Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
9198
Copyright2011MAA
PrintedinGreece.Allrightsreserved.
ANALYTICALINVESTIGATIONOFPIGMENTS,GROUND
LAYERANDMEDIAOFCARTONNAGEFRAGMENTS
FROMGREEKROMANPERIOD
HalaA.M.Afifi
ConservationDepartment,FacultyofArchaeologyCairoUniversity,PostCode:12613,Egypt
Received:31/07/2011
Accepted:12/09/2011
Correspondingauthor:halaafifi11@hotmail.com
ABSTRACT
Some cartonnage fragments from Hawara, Fayoum Excavation were examined to identify pig
ments, media and grounds. It belonged to the GreekRoman period. They were studied by Xray
diffraction(XRD),EnergydispersiveXrayanalysis(EDS)equippedwithScanningelectronmicros
copy (SEM) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). These techniques were used to
identifythecompositionandmorphologyofgrounds,natureofpigments andmediausedincar
tonnagefragments.Thecoarsegroundlayerwascomposedofcalciteandtracesofquartz.Thefine
ground layer used under the pigments directly was composed of calcite only. Carbon black was
usedasblackpigmentwhileleadoxideasredpigment,showingtheinfluenceofRomanandGreek
pigments on Egyptian art in these later periods. Blue colorant was identified as cuprorivaite and
yellowpigmentwasgoethite.Animalgluewasusedinthefourpigmentsasmediumcolored.
KEYWORDS:Fayoum,Hawara,Cartonnage,Pigments,FTIR
HALAA.M.AFIFI
92
1.INTRODUCTION
Analytical investigations of archaeological
objects bring us much information on the de
velopment and propagation of technologies on
cultures.Toconserveandrestorethesevaluable
andscarceobjects,itisindispensabletounder
stand their chemical constituents and crystal
structures.
The EgyptianPolish archaeological Excava
tiontoHawarrapyramidarea,Fayoum(Fig.1A)
coveredmanyarchaeologicalmaterialssuchas,
many pieces of human bones, various skulls,
two skeletons of sacred crocodiles, terracotta,
and one gilded mask with many fragments of
colored cartonnage. These fragments decorated
withreligiousgods.HawarraLabyrinthsiteisa
unique combination of buildings and artefacts
from two different eras and cultures: an Egyp
tian pyramid complex, and Roman period
cemeteries (Shaw, 2000; Verner, 2001; Vila,
1976).
During late Pharonic times, cartonnage was
usedtomaketheinnercoffinsformummies.It
wasmoldedtotheshapeofthebody,forminga
one piece shell. It was often highly decorated
with various geometric designs, an assortment
of deities and inscriptions, which included
versesfromtheBookoftheDead(Picton,etal.,
2007) colored with different pigments. Ancient
Egyptian pigments have been analyzed exten
sivelyinlaboratorystudies(Barbierietal.1974;
Riederer 1974; Jaksch et al. 1983; Goresy et al.
1986;Saleh1987;Riederer1988;LucasandHar
ris1989).
It is selfevident that nondestructive and
noncontact analysis in the field is indispensa
bleforinvestigatingancientremains.Theproc
ess,ofcreatinganentiremummiformcoffinout
of cartonnage, was a time consuming and ex
pensiveprocess.
During Ptolemaic times, a new, simpler
method of mummy decoration was adopted.
Instead of encasing the mummy in a onepiece
mummiform shell, it would be covered with
four to six separate pieces of decorated carton
nage. These would be attached to the outer
mummy wrappings and could easily be mass
produced. These separate sections of carton
nageconsistedofamaskcoveringtheheadand
shoulders,apectoral,anapronforthelegsand
afootcasing.
Sometimes, two additional pieces were
added to cover the ribcage and stomach. The
cartonnage pieces which covered the ribcage
andstomachoftendepictedthewingedbabird.
These sections wouldoften be cut tothe shape
ofthefigure.Sometimes,theimageofawinged
scarab was also depicted. On some of these
pieces, a small, generally square section of the
cartonnage would be left undecorated or
paintedaneutralcolor(Stewart,1986).
This work analyzed some fragments from
the painted cartonnage of a mummy that was
discovered in Hawara pyramid excavation Fig.
1(B)toestablishitselementalcompositionand
toverifyifthepigmentsusedinthedecorative
paintingsareinaccordancewiththoseusedby
Egyptian craftsmen in the Roman period
(Liritzis et al., 1997). These cartonnage frag
ments consist of two ground layers; coarse
groundlayerandfineorpaintinggroundlayer
Fig.1(C).
Fig.1(A)HawaraPyramidandtheareaofexcavationwork,Fayoum,Egypt.(B)Studiedexcavatedcartonnage
fragments.(C)Twopaintinggroundlayersofcartonnagefragment.
ANALYTICALINVESTIGATIONOFPIGMENTS,GROUNDLAYERANDMEDIAOFCARTONNAGEFRAGMENTSFROMGREEKROMANPERIOD
93
Fig.2(A),(B),(C)ThreeofHawaracartonnagefragmentsrepresentedtheexaminedpigments
3.RESULTS
To conserve and restore, it is indispensable
to understand the chemical constituents and
crystalstructures.Thetechnologyofthemateri
als used in the fabrication of ancient Egyptian
cartonnage is still not fully investigated.
(Daniels, 2007; Scott et al., 2003; Scott et al.,
2009).
Among archaeological objects, pigments are
most attractive targets for scientific study be
cause their colors are yardsticks of a sense of
beauty, and they provide a means for estimat
ing ancient technologies ability to prepare
pigmentsartificially(Green1995;Nagashimaet
al. 1996; Goresy 1997; Uda 1999, Uda et al.
2000a; Uda et al. 2000b; Yoshimura et al. 2002;
Goresyet.,al1986).
3.1.Groundlayers
From visual inspection and analysis of sam
ples by X ray diffraction (XRD), energy disper
siveXrayanalysisequippedwithscanningelec
tron microscope analysis (SEM) are character
izedbytwopreparationlayersorgroundpaint
HALAA.M.AFIFI
94
compositionofthefinegroundlayerusedunder
the pigments directly was composed of calcite,
CaCO3 only Fig. 3 B). This result agreed with
(UDA, 1999). EDX data of ground layers (Fig. 3
C,D)respectively,showedthefinegroundlayer
that composed of Ca that exhibited the highest
concentrations80.86%and11.14%ofC.Thisre
sultindicatesthatthelayerisconsistsofcalcite.
The coarse ground layer is composed of Ca, C,
Si, agreed with the result of XRD data that is
composedofcalciteandquartz.
Fig.3(A,B,C,D)XRD,EDXpatternsoftheinternalandexternalgroundlayersofthecartonnagefragments.(A)
XRDdataofinternalgroundlayerthatconsistedofcalciteandquartz.(B)XRDdataofexternalgroundlayerthat
containedcalciteonly.(C)EDXpatternofinternalgroundlayer.(D)EDXdataofexternalgroundlayer
3.2.Pigments
3.2.1Redpigment
Themajorityofredpigmentsusedinancient
Egypt were earthen based colors containing
iron oxide. Hematite (Fe2O3) was very com
mon (Green 2001, M. Uda, et al 2000). This Fe
based colors are longer lasting and light faster
than others, and are sometimes of astonishing
brilliance.Twofurtherredpigmentshavebeen
imported to Egypt by the Romans: Red lead
(Pb3O4)andVermillion(HgS).Ifthesepigments
arefoundonancientobjects,itcanbeassumed
tobeproducednotearlierthanthefirstcentury
B.C. Mineralogical analysis conducted by XRD
showedintheFig.(4A).Itpresentedcalciteasa
painting ground layer, lead oxide Pb3O4 as red
pigment with carbon as black. This result
agreedwith(Burgioetal.,2007;RoccoMazzeo,
etal.,2004).Calciteandleadoxideweredeter
mined by SEMEDS. Pb, Ca, with minor com
ponentofSi(Fig.4B).
3.2.2Bluepigment
In 3000 BC, Egyptian craftsmen created the
firstsyntheticpigmentproducedbyman,Egyp
tianblue,whichwaswidelyusedduringantiq
uity, spreading all around the Mediterranean
basin until the 7th century AD. The Egyptian
green pigment, also called green frit, appeared
shortly after, presenting the same chemical
elementsandaturquoisecolor.Thesetwopig
ments have been confused for a long time
(Mazzochin, 2004; Page`s 2003; Daniels, 2007).
In many cases, Egyptian blue was added in
smallamountstoenhancethebrillianceofother
colors. It was reported by (Mazzochin 2003;
Mazzochin ,et al., 2003). XRD data of blue pig
ANALYTICALINVESTIGATIONOFPIGMENTS,GROUNDLAYERANDMEDIAOFCARTONNAGEFRAGMENTSFROMGREEKROMANPERIOD
95
Fig4(A,B,C,D,E,F)XRDandEDXofpigmentsamples.Fig3(A)XRDdataofredandblackpigmentsshowed
thatredpigmentconsistedofleadoxidePbO3andblackascarbon.Fig3(B)EDXdataoftheredandblackpig
ments.Fig3(C)XRDofblueandblackpigmentsdataexplainedthecuprorivaite,CaCuSi4O10asblueandblack
wascarbon.Fig3(D)EDXdataoftheblueandblackpigments.Fig3(E)XRDdatashowedthatgoethite
Fe2O3.H2Owasyellowpigmentusedonthecartonnagefragments.Fig3(F)EDXdataofyellowpigment
3.3.Bindingmedia
The spectroscopic study was essentially ad
dressed to characterize the colouring medium
usedinthecartonnagefragments.Inalltheana
lysed samples, the stretching vibrations of cal
ciumcarbonate,CaCO3,peakedat1409,705and
611cm1wereidentifiedsincethesubstratewas
just a calcarenite (Griffith 1987). In particular,
we evidenced the typical hydroxyl bands cen
tredat3694,3669,3652andat3620cm1,theSi
OSi band peaked at 1032 cm1, the SiOAl at
1009cm1andfinallytheAlOHbandsat938
and 914 cm1. The use of animal glue is also
showninthisIRspectrumbythepresenceofa
bandat1540cm1associatedwiththedeforma
tion vibration of the NH link in the protein
4.CONCLUSION
Thepresentstudyhasshownthecharacteri
zation of painted cartonnage fragments from
HawaraexcavationinFayoumthatbelongedto
theGreekRomanperiod,Egypt.
The technology of cartonnage making,
ground layers composition, pigments constitu
entsandcolormediumwereidentifiedbyusing
differentanalyticalmethodsasXRD,EDX,SEM
andFTIR.
96
HALAA.M.AFIFI
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author gratefully acknowledges the help of the Egyptianpolish excavation members. The
helpofProf.Dr.AllaElDienShaheenpreviousDeanofFacultyofArchaeology,CairoUniversity
andProf.Dr.MohamedAbdElHadyProf.ofConservationandRestorationmonumentsinFaculty
ofArchaeology,CairoUniversitywasinvaluableforhelpfuldiscussions.
REFERENCES
Barbieri,M.Calderoni,G.Cortesi,C.Fornaseri,M.(1974)Huntite,Amineralusedinantiquity.Ar
chaeometry16:211220
Bikiaris,D.Daniilia,S.Sotiropoulou,S.Katsimbiri,O.Pavlidou,E.Moutsatsou,A.Chryssoulakis,
Y.(1999)Spectrochim.ActaPartA,56318
Brecoulaki,H.Fiorin,E.Vigato,P.A.(2006)Thefuneraryklinaioftomb1fromAmphipolisanda
sarcophagusfromancientTragilos,easternMacedonia:aphysicochemicalinvestigation
onthepaintingmaterials,JournalofCulturalHeritage,7,301311
Daniels,V.(2007)AnalysesofcopperandbeeswaxcontaininggreenpaintonEgyptianantiquities.
StudiesinConservation52,1318.
DomCnech,M.T.Carbe,V.PerkMartinez,J.V.,GimenoAdelantado,F.,BoschReig,MoyaMoreno,
M.C.M.(1997)Fouriertransforminfraredspectroscopyandtheanalyticalstudyofsculp
turesandwalldecoration,JournalofMolecularStructure,410411559563
Goresy, A. E., Jaksch Razek, H.M.A. Weiner, K.L. (1986) Ancient pigments in wall paintings of
Egyptiantombsandtemples.Rep.M.P.I.HV12:145
Goresy, A.E (1997) Polychromatic wall painting decorations in monuments of pharaonic Egypt:
compositions,chronology,andpaintingtechniques.1stInternationalSymposiumonthe
Wall Paintings of Thera, August 30 September 4, Santorini, (organized by The Thera
Foundation,Piraeus,Greece,pp.4970
Green,L.R.(1955)RecentAnalysisofPigmentsfromAncientEgyptianArtifactsInConservationin
Ancient Egyptian Collections, Brown CE, Macalister F, Wright MM. (eds). Archetype
Publication:8591
Green,L.ColourtransformationsofancientEgyptianpigments.In:W.V.Davies(Ed.),Colourand
PaintinginAncientEgypt,OxbowBooks,London,2001,pp.4348.
Hanlan, J. (1975) The Scanning Electron Microscope and Microprobe: application to conservation
andhistorical research. In ICOM Committee for Conservation 4th Triennial Meeting,
Venice,1318October,ICOMParis,p.6.
Hillyer,L.(1984)TheconservationofagroupofpaintedmummyclothsfromRomanEgypt.Studies
inConservation29,19.
ANALYTICALINVESTIGATIONOFPIGMENTS,GROUNDLAYERANDMEDIAOFCARTONNAGEFRAGMENTSFROMGREEKROMANPERIOD
97
Hodgins,G.,Hedges,R.(2000)Towardtheimmunologicaldetectionofmedia:thedetectionofarti
ficiallyagedcollagenbasedpaints.In:Artetchimie,lacouleur:actesduCongresssousla
directiondeJacquesGoupyetJeanPierreMohen.CNRS,Paris,pp.7579.
JakschH,SeipelW,WeinerK.L,GoresyA.E.(1983)Egyptianbluecuprorivaite,awindowtoan
cientegyptiantechnology.Naturwiss.70:525535
Katsaros, T, Liritzis, I and Laskaris, N (2011) Identification of Theophrastus pigments egyptios
kyanos and psimythion from archaeological excavations: A case study. Archaeosciences
(RevuedArchaeometrie)34,6980.
Liritzis.IandPolychroniadou.E(2007)OpticalandanalyticaltechniquesappliedtotheAmfissaCa
thedralmuralpaintingsmadebytheGreekartistSpyrosPapaloukas(18921957).Revue
dArchaeometrie(Archaeosciences),31,97112
Liritzis Y., Salter C. and Hatcher H. (1997) Chemical Composition of some GrecoRoman glass
fragmentsfromPatras,Greece.EuropeanjournalofPACT,No45,I2,2534.
LucasA,HarrisJR(1989)AncientEgyptianMaterialsandIndustries,London:Histories&Mysteries
ofMan,LTD.,338366
LuciaBurgio,RobinJ.H.Clark,MariamRosserOwen(2007)RamananalysisofninthcenturyIraqi
stuccoesfromSamarra,JournalofArchaeologicalScience34,756762
Mazurek,J.,Schilling,M.,Chiari,G.,Heginbotham,A.,(2008).Antibodyassaytocharacterizebind
ingmediainpaint.In:Bridgland,J.(Ed.),ICOMCommitteeforConservation,15thTrien
nialConference,NewDelhi,pp.849856.
Mazzochin,G.A.Agnoli,F.Mazzochin,S.&Colpo,I(2003)AnalysisofpigmentsfromRomanwall
paintingsfoundinVicenza.Talanta61565572.
Mazzochin,G.A.Agnoli,F.Colpo,I.(2003)Investigationofromanagepigmentsfoundonpottery
fragments Anal.Chim.Acta478(1)147161.
Mazzochin,G.A.Rudello,D.C.Bragato,F.Agnoli(2004)AshortnoteonEgyptianblueJ.Cult.Her.
5(1)129133.
Nagashima S, Kato M, Kotani T, Morito K, Miyazawa M, Kondo J, Yoshimura S, Sasa Y, Uda M
(1996)ApplicationoftheexternalPIXEanalysistoancientEgyptianobjects..Nucl.Instr.
Meth.inPhys.Res.B109/110:658661
Page`sCamagna,S.Colinart,S.(2003)TheEgyptianGreenPigment:ItsManufacturingProcessAnd
LinksToEgyptianBlueArchaeometry45(4)637658.
Perdikatsis,V.,Kilikoglou,V.,Sotiropoulou,S.,Chryssikopoulou,E.,2000.Physiochemicalcharac
terizationofpigmentsofTheranwallpaintings.In:Sherratt,S.(Ed.),TheWallPaintings
ofThera.ProceedingsoftheFirstInternationalSymposium.PetrosM.NomikosConfer
ence Centre, Thera, Hellas. 30 August4 September 1997, Petros M. Nomikos and The
TheraFoundation,Athens,pp.103118.
Perdikatsis,V.Brecoulaki,H.TheUseofRedandYellowOchresasPaintingMaterialsinAncient
Macedonia, Third International Symposium on Archaeometry, Athens, May 2003, Na
tionalHellenicResearchFoundation,Y.Facorellis,N.Zacharias,K.Polikreti(editors),pp.
559567.
Picton, J., Quirke, S., Roberts, P.,( 2007). Living Images. Egyptian Funerary Portraits in the Petrie
Museum.WalnutCreek,California.
RiedererJ(1974)Recentlyidentifiedegyptianpigments.Archaeometry16:102109
RiedererJ(1988)PigmenteinderAntike.Naturwissenschaften,37:310
Saleh,S.A(1987)Pigments,plasterandsaltanalysesInWallPaintingsoftheTombofNefertari:Sci
entific Studies for Their Conservation: First Progress Report, July 1987, Conzo MA, ed.
California:CairoandCentury,pp94105
Schilling,M.Khandekar,N.Keeney,J.Khanjian,H.(2000)Identificationofbindingmediaandpig
mentsinthepaintingsofJacobLawrence.In:Nesbett,PeterT.,DuBois,Michelle(Eds.),
98
HALAA.M.AFIFI
OvertheLine:theArtandLifeofJacobLawrence.UniversityofWashingtonPress,Seat
tle,pp.266269.
Scott,D.A.,Newman,M.,Schilling,M.,Derrick,M.R.,Khanjian,H.P.(1996)Bloodasabindingme
diuminaChumashIndianpigmentcake.Archaeometry38,103112.
Scott,D.A.,Dennis,M.,Khandekar,N.,Keeney,J.,Carson,D.,Dodd,L.S.(2003)AnEgyptiancar
tonnageoftheGraecoRomanperiod:examinationanddiscoveries.StudiesinConserva
tion48,4156.
Scott,D.A.Warmlander,S.Mazurek,J.QuirkeS.(2009)Examinationofsomepigments,grounds
and media from Egyptian cartonnage fragments in the Petrie Museum, University Col
legeLondon,JournalofArchaeologicalScience36923932
Schiegl, S., Weiner, K.L., and El Goresy, A. (1989) Discovery of copper chloride cancer in ancient
Egyptian polychromic wall paintings and faience: a developing archaeological disaster.
Naturwissenschaften76,393400.
Shaw,I.(2000)TheOxfordHistoryofAncientEgypt,OxfordUniversityPress.
Stewart,H.(1986)MummyCasesandInscribedFuneraryConesinthePetrieCollection.Arisand
Phillips,Warminster.
Uda,M.Sassa,S.YoshiokaY,Taniguchi,K.Nomura,S.Yoshimura,S.Kondo,J.NakamuraM.Is
kandar, N. Zaghloul, B. (1999) Xray analysis of pigments on ancient Egyptian monu
ments.Intern.J.PIXE9:441451
Uda,M.Sassa,S.Yoshioka,Y.Taniguchi,K.Nomura,S.Yoshimura,S.Kondo,J.Nakamura,M.Is
kandar,N.Zaghloul,B.(2000a)TouchfreeinsituinvestigationofancientEgyptianpig
ments.Naturwissenschaften87:260263
Uda, M. Sassa, S. Yoshioka, Y. Taniguchi, K. Nomura, S. Yoshimura, S. Kondo, J. Nakamura, M.
Ban,Y.Adachi,H.(2000b)Yellow,redandbluepigmentsfromancientEgyptianpalace
paintedwalls.Nucl.Instr.Meth.inPhys.Res.161163:758761
Verner,Miroslav,Pyramids(2001)TheMystery,Culture,andScienceofEgyptsGreatMonuments),
GrovePress.
Vila,A.,(1976)LesmasquesFuneraires.In:Vercoutter,J.(Ed.),MirgissaIII.Lesnecropoles.Mission
ArcheologiqueFranaiseauSoudan,Paris,pp.151268.
YoshimuraS,UdaM,SaitoK(2002)Astudyoftheuseofcalciteplasterforplasteringwallsinan
cientEgypt.Arch.NaturalScience.44:115
Griffith,W(1987)AdvancesintheRamanandinfraredspectroscopyofminerals.Spectroscopyof
inorganicbased materials. In: Spectroscopy of InorganicBased Materials, ed. by R.J.H.
Clark,R.E.Hester(Wiley,Chichester,),Chapter2,315:325
Farrell, E. Snow, C. Vinogradskaya, N. (2006) The study and treatment of Padimuts cartonnage
mummycase.JournaloftheAmericanInstituteforConservation45,115.
Uda,M.Sassa,S.Uda,M.Sassa,S.Yoshimura,S.KondoJ.,Nakamura,M.Ban,Y.Adachi H.(2000)
Yellow, redand blue pigments from ancient Egyptian palace painted walls, Nucl. Instr.
andMeth.B161163,758761.
Olsson, A.M.B. Calligaro, T. Colinart S., Dran J.C., Loevastam N.E.G.,Moigard B. and Salomon J.
(2001) MicroPIXE analysis of an Egyptian Papyrus Identification of the pigments used
fortheBookoftheDead,Nucl.Instr.andMeth.Phys.Res.B181,707714.
Edwards, H.G.M. VillarS.E.J. David A.R., de Faria D.L.A., (2004) Nondestructive Analysis of An
cientEgyptianFuneraryRelics,Anal.Chim.Acta223233.