Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Lisa J. Wuebker
Georgia Institute of Technology
ABSTRACT:
188
189
Table 1
Description and Reliability o f P S I - 3 S Subscales
Scales
Descriptions
Honesty
Measures job applicants' attitudes toward theft and crime. People who
score lower on this scale generally exhibit more rumination over theft
activities, more projection of theft in others, greater rationalization of
theft, less punitive attitudes toward thieves, and more inter-thief loyalty. Split-half reliability = .95. Examples of Honesty scale correlates
include: theft apprehensions; admissions (self-report and polygraph exams); dollar value of' thefts of cash, merchandise, and property; number
of criminal acts committed; number of minutes of unauthorized work
break extensions; convicted felon vs. job applicant status; prior criminal arrests; supervisor ratings for counterproductivity; cash drawer
shortages; company shrinkage; terminations for theft; dysfunctional
turnover; number of disciplinary actions {'or company cash mishandling;
and disregard for company rules in general.
Non-violence
Measures work applicants' tendencies toward on-the-job violent behavior and other related forms of counterproductivity, such as physical
assault, vandalism of company property and merchandise, damage and
waste of company materials, and argumentativeness. Split-half reliability = .87. Examples of Non-violence scale correlates include: number of violent acts committed; dollar amount of damaged company
property and merchandise; physical assault of co-workers, supervisors,
and/or customers; on-the-job waste of company materials and supplies;
violence admissions (polygraph exams and self-reports); and poor customer service.
Drug-avoidance
Safety-control
190
Criterion-Related Validity
A number of studies have provided evidence of the criterion-related
validity of the P S I - 3 S safety scale. An initial study by Jones and Wuebker (1985a) compared the safety scores of 158 university students with
self-reported accident histories. Subjects with more severe accident histories (i.e., at least one major injury, such as a broken bone) were significantly more "external" in their safety beliefs than students with less
severe or no accident histories (r phi = .54).
Other criterion-related validity studies have generated similar results. A study of 283 hospital employees showed that workers with more
external safety control orientations reported significantly more occupational accidents, as well as more severe and costly injuries, than workers with more internal safety attitudes (p < .05 in all cases) (Jones &
Wuebker, 1985b).
In an investigation using state motor vehicle reports of commercial
bus drivers, Jones and Foreman (1984) found that high risk drivers
191
(N = 21) (i.e., those with two or more convictions for unsafe driving)
scored in a significantly more external direction on the safety scale than
drivers (N = 25) with safer records. The relationship was moderately
strong (r phi = .44). This study supports findings by Montag and Comrey (1987). These researchers found driving locus of control test scores
significantly discriminated between drivers who did (N = 200) and did
not (N = 200) have a fatal driving accident in the past (Multiple R = .38).
Drivers in the fatal accident group were more externally-oriented in
their safety beliefs.
The P S I - 3 S safety subscale reliably discriminated between hotel
employees (N = 17) at high risk for on-the-job accidents (i.e., those employees with major accidental injuries reported in their personnel files)
and those employees (N = 103) at low risk for accidents (i.e., no accidents or injuries reported) (Wuebker, Jones, & DuBois, 1985). A significant difference in the predicted direction was obtained (t = 2.6, p < .01).
At an aggregate level, this study of two large, metropolitan hotels found
that the hotel which had a higher accident rate also had employees
(N = 58) who were much more externally-oriented in their safety beliefs
than employees (N = 62) in the low accident rate hotel (t = 2.4, p < .02).
This finding suggests that a poor "climate of safety" within a company
m a y be a reflection of the workers' safety attitudes and behavior. Zohar
(1980) has postulated the existence of a "safety climate" which reflects
workers' perceptions about the value of employee safety and the effectiveness of organizational safety programs.
J o y and Frost (1987) conducted a criterion-related validity study
with a short form of the safety scale. Fifty-four bus drivers completed
the scale and then their supervisors rated their overall job performance.
Statistically significant results ( p < .01 in all cases) were obtained between safety scores and measures of productivity (r = .50), customer relations (r = .52), and overall job performance (r = .51). Safety was a major aspect of the bus drivers' productivity and overall job performance
ratings; hence, these findings were not surprising.
Finally, Jones and Wuebker (1988) administered an expanded and
improved version of the P S I - 3 S safety scale to 106 grocery store employees. This new scale assessed a broader range of safety attitudes and
beliefs. It continued to assess safety locus of control beliefs, yet it also
assessed individuals' self-reported abilities to both concentrate and remain calm and alert under pressure. The new scale also assessed how
many accidents people expected to have in the future, along with their
desire to engage in dangerous, thrill-seeking behavior. The criterion
measure of safety was a supervisor's grouping of the employees into
a "high accident risk" group (N = 52) or a "low accident risk" group
(N = 54) based on accident histories recorded in the employees' personnel files. A statistically significant point-biserial correlation (r = .50)
192
was obtained. The low risk group tended to exhibit more internallyoriented safety beliefs than the high risk group.
Construct Validity
Wuebker (1987) examined the construct validity of the safety scale.
She found that safety scale scores of 1,732 employment applicants significantly correlated (p < .001 in all cases) with psychological measures
of dishonesty (r = .31), violence (r = .29), and drug abuse potential
(r = .18). She concluded that poor safety scores seem to be related to a
more general "counterproductivity" factor. That is, employees at risk for
accidents appear to be at slightly greater risk to break company rules,
damage and waste property, and use drugs at work. Parenthetically,
Wuebker found a non-significant relationship (r = .07) between safety
scale scores and distortion or "lie" scale scores. This finding suggests
that it is difficult to fake answers on the safety scale, probably because
its purpose is not obvious to applicants.
In another construct validity study, Fay and Jones (1987) attempted
to identify psychological predictors of exemplary childcare workers. A
small sample of adults (N = 24) was administered a projective drawing
test and the safety scale. Statistically significant results (p < .05 in all
cases) showed that safety scores were associated with the quality of projective drawings made by the adults. That is, "external scorers," when
asked to draw a house, a tree, and a person, were more likely to draw
very clumsy looking hands lacking one or more fingers. External scorers
were also more likely to omit one or both eyes from their drawings. Conversely, "internal" scorers were more likely to draw well-proportioned
hands with five fingers along with a pair of alert, appropriately placed
eyes. This pilot study suggests that safety beliefs might be associated
with subconscious processes, especially processes that reflect how attentive and coordinated people feel with their surrounding environment.
Jones and Wuebker (1985a) compared the safety scores of 15 highly
educated and experienced safety professionals to 46 college students
with low accident histories (e.g., they reported one very minor injury),
60 students with a moderate accident history (e.g., they typically reported two minor injuries such as cuts or small bruises) and 13 subjects
with serious accident histories (e.g., they reported three or more accidents, with at least one accident being a major accident such as a broken bone). Point-biserial correlations revealed that the safety professionals were more internally-controlled ( p < .05 in all cases) in their
safety beliefs than the low accident group (r = .45), the moderate accident group (r--.51), and the high accident group (r = .89). Research is
needed to explore any potential causal relationships between level of
safety education and safety locus of control beliefs.
193
Time-Series Analysis
The P S I - 3 S safety subscale appears to be a valid predictor of a
number of different safety criteria. This section examines the impact of
the entire P S I - 3 S battery, including the safety subscale, on the reduction of industrial accidents and insurance losses.
The research reviewed above indicates that the entire P S I - 3 S battery should effectively reduce industrial accidents. The research seems
to support the notion that rule-abiding, non-violent, non-drug-abusing,
and particularly safety conscious job applicants should have less industrial accidents than their more counterproductive counterparts. The
next research step is to document that companies that use test batteries
like the P S I - 3 S actually have a reduction in accidents.
Jones and Steffy (1986) evaluated the effectiveness of the P S I - 3 S
on accident criteria in a large national trucking firm. The study was a
41 month investigation. In Phase A (the first 23 months) interviews and
reference checks were used to screen job applicants. In Phase B (the last
18 months) the P S I - 3 S was added to the screening process and all applicants (over 300) were given the inventory.
The results supported the use of the P S I - 3 S as an effective accident
reduction program. Monthly paid insurance losses were significantly
(p < .05 in all cases) reduced from an average of $25,600 in Phase A to
an average of $5,400 in Phase B. Moreover, the average number of lost
work days due to injuries was significantly reduced by 50%, from 161
days per month in Phase A to 79 days per month in Phase B. These results are summarized in Figure 1. They suggest that a personnel selection approach to safety is a viable adjunct to more traditional safety
programs.
The next study examined the impact of the P S I - 3 S on the reduction of worker compensation losses (e.g., back injuries, slips and falls,
lacerations, and miscellaneous strains). This is a new study. It was specifically hypothesized that companies would experience a reduction in
worker compensation losses once they implemented the P S I - 3 S for personnel selection. Not only would more safety conscious employees be
194
Figure 1
Impact of P S I - 3 S on P a i d I n s u r a n c e Losses and Lost Work Days
A~rage MomMy PaidInsurance
Due to t N o r ~
Chart^
Cleft B
Pre-PSI-3S
PSI-3S
P~-PSI-3S
3o
m
175
$25,60O
PSI-3S
1~1
150
2s
~"
125
7s
79
._c
10
$5,400
s
50
2S
1983.1984
(23 Months)
1984-1986
(18 Months)
1983-1984
(23 Moths1
1984-1986
(18 Months)
hired, but use of the PSI-3S for applicant screening would communicate to all employees that management is fully committed to improving
workplace safety. An improved organizational "climate of safety" could
evolve (cf., Zohar, 1980).
Methods. the PSI-3S was implemented in eight milk processing and delivery companies beginning in the first quarter of 1985. The eight firms
were part of the same parent company. Each location employed approximately 35-40 employees. The employees within each company basically
shared duties when it came to processing, packaging and delivering
milk and dairy products. From March, 1985 through November, 1986,
the eight companies collectively processed over 200 PSI-3S's. They
hired approximately 80 applicants who passed all of the PSI-3S subscales. Based on PSI-3S scores, these applicants were classified as being at low risk to have workplace accidents.
A single-factor repeated measures research design was used. The
single factor was the year in which accidents were reported. Four years
were studied: 1983, 1984, 1985, and 1986. Since the PSI-3S was implemented in the first quarter of 1985, it was predicted that a significant
reduction in accidents would be observed in 1986. The dependent variable was the total frequency of worker compensation accidents recorded
for each company during each of the four years studied. Accident frequency rates were obtained from computer data bases maintained by
the company's insurance agent.
195
"f-'l
111
I
*i /
d) l
*,/
mZ
!
I
LC)
~
00
cp
>a)
>=
0
s
mc
r~
Lz
e")
o~
,t!
o.
~I
o.
~.
AOUr
(llelulldWoO II 9 N|
tWlllO uol|IIuodwo0 ~r
I~IJOA v
I
0
197
198
Gens, D. (1985). Technical reference industry guide: retail food stores. St. Paul, MN: The
St. Paul Fire and Marine, Risk Management Services Division.
Huber, P. (1987). Injury litigation and liability insurance dynamics. Science, 238, 31-36.
Jones, J.W. (1980). Attitudinal correlates of employees' deviance: theft, alcohol use, and
non prescribed drug use. Psychological Reports, 47, 71-77.
Jones, J.W., DuBois, D., & Wuebker, L.J. (1986). Promoting safety by reducing human
error. Personnel, 63, 41-44.
Jones, J.W. & Foreman, R. (1984). Relationship of P S I - 3 S safety scale scores to motor rehicle reports. St. Paul, MN: Technical Report: The St. Paul Fire and Marine, The Human Factors Department.
Jones, J.W., Barge, B., Steffy, B., Fay, L., Kunz, L., & Wuebker, L. (1988). Stress and medical malpractice: organizational risk assessment and intervention. Journal of Applied
Psychology. (In press, November Issue.)
Jones, J.W. & Steffy, B.D. (1986). The impact of applied psychology on the reduction of insurance losses. Park Ridge, IL: Technical Report, London House, Inc., Research and
Development Group.
Jones, J.W., & Wuebker, L.J. (1985a). Development and validation of the Safety Locus of
Control Scale. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 61,151-161.
Jones, J.W., & Wuebker, L.J. (1985b). Psychometric properties of the Safety Locus of Control Scale. Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Military Testing Association.
San Diego, CA, October 21-25.
Jones, J.W., & Wuebker, L.J. (1988). The psychological assessment of employees' safety potential. Park Ridge, IL: Technical Report, London House, Inc,, Research and Development Group.
Joy, D.S., & Frost, A.G. (1987). Validation of the Personnel Selection Inventory: Form 7S.
Park Ridge, IL: Technical Report, London House, Inc., Research and Development
Group.
Komaki, J., Barwick, K., & Scott, L. (1978). A behavioral approach to occupational safety:
pinpointing and reinforcing safe performance in a good manufacturing plant. Journal
of Applied Psychology, 63, 434-445.
London House, Inc. (1988). The Personnel selection inventory: Form 3S. Park Ridge IL:
London House Press. (1550 Northwest Highway, Park Ridge, IL 60068).
McKenna, F.P. (1983). Accident proneness: a conceptual analysis. Accident Analysis and
Prevention. 15, 65-71.
Montag, I., & Comrey, A.I. (1987). Internality and externality as correlates of involvement
in fatal driving accidents. Journal of Applied Psychology, 72(3), 339-343.
Moretti, D. (1983). Employee counterproductivity: attitudinal predictors of industrial damage and waste. Paper presented at the Annual meeting of the Society of Police and
Criminal Psychology, Atlanta, October Meeting.
National Safety Council (1983). Accident facts 1983 edition. Chicago, IL: National Safety
Council.
Rotter, J.B. (1966). Generalized expectancies for internal versus external control of reinforcement. Psychological Monographs. (80, 1, Whole No. 609).
Terris, W. (1985a). Employee theft: research, theory, and applications. Park Ridge, IL: London House Press.
Terris, W. (1985b). Attitudinal correlates of employee integrity. Journal of Police and
Criminal Psychology, 1, 60-68.
Wuebker, L.J. (1987). The safety locus of control scale: a construct validation study. Unpublished manuscript.
Wuebker, L.J. (1988). Relationship of P S I - 3 S safety scale scores to Rotter's general locus of
control measure. Unpublished manuscript.
Wuebker, L.J., Jones, J.W., & DuBois, D. (1985). Safety locus of control and employees' accidents. Paper presented at the Sixth Annual Industrial/Organizational Psychology
Graduate Student Conference, University of Akron, Akron, Ohio, April 12-14.
Zohar, D. (1980). Safety climate in industrial organizations.' theoretical and implied implications. Journal of Applied Psychology, 65, 96-102.