"

('

~
~

't-

"'-

-,

'\"\

L-:

"\'-:
~

~:

\'\

i '~

10'

Y.\

~\

(\.

(lJ

.s--

l
\r:.

&

v"

~",

t"-

")

\.

~,

~.

\p

'\

<>.

~.

<,

.\

'.I

<,

~
~

.~.

S'. ~

.\

-,

tI

~f
"-

fl:

'r-;
\['.

~)

"',

.~

~
''1

~t
".

f \~~

~i'..~
.'~'."'~

"

.~

~
",\
~

~
~

~
.

"

Q,

~\

~
\IV
,

.'t

-<I
;

1 ,~

!"

.-:;.

\'

~,

('

~-t
r

\\

\)

...._.~

'\)

~.~

~
~

.~
I

~
}

"

,~,

~.

r-

JJ

,'-1

. VI -

t-\
'~' \)

~ .. :.~\~
~.

fJ

\A

"\',

""", <,

~ f-

~
~

'*

11

I;.

\Iv

'-...

"\

"

-(

I"

-!..

"'I

--(

<,

k~

-';('

c:-

* .~

~>
~

2:

>-'

f ~. f

N' ~ ..
-c
-z-

6'

~)-""1

ISCAP APPEAL NO. 2012-048, document no. 13

DECLASSIFICATION DATE: July 8,2015

'\\ I DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE

--..; INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL,
R.O. 13526, SECTION 5.3(b)(3)

~~
.)

'-~

"\

r ~

~.

~ S ~

.~

~.f ~.~

~ t ~ :J

i
~,
,

\~

i'-

,<;,~

{,\

~~'i;

..~.f

~.)

, -y

1j f

"6'i~'

M,

Ii

~~

)\

<,

s\
--t:

,---rxl ' ct

~/I,f

+r-" -~_

~h?"-1-d

12-7'25.
; ,
i ~

.,4;, 'fv-; '?/

~~J

J S'!

4"'-<>

")"'Pcf"../'

,~

i ~

~~

L2~.v>-

/f,

c.:t!;4' -s-~

,--'

,!fl~

;:.~
e

V--t.-~~~

~~~

Gf.~

~"f'

v~

AJ~

~C{l'Y!(?-L1

t :

Tv~'

Cl-?."

.:'-!.~~~

4.~e:'-<~?~--r-

1r. YN

7~e'

L/--1.h~

~--7

'Iv

O~~;:;-Gd

.~~~~

"

r-=-d-~

~~~4~

v;P

?,:;~

~(/.ei~~ ~,?~--/

.~,~

Ie.

1.(1?

- d7",.ve~/R~,6

,.-e'-C;C4",",~",~.

~,~

'6Z

.Y /'

U/Zi-fl

#~

/11

'

'~/.r-;4'1 vSj

EM!r0) ,j-- d_.'

Ct/ccr~~'"-7

(~

~/f1"/

~
I

G~~

...
)2el

,~:

~C<~~--'-d'~~.
~

~X

~,

,V"','t'1~~'..e:~

! :
; t

,~

i-t, {!,.,
(./~5t-",./r'

(\i!

-rt_---.:I::::E:::.O::.::l::35::2:::6,=s::ec=ti:::oll=:1:=.4=(c=)=::1~

LJ __

i",

~AR~tZZ

'Toer;

<~

\~,Af:~.-rUA~~ -

Ie t1vi.r!&/

:~~I

;E;;/-~~

01'?c.

r:

~.-{

~<./'1'

I./~NN

G(/?;>,

~~

Ovvt;

'~~""

~01t...

/h

y~

f-rcyf?

'fC

:;; k-ti,;'"

tfl~(

t"V1

,416~

v19L-.

-'hi;' ~

'1

..e->r

cd~~;;:;

/2--, ,_

~)'c-:r-

:;
'.

/-:.'W/~--;:.

~~

~~y/

I E.O.

13526, section 1.4(c) I

;~~:z:

i"(fl~/

i;

~-vz/

.~

i~4

,~~-

k(

L1flL-

r:,A5'L-'/

/I'/r-

S'&~~";-.~

~~~It \

'-'t;f'c-#

:i

"

~G&-/

p~-V'd!_

'"

:!~~v64

~~<A

i-~

>~U'c-/

,~/,

..)Vy1-

~7

y~

Jn~

~;~

~-'~

/k--k/:'

_~;/.

~4;....

..i~~yP_

,~./~

'4 ~

~-:-

i ;

.Jo

'~-G<?

i:

!!

iJ

f,Vl'!

Ih

lid& <:1

il ~

,e~ ~

-M

-c-a

c;1i~

(-~

#~J
.t&:_ _~

~4~

?,'t-<-~~c--e::V)~~

&.;to;A

~~

~ :k:4).

C-c.~.,(~ .

dt'

.~

~ cJ ~w4

p{.~

f--t.~~

.e-t?7k4t1'-4'

i)

re&~v?

i,

4(~ d~),

,~~~I

('%b1( ,.

i:

r:itdf --:-R?fA6~----~-~JV::;-:;6;?J

!:

,
!j
:~

~--~-/br

4,,,c:&-

:: c~

h/
~

u~

J-e

.7b

c~~/

/~'~x-6

.----

-- /?

. ?'J

fill-,.:rl
~v

"

"

,f

5kfL"

4~

'

/''e'J.,t/

e-.~

~4

~,,/').,.~

~'/-

tI-/~ ~-

~-,

--.........

"v--

q ....

ytJ ~.

cUP cd~

~J

-e~ ~~
~ ~( 5;1

~._

~'-..o"/~

Jb~,
</VI

./p&;

-',
~~

~/~

~-"<

-It; ~"

c7/::':~

# .fl~-RL6_a~~\

(~JI ~ #~

~.?C~

I~k/?J,

~0~
/11

~~
;

,'-zI-

JkA'

,h

-kd

~LeP

9 --;,

~--6;~

~.

@'~

--vtgc.-

~d

!1
.

;.

,,<I

~~~

~<~
C

,
~

c;.

,. ~'(f(~"
: ~

C/l..f-.)

I
--.
,\.?~"<'~

C/~..;_

\&</~4r'

. ~;
n,h0-t:/0'

--..
/)'

~f'.~

;,~
~

P;L7-, ~,~~"...

~.

~&!'~

1"(//7,1

~ ~~

-' o.6!/~

,L-? j

Vry/&.L4--&".y4,

'~~<-Z"""S""J

I,

.V~="

,g..-(/~,

-t/.w) ,
;

:;

~'~/1

J,'A~"

i/

,-fa

iA':L.

~.~

~~

.~

V"1"'iL,'-e~

~A~~

.'

-'"N

d ~ #-?LY

u~

''1/'

(.u-r-.,z-".;;

Ih

f,'ed

-lP-v-. ~

~--&6~./zP

'I

Ju~

,jI/~

--h

</~

/'~

~"7

~g~

vu4/ /evi ~
" j.{/,v.kL

.~

iv~-""~.f

~~1

"~

<V~

~~_

;'vz-r./J.,y~

9, II

~
pd2

'~~._
cff

LC~

,y,A/c{i',dcfz'

Aye~

'-7'
.4' ~~

~~

C4g~6

v;

.~

U/~~

--i:.~~) -;;;/ldi--t1~

'~l

~~L4
01pD

~~~~~

I E.O.

..

13526, section 1.4(c) I

I E.O.

13526, section 1.4(c)

.,~------------------------------------------------------------~
j:

I E.O.

II

135~6,section 1.4(c)

tP i/S"k.(

~.

I
F7:,;e

/'1/-~

30;v,;

~-J-"Th

"""YI

.,A,/q;:r""G'

V- ~/'~

7'

cL.& ~

,tv'

,c'-r

'2.....

~ '*~.~.~ ~ C~~~

sk.://

f~~

C~-L-~

(..Q~~~~-

~).
!~-<-'h

U/'"~

~~./'~:""Y'

~~~

~~

-~~'

::

,~<,c?' ~

Ca:-~

c-vQ

c~

lhcrc.~~t

'~f.

, !

~~

V>;

JJ

';~~;~r--

~4-VV<'
~~ ~.~ /;/~~'?:f_~/
4~

c>

,~

i.-~

.e;j. P /3/

/4~'v~/.?

,\.n

.-4- ,'?/ -

,f~?~'

~,~.:r

1/::6-

~~Z;.

:.4rpP

~r.f.,

fz>

c.~~

,\-'1

fi/~.

'f' '1 /

(v~"e~,

~=~<

*~':"'I

fc-L.f

h.:0J

.-UJ-

uf

~-&~('7

~4!.

.--;;--'T4.5i-e.

/'"5'
:

r-

-It> ~

<'"

;;
Ii

~~

h',

~!

7[

i;
i'
: :

7e-<Z-J1

5;f,/;

~~)

,~~~,ec(,~

rz{j& -

~J

b'l.

tf!t~4

C~/

~~~-~
,7'

~~~~~
;

G', ~

r-"i

~(.'(?i-

uL;;..,ce; kyUf4

J},

'-I /~y/

,'n

l-

~,.f ~

1 ~

P~)l; !CJ"d ~

--

~?-..z;.--#,

<7~

.V~~~

-frv>f

.{,. 5',

~~

~~4p

L, /~~

..(2.~

~~~

~~.~~.

,!...

~ti/~7

i!

..

l{

/1~
ir
/"{.

A-r,'

~'>a~~

,~-f',/6t-~-~""'-.'
5' V~'l-,

J~/

d-.4---C(

d.R.~

'j

l'h

-ee/ d- ~ A.}?

('~~

~~

1_

~L,,~~

;
I
j

.J tJ

~~~~4-

....
-r-

z:y-"~

U/ZZ/?

,/?-'vV~/

~~

~~.:;<,u--.;u,.

qI

->:4,'<:; ,-

f'v- /1.."7

,-

~~_

./h..-!/~/; ''''6/ fir

:r~
~

~ .;e J

,o-<-~"t/

.f

~Z:;~4.

p:T

~-;,
,~~

~~-I

~...e.~v4-c;"?? ~

~~+
>'<//1/1

,~"""/~~.?

h~~
,)'

..
0'- ,~/.-Y/~<'-F-

h0! ~4-2t;;iA/4" ~!4'?/~.

;~

,~

J4,"4'

-r-c;r

d...,.?

LA3 '-

,-?~u,";z.._

a:r-4~--e:~-L-C<h

u~

,-?:::/ ,A-ld ;4Ck:?~

i,<ctN.~

;~(2

V~~~~

.4-c:2.. /

,4 ,~

'~.:<~~

;::ad
ClN'-<

,4~/ax-

(~,~(

o--t1&~ ~~

LA/("

,~d~/'

~
i.,1/",;"

.~-.:':hd-~~
?-f//1;'P' CJRt/~

1(1

1F#e~

?~~!Ao.

/.J.~. ~!3'

'-/'>1/~~:

tt~~

tf'~'
,:j,c,d.,'s.'

~~

c:~-,,*,6.:.~

.c~

~vfi//f'v1.1

4 ;~~

_~ ~.::6.-~~/

/~~/

~~

kt'~

\.-r

~~(

~ .s' i/~,,",-"'"

~tf5

!&-'-<C<-";

:3&;,1-

.:h-..

~/

k~

~6

c.-~/'4::J,,7Jvf

-: e /

--t&Af' d- 4

Pt!> i4'/

~-'-<!'j~:'"

3i."~-1

//~

c#~)3",>-

'0.

~I

A. ~ I

~7'

~Ao~e'.,

! ;

cA/~

V>--

-I-

~.
~

5<:-'Vi~fr1"~

,i-:-1

-=>JJ..iZ-z..,p

~~~c

I ~~

---

;-

~--...,-r~(i'l(~
(~

,40

Ph

'~":A.

4w-qf

,,7V\

V'-'? t/'1

(I~

ti;tt'

)"')j

-fr)

,#

~jol"'r:
~-r-

/ /)t.c-'Z

~,/'"'-fLc.e~~,

'/1

(n

"I !4r-

,h

~vo6".

f..c~

c; <-<./?7-;J?

-h

"'rM"I!-R~~c./

Ja.-'-jf2-...

------p'''~

q::g/s

cT
\ .-{~I

o p-?->

5 <c:v::1-

.
.~

/0 5",(1,

'P"".7~
t?/ 17

PL / ,~~

I.

h'~
:-'"1/
: :

~i

A&
~

-~

'f'

~/~~/

_)

--~

/~

vi k

t-~.

')V.tV-

'j::-

d~

-s t: ~

~c.r

Y()V.f~

r.lJ?~

L-cr~,,-u~~~
- ~~~
~~z...z...-:,

~
k

cA~

r~

petZ-r
/AA!...

Z -

1/.4'-/~

;'/-.

V./i?-

~4r

U- rC

I ~.i'

A-j-,q.>

c-v>~~4~_
~~

A~
i ~/'

~VZ;.~.

hv~~.

~d'\-7 w L

yo~

~c/?v,

~,~t>.t:r~

ft~ -~'k~;/-

y tT~~~#

'dJ~)

l~tfo~
y..

C< ~.~

~/<.R;

~.

ct::;.

ZU/j"'Z-

~~t:'

".

(), ~

~,y<~Cy&fo

d'~

~-'V~4 ,- ~~

er-:

~~~

,1

V ;;

r .;-

.f"'--?d?

A-8.

<"v?,

i :

0'-C ,-h

1~c;t244, ~
Q-7~~1'

"-/

/~~/~

(O'U-'JR% ,/'.1P/- 'u~

~.ve..~,!/v

'7 UJ3i--/-H
}Ji<l! <; ~

/--:}U{~

d1

ih

fi~

~:---

(iA-'"f!

'

~ -/rtir.-U:>

5";,., &--r~

/;.-z ~--4('

~
'<

-ff~

c'c~ff!--r

i/?--&~~

..v--d~/C/c..e.,;-(.

','

~nc-.;-//.A

/f r, -' ~."7

S,~

",i~"'4-~)

-.fo~k~~

)""~~~ c4~A~~/.4
uJ

~>-&J~rt-<--

</5

6-

.e:>

10

fI'~r1J- 4~

~~,~?

----

.--------~---.:.

~f)",'Au~~.

~
.W

~-7

(5'
"'2.--

/U./~~

~.4~

4..:r ~

r1a'''"v>~Q- e:

~'? '-

~a?

{/~..e.~-&:6;-

~w..4Cl~

/J-.,

u.rrJ

f;Krv..AJ6-0_"

~,Yo

~_
Pr'I-"

~~~.U)~
cl

~/f-

(.n ,/1ec..:6-

7M

-&e,

4~

'-'1'/-'/"/

~~

~krv
~~-'>(

iMOC(/c7O//

o~~~
for~

11

.~

,;JE~z~,~

-h/~

'ddP/

",&,

'~'/I

&J~

~(J?-C~

~'4

j':>"~

? C/l

..

(.,.!o

-'~ 7"e>Z

2 (.

c~-..v~-vf'

01;:;'-'>9--

;:

..fo

~yW?

.,....-th~

rr

7'~-..-h-.,

c.(..z;.-t~~ ~

~.~

.;- e..~~.L--e; ~~_-

; :;e~~?
j

ev-e'7-1

~;r~r

U~~~

C4.-ae~

.~,,..a?~0-~~

-fo /)., <J7A

.~--v2-,e--4::h~

C.-v?

r-=: .~

v .;

~e.,z...:U~

-fo

~/,,'.4..:.. ~.7

.(:'-.(2.

->

~~~r

~b:-?2:-~

~~.e

~..,r(

rh

''-''~

~"\

rs-r; ,.~ . ~.;.e~

;,.Aa

~~

ft~~

~~
'; c:.~-"

~c.6u.~

~,6-~

cT'P-4

~d

..
Jw''6

,~-e"l9

~~

( 'f:'- ,:--+- ~~h

~/v~

~c.,-<-ij.
,;4:;

7()vk~'

,~./ry
.~

~~

c&~-1 .~~

.4_~~

~~~~~4C<~~~~

7" f-

I)'

.~
~-

".u;~-4ft'

>

..e'Ji-,

rt ~

~"G-~?8'"

i~J?~-

.f~4

1rc>

a~

12

?sc-r
~

~.--v-e"",-

-J.4-e' ~

-~

t ~~~ ~~

#-71 h

ch~_

~~~

.~

dt/~

.A~

ei'Y'i
'-------'--ctt1-0'I<P

/~//,//Y[~

~_

Zb2J'
.-.t::;f'.J

~~~",:zt/

Y'-/-r-&/1??~

tt-cI'-~

-leL:-

.~~t.&1 4'-~4

{7~/.~1-v(/\4''1

c~

dc~0

~~7

_.-a~

fr, A-cf d~.,

~~

Cf

<fi~

ck,4

z-<Zf!

A4/

C""-

~i

d~'7-;:f

.~-C'/?
~

fu/~

;.i-.

-- .~~-yf

? ~---

;5-v~4

cv-e.,.'

~j

,~~A./'U?C--0/,;;-:t!b

</ ~

/)? 0

-------?v.::M'h;;

~~

iQ~~'..:---..d~ _0

~*""

fvr~/

4~

dJ.,

<P~~~~~,

J2&.....g~~.6~.:.

.h

~~Ac~/:G__

~-~

"A_4~;S;; ~~

1),~%f

~~

~~""~7

/h-or

~~

i .~~

(,t2_~L_~_'j

~~~~~

~'i

\-Ie

~-cf

G-.a-~?",_

/-fr?wt-<rur-r .- ~u-d

,j_4al~

'Y~

~~
fi'vtfL

~--4~~

~~_'P

C?~-

jJ /f-Y

,/h-vt'o/

./W.A-)

Tc:7'~/0("

CQ~

t.-/ q
d .~

41(>
~

{~..-6

;OJ?
Ih

/~

--c.--:::'
07

~~J'73',;.e~-,

,'-'~4
~

ffd~-

Cd<'-":"7

?'<../.

-J-1

..fd..4>E

c~

?C4> ~~

\.-h" /(

~.~~~

d~

a~,')-.J2

~4...,.

_),;/

0>:'1

c"h-"j1J

1i.J-

d c.&"~

V~

.4/ ~ij/,~.

~-YJ!.-;

/-..d-z-c-/....

S'4,z.-~

(~(/

~....;

vS

I-

I k,.,k..e

c<~

?~~

S.,t_

'~~

..

13

.-4~..
~~'

v-e-.~~;z:i.\/-> .,.,

;:;;a k
;

~~

cT

-kr-~.

v-r

C-V~e~~_

3-~~7 ~

f;/

-fr /d LtJl
./'TU(

/;/1

"
'-V~r"

~~r~ ....vr'/\-I&

~A/"'~Vl'

- Y4.
,

'

-~a~

;0-4. .../,>'~

A-i'.'

X'0~"'e:~

)4~

L/~~'

ITY'

~~_ -Ih/ /.24~

/1

c>.--c-r ~,(

2$t,.VVi-4;'

'2'!: fr~

Ihc~

/'y-..<.;.,.;y

<h ~';Yf

U/z,~;C:'
,

)".<7Pr./Jt

q4~

.~
~./'rQ

r4~'-"-)
fley..e:

#~",
..
,~
9'~p

~/I,-f'

k' ~

(~'-e

~'7; #cf-l

-d;~
(A~,~)

i.dvWJ:M'4?V

e/-~~I;;r,-r-=--

14

..-~

!7f;-~~~'~'

G.t~

('-4~'A~)

y~

(.L~.-L~~

~4t

f~/~

Oe~V'7

(J~

.~ ?&~

!7' ~,,~~/

~~

~~

)t-u!.~v-cf

C'~
~

- $~

-(/-::~~-

~ T-C'<d' t; ~fZ-,2rve--y

~-<.P

-MJ ~~~.~

h-:,Ir-A ~

"4:-1 ~~,

f'~'$/~tP
A-j{'
VJfIL~~

/'1~~
V>1

9'0 s .

..ea~

.:?"t(

/Y!<?,Jto.r

U/~-

f'c.r/"~.::a~ .~~

;P-..P<?~

~..4~

c;

~-:a~~\

M>A-t

-44~L/

qp:.~;z1.;,:"",

r"",vd..,i~

~~~-

'F~~

fl.g,;

~_~-c-

~~.

r
c>=iJ{
-

i-S

~
~

~~

~:r

~~~f

'--ve/ ,.
~

,~~ZA.-

,h;.~~

~.
1/-

~~'rl...c--~.

-~~~'(/

z..c-f

.L~

~J

A:

..--t'~

IV!

7~

~~~Y

?
c&""

'~~r-<f/

~~

&t/'-"'-:;)

~~>c_~~
v

,'!-t ,~

<..
dl~?

i(

/7

JC~

h~~'r

15

~--<.P

_----==~
,-0

'7'r'\-tf.~~\.4-fle-C:A?-.~.ft:;,

~";v"5

~k,~~E

/~,~.~

,~"'_

c::4r'~~.

-------(zr'o

.
&.2.&)

. ;

tl

~~y~

0n..i:t':r~
j:

.
i

: :
:

;
: i

. j

"--- ...

j,

~~ ..z

~c;,l

~,

~-~

.i-c;
~

~.

~<3__
e-s/~L4
~~

y'

c.~~

qS

~~,~

-fr. .~-,~k"
c.~(
,~

~
~

~~

II?LR/

t1'-"~)4-