Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
JOURNAL COMPILATION
Urological Oncology
ACUPUNCTURE FOR VASOMOTOR SYMPTOMS ASSOCIATED WITH LHRH AGONIST TREATMENT FOR PROSTATE CANCER
HARDING
et al.
BJUI
BJU INTERNATIONAL
CONCLUSIONS
The symptomatic improvement was at
levels comparable with that from
pharmacotherapy, and cost analysis
showed AA to be a viable alternative.
Larger randomized studies are needed
to fully evaluate AA against more
conventional treatments, and these are
planned.
KEYWORDS
prostate cancer, vasomotor symptoms,
acupuncture
INTRODUCTION
Prostate cancer is the most commonly
diagnosed cancer in UK men [1], with 35 000
new cases in 2004. This disease represents
almost a quarter of new cancer diagnoses in
males [1] and many men (about a quarter) will
have advanced disease at presentation [2]. The
treatment of choice for metastatic prostate
cancer remains androgen-deprivation therapy
(ADT) [3]. This type of treatment is associated
with significant side-effects, including
osteoporosis, loss of libido and psychological
illness [4]. Perhaps the most common and
bothersome side-effect from ADT is hot
flushes, that consist of a sudden perceived
increase in temperature, with erythema of the
skin, sweating and tachycardia, experienced
by 5080% of men on ADT for prostate cancer
[4].
186
JOURNAL COMPILATION
2 0 0 8 B J U I N T E R N A T I O N A L | 1 0 3 , 1 8 6 1 9 0 | doi:10.1111/j.1464-410X.2008.07884.x
Concern or problem 1:
0
Kidney
Not bothering
me at all
Autonomic
6
bothers me
greatly
Shen Men
Concern or problem 2:
0
1
2
3
4
5
Not bothering
me at all
6
bothers me
greatly
Wellbeing: How would you rate your general feeling of well-being now?
(How do you feel in yourself?)
0
As good
as it could be
Liver
Lung
6
As bad
as it could be
RESULTS
All 60 men completed the study protocol; the
side-effects of the treatment were limited
to transient exacerbation of vasomotor
symptoms in two men, that lasted only
seconds. All patients were able to selfcomplete the MYCAW questionnaire (Fig. 2)
and at the outset the primary concern was
hot flushes and night sweats in 37 (62%) men,
night sweats alone in 18 (30%), hot flushes
alone in three (5%) and depression in two
(3%). Secondary concerns were sleep
JOURNAL COMPILATION
187
H A R D I N G ET AL.
188
Mean (SD)
Frequency
Daytime
Night-time
Intensity
Daytime
Night-time
Weeks
0
10
P, ANOVA
7.2 (4.9)
6.3 (3.9)
3.8 (3)
3.0 (1.9)
2.2 (2.1)
1.9 (1.4)
<0.05
<0.05
3.2 (0.8)
4.3 (0.9)
2.7 (1.5)
3.1 (1.6)
1.6 (1.4)
1.6 (1.3)
<0.05
<0.05
DISCUSSION
The results from this pilot study suggest that
standardized AA is a safe, inexpensive and
effective treatment for troublesome
vasomotor symptoms experienced by men
taking ADT for advanced prostate cancer. We
provided 10 weekly sessions for 60 patients
(600 treatments) and found minimal adverse
events. On just two (0.3%) occasions patients
reported a transient increase in their
vasomotor symptoms which subsided in a few
seconds. The treatments were carried out by
one practitioner within the group setting
of up to 12 patients. This highlights the
economic benefit of this therapy, which is
relatively inexpensive when compared with
the potential costs of other treatments,
especially pharmacotherapy. The efficacy of
AA is highlighted by the results; the vast
majority of men had a reduction in both the
frequency and intensity of their hot flushes. In
addition to this, all domains of the validated
MYCAW questionnaire [17] showed a mean
improvement across the study group as a
whole. No patient reported any deterioration
in any of these three domains and there were
no patients reporting increases in either
frequency or intensity of hot flushes
throughout the duration of the study
protocol.
We found that the MYCAW questionnaire was
an excellent tool to use for this group of
patients (predominantly elderly men). All
patients were able to self-complete this
simple three-domain questionnaire with no
difficulty. Patients found the questions
unambiguous and the scoring system easy to
understand. Furthermore, the questionnaire
TABLE 1
The mean (SD) frequency
and intensity of day and
night-time hot flushes at 0,
4 and 10 weeks; the
intensity is scored out of 6
(with 6 representing
maximum intensity)
JOURNAL COMPILATION
4
A recent review by Spetz et al. [36] detailed
the evidence for the antiandrogen CPA in the
treatment of hot flushes. A decrease in
vasomotor symptoms is described in two
double-blind, placebo-controlled studies of
castrated men [37,38]. Eaton and McGuire
[37] found significant symptom reduction in
12 patients given CPA 100 mg three times
daily, but found that significantly many
patients (42%) complained of increasing
tiredness whilst on the treatment.
There are therefore various pharmacological
therapies which have confirmed efficacy
in reducing vasomotor symptoms. Each of
these has well described side-effects and
furthermore many men with advanced
prostate cancer are on multiple medical
therapies, and are reluctant to add to their list
of drugs.
In conclusion, the present pilot study showed
that AA might be a useful treatment for
vasomotor symptoms in men on LHRH
analogue treatment for advanced prostate
cancer. It reduces the frequency and severity
of these symptoms and significantly improves
well-being. The treatment is inexpensive and
has no side-effects. Further studies are
necessary and a randomized controlled
trial assessing AA against a conventional
pharmacological therapy is planned,
comparing AA with CPA in the treatment of
hot flushes in men on long-term LHRH
analogue treatment for prostate cancer. This
will provide useful pilot data before a larger
multicentre study in collaboration with the
National Cancer Research Institute.
10
11
12
13
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
14
None declared.
REFERENCES
15
JOURNAL COMPILATION
189
H A R D I N G ET AL.
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
190
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
JOURNAL COMPILATION