Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ON
COMPARISON OF ING VYSYA BANK
WITH ICICI AND HDFC BANK ON
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
Undertaken at
ING VYSYA BANK PVT LTD
Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree of
MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION
to
Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, Delhi
Submitted by
Sakshi Behl
MBA-III Semester
Enrolment No.:
Session 2013 14
PERIYAR MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER COLLEGE
Periyar Centre, FC33, Plot No. 1&2, Institutional Area, Jasola, New Delhi 110025
Page | 1
CONTENTS
Chapter Particular(s)
Page No.
Certificate-1
Certificate-2 company
Summer Training Appraisal Form
Acknowledgements
Executive Summary
1
Introduction
Literature Review
Research Methodology
Data Interpretation
Page | 2
Date:
Certified that the Summer Training Report submitted in partial fulfilment of Master of Business
Administration
(MBA)
to
be
awarded
by
G.G.S.I.P.
University,
Delhi
by
Date:
Page | 3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
If words are considered to be signs of gratitude then let these words Convey the very same. My
sincere gratitude to Mr. Abhishek Gupta junior manager, ING VYSYA BANK and giving
necessary directions on doing this project to the best of my abilities.
I am highly indebted to Mr. Ajay Yadav, Branch Manager, who provided me with the
necessary information and also for the support extended out to me in the completion of this
report and his valuable suggestion and comments on bringing out this report in the best way
possible.
So in the same sequence at very first, I would like to acknowledge my parents because of whom
I got the existence in the world for the inception and the conception of this project. Later on I
would like to confer the flower of acknowledgement to Mrs. Yamini Saraswat and other faculty
members who taught me that how to do project through appropriate tools and techniques.
Page | 4
CHAPTER -1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Page | 5
Banking system of a nation is the shadow of nations economy. A healthy and profitable banking
system is just like the backbone of nations economy. It is necessary for a nation to achieve
growth and remain stable in this global world and global economy. The Indian banking system,
with one of the largest banking networks in the world, has witnessed a series of reforms over the
past few years like the deregulation of interest rates, dilution of the government stake in public
sector banks (PSBs) and the increased participation of private sector banks.
History of INDIAN BANKING SYSTEM
Banking in India originated in the last decades of the 18th century. The first banks were The
General Bank of India, which started in 1786, and the Bank of Hindustan, both of which are now
defunct The oldest bank in existence in India is the State Bank of India, a government-owned
bank that traces its origins back to June 1806 and that is the largest commercial bank in the
country. Allahabad Bank, established in 1865 and still functioning today, is the oldest Joint Stock
bank in India.
Central banking is the responsibility of the Reserve Bank of India, which in 1935 formally took
over these responsibilities from the then Imperial Bank of India, relegating it to commercial
banking functions. After India's independence in 1947, the Reserve Bank was nationalized and
given broader powers. In 1969 the government nationalized the 14 largest commercial banks; the
government nationalized the six next largest in 1980.
In 1948, the Reserve Bank of India, India's central banking authority, was nationalized, and
it became an institution owned by the Government of India.
In 1949, the Banking Regulation Act was enacted which empowered the Reserve Bank of
India (RBI) "to regulate, control, and inspect the banks in India."
The Banking Regulation Act also provided that no new bank or branch of an existing bank
could be opened without a license from the RBI, and no two banks could have common
directors
Liberalization in INDIAN BANKING SYSTEM
Page | 6
In the early 1990s, the then government embarked on a policy of liberalization, licensing a small
number of private banks. These came to be known as New Generation tech-savvy banks, and
included Global Trust Bank (the first of such new generation banks to be set up), which later
amalgamated with Oriental Bank of Commerce, Axis Bank(earlier as UTI Bank), ICICI Bank
and HDFC Bank. This move, along with the rapid growth in the economy of India, revitalized
the banking sector in India, which has seen rapid growth with strong contribution from all the
three sectors of banks, namely, government banks, private banks and foreign banksThe next
stage for the Indian banking has been setup with the proposed relaxation in the norms for Foreign
Direct Investment, where all Foreign Investors in banks may be given voting rights which could
exceed the present cap of 10%, at present it has gone up to 49% with some restrictions.
The new policy shook the Banking sector in India completely. Bankers, till this time, were used
to the 4-6-4 method (Borrow at 4%; Lend at 6%; Go home at 4%) of functioning. The new wave
ushered in a modern outlook and tech-savvy methods of working for traditional banks. All this
led to the retail boom in India. People not just demanded more from their banks but also received
more.
Currently (2009), banking in India is generally fairly mature in terms of supply, product range
and reach-even though reach in rural India still remains a challenge for the private sector and
foreign banks. In terms of quality of assets and capital adequacy, Indian banks are considered to
have clean, strong and transparent balance sheets relative to other banks in comparable
economies in its region. The Reserve Bank of India is an autonomous body, with minimal
pressure from the government. The stated policy of the Bank on the Indian Rupee is to manage
volatility but without any fixed exchange rate-and this has mostly been true.
With the growth in the Indian economy expected to be strong for quite some time-especially in
its services sector-the demand for banking services, especially retail banking, mortgages and
investment services are expected to be strong. One may also expect M&As, takeovers, and asset
sales.
Currently, India has 88 scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) - 27 public sector banks (that is with
the Government of India holding a stake), 31 private banks (these do not have government stake;
they may be publicly listed and traded on stock exchanges) and 38 foreign banks. They have a
Page | 7
combined network of over 53,000 branches and 17,000 ATMs. The public sector banks hold over
75 percent of total assets of the banking industry, with the private and foreign banks holding
18.2% and 6.5% respectively.
To compare the banking products and services offered by ING Vysya Bank and other
private banks (ICICI & HDFC)
To study the customers expectations, behavior, responses & preferences for various
saving accounts of ING Vysya Bank.
To study the marketing strategies adopted by ING Vysya Bank to maintain & increase its
market share & to retain its customers.
SECONDARY OBJECTIVE:
ING Vysya Bank Ltd is a premier private sector bank with retail, private and wholesale banking
platforms that serves over two million customers. With over 80 years of history in India and
leveraging INGs global financial expertise, the bank offers a broad range of innovative and
established products and services, across its 547 branches. The Bank, which has close to 10,000
employees, is also listed in Bombay Stock Exchange Limited and National Stock Exchange of
India Limited. ING Vysya Bank was ranked among top 5 Most Trusted Brands among private
sector banks in India in the Economic Times Brand Equity Nielsen survey 2011.
The bank was formessdd from the 2002 acquisition of an equity stake in Indian Vysya Bank by
the Dutch ING Group. This merger marked the first between an Indian bank and a foreign bank.
Prior to this transaction, Vysya Bank had a seven-year old strategic alliance with erstwhile
Belgian bank Banque Bruxelles Lambert, which was also acquired by ING Group in 1998.
1.4.1 About ING Group
BANK WITH ING,
JIYO EASY!
ING is a global financial institution of Dutch origin, offering banking,
investments, life
insurance and retirement services to meet the needs of a broad customer base. With more than
82,000 employees, ING serves over 61 million private, corporate and institutional customers in
over 40 countries in Europe, North America and Latin America, Asia and Australia. The bank
draw on its experience and expertise, its commitment to excellent service and its global scale to
meet the needs of a broad customer base, comprising individuals, families, small, businesses,
large corporations, institutions and governments.
Contact Us:
ING Vysya Bank Limited
Page | 9
International Debit Card and the mi-bank net banking service. ING takes over
the Management of the Bank from October 7th , 2002 RBI clears the new name of the Bank as
ING Vysya Bank Ltd, vide their letter of 17.12.2003 Introduced customer friendly products
like Orange Savings, Orange Current and Protected Home Loans
2004:- Introduced Protected Home Loans - a housing loan product
2005:- Introduced Solo my Own Account for youth and Customer Service Line Phone Banking
Service
2006:- Bank has networked all the branches to facilitate AAA transactions i.e. Anywhere,
Anytime & Anyhow Banking Later years up to 2011 is a diversified financial services Group that
provides a range of banking and financial services to customers, including retail banking, project
and corporate finance, working capital finance, insurance, venture capital and private equity,
investment banking, broking treasury products and services.
The company operates in, India, the UK, Canada, and Russia and in 60 other countries. It is head
quartered in Amsterdam, Netherlands and employs about 1, 10,000 people worldwide.
Page | 11
Names
Designation
Shailendra Bhandari,Chairman
Jayant Mehrotra
J M Prasad
Chief-Human Resources
Brett Morgan
Mahesh Dayani
Susan Poot
B.Ashok Rao
Chief Auditor
Meenakshi A
Head-Operations
Aniruddha Paul
FY2007
FY2006
FY2005 FY2004
54,851
62,208
59,642
57,403
55,614
Page | 12
Banking operations
11,731
14,602
14,195
13,848
12,678
Total Income1
66,291
76,587
73,621
71,120
68,171
Insurance operations
5,422
5,515
5,275
5,195
4,746
Banking operations
10,303
9,967
9,087
8,844
8,795
15,725
15,481
14,362
14,039
13,541
1,280
125
103
88
465
-1,635
6,533
4,935
3,978
4,322
148
4,510
5,005
4,916
3,418
-1,487
11,043
9,940
8,894
7,740
-721
1,534
1,907
1,379
1,709
-38
267
341
305
276
-729
9,241
7,692
7,210
5,755
Net result
-0.36
4.32
3.57
3.32
2.71
Earnings 2)
-0.56
4.32
3.57
3.32
2.71
Dividend
0.74
1.48
1.32
1.18
1.07
Shareholders equity
8.55
17.73
17.78
16.96
12.95
Total assets
1,332
1.312
1,226
1,159
964
Total equity
29
40
41
38
28
Shareholders equity
17
37
38
37
28
13.8%
9.5%
9.0%
9.4%
10.2%
256%
244%
274%
255%
204%
8.5%
13.6%
14.2%
13.4%
14.3%
Operating Expenses
Page | 13
9.32%
7.39%
7.63%
7.32%
6.92%
15
60
74
65
49
2,063
2,226
2,205
2,205
2,205
16
63
87
87
-2.1%
24.2%
23.5%
26.6%
25.4%
-108%
20%
7%
1,023
1,113
807
805
632
13.9%
14.3%
13.3%
13.2%
12.1%
97%
97%
91%
95%
94%
- Cost/income ratio
87.8%
68.3%
64.0%
63.9%
69.4%
1.2%
19.9%
19.7%
22.6%
14.5%
551
643
600
547
492
124,661
124,634
25% n.a.
Insurance
- Value of new life business
- Internal rate of return
- Combined ratio (non-life)
Banking
Page | 14
of financial products and services, organised under four strategic lines of business: retail, private,
wholesale banking ad agricultural banking.
a) Retail banking :
With 547 branches and 10 counters, 28 satellite offices and 470 ATM's nationwide, ING
Vysya's retail operation offers checking accounts, savings deposits/CD's, retail wealth
management services, consumer loans, agricultural/rural banking and retail life insurance
products. The bank has rapidly expanded its distribution footprint and has created a national
brand presence through several innovative marketing campaigns.
b) Private banking :
ING Vysya's private bank operates on an advisory-driven model. Specialized market research
remains the bank's focus for the introduction of new tailored products to serve the high-end
private banking segment.
c) Corporate/wholesale banking :
The wholesale banking business provides corporate clients in India a range of commercial,
transactional and electronic banking products. The bank offers client focused products
including working capital finance, trade and transactional services, foreign exchange, term
loans and cash management services. The wholesale banking business comprises four
business sub-segments and multiple product offerings. The business segments Corporate and
Investment Banking, Emerging Corporate, Banking and Financial Institutions and financial
markets.
Page | 15
Page | 16
Several initiatives have been underway to empower the marginalized sections through awareness
and education and access to basic banking services such as savings, credit and insurance.
However data collated through various surveys indicate that for every 100 adult persons there are
only 17 credit accounts and 54 savings accounts with all the financial institutions put together
(June 2007), thereby highlighting the need for more concerted efforts from the Government,
Regulators and the Banks towards ensuring financial inclusion.
The term 'Financial inclusion' (FI) is defined as including the excluded sections of disadvantaged
and low income groups into the formal financial sectors by delivery of banking services at an
affordable cost. The services offered under FI constitute 'no frills' accounts, access to savings
products, providing easy and right quantum of credit at affordable interest rates, insurance etc.
ING VYSYA bank has drawn a three year plan to achieve Financial Inclusion objectives and has
taken up several steps in this regard. The highlights of these are:
a) They are providing Banking Services in 295 villages across the country.
b) As on September 2010, the Bank has opened 84000 No Frill accounts which has Covered
6.27 lacs persons under Financial inclusion.
c) Bank provides banking facilities to 12000 SHGs with credit facilities of Rs.100 crores.
ING VYSYA bank has been associated with Basaveswara Vidya Vardhaka Sangha, a registered
Society with over 100 years of existence. Sangha has a chain of institutes numbering over 120
covering all fields of education and established RUDSETI at Bagalkot with objective to identify,
orient, train, counsel, assist young people and to motivate and empower them to take up selfemployment venture by providing all the needed assistance. Since inception 13000 candidates
Page | 17
have been trained, out of which 8000 were women and 10,000 candidates were settled / linked
with finance by various banks in the district.
Bank has also devised various products for financial inclusion, namely
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
Bank has adopted the Business Correspondent Model for extending the services in rural areas
and deepening financial inclusion in the unbanked areas in AP and Karnataka State. Presently
bank has two BCs for disbursing amounts to NREGP & SSP beneficiaries. The achievements so
far in this regard are :
a)
b)
c)
d)
OTHER INITIATIVES:
The Bank has its Competence Development Centre at Bangalore, where importance of Financial
Inclusion is emphasized in all other Training programmes held. The Bank also proposes to roll
out a separate Module on Financial Inclusion. Banks Financial Inclusion Plan (FIP) and the list
of villages taken up for providing banking services are displayed separately.
Product launch: New milestone rewards with ING Vysya debit cards:
ING Vysya Bank and MasterCard today announced the launch of ING MasterCard Premium
Debit Cards. Unlike other debit cards in the market this card comes with reward points based on
spend-milestones. While using debit cards for shopping is an increasing trend in India,
Page | 18
redemption of rewards points isn't. "Indian customers are using their debit cards to shop, debit
spends are increasing by 38 percent. Surprisingly however, Indian customers redeem only 18
percent of their reward points," said Shailendra Bhandari, MD and CEO, ING Vysya Bank.This
is primarily due to the way most reward points programmes work, where a certain number of
points have to be accumulated, at times with certain tie-up merchants. They also come with
expiry dates.
How this works:
Under the spend-milestone-based system, you need to spend a certain amount for two years, after
which you could choose the reward from a number of choices the banks offers. For instance, you
should spend Rs 2 lakh (Rs 7,500 a month), Rs 4 lakh (15,000 a month) or Rs 6 lakh (25,000 a
month) over two years with debit card. These cards are available in three variants, Titanium, My
World and World Exclusive. The fee for the card is in the range of Rs 0 to as much as Rs 750,
depending on the variant you choose.
Other features:
It offers zero percent fuel surcharge and other privileges like airport lounge access, higher ATM
limit withdrawals and the like.
Page | 19
B) CURRENT ACCOUNTS:
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
C) DEMAT ACCOUNTS
D) TERM DEPOSITS
E) DEBIT CARDS
F) CREDIT CARDS
G) FOREX SERVICES
Page | 20
Page | 21
The ICICI Bank International debit card is a debit-cum-ATM card provides with the
convenience of acceptance at merchant establishments and cash withdrawals at ATM.
Anywhere Banking facility entitles the account holder to withdraw or deposit cash upto a
limit of Rs.50,000 across all ICICI Bank branches.
Third party withdrawal limit is only Rs 15,000 and free demand draft making facility for a
month is only up to Rs 10,000. Free withdrawal limit from ATM card is only up to Rs 25,000 in
all accounts.
Page | 22
Page | 23
CLASSIFICATION/ CATEGORIZATION
So, for convenience of the project and comparison the different accounts can be classified
into three categories:
Category A
1. PLATINA ACCOUNT
(ING)
2. TITANIUM PRIVILAGED
ACCOUNT
ACCOUNT (ICICI)
3. PREFERRED BANKING
SAVING
ACCOUNT/PLATINUM
Category B
FORMULA SAVING
ACCOUNT (ING)
Category C
ORANGE SAVING
ACCOUNT (ING)
GOLD PRIVILAGED
SAVING
ACCOUNT (ICICI)
(ICICI)
SAVING MAX
ACCOUNT (HDFC)
REGULAR
ACCOUNT (HDFC)
(HDFC)
Service quality
ING Vysya Bank provides the top notch quality to its customers. They have so many special
features that no other banks provide till date, like:
Page | 24
1. Special cabin/room for its customers to wait and relax when there is a rush or when
customer is asked to wait for some time.
2. Fastest RTGS and NEFT services, which takes place within minutes.
3. A well behaving staff and special highly sensitive customer care department. This is head
by a well efficient customer care manager.
4. Account verification with in promised 5 days.
5. Doing things in the right way at right time.
6. It is the only Bank which provides the facility of withdrawal of 1 lakh rupees from any
ATM at one go.
Page | 25
In Rs. Crores
YTD
YTD
2008
2007
Q3
Q3
2008-09
2007-08
172.7
144.9
Other Income
149
95.7
Total Income
321.8
Operating Profit
after Exceptional
Items
35.5%
21.6
6.4%
27.7
36.1%
279
887.8
585.0
30.4%
100
357
400
33.8%
81.7
106.5
487
55.9%
158.9
106.5
Provision &
Contingencies
19.2%
240.6
215.3
Operating Profit
growth
growth
Operating Costs
43.3%
637.5 39.3%
438
33.6%
302.8
199.5
51.8%
302.8
219.8
37.7%
-22.1%
84.7
33.9
150.1%
84.9
72.4
17.3%
218.1
186
17.3%
32.8
29.6
11%
78.4
71.9
9.1%
21.8%
139.7
114 22.5%
52.1
42.8
0.001
Deposits
0.400
Advances
Profits
0.400
0.001
Outlets
4
Page | 27
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
1.40
1.60
3.00
11.50
162.10
5900.00
6527.00
6863.24
7067.90
7473.20
7094.00
10196.70
11101.90
14260.00
5.30
20.10
91.50
1414.30
8509.40
74240.00
81411.10
80680.00
91870.00
104780.00
125693.10
133352.50
154185.70
204980.00
3.80
0.09
13.50
0.13
62.80
0.74
813.70
1.13
4584.80
50.35
39380.00 443.10
43163.10 371.90
44180.00 687.50
56120.00 863.50
69367.30 590.01
90805.90 (381.80)
102315.20
90.6
119761.70
889.0
146500.00 1569.00
16
19
39
228
319
481
484
483
456
523
536
562
626
677
Even in the recessionary period the ING Vysya Bank is going in profits. While other banks are
losing a big percentage of their expected profits.
Page | 28
Net Interest Income (NII) was up 19% to Rs.172.7 crores from Rs.144.9 crores and Fee &
Other Income increased by 56% to Rs.149.1 crores from Rs.95.7 crores in the prior year.
Nine months ended December08
The PAT for the period ended 31 December 2008 increased 23% to Rs.139.7 crores
fromRs.114.1 crores for the period ended 31 December 2007 and PBT grew 17% to Rs.218.1
croresfrom Rs.186.0 crores.
However, excluding exceptional items reported in the previous year, PAT increased by 40%
andPBT by 32% over the corresponding period last year. NII grew 36% to Rs. 487.2 crores from
Rs.357.9 crores and Fee & Other Income was up 43% to Rs. 400.6 crores from Rs. 279.6 crores
inthe previous year.
Business Highlights
Total Deposits grew 25% to Rs. 22,401 crores as at end December 2008 from Rs.17,871 crores
the year before. Current and Savings (CASA) deposits rose 8% to Rs.5,819 crores as at end
December 2008 from Rs. 5,406 crores as at end December 2007.
Advances grew 19% to Rs.16,014 crores in December 2008 from Rs. 13,409 crores in December
2007. Total Assets of the bank registered a 30% growth to Rs.29,050 crores. The Credit Deposit
Ratio was at 71.5% in December 2008 against 75.0% in December 2007.
The Gross NPA ratio and Net NPA ratio were at 1.84% and 1.09% respectively as at 31
December 2008 compared to 1.81% and 0.71% respectively as at 31 December 2007. The net
worth of the Bank as at 31 December 2008 stood at Rs.1,568 crores compared to Rs. 1,459
crores as at end December 2007 and the Capital Adequacy Ratio stood at 10.72% in December
2008. In October 2008, the bank increased its capital through the issue of Tier 1 Perpetual debt
amounting to approx. Rs.95 crores. Subsequent to the quarter end, the Bank raised an additional
Rs.200 crores of Upper Tier 2 capital which has been subscribed entirely by ING Group.
World over ING has strengthened its name as a good corporate citizen. The ING Chances for
Children initiative (CFC) a global program in partnership with UNICEF is to educate 50,000
underprivileged children in three countries, Ethiopia, India and Brazil by 2008. In India the focus
is primarily in the districts of Dharampuri and Krishnagiri in Tamil Nadu. Through the national
Child labor Elimination (NCLP) bridge schools, ING provides much needed support to UNICEF,
to fund, monitor, and provide children with quality primary education
The Indian arm of the Chances for Children programs is run by the support of ING business units
in India (ING, ING Life Insurance and ING Investment Management) through the ING Vysya
Foundation.
The Foundation was set up almost 3 year ago and was actively involved in the post Tsunami
rehabilitation of the victims. ING Group set up a dedicated Tsunami Support account. In India,
the Foundation partnered with five NGO providing much needed financial support, from
rebuilding of schools to providing fishing boats, giving much needed hope to destroyed lives.
The Indian chapter of CFC involves the partnership of the Foundation with 7 NGO working in
primary education. Not only does the Foundation provide much needed financial support to these
organizations but also runs strong voluntary programs giving the employees a chance to meet the
children, work with them and take ownership and responsibility for the vision of its partners. The
Foundation creates systems that ensure CSR activities within the organization. Various programs
are initiated with the employees, whether it is taking 100 children for a day out to the
planetarium or watching a film with them. It collectively influences the culture of the
organization; and also provides the employees with an opportunity to contribute to the vision of
the organizations CSR.
Recently ING Vysya Foundation launched its initiative Run Ricky Run. In this initiative, for
every run Ricky makes the Foundation will sponsor one child to go to school through its
association with its NGO partner in Bangalore, SUKRUPA.
Page | 30
CHAPTER - 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Page | 31
CHAPTER- 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Page | 32
.
3.1 RESEARCH METHODOLGY
All the conclusions are based on the survey done in the working within the time limit. I tried to
select the sample representative of the whole group during my training. I have collected data
from people linked with ING VYSYA BANK and OTHER BANK
RESEARCH PLAN:
Preliminary Investigation: In which data on the situation surrounding the problems shall be
gathered to arrive at
The correct definition of the problem.
An understanding of its environment.
.Exploratory Study: To determine the approximate area where the problem lies.
RESEARCH DESIGN:
Page | 33
Research was initiated by examining the secondary data to gain insight into the problem. By
analyzing the secondary data, the study aim is to explore the short comings of the present system
and primary data will help to validate the analysis of secondary data besides on unrevealing the
areas which calls for improvement.
DEVELOPING THE RESEARCH PLAN:
The data for this research project has been collected through self Administration. Due to time
limitation and other constraints direct personal interview method is used. A structured
questionnaire was framed as it is less time consuming, generates specific and to the point
information, easier to tabulate and interpret. Moreover respondents prefer to give direct answers.
In questionnaires open ended and closed ended, both the types of questions has been used.
COLLECTION OF DATA:
1: Secondary Data:
It was collected from internal sources. The secondary data was
collected on the basis of organizational file, official records, news
papers ,magazines, management
books, preserved information in the companys database and website of the company.
Primary data:
All the people from different profession were personally visited and interviewed. They were the
main source of Primary data. The method of collection of primary data was direct personal
interview through a structured questionnaire.
SAMPLING PLAN:
Since it is not possible to study whole universe, it becomes necessary to take sample from the
universe to know about its characteristics.
Sampling Units: Different Account Holder and Service receiver from the bank
Sample Technique: Random Sampling.
Research Instrument: Structured Questionnaire.
Contact Method: Personal Interview.
SAMPLE SIZE:
Page | 34
My sample size for this project was 100 respondents. Since it was not possible to cover the
whole universe in the available time period, it was necessary for me to take a sample size of 100
respondents.
DATA COLLECTION INSTRUMENT DEVELOPMENT:
The mode of collection of data will be based on Survey Method and Field Activity. Primary data
collection will base on personal interview. I have prepared the questionnaire according to the
necessity of the data to be collected
DURATION OF THE STUDY
Duration of the study is 6 weeks
CHAPTER- 4
DATA
INTERPRETATION
AND ANALYSIS
Page | 35
Page | 36
PARTICULARS
ACCOUNT NAME
HDFC
ICICI
Saving Regular Savings
ING Vysya
Orange
Savings
Account
Account
Account
Rs10,000
Rs 10,000
Rs. 5,000
AVERAGE QUATERLY
BALANCE
750.00 Rs
CHARGES
quarter Only.
per
Available
Only.
N.A
Available
N.A
Unlimited
3
FREE TRANSACTIONS
750.00
per
per
month
from
SBI/Andhra
from
Bank ATM
THIRD PARTY CASH N.A
Rs.15,000
WITHDRAWL/DEPOSIT
NET BANKING
Free
per day
Free
Free
MOBILE BANKING
Free
Free
Free
Page | 37
PARTICULARS
HDFC
ICICI
ING Vysya
Account name
SAVING MAX
ACCOUNT
GOLD
PRIVILAGE
D ACCOUNT
FORMULA
SAVING
ACCOUNT
25,000
50,000
25,000
Free DD
Upto 50,000/qat
N.A.
Upto 50,000/qat.
Upto 15,000
N.A.
Upto 25,000
Smart-serv
N.A.
N.A.
Present
Free Transaction
6 in a year
N.A.
Unlimited
Special Features
Direct
Bill Payments
from accounts
Present
Preference
rates on gold
coins
N.A.
12 annual passes of
famous night clubs
and restaurants,
across India
Present
Page | 38
PARTICULARS
HDFC
ICICI
Account Name
Privileged
Platinum
Titanium
Platina
QAB (Quarterly
Available Balance)
2,00,000
75,000 + TRV
of 5 to 10 lac
1,00,000
DD/PO Wavier
Available upto
50,000
N.A.
Available upto
50,000
PAP books
Unlimited
unlimited
unlimited
N.A.
Available*
N.A.
ING Vysya
N.A.
N.A.
1 to 2 %
Cashnet enabled
credit/debit card
N.A.
N.A.
Available
Page | 39
As per the data collected and analyzed, most of the people in Muzaffarnagar have chosen ICICI
Bank for their banking. It is because ICICI was the first private banking player in the newly
formed state (U.K.) they hold the accounts of 51% of the respondents. Next rank comes to
HDFC with 31% of accounts. ING has captured 18% (speculative) of the market share within 6
months of its establishment in the State.
Page | 40
Page | 41
It is the amount which one has to maintain for a single quarter. 45% of the respondent were
maintaining 5,000 rupees. 35% were maintaining nothing, 12% were holding 10,000 as their
QAB. And 8% were holding more than 10,000 rupees.Out of 45% of the respondents who
maintain 5,000 rupees as their QAB, most of the respondents are having account in ICICI and
ING Vysya bank.
Page | 42
Smart serv is type of special services in which a person can send/present gifts to any of his/her
known in any of the city by just telling your banker the address of the person. The gift will be
purchased and will be delivered by the bank only, and the amount for the gift will be
automatically deducted from the senders account.
10% of the people who were really enjoying some of the special services provided by bank were
found to be associated with ING Vysya Bank.
Page | 43
51% of the people have rated ICICI Bank as 1st, this is because of wide market share of ICICI
Bank. 2nd Rank has been awarded to HDFC Bank by approximately 23% of respondents. 3rd
rating is given to ING Vysya bank by approx. 15% of the respondents. And last comes AXIS
Bank. Thus ING Vysya is better than AXIS and HDFC Bank in its Marketing Strategy.
Page | 44
All of the bank customers interact most frequently with the bank by doing their transactions from
ATM. 35% of them visit branch quite often and 35% of the respondents also go for phone
banking. Internet Banking is the 2nd most point of interaction of bank and the customer. People
who use Internet banking and mobile banking were found to be associated mainly with ICICI
and ING Vysya Bank. ING Vysya is having best Internet banking attributes. This implies the
technological advancement in Muzaffarnagar Citizens.
Page | 45
4 - Most/excellent
2- Fair
3- Reasonably good
1- Disappointing
1. Most of the people who are associated with ING Vysya Bank found their Bank charges
quite nominal and well justified. About 97% of the ING Vysya customers state the same. Even
AXIS Bank is charging best rates of charges to its customers. ICICI customer agrees that they
think of getting better bank charges.
2. People have ranked ICICI at the top notch for its 12hrs. working hours 8 to 8. Even
ING Vysya operates from 10 to 7, which is 2 hrs. more than HDFC and AXIS. Therefore ING
Vysya Bank has an edge over AXIS and HDFC as per working hours.
3. 80% people have again rated ICICI as one of the best banks location wise. Its large no.
of branches provides access to bank anywhere. As ING Vysya has got number other branch in
Uttar Pradesh it has been rated lowest as per most of the respondents and ING Vysya customers.
According to respondents even AXIS and HDFC bank have no. of branches and are located at an
accessible location.
Page | 46
4- Most/excellent
2- Fair
3- Reasonably good
1- Disappointing/least
4. Almost all respondents who are in connection with ING Vysya Bank have rated it best
in the customer care services. 55% of the respondent who are associated with HDFC Bank have
rated HDFC, reasonably good in customer care services. But customer of ICICI and AXIS Bank
are not very much delighted with customer care services of their bank. This way ING Vysya has
got an advantage of delivering excellent customer care services.
5. In case of Behavior of the Staff most of the ING Vysya customers have rated ING
the best. Almost 100% of the ING customers are well satisfied with their bankers behavior. On
the other hand 72% customers of ICICI bank and other respondents as well have ranked ICICI as
very disappointing as per behavior of the staff. Most of them stated that when they visit branch,
any of the employee there, hardly pays full attention towards them. Even some of the preferred
customers have to stay in a cue or have to wait for long to get their job done by the bank. HDFC
and AXIS Bank has been rated reasonably good by the respondents as far as behavior of the staff
is concerned.
Page | 47
6. With the criteria of Variety of Accounts, people have rated ICICI as the top one. This is
because ICICI is having bank accounts for the different customers with different needs. They
have account for old age citizen, pension account, kids account of various types and many more.
Where as ING Vysya has been rated least, because they are operating with only 3 types of saving
accounts in the city.
4- Most/excellent
3- Reasonably good
2- Fair
1- Disappointing
7. Most of the ING Vysya customers are happy with processing speed of their banking
transactions. ING Vysya Bank boasts about delivering the commitment. According to the ING an
account takes 5 days for activation.
8. The queries handling is done very well by ING Vysya bank according to the
respondents. 57% of the ICICI customers are unhappy with the bank regarding their queries
handling. Whereas AXIS Bank has been rated good.
Page | 48
According to the respondents, they mainly disagree for opening a bank account on their
friends or relatives recommendation. And to 27% of the respondents it doesnt matter.
Very few people agree to the recommendation. This means that the WORD OF MOUTH
is not an essential marketing channel for opening an account in bank. People first try to
find the real facts by their own.
Many people are bothered about their QAB, and to 23% people QAB doesnt mean
much. According to them they were never charged for not keeping enough QAB.
3) I am generally motivated by the television add for saving bank account.
Most of the respondents were unaware of the new advertisements of various banks. For
them it hardly plays any important role in capturing market share.
Page | 50
Most of the respondents were very much bothered about the distance from their bank and home.
That implies that PROXIMITY to bank is one of the very BOLD VARIABLE for account
opening.
Page | 51
Most of the Customers strongly agree that they give preference to instant alert about the
deposits and withdraw in their accounts by the bank. They also prefer the facility of net
banking and phone banking as it gives them ease for banking.
Page | 52
SWOT ANALYSIS
Strengths
Weakness
Page | 53
Opportunities
Threats
CHAPTER - 5
Page | 54
The study conducted directs toward the Private Banking scenario in Delhi. Study suggested that
a large market share has been captured by ICICI Bank and HDFC Bank. Out of two ICICI is
Page | 55
enjoying the maximum market share. This is probably because of the reason that ICICI was the
first private bank in the state as well as in city.
Most of the people know about the account and services associated with it. Most of the people
are maintaining 5,000 rupees as QAB in their private banking account, but most of them except
ING Vysya customer are unaware of the special facilities available.
People have ranked ICICI bank as best in the city. This is may be due to the oldest persistence of
ICICI bank in the city. They have rated HDFC as 3rd and ING Vysya as 2nd.
Almost everyone comes in contact with their bank by the use of ATM machines. 80% of the
respondents were using internet banking that implies high literacy rate in the city.
People think that the staff of ICICI does not behave well with their customers but ING Vysya
customers are glad with the staff of ING Vysya Bank. But on the other hand ICICI customers are
very happy with the working hours of ICICI bank. HDFC customers are a bit unhappy with the
working hours of their bank.
People are very much bothered by the distance between their home and the bank. They believe
that this a major issue which influence the customer to open an account in any bank. Most of the
people are not entertained by the television advertisements about various banks. Even word of
mouth has not been proved as strong marketing channel about banking. It implies that for
banking customer is looking at the commitment, real facts, distance between their home and
bank, behavior of the banker, QAB and many more.
LIMITATION
Page | 56
Page | 57
RECOMMENDATION
Many of the respondent are not aware about their key services. Bank has to take some
initiatives.
Bank can post a list of services that they can rendered to the customer inside the bank
premises.
ING Vysya Bank has to improve its brand image i.e. create a position in the mindset of the
customer.
It should more emphasize on advertisement. Advertisement is a most powerful tool for
position and brand in the mindset of customer.
ING Vysya Bank should ask for their customer feedback to know whether the consumer are
satisfied or dissatisfied.
Due to intense competition in the financial market. ING Vysya Bank should adopt better
strategy to attract more customer
Page | 58
BIBLIOGRAPHY
WEBSITES
www.ingvysyabank.com
www.icicibank.com
www.hdfcbank.com
www.moneycontrol.com
www.economictimes.com
www.blackle.com
India Today
Chronicle
Business World
Business Today
BOOKS
ANNEXURE
Page | 59
Questionnaire
Comparative analysis of saving bank accounts of different private sector banks
Dear respondent,
We are conducting a research to know the general perception and attitude of customer towards
the products & services that are offered by ING Vysya Bank & other private banks (ICICI &
HDFC) in Muzaffarnagar. The information will be valuable input for the research and we assure
you that the information will be kept confidential. We hope that you will co-ordinate with us and
give quite a few minutes from your precious time and give the genuine answer.
Personal Details:Name:Gender :-
Age:Address:Occupation:-
Service
Professional
Businessman
Educational Qualification:-
Page | 60
Below 1 Lac
1 Lac 3 Lac
3 Lac - 5 Lac
Above 5 Lac
3. HDFC Bank
(Please
Specify)
3) Do you have complete knowledge of the saving account and services associated with
that account you have?
a) Yes
b) No
c) Cant say
4) Are you a preferred/privileged customer of your bank?
a) Yes
b) No
Page | 61
5) Mobile Banking How much Quarterly Available Balance (QAB) you need to maintain?
a. Nil
b. 5,000
c. 10,000
d. More than above
6) Does your Bank provide you some special services like, smart serve, mi-banking?
a. Yes
b. No
7) Please rate the following banks on the scale of 4 where 1is the least and 4 is the most
according to your perception you are having for reputation of the banks.
ING Vysya
Bank
ICICI Bank
HDFC Bank
Axis Bank
Visit Branch
ATM
Phone Banking
Drop Box
Internet Banking
Page | 62
9) Please rate the following banks on the basis of your perception about the given attributes
out of 4, where 1 is the least/disappointing and 4 is the most/excellent
S.NO
ATTRIBUTES
1.
Bank charges
2.
Customer care
3.
4.
5.
Working Hours
6.
Location
7.
Personalized attention
8.
Processing Speed
9.
Grievance/queries handling
ING
Vysya
Bank
ICICI
Bank
HDFC
Bank
Axis
Bank
10) Please rate the following variables which influence you when it comes to open an
account on the scale of 1 to 5 where 1 is strongly disagree and 5 is strongly agree.
SL
NO
STATEMENTS
SRONGLY
STRONGLY
DISAGREE AGREE
Page | 63
1
1
.
Tthank you for your cooperation for devoting your valuable time and sharing the valuable
information with us which will help us to complete our project successfully.
Place
Date..
Signature of the respondent
Page | 64
Page | 65