1

SOME QUESTIONS FOR ENGINEER ALI MIRAZ

2[Q,1,A]
1

31)Respected Ali Mirza Of Jhelum you have confessed that that there is an IJMAA on
4the Muttassil Al Asnad Ahadis of Sahih Al Bukhari and Sahih Al Muslim that they are
5CERTAINLY SAHIH with out any shadow of doubt.The same openion is held by your
6teacher Shaikh Aki Zai. But Ithana Ashriah do not accept a single Hadis of Sahih
7Muslim and SAHIH BUKHARI Through there Asnad. So they are Munkir Of Both of
8them. Hence they are Munkir Of Ijmaa. As Mukir of Ijmaa they cannot have be
9advocated in any sense. The question is do you accept them as Munkir Of Ijmaa or
10not?
112) Can you prove that RIJAL OF BUKHARI AND MUSLIM are CIQH/SIQH from the
12books of Rijaal of Ithna Ashriyh.?
133)Can you prove each and every HADIS of Bukhari and Muslim from the Ithna
14Ashriah books like USUL AL CAFI ,or Tahzib or Man La Yahdir or Istabsar or even Faru
15Al Cafi? If you cannot then do you accept that Ithna Ashriah discard Bukhari and
16Muslim as authentic books of AHADIS.?
174)How many Ahadis of Bukhari and Muslim can be proved to be Sahih from the
18books of traditions of Isna Ashriyah like Usul Al Cafi. Etc.
195)Respected Ali Mirza Of Jhelum you do accept and confess in one of your lectures
20which you call research papers ,that there is an IJMAA that QURAN IS GHAIR
21MAKHLUQ. But can you prove that
22IthNA ASHRIYAH BELIEVE THAT QURAN IS GHAIR MAKHLUQ, from most authentic
23ISNA ASHRI SOURCES, or they agree with Mutazilah on this issue.? If they agree
24with Mutazilah on this issue then do you accept they are MUNKIR OF IJMAA on the
25Issue Quran is Ghair Makhluq?
266)Do you believe in the visibility Of Allah in heavens after doomsday [ALQIYAMAH].
27If yes then do you know there is IJMAA on this issue and a number of AHADIS ON
28THIS ISSUE. There is an Ijmaa to take all the AHADIS of DIVINE VISIBILITY literally.
29But Isna Ashriah/Ithna Ashriyah deney the Divine Visibility. Do you accept that they
30not only denounce all the AHADIS IN THIS regard as well as the Ijmaa stated in this
31question?
327) Do you believe that SAIYIDNA MUAVIAH RD poisoned SAIYIDNA HASAN RD.? If
33so then you are asked to provide the references with Asnaad.If not then you are
34asked to deney it EXPLICITLY.
1
2
3

2
4
358) Do you believe that Holy Prophet SAVS was attributed with ILM AL GHAIB.? It is
36requested that the answer must be either in affirmation or in negation. No details
37are required in this question.
38How ever if you believe that a strict answer is not possible neither in Affirmation nor
39In negation then it
409) Do you believe that ACTS of human beings are created by ALLAANAHU VA
41TAALA . IF so then in which of the following senses?
42a) In the very same sense ALLAH is the CREATOR /KHALIQ of each and every thing.
43b)In some other sense,
44If you choose the option B then it is required to state both of the two senses of the
45word KHALIQ
46And their differences EXPLICITLY.
4710)What do you say about Mutah. Is it HARAM or HALAL. ? You have just to say
48whether it is Haram or Halal. No detail may please be given?
4911)A) What do you say about a person who says that the following persons are
50MASU:M:=
511]SAIYIDUNA ALI RD.
522] SAIYIDATUNA FATIMAH RD.
533] SAIYIDUNA HASAN RD
544]SAIYIDUNA HUSAIN RD
555]HAZRAT ALI BIN HUSAIN RH
566]HAZRAT MUHAMMAD BIN ALI BIN HUSAIN RH
577]HAZRAT JAFAR BIN MUHAMMAD RD
588] MUSA BIN JAFAR
599]ALI BIN MUSA
6010] MUHAMMAD BIN ALI
6111] ALI BIN MUHAMMAD
6212]HASAN BIN ALI.
2
5
6

3
7
63B) What do you say for such a person who says that each one of the above
64mentioned person is higher [AFDAL] then all the prophets with the exception of Holy
65Prophet SAVS.
66C) What do you say about a person who says that every Prophet is Afdal then each
67one of them but not with certainty [QATI] but with Probability [Zanni]. AL AYADH
68BILLAH TAALA
69You should state whether such a person is Kafir/Cafir or not in each part of the
70question (11).
7112) Do you believe that Usul Al Cafi /Kafi is as authentic as Bukhari sharif or not. If
72not then is it as authentic as any one of the books of Sahah. The answer should be
73given properly.
74Also it is asked whether do you believe that NAHJUL BALAGHAH is an authentic book
75of AASAAR of Saiyiduna Ali RD. or it is just an unauthentic book like Man La Yahdir Al
76Faqih anf Faru Al Kafi.
77It must be noted that AHLUSSUNNAH DO REGARD these two Isna Ashri books as
78unauthentic. Do you agree with them or not.
79

More Questions shall be raised soon.

80Please note that the Arabic letter

81Is some time represented by z and some time by dh or by z:.
82Similarly the Arabic letter
83

is

84REPRESENTED BY s and some time by th or by s:.

85Insha Allah an unique system shall be adopted as we continue to criticize Engineer
86Ali Mirza Of Jhelum.
87@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
88@@@@

3
8
9