FINAL EPA CLEAN POWER PLAN RELAXES CARBON LIMITS,

EXTENDS TIMELINE FOR COMPLIANCE

Electric Cooperative Member-Consumers Face Higher Costs, Reliability Concerns

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Aug. 4, 2015

Contact: Geoff Oldfather, Communications and Public Relations Manager
(520) 586-5465, C: (520) 444-3473. goldfather@ssw.coop
Visit our website at www.azgt.coop
Benson Almost half a million rural electric cooperative member-consumers in Arizona,
California, and New Mexico will be affected by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agencys
(EPA) Clean Power Plan (CPP) final rule, and the impacts could include everything from rate hikes
to issues of reliability.
The final rule announced this week differs substantially from the EPAs original proposal made in
June 2014. The final rule relaxes both the interim and final carbon emissions goals and provides
an additional two years to move toward compliance of the interim goal.
The CPP final rule requires Arizonas coal plants to reduce CO2 emissions to an average of 1,173
lbs/MWh between 2022 and 2030 the interim goal. The previous interim goal of 735 lbs/MWh
was much stricter and would have been required to start in 2020. The CPP also requires a final
limit of 1,031 lbs/MWh by 2030, a reduction of 29 percent. The previous final goal of 702
lbs/MWh was a 52 percent reduction, and Arizonas electric utilities have been unanimous in
saying it couldnt be met.
The revised goals are substantial revisions from the original plan that show the EPA took into
account our assertion that the original goals were simply unachievable, said Patrick Ledger,
Arizonas G&T Cooperatives (AzGT) CEO.
We have already made substantial investments in reducing emissions and will be investing more
than $32 million to meet the EPAs regional haze requirements by converting one of our two coal
units to natural gas a major step that in itself shows our commitment to reducing our reliance on
coal generation, Ledger said.

Http://azgt/sites/azgt/pr/Managed Documents/News Releases/EPACPP.docx

Aug. 4, 2015
Page 2

The extension of the timeline for compliance with the interim goal from 2020 to 2022 not only
provides utilities with more time to achieve compliance, it gives the Arizona Department of
Environmental Quality (ADEQ) more flexibility in how it implements reductions in the interim
period before 2030. But the final rule also establishes prescriptive requirements that ADEQ must
meet in its part of the process, called the State Implementation Plan (SIP).
Ledger said it still remains to be seen how the new goals can be met and that a detailed analysis of
the new plan and its complicated verification provisions is being conducted. He cautioned there
are still challenges, including:
Higher rates for consumers as the CO2 emissions requirements are met or more costly
renewable energy resources are brought on-line
Lack of good regulatory fit with the multi-layer cooperative model
Concerns about electric reliability
The possibility of AzGT seeking bankruptcy protection from $255 million in stranded debt
debt still owed on the Apache Generating Station and other facilities. Most of that debt
is owed to the Rural Utilities Service (RUS), itself a government agency funded by the
taxpayers.
Ledger said the cooperatives want to express appreciation to members of the Arizona
Congressional delegation and state legislators who supported them, as well as member-consumers,
employees, community leaders and others who generated postcards, emails and phone calls
backing AzGTs alternative plan.
We are humbled and heartened by the tens of thousands of people who are supporting us, Ledger
said
NEXT STEPS
The cooperatives will be meeting with local officials, key stakeholders, other utilities,
lawmakers, and ADEQ officials to discuss the SIP process as ADEQ analyzes the final rule and
how it will be integrated into the SIP.
About Arizonas G&T Cooperatives
Arizona Electric Power Cooperative (AEPCO), Southwest Transmission Cooperative
(SWTC) and Sierra Southwest Cooperative Services collectively make up AzGT.
AEPCO owns and operates the 605 (combined gross) megawatt Apache Generating Station
in Cochise, Arizona, east of Benson.
SWTC owns and maintains more than 622 miles of transmission lines and 27 substations
that transmit wholesale power from the Apache Generating Station to six Member
Distribution Cooperatives in southern Arizona, northwestern Arizona, and California.
Combined, the Distribution Cooperatives that receive AEPCOs wholesale power serve
more than 150,000 meters representing more than 350,000 individual residential,
commercial, agricultural and industrial customers.

Http://azgt/sites/azgt/pr/Managed Documents/News Releases/EPACPP.docx

Aug. 4, 2015
Page 3

The Class A Member Cooperatives that receive wholesale power from AEPCO include:
o Sulphur Springs Valley Electric Cooperative in Willcox,
o Duncan Valley Electric Cooperative in Duncan,
o Graham County Electric Cooperative in Pima,
o Trico Electric Cooperative in Marana,
o Mohave Electric Cooperative in Bullhead City,
o And the California member, Anza Electric Cooperative in Anza.
These member cooperatives own the AzGT and by extension, the G&T Cooperatives are
owned by their members, the people at the end of the line who use the power.
These cooperatives also borrow from RUS, a federal agency.

About Arizonas electric cooperative member-consumers

The G&Ts and their member cooperatives are not-for-profit utilities that are owned by the
people they serve, most of whom live in rural areas.
These cooperatives depend on fewer consumer-members to share their costs than for-profit
utilities.
On average, one third of these consumer-members live at or below the federal poverty
level.
Cooperative consumer-members spend a higher percentage of their income on electricity
than customers of for-profit utilities.
Electric cooperatives provide much-needed, highly-skilled jobs for their communities.

Http://azgt/sites/azgt/pr/Managed Documents/News Releases/EPACPP.docx