Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Abstract
The objective of this paper is to observe and quantify the relationship between elastic buckling and the tested response of cold-formed
steel columns with holes. Compression tests were conducted on 24 short and intermediate length cold-formed steel columns with and
without slotted web holes. For each specimen, a shell nite element eigenbuckling analysis was also conducted such that the inuence of
the boundary conditions and the hole on local, distortional, and global elastic buckling response could also be captured. Slotted web
holes may modify the local and distortional elastic buckling half-wavelengths, and may also change the critical elastic buckling loads.
Experimentally, slotted web holes are shown to have a minimal inuence on the tested ultimate strength in the specimens considered,
although post-peak ductility is decreased in some cases. Tangible connections are observed between elastic buckling and
loaddisplacement response during the tests, including mode switching between local and distortional buckling. The columns are
tested with friction-bearing boundary conditions where the columns ends are milled at and parallel, and bear directly on steel platens.
These boundary conditions, which greatly speed specimen preparation, are determined to be viable for evaluating the tested response of
short and intermediate length columns, although the post-peak response of intermediate length specimens must be considered with care.
r 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Elastic buckling; Experiments; Ultimate strength; Holes; Cold-formed steel; Perforations
1. Introduction
Cold-formed steel structural members are commonly
provided with holes to accommodate plumbing, electrical,
and heating conduits in the walls and ceilings of buildings.
These holes are typically pre-punched perforations located
in the web of Cee or Zee sections and can alter the elastic
stiffness and ultimate strength of a structural member. The
majority of existing experimental data on cold-formed steel
columns with holes has been obtained from stub column
tests, where the ultimate strength is driven by local
buckling and yielding of the cross-section [18]. Stub
column tests in [1] demonstrated that ultimate strength
decreased as circular hole diameter increased, relative to
web depth. Similar conclusions when evaluating the
inuence of circular, slotted, and rectangular web holes
on stub column ultimate strength have also been reported
[24]. The impact of the location of the hole in the stub
Corresponding author.
column [57] as well as the length of the hole [8] have also
all been studied. In addition to the stub column testing, 25
intermediate and long column tests were completed by [1]
and demonstrated that a single hole at the mid-height of a
pinnedpinned column did not affect ultimate strength.
The motivation for this experimental program is to
expand the existing column data set with tests on short and
intermediate length columns with holes. The column
lengths and cross-section dimensions are specically chosen
to explore the connection between local, distortional, and
global elastic buckling modes, ultimate strength, and the
resulting failure mechanisms. The elastic buckling behavior
is evaluated for each specimen with a nite element
eigenbuckling analysis, taking care to accurately simulate
the tested boundary conditions and measured specimen
dimensions. These elastic buckling results are used to
provide a means of understanding the varied deformation
response under load.
The columns are tested with friction-bearing boundary
conditions where the ends of each specimen are milled
at and parallel, and bear directly against steel platens.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1165
2. Testing program
Twenty-four cold-formed steel lipped Cee channel
columns with and without pre-punched slotted web holes
were tested to failure. The primary experimental parameters are column cross-section, column length, and the
presence or absence of slotted web holes. The specimen
naming convention, as it relates to the testing parameters,
is dened in Fig. 1. The rationale for selecting these
experimental parameters is discussed in Section 2.1.
Table 1
FSM local and distortional buckling half-wavelengths for nominal
362S162-33 and 600S162-33 cross-sections
Cross-section
362S162-33
600S162-33
70
120
390
310
No Holes
362-1-24-NH
362-2-24-NH
362-3-24-NH
SSMA 362S162-33
362-1-48-NH
362-2-48-NH
362-3-48-NH
600-1-24-NH
600-2-24-NH
600-3-24-NH
SSMA 600S162-33
600-1-48-NH
600-2-48-NH
600-3-48-NH
Holes
362-1-24-H
362-2-24-H
362-3-24-H
362-1-48-H
362-2-48-H
362-3-48-H
600-1-24-H
600-2-24-H
600-3-24-H
600-1-48-H
600-2-48-H
600-3-48-H
20
Stub column tests
18
16
number of specimens
14
12
Specimens with
holes in this study
10
8
6
4
2
0
0
200
400
600
Short Column
Intermediate
Column
362-1-24-NH
Specimen with holes
(H) or without holes
(NH)
Short Column
Cross-section type
Intermediate
Column
Specimen
number within
common group
(1,2,3)
Nominal specimen
length, 610 mm (24 in.)
or 1219 mm (48 in.)
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1166
Fixed Crosshead
Load Cell
Position
transducers (with
magnet tips)
Friction-bearing boundary
conditions (specimen bears
directly on steel platen)
Fig. 3. Column test setup and instrumentation.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1167
North
S1
D1
a
West
West
D2
B1
East
B2
F1
East
S2
F2
H
RT1
RT2
West
East
South
RB1
RB2
Section a-a
Table 2
Summary of measured specimen cross-section dimensions and yield stress
Specimen
fy
(MPa)
t
(mm)
L
(mm)
H
(mm)
B1
(mm)
B2
(mm)
D1
(mm)
D2
(mm)
RT1
(mm)
RT2
(mm)
RB1
(mm)
RB2
(mm)
S1
(deg)
S2
(deg)
F1
(deg)
F2
(deg)
362-1-24-NH
362-2-24-NH
362-3-24-NH
362-1-24-H
362-2-24-H
362-3-24-H
362-1-48-NH
362-2-48-NH
362-3-48-NH
362-1-48-H
362-2-48-H
362-3-48-H
600-1-24-NH
600-2-24-NH
600-3-24-NH
600-1-24-H
600-2-24-H
600-3-24-H
600-1-48-NH
600-2-48-NH
600-3-48-NH
600-1-48-H
600-2-48-H
600-3-48-H
380
380
380
400
394
386
412
409
407
404
412
402
405
405
405
427
403
415
415
437
422
423
428
424
0.98
0.98
0.98
0.99
0.97
1.00
1.00
1.00
0.99
1.00
0.99
1.01
1.11
1.11
1.11
1.07
1.05
1.09
1.10
1.10
1.10
1.09
1.09
1.10
612
612
612
612
612
612
1225
1227
1224
1225
1225
1224
612
612
612
612
612
612
1226
1226
1227
1221
1226
1221
92.8
94.3
92.0
91.0
92.6
93.3
92.0
92.0
91.8
92.0
92.0
92.3
153.3
154.2
153.2
153.4
152.7
153.2
152.9
152.8
153.1
152.6
152.8
154.0
39.4
40.3
42.6
41.9
41.3
42.5
40.9
40.9
40.7
40.7
40.5
40.7
40.6
40.2
40.7
40.5
40.9
40.8
41.2
40.5
40.3
40.6
40.4
41.5
41.2
40.3
42.6
40.5
40.5
43.1
40.8
40.3
40.6
40.5
40.9
40.9
41.4
41.0
40.4
40.8
40.7
40.0
40.9
40.7
41.3
41.3
40.8
40.3
10.4
10.6
10.8
10.9
11.2
10.6
10.5
10.3
10.8
10.7
10.8
10.0
12.4
12.0
9.4
12.3
9.4
9.1
12.3
12.2
12.4
12.2
12.1
9.3
10.9
10.7
10.1
11.1
9.9
10.8
10.8
10.7
10.2
10.5
10.2
11.0
9.3
9.7
12.3
9.1
12.7
12.1
9.5
9.1
8.6
9.9
9.0
12.2
4.8
4.4
4.8
4.8
4.8
4.8
4.4
4.8
4.8
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
5.2
4.0
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.8
4.4
4.4
4.8
5.2
4.4
5.2
4.8
4.8
4.4
4.4
4.8
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.0
5.2
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.4
4.0
4.4
4.4
4.4
6.7
7.1
7.1
7.1
6.7
7.1
7.5
6.7
7.1
7.1
7.1
6.4
6.7
6.7
6.4
5.2
6.4
6.0
6.0
6.7
6.4
6.0
5.6
4.8
7.1
7.1
7.1
7.1
6.7
7.1
7.1
6.7
7.1
7.1
6.4
5.2
6.7
5.6
5.6
6.0
5.2
5.6
6.0
5.6
5.6
6.0
6.4
12.8
11.4
9.6
11.1
4.4
10.5
7.8
8.0
9.1
8.5
8.3
9.7
1.6
1.7
2.2
1.0
1.8
0.1
0.2
2.0
2.6
2.5
2.4
0.7
8.4
11.6
9.4
10.9
10.3
10.8
10.1
10.8
12.2
9.8
11.2
7.3
2.1
2.3
3.5
2.0
1.1
4.1
1.4
2.4
2.3
2.1
1.0
3.6
86.0
87.6
86.3
87.6
86.3
87.7
85.0
84.2
85.3
85.6
85.6
84.1
91.4
91.5
92.7
91.2
92.0
90.1
90.6
89.9
90.0
90.0
88.9
92.3
86.8
85.5
85.4
85.6
85.2
86.1
85.6
84.6
84.1
84.2
83.8
85.3
93.8
93.3
89.7
92.6
89.0
86.3
92.8
91.9
92.1
92.6
91.2
89.4
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1168
rhole = hhole
2
hhole
a
a
Lhole
Hole detail
W1
W2
Section a-a
Front view
Fig. 6. Hole dimension and location nomenclature.
Table 3
Measured slotted hole dimensions and locations
Specimen
X
(mm)
W1
(mm)
W2
(mm)
Lhole
(mm)
hhole
(mm)
362-1-24-H
362-2-24-H
362-3-24-H
362-1-48-H
362-2-48-H
362-3-48-H
600-1-24-H
600-2-24-H
600-3-24-H
600-1-48-H
600-2-48-H
600-3-48-H
L/2
L/2
L/2
(L610)/2
(L610)/2
(L610)/2
L/2
L/2
L/2
(L610)/2
(L610)/2
(L610)/2
24.0
29.1
23.7
31.8
28.6
24.9
54.5
60.1
59.6
54.9
55.0
60.2
29.0
24.6
28.3
24.7
25.8
28.2
60.0
54.7
55.0
60.3
59.7
54.9
101.7
101.6
101.7
101.6
101.6
101.6
101.7
101.6
101.6
101.7
101.6
101.6
37.9
38.2
37.9
38.1
38.0
37.9
38.0
37.9
37.9
37.9
38.1
38.0
X
(mm)
W1
(mm)
W2
(mm)
Lhole
(mm)
hhole
(mm)
(L+610)/2
(L+610)/2
(L+610)/2
30.4
29.7
24.6
24.2
24.7
28.8
101.6
101.7
101.7
37.9
38.0
37.9
(L+610)/2
(L+610)/2
(L+610)/2
54.9
55.3
60.1
60.5
59.9
54.8
101.5
101.7
101.7
38.0
38.0
38.0
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1169
Location of interior
web edge
9.67 mm (600S162-33)
12.75 mm (362S162-33)
CL Platen
Column specimen
1.2
Local DSM
Distortional DSM
Pn/Pyg
0.8
0.6
0.4
600S162-33 short
columns
L
D
Local (L)-Distortional (D) interaction is
expected since predicted strengths (Pn)
are of similar magnitudes
0.2
0
0
1
4
5
2
3
0.5
1
1.5
2
slenderness, or d
2.5
Fig. 9. Local (L) and distortional (D) DSM strength predictions are
similar in magnitude for both 362S162-33 and 600S162-33 cross-sections,
indicating that LD modal interaction will occur during the tested
response of the columns.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1170
cross-section dimensions input into ABAQUS are calculated using the out-to-out dimensions and ange and lip
angles at the mid-height of each column specimen as
provided in Table 2.
The loading and boundary conditions used in the
eigenbuckling analyses are summarized in Fig. 8. Each
column specimen is loaded with a set of consistent nodal
loads in ABAQUS to simulate a constant pressure across
the bearing edge of the specimen. The nodes on the loaded
column face are coupled together in the direction of
loading (one direction) with an ABAQUS pinned rigidbody constraint. This constraint ensures that all nodes on
Distortional Buckling
Local Buckling (L)
Hole terminates
web local
buckling
Fig. 10. Local and distortional elastic buckled mode shapes for short
(L 610 mm) 362S162-33 specimens.
Fig. 12. Local and distortional elastic buckled mode shapes for short
(L 610 mm) 600S162-33 specimens.
D+L
Hole terminates
web local
buckling
Fig. 11. Local and distortional elastic buckled mode shapes for intermediate length (L 1219 mm) 362S162-33 specimens.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1171
Table 4
Critical elastic buckling loads and the inuence of holes on elastic buckling
Specimen name
Hole inuencea
Elastic buckling
Pyg (kN)
Pcre (kN)
Pcr (kN)
Pcrd (kN)
362-1-24-NH
362-2-24-NH
362-3-24-NH
362-1-24-H
362-2-24-H
362-3-24-H
68.8
69.2
69.9
72.7
69.9
73.0
486.8
500.2
498.9
530.5
501.6
580.7
21.6
21.1
22.1
26.0
24.1
25.4
46.9
45.3
47.6
59.9
55.1
57.5
362-1-48-NH
362-2-48-NH
362-3-48-NH
362-1-48-H
362-2-48-H
362-3-48-H
75.3
74.5
73.8
73.7
74.9
74.9
135.5
131.1
131.5
133.2
132.2
160.9
22.9
23.0
22.7
23.5
23.2
25.3
43.0
42.9
42.4
42.0
41.5
42.6
600-1-24-NH
600-2-24-NH
600-3-24-NH
600-1-24-H
600-2-24-H
600-3-24-H
109.7
109.1
108.8
111.3
102.8
110.0
1087.5
1044.9
971.5
1064.6
1060.6
1079.2
15.3
15.3
15.3
14.5
14.3
15.4
30.1
29.6
29.5
31.2
30.0
32.7
600-1-48-NH
600-2-48-NH
600-3-48-NH
600-1-48-H
600-2-48-H
600-3-48-H
111.8
116.5
112.9
112.3
113.2
113.7
274.9
265.3
267.6
250.3
235.9
248.0
15.4
15.0
15.2
15.1
15.1
15.3
23.0
25.3
25.2
22.5
22.1
22.4
Pcre/PnoH
cre
Pcr/PnoH
cr
Pcrd/PnoH
crd
N/A
0.98
0.98
0.99
1.03
1.02
1.02
1.12
1.13
1.12
N/A
0.94
0.94
0.95
1.03
1.03
1.03
0.98
0.98
0.98
N/A
1.01
1.01
1.02
1.02
1.01
1.01
1.09
1.08
1.08
N/A
0.87
0.87
0.86
1.02
1.02
1.02
1.02
1.02
1.02
For specimens with holes (H), the holes are removed and elastic buckling calculated (noH). The hole (H) and no hole (noH) nite element models are
otherwise identical, isolating the inuence of the holes.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1172
D+L
Holes change
number of
half-waves
from 8 (NH) to
12 (H)
Fig. 13. Local and distortional elastic buckling mode shapes for intermediate length (L 1219 mm) 600S162-33 specimens.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1173
600-1-48-NH
362-1-48-H
600-1-48-H
Fig. 14. Comparison of global mode shapes for intermediate length 362S162-33 and 600S162-33 specimens.
Table 5
Specimen ultimate strength results
Specimen
362-1-24-NH
362-2-24-NH
362-3-24-NH
362-1-24-H
362-2-24-H
362-3-24-H
362-1-48-NH
362-2-48-NH
362-3-48-NH
362-1-48-H
362-2-48-H
362-3-48-H
600-1-24-NH
600-2-24-NH
600-3-24-NH
600-1-24-H
600-2-24-H
600-3-24-H
600-1-48-NH
600-2-48-NH
600-3-48-NH
600-1-48-H
600-2-48-H
600-3-48-H
Ptest (kN)
46.6
46.7
45.1
44.5
46.2
44.2
40.4
42.2
42.2
39.8
40.8
41.7
53.1
53.2
54.4
54.0
51.7
52.4
49.6
50.9
50.2
49.6
52.0
49.6
Ptest statistics
Mean (kN)
46.2
0.9
45.0
1.1
41.6
1.0
40.8
0.9
53.6
0.8
52.7
1.2
50.2
0.6
50.4
1.4
4. Experiment results
4.1. Ultimate strength
The peak tested compressive load for all column
specimens and an average peak load for each test group
are provided in Table 5. The slotted holes are shown to
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1174
Distortional buckling
in one half-wave at
peak load
Fig. 15. Loaddisplacement progression for short column specimen 362-2-24-NH. (a) P 0 kN, (b) P 31.3 kN, (c) P 46.7 kN (peak load) and
(d) P 33.4 kN.
Fig. 16. Loaddisplacement progression for short column specimen 362-2-24-H. (a) P 0 kN, (b) P 46.2 kN (peak load) and (d) P 31.1 kN.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
post-peak resistance is quantied by observing the reduction in area under the loaddisplacement curve for the
column with the slotted hole, as shown in Fig. 17.
Position transducers placed at the mid-height of the
short column specimens capture the rate of lateral ange
displacement associated with distortional buckling, dD, as
shown in Fig. 18. Fig. 18 demonstrates that the initiation of
web local buckling does not inuence the axial stiffness of
specimen 362-2-24-NH, but rather that a softening of the
loadaxial deformation curve coincides with the increased
rate of lateral ange movement (distortional buckling).
This observation suggests that the loss in axial stiffness
associated with distortional buckling plays a larger role
than web local buckling in the peak load response of the
60
362-2-24-NH
362-2-24-H
362-2-24-NH
362-2-24-H
50
40
Increased rate of flange distortion
is observed for column with a hole
after peak load is reached
40
D (mm)
30
20
1175
30
20
Peak load
occurs here
NH
10
10
D =
+west
+east
west + east
2
0
0
60
60
Local buckling
half-waves
first observed
50
40
40
30
30
20
D (mm)
50
20
10
+west
+east
10
D = west + east
2
0
0
2
3
Column axial displacement (mm)
Fig. 18. Comparison of loaddeformation response and lateral ange displacements for specimen 362-2-24-NH.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1176
Web local
buckling
Distortional
buckling in one
half-wavelength
at peak load
Fig. 20. Loaddisplacement progression for short column specimen 600-1-24-NH. (a) P 0 kN, (b) P 35.6 kN, (c) P 53.1 kN (peak load) and
(d) P 35.6 kN.
Web local
buckling.
initiates
Similar failure
mode to no hole
specimens
Fig. 21. Loaddisplacement progression for short column specimen 600-1-24-H. (a) P 0 kN, (b) P 33.4 kN, (c) P 54.0 kN (peak load) and
(d) P 35.6 kN.
Fig. 12b, which shows two distortional half-waves; however, specimens 600-2-24-H and 600-3-24-H did buckle in
two half-waves, see [14] for pictures. These results suggest
that geometric imperfections also have a role to play in the
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
50
40
30
NH
20
10
0
0
1177
Pure distortional
buckling dominates over
3
Fig. 23. Loaddisplacement progression for intermediate length column specimen 362-3-48-NH. (a) P 0 kN, (b) P 35.6 kN and (c) P 42.2 kN (peak
load).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1178
60
50
362-3-48-NH
362-3-48-H
40
30
NH
20
10
H
0
0
2
3
4
Column axial displacement (mm)
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1179
50
40
30
Abrupt failure
20
D, T (mm)
10
east west
T =
-10
-20
-30
+ east
+ west
Peak load
occurs here
-40
D =
east + west
2
-50
0
Fig. 27. Loaddisplacement progression for intermediate length column specimen 600-1-48-NH. (a) P 26.7 kN, (b) P 49.6 kN (peak load),
(c) P 49.6 kN and (d) P 31.1 kN.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1180
60
600-1-48-NH
600-1-48-H
50
40
Drops in load occur when
multiple web local buckling
half-waves change abruptly to
one distortional half-wave
(north end first, then south end)
30
20
10
0
0
2
3
4
Column axial displacement (mm)
Fig. 29. Loaddisplacement comparison of intermediate length 600S16233 specimens with and without holes.
5. Conclusions
An experimental study was conducted to evaluate the
inuence of industry-standard slotted holes on short and
intermediate length cold-formed steel structural studs. The
presences of slotted holes caused only a slight decrease in
the ultimate compressive strength of the tested columns,
although the post-peak response and column ductility were
inuenced by the presence of slotted holes, the crosssection type, and the length of the member. The post-peak
response is studied in relation to the inuence of holes on
the elastic local and distortional buckling behavior of the
columns. In the case of the 362S162-33 columns, the slotted
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 11641182
1181
Fig. 30. Short 600S162-33 column specimen ange-lip corner lifts off platen during post-peak portion of test.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1182
[18] Moen C, Schafer BW. Direct strength design for cold-formed steel
members with perforations, progress report #4. Washington, DC:
American Iron and Steel Institute; 2007.
[19] Moen C, Schafer BW. Impact of holes on the elastic buckling of
cold-formed steel columns with applications to the direct strength
method. Eighteenth international specialty conference on coldformed steel structures. Orlando, FL: Recent Research and Deve-