Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Constitutional Law-II
Submitted by:
Gaurob Marik
Roll No. 52
Semester - IV
Acknowledgment
I take this opportunity with great pleasure to thank faculty Incharge of Constitution, my friends and library staff members who
have supported me in the completion of this project work. I would
like to extend my heartfelt gratitude to my faculty in-charge of
above mentioned subject for his vital encouragement and support.
He has given me the opportunity to point out the purpose and
comprehensiveness of this project work.
Finally, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to my parents
who made all things possible.
Index
Introduction
India in Reality
Present Deliberation
8
12
A Balanced Approach
12
13
Conclusion
14
Bibliography
16
Introduction
Abortion remains a sensitive matter in most countries, receiving
considerable international attention not only as a public health
concern but also as an ethical, moral and religious issue. This
paper deals with the grim realities concerning abortion in India,
the present debate which is inclusive of pro-choice and pro-life
issue, followed by the abortion laws in different countries and
Indias Balanced Approach, lastly my take on the issue of
abortion in India.
India in Reality
Indias pioneer in legalizing induced abortion was incorporated
through the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971, under
which a woman can legally have an abortion if the pregnancy
carries a risk of grave physical injury or endangers her mental
health, if it is the result of contraceptive failure in a married
woman, if it is the consequence of rape, or if it is likely to result in
the birth of a child with physical or mental abnormalities.
According to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MOHFW), about 5.4 lakh
MTPs were performed in the country in 1996 97, an estimated 6.7 million abortions
per year are performed in other than registered and government recognized
institutions, often by untrained persons in unhygienic conditions. According to
the Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in
India, every year an average of about 11 million abortions take
place annually and around 20,000 women die every year due to
abortion related complications.1 Most abortion-related maternal
1
Year
Number of
abortions
reported
97
05
04
15
14
42
Abortion was liberalized in India after the 1971 MTP Act came into
effect on 1 April 1972, according to which a pregnancy may be
terminated within 20 weeks of gestation. India was one of the first
countries during 1970s to have such a liberal to have such liberal
abortion laws. Before 1972, abortion was permitted only if it was
necessary to save the life of the woman. Now it is also allowed on
grounds of preserving her mental or physical health, as well as in
cases of pregnancy due to rape, incest or contraceptive failure.
However, it is illegal if performed just because a woman (or some
other person) requests it, or if it is sought only for social and/or
economic reasons. The Indian government has also repeatedly
emphasized that MTP should not be viewed as a method of family
planning or of reducing the national birth rate.
Unfortunately Legalizing abortion has not ensured its accessibility
to the poor nor been an effective method for curtailing population
growth. Moreover, abortion is still one of those issues in womens
life which is buried in silence. In a country like India, womens
http://www.aiims.edu/aiims/events/Gynaewebsite/ma_finalsite/introduction.html.
"Current status of abortion in India". Consortium on National Consensus for Medical
Abortion in India.
http://www.aiims.ac.in/aiims/events/Gynaewebsite/ma_finalsite/report/1_1_1.htm.
3
Historical abortion statistics, India Historical abortion statistics, India
2
health is given very low priority and their lack of control over
family resources denies them access to health care in general and
abortion in particular. In addition to being considered dangerous to
womens
health,
abortion
is
also
deemed
to
be
socially
unacceptable.
Studies in many developed and developing countries show that
even where abortion is legal, women are reluctant to talk about it.
In India, its incidence is always under reported, perhaps because of
the guilt or the moral stigma attached with it.
Although abortion is legal, it is estimated that four million Indian
women a year still resort to illegal abortions because of social
taboos, misconceptions about the law, and the lack of skilled
practitioners and medical facilities. Research has also shown that
the ratio of illegal to legal abortions is highly skewed there are
many more illegal abortions than the legal ones. Because of illegal
abortions, there are between 15,000 to 20,000 abortion related
deaths in the country every year, mainly among married,
multifarious women. But even generally, deaths due to induced
abortion are quite high; for example, in Maharashtra in 1995, 17.6
% of maternal moralities were due to induced abortion .It is
therefore evident that legislation of abortion is a necessary but not
sufficient condition for reducing the number of unsafe abortions.
A large proportion of abortions are now cited as falling under a
special category that was almost non existent at the time of
framing of the Act. This category is sex determination followed by
abortion of the female foetus. In such cases, it is not the pregnancy
but its outcome that is unwanted. The first sex- selective abortion
was
documented
in
India
in
1970s,
with
the
advent
of
sex of the foetus, with the sole purpose of circumventing the birth
of girls. The 2001 census jolted the govt and the civil society alike
an alarming decline in the juvenile sex ratio from 971 in 1981 to
945 in 1991 and 927 in 2001 made national as well as international
headlines.
Giving or taking prenatal tests solely to determine the sex of the
foetus is being criminalized by the Indian parliament. Female
children are still widely considered to be a social and financial
liability in a country where the dowry system is still a part of
marriage. The prenatal tests have been used to detect female
foetuses, which are then aborted. Under Indian law, ending a
pregnancy only because a foetus is female has already been
outlawed, although the practice is common. Poor women who
cannot afford the cost of either prenatal testing or abortion often
resort to female infanticide.
Despite the fact that it is now more than thirty years since MTP
was legalized in India, women still feel shy of speaking about it.
This has proved to be one of the major stumbling blocks in
gathering information about the extent of foetal wastage in general
and induced abortions in particular. There are a few clinic based
studies that provide information about abortions, but since the
sample used is very selective, it is difficult to extract information
about the processes and patterns associated with abortion from his
data. It is this lack of reliable data which necessitates research on
abortion that can shed light on the pathways leading to abortions
well as on the associated underlying factors, including quality of
care and cost.
Present Deliberation
10
twenty
weeks,
the
opinion
of
two
registered
medical
11
through
many
international
and
national
12
be
deemed
to
be
already
born"
human being or not...There is nothing in law to prevent a man from owning property before he is born. His ownership is
necessarily contingent indeed, for he may never be born all but it is nonetheless a real and present ownership. A man may settle
property upon his wife and children to be born of her or he may die intestate and his unborn child will inherit his estate..........A
child in its mother's womb is for many purposes regarded by a legal fiction is already born in accordance with the maxim
naciturus pro jam natro habetur.
13
Sec 20 of Indian succession act 1920, Sec 13 of Transfer of Property Act 1882.
842 Sw 2d 588
15
1935 SC (HL)57: (1935) AC 209.
14
13
deformity.
A Balanced Approach
16
14
17
17
18
15
16
Conclusion
If the question is put forward to me whether there should be
increase in the limit of abortion in India or not ? Then drawing
conclusion from the above arguments I would right away reject the
plea of increasing the limit of abortion from 20 to 24 weeks.
In U.K an all-party group of MPs had campaigned to reduce the
maximum age at which a baby can legally be aborted from 24 to 20
weeks. Change is urgently needed, they say, because medical
science has advanced so far since the limit of 24 weeks was set in
1990, that thousands of babies born at less than 24 weeks
gestation, who would probably have died then, now survive. Armed
with this evidence, campaigners argue that allowing a baby over 20
weeks to be aborted, unless the mother is in danger or the child
grievously malformed, is nothing less than child cruelty. Recent
polls show three quarters of women in U.K favor lowering the 24week limit. In France and Germany, appeal has been made to make
it within 12 weeks.
When developed countries like U.K, France, Germany, etc are
campaigning for lowering the abortion limit then why should India
17
The Abortion Act, 1967 of U.K. permits abortions till twenty four
weeks but there is no upper limit if the pregnancy poses a threat to
a womans life or if the foetus is likely to be born with severe
physical or mental deformity. Keeping in view the Nikita Mehta
case, it will be noteworthy to amend the MTP Act in accordance
with the Abortion Act of U.K. only difference will be that the
abortion limit will be till twenty weeks.
Every day nearly 48,000 abortions take place in India. , every year
an average of about 11 million abortions take place, around 20,000
women die every year due to abortion related complications,[1] The
2001 census showed an alarming decline in the juvenile sex ratio
from 971 in 1981 to 945 in 1991 and 927 in 2001. Most of these are
not cases of detected fatal abnormalities but unwanted
pregnancies. When the real picture of abortion in India is seen at
large then this present debate on Nikita Mehta case seems to be a
miniscule issue. At macroscopic level, the Nikita Mehta case can be
safely booked under exceptional cases. To legalize abortions at 24
weeks from the existing 20 weeks will result in killing off even
more babies.
In Mother Teresa words: If we accept that a mother can kill even
her own child, how can we tell other people not to kill one
another?
18
Bibliography
Leela
Visaria
and
Vimala
Ramachandran
Webliography
http://www.aiims.edu/aiims/events/Gynaewebsite/
ma_finalsite/report/1_3_8.html
http://74.125.95.132/search?
q=cache:nNTvD6Ao_R8J:www.cehat.org/aap1/poli
cyreview.pdf+abortion+amendment+in+india&cd
=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=in
http://in.keegy.com/tag/time-limits/
http://74.125.95.132/search?
q=cache:vKspT7jCLXYJ:www.searo.who.int/LinkFi
les/Regional_Health_Forum_Induced_Abortion.pdf
19
+abortion+amendment+in+india&cd=9&hl=en&
ct=clnk&gl=in
http://newsblaze.com/story/20081027115531zzzz.
nb/topstory.html
http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S09688
08004240174
http://policywise.net/2007/09/20/why-sexdetermination-should-be-legal-in-india/
http://infochangeindia.org/200804307089/Childre
n/News-Scan/PM-denounces-abortion-offemales.html
http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P31427436101.html
http://www.zeenews.com/news460332.html
http://www.india-server.com/news/abortion-limitmay-be-raised-to-24-3819.html
http://www.indiatoday.com/itoday/20030512/healt
h.shtml
http://www.dnaindia.com/report.asp?
newsid=1230474
http://www.1to9months.com/abortion.html
www.aiims.edu/aiims/events/Gynaewebsite/ma_fin
alsite/index.html
www.aiims.edu/aiims/events/Gynaewebsite/ma_fin
alsite/report/1_1_1.htm
blogs.expressindia.com/showblogdetails.php?
contentid=394265
www.cehat.org/aap1/work1.pdf
www.indiatogether.org/manushi/issue126/abortio
n.htm
www.flipkart.com/environmental-justice-rightsunborn-future/1844073661-6zx3fnjlpc
20
www.indg.in/primary-education/education-asfundamental-human-right/child-rights-handbook
www.amicus.iupindia.org/RighttoLife_ovw.asp
pib.nic.in/feature/fe1299/f3012991.html
www.indiatogether.org/2008/aug/kshmtpchoice.htm
http://www.aiims.ac.in/aiims/events/Gynaewebsite/ma_finalsite/repor
t/1_1_1.htm.
21