Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
<
. .
'sT''
~- ,-
"'
.~((c,' ,
KENYA UNION
1~;_.::_
dF POST~~fa:M.A:Rv
.;
;.~.z. ,~~<
1.
The present
c4WP~,>'::;><;c
Notice of Motion
the main:-
'
dat~d
2nd
Se;~;rrltr,~,i;~:~i),15:.seeking
.. .
--'.'',-.
orders 1n
- },:::,_
''"~~-;:~~~?:;:_< ~:s:;:<
:---
._,.:.
2.
-_~i<>,
't~~~;f
":~-~'A
;~~<{c
..:<-.'~s{~U
(e)
That 1}.~.{.
~Y
>{~;~;;~~~~r;~~~-~ ~f;: :
~tfike is ~~~~~~;,~~~17~
policy;,
'"
::~,~.~<'
:;: ,;-'.:,'s"\:-~
...
3.
4.
The
... .
.';
,_ro!56>..
;:~;;-, :-i/
,.,. . .
,~:t..
the Notice of
The objections were in the main that;(a) The matters raised were res judicata,
was functus
officio, the application was a blatant abuse'oftbe~~burt process and
that the petitioner had become a vexatiod';lifl~~t}':~;.
~J:;~.
~;::.~:,
:::\~~-~;;~;;r~ ~}
. ~ ;<;;.r:~~1~7(~t~
contetided:~hat'the"~otion
5.
af~er
hearing submissions by
Thy
She
5.
On
'
,_',:>:::\-,'
:~~-:~
::
J~rfued; as
matter
w~s
No. 3 of
<
.<<{; :~:-~'~:<::Y_,~;~:.::.-,
Senio'r;~,,@~~ns.~l{9)i~rithe
Mr. Ahmednassir
,he
'. f
a''
->.."",;' .. .
,. ~><
\i:.:
hoti:'se~k:eepi~~~.:i~~~~e,
:~~~;:: .<."
an.offspring of
~1!$:W$e~'iNderi's,juqgment
201S, the~learnledtf~~~~~;::i\W~s
;
handle it.
<,(...
. __ _} .
~-{;
'
;~
in Petition
1st
?~-~:'C~:~\~~0;~-~a:,)~-:~l\ _,,
._
~ attem~t,,\\~5~;i,fe\riew
'.-
',' .<'
-. .
(,v,
'
<'~, ~,,;:'
of2:()f$::!,
',~-
"'-;<-\
6.
or amend
,,r, .
t-.:'_--
.'
>),tl
than one Judge and now they were changing that it be placed
before Nderi J.
7.
the
"
'
::)
~:
'
',
,-,_
,,
--"
'
'"
procedur~s, fnq~\.~w~~fit~Mi~;funds
--
'
. '/
..
'
'.
>>25~-~J>--.'
ordered payable to
),;
. .,.
""\~" :;;~ti~.
t-,,:
~>,
8.
lor~g~i~
~~~~t.,if'~a~ ~:reed
by consent
of.:t~~:.~~tltion
and in that
:;;
<
.. ':.-.~~ :,,".>-..
9.
petidm:).._
(5) . Does the I?~tifion raisf eonstitu,ti~~hl issues?
(c)
Whether
th~ '.i~sues~;;.tli~.pr~~bttt
righ;f~
. : :. : 1:..;
>.
"':~~~~~f~;lj'i
(d). Is the
strike
of the C9nstitution absolute.
In othJr words doeR arti<;l:.~rfJ:Hfii1e':'~onstituti8!;J. dispense with the
. , _\
requirement .. t9 giv~ I]ptice 0fs.tri~e~{~s:.provided under section 76 of
the Labour Rel~ti\Dlis'"A:ct?
'
,-
-.
3
.
:-e7"
~~; :.o>>?(:>o;.!:_~.
sfarl~r'tJ/~ring
10.
University &
-.:..,
inCidental
disputes.
Othe~s:(20l3)".eKLR'f,ML
;<-,,',
,,...,
,,--:-;;:--::
''::}--,-;.,~~)''
"':~~: .
11.
"''-
'i}:G'~:1~
';.<,
;,hi~h:\Va$aci<:>pted by the
Court
int~t~f~.t~;;.~Constitutional
q~}t11l;[Iamental
rights
which
substantially
occur
context
of
12.
On this issue Mr. Obura submitted that his client had pleaded
that its rights under article 30,48 and 50 of the Constitution
6
that both sides are claiming rights under the Constitution hence
the Petition raises cdr:istitutional issues.
13.
Mr.
that
the
>>
,,
'
,,
';:.
,,
;.-;
,-,.,
'
-';>
.""-<_,<
'
furthe~ sub!Ilitt~'d
14..
Ist
tn~;~~~Jition as filed
Cotl.rr~~~; it showed the
k"-.
15.
conceding
While
have been
--
:. /
_. ._
-,~:
2015.? In othe'r,woJ:ds
'.;':.
"
.-
,. :::,~-
<
is.the;~presel!t
On this issue
. ..
.M:r.,:~.,ob1uta.:;su6lliitt:ed
<.~" ~~" -";).t:t~-~,
;.
of
'
that';'the
same was
:.. :
. ) \"''
. . .
. . . -.
became of the view that the Motiod :cthd the petition raised
different issues from those that wer~: Bef6te,(Iustice Nderi in
Petition No. 3 of 2015. According to
<'";";
17.
6:'0th~;s:t(2014 )eKLR.
18.
Mr.
Ahm~db,assir
fof'the;
isrtespcn;~:Jd.etit qn his
part submitted
No. 3 of 2015
.
h~rie ~~)~'8_](lr~~J,\.~~ck.
To demonstrate, he
,, . . '
20 15. According to
asks the
.. .
,;!.\'r,;t.it:;;f,'''' .
,.
c6uris~Ft:';R~?~~f~:;'(d) and;(~)
of the petition
"~~y~
'
-~.
'~;,~.
.; :: :, . <
"'
::
;:,::\:;.J::>---. ~
-. '
-':-'>),'
<
'.
".
~is
. '
No. 3
-~;" f
'
. ..
18.
:. "
' ,:
~'-:;_o<
Atvareri.~~s Trust
&
19.
s~e ...
-{
;,,~
Consfitl.~tion
>'
,''''
'~;
,,
'
',,
'
According to
ort~.6it~em.
It was Mr.
,;,',,
20.
7g of the
Labour
~nstitutions
Hence the
',-
"
-~-
'<
,- ..'
~-.- . .
..
stipulates conditions
strike.
. :. ,. :Z;-,-<\~-~,~~i:~ft;i;tfA:';~-.;;:,~.:1--~~....
whi~l:li~riiij$t:.:lfj~>riiet
.-->.,
'.
'
'
',~: ..
wrior to calling of a
,:''
ri#t
' ~ --'7<'
21.
:t:>
to' .'go
on strike.
~ ."
11
22.
compel the petitionetto pay the award made i:ri Petition No. 3 of
2015 hence the strikejs being used by the;:respondents as a tool
of f!Xecutio!l of a Court's Jqdgment.
...
23.
.. -
<.
.\
pro~e.~lure
,_
,qf
.
.. ~
The respondent
'
"
'
'
. . <~, ~~;~-:?:~--~~:::-~;~~~-~~:>~>:\:,).~-
"' '. : .
:>":
24.
."
'
T,: .. ;<::f.-_~
5th
January
25.
:s.tH~~c~:~ased
1st
on new
The Court
26.
-'
'
'''
'
Mr.
--,
'
'~
>-
'
'
,~
schedule to the
6th
eonstiJfution in OJ;iier''to
,_, 'J'>
'
':
~~~- :?!,("'
"'
27.
-'~~:
''"
~~,~\ssue another
a~ted i~:;~h. It was Mr.
>
<.~--~ ~'
','%
..
Union
of Metal
Workers
of South
Africa
&
Others
28.
.
.
On the issue\whether the current strike is a new o:p:e, Counsel
but about clf;mands,i;nade })y .the t~aGh~r$ which have not been
'
'
met whicl:l
'"\\'.;
':-
'"
<'
-J:< >
ocA:
~."'""'~
i~cllJcl~ .e~ecut19~~ar~:e.~~~-.CBA
to~ thes~/i~--
be no more strikes.
29.
strike notice
current constitution.
.~. --::::L>~
<Y.,
.c '
'f.-<
"'
~ ~:~ ":: <~'
::_ :'
-~:~.::.J:<ii'i:':~:)..
30.
Mr.
Kiragu
to . ~:~~ .
Kimani
\L\<1'
''k
c'
lOllS
,:;-,:>~ ::---t:<::i
by
the
The
,~ .
practice.
there
is
no
the
14
Constitution.
'Jn
prohibiting the
present s,tfike, the, Court'-.,;;-.; )would. nd:t I>e staying Nderi J's
Judgment since .Jh~ Judg~~:ttid :.m.B:t:) .sanction any strike.
0
.'
c.
-"
-~
.,<
Mr.
, > ;
1f~-:i2\~~ ~
_:
'
\<i+$)tn~
. ;fcirl:fse
;'''
7
,
;~f
'~ ~
trade dispute.
32.
(f) Does the petitioner have the 'locus t~~~iftii~~g the petition
goiiJ.g,chfJ'ttk~~;.and people of
~,;f.
'
~ .. ~, :.
'
petitioner
respondents
yet
the
have
engaged
In
public
Mr.
.-
~~
..
'>
';<'
;';c'.
"'::,->'
inthe''~nforoe~~~~~.:~~;~eedhl~s~/~yThe
~;;.
. ".::~;
'~
petitioner's
:.,".
_,_c.:')
,.
"
~',<>i>'o"i.
'"
t~ ~~~Y:.tl1~~ award
without
33.
Obura
s{iJsili:itted
.
proceedings have been commenced in th~ t~esp~~t~
On the issue of contempt, Mr.
' ..
34.
,,.
'~
that no
c:. z-;
article
249(1)
(c)
provide~
for
promotion
of
35.
Mr. Bitta for the Attorney General submitted that the Court had
children~
3rd
According to
defining examinations.
36.
the .\Jst
'i.'',
l\,~:'-,- ~}:-
ahticle:~ii2~i:~.ii
237 of the
is a body corporate.
~~R:.J'ffridical >persona
';
'-~
:';.::c, - ',
It
to file a
,'
is a state
rights.
'
'
'
'
''['
:~
M~.:A~~ednassir stated
be a~~~~~~#, then a right
''
, ~<- \j~),i'
Counsel
Counsel~
~,
,_, .,
,'(,>~,,
litigate
that
prticle.. 21 (3)
of the
Regarding
17
37.
: , --
'
<,
pe~tioncil',:i~,,~9i,~a~ 'it
cannot do.
amount to slavezyL ot
children under
the,
Court order.
'
-.:
In
seiV;itii~~.;:: . 'Cohcerni~g
a.Ftlicl~;5.3; thes~
What the
the rights of
.' >
'. "\~:i.;f~\:~~~1;\t~\}
38.
',o;;,, "_., ..
--.--:.~"''
orde~;J{~Relying on the
,<-,~
y~;;-,;
petitioner must purge the contempt and obey the Court order
regardless of what they think of it.
' -i'
the,
"<.
>
"
> c
":.:}'(";~;._,~J:;"f-:-< .'
"':,
~f
.:..' .
; ;
. >."
.~
'
""
".
"' ,
. . ~. '- ~::;:~}}~.
,.
. ,,
\''';?:.;;. . ~ .
,:{"'>>"
-;-..._o'/c~"~-
-,,
"''"'
3 9.
,\",i'trf:f~~.ction
7 of the
w~st1I<:~Lgovernment and
,:+>
not the teachers who was violating the I}ght.s df;jhe children by
not paying teachers.
40.
2nd
He submitted that
'"
A',~:';;,:
i' .f
Mr.
;
'
'
-,;:
~.
_,
submiH.ed
'
':;:_ "
~~-;<;;
<
~,= ~-
:.-..
..
..
~ ~.; \_
The
du~~.t9<uphold industrial
-i:'-. .F
:ih:.ithe
sppnn~d o~et;'a
/>""
..
;_
respond~nt's
,
petition and
long time yet
20
42.
must have
WOJ.;!ld
,. ,.,"
',
..:.
cl;ssi~t.
;;
JtS
the
:.
\:, :-c,. ~/'~ .::>
.\::q:;.:;"\.>~:~>;~,~~('~~~~.
C~J:;trt ,iri,,.'gtJ),prec~qj,i~:g.t:zt:f:r~~dispute
' ,_-i
'""."ZK,'
""
;,
.~
. <.
~ ~
r:rjl~~~Jii~t
.: :: .;,<:~:::~_y'
better and
--..
'
..
~:_
follows::..
(a) Jurisdiction of the,:. Court to he3.i\tllli~ 1 Petition.
As pointed out earlier, this issue although.iq~;ri~f~:~d as a ground
-~<-
1st
L" :
;~....
O,Ao"
,,
'',
c-'
0'
..~;
prese~t p~tltiQh.
:::'
'Fhe Court
Anne Kinyua v.
'
'
of~~
Con,stitution.
<
t
.....
.,,,
:C'-~
~:
"'~ ~
.. --.,
Having
"'
"'
}>.~:_:'.:~):
considereJ;i;stibmissfg~~~;~;~k~.:C~~nsel f~r
the parties on
'o: .
>. {:-Y}_:::.).ff
stipulated>u{\de:Pc:;~~ction
76 of the
regulation<~"Q~;~~ot
in any way
Th.f~~:~W~ndents
on the
"'-~<
The
"
~-
an~1egati~n, 1pfviolation
f',:_,-
of rights under
'>-
, '"-, ,
. -, :
''" , ~''
'
_<0:.._~<<'''
>o.{
''\'
"~
, ..,
. -
<j ; ><.h
"'?i:~:.
. ~t-
'
'
)'/
'., }
"-::'.
as those determined
.
,;
..
:::_
'
be~~~"Wi,J;hin
-:<" -". :-. . :.
:'\~
1st
reasonable
~etitioner over
where to
This second
decided then.
:-.
';
~-'"<!'=-'::;_;\,-':~
'
the<~~tY'.~ot
to shout fire
,c'>
43.
44.
b~
loc,al
including children
--;.
said to
'"
. - .. , ,
~>-""
.,.-;::; :>'=:\.>;>_~L;r
,--.>-~-,
;~:-.(;'~,-'
'
'
'
'
"
>
From
through to Francis
"
"
t'''
the
teachers
o~her
demands
hand
J;i~s
not yielded
45.
While I will return to the foregoing later, the Court observes that
the substance of the judgment in Petition No. 3 of 2015
25
The
Court further notes that the proposal for 50-60 percent increase
was based on proppsalspresentedtothe Court oy the petitioner.
It is therefore. understandable from the respondent's view point
by them and
pr()v;oqati~e
and justified
46. In
:~,'.~_::
<
:r
~~~;.~/ ~,::~:\:.;:\''::
.:
arsenal in
bargcrining
strike
constantly and
categorically
has
for
{'
becomes superfluous.
The petil:iqher
~
,: ~"
heietii>~d
. r. >~~>,":"
its allies in
..
award.i~g:lliP~;respondents a
This
was presumably and especially after the Court of Appeal and the
Supreme Court declined to issue intetintrelie(.pending appeal.
What purpose would a strike notice therefore serve under those
circumstances? Or to put it the other way, would if today, the
26
<
47.
doctrine
preparatoire~
of '"travaux
m.a.y
when,:~:.'P~Bcedural
In
be compelling
step may be
'
'
statutory
Parliament
'-?-- --"'
a srp.ooth
'
'
,,._
-,_~,
>
ihdustrial.'r'elatiori~
, \ ' - . ;
<>;-;):o,-
,.
~.~
48'.
to ,~dopt ~,;;ji:rtt~~pretation
<
'
-~
; ~ .
that
freedom.
',.
~,
'-> . .
,'
27
its core essential content. The foregoing having been said, the
Court declines to pronounqe the current strike as unprotected. _
49.
50.
NQ~.--3
of 2015.
by
51.
,-,:-~2'-t-' -y,~,~-"
,'L
,,
that the strike is being used by them --a:~_- a tool to compel the
petitioner to honour the judgment in Petition No. 3 of 2015.
28
52.
76.
53.
A persoh may participate in a strike or lock-out if:(a) the trade dispute that forms the subject of the strike
or lock-out concerns terms and conditions of
employDJ,;ent.
Furthe:ro:section 78(1) oLthe Labour R~latiotl.S'~Ctprovides:78 (1)' .~() pef~on ,shall.tak~.''~~l"~;;f'~ a strike or lock-out or in
any. f::ondu.'~t iti cQp#ifupla~t?J;ii{;.a strike or lock-out if -
~o~~~;~J~,~~~collec~ive
(c)
the partie$
'"';
~'
; ~:~
.h~ve ;a:ir~~a;;t~
-"
54.
'-~if<
~-:
',~
,_;;;'
<
doubt a
trade
_;.-,~ r~ ~'""
the
">"""
th~. respond~nt
of an award
-:~~'
':<\
Relations Act.
that the
<:f~spute ..
Relati~ns
Act
compel the
2015.
-.
a:Q,~';JMF~~:~~~t
~~-:
. :._.~.~~:~:~;~~>~~~-~~<4;~~1;:;~-~1/~ ~,~:~r~~y:
..
fofJhe'~responden,t's mymbers
. "' \
When the
execution of
and;i~b6#t"'f~Y:lations
;Z
'
';
Act to
., '
m~Il\~~t~~.0entitlement
as
of ;.~]J~L;;~~The appeal by
'
..
' ,.; ~
\'
'~
30
56.
(e) Does the petitioner have the locus standi to bring the
petition on its behalf and that of the. school going children
in public scho.ol and the people of Kenya generally?
pi~mqtion o.~~.g
~~\ . -~
J~::::-.
~-..
.}.,. ~~~:rt1\~~!i~~J~~~':,_:.J!?f:<~~
~ _:~.\~:~
and to this extent Counsel '~~S~t~~ri:that
the:P>?titioner
had the
;
.><" . . " , :,,.
y..
<~
by~~f;x,l~
.
:~"{-t;:.>
..,.
of article 253
PMt
()f Government
58.
The
petitioner
1s
established
under
237
of the
profession. Under article 248 read together with article 249, the
petitioner as one of the Constitutional Commissions has as some
of its objects, the protection of the sovereighty of the people, and
promotion pfconstitutionalism.
choseil,'.repres~,;~.1.:tativ~,~
It
~---;i::
---
:edit'ttiri.~,,s.defitl~St'''h~~nstitutionalism
<,. .
:;
12th.
~" ,
_:
~ .~. , . ~ ~ ~f<Y~
/:~~,~':: ?~'::~:;~--~-~
, ... adhepence.
f~ a systefiq.qf;t~o
.
' .
Concise Oxford
',.
..4~~J.
'
~,
..
. .
'fu.t{5g~<'gQ~~nment.
. .
:~
""
. -~~0;-,~~:-:,~~;:,::;r:~;fr
.. ..' .
as
the
Applying
. . ~~
these legal ct~finiti6.p.s to the.~~' .. ,P;~~ri'it !llay lR.e said that under
~
~.- .
....~
i~-~.:. ~
5aS,
Constitutional Coili~is~io~s
p~wer
so far a~
protection of the
enforce laws in
mandate.
Further, the
by,per::>ons"W!i~~~~Jall
~<t-"""~"-' _;-.;-';c{
":
within its
operation.
59.
237
of the
mandat~s,:as
Constitution
include
and
60.
Under article 93(l)'nf the Constitution, every child has the right
among others to free and compulsory basic education.
The
<
," '
., ,; 'l
' '
'
in~~ef{~pl,lJing
its constitutional
". . ,
It
n~;~liJ~.)fbg~ther'.. with
. <;:, ;, c:,
;.:.<-
-'~~
article 249(1)
~~~~lJ:~<:htpU,ght
either by the
'
61.
;i'
33
62.
reg~(:j.
63.
h~~( .Stating
- '"t
teachers
b~~k
to
44~s ~~~~}~~~~t
i, '-:
have:j~~~~:~;;~ml1..~ir memS~rs
''
'
'-
'-
't;"""~-,,
'\,;\
'o', \
~:.'_:;-:_.'-'-,
'""'
,, <
'
.'>
'
;<:!<
",
to stay away
3 of 20 15 is
'
'
other,
m&.:~~~r
<
portends a
;_'-i_"'"---+:::>,
the
interpretation.
law
and
make
orders
inf~ied
by
such
;sho~ld~:~regard him or
:of the ,fip~ople of Kenya
..
:"<>><1
34
'v
64.
pronouncem~nt
th,~~ sta.t~r;(exeutive)
incumbent upon
-_
',
'
',:,
-~-_,"
<
. .. ..
,_,
~".
.-
,,
-- ,
,..
::
::.:> \
;,
"',,
,.-~IT.{~
.~
65.
><
"'
The
>'
'
~~
. . ... :
tfl.~~ip~~blogist as well.
--
. . -- .
>.
Let the executive and legislature take the rol~ ot~~mortician and
tell Kenyans the cause of death of the
Blackmail,
35
66.
'
'
national
6 7. The
--
governmen~.
fit in the
the dispute
. .
'
''
caltli).~~.ss
and respect
dis~t~yed in awaiting
---<_,,::_:--y,~~.>l;'il
toL.0\:V~~.
;;._
'
36
and mutually
"'
-,
'
" '
and
award in Petition
.P9!icies ~nd"b~dgetaeyi~y~J~i}'
C.
step
calledaj11~~ sl~p~ember,
for
2015 by
of
the
period
tiU~L
respond~:q.~s'
-:: ,-.
-:.
-~,~.~,-:,
members
D.
";<,
Either party shall upon the expiry c,f tb.@L90 day period
stated in A and failure to conciliate
tJte
dispute as stated in
E.
F.
It is so ordered
. .
. t.c
...
,
. . .
Abirbd~ N@J$0ii;
~i~~~d~e ' .
"\:
In the
da~:~
.' , :/
rfl"''~~-
presenc~,t>f:..;
r
"~-
.::.,._-..
;>
''
I
''
:"
'
J.,.
--'
.;
Abu
38