VALORAO DE DANOS AMBIENTAIS IRREVERSVEIS

#%%'0$3'"5,%/'$1,"6/'$70'&'1

!"#"$%&'%$()*+,"&,"&)%,")-.$'%/)0"$11'2'1342'0

"#$%$&'$! '#()(*+,! "(#'$! -(! "#$./%%(! -$!

01$!(!$2$'/3/-(-$!&(!#$"(#(45,!-,!-(&,!
ao ambiente pressupe a compreenso
sobre as formas de reparao do dano,
-$! .,-,! (! "$#./'/#! (! $%6,*+(! -(01$*(!
01$!.$*+,#!('$&-(!7%!21&48$%!-(!#$%",&%()/*/-(-$!6/3/*!$!
.$*+,#! (%%$91#$! (! "#,'$45,! /&'$9#(*! -,%! )$&%! (.)/$&'(/%!
.('$#/(/%!$!/.('$#/(/%:
;(!('1(*/-(-$<!&5,!%1)%/%'$.!-=3/-(%!&,!%$&'/-,!-$!01$!
a opo prioritria da ordem constitucional brasileira,
/&%'/'1>-(! "$*,! (#':! ??@! -(! A,&%'/'1/45,! B$-$#(*! -$!
CDEE<! F! "$*(! #$%'(1#(45,! $2$'/3(! -,! -(&,<! )1%6(&-,G%$! (!
/."*$.$&'(45,! -$! .$-/-(%! %1H6/$&'$%! 7! #$()/*/'(45,!
$6,*I9/6(! $! 21&6/,&(*! -,! "#I"#/,! (.)/$&'$! -$9#(-(-,!
,1! -$! J#$(! "#IK/.(! (,! *,6(*! -,! -(&,<! -$! .,-,! (! %$!
"#,",#6/,&(#$.! .$*+,#/(%! &,! $6,%%/%'$.(! 6,.,! 1.!
',-,:! ;,! $&'(&',<! 01(&-,! (! #$%'(1#(45,! &('1#(*! ,1!
(! 6,."$&%(45,! $6,*I9/6(! #$3$*(#$.G%$! '$6&/6(.$&'$!
/&3/J3$/%<! ,! L/#$/',! -$3$#J! -$)#14(#G%$! %,)#$! (%!
.$',-,*,9/(%! "(#(! ,! $%'()$*$6/.$&',! -$! 1.! 3(*,#! -$!
/&-$&/M(45,!-,!-(&,!(.)/$&'(*!/##$3$#%>3$*<!%1"$#(&-,!(%!
-/H61*-(-$%!#$"#$%$&'(-(%!"$*(!2(*'(!-$!2(./*/(#/-(-$!-,%!
juristas com frmulas matemticas e com as abstraes
"#I"#/(%!-(%!6/N&6/(%!6,&'J)$/%!$!$6,&O./6(%:

24 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

P!"#$6/%,!$%6*(#$6$#!01$!(!3(*,#(45,!$6,&O./6(!-$!#$61#%,%!
&('1#(/%!&5,!F!1.!'$.(!/&$K"*,#(-,:!Q6,&,./%'(%!3N.!%$!
-$-/6(&-,! (,! $%'1-,! -$! .$',-,*,9/(%! -$! 3(*,#(45,! -$!
#$61#%,%! &('1#(/%! 6,.,! 2$##(.$&'(%! -$! 9$%'5,! (.)/$&'(*!
para compreenso da Disposio do Consumidor em
R(9(#! SLTRU! ",#! 1.! )$.! ,1! %$#3/4,! (.)/$&'(*! 01$! *+$!
"#,",#6/,&(#J!)$.G$%'(#:1
A,&2,#.$!(!Q6,&,./(!-,!T.)/$&'$!SATVRWX!YZ;[W\<!
?]]^<! ":! _]U<! ,! 3(*,#! -,%! )$&%! (.)/$&'(/%! ",-$! %$#!
representado pela formulao2! `Qa! b! S`cL! d! `c[! d!
`W! d! `QU! 01$! F! 6,&%'/'1>-(! ",#! 1.! 6,&e1&',! .$&,#! -$!
3(*,#$%! 01$! ()(#6(.! (%! -/2$#$&'$%! ",%%/)/*/-(-$%! -$! 1%,!
$6,&O./6,!01$!",-$.!%$#!2$/',%!-,!.$/,!(.)/$&'$:!T%%/.<!
C! !Q%6*(#$6$!X$#O(!-(!V,''(!01$!f(!'(#$2(!-$!3(*,#(#!$6,&,./6(.$&'$!
1.! #$61#%,! (.)/$&'(*! 6,&%/%'$! $.! -$'$#./&(#! 01(&',! .$*+,#! ,1! "/,#!
$%'(#J! ,! )$.G$%'(#! -(%! "$%%,(%! -$3/-,! (! .1-(&4(%! &(! 01(&'/-(-$! -$!
)$&%! $! %$#3/4,%! (.)/$&'(/%<! %$e(! &(! ("#,"#/(45,! ",#! 1%,! ,1! &5,:! L$%%(!
2,#.(<! ,%! .F',-,%! -$! 3(*,#(45,! (.)/$&'(*! 6,##$%",&-$#5,! (! $%'$!
,)e$'/3,!7!.$-/-(!01$!2,#$.!6("(M$%!-$!6("'(#!$%%(%!-/%'/&'(%!"(#6$*(%!
-$!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,!-,!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*g:!SVWaaT<!?]]h<!":!C^U:!R(#(!
1.(!6,."#$$&%5,!(."*(!-(%!-/3$#%(%!(),#-(9$&%!$K/%'$&'$%<!3$#!V(ij!
`$/9(!;$',j!R,M,!S?]CCU:
?! ! `(*,#! Q6,&O./6,! a,'(*:! ;(! )/)*/,9#(H(<! $&6,&'#(G%$! '(.)F.! (!
-$&,./&(45,!`Q\T!S`(*,#!Q6,&O./6,!-,%!\$61#%,%!T.)/$&'(/%U:

,!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,!','(*!S`QaU!6,&%'/'1/G%$!$.!3(*,#!-$!1%,! 3(*,#(.! ,%! )$&$2>6/,%! (.)/$&'(/%! 1%(&-,! ,%! 61%',%!

$! 3(*,#! -$! &5,! 1%,<! ,%! 01(/%! %$! %1)-/3/-$.! -(! %$91/&'$! $3/'(-,%<! #$*(6/,&(-,%! /&-/#$'(.$&'$! 6,.! (%! .1-(&4(%!
&(!01(*/-(-$!(.)/$&'(*k!$!.F',-,%!-/#$',%<_!01$!1'/*/M(.!
forma:
.$#6(-,%!-$!)$&%!$!%$#3/4,%!%1)%'/'1',%!$!6,."*$.$&'(#$%!
Valor de uso direto! S`cLUk! 3(*,#! 01$! ,%! /&-/3>-1,%! ,1! .$#6(-,%! +/",'F'/6,%! "(#(! .$-/#! (%! 3(#/(48$%! -$!
atribuem a um recurso ambiental pelo fato de que dele se )$.G$%'(#! -/#$'(.$&'$! -(! -$.(&-(! -,%! /&-/3>-1,%! ",#!
1'/*/M(.!-/#$'(.$&'$<!",#!$K$."*,<!&(!2,#.(!-$!$K'#(45,<! 01(*/-(-$!(.)/$&'(*:
-$!3/%/'(45,!,1!,1'#(!('/3/-(-$!-$!"#,-145,!,1!6,&%1.,!
a(.)F.! ,! [&%'/'1',! m#(%/*$/#,! -,! V$/,! T.)/$&'$! $! -,%!
-/#$',:
\$61#%,%!;('1#(/%!\$&,3J3$/%!S[mTVTU!3$.!%$!-$-/6(&-,!
Valor de uso indireto!S`c[Uk!3(*,#!01$!,%!/&-/3>-1,%!('#/)1$.! (,!$%'1-,!-(!3(*,#(45,!$6,&O./6(!-,%!/."(6',%!(.)/$&'(/%!
a um recurso ambiental quando o benefcio do seu uso -$6,##$&'$%! -$! /&%'(*(48$%! -$! 6,.1&/6(45,<! #$-$! $*F'#/6(!
-$#/3(! -$! 21&48$%! $6,%%/%'N./6(%<! 6,.,<! ",#! $K$."*,<! (! $! -1',%! $.! c&/-(-$%! -$! A,&%$#3(45,<! 6,.! ,! ,)e$'/3,!
6,&'$&45,!-$!$#,%5,!$!(!#$"#,-145,!-$!$%"F6/$%!.(#/&+(%! -$! 6(*61*(#! 1.(! 6,."$&%(45,! H&(&6$/#(! (! %$#! "(9(!
"$*,%! $."#$$&-$-,#$%<! &,! 6,&'$K',! -$! */6$&6/(.$&',%!
"$*(!6,&%$#3(45,!-$!l,#$%'(%!-$!.(&91$:
(.)/$&'(/%! 6,##$'/3,%:! W! .,-$*,! 6,.)/&(! -/3$#%(%!
Valor de opo! S`WUk! 3(*,#! 01$! ,! /&-/3>-1,! ('#/)1/! $.! .$',-,*,9/(%!(."(#(-(%!&(!-/%",%/45,!-$!6,&%1./-,#$%!
"#$%$#3(#! #$61#%,%! 01$! ",-$.! $%'(#! (.$(4(-,%<! "(#(! (!"(9(#!",#!%$#3/4,%!(.)/$&'(/%:@
1%,%! -/#$',! $! /&-/#$',! &,! 21'1#,! "#IK/.,:! R,#! $K$."*,<!
,! )$&$2>6/,! (-3/&-,! -$! '$#("/(%! 9$&F'/6(%! 6,.! )(%$! $.! W!01$!F!#$(*.$&'$!&,3(!F!(!"#$,61"(45,!-$!'#(&%",#!$%%(%!
"#,"#/$-(-$%!-$!9$&$%!(/&-(!&5,!-$%6,)$#',%!-$!"*(&'(%! .$',-,*,9/(%! "(#(! (! %$(#(! -,! L/#$/',<! '$&-,! $.! 3/%'(! ,%!
'#,"/6(/%:
3(*,#$%! e1#>-/6,%! "#,'$9/-,%! "$*,! ,#-$&(.$&',! e1#>-/6,!
(.)/$&'(*!$!(%!21&48$%!-(!#$%",&%()/*/-(-$!6/3/*!,)e$'/3(:!
Valor de no uso ou valor de existncia! S`QUk! 3(*,#! 01$! T'F! #$6$&'$.$&'$<! &5,! #(#,<! ,! "#I"#/,! Y1/M! (#)/'#(3(!
$%'J! -/%%,6/(-,! -,! 1%,! S$.),#(! #$"#$%$&'$! 6,&%1.,! 3(*,#$%! /&-$&/M('I#/,%! "(#(! -(&,%! (.)/$&'(/%<! 6,.,! %$!
(.)/$&'(*U!$!-$#/3(!-$!1.(!",%/45,!.,#(*<!61*'1#(*<!F'/6(! $%'/3$%%$! */-(&-,! 6,.! 1.(! "$&(:h! o,e$<! )1%6(G%$! .(/,#!
,1! (*'#1>%'/6(! $.! #$*(45,! (,%! -/#$/',%! -$! $K/%'N&6/(! -$!
,1'#(%!$%"F6/$%!01$!&5,!(!+1.(&(!,1!-$!,1'#(%!#/01$M(%! _! !VF',-,%!-/#$',%k!(-./'$.!(!(*'$#(45,!-,!)$.G$%'(#!"$*(!3(#/(45,!-(!
naturais, mesmo que estas no representem uso atual ou -/%",&/)/*/-(-$!-$!1.!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*!$<!(%%/.<!"#,61#(.!/-$&'/H6(#!
(%!"#$2$#N&6/(%!#$3$*(-(%!&(%!61#3(%!-$!-$.(&-(!S3(#/(48$%!-,!$K6$-$&'$!
21'1#,! "(#(! &/&91F.:! c.! $K$."*,! 6*(#,! -$%'$! 3(*,#! F! (! -,!6,&%1./-,#U<!01(&-,!,!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*!F!-/#$'(.$&'$!6,&%1./-,<!
9#(&-$!.,)/*/M(45,!-(!,"/&/5,!"=)*/6(!"(#(!,!%(*3(.$&',! ,1!&(%!"$#-(%!-$!#$6$/'(%!*>01/-(%!S3(#/(48$%!-,!$K6$-$&'$!-,!"#,-1',#U<!
-,%!"(&-(%!,1!-(%!)(*$/(%<!.$%.,!$.!#$9/8$%!$.!01$!(! 01(&-,! ,! #$61#%,! (.)/$&'(*! F! 1.! /&%1.,! &(! "#,-145,! -$! ,1'#,! )$.!
,1!%$#3/4,:!X1(!("*/6(45,!F!6,."*$K(!$<!.1/'(%!3$M$%<!61%',%(<!'(&',!$.!
.(/,#/(!-(%!"$%%,(%!&1&6(!",-$#J!$%'(#!,1!2(M$#!01(*01$#! '$.",! 6,.,! H&(&6$/#(.$&'$<! ",/%! #$01$#! 1.(! (."*(! -/%",&/)/*/-(-$!
-$!-(-,%!S(.)/$&'(/%!$!$6,&O./6,%U!$!,!(",#'$!-$!.,-$*,%!$%'('>%'/6,%!
1%,!-$!%1(!$K/%'N&6/(:
Q%'(! 2,#.1*(45,! 2,/! /&6*1>-(! "$*(! T%%,6/(45,! m#(%/*$/#(!
-$! ;,#.(%! aF6&/6(%! STm;aU<! &(! ;m\! C_h@^! n! R(#'$! h<!
01$!3$#%(!%,)#$!.F',-,%!$!"#,6$-/.$&',%!"(#(!(3(*/(45,!
-$! #$61#%,%! &('1#(/%<! ',-,%! )(%$(-,%! $.! .$',-,*,9/(%!
3,*'(-(%! 7! (2$#/45,! -(! -/%",%/45,! -$! 6,&%1./-,#$%! (!
"(9(#! ",#! %$#3/4,%! $6,*I9/6,%! $! 21&48$%! (.)/$&'(/%:!
T%! (),#-(9$&%! -/3/-$.G%$! $.! .F',-,%! /&-/#$',%<3 que
^! !A,&2,#.$!$K"*/6/'(!,!/'$.!E:h!-(!;m\!C_h@^Gh<!$%%$%!.F',-,%<!(,!/&3F%!
-$! $%'/.(#$.! -/#$'(.$&'$! 3(*,#$%! (%%,6/(-,%! 7! -/%",%/45,! (! "(9(#! ,1! (!
#$6$)$#! -,%! /&-/3>-1,%! 01(&',! (! 3(#/(48$%! -$! 01(*/-(-$! ,1! 01(&'/-(-$!
(.)/$&'(*<!1'/*/M(.G%$!-$!$%'/.('/3(%!-$!61%',%!(%%,6/(-,%!(,%!-(&,%:!R,#!
/%%,<!%$1%!3(*,#$%!-$3$.!%$#!$&'$&-/-,%!6,.,!("#,K/.(48$%!-(!3$#-(-$/#(!
-/.$&%5,!$6,&O./6(!-,%!-(&,%!$!-$3$.!%$#!1'/*/M(-,%!01(&-,!,%!.F',-,%!
-/#$',%!&5,!"1-$#$.!%$#!("*/6(-,%!",#!2(*'(!-$!-(-,%!'(&',!'$6&,*I9/6,%!
6,.,!$6,&O./6,%:!A,.,!%5,!)(%$(-,%!$.!61%',%!"(#(!#$",#!(!01(*/-(-$!
(.)/$&'(*!,1!#$*,6(*/M(#!,1!$3/'(#!-(&,%<!%1(!-/.$&%5,!",-$!/&6,#",#(#!
3(*,#$%!-$!1%,!$!-$!&5,!1%,<!",/%!%$!(%%1.$!01$!,!-(&,!%$#/(!#$%'(1#(-,!
,1!$3/'(-,:!X5,!$K$."*,%k!(U!Custo de reposio/recuperao do bemj!)U Custos
de relocalizaok!3(#/(&'$!-,!61%',!-$!#$",%/45,!1'/*/M(-(!"(#(!3(*,#(#!-(&,%!
(.)/$&'(/%! ",#! .$/,! -,%! 9(%',%! &$6$%%J#/,%! "(#(! #$*,6(*/M(#! ,! #$61#%,!
(.)/$&'(*!-$9#(-(-,j!6U!Custos defensivos ou de proteo evitados: estima o
3(*,#!-$!1.!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*!",#!.$/,!-,%!9(%',%!$3/'(-,%!,1!(!%$#$.!
$3/'(-,%!6,.!('/3/-(-$%!-$2$&%/3(%<!%1)%'/'1'(%!,1!6,."*$.$&'(#$%!01$!
",-$.!%$#!6,&%/-$#(-(%!6,.,!1.(!("#,K/.(45,!.,&$'J#/(!-(%!3(#/(48$%!
-$!)$.G$%'(#!-,!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*j!$!-U!Custo de oportunidade de conservao:
&5,!3(*,#(!,!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*<!.(%!%/.!,!61%',!-$!%1(!6,&%$#3(45,<!",#!
.$/,!-(!.$&%1#(45,!-,!61%',!-$!,",#'1&/-(-$!-$!('/3/-(-$%!$6,&O./6(%!
#$%'#/&9/-(%!"$*(%!(48$%!-$!"#,'$45,!(.)/$&'(*<!6,&%/-$#(-,%!,%!)$&$2>6/,%!
$6,*I9/6,%!-(!6,&%$#3(45,:

$! $6,&,.F'#/6,%:! X5,! $K$."*,%! -$! .F',-,%! -/#$',%k! ,! mtodo da

produtividade marginal<! 01$! /-$&'/H6(! ,! 3(*,#! -,! #$61#%,! (.)/$&'(*! ",#!
sua contribuio como insumo ou fator de produo para a obteno de
1.!"#,-1',j!,!mtodo de mercado de bens substitutos<!01$!%$!3(*$!-,%!"#$4,%!
-$!.$#6(-,!-$!)$&%!%1)%'/'1',%!"(#(!,!)$.!*$%(-,j!,!mtodo dos preos
hednicos<! 01$! 1'/*/M(! "#$4,%! -$! .$#6(-,<! "#/&6/"(*.$&'$! -$! /.I3$/%!
,1! 61%',%! -$! %$#3/4,%! "(#(! $%'/.(#! ,! 3(*,#! -(%! -/2$#$&4(%! -$! &>3$*! -$!
('#/)1',%!(.)/$&'(/%!/.",#'(&'$%!&(!2,#.(45,!-$%%$%!"#$4,%!,1!61%',%j!
o mtodo de custo de viagem, que estima a demanda dos consumidores por
1.!%>'/,!&('1#(*!,1!+/%'I#/6,!$.!3/#'1-$!-(!-/%",%/45,!$.!"(9(#!"$*,%!
61%',%! -$! -$%*,6(.$&',j! ,! mtodo da avaliao contingente, que consiste
$.!%$!$%'/.(#!,!3(*,#!-$!-/%",%/45,!(!"(9(#!(!"(#'/#!-(!6,&%'#145,!-$!1.!
.$#6(-,!+/",'F'/6,!"(#(!,!)$.!,1!%$#3/4,:
@! !W!.,-$*,!$&3,*3$!%$/%!"(#6$*(%!-/%'/&'(%k!(U!"$#-(!-$!,",#'1&/-(-$%!
-$! 1%,! #$91*(.$&'(#! -(%! c&/-(-$%! -$! A,&%$#3(45,! (2$'(-(%! "$*(%!
*/&+(%!-$!'#(&%./%%5,j!)U!/."(6',!6N&/6,<!("1#(-,!(!"(#'/#!-$!3(*,#(45,!
6,&'/&9$&'$j!6U!"$#-(!-$!3/%/'(45,<!("1#(-(!(!"(#'/#!-,!61%',!-$!3/(9$.j!
-U! "$#-(! -$! 21&48$%! (.)/$&'(/%! "#,",#6/,&(-(%! "$*,%! $6,%%/%'$.(%j! $U!
3(*,#! -$! #/%6,! -$6,##$&'$! -(! $K/%'N&6/(! -(%! /&%'(*(48$%j! $! 2U! 2(',#! %,6/(*!
01$!6,&%/-$#(!(!/.",#'p&6/(!"(#(!(!","1*(45,!-(!.(&1'$&45,!-(%!*/&+(%!
-$!'#(&%./%%5,<!-$!%,#'$!01$!,!3(*,#!-,!-(&,!%$#J!(2$'(-,!",#!$%%$!2(',#:!
S[mTVT<!?]]?U:
h! !`$#<!6,.,!$K$."*,<!(!%$&'$&4(!-(!Y1>M(!B$-$#(*!q/,3(&(!q1/.(#5$%!
A,#'$M<!-(!?r!`(#(!B$-$#(*!-$!Y,/&3/**$<!("#$6/(&-,!(45,!6/3/*!"=)*/6(!$.!
01$!%$!"$-/(!(!6,&-$&(45,!-$!1.(!$."#$%(!(,!"(9(.$&',!-$!/&-$&/M(45,!
"$*(!",*1/45,!('.,%2F#/6(!6(1%(-(:!R#,6$%%,!&s!?]]?:t?:]C:]]^@?tG]uXA<!
e1*9(-,!$.!?_:]D:t?]]D:!L/%",&>3$*!$.k!vwww:'#2_:e1%:)#x:!T6$%%,!$.k!
Ch!-$M:!?]C]:

MPMG Jurdico Especial !25

6/$&'/H6/-(-$!"(#(!(%!.$',-,*,9/(%!-$!3(*,#(45,!-,!-(&,! /&'#>&%$6,<!/&6*1/&-,!,%!3(*,#$%!$6,*I9/6,<!9$&F'/6,<!%,6/(*<!
.('$#/(*!/##$3$#%>3$*<!-$/K(&-,G%$!,!(#)/'#(.$&',!e1-/6/(*! $6,&O./6,<! 6/$&'>H6,<! $-16(6/,&(*<! 61*'1#(*<! #$6#$('/3,! $!
"(#(! (%! +/"I'$%$%! -$! -(&,! $K'#("('#/.,&/(*! (.)/$&'(*! $%'F'/6,:gE
S-(&,!.,#(*!6,*$'/3,U:
R,#! %1(! 3$M<! (! #$%",&%()/*/-(-$! 6/3/*! ,)e$'/3(! "$*,! -(&,!
;,! $&'(&',<! 6,.,! (! .(/,#! "(#'$! -(%! .$',-,*,9/(%! ambiental9! "#,"8$G%$! 7! #$"(#(45,! f/&'$9#(*g! -,! -(&,<!
(."(#(G%$! &(! -/%",%/45,! -$! 6,&%1./-,#$%! $.! "(9(#! ,! 01$! /."*/6(! (! /.",%/45,! (,! ",*1/-,#! -$! ,)#/9(48$%!
",#! )$&%! $! %$#3/4,%! (.)/$&'(/%! SLTRU<! $%'(! '#(&%",%/45,! 3,*'(-(%!7!"#$3$&45,!-$!&,3,%!-(&,%<!7!#$%'(1#(45,!-,%!
"(#(! ,! 1&/3$#%,! -,! -(&,! (.)/$&'(*! -$3$! %$#! "#$6$-/-(! (%"$6',%! #$3$#%>3$/%<! 6,.! 3/%'(%! (,! #$',#&,! (,! status quo
-$! (*91.(%! #$l$K8$%:! P! "#$6/%,! %()$#! $K('(.$&'$! ,! 01$! ante<! $! 7! /&-$&/M(45,! -$! -(&,%! $K'#("('#/.,&/(/%! $! -$!
$%"$#(#! -$! 6(-(! 1.(! -(%! .$',-,*,9/(%<! %1(%! */./'(48$%! -(&,%!.('$#/(/%!/##$3$#%>3$/%:!X(*/$&'$G%$!01$!(!#$"(#(45,!
$! %1(%! ",%%/)/*/-(-$%<! 6,.! /%%,! ()#/&-,G%$! $%"(4,%! /&'$9#(*!F!1.!/-$(*!e1#>-/6,<!&5,!&$6$%%(#/(.$&'$!('/&9>3$*!
"(#(! ,! -$%$&3,*3/.$&',! -$! ,1'#(%! 6,&6$"48$%! '$I#/6(%! &(! #$(*/-(-$! 2J'/6(:C]! X,)! ,! ",&',! -$! 3/%'(! -(! Q6,*,9/(<!
01$! ",%%(.! 6,##$%",&-$#! .$*+,#! (,%! ,)e$'/3,%! -(! ',-,%! ,%! -(&,%! (.)/$&'(/%! %5,! /##$3$#%>3$/%<! eJ! 01$! (!
#$%",&%()/*/-(-$!6/3/*:!L/(&'$!-/%%,<!,!,)e$'/3,!-$%'$!)#$3$! .('F#/(!$!(!$&$#9/(!"$#-/-(%<!("I%!(!-$9#(-(45,!-$!1.(!
$%'1-,! F! #$%",&-$#! 7%! %$91/&'$%! /&-(9(48$%k! ,! 01$! &I%<! J#$(<! %5,! /##$61"$#J3$/%:! SmQ\a|W<! ?]]t<! ":! ^EDU:! ;,!
,"$#(-,#$%! -,! L/#$/',<! $%"$#(.,%! -$! 1.(! .$',-,*,9/(! $&'(&',<! +(3$#J! (! #$"(#(45,! e1#>-/6(! /&'$9#(*<! .$%.,!
-$! 3(*,#(45,! -$! -(&,%! (.)/$&'(/%! /##$3$#%>3$/%y! A,.,! 01(&-,!(!#$%'(1#(45,!&('1#(*!2,#!/.",%%>3$*<!01(&-,!-,!
"(9(.$&',!-$!1.(!/&-$&/M(45,!01$!$&6$##$!(!.(/,#!"(#'$!
",-$.,%!6,&'#/)1/#!"(#(!01$!$%%(!3(*,#(45,!,6,##(yt
-,%!3(*,#$%!(%%,6/(-,%!(,!-(&,:

8!"93",.:'/$2,3"&)"2)0,1)*+,"';,%<-$;)"&,"&)%,"
Portanto, quando da ocorrncia de um desmatamento,
&$)%/'"&)"1'3=,%3).$0$&)&'";$2$0")-.$'%/)0
X,)!,!",&',!-$!3/%'(!e1#>-/6,<!,!-(&,!(.)/$&'(*!#$"#$%$&'(!
1.! 9#(3$! -$%$01/*>)#/,! &(%! 21&48$%! -,! $6,%%/%'$.(! $!
$.! %$1%! $*$.$&',%! /&'$9#(&'$%<! 6,.,! ,! %,*,<! (! J91(<! (!
3$9$'(45,<! (! 2(1&(! $! ',-,! ,! 6,."*$K,! -$! /&'$##$*(48$%!
-(>!#$%1*'(&'$%:!T!6,&%'#145,!-$!1.!6,&6$/',!()#(&9$&'$!
para o dano ambiental decorre do prprio conceito de
.$/,!(.)/$&'$<!6,&%,(&'$!-$H&/-,!"$*,!(#':!^<![<!-(!z$/!&s!
h:D^EuEC<!%$91&-,!,!01(*!,!.$/,!(.)/$&'$!F!, conjunto
-$!6,&-/48$%<!*$/%<!/&l1N&6/(%!$!/&'$#(48$%!-$!,#-$.!2>%/6(<!
01>./6(! $! )/,*I9/6(<! 01$! "$#./'$<! ()#/9(! $! #$9$! (! 3/-(!
$.! ',-(%! (%! %1(%! 2,#.(%g:! T*F.! -/%%,<! (,! #$6,&+$6$#! ,!
3(*,#!-(!)/,-/3$#%/-(-$<!,!L$6#$',!B$-$#(*!&s!_:^^Du?]]?<!
$K"#$%%(.$&'$!#$2$#$!01$!f,!3(*,#!-$!1%,!-(!)/,-/3$#%/-(-$!
F!-$'$#./&(-,!"$*,%!3(*,#$%!61*'1#(/%!$!/&6*1/!3(*,#!-$!1%,!
-/#$',! $! /&-/#$',<! -$! ,"45,! -$! 1%,! 21'1#,! $<! (/&-(<! 3(*,#!
fP!)(%'(&'$!-/2>6/*!01(&'/H6(#!"$61&/(#/(.$&'$!,!-(&,!%,2#/-,<!1.(!3$M!
01$! ,! 3(*,#! -,! )$.! F! /&$%'/.J3$*:! P! 6$#',<! ",#F.<! 01$! (! /&-$&/M(45,!
-$3$! #$l$'/#! ,! "#$e1>M,! %,2#/-,! "$*(! 6,*$'/3/-(-$! $<! (,! .$%.,! '$.",<!
-$3$! ,)e$'/3(#! (! -$%$%'/.1*(#! (! ,6,##N&6/(! -$! ,1'#(%! 6,&-1'(%! *$%/3(%:!
\$9/%'#,!01$!-$/K,!-$!#$.$'$#!7!"$#>6/(!(!HK(45,!-,!3(*,#!-(!/&-$&/M(45,<!
'$&-,! $.! 3/%'(! (! "(#'/61*(#/-(-$! -$! %$! '#('(#! -$! ",*1/45,! ('.,%2F#/6(<!
que em muito se diferencia dos casos mais comuns, de supresso de
3$9$'(45,<!&,%!01(/%!(!6,)$#'1#(!3$9$'(*!%1"#/./-(!'$.!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,!
"(%%>3$*! -$! (2$#/45,! ",#! "$#>6/(:! R(#(! $%'/.(#! ,! 3(*,#! -(! /&-$&/M(45,<!
1'/*/M,!6,.,!"(#p.$'#,!/&-$&/M('I#/,!(!"$&(!('#/)1>-(!(,!2(',!&(!%$(#(!
(-./&/%'#('/3(<!01$!"#$3N!.1*'(!.>&/.(!-$!\{!@:]]]<]]!S6/&6,!./*!#$(/%U!
$!(!.JK/.(!-$!\{!@]:]]]:]]]<]]!S6/&01$&'(!./*+8$%!-$!#$(/%U!"(#(!,!6(%,!
-$! ,! (9$&'$! %$#! 6(1%(-,#! -$! ",*1/45,! -$! 01(*01$#! &('1#$M(! $.! &>3$/%!
'(/%! 01$! #$%1*'$.! ,1! ",%%(.! #$%1*'(#! $.! -(&,%! 7! %(=-$! +1.(&(<! ,1!
01$!"#,3,01$.!(!.,#'(&-(-$!-$!(&/.(/%!,1!(!-$%'#1/45,!%/9&/H6('/3(!
-(! )/,-/3$#%/-(-$! S(#':! hh! -,! L$6#$',! &s! h:@C_u?]]EU:! ;(! +/"I'$%$<!
,)%$#3,! ,%! %$91/&'$%! "(#p.$'#,%k! ,! ",#'$! -(! $."#$%(G#F<! (&(*/%(&-,!
%,)!,!"#/%.(!-$!%$1!6("/'(*!%,6/(*!$!&=.$#,!-$!$."#$9,%j!,%!/&6O.,-,%!
6(1%(-,%!"$*(! ('/3/-(-$!-(!#F! (,%!3/M/&+,%j!$! ,!2(',! -$!01$! (! $."#$%(!
operou por mais de quatro anos sem a competente licena ambiental,
*(&4(&-,!&(!('.,%2$#(!.('$#/(*!"(#'/61*(-,!(6/.(!-,%!&>3$/%!',*$#(-,%:!
T%%/.<!*$3(&-,!$.!6,&'(!'(/%!6#/'F#/,%<!'$&+,!",#!#(M,J3$*!$!",&-$#(-(!(!
HK(45,!-(!/&-$&/M(45,!$.!\{!?]:]]]<]]!S3/&'$!./*!#$(/%U<!.,&'(&'$!01$!%$!
("#$%$&'(!$.!%/&',&/(!6,.!(!#$(*/-(-$!$6,&O./6(!-(!$."#$%(!#F:g
t! !Q.!3/#'1-$!-(!*/./'(45,!-$!"J9/&(%<!&5,!",-$#$.,%!-/%6,##$#!%,)#$!
(%! .$',-,*,9/(%<! .(%! #$.$'$.,%! ,! *$/',#! "(#(! V,''(! S?]]hU<! ,&-$! (!
2,#.1*(45,!`Qa!S`Q\TU!$%'J!)$.!$K"*/6/'(-(:

26 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

",#! $K$."*,<! F! .1/',! /.",#'(&'$! 01$! ,! .F',-,! "(#(!

01(&'/H6(45,! -(! /&-$&/M(45,! (! %$#! "(9(! "$*,! -(&,!
(.)/$&'(*!/##$3$#%>3$*!%$e(!6("(M!-$!.$&%1#(#!&5,!("$&(%!
(%"$6',%! ,)e$'/3,%<! 6("'(-,%! "$*,! .$#6(-,! 6,&%1./-,#<!
01$!#$"$#61'$.!&,!"#$4,!-,!)$.!,1!-,!%$#3/4,!*$%(-,<!.(%!
'(.)F.! ,! 3(*,#! -(%! 21&48$%! $6,%%/%'N./6(%! -$9#(-(-(%<!
'(/%!6,.,!(%!21&48$%!-$!()#/9,!"(#(!2(1&(<!-/%"$#%5,!-$!
%$.$&'$%<!#$91*(45,!-,!6*/.(<!$'6:
Q%'(! "(#6$*(! f%1)e$'/3(g! -,! -(&,<! 6,##$%",&-$&'$! 7%!
21&48$%! $6,%%/%'N./6(%<! (,! 3(*,#! -$! ,"45,! $! (,! 3(*,#! -$!
$K/%'N&6/(<!F!1.!-$%(H,!(!%$#!$&2#$&'(-,!"$*,%!$%'1-/,%,%!
-,! '$.(:! A,&2,#.$! $K"*/6/'(.! V(ij! `$/9(! ;$',j! R,M,!
S?]CCU<! (%! .$',-,*,9/(%! (."(#(-(%! &(! -/%",%/45,! $.!
"(9(#!&5,!%$!#$3$*(.!(-$01(-(%!7!(2$#/45,!-,%!3(*,#$%!-$!
1%,!/&-/#$',<!-,!3(*,#!-$!,"45,!$!-,!3(*,#!-$!$K/%'N&6/(<!
pois a maioria dos benefcios ecossistmicos
}:::~!&5,!'$.!3(*,#!-$!.$#6(-,<!,1!%5,!#$(*/MJ3$/%!%,.$&'$!
(!*,&9,!"#(M,<!&5,!%$&-,!6("'1#J3$/%!-1#(&'$!,!+,#/M,&'$!
'$.",#(*! -,! 1%1J#/,! }:::~:! a(.)F.! (%! 6,."*$K(%!
/&'$#6,&$K8$%! $&'#$! ,%! "#,6$%%,%! $6,%%/%'N./6,%! $! (!
9$#(45,!-$!"#,-1',%!6,.$#6/(*/MJ3$/%!,1!-$!%1)%/%'N&6/(!
&5,!%5,!%$."#$!$3/-$&'$%!(,!1%1J#/,!-$!#$61#%,%!&('1#(/%<!
*$3(&-,!7!%1(!$K(1%'5,!,1!-$9#(-(45,:11

T-$.(/%<!&5,!+J!/-$&'/-(-$!$&'#$!,%!6,&6$/',%!-$!"#$4,!$!
-$! 3(*,#:! 1(&-,! 1.(! -$'$#./&(-(! $%"F6/$! F! -$6*(#(-(!
E! !T&$K,<!/'$.!?<![`:
D! !`$#!(#'/9,%!??@<!!^!-(!ABuEE<!$!C_<!!C -(!z$/!&s!h:D^EuEC:
C]! !T!#$%"$/',<!*$6/,&(!X(&%$3$#/&,!S?]C]U!01$!f,!"#/&6>"/,!-(!#$"(#(45,!
/&'$9#(*!,1!"*$&(!)1%6(!6,*,6(!,!*$%(-,<!&(!.$-/-(!-,!",%%>3$*<!$.!1.(!
%/'1(45,!$01/3(*$&'$!7!01$!%$!$&6,&'#(3(!(&'$%!-$!,6,##$#!,!2(',!-(&,%,<!
-$! .,-,! 01$! 6,&%'/'1/! 1.(! -/#$'/3(! "(#(! (! (3(*/(45,! -,%! "#$e1>M,%! $!
01(&'/H6(45,! -(! /&-$&/M(45,:! a#('(G%$! -$! 1.(! H645,<! ",/%<! $.! .1/'(%!
%/'1(48$%<!6,.,!&,!6(%,!-$!-(&,!.,#'$<!/%%,!F!,"$#(-,!-$!2,#.(!("$&(%!
("#,K/.('/3(!,1!6,&e$6'1#(*:!Q%6*(#$6$!01$<!",#!$%'$!"#/&6>"/,<!,%!-(&,%!
-$3$.! %$#! (3(*/(-,%! -$! '(*! .,-,! (! 6,."$&%(#! /&'$9#(*.$&'$! ',-,%! ,%!
"#$e1>M,%!%,2#/-,%!"$*(!3>'/.(g!SXT;XQ`Q\[;W<!?]C]<!":!_DU:
CC! !V(ij!`$/9(!;$',j!R,M,!S?]CCU:

6,.,! (.$(4(-(! -$! $K'/&45,<! %$1! 3(*,#! -$! $K/%'N&6/(! 01(*/H6(45,! -$! (9#(3,%Ct! '(.)F.! %$! "#,"8$.! (! (2$#/#!
(1.$&'(!-$!/.$-/(',:!V(%!&$.!%$."#$!/%%,!,6,##$!6,.!,! 3(*,#$%!-$!1%,!/&-/#$',!(!"(#'/#!-(!6,&%'#145,!-$!'()$*(%!
%$1!"#$4,<!01$!",-$!3(#/(#!,1!&5,:12
$.! 01$! ('#/)1$.! f"$%,%g! "(#(! ,%! -/3$#%,%! ('#/)1',%!
(.)/$&'(/%!-,!(.)/$&'$!*$%(-,:
A,.,! #$%,*3$#! ,! /."(%%$y! Q&'$&-$.,%! 01$! ,!
#$6,&+$6/.$&',! e1#>-/6,! -(! -/.$&%5,! $K'#("('#/.,&/(*! Q.! 1.(! (&J*/%$! *$/9(<! "$#6$)$G%$! 01$! $%'(! (),#-(9$.!
-,!-(&,!(.)/$&'(*<!01$!F!,)e$',!-$!(#)/'#(.$&',!e1-/6/(*<! (%%$.$*+(G%$! 7! ,"45,! (-,'(-(! "$*(! c&/5,! B$-$#(*<! &,!
#$%,*3$! ,! "#,)*$.(! -,! -(&,! (,%! 3(*,#$%! -$! ,"45,! $! -$! L$6#$',! &s! h:E_Eu?]]D<! 01(&-,! #$91*(.$&',1! (! 2,#.(!
$K/%'N&6/(<! ",/%! $K/%'$! (01/! 1.(! -/.$&%5,! F'/6(! 01$! ,! de calcular a compensao ambiental a que se refere o
-/#$/',!'(.)F.!(6,*+$!01(&-,!'1'$*(!(!3/-(!$.!',-(%!(%! (#':! ^h! -(! z$/! &s! D:DE@u?]]]<! "(#(! $."#$$&-/.$&',%! -$!
%1(%!2,#.(%<!,!-/#$/',!+1.(&,!$!-,%!(&/.(/%!7!01(*/-(-$!-$! %/9&/H6('/3(!-$9#(-(45,!(.)/$&'(*:!W!(#':!^CGT!"#$3N!01$!
3/-(<!,!-/#$/',!7!"#$%$#3(45,!-(!.$.I#/(!$!-(!(2$'/3/-(-$! ,! 3(*,#! -(! 6,."$&%(45,! %$#J! 6(*61*(-,! "$*,! "#,-1',! -,!
"$*,%!)$&%!61*'1#(/%!$!&('1#(/%:13
9#(1!-$!/."(6',!6,.!,!3(*,#!-$!#$2$#N&6/(<!-$!(6,#-,!6,.!
(!%$91/&'$!2I#.1*(k!CA b!VR!K!GI, onde VR!b!%,.('I#/,!
R,#! %$1! '1#&,<! ,%! 3(*,#$%! -$! 1%,! /&-/#$',<! /-$&'/H6(-,%! -,%! /&3$%'/.$&',%! &$6$%%J#/,%! "(#(! /."*(&'(45,! -,!
6,.! (%! 21&48$%! $6,%%/%'N./6(%<! $2$'/3(.$&'$! $."#$$&-/.$&',<! &5,! /&6*1>-,%! ,%! /&3$%'/.$&',%!
.$#$6$.! .$',-,*,9/(%! 01$! "$#6$)(.! (! &$6$%%J#/(! #$2$#$&'$%! (,%! "*(&,%<! "#,e$',%! $! "#,9#(.(%! $K/9/-,%! &,!
/&'$#-/%6/"*/&(#/-(-$!"(#(!6,."#$$&%5,!-(!6,."*$K/-(-$! "#,6$-/.$&',!-$!*/6$&6/(.$&',!(.)/$&'(*!"(#(!./'/9(45,!
(.)/$&'(*:! T! #$%"$/',! -$%'$! (%%1&',<! T*.$/-(! S?]]EU! de impactos causados pelo empreendimento, bem como
(",&'(!01$!$%'(!f"(#6$*(!%1)e$'/3(g!-,!-(&,!",-$#/(!%$#! ,%!$&6(#9,%!$!61%',%!/&6/-$&'$%!%,)#$!,!H&(&6/(.$&',!-,!
apurada a partir de ndices que
$."#$$&-/.$&',<!/&6*1%/3$!,%!#$*('/3,%!7%!9(#(&'/(%<!$!,%!
61%',%!6,.!("I*/6$%!$!"#N./,%!-$!%$91#,%!"$%%,(/%!$!#$(/%j!
}:::~!"#,61#(.!01(*/H6(#!$!+/$#(#01/M(#!1.!-$'$#./&(-,! e GI!b!q#(1!-$![."(6',!&,%!$6,%%/%'$.(%<!",-$&-,!('/&9/#!
$6,%%/%'$.(! $.! 21&45,! -,%! .(/%! -/3$#%,%! "(#p.$'#,%!
3(*,#$%!-$%-$!M$#,!(!]<@:CE
",%%>3$/%!}:::~:!Q%%$!2(',#!",-$!%$#!-$%$&3,*3/-,!$.!21&45,!
-$!>&-/6$%!(6(-N./6,%<!-(!6('$9,#/M(45,!-(%!c&/-(-$%!-$!
A,&%$#3(45,! $! '/",! -$! %,*,! ,1! ,1'#,! .F',-,! 01(*01$#<!
-$%-$!01$!9(#(&'(!(!"#,",#6/,&(*/-(-$!$&'#$!,%!-/3$#%,%!
$6,%%/%'$.(%:C_

T/&-(<!,!(1',#!(",&'(!"(#(!(!&$6$%%/-(-$!-$!01(&'/H6(45,!
-,! *16#,! 6$%%(&'$! (.)/$&'(*! "(#(! (%! +/"I'$%$%! $.! 01$!
-$'$#./&(-,%!%$#3/4,%!$6,*I9/6,%!-$/K(.!-$!%$#!2,#&$6/-,%!
"$*,!"$#>,-,!&$6$%%J#/,!7!#$%'(1#(45,<!,!01$!F!2$/',!('#(3F%!
-(!("*/6(45,!-$!2I#.1*(%!.('$.J'/6(%!$%"$6>H6(%:C@
T!.$',-,*,9/(!`Q\L!S`(*,#!Q%'/.(-,!-$!\$2$#N&6/(!"(#(!
(! L$9#(-(45,! (.)/$&'(*U<! -$%$&3,*3/-(! "$*,! 01>./6,!
T#'1#! \$&(',! T*)$6+$! A(#-,%,<Ch! $! (! .$',-,*,9/(! -(!
C?! !T!(1',#(!L$#(&/!SCDDt<!":!CC^U!$K"*/6(!01$!,%!)$&%!&5,!"#$6/%(.!%$#!
escassos por si, basta que sejam escassamente apresentados no mercado,
",/%!f&(!()1&-p&6/(<!&5,!+J!*16#,g:
C^! !T!#$%"$/',<!3$#!z$/'$!S?]]]<!":!?DEU!$!X'$/9*$-$#!S?]]E<!":!?^U:
C_! TzVQ[LT<!\,-#/9,!-$:![&k!aWAAoQaaW<!L,./&9,%!SW#9U:!Percia
;1$-$%)0!!A(."/&(%k!V/**$&&/1.<!?]C]<!":!??C:!W!(1',#!-$%$&3,*3$1!-1(%!
'()$*(%<!1.(!6,&%/-$#(&-,!,!.(6#,M,&$(.$&',<!$!(!,1'#(!"(#(!c&/-(-$%!
-$!A,&%$#3(45,!$!J#$(%!-$!"#$%$#3(45,!"$#.(&$&'$<!('#/)1/&-,!2(',#$%!
"(#(! 6(-(! 1.(! -(%! 6('$9,#/(%:! R,#! $K$."*,<! &(! '()$*(! 01$! 6,&%/-$#(!
,! .(6#,M,&$(.$&',<! %$! ,! -(&,! ,6,##$! $.! 1.(! M,&(! -$! 6,&%$#3(45,!
(.)/$&'(*<!,!2(',#!F!?<]j!%$!2,#!$.!J#$(!#1#(*!#$.(&$%6$&'$<!,!2(',#!F!C<?j!
$! (%%/.! ",#! -/(&'$:! ;(! '()$*(! -$-/6(-(! (,%! $%"(4,%! "#,'$9/-,%<! %$! ,!
-(&,! ,6,##$#! $.! 1.! "(#01$! &(6/,&(*! ,1! $.! 1.(! J#$(! -$! "#$%$#3(45,!
"$#.(&$&'$<!,!2(',#!('#/)1>-,!F!h<]j!%$!2,#!2,#(!-$!01(*01$#!1&/-(-$<!,!
2(',#! F! C<]:! L$%%(! 2,#.(<! %$! ,6,##$#! 1.! -$%.('(.$&',! -$&'#,! -$! 1.!
"(#01$!&(6/,&(*<!,!3(*,#!6,##$%",&-$&'$!%$#/(k
A\!b!A\W!K!?<]!SATU!K!h<]!SR;U!b!C?!!A\W<!,&-$k
A\!b!A1%',!-$!#$%'(1#(45,j
A\W!b!A1%',!-$!#$%'(1#(45,!,)e$'/3,j
AT!b!,&(!-$!6,&%$#3(45,!(.)/$&'(*j!$!R;!b!R(#01$!;(6/,&(*:
C@! ![-$.<!":!??@:
Ch! !AT\LWXW<!T#'1#!\$&(',!T:!#"&'71)&)*+,")-.$'%/)0"'"3'>3"2)0,1'3"
econmicos associados:!R,#',!T*$9#$k!X$#9/,!T&',&/,!B()#/%<!?]]^<!":!?t:!

W! (1',#<! (! "(#'/#! -(! ,)#(! -$! V(*$#! $! iM9(! SVTzQ\<! :! qj! qT<!
\:! Q:! Q6,&,./6! .$(%1#$.$&'! ,2! $&3/#,&.$&'(*! -(.(9$k! (! '$6+&/6(*!
+(&-),,:!R(#/%k!WQAL<!CDth<!C@C!":U<!6#/,1!1.(!.$',-,*,9/(!-/%",%'(!
(!/-$&'/H6(#!,%!3(*,#$%!$6,&O./6,%!associados!(,!)$.!(.)/$&'(*:!W!(1',#!
/&-/6(!,%!%$91/&'$%!"(%%,%!&(!3(*,#(45,!$6,&O./6(!-,%!)$&%!(.)/$&'(/%k!
C:! [-$&'/H6(#! (%! variveis tangveis<! 01(&'/H6J3$/%<! ! (%%,6/(-(%! (,! )$.!
(.)/$&'(*<! '(/%! 6,.,! S3(*,#! -$! 6,.$#6/(*/M(45,! -$! )$&%! %$.$*+(&'$%<!
61%',%! $3/'(-,%! 6,.! */6$&6/(.$&',! $! '#('(.$&',! -$! #$%>-1,%! $! J91(<!
$'6:U:! Q%%(%! 3(#/J3$/%! %5,! -$&,./&(-(%! f0gj! ?:! [-$&'/H6(#! (%! variveis
intangveis<! 6,&%/%'$&'$%! $.! f-(&,%! $! #/%6,%! $2$'/3,%! ,1! ",'$&6/(/%<!
"#('/6(-,%!6,&'#(!,%!(.)/$&'$%!2>%/6,<!)/I'/6,!$!(&'#I"/6,<!$.!01$!&5,!+J!
6,.,!$%'()$*$6$#!,1!(%%,6/(#!1.!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,:!Q&01(-#(.G%$!&$%'$!
6(%,k! /&6O.,-,%! 7! %(=-$<! -$%9(%'$%! "%/6,*I9/6,%<! -(&,%! (,! "('#/.O&/,!
+/%'I#/6,! $! 61*'1#(*<! /."(6',! 3/%1(*<! -(&,%! (! 21&9,%<! *>01$&%<! /&%$',%<!
#F"'$/%<!#,$-,#$%<!$'6:g:!Q%%(%!3(#/J3$/%!%5,!-$&,./&(-(%!f/g:!^:!T'#/)1/#!
1.! 9#(1! "(#(! 6(-(! 3(#/J3$*! /&'(&9>3$*<! 01$! /#J! 3(#/(#! -$! ]! SM$#,U! (! _!
S01('#,U!$.!21&45,!-(!/&'$&%/-(-$!$!-1#(45,!-,!/."(6',!6(1%(-,!%,)#$!
,!.$/,!$!%$1%!6,.",&$&'$%<!-(!%$91/&'$!2,#.(k
[."(6',!-$!61#',!"#(M,!S-/(%Uk!]!SM$#,Uk!%$.!/."(6',j!Ck!)(/K,j!?k!.F-/,j!
^k!(*',:
[."(6',!-$!.F-/,!(!*,&9,!"#(M,%!S.$%$%!$!(&,%Uk!_:
W!3(*,#!','(*!-$!f/g!SinU!%$#J!#$"#$%$&'(-,!"$*(!%,.(!-,%!01(&'/H6(-,#$%!
-$! 6(-(! 3(#/J3$*! /&'(&9>3$*! /-$&'/H6(-(! &,! -(&,! (.)/$&'(*! $! %$#J!
.1*'/"*/6(-,!"$*(!%,.(!','(*!-,%!3(*,#$%!-$!f0g!SqnU:
Ct! ! W! .F',-,! 6,&%/-$#(! ,%! ('#/)1',%! 01$! $K$#6$.! /&l1N&6/(! &(!
2,#.(45,!-,!3(*,#<!2,6(&-,!(!('$&45,!%,)#$!-,/%!(%"$6',%k!3(*,#!/&/6/(*!$!
-$!%/&91*(#/-(-$:!W!3(*,#!/&/6/(*!#$"#$%$&'(!,!3(*,#!-(!'$##(!,1!$-/H6(45,!
6,&%'#1>-(! (2$'(-(! 01$! $%'J! -/#$'(.$&'$! (%%,6/(-(! (,! "('#/.O&/,<!
-$%6,&%/-$#(&-,! (! %/&91*(#/-(-$<! ,1<! $&'5,<! ,! 61%',! +/",'F'/6,! -$!
#$%'(1#(45,!-,!)$.:!W!3(*,#!6N&/6,!,1!-$!%/&91*(#/-(-$!F!(%%,6/(-,!(,%!
('#/)1',%!-$!#(#/-(-$<!('#('/3/-(-$!$!2(',#$%!$K'$#&,%!$!/&'$#&,%!#$*('/3,%!
(,!"('#/.O&/,!.('$#/(*<!$!F!*$3(&'(-,!(!"(#'/#!-$!"$%01/%(%!-$!,"/&/5,:!T!
#$%"$/',<!$&%/&(!Y,%/.(#!\/)$/#,!-$!T*.$/-(!S?]]E<!":!^hhU!01$!f,%!-(-,%!
(.,%'#(/%! %5,! %1).$'/-,%! 7! /&2$#N&6/(! $%'('>%'/6(<! 2$/',%! ('#(3F%! -$! 1.!
.,-$*,! .('$.J'/6,! (-$01(-,<! 6,&+$6/-,! 6,.,! .,-$*,! -$! #$9#$%%5,!
01$<! %1).$'/-,! (! -/3$#%,%! '$%'$%! "#$3/%',%! $.! ;,#.(<! '#(&%./'$! 7!
(3(*/(45,! (! 6,&H()/*/-(-$! -,! $%'('>%'/6,:! L$3/-,! 7! #(#/-(-$! -,! )$.!
(3(*/(-,!$!(!6,&%$01$&'$!/&$K/%'N&6/(!-$!(.,%'#(%!01$!6,&'$."*(.!,%
('#/)1',%! /&$#$&'$%! 7%! 6(#(6'$#>%'/6(%! $%"$6/(/%! -,! )$.<! $! 6,&%/-$#(&-,!
(! &$6$%%/-(-$! -$! 6(*61*(#! ,! 3(*,#! /&-$&/M('I#/,! -$! -$%("#,"#/(45,<! (!
.$',-,*,9/(!F!)(%$(-(!&,!!.F',-,!6,."(#('/3,!-$!-(-,%!-$!.$#6(-,%:!
STzVQ[LT<!?]]E<!":!^hhU:
CE! ! W! q#(1! -$! [."(6',! F! -(-,! "$*(! %$91/&'$! 2I#.1*(<! 6,&%'(&'$! -,!

MPMG Jurdico Especial !27

X$.!$&'#(#!&,!.F#/',!-(!6/$&'/H6/-(-$!-,%!3(*,#$%!(",&'(-,%!
para cada um dos atributos analisados, entendemos
que caberia, ao menos, um estudo mais apurado sobre
(! ",%%/)/*/-(-$! -$! 1'/*/M(45,! -,%! ('#/)1',%! /&-/6(-,%!
&$%'$! L$6#$',! "(#(! 3(*,#(45,! -$! /."(6',%! &$9('/3,%! 7!
)/,-/3$#%/-(-$!&(!$%2$#(!-(!#$%",&%()/*/M(45,!6/3/*!Sex postU:

-$&%/-(-$! (#)I#$(! -$! h]]! J#3,#$%! ",#! +$6'(#$<! (! "(#6$*(!

,)e$'/3(! %$#/(! #$"#$%$&'(-(! "$*,! 3(*,#! &$6$%%J#/,! "(#(!
#$",#! (! -$&%/-(-$! (#)I#$(! $! (! -/3$#%/-(-$! -$! $%"F6/$%!
3$9$'(/%! $K/%'$&'$%! (&'$%! -,! -$%.('(.$&',:! Q*16/-(! ,!
(1',#! 01$! (! -$&%/-(-$! (#)I#$(! $! (! -/3$#%/-(-$! ",-$.!
%$#! (2$#/-(%! (! "(#'/#! -(! (&J*/%$! -,! '/",! -$! 3$9$'(45,! -,!
local, densidade arbrea das reas adjacentes e intactas ou
;$%'$!6(%,<!,!-(&,!",-$#/(!%$#!01(&'/H6(-,!1'/*/M(&-,G%$<! #$9/%'#,%!+/%'I#/6,%:21
(,!/&3F%!-,%!61%',%!-,%!/&3$%'/.$&',%!S`\U<!,%!61%',%!-$!
#$61"$#(45,!&$6$%%J#/,%!(,!+/",'F'/6,!#$',#&,!(,!status quo
ante:
W! .F',-,! -,! 61%',! -$! #$",%/45,u#$61"$#(45,! -,! )$.!
6,&%/-$#(! (! %,.(! -$! ',-,%! ,%! /&3$%'/.$&',%! &$6$%%J#/,%!
7! +/",'F'/6(! #$%'(1#(45,! -,! -(&,<! #$61"$#(&-,G%$! '(&',!
%1(! 6("(6/-(-$! "#,-1'/3(! 6,.,! %$#3/4,%! (.)/$&'(/%!
"#$%'(-,%! "$*,! $6,%%/%'$.(:! W%! $K$."*,%! 6,*(6/,&(-,%!
&(! ;m\! C_:! h@^Gh! 6,&%/%'$.! $.! 61%',%! -$! #$61"$#(45,!
-(! 2$#'/*/-(-$! $.! %,*,%! -$9#(-(-,%! ('F! 9(#(&'/#! ,! &>3$*!
,#/9/&(*!-$!"#,-1'/3/-(-$!(9#>6,*(!S61%',%!-$!#$",%/45,Uj!
61%',%!-$!6,&%'#145,!-$!"/%6/&(%!"=)*/6(%!"(#(!9(#(&'/#!(%!
('/3/-(-$%! #$6#$('/3(%! $&01(&',! (%! "#(/(%! $%'5,! ",*1>-(%!
S61%',%! -$! %1)%'/'1/45,U<! ,1! (! #$61"$#(45,! -$! 1.(! .('(!
,1!.(&91$M(*!('#(3F%!-$!#$l,#$%'(.$&',!$!#$3$9$'(45,:
Q%'$! .F',-,! '$.! %/-,! 1'/*/M(-,! 6,.,! 1.! -,%! 6#/'F#/,%!
-$! 3(*,#(45,! -(! L/3/%5,! -$! T%%$%%,#(.$&',! aF6&/6,! -,!
V/&/%'F#/,! R=)*/6,! -,! Q%'(-,! -,! \/,! q#(&-$! -,! X1*<! 6,.!
3/%'(%! (! /&%'#1/#! ,%! /&01F#/',%! 6/3/%! "=)*/6,%:! L(! .$%.(!
forma, a Polcia Federal, preocupada no estabelecimento do
3(*,#!-,!-(&,!(.)/$&'(*<!6,&%,(&'$!"#$3/%',!&,!(#':!CD!-(!z$/!
&s!D:h]@uDE<!'$.!1'/*/M(-,!,!6#/'F#/,!-,%!61%',%!-$!#$%'(1#(45,!
6,.,!.$/,!-$!(2$#/45,!-$!3(*,#$%!.>&/.,%!"(#(!,%!-(&,%:19
W%! "$#/',%! e1-/6/(/%<! &,! 6,&'$K',! -$! (48$%! 6/3/%! "=)*/6(%<!
'(.)F.! %$! 'N.! 3(*/-,! -$%'$! .F',-,<! 6,.,! 01(&-,!
,6,##$1! ,! -$%"$e,! -$! #$%>-1,%! /&-1%'#/(/%! "$#/9,%,%! &,!
\/,! X,#,6()(<! ,6(%/5,! $.! 01$! %$! 1'/*/M,1! 6,.,! 6#/'F#/,!
"(#(!HK(45,!-,!quantum!/&-$&/M('I#/,!,!3(*,#!&$6$%%J#/,!
7!#$6,.",%/45,!-,!$6,%%/%'$.(:?]
A,.$&'(&-,! ,! .F',-,<! T*.$/-(! #$2$#$! 01$<! &,! 6(%,! -$!
desmatamento de uma rea de cerrado, stricto sensu, com
T&$K,!-,!L$6#$',!&s!h:E_Eu?]]Dk
q[!b![Xm!d!ATR!d![cA<!,&-$k
[Xm!b![."(6',!%,)#$!(!m/,-/3$#%/-(-$j
ATR!b!A,."#,.$'/.$&',!-$!#$(!R#/,#/'J#/(j!$
[cA!b![&l1N&6/(!$.!c&/-(-$%!-$!A,&%$#3(45,:
CD! !VTqz[T;W<!V(1#,:!?)0,1)*+,"&'"&)%,3"'-";1$-'3")-.$'%/)$3:!
QK"$#/N&6/(%! -(! ",*>6/(! 2$-$#(*:! L/%",&>3$*! $.k! v+''"kuu_66#:"9#:."2:
9,3:)#u-,61.$&',%G$G"1)*/6(6,$%u61#%,%u61#%,G-$G3(*,#(6(,G-,G
-(&,G(.)/$&'(*u`(*,#(6(,-$L(&,%T.)/$&'(/%R,*/6/(B$-$#(*:
"-2x:!T6$%%,!$.k!?^!.(#:!?]CC:
?]! !aYXR<!TA!?Ch:C^CGC<!X,#,6()(<!-$!C^!-$!,1'1)#,!-$!CDD_:!\$*:!L$%:!
W#*(&-,!R/%',#$%/:

Atividade
Desmatamento (rvores, arbustos e gramneas)
97&/$-.()*!)51:5&;%3'$)0'%!/$#
Obra irregular

28 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

A$#'(.$&'$! (*91&%! '/",%! -$! -(&,%! (.)/$&'(/%! $K/9/#5,!

.(/,#!$%2,#4,!-,!(3(*/(-,#!"$*(!2(*'(!-$!.$#6(-,%!,H6/(/%!
$%'()$*$6/-,%<!6,.,!F!,!6(%,!-,!()('$!-$!(&/.(/%!%/*3$%'#$%:!
;,!$&'(&',<!1.(!"$%01/%(!2$/'(!e1&',!(,![mTVT<!M,,*I9/6,%!
$! 1&/3$#%/-(-$%! ",-$! /&-/6(#! ,%! 61%',%! #$*(6/,&(-,%! 7!
#$/&'#,-145,! -(%! $%"F6/$%! &('/3(%<! 6#/(45,! $.! 6('/3$/#,! $!
6,.F#6/,<!(/&-(!01$!6*(&-$%'/&,<!-,%!(&/.(/%:
?C! !LQ!TzVQ[LT<!op. cit:!":!?C@:!!
W! (1',#! ("#$%$&'(! (! %$91/&'$! '()$*(! -$!
$K$."*,%! -$! -$9#(-(45,! (.)/$&'(*<! 6,.! (%!
(),#-(9$&%!9$#(*.$&'$!(-,'(-(%:

Ao
!"#$%&'()*$)+!,!&$-.()/!0(+'*$)(1)*$%'23$*$)!0)%40!/()!)!5"63'!)"/!!7'5&!%&!8
!"(5'-.()*$)51:5&;%3'$)0'%!/$#)/!&'/$*$<)/!3(0"(5'-.()&("(,/=23$)!)*$)3$0$*$)
>6/&'#)*()5(#()!)/!"#$%&'()*$)+!,!&$-.()"/!!7'5&!%&!8
?!0(#'-.()*$)(:/$<)/!0(-.()*()!%&1#@(<)/!3(0"(5'-.()*$)3$0$*$)>6/&'#)*()5(#()!)
/!"#$%&'()*$)+!,!&$-.()"/!!7'5&!%&!8

T"I%<! ,! 3(*,#! ,)'/-,! %$#/(! .1*'/"*/6(-,! "$*,! 9#(1! -$! L$%%(! 2,#.(<! ,! "#,.,',#! -$! Y1%'/4(<! &,! 6,&'$K',! -,!
/."(6',<! ("1#(-,! 6,&2,#.$! .$',-,*,9/(! -,! T&$K,! -,! /&01F#/',!6/3/*<!-$3$<!(/&-(!01$!&$6$%%/'$!-$!(",/,!'F6&/6,<!
L$6#$',!h:E_Eu?]]D:!
nortear a percia de dimensionamento do dano ambiental,
2,#.1*(&-,! 01$%/',%! 6*(#,%! $! ,)e$'/3,%<! 6,.! 3/%'(%! (!
@!" A1,;'&$-'%/,3" =1'0$-$%)1'3" B" 2)0,1)*+,C" )" apurar:
(U!(!/-$&'/H6(45,!-(!%1)%'p&6/(!6(1%(-,#(!-,!-(&,!S%1(%!
;,%/1$.>$*+,"&,"5$%$3/D1$,"AE.0$;,
6(#(6'$#>%'/6(%<!3,*1.$<!01(&'/-(-$Uj
1(*01$#! 01$! %$e(! (! .$',-,*,9/(! $*$/'(! "$*,%! "$#/',%! )U!(!-1#(45,!-(!*/)$#(45,u-$##(.(.$&',u-$",%/45,j
e1-/6/(/%! ,1! -,! V/&/%'F#/,! R=)*/6,<! F! /."#$%6/&->3$*! 01$! 6U! (! -('(! $! (! *,6(*/M(45,! -,! -(&,<! 6,.! -$%6#/45,! -(%!
6,&-/48$%!-$!'$.",<!-(!$K'$&%5,!9$,9#JH6(!-,!-(&,j
-U! (! /-$&'/H6(45,! -(! 9#(3/-(-$! -,! -(&,<! -$%6#$3$&-,!
(%! 6,&%$01N&6/(%! *$%/3(%! $.! ',-,%! ,%! 6,.",&$&'$%! -,!
.$/,!(.)/$&'$!SJ91(<!%,*,<!3$9$'(45,<!(#<!$'6:U<!)$.!6,.,!
%,)#$! ,%! 1%,%! $! %$#3/4,%! (.)/$&'(/%! 01$! 6(-(! 1.! -$%%$%!
6,.",&$&'$%! "#,",#6/,&(3(! ,1! ",-$#/(! "#,",#6/,&(#!
'(&',!(,!%$#!+1.(&,!6,.,!(,!"#I"#/,!$6,%%/%'$.(!S3(*,#$%!
-$!1%,!$!-$!&5,!1%,Uj
$U! (! #$3$#%/)/*/-(-$! ,1! &5,! -,! -(&,<! 6,.! /&-/6(45,! -(%!
"#,3/-N&6/(%!&$6$%%J#/(%!7!%1(!$3$&'1(*!#$"(#(45,j
2U!01(/%!(%!"#,3/-N&6/(%!01$!",-$#/(.!'$#!%/-,!(-,'(-(%!
"(#(!$3/'(#!,!-(&,j
9U!(!()#(&9N&6/(!-$!"$%%,(%!(2$'(-(%j
+U!(!/-$&'/H6(45,!-,!$%'(-,!(&'$#/,#!-,!(.)/$&'$!*$%(-,<!
$K(./&(&-,!(%!J#$(%!6,&'>91(%<!(&(*/%(&-,G%$!/&3$&'J#/,%<!
$'6j
/U!(!/-$&'/H6(45,!-,%!61%',%!"=)*/6,%!01$!,!I#95,!(.)/$&'(*!
'$3$!"(#(!./&/./M(#!,%!-(&,%j
eU! (! /-$&'/H6(45,! -,%! /."(6',%! &(! %,6/$-(-$! S('/3/-(-$%!
(9#>6,*(%<!6,.F#6/,<!#$6#$(45,<!"$%6(<!'1#/%.,<!1%,!"=)*/6,!
-$!"#(/(%<!"(#01$%<!$'6:U:22
P! 6,&3$&/$&'$! 01$! (! "$#>6/(! %$e(! #$(*/M(-(! ",#!
'F6&/6,%! +()/*/'(-,%<! "#$2$#$&6/(*.$&'$! 6,.! 2,#.(45,!
/&'$#-/%6/"*/&(#<! 61/-(&-,G%$! -(! 01(&'/-(-$! $! 01(*/-(-$!
-(%! (.,%'#(%<! (! H.! -$! $3/'(#! 21'1#(%! -/%61%%8$%! %,)#$!
(! "#I"#/(! $K/%'N&6/(! -,! -(&,! $! -,! &$K,! -$! 6(1%(*/-(-$:!
T/&-(<!(!"$#>6/(!-$3$#J!$%'/.(#!(%!"#,3/-N&6/(%!&$6$%%J#/(%!
7! #$%'(1#(45,! -,! -(&,<! ,#4(&-,! ,%! 61%',%! +/",'F'/6,%! -(!
$*(),#(45,!$!$K$6145,!-,!"#,e$',!S61%',%!-$!#$%'(1#(45,U<!
/&6*1/&-,G%$!,!.,&/',#(.$&',!21'1#,!-,!*,6(*<!.$%.,!01$!
(!2,#.(!-$!#$"(#(45,!-$%%$!-(&,!&5,!3$&+(!(!%$#!('#(3F%!
de restaurao in situ.! a(.)F.! F! /.",#'(&'$! 01$! %$!
/-$&'/H01$.!,%!61%',%!01$!2,#(.!$3/'(-,%!"$*,!",*1/-,#<!
%$!",%%(!#$1&/#<!(,!*,&9,!-(%!/&3$%'/9(48$%!%,)#$!,!-(&,! tais como custos de licenciamento, custos de tratamento
(.)/$&'(*<! ,! .JK/.,! -$! /&2,#.(48$%! ",%%>3$/%! %,)#$! (! -$! $l1$&'$%<! 9$#$&6/(.$&',! -$! #$%>-1,%<! 6,&'#,*$! -(!
$K'$&%5,!$!9#(3/-(-$!-,%!-(&,%!6(1%(-,%<!,!01$!$&3,*3$! ",*1/45,!('.,%2F#/6(!$!-,%!#1>-,%:
6,&+$6$#!,!$%'(-,!-,!.$/,!(.)/$&'$!(&'$%!-(!-$9#(-(45,!
$! 01(/%! ,%! %$#3/4,%! (.)/$&'(/%! 01$! ,! #$61#%,! (.)/$&'(*! R,#! H.<! F! "#$6/%,! %1"$#(#! (! /-$/(! -$! 01$! +(3$#J! 1.(!
*$%(-,! "#,",#6/,&(3(<! 6,.! 3/%'(%! 7! /-$&'/H6(45,! -,%! .$',-,*,9/(! /-$(*! $! 1&/2,#.$! "(#(! (! 01(&'/H6(45,! -$!
3(*,#$%! -$! 1%,! -/#$',! $! /&-/#$',:! Q.! '$%$! -$! -,1',#(-,! ',-,%! ,%! '/",%! -$! -(&,%! (.)/$&'(/%:! A,&%,(&'$! #$2$#/-,!
%,)#$! (! 3(*,#(45,! $6,&O./6(! -$! -(&,%! (.)/$&'(/%! "$*(!R#,61#(-,#(!-$!Y1%'/4(!X+/#*$i!B$&M/!m$#'5,<!,6,##$!(!
-$6,##$&'$%! -$! -$##(.$%! -$! "$'#I*$,! $.! X5,! X$)(%'/5,<! /.",%%/)/*/-(-$!-$!(-,45,!-$!1.!=&/6,!.F',-,<!$.!#(M5,!
-(!-/3$#%/-(-$!-(%!+/"I'$%$%!-$!-(&,%!(.)/$&'(/%:23
Y,%F!Y=*/,!B$##(M!-$!A(.",%!Y#:!(-3$#'$!01$
(!#$(*/M(45,!-$!1.!(."*,!*$3(&'(.$&',!-$!/&2,#.(48$%!
%,)#$!,!,)e$',!-$!$%'1-,!F!21&-(.$&'(*!"(#(!(!-$H&/45,!
-$! 01(*! 'F6&/6(! -$! 3(*,#(45,! ",-$! %$#! ("*/6(-(<! %$&-,!
$%'(!$%6,*+(!/&l1$&6/(-(!'(.)F.!"$*(!9(.(!-$!2,&'$%!$.!
campo, das quais se deseja obter dados, ou seja, a escala
$.!01$!%$!'#()(*+(:!SATVRWX!YZ;[W\<!?]]^<!":!D^U:

??! ! T! (1',#(! \,.(&(! A:! T#(1e,! S?]]^<! ":! tCU! %(*/$&'(! 01$! ,! ,)e$'/3,!
F! *$3(&'(#! ,%! 61%',%! &$6$%%J#/,%! (! #$%'(1#(#! ,%! #$61#%,%! -$9#(-(-,%<!
(6#$%6/-,%<!(/&-(<!-,!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,!"$#-/-,!$.!01$!$*$!"$#.(&$6$%%$!
-(&/H6(-,:!T%%/.<!,!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,!','(*!()#(&9$#/(!,!3(*,#!-$!1%,!$!,!
3(*,#!-$!&5,!1%,:
?^! !m$#'5,!S?]]t<!":!^EhU:

MPMG Jurdico Especial !29

F!"G,%;0>3+,
T!,"45,!",#!1.(!,1!,1'#(!.$',-,*,9/(!"(#(!01(&'/H6(45,!
-(!/&-$&/M(45,!(!%$#!"(9(!"$*,!-(&,!(.)/$&'(*!/##$3$#%>3$*!
F! 1.! '$.(! 01$! "$#.(&$6$! $.! ()$#',<! ",/%<! 6,.,! (!
"#I"#/(! ;m\! C_h@^Gh! -(! Tm;a! #$6,&+$6$<! -$"$&-$! -(%!
/&2,#.(48$%!-/%",&>3$/%!&,!6(%,!6,&6#$',<!-(!6("(6/'(45,!
-,%! "$#/',%<! -(! -/%",&/)/*/-(-$! -$! #$61#%,%! $6,&O./6,%!
"(#(! 6,*$'(! -$! /&2,#.(48$%<! -(! $K/%'N&6/(! ,1! &5,! -$! 1.!
.$#6(-,!6,&%1./-,#!"(#(!,!)$.!(!3(*,#(#<!-$&'#$!,1'#,%!
(%"$6',%:
Q&'$&-$.,%! 01$! (! .$',-,*,9/(! -,! 61%',! -$! #$",%/45,u
restaurao, desde que considere as particularidades
'F6&/6(%!$!#$%'(1#(45,!-$!)$&%!(.)/$&'(/%!F!1.!",&',!-$!
"(#'/-(!.1/',!#$*$3(&'$<!01$!-$3$!%$."#$!%$#!1'/*/M(-,<!-$!
2,#.(!/%,*(-(!,1!6,.)/&(-(!6,.!,1'#(%!.$',-,*,9/(%<!(!
-$"$&-$#!-,!&>3$*!-$!/&2,#.(48$%!-/%",&>3$/%<!"(#(!01$!
%$!,)'$&+(!(!3(*,#(45,!-,!-(&,!.('$#/(*!S,)e$'/3,U:
Q.! 3/#'1-$! -(! 6,."*$K/-(-$! -,! $6,%%/%'$.(<! F!
/."#$%6/&->3$*! (! 6,&e19(45,! -$! .$',-,*,9/(! 6("(M! -$!
(2$#/#!,%!(%"$6',%!/&'(&9>3$/%!-,!$6,%%/%'$.(<!%19$#/&-,G
%$!1.!$%'1-,!.(/%!-$'/-,!%,)#$!,%!6#/'F#/,%!$%'()$*$6/-,%!
"$*,! L$6#$',! B$-$#(*! &s! h:E_Eu?]]D! "(#(! -$*/./'(45,!
-,! q#(1! -$! [."(6',<! 6,.! 3/%'(%! 7! %1(! ("*/6(45,! "(#(!
+/"I'$%$%! -$! #$%",&%()/*/M(45,! 6/3/*:! ;$%'$! 6(%,<! ,! 3(*,#!
,)'/-,!('#(3F%!-,!.F',-,!-$!61%',%!-$!#$61"$#(45,!%$#/(!
.1*'/"*/6(-,!"$*,!9#(1!-$!/."(6',<!(3(*/(-,!6,&2,#.$!(%!
2I#.1*(%!("#$%$&'(-(%!&,!(&$K,!-,!#$2$#/-,!L$6#$',:
Q.! %>&'$%$<! ,! '$.(! F! 6,."*$K,! $! (/&-(! .1/',! #$6$&'$<!
6(#$6$&-,! -$! .(/,#$%! #$l$K8$%! (! "(#'/#! -$! (),#-(9$.!
interdisciplinar, em que as formulaes sejam construdas
&,!6,&'$K',!-(!#$%",&%()/*/-(-$!6/3/*!"$*,!-(&,!(,!.$/,!
(.)/$&'$<!6,."#$$&-$&-,G%$!%1(%!21&48$%!$!,)e$'/3,%:

H'I'1J%;$)3C
TzVQ[LT<!Y,%/.(#!\/)$/#,!-$:!A'14;$)")-.$'%/)0K":>&$;$)0"'"3';>1$/L1$)!"
[."(6',<!-(&,!$!"(%%/3,!(.)/$&'(*:!\/,!-$!Y(&$/#,k!a+$K<!?]]E:

T\TcYW<! \,.(&(! A,N*+,! -$:! A1,;'&$-'%/,3" =1D2$,3" =)1)" 2)0,1)*+,"

';,%<-$;)" &," &)%," )-.$'%/)0" '-" $%M>D1$/," ;$2$0" =E.0$;,!! ?]]^:!
L/%%$#'(45,! SV$%'#(-,! $.! q$%'5,! Q6,&O./6(! -,! V$/,! T.)/$&'$U! n!
c&/3$#%/-(-$!-$!m#(%>*/(:![&%'/'1',!-$!A/N&6/(%!o1.(&(%:!L$"(#'(.$&',!
-$!Q6,&,./(:!m#(%>*/(<!LB:

mQ\a|W<! X+/#*$i! B$&M/:! aF6&/6(%:! `(*,#(45,! $6,&O./6(! -$! -(&,%!

(.)/$&'(/%:! [&k" N'" O>1'" P" H'2$3/)" O>14&$;)" &," 5$%$3/D1$," AE.0$;," &,"
Estado de Minas Gerais<!m$*,!o,#/M,&'$<!&:!D:!e1*:u-$M:!?]]t:
m\TX[z:! z$/! &s! h:D^E<! -$! ^C! -$! (9,%',! -$! CDEC:! L/%"8$! %,)#$! (! R,*>'/6(!
;(6/,&(*! -,! V$/,! T.)/$&'$<! %$1%! H&%! $! .$6(&/%.,%! -$! 2,#.1*(45,! $!
("*/6(45,<!$!-J!,1'#(%!"#,3/-N&6/(%:
m\TX[z:!z$/!&s!D:h]@<!-$!C?!-$!2$3$#$/#,!-$!CDDE:!L/%"8$!%,)#$!(%!%(&48$%!
"$&(/%!$!(-./&/%'#('/3(%!-$#/3(-(%!-$!6,&-1'(%!$!('/3/-(-$%!*$%/3(%!(,!
.$/,!(.)/$&'$<!$!-J!,1'#(%!"#,3/-N&6/(%:
m\TX[z:!L$6#$',!&s!_:^^D<!-$!??!-$!(9,%',!-$!?]]?:![&%'/'1/!"#/&6>"/,%!$!
-/#$'#/M$%!"(#(!(!/."*$.$&'(45,!-(!R,*>'/6(!;(6/,&(*!-(!m/,-/3$#%/-(-$:

30 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

m\TX[z:! L$6#$',! &s! h:@C_<! -$! ??! -$! e1*+,! -$! ?]]E:! L/%"8$! %,)#$! (%!
/&2#(48$%! $! %(&48$%! (-./&/%'#('/3(%! (,! .$/,! (.)/$&'$<! $%'()$*$6$! ,!
"#,6$%%,!(-./&/%'#('/3,!2$-$#(*!"(#(!("1#(45,!-$%'(%!/&2#(48$%<!$!-J!,1'#(%!
"#,3/-N&6/(%:
m\TX[z:! L$6#$',! &s! h:E_E<! -$! C_! -$! .(/,! -$! ?]]D:! T*'$#(! $! (6#$%6$&'(!
-/%",%/'/3,%! (,! L$6#$',! &! _:^_]<! -$! ??! -$! (9,%',! -$! ?]]?<! "(#(!
#$91*(.$&'(#!(!6,."$&%(45,!(.)/$&'(*:
ATVRWX! YZ;[W\<! Y,%F! Y=*/,! B$##(M! -$:! ?)0,1)*+," ';,%<-$;)" &'"
&)%,3" )-.$'%/)$3C! ,! 6(%,! -,%! -$##(.$%! -$! "$'#I*$,! $.! X5,! X$)(%'/5,:!
a$%$!SL,1',#(-,U!n!c&/3$#%/-(-$!Q%'(-1(*!-$!A(."/&(%<!B(61*-(-$!-$!
Q&9$&+(#/(!V$6p&/6(<!A(."/&(%<!?]]^:

AT\LWXW<! T#'+1#! \$&(',:! #" &'71)&)*+," )-.$'%/)0" '" 3'>3" 2)0,1'3"

econmicos associados:!R,#',!T*$9#$k!X$#9/,!T&',&/,!B()#/%<!?]]^:
LQ\T;[<! A#/%'/(&$:! N$1'$/," )-.$'%/)0" ';,%<-$;,!! X5,! R(1*,k! V(K!
z/.,&(-<!CDDt:
LQ! TzVQ[LT<! \,-#/9,:! [&k! aWAAoQaaW<! L,./&9,%! SW#9U:! Percia
)-.$'%/)0";1$-$%)0!!A(."/&(%k!V/**$&&/1.<!?]C]:
[;Xa[acaW! m\TX[zQ[\W! LW! VQ[W! TVm[Q;aQ! Q! LWX! \QAc\XWX!
;Tac\T[X! \Q;W``Q[X! n! [mTVT:! 5,&'0," &'" 2)0,1)*+,"
';,%<-$;)" &,3" $-=);/,3" )-.$'%/)$3" '-" Q%$&)&'3" &'" G,%3'12)*+,!
Q."#$$&-/.$&',%! -$! 6,.1&/6(45,<! #$-$! $*F'#/6(! $! -1',%:! Q%'1-,!
"#$*/./&(#:! A,,#-$&(45,! -,! "#,e$',k! XO&/(! z:! R$/K,',! $! W2F*/(! q/*!
/**.$#%-,#2:!%$':!?]]?:
zQ[aQ<!Y,%F!\1)$&%!V,#(',:!N)%,")-.$'%/)0C!-,!/&-/3/-1(*!(,!6,*$'/3,!
$K'#("('#/.,&/(*. X5,!R(1*,k!\$3/%'(!-,%!a#/)1&(/%<!?]]]:
VTqz[T;W<! V(1#,:! ?)0,1)*+," &'" &)%,3" '-" ;1$-'3" )-.$'%/)$3:!
QK"$#/N&6/(%! -(! R,*>6/(! B$-$#(*:! L/%",&>3$*! $.k! v+''"kuu_66#:"9#:."2:
9,3:)#u-,61.$&',%G$G"1)*/6(6,$%u61#%,%u61#%,G-$G3(*,#(6(,G-,G
-(&,G(.)/$&'(*u`(*,#(6(,-$L(&,%T.)/$&'(/%R,*/6/(B$-$#(*:
"-2x:!T6$%%,!$.k!?^!.(#:!?]CC:
VTzQ\<!:!qj!qT<!\:!Q:!R;,%,-$;"-')3>1'-'%/",I"'%2$1,%-'%/)0"
&)-)7'k!(!'$6+&/6(*!+(&-),,:!R(#/%k!WQAL<!CDth<!C@C!":
VT<!R$'$#j!`Q[qT!;QaW<!B$#&(&-,j!RWW<!W%.(#:!?)0,1)*+,"
';,%<-$;)"&)".$,&$2'13$&)&'"%,"S1)3$0k!#$3/%5,!-(!*/'$#('1#(:!
L/%",&>3$*!$.k!+''"kuu/&2,:w,#*-)(&:,#9u$',,*%u-,6%u
*/)#(#iuCCt^CEu..(:"-2x:!T6$%%,!$.k!?D!.(#:!?]CC:
VWaaT<!\,&(*-,!X$#O(!-(:!R;,%,-$)")-.$'%/)0:!\/,!-$!Y(&$/#,k!Bq`!
Q-/',#(<!?]]h:
XT;XQ`Q\[;W<!R(1*,!-$!a(#%,!`/$/#(:!A1$%;4=$,"&)"1'=)1)*+,"$%/'71)0:!
X5,!R(1*,k!X(#(/3(<!?]C]:
XaQ[qzQLQ\<! T&&$*/%$! V,&'$/#,:! A#/'F#/,%! "(#(! ,! (#)/'#(.$&',!
-,! -(&,! $K'#("('#/.,&/(*! (,! .$/,! (.)/$&'$: [&k! AW;q\QXXWX!
[;aQ\;TA[W;T[X! LQ! L[\Q[aW! TVm[Q;aTz<! C?<! ?]]E<! X5,! R(1*,<!
XR: Anais... V1-(&4(%! 6*/.J'/6(%<! )/,-/3$#%/-(-$! $! 1%,! %1%'$&'J3$*!
-$! $&$#9/(:! T&'O&/,! o$#.(&! m$&e(./&<! Q*J-/,! z$6$i<! X/*3/(! A(""$**/!
SA,,#-:U!X5,!R(1*,k![."#$&%(!WH6/(*!-,!Q%'(-,!-$!X5,!R(1*,<!?]]E<!":!?^: