4/21/2015

Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthereadifferenceintorque/speed?Quora

Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormal
pistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthere
adifferenceintorque/speed?

SHAREQUESTION

Twitter
Facebook

Whyisn'tthereanydevelopementfromHugeCarfirmslikeBMW,GM,AUDI
etc.Couldsomeonepleaseprovideanyinformationonthis.Here'salink
SolenoidEngineby7thCrook

Google+

RELATEDTOPICS

WantAnswers

SIGNINTOREADALLOFQUORA.

ContinuewithGoogle

ContinuewithFacebook
Bycontinuingyouindicatethatyouhaveread
andagreetotheTermsofService.

SignUpwithEmail

CultureandSociety
1ANSWER

Culture(social
science)

RELATEDQUESTIONS

GaganMakhija,MechanicalEngineeringstudent

MaterialCulture

2upvotesbyArijitMukherjeeandSanidhyaGupta.

ConsumerProducts
andServices

IwouldliketosharewhatIfeelmaybethereason.

Carsand
Automobiles

FirstletusseethebenefitsofusualmotoroverInternalCombustionengines
1. Amotorhasveryfewmovingparts.23comparedtomanyincaseof
engine.Thisensureslesserplacesoffailureandalsoensureshigh
efficiency.Byandlargeitisverysimple.
2. Sinceitisrunningonelectricity,itcanbeprogrammedortunedasper
needs.
Nowtheproblemwithmotoristhatitrunsonelectricityandsothebattery
needstobechargedwhichtakesalotoftime.
Nowthedesigngiveninthelinkhastheissuethatithasalotofmoving
components.Thisscrapsoutoneoftheadvantagesofamotor.Furtheritwill
runonelectricitysoitdoesnotsolvetheproblemwithmotor.
NowhereisanotherthingthatIthinkthoughIcan'tproveitverywell.The
forcedevelopedbyasolenoidpullingtherodinbetweenwillbequitelessasit
isbasedoninducedmagneticfield.Ontheotherhandmotorwillproduce
greaterforce.
Seeitthisway.Incaseofasolenoid,themagneticfieldisquitedispersedatthe
endsandtherodishalfoutsidewherefieldisverylesssoalargepartisgetting
wasted.Thiswillnotbethecaseinrotarymotorasthecurrentcarryingwireis
alwaysinsidethefield.
ByandlargeIthinkthesolenoidenginewillhavelesserpowertoweightratio
comparedtousualmotorandalsohasnumerousmovingparts.

Whatisthedifferencebetweenthespeed
andthetorqueofamotor?
Whyisn'tthereanymagneticbased
pistonsmotoraround?
Whycan'twegenerateelectricityby
usingcombustionpistonassolenoidin
reverse,tosimplifythemechanics?
InternalCombustionEngines:What
wouldhappenifyouputmotoroilinthe
gastankofacar?
MotorControl(engineering):Whatarethe
drawbacksofaVFD(variablefrequency
drive)?
SoundEngineering:Wherearehigh
currentlinearregulatorsarestillusedto
suppressnoise?
ElectricalEngineering:Howarethe
voltages/currentsuseddifferentbetween
defibrillatorsandECT?
ElectricMotors:Howdospeedregulators
ofcommonfansathome&offices
operate?
Whydidn'ttherotaryenginereplacethe
pistonengine?
Engines:Whatisthedifferencebetween
acylinderandabarrel?

Otherproblemswillalsocomelikethatoflubricationtofacilitatelinearmotion
oftherodbuttheyaresecondary.
Ihopethisanswersthequestionasked.Ifyoufeelsomethingiswrongor
unclear,letmeknow.
Written1Jan.167views.

Upvote

Downvote Comments 1+

Writeananswer
Searchforquestions,people,andtopics

Login

SignUp

RelatedQuestions
http://www.quora.com/WhyisntaSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuseIsthereadifferenceintorquespeed

1/3

4/21/2015

Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthereadifferenceintorque/speed?Quora

Whatisthedifferencebetweenthespeedandthetorqueofamotor?
Whyisn'tthereanymagneticbasedpistonsmotoraround?
Whycan'twegenerateelectricitybyusingcombustionpistonassolenoidin
reverse,tosimplifythemechanics?
InternalCombustionEngines:Whatwouldhappenifyouputmotoroilinthegas
tankofacar?
MotorControl(engineering):WhatarethedrawbacksofaVFD(variable
frequencydrive)?
SoundEngineering:Wherearehighcurrentlinearregulatorsarestillusedto
suppressnoise?
ElectricalEngineering:Howarethevoltages/currentsuseddifferentbetween
defibrillatorsandECT?
ElectricMotors:Howdospeedregulatorsofcommonfansathome&offices
operate?
Whydidn'ttherotaryenginereplacethepistonengine?
Engines:Whatisthedifferencebetweenacylinderandabarrel?
HowcanIcalculatetheinstantaneoustorqueproducedbyagivenpistonforce
aboutthecrankshaftofapistonengine?
EngineeringinSiliconValley:WhatarethedifferentcircuitscanImakeusing
(optional)IC741?It'smyminiproject.
TeslaMotors(carcompany):Whatistheadvantageofusingmanysmall
batteriesoveralargebatterytopowertheelectricvehicles?
AerospaceandAeronauticalEngineering:CanVirginGalactic'sSpaceShipTwo
beusedforpointtopointtravel?Woulditrepresentasignificantspeedincrease
overexistingairliners?...(continue)
Whichmotorusedinrailwayelectricengine?
TeslaMotors(carcompany):CouldthefreepublicreleaseofTesla'stechnical
engineeringdocumentsultimatelyleadtotheirfinancialsuccess?
Whydoesn'tWeMouseasolidstaterelayinsteadofmagneticsolenoidrelay?
ElectronicsEngineering:Howcanasteppermotorcontrolledbymicrocontroller
8051?
Whatistherelationbetweentorque,slip,andspeedininductionmotors?
AutoParts:Whatdifferenttypesofcarmotors/enginesarethere?

TopStories
Wouldhumanbloodbeahealthy
drinkforhumans?
IanYork,Virologist,immunologist,
biologist
549upvotesbyCatarinaDeMarchiAssuncao
(brazilianmedicaldoctor,neurologyresident),Sunil
Sati(PediatricianatLadyHardingeMedical
College,...(more)),LiangHaiSie(Retiredgeneral
internist,formerintensivecar...(more)),(more)
Humanbloodwouldbeaterribledrinkforhumans.
Notonlywouldithaveanexcellentchanceof
spreadingdisease,ithasverylittlenutritionand
containstoxiccomponents.Ithinkthedisease
concernisobvious.Anybloodbornedisease
(hepatitisC,hepatitisB,HIV,manymore)would

Whataresomelesserknown
Gmailtipsandhacks?
AdityaLesmana
846upvotesbyGauravJha(Software
EngineerIIIatGoogleIndia),VickySirwani
(Googler),JoshSiegel,(more)
Thesearedefinitelylesserknownhackssince
nonehasmentionedabove.1.'Dotblind'hack
Gmailis'dotblind'andwillignoreanydotinyour

Whatisthegreatestmathematical
discoveryofalltime?
DavidJoyce,ProfessorofMathematics
atClarkUni...(more)
2.6kupvotesbyOriGurelGurevich(Level17
Mathematician),MichalForiek(Ph.D.in
theoreticalComputerScience),JeffNelson
(InventedChromebook.FormerMathPhD
student.),JensAdlerNielsen(<br>),(more)

emailaddressbefore@sign.fromsupportpage
[1]:Gmaildoesn'trecognizedotsascharacters
withinusernames,youcanaddorremovethedots
fromaGmailaddresswithoutchangingtheactual
destinationaddressthey'llallgotoyourinbox,and
...

havethepotentialforspreadingthisway.Asfor

http://www.quora.com/WhyisntaSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuseIsthereadifferenceintorquespeed

2/3

4/21/2015

Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthereadifferenceintorque/speed?Quora

nutrition,bloodismostlyliquid.Ifwelookto
ReadMore
vam...

ReadMore

ReadMore

Sitemap # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
AboutCareersPrivacyTerms

http://www.quora.com/WhyisntaSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuseIsthereadifferenceintorquespeed

3/3