Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
shielding,
I. INTRODUCTION
UMAN exposure to low-frequency (50- and 60-Hz) electromagnetic fields (EMFs), emanated from transmission
and distribution electrical networks, has occupied the publics
interest for many years. The possible effects to human health
from exposure to low-frequency EMFs are presented in [1] and
[2]. Consequently, many countries adopted limits for the recommended maximum exposure to EMFs for the general public and
workers based on guidelines that were introduced by international organizations, such as the International Commission on
Non- Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP), National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB), and IEEE [3][5]. In accordance with the ICNIRP guidelines, the exposure limits to 50-Hz
T and 5 kV/m for public
magnetic and electric fields are
T and 10 kV/m for occupational exposure, respecand
tively. These limits are taken into consideration when the power
networks are designed and constructed.
This paper has focused on the measurements of the resulting
magnetic field near two-pole-type distribution substations of
20/0.4 kV and 400 kVA in urban areas, during spring and
summer. In addition, a comparison between the measured
values of the field and those specified as limits by ICNIRP are
also presented. Furthermore, the measurements of the resulting
magnetic field were carried out after placing thin aluminum
Manuscript received May 29, 2010; revised September 05, 2010; accepted
October 07, 2010. Paper no. TPWRD-00401-2010.
A. N. Proios, C. D. Halevidis, and P. D. Bourkas are with the School of
Electrical and Computer Engineering, National Technical University of Athens,
Athens 15780, Greece (e-mail: axilleas_proios@yahoo.gr; khalev@central.ntua.gr; pbourkas@central.ntua.gr).
E. I. Koufakis is with the Public Power Corporation S.A., Chania 73300,
Greece (e-mail: e.koufakis@dei.com.gr).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2010.2089068
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
2
TABLE I
CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER OF MEASUREMENTS
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
PROIOS et al.: MAGNETIC-FIELD MEASUREMENTS NEAR TWO-POLE-TYPE DISTRIBUTION SUBSTATIONS
(2)
Fig. 6. Load curve for substation 12 during summer.
TABLE II
LV SIDE CURRENTS OF THE TWO-POLE-TYPE DISTRIBUTION SUBSTATIONS
III. DISCUSSION
The analysis of the experimental data revealed that all of
the measured magnetic-field values were lower when compared
T for public exposure introduced by ICwith the value of
NIRP, when the doors of the LV fuse boxes were closed. In addition, as the distance from the substations increased, the field
weakened at a high rate in every direction.
The measurements conducted in spring (Fig. 7) show that for
the horizontal distance of 030 cm from the substations, the
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
4
Fig. 10. Mean magnetic-field values measured for three heights along the line
connecting measuring points 4 and 68 during spring.
Fig. 9. Mean magnetic-field values measured for three heights along the line
connecting the measuring points 28 and 44 during spring.
Fig. 12. Mean magnetic-field values of the measuring points 128 (between
the poles) at horizontal distances of 030 cm (side D) during summer.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
PROIOS et al.: MAGNETIC-FIELD MEASUREMENTS NEAR TWO-POLE-TYPE DISTRIBUTION SUBSTATIONS
Fig. 13. Mean magnetic-field values for three heights along the line connecting
the measuring points 16 and 56 during spring.
Fig. 14. Mean magnetic-field values of the measuring points 920 (side D) with
the LV fuse boxes open at horizontal distances of 03.0 m during the spring.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
6
Fig. 15. Mean magnetic-field values of the measuring points 920 (side D)
with the LV fuse boxes open at distances 030 cm.
Fig. 16. Mean magnetic-field values between the poles of the measuring points
128, with the LV fuse boxes covered with aluminum plates, 030 cm away from
substations (side D) during the spring.
Fig. 17. Mean magnetic-field values between the poles of the measuring points
128, with the LV fuse boxes with and without aluminum plates at distances
030 cm away from substations (side D) during the spring.
Fig. 18. Mean magnetic-field values between the poles of the measuring points
128, with the LV fuse boxes with and without aluminum plates at distances
030 cm away from substations (side D) during the summer.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
PROIOS et al.: MAGNETIC-FIELD MEASUREMENTS NEAR TWO-POLE-TYPE DISTRIBUTION SUBSTATIONS
between 54% and 99%, when compared with the values without
the aluminum plates.
As the horizontal distance increased to 1.0 m and for a height
of 1.0 m, the mean values of the field were between 3 and 25% of
those at 0 m. At a distance of 2.0 m, all of the mean values were
, and at 3.0 m, they were less than
less than
during both periods of the experimental study. The greatest reduction in the field was recorded at a height of 1.0 m from the
ground, while at other heights, the reduction was smaller.
With regard to the two-pole-type distribution substations, further study for the mitigation of the magnetic field is suggested.
As mentioned in [25][28], plates made of different materials
and thicknesses can be used to cover the LV fuse boxes and the
LV and MV cables.
IV. CONCLUSION
Measurements of the resulting 50-Hz magnetic field near 15
two-pole-type distribution substations of 400 kVA during the
spring and summer showed that all the values recorded were
lower when compared with the values presented in the guidelines that ICNIRP has introduced for public and occupational
exposure. The loading of the substations during summer was
higher when compared with those in the spring, resulting in
higher magnetic-field values at all measuring points.
For the first 30 cm of all directions from the substations,
the field decayed at a high rate. As the measuring distance increased, the reduction in the field was even greater, and at 3.0
m, all of the values were less than 2.20 T in both seasons of
the study.
Near the LV fuse boxes at point 13, at a horizontal distance
of 0 m and height of 1.0 m from the ground, the highest values
during
were recorded. These values were 59.40 and
spring and summer, respectively, with the doors of the LV
fuse boxes being kept closed. When the doors were kept open,
the maximum recorded values were 118.69 and
during spring and summer, respectively. The mean attenuation
achieved through the LV fuse box housing was approximately
54% during the spring and 57% during the summer at the
region of up to 30 cm from the substations and at a height of
1.0 m from the ground, at the measuring points near the LV
fuse boxes.
At measuring points 920 and 4960 near the LV fuse boxes,
high values of the field were recorded. In these points, the mitigation of the field was achieved, with the external placement of
thin aluminum plates on all sides of the LV fuse boxes.
The mean attenuation achieved was approximately 23%
during spring and 18% during summer at the region of up to
30 cm from the substations and at a height of 1.0 m from the
ground, at the measuring points near the LV fuse boxes. At all
of the other measuring points, there was no notable change in
the magnetic-field values when compared with those measured
without the aluminum plates.
Further study is suggested to examine the shielding materials
used in the LV fuse boxes and LV and MV conductors of the
two-pole-type distribution substations.
REFERENCES
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
8
Perikles D. Bourkas is Prof. Dr. Dipl. Eng. (Electrical Engineer) at the National Technical University
(NTU) of Athens, Athens, Greece. His working
experience includes positions, such as: President
of the Technical Council of the Ministry of Health,
Director of the Technical Services at the Ministry
of Health, and Director Electrical Engineer of the
Athens General Hospital. He has also been an Electrical Engineer in various industries. Currently, he is
Professor at the NTU of Athens and Vice President
of the Electrical and Computer Engineering Department. His technical experience and research activities involve high-voltage
engineering, electrical measurements, electrical insulating materials, electromechanical installations in industry and buildings, hospital installations, and
biomedical technology.