Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Leviathan
A film by Lucien Castaing-Taylor and Vrna Paravel,
2012, 87 minutes, DCP, 1.85:1, Dolby 5.1. Distributed
by The Cinema Guild, Inc., 115 West 30th Street, Suite
800, New York, NY 10001-4061, http://www
.cinemaguild.com
Hunter Snyder
Yale University
In the second century, Oppian of Corycus wrote in
Halieutica, in the sea, many things are hidden (in
mare multa latent) (Thayer 1928). Despite rich descriptions in literature and film since time immemorial, the
sea remains opaque and of much interest to us as
terrestrial species. Leviathan agitates our understanding,
our ways of seeing, and our intrigue within art, cinema,
and literature concerning how pelagic bodies move.
Trained as anthropologistsan academic title from
which they now seem to rescind in jest (Chang 2013)
filmmakers Lucien Castaing-Taylor and Vrna Paravel
sail northeasterly out of the worlds former whaling
capital, New Bedford, Massachusetts, to the North Atlantics most fruitful fishing ground. Location and context
are unimportant, however, because Leviathan does not
take place anywhere, apart from somewhere aboard,
overboard, aloft, and below a fishing trawler. Somewhere
between both consciousness and unconscious dreamworlds, sandwiched between the Gulf of Maine and the
North Atlantic Ocean, it is made unassumingly clear
even in the opening of recorded momentsthat whatever we have known of work at sea is partial.
Instead of the discursive clarity (Alvarez 2012)
that the documentary tends toward, Castaing-Taylor and
Paravel align with modes of interpreting beyond seeing
and hearing, to the exhausting/enfeebling/disorienting
opalescence of the sea. Through this negotiation with the
sea, Leviathan elides linear narrative and sequentiality,
sound/picture synchronicity, human characters, and
even the principal recordist as the eventual storyteller.
And a three-act (beginning, middle, and end) structure?
Leviathan isnt concerned with that so much either.
In the opening sequence of shots, the immediate
desperate search begins for something that seems historically familiar to documentary cinema or to the recognizable sea. Maybe a main character, or a location?
Through the motions of what we later find out to be a
stern man (although he and the other seamen will never
become distinctive, admirable, and/or despised characters), weonce audience, now embodied cameragaze
into the digital noise that is purported to be the sea over
Georges Bank before dawn, while an interminable
Film Reviews
177
FIGURE 1. Still from Leviathan. Used with permission from The Cinema Guild.
Leviathan, Ernst Karels cultivated yet hypercacophonous sound mix demands cognition through the
aural, especially within these moments of utterance,
nearly all of which are curiously incomprehensible.
At sea, orientation is a vital but often turbid state of
awareness. Intermixed with happenings taken by moving
bodies, cameras also make images on abiotic armatures.
Affixed to the mast or a long pole, then dunked overboard, and then back up for air (and when we come up,
I swear I hear the camera inhale), we are now suddenly far
outside of the body. In fact, much of Leviathan takes
place underwater, often without any sense of which way
is up or down. In our search for some orientation, we look
up from underwater at the top of the sea with floodlights
peering into the deep, and also look downupside
downfrom a birds-eye view of the seagulls giving
chase to the floating platform (Figure 2). The foreign
FIGURE 2. Still from Leviathan. Used with permission from The Cinema Guild.
178
Film Reviews
with text, Taylor Maurice Blochs claim that ethnographic film speaks for itself [like a text can] is wrong.
Instead, Taylor asks, But what if ethnographic film
does not speak at all? What if film does not say, but
shows? What if film does not just describe, but depicts?
In Leviathan, the only explicit saying comes after the
film has ended, in a list of Leviathans cast in binomial
nomenclature, and a shortlist of ships lost at sea. This
movement of limited explicitness is also seen in the end
credits of Sweetgrass and Foreign Parts, not as a trope,
but originating from a school of knowledge that shapes
this new discourse of ethnography and documentary
cinema. For those concerned with phenomenology, the
anthropology of work, sensory ethnography, and/or the
tradition and transgressions of ethnographic film,
Leviathan is compulsory viewing. In Leviathans
showing and limited saying, the argumentation of film
as logically inferior to that of text is swallowed whole
by more feral bodies. Perhaps it is Leviathans recording
of the illogicality of life itself that allows this filmic sea
creature to slip away.
Note
1
Filmmakers Paravel, Sniadecki, Barbash, and CastaingTaylor have produced their films under the auspices of
Harvards Sensory Ethnography Lab. See Nakamuras
Making Sense of Sensory Ethnography: The Sensual and
the Multisensory in American Anthropologist, vol. 115, no.
1, pp. 132144, or McDonalds American Ethnographic
Film and Personal Documentary (University of California
Press, 2013) for comprehensive details on SEL at Harvard.
179
References
Alvarez, Patricia
2012 Interview with Verena Paravel and J.P. Sniadecki.
FieldsightsVisual and New Media Review, Cultural
Anthropology Online, December 17. http://
production.culanth.org/fieldsights/33-interview
-with-verena-paravel-and-j-p-sniadecki, accessed
April 17, 2013.
Banks, Marcus
1988 The Non-Transparency of Ethnographic Film.
Anthropology Today 4(5):23.
Castaing-Taylor, Lucien
1996 Iconophobia. Transition 69:6488.
Castaing-Taylor, Lucien, and Ilisa Barbash, dirs.
2009 Sweetgrass. The Cinema Guild. New York.
Chang, Dustin
2013 Interview: Lucien Castaing-Taylor and Vrna
Paravel on LEVIATHAN and the Possibilities of
Cinema. International Interviews, February 26.
http://twitchfilm.com/2013/02/lucien-castaing
-taylor-verena-paravel-interview.html,
accessed
April 17, 2013.
Clifford, James, and George E. Marcus
1986 Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Paravel, Vrna, and J. P. Sniadecki, dirs.
2010 Foreign Parts. Kino Lorber. New York.
Sullivan, Chip
2008 Telling Untold Stories. In Drawing/Thinking. Marc
Treib, ed. Pp. 122135 London: Routledge.
Thayer, Bill, trans.
1928 Oppian - Halieutica, Book 1. Oppian, Halieutica or
Fishing. Vol. 1. Pp. 201281 Cambridge, MA: Loeb
Classical Library.