Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
BOUNDARIES
OF THE SOUL
The Practice of Jung's Psychology
of
that
/W^
'3.
Uf^
^^
BOUNDARIES
OF THE SOUL
^^-
JUNE SINGER
ANCHOR BOOKS
ANCHOR PRESS DOUBLEDAY
GARDEN CITY, NEW YORK
BY
PERMISSION
OF
CO.,
LTD.
COPYRIGHT
1972 BY JUNE K. SINGER
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AIMERICA
Heraclitus
am
style; to
final
am
copy; and to
grateful to
my
analysands,
who
me to
my own
allowed
understanding.
June Singer
Chicago, ig72
2011
http://www.archive.org/details/boundariesofsoulOOsing
CONTENTS
xi
Introduction
1
37
From
83
Individuation:
Associations to Archetypes
97
Whole
7
121
157
179
209
11
Understanding
32
Dreaming the
ination
Our Dreams
Dream Onward:
229
271
303
Active Imag333
contents
x
13
knowable
14
We Were
Born Dying
Notes
List of
367
409
435
Works Cited
447
Index
453
471
INTRODUCTION
life
and the
Too
often
it diflBcult
it
tween the rationalistic-academic way of life or the anticamp. Jung's greatness is in that he saw both of
these as aspects of the same realit}', as polar opposites on a
intellectual
single axis. The challenge has been put to me to describe howJung came to his position, and to explain how Jung's concepts
have been integrated into my work as an analytical psychologist.
One
of the
comments
heard
when
I first
began attending
'Tou cannot
really
and
live
You have
them
to assimilate
acti\ely.''
While
)
1
XU
INTRODUCTION
have come to agree that the most direct way of doing this is
through a guided tour, that is to say, through the analytic
process, I am convinced that this is not the only way. And it
is of course fortunate that it is not the only way, for Jung's
teachings ha\'e
much
last tliird of
still less
than
five
hundred members
is
in
of
time,
own
T
i
._
More
^
^
demand
for Tung
dents have
come
across references to
in their readings in
Jung
philosophy or personality psychology, or in the works of such
men as Tillich or Fromm or RoUo May, or Buber, Mircea
Eliade or Claude L6vi-Strauss, Alan Watts or Aldous Huxley,
Hesse or Freudmen who have read Jung or known Jung, and
who have never been the same afterward. Remarks these men
have made, taking issue with Jung, never quite resolving their
differences with him, leave their readers \^ith the misty awareness that Jung had the capacity to touch something essential
in the human soul which needs to be touched or needs to be
healed, in order to be
made whole.
he
left his
many
of
tlie
great
'
^
j
^
I
^
i
'
INTRODUCTION
Xlll
down
as too
much
fact that
he himself was
The
students
among
these peo-
and more
at the universities
in tlie de-
One
Works
tions of papers
and
lectures,
and
isolated essays
time.
may be
Still
have been
much
longer
Jungiana.
Much
lands and by
many
many
human beingsliving
conscious. It
is
in
theoretical
ap-
therapists
and
vitality of
periences from which his theories were generalized. Such writings often lack a real understanding of the struggles of think-
is
which
fails
who
to offer sustenance
XIV
INTRODUCTION
it
surfeits
them with
things
and
all
of this to give
is
man
concerning
may be called
which all men ex-,
the "inner
life.''
This
is
tliat
part of life
it
is
self-
Jung did share shortly before his death with his collaborator,
longtime assistant, and trusted friend, Aniela Jaff6. While he
wrote
much
of the
material was
bears his unique imprint. It was not the product of his isolation
with anotlier
'liis
own" unmust
it.
The
passage follows:
INTRODUCTION
X\'
rhizome.
Its
true
life
is
me
invisible,
on
hidden
in
the rhizome.
its
The
summer.
Then
we
it
withers
away an ephemeral
apparition, ^^'hen
think
civilizations,
we
flux.
The rhizome
What we
see
is
remains.^
much
in the con-
what
it
is,
The bloom
or to be
more
accurate,
of existential psychology
and
all
of one's
is
and
all
plined
partner
to
thinking provides.
the
emotional
ex-perience
that
rational
INTRODUCTION
X\d
mechanisms
are so al-
if
world
that world
of the plant
is all
We forget that
it
But
just
it
relatively adequately
has not been necesJung or for Jungians to dwell overlong upon grounds
that have been competently tended by others. Therefore, at
its
metliods,
it
sary for
way and
stress
my
approach,
I will
follow
meaning
have found that this is what many young people are looking for, to round out the one-sided views of life they are fed
on most campuses, in most churches, and elsewhere. I have
found this out in my own analytic practice, where I listen to
the concerns of undergraduate and graduate students, proI
INTRODUCTION
fessors,
XVll
who have
turned their
me
to Jung,
life.
proceed
I will
much
as a therapist
must do with
man
I will
early
review
life.
a patient, that
were
and which determine to a large degree
his subsequent attitudes and activities.
Born in 1875 in Kesswil, Switzerland, Jung came to manhood just at the turn of the century. His interests had been
varied during his student years, but they divided naturally
between his philosophical, humanistic and rehgious concerns,
and his fascination with science. To the latter category belonged archaeology, the subject that most intrigued him. He
wrote in his autobiography. Memories, Dreams, Reflections^
that he was intensely interested in everything Egyptian and
Babylonian. As we know from his later writings and the course
of his life, this interest was not in the shards and stones so
much as it was in the mysteries that inspired ancient peoples
to tell and preserve their myths and legends about how the
world was created and the nature of the forces that animated it.
The autobiography reveals Jung's early awareness of two
quite distinct aspects of his own personality. Each one held
sway over its own sphere of interests, and each one had its
history, with particular reference to the patterns tliat
established in youth,
own
style of functioning.
exist in
many
when
the direc-
is
sci-
XMU
INTRODUCTION
this or that
hero of our secret life until there comes a time when we must
decide what role to assume, what may be possible and what
impossible in terms of our resources and limitations! Yet in
most of us the awareness of these ^'personahties in potentia'
is
v-agne
and
diffuse,
and
is
and resolved.
WTiat was unusual about Jung's "two personaHties'' was
that from early childhood he reflected upon them. Gradually
he came to know each one of them in its uniqueness and
watched the development of each from the standpoint of the
consciously thought through
o\\Ti
functioning
a\^*areness. It
is
from his
experiences
of
self-
been
first
stress
of the adult. It
he did not
in
it.
He
he tells of
dim awareness that
his
it
ill-
had
INTRODUCTION
XIX
early impressions
pointed."
He
when
room
window were
father's
phrases.
He
mag-
XX
INTRODUCTION
at
first
The
be named/' Jung
''not to
that
the marueaterr
dream he had
felt.
is
is
How
religion
and
The
analysand to
first
It is
much more
dream
is
that
it
gives
the analyst an impression which comes directly from the unconscious and
sires
is
on the part
not modified by any conscious wishes or deof the analysand. Presented as he is with the
INTRODUCTION
XXI
image that the analj^and puts forth, largely for his own conand with certain intentions to create an image,
the analyst wants to gain access to a view that takes him beyond this. Often, the patient brings an "initial dream" to the
first session or two, a dream which may lay open the whole
scious purposes
psychic process as
it
quently, or for a
dream of
an adjunct to
it,
the
fre-
as
some borderline
area of consciousness
many
from which
it
We
power in nature
and in men, who are seen as small fragments of the created
and creating world.
Jung had learned early in his childhood that reality had to
be discriminated in order that one could separate what could
be lived out and talked about, from what had to be reserved
and thought about. One ear had to be tuned to an outer
world, which might be parents or school or community, and
INTRODUCTION
XXll
the other to an inner world which has its own way of knowing
and growing, based on innate or spontaneously arising images
and on individual developmental patterns.
During his school years, the secret, introspective life remained important to Carl Jung. When he was a student,
much as it is today, independent thought and fantasy were
rarely encouraged in the classroom. The way to get along in
school was to accept what you had been taught without questioning it too much and to repeat what you had heard at
examination time. This was well and good for Jung when
it came to history and languages, because they did not really
deal with the direct experience of the learner. But when it
came to mathematics, specifically algebra, he could not accept
the concepts at all. He enjoyed his studies of flowers and fossils and animals, because these were observable, but he was
unable to say what numbers really were; he could not imagine
quantities that resulted from merely counting. When it then
came to algebra he was unable to recognize that different
letters amounted to the same thing; to him 'V and "b" had
to be different. He objected to rote learning; an idea was only
valid for him when he could discover it himself.
An unhappy incident for Jung, but a fortunate one for
posterity, occurred and temporarily resolved tlie academic
problem for the young scholar. One day Carl was given a
shove by another boy that knocked him off his feet and against
the curbstone, so tliat he almost lost consciousness and for
about a half hour afterward was a little dazed. He recalls
that at that moment the thought that he would now not have
to go to school any more flashed through his mind, and that
he remained lying there on the sidewalk somewhat longer
than was necessary contemplating the possibility. After receiving more than his share of solicitous attention from
maiden aunts and worried parents, he began to have fainting
spells from time to time, especially when he had to return to
school or when homework became particularly irksome. He
managed to stay away from school for months at a time, and
during these periods he happily engaged himself in pursuing
his
own
INTRODUCTION
XXIU
shaded pools, and the swamp near his home teeming with
tiny animals and plants. There was also his father's library
with books on the classics and philosophy which often absorbed him for hours. There were times when he busied himself making drawings of whatever amused or interested him,
or haunted his fantasies. Although much time passed in loafing, collecting, reading and playing, he was not altogether
happy. The vague feeling persisted that he was not really
living, but rather escaping from the challenges and excitement
of hfe.
One day
a shocking realization
epilepsy
He
ment had
him
recognized that
tlie
mo-
games and
return to his studies. Again and again fighting the growing
tendency to faint, he refused to give in, and within a few
weeks he was able to return to school. He writes, "I
never
suffered another attack, even there. The whole bag of tricks
was over and done with! That was when I leamed what a
arrived for
to put
away
his childish
neurosis v^s.''^
In
later life,
The
of
seeks
its
its
own
tendencies,
an
survival as
offspring: thoughts
its ''genius"
and
in the less
common
has
its
particular
or identifying character or
spirit,
embodied
as
''a
tutelary
spirit.''
INTRODUCTION
XXIV
by conscious
efforts of
when
the threshold of
it
forth.
This suggests the classic story of the genie (same root word)
streams out of the bottle when the stopper is released,
who
and performs for the individual his every secret wish. It may
be compared to the conduct of the neurotic who responds to
every impulse, until at last the consequences of his acts begin
to come dowTi upon his head and he cannot cope adequately
with them. It is then that he runs with his neurosis to the
him
bottle.
Carl Jung
managed
to get
function in other ways than those approved by his schoolmasters. It was often a struggle, however, and remained so
until
he learned
to
come
to terms with
God and
and
to secrets.
He
which aspect of personality was in the forefront of consciouswas never very far away. This dual experiencing
of reaht}' produced at times a rare richness of approach, at
other times a gloomy obscurantism, and sometimes confusion
and anxiety. This characteristic "di\dsible" quality of personality exists in varying degrees in ever\'one and is the basis
of many unconscious conflicts, as dynamic psychiatry has well
ness, the other
INTRODUCTION
XXV
gift
years.
He was
for
it
still
research,
fortable livelihood.
And
so, in
direction.
The
first
home
summer
knitting.
jumped up from
his
hands. "It was right beside me!" she cried out, and Jung,
INTRODUCTION
XXVI
rf
following her eyes, saw that the sturdy round table which had
now about
and was
straiglit
means something/'
When
incident later, he recalled that against his will he was impressed and annoyed with himself at not having anything to
say.
The next
INTRODUCTION
XXVU
many
When
he was never willing to say simply, "That is out of my province, I will not allow myself to be concemed with it or sidetracked by it." Rather, his attitude was, "I will try to understand it, but if I cannot, I will keep it always near me, and
hope that one day the meaning that is concealed in the mystery may be in some measure revealed.''
Perhaps something of the uneasy mood still pervaded the
atmosphere when, a few weeks later, Jung heard of certain
relatives who had been engaged in table-turning, and also
about a young medium in the group who was said to be producing some peculiar trance states during which she would
relay messages from spirits of departed persons. Jung immediately connected the strange manifestations that had so
recently occurred in his house with the conversations he was
hearing from members of his family about the fifteen-and-ahalf-year-old girl, S.W. Out of curiosity he began attending
the regular Saturday evening seances which were held by his
relatives. For about two years Jung followed these stances,
obsening instances of what purported to be communications
from the beyond, tapping noises from wall and table, and
some highly interesting verbal messages relating to what appeared to be a reconstruction of a long bygone past.
Toward the end of this time Jung was preparing for the
examinations which would conclude his formal medical education. He had not found the usual lectures and clinics in
psychiatry particularly interesting and so had put off until
last his preparations for the examination in that subject. In
those days psychiatry was held in contempt rather generally
by the medical profession. Insane asylums for the most part
were isolated in the country' and the doctors lived there with
the patients, remote from the rest of the world. Mental illness
was considered to be a hopeless and fatal disease, and the
INTRODUCTION
XXVlll
psychiatrist a fool to
less
cause. So,
want
effect that
further on,
tlie
became aware,
in
what he
called
from
No amount
of persuasion
from colleagues and friends could dissuade him from embarking upon the career that they all assured him would be a bypath to obscurit^^
He completed his examinations successfully and on December lo, 1900, took up his post as resident at Burgholzli, the
cantonal mental hospital of Zurich. There Jung's attitude took
on a quaht)^ of profound intention, consciousness, duty and
complete responsibility. He became committed to a stern regime within the walls of the hospital: studying, reading,
learning to make diagnoses, obsendng the patients, observing
his colleagues and reflecting again upon the S.W. notes he
his teacher or
had made during the two years in medical school. These notes,
which he had laid aside not knowing W'hat to make of them,
now took on new meaning in the perspective of a doctor oc-
INTRODUCTION
XXIX
when
the
di-
clearer
of consciousness in S.W.,
and
made
it
possible for
Through
him
and
view.
this,
it
what we perceive
image which
experience
I
is
experience;
psychic.
my
own
Even
words:
physical pain
sense impressionsfor
is
a psychic
all
that they
INTRODUCTION
XXX
force
upon
me
experience,
immediate
for
consciousness.
my
My own
my
falsifies
artificial
it
alone
is
immediate,
is
superlatively real.^
making these
discoveries for
the physicist
work which
Max
and presented
of 1900 that
summer
own
new
his
ideas
on
a long
made
physics science started from the beliefor should one say from
we could
in
least
.
INTRODUCTION
XXXI
come
,
the
first
any
scientific result.
quantum theory does not contain genuine subfeatures, it does not introduce the mind of the physia part of the atomic event. But it starts from the di-
Certainly
jective
cist as
and the
This division is arbitrary and historically a direct consequence of our scientific method; the use of the classical
concepts is finally a consequence of the general human way
.
of thinking.
But
this
is
and
in
is
man and
his
world took place: Sigmund Freud published his Interpretalion of Dreams, In this momentous volume, Freud published
the results of his years of study and inquiry into the meaning
of dreams, his own and those of his patients. One of his guiding principles was that the dream could not be studied prop-
erly apart
first
came
out.
He
had
making
consciousness.
But
all
laid the
it."^
their
all
book
The book,
aside, at
like
many
INTRODUCTION
XXXll
made order of the chaotic supply of mahe had gatliered during the previous year when he had
attended the seances. Jung began his dissertation with the
and, in the piocess,
terial
ture
up
rare
states
is,
He
identified
and defined
terms whose meanings had not yet been agreed upon by the
various authors: ''narcolepsy" (a tendency to fall asleep for
"letharg}'/'
"^autorruttisme
(activity in a trance
ambulatoire"
(automatic
He
which the subject is at one time aware of the external conditions sunounding him and able to communicate to those
in
And
lastly,
he
The
tions
is
Jung in
all
these condi-
set of psychiatric
who
syndromes.
He
i^ard
toward
its
INTRODUCTION
XXXlll
human
of the
common
of thinking patterns
Tliese Jung
named
The complexes
the images which
to the entire
human
man
men
much
And
it
was
the
species.
the archetypes.
so
come
to believe
and
my own
tried to
communicate was
distilled in
the
analytic experience.
INTRODUCTION
XXXIV
There
me
with
their
sonows and
moments
of understanding
also
some
joy.
Their
has,
my
students.
They have
listened
refine
my
the
me
to rethink
and
ap-
XXXV
INTRODUCTION
chotherapy,
am
necessarily representative of
is it
is
my own
is
analysts
so personal,
experience, as examples
AnaMical
Psy-
And yet, as
which are common
chology.
and commonality structures the human personThis constant and ever-changing interplay of the indi-
individuality
ality.
vidual psyche
for
and the
collective
self-
Self, as carried
on
ANALYST
AND
ANALYSAND
The
therapy, Reichian bio-energetics, the neoFreudian social psychologies, Rogerian client-centered therapy.
psychoanalytic
therapy,
vi^ay
to bliss
trols is cited as
on
earth.
Abandonment
of emotional con-
while the ability to gain control by the mind over the body,
including the autonomic nervous system, through bio-feedback
training
Many
is
which can be universally applied for the benemankind. Each new panacea is presented by its
creator in lucid and persuasive termsit is not unusual to see
on the dust jacket of the book ''X Therapy: The Cure for
Neurosis.'' Next month it will be Y therapy that is the cure,
and the following month, Z.
Wliy then should there be still another book about still
another approach to the problem of the human psyche, and
especially an approach which is not very current, not very
popular, and which does not promise a "cure'' to anybodymuch less to everybody? I refer to the work of the Swiss
psychiatrist Carl G. Jung, work which is a ''psychology^' only
health, a secret
fit
of
all
it
is
it
deals with
human
'
work from that of the founder of "psychoanalysis") includes and is subject to the discipline of the scientific method,
but it is not Umited to the traditional methodology of science.
It includes and is subject to the insights of religion, but is
his
some
but in
rect,
many
is
he
of his works
is
difficult
and
abstruse,
is
the
first
is
at his best in
clarity
plication.
The
m\h more
of a promise than
him the
And it is the
many who read Jung that wth each successive
w^hole new \dew of his meaning is revealed, so that
larges,
experience of
reading a
in
The meaning
psyche.
of Jung's life
its
impli-
Why
ment
are
when
is
adherents and
licity or prosehiiizing?
be taught in
on
Why
is
this
Jung
just
now beginning
Why
to
is
who
are willing to
process which
which
must
its
appeal
is
^Vhy
^er}^
difficult
premises upon
investment of time and energ\^, and the absence of the familunconditional guarantee of success?
iar
The problem
was
antici-
When we
find the
nothing
is
most
than astonishing.
less
book of pathology for a given disease, we may confidently assume that none of these remedies is particularly efficacious. So,
amounts
very
number
mind
is
of
them
leads with
those advocated in a
of present-day "psychologies"
to a confession of perplexity.
access to the
wonder
The
all
gradually borne in
The
difficulty of gaining
upon
us.
It
is
small
multiplied,
How much
first
from one
more
side
true this
is
fort}'
years after
Jung
life,
so that his
way
of looking at things
is
actually of
we
see it
we can
if
is
not so
much how
it
objectively
is,
as it
is
how
That which is
give up certain
prejudices
man changes himself. Jung, writing on ''AnalytiPsychology and Weltanschauung,'' illuminates his entire
changes, so a
cal
approach to the
human
psyche:
conclusions,
Weltanschauung
and with
to his
as
this
own
edification.
But
if
victions tell
he
will
shown
single individuals
itself
have desperately
the
human
personalit)'
resisted
it,
years
fifty
for to their
way
of
life
and not
ment
If science
mere
h an end
intellect. If art
in itself,
is
man's raison
an end
in itself,
then
its
The consequence
is
that peo-
become
tools
them.sehes.2
The
theories
inevitable conclusion
become
rationales
is
that the
for
many
psychological
psychotlierapies,
rationales
Thus
is
considered valuable by
one system the achievement of maturity might be the crowning goal, freedom from
for
symptoms for another, self-understanding for a third, or adjustment to the norms of societ}^, or realization of potential for
growth, or learning to accept responsibility, or reducing existential Angst, or simply ''being real," and so on ad infinitum.
on a
single
reduce
all
While
problem or
human
psychological
to a single explanation.
ills
may be many
Jung's psychology
things to
many
peo-
its
con-
own Weltanschauung^
his
own
his
"philosophy of
life," if
you
will, in
and
in their
own
time,
and
stances
which
born and the circum-
is
mentary approaches
subject of so
much
to the
human
man
as a unitary
that
and
total
some
that
man
is,
even
in direct opposition
others.
Jung has wisely said that if you are able to observe a quality
that is characteristic of a man, you may be quite certain that
somewhere in him the opposite is equally true. I believe that
the greatness of Jung rested in his ability to accept the paradox
as a fact of man's psychological being. And the great paradox
of Jung's work is that it is highly individual it depends very
much on
it,
it
who
conceived
drawn from the history of human consciousness and experience and thus is applicable to a wide spectrum of human
nature.
My
Some
no way
recast
them
Otliers insist
properly
ligion.
falls
others say
Still
a better life,
Some
formalized structure.
and
as
it
as
is
way
man
of educating a
for
cal psycholog}\''2
tempt to explain
Thus
it is
clear
why
it is
so difficult to at-
how
Jungian analysis
seems a more practical undertaking to write about Jungian analysis and how it works for
me. In such an undertaking it will be possible to discuss some
of Jung's basic principles, how he discovered them, and how
an understanding of what he has illuminated makes it possible
for the Jungian analyst, specifically this Jungian analyst, to
works.
On
it
function.
"Anima
me
them.
1
I could see that they had obvious psychological problems which required attention. But I could not see that I
because
personally
analy-
tic
came
way
to experi-
the interpreters
how
doesn't
somebody
plaining
I
how
ex-
never received a
satisfactory^
till
answer.
Many
"J^^^i^iis''
come
to a real appreciation."
began
to
have
my
doubts. It seemed
The "way
of indi\ddua-
read
before
more
realized that
man
with
At the end
full of
my own
my head crammed
come
to terms Vvith
I
would now
how
erature of the
Middle Ages,
its
Hebrew
and elsewhere. I was ready to illustrate and document all statements I would be asked to make. I appeared.
I was informed that there would be only one question for
Scriptures
this
examination, that
is,
The
"If
is
commentar}'.*'
Quieted by this thought, I had a momentary vision of something I had been doing the day before, taking a saihng lesson
on the Ziirichsee, the Lake of Zurich. It was as though the
unconscious had presented
me
at the right
moment
with an
10
Ziirichsee,
where you were going sooner or later. Or, you might bob
around indefinitely and get nowhere. Or a storm could come
up and you could be overturned and the whole project could
end in disaster. But begin the Process, guided by another who
has been through it himself and coped with the difficulties
and found ways to solve them, and it is all different. You
learn to take into account the structure of the boat
how
it
wind.
is
The boat
is
it
itself,
which you are situated and which are someYou learn about the winds, which are in\dsible and less predictable, and these correspond to those spiritual forces which seem to give direction to life without ever
showing themselves. In learning to sail you do not change
the current of the water nor do you have any effect on the
wind, but you learn to hoist your sail and turn it this way
and that to utilize the greater forces which surround you. By
understanding them, you become one with them, and in doing
realities of life in
what
predictable.
harmony
own
direction so long as
it
is
in
You may
still
^i
11
I
found that
this
was a question
ready in consciousness.
of awareness that
is
By
consciousness, I
mean
is al-
that level
My
relationship
between them
as
it
my
appears to me. It
is
clear
is
it
The psyche
consists of consciousness
lies
outside
field,
the un-
12
conscious, but the critical point
is
the exchange of energy between consciousness and the unconscious prodding the dynamic for growth and change. This
a natural
life in
into the
fall
unconscious.
It
with
is
this
in the direc-
end we
ness,
need
of senselessness.
Toward
this
of systematically drawing
The
analytic process
upon the
is
means
scious
sciousness; at the
essaty or desirable.
The
is
rarely
understood at the
is
the shift
ego as
its
How
tliis
shift of
its
own
and unwhich
center,
"self," in contradistinction to
it
the "ego."
means
in
The importance
it
establishes
analytical
work and
To
begin with, the attitude of the analyst toward his patient will
nc
I3
The
its
effect
new
pa-
dividuality
has
of
some crisis arose which tested all his abilities and resources
and still could not be dealt with in any satisfactory way. He
feels frustrated, hurt, or desperately alone in an alien or hostile
world. If he is young, he may feel blocked in achieving some
career goal; he knows he should be able to get beyond the
point where he is stuck, but he cannot. Or, if he is in the
second half of life, he may reflect upon himself and find that
for all his strivings he has had precious little satisfaction; life
has become empty, meaningless, boring. Success or failure are
alike to
him.
The
He
a sense of
him
all really
But
am
14
this principle, or that
that
we
it is a good thing
both in terms of our psychological
our way of dealing with the world.
constitution as well as
Too many
believe, or act as
of psychotherapy
to
is
if
smooth
off
differ-
demands
himself.
To be
"normal" means to
many
which he
finds
The
"How
a successful analysis.
lar
magazines,
Each
wTiter
is:
who
man
in their
own
image. In
woman/ be more
facilitator
like
desirable
push for
likely to
"self-master}^" or "im-
and
a Behavior
The danger
is
and consequently
an ego
stand
trip,
it is
and
precisely
what the
careful to avoid. It
is
analytic process as
under-
must go through a
undergo the experience
He must
I5
may be
The
must
and determine what he will deal with in
any given moment and what he will exclude. Othenvise the
analysis would never proceed very far, and surely it would
regarded as being of potential importance.
analyst
never terminate.
The
make
similar decisions,
but often for different reasons. Even at the very start, in that
fateful phone call in which a stranger informs the analyst
that he has learned of this analyst in this or that way and
that he would like to make an appointment to come in and
talk with him or to consider the possibility of undergoing
analysis or simply to discuss a certain problem. Obviously the
analyst will not be able to inteniew everyone who thinks he
might like to come in, and so there is a need to learn right
then whether this may be an individual with whom the analyst
may be able to work. A few questions can reveal much: How
it that the person on the phone has selected this analyst
and not another? Has he ever had any psychotherapy or
is
analysis? If so,
What
is
for
how
long?
requesting? Is he aware of
some
practical considerations?
possible.
Others
l6
and
starting off
i'
say,
in all directions:
who
is
of reality,
and
I \\dll
approach, with
its
of consciousness,
is
seriously question
requirements
going to
makes sense
tlie
me
ser\'e
to
it
to offer
he should bring
will
teU
It says
me
^^
I7
with a few
errors, or
how much
into.
note
this,
because as a therapist
this signals.
Some
will
w^nt
been"time
who
get lost, or
who
who push
They
had better
Sitting in
my
are
all
ahvays,
telling
me something
And as ther-
realize it or not.
office, I
hear a knock on
my
door. Is
Or
And
Or an
aggressive
it
timid,
didn't hear?
10
hear
ion. I
his
The door
it.
am
own
tagonize
to
me
is
good.'' I
him
that
if
am
it is my role to provide an
atmosphere of trust and freedom in which tlie new patient
will be helped to face hidden aspects of himself that he may
fear. I am to help open wide the doors that have long been
shut, the doors which have long kept out the dangerous and
stormy thoughts and feelings which he did not dare to meet
alone. Now I am to be fully present to him; and I must
get this fact across to him. It begins at the threshold of my
consulting room.
\Vhen our eyes meet for the first time, I pronounce his
name. He is an individual to me, I look squarely at him so
that I will see him as a person, and I let him see me. I introduce myself. I bring him into my office, my place as I have^
arranged it; a place which expresses me, my likes and dishkes,
my totems and talismans, my pictures and the great antique
roll-top desk that dominates the room.
One reason I prefer private practice to working in an insti-
tution
is
that here
It is a place of
makes
it
am
able to establish
my own
environment.
and
way outside
immediacy. I belie\'e that the unconscious does not perform well before an audience. Perception
of it becomes contaminated with all sorts of cultural values
and needs for approval. This is what I try to minimize in
my way of being-with a patient, and I can do it less selfconsciously if I know that in my work I am not answerable
to anyone except to tlie person ^^il0 sits with me, and to
of
its
pressures
its
myself.
I am not unaware of the value of cross-fertilization that
comes when one works with other professionals. In a group
IQ
The
am
not
sure.
is
me
my
my own
self-concept.
my own
That
reser\^es for
personal
life
and
and where it
which we are mutually engaged.
The initial session begins, and I have been
with
it
task in
know how
as receptive as
have come
way: the patient's general appearance indicating his selfimage, his voice and posture and his walk. He decides which
I
my
of the chairs in
for
me
to
my
make the
office
he
perhaps he waits
matters
these
material
One
is
a primary consideration.
approach
is
the ana-
20
openness about himself and his own reactions. His involvement in the process is activehe is not merely an observer, nor even a participant-obsewer, but he is an active
partner in a mutual endeavor. Receptivity to the patient continuesas he is now in this moment and to all that he brings
to recount as he discusses the details of the situation which
has brought him to therapy. The analyst Hstens attentively
so that he may understand what the patient is saying and
hear the feeling behind the words. He will be continually
checking with the patient to make sure he is getting the message intended. As he listens he will be evaluating the nature
of the problem and the patient's motivations and capacity
lyst's
for carrying
Up
on therapy or
to this point
analysis.
and
"analysis"
more
or less
interchangeably. "Therapy/' an abbreviated form of "psychotherapy," refers to "the use of any psychological technique
for the treatment of mental disorder or maladjustment" per-
specific
on
The
terial to
is
in
upon a
it
is
parative religions
and other
fields
and the
ability of the
analysand to deal
21
is/'
At
first
or for
in that spirit.
what
newly emerged
what he
will
do spontaneously with
Two
its
important to
sessions.
One
let
first
in the analysis,
why he
is
say.
come
The
his understanding
to analysis:
when he
room and
him
that
needs
to
be discussed
is
is
the
identified with
his
22
means
which has
and
stays
"underground" to
Thus
in
come
and
some ways the
all
intents
scious attitudes.
the analysand
first
dream
is
not
to be a significant one,
Gina, a young
woman
of
Roman
five
months pregnant by the first man with whom she had had
sexual relations. He had no intention of marrying her. She
was the sort of woman who seemed ideally suited for the
role of wife and mother, but circumstances were against it.
t
je
23
and she blamed her own impetuousness for not ha\dng avoided
the pregnancy. Yet she felt that she was unwilling to compound her guilt by adding murder to her crime of carelessness.
She would have the child, and she would have to find an
attitude toward it that would be consistent with what she
understood as the meaning of her hfe. This did not permit
the negation of a life for which she was responsible, her firstbom. Gina brought the following dream to the first analytic
session: J was thinking about coming to you, I had a guide.
She said you do all sorts of weird things. She said you told
one lady to throw her car into the water. She said you told
another lady to jump into the cold icy water of the lake and
swim across.
This dream contained Gina's fears of the analytic process.
The whole thing was mysterious to her. She expected to have
demands made which would be extremely difficult for her to
meet. In the course of our discussion of the dream I asked
her what a car meant to her. Her car was her most valuable
possession; she had worked very hard to pay for it. It was
When
had sexual
treasure
it
bound up
(her sexuality)
therefore
would have
be
in her ha\ing
sacrificed. All
Her
sence of
is
as
feel
my
sensitivit}^ to
dream represented
though all my
nothing for anyone,
And
still
miss
to
is
24
be made, the
risk will
The
initial
image of a stem
upon
whom
these expectations
had
reflections of her
own
tions
to
were
herself; they
relationships.
new and
intense relationship.
is
trans-
Thus we
all
I
want
to return to the
first
trates
how
Gina because it
dream, which illus-
session with
initial
entered into this case in an especially dramatic way. This concerned the attitude of the analyst to the patient, an attitude
which, like that of transference, has a strong unconscious asis the term used to describe the
unconscious analyst-analysand relationship as experienced sub-
pect. Countertransference
jectively
from the
moment
reac-
her long straight brown hair, her dark eyes with the mod
glasses, reminded me with excruciating sharpness of my only
daughter who had died just a few months before. My daughter
child,
and
my hopes
Now Gina's
so
2$
my own
unconscious.
my
cases
first
under supervision.
was, like
all
analysis
neophytes, ex-
become
when
to \^^ork \^ith
tended
if I
acted out of
my
The
it all
the elements
which are necessary both to produce a neurosis and to transform the neurosis into a constructi^ely functioning element.
If I, as analyst, impose my concepts of the direction into
which the analysis should go and what the outcome should
am
be, I
My
psyche.
tiie
that
analysis with
I
my own
problems.
constantiy need to be
my own
a\\'are
And
of
it is
my own
needs and
biases.
of transference
and countertransference
26
in the ps}'cholog>^ of Jung are given a position of great importance in the analytic process. In this, analyiical psychologists are in full
most
all
phenomenon
of transference,
al-
round the
fundamental
The
way.'''^
by the
sis off
all
(I
clearly
don't believe
it is
analyst sitting
aims at estabhshing
very
as far as pos-
an 'impersonal,'
also forms one of the defense
far, in fact)
self-protection
of the couch
is
evident,"
technique. ^^
on the same
le\'el.
sit
flexibility to
face
the
relationship.
to countertrans-
ference:
27
The
doctor
inclined to
is
demand
himself.ii
The
is
on the
to rely
material
is
we can
them
directly
come
into
see
we can
conscious notions.
my own
In
material
is
censor''
clarity.
it
did I
me some and
it, remarking
fudge to me. She says, ''See, what
you about drugs?'' I leave to walk out of the bird
I taste
tell
and
'
28
to stay in the
grab her
\^dtli
life is like a
big
apparent freedom,
but go too
is
ing sexually
He
was informed in
was held
in high regard.
In his analytic "confession'' he described his masturbatory
29
full of
unend-
all
abuse being heaped on him, or performed by him on other people. I listened to it all without
much comment, primarily interested in understanding what
sorts of scenes of sexual
it
meant
he had
my
side,
rela-
felt freer in
no blame from
These were
brief impersonal
homo-
sexual encounters.
My
me
as
in which
him
to convert the
he had learned back into its original context of something naturalto him that was sweet and delicious, like "regular fudge." But the old suspicion was not gone from him;
he felt that my acceptance of him could not be altogether
real, it must carry a moral judgment, perhaps referring to my
having questioned his sometime use of LSD or mescaline. He
associated me in his mind with tlie image of the criticizing
mother. In other words, he had projected that image onto
me. So even while consciously and rationally he saw me as
myself, on an unconscious level he saw mother and he transferred his feelings of fear and distrust of his mother to me.
Therefore, in the dream he tried to escape (and in reality
this preceded his attempt to flee from analysis because of the
tensions it produced), and then we were able to see what
it was that he was resisting. I was really his mother after
all, it appeared, and he saw any attempt on my part to hold
disgust
30
is
symptoms
rest
on
a base of conflict
between the
instinctive
3I
man and
nature of
society in
way was
left
open
development in
the future. In any case one would say that the neurosis
a purposive aspect, namely to lead
tion;
therefore
such time as
I
made
it
him out
it
had
out until
32
are,
of a
member
much,
or sexual impotence, or a
all
boils
down
to a truth
It
entrancing lover, the second entity was sacrificed the birthright for the
mess of pottage. For some this meant the deterof the dreams of youth, and sometimes
away un-
mysterious
this,
would
try
entit^^ that
by
gave
soul.''
their
Those people
own means
life its
zest
of an ancient
failing
Such
set
him
be an
illness, a
members
33
vitality,
like
the
the primitive in search of the wise one of the tribe to get back
Today, there are many self-proclaimed wise ones,
his soul.
becoming
lost,
is
the "soul"
as a travelers'
may come
if so,
it
will result in a
is
not
not *'make
it
when
is
The
for
analysand.
He
is
initiative to
is
is
a subtle matter,
when the
situation
34
for the
most
and by
is
carried
analysand
Analysis
I
on by the analysand,
from his unconscious as
daily living experience. Contrary
am
is
analysis, the
is
reminded of an
initial
hood.''
anal}i:ic process,
many and
the analysand
bilit}' those
35
hand
who
re-
or accepting
is
looking
him
when
become aware
him
feel rejected
by the
I,
person
feel
who
is
so disturbed
and
\^-ho
times do,
commit
it is
only that
this sin
capable of
were
be broken of
tliis
am
patient.
"How
hubris at
me and
from
learn
and
all costs,
to forget for a
Could
can this
functions so uncertainly
my wisdom? He has to
hope I am able to avoid
and
whether it
to account,
is
often won-
moment
if I
some-
could easily
that
am
fully
it!
as
36
and the
have
own way
his
of doing things,
The
native
may
his
He
What
could
the sessions.
There
is
on the part
of the patient
analyst. This
is
from one of
my
a fact that
may be
when
welcome
resistance
analysands.
that
break
down
To
this
she heartily
agreed,
ent standpoint."
COMPLEXES BY DAY
AND
DEMONS BY NIGHT
I
if
are
areas. I
understand
is
ponents.
One
is
foundation
is
and
is
some point
innate:
its
WTien the
that no
harm
is
done
your equilibrium
is
or, if
38
enough, and if you were totally unprepared for it, you may
be cut or bruised or broken, and the area may remain sensitive. Then every time you touch it, you will feel the hurt;
you
and
someone
will favor it
nevertheless,
analysis
hits
its
roots, I
am
likely
is
jolts
and bumps
and
which
tity.
quantity,
to
it,
is
The more
energic quantity,
life
make a
You may either
it
is
possible for
you
as
an
individual to
plex.
tions
how
produces. But
if,
as
unconscious then
y
it
becomes impossible
39
to achieve a sub-
were.
The bomb
is
still
component
scious
it
is
complex continues
not
now
so dangerous.
to
believe that
it
is
slips
errors
and bungled
actions,
he used
The word
40
on "Psychological Aspects
in his essay
type/'^
sion''
He
"Spirits
appear
of the
when
itself
in
Mother Arche-
complex of "possesa
belief
in
collective unconscious
spirits:
which
reality,
or
which seek to replace the inadequate attitude of a whole peopie by a new one. They are therefore either pathological fantasies or new but as yet unknown ideas. "^ Other complexes,
according to Jung, are ideas with which people identify themselves and their endeavors, hence the "saviour complex," the
"healer complex,'' and the "prophet complex," to name only
a few. Even the ego, according to Jung, might better be called
the "ego complex" as it is a specific self-concept with which
the individual identifies himself and which draws to itself
certain very specific ideas. A list of complexes could be extensive, for it would cover every type of feeling-toned idea
that tends to create a highly charged atmosphere of thought
or behavior.
life
of the individual.
4I
verely
this,
all sorts
of degrading
man
in
group
may have
went on she discovered that instant ecstasy is not necessarily followed by instant enlightenment. She wanted to find out what others had to say about
enlightenment. She began to read Jung, and discovered that
his way to a deeper understanding of the mysterious processes
42
offered a slow
a creation of substance.
After the ''easy way" did not work for Cecelia, she decided
to
come
into analysis
and submit
some
mean
w^riting poetry
was then
him
li\dng
it
seemed
as
of the hole
and she
alive,
bear.
Then
bride
comes
there
out.
is
is
is still
blood
She
is
very ugly
and she
is
all
is
little bit
over the
there.
sneezing.
Tte
Her
43
mother puts a fake fur dress and coat in brown and black
over her wedding dress,
Cecelia's dream expressed her feeling of the heavy and
threatening power that constantly opposed her conscious
wishes. The power was female and inexorable whatever you
did it could not be done away with. The power of the masculine element in her life was of little use against the dreadful
she-bear. Cecelia tried to help by getting a gun. She thought
that she could destroy the rough and cruel animal but, since
it was a part of her, she could not do so without jeopardizing
the totality of herself. Stuffing the bear down a hole was
symbolic of trying to get rid of some element in life that
could not be tolerated. In this case the she-bear image may
have referred on one level to the girl's mother, in her menacing aspect. But the mother-complex had over the years
drawn to it so many experiences and feelings and attitudes
that it was now well covered over, and the original image that
attracted these contents was no longer recognizable. A whole
complex of ideas relating to the terrible power. Mother, her
cruelty, and her blind-instinctive protectiveness of her young,
was represented by this brutal creature. The rebellious aspects of the girl, the runaway who attempted to deal with
the problem by avoidance, were symbolized by the men who
shot the bear while she was down in the hole.
The
lytic process of
is
the purpose seemed to be to demolish the destructive complex. Living with the
young man,
mother's wishes was a bloody business, and all the more when
we see how the young man's personality resembled in some
girl's weak and ineffectual father. In the end of the
dream the bride came out and was very ugly and sneezing.
ways the
The negative-mother-complex
associated with a
44
demand what
fore continued to
way.
The angry
it
needed in an unreasonable
own
personality
had
to
be given what
newed her
own
interest in painting
interests and skills. She reand her works were hung where
new
ing.
maternal.
Some may
and her
But I would not
tell her that. I cannot imagine that she would settle for that,
she who has fought the battle for deliverance from the terrible
say of her that she was using her art
mother.
Anyone
Dreams
will
have been
interpreted in the traditional psychoanalytic manner. Her difficulty in relating sexually to her young man could have been
seen in purely personal terms, rather than in terms of the
readily see that Cecelia's
devouring mother
who
dream could
and unable
easily
as
to progress
still
li\ing in a pregenital
beyond an
oral
dependency on
45
What
is
important
is
the dif-
em-
etiology
see the
But there
w^ere differences.
46
members
its
when
family,
Or when
must have
On
became
S.W. was,
as I
have
indicated, a
as events
any
girl
of
little
special effort
to require
47
if
sometimes
at the
Our
the belief that every event has a cause, believe that they have
as
if
exposes
The Psychopathology
of Everyday Life was instrumental in promoting the view that it could. Its influence has
been tremendously important in changing the course of edustition," in
Enlightenment that called for the elimination of the superstitious, the mystical, and the non-rational in the Western
intellectual tradition.
and half
and
felt
movement
and
in the table
48
around which they were
all
Those present, and among them the mediwere surprised by the clerical tone of the messages, which seemed to be "in character" with the old man.
piece together some of what must have taken place from
Jung's dissertation, based on his notes taken after returning
home from the seances.
He described the trance state, which he called "somnambulism," after his first observation in August 1899. He spoke
of the event as an "attack" and apparently regarded the whole
matter as the manifestation of a psychiatric illness. Whatever
else it might be, he did not feel free to conjecture at that
of her grandfather.
cal student,
We
time.
At the onset
of the attack,
pale, slowly
state of
WTien she
Then
she
known
as cata-
and
carried
at last
them
off
dramatic scenes full of passion and glo\\ing rhetoric. Sometimes she would even expound \nth great fluency in literary'
girl
49
of her background.
him
in their private
meet-
The
Only
and then at night, did she see terrifying
images of a demonic character.
Jung became convinced that S.W.'s visions had a realit}^ of
their o\mi, the nature of which he could only surmise. As the
weird experiences developed they seemed perfectly natural to
her, and she told him, "I do not know if what the spirits say
and teach me is true, nor do I know if they really are the
on
rare occasions,
people they
call
yond question.
naturally as
Fm
my
They must be
\^ish as
real."
Yet the
young girl who was seeing the apparitions was quite different
from the one who hved a normal unremarkable life in between
times. Jung saw that she w'as leading a "double life" \\ith two
personalities existing side by side or in succession, each continually striving for master}'.^
girl's
acti\ities in
her trance
automatic writing, glossolalia (speaking in strange incomprehensible tongues) and cr^-ptomnesia (the appearance
in consciousness of memory^ images which are not recognized
as such but which appear as original creations).
w^ere
50
scientific
happening.
He
He
also experi-
push
The movement
and continue even when
He
some
5I
S.W. produced other extravaganzas. One featured a frivNorth German accent who attempted
to charm all the ladies present. Another was the report of
the instructions of the spirits on the subject of the geography
of Mars where, she learned, everyone travels by flying maolous gentleman with a
by
Wright
brothers'
first flight
is es-
preceded
in a power-
role in the
his
which,
which is not to be accounted for solely by a theory of represBut something had occurred which inhibited Jung's tend-
sion.
52
It
to
is
accessible
to suggestion
center.
conscious personalities.
off
He
conjectured that
when
the
split-
dream investigamust remain unanswered, for we have no means of judging how far the emotion in question may be considered 'rethis offers a parallel to the results of Freud's
tions
pressed.'
As
'"^
Where
visual images.
The
Then appear
the
work
at the
this initial
is
his
published
assumption that
'4
Li
53
when the concept of the unconwas only beginning to be talked about in the field of
psychology (although it had been well known to artists and
poets and playwrights and certainly to the romantics of all
achieved this insight in a day
scious
ages).
its suitability
for a scientific
No
The work on the Association Experiment occupied an enormous amount of Jung's energy while he was at the Burgholzli
Clinic. It
was
as
though he
v/ere willing to
put
all
the fury
no
is
54
the person being tested can
sired
by the
come
tester.
first
wrong answers, and there was to be no competiti\'e evaluThe patient was given one hundred words one by one
and he was to respond to each word as quickly as possible
with the first word that came into his mind. He was told
that his responses would be noted and the response time would
be clocked. After this was done, the list of words was given
to tlie patient a second time, and this time he was asked
to reply using the same word he gave the first time if possible.
or
ation.
The purpose
word
mental patients
He had
was unthinkable.
expressed his
amazement
that "the^
is
strangely
enough
still
contested."
He
asserted that
it is
number
of
more
Among
the
as-
"On
the
acti\'ity of
association there
is
55
all
we have
their
all
the
to decipher in order to
'*ever}'
psychical event,
man with
one definite way. Each single action
represents the whole man: the endeavor to deduce the whole
man from his handwriting, physiognomy, shape of his hand,
his stymie, even the way he wears his shoes, is not altogether
every
movement,
is
folly.''9
As
periments were based, the work Jung and his associates carried
on over a period of several years was a spectacular failure.
correlate in
\^ith various
There were
disease entities.
any
a
significant
way
few exceptions,
$6
ject.
a dy-
namic theory
of association; the
to
what we
To
we are attentive
we are able to
think about
it
when
it.
In
carried out.
tice of
Some
be related
57
mind); 8)
would be
and possibly
same word
(this too
it would be important
what part the language played in the life of the
individual); and lastly, 12) a total lack of reaction (for this
is also a reaction, and a meaningful one; in psychotherapy
to find out
is something).
So Jung was off on a whole new track, that of discovering
how the presence of complexes in the mental patients subjected to the experiment interfered with the process of their
associating words to one another. The same difficulty was
experienced by other people who were not mental patients;
and while the results were less dramatic than with the patients,
'*no-thing"
come from
and
The
pattern of
followed
\'ery
closely
by the
analyst.
By
stimulating the
and
had
charge,
He had made
life,
a great deal of
money
transactions.
58
would begin to
it
conscious
mind through
thumb
my
catches
it
unconscious
this device of
and
it
controls
falls
my
object.
I
asked Paul
to those that
often had the feeling that certain happenings in his life were
omens, that tliey showed him how things were going to work
out, and when they made their predictions there just never
was any way out of what they predicted, they always seemed
to work out in the way that he had known of beforehand.
I asked him if he could recall any other instances, could he
perhaps trace back to the first time when something of this
nature happened to him?
He thought awhile and then said he thought he knew what
might have been the first of this kind of experience. It had
happened on a golf course. He had managed to play his way
59
a single point.
was back
from his thoughts. After
that, though, he was never very good at golf. \Vhenever the
going got tough, he would mess it up. He would know ahead
of time that he was going to do it, and it always worked
out that way. He knew it was because he had not kept his
to his old tricks.
far
bargain.
He
6o
him
life for
He
Pi
6l
whom
of
his
early
ver}^
essays,
still
at Burgholzli.
Recognizing
mentary phase,
it
is
much
across with
by Paul in the
Jung wrote:
Reality sees to
it,
and how
how he
it
comes
it
is
by
affects.
and puts in
their place a
crowds everything
else into
complex of other
it
is
it
it
ation,
strongest attention-tone.io
in his
complex
He
theory.
ergy in physics.
one thing in
''Modem
common
psychology,''
he wrote in 1934,
its
'Tias
method
its
psyche,
its
manifestations, so indefi-
nite
so infinitely diverse in
is
difficult
if
definitions given of
which
result
."^^
He
it
are
goes on
obsen^ation are
research,
is,
itself
62
call
its
By
purpose.
assimilationy
on the part of the subject, who misinterprets the experiment because he has at first an insuperable
tendency to assume that it is, shall we say, an intelligence
test or an attempt to take an indiscreet look behind the
scenes ."^^ Such an attitude on the part of the subject brings
him to attempt to disguise the very process which the experimenter is trying to observe.
Jung meant
*'an
attitude
utmost importance that Jung's discovcomplex came not as a result of looking directly
for proof of a hypothesis that such a mechanism as the complex did indeed exist. Rather, the complex was discovered inadvertently, as the method of the association experiments was
disturbed by the autonomous behavior of the psyche, that
is, by assimilation of the apparent purpose of the experiment.
Then it was that Jung discovered the compleXy which had
been registered before as a failure to react.
It was, therefore, of
ery of the
The
discovery of
how
mental stimuli, and then draw to themselves associated contents, made it evident to Jung on how weak a footing the
old view stood that it was possible to investigate isolated
psychic processes.
He
no
no
isolated psy-
accomplish what he
sets
63
play
all
It
is
kinds of
tricks, as
we have
seen.
Jung
is,
complex:
is
strongly
it
has
its
own wholeness
and, in addition, a
mind
it is
subject to the
and
body in the sphere of
consciousness. The complex can usually be suppressed with an
effort of will, but not argued out of existence, and at the first
control of the conscious
suitable opportunity
it
reappears in
all its
original strength.^^
maximum
amount
knowm to his
man
get the
possible
associates as
in his deahngs,
he was
directly responsible.
but
an extremely
still open to
businessman, clearly on his way to becoming the next president of his company. He was, however, constantly in a state
of dissatisfaction with his work. He spent most of his spare
time reading trade journals, calculating his investments in the
64
He
him after
all he
and status, and
the opportunities to follow her own interests. At the same
time, he was vaguely aware that no matter how hard he worked
there was always more to be done and no matter how much
he studied tliere was more to be learned. He was running
on an ever-faster-moving treadmill, and he was desperately
tired. He knew that he needed help, and so he consulted
an analyst.
In the first session Leroy told me that he had been extremely upset lately, that he was sleeping poorly and that his
nights were full of dreams, and images that he could not be
sure were dreamsmaybe they were waking visions. He was
hardly
had done
to
him
that the
when the
conscious defenses
are quite
i
COMPLEXES BY DAY AND DEMONS BY NIGHT
one of the stones out and
it
was
A woman
was
sitting
would
falling.
More than
65
on her head.
asked
suspected that
Here he broke
in to tell
to
admit
66
because
it,
word.
My
it
a bit ugly,
is
name
but
this
le roi^ whic
Although I was named after my granc
father, I always thought there was something fateful aboi
it. I remember when I was quite young thinking I was goir.
to be something special. It seems my mother determined that
her son was going to grow up to be a 'great man' of some
kind. The extreme limit of this, I remember, came one day
when I wondered if I was the next messiah.
"Maybe the church has something to do with the fact that
in trying to be very much my father's son, in trying to be
just exactly what he wanted me to be, I went to church witli
him (my mother was not religious in this sense) and became
exceedingly religious at a very early age. I remember one birthday I was given money which I took and went, with my father
of course, to a 'religious store' and spent the whole amount
on religious items such as a big leather-bound Bible, pictures
of Jesus, crosses, and such things. I was going to be a minister
is
French
is
for 'king/
in those days."
I
asked
him
if
on myself.
It
is
as if I
am
Somehow
center of attention.
I
connect
expect
am
this feeling,
the
which
My
parents' friends.
of telling
It
seems
was:
mean good
^^ery
often,
make
all
my
a big point
said
I
this
good boy
word good-looking,
my parents, and so on. Even
now,
admired by
me when somebody
standing boy
if I
be better than
"
He
67
Other people/'
hesitated,
I've
am
king of a
and
admitted
company meetings.
little
principality at
French court,
I have
my
me
of a
little
My
game
trying to fly
I
asked
since
effort,
and
am
rise in
this fashion. I
00
always
that
fall
make
stop flapping
if I
my
move
arms
when
always
know
hard as I can, I
doing this \nth all
just as
am
will
my
don't
at
all.
manage
So taking a
risk, I
out getting
hit, to
to get close
continue trying to
fly
around in
it
air,
this
may be coming.
manner.
am
my
above
arms,
Until
now Leroy
he
tried
by designating
The dream
is
tlie
his successor.
fly
up
in the air
and use
it
But
problem.
with
on
it
as a resting place
to another section of
to this
mode
under
my own
power. Leroy
now
begins to
make
use of an
69
TV
of which a
new
king must
me
to pick him.
up the
The way
road, or appears in
is
that he walks
my
sub-
jects, all of
symbolism
reflect
and
foliage.
In
its
most general
sense.
yO
the symbolism of
its
tlie
tree denotes
and
and regenera-
sym-
But the
significant
the activity under the surface. All of this leads to the thought
that the locust may be an agent of transformation, and this
seems to be suggested in this dream. The idea is not new;
it can be found in the Bible. When Moses vv^as leading the
children of Israel through the wilderness of Shur they were
three days without water. And when they came to Marah
they could not drink the waters of Marah for they were bitter,
and people murmured against Moses. "And he cried to the
Lord and the Lord showed him a tree, a locust tree, and
he threw it into the waters, and the waters became sweet/'^^
As the dreamer, Leroy, was considering his wound, as he
was tr}dng to assess the results of getting help from something
beyond his own ego, namely the locust tree, he suddenly realized that his time was nearly up. He was brought with a rush
back toward the w^orld of ever}^day consciousness the TV
show would soon be over, and that was all the time that was
allowed. The dreamer w^as desperate, but only "in a way"
and that meant that his desperation w^as based on his assumption that he
had
to
7I
he found out that this was not the way it was going to work
but that destiny had its own way of determining who shall
rule and \^-ho shall lay down the scepter.
When the time was right, the appropriate person arrived
and was chosen king. It was not that Leroy did it, and it
was not whom he expected. In fact Leroy hardly knew him.
But he did know that he would make a good king.
The complex which had Leroy was clearly delineated by
the dream. It was a power-complex, pressing on him the feeling that by reason of his birth and his name was his birthright
he was entitled to be and expected to be in a controlling
position. This nucleus, "the king idea,'' had conditioned much
of his behavior from early childhood. As the years went by,
in his religious fantasies with their messianic flavor, in his
business,
the
demands
is
sense or,
if
he
is
is
72
and
eflfort is
getting
them
to
move on.
The unconscious
contains the
individuation, that
is,
it
is
may
develop.
domain
of the
unknown,
this closed
of the formless.
is
world be-
On
this side
is
kingdom
Jung would
insist that
man
are
much
modem,
It is
human
civilised
ment,
is still
He
civiHsed
73
man.
Every
an archaic
man
by natives in
he observed them in his travels
to the interior of the African continent. The aborigines he
met disclaimed any awareness of particular significance of their
che/'^^
their rituals
and ceremonies,
as
acts,
and the
spirits,
trates his
Now
us suppose that
have come to
I settle
come
am
down on
then say
He is busily mnning about the garden, hiding coloured eggs and setting up peculiar rabbit idols. I have caught
occupation.
him
acterized as archaic,
tions predominate,
way.
and
man
be functioning in a civilized
have no intention of placing a
said to
74
its
and technological
progress. Rather,
am
attempt-
human
or place.
it is
may be
necessary for
own way
is
aw^are of
hidden individual
dif-
him
of being,
if
common
and was
still
She told
me
accident of fate.
a great deal
it
as a
ing
it
75
pened by mere chance. Evetything was a kind of random accident. There was no use trying to exert effort or m\\; you had
no control anyhow. Life was a series of aimless events. Such
was Matilda's conscious attitude when she came to me.
I let her know that I accepted her attitude as being a logical
one in the face of what had recently happened to her, also
because of earlier events in her life which had led her to reject
various forms of authorit\% including that of the fundamentalist Protestant religion in which she had been reared as
a young child. But I asked her if she could see that her attitude
must be unconstructive, because it is impossible to build any
is
purpose, plan
managed
to survive. Tliose
who
able to find
some meaning
purpose for which they felt they were intended to live. They
were impelled by a sense of destiny, and witli that sense they
would not or could not break faith.
In the particular session that enabled her to bring forth
secrets
thing moving
him
outside of his
own
energies, that
is
to say,
The
idea
76
cause.
\vitli
on prior
that there were times when an antici-
all
events depended
that
felt
like choral
It
\^'as
dream
her
if
music.
clear to
me
that this
had been a
particularly
moving
I
asked
when
it.
planets
all
God
for a fear of
was lacking.
There was
fell
little
it,
more
God,
and we
of this dream had led her thoughts onto something else. She
seemed hesitant to speak, she almost began once or twice,
and finally, "There was another dream. I dreamed it over a
year ago."
The dream
home
77
about 10:30.
It is a
she said.
The
"A couple
was
of
months
me,
"I
and that
it
was mov-
yS
predicted
Bill's
death.
He
questioned
me
about
my
relation-
had
imperfections.
its
The dream,
wish.
He announced
I
had
really
his conclusion,
wanted to see
had
which
it
Bill dead.
^^be-
allow very
ESP."
it, but
Now
much
particular
of
it
moment
they rattled.
don't
know what
to
make
it."
all wound up now in her narrative, Matilda conShe talked about an old lady who had been a neighbor
of hers, who had been sickly, and whom she had visited from
time to time in her home. A few months before the incident,
this old lady had been taken to a nursing home, which was
on the road that Matilda took each day as she drove to work.
For several days she had been thinking that she ought to stop
Getting
tinued.
79
Then
"You know, Cartwright is dead.'' Cartgood friend in another city whom they
had not seen or heard from in several months. A few days
after that they learned that Cartwright had suffered a fatal
heart attack, and at almost exactly the time Bill had felt like
to her, out of the blue,
w^right
had been
saying, "Cartwright
is
dead."
such assertion.
had
him
a belief in "super-
actually
made any
reality,
knew
know
the nature of that realit}-. I could see that she had left her
Freudian therapist ven^ much as Jung had left Freud long
ago, when Jung had brought his "mystical speculations" to
He
could,
and often
his
way was
speak of
them
"as though."
way he
He was
realities,
and
I
80
and
this
if
is
imagination then
reality emerges.
^'What
The
is
now
Wilham
Blake
it is
tells
us in
one of
his Proverbs:
life.
And
grown, drawing to
so the denial-of-the-mystical
itself
complex had
inexplicable contents
channels.
any enthusiasm for life. All this was expressed by her state-^
ment, "Ifs not that I want to die, it's just that I see no
reason to go on living."
For me, Jung's explication of the complex makes the cases
of Matilda and the others more comprehensible. He also clarified the correspondence between complexes and demons:
The
personal unconscious
life.
When
an increase of power.
So
far,
Many
way .21
of the complex.
territor}^:
t
e
8l
collective un-
The irruption of
symptom marking the
.
i.e.,
is
many mental
onset of
a characteristic
illnesses.
The
so on.22
To
this
Those who
description
know
my
common symptomatology
common
defensive
He went on
to say:
While the contents of the personal unconscious are felt as belonging to one's own psyche, the contents of the collective unconscious seem alien, as if they came from outside. The reintegration of a personal complex has the effect of release and
often of healing, whereas the invasion of a complex from the
collective unconscious
phenomenon. The
spirits
is
obvious:
is
souls
correspond to
a very disagreeable
unconscious.
We, from
and
the
spirits to
those of the
scientific
if
standpoint,
shadows of
we
consider
52
more deeply
into
tlieir
must go
ratlier
nature .23
The
life
of the individual.
The complexes
of the collective
uncon-
ex-peri-
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS
TO ARCHETYPES
When
his discoveries
its
origin to
made
about
some
deep and
shocking impression, so painful that it could not be endured
for long in consciousness. The mechanism of repression helped
to insulate the wounded psyche from the source of the pain
so that it could continue functioning. Sometimes a loss of
feeling occurred, for repression is a kind of psychological anaesthetic, but when there is great suffering an anaesthetic
serves a purpose. It leaves the wound untouched, but the pa-
experience in the
tient
is
life
able to tolerate
it.
work on the Association Experiment led him to reread Freud's Interpretation of Dreams, a book which he had
put aside a year or two before. Now it was suddenly a revelation to him, for he recognized that in his work on dreams
the father of psychoanalysis had come upon the concept of
repression from an entirely different direction, but that his
understanding of the mechanism was almost identical with
his own. Much of w^hat was new to Jung, and had derived
from his work with schizophrenic patients at Burgholzli, had
already been formulated by the older man.
This discovery led Jung to follow Freud's work avidly, and
to introduce the study of psychoanalysis to the clinic where
Jung's
'
84
professional
colleagues.
if
a correspondence
new
the
psychoanalytical findings.
scientific circles.
I
all
find
ironic, in looking
it
association,
Freud was considered a man of highly speculawhich were mentioned surreptitiously if at all
by "important people." Jung could easily have published his
own work without mention of Freud. But in 1906, at a congress in Munich where a lecturer discussed obsessional neuroses but carefully avoided mention of Freud's work in this
area, Jung decided to take a stand. In connection with the
incident he wrote a paper for the Miinchener Medizinische
Wochenschrift on Freud's theory of the neuroses, which had
research, while
tive theories
Two German
Jung continued to defend Freud he would be endangering his academic career. The learned professors' threats did
not deter Jung, once he had taken his stand.
A decade later, when the Freud-Jung friendship had reached
its apogee, then deteriorated, and finally disintegrated with
Jung's withdrawal from the psychoanalytic movement, Freud
that
if
'
r
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS TO ARCHETYPES
was in his
full
85
At
this
as a speculative philosopher
86
man
sentially a
of religion, although
attending the transformative experiences of life birth, confirmation, marriage and deathhad not failed to establish
in his thinking. His world was full of
which could only be known through their
certain
patterns
unseen
forces,
manifestations.
By
''
neurosis.
principles,
Jung's
own
mendous
tre-
fully
accommodate
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS TO ARCHETYPES
87
trail
of id eas
j}r^^
form of dreams or
as
Life.
in
Word
Association.
analytical
and also
from their dreams, he inferred th e unconscious as an unkno^^^l
and hidden area where reality was cleverly concealed hj^^^
el aborate system ot def ense mechanism-s. Freud had conceptualized the unconscious asT^eing^composed of two basic kinds
of contents. The ^t part of that unconscious reality, which
Freud called the'jd^ is associated with the instinctual drives
which are innate or in botentia at birth Freud's sexual theory
gave primacy to those drives which stem from the infantile
need for gratificationa need which, he thought, is essentially
sexual in
its
nature.
and attitudes
which are imposed from earliest infancy by the
[parents and later by the agents of the culture in which the
child is raised namely his friends and relatives, his church
and school, and then the traditions of his community and
fit
has
its
of thought
conscious they
fall
indi-
88
vidual
is
fi
its
conseq uent
expectations form a structure which then appears to the individual as part of his very being as
himself. This psychic structure
rules
come
is
and
controlli ng
effect o n the instinctive side, the id, thus giving rise to con-
flicts
life
active
of infancy
in
in the beginning
a time
when
by the parents
as natural,
component. These
rules
trans-
mitted
what he
The
is
actually told.
central
problem of infancy,
was to Freud
as
of the
all
was
attachment, countered as
it
own
wth
sex,
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS TO ARCHETYPES
89
dream
tice, for it
was
He
even
own
prac-
interpretation.
forth by the
founder of psychoanalysis.
When Jung began to concern himself with child development, he started from the Freudian point of view by examining the so-called "incest wish'' which occupies so central a
properly study
He
90
be found
and at
mankind, he came
un conscious is at its basis coU
is composed of contents th:at
He wrote: "From the uncon-
diflferent periods
throughout the
^g
lectiye^in-charncter, that
it
js,
historv^ of
scious there
new
ideas
development.
Jung pointed out how Freud had shown in a little essay on
Leonardo da Vinci^ that Leonardo was influenced in later life
by the fact that he had t^^o mothers. This was real enough in
Leonardo's life, but the idea of double descent has played
an important role in the lives of other artists as well. But
beyond this, double descent is a mythological motif, occurring
over and over again in the lives of legendary^ heroes. Some-
two
it is
sets of parents.
brief: the
hero
is
under
difficulties,
and there
is
He
is
rescued by people of
many
becomes
hero and attains fame and greatness. The best known, as mentioned in this series, are Sargon of Agade, Moses, C\tus, and
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS TO ARCHETYPES
9I
developments
Jung could not accept
in his
as
complete
this
all,
on
his
own
patients.
investigations
it
It
linked ideas to which he could find parallels only in mythois, in mythologems. If his
thorough investigations had shown that in the majority of such
cases it was merely forgotten or repressed material, he would
not have gone to the trouble of making extensive researches
and
he wrote,
"typical
92
rather mythological
we can
cal nature,
call 'motifs,'
categorized
them
in
and
ney,"
called
such terms
as
them archetypal
situations.
He
jour-
suggested
vine child, the trickster, the double, the old wise man, the
primordial mother.
makes
his
meaning
the best of
my
Of
"To
made so far. Critics have contented themwith asserting that no such archetypes exist. Certainly
they do not exist, any more than a botanical system exists in
types] have been
selves
But will anyone deny the existence of natural planton that account? Or will anyone deny the occurrence
and continual repetition of certain morphological and func-^
tional similarities? It is much the same thing in principle
nature!
families
The
norms of psychic
activity. "^^
great primordial
human
imagination as
it
phenomenon
why
his
Symbols
of Transformation,
and
modern
pa-
in other places. ^^
was Jung's understanding that the archetypes, as struafnrmina f?lrmr?ntQ in fha iinnnn<:rinys, g ave rise both tO
"
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS TO ARCHETYPES
fantasies
of children
stemmed
93
entirely
from
their personal
how
what appears to be a more parsimonious explanation, saw the myth a<; a ro1]6^^tlV^ vpr<;inn
ing fantasies. But Jung, in
of Jhe
just as
The
is a dominant of the
comprehend the role of
it
will
be necessary to see
how Jung
its
is
crucial
conscious.
suflSciently inclusive.
These
was hence-
94
was a borderline
area, the
it
(adaptation). "12
I
not to be questioned that Freud created the foundations of modem depth psychology through his epochal discovery of the unconscious as a dynamic entity which makes
a profound impact upon human awareness, which is consciousness. The unconscious realm, according to Freud, manifests
itself in dreams and in everyday conscious Kfe through neurotic symptoms as well as in faulty actions. Freud's concept
of the unconscious has greatly enlarged and deepened man's
potentiality for self-knowledge and for understanding of the
needs and motivations of his fellow man. The basic concept
as enunciated by Freud, which met with such a storm of inIt
is
dignant rejection
when
it
was
first
published,
is
commonly
The
question
The
that are
per-
t
i
FROM
ASSOCIATIONS TO ARCHETYPES
cqjtions,
95
The
is
""I t
may be thought
collective unconscious
p^rSMia]
ve rsaly
and because
its
is
of as an ima.^
Jnn^ SavS,
entirely
un i-
him too
literally.
They assume
may be
that there
must be
a clear
scious,
to ever^iJiing
that
collective un-
some
no one else
As we read Jung's works we become
gradually aware that in the psychological material brought
up by indi\'iduals, the personal material sho\\^ the effects of
its collective background and often is as a personal voice givconscious
is
an age-old
ing expression to
is
of.
liturgy.
The
personal unconscious
it
does not
common
to all
ripe'' is
is
im-
unconscious and
it is
ing conscious of
new
material,
potential.
The
sio n
cnnertiv?^ nnr^nscious
is
96
by
linconscious
all
of
may be thought
TrnPTnro<;rn wi>hi^TjJTP^mnrrorn9m.
The
exploration of this
world
is
ARE ARCHETYPES
NECESSARY?
Are archetypes necessary? Most academic psychologists,
have addressed themselves to the question at
swered no.
It is difficult for
me
*^^lH"g^,
who
rp^s^-ly
man
name
often
is
be
moved
human
psyche have
what we know,
a nd
we
they
hesitated to
if
have an-
by
all,
is
mind
from
is
man.
wh at
are the
crust. That
enough when
its
clear
is
98
raise
more
They work
mental functioning.
I,
for one,
But
in
its
ancient ground.
Are archetypes necessary? Are typical patterns of behaviorpotential present in the young at birth? Perhaps the experimental psychologist will be the last to know. But the great
playwrights and artists have always known, and the poet has
asked the right questions:
With what
sense
is
it
rav'nous hawk?
With what
sense does
tlie
expanse?
With what
habitations
And
and
as their joys.
ass
why he
refuses burdens,
and the
meek camel
Why
he
loves
man:
is
it
because of eye,
or skin.
Or
ear,
mouth
'
99
and why
her spires
Love to
curl
ravenous snake
Where
why he
And
psyche. It
may be
by
it,
uality
and
and archaic
vestiges in
modem man.
lOO
and thus
to explain
able to grasp/'^
The
scious/'
he
to
titled ''Confrontation
oi^
dis-
soul's wanderings.
how he
tells
is
own
the unconscious
\is-a-\is
his
nb^^eTy^rl
fell
Jung came
to
know
The dynamic
symbols,
lar culture,
and
human
experience,
psyche that are exposed in psychological analysis. The collected works of Jung are, of course, filled vdth examples of
archetypal phenomena. The archetype always seems to lie
behind and beyond the personal experience. The poet perceives that the child
humanity.
presses the
is
bom
De Profundis^
A few lines
human conditionconsciousness emerging from
from Tennyson's
great mystery:
Out
of the deep,
Where
all
my
all
that was,
Waste dawn of multitudinous-eddying lightOut of the deep, my child, out of the deep,
Thro'
all this
comest
orb
.
ex-
the
101
The
of consciousness
to
is
necessary
if
we
are
own
occurred,
own
ple in our
the
deliver
day, indeed,
suffering
how
individual
may
disaster.
Sara
is
woman
well respected
not married
ence.
But
this
is
is
far
from the
man. In
been able
college she
ment
life-style,
friends of her
own
close to
home,
criticizing
them
all
to her
away from boys." As well as about modand humility and going to church. And being good to
maiden aunts.
As the analysis progressed, Sara reviewed the events of her
102
childhood, adolescence and young
over, controlled.
The
Affect
is
had been
lifted.
is
at the
seem to be
useful
the
way
in
relief.
ex-
The
is
observation of affects
is
inappropriate,
when
affects
When
the affect
it
may be assumed
becomes
to determine the
was
not the key, then it might be possible that the root of the
neurosis did not stem from some personal experience entirely.
I had, after all, dealt quite thoroughly with the personal history of the patient.
still
more there, and that perhaps the still more did not really
on her mother at all. I did not intend to tell this to
center
IO3
it in-
had presented
that she
me
as she told
about
it:
awoke
in the
how
it had felt:
marrow of the bone in me, as far in
as you can go wthout coming out, there was a mist in me that
condensed into this shadowy form. ... I felt it in every por-
that
can
recall exactly
tion of
Then
my
being
."
.
and
eration
had
carried
was able to confront it, to speak to it. She did this in her
fantasy, and it was so vivid that she was able to write down
the words aftenvard:
"You have controlled me, stunted my growth, kept me from
fulfilling mature sexual function. You frightened me with a
stOT)' of men who have a big organ they stick into you
thought it was a stick. You said not to disagree in public, you
cut off my expression. You told me to 'come on in' to see
your friends I wasn't ready to, I was angry, you forced me.
You threw a murky shade over me, undermined my own expression, my own confidence. I was not me. You controlled
my brothers usurped their lives, decimated the identity of
my
father.
104
emyYou
my
are.
You hold
You
me separate spiritThing
me I should slay you!
mother's image in
in her to capture
depotentiated.
The
indi\idual.
strange
cir-
my
cumstances to
stress,
itself
sciousness.
mature woman who had been recently widto me. She was working with the problem
of discovering inner resources within herself which would help
her to compensate for the loss of a strong and competent life
Margaret
is
She
IO5
had no rehgious
faith,
and that
she did not beheve that there could be any possible help
outside of herself. And, since she felt quite inadequate to the
demands
her find
of readjusting her
new wa}s
life,
she had
come
to
me
to help
WTien
some of the helpful character she assohusband or with her relationship with her
husband might still be accessible to her, she brushed off my
remark as unrealistic. However what I said must have struck
a responsive chord below the level of her awareness, for shortly
the possibility that
fol-
106
comer
far
As
light.
my
of the
stared at
it,
a faint
glow of
woman,
the
comer
to
my
of the
friend,
room
and
it
was
observing.
as
And
though I was
I was also
yet
my
that
tliis
this day."
who
is
had one
or
'
IO7
The
fantile sexuality as
now he began
to investigate
clarifying his
difficult
own
ideas
And
may
lo8
\^s the statement which would cost him his friendship with
Freud.^ Here Jung presented his o wn concep tion nf tV^^ rnpan^
ing_ofJnce st, which ha d been the cornerstone of Fr<"^if^'<^ <^<"yu al theory. Jung felt that the incest problem was to be understood symbolically and not literally. Tlius libido, had become
for him more than the force behind sexuality; it had become
th ^ cIiVtip rrpitnrp fnrrp nf nqtnrp The problem of iuCCSt waS
seen no longer as a purely individual dilemma, but as a phase
in the collective experience of man as Jie-jkyelpps towar d
q tiighpr fnrm nf r^on ^cioUSnCSS
.
The problem
child had to
And
The
all
sides
Jung wrote:
As the all-encompassing world-soul, Purusha had a maternalhe represented the original "dawn state'* of tlie
psyche: he was the encom passer and the encompassed, mother
and unborn child, an undifferentiated, unconscious state of
primal being. As such a condition must be terminated, and as
it is at the same time an object of regressive longing, it must
character, for
IO9
by gods and
the earth;
physical,
jects.' "^
many
it
is
sexual pleasure,
That the archetypal experience appears in the young child by no means implies that it is limited to the young child. Archaism is a dynamic factor in the psychic life of adult civilized men as well,
according to Jung, and the evidence is all about us if we will
but notice it. One place where it may appear is in our dreams.
An example of an archetypal dream in a young adult will
show how a Jungian analyst looks at a dream w^hich contains
material which the patient cannot connect with his early life
for pleasure
can have
different sources.
110
him with
One
rocket take
off.
Suddenly
it
am
watching a
am
moment
tall.
its
made
leg.
of
In
wax
Ill
leg. i\lso, I
its
think of
it
jovial
mood
is
the
as I held
great
harmless.'
giant
way
in a positive
seems
me.
that
feared;
he
is
ever since. It
felt in a festive,
as if to say 'this
really
small
and
''
now became
No wonder
like
on the
sea of the
No
scum
longer would
of knowledge
Now
he under-
stood that he could reach into the depths, and bring up contents of the unconscious, rational or irrational no matter
might look
them and
see
how
what they
like.
archetype
th en
we become aware
of dealing
with
that there
M ythology provides
told
how
to apply
112
myth
that.
I
asked Murray
if
told
way home
had re-
traveler
contest
stump
My
lovesick analysand
may
or
the
r
ARE ARCHETYPES NECESSARY?
II3
myth of the Odyssey; he did not recall it. Yet he had somehow
known that the act of fashioning the bed had a symbolic
meaning to him which he had not understood, but truly felt.
The mythologem reappears and reappears.
The archetype, as we have seen in the case of Sara, manifested itself
mon
to
all
men
is
of recent studies
that babies
all
quite believable
when
on the foundation
of language."
He
notes
havior at the same time and in the same way. This behavior,
he
says, is
is
ity to
114
The
above
is
se-
which produces its own proofs for its existence and its
A dream brought to me by Ben, a schoolteacher in
his first year of teaching elementary-school children and only
beginning to perceive the manifold ways in which learning
itself,
nature.
takes place,
is
a case in point: I
am
in
some kind
of under-
about
my goddam
own
They don't
languxige.
care
phonics.
What
known
was
own
culture.
is
bom
Chomsky
language
Do
not underestimate
of the human mind to develop
cautioned:
language.
How
very different
behaviorists
who
is
this
human organism
as
bom
11 5
is
down
to
"causes'' which
its
early experiences
present in
human
is
importance
that
it
is
that
it
all
experience. Its
attitude
and behavior
Of
course
it is
possible
willing to accept
country, even to
of those
who
sit
man
carries
down
life
into "problems"
is
within
thinking,
is
which then
is
to find that
Il6
Some-
by
shifting behavior
from a
less
acceptable kind to
is
choices offered.
Problem-solving
psychology.
If
is
may
be a by-product. If we are ever to effect constructive and lasting changes in our own lives, we must strive for a transforrrui'
tion (note: I did not say a "cure") of the potentially disturbing or disrupting problems, by reaching toward tlieir
archetypal cores. Such a transformation cannot take place before one has gone beyond the personal to the universal dimension. In this process man, becoming more and more conscious,
will not be satisfied by being told what his place in society
is. The modem man needs to rescue himself from his cultural
provincialism. No one can do it for him. To accomplish this,
the convergent
proach.
way
The view
of thinking
is
al-
II7
Archetypes' and
"The term
the idea of
'archetype'
it is.
'Archetypal stone.'
.He
is
not found in
St.
Augustine, but
archaic
sal
Il8
of the imagination/'
The
referred to ""categories
that
all
human
tion,
form does
not stand alone but is something that is recognized and named
in other fields of knowledge.
Students of animal beha\ior have coined the term "innate
releasing mechanism'' (IRM) to designate the inherited structure in the nervous system that enables an animal to respond
in a predetermined way to a circumstance never experienced
before. Chicks with their eggshells still adhering to their tails
dart for cover when a hawk flies overhead, but not when the
bird is a gull, duck, heron or pigeon. Furthermore, if the
wooden model of a hawk is drawn over their coop on a wire
they react as though it were alive unless it is drawn backward,
his idea of the archetypes, literally a pre-existent
when
there
is
no response.^^
Tinbergen, who has given particular attention to the problem of animal learning, has shown that not only do differing
species have different dispositions to learn, but that such innate dispositions come to maturity only in certain critical periods of the animal's growth. He writes about the Eskimo dogs
of east Greenland, living in packs of five to ten individuals.
The members
all
II9
There
is
no opportunity here
for trial
and
error,
nor
is
there a
the water.i^
What
does
it all
How shall we
about
own
rhythms?
Is
it
way
of sensing that
we
way
of synchroniz-
we
is still
same-
120
investigator's task
formulates
them
in concepts.
become evident
to him.
He
meaning
ANALYSIS
AND THE
COUNTER-CULTURE
am
freely to
and
objectivity.
Of
course
i^
seek psychotherapy.
at
some
of our
On
'iDest''
the other
The
whom
others do not
is
say that
at least as
Some
building.
I
am
My
posture changes,
expected to
fit
get constricted,
into a pattern as
outmoded
How
Is
she cheerful?
she neat?
is
told?
all
things that
feel that
as the fake
reminds
me
of
we were graded
122
Is
some
tranquilizers/ they
tell
is all
are not
wrong. Anxiety? 'Here, try
is,
A woman
women's
fields
if
she
is
velopment, etc.). I was told this by Nora, who is in the anthropology program. She had been married just a few weeks
previously. Nora came to her session one day with sparks
shooting from her eyes, and just about ready to explode. This
student, she
is all
right,
is
'
123
The
pand the
intellectual
dedication
son
intellectual. Its
is
powers of the
is
is
we examine
is
to ex-
Its basic
It insists
that
purpose
human community.
And
it
demands
by our
which come to us
constantly seek
cellence that
in the
is
new methods
offers
is
comprehend our
is
ex-
no compromises. Our
intellectual heritage to
be
on the path
may be more
of reason.
of the eighteen-year-olds
who
many
on
pep pills or tranquilizers before the first quarter of their academic year was over. The goals set forth are undeniably valid
for those
who
I have no criticism
But I wonder whether they are enough to
capture the minds and hearts of the best students today? It
of
them per
seems to
me
se.
it
often
is
Many
frustrating.
but they
is
The
tell
life
of the
campus
me
lists
is
tantalizing but
there
distillation of
all right,
many
it
of
124
like a child
To
Where do
to
is
And what
all
It is clear
by the very
be distinguished by
of those others
who
superiority,
are surpassed?
lives
by the
collective.
as
'
12?
The
to
We
126
came up
to Switzerland
WTien
realized that a
was in progress.
Today's
when
universit}' students
process
of toughening their
fact of
many
We
We
We
kill ratio
one thing wrong with O.C.S. was, we never learned that in \'ietnam there will be friendly civilians all around us. Sure: in Saigon
there will. In the secure areas the \'ietnamese may be clapping
French in the 1944 newsreels do, "Yay
But we would be somewhere else: we would be
where the V.C. are. It was drummed into us, "Be sharp! Be on
your guard! ... In combat you haven't any friends! You have
and cheering
for America!*'
like the
"^
enemies!'*
self,
ril act as
if
Vm
in
I27
never secure. As
people's a massacre:
don't understand .2
Today's students don't understand either. Some are in colwant to be there but because it is that,
or an education like Lieutenant Galley's. Either hand in your
term papers and give the professors \^hat they want on the
men.
versity
ser\'e as
woman, and
Jennifer
my
entering class
is
now
gone. It takes
all I
we demand
this
no excuses then
to
be handed in on time-
relief.
The
I'd
128
"When
studies. I
from Birmingham.
him
He
said,
means to an end. He
denying anything that wasn't altogether rational.
You have to struggle to keep your humanity. He said, *How
can you work with anything where there aren't answers?' You
I
told
was
totally
be
satisfied. If I
guilty
I feel
the morning at
satisfied
I
know
out
is
it
came
solving
desk to
in another
it
way drop
it
here.
have no
"I
came
it,
my
if
drugs,
I
still wouldn't
go to the Art Institute on Saturday morning,
here.
if
the world
There used
really matter.
no optimism,
trust,
feel like
to
^
more downs than ups. Despair, despair, despair.
like my mind saying, 'You're not going to study.' At
there are
"It's
one time
find
it
know
enjoyed
it.
If
"It's a
realit}^;
don't even
reality
if it is
chunk
of reality so
much
that
is
real
is
out of
left
The people
it
up.
have
tremengrown
emotionally.
Fve
been extremely immature
dously since I've been here in all sorts of ways. But have
they, the intellectual ones? They have really sharp minds, but
I
intellectually
want
I
keep
my
when
to read,
my
play
my
flute, or
when
read what
Jung book
to the side.
say, okay,
my
I really
book on Jung.
when
finish
French and
my
'
is
keep
my
eyes
open
get to read
a lollipop.
come back
them feel
Fd commit
after they've
that theyVe
suicide, but
beaten you. I think about suicide.
then they would have won, so I can't.''
Mixed up? Disturbed? Not seeing reality clearly? Perhaps.
still
make
to
can
It's like
dropped out,
if I
I29
130
human
per-
Then
it is
that dissident
These
the people
who form
Jung invested
are
the counter-culture.
and
interest ini
mists.
He
preserving
the bridge
nature,
to
i.e.,
to
engaged
the unconscious
tlie
Christian process. It
is
no doubt as to the Church's attitude tobut on the other hand it was effectively protected by the
obscurity of its symbolism, which could always be explained as
harmless allegory. For many alchemists the allegorical aspects
undoubtedly occupied the foreground to such an extent that
they were firmly convinced that their sole concern was with
certain decrees leave
ward
it,
whom
lab-
of symbols
I3I
and
their psychic
effect.3
common
magical
elixir
similarly
announces that
''our
panacea
is
not the
Religion on Campus"^ described various groups which combine "the put-on and the serious, the deliberately comic and
of
neo-sacred
movement now
observable
He
'
132
was reported that the student body in a Canadian uniwas given a chance to have a voice in the selection of
courses in their curriculum. The majority of the courses chosen
had to do with astrolog}', Zen, sorcer>^ and witchcraft.^ Nori
are the seekers interested in having their subjects technolo-l
gized. For several months a big-cit}- newspaper ran a horoscope
column prepared by a computer. The paper reported, "Thatj^
was a mistake. Readers neither liked nor trusted the machine/'
It announced that next Sunday it would correct its error.
"Man replaces the machine, after months of searching for
the right man.""
may hopefully assume the search was
carried on by someone from the personnel department, and
not by the computer.
Isaac Bonewitz is an enterprising young man who evidently
believes in magic and con\dnced his advisers that the subject
was a legitimate area of study. He concocted a magic course
with ingredients from psychology, sociology, anthropology, religion, folklore and mythology, and received his B.A. in magic
from the University of California at Berkeley. He considers
magic "one step beyond parapsychology which painted itself
into a corner years ago and is still there." The problem, he
It
versity
We
is
limited to spontane-
.^
ously reported cases or laborator}^ experiments. It doesn't take
nomena
one thing
It is
all
in primitive cultures.^
for a university to sanction the investigations
ence.
tr}^
Some
them.
The
universities, a very
Now we
fact that
all
to psychiatrists."^
On
I33
Phenomena has
in,
come
The
is,
it
faculty
and
its
disciplined
known
demands
for
theoretical
hallucinations.
now at her home, ostensibly to help her, but without the knowledge of his supervisor. He began practicing hypnosis on her and found it easy and fascinating to get her to go
seeing her,
134
and
tional
relate
me
nature.
He came
up was
do with
to
I
to
know what
it.
competent
professional
Therefore
help
should
the
manifestations
continue.
man was
seek-
own
to
My own
acceptable to academicians
My
whom
regarded as overintellec-
I was unhappy
about it. The night following my lecture I had the following
dream: I am in a hospital ward where I am to visit psychotic
tual.
patients. I
am
He
is
assistant.
i
i'
gloom
tition,
I35
out of their vieWy perhaps behind a curtain or parhut close enough so that I can watch and listen. All
just
the time I
am
my
if
they are so
''in
touch''
At this moment
they ["thef are the theology student M'ho was my former
appearing as a warlock and a witch,
patient and his fiancee
reach out to where I am standing and grab me. They try to
force a confession out of me by holding me down and massaging my inner thigh, which has at one time an exciting and
they will prove
it
by sensing
presence.
Then
there
is
nance between them and me. I was not sure how it came out.
The dream brought out into clear focus my own ambivalence concerning the matter of psychic forces about which so
little is known and their ways of affecting sense impressions,
thought and behavior. I have tried to keep an open mind to
the phenomena brought to me by my patients, for I know
that there is a thin line between intuition and vision, and
wilderness
is
who
called
in
upon
wth
i
BOUNDARIES OF THE SOUL
136
is
given a
God and
with
is
Israel,
men and
meaning
''he
who
has prevailed."
From
and
in every genera-
spirits,"
of the dead.
last
when
is
spirit apparitions
me
lyst
Man"^^
who
calls to
mind
live close to
the stereot^'pi-
ideas
adult.
>>^
truth
is
I37
such as the
start,
'
^
:
'
He makes
it is perfectly understandable to us that people die of advanced age or as the result of diseases that are recognized
to be fatal, this is not the case with primitive man. When old
persons die, he does not believe it to be the result of age. He
argues that there are persons who have lived to be much older.
Likewise, no one dies as the result of disease, for there have
been other people who recovered from the same disease, or
never contracted it. To him, the real explanation is always
magic. Either a spirit has killed the man, or it was sorcery.
Many primitive tribes recognize death in battle as the only
natural death. Still others regard even death in battle as unnatural, holding that the enemy who caused it must either
have been a sorcerer or have used a charmed weapon. "^2
Jung reviews the many ways in which the thinking of "primitive man'' is reported to be of a distinctly different nature
from that of the modern cultivated European or American.
He then comes through with his ironic little joke, which is
that "it is not only primitive man whose psychology is archaic. It is the psychology also of modem civilized man, and
not merely of individual 'throw-backs' in modem society. On
the contrary, every civilized human being, however high his
conscious development, is still an archaic man at the deeper
numerous
psyche
is
Just as the
human body
'
to
its
origins,
What
in
is
it
when
displays
human
followed back
traits."^^
which magic
is
is a world that is
an affront to the establishment,
an everyday occurrence
prodigiously strange? Is
whose
power of
it
rational presupposition
it
is
138
unless, indeed,
we descend with
the
modern
not
physicist into
iti
from the beaten track. We distinctly resent the idea of invisiand arbitrary forces, for it is not so long ago that we made
our escape from that frightening world of dreams and superstitions, and constructed for ourselves a picture of the cosmos
worthy of our rational consciousness that latest and greatest
achievement of man/'^^
Shades of the university president's keynote address! Is it
any wonder that the archaism in the mind of civilized man,
forcibly isolated from the realm of intellectual development,
ble
finds
its
expression in
its
own
perience mysterious happenings which cannot be brought under the control of the academic hierarchy?
believe that
it is
is
finely
behind magic
is
state.
The
original idea
people are capable of employing a power by which they canmake nature obey their
is,
which
atom
Our
scientists
applying
them
way
Magic
is
he means "a careful and scrupulous observawhat Rudolph Otto^^ aptly termed the numinosuniy
that is, a dynamic agency or effect not caused by an arbitrary
act of will."^^ The numinosum^ then, refers to a sense of
of religion here,
tion of
an
sciousness.''
is
human will,
man by virtue of
is
said to
come
to a
I39
the experience of
a
(divine)
grace.
offers the
is
many
religious practices
."^'^
.
140
To
as divine
omnipo-
instead,
To
it
merely served as a
and better known elsewhere. Thus Jung found it quite impossible to make a living symbol, that is, one which is pregnant with meaning, from known associations. ''What is thus
manufactured can never contain more than what was put into
it." The living S}Tnbol, on the other hand, was for him an
expression that designated something that w^s "only divined
The
clearly conscious."^^
symbolic approach
offers
the analyst a
which leads
intelligent
way
of taking
and searching
lies
behind their
accessibility to
'^
ANALYSIS
.VNTD
THE COUNTER-CULTURE
upon
to treat patients
I4I
even physiological damage after taking certain drugs. A spet}-pe of person tends to look to a Jungian analyst for
help, I have obser\'ed. He has been experimenting with hallucinogens such as marijuana, LSD or mescaline, \nth some
cific
too
full.
No
intensit\-
142
there
fore
is
death.
this,
How
came
compulsion.
No
could
be in
up-tight stujBEng
this
it.
The
water sliding
off a
smooth sheet
shallow
all
143
the structures of
attached to
and innervated.
An underground spring surging into open space, created by
returning to itself. Watertight means death; no dissolution of
forms without a dissolver, and room to do it in."
Mescaline, for Carol, was the dissolving substance. Through
mescaline she came to that fullness of vision which William
Blake had promised when he wrote, "If the doors of perception were cleansed, everv^tliing would appear as it is, infinite."
Carol, not knowing fully what the "infinite" was, could only
identify it with herself and with her own sexuality. She wrote:
other, a circular broken exchange, enervated
"My own
ning
of
fire,
power.
My
breast
is
my body
my
love's
it
all
of those, at once."
She was
in
process
The excitement
own rhythm
until
it
came
to
its
it. It had to
She wrote on:
consumed, each part
place.
is
144
consuming
tlie
The act
Then
of
combination life,
creation, death."
subhme came
The
fear.
meant
it,
Some
realit)\
remained in the
fabric of the
ing this kept her from lea\ing school, although she was not
really in
either.
it
clarib.-,
new
In coming
anal}'sis,
power, death.
part of the
self.
progression of ex-perience
clear,
making something clear, fear of the diffuse, confusing, amorphous thing which experience can become
clarity must come, or death retums, a pulling do\Mi, stuck,
fear of not
feel
them
as strongly
way
making meaning for the feelings, and the release and satisfaction which comes from that. But with more or less clarity,
comes power from the release of all the former burdens, but
also from the certaint}' of knowing that I figured something
out. The power is doomed to a horrible pulling-dowTi kind
of death if the clear things are allowed to remain static. But
as I
clarity,
stable
of
is
is
always
must be
that death
is
145
again,
but never
am.
And
moment
who
a hurricane. It
was
being
for hers
chosen role
to glimpse
conscious perceptions
when
the hallucinogens.
first to learn that the conscious mind estabboundaries for its own reasons, knowing that the waters
of the unconscious are to be tasted in sips and swallowed,
and are not to be allowed to inundate or overv^^helm. Carol
had experienced many symbols, among themMother, spinning forms, snake's skin shedding, energy of forms hollow and
Carol needed
lishes
rigid,
analyze these away by saying that this means this and that
means
vision
this I
146
herself together,
may and
some
flashes
The
of the kind
pharmacological panacea, which began as an effort to transcend the difficulties and the disciplines which are imposed
we
tially,
an exploration of the
psychedelic experience
method
falls
politics
is,
essen-
of consciousness, then
of
that of Jung
is
of
all
ness.
I47
men
in all age^,
is
common
mind when
ordinary conscious-
put away and the person opens himself to the translucence of realit}^ This translucence means that the apparent
solidity of things, which gives them their boundaries, is actually not solid but permeable, and permeated m\h the quality
of infinity that connects everything to everything else. To see
this is to see the spaceless world, which is also timeless; that
is, the continuum of space or time which stretches like a ribbon before us and behind us with never any end. Our lives,
then, become a short stretch, a tiny segment on that endless
ribbon, separated from it only by our state of consciousness
in which we become aware of ourseh'es as indi\iduals. This
awareness seems to require us constantly to be wresting
more and more consciousness from tlie unknown and unness
is
limited.
scious,
And, paradoxically,
in order to
of
what we may
is
call
is
customary
more open
the "archetypal
more.''
148
possibly (although they
would be the
last to
admit
it)
sur-
than
The groups
its
own
thing.
The movements'
supporters
make
well-being
ing of
Each group,
as
creed
is
a confession of
world at large and is thus an intramundane affair, while the meaning and purpose of religion
lie in the relationship of the individual to God or to the path of
He
goes on to say:
_-j
149
them the
living relationship to
and
exclusively
on
his relation to
is
an authority which
is
not of
this
world .22
believe that Jung
to
mean
is
''this
worW
cases,
when
it
serves to
widen
is
candor.
who
setting.
give
of the
and
group
Thus the Monday-morning hangover from a "marais often more painful than the traditional
thon weekend*'
its
seems to
me
would have
aeternitatis^
sion
psychology
is
an aspect of
all
is
said in
essentially
what Jungian
totality,
and a seeing
self as
the synthesis of
150
many
parts.
Thus
all
removed, including
An
most
may
who was
in one of its
an adjunct to the wholly
meaning
wider context.
an art teacher in high school. Before he studied
Eric
par-
ser\e to illus-
is
its
and
in art school
original in his
interaction
would be
After the extended m.arathon was over, Eric wanted to discuss in therapy something that
One
had happened
in the group.
sunlight.
He
f
ANALYSIS AND THE COUNTER-CULTURE
I5I
on
a blank field.
And
much
of his
own
it
was
work. But,
other
reported,
as sou-
he
felt
very happy.
The
sessions.
We then
tried to
understand
\\'hy
was
about
it
it
that was so
''right,''
total well-being?
The
product of his
own
efforts,
152
Looking over
when he
finished.
own
earlier
We
must flow through, for if it is held in, stopped, if the paintall that it meant had been held onto, the flow would
have been dammed up, the precious waters of creativity would
it
ing and
I53
to give
movement in Jim.
Eric came to know
group experi-
that
when we
modes
of the counter-culture
we
demand
are willing
becomes necessary
meaning in
it
counter-culture
is
movements
to ef-
als in
common
task to improve
some aspect of
society,
and
154
being sold on the idea of marches and mass meetings conducted in the spirit of obstructing or destroying the current
scapegoat in the
name
of social progress.
Where
efforts to
it
di\idual
is
commitment, people
make
is
me
With
this in-
so characteristic of Jung,
"elitist
mean is that individuals are essentially different and that those who emphasize the development of these
differences to their highest potential must necessarily become
more differentiated than those who are satisfied to go along
it
seems to
to
\vith
we
that since
v^ery least,
feel that
vv^e
are in
find a
it,
way
vv^e
must above
all
win
it,
or at the
we
dissociate ourselves
from
national policy and cry out with horror and outrage at the
country so
immorally,
So we
name
of countr}%
all
with protesta-
we love our
much that we are torn to pieces when she acts
as we would be ov^er our ovvti delinquent child.
what we do
to the literature
is
and
We
criminal position.
I55
an untenable
would do better
if
not actually
to consider the
words
of Jung:
We
we change
Only those
ourselves as such.
as a nation,
nor can
or improve themselves who are able to develop spiritually beyond the national prejudices. The national character is an involuntary fate which is imposed upon the individual like a
tion"
...
is
life
of
not an end
It all
its
own
if
we
The
is
nation
therefore
in itself.^^
comes down
society,
we would change
we must begin by
if
changing ourselves.
the generations of
notable success,
disappointment and
salvation for
the
new
all
failure.
There
who would
is
follow
months.
There is a process in which all men are engaged, and which
is a developmental process. It has been called by many names;
Jung has called it the Way of Individuation. In his lifetime
of absorption in matters of the psyche, he has come to some
basic understandings. These have served me well in my work
as a Jungian analyst. I have found much help in Jung's statement, "All life is individual life, in which alone the ultimate
meaning
is
to be found."^^
INDIVIDUATION:
THE PROCESS
WHOLE
OF BECOMING
In Chicago, which depends for
its
a section called
It
.
is
the successor to
is
existence largely
be the center
when
who had begun
Old Town and who had outgrown
to
on me-
New Town.
it
moved
in.
People
with the psychedelic experience as an endhave been opening up small shops and businesses
in New Town, where they make, display and sell interesting
and unusual products. You can walk down a busy street when
suddenly the delicious odor of bread baking streams out from
a little storefront bakery and wraps you in nostalgia. The "Clay
People'' make and sell ceramics and invite you to come in
and learn their craft. Artists paint in shop-studios, and there
is a shop where people sit around and do macrame and sell
their fascination
in-itself,
158
'
increasingly attracting
of those
who
That
1970s.
effort offered a
feel
imposed by the
way which is
the attention and then the commitment
and personal
tinctly individual
effort, as
Jung conceived
it,
the
is
way
of indu
yiduatia
Thefjndividuation\process,
immanent
tiie
individual It
.
is
all
means the
work,
it
also
demands the
t^an
own
direction,
':
who
su ffer
froinjhgfeeling thatth ey jireunable to measure up to collective norms and collectiveT3eals. To those who are not rec- Mi
ognized by the collective, who are rejected and even despised,
this process offers the potentiality of restoring faith in them-
selves. It
them
What
come
may
give
them back
their
human
dignity
and assure I
WHOLE
159
We
'
s eeking
The
after self-knowledge
criticism
is
often
t^^
made
^<^i^t^:^^-v
that
t^
searching
^^^.^
for
'^vT^W^^x.
self-
experiences of living.
The
Each of
The Hindu
gods, Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva Creator, PreDestroyerlive in each of us; all must be reckoned
with. It is as though we exist in a psychic system where an
ecological balance must be maintained. One analysand of
ness.
server,
l6o
mine put it this way: "I was reading about how the government took all that highly dangerous nerve gas and sealed it
in tons of concrete and took it out and dumped it in the
Atlantic to 'dispose of it/ I realized how wrong that statement
was, for
we
with
is
us,
and even
it
to.
Even
in the Atlantic
And
is
isn't
any
is
still
it
limited and
what
we cannot
ourselves, we
so in the psyche,
own
good."
When my
plies
today.
Let
me
give
right
means
fail
Dale came to
me
whole
a case of
161
my own
prac-
His latest
Dale was no
Or
fool,
perseverance.
nor
He
them
honeymoon was
would complain that Dale had completely changed. He didn't see it, he never could understand
what went wrong.
This man had joined the Army, where he got into trouble
in one relationship after another. He became involved in fist
fights, was called down for insubordination, until at last it got
so bad that he was given a psychiatric discharge. The Army
recommended psychotherapy, and w^as willing to pay for
it. In addition he was awarded disability benefits, so he did
of
in succession,
l62
fact
after garbage
then,
men
in the nation.
He
new
of the
most sought-
felt
powerful enough
job he
what was expected of him, "not a bit more and not a bit
less," he would say dogmatically. Taking any criticism was
out of the question, or doing any bit of work that could possibly be done by a subordinate was not even a matter for
discussion. He asserted that he wouldn't take any shit from
anyone, but ironically the nature of his work was such that
he was taking shit from everyone.
Despite his acknowledged expertise, he was continually
either quitting or getting fired. Then he would get a new
job for more money and the whole thing would start all over
again.
plainly speaking,
to
make
it
little.
endurable.
The
world,
pile of shit,
whole
163
destructive aspects.
We
much mentioning
he began to think of
from the human race, and more as
a member of it, whose survival and productivity depended
very much upon his making himself and his knowledge useful
to tlie world, with its people and their needs. Gradually, he
began to give a little, instead of only taking. And one day
it dawned on him that the analytical work in which he was
engaged could be understood as "psychological ecology/' He
had known it all along, in his head, but suddenly one day
he accepted it fully as a fact of his total being. He knew
that he was a microcosm of the whole world, and that in
his inner life he could work to convert his own filth into
clear life-giving waters and fertilizer, just as in his professional
vocation he could act to convert filth and pollution in the
environment into breathable air and drinkable water. A change
of attitude appeared quite suddenly, but the potential for it
had been in him all along. It had been the inner urge for
redemption from his own filth that had arranged the neurotic
himself
less as a discard
164
behavior which got him out of the Army and into a place
which could prepare him to fulfill his inner necessity.
Once, at tlie start of our work together, he said that he had
just drifted into this particular branch of engineering because
it was a wide-open field not many people were interested in
spending tlieir working days examining the decomposing
wastes from the city sewers and the pay was good. Some time
later he admitted he had experienced the strong feeling of an
inner voice that had guided him to choose the courses that he
did, unpopular as these courses were in the university at the
time. For some reason which he was unable to fathom, the
field of work appealed to him, and so he followed his feelings
there and applied himself to his studies. Recently Dale has
come to see purpose in what he is doing, and I am guardedly
hopeful that if his potentialities now unfold, that he will
make an outstanding contribution to society. He is beginning
to know who he is. Today there exists the possibility that the
right man v^ll begin to work in the right way.
The analysand who has gone through the current problems
of his life and attempted with the analyst's help, to see what
the meaning may be behind the symbolic forms of behavior,
and who has been willing to trace back the current behavior
to whatever earlier stages hold the key for unlocking the patterns that
analysis.
It
some symptoms
are
is
no longer
no longer
visible, or
much with
so that they
his functioning.
damage seems
He
is
passed, the
that
if
them and
is
present. It
may be
they are,
to exert
better, the
is
most obvious
The
sis,
process of individuation, as
requires a long
it is
experienced in analy-
of pulling together
Su^y<r^y^^ -^'w^-C^
fhnspfrnp[nieriterl
<;ripn<;
sci ous
pp-r.9nri a1ities,
^ t[(\
ch^CiY\c. hits
165
piec^ofjincon^
iTcon-
and th e way
of itself
anrl
WHOLE
injwhich
it
we
is
They
ation process.
and that
is
for individuation
several years.
is
in reading
own
herself
We
felt,
Jung and
could help
l66
sued
all
night.
The more
The
she brought
made
in stirring
in
as
to
it,
flying
in brilliant sparkles.
As
leaned forward
it
occurred to
me
to
swnftness.
Without going
clear
enough
to
me
it
was
167
help her regain her hold on the material world. Tlie stress
of the individuation process was surely contraindicated for
But the following dream presents quite a different meswas brought by a woman whose life situation w^as
progressing adequately, and who was reasonably successful in
sage. It
it
commen-
beyond
up and express her ideas in
a more forceful way. But she lacked courage. She dreamed:
I was in a house that looked like the house in which I grew
up, and 1 was standing before the door to my father's workshop. That was a room which I had been told not to enter;
now I know that it was where father kept certain electrical
tools which could have been dangerous. But, as a child, I had
been warned that terrible things would happen to me if I
went in there, and I imagined that it was full of monsters
and bogeymen who would get me if I ever opened the door.
As I stand before this door I see that it is of enormous size.
surate with her ability.
She
felt
In the center of
brass handle on
it
there
is
mth
a great
door slowly opens. I look inside, but all that I can see is
am trembling. I then hear a voice which says,
""Why not go in?'' I feel that it must be all right to do so, and
I walk into the darkness. That black space stretches as far as
I can see. Nevertheless I take a few steps inward. Soon in the
uttermost distance I can distinguish the faintest shade of deep
blackness. I
This
woman was
He
tended to
l68
more
to
who
am
new
in a
make an
effort to
warm
him. But he
stiff
is
dead.
Then
cupping
the
fills
feathers
cal error,
Then he
this? Is
that passes.
My
He
parents
bird, that
he
is
doesn't.
come
alive. I
am
very
moved
in telling them.
and
sits
some others
that M^ere a
warm in here. No
Then I look to
open. Xom'
little
169
mHI be
it
really
chills.
is
Then
tain,
my
out to
this place
the bird
then he
I scnv
parents.
out well
first,
is
skis
and
They
mth
me
ask
if
my
skiing
on
down my
little skis.
shirt.
He
all.
He
has
down
skis
little ski
the cur-
poles which
is
I notice that
Then
so intelligent.
He
is
so amazing.
I say:
The
man.
""This
is
life,
not reproduced
to bring light
his difficulties
it
and
upon
his orienta-
I have
but rather to
his potentialities.
dream
as
it
was reported,
tlie
tween
dreamer and
being a creature
fly, is a symbol
for that incomprehensible part of man that is sometimes
called "spirit/' It evokes the feeling of relatedness on a plane
which is not strictly material there is a non-corporeality
about the man-bird connection. In our discussion of the dream
we understood the bir d as the expression of th at pnpnngrjnng
tlie
he can
most responsive
and c^ned for. It
is
to the tender!
is
tliis
quality)
lyO
dreamer that
in the
He
is
nearly gives up on
it,
expended corresponds
The
and
and the
care
life
if
to test
own openness
re jected his
o wn
whole
171
He
life as
worthy
to
who corresponded
to keep this
all
newly revived
means avoid
ca-
letting
the parental "criticar attitude endanger the new development. \\Tien he decided to take a firm stand, to care for the
bird regardless of what the parents might think, he found
that everjiiiing he needed to carry through had already been
provided for him thus the bird's food and water and other
things which appeared when the dreamer looked for him.
With the man^elous humor that dreams sometimes pro\dde,
the bird suddenly became an independent creature, and was
winding up the little toy doll, much to the dreamer's amazement. How much like life: when we finally learn to do something in a new way, that knowledge takes over and begins to
have an existence of its own, introducing us to possibilities
of which we have never dreamed. The skiing is a case in point
it is sheer exuberancel The dreamer ^Yas utterly amazed
that what he thought was a small creature who could at best
be a pet, turned out to have imagination and flair. The
dreamer associated the skis with the special meaning that
mountains have for him tlie pristine heights where spiritual
values are the primarv^ values. The dreamer had been interested in reading about mountain religions, and the symbolism
from these religions often colored his dreams. In this particular dream, however, t^vo opposing and disjointed aspects of
the dreamer came together: one was the rarified intellectual
interest in religion as a discipline acquired through reading
and study, and the other was the capacity to extend the abstract concept of the unity of all things to a sense of relatedness with actual living things. That the bird was seen as the
spirit of a
times,
seemed
human
being of former
between
172
man
old wise
hand
in the
of the dreamer.
cannot say
dealing with
its
how
direction.
the decision
is
made
as to
with
all
its
its
the information
itself.
The
manifestations in ever\^day
we need
to
factor
unconscious, through
life,
pro-
is
there
is
chotic
to it
it
woman.
It is
jlie
E
j
jinet
jabil
whole
173
Each person will, in the process of his analysis, find his own
methods and ways of confronting the unconscious. Tlie possibilities are varied, and throughout the course of this book
I \^ill continue to give examples. \\Tiat is essential to all of
ways
these
fully to
is
commit himself
or herself
may
at times
him know
a great deal of
this at
emo-
the beginning. If
appears that he
is not able or willing to sustain the addiburdens of increasing consciousness, he ought not to
subject himself to the rigors of the indi\'iduation process in
it
tional
not expect to be
made whole
or wives or lovers.
and
to
make
sure
174
that
on each step along the way the new discoveries and incan be thoroughly assimilated so that they become usa-
sights
move
fonvard. Furthermore,
could be said that the analyst should encourage the analysand to utilize his own critical judgment in regarding his
it
material,
But the
it
it
hour.
fact of the matter
is,
all this is
purely theoretical;
The Jungian
know amthing
This
is
The
consulting
room
is,
more advanced
stages of analysis.
them
when even
WHOLE
I75
talking together
edge that
sufficient to tide
There
as a
is,
human
being.
believe
it
is
a mistake for
an analyst
make himself unreachable by telephone except during certain brief and specified hours. On the other hand I believe
to
it is
I
BOUNDARIES OF THE SOUL
176
this
He
\Vhen
am
low,
when my
*Tor God's
you Know."
That's
when
when
my magic is scattered,
my friends.
wife soothes my soul with
all
on each of
loving
sake, the
it's
rejection
for.
when he
craves to be alone
to let his
play witli
space,
all sorts
of notions
WHOLE
I77
rather the
onto your
that
who
not she
is
demon who
remember
to
it
the problem
is
plain to me.
is
li\'es
w^ife
same time
that at the
it
being projected
is
is
is
requires
it
many
but now
and
let
lest
this
let
those
it
stand as
who
it
is,
understand be quiet
is
in
my
heart,
let
away
to
my
with
me issue
my loving
my
wife
wife,
and
will
of the past.
not run
will stay
put
irresponsible,
I
in
ha\^e
that
but
will
all
as
so
wormy day
that
is
about to
close,
and already
There
is
no need
when he wrote
''let
those
he has said
who understand be
it
well
quiet.'' I
only
want
when
all
is
used. It
is
last
nearly as
lyS
PSYCHOLOGICAL TYPES
KEY TO
COMMUNICATIONS
A well-knowTi
actor
\\-as
former actors
offices.
And
The
moment, and then rean actor, like any other man, should take
an interest in government. But as far as running for office,
I don't think that is a good idea, because actors are essentially
actor thought about this for a
was then asked how he could consider a man who conan audience to be an introvert. To this he answered, "In acting, a man's greatest concern is placing himself
into the role of the character; that means he has to let the
feehng of that character affect him, he has to live it in a
ver\' personal way from his own insides. This requires knowing
yourself, for unless you know yourself you cannot really know
another person. Actually the audience is a relatively unimportant consideration to the actor as he masters his role. But
with politicians it is all different. There the game is to conquer
He
tinually faces
is
incidental.''
"introvert''
and
"extra-
.,
BOUNDARIES OF THE SOUL
l8o
He had
and
two basically different attitudes which charand called these attitude types extraversion
identified
acterize people,
introversion.
it
was the
fruit of
twenty
data.
way
He
became
described
a character-
how
the spirit
101
ci^dlization.
He
is
a collision
spirit.
is
on one
side to
man's animal
spirit
and
instinct are
in right harmony."^
Lea\Tng his concerns about the Freudian approach, creditit fully for its breakthrough on the side of freeing sexualit}^
from the repressiveness that had held it crippled, while at
the same time noting the limitations of the "Eros theory,"
Jung moved on to consideration of anotiier point of view.
This was Adler's "Individual Psycholog}%" which Jung charing
acterized
phrase
is
Nietzsche's,
a "yea-saying" to instinct which, carried to its extreme, resulted in his establishing for himself his own morality, which
l82
was characterized as 'iDeyond good and evil/' Nietzsche beHeved and wrote that he Uved his instinctual life in the highest
sense. But Jung saw this as an impossible contradiction. For
living the instinctual life suggests a simple naivete, expressing
directly
and without a
and
^i
We
more broadly
He
noted
preservation
of
self-
preservation.''^
According to Jung, Adler saw the instinct for selfpreservation as being expressed in a power instinct which
wants the ego to be in a controlling position under all circumstances and by whatever means. The "integrity of the personality" must be preserved at all costs. Adler stressed the
great need of the individual to meet every attempt or apparent
attempt of the environment to obtain dominancy over him.
Adler formulated his view of neurosis based as exclusively on
the power principle, as Freud's was based on the sexual question. Their views contrasted in a whole series of principles.
As Jung explained: "With Freud everything follows from
antecedent circumstances according to a rigorous causality,
The
with Adler everything is a teleological 'arrangement.'
Freudian method at once begins burrowing into the inner
causality of the sickness and its symptoms ... If, however,
we look at the same cUnical picture from the point of view
.
a different aspect.'"^
Then
it
becomes
it
assumes quite
183
own
his peculiarity."^
point of view.
184
from those
attitudes.
My
own
stemming
me
a basis
were
bom
The
father told
me
the
first
moment he saw
From
ment went
185
freed
to terms
came
to her teacher,
closely attached
on any aspect of
how
other,
by the
at a loss to understand
had to be made clear to this family bewould be any hope of a successful outcome to tlie
individual differences
fore there
psychotherapeutic
efforts.
Theories of t}Tpes are not new with Jung, but he was one
of the first to utilize typology as a therapeutic tool. Differences
in typology can be traced back to antiquity, as Heinrich Heine
has done
when he wrote
in Deutschland:
Plato and Aristotle! These are not merely two systems; they
are also types of
two
distinct natures,
opposed.
riven
by
is
and
essentially
astic, mystical,
it is
Though under
of Plato
and
Practical,
these ideas
different
names, always
we
speak. Enthusi-
Aristotle that
ordering,
and symbols a
the bottomless
Aristotelian
solid system, a
depths of their
dogma and
a cult.
The
l86
among
of
them
shelter-
ticism.ii
many
The
investigators
up
Most
of those
and
es-
who were
is
by the indi\ddual
sume
who
as-
and structure
the personality
traits
and tendencies
moment
of birtli.
Whatever
its basis,
The
typical
symptom
is
radically different
of that
is
cr}^
of exasperation
187
is
first
to
all
campus
The
areas of
life,
tlie
psychoanalytic circle
The
introverted nature
itualized,
and perceives
verted nature
is
is
Platonic in that
it is
mystical, spir-
Aristotelian in that
it
is
practical, a builder
of a solid system
ibb
the object
way
in the
lies
in
which
it aflfects
the subject. In
itself,
to a large
The
introvert's
is
more
socially oriented.
The
introvert
type.
may be
when what
is
sought
Then
the development
is
way.
It
must be made
clear
from the
start that
no one
is
alto-
demands
mental
he would
he would be
in a
be diagnosed
own
construction, in
many
respects bearing
reality.
But if he
would
matic
illness;
it
tempt to bend
his
at-
his
The
rest of us
who
189
call ourselves
it is still
true in
some
would rather
curl
up with
ball
and
dren.
The
is
who
child
him
that
circles,
The
to get out
and
little
disturbed,
The
it.
extravert,
He
is
many
are those
rewarded in contrast to the charown understanding of a role than he is in what others may think
of him. Then there are those who function with an eye toward
public acceptance: the advertising account executive, the politician, the businessman, the manufacturer of what the public
tainer, for instance,
acter actor,
who
is
is
richly
more
much
less
who
sells it.
How
and
types exist
190
The
unconscious, as
we have
also true in
a group,
person
who
is
members
of the group,
own emotional
reactions to
periences of other
is
in
ex-
nonetheless experi-
is happening
however he is unconscious of them. The unconscious carries
the opposing attitude, in this case introversion, which often
makes itself heard by coming out with a thoughtless or inappropriate remark, or by interrupting another person in order
to put forth an idea which has suddenly burst upon him with
encing his
what
unreasonable urgency.
As one
of
my
analysands put
my
it
to
me:
''Jung's
system of
considered non-rational,
when
the situation
IQl
sponding to
it.
re-
The
sensation
all details
sation function
directly,
seeing
employing
all
and the
sizes,
intuitive
shapes,
function.
colors,
The
hearing
sounds,
and
is
to gain
leading, that
is,
for
poorly developed).
The
and
feeling.
it is
To
When we
192
we mean
perior function.
employed,
tion
is
is
The
tlie
others
su-
The
superior func-
and mode of
oped and
tion
is,
relatively unconscious.
A person whose
superior func-
would be expected
function.
we now
If
tr)'
to put the
two
attitudes, introversion
and
and
types,
is
is
happen-
He
ing.
He
will
be competent
at
dependent on
feel-
ings,
tlie
life
may become
indirectly
life.
may
The
itself
m-
mean and
But
petty
if
I93
is
introverted,
its
him.
for
orientation
is
The
sake.
is
own
of ideas, yet
to
them to others. He
prove a point, and then he often
does
it
badly.
The
human
be protective ob-
to
relationships.
He
it is fitting
to
do
He
together in his jalopy and heads for the rock festival three
states
away,
or, if
he has made
it
a box at the opera and invites his friends. Jung was of the
opinion that as men comprise most extraverted thinking types,
comprise most extraverted feeling iyipes. He asfeeling tends to correspond with generally accepted values, that she loves a "suitable man'' because
he corresponds in standing, age and capacity with the requirements of society. Jung regarded her feeling as genuine, however, and not manufactured. It is natural to her to believe
that everything which corresponds to accepted valuation is
good.
so
do
women
serted that a
As
woman's
reflect that
this
notion about
recall
that his
women become
believe that
194
coming
may have
they
Nor
verted feeling.
whose
it
so
common
today to find
women
would become
woman's thinking
function is repressed we often find that she tends to form
her opinions on a scant basis of facts, and to use her charm
repressed and, as a force of the unconscious,
infantile, archaic
Men
way
them
it is,
immune from
are not
is
still
the
demand from
may
lead
him
to
become cold
and
when
it
extreme,
is
may
these people
tation
may
a need,
sacrificial,
P^'^
may assume
superior
a benevolent neutrality
and
I95
critical attitude.
We move now to a
The
he accepts, whether
He does not
always stop to take a "thought-out" position on it, nor does
he react strongly with his feelings. But he can describe a room
he has been in with accurate detail and has no trouble finding
his way when he has once traveled over the terrain.
The extroverted sensation type is that t}npe idealized by the
devotees of sensor\^-awareness. His life is an accumulation of
of the senses.
it is
Whatever he
sees or hears
the type
is
lives to eat,
excessive eating, or of
these days, to
his morality
who
is
life,
make
he
all
will
make much
of dressing in
a complete ensemble, or
he
make
\Vhen
his extra-
developed in the extreme, the compensation tends to appear in the form of certain specific neuroses.
Such a person may de\dop every sort of phobia, and especially
compulsive symptoms. These compulsions represent the un-
verted sensation
is
comes neurotic he
is
difficult
to rely heavily
on the attach-
196
ment
The
tlie
is
him
what the
senses convey
Looking at him from the outside, we can never tell what will
make an impression on this type of person; his reactions are
unpredictable and appear irrational because he sees what
him but
not
is
His unconscious
intuition is of an extraverted and archaic character. It has
an amazing flair for the ambiguous, gloomy and dangerous
before
is
really related to
it.
possibilities
worst
it is
At
as a process
which
extracts the
perception unconsciously, at the same time producing an unconscious effect in the object. Sensation as an inferior function
disturbs the intuitive's clear, naive perception with sensory
stimuli,
most accurate
encompass the
tries
to
greatest possibilities.
The
eye
is
bored with
for instance, to
He becomes
new
possibilities.
He
is
likely,
brief,
I97
ideas
is, if
to
The intuitive extravert can be the sucOften he is able to inspire other men. The
danger is that he will squander his energy animating others,
running after some new possibility, leaving his newly started
business for someone else to carry on and turn into a profitable
enterprise. Often he goes away empty. He also has the unconscious against him since in his enthusiasm he often represses
sensation of actual though painful realities. These then suddenly command his attention at the point where they have
is
cessful promoter.
become
The
destructive.
or the seer, or
As
tion.
unrestraint.
self-control
self is in
Who
artist,
and
the goal
feeling are
he him-
have described
their unconscious
198
is
then
may happen
is
superior anyway. It
becomes exag-
spondingly loses
its
structive.
One might
most
and therefore of
tance,
ness,
is
factor/'^^
is
The
secondary function
is
a relatively determining
is
though not antagonistic to, the leading funcremains relatively unconscious and it serves tlie leading
different from,
tion;
it
function.
is
most
effective
an exaggerated
tlie
intellectual, for
Jung sug-
Jung
said,
is
is
The
advantage,
possible
If his
is
is left
I99
By
a relatively
and simultaneous entrance into both conscious and unconscious functions; one that never loses touch with the one even
as it aims to modify or stimulate the other.
In actual practice I have found tliat very few people fall
into the distinct categories that
we have
outlined.
Most
rely
The
upon
many
of
The
one
is
question
is
when
who are experiencing marital difcouples who seem, potentially, to have
ficulties.
So often
see
everything going for them, and yet they are so cruel and disagreeable with one another that
much
despair of getting
less
them
is
a degree
outcome
200
They may be
of different t}poIogies.
if
each
one can recognize the vahdity of the views of the other, and
see the other's views as necessary to round out a more whole
approach to a set of circumstances, the two may begin to
consult each other before making a decision rather than fighting about it aftenvard. Each may learn from the other and
so increase his or her
own
ability to
respond in a variety of
own make-
own
intrinsic nature.
come
to a decision. Tliey
go into the
of each type.
Then
I believe,
who
is
I said,
"You
are a person
He
what
Vm
a sculptor."
said, ''So
comes
reality,
is
and that
is
for you.
The
much how
201
it, but
you when you conas you are constructing
struct your own reahty,
it/' I didn't use the term "introverted sensation" but I described the characteristics of this type^ and he recognized himself without any hesitancy whatever.
Then I turned to the young woman. "Are you happy in
not so
important thing
is
how you
yourself,
view
your work?''
it
it
what it does
and perceive it
for
asked her.
She repUed, "Oh, yes, it's really very satisfying and I enjoy
very much, and Fm good at it, Tm the best one in my
office."
Then
a well-known politician.
many
these many,
He
come
has a whole
letters that
come
"My
job
is
staflE
of us
in with
who answer
all sorts
of ques-
tions."
I
you
from someone
whom
you have
what his
hangups are, what his difficulties are, what kind of background
he has, what kind of help he needs, what his self-interest
demands, what kind of language will win his support. You
are able to project what you write into the future and somehow to realize how what you say will affect that person, how
tions,
it will
this
unknown
is
like,
it
from
person
whom
is,
\Vhen the
introverted sensation
agreements.
there are bound to be some distwo that when people are of opposite
b.'pe,
told these
it
were looking
world differently. I
with the following example: "Supposing you two
at a house." I said to the
202
living-room window."
And
to the
when we
disagree/"
This couple was able to see that there are two possible
ways to deal with the problem of typology. One is to allow
it to become an insurmountable barrier and to become resigned to the feeling that one type can never understand the
other. The second way is to recognize that each type provides
the other witli insights into the world which he would never
203
doing so to
fill
own
personality. In tlie
to work
he could not
it
enlarge their
In
my
see a
own
work
fingers,
as a psychotherapist, I rarely
Not long
when
am
who
life situation.
The
student wrote:
204
graduated from high school and
home
left
She
when
she's
reads
little,
dead
and
finer arts.
had
to find
work
He became
a plumber's apprentice
full
little
of feelings
is
205
tively accepting.
family and
is
Father
home
with his
children.
"What seems
vate
make
to
is
this
for
both
culti-
marriage so
'right'
the other.
While Father
is
a quality of
It
and
is
tries to
all its
relationships
is
The
own
basic typology
and
to live in
it.
result
was forthcoming. In
all,
all
pointless;
little
reward
him.
206
haunted him ever since. It remained so vivid that at the retelling he could recapture the feeling tone with all the intensity
that there had been when the dream occurred. It was altogether an auditory dream. There was no visual image whatsoever. This is the dream: J was asleep, I heard vague music
off in the background. It sounded like something that could
only have been composed by Wagner. There were the deep
sonorous tones, with really beautiful crescendos. The music
grew louder and louder. At first I was fascinated, then I began
to be afraid because the music w^as uncontrollable. It continued to increase in volume and depth, louder and louder. I
got the shivers and the shakes and I had to force myself to
wake, and I woke up in a sweat, in a real panic. As I became
fully awake the music stopped, and I gradually began to calm
down. As I started to drift back to sleep the music began
again. It was more quiet now, but slowly s^velling and becom-
returned,
I forced myself
awake again.
tlie
been a musician,
207
wish I had
dream, James commented,
then I could have \^Titten down this
'1
for
music."
The dream
the dreamer; he
is
medical school.
The kind
208
dramas of mankind. If the dreamer could sink into the meanmyth which is given voice in the music, he would
find a way of experiencing his life as more than a mass of
petty details. He would begin to envision the larger plan, the
archetypal model of man, into which every detail may be seen
ing of the
to
fit,
The theme
But the
music would become loud and insistent and demanding,
nearly deafening, when he would become too one-sided, and
not let his real nature have the space it needed to stay alive.
The dream of music became for him a sort of inner gyroscope;
it would help him to measure his inclinations and it would
sen'C as a guide for him on the path toward individuation.
exercising perforce the less differentiated functions.
The concept
we come
is
way
to the unconscious
music in James' dream, act as unconscious "regulators,'' springing into action whenever there is a psychic imbalance. It is
only from this angle that Jung's theor}^ of psychological types
can be properly understood. "These t^pes are not static posi-
but
of behavior
."^^
8
PERSONA
AND SHADOW
A
very proper
a respectable conservative
We
and meaning
are defined
by the
society.
Jung wrote:
is
more
or less
we make
210
the mistake of accepting
But, as
a
its
mask
name
shows,
it
it is
in toto as
something "individual."
is
individual, whereas
make
one
is
others
and
simply play-
When we
we
at
is
was only a
Fundamentally the persona is nothing real: it is a
compromise between the individual and society as to what a
man should appear to be. He takes a name, earns a title, represents an office, he is this or that. In a certain sense all this
in other words, that the persona
tive psyche.
is real,
concerned
in
it is
only a secondary'
making which
persona
is
product of compromise,
The
The symbols
appear in dreams as
may
reality, a
take on
tlie characteristics
may
they
of a profession or trade, as
common
in
all
parts of society,
fit.
Thus the
"identit}^ crisis"
functioning well,
they
tell
many
themselves. "I
am
it.
"I
am
that,"
a doctor, or a schoolteacher, or a
and
will let
you know
word wdth
me."
This was the case with my patient, a priest in a large
suburban church. He came to one analytic session carrying
a letter in his hand, and evidently quite upset about it. Tlie
211
recently retired
lav^yer
to keep
life,
who
him
and he
The
letter
many
ended, "I
am
lawyers in the
would
listened
We
practices
212
collar.
it
clear
he
be treated with proper respect. Even the policeman who
stops him for speeding waves him on with a smile, when he
is
to
sees
the garb, or
lets
him
off,
suggesting,
comes
he
'Tm
sure you're
a pair of slacks.
He
lawyer's, idea of
how
t\^pically
Leo had
who assumes
is
that of an indi\idual
is
not to say that he doffs his beliefs or his concern with matters
of the spirit when he takes off his collar, not by any means.
am
but
and then
jolly
21
him
214
in
of maintain-
of
who was
what was
sense of
stro
own
sci(
valuable.
a certain
of receiving stimuli
is
also recei\ing
and sometimes
is
in conflict with
it.
is
participating,
always to
demands
that are
of the
As we have
and consequently
collective that
is
way
charac-
teristic
for
its
role.
It
self,
is
|
not
directly.
is
chiefly manifest
21
is
own means of expression, though, particularly in prowe cannot admit in ourselves we often find
others. If, when an indi\idual speaks of another person
finds
its
jections. ^V^lat
in
The shadow
personalit}',
is
for
without
it.
Jung writes:
a moral problem that challenges the whole egono one can become conscious of the shadow
To become
conscious of
it
in-
and
and
real.
it
Indeed,
This act
self-knowledge
quently requires
period.
is
much
as
psychotherapeutic
measure
fre-
21
An
elementaty'School principal,
whom we
tlie
will call
case of
Brian B.
an
On
was
man
described himself to
He
me
as 'Very lucky."
"Things always go
me know
that he had a
knew
when
manelous
promote a new
program, when to hold off. He handled his facult}^ well, was
popular with the students, put in long hours at his work, and
frequently received commendation from the school board.
He came to me, he explained carefully, not because of himself but because of marital difEculties. (I have long ago learned
to beware of the patient who comes into therapy to learn
to live \nth somebody else's problems!) His wife, he said,
was grouchy and irritable, and she constantly belittled him
in public. She had a mania for neatness which he could not
abide, and she was quite independent and controlling. He
said that he would like to get out of his marriage, except
that it would probably cost him his position which is very
important to him, so much so tliat he could not turn it off.
Often in tlie evenings he attended the sports events at school
or meetings of various sorts, and many weekends were consumed with outings and camping trips with students. Hardly
much to criticize here, especially from tlie communit^^'s point
for me,''
he
said.
let
of
just
to
vie\^-!
spect
women and
moral standards.
He was
brought up to
re-
tivity' was within the structure of marriage, and that the purpose of sex begins and ends with procreation. E\idently the
idea of sex as recreation had never occurred to him.
Outside of sexual relations once with a prostitute while he
2I7
As he put it, he got carried away \nth his emotions one night,
and as a result she became pregnant. He married her because
"it was the gentlemanly thing to do/' But there had been
little sex in the marriage he did not especially want it. His
bored wife had had a brief extramarital affair. He scolded her
as he would a naught}- student, then promptly forgave her.
The impression he gave me was, he just can't be that good!
If he were, I asked myself, why would his wife have been
so obviously unhappy with him? ^V^ly had she become pregnant by him in the first place? Surely she was not that naive?
What
when
she
Brian B. told
a
dream
me
of being in a fight: I
meet someone
It
dont
was
like.
that
tion in the
first
The obvious
make it sexhim an aggres-
reductive interpretation
is
sion
21
tence,
fear
the unconscious.
The
if
he didn't
He
"they''
all
got from
him was
want
really
I felt like
to do, all
replying,
"Whom
invincible.
few days
after
he had recounted
me
some
this incident
scratches
on
he came
his face.
He
21
He went
had
in\'ited
it
to break through.
The
for
some
situation
which
tum-of-the-centur}^ French
220
men-
awareness.
is
of-balance persona.
Early in analysis
it
may be
tries to
maintain
its
seem
of himself.
tically,
as the
image
more
fran-
pressure on
guns.
it
Someone
netting.
He
infantry.
We
also
had antutank
down
the
undoing our work and saw him going over to his house we
blew it up with an anti-tank gun. Then the scene changes.
Fm on the second floor looking out the window in the morru
ing and I see two or three elephants busily tearing up the
electric wiring and the camouflage. They are under the direction of several men. For some unknown reason there is no
glass in the windows where there should be. I rush over and
pull the switch.
to their trunks.
the wire from their trunks with the help of their feet. One
of the men tells the elephants to find the switch. Apparently
their feet insulate
them
One
dow where
as
am and
felt sure
a switch. I
221
the psyche
from the onslaught of the unconscious factors that were long
repressed and had an untold amount of strength bound up
in them. Electricity is the image provided by the dream to
evoke the concept of the life energy which is, in this patient,
all directed to protecting his house (his psychic structure)
from destruction. There are also the anti-tank guns, instruments of attack which seek to destroy that shadow element
of his personality, the one who is trying to undo the work
of the defense. And even though the initial battle is won,
it is of no avail, for in the moment he is asleep (unconscious)
the electric-wiring-defense is again attacked, but this time by
vast, inhuman forces. The elephants seem to belong more to
had no
specific
meaning
the patient.
was
It
as
Once the
The
fantasies
and
An
i.e.,
and spatial
enormous speed and extension of movement, "astrological" associations, telluric, lunar and solar analogies, changes in
are connected with cosmic qualities, such as temporal
infinity,
The
obvious application of
The wealth
unconscious
sona there
nothing
is
else
With
which
is
apparently
dreamed
of before.
But
uncon-
222
becomes
it
mind
led,
loses
its
power of
leader-
Now we
may
is
when
The
may be an
them
at bay.
hopeful element
man
him accomplish
may be
this necessity
He
tells
prime consideration
is
diffi-
cannot be cured
by
mands
so
number, adaptation
much work
is
artificially
induced
223
and there
an anguish
beyond comprehension.
has given
way
What
It is
it.
has happened
is
But
power
of conxiction
and gave
How will
life
and
fails
life
new
direction."^
to offer a
new way
is
in
its
the crucial
question.
several possibilities.
One
is
and
When
morbid
this
Then
interested.
224
third
way
is
"regressive restoration of
built
up
which destroys
all
Such
some
destruc-
a person, deeply
wounded
as
has
in
it
Such a
him
to do.'"^
man
will utilize
most
meas-
own
more
of
what he
sets
out to
An
fails to
which dog
your
it
to consciousness: this
22
it
relates
and then, when the shadow is laid to rest can assume that
he is able to go on to the finer and more glorious aspects
of the analysis. The shadow is, in truth, a de\ilish form, and
just \^hen you think you know who he is, he changes his
disguise and appears from another direction. So it is, in the
Jungian analysis, that the analysand
process, that of looking \\ithin,
is
to reflect
Nor,
it.
must add,
of the shadow. It
as
long as he
is
is
is
an
the analyst
immune from
the onslaught
and probably
as long as
he
lives.
own unconscious
^^hat is
contents that he
is
a reflection of his
projecting
onto the
shadow projection
226
ing analysis which
is
We
as
common
of the
from
a lounge chair
We
227
is
much
less to nations.
This
is
blame
not to sug-
most
own
critical of himself,
flaws
and
toward
who
social justice
is
will
be most
the one
who
He
will
effective by setting an example, than by bludgeoning his opponent into submission. The person who commits himself to
life
the outside]!"
In and
Yo not
The
ancient
dial
wholeness which
into two,
myth
with a primor-
power of
fills
the
world
is
There
is
posites in
an archetypal need,
our
lives
as
human
also, for a
beings. This
230
men and
women, which
is
and every
creativeness.
woman
man
we develop our
as a
becomes
or
To
say,
up
largely unconscious,
The
also experienced as
all
and
con-
man
as a
man
or
remains
woman.
we
It
important
that
we
We
roles
carry in us.
must go back
woman, both
poses
woman from
tuned in to
and
physically
the
spiritually.
start, just as it
is
and recog-
man
water, light,
presup-
His system is
is prepared for
woman
air,
salt,
presup-
Our
so.
which contributes
to the
The young
but he derives
his
own
These
and
also
to love
in
dis-
23
little
his
mother
knitting.
is
Alone
in his
when his mothbe praised for his cleverness. The ladies laugh derisively at him.
A girl is asked by her grandmother what she wants to be
when she grows up, and she answers "a doctor." Grandmother
looks at her and with a smile of saccharine wisdom says, "You
he brings out
gether. Proudly
er's
bridge club
mean
is
his production
there, expecting to
five-year-old
its
temptations.
Tlius
we can
tribute to the
development of
a contrasexual
so function
only
is
are po-
232
that one
The
of the
is
longing
is
not
unknown and
all.
There
may
is
is
all
be, unconsciously.
The
the incomprehensible.
to the instincts.
man
for the
is
The
them
human
other
just as
he
crucial primordial
is
ages have
and
man
is
a biological heir
image or archetype
phenomenon
is
to
be found
in the
figures of the
artistic
parent in the
rites,
disturbed.^
archetype
gi\'es
rise to
many
different
The Mother
233
tlie
depths
the
damp darknessso
it is
woman,
come
to
know
women
and which
intimately,
experience and
blood, with
its
life,
it is
r
I
of her own.
new
The
who
event
is
is
now
tions
is
that
woman
of time, during
a
man
experiences
experiences tliese
through her.
them over
which something
Woman
is
a protracted period
there,
and
is
234
a
woman
she
is
and stops
more
activity, a
may
And
tions
man
because he
less at
even though, in our day, many of the biological restricwhich women have felt as impositions have been greatly
woman who
lightened, the
them
may
is
just as
Furthermore, the
them and
woman who
same degree
carry
must
all
may
this
as that of a
also
woman.
said,
be intense, but
'The
if
she
it is
in-
rarely to tlie
Society teaches a
woman
not
is
man's
man
re-
instinctive.
Women
think
him
it
and during
tliat
time
him, to
fill
no part of his conscious adaptation that inwhole man. He seeks his opposite in
projected form, in a woman who will embody for him what
he cannot be for himself.
Sometimes a man whose work demands a certain toughness
and practicahty and allows no room for sentiment or iuzz)^
because there
voh'cs
him
is
fully as a
feel
complete. She
may
woman
woman who
tlie
for the
anima
235
whom
with
who
he
as long as
will
man's
most suitable for him
her power over him for
is
he
is
the unconscious, the side which he cannot live out. She will
him
create in
may be
way he attempts
life.
man
is
is
same
competent
is
not so
likely to
areas in
appeal to
him
ition,
grace,
other
traits
women
difficulty
is
and many
when
that
which
these 'rights' can be exercised, they tend to feel trivial. For
example, women are allowed to be emotional, but their emotions are seldom given full play in the political arena where
they might bring about significant change. Women are allowed to cultivate and express aesthetic values in their clothes
and appearance, but are discouraged from becoming fashion
are deprived of a significant context within
designers.
them
seem that
men
insist that
women
is
a fear that
women
As
a whole,
it
would
tal-
this in-
One
236
to nature.
women
man, he would
to her
need to
find himself
more
sensitive to
woman and
own which
A man who
to use
women
re-
activity, de-
and determination.
and
own
gratification
He
may,
may be
ut-
Playboy
suggests, make elaborate preparations to stock his kitchen with
the most elegant delicacies to support the seduction scene.
The game is not only to get her to submit herself to him
but to make her enjoy it in the process. Soft music from
all four comers of the room alert her sensibilities, and gentle
wines are there to blunt her inhibitions, so that she will allow
herself to be taken, and I do mean "taken." He does not
expose himself to her total self, but only to her sexual self,
an area in which it is clearly understood that he will be the
terly
leader
follower.
However
who
man
desires
it is
as
enthusiastically she
may
cannot really respond fully in sexual intersupposed to be the way to get along with men.
The need in tliis sort of man to dominate his woman arises
out of his basic fear that he will not be able to control her
to "fake it"
course. This
if
if tliey
is
she ever realizes the power that she has witliin her. It
to help a
man
is
237
that concerns him, but his need of her in order to find total
He
fulfillment.
woman
encouragement,
home
when he
is
fretful,
He
them how
them
own
to all
relation-
somehow
made him
feel
well-spoken,
238
of crossing.
ment
that
if
am
woman
state-
before
my
have to pick up
do
so.
But
pace
as I pick
effort I
239
pect
only one of
is
The
strange thing
many ways
is
all
her
terrors,
is
in the
attitude
is
is
why
she
is all
not.
lives in woman as the element of the unconwhich corresponds to man's anima. The animus repre-
The animus
scious
sents for woman all that her conscious attitude is not. This
means, quite naturally, that the animus is ver}^ different in its
nature from the anima, ha\ing a different psychological basis.
To understand something of what the animus is, it is first
necessar\^ to
that
we need
to get
is.
By
of our cultural
experiences
it is
mean
240
and what happens here filters through and has its effects
upon all the events which occur throughout tlie existence
of the individual.
Woman's
knows
first
experience of herself
is
as a girl-child
who
even
of
life,
of
womanness
if
nothing
is
is. The
woman is
else
that a
daughter's
the one
first
who
experience
is
there to
To
all this
that
just a
it
is
member
is
is
not assured
outside of
fully
participating
grows up.
It is
she will be a
of father-world.
full
member
positions of authority
and control
is
as it
that,
if
much
access to
and
is
of society with as
home and
family
if
may have
to forego marriage or
for tenderness
is
just the
problem. Girls
at least
From
to achieve
shown
more or
less
24
"YouVe come
of a
woman who
the
Animus
is
for a
woman
It is
woman
has
242
of the one
who
home,
the authority to
Animus
in a
woman
facts, gaining
make the
de-
the
animus can
is
his "castle;'
also
repressed,
ity.
function
may come
is,
clarifying facts
man-woman
of four:
this
He
a single relationship
distinguishes
between the
ANLMA
ANIMUS
fol-
'0M^
An
(2)
243
man
to his
anima and
of the
animus to the
man and
of the
is, it
occurs
when one
relates to
is
what
relatively
tween them.
The
to
relationship of the
man
to his
anima or the
woman
may
man, and
play a role
in
or
anima image
How
is
A man
has de-
woman, including
will behave. WTien
part at least,
particulars.
244
As long
'!^.^
lationship" corresponds to
Nor
who
is
partners
and so one partner feels deceived while the other feels put
upon with demands. Is it any wonder that so often one sex
fails
The
when
the traditional
is
able
to
The
low that
nature.
parallel
side in
The
trasexual aspect
man
him which
to a certain
woman
or the
woman
attracts
to a certain
man.
'
MAUREEN
K.us;ioo
u.TM CShioKjS
CHARLES
DOLORES
^^
-r^iy:,Ka
r^O<M'?gV-~S&i::^^
^S^
\;^,,,iiap^-'
( i^rt'^f^A
'(>$
;Js
ufc
are
'
'
|i
245
^^hat
is
he or she
loves,
and each
strives
relationship.
Still,
is
woman
is
is
woman,
man
man.
Then
the
or the animus
If this
happens,
all
women:
nagging, stubbornness,
like.
Woman
man-woman
relation-
between animus and anima. It is a relationship on an unconscious level; men and w^omen are controlled by it, and never know why or how it happens. Over
and over again I see this in my practice, especially when I am
dealing with couples who, on the surface at least, seem to
have everything going for them. But for some unconscious
reason they are desperately unhappy with each other. The
woman's animus takes over the relationship, derides the man
for all that he is not and cannot be and never w^as. At the
same time his anima takes over from his side wdth petuship, the relationship
lance,
women
."
which indicate
"all
weak
246
An
attractive career
woman
an
actor.
was
to marry.
man
all the wary suspicion of a businessabout to be taken over in an exploitative merger, her
of functioning,
the
the
and
likewise the
woman
mode
is
Such people, with the ever-widening consciousmodes of functioning encourage, are able to meet
the opposite sex, and indeed, the world, without antagonism.
They are able to participate in unconscious communication
with other people which takes place on a level so deep that
only its effects are perceptible, and those not always. In close
relationships their unconscious communication is responsible
for the feeling of knowing what the other is thinking, for
for her rights.
ness their
who may be
very far away, for nameless anxieties and fears that often
accompany love
relationships,
and
247
relationship of
all
the
is,
at
all its
Although
this
is
come
to
most
We
me
am
to
I
is
felt as
being
woman,
I
desirable.
the
in
interested
latter
my
since,
directly.
being a
Therefore
The anima
came
to the fore in a
tlie
in his
life:
of opposites.
right
all
The anima
the world,
is
The
is
sire.
is
248
full
payment
in
advance.
Simon Magus must have had his soul torn apart in much this
manner when he first ran across his Helen in a brothel. I think
I know what it's like. This Helen appears before me in flesh
and blood recurrently, and I am almost helpless before her.
T}pically she
is
little heart.**
The
student
way which
who
wrote
learn
with
free your
women
in a
showed that
his
additional money.
whether
his
means
They became
less
He
make
and
less so.
He
ANIAIA
AND ANIMUS
249
trapeze bar by
abyss. I
am
same time
my
up by
bouncing a
my
from falling, as well as maintaining my own balsometimes goes forward, sometimes backward,
and I have to maneuver the bar so that it will touch the ball
on its descent and bounce it up again, I feel myself getting
keeping
ance.
it
The
ball
is
it is
balance, for
ball, in
The
string
other words
free-floating. I
my
a string.
ball,
it is
with both hands, let alone with one hand. I realize that sooner
or later I will probably have to let go of the ball. There is a
Wayne's
it.
awaken
in panic.
250
it
became
the
ply,
twist
"Let her go, the only thing is to let her go.'' The ironic
was that the dream also warned that he might ha\'e to
Events
tliat
He did break
with the woman, but there continued to be
a strong pull on him from her direction. For quite a long
time he found it extremely diEcult to stay away from her.
accurate in portraying the dreamer's condition.
off his relationship
when he
least
expected
itself
upon
his
thoughts, often
it.
25I
We
way
the
conscious.
out.
Now
still
more
in
it
all,
he had withdrawn
not
would have
own
another
to understand the
still
smarting, he did
woman
to carry
anima as the
it.
He
bearer of his
own needs
whether they originated
within himself or were presented to him by other people.
The anima at her best has the capacity to further relationships
to hear the needs of other people, not merely his
new
ideas,
way
to
Wayne
make them
a part of his
own
conscious
of functioning. For
him
be
way
252
ser\'e
him
come
to this
he needed
to develop his
own
and
sensation
feel-
somehow be
him by
transmitted to
woman.
first
man upon
me
to
And
chological relationship
becomes
or for
an indeterminate span.
when
of
common
than not.
as a relationship
it
when
I
may
stemmed from an
It
life
like.
This
unrealistic
may seem
do not think
it is
view
preposteris
more
preposterous. As long
ties
of tenderness
and
feeling.
253
rela-
increasingly in-
new
thing
to fascinate
marriage there
there
is
not so
is
much
of people
It is
and
not so
easily turn
relationship,
\\ill
life all
become more
real in
the
becomes more
not the
is
each really
come
is,
but often a
when
to
for
what
crisis
when
the
home and
first
time in
years instead
in a different
way and
now
many
on the subject
of
man-woman
much
attention from
relationships.
Marriage
amy
grown
Monog-
2 54
more
otlicis
development.^
My own feehng
is,
anima-animus con-
cept,
that
if
broken
errors again
whom
then takes
productivity, so
her in her
life. Tliis
and grow on
its
own
all is
warm and
not
let it live
end,
she
lost, for
if
come
to
an
respondence kept
2^$
fast-moving group of
were purely hedonistic, not really what Brad was looking for
at this time of his life. The image of Andrea remained before
him, as if to urge him to continue on the project that he had
been working on for a long time, but which he had not
touched during the last year of his unhappy marriage.
Brad's first dream: I come into an old mined house. It has
been burnt out, only a shell is left and some charred remains.
The light in the stairwell is still burning. Andrea is on the top
floor but I cannot reach her, I can only get part wcry up the
stairs, the rest is burnt out and there is this hiatus betM'cen
us. However, on the level where I stand is my friend fames,
and I am able to go and meet him.
A few days later a second dream followed: 'There are many
people, men and women, taking nude sJiowers together. Ihey
ask me to join, but I hold back until all are finished and gone,
and then I take my nude shower alone. Andrea appears and
sees me taking the shower through a glass window. Slie comes
into the room and embraces me.
line first dream showed the ruins of his own psyche after
when
criminate intimacy was put aside (the shower was taken separately),
alone witli-
256
his
And
him.
special
instruction."
Jill,
ship,
not only
as a personal transac-
interchange. Here
is
my
body, uniting
my
is
its
rim the
circle
along which
dimensions only
when he
is
there to
make
the form, to
let
257
the feelings exist on more than one plane. Inside the cone
a whirlpool, eddying into the vortex at
turns into
fire.
The
its
point,
where water
Beyond
that every-
blackness until a thin spun glass shaft of silver glittering in the blackness with the sparkling colors of simlight
thing
is
in a tiny prism
.
The body
is
points have
own
their
When
he touches
skin
at the
is
energy but
when
a flow, a movement.
collective un-
in her
resting
some days was able to carry on her work smoothly and effecbut on other days she tended to be depressed, slow,
withdrawn. At those times when people approached her she
was apt to snap back with some thoughtless remark or impatively,
came
in response to
someone
258
become
men
away, and
then she would become relatively non-functional. In her writings she was able to move away from her purely subjective
experience and to relate to it as though she were a spectator.
She could see the masculine element in the relationship, as
well as the feminine. \Vhen I asked her how it was possible
to do that she was amazed to recognize how easily it had
come to her, without ha\dng strained to understand. It
was more nearly like an automatic sort of wTiting, as tliough
a channel had opened for her which was not ordinarily accessible to her. She had not only felt herself as the huge hilllike mountain, immobile and heaw, she had also felt the
volatile sliver of sunlight finding its way swiftly into tlie dark
places. Could Jill have imagined that she had been able to
experience that, as an objective happening, only because it
had been already present in her, waiting to be actuahzed?
No, she was not yet prepared for this. Under the cloak of
the sexual relationship she was really seeking the warm and
supportive relationship she had had with her father when
she w^as a little girl, the tenderness which had been snatched
away when her father had left her and her mother to go off
on his own. The pattern of the passive little girl to w^hom
exciting things would happen if she w^ould be still and be
good w^s never altogether broken. For her, the "good" depended on receiving it from a man. She saw^ herself as instrument, the harmonies and vibrations needed to be released by
someone else though she had all the potentialities within herself, she w^as convinced that she could not use them without
help from a man.
In the analysis it was necessary for me to help Jill to get
unbound from her state of confusion with the animus nearly
an undifferentiated chaotic state in which ego and animus
were mixed together, unable to be seen in their separate ways
had a difficult time
of contriburing to a total enterprise.
in dealing with the transference in the analysis. Jill had ahvays
seemed terribly afraid of me. I had been aware that although
she appeared open a good deal of the time, there w^ould be
times when she would close up and look at me as though
We
259
were about to put a gun at her head and pull the trigger.
was something extremely irrational here, which
needed to be brought out. Early in her therapy she had spoken
about some sexual advances which her father had made to
her when she was five or six. Her description did not make
the incidents sound terribly traumatic, in fact I had the distinct impression that the fondling of her genitals had been
pleasurable to her, and that she may even have solicited it
some of the time. I had asked her where her mother was
when this was going on her mother had worked away from
I
realized there
home
in the evenings, and this father-daughter sexual achad occurred mostly while the father was putting his
daughter to bed at night. If, as in our culture, we were not
so thoroughly conditioned to erupt like a volcano whenever
anything approaches the incest problem, we would not consider this the sort of psychological trauma that would necessarily have to damage a child for life. Yet, always, I had the feel-
the
tivity
Jill
it
fear reaction to
me seemed
not
26o
AND ANIMUS
ANIISIA
from
its
261
made
feel
the separation.
a remark
ago, a remark
miss
I
must
say,
that.''
find in
my work
their
most intimate
thoughts the truth of the adage that the more things change
the more they are the same. This is particularly applicable
to the anima-animus problem.
who
see
it
most
in dealing with
and not
at all
Even
youth
among
porters of
women's
liberation
among both
no question about
sexes,
it
it, it is still
is
still
man's
Men
are in
all
and most
from 1900 to 1968 the ratio of male college graduates to female ranged between three to one in 1900 to four to three
in 1968, with the exception of the years of
when women
World War
262
But
women
degrees at
men
tlie
six
completing
times as
many
'^
Whether
it
is
ability,
or
What
ago
is
Jung stated in
still
this
still
we are now
momentous change. He wTOte:
woman
is
man
fields of
experience in a
has
little interest.
and interesting to her than objective facts and their interconnections. The wide fields of commerce, politics, technolog\\ and
science, the whole realm of the applied masculine mind, she
relegates to the penumbra of consciousness; while, on the other
hand, she develops a minute consciousness of personal relationships, the infinite nuances of which usually escape the man entirely.
263
us
to
While
woman
is
generally
woman
values
he
is
sick or
264
issue.
The anima
had ever been imagined before. Also, TOth increasing industrialization and consequent reduction in the hours of the typical
work week, there is time for those who wish to use it to come
closer to the unconscious dimensions of their beings.
It
seems to
greater effort to
me
be made by
women
in the direction of
coming
became
this
is
and
if so,
woman's
At the bottom
much of it happen
alities for
fulfillment.
of
to her.
ANITvIA
AND
265
ANIISIUS
pregnan-
except by refusing sexual relations. In the past, many professional women with high levels of education were women
cies,
who had
of about 25,000
in universities
and four-year
colleges,
more than
half
had never
women
childless
my
woman
herself.
practice
am
woman
However, one
why can't
One of
role thoroughly.
266
confronted
him
directly.
He
refused
to
reply
to
her
charges,
emerging in her.
It did not take very much analysis for Dorothy to recognize
that she had "let it happen.'' She had all too eagerly given
up her own interests in the world outside of the home and
indeed in herself as a worthwhile person. Her perfectionist
267
to stay
home
268
go''
of him,
relationship
first
other to
Not
herself.
fill
own
personality development.
woman needs to go
But many women do need
every
to
work
in order to find
to explore the
animus
di-
mension of
fructifying
receptive to
new
possibilities.
own
role as the
one-sided
one
pre-
hostility that
accompanies unreasonable
"rights
and
the opposite sex only. Neither course can lead to inner har-
bound together
in a sacred un-
Without
With
may
surface
it,
each person
felt
and become
feels
enslaved in
visible.
The
truth seems to
side of
paradox
'^^
r'
^
t\
may
Self, of
Jan
is
269
is
not
really '"outside"
self is
is
although
the greater
a part, a participant,
known
to us, the
Self.
10
CIRCUMAMBULATING
THE SELF
Infused with the energy that
is
now
all
some purposive
force, a force
272
sun. So one
tlie
enough
The
is,
is
subordinate. Self, as
refer to Jung's
typal experience.
We
the ego
|a^'
273
to discover
is
ways of learning
God
is
its
One way
am
not so sure that in their essentials these two ways are so fundamentally different. At the beginning of analysis the patient
brings his
very
much
symptoms and
like the child
places
who
them
when we speak
of the unknowable.
In the beginnings of
human
and
otherness.
ber of ways;
it
stated in an endless
man from
num-
who
God from
tlie
274
was apparent
and mystical alchemists. For
this reason
texts.
undifferentiated
It
self.
Of
it
it
\s
is
con-
incorrect
maintain that the alchemists never said what the prima maon the contrary, they gave all too many indications and
so were everlastingly contradicting themselves. For one alchemist
the prima materia was quicksilver, for others it was ore, iron,
to
teria was;
water of
shadow,
.
sea,
air,
fire,
earth, blood,
sky, dew,
mother, moon, dragon, Venus, chaos, or microcosm
life,
lapis
[stone],
poison,
spirit,
cloud,
a deeper
"man,"
or
"Hades"
or a "part of
275
man."3
is
''greater
than great/'
there
be
it
is
related
is
with
he was sent to
years old
he was
a teacher,
all the V^edas, he returned home full of conceit in the belief that
he was consummately well educated, and vei)-- censorious.
His father said to him, "Svetaketu, my child, you who are so
full of your leaming and so censorious, have you asked for that
knowledge by which we hear the unbearable, by which we perceive what cannot be perceived and know what cannot be
kno\\Ti?"
"What
is
"But
this
knowledge; for
they possessed
if
it
is
broken,
seeds,
mine
is
that knowl-
are ignorant of
that knowledge."
And he
said,
"Bring
me
sir/'
"WTiat do you
"Some
child,
me
to
"It
my
see there?"
sir,
exceedingly small."
is
broken,
sir."
The
father said,
"My
which you do
tlie
276
huge nyagrodha
has
exists
its
tree.
In that which
That
self.
is
is
is
all
that
"Pray,
'*Be
sir," said
my
it so,
The son
the son,
more."
and he said, "Place
tomorrow morning."
and come
to
me
me
**tell
me
in the water."
The
had
course,
The
it,
it;
dissolved.
of the vessel.
How
is
some
it?"
"Salty."
How
is
How
is
it?"
"Salty."
it?"
"Salt}'."
The
me
to
father said,
"Throw
come back
again."
ever.
Then
my
the father
son,
That."^
self.
the
human
an
entit}^ as
The
is
is
the archetype
the element in
which it is a part,
hands separate from
the body, although they are agents of the authority which
resides in the body and directs their movements. The separation of the ego from the self is a separation that is made
is
capable of conceiving of
tlie
is
Nor
body
of
are tlie
277
relations.
is
a process of
unit of
and
we
later separate
from
if."
all
We
strive to attain
our individuality,
family.
The
is
clude, as
we have
the unconscious.
unconscious
is
The
and
ment.
it
works well,
we
world
CI-
278
what he is fitted
away his energies in
by
own
nights doing
for
frittering
his
nature, without
grets.
If
analysis
are
first
reasonably
well
fulfilled,
aims
different
will
emerge during the second half or the later stages. While the
first part is directed toward achievement, the second part is
directed toward integration. Where the first part is directed
toward emergence as an individual, the second part is directed
toward harmony with the totality of being. In the beginning,
the ego arises out of the depths of the unconscious. In the
end, the ego surrenders to those depths. That is why the
ancient Hebrews were told to rejoice when death comes to a
friend, and to mourn at a birth for it is a fearsome thing
to send a ship forth on a voyage to an unknown destination,
but a glad welcome is due when the ship returns at last to its
home
port.
glimpse of what
impossible goal
is
it
would be
like to achieve a
seemingly
glimpse
itself.
Or,
it
may
may
occur
may become
it may
belief in a personal
ment
witli
a strong
As Vincent studied
sci-
279
and
28o
dream, had experienced an archetypal conevent in his hfe had led him to discover
what the experience was all about, if not to understand it.
Through his analysis Vincent was able to accept that the
woman in his dream was a representation of the anima, who
leads man to his unconscious depths if he will but dare to
approach her in all her beauty and sometimes terror. The
rock symbolized the basis, the solid, unchangeable impenetraat the time of the
figuration.
Then some
ble reality
which
trate
in
this task,
and when
it
does there
The
is
self
challenges
The
This
self is
is
is
undertaken consciously,
commitment
any goal which goes beyond the merely personal. The self
is the whole of psychic totality, incorporating both consciousness and the unconscious; it is also the center of this totalit}\
The ego belongs to it and is part of it, the ego being the
whole of consciousness at any given moment and also the
to
organ that
From
is
tlie
informal kind
is
wisdom;
(empirical experience).
this
is
essentially
The second
category'
the understanding of
human
own
of the ego,
From
is
individuation
toward
its
is
quite different.
self,
Where
however,
tlie
goal of
self is
251
unknown and
of the
final battle is
What
then,
the
it
thus to increase
self.
may be
asked,
is
the point of
all
the struggle
WTiy undertake the wear\ing and often fearsome joumey? WTiy strain and strive and seek to know more,
when knowing more is only to open the gates to deeper mysteries? I have often pondered this question myself, and especially in my writing, as I ask myself what possesses me to sit
for awareness?
my
t}pe\rater
a singing blue
self in
your
own
I did take
time out from writing to watch the landing of the Apollo 1
mission on the moon, and to hear Astronaut Dave Scott proclaim as he set foot on the lunar surface: ".\s I stand out here
202
who
all
undertake
heroic in
all
it
of us, else
we could not
is
and though
a touch of the
dangerous and
live in this
desperate world.
its
way between
The
it
other.
The
this
is
all
The Jungian
a methodical
analysis does
not follow a
process,
and
set
it is
sona
is
on the
surface,
who produces
it is
it.
it
leads,
What-
the
initial session,
the time
it
as
dream
figures
who
who
tasies or
we know
283
they
may be
may be
we apply
dream
fig-
myths and
legends, or they may strike a responsive note when we meet
them for the first time in literature or on the stage or screen.
Or they may be brought up from our own depths through
specific techniques which are used in analysis to probe the
unconscious. While the figures appear to be individual, they
reflect the archet}T>al background of the unconscious which
gives rise to their formation. In this sense they may be thought
people.
to us out of forgotten
of as archet}^pal figures.
These archetypal
figures
came
to
be
cr\'stallized
him by
by Jung as
amounts of
his patients.
They
knew
to approach the
area of the
imagination.
lem there
The
\Vhen we
is little
feel that
we have
and loss
and then at last to regeneration in a
new unity that is marked by aw^areness of all the component
parts and by harmonious functioning between them. The
drama of transformation is played on many stages. The characters appear in all varieties of make-up and costume, but
and
despair,
284
who
act in some-
The archetype of the divine child tends to appear in advance of a transformation in the psyche. His appearance recalls the marking of aeons in the historj* of the world which
were heralded by the appearance of an infant who overthrows
an old order and, with passion and inspiration, begins a new
one.
know
of
The
Liberty,
tlie
di\ine child, a sun god with flaming hair. This e\'okes the
jealous rage of the old king, the
darkness and
Though
all
**starr}^
king
and
of night
'
come upon
the world.
the king flings the di\ine child into the western sea,
when
place and
it is
morning
will rise in
On
was heard
it
new bom
the
all
now
new bom
terror,
barr'd out
howling:
by the
atlantic
fire
Flag'd with grey brow'd snows and thunderous \isages, the jealous
The
hand bumed
spear\'
The
The
fire,
fiery
the
fire is
aloft,
among the
shield; forth
went
falling!
limbs, the flaming hair, shot like the sinking sun into
ing his
fire,
beamy
fire in his
his ten
commands,
glanc-
in dark dismay,
morning plumes
Spuming the
Empire
is
of night, crying:
cease.^
tlie
285
own
At
first
the analysand
may
"sa\ior"
many
difficulties,
a style of living
286
The
or cut off?
scious material,
similar details as
religion
may
camp
his
experiences, those
and
who
regarded their
lives in
the
camp
lived only
us gives
meaning
to our
immature
The
strivings;
we
he shows us the
experience, and
that
teristics
which
are
normal in a youth in
continued
Perhaps the expression 'Tiigh living" best describes what this archetype is about: the young man indulges
his high-flying fantasies, living out experiences for their sheer
into later
life.^
287
category,
in
and
and of
again, for
itself.
The
some
^'getting high''
aimless traveling,
is
moving
the objective
in
and out of
Homosexuality is
an expression of this archetype, especially when homosexuality takes the form of casual and promiscuous relationships,
compulsively arrived at. If he is heterosexually inclined, he
forms one liaison after another, only to drop each one at the
first suggestion that some commitment may be required of
him.
Von Franz, in her study of the puer aetemus archetype^
various groups,
is
man who
is
on application
his instability
is
usually rejected
show up
profession.
The dreams
in a secure position,
disclose the
precarious
conscious
as a
is
205
When
and impulsive.
reckless
it
comes
to
making an impor-
many people
for advice.
She then
denness, and she regrets her actions almost before they are
completed.
Living the archetype of "eternal youth"
is
not altogether
negative, as
manifest
wisdom
to discern
is
worth
the struggle, and they often do not provide the steadying and
staying
power
\Vhen
this archetype
it is worth while.
dreams and schemes will
be hatched. If they are to succeed, even in the smallest part,
a compensatory archetype must come into play. This is the
to carry
it
is
through
if,
indeed,
active great
"senex' archetype.^^
Senex means old or aged, and, as archetype, it stands behind the forces that would preserve the traditional values,
that hold out for keeping things the way they are, for applying
sober judgment and consideration to the schemes of the eternal youth. At best this factor in the unconscious is expressed
in mature wisdom bom of experience, and, at worst, it represents a hidebound orthodoxy that tolerates no interference
from those who would break with established patterns.
A variant of the figure of the puer aeternus, sometimes
even incorporating aspects of the senex, is the enchanting
archetypal figure who is known as the trickster. Of him, Jung
says:
perfect state
He
289
is
divine being,
affairs
as
and
jokes of
all
We
whom
when we
are
ourselves at the
down when we
get inflated, or to
He
is
the
satirist
par
290
uncanny power
They can be
aspects,
free to
make
offer. It
is
his
own
choice
is
a long,
forces at
work
we become
is
in us
below the
able to recognize
their tricks
them through
illusion
become
29
need to express themselves as those anima and animus functions which interfere with relationships, inhibit productivity
and undermine the possibility of inner peace. This means
that the animus and anima are capable of being rescued from
their roles as autonomous complexes. When this occurs, they
lose their negative charge and become partners with the ego
in what has been described as the inner marriage. The man
is
no longer anima-possessed, nor the woman animuspossessed.
Each
which
will arise
The
own
lives as a
genitalia, or
sider her
quacy she
on the prejudices of
own
society,
and begins
to
con
feels.
situation as
it
applies to the
man who
anima
292
one by one, complexes arising from the archetypal configurapower over the individual, one would expect
the ego to experience a new freedom, a relatively complexfree state. It is true that much energy is released and the
indi\idual feels expanded, uninhibited, open to the storms of
the world and able to withstand them. The new sense of
power that he experiences will very often endow the individual with a sense of his ovm very great importance. He is now
''enlightened,'' no longer subject to the moods and tensions or
the neurotic defenses that had previously been a load on his
personality. Now he feels he can do just about whatever he
sets out to accomplish, and, most particularly, that he is well
qualified to advise anyone who comes to him with any problem. He is at once a "man of action" and a ''sage."
The feeling of being able to subjugate nature through the
use of this special power is, of course, not always what it seems
to be to the person who experiences it. If one is able to resolve
a conflict that had been absorbing his attention and consequently his energy, he may claim the mana the power that
formerly was caught in the conflict, as his own. He may hold
the conviction that he is able to exert his unusual power upon
others. At the same time he may appear ridiculous to others
tions lose their
who
is
He who holds it is someone particularly blessed. In the beof many primitive tribes [the Malays, the Malagasy, vari-
liefs
souls
identification
293
with
the
manaAn-
all exits
294
There are those who feel that the power is their own, and
believe it to be entirely under the control of the ego.
Forgetting to reckon with the unconscious dimension of their
natures, with the important forces within them which they
are able to understand to a degree, but not to control completely, they are overcome by the real power. The problem
is that they really do not know where the mana lies.
An analysand of mine had reached an important turning
point in his analysis. Ever since Walter could remember he
had been repressing his emotions in any situation where expressing them might have involved taking the risk of being
who
rejected.
He
manner
of function-
me know how
worthless
was, so
Whatever emotions
hardly ever
295
walk the fine line between putting him under the same kind
of pressure he had felt coming from his mother, and encouraging him in any way. The difficulties extended into the
most minute matters. An example of the first instance occurred when one day he brought a raincoat and placed it in
my
to take
it
with
to
296
woman who
took
development and who took every opportunity to depreciate his analytic work. Tlie only weapon he
had against her (and of course this was at first totally unconscious) was to deprive her of sexual satisfaction. On the
rare occasions that he felt sexually aroused, he would over-
no
interest in his
come
After
place
to
He
laxed.
negative anima.
He
re-
life as
never
new energy into his work and into his relationship with women. He even managed to be more engaging
and pleasant to his family at home than he had been in years.
before, pouring
At
dream.
It
in different situations.
man who
For a
less,
dream
to
of himself as Christ
mana
bolic terms,
and
vvath its
is
also offered
by the archetype
To be
of the mana-personality.
It re-
297
One
of
my
analysands dreamed: I
^vork
early because
derstanding.
is
It
down
is
still
early evening,
pajamas. I ask
him
nothing.
but he
is
He
finally says,
Then
I tell
him
on
his door.
He comes
why
I
over. I
can
me over?
analysis. He gets
am
in
up
to go, but
298
By
dergoes a change.
this
is
it
the
man
with
it
The
whom
he
in a
is
relationship
The
quatemity
triad a
is
Man
woman
in this phase.
The
if
you
will,
is
is
\.
OLD WISE
jXIAN
WOMAN
MOTHER
thing which
is
the
new
^ ANIMA
MAN
PRIMORDIAL
It
is
>VV^OMAN
3NIAN
although no experience
She has a
transcended
marriage quaternio.
is
life
consciously.
woman
third element
Old Wise
comprehended
again fourfold. In
The
relationship.
is
ANIMUS
entirely "inner'' in
my
view. Every-
point has
299
related to
is
is
human
That which
the aspect through which the self is
limitations of
its
finitude.
transcendent in
is
Of
This
God
why Jung
is
it
self,
"The
self
ego to the
even though
self,
never-ending process."^^
We
am
total nature.
The
better
know
it,
the less
it
and we
rest
overcomes
300
residue of
him
human
experience those
are,
in
The
self is also
kinds. It
is
scribe or even to
name
this
work
many
to attempt to de-
made
self's centrality,
acter.
The
its
extensity
circle as center
way of individuation.
Mandala is the Sanskrit word
for the
pecially a
magic
circle.
of power attached to
The
it is
for circle;
it
means more
es-
it is fre-
God,
city.
as described in the
The
the center
on every
the image of
gates
is
suffering
human
Book
of Revelation
is
mandala
and in
God
in the
mind
of man.^^
He
has lost
3OI
He
is
intuitively
knows
as his real
able to carry
this
becomes
evi-
302
sessions wider
as
we had
tie
he acquired
own uncon-
between
us, for
am
we
are over a
We
deep
is
find
forest.
trying very
I say, I think I
II
UNDERSTANDING
OUR DREAMS
I
we have
The
is
life of an inthrough dreams, and whoever carefully obsenes his dreams may gain access to dimensions of his nature
that would other\\-ise remain impenetrable. The way we approach our dreams depends ver}- much upon our o\\-n attitude
toward the unconscious.
hong before they met, both Freud and Jung were committed to the importance of interpreting dreams as a means
of gaining access to unconscious processes. Freud's monumen-
inner
di\'idual unfolds
tal
study,
The
from
They
scious
mind
discussed
resists
and
Non-
ps^'chologists objected
human
304
personality that they
likes to
have
No one
be told that
to ignore.
beneath apparently respectable adult behavior there lurk unresolved sexual conflicts, or even infantile, incestuous aspirations. Under the most virulent kind of criticism, Freud steadfastly maintained his theoretical position.
During their early years together Jung supported this position publicly, against the advice of his elder professional col-
fully
dream
interpreta-
we
do, has a
felt
meaning that
during sleep, or
even out of the events of the day. These merely furnish the
elements upon which the psychological processes do their
work. He explained how Freud saw the manifest content of
the dream as a cover story for the real situation of the dreamer,
which had to be a state of conflict between a repressed wish
seeking expression and the need to keep the wish unconscious.
In this essay, Jung made a passing reference to the possibility
of getting to the latent content of the dream the story hidden behind the dream eventsthrough the use of the association experiment. Then he went on to explain how Freud
From
his point of
view
this
encounter foreshad-
305
tage rested.
Jung related
tlie
ing places, the deepest of which contained only the two skulls
as
evidence that
it
terms
meaning.
306
The
latter
is
is
apparent
manifested in
in "new''
ideas.
own
age" in the
disparity
of
its
as-
sumptions?"^
By 1914,
None
phenomena, but
all
of
them
UNDERSTANDING OUR
DREAT^IS
307
as-
Not
in
had
drifted
from job
thing wrong with the employer or with "conditions.'' His objective seemed to be to make as much money as possible while
expending as little effort as possible. In his sex life he was always haunting the dating bars for a good-looking girl whom he
could get into bed as quickly as possible. He had come into
analysis with the statement that life was empty and meaningless for him, that he was bored, and that he was afraid to
get married because he had never stayed with anything he
had started. He came to me for help saying, "I hope you
can do something for me."
I did not accept Alex unequivocally in the initial session.
I
if
told
for the
He
this
dream:
am
fooling
308
around with a bolt that is about three inches long and a quar^
ter of an inch in diameter. I have a nut but can't seem to
find the way to get the nut and bolt together and I ask you
to help. You place your hands on mine and show me how,
by patient and careful movements, I can get them to fit together perfectly.
The symbolism
He
problems.
I
realized
of the process,
didn't
work
all
out.
his
know why
really
who
come to
The act of sitting with an analyst
miracle. You come and talk about your-
own
reality.
supposed to work a
you reveal your secrets, you pay your bills, and you wait
for something to happen. There is little or no change, and
heaven knows you have tried, so it must be the analyst's fault.
I followed the practice described by Jung of looking into
the context of the dream itself, instead of moving back in
time to try to find the supposed "cause" of Alex's difficulties.^
is
self,
309
is
what
it
says.
the ego
To
it is
discover
what
is
its
function of striving
of the
dream
bringing to
We
him
in.
The
nut was a vagina. And clearly the root of his problem was
that he couldn't get the two together properly. Or was it?
Jung's research
of dreams
way ...
is
it
hand without
their necessarily
solution
There
is
no
real
conception
of,
and attitude
310
to,
is
when
dropped."^
what
He
knew,
with a
He
in connection
bolt?''
a bolt of hghtning.
"You can
it
bolt a door.
is all
bound up
The
bolt
is
asked him.
can't manage,
it's
in that."
what
fastens
it,
keeps
We
a connection."
a profit."
"Anything else?"
"Well, nuts are
asked him.
testicles.
That
certainly
fits
in with the
sexual theory."
"Maybe
3II
to
him
by letting him
dream is a selfgiven moment, I find that
the best
way
to understand
upon
and
it,
it
is
to fix
I
my
total attention
bear in
mind
that
must
dream images.'"^ I
makes for immediacy in the relationship of analyst, analysand and dream material.
The next part of Alex's dream consisted of the words you
showed me how ... A typical mode of operation in the
dreamer was demonstrated here. He was always expecting the
other person to perform the magic. The analyst was to be
no exception. Everything would work out if the analyst would
just take the dreamer's hands in hers and show him how to
do what had to be done. Alex was prepared to play a passive
I
this course
The dream
is
and
careful
"fooling around."
patient
and
distinguishes
careful
man
sorts of specifically
human
accomplishments.
312
The dream
lems Alex
is
meaning of what he
does, as
He
he
is
is
someone, or taking advantage. Sexuality is a part of his probit, and it would be a mistake to
overemphasize this. What is more important than a concretistic approach is the joining of the disparate elements of the
dream into a chain. This cannot be done carelessly; no
amount of struggling or forcing will do it; but if the task
is approached with care and delicacy, it can be accomplished
quite easily. Openness to the implications of the associations
is needed. Locked into the components of the dream is the
natural power of the psyche to restore its own balance. Our
lem, but not the whole of
task in interpretation
We
is
move through
can
An
is
important aspect of
this
sort of
approach to dreams
terial
that
would lead
ma-
sand and his unconscious. When the analyst offers interpretations, these always have a tentative quality. "Understanding
a dream" requires agreement between the analyst and the
analysand. It must grow out of the dialogue between the two,
and it must be felt as valid by the analysand, it must "click''
with him. Otherwise the analyst's pronouncements are mere
intellectualizations. The analysand may follow what the
analyst is saying, but the words will have little effect upon
him.
There
is tlie
further danger,
if
interpretation
may be mistaken
as the
own
is
a unilateral
projection onto
Unless the analyst can say, "I think it may be like this; what
is your reaction?" there is no way for the analyst to check
as to
whether he
is
really
on the
if
the analy-
UNDERSTANDING OUR
sand
is
DREAIvIS
313
treated as a
mechanism
on
he
is
be
ex-
ver}' clearly,
is,
is,
to the
the
moment, and
but
it
314
explain
Nor
is
The
point of view
insufficient; a
is
cans-
or goal.
"All psychological
phenomena/' Jung
says,
nomena
involves correction of
some conscious
When
medium
the
;(
of dreams.
was so
impact.
structure with
side
from
ings
is
it
fitted
315
my aunt
pushed into the wall. On
the inside of the brick walls is a hot fire. My aunt had been
told that she had cancer of the lungs and thai she was going
to die anyway and this would be an easier death than by
cancer. I found this very horrifying, but didn't question it.
Then I am told the same thing about myself and am again
horrified because now Vm supposed to follow my aunt. However, I want to check with another doctor because I just had
a chest X ray and no one reported cancer then. Before this,
however, I was standing at the furnace thinking I had incura^
ble cancer of the lungs and I thought I must take the furnace
as the way out. After I thought about it, I decided to get
some X rays somewhere else, or to ignore the whole thing.
As I am hurrying to get X rays somewhere else, my Dad runs
up from behind and hands me the keys to his car and the
the hole in the brick wall. In the opening scene
am
is
He
We
rigidity.
The
best that
3l6
and concurrently his dream life increased in activand in the powerful way it affected him. Tlie above dream
was the climax of a series.
Reading the dream, Steven could hardly manage to get his
words out. At the point of relating where his father appears
and tells him that he has cancer and is preparing to go to the
furnace, Steven broke into uncontrollable tears. "You don't
know the worst of it," he cried, "you don't know where this
led me." He managed to pull himself together enough to read
the rest of the dream, then quietly wept until it was all out.
Then he told me what he understood of the dream: "I interpreted it to mean, I am going to have to think for myself.
depressants,
ity
317
hopeless, that
was love
there. It
came too
late."
last
days
And
when
later,
his
her
life.
We
new
or helpful
had apparently
tation toward
its
life
and
"sick-
doomed
to
go the way of the others in your family, you need not accept
your fate without questioning it. The dream dramatizes the
unconscious revulsion against the passive conscious attitude
31
that Steven
had been
get over
irreparably
in his
it.
The dream
still
this
tells
exists as a
him
The
father in
him once
The
seen in
sis.
it, first
had very
pretation.
little to
own
inter-
We
tween us seared more deeply than the actual verbal communiThe dream was full of the inescapable fact of death
as the end of life, the tenuousness of life, and the importance
of embracing the time that is left-each of us-and loving that
cation.
319
it well. There is no room
we both knew that, nor for
The future is too swiftly upon
tliis
brief span,
regrets
us;
we must
address ourselves to
is
when
it.
in analysis
from experiencing
my own
interpret
alone.
it
dreams?
Many
If,
is
people ask,
after
all,
very different
why
can
not
it
The
it
who
with another,
analyst
is
able to participate
of his being
is
may
and
same
at the
own
own
his
wishes, his
Much
their
some
it is
is
as
that this
it
To
friends.
is
my
tell it
as I dislike
when
feeling
dream
is
between the ego and the unconscious, a relationship that is carried by a slender bridge that can only be walked
alone. I am reminded of the tradition of the earliest Je\^ish
mysticism, having to do with the \ision of God's appearance
relationship
320
on the throne,
it is
to
vitally
it
from
dream
is
not told
means that he
dream to the analytic hour in all its purity, and
even intensified by his contemplation. In my experience I have
found that those analysands who allow their dreams to work
on them in solitude are hkely to be the ones who find their
analyses most productive. As they learn to maintain the tento extract
it
all
brings his
sions of their dreams, they also learn to live with the tensions
of their lives.
They
filtering
a partnership
he
said that
that
about
what
it
it
in confidence. It
is
give
him
know
321
while
he
will
show
nostic,
many
The
first
dream
is
diag-
the "neurosis,"
prognosis,
The
a cohesiveness of theme.
third
it
if
suggests
dream
method
of treatment.
The
322
is
323
if
try to build
on the present
basis.
All of this
would appear
to
be an external interpretation.
Jungians hold that the external situation (in the world) generally reflects the inner situation of the individual. When we
is
We
experience.
it is tJiat
is
324
good health.
Tliis
means
The dream
total
way to go
upward, and that the process will require more attention
than the goal.
It may well be asked here whether dreams predict the future. Jung has answered this question by saying that dreams
are no more prophetic than a meteorologist who predicts the
psychologically.
is
weather.
What
is
if
we
is
on the
its
basis of
The
what
forces are in
motion and
are going.
He
325
be revealed.
Other dreams reiterated this message in var^dng w^ys. Nicholas began to recognize the importance of taking time for
those practices which would provide for him a temporary separation from the demands of his external life, and then allow
him to return with new energy and vigor. He followed the
attitude prescribed by the dream, and though there were better
times and worse times, he gradually gained the capacity to
return at will to the high mountain plateau when it was necessary to \iew his situation from another prospective.
The fourth dream was my own. It occurred near the end
We
maybe
sun
is
for fishing. It
warm,
I lie
is
noisy.
remains standing.
have said that this fourth dream had to do with the end
of analysis which requires the dissolution of the transference
relationship. The dream points to tlie unconscious relationship between analyst and analysand, from the point of \iew
of the analyst. This is more properly called "countertransference.'' Countertransference in orthodox psychoanalysis was
thought of as dangerous, a condition which the analyst should
by all means tr>^ to avoid. He was advised to remain remote
and objective and not to allow his personal feelings to enter
olas
I
it is
know what
is
may be
helpful in
and the patient, far better than if his judgment were based
on thinking alone. The analyst must, therefore, consistently
3-6
As
Nicholas and
life
arc
all
in
its
own
its
this
widening of
his
view
new
was not repressed and made unconscious, but merely appeared in a different light, and so, did
indeed become different. What, on a lower level, had led to the
wildcvst conflicts and to panicky outbursts of emotion, viewed
from the higher level of the personality, now seemed like a
storm in the valley seen from a high mountain-top. Tliis does
not mean that the thunderstomi is robbed of its reality, but
instead of being in it one is now above it.^i
and stronger
life-tendency. It
t\\'0
may be
level, Ever}^
One
is
to analyze
life,
327
life
If it
is
a prognostic
dream,
it
may
some problem
Sometimes there
in a
dream. Tlien
are
it is
no recognizable or
familiar characters
dream
jectively.
is
necessary in cases
woman, may
am
chased by those
friends
me
lightly, in
among my
more
friends,
being
have
beating
destructive beating.
who would
betray
328
me. Alas.
awaken
my
life
has
changed.
In exploring this dream with her on the objective level
found
it
necessary to raise
first
is Jewish, so I asked if perhaps she felt in some way discriminated against because of her Judaism. She did not respond
to this probe with any particular feeling, for she was not aware
of ever having suffered for this reason. There had been no
event that she could think of in recent days that would have
provided any basis for the content of the dream. As to friends
among her enemies, she thought of some men in her business
firm who were immediately above her. They would often help
her in various ways, so that she had gained a reputation for
excellence which she thought was better than she deserved.
Enemies among her friends might refer, she conjectured, to
other women on her same level who may have been jealous
of her accomplishments. But somehow this objective level interpretation of the dream did not seem significant to the
dreamerit did not correspond to the strong feelings she experienced when she awakened from the dream.
Reading the dream from a subjective point of view brought
quite
different
results.
*'Race"
was seen to
refer
to
the
woman
which she
of her weaknesses,
to
become
distracted,
if
not repressed.
329
way
of being w^hich, as
it
hap-
pened, were also reflected in her current life situation. Naturally Edith had been totally unaware of these forces underlying
her behavior. In working through the dream with tlie analy-
sand,
life
situation
rently experiencing.
The
was valid in this case came as the dreamer recalled that her ongoing life problem was not an isolated one
but bore a resemblance to other situations which had come up
before all in response to the ongoing character problems
which the dream indicated.
Much more could be said about the process of dreaming.
We could discuss how dreams are classified, or how they may
be systematically approached. ^^ But all this would be theorizing. What w^e do in the analytic process is to carry on a dialogue with the dream, instead of trying to make it conform
to a theory. The few general principles that have been illustrated above may be helpful to suggest avenues of approach
to the dream. The important thing is to record the dream,
to pay attention to it, and to allow the dream to speak for
itself. It is not even absolutely necessary that the dream be
understood. As in the most helpful of human relationships
where much can transpire which is not fully understood, so
with dreams. This or that element reveals something that
was not known before, or one is reminded of some quality
terpretation
330
or capacity that he
time passes.
as
called everything
from a "temporary
uncon-
scious."
Much
of
what we
see
when
\\:e
And
depends upon the aJlitud^^iA .which^^
much of what we do by day may be aflfected by the attitude
we
12
DREAMING
THE DREAM ONWARD:
ACTIVE IMAGINATION
Dreams may be a source of potential strength and wisdom,
but unfortunately they present their difEculties and problems
too. For one thing, I do not find that it is always possible
to understand dreams. Often they are unclear and it seems
that no amount of reflection and examination will produce
the feeling of having come to the essence of the dream.
Dreams may have to be shelved until some future time when
they may become clearer meanwhile we can keep them in
view and turn them over in our thoughts, now and again.
Since dreaming is a spontaneous function of the unconscious, we cannot, by any conscious efforts, "cause" dreams
to appear much less can we command dream content that
will serve our needs at any given moment in time. It seems
as though the unconscious were like the vault of a great bank
in which is stored all the wealth inherited from our ancestors
and in which we, as individuals, also have deposited our own
coin. All of this treasure is said to belong to us, to be at
our disposal, but the trouble is that we cannot withdraw it
on demand.
have to wait until the guard at the door
is ready to open up, and we must be present at that moment
and ready to receive what is offered to us.
cannot withdraw more than what the guard may decide to give us. This
may be more than we need at this particular moment, or
We
We
332
comes.
vault of dreams.
when we
us just
Looking
we can
see
when we
least desire it
modes
of relating to the unconscious other than the straightforward analysis of dreams. The first situation occurs when
the individual's ego is barricaded against the unconscious,
when there is little sense of flow, of fresh ideas, of genuine
expression or even perception of feelings. In this situation,
dreams may be completely absent, or they may be so fragmenand superficial that they are practically valueless. The
second situation is the opposite: here the ego actively attacks the unconscious, stimulating it to produce more contents
dreams and fantasies and a tendency to act out in bizarre
behaviorthan the ego can deal with in any creative or productary
tive
way.
different
way
may be
coming from
itself,
instead of
spontaneously flood
Orand
in a sense this
is
more
excruciat-
painful
situation the
or importance to him.
These
which give
rise to a third
human
element,
They
framework
experiences in analysis
less transitory
and ram-
333
unconscious.
Maureen came
me
after she
had been
and behaved like a frightened little girl of about twelve, although her chronological age was nineteen. She would curl
up in the comer of a large chair in my office, as if she would
have liked to disappear. Yet she answered every question I
put to her in the beginning with clarity, although I noted
the absence of any show of feeling. She told me that she
had been told by her former doctor not to call him any more,
and that she felt that he had rejected her, "just like everybody
else.'' It came out that her father, a successful businessman,
had interests which kept him away from home most of the
time while Maureen was growing up; he was always either
working, or sailing his boat, or flying his plane. Her mother
had been at home, but Maureen remembers little about her
334
until the birth of a brother,
the
and had
to
home
same
Maureen
at the
home
came
left
her
and
sit
and answering
my
monosyllabic responses
my
office,
if
she spoke at
all.
It read:
the other
one laughs
is
worried
am
the other
DREAMING THE
who
who
not
who
who
who
335
and no words
who
IMAGINATION
is
i:
in his
mouth
unacquainted with
me
with himself
not worried
does not
move
the other
indifferent to himself
of
of
whom
whom
know nothing
who
does not
that
is
knew
is
move me
me how
she
felt,
and that the poem she had come across said what she would
have liked to have been able to say. It was clear that there
were two figures in conflict within her, the ego, which was
represented by a very small girl who could not make herself
heard, and a bigger, older, wiser person. We began to talk
about these two, and although Maureen was not too responsive, I had the feeling that I was beginning to reach her.
Often, however, she would sit through the hour hardly saying anything. Then at the end of the hour she would become
cHnging and begin to bring out what had obviously been on
her mind all along. She would attempt to extend the hour this
wa5% and to get control of meshe must have sensed that I
would not want to play the part of the rejecting mother by
sending her off just when she wanted to talk to me, which
was of course true. Furthermore, she must have known that
I did not want to miss these bits of communication at last
so tantalizingly dropped. It is always amazing to me how
certain patients are able unerringly to zero in on the therapist's own weaknesses and sensitive points! I could see Maureen was making it nearly impossible for me to act as a mediator between herself and her unconscious material, and it was
clear to me why her former therapist had been eager to refer
33^
the case.
me
to
make her
ineflFective.
One day she was even more withdrawn than usual. She admitted that she was afraid to speak out. At the end of the
hour she cried a little, and just as she was getting ready to
and handed
had written:
blissful places to
hide
in. I
want
it
guess
be
mothered by the big girl the big girl has no feelings or emotionsshe is cold and hard and efficient and maybe bravebut
the little girl doesn't want to grow up without feelings and is
afraid of what the big girl could do to her little girls are a nuisancethey reduce efficiency and get in the way they have feelings and needs that big girls want no part of and when they're
neglected they scream but sometimes after something screams
loud enough and long enough, it just gives up and \^dthdraws
into a comer too hurt to react that is what this little girl has
doneand she is sitting in the comer refusing to grow the big
girl likes it this
as long as she
little girl is
are
much
to
involved, because
ever
sits
herlittle withdrawn
love
know
her or
of a nuisance than
less
want
will
to
girl
to
is
also
an aspect
in one
become and
sume the
responsibility
is
337
as-
be appropriate.
WTiat she had written was more than idle fantasy, it was a
conscious attempt to bridge the gap between the conscious
'little giri" sense of herself and the frightening image of the
'^big giri'' with all of her big demands and requirements.
Maureen, who had not gotten any help from her dreams, had
stumbled upon the rudiments of the transcendent function
as a
way to gain a position outside of the inadequate ego poand also outside of the power of the unconscious. It
sition,
was that aspect which could stand over the big girl and the
little girl and view them both, as well as the relationship
between them. As we talked about the telephone booth paper, Maureen began for the first time to be able to acknowledge her fears openly, but she was obviously still terrified by
much more than she was saying. It seemed to me a good time
to help her embark on the kind of interaction between ego
and unconscious that makes use of imagination to perform
the work of the transcendent function.
Imagination, employed in this way, is not the same as fantasy. Jung has called this use of imagination by the term active
imagination, to distinguish it from the ordinary passive imagination which is nothing else than a self-propelling fantasy.
Active imagination is entered into consciously, in an effort
to engage the unconscious in dialogue with the ego. And, since
the unconscious
is
not limited in
its
sented
way.
great
Now
difiiculty
perhaps
we
for
could
move
in
338
would represent the way she felt about herself at that very
moment.
While she was drawing I reflected on what had happened
to her during the past two months since she had started to
work with me. She had secured a
clerical position
and was
doing routine oflice work, fitting into the office very much like
a part of a machine. She was efficient, bland, and compulsive
about getting her work done. Her employer was well satisfied
vtith her work. She had made no friends, and she always came
straight home from work to her small apartment where she
spent her time alone until she returned to the office the next
day.
It
showed a
large stick
self.
In other words, "they'' referred to the terror of the unis a nameless terror, but it has the shape of other
conscious. It
human
in words.
We
more about
herself,
To seal
home "in
339
SO hard to reach.
the compact
crayons to take
To
my own
role as
It
is
the analyst
who
the
new movements
way
to
make
is
use of
set in
was that in the first picture the ego figure had been drawn
with hesitating, sketchy lines. In this one, the lines were clear
and definite. And, interestingly enough, the crowd in the second picture was smaller than it had been in the first.
The third picture showed her running head-on into a fence
or grill. "They" were still following after, but the crowd was a
little smaller still than the one in the previous drawing, and
no single figure was out in front. The title of this picture was
"Wanting Free." I had asked her how long the little girl could
keep on running away. She had put this question to the unconscious when she had started to draw. Here was the answer
that came: "One day you will come up against something
340
to
We
nails she
made
movement
over
and
over, spiraling
had the
and
seemed
as
coming from those quiet hours when she would sit down at
home with her crayons and trace out the images that would
come to her. She brought the drawings to her sessions. Grad-
34I
their legs
them.
To
show them
them
to
all
alone.
She wanted
me
as the
have wanted to have, and she tried to force me into the role
of mother by constantly asking me for advice and for special
little favors in a childish way.
There came a time when she told me that she was thinking
of moving to share an apartment with a girl with whom she
had gotten acquainted at work. This took me somewhat by
surprise and I responded that it appeared that she was getting
ready to interact with someone on an ongoing basis. I knew
the moment I said it that it was the wTong thing to have said.
At the end
not leave.
The
and would
difficult.
342
an intruder.
my
fortress
down, by en-
ting better
l}ing
all
now
When she next came she was tense and distant, really quite
out of touch. She said, "I don't want to talk, I feel too flippedout." ^^^len I suggested that she might prefer to paint what
she was feeling, she readily agreed. She made one finger painting after another, always the stereotype of the stick-figure
always running. Finally I encouraged her to show
what the girl was running from. She painted furiously, a
painting in which the figure in front is about to be overtaken
by the one approaching from the rear. She stared at the picture and said coldly, ''One of them will have to be killed!"
This marked the beginning of the most crucial period in the
therapy. Maureen was testing me and she even went so far as
girl-ego,
me
to
make a
which was obviously not genuine. She thought I would hospitalize her and thereby reject her as her mother had done.
I did not. I asked her whether I could trust her to continue
working on her problems and not give up. She said yes, and I
did trust her. Gradually she began to trust me again, and
this time it seemed that she was involved in therapy in a different way than she had been previously. The pictures had
helped her to feel that she had some way of reaching the unconscious and looking into it. She did not have to close herself
oflE from it any longer.
One day she brought a drawing which she titled "Sometimes the mind runs faster." She said that she had taken out
her crayons and then had put a question to the unconscious,
^'Why do I become afraid?" Then she had let her imagination
find an image. What now appeared before her was the same
figure, but this time the head was separated from the body
and was running ahead of it. "They" had retreated far into
343
I asked her what was happening in the picand she laughed. "My fantasy life runs ahead of me, it
disconnects from me as a person, and I am always struggling
to keep up with it. It looks as though w^hat I am running from
is not those others, whoever 'they' are, but I am running to
keep up with what is in my head.''
Then she wanted to fingerpaint again. The painting she
made was the last of this series. The figure was seated. She
saw what she had painted and knew that she was able at last
to stop running. She would allow to happen whatever would
happen. She had become aware that just as her pictures had
in a sense created themselves there were forces in her which
needed expression and that would follow her relentlessly like
her own shadow no matter how she might try to avoid them.
One cannot avoid what is part of one. The pictures provided
a point of view that was able to transcend her ordinar>^ awareness and also to avoid capitulating to the unconscious. She
had objectified the struggle, and so could deal with it in a
tlie
background.
ture,
new way.
From this
Maureen began
to
have
else, an attitude
cannot be said to be a technique
or even a method of coming to terms with the unconscious,
because it is a different experience for each person who is able
Active imagination
is,
to use
nation
it.
The common
is its
recognizes
It
feature of
all varieties
of active imagi-
its
which inevitably define the potentialities and the limitations of the personality. Through the use of active imagination. Analytical Psychology works in specific ways that differ
from the approaches to the unconscious employed by other
psychotherapeutic methods.
Gerhard Adler, a Jungian analyst who has written extensively on active imagination, summarized this difference:
t}^es)
The
Psychology
its
specific character,
foundation on which
its
344
its
it
it
were, a superior
way
wholeness of the personality, does it make sense to advise a patient to face his unconscious in such a direct and forceful manner .^
Active
imagination
active
is
not without
its
we
dangers.
Unlike
wake up,
imagination may become extremely fascinating and may
eventually
own thoughts
Maureen
what he
discovers,
and
relates it to
when
she
would have
felt
to
be
Maureen
there was a
t\^'o
figures
killed.
Charles was a graduate student in psychology, and a parttime occupational therapist at a mental hospital. He was at
the opposite extreme from Maureen when it came to approaching his own unconscious processes, as well as those of
everybody else. If Maureen barricaded herself against the unconscious, Charles wanted to dive in head first. He had taken
LSD
on two
or three occasions
345
in fantasy,
responsibility.
were carried out in a highly professional manner. He conformed to the standards of style and content that were required, and he also managed to psych out his professors and
give them the content they wanted, even when they were not
aware that this was what they were looking for. In short, it
looked as though Charles was sailing through graduate school
without a worry.
346
about
all
we have been
Superficially,
it
self in
talking
human
human
beings. Rather,
it
being within a
much
less in
field
among
space,
To
painting.
pinkish-white skin.
and older-looking
version.
Neanderthal man, a
little
The
OX^^^ARD: ACTIVE
IMAGINATION
347
oval-like image,
Here was a
its
self-image
man
The
a primitive side
process of rationalization
cated.
The
dark
when
man was
instinctive beha\aor
was
indi-
man
as
to
what
ra-
Consequently, the dark-man-aspect had been rejected as ha\dng nothing of value to offer to this sophisticated
student. It was seen by him as "illness," and not any illness
he could discover in himself. It was, rather, the illness of the
world, which was concentrated in the mentally disturbed
tionality
is.
as ^'balanced" as
for
him
elements of a single psyche. The glowing yellow light pervaded the picture with a feeling of clarit}^ No escaping the
implications of this picture!
Then Charles
He would
into
he
many
said, "I
pieces of
made
all
layer
different shapes
upon
and
colors.
Of
this
change."
this
period,
348
Charles
felt
He faced the hopelessness of ever accomphshing anything with the patients. He was not able to see
them through day by day, but could only work with them
for an hour or two a week when they came to the O.T. room.
It irked him that the psychiatrists regarded what he was doing
as 'TDusy work/' and did not pay the slightest attention to it.
Around this time Charles had quite a few dreams dealing
with conflicts between menbetween brothers, or between
himself and an enemy soldier or someone criminal or unconpational therapist.
trollably impulsive or in
He
socially unacceptable.
image of himself,
environment and to be able to react to it directly and spontaneously. Charles, as he saw himself, in contrast, was flabby
and rather weak physically. He had to rely on his will and
his reasoning to assure his supremacy. His skill was all learned,
and the only way he could stay ahead of other people, he
had felt, was to learn more, and to develop more skills in
exploiting his learning to his
own
advantage. It
life
and that
much
became
ap-
of the vitality
this vitality
could accept
it
in
an unprejudiced way. He
own body by allowing himself to
and
but
it
would be necessary
to go
beyond pure
reflection
ON\\^ARD: ACTIVE
IMAGINATION
349
A
B
and drew a
pencil down.
encir-
Now
drew a larger
one at a forty-fivedegree angle to the one he had
drawn the last time.
Charles
square, this
350
Now
the
made
ape-man
cross.
Charles
cross of his
him;
it
responded with a
own, but it disturbed
was not
*'neat";
the cor-
the triangle.
that they should have.
again en-
whole drawing.
The ape-man
351
encircled
The drawing
cle,
finally created
corresponding to
for
us,
own
associations,
and
for wholeness
His
mandala called
many symbols
and we turned
initial triangle.
form which w^e do not find anywhere in naan arrowhead, moving, d}Tiamic. Three is a
masculine number, the triangle is like the arrangement of the
male genitals. Three is the holy trinity. Again all male.
[A]
ture.
"It
is
It is like
The ape-man
we see
[B]
natural form,
many
in the sun,
moon,
The
circle
is
in flower forms,
The ape-man
be-
longs to nature.
mascuhne
trinity.
The
fourth
is
something other,
it
may
[Dl
[E]
A new
become
four.
352
The one
[F]
become
that has
four
is
now
divided into
[G]
is
disconcerted
when
the un-
which
is
is,
human
own
[J]
dala
is
The whole
is
encircled
complete. There
is
circle.
new
figure.
The
his
He drew
asked Charles,
"There
figure.
He
is
"What
them experienced
353
with the other one, the primordial man who is for him the
representation of a potency he did not know he possessed. Not
alone sexual potency, though that was part of
and drive
intended with energy and dehght/'
in the sense of the vigor
We
it,
but potency
to carry through
what he
pri-
mordial
side
is
able to assimilate
some
of the energy
of the unconscious?"
"Yes," repHed Charles, "and the ego side also gives something.
He
erections."
was
fact of the
human
being.
354
if
seriously undertaken,
from
gives
way
to the capacity
is
re-
The changes are often subtle, but they go deep, and the
one who experiences them knows that he is living in a different way than he did before. This difference may not be readily
evident to people who know him, for often he has hidden his
self-doubts and insecurities well enough from public view; but
he knows, and this is what is important.
In the case of Charles the analytic work and specifically
the active imagination led him to withdraw the projections he
had made on the patients with whom he was working in the
mental hospital. He no longer looked upon them as subhumans and himself as a superior being. Of course he would
never have admitted, early in his analysis, that this is what
he had been doing; but his very attitude of hopelessness toward what he was trying to do and the patronizing way he
spoke about the patients gave away his real view of them.
His manner of distancing himself from his patients by standing over them and observing them and waiting for the psychiatrists who never came, was evidence enough that he was
ity.
355
who
side
As the alien
own
became
ego.
w^ay, as
who
the psychotherapists
son
who was
how
deeply
and he began
from before.
there,
The
He no
he began
though seek-
friends,
to
be
way
fully there in a
with respect to
acti\'e
The
Analytical Psychology.
comes from within the individual himself, rather than from any outside agent. There is no dictum
in Analytical Psychology that the environment must or should
shape the individual, nor is there the impUcation that the
behavior of the individual ought to be modified to conform
with the en\ironment or its demands. ^Analytical Psych olCj^
tion, in the individual
when
Teace,'
there
is
no
peace.''
Nor does
this psychological
which
is
or behavior
and
offers
is
its lot
or psychological
has
is
chology casts
is
may
be.
owTi individual
way
man
Active imagination
ess.
Sometimes
it
is
comes
momentary experience
356
out
of
were thoroughly
inhibited.
in analysis
it
became possible to
and in time the pos-
wdth a certain
her
had
and
man
api>eared
on the horizon. She had one or tw^o erotic dreams, and then
the dreams stopped, or she stopped remembering them. She
put off taking any active steps toward encouraging the relationship with the man. I had wTitten in my notes after her
last analytic session: "An arid session. She is in a rut. Can't
move out
into
life
hard to get up
it
in the morning.''
When
me
eager to
that she
tell
something.
It
of getting inundated.
Then
can do is overflow.
floated through my mind."
ting excited,
all it
What seemed
The word
^unconscious'
that
is,
me
flow,
but in
dis-
it
released
some
of
its
What was
appeared in such a
especially interesting
humdrum
seemed
to say, "Let
it
was that it
and
happen, at
least
its
own
balance.
something in your
be moving, and
believe/'
The
it
may not be
as
357
dangerous as you
came
as well.
Active imagination
deeply depressed,
Her
woman whom we
she had problems with her aged father, she suffered from stom-
ach ulcers, she had "financial problems" which were completely unrealistic in view of her more than adequate income,
but mostly she complained that she felt no zest for life, she
was always weary; she regarded herself as being without love
and without purpose.
Dolores had suffered for many years from periodic depres-
common
358
move
first
to
much time
one another.
me
She told
seemed
to her as if some of
had come out of her
attempts to handle depression and boredom. In this way she
went to college, went into the Peace Corps, and went to graduate school. In a way, she said, her trip to Zurich had a similar
motivation. One reason she felt so depressed and desperate
now, was that she could see no place to run, just an endless
procession of days leading eventually to retirement which she
both anticipated and dreaded. She asked, "What will I do
when I am left entirely upon my o\\ti resources? I can hardly
episodes.
that
it
day
life
nowhow
me know how
let
it
was.
down
and
to
knowledge and experience in Jungian therapy as a barrier between us; in fact, I dismissed her theoretical framework completely. In this first session her feeling of ha\dng no place
to escape was intensified. When she left, I suggested that
between now and the next day she should examine her feelings
and put them down in some way, either by writing or drawing.
In the interim she did both. She had written, "Perhaps
I was expecting instant relief from all the tension I have
been under, but I was disappointed to continue feeling badly
today, especially nauseated and as if I would throw up
any minute. This is disconcerting and makes it hard to
concentrate."
She had
also
drawn a
picture,
and brought
it
to
me.
asked
her to describe what she saw there. She said, "It's me, it's
sitting alone, in my cage and that is all there
how I feel.
is, nothing inside the cage but me, and nothing outside it.
Fm
That's
all
there
is."
359
me
my
sense of being
by myself.
When
sense of
had
it, I
let
how
It
had no back,
after
all,
who
"Yes,
doesn't understand."
I
impose the new view. The new view can and will come
from the unconscious itself, given the enabling situation in
which it can happen. The analyst's role is to follow the emergto
When Dolores
360
"The
last session/'
me up
to a few
She had made t^vo pictures and now wanted to explain
them to me. The first showed a vast horizontal blue plane
things/'
ver}^
much
Upon
it
stood a tiny
free.
The second
of any human
picture, also
life.
The
done
in blue
tree,
words:
As
The second
separate as a star.
even
as
condition,
its
becomes
and
"single," that
differentiated
from
is,
all
individual,
this
is,
human
To
36
,accept this
We
Her
unmistakably.
there,
but
it
but
The
this picture
elements of
was entirely
meadow reflecting
the sky and the yellow sunshine. The tree was
was not the same tree. It was now a strong tree
the blue of
there,
all
a grassy
many
branches, an old tree, solid and substantial. Sunand shadow played on the trunk, which was rounded
and dimensional, not flat as before. Most exciting was the
crown of the tree, full of many-colored leaves in great joyous
clusters, interspersed with pink blossoms. The sky was light
blue with gentle, white clouds floating across, and in this sky
four birds were flying separate, alone, yet belonging where
they were and sharing their condition with each other.
Dolores's mood had changed to match the picture. She was
ready to move back into Ufe and to become active again. I
do not mean to suggest that any problems had actually been
solved, only that she was able to view her problems in a differ-
with
light
first step toward dealing with the objecnext step would have to be taken by her,
damned, the only validation that I know for the analytic process is the vahdation which is stamped on th^ life of the individual
who
has experienced
it.
362
The unconscious
has
many ways
of
communicating with
we have seen
people are able
Some
in conversation.
take place.
The
its
it is
is
know
unconscious."
The
material that
comes
forth
when
the con-
conscious position.
active relation-
363
chisel against
some
of his
most
He
364
with the unconscious. Writing and the graphic arts are avail
we need not be hmited to these. New
media
offer
new
many
possibilities,
still
to the
list.
It
ef-
may
way
The
very difficulties
become
An
part of the
creative process
may
serve the
me
if I
(hell,
|;
the unconscious),
''till
n
DREAMING THE DREAM ONWARD: ACTIVE IMAGINATION
|i
hung over
^
katabases
this
& we
immensity."
I,
we must be held by
365
is,
by
our connection with the real world. That is just the danger
of uncontrolled use of psychotomimetic drugs that they may
cut off the connection with the objective world, especially
in cases
begin with.
is
is
to
be employed
with utmost care and respect for the volatile nature of the
unconscious.
way of
meant to him.
It is possible
He
what
had
who one
is.
When
is,
to
be unraveled
is
an
art to
accomplish
this
if
practiced properly,
madness to the
may
right degree.
13
RELIGION:
man
is
proposition that "indi\idual consciousness is based on and surrounded by an indefinitely extended unconscious psyche/'^
Jung's psychology, as we have seen, is based on the need he
them by the
transference. Rather,
he saw
conscious/'
is
But
it is
the birthplace of
and
consciousness,
368
it
own
empirically took
practice
new
and research
up most of
ij
in
his attention
and thereby imposed limitations on his personal search. Whatever feelings Jung may have had during these years (1900-13)
about the necessity of going beyond the province of the methodical researcher and theoretician, his responsibilities and
held him in check. His conscious efforts were directed
toward widening his experience and knowledge in areas to
which he had committed himself both publicly and in the
loyalties
The unconscious, however, did not fail to make its autonomous tendencies known to Jung whenever he turned his attention to it. I do not mean tliat he recognized the unconscious
only in his patients, or in the clinical reports of others. The
primary opening to the unconscious was through the aperture
of his own consciousness, through his dreams and visions and
RELIGION
369
circle,
Some
as
him
in his vision or
tions,
some
some
in
in the Bible.
Ehjah, "the figure of the wise old prophet represents the factor
of
intelligence
turning point
who was
to
figure
of his
The opening to the unconwhich preceded the appearance of the Philemon figure
came in a dream which he described as an epiphany:
soul in matters of the unconscious.
scious
brown
sky, like
if
370
apart and the blue water of the sea were becoming visible betw^cen them. But the water was the blue sky. Suddenly there
appeared from the right a winged being sailing across the sky.
.^
I saw that it was an old man with the horns of a bull
.
Jung accepted
[He] brought
home
to
me
me
later, as
he looked back
terial
tified
helped to keep
RELIGION
practice.
371
He
forced himself to
its
its
forth
distinct, if temporal,
from the
demands
he attained a capacity
life
and,
for
when
the other.
He had
principle, it
made
many
people have
Only Jung was the pathfinder who introduced active imagination into the area of psychotherapy. He had the courage to
state that psychotherapy cannot be defined altogether as a
science. In making a science of her, he said, "the individual
imagines that he has caught the psyche and holds her in the
hollow of his hand. He is even making a science of her in
the absurd supposition that the intellect, which is but a part
and a function of the ps}xhe, is sufficient to comprehend the
to
as
much knowledge
as possible.
is
human
all
that
is
all
necessary to recognize
all
that
is
neither finite
neither distinct
that which
nor poten-
not accessible
to logic or to the "word." It begins at the outermost edge
of knowledge. Despite the continuing expansion or even explosion of information, there will forever be limits beyond which
the devices of science cannot lead a man.
It becomes a matter of seeing the "created world'' in terms
of a "creating principle.'' This is difficult when we conceive
of ourselves as being among "the created'' and hence being
unable to comprehend that which was before we existed and
which will continue after the ego-consciousness with which
we identify ourselves no longer exists in the form in which
tially,
at leastexphcable. It
is
is
372
we know
We
it.
cannot, however
much we
strive,
incorporate
first is
inim-
It
must be taken.
scious
is
record the
phenomena
that occurred.
And what
did occur
the
self.
clearly
a normal family life and carrying on his therapeuwork with patients, which gave him a sense of active
living
tic
productivity.
more
RELIGION
373
seemed even to
aJffect
characteristic of
mood
the other
He
spirits.
of the household;
of apprehension, as though
of a houseful of
members
things,
He had
it is
Jung were struggling with the issues raised in the dialogues with the "DeadJ' who are the spokesmen for that dark
realm beyond the understanding of man; but it is in Jung's
last great work, Mysterium Coniunctionis^ on which he
worked for ten years and completed only in his eightieth year,
as if
that the
Jung said that the voices of the Dead were the voices of the
Unanswered, Unresolved, and Unredeemed. Their true names
became known to Jung only at the end of his life.
The words flow between the Dead^ who are the questioners,
and the archetypal wisdom which has its expression in man,
374
who
regards
it
as revelation. It
is
God
spoke
two thousand
years ago
tation of
all its
general contents."
They belong
all
of his work,
all
The dead came back from Jerusalem where they found not what
They prayed me let them in and besought my word,
they sought.
and thus
began
Hearken:
my
teaching.
is the same
no better than empty. Nothingness
As well might ye say anything else of
full.
is
it is.
since
it
thing that
hath
is
it iSy
infinite
or blacky or again,
and
eternal hath
no
it is
quali-
all qualities.
name
the pleroma.
is
it
that
is
it
goes beyond
of another order
RELIGION
375
Sermon
Creatura
continues:
not in the pleroma, but in
is
itself.
The pleroma
is
both
We
essentially, since
we
The quahty
of
in the degree to
are distinguished
human
is
in our
is
is
What
is
we do not
Therefore
Hence the
tiveness,
we
is
We
we do not
distinguish.
is
This
the
is
es-
In the pleroma
all
is
no tension
in
The
Effective
and the
Ineffective,
376
Living and Dead.
the Cold,
Time and
Space.
Good and
Evil.
These
and separate
and
Thus
tive.
pleroma
Here
are
we the
in us one
from the
The
rent in us.
is
lies
mus
woman,
man
for the
tempting to
live
The
is
When we
get our
strive after
own
nature,
which
is
distinctiveness,
we
and we
We
same time we
also lay hold of the evil and the ugly, since in the
pleroma these are one with the good and the beautiful. When,
however, we remain true to our oMm nature, which is distinctiveness,
we
distinguish ourselves
and
therefore, at the
thus
we
fall
dissolution.
not into
RELIGION
377
He
is
is
He
"Do you
an enigmatic smile,
believe in
God?"
there
is
is
required because
it
if
that which
is
"I
is
process of differentiation
we make
view of
separations
reality
posed of
six or
how many
begins.
world in
and
seven colors;
it is
We
when you
may be
illusory as
from
illusory
as
on a Mon-
378
ate
qualities.
We
cre-
ence, as ye think
At bottom,
is
it,
distinctiveness. Therefore,
must ye
therefore, there
own
not after
differ-
strive;
is
being. If ye
had
this striving ye
would
not need to
and
yet
being.
The
Perhaps
it
suggests
on
differences or same-
convenience for purposes of describing appearances, or for comm^unicating with other theranesses, except perhaps as a
must
teach you
thought in
wheremth
may be
able
to
hold your
leash.
Suddenly we know
We
ye
who
are psychologically
the
dead
if
RELIGION
379
'
estrangeth from
The
man may
portant,
what
is
important
is
man
be enucleated from
his attitudes he must be hopelessly split in two, and the
psyche which is largely spirit, must surely die within him.
wherewith ye may be able to hold
That knowledge
your thought in leash must, I believe, refer to knowledge
which comes from those functions otiier than thinking. It
consists of the knowledge that comes from sensation, from
intuition, and from feeling. The knowledge which comes from
sensation is the immediate and direct perception which arrives ^da the senses and has its reality independently of anything that we may think about it. The knowledge which comes
from intuition is that which precedes thinking and also which
suggests where thinking may go; it is the star which determines the adjustment of the telescope, the hunch which leads
to the hypothesis. And finally, the knowledge which comes
from feeling is the indisputable evaluative judgment; the
thing happens to me in a certain way and incorporates my
response to it; I may be drawn toward it or I may recoil from
it, I love or I hate, I laugh or I weep, all irrespective of any
intervening process of thinking about it.
It is not enough, as some of the currently popular antiintellectual approaches to psychotherapy would have it, merely
to lay aside the intellectual function. The commonly heard
cries, "I don't care what you think about it, I want to know
how you feel about it," are shallow and pointless; they miss
the kernel while clinging to the husk. To hold your thought
behaves." For
if
a man's behavior
is
to
380
in leashy that seems to
me
sciousness as
it
way
the knowledge so
all
valuable only
field is
it is
it
man
as
he addresses himself to
God.
Jung's approach to religion
First, there is
there
man
to
it is
when he
that he
dualistic.
second,
is
even
not
God and
is
own
twofold, yet
is
is
writes as a psychotherapist
a limited
human
about
religion;
Nor
he alone in
is
need a
this.
religious system
Margaret
Mead
with science at
its
himself to
self off
I
from the
rest of
ha\e discovered in
my
analytic practice
and
also in
my
that he
is
to
find
thoughts and
activities,
by quoting from
may be
illustrated
my
students:
I came into this class with a vague notion that Jungian psychology would be helpful in the task of relating psychology and
RELIGION
religion.
jElled.
581
As the
My
and Personality
field
is
to dis-
Jung has offered one approach to that task which I find helpful
and stimulating for my ovmi thought.
One of the reasons why there has not been to date a convincing psychology of religion (there has been an ample supply
of modem attempts to do psychology and religion) is that both
psychologists and theologians have ignored the important place
of myth and symbol in the life of m.an and in rehgion. It is
precisely here that Jung makes a unique and significant
contribution.
Once one
And once
di-
mensions of the archetypes are understood as well as their personal dimensions, we are immediately thrown into contact with
the numinous aspects of
life
we
his-
apply Jung*s
we
are
then forced to deal with the structure of the psyche, and Jung's
structural categories (e.g., the conscious, the unconscious, archetypes,
self, etc.)
Any
stands
man
throw
light
in relationship to
\Vhat Jung
is
is,
re-
history.
human
ex-
own
essence,
382
is
ear,
its
voice there,
all terrors
bears
within
him
there.
it
is
It is not in the least astonishing, [Jung tells usl that numinous experiences should occur in the course of ps^-chological
treatment, and that they may even be expected with some regularity, for
may
them
as psychic
we
and
collecti\'e
occurrence
it.^
man
specifically,
RELIGION
383
posters.
The
of the play^
'Foolsr'
That was the name of a play, she told me, that had been
on by the university faculty. It had flopped. As
recently put
she gave her further associations to the dream, she said that
while she had been preparing for the exams the phrase kept
there
is
No
384
gionwhich seems to be a screen behind which can be estabone true faith derives its rationale by purporting
to determine what is valid and what is not, and ranking ideas
lished the
in hierarchies.
is
to
be saying
essentially that
who
on one
side
critically at
own
waves into hues and forms to delight the eye the ineffable
is brought into the realm of human experience. She is faced
with both, they both belong to the same sheet of paper, which
is
make meaningful.
with either her intellectual function or with her spiritual function. Or, she can attempt to
this task
bring both to bear on the problem; she can at one time think
and
thought in
leash.'' If
example of Jung in
his exposi-
by
side
it,
that attach to
with the
rituals
it.
is
that the
is
element
is
ment
in
man
is
and
religion.
The
spiritual ele-
RELIGION
385
way
is
of
becoming what he
wholeness, which
is
is
The ways
in
which the
self
self.
that
it
womb
of a
as
a divine child?
Symbol
is
in time.
But
it
can only
386
must be supplemented by
situation
is
simply in
is,
their opposites
to be characterized conectly.
tlie
the transcendental
We
can do
this
most
UNrrEMPor^vL
UNIQUE
UNIVERSAL
ETERNAL
This formula expresses not only the psychological self hji
dogmatic figure of Christ. As an historical personage
Christ is unitemporal and unique; as God, universal and eternal.
also the
Now
if
is bound to
on the other side
The resultant quaternion of opposites is united on the psychological plane by the fact that the
self is not deemed exclusively "good** and "spiritual**; consequently its shadow turns out to be much less black. A further
result is that the opposites of "good** and "spiritual** need no
longer be separated from the whole:
"spiritual/'
arise
GOOD
SPIRITUAL
INIATERIAL
EVIL
This quaternio characterizes the psychological
self.
Being a
must by definition include the light and dark aspects, in the same way that the self embraces both masculine
and feminine, and is therefore symbolized by the marriage
quaternio. [See chapter 9 on Animus and Anima, supra]
Hence individuation is a "mysterium coniunctionis/* the self being experienced by a nuptial union of opposite halves and detotahty,
it
RELIGION
387
drawn sponwas
imagination of the patient Charles and
[We
taneously by patients. ^2
expressed in the active
recall
how
beautifully this
the ape-man.]
in analysis, the
image of the
self
often
manifests very early and provides the impetus for the entire
may come in a dream which is only partly underand remains in a prenascent state until its time has
come. This was the experience of Vincent, whose dream was
discussed in chapter 10, Circumambulating the Self. The
dream is repeated here, to show how the religious significance
of a dream sometimes only begins to emerge after it has been
process. It
stood,
carried to
its
maturity: I
scene by moonlight, I
am
woman
walking with a
slightly
a glacial idyllic
also somehow watching myself.
It is
We
come
We
am
mountain path.
to
Her
ugly.
face takes
gets very
to have intercourse with her. My penis enters her vathen goes through her body and into the rock behind
her. Then she disappears and I am aloncy haying intercourse
that
is
gina,
The
setting
scious farthest
is
colorless
one
older than
myself
moon-
mountain, of
spirit.
**slightly
uncon-
has two
as-
referring to the
woman becomes
color.
offers
old
and
on
The
a greenish
388
ion.
The
stillness of
and
fertility
him with
to infuse
is
member
is
is the color of
the night, brings
rebirth.
The
effect
a miraculous potency,
and not
only her, but through her and into the rock! "Hence, individuation
is
enced
as a nuptial
anima
tlie
self, as
The
union of opposite
halves.'^
indi\idual has
being experi-
Through the
his transpersonal
of alchemy.
The
is
its
meaning
which
it
would
find
its
man
union
into
its
spiritual potentiality in
as
many
The
many
it,
was
individuation.
first
of the
Man
is
is
is
fixed
and
incorruptible.
The
indi\dduation
is
The
ji
I.
natural,
^11
(}
of
RELIGION
389
and
is
called
prima
all
de-
We
quest
is
commitment that
Arabic
[It]
cites
style:
is
'This stone
it
can be
elicited that
is
man:
hand
a mat-
the
fits
as
its
I
BOUNDARIES OF THE SOUL
390
the conscious mind, just as
it
called
The study of Jung's extensive writings on religion and alchemy, of which the above lines give only the merest suggestion, led Vincent into a consideration of his own potentiality
for realization of the promise of his dream.
He
was able to
life,
One may
Why
well ask,
did Jung
its
become
all
of
its
so involved with
pseudoscientific
ous conclusions?
Why
its
dubi-
of the
non-Christian religions?
To be
sure
of alchemy held
him
is
fascinated.
ago pried him away from his medical studies to attend the
seances where S.W. fell into trance states and described her
What
visions?
was
it
that
ropean psychiatrist?
lished
And
again,
>
of our fate.^'^
latter,
t'^
well estab-
'
SS
^ri
RELIGION
391
and myth
member?
jes.
ty
Symbolism
in the Mass"^^
Jung described
significance
and the
altar,
the
end of the canon, breaking of the host, concommixtio and conclusion. He tells us: "the uttering
of the words of the consecration signifies Christ himself speaking in the first person, his living presence in the corpus mysticum of the priest, congregation, bread, wine, and incense,
which together form the mystical unity ofl[ered for sacrifice.
At this moment the eternal character of the one divine sacrifice is made endent: it is experienced at a particular time
and in a particular place, as if a window or a door had been
opened upon that which lies beyond space and time.''^^ "TThe
Mass thus contains, as its essential core, the mystery and miracle of God's transformation taking place in the human
sphere, his becoming Man, and his return to his absolute existence in and for himself."^^
Jung then makes the statement that although the Mass is
a unique phenomenon in the history of comparative religion,
consecration,
signatio,
its
symbolic content
it
may be
is
rooted in the
expected that
in visions
some parallel
and practices,
rites
in
of transformations as depicted
myths and
rituals
and in
allegorical
392
legends.
He
natural philosopher
preser\'ed,
lates a
says,
sacrificer
Looked
at
resents a totalit}'
by Christ. In
the
rite
mto
v\^e
seems to me that in his essay, "The Lapis-Christus Paralin Psychology and Alchemy, the true position of Jung
vis-a-vis the opposition between orthodox Christianity and alchemy is made clear. There is Christ; and there is the stone.
It
lel,''
is
bom
and
lives
for
man,
dies
and
precious body,
is
mass; and
it is
as the alchemist,
i
'^
RELIGION
^
393
dissolution in matter.
Mass
self
bol for
God),
As Jung points
out, tlie
f
I
The
for him_-
him
redeemer of God
concerned to perfect the substance than himself/'
Now we
whom he
of
for
fathers.
me whose
the contract to
known
to
me.
is
man
And
is
is
equally
soul.
The
consulting
room
alchemist's laboratory.
is
From
symbolically represented
this it
can be seen
how
human
by the
the
al-
symbolism of alchemy, he
was careful to make it clear in speaking of the alchemist:
"One should not suppose for a moment that he presumes
to the role of redeemer from religious megalomania. He does
so even less than the officiating priest who figuratively sacrifices
o\vn unconscious contents into the
Christ.
The
394
Christ;
human consciousness.
when he became interested in
in the history of
of Jung,
trology was
no exception.
led to misunderstanding
If
and
zeal,
It
was characteristic;!^
a subject to pursue
and the
lore of as-
Hard-nosed scientists asserted that Jung's scientific respectability was called into question when he investigated a field such
as this, which lies outside the area of what is considered by
them to be proper subject matter for experimental research.
On the other side, many people who wanted to give an air
of authenticity to their assertions about the validity of astrological predictions have tried to persuade an unwitting public
that Jung was a "true believer" in astrology as a predictive
instrument. I am quite comdnced that he was not, and I would
not even raise the question in this book, except for the fact
that it has often come up in my practice. Here is another
instance of people hearing a half-truth or a patently fraudulent
he
and their
and religious history. Since
with Jung about this, I can only
base
my
conclusions on
my
^'
1
|ii
|
|c
RELIGION
395
in
ment
An
of
and
The
astrology
of
scattered
are
throughout
the
speculative-
may
the tenets
and
phenome-
Jung
Matthew
2:1
ff.
is
given us in
even at the time of the apostles, was viewed from the astrological
astrological
myths
who
are
more
qualified than
I,
we
of astrological
the worldly
Above
all,
it
is
stories of
fish symbolism, either contemporaneous with the gospels themselves ("fishers of men," fishermen
and
fishes), or
immedi-
first
396
But
would
to anyone acquainted with astrology that he was bom
be
clear
as the
first fish
new
aeon,
it
Jesus. Astrology
human
of
stars,
sun,
fact that
phenomena in the heavens: the fertilityupon the sun shining in the heavens and
RELIGION
397
who
corre-
indistinguishable.
The
able,
is
* It
'
is
a matter of
ment
known about
the
many and
when
little
was
it
was bedimen-
Modern
stars
human
way that tlie ancients believed they were. But, as we all know,
and as ecologists are constantly pointing out, there is a correspondence, there is a very evident relationship between man
and his larger environment. The more we discover about this
relationship, the more we are able to withdraw our projections
398
of unconscious contents.
making
is,
The
If0>^^
is
the
first
)re\'i
tbi
^^
|st
to
be
basically
projections.
fi&
BOie
'
meaning
in these correspondences
had
tantalized
Jung for many years. The beginning of his serious study goes
back to the days when Albert Einstein was developing his
first theory of relativity. During this time he v^s a guest on
several occasions for dinner in Jung's home. In a letter on
Einstein and synchronicity, Jung wrote: "It was Einstein who
first started me off thinking about a possible relativity of time
.''^^
as well as space, and their psychic synchronicity
The study of meaningful coincidences could not be complete for him without a careful scrutiny of astrology. Since
there was a lack of legitimate scientific data either validating
or invalidating the correspondence of predictions based
ast
|al co
fcini
Ket
We
l^^
jiJ
evei
^\^
lla'
on
tun
horoscopes with subsequent events, Jung undertook an astrological experiment in the hope of finding out for himself how
accurate such predictions might be.
The
proposition to be
was the
astrological
pi
RELIGION
399
non-married couples.
The
results of the
experiment greatly
...
is
little
justification for
for astrology
cal
From
our investigation
.
there
correspondence
is
is
in
is little
some
hope
chemy
Nor
did
al-
man
and
his symbols.
and the appearances of things have changed. What was believed to be true in those days is no longer believed. But
taken synibolically they provide us with a history of the devel-
opment
of archetypal images.
unconscious.
The symbolic
representations
that
man
con-
400
man
and
literal
today.
among
college students
late 1960s,
Metzner and
tion,
"A Tribute
correctly, as
and
in order to guide
T^
RELIGION
is
401
book of
life
and how
is
all.
to say a
to live.
It
is,
they
assert, "a
book of the
The concept
book
living; it is a
of actual physical
/'^^
In this sense,
into
which in
new
their
realms of consciousness.
They
not appreciate the necessity for this leap into the unknown,
since, in their words, "He had nothing in his conceptual frame-
experience."^^
are not.
difficulty,
realization of the
One Mind
(according
402
to Jung's reading of
tion)
cally, with the non-ego. In doing so, One Mind becomes for
Jung an analogue of the collective unconscious or, more proj)erly, it is the same as the collective unconscious. Jung writes:
The
statement
other minds/*
contamination/* Since
scious condition,
separate
all
distinctions
to imagine
how
vanish
the uncon-
in
it is
But we
are unable
its
inevitable incompleteness.
is
hidden
unconquered
its
reality.29
place
help individuals to
this world,
throughout our reading of Jung, by the data of the unconscious. Of utmost importance is it that the unconscious maflow into consciousness, and furthermore, that material
from consciousness flow into the unconscious, adding new elements which dissolve, transform and renew what has been
present all along. But the most important thing, from the
terial
RELIGION
403
''it is
understand-
ing,
we
hve. It
science.
we
is
serious business,
it
is
play;
it
e^'e^}'
is
art
and
turn, except
it
is
when
(the unconscious).
In
my work with
come up about
in China.
beginning
all
quite
unknown
in the
West
except
meth-
404
method
he
says,
is
of fusing
...
yoga
a psychological disposi-
The
Indian mentality
The West, on
to believe
them a thought,
and all as "pure
therefore
makes
or
its
mysticism.''
it
The
which
is
is
to
becomes
either
and
be found of the unity and wholeness of nature
strictly religious
not a trace
them one
mind
characteristic of yoga.
The
is
always forgetting
make out
He
of
it
a willing robot
.22
i
be,
"How do
telling
about
RELIGION
405
Hannah worked
She was
in a uni-
also attend-
it.
When Hannah
all
the
way
to the sched-
her that
would
watched with her, the ex-periences she brought
the analytic sessions, and the effects that these experiences
destroy her.
to
tell
little,
406
We
first "crisis
patient"
would
be, or in-
deed, already was, herself. It was then that she began to be-
come aware
to see
crisis
wdthin herself,
there.
But looking within was not so easy. That which was within
was so cluttered by all the appurtenances, the many personas
she was used to putting on for various occasions, that it was
difficult to find out who the "who" w^as behind all its guises.
This involved looking at her beha\ior, and also at her attitudes, not as something which she initiated in order to create
an effect, but in a different way. Strange to say, because she
had never thought of it in just that way, she had to discover
that her ego was not the center of the universe! But it was
far more than a new way of thinking. Thinking, in fact,
scarcely entered into
necessity
made her
it.
shift
Perhaps
it
came
itself,
own ego
who
resisted
to enforce
Then
pressures
and
Hannah,
a chance to get
to hike in the
mountains
JEI
RELIGION
and
407
open
sky.
Hannah announced
human
experience.
Now
she
and
to learn,
to
do
it
at a relaxed
what
it is.
It is
on
much
is
not
means
want
to
unconsciousness."
carried
crete,
wheels.
end
of
make the
foresee. It
vehicle go;
it,
all
was not
she had to do
4o8
any longer one young woman out to save the world, or even
a part of it. She was a part of it, and she did not even have
to save herself. As she became able to hear with her inner
ear the harmony of nature, and to see it with her inner eye,
she could begin participating with it and so cease fighting
against nature.
its
is
Each person must find his own individual way, depending on many inner and outer circumstances. Hannah's
everyone.
case
is
it
exemplifies a certain
Western world, which seems to affect the ambitious, the energetic, the aggressive, and the people who
achieve "success," in the popular sense of the word. These
are also the people who become, more frequently than not,
weary, depressed, frustrated, dependent on medicine and alcohol and drugs to handle their moods, sexually unfulfilled,
and who sometimes even admit to being "neurotic." Unlikely
as it may seem, their problem is essentially a religious one;
for it has to do with that "hubris of consciousness" which
prevents man from looking beyond himself for the solution
to his problems and for the meaning that lies hidden in all
that he does, and sees, and is.
sickness of the
.-J
14
We
details.
enter into
life,
is
the
no way of knowing
summer
of life or
Only one
goal which
thing
is
is
death, and
much
that
it is
we
onward toward
its
do,
tliat
we make.
heard
41
announcement the other day asking for contribuon a fatal children's disease. The sentence that caught my attention was, ''Did you know that some
children are bom dying?" I started for a moment and then I
knew why the words had stabbed me I know that all children
a television
of hfpj]rm1ysi<;;
We
womb.
maternal
r^yin pJ TV>iq iq
fhe
lie
jTrnrp<;s^
grow there
until
it
time to be bom,
is
us through childhood
r<frihrQl_ fact
<
we
In the beginning
'
hnrn
nrr? nil
it is
which takes
to the mid-point of
then slowly, softly downward through tlie years of maturtoward a gradual or sudden surrender of the ego to the
unknowable to the darkness in the womb of earth, the matrix
life,
ity,
of the unconscious.
process
is
At
Since in every
beyond remains
matters.
The
life
is
it is
we
realize
it,
highly cultivated.
reached, and
sooner
the individuation
it is
is
what
lies
the sooner
we
identify with
more
likely
and
we
are to be able to
fruitless conflicts.
become
Thus, we
lib-
realization
we
is
Jung, in his old age, was able to look back and reflect:
''My life as I lived it had often seemed to me like a story
and no end.
was a historical fragment, an excerpt
and succeeding text was missing."^
for
in her
was consciously involved in individuation
while she was still young, on the very edge of her career.
She had come to an attitude not so very different from the
one Jung expressed, an attitude which would support her
to flow with life,
V^^ ^VERE
BORN DYING
41
because she
Engaged
in
this
analysand of mine.
time intended to
He was
that the
life
He
and
own
the battle
all
about? Are
we
is
On
and
horrifying.
He would
412
He
how he
related, afterward,
and with
his fingers,
the
heaw
all
all
it like
all
from
Under
the pain.
DEATH
AN ORGASM
IS
more than
So too the sacrament of the altar
What
The
so gorgeous as
is
fuck-up
final
is
a fuck-out of existence
he
vibrations,
its
experience:
held
I finally
it
Then
GOD-DAMNED
real
as they progressed
To have gone
pose
to say
just that
Words from
is
ansu'er!!!!??????
to die.
The poem
the blue
growing larger
the page:
WHAT!!???
But
an
there
thing.
Not
Is there
down
(////)
in a
hazy way as
It all
as I
my
breath
YES,
that's
WE WERE
I
BORN DYING
began to
taste of
413
it
ANXIETY
final one.
Then acceptance
of
overcoming
it
it.
The
When
you
re
To
learn
HOW
to die {willingly)
You
God
33 was experienced
orgasmically
Now
starts
beyond death
already
is
little).
the
life
may
die to life
and capture
willingly
Death
is
live again.
414
ones
He who
begins to taste of a
ONE EXISTS
one
LIVES
What
If
end.
NO MORE;
{and creatively !)
WHAT
am
(/)
I to say?
at the
It
know no
that can
Vm
Then
life
up
opens
Here a sketched
within
circle,
all
a great burst of
it
JESUS CHRIST
superstar
TO CONQUER
He
MESSAGE:
TO DIE
and by doing
conquer
it
hght, ex-
directions.
so
,
commending Himself
to the Father
RISING)
high {or
not on a
off to
tone,
spirit trailing
the depths.
felt exhilarated, as
The
re-
rary
life,
own
and
isolation.
WE WERE
BORN DYING
415
later, "I
time
a detergent breaks
stance of the
do
that."
let
says,
tell
you what
fall
feel
into your
own
resources,
on the conscious
level
are transcended."
What
can the analyst do in the face of the powerful matup out of the depths? I could only be there, be
there and let him know that he was not mad but had tapped
ter surging
is timeless, and
which death is not an end, but merely an incident.
There is not much more to say about Byron. His work
is
body bears
witness.
man
in
my
practice,
an older man,
Julian,
who
is
well into
41
Here
is
the
Our way
first:
two dreams.
itself in
of getting there at
all is full
of
smugglingy sneak-
through intncate
alleySy
rushing up
stairs,
leaping rooftopSy
opera house
We
from
and
like
it
La
Scala.
we
gilt in-
am
trying
and dress.
TheUy suddenly, it all begins to fall apartcolumns and
walls split and disintegrate before my eyes. The rich decorations and costumed people all collapse and melt away in
clouds and showers of paste, chalk, plaster. It is as though
all had been made of chalk masks, a pretense of overwhelming
interiors
proportions.
larSy
How
and
it all
fall
He
pretended to be
and spoke a good deal about morality and justice. But it had all been a front, a persona which
did not fit the person behind it. That person had been an
exploiter of the weak, an opportunist of sorts. He had carried
on shoddy romantic affairs which had been damaging both
to the women involved and to his wife. Inside of all the splendor and artistry that his appearance displayed the opera house
of the dreamwas decay and dust. "Gilt" covered it all, could
this have been a play on the word? For all his savoir-faire,
interested in social reforms,
WE WERE BORN
DYING
417
and mean
life.
The
real truth
is,
The
fact
is
at best another
twenty years or
so.
On
41
secret chambers of
mental truth .3
be moved by
this
funda-
meshed
own
construction,
there was no
way
it
collapse, all
foreseen.
We
how
ing about
happens,
it
occurs,
life
when
indicated
change
to
meaning
is
right for
it.
now we needed
to obsen'e
it
and
to
be
had come
point of ha\ing to
He wanted
all
woman
w/zo M'os not Bills mother to look at her, and she turns, rises
upy looks fresh and exceedingly healthy, and gives a trcmeru
dous, defecating blast. Two doctors come in and remark that
lives in a
kind
had some
moment
He
told
me:
formation:
of great trans-
%\rE
tremendous defecating
4lg
blast; at the
same time
his
psyche ex-
The double
^\^s kno\^-n,
funeral, the
The latter
anima who represents the
ing spirit. It is she who is
kno\Mi.
tells
One
of the unconscious
life
and
its
unthe
guid-
is
come powerfully
alive
and
create the explosive situation within. Either the foul stuff has
is
really a corpse.
The uncon-
what must happen and furthermore, by presenting the whole image in the funeral scene, it becomes clear
scious shows
that there
really
is
nothing to
consequently
shell
is
anyway.
The ''doubling''
who come in. We
heals, nor
is
may
am
mentbut we
this
lytic process,
haps
lose.
when
we
what
are not
who
mo-
occurs. Per-
supposed to
That theme came up when the shadowfigure. Bill, "wanted all the compliments." It is clear from the
role of the doctors just being there and paying attention to
what has happened that they do not do anything. The situation has been recognized, it has been faced. And from the
very depths of the unconscious, the change has come, and
burst into the world. WTien it comes out there is much noise
and it is ugly and it stinks, but it is possible for dead w^oman,
congratulate ourselves.
now
420
ing, for instance, when the time is right. The other dead
woman, pristine and property peaceful, is dead for all time.
The death-in-life experiences which we call psychological
lcno\A-ing
life
in
We were
WE WERE BORN
DYING
421
full of distraction
constantly to
come
to terms in
dusk approached.
He had been ill for a week, with one of the chronic complaints that afflict the aging,
in bed.
had
felt
By
in
visit.
come
he told me
weekend had been
dried me up maybe
to analysis,
"Tliey totally
We
it
thoughts
rest,
relate
He
them
what he
after
"I
to you."
am
said
Vm
It is
422
remember when
of detachment.
My
It required a certain
be'let
'let
amount
of will, this
my
desires.
detachment it was
brush on my psyche.
'Tve always been goal-directed. I think basically that is
where the real desert of my life has been. As I look back on
it,
ment
of the present
the sacrafiction to
no
no
less goal-directed,
freer
nor
less
bound than
was
before;
it
(St.
like
is
it.
we
St.
we
try to
irritable
do too
if
it
is
muchlike
tlie
deprived
children
"Our thinking
futile things;
we become
may be futile
was perceived improperlytherefore we may have derived a false meaning.
Thus only through this mysterious organ in the psyche that
we call intuition are we at all able to arrive at a meaning of
what we have lived through, and the extent to which we have,
in participating in
it,
field
falsified it.
from
fear
and the
'false
my
anxieties'
life is to find a
freedom
me
since childhood."
Here
asked
"false anxieties."
WE
He
423
of causal relationship to
is
almost
of
life
am
to the shames
We
new
difficulties.
person seems to be in
much
new problems,
the same place
The
events in Abraham's
had
life
anticipated.
ver\^
It
on the new
He had been
424
He
posed.
and disquietude.
Then one day he came
him
in
WE WERE
BORN DYING
425
and
The
build-
how he said
With the
it
full daylight.
This
is
was:
"WTiat
ing,
is
light,
on the other
longer
strikes
that
I lost
me
as
Phenomeno-
logically, there
here.'
screen. First, I
The
a train.
building. It
first
that
is
floor as
it
a courthouse, but
you go
in.
[He
it
later realized,
upon
reflecting,
426
own
me
arrange mine,
I say
sit
her.
There
is
my
topcoat.
We
part of
My
o\mi
much
WE WERE BORN
DYING
427
am moving
to *gall
about
I
my
this
asked
"I
kibe.' I
am
movement."
him about
am moving
"the East.''
The
building
Spirit, of
carrying
is
WilHam
Blake and
men
turn
So
him
this
is
at this important
moment
in his life!
He
described this so
could
it.
of light.
"What
really startled
me
when
made
the effort of
recall,
the faint
body
is
recalled. I
w^as a stage
Direction, in terms of
an orientation so
Looking back over the records of his dreams over the past
few months he saw that over and over again the action upon
the inner screen was oriented with precise reference to the
cardinal points
of the
compass without
fail.
Abraham,
as
428
North
or South,
of amplification:
movement
is
ment
color. The ensuing dream spoke clearly of the balance of opposites, in showing to Abraham's dreaming mind
that neither the one extreme nor the other was wholly satisfactory. The being-there experience was a prefiguration of individuation, the actual attainment and, also, the indication
of the path that lay between the polarities. This was the
light
and
WE WERE
BORN DYING
429
on
is
periences
of
life.
To
seems to be a
train, or
One,
ciations.
ill
in the hospital,
not long
after.
Abraham commented on
"train,''
means
Putting
it all
as,
together, he
at different levels,
and
mettre en
word
to set to work,
throw into
train.
witliin different
430
totality:
bottom
is
by the
loss
satori.
latter was
one of the
This
When Abraham
cated
came
life situation.
He
in
"The woman
herself
parts:
word
distorted.
The
with
its
part,
were transcend-
all its
one
He empha-
mean distortions
much as an absolute
crooked,
parts of her.
way between the upper and the lower poles. Concealed behind
this mask must be the repressions which had been rejected
by the conscious mind.
"I do not believe in the censor of Freud," Abraham continued, "nor in a lot that flows from it. Nevertheless, I do
feel that much that he has interpreted and ascribed to this
automation is a result of factors that arise elsewhere, as is the
case in this dream. The dream itself obviously has reference
to the transference of patient to analyst.
that
if
ever.
I
I
further believe
woman was
very sensible.
WE WERE
The
BORN DYING
43
had been idealized by the patient. She had reanima of the patient, she reflected
beauty and wisdom, and her expressiveness, which meant so
much to him was S}Tnbolized by the opera star, a singer,
which is, of course, a homonym for the analyst's name: Singer.
But the analyst was also a person, a very human person, who
was in reality unable to measure up to the image in the psyche
of the patient. Tlie dream apprised him of this, by diminishing the overvalued physical appearance and the attraction of
the woman for him. This was the way the dream denied to
the patient and the analyst a full resolution of their relationship. The patient was responsive to the analyst on an unconscious level, as the dream showed, but the patient and the
analyst
The
analyst
Working through this dream became a profound experience for Abraham. It was no less so for me, for it deepened
my understanding of the process and brought me closer to
the experience of living toward death as I moved slowly
through the experience with my patient.
In the weeks tliat followed, Abraham regained the calm that
easily
responsibilities.
432
he began to delegate
sought out younger
men who would be able to assume the tasks which he himself
had been doing and who would be able, when the time came,
to relieve him of his responsibility. His analytic work became
increasingly important to him. Much of it was done without
the analyst's help, although he continued to come in and
discuss some of the events of his inner life which he felt
needed clarification.
Then one day he brought a dream which he did not understand, and which troubled him deeply. This is the dream:
I am married. I have one child, about eighteen months old,
barely walking. I take him by the hand and tell him that we
will have an adventure.
find ourselves by a gigantic conCrete sewer pipe. A small boat is at the landing.
get into
the boat and take off, beginning to descend.
go deeper
his contemplative practices. Gradually
He
We
is clear, it is
There
are
A woman
many
stores.
me
We
Much
We
We
boat. We
finally
We
walk through
business
is
being transacted.
can go back
one arm and pull the blanket over
his head and begin to swim upstream. I am not aware of any
cold. I feel quite warm.
arrive in a room far above. Another woman takes the child from me and I disrobe to my
shorts and dry myself. Shortly another woman comes to me
tells
is
finished. I
my
We
433
ness, when he had found the time to reflect upon his hfe as
he had Hved it in the past, goal-directed in his professional
work and even goal-directed in his spiritual pursuits. This
was the period during which the insights came which had
their fruition in his change of commitmentfrom goal to
process. Also, during this time there had been the s\\ing away
from the inner life, and the many distractions that brought
life
child,
at
it
through the
and sloughed
filth
oflf
is pure rain
through his working on it, his willingness to look
carefully
and
see the
meaning
in
it.
But again he
finds
re-
In time he
waters.
And,
in those waters
he
is
The
room
"far above,"
Upon
arri^ing here
at various stages
434
who
brings a
But the
give
child,
We
up
in
appearance
of a divine child heralds a new development, or an era of
important change. In most legends and myths the advent
the end?
of the child
is
historically the
Abraham's dream.
When
Not
so in
with
Abraham
the child.
falls
He
to his knees
and
asks
God
to give
prays.
may not
or
It
is
It
may be
answered.
him back
NOTES
INTRODUCTION
1.
2.
Ibid., p. 4.
3.
Ibid., p. 84.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Ibid., p.
32.
CHAP TE R
W.
1.
The
2.
Practice of Psychotherapy, C.
8, p.
3.
4.
5.
W.
377.
340.
NOTES
436
6.
7.
for Neurosis.
S. Chesser,
9.
Horace B. English and Ava C. English, A Comprehensive Dictionary of Psychological and Psychoanalytical Terms.
The
W.
Practice of Psychotherapy, C.
10.
11.
W.
therapy, C.
cit.,
16, p. 164.
p. 344.
The
Practice of Psycho-
16, p. 178.
CHAP TER
3.
4.
Psychiatric Studies, C.
5.
Ibid., p. 24.
6.
Ibid., p. 39.
1.
2.
7.
Ibid., p. 56.
8.
Eugen
Bleuler's article
W.
1.
"Upon
Word
Association,
Ibid.
10.
11.
"A Review
Dynamics
12.
Ibid., p. 93.
13.
Ibid.
of the
W.
Complex Theory,"
of the Psyche, C.
W.
in
3, p.
41.
The
Structure and
8, p. 92.
14.
Ibid., p. 96.
15.
J.
16.
Exodus 15:25.
17.
18.
E. Cirlot,
19.
Ibid., p. 50.
20.
Ibid., p. 72.
21.
22.
Ibid.,
23.
Ibid., p.
pp. 311-12.
312.
the Psyche, C.
W.
8, p.
311.
NOTES
437
CHAPTER
From
1.
2.
Ibid., p.
3.
Letter quoted in
4.
p.
148.
150.
Anima Concept/'
5.
Associations to Archetypes
\^'ith
p. 58.
The Archetypes
Collective Unconscious/'
of His
of the
of the Collective
Schriften
zur
F. Deuticke, Heft
theism, p.
7.
5,
in
the
7.
8.
9.
Ibid., p.
p.
10.
"The
152.
153.
Psychological Aspects of the Kore," in
II,
W.
The Archetypes
9,
i,
Def. 26;
p. 183.
"The Arche-
Anima Concept/'
"The
Psychology of the Child Archetype," and "The Psychological
Aspects of the Kore," all in The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, C. W. 9, i; Commentar}^ on The Secret of
chetypes with Special Reference to the
"Psychological Aspects
of
Works
12.
13.
at the
end of
this
Ibid.
W.
13.
For
of Jung's Collected
volume.
14.
list
W.
7, p.
65.
Two
Essays in
NOTES
438
CHAPTER 4
Are Archetypes Necessary?
1.
2.
3.
7.
8.
Ibid.
4.
5.
6.
416-17.
9.
10.
Ibid., pp.
417-18.
Roche Report:
Frontiers
of
Clinical
Psychiatry,
March
12,
1969.
11.
Ibid.
12.
13.
Ibid.
14.
15.
The Masks
of
W.
9,
i,
p. 5.
p. 30.
16.
17.
Campbell,
loc. cit.
CHAPTER
Analysis
1.
2.
"The Confessions
p. 175.
4.
by First Lieutenant
William L. Calley, Jr., interviewed by John Sack, in Esquire,
November, 1970.
Jung, Psychology and Alchemy, C. W. 12, p. 34.
The New York Times Magazine, June 1, 1969.
3.
of Lieutenant Calley,"
5.
Ibid.
6.
Ibid.
7.
p. 64.
NOTES
10
439
11
Ibid., p.
12
Ibid.
1,
1969, loc.
in
cit.
51.
13
Ibid.
14
Ibid., pp.
15
16
54-55.
In
W.
gion, C.
11, p. 7.
Ibid., p. 8.
18
19
20,
Ibid., p.
21,
"The Undiscovered
of a
Counter -Culture,
156.
Self,'' in Civilization in
Transition, C.
W.
10, p. 257.
22
Ibid.
23
24
and
in
pp. 155-56.
25.
Civilization in Transition, C.
W.
CHAPTER
Individuation:
1.
Two
2.
The
The
Secret of the
3.
Ibid.
4.
Jolande Jacobi,
The
Way
of Individuation, p. 19.
CHAPTER
Psychological Types:
Two
10, p. 488.
Key
to
Communications
Ibid., p.
24.
Ibid., p. 26.
Ibid., p. 27.
Ibid., p.
31.
440
NOTES
6.
Ibid.
7.
Ibid., p.
34
8.
Ibid., p.
39.
9.
10.
f.
Ibid., p. 40.
11.
12.
Ibid.
first
p. 9.
13.
Ibid., p. 513.
14.
Ibid., p. 516.
15.
Gerhard Adler, ''Methods of Treatment in Analytical Psychology," in Benjamin B. Wolman, PsychoaTialytic Techniques.
CHAPTER
Two
W,
7,
pp. 155-56.
Ibid., p. 156.
Afon, C.
Two
W.
9,
ii,
p. 8.
W.
7,
pp. 158-59.
Ibid., p. 159.
Ibid., p. 161.
Ibid., p. 162.
Vber die Energetik der Seele und andere psychologische Abhandlungen, Zurich: Rascher, 1928,
CHAPTER
p.
158.
Nihongi translated by
W.
G. Aston, and
cited in
the Othei?
Mircea Eliade,
From
2.
Two
3.
Erich
4.
Ibid.
5.
Cf. Erich
p.
W.
7, p.
188.
3.
M.
Esther Harding,
Human
Relationships^ J^^g's
Con-
NOTES
441
series,
6.
7.
The Masks
of
God,
also
8.
Two
9.
U.S.
of
Education estimates
for the
p.
29
f.
W.
7, pp. 204-5.
based on a probability
who
time by a United States university or four-year college during the entire academic year 1962-63, cited in the
in the University of
Chicago report,
Women
p. 71.
CHAPTER 10
Circumambulating the Self
1.
2.
3.
below.
4.
The
5.
William Blake,
6.
The
Song
of Liberty.
essay
"The Psychology
is
discussed
by Jung
in his
The
W.
9,
i.
7.
8.
9.
Ibid!
10.
11.
the
Historical
9,
i,
p. 263.
12.
NOTES
442
13.
Two
14.
Cf. Aion, C.
W.
The
Transference" in
15.
Aion,
16.
Ibid., p. 23.
17.
The
22 and
p.
ii,
9,
W.
Practice of Psychotherapy, C.
of the
W.
16.
loo. cit.
reader
is
Psychology^ C.
W.
7;
Two
Aion, C.
ligion:
C.
W.
9,
ii;
West and
W.
ference*' in
Cf. Jung,
W.
East^ C.
ConiunctioniSy C.
The
The
W.
9,
The
i;
all
Arof
Alchemical Studies,
12;
volumes of
Essays in Analyt-
18.
225.
7, p.
"The Psychology
W.
14;
Practice of Psychotherapy, C.
Secret of the
Golden Flower,
CHAPTER
p.
of the Trans-
W.
99
16.
f.
11
2.
3.
Ibid., p. 161.
4.
Ibid.
5.
"The
Practical
Psychotherapy, C.
6.
7.
in
The
Practice of
16.
"The
Practical
Use
Psychotherapy, C.
8.
W.
ff.
of
Dream
W.
Analysis," in
The
Practice of
16, p. 149.
Ibid., p. 147.
10.
11.
Jung,
9.
12.
13.
"On
of the Psyche, C.
W.
8.
The
Dream
Psycholog\%" and
Structure
and Dynamics
NOTES
443
CHAPTER
12
C. \V.
8.
CHAPTER
Religion:
to the
West and
Unknowable
1.
2.
W.
3.
4.
Ibid., pp.
East, C,
W.
Works
5.
Ibid., p.
Sym-
p. 182.
183.
W.
11, p. 84.
Who
8.
9.
Ibid., p.
''Five
as
5.
182-83.
6.
7.
11.
548.
10.
Ibid.
11.
ii,
p.
62
12.
Ibid.
13.
14.
Afon, C.
15.
W.
W,
f.
9,
ii,
p.
W.
12, p. 277.
167.
West and
East,
C.
W,
11,
pp.
201-96.
16.
Ibid., p.
17.
Ibid., p. 221.
18.
Ibid., pp.
19.
Ibid., p.
214.
226-27.
273.
20.
21.
Aion, C.
22.
In
The
W.
9,
Structure
417-551-
ii,
W.
12, pp.
338-39.
pp. 89-90.
and Dynamics
of the Psyche, C.
W.
8,
pp.
NOTES
444
23.
24.
The
25.
p. 127.
Structure and
Dynamics
W. 8, p. 475.
W. 11 contains
of the Psyche, C.
West and
East, C.
Weg zum
Selbst,"
"Fore\^-ord
"Commentary on The
nese Book of Life."
26.
W.
to
Secret of the
Golden Flower:
a Chi-
of the Dead,
mth
a psychological
commentary by Dr. C. G.
Jung.
27.
28.
Ibid.
29.
"Psychological
31.
504-5.
Cf. M. Esther Harding, The
Psychology and Religion, C.
32.
Ibid., p.
33.
Ibid., p. 535.
30.
"F
W.
of the Great
W.
11,
pp.
525-26.
533.
CHAPTER 14
Were Bom Dying
We
1.
2.
3.
4.
tient
NOTES
445
on the whole, and with the whole person obsen^ed, something like treating the patient with a g>'psy
dream book. So little comes from the patient and so much
from the analyst. I suspect the long silences and the aptrary
meanings,
is^
mind from
Heraclitus
(c.
540-475
was said to be
b.c.)
uniform fact
in
nature
is
He
constant change.
and
multiplicity.
man
in a real sense
He
thus arri\'ed
The
senses are
"bad
consist in
witnesses'^;
Seven
Sermom
of the
Dead,
cf.
is
chapter 13,
LIST OF
WORKS CITED
BOOKS
Press (1959).
CiRLOT, J. E.:
Dictionary of Symbols.
New
New
York: Viking
York: Philosophical
Library (1962).
Eliade, Mircea:
From
Primitives to Zen.
New
Row
(1967).
Images and Symbols, translated by Philip Mairet, from the
:
LIST OF
448
English, Horace B., and
Ava C:
WORKS CITED
Comprehensive Dictionary of
New York: Long-
{1969).
for
Meaning.
New
York: Washing-
Works,
from the German under the GenJames Strachey, in collaboration with Anna
by Alix Strachey and i\lan Tyson. London: The
translated
eral Editorship of
Freud, assisted
(1970).
Jai^ies: Suicide
New
Row
(1964).
New
(1959)-
Neurosis.
New
WORKS CITED
LIST OF
Jones, Ernest;
The
Life
449
and
Work
of
Sigmund Freud,
New
3 vols.
Translated by R. F. C. Hull.
Two
Vol. 7:
The
Vol. 8:
Vol.
9,
i:
Structure
the
Collective
Unconscious
Jaffe.
(1963).
:
Modern Man
in Search of a
Soul
New
York:
Harvest
New
:
Psychological
Trubner (1922).
et al.r Studies in
Dr.
:
M. D.
Eder,
by
The
Secret of the
translated
tary
(1965).
:
Vber
450
J-IST
Jung,
OF WORKS CITED
Analytical Psy-
cholog}'
New
Psyche:
New
of
York: Pan-
Company (1937).
Tinbergen, N.: The Study
of Instinct.
London: Oxford
Universit}'
Press (1951).
of the Puer Aetemus. New
York: Spring Publications (1970). A private limited edition.
\\ HiTMONT, Edward C: The Symbolic Quest. New York: G. P. Put-
WoLMAN, Benjamin
ment
in Analytical Psycholog}'"
article,
(1967).
"Methods
New
of Treat-
LIST OF
WORKS CITED
45
PERIODICALS
BehayioT Today, June 22, 1970.
Chicago Sun-Times, August 12, 1970, p. 64.
Greeley, Andrew M.: "There's a New Time Religion on Campus/^
Psychological
Present,"
Eranos-Jahrbuch
Historical
XXXVI/1967,
Jung,
1953/'
Spring, 1971.
Roche Report:
March
12, 1969.
OTHER SOURCES
Jacobi, JoLiNDE:
Two
Women (May
1,
INDEX
Aborigines, 73. See also Archaic
(primitive) man and archaisms
Academic
pressures, analysis
trickster
and
ff.
archet}'pe
and, 2S9
Active imagination, 337-65, 371,
376. 403
Adler, Alfred, 39; and Individual
Psychology, 180, 181-82
Adler, Gerhard, 343
Affect (s), repression and, 102-3.
See also Emotions; Feelings
Aggression
(aggressiveness )
217-18, 354
373,
process),
aspects,
individuals,
kinds);
and,
337-65;
concept and,
247-69 {see also Anima; Ani-
mus);
bility'
availability
and
concepts,
active
accessi-
of analyst to analysand
process,
{see
also
38S-94, 399
Alienation, 81-82, 89
Alpert, Richard, 41
Amnesia, periodic, xxxii
Analysand. See Analysis (analytical process)
Analysis
(analytical
imagination
animus-anima
ff.;
and
and
aspects,
personas
and
concepts )
shadows,
psychedelics,
and
209-27;
140-47; relationship between
analyst and analysand and,
15-36, 173-75 {see also spe-
cie
aspects);
screening
for,
332-375.
INDEX
454
"Analysis
Dreams"
of
(Jung),
304
Psychology (Jungian
psychology and analysis), xi-
Analytical
xivff.,
111-12,
concepts
Archetypes
(archet^'pal
figures
and images; archetypal journey,
situations,
xxxiii,
imagination
140,
370,
292
and,
337--65,
376, 403; animus-anima
Myths;
types;
13, 20,
142,
and
vision),
91-96, 97-119,
281-91,
147,
ff.
conscious;
74
{see
also
Individuation
process);
and
instincts,
84;
conscious
{see
Unconscious,
283-84,
291-92,
294-96,
379.
See
also Non-rationalism
Anxiety, 422-23, 424, 429
"Archaic Man'* (Eliade), 72-74
ff.,
81,
109,
Uncon-
Mjths;
the;
scious,
aspects,
specific
374-80, 381
"Archetypes of the Collective
Unconscious" (Jung), 117
185, 187-88
psychological types and,
x\ristotle,
Artists,
197
complex
Assimilation,
theory
and, 61-62
Association (s )
38,
and,
53-57,
304,
complexes and,
87; dreams
309-11; symbols
84,
and, 140
Astrology,
attitudinal
t}'pes
aspects,
specific
and,
379;
psychological
equi-
behavior
conscious,
development of
self
ff.;
and, 278,
INDEX
455
Attitudes {confd)
293
ation
Ego; Individ-
{see also
ff.
Aztecs,
97
Bakan, David, 99
Basilides, 373
Bastian, Adolf, 118
Beatles (music group), 399
Behaviorists, 114
Behavior therapy, 1, 14
Bible, 369-70. See also specific
aspects, individuals
factors, animus and
anima and, 231, 232-35, 265
Bird symbolism, 168-72
Black magic, 130-365.
Biological
{see
155, 157-78
Individuation proc-
process,
also
ess)
relationship):
specific
aspects); psy-
(Jung), 385-87
Christianity, 130, 138, 180, 185,
300-1,
340,
350,
351-53,
384-85
Collected Works (Jung), xiii.
See also individual works
representations,"
"Collective
L^vy-Bruhl on, 136-37
Collective unconscious
(collective psyche), 40, 72, 80-81,
89, 399 {see also Psyche; Un-
conscious;
specific
concepts);
archetypes
Catharsis, 313
Centrality,
340,
90-96,
also
Circle
385-86. See
(and
sphere)
concepts, kinds )
culture,
and,
{see
also
113-120
Archetypes); and dreams, 305,
306;
Jung's
formulation
of,
symbolism
Change
aspects,
INDEX
456
counter-culture
Communality,
and, 148-49 ff.
(understandCommunication
animus-anima concept
ing)
and, 231-69 passim; psychological types and, 1795. {see
:
Personal
also
relationships;
specific aspects)
psychological
Compulsiveness,
types and, 195-96
(polarities);
types;
cal
psychologiaspects,
specific
kinds
Consciousness, xxx-xxxi, xxxixxxii, 5-6, 11-12, 22, 93 {see
Self-awarealso
Awareness;
ness; Unconscious, the; specific aspects); active imagination and,
337-65 passim;
concept and,
animus-anima
231
ff.,
237
ff.,
262
ff.;
of,
ff.,
116
also
religion (s),
and
198-208;
367-404 passim; and self,
2735., 280 ff., 291 ff., 299 ff.;
and transcendent function,
333-37 ff.; and unconscious
and dreams, 303 ff., 308-9,
317, 320, 322-23, 324, 32526 {see also Dreams)
Convergent thinking, 115-16
Corpus Hermeticum, 117
ff.;
24-31,
325-26
Creation legends, 368, 389
energy),
(creative
Creativity
tion
anima
250,
{see
arche-
Daedalus, 293
Death (dying), 373, 374, 400,
409-34; and dreams, 305,
Decision-making,
420
ff.
typology
and
INDEX
457
Schizophrenias
(Bleuler),
47,
45
Demons
(demonic
elements),
Spirits;
birth),
424-34;
symbolism
Depression (s),
and,
58,
122,
and
74;
dreams,
41^19.
415-17^
319-20;
discussing,
individuation
and,
165-78;
and
terpretation
ing of,
and
process
in-
understand-
303-30, 331-32
{see
315-19,
and
tyipQs
De
psychological
322;
and, 194-95, ^5
Profundis (Tennyson), 100
Depth
ps^'cholog}^
19,
94,
99,
115
Destructiveness. See
destructiveness
) ;
E\'il
(devils,
specific
as-
and
psychological
206-8;
and
31411.;
types,
purposiveness
in,
religion (s),
in
387un-
(histories)
Drug
x\a,
321-26;
of,
"vir-
319-20
ginal,"
experiences,
(psychedelic)
dso Psychedelic
410-14
{see
Double-consciousness, xxxii
Double
descent
(parentage)
drugs )
counter-culture
myth, 90-91
Drawing. See Painting (drawing)
Dream histories (dream series),
151^ 153
321-26
Dreams
(dreaming),
xxxi, 301-30 {see also
127-28,
and,
140-47,
131,
130,
399-405
xix-xxi,
specific
27,
29-30,
3075.;
34,
animus-anima concept and,
248-51,
237-38,
254-55,
culture,
women
Ego
i2iff.;
men261-62
higher,
relation and,
(ego-consciousness,
functioning),
11,
12,
ego-
272-
aspects,
INDEX
458
Ego {confd)
Ex-perience,
jective,
Extra verts
(extra version),
psy-
and
390
89;
psychological
183-84,
religion (s)
ff.;
and
self,
401-8,
sirtiy
Self);
and,
272-302
{see
434
ff.;
pasalso
function
transcendent
333-37
types
214-15;
and alchemy,
194,
and
uncon-
scious,
Elektra complex, 39
neuroses, 37
72 ff {see also
Complexes; Neuroses)
flF.,
Fantasy
(fantasies),
xvii-xx,
xxiii,
Feelings,
378-79
Moods;
tudes; Emotions;
cific aspects,
and, 37
ff.,
93,
spe-
kinds); complexes
61-62; psychologi-
192-
197-208 passim
Femininity,
See
229-70.
also
Anima
Free
association,
and
dreams,
Freudian
xviii,
31,
180-83;
80;
xii,
psychology),
52; Adler and,
and complexes, 52,
and
44,
dreams,
44,
181,
mons;
xxxi-xxxii,
Evil
(devils,
destructiveness),
shadow
and, 225-26
concepts, kinds);
sonality
per-
xxxiii,
2,
39,
48,
INDEX
459
and
anal)idc
theor)',
(sexualit}^)
108-9
Fromm,
Erich,
99
Functions
"Gifted
198-208
The'^
Child,
and
superior
ff.;
ff.,
t}^es),
Higher
and
psyche
159-60, 208,
278 ff., 312
148,
self
247,
and,
271
217-18
and,
278,
{see
74-77
Lama
also
Anagarika, 41
Greeley,
Group
movements,
\''i-
aspects, kinds
Psychedelic
Monogamy
(Otto), 253-54
Heine, Heinrich, 185
Icarus,
I
293
Ching, 131. 133
Id, the,
87-88
Identity
crisis,
210, 212
Images
{see
Fantasy;
ff.
Archetypes;
also
Imagination; Myths;
Visions;
specific
shadow
and, 225-27
kinds )
aspects,
projections
also
active,
337-
(hallucinations); specific
See
lachhus, 286
specific aspects);
Hallucinogens.
146, 275
xii,
Imagination,
counter-
sions
movement,
potential
148-53
293,
Religion [s])
Govinda,
Human
Huxley, Aldous,
272-73,
31-32,
ff.,
men-women
261-62, 265
and, 398-99
Hosrilit}'-,
ity),
xii
education,
Rabbi, 9
Hillman, James, 321
Homosexuality, 27-29,
(Jung),
Glover, Edward, 93
Goal-directedness
(intentional-
"Has
422
Hermann,
Hesse,
2S7, 333
Horoscopes, predictive astrology
154
God,
Heracles, 239
Heraclitus,
Hillel,
xii
192
relation and,
(functional
inferior,
Failed?"
and, 90-96,
Archet}pes
118
{see
also
types
and,
179-208. See
kinds
INDEX
460
Individuality^ 13-14, 26. See also
Individual differences; Individ-
uation process
Individual Psychology, Adler and
school of, 180, 182-83
Individuation process, 3, 8-13,
155, 157-78, 343 ff.,
388-89; active imagiand,
nation
337-65,
371;
animus-anima concept and,
231-69, 271; and death and
26, 72,
375
ff.,
passim;
410-34
rebirth,
de-
Intuition
80,
(intuitiveness),
379-
psychological
types
422;
ff.,
207-8
Invincibility (power) personality,
94
ff.
Irenaeus, 117
Ir^ationalit}^
See Non-rationalism
"Ivenes," 51, 53
fined,
ism,
and,
271-302 passim; religion (s)
and,
375 ff., 38793 ff.; transcendent function
Infancy,
psychological
function,
Inferior
Inferiority complex,
Innate
39
mechanism
releasing
(IRM), 118
Instincts
ture),
367
(and
94,
instinctual
98,
180-83,
na-
352,
(intellectualism),
Jacobi, Jolande,
371,
Jaffe,
Christ, 234,
273,
385, 391-96, 411, 414
Jones, Ernest, 99
Jesus
Joplin, Janis,
Jung,
56-57
Association
of
(introversion),
125,
134,
154,
and
man,
arche^es,
38,
81,
(primitive)
117-18,
{see
also
collective
psy-
136,
137;
xxxiii,
x\ii,
97-101 ff.,
286, 28S
Archetypes); and
83-96,
232-33,
unconscious
unconscious )
{see
and
Complexes);
counter-culture and, 126, 12829, 130, 133, 134-35; 3nd
Collective
complexes
264
ess,
296,
297
Carl G.,
International
7-8
198-208
ff.,
{see
and
individuation
process,
155,
158-60,
172-73;
165,
INDEX
461
and work
83
18
{see
of, xi-xxxv, 2 ff .,
107, 367
ff.,
also
ff.,
410, 417-
specific aspects,
writings);
concepts,
and na-
tionalism,
roses,
xxv-xxix,
xxxi-xxxii,
45-53,
78-82, 132-33, 136, 137-39
{see also Occult phenomena);
and personas and shadows,
Unconscious, the;
concepts);
symbolism, xxxiii, 140,
also
specific
and
xviii,
"two
Sym-
{see also
personalities
of,"
xxiv-xxvi
Jung
cific aspects,
kinds
Leonardo da Vinci, 90
Levi-Strauss, Claude, xii
Marriage; Sex[uality];
Women-men
aspects,
specific
relationship;
concepts);
LSD.
See
drugs
Psychedelic
(hallucinogens)
Luther, Martin, 418-19
aspects,
146, 299-300
bols);
Institute, Zurich, 7
Krishna, 285
of,
131-33
ff.
Love;
Wisdom
"Koinonia," 148
Krafft-Ebing. See
Ebing, Richard
Women-men
relation-
animus-anima concept
and, 2 36ff., 265-69, 295-96,
297-99; complexes and, 65,
ship);
Von
Krafft-
66;
psychological
types
and.
INDEX
462
Mysterium
Marriage (cont'd)
199-205;
196-98,
shadow
personality and, 2 1 6
Mystery
ff
229-69.
ff.,
297-
and
See
imagination,^' 118
See
{see also
263; discovery of
self
and, 292
child relationship
My
Occult
Un-
95-96, 99Archetypes);
self
300
Mystics (mysticism), xxviii-xxix,
80. See also Eastern religions
and philosophy; Occult phenomena; Religion (s)
Myth of the Birth of the Hero,
The (Rank), 90
Mythologems, 91, 113, 272
Myths (mythology),
xx-xxii, 20,
229,
108,
232;
specific
kinds )
concepts,
concept
archetypes
and,
and,
(see also
(Jung), 279
Monroe, Marilyn, 297
also
also
(see
animus-anima
141-47
Metzner, Ralph, 41
in Search of a Soul
and,
100
concepts
Modern Man
ings)
archetypes
aspects,
of,
373-79
Otherness;
relationship; spe-
cific aspects,
Moods
Women-men
xx,
Anima;
also
Dreams,
xvii,
xxxii-xxxiii,
Mass
Mescaline, use
(mysteries),
xxv-xxvii,
femininity,
209-27, 282
Men-women
xxiv,
phenomena;
Animus
Masks (personas), and shadows,
Memories,
Coniunctionis
Narcolepsy, xxxii
Nationalism, 154-55, 226
Nature,
404
tive]
351,
353,
380,
388,
man and
archaisms; spe-
cific
aspects);
Neologisms, 50
INDEX
463
Neumann,
On
Erich, 233
Neuroses, xxii-xxiv,
80
xxviii, 2,
82, 314
ff.,
408
{see also
Com-
plexes;
specific
aspects,
con-
tion and,
and,
self
314
337-65; archetypes
91-97
discovery
ff.;
of
and,
ff.;
180-84; Jung on
purposiveness of, 30-31, 32,
314 ff.; personas and repressions and, 221-22 ff.; psychoand,
181-88,
logical
types
and,
repressions
194-95 ^-y
84-97 ff., 222 ff.; tran83,
scendent function and, 33337 ff.; unconscious and, 80-82
Nietzsche, Friedrich, 182
theories of,
Non-rationalism,
73-74,
also
369
xi,
ff.,
xiii,
xviiff.,
379-80
Anti-intellectualism;
tellect;
scious,
Rationalism;
the;
specific
{see
In-
Uncon-
Normal (cy), 14
Numinosum, 139-40,
377, 382
Nurturance, animus and anima
and, 233-34, 238-42, 263
223
Occult
phenomena, xxv-xxix,
xxxi-xxxii, 45-53, 1 30-34 ff.,
369 ff., 398 {see also Alchemy;
Astrology;
ff.,
Parapsychology;
Supematuralism;
pects,
specific
concepts,
Cpposites
(polarities )
and principle
concept
352-54, 374386-87,
388-89,
381,
76,
of,
types;
specific
as-
concepts
Otto, Herbert A., 253-54
Otto, Rudolph, 138
aspects,
concepts);
counter-culture
psychological
and,
1 30 ff .;
types and, 190-208 passim
Obsessions, 84
as-
kinds )
(drawing )
Painting
33 8-4 3
346-54^ 358-63
Paradox, 6. See also Opposites
(polarities); Otherness
Parapsychology (ESP), 46-53,
77-81, 133-34, 398. See also
Occult phenomena; specific aspects, kinds
Parent-child
also
relationship
{see
Father-child relationship;
animus-anima
aspects )
concept and, 250 ff., 239-41,
257-60; understanding dreams
and, 307-19
cific
272-302
Personality,
3
32-37
Psyche;
ff.
specific
Self;
aspects,
con-
cepts, e.g.,
ses);
passim,
Ego;
{see also
INDEX
464
Prima
Personality {cont'd)
transformation
354-55
337 ^v
of,
dreams
specific
kinds,
e.g.,
materia,
undifferentiated
274-75
self as,
Projection,
397-
98
_
dreams
337-65;
Dreams);
self
transcendent
333-37
and
{see
and, 277-78;
function
and,
ff-
mulation
of,
for-
95-96
Phaethon, 293
Philemon, 369-70, 372
Philo Judaeus, 117
xxx-xxxi.
See
Physics,
Projections
mecha-
(projecting
xviii,
33, 375.
sonality;
scious,
xxiii,
{see also
Uncon-
Soul[s];
the;
aspects,
specific
archet\^es and,
also
Science
283-91
.\rchet\^es )
{see
collective
Collective unconscious);
{see
187-88
Fleroma, 374-76, 379
Poetry, 334-35
Polarities.
ties);
Otherness; Ps>'chological
types
Possession, 40. See also Demons;
Evil (devils, destructiveness
Power
instinct
(power-complex),
323. 327
Pre-conscious, Freud and, 94, 95
Predictions,
astrological,
394-
400
Pregnancy, 233-34
Primal therapy, 2, 14
goal-directedness
regulation
in,
271 ff.,
247,
personas and
and
self-
160-61, 208,
312-13;
278,
shadows and,
The
Metzner
Alpert), 41, 400
(Leary,
Psychoanalytic
and
theory,
83-96,
109-ic, 180-84, 368-69. See
INDEX
465
*Tsychological
Mother
40
Aspects
Archetype"
of
the
(Jung )
types,
179-208.
Psychological
400
"Psychology of Dementia Praecox, The'' (Jung), 61
"Psychology of the Unconscious,
30-31, 223
Complexes; Neuro-
xxviii,
also
specific aspects,
concepts,
96
Psychotherapy
{see
also
th erapy )
Analysis;
Psychology;
specific
1 ff
Analytical
aspects,
also
370-72,
transcendent
333-37
Puer aeteinus
381-82;
function
and,
{puella
also
{see
Intellect;
Thinking);
counter-culture
and,
129-30 ff.; and nonism)
Rational
{see Non-rational-
psychological
190-91
ff.,
199-200
Rational therapy,
t}pes,
ff.
40,
concepts,
aspects,
kinds);
imagination
active
and, 343-44, 359-65; dreams
specific
and,
309,
322-30;
personas
and,
t}^pes
Reform
1,
aeterna)
14
and,
counter-culture
153-55;
Reichian bio-energetics, 1
Reincarnation, 51, 136
Rejection,
170, 176-78,
316, 333-37 ff"Relations between the
the
Unconscious,
(Jung), 158-59
Religion (s), and
Spirits
aspects,
theory, xxx-xxxi
also
xi.
the
294,
Ego and
The"
religiousness,
86-
movement):
(reform
XX,
ff-
Quantum
371-72,
ff.,
tiplicity of, 2 ff
ses;
190-99
xvi,
rationalism
Psychological
{see
xiii,
{see also
[spirituality];
religions);
117,
283,
God;
specific
counter-
,:
466
INDEX
Repression (confd)
and archetypes,
268;
244,
102 ff.; and dreams, 304, 313;
personas and shadows and,
215-27 passim
Resistance, analytic process and,
22,
34-36
"Resistances,"
repression
and,
Sacrifice,
(biblical),
369
Schizophrenia, 45, 83-84, 188
389; psychotherapy
on, 371
as,
Jung
the
Golden Flower^
self-knowledge),
self-image,
12,
40,
75-
434
Con-
process;
Self-realization
{see
individuation
158-78
tion
{see
process;
also
Self)
and,
process
also
Individua-
specific
aspects,
concepts
Semiotic interpretation of symbols, Jung and, 140
"Senex" (aged) archetypes, 288,
290
201
ff.
Sensitivity training, 2
Serial
monogamy, 253-54
aspects,
concepts,
and,
27-29, 31-32; animusanima concept and, 229-69
analytic
process
23,
They 160
Self
384-408;
kinds);
of
and spirituality
shadow personality
and,
216-27; and
symbols, 275, 276 ff.,
280,
282-91 ff., 299-301
71; religion (s)
and,
Secret
93-94
Salome
Psyche);
animus-
ied,
300
99
Tradition
Baka n )
INDEX
467
Reform)
shadow projections and, 227
neo-
psychologies,
Social
Freudian,
eot}^es)
xxxii,
(Blake), 284
conscious;
animus-anima
concept
and,
2445.
xxi,
40,
86,
81,
275-76,
373 ff. {see cdso Demons; Evil;
Occult phenomena; Psyche;
aspects,
con-
archet}'pes,
80,
Soul[s];
specific
cepts);
and
104-7
^^^ Archetypes);
(^^^
and,
counter-culture
147-49;
417-18
Stone
S)Tiibolism,
(lapis)
91. 392
Students, and
121
388-
counter-culture.
ff.
Studies
Word
in
and,
394-400;
and,
1 39and, 67-72,
dreams
207-8, 309, 425-34
{see also Dreams); individuation and, 165-78; mythology'
41
ff.;
ff.,
384-94^
(Jung), 87
123-24
Superego, 87-89
Superior function, psychological
types and, 1922., 198-208
Spirits;
specific
as-
Superstitions,
(Jung), 92
Synchronicity, 395, 398, 426
"Synchronicity:
An
Acausal
Table-turning, 50
Association
Symbols
85,
274,
(spirituality),
Spirits
100-1
165
{see
its;
30 ff.;
92-96,
{see also Archetypes);
and,
counter-culture
48
Sorors, 131
7,
and,
process
lytic
astrolog}^
Somnambulism,
Song of Liberty
422
archet}'pes
Soul(s),
47
(symbolism)^
xix-xxi,
St., 422
Textbook of Psychiatry
(Krafft-
Ebing), xxvii-xxviii
Therapy
chotherapy)
"There's a
defined, 20
New Time
Religion
chetypes
as
119-20;
psychological
categories
for,
types
INDEX
468
Thinking (cont'd)
and, 190, 191-93, 194, 195^
197-208 passim
"Three world'' s}Tnbolism, 69-
70
Tibetan Book of the Dead, The,
400-3
birth),
of,
ff.,
107-10;
sion);
self
273-81
ff.,
Tumtypes,
transcendent
psychological
typol-
concepts);
per-
209-
aspects,
112-13
Ulysses,
xxxi-xxxii,
20-22,
96
9,
ff.,
11-12,
19,
P^^^y
87-
214-20
[see
25-34
211
ff.,
4,
unconscious;
Psyche; specific aspects, concepts ) ;
imagination
active
and, 337-65; analytic process
also
and,
Collective
18-34
specific
P^^^
(^^^
^^^
concepts);
concept and,
aspects,
animus-anima
229, 231 ff., 237 ff., 254 ff.,
263-69; archetypes and, 91111-12 ff., 27396, 97 ff.,
81 ff.,
290-91 ff., 298-302;
complexes and, 37 ff., 62-82
passim; dangers in stirring up,
and,
367-402
86-88 ff.
and,
Represarchetype of,
repression
ff.;
{see
also
as
290
ff.,
298-302;
and,
function
ff-
121
ff.
Attitudes;
specific
kinds);
concept and,
concepts,
aspects,
Unconscious, the,
xxv,
cific
{see
208
xvii, xxiii,
8799-100 ff.,
108-9,
96 ff.,
206 ff., 214-20 {see also spe-
333-37
Two
in-
animus-anima
230, 232-33, 234-35, 262 ff.;
individuation process and, 158
Vietnam War, 126-27, 154, 226
"Virginal dream,'' 319-20
64-65,
133-36,
369 ff392 ff., 429 {see also Archet\'pes; Demons; Images; Imagination;
pects )
Spirits;
specific
psychedelic,
as-
141-48,
149
Von
Krafft-Ebing,
Richard,
xx\ii-xxviii
War
V^ietnam W^ar
Watts, Alan, xii
INDEX
469
Way
"Will
also
to
power/'
Power
181-82. See
(power-
instinct
complex)
280-81, 288, 298,
377-79. See also Knowledge
Wise man archetype, 298
Wishes,
unconscious,
dreams
specific
masculinity
Wisdom,
Women-men
ity];
relationship
(see
aspects,
kinds):
and problems
and
femininity
199-208
Women's
liberation
movement,
261, 264-65
Word
association, 53-57,
86-87
XX.
Published by Princeton
1.
On
New
Jersey
Phenomena
(1902)
On
Cryptomnesia (1905)
On Manic Mood
Disorder (1903)
Case of Hysterical Stupor in a Prisoner in Detention (1902)
On Simulated Insanity (1903)
A Medical Opinion on a Case of Simulated Insanit}' (1904)
A Third and Final Opinion on Two Contradictory Psychiatric Diag-
noses (1906)
On
2.
STUDIES IN
The
Associations of
WORD
Normal
Experimental Observations on
The
An
ASSOCIATION (1904-7)
Memory
Association Experiment
472
C.
G.
JUNG
The
"^^
S(
On
Pneumo-
Jung)
Further Investigations on the Galvanic Phenomenon and Respiration
in
3.
The Psychogenesis
of
and Jung)
On
On
On
On
4.
Prince,
"Mechanism and
Interpretation of Dreams'":
Review (1911)
Criti-
C.
JUNG
G.
473
ence (1914)
Prefaces to "Collected Papers on Analytical Psychology"
(1916,
1917)
The
(1909/1949)
Introduction to Kranefeldt's "Secret
Ways
of the
Mind" (1930)
5.
Symbols
of Transformation
PART
Introduction
Two
Kinds of Thinking
II
Introduction
the
Mother
Epilogue
6.
Introduction
The Problem
of
Types
in
Thought
Schiller's Ideas
of
Human
Character
474
C.
G.
JUNG
Modem
Philosophy
Biography
in
in
Conclusion
7.
On
Two
8.
On
The
Structure and
Dynamics
The
On
Human
in Psychology (1929)
Behaviour (1937)
On
Spirit
Appendix:
On
An
Sjuchronicit)' (1951)
9.
PART
G.
C.
JUNG
475
edition,
1968)
The Phenomenology
On
9.
PART
II
Aion (2nd
edition,
1968)
The Ego
The Shadow
The Syzygy: Anima and Animus
The Self
Christ, a
Symbol of the
Self
476
C.
G.
JUNG
Man
(1931)
Woman
of
a Student (1928)
Europe (1927)
in
Wotan
(1936)
The Undiscovered
Self (Present
Flying Saucers:
A Modem Myth
View
(1958)
of Conscience (1958)
Evil in Analytical Psychology (1959)
Psychological
Good and
The
Reviews of Keyserling's "America Set Free" (1930) and "La Revolution Mondiale" (1934)
Complications of American Psychology (1930)
The Dreamlike World of India (1939)
What
India
11. Ps}^chology
West and
and Religion:
WESTERN RELIGION
Psychology and Religion (The Terry Lectures) (1938/1940)
Psychological Approach to the Dogma of the Trinity (1942/1948)
\G
|tHE
collected works of
Cure
C.
G.
JUNG
477
of Souls (1928)
Ching" (1950)
12. Psychology
Prefatory
Note
Weg zum
edition,
1968)
added 1967)
Alchemy
Alchemy (1936)
Dream Symbolism
Religious Ideas in
in Relation to
Alchemy (1937)
Epilogue
14.
edition,
1970)
478
C.
G.
JUNG
The
Spirit in
Man,
Art,
Paracelsus (1929)
Sigmund Freud
in
On
16.
The
What
is
Psychotherapy? (1935)
Fundamental Questions
of Psychotherapy (1951)
17.
The Development
of Personality (1954)
C.
G.
JUNG
479
19. Bibliography
and Index
COMPLETE BIBLIOGRAPHY OF
C.
Vv^ORKS
(in preparation)
G.
JUNG's ^-RITINGS
R3
Psychology
JUNE SINGER
BOUNDARIES
OF THE SOUL
The Practice of Jung's Psychology
'Mt is
Jung around
and constructed book with a
warm and lovely and rich..."
beautifully conceived
is
Joseph Campbell
"In a
that this
to
have been published, because it gives away the essential secrets of psychotherapy and is from the pen
of one of the great masters of the art." Alan Watts
^B[SS^
isbn: o-385-o69oo-6