranceandthelike,whichpushapartofthecostsontothepublicasawholeratherthan
ontothecorporation).
BigDeal:thegameissimplyracistandethnocentric.Livewithit.Itwasdesignedin
Alabama.Youwereexpectingsomethingelse?
Thiscapacityexpansionmaywellcometoahaltwithaninstructor'sinterventionatsome
point,onoccasionwithaninstructorabsolutelyforbiddingfurtherexpansion,andforothers,
withprofessorialpenaltiesforexcesscapacity.Morefrequently,aninstructorintervenesby
10/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
increasingmarketsizewhichwilleffectivelyshrinkyourmarketshare.Sincemarketshareis
halfthedeterminingfactorinimage,italsoaffectsyourimagerating.Soexpandrapidlyearly
on.
Marketshareinearlystagesofthegameisaliabilityasmuchasanassetifyousetyour
priceslow.Ifyouselleveryshoeyouhave,ataprofitof,say$7,andyournextbest
opponenthasa"deal"forthepublicatadollarhigher,ataprofitof$8,andyoucanonly
produceenoughshoestomeethalfthedemand,theotherhalfwillfalltoyourcompetitorby
default.Eachofyouwillhavehalfofthemarket,withtheirhalfyieldinghigherprofits.They
willwineveryroundplayedinsuchafashion.Inreality,therearemoreteamsandmore
factorsinvolved,butyougetmydrift.YourROEandEPSwilldriftlower,andyourstock
pricewillsufferthroughoutthegameunlessyoucanbegintomeetdemandforyourshoes.
Andbecauseyouaren'tabletodeliver,thenumberofretailerswillingtohandleyour
productsnextroundwillshrinkthenumberofretailersisnotamajorfactor,butafactor
nonetheless.
Inborrowinginround1(andeveryroundthereafter),youwillwanttocompareyourcurrent
interestratewiththatontheoutstandingloansassignedyourcompanyatthebeginningof
thegame.Youmayfinditcheapertorefinancecalled"EarlyRepaymentofLoan"onthe
financepage)theoutstandingpartofthoseloansalongsidenewloansforexpansionand
inRound1youwillwanttoborrowprimarilyforrapidexpansionandbuyingstockback.If,
forexample,yourcompanyhasbeenassignedanoutstandingprinciplewhichis30%ofthe
maximumallowedforlongtermloans,atahigherinterestratethanonalongtermloanyou
cancurrentlytakeout,youwillnotwanttoborrowthatamountonly,topaydowntheloanat
alowerinterestrate.Youwillwanttoborrowthemaximumallowedinlongtermloansand
useittoincreaseyourAPproductioncapacitybyatleast25%ifatallpossible.Yourstock
priceisatapremiumontheeveRound1too,andyoumaynotwanttowinthisroundina
largeway.Infact,youmaywanttoloseit,sothatyourstockpricetanksandyoucanuse
the2ndroundtobuyitbackmuchmorecheaply(seebelow).Borrowthemaximuminlong
termloanstostartaplantinLA,andtoincreaseyourcapacityinAPinRound1,anddo
thesetupupgradeintheAP.InRound1,wemadethemistakeofborrowingearlyonto
investinvariousplantupgradesalongsideexpandingcapacity,ratherthanfocusingonlyon
thelatter.Youcandotheupgradesinlaterrounds,whichisabetteridea.
Theexceptionistheproductionsetupupgrade.Asplantsandmodelnumbersexpand,this
upgradebecomesprohibitivelyexpensive,andyetthesavingsbecomeevermoreimmense.
Dothisupgradeasrapidlyaspossible(seeplantcapacitybelow).Byinvestinginitwhile
plantsaresmall,thebenefitisinheritedasplantsgrowandcostoftheupgradeisnothing
additional.
StockDividends:Thegamedoesnottrackthesizeofthedividends(exceptaspartof
EPS/ROEandequity),onlywhetheritincreasesordecreases.Setthestockdividendlowat
thispoint.Weputitat$.05annuallyandaddedapennyeveryyearsothatattheendofthe
6thround,wewereshellingoutadime.Thatgaveusascore(+/)of5/1inraising/lowering
thedividends.Otherteamswhichtriedtoimpressthe"investors"werepayingout$12in
Round1butnecessarilydroppingthemeveryroundfollowingforascoreof1/5,orroughly
25timeslowerthanours.TheincreasedROEyoupostwillmorethancompensateforthe
smallsizeofthedividend.However,it'simportanttorememberthatlowerdividendsmean
thatprofitsarebeingplowedbackintothebusiness,whichmeanshigherequityforthefirm,
andthisequityisadenominatorinoneofthefinancialscores(netprofitdividedbyequity).If
youhaveinvestedheavilybutstillhaveatonofcashlayingaroundandexpecttodosofor
11/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
futurerounds,increaseyourdividendpayments.Otherwise,simplyincreasethemeach
roundbyaminimalamount,inourcaseapenny.
EXCEPTION:Thelastround,bywhichtimeyoushouldhaveyourearlyloanslargelypaid
off,youcanborrowthemaximumallowedyouin10andeven5yearloansprovidedyour
creditdoesn'tfallbelowaB+asaresultandhanditouttostockholders.Itwillgreatly
increaseyourROEandswingaclosegameyourway.Ofcourse,thiswillleavefuture
stockholders/generationswithastaggeringdebtthatwillsurelydragthecompanytoits
death.Meantime,thestockwillsurge,andtheCURRENTstockholderswillrewardYOUwith
yourbonusandbothyouandtheycanwalkawaybeforethepyramidschemecrumbles.
That'showbusinessisdonethesedays.Ifyou'veanydoubts,youcanexaminethehistory
ofthemortgagecompaniesrecently.
StockBuybacks
Ifyourstockpricetanksafterthefirstroundyouareinluck,ifyouaresmartandmake
arrangementstobuystockback.Weinplanningthefollowingroundscouldborrow
enoughtobuybackallthestocksharespermitted(2,500,000of10,000,000shares)in2
roundsandtherestofthegameweweredividingby3(theremaining7,500,000shares)
whileothersweredividingby4(theoriginal10millionshares)inROE/EPScalculations
givingthemanautomatic33.3%disadvantageinscoringuntil2otherteams"caughton"late
inthegameanddidlikewise.3of7teamsactuallysoldshares,increasingthenumberby
20%andfurtherdisadvantagingthem.Thus(seebelow),itmaybetoyouradvantageto
ensurethatyourstockDOEStankinround1.HoweveritisNEVERtoolatetobuystock
back.If,lateinthegame,yourstockhasrisensignificantlyinprice,andyoucan'taffordto
buybackallofitinacoupleofrounds,rememberthatthebulkofacompany'sequityisin
thestockvalue.Buyingupevenafewhundredsharesatveryhighpricesreducestheequity
considerable.ROEisreturn/equity.DecreasingthesizeofthedenominatorincreasesROE.
ThesameistrueofEPS=Earnings/numberofshares.Decreasingthedenominatoralso
increasesEPS.IhaveseenlatebuyoutofexpensivestockresultinROEofhundredsofper
cent.BUTNEVERSELLSHARES.Toidiots,sellingshareslookslikefreemoney.Butyou
don'tneedto"dothemath"toseeit'samistake.Thegamewilldothemathforyou.You
needonlytobeABLEtodoit,toseetheerrorinsuchamove.
PLANTCAPACITY
Havingsetyourstockdividendandarrangedyourloansasmentionedabove,gotothePlant
Capacitytab:
Useyourmoneytoincreaseyourcapacitydramaticallyanddothe"facilitiesupgradeto
reduceproductionrunsetupby50%"onlyontheAPlineinRound1,insofarasyoucan
withthemoneyavailabletoyou.OncetheLAlineisupafterthe2ndor3rdroundthen.,
12/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
dependinguponthesizeofthemarket(whichisafunctionofthenumberofteamsina
game),youlikelywillsellofftheNAplant.That,ofcourse,entailscatastropheforallthose
workingattheplant,butthegameisdesignedtoimmunizeyouagainstanyfeelingsof
remorseorempathy.Whenyougotoworkforglobalcorporations,youwillneedthat
immunity.Youwillnotbeusingsuchverbosephrasessuchas"sellingoffcapacity"instead
youwillbeusingacronymsdesignedtoevenfurtherremoveyoufromrealities."Westroveto
reduceXPCandDGRby80%butweonlymanaged65%"orsomesuch,whichistranslated
from"managementspeak"intoPlainEnglishas"wefailedtointroducethemiseryand
hardshipweplannedinto12,000ofthe35,000householdswehadplannedto"(impliedis:
"butwewillmakethemsufferthenextquarterinstead").
Whenyou'vefinishedenteringthesedecisions,moveontotheBrandedProductionpage.
PercentageofSuperiorMaterials:
Ostensibly,thecostofsuperiormaterialsissetbyworldcommodityprices,buttheexact
natureandsourceofthesepricesinthegameisasecretknownonlytoMcGrawHill.We
couldneverfigureouttheexactalgorithmalthoughsupplyanddemandamongtheteams
involvedinyourclassisahugefactor.Leatherisinvolved,asyoucanseebytrackingthe
weeklycostincommoditymarketsandlookingatthegame'sprices.Barringsomedisaster
suchasmadcowdiseaseorahoofandmouthoutbreakresultinginthemassslaughterof
thousandsofcows,thesecostswillfluctuateslightlyfromweektoweek(dueto
supply/demandfluctuations)forplantsoutsidetheU.S.,solongastheyarebuyingU.S.beef
(beefproductionisincreasingworldwide)andtheAmericandollar'sdebasementcontinues
unchecked.Thiswillbeoffsetsomewhatbytheincreasing"cultivation"ofcattleintoChina
(AP)andtheincreasingwillingnessofIndia(AP)tosendcowstoslaughterinspiteof
religiousimpulses(thehypocritically"devout"uppercasteHindussimplyoutsourcethe
"taboo"jobtoothers).Butthatoffsettingisalllikelytounravelascattlefeedcorn,primarily
goestobiofuel.Itmayevenbeundonecompletelybythetrend.LAhasalwaysbeena
largecattleproducingregionandtheongoingrazingoftherainforestbycattlebaronsonly
promisesmoreofthesame.Yet,heretoo,thebiofueldemandbyoilcompaniesis
threateningcattleproduction.Regardless,thepriceswillrisediscerniblyoverthecourseof
thegameasteamsincreasetheirS/Q(andmanywill),providedaworldwideeconomic
recessiondoesnottakeplace,asinevitablywilloccur.That'fluctuationwillespeciallybetrue
ascapacityexpandsamongyourcompetitors.Yeteachregionwillneedtobeconsidered
separately.Insomeregions,youwillfindthepercentageofrawmaterialsaremost
effectivelysetashighas35%,onoccasioneven50%,butasageneralrule,10%20%is
adequateforanS/Qof,say,5,dependinguponthechoicesyoumakeelsewhere.On
occasion,6%willbesufficientandeven0forverylowS/Q.Needlesstosay,theshoddier
andcheaperthematerialsyoucangetawaywith,thebetterforyourpricesandprofits.
Neverthinktwiceaboutthefactthatyourshoeswillfallapartonfirstwearing.That'snota
reallifebusinessdecision,anditdoesn'tfactorintothegameeither.Thereisnoscorefor
thesustainabilityoftheplanetinvolvedinmakingfewershoesofgreaterlongevity.The
CorporateResponsibilityscoresarewindowdressing.Thesocalledgreendecisionspage
hasnoimpactonyourscorewiththeexceptionofconservingelectricity(seebelow).
Generally,then,afigureof1218%isused.ItshouldNEVERexceed20%exceptin
exceptionalcases.
Findingthispageuseful?Donateafewbuckstokeeptheservergoing
13/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
EnhancedStyling:
Theimpactofenhancedstylingoneachofthe4marketregionsvaries.Inround1,youwill
wanttoexperimentwithvaryingtheenhancedstyling/features,percentageofsuperior
materials,thechangeinannualbasewages,andincentivepaytoseewhichsetoffigures
resultsinthelowestpossibleTotalCostofManufacturesShoesatthebottomofthepage.
Thesepercentageswillnotonlyvaryfromregiontoregion,butfromroundtoround.Insome
regions,enhancedstylingwillbemosteffectiveat0,andinothers,from10to15,depending
uponyourchoicesfortheothervariables.Initially,itwilllikelytakeyouanhour,atleast,to
trythevariouspermutationspossibleineachregion,butasthegameprogresses,youillfind
ittakesnomorethanafewminutes.Thisgamewilloftenbedecideduponpenniesso
initiallyputthebulkofyourtimehere.Bychangingthevariouscombinations,youwillfindthe
TotalManufacturingCostofBrandedShoesatthebottomofthepageshifts.Getthisfigure
downaslowaspossible.Andrememberthatintheageofglobalization,shoddygoodsare
notaliability.I'vecorrespondedwithteamswhosemembersinsisttheydon'twanttheir
namesassociatedwithlowqualityproducts.Ifyoufeelthatwaytoo,thenpleaseanswerme
this:"where,peuttre,areyouplanningtoworkaftergraduation?Qualitytodayisnothing
morethanamarketingslogan.Itdoesn'texistinthecorporateworld.Youdon'tbelongin
shoemanufacturing.Insteadofbeingenrolledinthisinstitution,youshouldbeworkingwith
anorganicgardenerorahandcrafttoymaker.Youwouldfindmoresatisfactionandfeel
betteraboutyourwork.Andyou'llcomeclosetobeingstarvedtodeath.Therearesevere
negativeconsequencesforqualityandintegrityintoday'smarketplace.
TQM/SixSigma,BestPracticesTraininginRound1:
SpendingthemaximumonTQMandespeciallyBestPracticesisa"must".Theseare
cumulativeinvestmentsandbytheendofthegame,BestPracticesinvestmentswillbe
saving$12apair.ThemaximumonTQMisusually$2.50.$5,000isusuallyasgoodasyou
candowithBestPractices.KeepspendingthemaximumonBestPracticesuntilthefinal
rounds,whenthecumulativevalueforthenonexistentfutureisofnopurpose.InRound1,it
willappearasthoughtheyaresimplyincreasingyourcosts.Theyare,buttheyarean
investmentinthefuturewhichisjustifiedbythereturnsdowntheroad.Ifyouhaveto
sacrificeoneortheother,lowerTQM.
Thisis,bytheway,themostunrealisticpartofthegame.TQMcircleswerea"buzzword"in
theNinetieswhenthegamecameofage.ThesuccessofTQMdependsuponaneducated
workforcecapableofanalyzingproductioncostsandfailuresstatistically,andalsoupon
therebeingnolessexpensivemeansofcuttingcosts.TheAmericanworkforceisfrombeing
trainedbyemployerstobemathematicallyliterateanddependsentirelyuponmanagement
producedstatisticalanalysis.Ratherthandevotetheconsiderablelaborcostsinholding
regularmeetingstotrainemployeestoanalyzetheseresultsviaTQM,itisfarlesscostlyto
simplyimplementanychangesbyfiat.ThegaininworkermoraleviaTQMtoutedbythe
method'sproponentsiseasilyoffsetbyhiringimmigrantsorrecentcollegegradsdesperate
forworkatevenminimalwages,workingthemtodeathandthenriddingoneselfofthem
whentheyareburnedout.Andthequalityoflifeofotherhumanbeings,ontheprioritylistof
CEOs,ranksaboutthesameastheideaofpersonallyrecyclingcoffeegroundsintheflower
potsonthewalkwaystotheirsuites.Theyaredevoidofempathy,andthegameisdesigned
toridyouofyours,asisthecurriculumyou'refollowingorelseyouwouldn'tbeplayingthis
game.YoucouldtaketheheartofmostCEOs(anduniversityprofessorsandpresidentsfor
thatmatter)andstickitinthebellybuttonofanantandstillhaveampleroomforhisorher
brain.Ifyougettothisstagetoo,congratulationsyou'veshakenyourstatusasmere
sociopath.Theinabilitytofeelempathyistheclinicaldefinitionofthemuchmoreserious
psychopath.
14/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
Butthisaspectofthegameisrealisticinthatitshowsthatthefocusofacompany'sfinancial
investmentinbetterproductionisalwaysintermsofoverhypedprocess,ratherthan
focusingontheactualjobsatisfactionofemployees.Collegebusinessclassescontinueto
pretendasthoughQualityCirclesorevenanemphasisonqualityarearealityin
Americanbusinesslife.Theyarenot.You'dfinditdifficulttofindasinglefirmwith"Total
Quality"circlesthesedays.Getcostsdown,gettheshoddiestpossibleproductsoutthe
door.It'saWalmartera:move'emin,slop'emdown,move'emout.Butthecollegebiasin
thegamewillbeaccommodatedbytheastuteplayer.SospendsomeonTQMand
squanderthemaximumononBestPractices(say,$5000).Itfitsthegame'sdesign.
Wages
Asthemanualpointsout,currentstandardsoflivinginAPandLAareonly20%ofthosein
NAandAP,andthecorporationsinvolvedabroadwilldowhateverisnecessarycoup
d'etats,faked"elections"boughtandpaidfor,etc.tokeepthoseratios.Thecurrent
destructionrampantinHaiti,forexample,beganasasimpleattempttoraisewagesata
baseballfactory.Thesuccessiveattemptstoisolatetheregimefavoringsuchattempts,and
thesuccessivecoupsandcountercoups,havecombinedwithanearthquaketobringthe
countrytoruin.Andbecauseofit,wagesatthebaseballfactoryarelowerthaneverbefore.
AndtheironyofitallisthatAmericanswhoseownbaseballfactorieshaveclosedintheface
oftheselowwages,wereprobablythefirsttosignupforthearmyandjoinintheinitial
occupationofthecountry.Andjoyfully.Howeveryoufeelaboutitasanethicalorself
preservationissue,youhavetoadmitit'sastrokeofbrillianceonthepartofUScorporations
tohaveeffectedsucharemarkablescenario.Similarscriptshaveplayedthemselvesoutin
theUSoverCuba,Venezuela,andelsewhere.Atthemoment,forexample,theChinese
governmenthasinstitutedaseriesoflaborreformstopermitmigrantworkersatAmerican
factoriesinChinatoseebetterwagesandworkingconditions.Americancorporationsissued
aseriesofthreatsthatledtotheguttingofapartofthesereforms.Andthosesame
Americanworkerswhosejobsarebeingexportedabroadbecauseofsubstandardwages,
workingconditionsandenvironmental/healthregulations,wouldbeshovingtobefirstinline
tomanthewarshipsdockingatChineseportsinavainattempttoenforceAmericansuper
power.Athirdofthepopulationwouldbedrivingaround,encouragingthesechumpswith
"VetsareHeroes"bumperstickers.Childlaborethicsbedamned.Quaintsustainability
issuesbedamned.Thelongtermconsequences,creatingadeepandabidingresentmentof
theU.S.aroundtheworldculminatingindevelopmentslike"9/11",isofnomoreconcernto
youinthisgamethanitistothe"owners"ofsimilarcompaniesintherealworld.NoCEOsor
BoardMembersdiedinNewYork.Onlypeoplewho"don'tmatter".Peoplelikeyou.
Theeffectivenessofraisingwageswillvaryradicallyfromregiontoregion,andwillshiftfrom
roundtoround,dependinguponsuchseeminglyunrelatedfactorsascapacityormodel
numbers.Itwillusuallybelessthan5%andmaybezeroincases.Incentivepayfollowsthe
sameruleofthumb,with.20.40usuallyyieldingthelowestcostforshoes.Playwithas
manypermutationsaspossibleamongthese2,andwithmaterialsandstylingtoachievethe
lowestpossiblecostperpairatthebottomofthepage.Remembertokeeptheglobal
15/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
politicaleconomyinmind.Thegamequiteopenlyputsmoreemphasisonpieceworka
meansforcorporationstoeffectivelycircumventminimumwagelawsandthustodepress
theincomeofemployees.Thatmeansbiggerprofits.APislargelydrawingfromrural
reservesoflabor,andinsomeplaces,forexampleinChina,thesereservesarenearly
absorbedintothemanufacturingeconomy.McGrawHill'salgorithmsonlaborineachofthe
4regionsissecret,butisevidentlytiedtocurrentrealconditionsinthe"labormarket"
(humanexistencebeingthecommodityfor"sale"insuch"markets").IfAPcomestotheend
oftheircheaprurallaborreservesasispredictedinChina,forexample,by2015atthe
latestyouwillfindradicallydifferentconditionsthanthoseprevailinglastweek,andthe
laboralgorithmswillnodoubtreflectthattighteninginthegameintheinterveningyears.
S/Q
Asyoumanipulatetheabovefactors,youwillseetheS/Qchangeonyourpage.Youshould
determineinadvancewhatS/Qyouwanttohavebeforeyouevenbeginplayingwiththese
numbers.Asageneralrule,anS/Qof5ismorethanadequate,andlowerwillusuallyprove
moreprofitablealthoughIwouldrecommendnotgoingbelowa3unlessthecompetition
getsfierce.It'srisky.Globalchampionshipteamsoftengoaslowas0.Butoneshould
certainlynotgothereimmediately.Thestrategicadvantageofdisguisingintentionsisalways
immense.S/Qisactuallygivenamisleadingprominenceonthegame'spages.Farmore
importantinthealgorithm,thanraisingS/Q,formarketshare,isthenumberofmodels
"breadthofline",butthiswillnotbeapparentasitwasnottousuntillaterinthegame.
Youwillwanttoincreasethisambiguityforotherteams,aboutthecrucialroleofmodel
number,byregularlyraisingandloweringS/Q,loweringpriceoraddingcelebrityappealat
thesametimeyouGRADUALLYraisethenumberofmodelsinfuturerounds.Itwilldisguise
thereasonsforyoursuccesswhichultimatelyliein:economyofscale,breadthofline,and
restrictedstockownership.
LA,alternatively,hasyettosoakuptheirurbanunemployed.AlthoughasinAsiathereis
amigrationfromthecountrysidetothecities,itisoffsetbythemigrationnorthward.Ifyou're
planningonpullingupallyourstakes,cuttingtieswithallyouknow,whywouldyoustopat
TegucigalpainsteadofMiami,wherewagesare10timesashigh?Thus,forallpractical
purposes,thereserverurallaborforceinLAisnonexistentatpresent.IftheflowtoMiami
andotherpointsnorthshouldeverbeinterdicted,youcanexpectthealgorithmsaffecting
labortobeskewedtoaccommodatetheresultinglaborsurplus(amildphrasetodescribe
themassiveunemploymentandsocialunrestinLAwhichwouldresult).
WholesaleMarketingofBrandedFootware
YouwillwanttouseALLofyourcapacityeveryround,includingthemaximumallowedfor
overtime.Period.Repeatthattoo:useeverypossibleshoeineveryround.WHEREyouuse
itisamorecomplexmatter.Initially,youwilllackthecapacitytodominatethebranded
market,andingameswithlargenumbersofteams,oraprofessorcontinuallyinterveningto
expandmarketsizeinordertosavefailingteams,youmayNEVERhavethecapacityto
dominate.Inbothinstances,youwilldumpoffagoodpartofyourproductionintothePrivate
LabelmarketATNEARCOSTinordertocreateartificialshortagesforyourproductinthe
BrandedMarket,allowingyoutoraisepricesandstillbeabletofaceshortfallsinsupplying
thedemandforyourproduct.Thismayseemunethicaltoyou,sinceitmeanstherewillbe
childreninLAorAPwhocannolongeraffordshoesbecauseofsuchpricingpractices.Yes,
that'strue.ItISunethical,butlookaroundyou.Thesesamefirms,intherealworld,are
ALSOunabletodeliverhousing,food,orfuel,theVERYBASICOFLIFEtoAMERICANS
ataffordableprices.Getreal.Thisisbusinessonthecorporatescale.Theonlyjustification
foranyeconomicmodelisitsabilitytodelivergoodsandservicestothosewhoneedthem,
andthecorporatemodelceaseddoingthatacenturyago.Tossthescoundrelsoutonyour
owntime.ThisistheBSG.It'sagamenotjustGrandTheftAuto,butTHEGrandTheft
16/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
Auto.Andyou'reit.
Intheearlyrounds,theprivatelabelmarketmayyieldatidyprofit,butasthegame
proceeds,youwillbedumpingintothismarketatveryclosetoyourcosts.Ifyoufailto
recognizethis,youwillfindyourselfunderbidandstuckwithmillionsofshoesandalosing
roundyoumayneverrecoverfrom.Theprofitswill,commencingearly,comeexclusively
fromthebrandedmarket.Experimentwithhowmuchtodumpoffinordertomaximize
EPS/ROE,butageneralruleofthumbisthatitwillneverpaytoputsmallnumbersineither
thebrandedorprivatelabelmarket.Thefixedcostsdistributedacrossasmallnumberof
shoesaretoohighbecausethegametreatsasingleplantdistributedacrossboththe
BrandedandPLmarketsastwosmallplants.YoucangetawaywithdividinganAPplantof
4000into2equalplantsof2000devotedtoeachmarket,barely.Butdividingaplantof2000
orlessinto2isapoordecision.Intime,youwilllikelybecomealowcostleader",andfindit
mostprofitabletoputallyourshoesinthebrandedmarket.Thatwillresultinlower
ROE/EPSforeveryone,somakesureyoutakeadvantageofthefirsfewroundstomaximize
pointsforthefuture.Thesearethe7yearsofFat,tobefollowedbythe7yearsofLeanas
Mosesforecast.
Aspointedout,thePrivateLabelarenaisalsousefulforpreservingcapacitywhilecreating
artificialshortagesinthebrandedmarket.Butbeware:thePrivateLabelisgenerallya
digital,versusanalogmarket.Yourbidiseitheracceptedoritisnotinmostinstances.You
sellordon't,whereasinthebrandedmarket,youcanusuallysellsomeshoes.Itisa
commonmistaketobelievethatbymakingshoesabovetheminimumS/Qsetbytheretail
chains,thatabiddingadvantageinPLishad.Itisnot.Onlypricecounts,solongasthe
minimumS/Qismet.Ifyou'rehavingdifficultyunderstandingthis,putyourselfintheplaceof
theretailchain.Ifgiventheopportunitytobuya$17pairofshoesthatlasts3months,ora
$25pairofshoesthatlasts6months,andtackingyour$3profitontothepriceofeither,
whichwillyouchoose?Ashoethatwillneedtobereplacedwithanother$3profit,in3
months,oronethatneedsreplacedalsowitha$3profitin6months?It'stwiceas
profitabletobuythejunkshoes.There'snothreatoflostsales,really,sincethehandfulof
otherretailchainsaredoingthesamething.Environmentalsustainabilityandcustomer
satisfactionareimageslogansyouplaceinyourads,usingcelebritiestomouththem,and
notsomethingtobetakenseriously,ineitherthegameorreallifecorporatestrategy.Ifyou
findadoptingthisstrategylookstoyouasthoughyou'rerippingyourneighborsoff,thenvery
quicklyfindamirrorandlookyourselfintheeyes.Repeatthistothemirror:
"Congratulations."After4yearsofhavingsandflungrepeatedlyinyoureyestoconfuse
them,thoseeyesyetserveyouwell.
Itistheincompletenessofthiscollusiveaspectofthegame'sstructurewhichmostreflectsit
obsolescence.Thegamewasdesignedinanerawhenthehiringoftemporaryworkersby
thethousandswasgivingwaytotheeraofU.S.corporationsshiftingfactoriesabroad.That
wastheeraoftheCelticTiger,oftheTaiwanMiracle.TheBSG's"SelfConstructionof
Capacitytabreflectssuchanera.Subsequently,thosesamefirmsceasedfoundingfactories
andinsteadassistedlocalbusinessownersinsettinguptheirownfactories.Atfirst,these
factoriesmanufacturedcomponentsofproductsandthentheproductsthemselves.This
allowedthe"parent"firmtorelinquishresponsibilityforhiringandfiring,forenvironmental,
safety,andallotherlocallaws.Eventually,thefactoriesweregivenresponsibilityforthe
completeproductandtoday,afactoryinMalaysiawillmanufacturetheproductsoffirms
competinginthemarket.Intime,ofcourse,theseoutsourcersmakingalltheproductswill
beginmarketingthemundertheirownbrandaswellasothers,andthatspellsdoomforthe
originalbrands,butthinkshorttermhere.ONLYshortterm.
Meantime,thedifferencebetweenproductsisamatterofbrandingonly.Themostmarked
sectorofemploymentexpansioninAmericanindustryisinMarketing,becausethesole
17/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
differentiationamongmanufacturersisinsuperficialities:"Ourgarbageisbetterthantheir
garbage",eventhoughallthegarbagecomesfromthesamefactories.Anditbecauseofthe
homogenousnatureoftheproductsthatnoneofthefirmsisthreatenedbythelackof
quality.Theanswertoconsumerdissatisfactionisalways:"Whereareyougoingtogo?"
Onceyou'vefinishedtheabove,moveontotheWholesaleMarketingtab
WholesaleMarketing
ThispageisascomplexastheBrandedProductionPageabove,withslightlyfewer
variables.Thegoalistosellyourshoesatapricecreatingademandwhichresultsina
shortfallof,say,15to25ineachofthe4marketingregions.Youdothisbyadjusting
price,Retailsupport,Deliverytime,rebatesandusingthePrivateLabelmarket(see
elsewhereonthispage.YouwillwanttogofromthispagetotheBrandedDistributionPage
toseeclearlytheimpactonthemarket:
Theideahereissimplytoshipallyourshoes,focusingonthemostprofitableregionsand
completelyshortingtherest.
PrivateLabel
StayoutofthePrivateLabelMarketexcepttocreatetheshortagesinthebrandedmarket
mentionedabove.Initially,moneycanbemadeonbidsinthePL.Overtime,theother
teamsmaybegintreatingtheprivatelabelmarketlikea"milkcow",anditwillbetempting.
Butasthegameproceeds,thepriceswillfalldramaticallyinthePL.Atthepointforus,the
lastroundwhereyourcapacitypermitsasingleplanttobedevotedtothePrivateLabel
market,andtaketheentirething,doso.Itwouldbebestifyouhadn'tputanythingintothe
PLmarkettheprecedingrounds.Itwillcomeasashock,andtheotherteamsmayhavebid
highpricestoincreasetheprofitabilityofthemarket.ThatallowsyourbidstosweepthePL.
Formyteam,wesweptthePLthelastround.Weunexpectedlydropped10,000,000shoes
inthePLfromourNAplant,whichwepickedupasusedandwhichproducedshoesonly
forthePLmarket,andwetookitall,usingtheother2plantstofeedthebrandedlabel
market.Itlefttheotherteamswith10,000,000shoesfromPLthattheycouldn'tmove,and
halfouroppositionendedwithnegativeROE/EPS,withstockprices,creditratingand
investorconfidenceflounderingasbadly.Ourtwostrongestcompetitorswentbankrupt.
Periodically,ifyou'veestablishedyourreputationaslowcostleader,youcanthrowafew
hundredthousandshoesintotheprivatelabelmarketatalittleabovecosttowatchthe
pricesandprofitsofpanickedteamsdropdrasticallyintheprivatelabelmarket,butit
shouldbeastrategicmoveonly.Inrecentgames,pricepressuresinthePLhave
increasinglybroughtprofitstheretonilearlyoninthegame,andinthatinstance,ifnoprofit
istobemade,youwillsimplydumpanyunprofitableplantcapacity(likelyNA)inthePLat
cost.Inisolatedinstances,verystrongteams,withcapacitiesexceeding25,000,haveeasily
dominatedtheentirePLmarketbydevoting2entirefactoriestothePL,withsubstantial
profitsoverseveralturns.Earlyinthegame,youwillfaceasituationwhereyourcapacityis
largerthanthebrandedmarketandyouwillwanttopawnofftheexcesstothePLmarket
justtoprotectyourcapacityuntilthebrandedmarketexpands.
Celebrities
YouwillwanttobidoncelebritiesfromRound1.AlthoughOprah(andthenamesofthe
starsvarybyprofessor)ismoreappealingforhernumbers,Anikaismoreofanassetforher
longevity.Oprahwascontracted,inRound1ofourgame,for$8millioninitially,Anika(the
namesofcelebritiescanbealteredbyprofessorsAnikaisusedbecauseher6yearcontract
18/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
islongterm)for$1.5million.Forpurposesofcomparison,bytheendofthegame,1team
wasbidding$42millionforacelebritywithlowernumbersthaneitherAnikaorOprah,but
youwillnotwanttosetoutonsuchanexpensiveroadatthebeginningofthegame.The
addedcostof34dollarsperpairensuingfromsuchasinglebidisquestionablyworthit.
Keepthebidsreasonable,buthighenoughtowinatleast1celebrityinRound1,preferably
onewithalongtermcontract,ifyoucan.Ihavewrittenasmallapplicationforusein
calculatingthevalueofacelbritytoyourteam,here.Ithaslittleerrorchecking,sofollowthe
instructionsfaithfully.Ifinitialwinningbidsbeginat$2025million,forgetthecelebrities
altogetheruntilpricesfall,astheywill.Inreportsfromstudentsplayingrecentgames,the
costofcelebritiesissoaringinsomeregionsoftherealworld,andthepricesofshoesare
risingtoreflectit.Youdon'twanttobeleadingthatpack.Youcangetaroughideaofthe
worthofacelebritybyusingtheforecastscreen,althoughincreasesinfuturecapacityneed
toaccountedfor.AstudentfromIndonesia,playinginAustraliasummeditup:"Let'ssay
that,ifweputacelebrityundercontract,itgivesusanadditional0.5%marketshareinall
regions.Andthenwefindoutwecanalsoget0.5%moremarketshareifwereducethe
priceofeveryshoesby$0.50.Ifthetotalnumberofextrashoeswesellis10millionpairs,
thenthecelebrityisapproximatelyworth10million*0.5=5million.Themorecapacitywe
have,themorevaluableacelebrityis."That'sonlytrueiftheprofitmargindoesnotfallwith
theincreaseinmarketshare.Thevalueofacelebrityistheprofitmarginmultipliedbythe
numberofextrashoessoldineachregion.Sincetheprofitmarginvariesfromregionto
region,thevalueofacelebritydoestoo,INADDITIONtothevarianceinregionalappeal.
Onceyouhavefinishedmanipulatingtheabovenumbers,gobacktotheSalesForecasttab.
Youwillseemuchoftheworkyouhavealreadydoneisreflectedonthispagenow.Setyour
internetshoepricehere,slightlyabovetheretailprice.Themanualtellsyouthatretailerswill
fallawayifyousellshoesontheinternetforlessthan40%abovetheretailprice.That'strue,
butthenumberofretailersshouldbeyourlastconsideration(unlessyou'veignoredthemfor
solongthattheshrinkagehasbecomeconstricting).Thenumberofshoesindemandwillbe
handledbytheremainingretailersprovidedyoukeepitreasonable.Ifitseemsthatyour
retailersarefallingawayalarmingly,upyourinternetpricessomewhat.OntheSales
Forecastpage,youcanfinetunesuchthingsasadvertising.Somehardnumbersmaybe
usefulhere,sincestudentsseemtogenerallyapproachtheseareaswithnoideaofwhat
theyshouldbe.Youradvertisingbudgetinthevariousregionsshouldbesetinitiallyat
somethinglike$9000forNAandEA,and5000forAPandLA.Thesewillclimbto1520,000
forNA/EAand750010,000forAP/LA.SeewhatisneededtogivetheshortfallsinBranded
shoesupplythatyouwant.Rebatesshouldbesetto0,deliverytimeto3.Retailsupport
shouldnotexceed250350andthenumberofretailersshouldnotexceed2500forNA/EA
(and1500isacceptable).ForLA/APitcanbe1500and1200isacceptable.Theadditional
moneyspentonretailersupport,multipliedbytheadditionalnumberofretailers,canbe
expensive.IfyoulowerS/Q,sellingoffinventorymakesnosense.Ifyourcurrenttargeted
S/QforNAisa7,andyouhavelargenumbersofshoesintheregionleftfromlastdecision
whicharean8,thenyoucanmanufactureshoesinNAata6toreachyourtargetof7,since
theS/Qisanaverage.Italmostneverpaystoselloffinventoryinaregionfromapreceding
decisionofthatinventoryisahigherS/Qthanthecurrentplannedtarget.
Insettlingonthenumbersforthispage,youshouldtrytwoversions:
1)Theversionwherethe"industryaverage"issetbytheBSG.
2)Theversionwherethe"industryaverage"issetatthedecisionsofyourstrongest
opponent,withtheassumptionthatyouropponentwillonlytrytobecomestronger(lower
19/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
prices,higheradsupport,etc.).Thiswillgiveyoutheworstcasescenario.
ANOTEONIMAGE:
Imageisprobablytheareayoushouldworryleastabout.Itshouldfollowmarketshare
anyway.But,perhapsasaresultofthispageandthewinningstrategieswhichhaveensued,
McGrawHillhasintroducedanoptioncalled"corporatecitizenship".Thepageisdesignedto
boostimageratingsforyourteam,ostensibly,butactuallyisdesignedtoboosttheimageof
globalcorporations.TheoptionsonthepagerarelyaffectEPS/ROEpositivelyexceptforthe
energyinitiatives,andthatonlyirregularly.Thispage,incidentally,isnotFantasyland,since
thesectionisonlydesignedtoboostimage,nottocontributeinanymeaningfulwaytoa
responsibleroleforyourcorporation.That'sactuallythefunctionof"greenness"inthe
corporateworld.Itisamarketingtoolandlookingbeneaththecoversofanycorporate
"greeninitiative"willinvariablyrevealagrimierreality.Forexample,themandatesofthe
EPAortheEUareoftenportrayedasacorporate"greeninitiative"incompanyadvertising.
Inreality,theyaremandatedbylaw,andinmostcaseswerefoughtbitterlybytheverysame
corporationsnowboastingofthem.
ROUNDBYROUNDOUREXPERIENCE
Note:thenumberofroundsinthegameissetindividuallybyeachprofessor.Ihaveseen
verylonggamesinclasseswhereprofessorsspentayearonthecourse.ButIhavealso
seenprofessorswhohadtheirstudentsstartthegameanewseveraltimes,eachwithonly4
rounds,playedrepeatedlythroughoutthecourse.Followingaretheactualresultsforour
team.Remember,thiswasaFIRST,ineptattemptatputtingtheaboveprinciplesintoplay.
Since,wehavecollaboratedwithhundredsofteamsandhaverefinedthestrategyas
outlinedabove.
ROUND1:DONOTWINSMASHINGLY
Ifyouchoosetolosethisroundsoyoucanbuyupyourstock2ndround(therearelimitson
theamountofstockyoucanbuybackinthegame),prepareyourself.Itisashockforevery
teamwhichsetsoutonsuchacoursewhenitactuallyoccurs.Andprofessorstendto
becomealarmedaswell.OneteaminSouthAfricareceivedasummonsfor"counseling"
fromaninstructorafterRound1,gravelyinformingthemthattheyhaddoneworsethana
placeboteamwithnooneinit,andthathewasalarmedandconcernedfortheirfuturewell
beinginlife.Recoveryfromagrandlosscanbeslow,althoughagreatdealofmoneycanbe
savedinbuyingupthestock.
Round1resultsforourteam(ThepricesinNAwerereflectiveofpricesinallregions.We
wereTeamB)
Team PriceofshoesinNA
S/Q
MN
A
50
7
249
B
34.70
7
52
C
50
6
200
D
48.50
6
249
E
49
6
200
F
50
7
249
G
52
7
217
*MN=ModelNumber
AlthoughyoudonotwanttogobankruptinRound1,youmaywanttoloseit,sothatyour
stockpricefalls(although,astrafficonthispagehasincreasedtosome200newusers
20/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
daily,thegameisgettingtighter,andforfeitingthefirstroundbadlymayputyouatadistinct
andfataldisadvantageforseveralrounds).Ifyouselectaminimumnumberofmodel
numbersforyourshoes,andkeepyourpriceslowenough,andyoucanalmostbe
guaranteedofthatresult,dependinguponthechoicesyouropponentsmake.However,ifthe
stockrises,youshouldstillbuyitupsinceequitywillfall,leadingtoahigherROE
(Return/Equity)thanifyoudidnot.
Alwaysspendtimeonthedecisionsandresultsofothers.Especiallyearlyinthegame,
whenslightdifferencesinotherteams'approacheswillillustratewhatisworkingbest.The
instructorcansetmanyoftheparametersinthegame,andyouwillwanttotailoryour
movesaccordingly.Youarepermittedtoseethesameresultsforotherteamsthatyousee
foryourown,withaclickhere,aclickthere.Itwilldeterminetheoutcomeofthegame.
Lookforslightvariationsinthedecisionsmadebytheseotherteamseven,andmaybe
especiallythosewhodonotwintheroundfromweektoweekandlookattheoutcome.At
times,youropponentswillnotthemselvesbeawareoftheserelationshipsamongtrailing
teams,becausetheywillbecomparingthemselvestotheleaders.Youcanlearnfromthem.
Forexample,ateam(TeamDbelow)whichdeclinedtoraiseS/Qdidrespectably,though
makingerrorselsewheretheirpriceswerehigher,theirmodelnumberslower.Asa
consequence,theyplaced3rd.Buttheirsavingsinexpenseslargelycancelledthemistakes.
Becausetheydidnotfareaswellastheleaders,theychangedcoursethefollowinground
anduppedtheirS/Q,withtheresultthattheyfellfurtherbehind.Butevenaninexperienced
observercouldspotthedistinctionbetweenthisteamandateamwhosedecisionwere
exactlyalike,exceptfortheS/Q(theotherhadraisedS/Q).Andtheotherteamdidpoorlyby
comparison.ThereasontheotherteamsdidnotspotthedifferencesandquitpursuingS/Q
isbecausetheywerefocusedonlyonthemovesoftheteamwhichledafterthefirstround.
Thatwillnot,ifyoufollowouradvice,beyours.
Aboveall,rememberthatthisisagameovertime,nota"suddendeath"playoff.Keepyour
SherlockHolmeshaton,throughoutthegame.LookattheStrategicGroupMapforeach
region.Ifalltheothercompaniesarecuttingoneanother'sthroatsintheupperendofthe
market(andvanitybeingasitis,theywillmostlikely,unlessthey'realsoreadingthis),head
forthelowend,butnotallatonce.Drifttheresoasnottomakeitevidentwhatyou'redoing.
Ifthey'reinthelowend,headslightlyhigherbutbeattheminpriceswithyourhigher
productioncapacityEconomyofScale.Studyyouropponentscarefully.Getafeelfortheir
foiblesaswellastheirsuccesses.
Theinverseisalsotrue.Therewillbeatleastoneotherteamlookingatyourresultsunder
thesamemicroscopeyouareturningonthem,andespeciallyifyouconsistentlyaredoing
well,asyoushouldbe,laterinthegame.Asaconsequence,itisbestthat,whenyoumake
decisionsshiftingyourpositioninthemarket,thatyoudosowithatleast2changes.Ifyou
dowellintheround,eventhoughyoubelieveyouknowwhichofthe2changeswascrucial,
youropponentsmaynot.Andthereisa50%chancethattheywillchoosethewronganswer
whentryingtoguesswhichwasresponsibleforyoursuccess.Trustinthe"sheepmentality"
prevailing.Themajorityofthose"intheroom"willlookforsafetyintheherd.Theywilltry
repeatedlytoapeyou.Yourbestadvantageinthegamearetheelementsofconfusionand
surprise.Rememberthisisagame,astrategygame,andlikesimplerstrategygames,such
asrockpaperscissors,agoodpartofthegameisinleadingyouropponentstobelieveyou
willbemakingmovesinadirectionexactlyoppositeofwhereyouaretrulyheaded.
Ifyourstockpricetanksafterthefirstround,thenifyouaresmart,youwillmake
arrangementstobuynearlyallofyourstockback.Weinplanningthefollowingrounds
couldborrowenoughtobuybackallthestocksharespermitted(2,500,000of10,000,000
shares)in2roundsandtherestofthegameweweredividingby3(theremaining7,500,000
shares)whileothersweredividingby4(theoriginal10millionshares)in4inROE/EPS
21/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
calculationsgivingthemanautomatic33.3%disadvantageinscoringuntil2otherteams
"caughton"lateinthegameanddidlikewise.3of7teamsactuallysoldshares,increasing
thenumberby20%andfurtherdisadvantagingthem.
Thefirstround,andtherestofthegame,willbecatandmouseor,rather,lionandmouse
sinceyounowhaveanadvantageincapacitywhichotherswillbeunlikelytomatch
throughouttherestofthegameprovidedyoustayapaceofthem.Butyouwanttomakeit
uncleareachturnwhatyouwillbedoingnext.MyteamwentfromS/Q6atthebeginningof
thegametoS/Q7inRound1,thentoS/Q8inRound2.Wetooktheround,butfailedto
meettheminimumof15%inROEbyhalfapointbecauseweidlyspenttoachievean8S/Q
alongwithincreasingcapacityanddoingupgrades.ButourraisingtheS/Qandretainingthe
leadhadtheadvantageofpropellingtherestoftheteamstowardchasinganelusiveand
expensiveS/Qof10whichateamachieved,fornopurposereally,inthelastroundwhilewe
droppedtoS/Q7inRound3andstayedtherebeforedroppingtoS/Q6inthefinalround.At
nopointwerepeoplematchingourinvestmentinproduction,andfollowingsuggestions
madebytheinstructorinthebeginningofthegamemanysoldoffexcessproductionstock.
Westayedupuntiltheresultsofeachroundwaspostedsothatwecouldpurchaseany
capacityforsaleimmediately,beforeotherscould(thesepurchasesaremadeontheportal
page)refreshingthepageeveryfewsecondsasinanebayauction.Itwascrucialtothe
outcome.NewbutUsedcapacityisboughtata20%discount.Manyteamshavehad
successsellingoffALLtheirNAcapacityoncetheLAplantiscapableofsupplyingbothNA
andLAdemand.Howeveralltheotherteamsareusuallydoingthesameandsuccesshas
alsobeenenjoyedbysomeofthosewhotookadvantageofthedumpingandbuiltupanNA
monolithcheaply.DoNOTletanyethicalconcernsaboutwipingoutyourfather'sjob
concernyouhere.Incaseyouhaven'tfigureditout,agoodpartofyourbusinesscourses
aredesignedtoinureanddesensitizeyoutosuchhumandilemmas,toreduceyoutoan
automatoncapableoffocusingonlyonmonetaryreturnsconfinedto"your"company.Ifyou
buyintothat,inyour"reallife",youarenotonlyachumpbutadangertoyourcountry
(whereverthatmightbe),butforthepurposesoftheGame,pretendyoudo.
Round2
Round2inNA
Team PriceinNA
A
49
B
42.13
C
55
D
49
E
50
F
48.99
G
47.77
S/Q
7
8
8
7
7
8
7
MN
250
150
244
240
200
344
206
Inretrospect,ourS/Q8inRound2wasagoodideabecauseitcreatedconfusionasto
wherewewereheadedwhen,nextround,wedroppedbacktoS/Q7(weshould,perhaps,
havegoneto5),butweshouldhaveandIexpectyoutoincreasemodelnumberto350
500andwelikelywouldhaveexceededinvestorexpectations.WedidthatinRound3and
thereafter.TheonlyteamwhichwoncelebritybidsbeforethisroundwereTeamA.Despite
verysimilarprices,S/Q,etc.,TeamAsold50%moreshoesthanTeamD,whichbrought
hometoustheimportanceofwinningsomeendorsements.WethusbidonandwonTiger
22/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
for$6.2million.YoualsowillwanttobidoncelebritiessothatbyRound4youhave
superiorityinthisfieldifitcanatallbejustifiedeconomically.
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
MS
17.1
21.8
9.3
12.3
9.7
16.1
13.8
ROE
5.1
14.8
.2
4.5
.6
9.5
7.5
EPS
.85
2.76
.03
.83
.09
1.68
1.48
SP
15.84
29.80
17.55
21.89
10.89
33.28
12.63
Thepatternwasthesameformarketshare,EPSandROEasinthenextfewrounds:Our
team'sprimaryopponentswereTeamFandGinthefightformarketshare.TeamA'sstrong
marketsharewasbasedstrictlyonitscelebritiesandwedeterminedtokickthosesupports
outintime.Inround2andeveryroundthereafter,youwillwanttoadjusttheproduction
numberstomaximizeprofitabilityperpairofshoes,bidoncelebrities,increaseyourdividend
byapennyassuggestedabove,etc.
Round3
Round3
Team PriceinNA
A
50
B
44.90
C
49.99
D
47
E
48
F
51.45
G
46.24
S/Q
7
7
9
7
7
9
8
MN
250
319
343
331
244
333
200
Bythe3rdround,myteamhaddevelopedapatternwhichwouldlargelybecomeroutinefor
usandwhichyoushouldmakeroutinetoo:addcapacity,playwithnumbersonthe
productionpagetoachievethecheapestshoe,workingourwayup,eventually,tothe
maximumof500models,withTQMandBestpracticesatamaximum,adjustingwages,
styling,percentageofsuperiormaterials,incentives,etc.toachievethelowestpriceshoes.
Ifyouhaveanystockoutstandingwhichyoucanpurchase,doso.Alwayscomparecurrent
interestrateswithpastloans.Borrowtopaythemdown.Borrowtoincreasecapacity.
Borrowtobuybackstock.Borrowforplantupgradesiftheyprovepromising.Thenturnto
thepricingpage.Lookingateachofyouropponents'priceslastturn,calculateasifyour
opponentswill,nextturn,droppricesby$1.50$2andmakesureyoubeatthatprice.Add
themaximumallowableforLA(750,000foranexistingplantof1,500,000inourcase).The
onlyotherteamtoaddcapacityinourgamethatyearopenedaplantof1000inEA,which
provedtobeoflittlevaluetherestofthegame.Celebrityappealcan,bytheway,overcome
adifferenceinpricestosomedegree.Image,aspointedoutabove,consistsof2
components:S/Qandmarketshare.Thelatter,inturn,consistsof3separatespheres:the
internet,thebrandedmarket,andtheprivatelabelmarket.The3appeartoact
independentlyofoneanother.Thus,totaldominanceinthePLmarketwhichyoucannot
possiblyachieveatthispointinthegamecangiveanimageof100,largelyindependentof
whathappensinthebrandedmarket.SinceS/Qisexpensivecostsmoneywhilemarket
shareyieldsmoney,wefocusedhenceforthlittleattentiononS/Qandmoreonmarket
share.
23/29
2/4/2015
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
Capacityatonsetof4thRound
7000
9050
6000
6600
6000
7000
8000
Attheendoftheroundwepickedup400,000usedcapacityinNA(usedcapacityis
availableforuseimmediatelyandyouwillalmostinvariablyfindNAcapacityisthefirsttobe
givenup).TheresultsforRound3were:
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
MS*
16%
21.6
12.4
14.7
10.3
13.5
11..7
ROE
10.9
22.5
0
6.2
.5
12.9
.6
EPS
1.97
4.43
.01
1.16
.08
2.26
.10
SP
17.82
59.30
10.83
12.70
6.87
23.73
8.12
*MS=MarketshareinNA
Webidon,andwonNatalieKwanat$13millionandSergioat$9million.Wealsopickedup
Paytonat$3millionsimplytoknockoutTeamA'ssolesupportits2celebrities(wewould
pickupOprah,the2nd,later).Remember,you'renotfocusingonrunningsomesortofideal
"goodbusiness"here.You'refocusingonruiningyouropponents.It'sessentialthatinthe
antepenultimateround(theroundbeforethenexttolastround,whichforus,Round4was,
althoughmanyinstructorsshortenthegamebyaroundortwo,sometimesunexpectedly,
andothersdragthegameoutoverasemester,orevenanentireyear),youhavesuperiority
incelebrityappeal.Inthatround,youcanthenlocksuperiorityincelebrityappealin,at
minimalexpenseforthefollowing2roundsbybiddingunexpectedlyhighforALLthe
celebrities(Forourteamthatmeantbidding$20,156,000foreachapproximately50%
higherthanpreviousbids.Youwillwinthemall,thencancelallbutwhatyouneedto
maintainsuperiorityatthebeginningofthepenultimate(nexttolast)round.Theotherteams
willseenoneofthecancellationsuntiltheeveofthelastroundinwhichcaseitwillbeofno
valuesincetheywouldonlybidoncelebritiesforanonexistentfutureround..Itwillcostyou
10%ofthecontractstocancelnextround(forourteam,thiswasatotalof$10millionand
change)whichisnegligiblecomparedtothecostofcompetingagainstthemorofactually
biddingonallofthemandespeciallyoflosingthecelebrities.Thefollowinground(the
penultimate),therewillbethosewhoseeyourbidstheprecedingroundandactuallytryto
outbidyouwithoutknowingyou'recancelingasthey'rebidding.Inourcase,oneteambid
thus$42millionforaminorcelebrity.Mostteamswillsimplygiveup.You'llrepeatthe
processinthenext(penultimate)roundofcourse,biddingslightlyhigherthanthelast(we
bid22,500,000foreachandwononlyoneofthe3availablewithouropponentsbidding
astronomicalsumstotrytoemulateour"success",sincewealreadyhadandwere
cancelingtheothers.Wethusalreadyhadsuperiorityofcourse,andcancelledthenewly
wononetoo,inthelastround.Theother2were"won"byteamswhichnowhadtoraise
pricesonshoesalreadytooexpensive,cancellingneverhavingoccurredtothem,andnot
reallyanoptiongivenoursuperiority.Onewasaprimarycompetitorandbecauseweshut
downtheprivatelabelmarketbyfloodingitwithcheapshoes,webankruptedthemthelast
24/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
round.Havinganexpensivecelebritybilldidn'thelpthemeither.).
Ifthisseemscomplex,perhapsthefollowingmakesthingsclearer:
LockinginCelebrityDominance
Whenthereare4roundsleftinthegame,then:
Round1(ofthelast4):Ensureyourteamhascelebritydominanceforthisroundonly.It
needn'tbeagreatadvantage.
Round2(ofthelast4):Bid50%higherthanhaseverbeenbidforanycelebrity,oneach
oneavailable.Thiswillbeanastronomicalsumbutitwilldenyyouropponentsanychange
inyourcelebritydominance.Youropponentswillonlyseethesewinningbidsthefollowing
round(3rdRound).
Round3(ofthelast4):Youwillcancelallcelebritycontractsexceptwhatyouneedto
maintaindominance.Youropponentswillnotseethisuntiltheeveofthenextround(Round
4),whichisthelastroundandcelebritydominanceontheirpart,atthatpoint,isuseless
sincethereisnofutureround.Thecostofcancellingthesecontractstoyouis10%,whichis
negligiblecomparedtothecostofgivingthemthecelebrities(allofthisassumesyouhave
followedtheaboveinstructionsandaredoingwellinthegame,andcanthereforeaffordthe
financialpenalty).Atthispointallyouropponentscanseeisthatyouaredoingwellandpart
ofitmustbeattributabletoyourdominanceinthecelebrityfield.Theyaresheep,afterall,in
manycases,andwilltrytoemulateyou,willinfactlikelybidevenhigherthanyouinthelast
round,andlackingdominanceinthearea,willbesaddledwiththosecostsfinalround,when
theycannotcancelcontractsassumingtheyknowthat'sfeasiblewithoutfurthereroding
theirposition.Younowhavethembetweenarockandahardplace.
Round4(ofthelast4):Lastround.Theygobroke.Youwin.Comprendez?
THE3YEARPLAN
Atsomepoint,yourinstructorwilllikelyaskyoutofillouta3yearbusinessplan.Sincea
disproportionatelylargepartofyourgaminggradedependsonit,thisisnotsomethingto
approachedlightly.Inmyclass,itwastheontheeveofthe4throundwhenwewere
requiredtosubmitourplan.Dothisplancarefully,meetingminimumtargetsforinvestor
expectationsandexceedingthemineachyear,butdonotgetcarriedaway.Meetingand
especiallyexceedinglowertargetswillyieldahigherscorethanmissinggoals.
Round4
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
PriceinNA
50.75
47.72
49.5
48.99
48
55
47.75
S/Q
8
7
9
8
8
9
7
MN
250
500
252
301
247
466
200
Results:
25/29
2/4/2015
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
MS*
14%
25.5
13.8
14.4
11.3
10.6
10.4
ROE
10.9
22.5
0
6.2
.5
12.9
.6
EPS
1.97
4.43
.01
1.16
.08
2.26
.10
SP
17.82
59.30
10.83
12.70
6.87
23.73
8.12
Round5:Theinstructor'sIntervention
AfterRound4,ourmarketsharewasnearlydoublethatofourclosestcompetitor,and
severalteamswere,asweintended,drowningininventories(oneteamhad6months
inventory)whichtheycouldn'tmoveandwereonthevergeofbankruptcy(defaulton
principle/interestpayments),havingreceivedtoomany1yremergencyloanstocovertheir
cashshortages.Theinstructorhadpreviousrelationshipswithsomeofthosestudents,and
inourestimationintervenedto"savetheirbacon".Sheincreaseddemandshesaiditwas
forthefirsttimein15+years"by10%topermitthemtomovetheirinventoriesandworked
withseveraloftheteamstoimprovetheirscores.Henceforth,wewerenotonlypitted
againsttheotherteams,buteffectivelyagainsttheinstructorherself.She,however,like
theotherteamsthemselves,failedtograspthetrueimplicationsofEconomyofScaleand
advisedthosewithexcessinventoriestosell,ratherthanadd,capacity(thusspreadingfixed
costsoveralargernumberofshoes,permittingpricestobeloweredandthusmarketshare
increased).Otherteamshavehadtheinstructorintervenetofreezecapacityadditionsdueto
excessinventories,inwhichcase,you'dbetterbeleadinginnumbersofshoesproduced.
Atthebeginningoftheround,wepickedup5300(thousands)ofusedcapacityinNAand
Asia.
Team Capacityatonsetof5thRound
A
7000
B
15,950
C
6000
D
6600
E
5000
F
6500
G
5800
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
PriceinNA
49.99
43.66
52.49
50.25
48
56
48.50
S/Q
8
7
9
9
8
9
7
MN
331
500
346
323
250
498
245
Results:
Team
MS*
ROE
EPS
SP
26/29
2/4/2015
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
10.1
33.1
12
11.3
10.1
13.4
10
.6
33.4
6.2
6.2
4.5
10.9
5.2
.12
11.47
1.39
1.37
.83
1.90
.95
6.48
223.75
18.90
15.37
9.39
18.96
8.22
*MS=MarketshareinNA,SP=StockPrice
DemandinYear5was49,839thousands)Ouredgeincapacitywouldhavebeensufficient
towinthegamebutnotasdecisively.Youwillwanttodoaswedid,andtakeout1,5and10
yearloanslater,ontheeveofthelastround(forus,Round6),andorderanadditional5600
(thousands)capacityinpreparationforround6.Sinceyouhavenoresponsibilitytopaythe
longtermloansoffinnonexistentfuturerounds,debtatthispointisoflittleconcernsolong
asyoucanmaketheannualpaymentrequireforthelastround.Ournemesis,TeamF,
orderedanother1200(thousands).Wecancelledallthecontractsforcelebritieswhichwe
wonexceptforthenumbernecessarytokeepoursupremacy.Wealsodecidedtorepeatthe
processandbidastronomicallyonthosenewlyavailableat22,500,000apiece,knowingthat
ifwewonthem,wewouldtakethe$8.8millionpenalty(10%forcancellingcontracts),and
knowingitwouldbecheapcomparedtoallowingsometoescapecheaplywhilewebidon
others.However,weexpected12teamstolookatourwinningthepreviousround,believing
ustobepracticalinbusinessmattersandbelievingtheastronomicalpricesmusttherefore
beworthit(itdidnotbecomeapparentuntilthebeginningofRound16thatwehad
cancelledthecontracts)andweexpectedthattheywouldoutbidusonatleastsome.In
truth,ournemesisFbid50%higherthanourownridiculousbidson2celebrities,andTeam
Cdoubledourbid(200%)onanother.Wewishedthemwellnotreally,consideringthe
additionalcostsaddedtotheirshoeprices.TeamGhadcaughtontoourS/Qstrategy,and
severalteamsnowbegantograsptheimportanceofmodelnumber.
Round6
Ourteamhadshunnedtheprivatelabelmarketexcepttotossafewhereandthereto
threatenentryandthusholdpricesandprofitsdownontheotherteams'parts.Wehadnot
doneeventhelatterforseveralroundsandthevariousteamshadbeguntoviewthePL
marketasasourceofgoodprofit,typicallysubmittingonlybidsthatwereashighasthosein
thebrandedmarkets.Onlyapartofthishighpricingwasduetothefactthattheywere
dividingsmallplantsbetween2marketsitwassheergreed.Werealizedthatdevotingour
entireNAplanttothePLpermittedustobidonnearlyallthe9million+shoes,ataprice
radicallylowerthanourcompetitorsandyetmakehugeprofits.Wealsodeterminedthat
doingso,gaveusanimageratingof100,thesameasifwe'dproduceda10withalarge
marketshare.WethereforedroppedtheS/Qandpricesinthebrandedmarketandyou
mayfindthesametacticuseful,todroptheentireNAplant'soutput(pershoe,themost
expensivefactoriesinthebrandedmarket)intothePL.
Thefinalround,'stockingout'(creatingmoredemandthancanbefilled,asaresultoflow
prices)whichinpreviousroundscarriesanuisancepenaltyofreducingthenumberof
retailersavailableandtherequirement(withpenaltyofretailersdroppingawayanarchaic
penaltynolongerapplyingintherealworld,incidentally)inpreviousroundsforaninternet
pricenotmuchlessthantheretailprice+40%foranyregionisofnoconsequencesince
thereisnofutureround.Therefore,theinternetpricecanbesetatanythingandbystocking
outsufficiently,onecanbeprettyclosetothetargetsindicatedbytheforecastspreadsheet,
providedyourpricesarelowest.
27/29
2/4/2015
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
PLPriceRound6inNA
(nobids)
31.72
45
48.50
47
43.98
44
#shoessold(000s)
2310
261
218
300
198
137
Needlesstosay,ourbidwasacceptedandnoneoftheotherteams'were
BrandedPricesinNA:
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
PriceinNA
50.25
42.22
53
51.50
49
56
54
S/Q
8
6
10
9
8
9
8
MN
342
500
350
331
250
500
156
Results:
TeamMS*
A
10.7%
B
31.7
C
13.2
D
12.1
E
10.6
F
14.2
G
7.5
ROE
4.6
38.5
8.7
7.4
2.7
10.6
18.9
EPS
.9
19.10
2.07
1.75
.53
1.84
3.22
SP
4.75
392.12
30.19
20.35
6.32
11.15
5.66
*MarketShareinNABrandedMarketwetookallthePL
Round6wasthe"coupdegras".TeamsFandG,our2closestcompetitors,defaultedon
theirinterestpayments,throwingthemintobankruptcy.Theinstructor,whohadplannedon
givingoutgradeswhichwere50%basedonGametoDatePerformancescores,and50%
basedonInvestorConfidencelevels,hadinsteadtoturntoacurvegradeacurvewhose
componentsshedeclinedtoexplainsincetheoriginalplanyielded:
Team
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
Grade
35.5%
100.5%
58%
57.5%
45.5%
54.5%
29.5%
Ineffect,therewouldhavebeenone'A'andsix'F'gradesforthegame.
Hereisanexamplefromaroundmidgame,sentbyateamseveralyearsago.Itmaygive
youafeelforhowthedecisionsaremadeusingthestrategydetailedabove.Ifyouhave
questions,writemeherewiththesubjectheadlineBSG.Andyes,themailaddressisatthe
28/29
2/4/2015
HOWTOWINTHEBSG
bottomofthepagebecauseIdon'tevenwanttotalktoyouunlessyou'vereadthisfar.I've
hadtoomanypeoplewriteme,tellingmetheycan'tflunkthiscourseorelsethey're
doomed,buttheydon'twanttoputintoomucheffortoniteither.Ifyou'vedoneyour
homeworkandarestillbaffled,oraresimplypuzzledorfailinginyourgame,I'mhappyto
talktoyou.Butremember,that'strueonlyforstudentsneedingtopassthiscourse.If,onthe
otherhand,youfindyourselfbeinginvitedtotheGlobalsChampionships,you'reonyour
own.That'sextracurricularactivityasfarasI'mconcernedandyou'reonyourown.
Findthispageuseful?UsePaypaltodonateafewbuckstopayfortheserver
29/29

How To Win The BSG

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

How To Win The BSG

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

2/4/2015

Você também pode gostar