TECHNICAL VENDOR BID EV

Document No.

PUMP

PTN-318-TE-MC-0001

CLIENT

PT. PLN (Persero)

PROJECT NAME

PLTU Tembilahan 2 X 7 MW

PROJECT TITLE

PTN

JOB NUMBER

2011000056

LOCATION

TEMBILAHAN, RIAU

4-Apr-2013

Issued For Information

28-Mar-2013

Issued For Information

REV.

DATE

REVISION DESCRIPTION

CHNICAL VENDOR BID EVALUATION

PUMP

Rev. : 1
Page Number
1 of 3

Information

DBP/WHN

MDI

MNN

Information

DBP/WHN

MDI

MNN

PREP'D

CHK'D

APPRV'D

DESCRIPTION

TECHNICAL VENDOR BID EV

Document No.

PUMP

PTN-318-TE-MC-0001

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TECHNICAL SUMMARY BID EVALUATION

ATTACHMENT-1 TECHNICAL BID ANALYSIS SHEET FOR PUMP

CHNICAL VENDOR BID EVALUATION

PUMP

ALYSIS SHEET FOR PUMP

Rev. : 1
Page Number
2 of 3

TECHNICAL SUMMARY BID EVALUATION

Project
Client

: PLTU TEMBILAHAN 2 X 7 MW
: PT PLN (Persero)

ITEM
NO.

DESCRIPTION

PT. KSB

PT. TORISHIMA GUNA ENGINEERING

PT. KSB

PT. TORISHIMA GUNA ENGINEERING

Q/KSB-P/13020248R5
2-Mar-13

PQ/13/0013.R2.A
14-Mar-13

MANUFACTURER

QUOTATION/PROPOSAL NO.
DATE NO QUOTATION

COUNTRY

Indonesia

Indonesia

CONFORMANCE TO PROJECT

ACCEPT

ACCEPT

4.1 APPLICABLE SPECIFICATIONS/

DATA SHEET

ACCEPT

ACCEPT

4.2 APPLICABLE STANDARD/CODE

ACCEPT

ACCEPT

4.3 SCOPE OF SUPPLY/WORK

ACCEPT

ACCEPT

4.4 DESIGN COND.& PERFORMANCE

ACCEPT

ACCEPT

FOT Project Site

Ex.Works Jakarta

DELIVERY SCHEDULE

23 weeks

28-32 weeks

EVALUATION AND COMMENT

ACCEPT

ACCEPT

POINT OF DELIVERY

HNICAL SUMMARY BID EVALUATION

Description
Department

PT MULTAN KUSUMA SAKTI

: PUMP
: MECHANICAL

Rev.

Date

Prep'd

Check'd

Appr'd

4-Apr-2013

DBP/WHN

MDI

MNN

28-Mar-2013

DBP/WHN

MDI

MNN

PT. MULTAN KUSUMA SAKTI

13GS.016MY.Rev3
7-Mar-13
Indonesia
ACCEPT
ACCEPT

ACCEPT
ACCEPT
ACCEPT
Franco Jabodetabek
Rotos pump : 22-24 weeks
Ducthing Pump : 40 weeks
ACCEPT

1
2
3

ACCEPTED VENDOR (W/RANKING)

PT. KSB
PT. TORISHIMA GUNA ENGINEERING
PT. MULTAN KUSUMA SAKTI

Title
Project
Project No
Location
Requisition No
Equipment

: Technical Analysis
: PLTU Tembilahan 2 x 7 MW
: 2011000056
: Tembilahan - Riau
: PTN-318-TE-MC-0001
: PUMP

NO
1

DESCRIPTION

PT. KSB
Description

General
1.1.
1.2.
1.3.
1.4.
1.5.

REQUIREMENT

Vendor Name
Origin/Country
Principal (if any)
Quotation/Proposal No
Quotation/Proposal Date

PT. KSB
Indonesia
Q/KSB-P/13020248R5
2-Apr-13

Design Condition/Performance Guarantee

Power Consumption
Boiler Feed Water Pump
Condensate Pump
Circulating Water Pump
Head
Boiler Feed Water Pump
Condensate Pump
Circulating Water Pump
Capacity
Boiler Feed Water Pump
Condensate Pump
Circulating Water Pump
Scope of Work
Scope of Supply shall include the following items but not limited to :
(Subcontractor shall propose others equipment wich are necessary for
the system related to subcontractor)
1 Engineering/Construction Service
- Detail Specification
- General Arrangement
- Detail drawing
- Shop drawing & as build drawing
- Calculation
2 Equipments supplied
3 Common
- Spare parts & consumable material for erection, commisioning, and start up
- Mandatory spare parts & consumable material for 2 years operation
- Recommended spare parts for 3 years operation
- Painting
- Shop Painting (up to final)
- Site Painting (up to final)
- Touch-up Paint
4 Fabrication and manufacturing
5 Testing and inspection
- Shop inspection, test and report including at subcontactor
6 Packaging & Transportation to site
- Point of Delivery
- Delivery Time (Duration of Delivery)
- All Protection of equipment for entire transportation
- Insurance
7 Commisioning and performance test
- Dispatch of supervisor for erection, pre-commissioning and commissioning

200 KW
120 KW
240 KW

440 KW
30 KW
640 KW

815.76 m
59.73 m
27 m

816 m
59.73 m
27 m

24 m3/h
38 m3/h
1500 m3/h

24 m3/h
38 m3/h
1500 m3/h

REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

REQUIRED

SUPPLY

REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

REQUIRED

SUPPLY

Horizontal Multistage Centrifugal

6 (3x50%)

HD A 65/13
6
ISO 9906 Gr1
24
816 m
105
954.8
3.7
Water
54.5
2980
13
KSB

Technical Data
2.1.

Boiler Feed Pump

1 Pump Performance
Type
Quantity
Standard
Capacity
Head
Temperature
Density
NPSHR
Pump Fluid
Efficiency
Speed
Jumlah Stage
Brand
2 Material

m3/hr
MPa
C
kg/m3
m
%
rpm

24
7.6 or 815.76 m
105
vta
vta
Water
vta
vta
vta
vta

Casing

vta

Suction & Stage Casing : CI; Discharge Casing :

A 216 Gr.WCB

Impeller

Stainless Steel

CI

vta

AISI 410

Mechanical Seal
vta
Stainless Steel

Mechanical Seal
Closed
1.4008.09

vta
vta
50
vta
vta
vta
vta
vta

Electric motor
TBA
110
380
50
3
TBA
IP55

Shaft
Shaft Seal Type
Impeller Type
Diffusser
3 Motor
Drive Type
Speed
Driver Rated Power
Voltage
Frequency
Phase
Bearing Type
Protection
2.2.

unit

Condensate Pump
1 Pump Performance

rpm
kW
V
Hz

Type
Quantity
Standard
Capacity
Head
Temperature
Density
NSPHR
Pump Fluid
Efficiency
Speed
Jumlah Stage
Brand
2 Material

m3/hr
MPa
C
kg/m3
m
%
rpm

Horizontal
4 (2x100%)
38
0.58 or 59.73 m
42
vta
vta
Water
vta
vta
vta
vta

Casing

vta

Impeller

vta

Shaft
Shaft Seal Type
Impeller Type
3 Motor
Drive Type
Speed
Driver Rated Power
Voltage
Frequency
Phase
Bearing Type
Protection
2.3.

unit

Circulating Water Pump

1 Pump Performance
Type
Quantity
Standard
Capacity
Head
Temperature
Density
NSPHR
Pump Fluid
Efficiency
Speed
Jumlah Stage
Brand
2 Material

rpm
kW
V
Hz

unit
m3/hr
MPa
C
kg/m3
m
%
rpm

Casing
Impeller
Shaft
Shaft Seal Type
Impeller Type
3 Motor
Drive Type
Speed
Driver Rated Power
Voltage
Frequency
Phase
Bearing Type
Protection

rpm
kW
V
Hz

MCPK 65-40-250 C1
4
ISO 2858
38
59.73 m
42
991
2.41
Water
56.8
2920
Single
KSB

Volute casing & casing cover : Stainless steel

1.4408/A743 GR CF8M

vta
vta
vta

Stainless steel 1.4408/A743 GR CF8M

Steel IS 5517 45 C8
Gland Packing
Closed

vta
60
vta
vta
vta
vta
vta

Electric motor
2920
15
380
50
3
Anti-friction bearings
IP 55

Horizontal
4 (2x50%)
1500
0.3 or 27 m
30
vta
vta
Water
vta
vta
Single
vta

Omega 350-360 B GC 2 PF
4
KSB
1500
27 m
30
995
6.72
Water
84
1488
single
KSB

NI Resist or Stainless steel

Volute Casing : Grey Cast Iron JL 1040

Stainless steel 316 L

vta
vta
vta

GX2CRNIMOCUN25-6-3-31.4517
Chrome steel 1.4021+QT800
Gland Packing
Closed

vta
vta
60
vta
vta
vta
vta
vta

Electric motor
1488
160
380
50
4
Anti-friction bearings
IP 55

Revision No.
Revision Date
Prepared
Checked
Approved
PT. KSB
Remarks

PT. TORISHIMA GUNA ENGINEERING

Description
Remarks

:1
: 4 April 2013
: DBP/WHN/AHN
: MDI
: MNN

PT MULTAN KUSUMA SAKTI

Description

Remarks

PT Multan Kusuma Sakti

Indonesia

PT. Torishima Guna Engineering

Indonesia
PQ/13/0013.R2.A
14-Mar-13

13GS.016MY.Rev3
7-Mar-13

ACCEPTED WITH NOTE

COMPLY
ACCEPTED WITH NOTE

440 KW
30 KW
640 KW

ACCEPTED WITH NOTE

COMPLY
ACCEPTED WITH NOTE

440 KW
30 KW
640 KW

ACCEPTED WITH NOTE

COMPLY
ACCEPTED WITH NOTE

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

815.76 m
59.74 m
30.59 m

COMPLY
COMPLY
ACCEPTED

816 m
59.74 m
30.6 m

COMPLY
COMPLY
ACCEPTED

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

24 m3/h
38 m3/h
1500 m3/h

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

24 m3/h
38 m3/h
1500 m3/h

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

COMPLY

SUPPLY

COMPLY

SUPPLY

COMPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY
SUPPLY

COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY
COMPLY

COMPLY

SUPPLY

COMPLY

SUPPLY

COMPLY

comply
comply

Horizontal Multistage
6
JIS Standard & MFR Standard
24
815.76
105
955
3.1
Water
54
2950
13
TORISHIMA

comply
comply

Centrifugal, Horizontal Pump

6

comply
comply

comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

24
816 m
105
955
4.1
Water
59.9
2980
14
Duchting Pump

comply
accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

comply

Discharge & Suction Casing : JIS/ Cast Steel

SCPH22
Stage Casing : JIS/ NiCrFC

comply

EN 1.4317 (Similar to CA6NM)

comply

accepted with note

Stainless Steel SCS1T1

accepted

EN 1.4317 (Similar to CA6NM)

accepted

comply

JIS/ Carbon Steel S45C HCr plating

comply
comply
comply

Gland Packing
Closed
Stainless Steel SCS1T1

accepted
comply
comply

Stainless Steel
Mechanical Seal
Closed
no data

comply
comply
not comply

Include space heater

Electric motor
2955
110
400
50
3
Ball
IP 55

accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

Foot Mounted
2900
110
380/660
50
3
no data
IP55

accepted
comply
comply
comply
not comply
comply

accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

Horizontal End Suction

4
JIS Standard & MFR Standard
38
59.74 m
42
992
2.2
Water
51
2930
Single
TORISHIMA

comply
comply

Centrifugal, Horizontal Pump

4

comply
comply

comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

38
59.74 m
42
988
2.7
water
48.4
2930
1
Rotos

comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

Cast Iron FC250

comply

ASTM A351 CF8M

comply

comply

comply

Cast Iron FC200

not comply

ASTM A743 CF8M

comply

comply
comply
comply

Stainless Steel SUS420J2

Gland Packing
Closed

comply
comply
comply

AISI 316
Mechanical Seal
Closed

comply
comply
comply

Include space heater

comply
accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

Electric motor
SS.3000 (Synchronous Speed)
15
400
50
3
Ball
IP55

comply

comply

accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

Foot Mounted
2935
15
400
50
3
no data
IP55

accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

comply
comply

Horizontal Split Case

4
JIS Standard & MFR Standard
1500
30.59 m
30
995.7
3.5
Water
86
980
Single
TORISHIMA

comply
comply

Centrifugal, Horizontal Pump

4

comply
comply

comply
accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

1500
30.6 m
30
998
7.1
water
83.6
1450
1
Rotos

comply
accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply
Include ceramic coating
comply

Cast Stainless Steel SCS14

comply

ASTM A351 CF8M

accepted

comply
comply
comply
comply

Cast Stainless Steel SCS14

Stainless Steel SUS316
Gland packing
Closed

comply
comply
comply
comply

ASTM A743 CF8M

AISI 316
Packing Seal
Closed

accepted
comply
comply

Include space heater

comply
accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply

Electric motor
SS.1000
160

Include space heater

50
3
Ball
IP 55

comply
comply
comply
comply

Foot Mounted
1485
160
400
50
3
no data
IP55

accepted

comply
accepted
comply
comply
comply
comply
comply