Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Introduction
Selecting Crete as the analytical
analogy for Cyprus became obvious
on a rst level through the clear
similarities between the two islands.
The comparable size of two of the
largest islands in the Mediterranean,
the similar climatic, topographical,
faunal and oral characteristics, their
geographical location in relation
to Anatolia and mainland Greece
respectively, as well as their similar trajectories are points that have
already been highlighted by scholars.1
More importantly, the parallel routes
that both islands followed throughout
most of the Neolithic and early part
of the Bronze Age provide us with
a particularly promising avenue for
comparative research in prehistoric
social developments.
Though for a long time islands
were considered to have represented
isolated laboratories of biological and
social developments, and thus ideal
units of controlled analysis, recently
this idea has come under re. It has
been realised that dening islands
as cultural units is not a straightforward process, as it is rare that we
can prove they existed in isolation
from the surrounding world.2 On the
contrary, insularity is perceived as a
Medelhavsmuseet 171
172 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
In the ceramic Neolithic, the pattern noted for the aceramic period
is reversed. Starting with Crete, the
sample in question consists of 121
gurines, the vast majority of which
have been recovered from Knossos.
The overall pattern suggests a distribution that corresponds chronologically with the dispersal of population
around the Cretan landscape,22 as
indicated by the recovery of gurines
from Final Neolithic sites, the foundation of which was the result of population growth. There is, therefore, a
diachronic use of anthropomorphic
symbolism in the form of gurines
throughout the Neolithic on Crete
(Fig. 1).
The chart in Fig. 2 shows a clear
predominance of Female and other
Female-related categories, followed
by the Asexual variety, while Male
and Ambiguous gurines represent a
very low percentage.23 The evidence
suggests that it is a pattern that generally stays the same throughout the
Neolithic, apart from the Ambiguous
variety that is not attested in the Final
Neolithic phases (Fig. 3).24 Systematic
analysis conducted on Neolithic gurines from the whole of the Aegean
has also revealed that the overlap of
motifs between Female and Female
form gurines (Fig. 4), and Female and
Asexual gurines (Fig. 5), suggests a
multi-faceted way in which female
gender identity was constructed,
though it is possible that some undecorated Asexual gurines were perhaps
intended to represent men.25 I propose, therefore, that Female form and
Asexual gurines represented different
stages in a persons life (pre-pubescent
or mature age) and Ambiguous gurines may have symbolised an actual
third gender or a symbolic unison of
Medelhavsmuseet 173
174 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Fig. . Shared motifs between Female (left) and Female form gurines from Sitagroi,
Late Neolithic (my emphasis). (Source: Renfrew, C., M. Gimbutas & E. S. Elster
, Figs . and ..)
Fig. . Shared motifs between Female (left) and Asexual gurines from Sitagroi, Late
Neolithic (my emphasis). (Source: Renfrew, C., M. Gimbutas & E. S. Elster ,
Figs . and ..)
Medelhavsmuseet 175
176 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Medelhavsmuseet 177
178 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Medelhavsmuseet 179
180 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Fig. . Example of EBA anthropomorphic symbolism of Cyprus. (Drawing by the author after Karageorghis
, no. .)
Medelhavsmuseet 181
Conclusion
The study of gurines through a
comparative analysis has uncovered
some of the ways in which anthropomorphic symbolisms can offer
insights into social organisation and
the construction of prehistoric social
identities. Furthermore, examining
the impetus behind the production
and circulation of gurines can reveal
the active processes behind the sha-
182 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Acknowledgements
I wish to thank the Medelhavsmuseet,
which helped fund my visit to
Stockholm for the purposes of the
conference. I am very grateful to
Professor C. Renfrew and Dr L.
Talalay for granting me permission
to reproduce illustrations from their
publications, and to the British
School at Athens for granting me
the permission to study unpublished
gurine material from the 19691970
excavations at Knossos. Lastly, I wish
to thank my supervisors Professor R.
Whitehouse and Dr C. Broodbank for
their useful comments on my doctoral
thesis that this paper partly draws
from.
notes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Swiny 1997.
Broodbank 2000, 26.
Broodbank 2000, 18; Clarke 2003;
Finlayson 2004.
Mina [b] forthcoming.
Mina [b] forthcoming.
Aalten 1997; Gatens 1992, 298;
Lindemann 1997; MacRae 1975.
Moore 1994, 325.
Hatcher 1985; Tanner 1992.
Hatcher 1985; Tilley 1989, 189; Wolff
1993.
See Knappet 2002, 100-1.
Rowlands 1993.
Rowlands 1993, 142, 144.
Rowlands 1993, 142.
Rowlands 1993, 146.
Fraser 1971.
Bolger 2003, 85; a Campo 1994;
Dikaios 1953; Karageorghis et al.
2003; Le Brun 1997.
Evans 1964.
Triantaphyllou forthcoming.
Steel 2004, 52.
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
Medelhavsmuseet 183
bibliography
Aalten, A. 1997.
Performing the Body, Creating Culture, in: Embodied Practices: Feminist
Perspectives on the Body, ed. K. Davis,
41-58, London.
a Campo, A.L. 1994.
Anthropomorphic Representations in Prehistoric Cyprus: A Formal and Symbolic
Analysis of Figurines, c. 3500-1800 BC.
Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology
and Literature, Pocket-book 109,
Jonsered.
Blackman, D.J. & K. Branigan 1973.
An Unusual Tholos Tomb at Kaminospilio, S. Crete, Cretika Chronika 25,
199-206.
Boas, F. 1955.
Primitive Art, New York.
Bolger, D. 1996.
Figurines, fertility, and the emergence
of complex society in prehistoric
Cyprus, Current Anthropology 37, 365373.
Bolger, D. 2002.
Gender and Mortuary Ritual in
Chalcolithic Cyprus, in: Engendering
Aphrodite: Women and Society in Ancient
Cyprus, eds. D. Bolger & N. Serwint,
67-86. CAARI Monographs 3, Boston.
Bolger, D. 2003.
Gender in Ancient Cyprus: Narratives
of Social Change on a Mediterranean
Island, Walnut Creek, CA.
Branigan, K. 1988.
Pre-Palatial: The Foundations of Palatial
Crete, A Survey of Crete in the Early
Bronze Age (2nd rev. edn.), London.
Broodbank, C. 2000.
An Island Archaeology of the Early
Cyclades, Cambridge.
Clarke, J. 2003.
Insularity and Identity in Prehistoric
Cyprus, in: Le Nolithique de Chypre:
Actes du Colloque International Organis
par le Dpartement des Antiquits de
Chypre et l cole Franaise d Athnes,
Nicosie 17-19 Mai 2001, eds. J. Guillaine
& A. Le Brun, 203-218, Athens.
Dikaios, P. 1953.
Khirokitia, Oxford.
Evans, A. 1928.
The Palace of Minos at Knossos, Vol. II:I,
London.
Evans, J.D. 1964.
Excavations in the Neolithic Settlement of Knossos, 1957-1960 (Part
I), The Annual of the British School at
Athens 59, 132-240.
Finlayson, B. 2004.
Island colonization, insularity or mainstream?, in: Neolithic Revolution: New
Perspectives on Southwest Asia in Light
of Recent Discoveries on Cyprus, eds. E.
Peltenburg & A. Wasse, 15-22, Oxford.
Flourentzos, P. 1988.
Ta Eidolia tis Kyprou, Nicosia.
Frankel, D. 1997.
On Cypriot Figurines and the Origins
of Patriarchy, Current Anthropology
38:1, 84.
Frankel, D. 2000.
Migration and Ethnicity in Prehistoric Cyprus: Technology as Habitus,
European Journal of Archaeology 3:2,
167-187.
Frankel, D., J.M. Webb & C. Elsick 1996.
Anatolia and Cyprus in the third millennium BCE. A speculative model of
interaction, in: Cultural Interaction in
the Ancient Near East, ed. G. Bunnens,
37-50, Louvain.
Fraser, P.M. 1971.
Archaeology in Greece, 1970-71,
Archaeological Reports for 1970-1971,
3-32.
Gatens, M. 1992.
Power Bodies and Difference, in: Destabilizing theory: contemporary feminist
debates, eds. M. Barrett & A. Phillips,
120-137, Cambridge.
Goring, E. 1991.
Pottery gurines: the development of
coroplastic art in Chalcolihic Cyprus,
Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 282/283, 39-60.
Goring, E. 1998.
Figurines, gurine fragments, phalli,
possibly gurative worked and unworked stones, unidentiable worked
stones and pottery fragments, in:
Lemba Archaeological Project II. 1 A:
Excavations at Kissonerga-Mosphilia,
184 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Lindemann, G. 1997.
The Body of Gender Difference, in:
Embodied Practices: Feminist Perspectives on the Body, ed. K. Davis, 73-92,
London.
MacRae, D.G. 1975.
The Body and Social Metaphor, in:
The Body as a Medium of Expression,
eds. J. Benthall & T. Polhemus, 59-73,
London.
Maggidis, C. 1998.
From Polis to Necropolis: Social Ranking from Architectural and Mortuary
Evidence in the Minoan Cemetery at
Phourni, Archanes, in: Cemetery and
Society in the Aegean Bronze Age, ed. K.
Branigan, 87-102. Shefeld Studies in
Aegean Archaeology 1, Shefeld.
Manning, S. W. 1993.
Prestige, distinction, and competition:
the anatomy of socioeconomic complexity in fourth to second millennium
BCE, Bulletin of the American Schools of
Oriental Research 292, 35-58.
Mina, M. (a). Forthcoming.
Figurin Out Cretan Neolithic Society, in: Rethinking the Cretan Neolithic,
eds. P. Halstead & J.C. Barrett. Shefeld Studies in Aegean Archaeology
series, Oxford.
Mina, M. (b). Forthcoming.
Anthropomorphic Figurines from the
Neolithic and Early Bronze Age Aegean:
Gender Dynamics and Implications for
the Understanding of Aegean Prehistory.
BAR Monograph series, Oxford.
Moore, H. L. 1994.
A Passion for Difference, Cambridge.
Mpirtacha, K. 2003.
Chromata kai Chromatismos kata tin
Proimi Epochi tou Chalkou stis Kyklades, in: Argonautes: timitikos tomos gia
ton kathigiti Christo G. Douma, eds. A.
Vlachopoulos & K. Mpirtacha, 263276, Athens.
Murphy, J. 1998.
Ideologies, Rites and Rituals: A View
of Prepalatial Minoan Tholoi, in: Cemetery and Society in the Aegean Bronze
Age, ed. K Branigan, 27-40, Shefeld.
Papadatos, G. 2003.
Ena Palimpsisto, Loipon, in: Argonautis: timitikos tomos gia ton Kathigiti
Christo G Douma, eds. A. Vlachopoulos
& K. Mpirtacha, 277-291, Athens.
Peltenburg, E. 1993.
Settlement discontinuity and resistance to complexity, ca. 4500-2500
BC, Bulletin of the American Schools of
Oriental Research 292, 9-23.
Peltenburg, E. 2002.
Gender and Social Structure in Prehistoric Cyprus: A Case Study from
Kissonerga, in: Engendering Aphrodite:
Women and Society in Ancient Cyprus,
eds. D. Bolger & N. Serwint, 53-66.
CAARI Monographs 3, Boston.
Peltenburg, E. 2004.
Social space in early sedentary
communities of Southwest Asia and
Cyprus, in: Neolithic Revolution: New
Perspectives on Southwest Asia in Light
of Recent Discoveries on Cyprus, eds. E.
Peltenburg & A. Wasse, 71-90, Oxford.
Renfrew, C., M. Gimbutas & E.S. Elster,
eds. 1986.
Excavations at Sitagroi: A Prehistoric
Village in Northeast Greece, 1. Monumenta Archaeologica 13, Los Angeles.
Ribeiro, E. 2002.
Altering the Body: Representations
of Pre-Pubescent Gender Groups
on Early and Middle Cypriot Scenic Compositions, in: Engendering
Aphrodite: Women and Society in Ancient
Cyprus, eds. D. Bolger & N. Serwint,
67-86. CAARI Monographs 3, Boston.
Rowlands, M. 1993.
The Role of Memory in the Transmission of Culture, World Archaeology,
25:2, 141-151.
Sakellarakis, G.E. 1974.
Anaskaphi Archanon, Praktika tis en
Athenais Archaioligikis Etaireias, 310353.
Sapouna-Sakellaraki, E. 1983.
To eidolio tou Sampa kai ta amorfa
lithina eidolia tis proimis epochis tou
Chalkou stin Kriti, Arhaiologiki Ephimeris 122, 44-74.
Medelhavsmuseet 185
Triantaphyllou, S. Forthcoming.
Living With The Dead: A Consideration Of Mortuary Practices In The
Greek Neolithic, in: Rethinking the
Cretan Neolithic, eds. P. Halstead & J.C.
Barrett. Shefeld Studies in Aegean
Archaeology series, Oxford.
Ucko, P.J. 1968.
Anthropomorphic Figurines of Predynastic
Egypt and Neolithic Crete with Comparative Material from the Prehistoric Near
East and Mainland Greece, London.
186 Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 19271931: A Gender Perspective
Whitelaw, T. Forthcoming.
Beyond the Tell: Neolithic Knossos in
long-term demographic perspective,
in: Rethinking the Cretan Neolithic, eds.
P. Halstead & J.C. Barrett. Shefeld
Studies in Aegean Archaeology series,
Oxford.
Wolff, J. 1993.
The Social Production of Art, 2nd edition,
London.