Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
工 業 設 計 研 究 所
碩 士 論 文
虛擬實境對自行車人體動作實驗影響之研究
The Virtual Reality Applicate Problems and Motion Sickness in
Human Motion Analysis of Bicycle
研 究 生:吳信典
指導教授:陳建旭
中 華 民 國 八 十 八 年 六 月
中文摘要
本研究主要探討虛擬實境在自行車人體動作分析使用上可行性
之問題。由人因設計為出發點來探討此論點,探討虛擬世界和真實世
界間的關係﹔在實驗過程中,受測者會在真實世界及虛擬世界中騎乘
自行車,於實驗室中的虛擬世界騎乘自行車之時,受測者將會頭戴「頭
盔顯示器」來模擬真實世界中所看到的事物,受測者在接受測試的同
時,我們將以攝影機來記錄受測者騎乘的動態姿勢,在整個實驗過程
中,改變場景顯像方式,來比較受測者在虛擬世界和真實世界中的反
應,藉由 T 檢定以及 One-Way ANOVA 來比較虛擬實境與真實世界中之
不同的運動分析數據,以獲得虛擬實境與現實世界的差異點;最後,
探討在實驗過程中,虛擬實境技術對於人因設計的影響,並討論虛擬
實境應用是否會帶來不良的副作用以及對受測者產生不適應感。
英文摘要
Keywords:
Virtual Reality、Virtual World、Reality World、Human Factors Design、Bicycle、
Human Postures、Ergonomics、Human Factor、Motion Analysis System、
Human Performance。
HMD
1.2
HMD
1.3
3D
110 ( )
21 100
1.4
pdf ps (PostScript )
Html 1999
pdf 216
( VR 500 1993-1999 )
pdf
Adobe Arcobat Exchange 3.0 300dpi
pdf ps Adobe Arcobat Distillr 3.0 pdf
PDF Writter pdf
5 (Human
Factors) 14 (Computer Graphices) 9
28
HCI(107 )
Motion Analysis(12 ) VR for Face Application(5 ) Virtual Actors(14
) VR (10 ) Virtual Enviroments(6 ) Stereo
Display(7 ) (10 ) 171 WTK
(3 ) (14 )
HCI VR HCI
107 Stanford 86 Cambridge 6
Delaware 6 Maryland HCI 4
HCI 5 HCI
HMD 3 HMD 1
HUD
4 6
2 1
2
18 ( 9%)
198 ( 91%)
1997 1999
80 1999
HCI
2.1
2.1.1
( 1989)
2.1.2
(Wood worth)
5
15 20
55
70 94
(Stereo Scope)
(Stereo
Scope)
(Double Image)
(HUD) 30
90 0.7
180,000 640 480
60MHZ 8
226.7
2.1.3
( )
(1)
(2)
(3)
2.2
2.2.1
(1)
(2)
(3)
2.2.2
(1)
( )
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
1950 ( )
1990
(1)
Sense8
World Tool Kit NT Release 7
wtkgui40.lib wtkgui42.lib.
800 Wtk.pdf
CAD
Curves-Base
Curves-Base
Microstation Geometric-Base
Geometric-Base
(x, y, z)
( Z
1 Scaling Matrix )
Geometric-Base
( )
Geometric-Base 3D Studio
Max Maya VRML
Geometric-Base WTK
LoadObject (szFileName);
WTuniverse_go();
WTK C
(2)
Image-Base
24Bits
Bytes Image-Base
Vector
Graphic
CPU Raster
Graphics Raster Graphics
MS-DOS
Windows GDI
Graphics Device Interface
API
Direct-X
2.2.4
(Translator)
(Image Generators) (Display)
2.2.5
(1) VRML
MUD Telnet
Windows Game
VRML VRML
JAVA
3D Avatar
(2)Quick Time VR
Apple Computer
15 24
A. (Panoramas)
QTVR
360 3D
B. (Objects)
QTVR
.. .
2.3
2.3.1
(
VTC-Internet.mpg vcontrol.mpg)
2.3.2
Geneva
NVE(Networked Virtual Environments)
NVE VLNET(Virtual Life Network Systems)
(Magnetic)
HMD 247*230 57600 NTSC
SGI Onyx2
Onyx(ATM )
ATM
ATM
2.3.3
Hull
(Virtual Enviroment Knee arthroscopy Training
System; VE-KATS)
(Electromagnetic Tracker)
( vekats.mpg)
(HUD)
2.3.4
Kansas
(http://ukanaix.cc.ukans.edu/~mreaney )
2.4
2.4.1 HMD
HMD (Accommodation)
California 1997
HMD
97 Teleoperators
& Virtual Environments Strickland Dorothy Chartier Dan
(Electroencephalogram; EEG) HMD
2.4.2
(Georgia Institute of Technology) 1998
IEEE Computer Graphices and Applications
David Brogan Ronald
Metoyer Georgia Jessica Hodgins
(dbrogan@cc.gatech.edu)
SGI Power challenge 16 195-MHz
R10000 A 200-MHz,
R4400 SGI Indy Motorola 68332
HMD
vitrual I/O I-Glasses Poly-
gon-Base B-Spline (NURBS)
26,000
16 300
12 (Segment)
17
Olympic
2.4.3
VLNET
2D
Geneva MIRALab 1998
CCD 3D
360 Geneva MIRALab
Morph
2.5
2.5.1
(Scapula) (Clavicle)
(umerus) (Radius) (Ulna)
27
(1) (ElbowJoint)
(Contraction)
(1)
(2)
(Femur) (Tibia)
(Fibula)
(Patella) (Quadricep Femoris Muscle)
(Tarsal) (Metatarsal)
(Phalanges)
95 140
2.5.2
(Magnetic)
(Optical)
(Transmitter)
(Receiver)
(Small Reflective Markers)
20 30
100
240 Hz
100
140 Hz
100 500
(7DOF)
Keio (http://www.aist.go.jp ) Yamazaki
(mmochimaru@nibh.go.jp)
CCD
16
2D 2D
VLNET
SGI Onyx2
ATM
3D CCD
2D
HMD I-Glasses HMD
HMD
6
10
( )
3D Studio MAX
WTK NT
Rendering
2Gbytes
4
3.1
QB C
3.1.1
12Bits A/D
8255 IC QB OUT ( C
outportb) INP (C inportb) &H280
ADDR = &H280
( 280 ADDR)
U3PORTA = ADDR+8
( U3PORTA ADDR 8)
U3OPRTB = ADDR+9
( U3PORTB ADDR 9)
U3OPRTC = ADDR+A
( U3PORTC ADDR 10)
U3CTL = ADDR+B
( U3CTL ADDR 11)
U3MODE = &H9B
( U3MODE 9B)
OUT U3CTL, U3MODE
( U3MODE U3CTL
)
ADLB = INP(U3PORTA)
( U3PORTA Low Bits)
ADHB = INP(U3PORTB)
( U3PORTB High Bits)
AD = (ADHB AND &HF)*256 + ADLB
( High Bits Low Bits AD)
V! = ( 5/4096) * AD
( )
1/1000 1/10
[ : : . ][ ]…
1/10
3.1.2
sAD
outportb inportb 0x2E0
16bits 0 65534
1600
(Timer)
COM PORT
COM
init_com()
{
outport(0x03fb,0x80);
( COM1)
outport(0x03f8,0x30); /* 115200/2400 = 30h Low bits */
outport(0x03f9,0x00); /*High bits*/
( 2400bits)
outport(0x03fb,0x03);
outport(0x03f9,0x0b);
outport(0x03fc,0x0b); /* Trans Ready */
( COM PORT )
}
COM PORT
send_char(char c)
{
while(!(inport(0x3fd) & 0x20));
( Buffer )
outport(0x03f8,c);
Bytes Buffer Byte
COM PORT
3.1.3
EPROM RS-
232
10
-128 128
timer0 = clock();
now_timer = (double)((timer0 - start_timer) / CLOCKS_PER_SEC);
raw = (WTglove5DT_rawdata *)WTsensor_getrawdata(iglasses);
WTmessage(“%5.1f,%6d,%6d,%6d,%6d,%6d,%6d,%6d\n”,
now_timer,
raw->bPitch,
raw->bRoll,
raw->bFinger[0],
raw->bFinger[1],
raw->bFinger[2],
raw->bFinger[3],
raw->bFinger[4]
);
STDOUT
hand.exe
C:\WTK> hand > file1.txt
file1.txt
COM PORT
C:\WTK>hand > COM1:
STDOUT
OS 1/10
3.1.4
Geometric-Base Visual C 5.0
WTK C 3D
WTK OPEN GL
WTK
ELSA Asia GLoria-XL L
PC-based 3D True
Color 1920 x 1080 (pixels) local
buffer Windows NT(r)
OpenGL(r), HEIDI
Direct3D GLINT MX (3Dlabs) 3D
GLINT Delta (3Dlabs) 2D Trio64V2/
DX 1 MB DRAM (S3) 40Mbytes
Image-Base Visual BASIC 5.0
HMD
Double Buffer
24
Pentium II-350
128Mbytes SDRAM
3.2
170
160 0.9
HMD 1 3
10 Simon(1976)
(Human Factors) 50%
9 25% 9 11
300
10
HMD
3.2
4.0
Visual Studio Visual BASIC
Hi-8
3.2.1
3.2.2 :
I-Glasses(HMD)
Data Gloves(5DT)
HI-8
V3, ENG
3.2.3
RGB
Active-X
Visual C Point
?
Hi-8
Microsoft Access
(x,y,z)
100
32 8 100
(x, y) MyPoint(x).Sx
MyPoint(x).Sy MyPoint(x).E1, MyPoint(x)
.E2, MyPoint(x).E3 MyPoint(x).E4
(Range of Motion)
cR = &HFF And cP
cG = (&H100FF00 And cP) / &H100
cB = (&HFF0000 And cP) / &H10000
3Bytes(24Bits)
(cP)
RGB VisualBASIC 00FF00
FF00 cP AND 1Byte
100FF00
3.2.4
3D Studio
MAX True-Space 4.0
WTK Ulead
Media Studio 5.0
3.3
HMD
WTK
Render Video
HMD
14
( )
3.4
100
10:00 11:00 24
3.5
(Independent Variable)
(Dependent Variable)
(Secondary Extraneous Or Irrelevant Variables)
(Dependent Variable)
(Independent Variable) William H Cushman
1989
(Product Variables)
(Task Variables)
(Environmental Variables)
3.5.1
1.
2.
3.5.3
175 160
0.9
3.5.4
3.6
3.6.1
RS232
1/1000 1/10
…
(Overlay)
(
) ( ) ( )
(X Y Z )
1/10
3
HMD
320*240*16Bits
15 RGB
AVI
(6Gbytes)
(7Mbytes) (3Mbytes) (3Mbytes)
3.6.2
3.6.2
100 1
2/3
HMD
100
HMD
WTK Geometric-Base
HMD
AD
( )
1/10 486
RS-232
HMD
4.2
V3
HMD
HMD
HMD HMD
HMD
HMD
HMD
WTK
100 100
WTK
Image-Base Rendering
HMD
10Gbytes
Hi-8
4.3
Gemetric-Base
Image-Base
Gemetric-Base
5
1
5.1
Geometric-Base
HMD
30 94
30 94
10:00
11:00 1024*768
Hi-8
Video AVI
WTK
3D
3D
5.2
WTK
5.3
3D 3D Studio MAX
2D CAD
2D
2D 3D Studio MAX
BOX
24,560 3D
3DS Optimum
IPAS
BOX
3DS
5.4 WorldToolKit
HMD
COM1 COM2 WTK
Sensor Sensor
WTK
Frame rate 50 Frames
Visual C
(5.6 )
Render Video
Render 3D Ray-
Tracing 30 Frames Video
VidoeTape
5.6
3D WTK
Visual C
5.6.1
(Head Files) windows.
h winuser.h time.h stdio.h
#include <windows.h>
#include <winuser.h>
#include <time.h>
#include <stdio.h>
WTK Head File
wt.h winbase.h
#include “wt.h”
wt.h WTK I-Glasses
Bird Glove5DT… wt.h WTK
WTK
void Actions (void);
Actions WTK
3D
void LoadObject (char *filename);
void setup_viewpoint(void);
WTK
Actions LoadObject setup_viewpoint
Wtviewpoint
WTK MyViewPoint
Myp
WTviewpoint *MyViewPoint;
WTp3 MyP;
HMD
WTsensor *mouse; /* The Mouse */
WTsensor *iglasses; /* The HMD */
viewlink HMD View Point
WTmotionlink *viewlink;
root
WTnode *root, *mnode = NULL;
I-Glasses
WTiglasses_rawdata *raw;
WTK
/*
* Main program function
*/
int main ()
{
int i;
i
WTnode *light;
WTp3 lightdir;
3D 3
Wtuniverse_new WTK
WTuniverse_new (display_config, WTWINDOW_DEFAULT);
root = WTuniverse_getrootnodes();
root
SetupWindow ();
iglasses = WTiglasses_new(SERIAL2);
HMD WTK HMD COM2 (SERIAL2)
HMD
if (!mouse) WTerror (“Couldn’t find mouse\n”);
HMD
WTuniverse_setactions (Actions);
WTK Actions
WTkeyboard_open ();
WTuniverse_ready ();
setup_viewpoint();
WTuniverse_go ();
WTuniverse_delete ();
Windows
return 0;
} /* END main */
Actions
5.6.3
void Actions (void)
{
WTpq pq;
pq WTpq
char *MyClipBuf;
Clipboard WTK COM
PORT
Clipboard RS-232
int key;
float tx;
tx
int go_x;
X
int go_y;
Y
int go_z;
Z
int go_value;
har tbuffer[9];
clipboard
WTviewpoint *vpoint = WTuniverse_getviewpoints();
go_value = 0;
go_x = 0;
x
go_y = 0;
y
go_z = 0;
z
/* get key presses, if any */
key = WTkeyboard_getlastkey ();
if (key)
switch (key) {
case ‘1’:go_x = 10;break;
case ‘2’:go_x = -10;break;
case ‘3’:go_y = 10;break;
case ‘4’:go_y = -10;break;
case ‘5’:go_z = 10;break;
case ‘6’:go_z = -10;break;
}
1-6
10
if (ShowInfo) {
COM PORT
/* DataSize = WTserial_ntoread(MySerial);
COM PORT
if (DataSize > 0) {
COM PORT
WTmessage(MyClipBuf);
}
else {
strcpy(MyClipBuf,”None”);
} */
COM PORT
Clipboard
_strtime(tbuffer);
WTviewpoint_getposition(MyViewPoint, pq.p);
WTviewpoint_getorientation(MyViewPoint, pq.q);
tx = pq.p[X];
tx += go_x;
pq.p[X] = tx;
x
tx = pq.p[Y];
tx += go_y;
pq.p[Y] = tx;
y
tx = pq.p[Z];
tx += go_z + go_value;
pq.p[Z] = tx;
z
WTviewpoint_moveto(MyViewPoint, &pq);
/* END Actions */
5.6.4
if (!mnode) return;
View Point
(WTFRAME_VPOINT)
/* END LoadObject */
switch (uMsg) {
case WM_COMMAND:
switch (wParam) {
case ID_FILEOPEN:
LoadObjectDialog (hWnd);
break;
case ID_FILE_RESET:
setup_viewpoint();
WTmouse_trackballreset (mouse);
WTmouse_trackballreset (iglasses);
break;
case ID_FILE_DISPLAYINFO:
if (GetMenuState (hMenu, ID_FILE_DISPLAYINFO,
MF_BYCOMMAND) == MF_UNCHECKED) {
CheckMenuItem (hMenu, ID_FILE_DISPLAYINFO, MF_CHECKED);
ShowInfo = TRUE;
}
else {
CheckMenuItem (hMenu, ID_FILE_DISPLAYINFO,
MF_UNCHECKED);
SetWindowText (hWnd, “WorldToolKit”);
ShowInfo = FALSE;
}
break;
case ID_FILE_ABOUT:
MessageBox (hWnd, AboutThisApp, “ Beta”, MB_OK);
break;
case ID_FILEEXIT:
WTuniverse_stop ();
break;
case ID_RESET_STATE:
LoadObject( “face.3ds”);
break;
break;
default:
return CallWindowProc (orgWndProc, hWnd, uMsg, wParam, lParam);
}
} /* END myWndProc */
WTK
void SetupWindow (void)
{
/* get a handle to the WTK window */
hWnd = (HWND)WTwindow_getidx (WTuniverse_getcurrwindow ());
if (!hWnd) return;
/* set background color to black */
WTwindow_setbgrgb (WTuniverse_getcurrwindow(), 0, 0, 0);
/* set WndProc for window */
orgWndProc = (WNDPROC) SetWindowLong (hWnd,
GWL_WNDPROC, (LONG)myWndProc);
/* load the menu from resource */
hMenu = LoadMenu (NULL, MAKEINTRESOURCE(IDR_MENU1));
if (!hMenu) return;
/* attach the menu to the window */
SetMenu (hWnd, hMenu);
} /* END SetupWindow */
1 6
5.6.5
WTK 3D Studio MAX WTK
void setup_viewpoint()
{
float radius;
WTpqpq;
radius = WTnode_getradius(WTuniverse_getrootnodes());
WTmessage(“ n”);
WTviewpoint_getposition(MyViewPoint, pq.p);
WTviewpoint_getorientation(MyViewPoint, pq.q);
pq.p[X] = -6.157f;
pq.p[Y] = -160.854f;
pq.p[Z] = -1036.827f;
WTviewpoint_moveto(MyViewPoint, &pq);
WTviewpoint_addsensor(MyViewPoint, iglasses);
I-Glasses
WTK Actions
WTK
AVI
AVI BMP
1024*768
VHS 320*240
1,00,000 ( 55
)
6.1
Point_Struct Join_Struct
34
6.2
Sub AutoScanMakerbyRed()
Dim cP As Long
Dim cR As Long
Dim cG As Long
Dim cB As Long
RGB
Dim pS As Integer
Dim pY As Integer
Dim pX As Integer
Dim oX As Integer
Dim oY As Integer
Dim tR As Integer
Dim nP As Integer
Dim nX As Integer
Dim nY As Integer
Dim TheRedValue As Integer
TheRedValue = RedValue.Value
tR = RangeScale.Value
Picture1.DrawWidth = 1
AntiCollisionRange = AntiCollision.Value
Now_Index = 0
For pS = 0 To ScanRangeList.ListCount - 1
S$ = ScanRangeList.List(pS)
StartX1 StartY1
StartX2 StartY2
StartX1 = Val(Left(S$, InStr(S$, “,”) - 1)) - tR
StartY1 = Val(Mid(S$, InStr(S$, “,”) + 1)) - tR
StartX2 = StartX1 + tR * 2
StartY2 = StartY1 + tR * 2
oX = 0
oY = 0
nP = 0
For pY = StartY1 To StartY2
For pX = StartX1 To StartX2
cP = Picture1.Point(pX, pY)
cR = &HFF And cP
cG = (&H100FF00 And cP) / &H100
cB = (&HFF0000 And cP) / &H10000
RGB
cP = (cR - (cG + cB) \ 2) * (cR * (RedRange / 10) /
TheRedValue) * RedRange / 10
R cP
If cP < 0 Then cP = 0
If cP > 255 Then cP = 255
If cP > nP Then
nP = cP
nX = pX
nY = pY
End If
DoEvents
Next
Next
If nX < oX + AntiCollisionRange And nX > oX - AntiCollisionRange
And nY < oY + AntiCollisionRange And nY > oY - AntiCollisionRange Then
‘Beep
Else
Frames(Now_Index).Sx = nX
Frames(Now_Index).Sy = nY
Picture1.Circle (nX, nY), Val(MaskSize.Text), RGB(255, 0, 0)
DoEvents
Now_Index = Now_Index + 1
oX = nX
oY = nY
Frames
End If
Next
End Sub
If cP > nP Then
nP = cP
nX = pX
nY = pY
End If
6.3
10,000
Sub AutoScanNextStep()
Dim pS As Integer
Dim pY As Integer
Dim pX As Integer
Dim oX As Integer
Dim oY As Integer
ASR = AutoSnapRed.Value
SystemBusy = True
For pS = 0 To ScanRangeList.ListCount – 1
S$ = ScanRangeList.List(pS)
pX = Val(Left(S$, InStr(S$, “,”) - 1))
pY = Val(Mid(S$, InStr(S$, “,”) + 1))
Now_Range_Index = pS
End Sub
6.4
Click AutoSnap
6.3
Sub AutoSnapRedHits(x, y)
6.2
Dim cP As Long
Dim cR As Long
Dim cG As Long
Dim cB As Long
Dim pS As Integer
Dim pY As Integer
Dim pX As Integer
Dim tR As Integer
Dim nP As Integer
Dim TheRedValue As Integer
Dim S$
TheRedValue = RedValue.Value
tR = RangeScale.Value
nP = 0
cP = 0
HitX = LastX
HitY = LastY
For pY= y - tR To y + tR
For pX = x - tR To x + tR
cP = Picture1.Point(pX, pY)
cR = &HFF And cP
cG = (&H100FF00 And cP) / &H100
cB = (&HFF0000 And cP) / &H10000
cP = (cR - (cG + cB) \ 2) * (cR * (RedRange / 10) / TheRedValue) *
RedRange / 10
If cP < 0 Then cP = 0
If cP > 255 Then cP = 255
If cP >= nP Then
nP = cP
HitX = pX
HitY = pY
End If
6.2
DoEvents
Next
Next
End Sub
6.5
X Y
-1
Function CheckMaskXY(x, y) As Integer
Sub CopyScanRange2MaskPoint()
Sub DrawMaskRange()
Sub DrawScanRange()
Sub LoadNote()
Sub LoadScanRange()
Sub Paint_A_Point(x, y)
Sub RecData2Disk()
6.6
X1
Y1 X2 Y2 Xo Yo
Function Request_Angle(x1 As Integer, y1 As Integer, x2 As Integer, y2
As Integer, oX As Integer, oY As Integer) As Single
px1 = x1 - oX
py1 = y1 - oY
px2 = x2 - oX
py2 = y2 – oY
Z 3D
2D Z 0
z1 = 0
z2 = 0
Sum1 = px1 * px2 + py1 * py2 + z1 * z2
Sum2 = ((px1 * px1 + py1 * py1 + z1 * z1) ^ 0.5) * ((px2 * px2 + py2 *
py2 + z2 * z2) ^ 0.5)
6.7
…
…
0_1_2, 1_2_3, 0_1_4, 1_4_5, 4_5_6, 5_6_7,
128.8236, 143.9065, 173.2186, 64.63668, 71.41814, 80.37185,
128.8236, 143.9065, 173.2186, 66.07007, 78.13425, 81.37873,
110.5425, 149.2426, 174.1325, 63.43495, 77.8894, 85.65457,
110.908, 143.5541, 169.6051, 75.6031, 91.7733, 78.98289,
0_1_2 0 1 2
analysis.exe
Excel SPSS
Excel
Excel SPSS
7.1
7.2
10
T T
7.2.1
(1) T
H0 U<=U0
H1 U>U0
t=3 df=9
HMD
HMD
HMD
SPSS
V001 HMD
(2)
X Y 74 5402
SPSS
V001 V002 X Y
7.2.2
WTK, RENDER VIDEO
VR (
) (WTK t=2.250 Render t=2.333 Video t=2.
090)
One-Sample Test
Test Value = 3
90% Confidence
Interval of the
Sig. Mean Difference
t df (2-tailed) Difference Lower Upper
1 2.250 9 .051 .6000 .1112 1.0888
2 2.333 9 .045 .7000 .1501 1.2499
3 2.090 9 .066 .7000 8.6E-02 1.3141
HMD
HMD ( t=2.714 t=0.00 t=-1.
616)
One-Sample Test
Test Value = 3
90% Confidence
Interval of the
Sig. Mean Difference
t df (2-tailed) Difference Lower Upper
2.714 9 .024 .6000 .1947 1.0053
.000 9 1.000 .0000 -.6110 .6110
-1.616 9 .140 -.6000 -1.2804 8.0E-02
WTK WTK
(t=1.5)
One-Sample Test
Test Value = 3
90% Confidence
Interval of the
Sig. Mean Difference
t df (2-tailed) Difference Lower Upper
1 1.500 9 .168 .4000 -9.E-02 .8888
RENDERING
( t=1.861 t=2.236)
One-Sample Test
Test Value = 3
90% Confidence
Interval of the
Sig. Mean Difference
t df (2-tailed) Difference Lower Upper
2 1.861 9 .096 .5000 7.4E-03 .9926
2 2.236 9 .052 .5000 9.0E-02 .9099
VIDEO
( t=2.058 t=1.861
t=1.627)
One-Sample Test
Test Value = 3
90% Confidence
Interval of the
Sig. Mean Difference
t df (2-tailed) Difference Lower Upper
3 2.058 9 .070 .8000 8.7E-02 1.5126
3 1.861 9 .096 .5000 7.4E-03 .9926
3 1.627 9 .138 .5000 -6.E-02 1.0633
WTK
:1. (0.846) 2. (
-0.821) 3. ( -0.672)
Correlations
1 1 1 1
Pearson 1 1.000 .846** -.821** -.672*
Correlation 1 .846** 1.000 -.668* -.624
1 -.821** -.668* 1.000 .787**
1 -.672* -.624 .787** 1.000
Sig. 1 . .002 .004 .033
(2-tailed) 1 .002 . .035 .054
1 .004 .035 . .007
1 .033 .054 .007 .
N 1 10 10 10 10
1 10 10 10 10
1 10 10 10 10
1 10 10 10 10
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
1. ( -0.668) 2.
(0.864) 3. ( -0.647)
(-0.782)
Correlations
1 1 1 1
Pearson 1 1.000 -.668* .846** -.647*
Correlation 1 -.668* 1.000 -.821** .190
1 .846** -.821** 1.000 -.354
1 -.647* .190 -.354 1.000
Sig. 1 . .035 .002 .043
(2-tailed) 1 .035 . .004 .598
1 .002 .004 . .315
1 .043 .598 .315 .
N 1 10 10 10 10
1 10 10 10 10
1 10 10 10 10
1 10 10 10 10
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
(0.650)
RENDERING (0.
677) (0.692) (-0.773)
Correlations
2 2
Pearson 2 1.000 .677*
Correlation 2 .677* 1.000
Sig. 2 . .032
(2-tailed) 2 .032 .
N 2 10 10
2 10 10
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level
(2-tailed).
Correlations
2 2 2
Pearson 2 1.000 .692* -.720*
Correlation 2 .692* 1.000 -.373
2 -.720* -.373 1.000
Sig. 2 . .027 .019
(2-tailed) 2 .027 . .289
2 .019 .289 .
N 2 10 10 10
2 10 10 10
2 10 10 10
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
VIDEO
RENDERING (0.684)
(-0.642)
(0.652) (0.666)
VR
VR
RENDERING
7.3
7.3.1
Paired Sample T-Test HMD
One-Way ANOVA
7.3.2
Paired Sample T-Test HMD
(t=-5.45~-2.793 P=0~0.021)
( HMD
HMD WTK HMD Render HMD Video ) One-
Way ANOVA
HMD (F=4.57~9.968
P=0.005~0.046)
HMD(F=4.874~16.645
P=0.001~0.040) HMD Video(F=5.388~4.740 P=0.032~0.043)
HMD WTK(F=4.448~6.6 P=0.19~0.49)
Paired Samples Test
Paired Differences
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Std. Std. Error Difference Sig.
Mean Deviation Mean Lower Upper t df (2-tailed)
Pair 1 OSPINE1
- -7.4294 8.4127 2.6603 -13.4474 -1.4113 -2.793 9 .021
NSPINE1
Paired Differences
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Std. Std. Error Di fference Sig.
Mean Deviation Mean Lower Upper t df (2-tailed)
Pair 1 OSPINE2
- -11.0783 6.4237 2.0313 -15.6736 -6.4831 -5.454 9 .000
NSPINE2
Paired Differences
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Std. Std. Error Difference Sig.
Mean Deviation Mean Lower Upper t df (2-tailed)
Pair 1 OSPINE3
- -12.5184 11.0212 3.4852 -20.4025 -4.6343 -3.592 9 .006
NSPINE3
Paired Differences
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Std. Std. Error Difference Sig.
Mean Deviation Mean Lower Upper t df (2-tailed)
Pair 1 OSPINE4
- -12.0039 12.3621 3.9092 -20.8472 -3.1606 -3.071 9 .013
NSPINE4
HMD
(109.27 ) (94.12 )
HMD(173.55 ) HMD Video(169.69 )
HMD WTK(168.23 ) (162.
80 ) HMD
HMD Render
(167.50 )
HMD
HMD
(R=0.839~0.986)
HMD
(R=-0.305) HMD
(R=-1.01~0.228)
8.1
WTK Render Video WTK Geomet-
ric-Base Render Video Image-Base
HMD
HMD
HMD Render
WTK 3D
(Motion Sickness)
WTK
WTK Image-Base
Image-Base
Image-Base Video
Render
Render
VR
VR
HMD
HMD
Render
Image-Base Render
Image-Base Video WTK
HMD HMD
Video
HMD
2D
3D
HMD 640*480
HMD
Video Morph