Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
IN THE MATTER
AND
IN THE MATTER
AND
IN THE MATTER
2
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
Business Park
City Centre
Countryside Living
Future Urban
General Business
Heavy Industry
Height Sensitive Areas
Historic Character
Large Lot
Light Industry
Local Centre
Metropolitan Centre
Mixed Housing Suburban
Mixed Housing Urban
Mixed Rural
Mixed Use
National Grid Corridor
Neighbourhood Centre
Outstanding Natural Feature
Outstanding Natural Landscape
Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control
Public Open Space
Rapid and/or frequent service network
Rural and Coastal Settlement
Rural Coastal
Rural Conservation
Rural Production
Rural Urban Boundary
Significant Ecological Areas
Single House
Special Purpose
Strategic Transport Corridor
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings
Town Centre
Volcanic Viewshafts
Abbreviation
BP
CC
CL
FU
GB
HI
HSA
HC
LL
LI
LC
MC
MHS
MHU
MR
MU
NGC
NC
ONF
ONL
Pre-1944 BDC
POS
RFN
RCS
RC
RCon
RP
RUB
SEA
SH
SP
STC
THAB
TC
VV
3
1.
SUMMARY
1.1
The purpose of this Joint Evidence Report (Report) is to consider submissions and
further submissions to the Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan (PAUP) Topic 081
Geographic Rezoning (Topic 081). This Report considers submissions and further
submissions that were received by the Auckland Council (the Council) in relation to
zoning of the Urban (South) area.
1.2
The Urban (South) area is generally comprised of the Manurewa and Papakura Local
Board Areas and is situated in the South of the Auckland Region. The Urban (South)
area also contains rural properties to the east of Mill Road in the Franklin Local Board
area. The main centres include Manurewa, Clendon Park, Takanini and Papakura.
1.3
A total of 1508 submission points have been received by the Council in relation to the
PAUP zoning within Urban (South) area. The area has been divided into the following
3 sub areas:
S11 area - Manurewa, Homai, Clendon Park, the Gardens and Randwick
Park (1002 submission points)
1.4
The Report states whether or not we support the submissions, in full or in part, and
identifies what amendments, if any, should be made to address matters raised in
submissions.
1.5
In response to these submission points which either seek to amend or retain zoning,
an assessment was made against the relevant PAUP objectives and policies of the
relevant zone/s, the Regional Policy Statement (RPS), and local and regional context
to determine whether the requests are supported or rejected.
As a result of the
Submissions seek retention of the zone and where this is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives and policies of the PAUP zone(s) and gives effect
to the RPS, retention is supported.
4
b)
c)
Submissions seek to make changes to business zoned land, the requests are
assessed against the relevant zone objectives and policies, the RPS, the context
of the site and its surroundings and the potential economic growth and viability of
the area. We support changes to zoning where the zoning complements the
local context, and/or is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives and
policies of the zone, and/or gives effect to the RPS.
1.6
1.7
Attachment B to this Report sets out the analysis and planners' position with regard to
the themes raised in submissions requesting relief in relation to the zoning of the
Urban (South) area. Attachment C contains the analysis and the planners' proposed
position against each submission point and proposed changes to the zoning maps.
Attachment D addresses area wide submissions, on which we have relied in
proposing a number of in scope area-wide or street-wide changes to the notified
zones.
1.8
Attachment E contains two maps for each of the geographic submission area units
within the Urban (South) area: the PAUP zones as notified but with properties
identified that are subject to submissions; and the zoning changes now proposed by
the Council, with in-scope and out of scope changes identified. Proposed changes
that are within scope are shown as black outline, while those that are out of scope are
shown as blue outline. The out of scope changes proposed are set out in Attachment
F, together with the reasons for them.
5
PART A: OVERVIEW AND BACKGROUND
2.
INTRODUCTION
2.1
The purpose of this Report is to consider submissions and further submissions that
were received by the Council in relation to zoning of the Urban (South) area (as shown
in Figure 1).
2.2
S11 area - Manurewa, Homai, Clendon Park, the Gardens and Randwick
Park
S11 area - Manurewa, Homai, Clendon Park, the Gardens and Randwick Park
2.3
The sub-area is located generally within the Manurewa Local Board Area and includes
the suburbs of Manurewa, Wattle Downs, Homai, Clendon Park, Weymouth Peninsula,
the Totara Heights development, The Gardens and Randwick Park. The zoning under
the PAUP as notified is predominantly characterised by residential MHS, with more
intensive zones of MHU and THAB around Manurewa Town Centre, Homai Station
and Clendon Park Local Centre. There is a large area of SH zone to the north-east of
Manurewa Town Centre and some smaller pockets dispersed through the area.
2.4
The area has a number of main arterial roads including Great South Road, Hill Road,
Alfriston Road, Orams Road, Roscommon Road, Weymouth Road and Mahia Road.
There is also good access to State Highway 1. Parts of the area are well served by
public transport with the Homai, Manurewa and Te Mahia Train Stations and Great
South Road bus routes. There are a number of large areas of open space including
Totara Park, Mountfort Park, War Memorial Park, Randwick Park, Weymouth Park and
the Auckland Botanical Gardens. Parts of the area are subject to flooding constraints,
the Significant Ecological Area (SEA) overlay and a National Grid Corridor (NGC).
S12 area - Takanini
2.5
The topic area is generally comprised of an area of both urban and rural land, located
between Manurewa and Papakura. Great South Road, the Southern Motorway and
the railway line run from north to south through the western part of the area. Ardmore
Airport (between Hamlin and Mullins Roads) is also included in the area.
6
2.6
Established residential areas are zoned a mixture of SH, MHS and MHU under the
PAUP as notified. They are located:
(a)
(b)
In Conifer Grove (west of Great South Road in the north of Area S12)
(c)
In Longford Park (west of Great South Road in the south of Area S12)
(d)
2.7
Residential growth areas are located in eastern Takanini and are zoned a mixture of
SH and MHS under the PAUP as notified.
2.8
Established business areas which are zoned a mixture of Light and Heavy Industry
under the PAUP as notified are located:
(a)
(b)
In the Great South Road vicinity between Taka Street and Waterview Road
West
2.9
Evidence has already been provided to the AUPIHP about requests to rezone Light
Industrial Land in Takanini North to Heavy Industry (Topics 051 to 055 Centre
Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business
Controls). That evidence supports the rezoning of the block bounded by Rangi
Road to the north, Takanini School Road to the east, Spartan Road to the south and
the Southern Motorway to the west from Light Industry to Heavy Industry zoning.
2.10
A partly developed retail and commercial area between the railway line and Arion
Road has been zoned Mixed Use under the PAUP as notified.
2.11
(b)
(c)
Neighbourhood Centres
(i)
7
(ii)
2.12 Details of the planning history of the eastern Takanini area (The Gardens/Alfriston
Ardmore/Takanini) are set out in Joy LaNauze and Trevor Watsons planning evidence
for Council for Topic 017 (RUB South) Takanini.
2.13 Approximately 500ha of land in eastern Takanini has been zoned FU within the PAUP
as notified.
2.14 An area zoned CL under the PAUP as notified (identified in Joy LaNauze and Trevor
Watsons planning evidence for Topic 017 (RUB South) Takanini as Sub-group 2:
Takanini North and the Gardens (beyond the RUB as notified) is to the north of the
area, bounded by the northern side of Ranfurly Road between Stratford and Mill
Roads, the west side of Mill Road north of Ranfurly Road, properties east of Stratford
Road and properties south of Hill Road. CL zoning is also located further north east in
the Redoubt Road area in the PAUP as notified.
2.15 The remainder of the rural land in Takanini S12 is zoned MR under the PAUP as
notified.
S13 area - Papakura
2.16 The topic area is generally comprised of an area of both urban and rural land, located
south of Takanini, north of Drury and east of Hingaia. Great South Road, the Southern
Motorway and the railway line run from north to south through the western part of the
area.
2.17 Established residential areas are zoned a mixture of SH, MHS, MHU and THAB under
the PAUP as notified. They are located:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
2.18 Areas of THAB as notified are to the south and east of the Metropolitan Centre zone.
The notified Metropolitan Centre zone is ringed by an area of MHU, which also
extends north along Great South Road.
residential area is MHS, apart from where SH zoning reflects flooding constraints.
8
2.19 Residential growth areas are located north and south of Papakura-Clevedon Road and
are zoned SH and MHS under the PAUP as notified. Details of the planning history of
these areas is set out in the eastern Takanini section of Joy LaNauze and Trevor
Watsons Takanini planning evidence for Council for Topic 017 (RUB South).
2.20 Centres have been zoned as follows under the PAUP as notified:
(a)
Papakura Metropolitan Centre generally west of the railway line and centred
on Great South Road between Coles Crescent and Wood Street
(b)
2.21 MU areas are located on the periphery of the MC zone in Vernon Street, around
Coles Crescent and around Wood Street.
2.22 Established business areas which are zoned a mixture of Light and Heavy Industry
under the PAUP as notified are located:
(a)
(b)
In Elliott Street
(c)
2.23 The area includes a small amount of land in Opaheke zoned FU within the PAUP as
notified.
2.24 A CL area is located near Kaipara Road and Settlement Roads east of urban
Papakura under the PAUP as notified. The remainder of the rural area is zoned MR
under the PAUP as notified. Parts of these rural areas are identified as Sub-group 4:
Ardmore South (beyond the RUB as notified) in Joy LaNauze and Trevor Watsons
Topic 017 planning evidence incorporating Takanini, The Gardens, Alfriston, and
Ardmore
(b)
(c)
Takanini Precinct
(d)
(e)
Ardmore 1 Precinct
(f)
Ardmore 2 Precinct
(g)
(h)
(i)
Papakura Precinct.
10
2.26 We note that submission points on the precinct provisions are addressed in the
separate precinct Evidence Reports by Juliana Cox (Regional Parks Precinct Topic
080), Anna Jennings (Mill Road Precinct Topic 081), Joy LaNauze (Takanini and
Papakura Precincts Topic 081), Anthony Traub (Integrated Development Precinct
Topic 080), Mark Vinall (Ardmore 1 and 2 Precincts Topic 045), Joint Evidence of
Bruce Young, Joy LaNauze and others (Ardmore 3, Special Purpose Tertiary
Education Zone Topic 080) and Todd Webb (Manukau 3 Topic 081).
2.27 The Report has been prepared by Danni Maree Briggs, Anna Fay Jennings and Joy
Martha La Nauze. The qualifications and experience of the Report writers are attached
in Attachment A.
2.28 The Report states whether or not we support the submissions, in full or in part, and
identifies what amendments, if any, we consider should be made to address matters
raised in submissions.
Analysis of Submissions by Planners
2.29 Submission points on sub area unit S11 (Manurewa, Homai, Clendon Park, the
Gardens and Randwick Park) were addressed by Danni Briggs and Anna Jennings.
2.30 Submission points on sub area units S12 (Takanini) and S13 (Papakura) were
addressed by Joy LaNauze.
3.
CODE OF CONDUCT
3.1
We confirm that we have read the Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses contained in
the Environment Court Practice Note 2014 and that we agree to comply with it. We
confirm that we have considered all the material facts that we are aware of that might
alter or detract from the opinions that we express, and that this Report is within our
area of expertise, except where we state that we are relying on the evidence of
another person.
4.
SCOPE
4.1
11
4.2
In preparing this Report we have relied on the Auckland-wide evidence of John Duguid
for Topic 080 Rezoning and Precincts (General) and Topic 081 Rezoning and
Precincts (Geographical Areas), which sets out the statutory framework, methodology,
principles, and section 32 evaluations used to guide the development and application
of zones and precincts.
4.3
In preparing this Report we have also relied on the statement of evidence of Marc
Dendale for Topic 081f Rezoning and Precincts (Geographical Areas) - South, which
sets out a sub-regional overview of the South area including an area description of the
area, overview of key infrastructure and transformation projects, and a summary of the
precincts and rezoning outcomes in the South area.
4.4
The following expert statements of evidence have been relied on in preparing our
Report:
(a)
Alastair Cribbens, Steve Wrenn and Liam Winter, Public Transport (Auckland
Transport);
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
12
(n)
Jeremy Wyatt planning evidence for Council for Topics 051 to 054 Centre
Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business
Controls;
(o)
Douglas Sadlier planning evidence for Council for Topics 051 to 054 Centre
Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business
Controls;
(p)
Susan Fairgray economic evidence for Council for Topics 051 to 054 Centre
Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business
Controls;
(q)
Joy LaNauze planning evidence for Topic 051-054 Centre Zones, Business
park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls;
(r)
Bruce Young, Joy LaNauze and others, Topic 080 Joint Evidence Report on
Submissions on Special Purpose: Tertiary Education Zone; Lincoln, Mt Albert
2, Ardmore 3, Epsom, Grafton, Manukau 4; St Johns Theological College;
Tamaki Campus Precincts;
(s)
(t)
Joy LaNauze and Trevor Watson, Joint statement of Evidence Topic 017
Area-Specific Evidence South Planning Takanini;
(u)
Joy LaNauze and Trevor Watson, Joint statement of Evidence Topic 017
Corrections to Area-Specific Evidence South Planning Takanini;
(v)
Joy LaNauze and Trevor Watson, Joint statement of Rebuttal Evidence Topic
017 Area-Specific Evidence South Planning Takanini;
(w)
(x)
(y)
Michael Tucker, Ian Bayliss, Chloe Trenouth, Don Munro (Auckland Transport
(AT)), David Blow (Watercare Services Ltd (Watercare)) Phillip Jaggard
(Stormwater) provided in support of the Councils position in relation to Topic
013;
(z)
13
(aa)
Ian Bayliss (Background to the Notified RUB) Topic 017 RUB South;
(bb)
Trevor Watson, Eryn Shields and Peter Vari (RUB Sub-Regional Context)
Topic 017 RUB South;
(cc)
(dd)
(ee)
Theunis van Schalkwyk, Evan Keating, Alastair Lovell and Scott MacArthur
(AT joint statement of evidence) Topic 017 RUB South;
(ff)
(gg)
David Colin Blow, Chris Allen and Andre Brian Stuart (Watercare joint
statement of evidence) Topic 017 RUB South;
5.
(hh)
(ii)
Dawne Mackay (Future Urban Land Supply Strategy) Topic 017 RUB South.
5.1
5.2
Paragraph 5.12 of Mr Duguid's zoning evidence identifies the provisions of the New
Zealand Coastal Policy Statement of particular relevance to zoning, while paragraphs
5.13 to 5.21 address the provisions of the Auckland Plan. Section 6 then discusses
the key sections of the RPS, as amended by the Council's current position, which need
to be considered and given effect to through the application of zones (and precincts).
Again, we do not repeat Mr Duguid's evidence here. However, of particular relevance
to the planners' proposed positions relating to the Urban (South) area are the following
RPS provisions discussed at paragraph 6.2 of Mr Duguid's evidence (with specific
paragraph references in brackets):
(a) B2.1 Providing for growth in a quality compact urban form Objectives 1 and 3
and Policy 2 (paragraph 6.2(a)).
(b) B2.2 A Quality Built Environment Objective 1B (paragraph 6.2(b)).
14
(c) B2.3 Development Capacity and Supply of land for urban development
Objective 2 (paragraph 6.2(c)).
(d) B2.5 Rural and coastal towns and villages Objectives 2 and 3 (paragraph
6.2(d)]
(e) B2.7 Social infrastructure Policy 1 (paragraph 6.2(f)]
(f) B3.1 Commercial and Industrial Growth Objective 1 (paragraph 6.2(g)).
(g) B.3.2 Significant infrastructure Objectives 5 and 6 (paragraph 6.2(h)).
(h) B3.3 Transport Objective 2 (paragraph 6.2(i)).
(i) B4.1 Historic heritage Objective 1 (paragraph 6.2(j)).
(j) B4.3.1 Natural character Objective 1 (paragraph 6.2(l)).
(k) B4.3.2 Landscape and Natural Features Objective 7 (paragraph 6.2(m)]
(l) B4.3.4 Biological diversity Objective 1 (paragraph 6.2(n)]
(m) B6.1 Air Policy 1C (paragraph 6.2(r)]
(n) B4.3.2 Landscape and Natural Features Objective 7 (paragraph 6.2(m)).
(o) B6.7 Natural hazards Objective 1 (paragraph 6.2(s)).
(p) B7.1 Subdivision, use and development in the coastal environment Objective
5 and Policy 2A (paragraph 6.2(t)).
(q) B8.1 Rural Activities Objectives 2 and 3 (paragraph 6.2(w)]
(r) B8. 2 Land with High Productive Potential Objectives 1 and 2 (paragraph
6.2(x)]
(s) B8.3 Rural Subdivision Objectives 1, 2, 3 and 4 (paragraph 6.2(y)].
6.
6.1
We have read the Panels Interim Guidance and in particular those relating to:
(a)
(b)
15
6.2
(c)
(d)
The Panels Interim Guidance on best practice approaches to re-zoning and precincts
sets out best practice approaches to changing zoning and precincts and Air Quality.
We support the Panels guidance.
7.
7.1
As noted above, the Councils zoning principles are set out in Mr Duguids evidence
about zoning for Topics 080 and 081 dated 3 December 2015.
The Councils
Section 32AA of the RMA requires a further evaluation for any changes that are
proposed to the notified zones since the original Auckland Unitary Plan Evaluation
Report (the Evaluation Report) was completed under section 32.
All of the
amendments to the notified PAUP zonings proposed in our evidence have been
assessed in accordance with section 32AA. Although not explicitly stated, the options
that we have considered in our assessment include the notified zoning, the amended
zoning as sought by submitters, and the zone we have proposed in each case. The
outcome of our section 32AA analysis is reflected in the reasons stated in (as relevant)
Attachments B, C and F.
7.3
The zoning issues to which this Report relates are not specifically discussed in the
Evaluation Report, however they reflect any recent decisions of the Environment
Court, if relevant, and have been the subject of a section 32 process.
Auckland Transport / Watercare / Stormwater Unit input
7.4
Watercare Services Limited (WSL), Auckland Transport (AT), and the Council's
Stormwater Unit (SWU) have provided technical input on rezoning. There was also
consultation on HC and Pre-1944 BDC matters and VVs / HSAs as required.
7.5
In particular, WSL has provided input on the known transmission capacity constraints
and planned investment of infrastructure in respect of their network. This information
was provided on the basis of WSLs understanding of capacity as at November 2015.
16
7.6
AT has provided input on planned infrastructure investment in line with the new public
transport network to be implemented from 2016, as well as more specific comments on
particular areas where other transport investment is planned. These infrastructure
factors have informed Councils consideration on appropriate zonings in the Urban
(South) area, with the view to reach alignment between land-use and infrastructure
provision.
7.7
SWU has also provided relevant input where there are flooding constraints on
properties. For instance, as noted in Attachment D to David Mead's evidence of Topic
080 on flooding and natural hazards, in some cases SWU has assessed a particular
site as being "in an area where flood plain hazards are considered to be inaccurate
and/or not significant". That advice, alongside the other factors / principles also listed
in Mr Mead's Attachment D, have influenced our assessment of the appropriate zoning
of properties affected by a flood plain.
SUBMISSION THEMES
8.1
A total of 1508 submission points have been received by the Council in relation to the
PAUP zoning within Urban (South) area. The area has been divided into the following
3 sub areas:
S11 area - Manurewa, Homai, Clendon Park, the Gardens and Randwick
Park (1002 submission points)
8.2
The following themes have been identified across the Urban (South) area from our
review of the 1509 submission points received. Within these themes, submissions
seek to retain the notified zone or rezone land, details of which are set out in the
analysis in Attachment B:
(a)
(b)
Business to other Business Zone (excludes mixed use and centres zones) - 4
submission points
17
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
Heavy Industry Zone (HIZ) and Light Industry Zone (LIZ) - 5 submission
points
(h)
8.3
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
(n)
(o)
(p)
(q)
There are 13 Auckland Council submission points which seek to rezone properties in
the Urban - South area to rectify mapping errors.
8.4
8.5
The following submission has been coded to the incorrect geographical locations
within Topic 081:
(a)
Submission 6096-77 (Bunnings Ltd) relating to 173, 177 and 179 Great South
Road, Takanini has been incorrectly coded to hearing topic area South
18
Rural West (Area S15). It relates to Area S12 Takanini, but it is addressed in
the evidence for South Rural West.
PART C: ANALYSIS
9.
ANALYSIS OF SUBMISSIONS
Attachment B
9.1
Attachment B contains an analysis and planners' position with regard to the themes
raised in submissions requesting relief in relation to the zoning of the Urban (South)
area.
9.2
In undertaking this analysis we have had regard to the expert statements of evidence
listed at paragraph 4.4 above.
Attachment C
9.3
9.4
The table in Attachment C has 16 columns for each submission point. The purpose of
each column is generally self-explanatory. However we wish to explain briefly the
content in the column entitled Relevant Overlays, Precincts and Constraints (the
constraints column), and clarify the relationship between the content of the
constraints column and the Reasons column:
(a)
(b)
19
(c)
Consistent with (b) above, the use of N/A in the constraints column does not
necessarily mean that there are no overlays or constraints affecting a
property. In some instances we have reached the view that any overlays or
constraints are not directly relevant to the determination of the appropriate
zoning and have used the abbreviation N/A in those circumstances.
(d)
Attachment D
9.5
9.6
The PAUP zones as notified, but with properties identified that are subject to
submissions; and
(b)
The zoning changes proposed by the Council, with both in scope and out of
scope changes identified. Proposed changes that are in scope are shown as
black outline, while those that are out of scope are shown in blue outline.
9.7
Having regard to the requirements of section 32 and 32AA of the RMA, the other
statutory criteria of the RMA outlined in the evidence of Mr Duguid and the matters
raised by submitters, we consider that the proposed zoning changes are appropriate
because:
(a)
The proposed amendments to the zones meet, and are the most appropriate
way to achieve, the relevant PAUP objectives and policies of the Residential
and Business zones.
(b)
The proposed amendments give effect to the RPS provisions of the PAUP.
(c)
The proposed amendments which are outside the scope of submissions are a
holistic and comprehensive approach, which enables Council to give effect to
20
the RPS, achieve the zone objectives and policies and which is in accordance
with best planning practice.
(d)
(e)
The proposed zoning of land takes into consideration the Councils approach
in determining the most appropriate zone, where the area/site is subject to the
pre-1944 and historic (special) character and SEA overlays.
10.
10.1
10.2
Out of scope changes proposed by the Council are, as noted, shown as blue outline
on the zoning changes proposed by the Council map for each sub area in
Attachment E.
10.3
11.
11.1
There are consequential amendments required to other parts of the PAUP as a result
of our Evidence Report and these are addressed in Section 10 of our Evidence
Report, and the "Consequential Amendments" column of the table at Attachment C.
12.
CONCLUSIONS
12.1
We have considered the submissions received on the zoning of the Urban (South)
area and we consider that the zoning changes which we have proposed, as set out in
the maps included within Attachment E most appropriately meet the statutory
21
framework for zoning set out in the statement of evidence of John Duguid about
zoning for Topics 080 and 081, and the purpose of the Act.
22
ATTACHMENT A: CVs of Report Writers
Danni Briggs
Career Summary
Career Summary Period
2015 -
Organisation
Auckland Council
Role
Planner (South Planning
Unit)
London Borough of
Haringey
Planner
Planner
2013 - 2014
London Borough of
Newham
Planner
2010 - 2011
City of Mandurah
Qualifications
Bachelor of Science (Honours) (Urban and Regional Planning), University of Western
Australia, 2010
ANNA JENNINGS
EDUCATION AND AFFLIATIONS
Member of the New Zealand Planning Institute
Full Membership of NZPI granted in February 2011
Master of Planning (Honours), University of Auckland
July 2004 July 2005
Bachelor of Planning (Honours, Senior Scholar), University of Auckland
July 1999 July 2003
EMPLOYMENT HISTORY
Principal Planner, Planning South, Auckland Council
Auckland, April 2013 to present
Regional Stormwater Policy Advisor, Melbourne Water
Melbourne, Australia September 2011 to December 2012
23
Planning Consultant, Hill Young Cooper
Auckland, New Zealand, March 2010 to May 2011
Major Projects Officer/Technical Specialist, Environment Agency
London, United Kingdom June 2006 to July 2009
Planning Consultant, Meridian Planning Consultants Ltd
Auckland, December 2004 to December 2005
Policy Advisor, Ministry for the Environment
Wellington, February 2004 to July 2004
AFFLIATIONS AND CONFERENCES
Stormwater Industry Association 2012 Victoria Excellence Awards
Merit award for Excellence in Research, innovation, policy and education
Healthy Cities Conference Geelong, June 2012
Presentation titled Improving Liveability through the Implementation of WSUD
Stormwater Conference 2012 Melbourne, October 2012
Presentation and paper titled Building capacity with regional and rural councils Water
Sensitive Urban Design and Integrated Water Management
24
ATTACHMENT B: Analysis of Submissions by Theme
Locality
Theme
Sub pts
No of Submitters
Assessed by planner
39
43
2
296
609
6
2
12
30
1
11
1
1002
1
2
1
44
Joy LaNauze
2
2
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
11
2
4
4
6
6
1
1
1
1
47
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
1
5
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
5
1
1
11
1
1
1
1
1
35
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
Joy LaNauze
S12 (Takanini)
S13 (Papakura)
25
S11(Manurewa, Homai, Clendon Park, The Gardens and Randwick Park)
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Position: Submission points seeking change to MU are not supported as the site is
not adjacent to Manurewa Town Centre, nor easily accessible by public transport
and therefore does not achieve the MU zone objectives. The notified zoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the NC zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Position: The Manurewa Town Centre Concept Plan was taken into account during
development of the draft Unitary Plan and the PAUP. Further amendments to zoning
to align with the Concept Plan are not supported. The notified zoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zones and gives effect to the RPS.
Position: The submission points seeking to retain THAB and MU are supported. The
sites are within close proximity to centres, POS and/or a RFN. The notified zoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB and MU zones and
gives effect to the RPS.
Position: Of the site-specific submission points seeking change to THAB zone, four
have been supported, three have been rezoned to an alternative zone (MU or MHU)
and six have not been supported. Four of the area-wide submission points have
26
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
been supported and two partially supported. This support is based on analysis of the
location of the site and whether it achieves the THAB zone objectives and gives
effect to the RPS.
Clendon Park
Manurewa
Position: Submission points to rezone to THAB around Te Mahia Station are not
supported Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification here may
compete with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for surrounding Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for
intensification. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and give effect to the RPS.
Clendon Park
Position: The four area wide submissions to rezone areas surrounding the Clendon
Park Local Centre to THAB are supported, either in part or in full. Providing THAB
around the centre will promote a walkable neighbourhood and achieves the THAB
zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS. To create an appropriate level of
intensification for the area and provide a transition between THAB and MHS, some
properties have been rezoned to MHU.
The Gardens
The Gardens
Position: Submission points seeking change from LI to MHS are not supported. The
land is adjacent to the rail line and is better suited to non-residential land uses. The
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the LI zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
27
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Site-specific
Area-wide
Position: These area-wide submission points have been partially supported. Where
managing flooding risks on a site does not require maintaining a SH zone or where
spot zoning is being avoided, the site has been rezoned to MHS or MHU. However
where the site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS, no change has been made.
Site-specific
Position: The submissions seeking to retain the MHS, MHU and THAB zoning are
all supported as the notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the zone and give effect to the RPS.
Position: Of the submission points seeking rezoning from SH, 14 have been
supported as managing flooding risks on the sites does not require maintaining a SH
zone, 26 have been rezoned to an alternative zone which better aligns with the zone
objectives and 31 have not been supported as the sites are affected by flooding
constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
Position: Of the submission points seeking rezoning from MHS, 15 have been
supported, five have been rezoned to an alternative zone and 125 have not been
supported. This position is based on analysis of the location of each site and whether
it aligns with the MHU or THAB zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS.
Position: Of the submission points seeking rezoning from MHU, two have been
supported in full, two supported in part and five have not been supported. This
position is based on analysis of the location of each site and whether it aligns with
the THAB zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS.
Position: The submission points seeking rezoning to SH are supported as the sites
are affected by flooding constraints and change to SH zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
Area-wide
Position: Submission points seeking to retain the current zoning pattern have all
been partially supported. Some of the areas surrounding the centres and transport
networks have been rezoned to promote the compact city approach in line with the
RPS.
28
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Position: The submission points seeking rezoning to MHU have been supported as
the properties are in close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and have good
access to a RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Site-specific
Site-specific
Position: With one exception, all submissions seeking to retain the MHS and MHU
zoning are supported as the notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHS and MHU zones and gives effect to the RPS. One
submission point seeking to retain MHS is not supported as the zone does not align
with the Mill Road Precinct, which is located over the site. This is discussed in the
evidence of Anna Jennings for Topic 081.
Position: Submissions seeking rezoning from MHU to MHS are not supported as the
properties are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are
therefore suitable for more intensive development. The notified zoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Position: Of the submission points seeking rezoning from MHS to MHU, 26 have
been supported, two have been rezoned to an alternative zone and 364 have not
been supported. This position is based on analysis of the location of each site and
whether it aligns with the MHU zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS.
Position: The submission point is not supported as spot zoning in this location will
not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
Theme 7 Errors
Position: All submission points seeking to correct zoning errors have been
supported, with the exception of 5716-3072 and 5716-3073 where an alternative
zone has been supported as the Councils proposed zoning of surrounding
properties have changed since the PAUP was notified. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zones and gives effect to the RPS.
Position: The submission point is supported as the subject land is not designated
for the purposes of a railway line and the STC zone appears to have been an error.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the LI zone
and give effect to the RPS.
29
S12 (Takanini)
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Retention of TC zone
Rezoning of TC to MU or THAB
It is noted from Susan Fairgrays economic evidence for Council for Topics 051 to 055
Centre Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business
Controls that there is no further evidence to support enabling further retail in Takanini as
there are retail capacity surpluses in Papakura, Takanini, and Manukau.
Porchester
and
Porchester
and
It is noted that 62-66 Takanini Road (part of the Takanini Town Centre) is now a Special
Housing Area.
Given the relatively few scattered sites constrained by flooding in Conifer Grove, rezoning of
these scattered sites from SH to MHS is supported to avoid Spot Zoning. The MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximity to
centres and maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Taka Street
Balgowan Terrace
Kindergarten Drive
SH Zoning supported for Takanini existing residential area east of railway line except for
Berywn Avenue area, where MHS is supported
Given the extent of flooding constraints in this area the SH zone is generally supported for
this area. As flooding constraints lessen in the Berwyn Avenue area, some rezonings to
MHS zoning rather than SH zoning are supported in that area. MHS rather than MHU is the
most appropriate zone in the Berwyn Avenue area as the sites are not in close proximity to a
30
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
Berwyn Avenue
Challen Close
Chibnal Place
Porchester Road (part Takanini sub precinct D)
Arimu Road
Porchester Road (two submissions)
Waterview Road West (two submissions)
PLANNERS POSITION
centre or an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Some MHU Zoning supported in southern existing Takanini residential area
MHU is supported immediately east of the railway line as far east as Porchester Road
between the Takanini Town Centre and the Papakura Metropolitan Centre on sites where
flooding constraints do not prevent MHU zoning.
Rezoning to THAB not supported
Given the extent of flooding constraints in urban Takanini, no rezoning to THAB is supported
for this area, even in the vicinity of the Takanini railway station.
Support retention of notified MHS zone for sites in this (deleted) precinct
Chibnal Place
o Part of Integrated Development sub-precinct B
Cosgrave Road (two submissions)
o Part of Takanini sub precinct D
Cunningham Place
o Part of Integrated Development sub-precinct B
Kindergarten Drive (two submissions)
o Part of Integrated Development sub-precinct B
Rountree Place (two submissions)
o Part of Integrated Development sub-precinct B
Unspecified property
Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
zone. It is not in close proximity to centres and maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Papakura Military Camp site
Walters Road
Rather than rezoning the Papakura Army Base (on the south western corner of Walters and
Grove Roads) from SH Zone to MU as sought by the NZ Defence Force, it is considered
appropriate to rezone it from SH to MHS. While the site is designated, the underlying
zoning will then reflect the zoning of the land to the east and west of the block. This land
need not be restricted to SH zoning for flooding constraint purposes.
Takanini precinct see more detailed evidence in Joy LaNauzes separate precinct
Evidence Report for Topic 081
Takanini sub-precinct A:
Rezoning of 296 Porchester Road is supported a minor correction is needed. Realignment
of zone boundary with property boundary is required. Site boundary should be zone
boundary.
Rezoning of 55 Takanini School Road is not supported. The site is significantly affected by
flooding constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Takanini sub-precincts B and C
Support retention of notified zones.The zoning of what is now the Takanini Town Centre and
its extent was debated in Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change
12. This plan change also determined the extent of MU zoning east of the railway line and
31
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
o Takanini sub-precinct C
Retention of LC zone
of
Porchester
Walters Road
o Takanini sub-precinct C
Rezoning from MR to LI
the location and extent of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the
recent Environment Court decisions (most recently in 2012) on this plan change, no
and alteration to these zonings is proposed. TC is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the TC zone and gives effect to the RPS, including the centres
strategy/hierarchy.
Takanini sub-precinct D
Retention of MHS zone is supported
The zoning of the residential component of the portion of Takanini sub precinct D bounded
by Grove Road, Walters Road and Porchester Road (the Cosgrave Structure Plan area)
was determined by a plan change for Takanini Structure Plan Area 2A ( Auckland Council
District Plan (Papakura section) Private Plan Change 4 (operative 2010). It is noted that
resource consent for residential development has been granted for 61 Grove Road. MHS is
considered to best reflect the operative zoning.
344 Airfield Road
Rezoning is not supported
The site can rely on existing use rights for its light industrial activity. While the land is across
the road from Ardmore Airport, which contains light industrial uses, rezoning the land would
create a spot zone to the north of Airfield Road. Pressure to extend the industrial zone
further into the MR zone could then eventuate.
Rezoning from LI to GB
Do not support change of zone from LI to GB. It is noted that Pak N Save operate a
supermarket from 341-345 Great South Road and that Placemakers operate a trade supply
341-345 Great South Road
activity from part of 2-12 Great South Road. See Council evidence Topic 051-054 (Centre
Rezoning from LI to GB or LC
Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls)
about Large Format Retail and Trade Supply in Business zones. LI is the most appropriate
2-12 Great South Road
way to achieve the objectives of the LI zone and gives effect to the RPS. GB zoning will not
Note: Submission 6096-77 (Bunnings Ltd) relating to 173, 177 and give effect to the criteria in B3.1 of the RPS.
179 Great South Road, Takanini has been wrongly coded to Area
S15 (Rural South - Drury). It relates to Area S12 Takanini, but it is
addressed in the evidence for Area S15 (Rural South Drury). The
submission seeks rezoning from MHS to LI.
Four submitters have made four submission points
Rezoning of part of the Takanini North Industrial area to Heavy Industry is supported.
Retention of LI Zone
Rezoning from LI to HI
See Council evidence from Joy LaNauze for Topic 051-054 Centre Zones, Business park
and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls.
32
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Rezoning from SH to LC
It is noted that 106 Great South Road contains a medical centre, whereas resource consent
for a medical and retail development on part of the land at 104-112 Great South Road, 3
and 5 Manuia Road, 2 and 4 Manuroa Road and 104 - 106 Great South Road was refused
in 2014.
Do not support change of zone from SH and MHS to LC. The notified MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. For
the sites zoned SH, these are affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS. Rezoning to LC will not give effect to the RPS including the centres
strategy/hierarchy.
Do not support change from MHS to NC. It is noted that the site contains a medical centre.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone,
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
RUB expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there
are a number of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed
investigation. No rezonings of the FUZ are supported because detailed assessment of
these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning needs to be undertaken before an
appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FUZ.
Theme 8 Flooding
Given the relatively few scattered sites constrained by flooding in Conifer Grove, rezoning of
these scattered sites from Single House to MHS is supported to avoid Spot Zoning. The
MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. It is not in
close proximity to centres and maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Rezoning of SH to MHU
Rezoning of MHS to SH
Single House Zoning supported for Takanini existing residential area east of railway line
except for Berywn Avenue area, where MHS is supported
Given the extent of flooding constraints in this area the Single House zone is generally
supported for this area. As flooding constraints lessen in the Berwyn Avenue area, some
rezonings to MHS zoning rather than Single House zoning are supported in that area. MHS
rather than MHU is the most appropriate zone in the Berwyn Avenue area as the sites are
not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Some MHU Zoning supported in southern existing Takanini residential area
MHU is supported immediately east of the railway line as far east as Porchester Road
between the Takanini Town Centre and the Papakura Metropolitan Centre on sites where
managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or a MHS zone.
Rezoning to THAB not supported
Given the extent of flooding constraints in urban Takanini, no rezoning to THAB is supported
33
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
for this area, even in the vicinity of the Takanini railway station.
Rezoning to MHU supported in part of Takanini existing residential area between Great
South Road and railway line
Some isolated properties west of the railway between Great South Road and the railway line
have been rezoned to MHU for flooding constraint reasons. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone.
Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
zone. It is not in close proximity to centres and maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
RUB expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there
are a number of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed
investigation. No rezonings of the FUZ are supported because detailed assessment of
these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning needs to be undertaken before an
appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FUZ.
It is noted that resource consents have been obtained for a number of worship in the
northern Porchester Road area, however FUZ zoning is supported until appropriate live
zonings for the entire FUZ area are determined. Detailed assessment of any constraints
needs to occur, and structure planning needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live
zone can be determined for land within the FUZ.
MR is a more appropriate zone than CL because the area does not meet the criteria for
areas identified for CL in RPS B8.3 Rural Subdivision policy 6. In particular part of the land
is classified as Land Use Capacity Class 2 land (prime land). Retention of the MR Zone is
34
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
and neighbouring land
Retention of MR
MR zone accommodates a range of rural production activities and associated nonresidential activities while still ensuring good amenity levels for residents who use their land
for rural lifestyle purposes. Retention of the MR Zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB expert geotechnical and stormwater
evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number of constraints both inside
and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No rezonings are recommended
because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning
needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within
the FU zone. Retention of the FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
PLANNERS POSITION
Rezoning is supported.
The change will fix an error where the driveway of the property has been incorrectly zoned
MHU
S13 (Papakura)
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Retention of MC zone
Metropolitan Centre zone in close proximity to Papakura Train Station, Great South Road,
and Papakura retail and commercial area. Retention of the MC zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the MC zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Rezoning to THAB
Rezoning to THAB as notified in March 2013 draft of the Unitary Plan not supported
North of Ingram Street, Mixed Housing Urban considered more appropriate than THAB
because of distance from Papakura railway station.
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from sites on
northern periphery of central Papakura (Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944
Mapping). MHU zoning is supported for properties on the northern periphery of central
Papakura as they are close to Great South Road and community facilities, provided they are
not subject to flooding constraints.
Rezoning from Single House and Mixed Housing Urban to THAB for six blocks on the
35
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Porchester Road
Prictor Street
Retention of MU
Coles Crescent
Papakura character and intensity most suited to Mixed Housing Urban in this location rather
than THAB because of distance to Papakura railway station.
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from some of
these sites (Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Managing flooding risks
on 3 of the 5 Single House sites in Union/Menary/Wellington/Ray Small block does not
require maintaining a SH or a MHS zone ; sufficient space available for one building shape
factor.
To avoid spot zoning, appropriate to zone all the Single House zoned sites in
Union/Menary/Wellington/Ray Small block to Mixed Housing Urban. The rezoning of these
SH sites as although the SH zone could be retained due to the site being affected by
flooding constraints, in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context.
Retention of Mixed Use zoning supported
Mixed Use Zone appropriate for character of area and its proximity to Papakura Metropolitan
Centre and Great South Road
Pratt Street
Calvert Street
Orion Street
Osborne Place
Smiths Avenue
Single House Zoning supported in most urban residential locations where there are flooding
constraints
For sites subject to flooding constraints, managing flooding risks on those sites by
maintaining a SH zone is generally supported. While this creates a zoning pattern of Single
House zone amongst Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones, Single
36
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
House zoning is considered to be the most appropriate way to give effect to the RPS.
West of the railway line this zoning pattern reflects flood constraints in Rosehill, and
Opaheke. Much of eastern Papakura is also in flood constraint areas.
MHS zoning supported where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone
MHS is the most appropriate zone for the majority of sites in urban Papakura which are not
subject to major flooding constraints. This is because the sites are not in close proximity to
Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and MHS maintains the planned suburban built
character of this area. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU zoning is supported for properties on the northern periphery of central Papakura where
managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
These properties are close to Great South Road and community facilities.
MHU supported north of Ingram Street close to central Papakura where managing flooding
risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
MHU considered appropriate given the areas proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre
for these properties. Mixed Housing Urban is supported rather than THAB because of the
distance from the Papakura Railway Station.
MHU zoning supported near Marne Road Area close to central Papakura where managing
flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from this site
(Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Some sites constrained by flooding
can be upzoned up due to sufficient space available for one building shape factor. The land
is on the south eastern periphery of central Papakura, parks and community facilities, and is
suitable for rezoning as MHU.
While there are some sites subject to flooding constraints in the following areas, managing
flooding risks on those sites by maintaining a scattered SH zoning has not been supported
in these areas because opportunities for intensification exist and it is considered that to give
best effect to the RPS, these opportunities should override flooding constraint issues:
MHU zoning supported in Porchester/Old Wairoa Road/Arimu Road/Artillery Drive area
close to central Papakura
This is an area of several hundred properties. Seventeen properties were zoned Single
House for flooding constraint reasons in notified PAUP.Managing flood risks on six sites
within this area requires maintaining a SH zoning because there is no room for a building
shape factor (8m x 15m), and floodplain is significant constraint on site. the remainder of
the sites can be rezoned. Rezoning the entire area to Mixed Housing Urban is supported
given its proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. North of Ingram Street, Mixed
Housing Urban is supported rather than THAB because of its distance from the Papakura
Railway Station.
37
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
MHU zoning supported west and south of Papakura Metropolitan Centre
Mixed Housing Urban is supported west of the Papakura centre, and to its south between
Liverpool Street, Short Street and the railway line. Council position to remove Historic
Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from a number of sites in this area (Topic 079 Special
Character and Pre-1944 Mapping).
The residential properties bounded by Onslow Road to the north, Railway Street West to the
east, Short Street to the South, and Liverpool Street to the west, and by Settlement Road
and Opaheke Road are on the southern periphery of central Papakura, parks and
community facilities. Managing flood risks on some sites within this block requires
maintaining a SH zoning because there is no room for a building shape factor (8m x 15m),
and floodplain is significant constraint on site. Given the overall small number of properties
within this block which are subject to stormwater constraints, the rezoning of all properties in
this block to MHU is however supported as the most appropriate way to give effect to the
RPS.
THAB is supported in Railway Street West on periphery of Papakura Metropolitan Centre
Site is along the road from Papakura Railway Station and on periphery of Papakura
Metropolitan Centre, therefore suitable for THAB. THAB therefore the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB is supported east of the railway line in Ingram Street close to central Papakura
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from a number of
sites in this area (Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Managing flood
risks on 11 of the 14 Single House sites in the northern part of the block bounded by Ingram
and Prictor Streets, Clevedon Road, and railway line does not require the maintenance of a
SH or MHS zone; sufficient space available for one building shape factor. Papakura
character and intensity most suited to THAB in this location rather than MHU because of
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre. To avoid spot zoning and achieve intensity
close to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre, appropriate to zone all the SH zoned sites in in
the northern part of the block bounded by Ingram and Prictor Streets, Clevedon Road, and
railway line to THAB.
Papakura Precinct - see more detailed evidence in Joy LaNauzes separate precinct
Evidence Report for Topic 081
Retention of notified zone supported.
Sites contain a police station and a court and are in close proximity to Papakura Train
Station, Great South Road, and Papakura retail and commercial area. Retention of the MC
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the MC zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Takanini precinct see more detailed evidence in Joy LaNauzes separate precinct
Evidence Report for Topic 081
Takanini sub-precinct D
38
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
The zoning of the portion of Takanini sub precinct D bounded by Papakura-Clevedon and
Dominion Roads was determined by a plan change for Takanini Structure Plan Area 2C
(Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Private Plan Change 4 (operative 2010)).
MHS is considered to best reflect the operative zoning.
Takanini sub-precinct E
Rezoning is not supported.
Do not support change from SH to MHS given the distance from centres and frequent
service networks. Retention of the SH gives effect to the objectives and policies of the RPS
and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and Takanini subprecinct E.
Retain LI zone
Site provides an appropriate buffer between residential and heavy industry zoning. LI zoning
is considered to be the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the LI zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
40 - 52 Hunua Road
Single House Zoning supported in most urban residential locations where there are flooding
constraints
For sites subject to flooding constraints, managing flooding constraints on those sites by
maintaining a SH zone is generally supported. While this creates a zoning pattern of SH
amongst MHS and MHU zones, SH zoning is considered to be the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
West of the railway line this zoning pattern reflects flood constraints in Rosehill, and
Opaheke. Much of eastern Papakura is also in flood constraint areas.
MHS zoning supported where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone
MHS is the most appropriate zone for the majority of sites in urban Papakura which are not
subject to major flooding constraints. This is because the sites are not in close proximity to
Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and MHS maintains the planned suburban built
character of this area. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU zoning is supported for properties on the northern periphery of central Papakura where
managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
These properties are close to Great South Road and community facilities.
MHU supported north of Ingram Street close to central Papakura where managing flooding
risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
MHU considered appropriate given the areas proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre
for these properties. Mixed Housing Urban is supported rather than THAB because of the
distance from the Papakura Railway Station.
39
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
MHU zoning supported near Marne Road Area close to central Papakura where managing
flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from this site
(Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Some sites constrained by flooding
can be upzoned up due to sufficient space available for one building shape factor. The land
is on the south eastern periphery of central Papakura, parks and community facilities, and is
suitable for rezoning as Mixed Housing Urban.
While there are some sites subject to flooding constraints in the following areas, managing
flooding risks on those sites by maintaining a scattered SH zoning has not been supported
in these areas because opportunities for intensification exist and it is considered that to give
best effect to the RPS, these opportunities should override flooding constraint issues:
MHU zoning supported in Porchester/Old Wairoa Road/Arimu Road/Artillery Drive area
close to central Papakura
This is an area of several hundred properties. Seventeen properties were zoned Single
House for flooding constraint reasons in notified PAUP. Managing flood risks on six sites
within this area requires maintaining a SH zoning because there is no room for a building
shape factor (8m x 15m), and floodplain is significant constraint on site. the remainder of
the sites can be rezoned. Rezoning the entire area to Mixed Housing Urban is supported
given its proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. North of Ingram Street, Mixed
Housing Urban is supported rather than THAB because of its distance from the Papakura
Railway Station.
MHU zoning supported west and south of Papakura Metropolitan Centre
Mixed Housing Urban is supported west of the Papakura centre, and to its south between
Liverpool Street, Short Street and the railway line. Council position to remove Historic
Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from a number of sites in this area (Topic 079 Special
Character and Pre-1944 Mapping).
The residential properties bounded by Onslow Road to the north, Railway Street West to the
east, Short Street to the South, and Liverpool Street to the west, and by Settlement Road
and Opaheke Road are on the southern periphery of central Papakura, parks and
community facilities. Managing flood constraints on some sites within this block requires
maintaining SH zoning because there is no room for a building shape factor (8m x 15m),
and floodplain is significant constraint on site. Given the overall small number of properties
within this block which are subject to stormwater constraints, the rezoning of all properties in
this block to Mixed Housing Urban is however supported as the most appropriate way to
give effect to the RPS.
THAB is supported in Railway Street West on periphery of Papakura Metropolitan Centre
Site is along the road from Papakura Railway Station and on periphery of Papakura
Metropolitan Centre, therefore suitable for THAB. THAB therefore the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB is supported east of the railway line in Ingram Street close to central Papakura
40
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from a number of
sites in this area (Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Managing flood
constraints on 11 of the 14 Single House sites in the northern part of the block bounded by
Ingram and Prictor Streets, Clevedon Road, and railway line does not require the
maintenance of a SH or MHS zone; sufficient space available for one building shape factor.
Papakura character and intensity most suited to THAB in this location rather than MHU
because of proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre. To avoid spot zoning and achieve
intensity close to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre, appropriate to zone all the Single
House zoned sites in in the northern part of the block bounded by Ingram and Prictor
Streets, Clevedon Road, and railway line to THAB.
Theme 7 Flooding
Single House Zoning supported in most urban residential locations where there are flooding
constraints
For sites subject to flooding constraints, managing flooding constraints on those sites by
maintaining a SH zoning is generally supported. While this creates a zoning pattern of SH
zone amongst MHS and MHU zones, SH zoning is considered to be the most appropriate
way to give effect to the RPS.
West of the railway line this zoning pattern reflects flood constraints in Rosehill, and
Opaheke. Much of eastern Papakura is also in flood constraint areas.
MHS zoning supported where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone
MHS is the most appropriate zone for the majority of sites in urban Papakura which are not
subject to major flooding constraints. This is because the sites are not in close proximity to
Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and MHS maintains the planned suburban built
character of this area. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU zoning is supported for properties on the northern periphery of central Papakura where
managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
These properties are close to Great South Road and community facilities.
MHU supported north of Ingram Street close to central Papakura where managing flooding
risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
MHU considered appropriate given the areas proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre
for these properties. Mixed Housing Urban is supported rather than THAB because of the
distance from the Papakura Railway Station.
MHU zoning supported near Marne Road Area close to central Papakura where managing
flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH or MHS zone
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from this site
(Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Some sites constrained by flooding
can be upzoned up due to sufficient space available for one building shape factor. The land
is on the south eastern periphery of central Papakura, parks and community facilities, and is
41
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
suitable for rezoning as Mixed Housing Urban.
While there are some sites subject to flooding constraints in the following areas, managing
flooding risks on those sites by maintaining a scattered SH zoning has not been supported
in these areas because opportunities for intensification exist and it is considered that to give
best effect to the RPS, these opportunities should override flooding constraint issues:
MHU zoning supported in Porchester/Old Wairoa Road/Arimu Road/Artillery Drive area
close to central Papakura
This is an area of several hundred properties. Seventeen properties were zoned Single
House for flooding constraint reasons in notified PAUP. Managing flood risks on six sites
within this area requires maintaining a SH zoning because there is no room for a building
shape factor (8m x 15m), and floodplain is significant constraint on site. The remainder of
the sites can be rezoned. Rezoning the entire area to Mixed Housing Urban is supported
given its proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. North of Ingram Street, Mixed
Housing Urban is supported rather than THAB because of its distance from the Papakura
Railway Station.
MHU zoning supported west and south of Papakura Metropolitan Centre
Mixed Housing Urban is supported west of the Papakura centre, and to its south between
Liverpool Street, Short Street and the railway line. Council position to remove Historic
Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from a number of sites in this area (Topic 079 Special
Character and Pre-1944 Mapping).
The residential properties bounded by Onslow Road to the north, Railway Street West to the
east, Short Street to the South, and Liverpool Street to the west, and by Settlement Road
and Opaheke Road are on the southern periphery of central Papakura, parks and
community facilities. Managing flood constraints on some sites within this block requires
maintaining SH zoning because there is no room for a building shape factor (8m x 15m),
and floodplain is significant constraint on site. Given the overall small number of properties
within this block which are subject to stormwater constraints, the rezoning of all properties in
this block to MHU is supported as the most appropriate way to give effect to the RPS.
THAB is supported in Railway Street West on periphery of Papakura Metropolitan Centre
Site is along the road from Papakura Railway Station and on periphery of Papakura
Metropolitan Centre, therefore suitable for THAB. THAB therefore the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB is supported east of the railway line in Ingram Street close to central Papakura
Council position to remove Historic Heritage pre-1944 Demolition Control from a number of
sites in this area (Topic 079 Special Character and Pre-1944 Mapping). Stormwater Unit
advise 11 of the 14 Single House sites in the northern part of the block bounded by Ingram
and Prictor Streets, Clevedon Road, and railway line can be upzoned; sufficient space
available for one building shape factor. Papakura character and intensity most suited to
THAB in this location rather than MHU because of proximity to Papakura Metropolitan
Centre. To avoid spot zoning and achieve intensity close to the Papakura Metropolitan
42
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
Centre, appropriate to zone all the Single House zoned sites in in the northern part of the
block bounded by Ingram and Prictor Streets, Clevedon Road, and railway line to THAB.
MHS zoning supported where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone
MHS is the most appropriate zone for the majority of sites in urban Papakura as they are not
in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone
To give effect to the RPS, flood constraint restrictions identified by Council have however
been adopted, and generally create a zoning pattern of SH zone amongst MHS zones.
Some of these changes are out of the scope of submissions.
This zoning pattern in reflects flood constraints in much of eastern Papakura.
Public Open Space Community zoning has only been applied to parts of this land which are
owned by Council. The remainder of the land is zoned MHU. Community Facilities are
Restricted Discretionary Activities in the MHU Zone (as set out in in Nicholas Roberts track
change evidence for Council for the Residential PAUP Hearing Topics (059, 060 062 and
063)). The zoning does not affect the existing uses on the site. MHU is appropriate within
the surrounding context, and prevents potential spot zoning. The notified zones are the
most appropriate way to meet the relevant objectives of the MHU/POS zones and give
effect to the RPS.
Rezoning of MR to CL
The area does not meet the criteria for areas identified for Countryside Living in RPS B8.3
Rural Subdivision Policy 6. In particular part of the land is classified as Land Use Capability
Class 2 land (prime land). Retention of the MR zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
RCS zone not considered appropriate as the application of the MR zone best reflects the
mix of MR activities currently taking place in this location. The land is outside the RUB and
the RPS Chapter 2.1 Policy 1A states that new towns and villages outside the RUB are to
be avoided. Retention of MR zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
With regard to proposed zoning patterns surrounding existing centres, refer to Attachment
C. In accordance with the provisions of the RPS, intensification is proposed mainly around
centres and along the RFN.
43
SUBMISSION THEME
OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS
PLANNERS POSITION
infrastructure.
The notified zoning maintains the planned character of this zone. Otherwise, a spot zone
would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retaining the MR zone
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Theme 13 Errors
Mapping errors no longer require correction as the remainders of 64 and 68 Clevedon Road
have been rezoned from SH to MHS as managing flooding risks on those sites does not
require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
64 Clevedon Road
68 Clevedon Road
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 31 Christmas Road
Manurewa from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
31 Christmas Road
Manurewa
SUB
POINT
7-1
SUBMITTER
NAME
Gloria Mao
1030-1
MD Holdings
Limited (Attn:
John Childs)
Urban
(South)
S11
1030-2
MD Holdings
Limited (Attn:
John Childs)
Urban
(South)
S11
1731-87
Fletcher
Residential
Limited (Attn:
Angela Stewart)
Urban
(South)
S12
6566-2
Glenn W
Archibald
Urban
(South)
S13
1731-88
Fletcher
Residential
Limited (Attn: Ian
Craig)
Urban
(South)
S12
57163012
S12
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
246 Great South Road, Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Manurewa; 7
Housing Apartment
McAnnalley Street,
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Manurewa
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Manukau Golf Course Any residential
Conifer Grove
properties subject to a
key overlay
North of Papakura
town centre along
Great North Road and
the south side of
Trentham Road to the
railway line. Any site in
Papakura where THAB
was notified, and then
rezoned.
Rezone the Manukau Golf Course Manukau Golf Course
to predominantly Mixed Housing
Urban with Mixed Use zone. Refer
to Attachment 3 in submission
1731 for details.
Rezone 18 Waimana Road,
18 Waimana Road,
Conifer Grove (LOT 16 DP 17076) Conifer Grove
from Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban. Refer to
submission, Volume 4, page
16/35 and Attachment 729,
Volume 20.
Rezone 21, WAIARI ROAD,
21, WAIARI ROAD,
Conifer Grove from Mixed
Conifer Grove
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 2/35,1/35, CHALLEN
2/35 and 1/35 Challen
CLOSE, Conifer Grove from
Close, Conifer Grove
Single House to Mixed Housing
Suburban.
Retain the Metropolitan Centre
248 Great South Road
Zoning of 64 Wood Street,
Papakura
Papakura
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
REASONS
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to MHU, support alternative change to MHS - MHS is the most
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from NC to MU - The site is located outside of the RFN and is not
CHANGE; SUPPORT adjacent to the Manurewa Town Centre. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
RETENTION OF
the objectives of the NC zone and gives effect to the RPS, including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No
NC
MU
N/A
NC
MU (inferred)
N/A
MHS
MHU
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No Change
it is not in close proximity to a centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
The extent of THAB in Papakura has reduced between the March 2013 draft and September 2013
PAUP. Distance from Papakura Metropolitan Centre is the major reason for this reduction. Retention
or change of zone is proposed in response to submissions. Out of scope changes have been
proposed to give effect to the RPS, see Attachment F. Intensification is proposed mainly around
centres and along the RFN. The proposed zones are the most appropriate way to achieve the
relevant zone objectives and give effect to the RPS.
Various - see
site specific
submissions
where
change of
zone to
THAB is
recommende
d
No change
See site
No
specific
submissions
where
change of
zone to
THAB is
recommende
d
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Do not support change of zone from NC to MU - The site is located outside of the RFN and is not
adjacent to the Manurewa Town Centre. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the NC zone and gives effect to the RPS, including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
Centres/Terrace
Papakura
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
SH/MHS/MHU/ THAB
THAB
N/A
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHU/MU
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU or MU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the
site as it is not in close proximity to a centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS. MU zoning will not give effect to the criteria in B3.1 of the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
No
No
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
MHS
Yes
No
MC
MC
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. The site is significantly affected by flooding constraints,
however this site already contains two dwellings. The MHS zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. MHS zone recognises the
established uses.
Support retention of notified zone. Site forms part of Papakura Metropolitan Centre. Appropriate to
retain zoning because site contains a police station and is in close proximity to Papakura Train
Station, Great South Road, and Papakura retail and commercial area. Retention of the MC zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the MC zone and gives effect to the
RPS including the Centres strategy/hierarchy.
Support retention of notified zone. Site forms part of Papakura Metropolitan Centre. Appropriate to
retain zoning because site contains a District Court and is in close proximity to Papakura Train
Station, Great South Road, and Papakura retail and commercial area. Retention of the MC zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the MC zone and gives effect to the
RPS including the Centres strategy/hierarchy.
Support retention of notified zone. The functions of the Papakura Metropolitan Centre (such as civic,
retail, business, community, transport hub) mean that its zoning as MC remains appropriate.
Council's position is to revise the Papakura Metropolitan Centre notified heights of 40.5 metres and
24.5 metres to 40.5 and 27 metres(see evidence from DSadlier in Topic 051-054 Centre Zones,
Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls). There has been
significant public concern in Papakura over the initial proposed 72.5m height limit. The PAUP
recognised these concerns and modified the height of the metropolitan centre to a maximum of
40.5m. Providing for 40.5m in the core and reducing out to 27.0m (proposed to be revised from
24.5m) on the south and west edges as the centre adjoins residential living environments will still
enable significant growth of the town centre, whilst balancing the concerns of residents about heights
(shading, dominance and views). Retention of the MC zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the relevant objectives of the MC zone and gives effect to the RPS including the Centres
strategy/hierarchy.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Site adjoins FU zone and MHS zone aligns with
Takanini residential development area zoning. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is
not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
S13
4279-24
Minister for
Courts (Attn:
Justine Bray)
Urban
(South)
S13
MC
MC
4296-1
S13
MC
Unspecified
Papakura
Precinct/Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC,
Additional Zone
Height Controls
(24.5m and 40.5m)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Takinini
MHS
MHU
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
2462-1
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
4702-4
Kumaran Nair
Urban
(South)
S12
7 Princess Street,
Papakura
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Page 1
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
57163005
SUBMITTER
NAME
TOPIC
Auckland Council Urban
(Attn: Stephen
(South)
Town)
57163006
57163007
57163008
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S12
Rezone 2 Berwyn Avenue,
Takanini (LOT 1 D P 45283) from
Mixed Housing Suburban to
Single House. Refer to
submission, Volume 4, page
15/35 and Attachment 725,
Volume 20.
S12
Rezone 4 Berwyn Avenue,
Takanini (LOT 2 D P 45283) from
Single House to Mixed Housing
Suburban. Refer to submission,
Volume 4, page 15/35 and
Attachment 725, Volume 20.
S12
Rezone 282 Porchester Road,
Takanini (LOT 1 DP 145939-1/5
SH IN LOT 29 DP 136926) from
Single House to Mixed Housing
Suburban. Refer to submission,
Volume 4, page 15/35 and
Attachment 725, Volume 20.
S12
Rezone 156 Manuroa Road,
Takanini (LOT 4 DP 55975) from
Single House to Mixed Housing
Suburban. Refer to submission,
Volume 4, page 15/35 and
Attachment 725, Volume 20.
S12
Rezone 106, MANUROA ROAD,
Takanini from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
2 Berwyn Avenue,
Takanini
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Takinini
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
106, MANUROA
ROAD, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Yes
No
MHU
NGC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. The site is affected by flooding constraints and although
MHS
the SH zone could be retained, a spot zone would occur. A spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. A MHS zone
maintains the planned suburban built character and is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS at 70 Elliot Street. Managing flooding risks on this site does SH/MHS
not require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Yes
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support change of zone to THAB - the sites are located around the Clendon Park Local Centre and THAB
POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density in this location will promote a walkable
neighbourhood and could improve the vitality of the centre. The area is not currently serviced by a
RFN, however it is connected by buses to Manurewa Train Station. Managing flooding risks on the
sites does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS within Manurewa - MHU is appropriate around
No change
centres and along transport corridors. Intensification will increase the housing capacity and will
create a compact urban form. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support retention of MHS zone - the sites are within the Mill Road Precinct and have been
SH
subject to zoning changes due to the precinct provisions. Support rezoning to SH - refer to Mill Road
Precinct evidence. MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and the relevant precinct objectives, and gives effect to the RPS. This is an out of scope change see Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S13
49, CHICHESTER
DRIVE,1,3,2,4,
DUMAS PLACE,
Rosehill
57163010
S13
3224-1
Atonia Brooke
Trust (Attn: Paul
B Magill)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Kirkdale
Urban
Investments
(South)
Limited (Attn: Jon
Maplesden)
David Sharples
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
N/A
S11
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Gordon Parkes
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Area wide (ManuMHU
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
S11
MHS
Urban
(South)
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA), National
Grid Corridor
(NGC)
N/A
MHS
Urban
(South)
S12
MHU
Flooding
constraints
3511-1
37-3
3777-1
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
4 Berwyn Avenue,
Takanini
Mixed Housing
Papakura - Sout MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Roscommon Road,
Palmers Road and
Barneys Farm Road,
Manurewa
Clendon Park
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
81, MANUROA ROAD, Any residential
Takanini
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
SH
Takinini
SH
Page 2
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
RETAIN; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5067 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 116,2/124,1/124,
CHICHESTER DRIVE,5,
MARYBETH PLACE, Rosehill
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
S12
Rezone 108A, MANUROA ROAD,
Takanini from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S12
4088-2
4186-3
Heather Parlane
4186-6
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
PROPERTIES
OVERLAYS,
SUBJECT TO
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
116,2/124,1/124,
Any residential
MHU
N/A
Papakura - Sout MHS
CHICHESTER
properties subject to a
DRIVE,5, MARYBETH key overlay
PLACE, Rosehill
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
108A, MANUROA
ROAD, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
N/A
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Heather Parlane
Urban
(South)
S11
Hill Park
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
4188-3
Amy M Parlane
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4188-6
Amy M Parlane
Urban
(South)
S11
Hill Park
4190-3
Leslie J Parlane
Urban
(South)
S11
4190-6
Leslie J Parlane
Urban
(South)
S11
4194-1
Patricia Isaac
Urban
(South)
S11
4202-3
Marjory J Clark
Urban
(South)
S11
4202-4
Marjory J Clark
Urban
(South)
S11
4205-6
John Oliver
Urban
(South)
S11
4209-2
Olga K Mason
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
No change
No
No
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Hill Park
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS, MHU
SH
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support the inclusion of a new transition zone around Hill Park - the sites in question are in
close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development.
MHU in this location provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the
area. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support the inclusion of a new transition zone around Hill Park - the sites in question are in
close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development.
MHU in this location provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the
area. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support the inclusion of a new transition zone around Hill Park - the sites in question are in
close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development.
MHU in this location provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the
area. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to MHU, support change to THAB. The site is within close proximity to
the Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station and can support more intensive growth.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS. This is an
out of scope change - please see Attachment F.
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS, MHU
SH
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS and MHU to SH - the sites in question are in close
No change
proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. The
use of MHU and MHS zones provides a transition in density moving away from the Town Centre. The
notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS and MHU zones and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS, MHU
SH
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Hill Park
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS and MHU to SH - the sites in question are in close
proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. The
use of MHU and MHS zones provides a transition in density moving away from the Town Centre. The
notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS and MHU zones and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
48, EDINBURGH
AVENUE, Rosehill
Page 3
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
4274-96
SUBMITTER
NAME
TOPIC
Minister of Police Urban
(Attn: Justine
(South)
Bray)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone around Weymouth Town Area around
Centre from Mixed Housing
Weymouth Town
Suburban to Terrace Housing and Centre
Apartment Buildings as detailed
on page 5/17 [Vol 5] of
submission
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
THAB Isolated or new
Clendon Park
areas
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Do not support a change to THAB for the blocks located to the south east of Clendon Park Local
Centre crossing to the Local Centre from these areas is not a safe pedestrian environment. MHU
will provide a more appropriate level of intensification for this area. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
4274-99
S11
Centres/Terrace
TC
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 162, CHICHESTER
162, CHICHESTER
Any residential
Papakura - Sout SH
DRIVE, Rosehill from Single
DRIVE, Rosehill
properties subject to a
House to Mixed Housing Urban.
key overlay
Rezone 2/65,1/65, CHICHESTER 2/65,1/65,
Any residential
Papakura - Sout SH
DRIVE, Rosehill from Single
CHICHESTER DRIVE, properties subject to a
House to Mixed Housing Urban.
Rosehill
key overlay
TC
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No change
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
Flooding
constraints
No
No
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change to MHU, however support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing
flooding risks on this site does not require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate to
maintain the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
MHS
MHU
No change
No
No
54,1/52-6/52,
Any residential
AIRFIELD ROAD,254, properties subject to a
PORCHESTER ROAD, key overlay
Takanini
Takinini
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No change
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHU at 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15 and 17 Matawalu Place, and 15
Manuroa Road where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH
zone. The sites are in close proximitiy to the RFN. MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
SH/MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S12
4702-3
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
4702-5
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
Rezone
4/10,3/10,6/10,6,1/13,2/13,2/10,1/
10,1/17,2/17,2/14,2/15,1/7,1/5,9,6
/5,3/5,8,5/10,2/5,2/7,11,5/5,4/5,1/
15,1/14, MATAWALU PLACE,1/56/5,1/15-5/15, MANUROA ROAD,
Takanini from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
4/10,3/10,6/10,6,1/13,2
/13,2/10,1/10,1/17,2/17
,2/14,2/15,1/7,1/5,9,6/5
,3/5,8,5/10,2/5,2/7,11,5
/5,4/5,1/15,1/14,
MATAWALU
PLACE,1/5-6/5,1/155/15, MANUROA
ROAD, Takanini
Rezone 4,4A, PRINCESS
4,4A, PRINCESS
STREET,5/2,1/2,4/2,7/2,3/2,6/2,2/ STREET,5/2,1/2,4/2,7/
2, STATION ROAD, Takanini from 2,3/2,6/2,2/2,
Single House to Mixed Housing
STATION ROAD,
Urban.
Takanini
Rezone 5A,5, STATION ROAD,
5A,5, STATION ROAD,
Takanini from Single House to
Takanini
Mixed Housing Urban.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
N/A
Kumaran Nair
Kumaran Nair
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
4912-1
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Clendon
Residents Group
(Attn: Shiri Te
Whatu)
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Do not support change from SH to MHU at the remaining properties - the sites are affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
RETAIN; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Support retention of MHS in part - areas surrounding the Clendon Park Local Centre are suited to be THAB, MHU, Yes
rezoned to THAB and MHU to create a compact urban form, refer to Attachment F for out of scope
MHS
changes. Properties not within walking distance to Clendon Park Local Centre should remain MHS.
The rezoning, as shown in Attachment E - S11a proposed zoning map, is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the MHS, MHU and THAB zones and gives effect to the RPS.
No
46,46A, MANUROA
ROAD, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
2/48,2/52,2/50,1/408/40,1/52,1/50,1/48,
STATION ROAD,
Takanini
76B,76A,78A,78B,78,
MANUROA
ROAD,50B,50C,50A,
TAKANINI SCHOOL
ROAD, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
42A,44,42,44A, TAKA
STREET, Takanini
Page 4
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
5176-1
SUBMITTER
NAME
Bruce Ringer
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone "The Gardens,
Manurewa" subdivision adjacent
to 26 Charles Prevost Drive from
Mixed Housing Suburban to
Single House [pg 2/7 Vol 1]
S11
Rezoneland around Clendon
LocalCentre,Manurewaas
shown in the submission [refer to
page 37/104] fromMixed Housing
Suburbanto Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB Isolated or new
areas
Clendon Park
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Yes
No
Do not support a change to THAB for the blocks located to the south east of Clendon Park Local
Centre, support alternative change to MHU crossing to the Local Centre from these areas is not a
safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide a more appropriate level of intensification for this
area. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
5277-206 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
S11
S11
S11
2 Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 4
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 6
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 8
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 10
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 12
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 14
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 16
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa;
Manurewa
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MU
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
TC, THAB,
Unspecified
MHU, MHS,
SH, LI, MU, SP,
STC,POS, NC
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
Manurewa
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The THAB
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Yes
No
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of TC zone as notified. Retention of the TC is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the TC zone and gives effect to the centres hierachy/strategy in the RPS.
No
No
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support change of properties at 33, 35, 37 Halver Road, Manurewa and 14A, 16, 20 Alfriston Road,
Manurewa from MHU to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
THAB and
TC
Do not support change of 14 Halver Road, Manurewa from MHU to THAB. Support change of the
zone to TC the owner of this property has requested the change as the property is currently used
as parking for the adjoining property zoned TC. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the TC zone and gives effect to the RPS. Scope provided by submission 881-7,
refer to Attachment D.
5277-209 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
S11
S11
S11
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHU
THAB and SP
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as THAB
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Unspecified
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support change of properties at 7, 11, 15 ,17, 19, 25 and 27 Alfriston Road from MHU to THAB these sites are located in close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
THAB
Do not support change of zone of the remaining properties. Increasing the size of the
Neighbourhood Centre, will not give effect to the RPS, including the centres/hierarchy. MHU is an
appropriate zone for the properties on the east side of the block as it provides a good transition
between THAB and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MU
Flooding
constraints
Page 5
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support the change from THAB to MU - The sites are in close proximity to the Manurewa Town
MU
Centre and RFN, which achieves the MU zone objectives. The area is also surrounded on three
sides by LI and therefore MU is a more appropriate zone and will correct the spot zoning of THAB.
The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
TOPIC
5277-212 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-213 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-214 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-215 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-217 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezoneland onJutland
Road,Manurewaas shown in the
submission [refer to page 39/104]
from Light Industry to rationalise
the distribution of Light Industry
and Mixed Housing Suburban.
S11
Rezone land on Churchill Avenue
and Russell Road, Manurewa as
shown in the submission [refer to
page 39/104] from Mixed Housing
Urban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
S11
Rezone land on Corin Avenue
and Kelvyn Grove, Manurewa as
shown in the submission [refer to
page 39/104] from Mixed Housing
Urban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
S11
Rezoneland onClaude Way and
Fleming Street,Manurewaas
shown in the submission [refer to
page 40/104] from Single House
and Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone land between Redoubt
Road and Orams Road, Manukau
as shown in the submission [refer
to page 40/104] from Single
House to Mixed Housing
Suburban [to remove Single
House spot Zoning].
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
Land adjacent to 12
Jellicoe Road,
Manurewa
S11
Browns Road,
Roscommon Road,
Weymouth
Road,Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Business to other
Manurewa
Business Zone
(excludes mixed use
and centres zones)
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
LI
MHS
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SH
MHS
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
The Gardens
MHS
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Support change of zone from MHU to THAB - The sites are within close proximity to the Manurewa
THAB
Town Centre and RFN. One site is affected by flooding constraints, however if this site was excluded
from the zoning change, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally
achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Support change to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The THAB
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Yes
No
Yes
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH and MHS to MHU - the sites are in close proximity to the Manurewa MHU
Town Centre, Manurewa Train Station, POS and a RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC),
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support the rezoning of sites in The Gardens from SH to MHS where managing flooding risks on
those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on
S11a proposed rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change to MHU, support change to THAB. The site is within close proximity to the
THAB
Yes
CHANGE; SUPPORT Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station and can support more intensive growth.
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS. This is an
out of scope change - please see Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN PART;
Support the rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS or MHU where managing flooding risks
SH and MHS Yes
PARTIAL CHANGE
on those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on
S11a proposed rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
Do not support rezoning of sites in The Gardens from SH to MHS where the sites are affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS where managing flooding risks on those
sites does not require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on S11a
proposed rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS where the sites are affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU or MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
No
Do not support rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS or MHU where the sites are affected
by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
5277-221 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
S11
S11
S11
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support the rezoning of sites from SH to MHU where managing flooding risks on those sites does not SH, MHS
require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on S11a proposed
and MHU
rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
Do not support rezoning of sites from SH to MHU where the sites are affected by flooding constraints
and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of 150, 152, 154, 156, 158, 168, 170, 172 Russell Road from MHS to MHU the
MHU
sites are within close proximity to Homai Train Station and POS and are suitable for intensification.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Support change of 160, 162, 164, 166 Russell Road from SH to MHU the sites are within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and POS and are suitable for intensification. Managing flooding
risks on the sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Manurewa
SH, MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of properties at 32A, 32B, 34, 36, 38, 44, 46, 48, 50 Jellicoe Road from MHS MHS
CHANGE; SUPPORT to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS
Do not support change of properties at 2, 4, 6 Marr Road from SH to THAB. Support a less intensive
zone of MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The
proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Page 6
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
TOPIC
5277-225 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
THAB
Regional Parks
Precinct
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone land on Hill Road,
Manurewa as shown in the
submission [refer to page 42/104]
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
S13
Rezone 60, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill from Single
House to Mixed Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
120 and 121 Hill Road, THAB Isolated or new
The Gardens
The Gardens
areas
60, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
N/A
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
29, TAIRERE
CRESCENT, Rosehill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
N/A
155, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
Flooding
constraints
10, JADON
CLOSE,37A,37C,37B,
37, TAKANINI
SCHOOL ROAD,
Takanini
Area around the
Clendon Park Local
Centre
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S12
S11
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites
as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support a change of zone to THAB for the sites directly adjoining Clendon Park Local Centre, as
THAB and
shown on S11a proposed rezoning map in Attachment E the sites are located around the Clendon MHU
Park Local Centre and POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density in this location will
promote a walkable neighbourhood and could improve the vitality of the centre. The area is not
currently serviced by a RFN, however it is connected by buses to Manurewa Train Station. Managing
flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Do not support a change to THAB for the blocks located to the south east of Clendon Park Local
Centre, support alternative change to MHU crossing to the Local Centre from these areas is not a
safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide a more appropriate level of intensification for this
area. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
5280-208 The New Zealand Urban
Institute of
(South)
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
S11
S11
S11
Rezoneland on Halver
Road,Manurewaas shown in the
submission [refer to page 38/104]
fromMixedHousing Urbanto
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings
2 Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 4
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 6
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 8
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 10
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 12
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 14
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa; 16
Beaumonts Way,
Manurewa;
Manurewa
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MU
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
TC, THAB,
Unspecified
MHU, MHS,
SH, LI, MU, SP,
STC,POS, NC
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
Manurewa
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as THAB
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Manurewa Town Centre Concept Plan was taken into account and the Local Board was
No change
consulted on the draft and PAUP. The zoning proposed in and around the Town Centre provides for
further intensification and revitalisation of the Centre. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way
to achieve the zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support change of properties at 33, 35, 37 Halver Road, Manurewa and 14A, 16, 20 Alfriston Road,
Manurewa from MHU to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Yes
No
THAB and
TC
Do not support change of 14 Halver Road, Manurewa from MHU to THAB. Support change of the
zone to TC the owner of this property has requested the change as the property is currently used
as parking for the adjoining property zoned TC. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the TC zone and gives effect to the RPS. Scope provided by submission 881-7,
refer to Attachment D.
5280-211 The New Zealand Urban
Institute of
(South)
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
S11
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHU
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Page 7
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as THAB
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
TOPIC
5280-212 The New Zealand Urban
Institute of
(South)
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezoneland around Tadmor and
Gallaher Parks,Manurewaas
shown in the submission [refer to
page 38/104] fromMixedHousing
Urbanand Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings to Zoning
which is the result of a
comprehensive plan for the area.
Submission point seeks an
increase in THAB
S11
Rezone land on Beatty Way,
Manurewa as shown in the
submission [refer to page 39/104]
from Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings to Mixed Use
S11
S11
S11
S11
S11
S11
S11
S11
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHU
Unspecified
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
REASONS
Support change of properties at 7, 11, 15 ,17, 19, 25 and 27 Alfriston Road from MHU to THAB these sites are located in close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
MU
Yes
No
Do not support change of the remaining properties. Increasing the size of the Neighbourhood
Centre, will not give effect to the RPS, including the centres/hierarchy. MHU is an appropriate zone
for the properties on the east side of the block as it provides a good transition between THAB and
MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
2 Beatty Avenue,
Manurewa; 2A Beatty
Avenue, Manurewa; 2B
Beatty Avenue,
Manurewa; 2C Beatty
Avenue, Manurewa; 4
Beatty Avenue,
Manurewa; 4A Beatty
Avenue, Manurewa; 4B
Beatty Avenue,
Manurewa; 4C Beatty
Avenue, Manurewa;
Rezoneland onJutland
Land adjacent to 12
Road,Manurewaas shown in the Jellicoe Road,
submission [refer to page 39/104] Manurewa
from Light Industry to rationalise
the distribution of Light Industry
and Mixed Housing Suburban.
Rezoneland on Churchill Avenue Russell Road and
and Russell Road,Manurewaas Churchill Ave,
shown in the submission [refer to Manurewa
page 39/104] from Mixed Housing
Urban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Rezone land on Corin Avenue
Corin Ave and Kelvyn
and Kelvyn Grove, Manurewa as Grove, Manurewa
shown in the submission [refer to
page 39/104] from Mixed Housing
Urban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Rezoneland onClaude Way and Claude Road and
Fleming Street,Manurewaas
Fleming Street,
shown in the submission [refer to Manurewa
page 40/104] from Single House
and Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezoneland between Redoubt
Area between Redoubt
Road and Orams
Road and Orams
Road,Manukauas shown in the Road, Manukau
submission [refer to page 40/104]
from Single Houseto Mixed
Housing Suburban [to remove
Single House spot Zoning].
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
THAB
MU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support the change from THAB to Mixed Use - The sites are in close proximity to the Manurewa
Town Centre and RFN, which achieves the MU zone objectives. The area is also surrounded on
three sides by LI and therefore MU is a more appropriate zone and will correct the spot zoning of
THAB. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Business to other
Business Zone
(excludes mixed use
and centres zones)
LI
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from LI to MHS. The land is adjacent to the rail line and is better
No change
suited to non-residential land uses. Additionally, the property is not designated as part of the rail
network and should not be zoned STC, as outlined in the Council's evidence on Topic 080 - Strategic
Transport Corridor. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the LI
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Yes
No
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHU to THAB - The sites are within close proximity to the Manurewa
THAB
Town Centre and RFN. One site is affected by flooding constraints, however if this site was excluded
from the zoning change, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally
achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Support change to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The THAB
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Yes
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH and MHS to MHU - the sites are in close proximity to the Manurewa MHU
Town Centre, Manurewa Train Station, POS and a RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC),
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support the rezoning of sites in The Gardens from SH to MHS where managing flooding risks on
those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on
S11a proposed rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change to MHU, support change to THAB. The site is within close proximity to the
THAB
Yes
CHANGE; SUPPORT Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station and can support more intensive growth.
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS. This is an
out of scope change - please see Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN PART;
Support the rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS or MHU where managing flooding risks
SH and MHS Yes
PARTIAL CHANGE
on those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on
S11a proposed rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
Browns Road,
Roscommon Road,
Weymouth
Road,Manurewa
Manurewa
The Gardens
MHU or MHS
Do not support rezoning of sites in The Gardens from SH to MHS where the sites are affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS where managing flooding risks on those
sites does not require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on S11a
proposed rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS where the sites are affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU or MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
No
Do not support rezoning of sites in Manurewa from SH to MHS or MHU where the sites are affected
by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
5280-223 The New Zealand Urban
Institute of
(South)
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
S11
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support the rezoning of sites from SH to MHU where managing flooding risks on those sites does not SH, MHS
require maintaining a SH zone or where spot zoning is avoided, as shown on S11a proposed
and MHU
rezoning map in Attachment E. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support rezoning of sites from SH to MHU where the sites are affected by flooding constraints
and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Page 8
Yes
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
TOPIC
5280-224 The New Zealand Urban
Institute of
(South)
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
150, 152, 154, 156,
158, 160, 162, 164,
166, 168, 170, 172
Russell Road,
Manurewa
S11
The Gardens
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S12
5393-1
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S12
Planner's Position
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezoneland on Jutland Road,
Kent Road, Oxford Road and
Russell Road,Manurewaas
shown in the submission [refer to
page 41/104] from Single House
and Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Suburban and
Mixed Housing Urban
Gary J Blyth
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S12
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Support change of 160, 162, 164, 166 Russell Road from SH to MHU the sites are within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and POS and are suitable for intensification. Managing flooding
risks on the sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Manurewa
SH, MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of properties at 32A, 32B, 34, 36, 38, 44, 46, 48, 50 Jellicoe Road from MHS MHS
CHANGE; SUPPORT to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS
Yes
No
Do not support change of properties at 2, 4, 6 Marr Road from SH to THAB. Support a less intensive
zone of MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The
proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS
THAB
Regional Parks
Precinct
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites
as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHU
N/A
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
3,2,5,4,6, GYPSY
Any residential
MOTH
properties subject to a
PLACE,46,56,50,52,
key overlay
CHICHESTER DRIVE,
Rosehill
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Do not support change to MHU, however support change of zone from SH to MHS at 6 Gypsy Moth MHS
Place. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. Support
retention of notified zone for reminder of properties. Retention of the MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. They are not in close proximitiy to centres and
it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
55,57,53,
Any residential
CHICHESTER DRIVE, properties subject to a
Rosehill
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
NGC
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No
No
74,72, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Yes
No
24,25,26,27,20,21,22,2
3,28,3,5,7,6,9,8,11,13,
12,15,14,17,16,19,18,
JADON CLOSE,14,
AIRFIELD ROAD,
Takanini
Area bound by Hill
Road, The Botanical
Gardens, Totara Park
and Mill Road,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS at 72 Chichester Drive. Managing flooding risks on this site MHS
does not require maintaining a SH zone. Site is not close to a centre. MHS is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. Support retention of
notified zone for reminder of properties.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to SH - there are no constraints over the area that would
No change
require SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a
centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
1/260,1/258Any residential
3/258,2/260,
properties subject to a
PORCHESTER
key overlay
ROAD,1/4,1/2,1/8,2/8,
6,2/12,1/12,2/10,1/10,2
/4,2/2,2/14,1/14,
CLARICE PLACE,
Takanini
Takinini
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 2/12, 14 Clarice Place the sites No change
are affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
11,13, JUPITER
STREET, Rosehill
MHU
N/A
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Takinini
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 271, 271A, 273A, 279A, 279B, 279E Porchester SH, MHS
Road, support alternative change to MHS Although the SH zone could be applied due to the sites
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Rezoning to MHS zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
No change
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU at 258, 260 Porchester Road and 2 Clarice Place MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and
it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SH, MHS
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU at 279C and 279D Porchester Road - MHS is the
most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Page 9
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone Mixed Housing Urban
properties that immediately adjoin
a Single House zone to Mixed
Housing Suburban, particularly in
Hill Park, Manurewa.
S11
Reject Mixed Housing Urban at
108 and 152 Great South Road,
12 and 16 Kelvyn Grove and
between 6 and 10 Hill Road,
Manurewa. [Inferred to want
Zoning to be Mixed Housing
Suburban as it was in the March
Draft].
SUB
POINT
5646-14
SUBMITTER
NAME
TOPIC
Hill Park
Urban
Residents
(South)
Association (Attn:
Jennifer Parlane)
5646-2
Hill Park
Urban
Residents
(South)
Association (Attn:
Jennifer Parlane)
5646-3
Hill Park
Urban
Residents
(South)
Association (Attn:
Jennifer Parlane)
S11
5646-8
Hill Park
Urban
Residents
(South)
Association (Attn:
Jennifer Parlane)
S11
Urban
(South)
S12
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB
MHS
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from THAB to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU, THAB
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU and THAB to MHS - the sites in question are in close
No change
proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An
additional height in relation to boundary control applies when a site in a MHU or THAB zone abuts a
site in the SH zone, providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU and THAB zones and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH, MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 278 Porchester Road the site is affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Takinini
SH, MHS
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 282, 276 Porchester Road, support alternative
change to MHS - Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Rezoning to MHS zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU at 274, 280, 1/280, 2/280, 284 Porchester Road MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and
it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
5703-14
Glen Frost
Urban
(South)
S11
5703-2
Glen Frost
Urban
(South)
S11
5703-3
Glen Frost
Urban
(South)
S11
5703-8
Glen Frost
Urban
(South)
S11
5709-1
S11
Hill Park
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No change
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB
MHS
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from THAB to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU, THAB
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU and THAB to MHS - the sites in question are in close
No change
proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An
additional height in relation to boundary control applies when a site in a MHU or THAB zone abuts a
site in the SH zone, providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU and THAB zones and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
No
No
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
NGC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
Urban
(South)
S13
87,85, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Page 10
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7327 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
57162987
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 47,45,51,53,49, PARK
ESTATE
ROAD,147,145,1/143,141,149,13
3,131,137,135,2/143,129,139,
CHICHESTER
DRIVE,11,10,13,12,20,22,16,18,3,
5,7,24,9,8, JOANNE PLACE,
Rosehill from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S13
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
Rezone
1/144,150,152,1/140,154,1/142,2/
126,2/128,1/128,2/140,120,122,2/
142,1/126,138,2/144,
CHICHESTER DRIVE, Rosehill
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone 25 and 31 Halver Road,
Manurewa (Lot 5 DP 45123, Lot 8
DP 45123) from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban. Refer to
submission, Volume 4, page
14/35 and Attachment 713,
Volume 20.
Rezone 165,163, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 1 BERWYN AVENUE.
Takanini from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Any residential
MHU
N/A
Papakura - Sout SH, MHS
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change to MHU, support change to THAB. The site is within close proximity to the
CHANGE; SUPPORT Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station and can support more intensive growth.
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS. This is an
out of scope change - please see Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
165,163,
Any residential
CHICHESTER DRIVE, properties subject to a
Rosehill
key overlay
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
54 TAKANINI
SCHOOL ROAD.
Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
S12
Takinini
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
62, CHICHESTER
DRIVE, Rosehill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
N/A
4012-1
D E Nakhle
Investment Trust
(Attn: Brian Putt)
Urban
(South)
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
57163011
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
PROPOSED GIS MAP
ZONE
POSITION
REASONS
CHANGE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change to MHU, however support change of zone at 49 Park Estate Road from SH to MHS
Yes
CHANGE; SUPPORT MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Support retention
ALTERNATIVE ZONE of SH for 137, 139, 141, 143, 145, 147, 149 Chichester Drive, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 16, 18, 20, 22, 24
Joanne Place and 51, 55 Park Estate Road as they are significantly affected by flooding constraints.
Support retention of the MHS zone for 45, 47 Park Estate Road, 3, 8, 10 and 12 Joanne Place and
129, 131, 133 amd 135 Chichester Drive as the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Yes
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support alternative change to MHS - Although the
MHS
SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would
occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of
resources and does not recognise the local context. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. Rezoning to MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Yes
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Support change of zone from SH to MHU at 120 Porchester Road - managing flooding risks on the
site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The site is in close proximitiy to a RFN. Rezoning to
MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
SH/MHU
Yes
No
THAB
Do not support change from SH to MHU at 130 Porchester Road - the site is affected by flooding
constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
1/81, 2/81 CLARK
ROAD. Pahurehure
2/2, 1/2 ROSEHILL
DRIVE. Rosehill
1/19,2/19,
SUNNYPARK
AVENUE, Rosehill.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
10, MARYBETH
Mixed Housing
PLACE, Rosehill
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
121,123,121A,
Mixed Housing
CHICHESTER DRIVE, Urban/Mixed Housing
Rosehill
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
56, TATARIKI
Spot Zoning
STREET, Rosehill
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change to MHU, however support change of zone from SH to MHS. It maintains the
planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
Papakura - Sout SH
MHS
N/A
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHS
N/A
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Page 11
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5188 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
Papakura - Sout MHS
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 56, TATARIKI STREET,
Rosehill from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
56, TATARIKI
STREET, Rosehill
12 Sheriff Place,
Randwick Park
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
The Gardens
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - managing flooding risks on the site does not require
MHS
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to
a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
69 Palmers Road,
Clendon Park
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHS to SH - this sites is affected by flooding constraints and rezoning
to SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
SH
Yes
No
50 Coxhead Road,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from MHS to SH - The site is affected by flooding constraints and rezoning to SH
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
SH
Yes
No
Clendon Park
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
2 Landette Road,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHS to SH - this sites is affected by flooding constraints and rezoning
to SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
SH
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support a change of zone to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in
MHS
close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been
provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of
growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should
also be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
24 Sharland Avenue,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHS to SH - this sites is affected by flooding constraints and rezoning
to SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
SH
Yes
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
57163022
S11
57163023
S11
57163024
S11
57163025
S11
57163026
S11
57163027
S11
57163028
S11
57163030
S11
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S12
7, BRAEBURN
PLACE, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
1/62,2/62,1/64,2/64,
TIRONUI ROAD,
Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
Rezone 1/62,2/62,1/64,2/64,
TIRONUI ROAD, Takanini from
Single House to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 24, GOODWIN DRIVE,
Rosehill from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to THAB, support alternative change to MHU - managing
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. MHU aligns with the zoning
ALTERNATIVE ZONE immediately east of the railway line as far east as Porchester Road between the Takanini Town
Centre and the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. Rezoning to MHU is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
RETENTION OF
and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
RETENTION OF
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
NOTIFIED ZONE
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
Page 12
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5503 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S13
Rezone 22, TAIRERE
22, TAIRERE
CRESCENT, Rosehill from Mixed CRESCENT, Rosehill
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
Papakura - Sout MHS
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
S13
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
3, JUPITER
STREET,25A,
EDINBURGH
AVENUE, Rosehill
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Rezone 3, JUPITER
STREET,25A, EDINBURGH
AVENUE, Rosehill from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 19,17, EDINBURGH
AVENUE, Rosehill from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
19,17, EDINBURGH
AVENUE, Rosehill
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
57163068
S11
25 Marr Road,
Manurewa
Errors
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from MHS to MHU - corrects the small portion of land that was incorrectly zoned
MHU
MHS. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Yes
No
57163069
S11
Errors
Clendon Park
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to SH and support change to POS - the subject parcel and
CHANGE; SUPPORT surrounding properties have now been zoned POS. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
ALTERNATIVE ZONE achieve the objectives of the POS zone and gives effect to the RPS. Scope provided by submission
5716-2138, refer to Attachment D5 of the joint evidence of C Stewat, A Reidy, L Deverall and J Cox
on Topic 080c Rezoning and Precincts - Public Open Space.
Yes
No
57163072
S11
10 Nield Road,
Manurewa
Errors
Manurewa
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of driveway to SH zone. Support change of zone of 10 Nield Road as
MHS
managing the flood risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning to MHS is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
57163073
S11
12 Coxhead Road,
Manurewa
Errors
Manurewa
Road
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from Road to MHU - corrects the small portion of land that was incorrectly zoned
MHU
Road. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Yes
No
57163074
S11
Manurewa SouthRoad
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from Road to MHS - corrects the small portion of land that was incorrectly zoned
MHS
Road. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Yes
No
Page 13
POS
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
57163076
SUBMITTER
NAME
TOPIC
Auckland Council Urban
(Attn: Stephen
(South)
Town)
57163077
Urban
(South)
57163099
57163101
S11
57163553
S11
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Errors
Manurewa
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Road
MHS
N/A
36 Myers Road,
Manurewa
Errors
Road
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from Road to MHS - corrects the small portion of land that was incorrectly zoned
MHS
Road. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Yes
No
39,43,41, ROSEHILL
DRIVE, Rosehill
Mixed Housing
Papakura - Sout MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
Errors
The Gardens
MHU
N/A
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of driveway to SH zone. The notified zone was a mapping error but this no
MHS
longer needs to be corrected given the adjacent sites has had a change of zone to MHS. The zoning
of the driveway now matches the adjacent zone.
No
No
Errors
Clendon Park
Road
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from Road to MHS - corrects the small portion of land that was incorrectly zoned
MHS
Road. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Yes
No
Errors
Manurewa
Road
NC
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change from Road to NC - corrects the small portion of land that was incorrectly zoned
Road. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the NC zone and gives
effect to the RPS
Yes
No
SH, MHS,
MHU, THAB
SH, MHS,
MHU, THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
SH, MHS,
Yes
MHU, THAB
No
Rezone 18,20,14,16,
EDINBURGH AVENUE, Rosehill
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone area to the west of
theSingle Housezone on Scenic
Drive, Manurewafrom Mixed
Housing Urban to Mixed Housing
Suburban [refers to properties
between Great South Road and
Scenic Drive].
Rezone area around Te Mahia rail
station to 3-4 storey terraced
homes.
18,20,14,16,
EDINBURGH
AVENUE, Rosehill
Mixed Housing
Papakura - Sout SH, MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
MHU
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
SH/MHS
Yes
No
MHS
Flooding
constraints
No change
No
No
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support a change of zone to THAB - The properties are in close proximity to Te Mahia Train
No change
Station, however Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification here may compete
with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for surrounding
Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for intensification. The notified zoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
10 Banksia Place,
Goodwood Heights
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
MHS
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone part of 19 and 23 Scotts
Road, Manurewa (LOT 189 DP
47154 & LOT 3 DP 39260 and
LOT 190 DP 47154 & LOT 4 DP
39260) from Single Housing to
Mixed Housing Suburban. Refer
to submission, Volume 4, page
19/35 and Attachment 784,
Volume 21.
S11
Rezone part of 36 Myers Road,
Manurewa (Lot 191 DP 47771)
from Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban. Refer to
submission, Volume 4, page
19/35 and Attachment 785,
Volume 21.
S13
Rezone 39,43,41, ROSEHILL
DRIVE, Rosehill from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone part of 124 Alfriston
Road, Manurewa (Lot 3 DP
151506) from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Single House. Refer
to submission, Volume 4, page
20/35 and Attachment 807,
Volume 21.
S11
Rezone Section 1 SO 344643
(225 Weymouth Road, Manurewa)
from Road to Mixed Housing
Suburban. Refer to submission,
Volume 4, page 20/35 and
Attachment 808, Volume 21.
57163098
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support in part, as shown on S11a proposed rezoning map in Attachment E - As the objectives and
policies of the zones have been amended since the notified PAUP through the hearing process, the
zoning layout has been adapted to suit these new objectives. Where managing flooding risks on a
site does not require maintaining a SH zone, the zoning has been amended from SH to MHS, MHU
or THAB. Submissions that seek a change of zone have also been considered and where the request
is an appropriate zone we have amended the zoning for a number of properties. In some cases the
adjacent area has also been rezoned to avoid spot zoning and create a logical zoning pattern.
Auckland Transport have also provided more detailed information around the RFN that has enabled
a change of zone to take place to support the delivery of the public transport network. These updates
have lead to further intensification of parts of Manurewa, particularly around the centres. These
zonings are the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zones and gives effect to the
RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support rezoning of 20 Edinburgh Avenue from SH to MHS where managing flooding risk does not
CHANGE; SUPPORT require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is appropriate given the site is not in close proximity to a centre
ALTERNATIVE ZONE or a RFN. The MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the
CHANGE; SUPPORT Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
RETENTION OF
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
NOTIFIED ZONE
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Urban
(South)
S13
5746-1
Urban
(South)
S11
5752-2
John D Turner
Urban
(South)
S11
5789-7
GJ Mathieson
Family Trust and
Marrah Trust
(Attn: Graeme
Mathieson)
Joanna E
Mawdsley
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Daniel Marshall
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
5799-1
5803-1
26, JUPITER
Spot Zoning
STREET,23, TAIRERE
CRESCENT, Rosehill
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 14
NC
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
5913-2
SUBMITTER
NAME
Anurag Rasela
6082-6
Marilyn
McPherson
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 57 Senator Drive,
57 Senator Drive,
Manurewa [from Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Suburban] to either
MixedHousingUrban or Terrace
Housing and ApartmentBuildings.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
THAB or MHU N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
Urban
(South)
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Takinini
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to THAB at 15 Tironui Station Road East - this site is
SH/MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to
ALTERNATIVE ZONE achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Yes
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to THAB at 13A Tironui Station Road East, support
alternative change to MHU - managing flooding risks on the sites does not require maintaining a SH
zone. Site is close to RFN and MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
6230-34
The Department
of Corrections
Urban
(South)
S11
6257-29
Rockgas Limited
(Attn: Rosemary
Dixon)
Urban
(South)
S11
6417-2
Judith Frost
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S12
6417-7
Judith Frost
Urban
(South)
S11
6552-15
NZ Landcare
Urban
Trust (Attn: Trudy (South)
Rankin)
S11
6552-2
NZ Landcare
Urban
Trust (Attn: Trudy (South)
Rankin)
S11
57163054
Urban
(South)
S13
S12
Urban
(South)
S13
20 Beatty Avenue,
Manurewa
Special Purpose
Manurewa
STC
LI
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support a change to LI - the site is currently used as a corrections facility and should not be zoned
LI
as a STC. Light Industry is an appropriate zone for the site. The rezoning is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the LI zone and gives effect to the RPS
Yes
No
112-116 Weymouth
Road, Manurewa
MHU
LI
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to LI - spot zoning in this location will not generally achieve No change
integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. Current land use as a
service station can rely on existing use rights or obtain resource consent. The notified zoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHU - managing flooding risks on the sites does not require
MHU
maintaining a SH zone. MHU aligns with the zoning immediately east of the railway line as far east as
Porchester Road between the Takanini Town Centre and the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. MHU is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Hill Park
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU, THAB
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU and THAB to MHS - the sites in question are in close
No change
proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An
additional height in relation to boundary control applies when a site in a MHU or THAB zone abuts a
site in the SH zone, providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU and THAB zones and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Hill Park
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. An additional height
in relation to boundary control applies when a site in the MHU zone abuts a site in the SH zone,
providing a transition in height between the zones. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHU to SH to correct map error and split zoning. Driveway is zoned
MHU and rear property is zoned SH. Rear property should be retained as SH as it is affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
31 Takanini Road,
Takanini
47, TATARIKI
Spot Zoning
STREET,10,12,
TAIRERE CRESCENT,
Rosehill
Takinini
MHU
Page 15
SH
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7330 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
6552-3
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
NZ Landcare
Urban
Trust (Attn: Trudy (South)
Rankin)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
Papakura - Sout MHS
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 22, ORCHARD
RISE,2/29,1/29, ROYSTON
STREET, Rosehill from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S13
Rezone 20 ORCHARD RISE.
Rosehill from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
22, ORCHARD
RISE,2/29,1/29,
ROYSTON STREET,
Rosehill
20 ORCHARD RISE.
Rosehill
Spot Zoning
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It maintains the planned suburban built Rosehill character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Also do not support change to MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not
generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
THAB
MHS
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from THAB to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. MHU aligns with the zoning immediately west of No change
the railway line as far west as Great South Road north of the Takanini Town Centre. The notified
zoning maintains the planned character of this zone. Otherwise, a spot zone would occur and in this
location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not
recognise the local context. Retaining the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to MHS - the sites in question are in close proximity to the No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN and are suitable for intensive development. MHU in this location
RETENTION OF
provides a transition in density from the THAB and MHS zoned properties in the area. The notified
NOTIFIED ZONE
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH/MHU to THAB, which is sought for six blocks on the western MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT side of the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. Change of zone to MHU is supported for the all SH sites in
ALTERNATIVE ZONE the block contained by Union Street/Menary Street/Wellington Street/Ray Small Drive; 9 and 9A
Menary Street is affected by flooding constraints and although the SH zone could be retained, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. For the remaining SH sites,
managing flooding risk does not require maintaining a SH zone. The Papakura character and
intensity is most suited to MHU in this location rather than THAB, and also because of the distance to
Papakura railway station. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - a spot zone would occur and in this location a
No change
spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
the local context. MHU aligns with the zoning immediately west of the railway line as far west as
Great South Road north of the Takanini Town Centre. Retaining the MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH/MHU to THAB, which is sought for six blocks on the western MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT side of the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. Change of zone to MHU is supported for the all SH sites in
ALTERNATIVE ZONE the block contained by Union Street/Menary Street/Wellington Street/Ray Small Drive; 9 and 9A
Menary Street is affected by flooding constraints and although the SH zone could be retained, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. For the remaining SH sites,
managing flooding risk does not require maintaining a SH zone. The Papakura character and
intensity is most suited to MHU in this location rather than THAB, and also because of the distance to
Papakura railway station. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S12
6944-2
Urban
(South)
S11
Claude Road,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
MHS
S13
Centres/Terrace
Papakura
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHU
THAB
Urban
(South)
S12
Block
Queen/Green/Elliot
Street and Ray Small
Drive; block Ray Small
Drive/Elliot
Street/Green
Street/Union Street;
block Union
Street/Menary Street/
Ray Small
Drive/Wellington
Street; block
Wellington/West/Nelso
n Streets and Ray
Small Drive; block
Nelson/West/Duke/We
llington Streets; block
Duke/Nelson/East/Well
ington Streets
8B,8,8A, GLENORA
ROAD, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
S13
Centres/Terrace
Papakura
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
Urban
(South)
S12
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Takinini
MHS
MHU
Takanini Strategic
Area SHA,
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on one of the sites does not require a SH zone. The
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
5712-7
A G Dryden Ltd
Urban
(south)
S12
Business to other
Business Zone
(excludes mixed use
and centres zones)
Takinini
LI
GB or LC
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from LI to GB or LC. The site is near the Takanini Interchange and is No change
subject to NZTA's Southern Corridor NoR to widen the Southern Motorway. Retaining the LI zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS. Rezoning
to GB or LC will not give effect to the criteria in B3.1 of the RPS.
No
No
7129-1
Olivia Brown
Urban
(South)
S11
Block
Queen/Green/Elliot
Street and Ray Small
Drive; block Ray Small
Drive/Elliot
Street/Green
Street/Union Street;
block Union
Street/Menary Street/
Ray Small
Drive/Wellington
Street; block
Wellington/West/Nelso
n Streets and Ray
Small Drive; block
Nelson/West/Duke/We
llington Streets; block
Duke/Nelson/East/Well
ington Streets
Rezone 5, MATHESON
5, MATHESON
STREET,88,84, GROVE
STREET,88,84,
ROAD,11,10,13,12,15,14,17,16,1 GROVE
9,18,3,2,5,4,7,6,9,20,8, CORKILL ROAD,11,10,13,12,15,
PLACE, Papakura from Mixed
14,17,16,19,18,3,2,5,4,
Housing Suburban to Mixed
7,6,9,20,8, CORKILL
Housing Urban.
PLACE, Papakura
Rezone the site at 2-12 Great
2-12 Great South
South Road, Takanini to General Road, Takanini
Business or Local Centre, see
submission 5712 Volume 2 for
details (this has been renotified)
Rezone the area bordered by
Area bound by Orams
Orams Rd, Great South Rd to
Rd, Great South Rd,
Halver and Arthur Rd, Hill Park,
Halver Rd, Arthur Rd
Manurewa back to the motorway and the southern
to Single Dwelling
motorway
MHS, MHU
SH
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support change of zone from MHS to SH - The site is affected by flooding constraints and rezoning
to SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
No
No
Barry J Brown
Takinini
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Takinini
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 16
No change
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1540 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 73, BURUNDI AVENUE,
Clendon Park.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
73, BURUNDI
AVENUE, Clendon
Park
3, HOOKS ROAD,
Manurewa
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa SouthMHS
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
2,2A,2B, CHAPEL
STREET,292A,292B,2
92, GREAT SOUTH
ROAD, Papakura
Centres/Terrace
Papakura
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S12
Business to other
Business Zone
(excludes mixed use
and centres zones)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
S12
1705-1
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of THAB zone. THAB is the most appropriate zone as it is adjacent to Pakuranga
Town Centre and close to the RFN. Retention of the THAB zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the relevant objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
LI
GB
Do not support change of zone from LI to GB. It is noted that Pak N Save operate a supermarket from No change
this site. See Council evidence Topic 051-054 (Centre Zones, Business park and industries zones,
Business activities and Business Controls) about Large Format Retail in Business zones. LI is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the LI zone and gives effect to the RPS. GB zoning
will not give effect to the criteria in B3.1 of the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. A spot zone would occur and in this location a
No change
spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
the local context. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified THAB zone - The site is across the road from a Neighbourhood Centre, No change
adjacent to Gallaher Park, in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. Retention of the
THAB zone gives effects to the objectives and policies of the RPS and is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the THAB zone.
No
No
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Takinini
TC
TC
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
11,11A,11B,
Centres/Terrace
Papakura
PORCHESTER ROAD, Housing Apartment
Takanini
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
25,27B,27,27A,31,29B, Centres/Terrace
Papakura
29,29A,
Housing Apartment
PORCHESTER ROAD, Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Takanini
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified TC zone. The zoning of what is now the Takanini Town Centre and its
No change
extent was debated in Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 12. This plan
change also determined the extent of MU zoning east of the railway line and the location and extent
of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent Environment Court decisions
(most recently in 2012) on this plan change, no alteration to these zonings is proposed. TC is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the TC zone and gives effect to the RPS, including
the centres strategy/hierarchy.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. A spot zone would occur and in this location a
No change
spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
the local context. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
SH, MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Yes
No
25,25A, PRICTOR
STREET, Papakura
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support change of zone of SH to MHU at 31 Porchester Road where managing flooding risks on
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. Support retention of MHU for the remaining
ALTERNATIVE ZONE sites. MHU is the most appropriate zone given the proximity of the block to the Papakura
Metropolitan Centre. North of Ingram Street, MHU is considered more appropriate than THAB
because of its distance from the Papakura Railway Station. The MHU zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. A spot zone would occur and in this location a
No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
RETENTION OF
the local context. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
NOTIFIED ZONE
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Rezone 11,11A,11B,
PORCHESTER ROAD, Takanini
from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Rezone
25,27B,27,27A,31,29B,29,29A,
PORCHESTER ROAD, Takanini
from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Rezone 25,25A, PRICTOR
STREET, Papakura from Mixed
Housing Urban to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Centres/Terrace
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 94, COXHEAD
Mixed Housing
at 94, COXHEAD ROAD,27,
ROAD,27, HOOKS
Urban/Mixed Housing
HOOKS ROAD, Manurewa.
ROAD, Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 21, VOLANTE
Mixed Housing
at 21, VOLANTE AVENUE, Wattle AVENUE, Wattle
Urban/Mixed Housing
Downs.
Downs.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 25, GAINSBOROUGH Any residential
at 25, GAINSBOROUGH
STREET, Manurewa
properties subject to a
STREET, Manurewa.
key overlay
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 22, BERNINA PLACE,
Weymouth.
Takinini
Papakura
Manurewa
Page 17
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. A spot zone would occur and in this location a
spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
the local context. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1569 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Mixed Housing
MHS
N/A
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at 2, 2, RONDORLYN
Mixed Housing
MHU
MHU
N/A
Manurewa
RONDORLYN PLACE,
PLACE, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Use at 1/18-6/18
1/18-6/18 COLES
Centres/Terrace
Papakura
MU
MU
Flooding
COLES CRESCENT. Papakura. CRESCENT. Papakura Housing Apartment
constraints
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 152, COXHEAD
Mixed Housing
MHS
N/A
Manurewa SouthMHS
at 152, COXHEAD ROAD,
ROAD, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 24, BROWNS ROAD, Mixed Housing
MHS
MHS
N/A
Manurewa
at 24, BROWNS ROAD, Wiri.
Wiri
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
20, DREADON ROAD, Mixed Housing
MHU
MHU
N/A
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
20, DREADON ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 10, CAPELLA PLACE, Mixed Housing
MHS
N/A
Manurewa SouthMHS
at 10, CAPELLA PLACE,
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone block of land between
block of land between Any residential
Papakura
SH, MHU
MHU
Flooding
Waitaua Street, Porchester Road, Waitaua Street,
properties subject to a
constraints
Old Wairoa Road and View Road, Porchester Road, Old key overlay
Papakura one contiguous zone of Wairoa Road and View
Mixed housing urban
Road, Papakura
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 7, SENECIO PLACE,
Weymouth.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
7, SENECIO PLACE,
Weymouth
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
2154-1
Dean Martin
Urban
(South)
S13
3400-1
Nigel Smith
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
31, BURBANK
AVENUE, Manurewa.
S13
S13
Fourteen residential
Any residential
properties in northern properties subject to a
part of block bounded key overlay
by Ingram and Prictor
Streets, Clevedon
Road, and railway line.
Urban
(South)
S11
33, FEASEGATE
STREET, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and No change
a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the change of zone of SH sites to MHU for the entire affected block. The SH zones are
MHU
affected by flood constraints. On some sites managining flooding risks does not require maintaining a
SH zone, and they have been rezoned. On others, as although the SH zone could be retained due to
the site(s) being affected by significant flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this
location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not
recognise the local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone given the proximity of the block to the
Papakura Metropolitan Centre. North of Ingram Street, Mixed Housing Urban is considered more
appropriate than THAB because of its distance from the Papakura Railway Station. The MHU zone
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
Support change of zone from SH to MHU. As although the SH zone could be retained due to the site
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the location
context. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHU. 9 and 9A Menary Street is affected by flooding constraints
and although the SH zone could be retained, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot
zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resourecs and does not recognise the
local context. For the remaining SH sites, managing flooding risk does not require maintaining a SH
zone. The Papakura character and intensity is most suited to Mixed Housing Urban in this location
rather than THAB, and also because of the distance to Papakura railway station. The MHU zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
In the block surrounded by Ingram Street, Prictor Street and Vernon Street, change of zone from SH
to THAB is supported where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maitaining a
SH. Where SH could have been retained due to flooding constraints, the THAB is supported zoning
to avoid spot zones. The THAB zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
THAB zone and give effect to the RPS. Support change of zone on 26 and 28 Ingram Street from SH
to MHU. Support change of zone on 2 Renwick Street from SH to MHU. Support change of zone on
12, 17 and 21 Snell Ave from SH to MHU. Support change of zone on 42 Clevedon Road from SH to
MHU. Flooding risk can either be managed without the SH zone or change of zone has occured to
avoid spot zones. Do not support change of zone to THAB on some SH sites along Prictor Street,
however support change of zone to MHU where managing the effects of flooding risk does not
require the retention of SH. THAB is not supported as this would create spot zoning in blocks of
MHU. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SH/MHU/TH Yes
AB
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH
MHU/THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
SH
SH/MHU/THAB Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
N/A
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
220, BROWNS ROAD, Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Wiri.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
15, BILL PHILLIP
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
PLACE, Clendon Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 18
No
Support retention of notified MU zone. The MU zone is appropriate for character of area and its
No change
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and Great South Road. Retaining the notified MU zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone and give effect to the RPS.
SH
Papakura
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
109, HYPERION
Any residential
DRIVE, Randwick Park properties subject to a
key overlay
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1601 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 29, KOPARA PLACE,
at 29, KOPARA PLACE, Clendon Clendon Park.
Park.
SUBMISSION THEME
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 126, SHIFNAL
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
at 126, SHIFNAL DRIVE,6, RIBOT DRIVE,6, RIBOT
PLACE, Randwick Park.
PLACE, Randwick
Suburban/Single House
Park.
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 18, YEARSLEY
Mixed Housing
at 18, YEARSLEY PLACE,
PLACE, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 62-66 Takanini Road,
62-66 Takanini Road, Centres/Terrace
Takanini from Town Centre to
Takanini
Housing Apartment
Mixed Use or Terrace Housing
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
and Apartments.
Use
Expansion/Contraction
LOCALITY
Clendon Park
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Takinini
TC
MU/THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
S12
2859-5
Urban
(South)
S11
19, BALLOCH
STREET, Randwick
Park
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura
SH
MHU/THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Urban
(South)
S13
Fourteen residential
Any residential
properties in northern properties subject to a
part of block bounded key overlay
by Ingram and Prictor
Streets, Clevedon
Road, and railway line.
Papakura
SH
SH/MHU/THAB Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Urban
(South)
S11
33, ROSEMEAD
PLACE, Randwick
Park.
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
40, WAIMAHIA
AVENUE, Weymouth.
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
8, ASHMERE LANE,
Weymouth
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
4, ASHMERE LANE,
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
1, PIRITI PLACE,
Weymouth.
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
4804-1
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
MU
Pre-1944 BDC,
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 55, THOMPSON
Mixed Housing
at 55, THOMPSON TERRACE,
TERRACE, Manurewa Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone multiple sites listed in the multiple sites listed in Centres/Terrace
submission (refer page 4/21) to
the submission (refer Housing Apartment
Mixed Use.
page 4/21)
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 26, HOOKS ROAD,
Mixed Housing
at 26, HOOKS ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
267, MAHIA ROAD,
Mixed Housing
at 267, MAHIA ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 30, HOBART
Any residential
at 30, HOBART CRESCENT,
CRESCENT, Wattle
properties subject to a
Wattle Downs.
Downs
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Ross Holdings
Limited (Attn:
David Haines)
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
LI , MHU
Page 19
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from TC to MU/THAB. It is noted that this site is now a Special
Housing Area. However the zoning of what is now the Takanini Town Centre and its extent was
debated in Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 12. This plan change
also determined the extent of Mixed Use zoning east of the railway line and the location and extent of
what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent Environment Court decisions
(most recently in 2012) on this plan change, change of zone is not proposed. TC is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the TC zone and gives effect to the RPS, including the
centres strategy/hierarchy.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHU. 9 and 9A Menary Street is affected by flooding constraints
and although the SH zone could be retained, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot
zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resourecs and does not recognise the
local context. For the remaining SH sites, managing flooding risk does not require maintaining a SH
zone. The Papakura character and intensity is most suited to MHU in this location rather than THAB,
and also because of the distance to Papakura railway station. The MHU zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
In the block surrounded by Ingram Street, Prictor Street and Vernon Street, change of zone from SH
to THAB is supported where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a
SH. Where SH could have been retained due to flooding constraints, THAB zoning is supported to
avoid spot zones. The THAB zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB
zone and give effect to the RPS. Support change of zone on 26 and 28 Ingram Street from SH to
MHU. Support change of zone on 2 Renwick Street from SH to MHU. Support change of zone on 12,
17 and 21 Sneall Ave from SH to MHU. Support change of zone on 42 Clevedon Road from SH to
MHU. Flooding risk can either be managed without the SH zone or change of zone has occured to
avoid spot zones. Do not support change of zone to THAB on some SH sites along Prictor Street,
however support change of zone to MHU where managing the effects of flooding risk does not
require the retention of SH. THAB is not supported as this would create spot zoning in blocks of
MHU. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from LI and MHU to MU. Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura
section) Private Plan Change 7 reviewed most of the submission area in 2009 and rezoned it from
Residential 1 to Industrial 1. The notified zones are the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the LI or MHU zone and give effect to the RPS. MU zoning will not give effect to the
criteria in B3.1 of the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
SH/MHU/TH Yes
AB
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1629 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at 5, 5, BERKELEY ROAD,
BERKELEY ROAD, Manurewa.
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
31, ROSEANNE
ROAD, Manurewa
S13
57162982
25, FELLBROOK
STREET, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Centres/Terrace
Takinini
LC
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
N/A
MHS, MHU
Takanini Sub
precinct B,
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura
MHU
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
N/A
SH
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
Clendon Park
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
4, BALLOCH STREET,
Randwick Park.
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
42, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
17, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
17, INNISMARA
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
3, KIRTON
CRESCENT,
Manurewa
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
1, HYPERION DRIVE,
Randwick Park.
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
S12
LC
MHS or MHU
Takanini Sub
precinct B,
Flooding
constraints
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
Centres/Terrace
Takinini
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
10, COTTRELL
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
PLACE, Clendon Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 20
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Homai Train Station and
achieves the MHU zone objectives. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from LC to MHS or MHU. It is noted that this land is now a Special
CHANGE; SUPPORT Housing Area, forming part of the Takanini Strategic Area. Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura
RETENTION OF
section) Plan Change 12 determined the extent of Mixed Use zoning east of the railway line and the
NOTIFIED ZONE
location and extent of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent
Environment Court decisions (most recently in 2012) on this plan change, change of zone is not
proposed. LC is the most appropriate way to acheive the objectives of the LC zone, and gives effect
to the RPS, including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to SH. Although the site is subject to flooding constraints,
CHANGE; SUPPORT the adjacent sites have been zoned MHU and a SH zone would create a spot zone which will not
ALTERNATIVE ZONE generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context.
The residential properties bounded by Onslow Road to the north, Railway Street West to the east,
Short Street to the South, and Liverpool Street to the west, and by Settlement Road and Opaheke
Road are on the southern periphery of central Papakura, parks and community facilities. As well, the
site is in close proximity to a RFN and a center. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre
RETENTION OF
and RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. Retaining the notified
NOTIFIED ZONE
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Do not support change of zone from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
RETENTION OF
it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
NOTIFIED ZONE
suburban built character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from LC to MHS or MHU. It is noted that this land is now a Special
CHANGE; SUPPORT Housing Area, forming part of the Takanini Strategic Area. Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura
RETENTION OF
section) Plan Change 12 determined the extent of Mixed Use zoning east of the railway line and the
NOTIFIED ZONE
location and extent of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent
Environment Court decisions (most recently in 2012) on this plan change, no alteration to these
zonings is proposed. LC is the most appropriate way to acheive the objectives of the LC zone, and
gives effect to the RPS, including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1656 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 16, CLAYTON ROAD,
Manurewa.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
S13
57162985
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
57163020
S13
57163021
S13
57163056
S13
68-1
Joanne Davies
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
16, CLAYTON ROAD, Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 2, BARCROFT
Mixed Housing
at 2, BARCROFT PLACE,
PLACE, Clendon Park. Urban/Mixed Housing
Clendon Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 18, FIELDS ROAD,
Mixed Housing
at 18, FIELDS ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 30, GAINSBOROUGH Any residential
at 30, GAINSBOROUGH
STREET, Manurewa
properties subject to a
STREET, Manurewa.
key overlay
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
N/A
Manurewa SouthMHS
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
MHS
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 14 Settlement Road,
14 Settlement Road,
Any residential
Papakura
SH
Papakura (Pt Allotment 136 SECT Papakura (part of area properties subject to a
11 VILL OF Papakura) from
of residential
key overlay
Single House to Mixed Housing
properties bounded by
Urban. Refer to submission,
Onslow Road to the
Volume 4, page 14/35 and
north, Railway Street
Attachment 711, Volume 20.
West to the east, Short
Street to the South,
and Liverpool Street to
the west, and by
Settlement Road and
Opaheke Road)
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 15, MASSINE PLACE, Mixed Housing
MHS
The Gardens
at 15, MASSINE PLACE,
Randwick Park.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Randwick Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 202, MAHIA ROAD,
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
at 202, MAHIA ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 24-30 Settlement Road, 24-30 Settlement
Any residential
Papakura
SH
Papakura (Lot 2 DP 108939) from Road, Papakura
properties subject to a
Single House to Mixed Housing
key overlay
Suburban. Refer to submission,
Volume 4, page 16/35 and
Attachment 735, Volume 20.
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Clendon Park
Manurewa
7, LYNDON PLACE,
Manurewa
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS where managing flooding risk does not require maintaining MHS
a SH zone. The land is on the south eastern periphery of central Papakura, parks and community
facilities, and is suitable for change of zone as MHS. The MHS zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of 1 Nina Place, 11 and 13 Burbank Avenue from SH to MHU zone. Support
change to MHS as an alternative - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a
SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHU. This site is affected by flooding constraints and although
the SH zone could be retained, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not
generally achieve the integrated managmeent of resources and does recognise the local context.
The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give
effect to the RPS.
18 Alexander Street,
Papakura (part of area
of residential
properties bounded by
Onslow Road to the
north, Railway Street
West to the east, Short
Street to the South,
and Liverpool Street to
the west, and by
Settlement Road and
Opaheke Road)
Rezone the driveway at 20D
20D Trentham Road,
Trentham Road, Papakura (LOT 3 Papakura
DP 352236 1/4 SH LOT 5) from
Mixed Housing Suburban to
Single House. Refer to
submission, Volume 4, page
18/35 and Attachment 763,
Volume 21.
Rezone Short Street Papakura to Short Street Papakura
only include one to two storey
single and Mixed Housing
Suburban zones.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHU where managing the effects of SH does not require
maintaining a SH zone.The residential properties bounded by Onslow Road to the north, Railway
Street West to the east, Short Street to the South, and Liverpool Street to the west, and by
Settlement Road and Opaheke Road are on the southern periphery of central Papakura, parks and
community facilities. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
MHU
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura
MHU
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHS to SH. This change is to correct a mapping error as the driveway
was zoned differently to the substantive site in the notified PAUP.
SH
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
MHU on
Yes
northern side
of Short
Street
No
2/11A,1/11A,
RAILWAY STREET
WEST
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to MHS from SH or MHU. The residential properties bounded by
CHANGE; SUPPORT Onslow Road to the north, Railway Street West to the east, Short Street to the South, and Liverpool
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Street to the west, and by Settlement Road and Opaheke Road are on the southern periphery of
central Papakura, parks and community facilities. On the northern side of Short Street, sites zoned
SH are affected by flooding constraints and for some sites, managing the flooding risks on those
sites does not require the retention of the SH zone. For 4, 4A, 8, 26, 28, 30 and 32 Short Street, as
although the SH zone could be retained due to the sites being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The southern side of Short
Street, given its distance from Central Papakura forms a logical boundary for the extent of the MHU
zone. SH zones on the southern side of Short Street should be retained as SH as they are affected
by flooding constraints. It is therefore proposed that sites on the northern side of Short Street be
zoned MHU and sites on its southern side remain a mixture of MHS and SH.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of notified zone. The site is in close proximity to the RFN and Papakura
RETENTION OF
Metropolitan Centre. Retaining the THAB zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
NOTIFIED ZONE
of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
11, MOUNTFORT
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Page 21
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1684 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
125, WEYMOUTH ROAD,
Weymouth-Manurewa East.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
125, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, WeymouthManurewa East
23, EDDOWES
STREET, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHU
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
11,11A, MANSE
Any residential
ROAD,12A,12, CLARK properties subject to a
key overlay
ROAD, Pahurehure.
Papakura
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
9, ASTOR PLACE,
Manurewa
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 12, EWBANK PLACE, Mixed Housing
at 12, EWBANK PLACE,
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at 5 5 MAADI PLACE.
Any residential
MAADI PLACE. Papakura.
Papakura.
properties subject to a
key overlay
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 35, BURBANK
Mixed Housing
at 35, BURBANK AVENUE,
AVENUE, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 27, BERNINA PLACE, Any residential
at 27, BERNINA PLACE,
Weymouth
properties subject to a
Weymouth.
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura
SH, MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
8, ROSEANNE ROAD, Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
32, THOMPSON
Mixed Housing
TERRACE, Manurewa Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
6, SEAWARD PLACE, Any residential
Wattle Downs
properties subject to a
key overlay
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 2, CLAYTON ROAD,
Mixed Housing
at 2, CLAYTON ROAD,
Manurewa.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 4, BLUEWATER
Mixed Housing
at 4, BLUEWATER PLACE,
PLACE, Wattle Downs Urban/Mixed Housing
Wattle Downs.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
81, JELLICOE ROAD, Mixed Housing
81, JELLICOE ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 62, THOMPSON
Mixed Housing
at 62, THOMPSON TERRACE,
TERRACE, Manurewa Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 31,31A, CLEVEDON
31,31A, CLEVEDON
Any residential
ROAD, Papakura from Mixed
ROAD, Papakura
properties subject to a
Housing Urban, Single House to
key overlay
Mixed Housing Urban.
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at 8, 8, KIRTON
Mixed Housing
KIRTON CRESCENT, Manurewa. CRESCENT,
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Manurewa
Homai Station
Page 22
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre
and RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. Retaining the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support a change of zone to THAB and support change to MHU - the sites are located in
close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre however crossing to the Local Centre
from this area does not have a safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide an appropriate level of
growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of THAB zone - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied to one of the sites due to the site being affected by flooding
constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retaining the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of notified MHU. Site is within close proximity to the RFN, parks and community
facilities. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. The site is in close proximity to the RFN and Papakura
Metropolitan Centre. Retaining the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHU zone - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station and a
higher level of intensification will increase the capacity of housing with good access to public
transport. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
31 Clevedon Road is already MHU. Support retention of SH zone at 31A Clevedon Road. The site is
affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Mountfort Park and located
nearby an arterial road. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
REASONS
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Mountfort Park and located
on an arterial road. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5386 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 2/6A,1/6A, SHORT
STREET, Papakura from Single
House to Mixed Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
61, HOBART
CRESCENT, Wattle
Downs
Urban
(South)
S11
17, RIVERTON
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
Urban
(South)
S11
102, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Papakura
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
THAB
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
REASONS
Support change of zone from SH to MHU where managing flooding risks on those sites does not
require maintaining a SH zone.The residential properties bounded by Onslow Road to the north,
Railway Street West to the east, Short Street to the South, and Liverpool Street to the west, and by
Settlement Road and Opaheke Road are on the southern periphery of central Papakura, parks and
community facilities. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of THAB zone. THAB is the most appropriate zone as it is adjacent to Pakuranga
Town Centre and close to the RFN. Retention of the THAB zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the relevant objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre
and RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. Retaining the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of notified MHU zone. The land is on the south eastern periphery of central
Papakura, parks and community facilities which is suitable for MHU zoning. Retention of the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No change
No
No
S13
Rezone 24,26,30,28,
24,26,30,28,
Any residential
SETTLEMENT ROAD, Papakura SETTLEMENT ROAD, properties subject to a
from Single House to Terrace
Papakura
key overlay
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Papakura
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
42, INNISMARA
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
26, RIVERTON
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
MHS
MHS
N/A
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
12A,12, ALBERT
STREET, Papakura
(part of area of
residential properties
bounded by Onslow
Road to the north,
Railway Street West to
the east, Short Street
to the South, and
Liverpool Street to the
west, and by
Settlement Road and
Opaheke Road)
121, FINLAYSON
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
AVENUE, Clendon
Urban/Mixed Housing
Park
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4, MELLERAY PLACE, Any residential
The Gardens
Randwick Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to THAB, however support change of zone from SH to MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. The land is on
ALTERNATIVE ZONE the south eastern periphery of central Papakura, parks and community facilities which is suitable for
MHU zoning. Change to alternative zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to THAB, however support change of zone from SH to MHU.
CHANGE; SUPPORT As although the SH zone could be retained due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a
ALTERNATIVE ZONE spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
71, FERGUSON
STREET, Manurewa
East
Centres/Terrace
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of 1, 3, 5 Oratu Place from SH to MHU zone. Support change to MHS as an
alternative - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Do not support change of 7, 11, 15, 17 Oratu Place from MHS to MHU zone - the sites are not within
close proximity to a centre or RFN and are not suitable for further intensification. The notified zoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
Centres/Terrace
Homai Station
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 23
Support retention of notified THAB zone - The site is within walking distance to Homai Train Station
and Local Centre. Retention of the THAB zone gives effects to the objectives and policies of the
RPS and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7289 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 29B,29,29A, OPAHEKE
ROAD, Papakura from Single
House to Mixed Housing Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Papakura
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S13
Rezone 3,5,3C,3B,3A,5A,5B,
COLES CRESCENT, Papakura
from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
63, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, WeymouthManurewa East
Urban
(South)
S13
21B,21,21A, INGRAM
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
5711-2
Urban
(South)
S12
Addison
Developments
Limited (Attn:
Emma Bayly)
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
SH, MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
MHS
MHS
N/A
MHS
MHS
N/A
MHU
THAB
N/A
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH, THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. North of Ingram Street, MHU is considered more No change
appropriate than THAB because of its distance from the Papakura Railway Station. It would also
result in a spot zone which will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and
does ot recognise the local context. The notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and No change
a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support change of zone from SH to THAB where managing flooding risks on those sites does not
THAB
require retaining a SH zone. Papakura character and intensity most suited to THAB. The THAB zone
is the most appropriate way to achieve the purposes of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are on the south eastern periphery of
central Papakura, parks and community facilities, and given its distance from the Papakura Railway
Station, MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
LC
Takanini Sub
precinct B,
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. Support retention of notified MHU zone. The
property is located on the southern periphery of central Papakura, within close proximity to parks and
community facilities which makes it suitable for the MHU zone. It is not adjacent to the Metropolitan
Centre or the Papakura Train station. MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified LC zone. Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan
Change 12 determined the extent of Mixed Use zoning east of the railway line and the location and
extent of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent Environment Court
decisions (most recently in 2012) on this plan change, no alteration to these zonings is proposed. LC
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the LC zone, and gives effect to the RPS,
including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
No change
No
No
3, MATUA PLACE,
Clendon Park
Manurewa SouthMHS
LC
Page 24
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, however, support change of zone from SH to MHU at 3C
CHANGE; SUPPORT Coles Crescent as although the SH zone could be retained due to the site being affected by flooding
ALTERNATIVE ZONE constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Support change of
zone from SH to MHU at 3B Coles Crescent where managing flood risks on those sites does not
require maintaining a SH zone. The MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant
objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. A spot zone would occur and in this location a
CHANGE; SUPPORT spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
RETENTION OF
the local context. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
NOTIFIED ZONE
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
MHU
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 28, LIMOND STREET, Mixed Housing
The Gardens
at 28, LIMOND STREET,
Randwick Park.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Randwick Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 8,6, OLD WAIROA
8,6, OLD WAIROA
Any residential
Papakura
ROAD, Papakura from Mixed
ROAD, Papakura (part properties subject to a
Housing Urban to Terrace
of block of land
key overlay
Housing and Apartment Buildings. between Waitaua
Street, Porchester
Road, Old Wairoa
Road and View Road,
Papakura)
Rezone 18,18A, INGRAM
18,18A, INGRAM
Any residential
Papakura
STREET, Papakura from Mixed
STREET, Papakura
properties subject to a
Housing Urban to Terrace
key overlay
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
TOPIC
5277-254 The Urban Design Urban
Forum New
(South)
Zealand (Attn:
Melanie
Whittaker)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezoneland on Porchester Road
and Great South Road, Papakura
as shown in the submission [refer
to page 55/104]from Mixed
Housing Suburban and Mixed
Housing Urbanto Mixed Housing
Urban. This is a mixture of change
of zone and retain.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
46, INNISMARA
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Over 120
ha:Residential land
north of Trentham
Road and east of
Great South Road; and
across railway line
east to edge of
Takanini precinct, and
north to Walters Road,
and residential land in
part of Takanini
precinct south of
Airfield Road
10, HYPERION
Mixed Housing
DRIVE, Randwick
Urban/Mixed Housing
Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
2/50,1/50, OLD
Mixed Housing
WAIROA ROAD,
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
2, TAATAHI STREET, Mixed Housing
Weymouth
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
22A,22,22B, SHORT
Mixed Housing
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
(part of area of
Suburban/Single House
residential properties Expansion/Contraction
bounded by Onslow
Road to the north,
Railway Street West to
the east, Short Street
to the South, and
Liverpool Street to the
west, and by
Settlement Road and
Opaheke Road)
16, BLUEWATER
Any residential
PLACE, Wattle Downs properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
41, FEASEGATE
STREET, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
85, BURUNDI
AVENUE, Clendon
Park.
Urban
(South)
S11
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS, MHU
MHU
Takanini Sub
precinct D,
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
38, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
55, FERGUSON
STREET, Manurewa
East
Mixed Housing
MHU
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Papakura
MHS, MHU
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Homai Station
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre No change
and RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. Retaining the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of THAB zone. THAB is the most appropriate zone as it is adjacent to Pakuranga
No change
Town Centre and close to the RFN. Retention of the THAB zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the relevant objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Te Mahia Train Station. The No change
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
MHU
Takanini Sub
precinct D,
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. The zoning of the residential component of this
No Change
area ("Addison") was determined by plan changes for part Takanini Structure Plan Area 1A (
Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 12 (operative 2012)) and part Area
1B ( Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 3 operative 2005). Subdivision
plans for the majority of the area have been approved, and the majority of the area has now been
built on, creating a subdivision pattern which does not allow for additional dwelling sites to be
created. MHS best reflects the approved development pattern. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it gives effect to
the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is in close proximity to a centre and RFN and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 25
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1806 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
LOCALITY
Clendon Park
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
8, YEARSLEY PLACE, Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
89, THOMPSON
Mixed Housing
at 89, THOMPSON TERRACE,
TERRACE, Manurewa Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 3, COTTRELL PLACE, Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
at 3, COTTRELL PLACE, Clendon Clendon Park
Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
24, MARR ROAD,
Any residential
24, MARR ROAD, Manurewa.
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 8, YEARSLEY PLACE,
Manurewa.
58, BURBANK
AVENUE, Manurewa.
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
2/48, 1/48 SHIRLEY
Mixed Housing
2/48, 1/48 SHIRLEY AVENUE.
AVENUE. Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 103, MAHIA ROAD,
Mixed Housing
at 103, MAHIA ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
2/40, 1/40 INGRAM
Mixed Housing
2/40, 1/40 INGRAM STREET.
STREET. Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 54, HOBART
Mixed Housing
at 54, HOBART CRESCENT,
CRESCENT, Wattle
Urban/Mixed Housing
Wattle Downs.
Downs
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Terrace Housing and
135, RUSSELL ROAD, Centres/Terrace
Apartment Buildings at 135,
Manurewa.
Housing Apartment
RUSSELL ROAD, Manurewa.
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 181, COXHEAD
Mixed Housing
at 181, COXHEAD ROAD,
ROAD, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 5, CAPELLA PLACE, Mixed Housing
at 5, CAPELLA PLACE,
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
23, LIMOND STREET, Mixed Housing
at 23, LIMOND STREET,
Randwick Park.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Randwick Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 18, SOLO PLACE,
Mixed Housing
at 18, SOLO PLACE, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Use at 307A,
307A, GREAT SOUTH Centres/Terrace
GREAT SOUTH ROAD,
ROAD, Manurewa.
Housing Apartment
Manurewa.
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
24A WILLIS ROAD.
Mixed Housing
24A WILLIS ROAD. Papakura.
Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 15, FRANGIPANI
Mixed Housing
at 15, FRANGIPANI AVENUE,
AVENUE, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 438, PORCHESTER
Mixed Housing
at 438, PORCHESTER ROAD,
ROAD, Takanini
Urban/Mixed Housing
Takanini.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 20, KOPARA PLACE, Mixed Housing
at 20, KOPARA PLACE, Clendon Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 110, COXHEAD
Mixed Housing
at 110, COXHEAD ROAD,
ROAD, Manurewa.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 49, ORAMS ROAD,
Mixed Housing
at 49, ORAMS ROAD, Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Homai Station
The Gardens
THAB
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MU
MU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
Page 26
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is in close proximity to a centre and RFN and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified THAB zone - The site is within walking distance to Homai Train Station
and Local Centre. Retention of the THAB zone gives effects to the objectives and policies of the
RPS and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified MU zone - the zone provides flexibility for a mix of uses including
residential which is well suited to this location being on a RFN and close to Te Mahia train station.
The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. The site is in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and parks. Retaining
the notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Homai Train Station and
achieves the MHU zone objectives. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. The site is in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and gives effect to the
RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1843 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 38, INNISMARA AVENUE,
Wattle Downs.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
38, INNISMARA
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Urban
(South)
S11
13, RIVERTON
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
Urban
(South)
S13
9A CAMPBELL
PLACE. Papakura
Urban
(South)
S11
5, PALLANT STREET,
Manurewa.
Urban
(South)
S11
8, STOLL PLACE,
Clendon Park
Urban
(South)
S11
20, BLUEWATER
PLACE, Wattle Downs
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
98, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
Urban
(South)
S11
2, BERNINA
PLACE,109, SYKES
ROAD, Weymouth
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
23, TRENTHAM
ROAD, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Any residential
MHS
Flooding
Manurewa SouthMHS
properties subject to a
constraints
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Mountfort Park and located
nearby an arterial road. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. The site is in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and parks. Retaining
the notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB isolated or new
areas
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB isolated or new
areas
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
THAB
N/A
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
3/25,2/25,1/25,
SMITHS AVENUE,
Papakura
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
23A,23, RAILWAY
STREET WEST,
Papakura (part of area
of residential
properties bounded by
Onslow Road to the
north, Railway Street
West to the east, Short
Street to the South,
and Liverpool Street to
the west, and by
Settlement Road and
Opaheke Road)
117, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick Park
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. A spot zone would occur and in this location a
No change
spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
the local context. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
23, BURBANK
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Rezone 15A,15B,17C,17B,17A,
15A,15B,17C,17B,17A, THAB isolated or new
PRATT STREET, Papakura from PRATT STREET,
areas
Mixed Housing Urban to Terrace Papakura
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
No change
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Papakura
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Page 27
No change
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1875 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
4022-2
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Dalkara GP
Urban
Limited (Te Mahia (South)
Village) (Attn:
Brian Putt)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 4, FOXLAW STREET,
Randwick Park.
S12
Planner's Position
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
4, FOXLAW STREET, Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Randwick Park.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4 Cunningham Place, Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
Takanini
precinct submissions
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Integrated
Development sub
precinct B, National
Grid Corridor
(NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S13
56A,56, MARNE
ROAD, Papakura
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura
MHU
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 63A, STRATFORD
Mixed Housing
MHS
The Gardens
at 63A, STRATFORD ROAD,
ROAD, Manurewa.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 2/27, 1/27 SETTLEMENT 2/27, 1/27
THAB isolated or new
Papakura
MHU
ROAD. Papakura from Mixed
SETTLEMENT ROAD. areas
Housing Urban to Terrace
Papakura
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
MHU
THAB
Pre-1944 BDC
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
5 SMITHS AVENUE.
Papakura
456, PORCHESTER
ROAD, Takanini.
Papakura
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
196D,196E, HILL
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
ROAD, Manurewa.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
3, ADVOCATE PLACE, Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Randwick Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 28
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No change
it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Site is a caravan park. Has 2015 resource
consent for use as emergency housing facility. Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the
MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. Deletion of Integrated
Development sub-precinct B supported in Topic 080 Council evidence. The site is not in close
proximity to a centre and MHS zone maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to THAB. Support retention of notified zone. The site is in close
proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Center making MHU appropriate. However, it is not within a
suitable distance to the Metropolitan Centre and Papakura Railway Station to be zoned as THAB.
Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to THAB. Support retention of notified zone. The site is in close
proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Center making MHU appropriate. However, it is not within a
suitable distance to the Metropolitan Centre and Papakura Railway Station to be zoned as THAB.
Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to THAB. Support retention of notified zone. The site is in close
proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Center making MHU appropriate. However, it is not within a
suitable distance to the Metropolitan Centre and Papakura Railway Station to be zoned as THAB.
Retention of the MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The site is on the southern periphery of central
Papakura, within close proximity to parks and community facilities which makes it appropriate for
MHU zoning. THAB zoning would create a spot zone and in this location a spot zone will not
generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recongise the local context.
Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU
zone and give effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2078 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 24,10,12,20,14,22,16,18,
FOXLAW STREET, Randwick
Park.
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 11,13,15,17, NERISSA
PLACE,472,478,476,474,480,
PORCHESTER ROAD, Randwick
Park.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
63,65,67, FERGUSON Mixed Housing
STREET, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4, RIBOT PLACE,4,
Mixed Housing
HYPERION DRIVE,
Urban/Mixed Housing
Randwick Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
3,5, RIBOT PLACE,
Mixed Housing
Randwick Park.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
18,16, HYPERION
Any residential
DRIVE, Randwick Park properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
39,37, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S13
3195-1
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
36, Kindergarten
Drive, Conifer Grove
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
precinct submissions
MHS
MHS
N/A
1 ALPHA STREET.
Papakura
Papakura
MHU
THAB
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Rural
MR
CL
MHS
MHS
116, SHIFNAL
DRIVE,3,5,7,
BALLOCH STREET,
Randwick Park.
322,320,318,
ROSCOMMON ROAD,
Wiri-Manurewa
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
4, EWBANK
PLACE,14,16,
FELLBROOK
STREET, Manurewa
312,310,
ROSCOMMON ROAD,
Wiri-Manurewa
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
10,8, FINLAYSON
AVENUE, Clendon
Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
226, BROWNS
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
ROAD,3, FELLBROOK Urban/Mixed Housing
STREET, Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
26,30,28, WINSFORD Mixed Housing
Manurewa
STREET, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
93,95,97,
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
WEYMOUTH ROAD, Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth-Manurewa Suburban/Single House
East
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Buriatia Limited
(Attn: Niksha
Farac)
125,127, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick
Park.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Integrated
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Development sub RETENTION OF
precinct B, National NOTIFIED ZONE
Grid Corridor
(NGC)
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 29
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the sites are within close proximity to Te Mahia Train Station.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to one of the sites being affected by flooding
constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximity to centres and maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. The sites are not in close proximity to
Metropolitan Centre and RFN to be zoned as THAB. Retaining the notified MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MR to CL zone. The area does not meet the criteria for areas
No change
identified for Countryside Living in RPS Policy B8.3 Rural Subdivision Policy 6. In particular the land
is classified as Land Use Capability Class 2 land (prime land). The notified MR zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MR zone and give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. Deletion of Integrated Development sub-precinct B supported in Topic
080 Council evidence. Site is not in close proximity to centres and MHS maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the sites being affected by flooding constraints,
a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the sites are within close proximity to Mountfort Park and
located on an arterial road. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2129 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 24,26,19,30,28,2/32,
Mixed Housing
at 24,26,19,30,28,2/32,
JUSTAMERE PLACE, Urban/Mixed Housing
JUSTAMERE PLACE, Weymouth. Weymouth
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 11,9,13, REREMANU Mixed Housing
at 11,9,13, REREMANU PLACE, PLACE, Weymouth
Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 13,14, ZURICH
Mixed Housing
at 13,14, ZURICH PLACE,
PLACE, Weymouth.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 227, MAHIA ROAD,3, Mixed Housing
at 227, MAHIA ROAD,3,
ANGLERS WAY,
Urban/Mixed Housing
ANGLERS WAY, Manurewa.
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 9,14, CELMISIA
Any residential
at 9,14, CELMISIA PLACE,4,
PLACE,4, SENECIO
properties subject to a
SENECIO PLACE, Weymouth.
PLACE, Weymouth
key overlay
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
1,2,5,4,7,6,9,8,
ROSEMARY LANE,
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
129,131, MAHIA
ROAD, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
142,140, MAHIA
ROAD, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
69,71, FINLAYSON
AVENUE, Clendon
Park.
LOCALITY
Clendon Park
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MU
MU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
18,16, INNISMARA
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
10,8,4,6, INNISMARA
AVENUE,134, MAHIA
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
9,5,7, KENDALL
COURT, Wattle
Downs.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
12,14, SOLO
PLACE,18, ASTOR
PLACE, Manurewa
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
90,88,92, THOMPSON Any residential
Manurewa SouthMHS
TERRACE, Manurewa. properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
121, COXHEAD
ROAD,109,111,113,
MAHIA ROAD,
Manurewa
4,6, HOBART
CRESCENT, Wattle
Downs
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
77,75,81,79,85,
Any residential
Manurewa SouthMHS
THOMPSON
properties subject to a
TERRACE, Manurewa key overlay
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
150,148, MAHIA
ROAD, Manurewa
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Page 30
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support the retention of THAB zone - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the one of the sites being affected by flooding
constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the one of the sites being affected by flooding
constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified MU zone - the zone provides flexibility for a mix of uses including
residential which is well suited to this location being on a RFN and close to Te Mahia train station.
The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2149 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 103,109,111,107,113,
COXHEAD ROAD,82,84,78,
THOMPSON TERRACE,
Manurewa.
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 95, COXHEAD ROAD,68,66,
THOMPSON TERRACE,
Manurewa.
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 96, MAHIA
ROAD,25,13,15,21,17,23,19,
HOOKS ROAD,98, COXHEAD
ROAD, Manurewa.
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 9,7, HOOKS ROAD, Manurewa.
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Murdoch Newell
Limited (Attn:
John Murdoch)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Mixed Housing
MHS
N/A
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
11,9, EDDOWES
Mixed Housing
MHU
Manurewa
11,9, EDDOWES STREET,
STREET, Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 24,26,32,30,28,34,
Any residential
Manurewa SouthMHS
at 24,26,32,30,28,34, INNISMARA INNISMARA AVENUE, properties subject to a
AVENUE, Wattle Downs.
Wattle Downs.
key overlay
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
S11
MHS
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Rural
MR
properties subject to a
key overlay
Flooding
constraints,
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
N/A
CL
Flooding
constraints
57162984
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
57163019
S13
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHS
38A,38, BOUNDARY
ROAD,58,58A,
GREENHAVEN
AVENUE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
40, HOOKS
ROAD,102,100,
COXHEAD ROAD,
Manurewa.
6, CLAYTON
ROAD,18, CAPELLA
PLACE, Manurewa
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the sites are within close proximity to Mountfort Park and
located nearby an arterial road. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MR to CL zone. The area does not meet the criteria for areas
identified for Countryside Living in RPS Policy B8.3 Rural Subdivision Policy 6. In particular the land
is classified as Land Use Capability Class 2 land (prime land). The notified MR zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MR zone and give effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on these sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
Flooding
SUPPORT IN FULL;
constraints, Heavy CHANGE OF ZONE
Industry Air Quality
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on these sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
Yes
No
MHS
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. Site is not in close proximity to a center or RFN. MHS is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Heavy
Industry Air Quality
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS. This site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Heavy
Industry Air Quality
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS. This site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone to MHU, however, support change of zone from SH to MHS as
MHS
managing flooding risks on this site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Site is not in close
proximity to a center or RFN. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
26, GREENHAVEN
AVENUE, Opaheke
Urban
(South)
S13
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
61, GREENHAVEN
AVENUE, Opaheke
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Heavy
Industry Air Quality
Urban
(South)
S13
2/50,1/50, ORION
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
THAB
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, however support change of zone from SH to MHS as
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT managing flooding risks on these sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. These sites are not
Industry Air Quality ALTERNATIVE ZONE in close proximity to a center or RFN. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Page 31
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
MHS
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7295 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 24,20,14,22,16,18,
CALVERT STREET, Papakura
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
24,20,14,22,16,18,
CALVERT STREET,
Papakura
8,6, CALVERT
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
19,21,23, HUNUA
ROAD,1,3,5,7,
CALVERT
STREET,46,50,48,
BATES STREET
9,7, HUNUA ROAD
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PLANNER'S
PRECINCTS,
PROPOSED
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
POSITION
REASONS
PAUP ZONE
Any residential
THAB
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, however, support change of zone from SH to MHS for 14
Papakura - Sout SH, MHS
properties subject to a
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT and 18 Calvert Street as managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH
key overlay
Industry Air Quality ALTERNATIVE ZONE zone. Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS for 16, 20 and 22 as these sites are affected
by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS. Support retention of MHS on 24 Calvert Street
as site is not in close proximity to a center or RFN. The notified MHS zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and give effect to the RPS.
Any residential
MHU
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
Papakura - Sout MHS
properties subject to a
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
key overlay
RETENTION OF
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
MHU
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
Papakura - Sout MHS
properties subject to a
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
key overlay
RETENTION OF
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality ALTERNATIVE ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
Flooding
constraints
MHU
Yes
No
20,22, BATES
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
No
No
11,19,13,15,17,
CALVERT
STREET,11,9,3,5,7,
OSBORNE
PLACE,11,25,39,27,15
,21,17,23,19,31,37,29,
35,2/41,1/41,33,
BATES STREET,
Papakura
29,29A,
GREENHAVEN
AVENUE, Opaheke
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
THAB
Do not support change of zone to MHU. However, support change of zone from SH to MHS for 34
SH/MHS
Bates Street, as managing stormwater does not require the maintaining a SH zone. Support retention
of SH at 26, 28, 30 and 32 Bates Street as these sites are affected by flooding constraints. Retaining
the notified SH zone at is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give
effect to the RPS. Support retention of MHS at 36, 38 and 40 Bates Street, these sites are not in
close proximity to a center or a RFN. Retaining the notified MHS zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change to MHU. Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the No change
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to an
RETENTION OF
RFN or centre and MHS maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect
NOTIFIED ZONE
to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, however support re-zoning from SH to MHS for 13 Calvert SH/MHS
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT Street, as managing stormwater for this site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Support
Industry Air Quality ALTERNATIVE ZONE retention of SH where notified for other sites as those sites are affected by flooding constraints.
Retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS. Support retention of MHS where notified as those sites are not in close
proximity to an RFN and MHS maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Retaining
the notified MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
give effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
Flooding
constraints
8A GREENHAVEN
AVENUE. Opaheke
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
11A LIVERPOOL
STREET. Papakura
14A GREENHAVEN
AVENUE. Opaheke
S13
1/4,2/4, LORELEI
PLACE, Opaheke.
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to an RFN and MHS maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
RETAIN; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Do not support change of zonefrom SH/MHS to MHU. Support change of zone from SH to MHS
MHS
where managing flooding risks on those sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. Site is not in
close proximity to a center or RFN. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura - Sout SH
MHU
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU. This site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
33, BOUNDARY
Mixed Housing
ROAD, Papakura.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
70, OPAHEKE ROAD, Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
9A,9B, BOUNDARY
Spot Zoning
ROAD, Papakura
MHS
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The sites are not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Spot Zoning
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The sites are not in close proximity to a centre
or an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS. Also do not support change to the MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS. Also do not support change to the MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS. Also do not support change to the MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
No
No
Page 32
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7301 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Mixed Housing
MHU
Flooding
Papakura - Sout MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
constraints
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 3,2,5,4,7,6, TENSING
PLACE,10,12,18,16, BATES
STREET, Papakura from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S13
Rezone 15 ORION STREET.
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
3,2,5,4,7,6, TENSING
PLACE,10,12,18,16,
BATES STREET,
Papakura
Spot Zoning
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
28,26,30,20,32,
SMITHS
AVENUE,10,2,8,6,
OSBORNE PLACE,23,
CALVERT STREET,
Papakura
32,30,28, CALVERT
STREET,36,34,
SMITHS AVENUE,
Papakura
Rezone 2/49,1/47,1/49,2/47,49A,
SMITHS
AVENUE,1/30,2/30,1/28,2/28,
ORION STREET, Papakura from
Mixed Housing Suburban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Rezone 28,26,30,20,32, SMITHS
AVENUE,10,2,8,6, OSBORNE
PLACE,23, CALVERT STREET,
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Rezone 32,30,28, CALVERT
STREET,36,34, SMITHS
AVENUE, Papakura from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS. Also do not support change to the MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS. Also do not support change to the MHU zone, spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
Support retention of notified MHS zone. MHS is appropriate for the site given its distance from the
Papakura Metropolitan Centre. The site is part of the boundary between the MHS to the south and
MHU zone to the north. THAB zoning would create a spot zone and a spot zone will not generally
achieve the integrated management of resoureces and does not recognise the local context. The
MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and give effect to
the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
THAB
Urban
(South)
S13
10,18,16, SMITHS
THAB isolated or new
AVENUE,2/9,3,5,7,1/9, areas
BATES STREET,
Papakura
3159-30
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
57163060
S13
1634-1
James Dufty
Urban
(South)
S13
2154-2
Dean Martin
Urban
(South)
S13
57162988
S13
4015-1
57163059
15 ORION STREET.
Papakura
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. Retention of the notified MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support rezoning MHS/MHU to THAB. Notified MHS and MHU within the block is not in the
No change
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre which would be appropriate for THAB zoning. Retention of
notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the relevant objectives of the respective zones
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
MHS
No
No
SH
MHS
Support retention of the MHS zone given the distance from the Papakura Metropolitan Centre and
No change
RFN. Retention of the MHS gives effect to the objectives and policies of the RPS and is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone. It is also the most appropriate way to
achieve the relevant objectives Takanini sub-precinct D.
Do not support change of SH to MHS given the distance from centres and frequent service networks. No change
Retention of the SH gives effect to the objectives and policies of the RPS and is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone. It is also the most appropriate way to achieve the
relevant objectives of Takanini sub-precinct E.
No
No
64 Clevedon Road,
Papakura
Errors
Papakura East
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support rezoning of 64 Clevedon Road, Papakura from SH to MHS as managing flooding risks on
MHS
CHANGE; SUPPORT this site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
ALTERNATIVE ZONE achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. With this rezoning, the mapping
error no longer needs to be corrected.
Yes
No
68 Clevedon Road,
Papakura
Errors
Papakura East
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone to SH. Split zoning - mapping error no longer applies as the reminder No Change
of 68 Clevedon Road, Papakura has been rezoned from SH to MHS. With this rezoning, the mapping
error no longer needs to be corrected. The MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone to MHS. This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the No change
notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support the rezoning of SH on this site to MHS as managing flooding risks on those sites does not
SH/MHS
require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone to SH. This site is affected by flooding constraints and the SH zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Page 33
SH
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2091 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
57163013
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
S12
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 47,45,51,49,
Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
at 47,45,51,49, KINDERGARTEN KINDERGARTEN
precinct submissions
DRIVE, Conifer Grove.
DRIVE, Conifer Grove
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
S13
9,13,5, SEAWARD
Any residential
PLACE, Wattle Downs properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
27, BURBANK
AVENUE, Manurewa
9 RHINE PLACE.
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park MHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa SouthMHS
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
57163017
S13
57163018
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
Integrated
Development sub
precinct B, National
Grid Corridor
(NGC)
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support the rezoning of SH to MHS as managing flooding risks on those sites does not require
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
The Gardens
SH
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the rezoning of SH on this site to MHS as managing flooding risks on this site does not
SH
require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone as managing flooding risks on this site does not require a SH zone.
MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan
Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
The sites 1/10, 2/10, 12 and 4/12 served by the right of way have been changed from SH to MHS,
MHS
which matches the zoning given to the right of way. There is no requirement now to rezone this right
of way. Support rezoning of these sites from SH to MHS as managing flooding risks on those sites
does not require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone as these sites are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre. It is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre
and RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. Retaining the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the rezoning of MHU to SH as this site is affected by flooding contraints and the SH zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS. This
corrects a mapping error.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
SH
Yes
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
10 REREMANU
PLACE. Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
12 MYERS ROAD.
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
37 ARNWOOD
STREET. Manurewa
S13
57163053
Page 34
MHS
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Yes
57163050
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2301 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 229 MAHIA ROAD. 1
ANGLERS WAY. Manurewa.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
S13
57163057
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
10 SAMARA PLACE.
Clendon Park
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Mixed Housing
MHS
N/A
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
MHU
MHU
Flooding
Manurewa
properties subject to a
constraints
key overlay
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 9 CARNOUSTIE
Mixed Housing
at 9 CARNOUSTIE DRIVE. Wattle DRIVE. Wattle Downs. Urban/Mixed Housing
Downs.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
10 HALSEY ROAD.
Mixed Housing
10 HALSEY ROAD. Manurewa.
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 20 NEWBEGIN
Mixed Housing
at 20 NEWBEGIN PLACE.
PLACE. Weymouth.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Terrace Housing and
31 MARR ROAD.
Centres/Terrace
Apartment Buildings at 31 MARR Manurewa.
Housing Apartment
ROAD. Manurewa.
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Terrace Housing and
219A GREAT SOUTH Centres/Terrace
Apartment Buildings at 219A
ROAD. Manurewa.
Housing Apartment
GREAT SOUTH ROAD.
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Manurewa.
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 99 SYKES ROAD.
Mixed Housing
at 99 SYKES ROAD. Weymouth. Weymouth
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 9 KAIMOANA
Mixed Housing
at 9 KAIMOANA STREET.
STREET. Weymouth
Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 2 LYNDON PLACE.
Mixed Housing
at 2 LYNDON PLACE. Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone part of 115 Old Wairoa
115 Old Wairoa Road, Any residential
Road, Papakura (Lot 34 DP
Papakura
properties subject to a
38486) from Mixed Housing
key overlay
Suburban to Single House. Refer
to submission, Volume 4, page
18/35 and Attachment 764,
Volume 21.
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
270 GREAT SOUTH Mixed Housing
270 GREAT SOUTH ROAD.
ROAD. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at 7 7 BEESTON
Mixed Housing
BEESTON CRESCENT.
CRESCENT.
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 131 PALMERS ROAD. Mixed Housing
at 131 PALMERS ROAD. Clendon Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 61 WAIMAHIA
Mixed Housing
at 61 WAIMAHIA AVENUE.
AVENUE. Weymouth Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
86 WEYMOUTH
Mixed Housing
86 WEYMOUTH ROAD.
ROAD. WeymouthUrban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth-Manurewa East.
Manurewa East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
61 FERGUSON
Mixed Housing
61 FERGUSON STREET.
STREET. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa East.
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Terrace Housing and
32 WEYMOUTH
Any residential
Apartment Buildings at 32
ROAD. Weymouthproperties subject to a
WEYMOUTH ROAD. Weymouth- Manurewa East
key overlay
Manurewa East.
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 39 SANDWICK DRIVE. Mixed Housing
at 39 SANDWICK DRIVE.
Weymouth
Urban/Mixed Housing
Weymouth.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
12 SAMARA PLACE. Mixed Housing
at 12 SAMARA PLACE. Clendon Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Park.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre
and RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. Retaining the notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No
No
No
No
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified THAB zone - The site is within walking distance to Homai Train Station No change
and Local Centre. Retention of the THAB zone gives effects to the objectives and policies of the
RPS and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone.
Manurewa
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified THAB zone - The site is in close proximity to Gallaher Park, Manurewa No change
Town Centre and RFN. Retention of the THAB zone gives effects to the objectives and policies of the
RPS and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone.
No
No
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Papakura East
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support change to road. This is a mapping error where Road Reserve has been incorrectly zoned as
MHS, and has been corrected to Road.
Road
Yes
No
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and No change
a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Mountfort Park and located
nearby an arterial road. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Te Mahia Train Station. The No change
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Te Mahia Train Station. The No change
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Manurewa
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support the retention of THAB zone - The site is in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
Page 35
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-4995 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
57163058
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
S12
Rezone 29, ROUNTREE PLACE, 29, ROUNTREE
Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
Conifer Grove from Mixed
PLACE, Conifer Grove precinct submissions
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Integrated
Development sub
precinct B, Coastal
Inundation
S13
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone the driveway at 120B
120B Clevedon Road, Any residential
Papakura Clevedon Road, Papakura (LOT 5 Papakura
properties subject to a East
DP 208714) from Mixed Housing
key overlay
Suburban to Single House. Refer
to submission, Volume 4, page
18/35 and Attachment 769,
Volume 21.
Rezone 24,10,12,22,4,6,8,
24,10,12,22,4,6,8,
Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
ROUNTREE
ROUNTREE
precinct submissions
PLACE,11,10,13,12,15,14,17,16,1 PLACE,11,10,13,12,15
9,18,22,3,5,4,7,6,9,20,8,21,
,14,17,16,19,18,22,3,5,
VERNER
4,7,6,9,20,8,21,
PLACE,2/71,65A,61,75,63,73,65, VERNER
69,1/71, KINDERGARTEN
PLACE,2/71,65A,61,75
DRIVE, Conifer Grove from Mixed ,63,73,65,69,1/71,
Housing Suburban to Mixed
KINDERGARTEN
Housing Urban.
DRIVE, Conifer Grove
Retain Terrace Housing and
11A JAMES ROAD.
Any residential
Manurewa
Apartment Buildings at 11A
Manurewa
properties subject to a
JAMES ROAD. Manurewa.
key overlay
MHU
MHU
N/A
SH, MHS
SH
MHS
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
THAB
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
S13
57163061
Urban
(South)
S11
S13
2 CELMISIA PLACE.
Weymouth.
Papakura East
12 COXHEAD ROAD.
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
S13
57163063
57163064
Urban
(South)
S11
S13
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
5 KAIMOANA
STREET. Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4 Yang Place and 9A Any residential
Papakura Yang Place, Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of THAB zone - The site is in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone to SH. Mapping correction needed to remove corner of Mixed Housing
Suburban zoning. This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
SH
Yes
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is located nearby an arterial road with good access to
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone to SH. Mapping correction needed to rezone driveway from MHS to SH.
They sites served by driveway are SH. These site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining
the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give
effect to the RPS.
SH
Yes
No
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No change
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
THAB
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support the retention of THAB zone - The site is in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS. Mapping correction needed to rezone driveway serving 4
Yang Place and other MHS sites from SH to MHS to match adjacent zoning. MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and give effect to the RPS. There is
currently a mapping error which means the driveway still shows SH instead of MHS.
MHS
Yes
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS. Driveway serves both SH and MHS sites, and
should remain as the more restrictive zoning. Driveway is also subject to flooding constraints.
Retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH
Page 36
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
57163065
SUBMITTER
NAME
TOPIC
Auckland Council Urban
(Attn: Stephen
(South)
Town)
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone the driveways at 9, 11 &
22 Jack Farrell Place, Papakura
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Single House. Refer to
submission, Volume 4, page
18/35 and Attachment 772,
Volume 21.
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 25 LIMOND STREET.
Randwick Park.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
9, 11 & 22 Jack Farrell Any residential
Papakura Place, Papakura
properties subject to a East
key overlay
S13
25 LIMOND STREET.
Randwick Park.
7 KAIMOANA
STREET. Weymouth
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
SH
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of notified MHS. 1/123 and 2/123 Old Wairoa Road have been rezoned to MHS.
CHANGE; SUPPORT The parcel of land (Lot 43 DP 43588) to be retained as MHS to match the adjacent zoning. The
ALTERNATIVE ZONE rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is within close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and No change
a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support rezoning from MHS to SH. The site is significantly affected by flooding constraints. Rezoning SH
RETAIN; SUPPORT
to SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and recognise the flooding
ALTERNATIVE ZONE constraints, giving effect to the RPS. Change proposed is out of scope (refer Attachment F)
No
No
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified THAB zone - The site is within walking distance to Homai Train Station No change
and Local Centre. Retention of the THAB zone gives effects to the objectives and policies of the
RPS and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone.
No
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHU zone - the property is within close proximity to Homai Train Station and
No change
POS and achieves the MHU zone objectives. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The property is covered by the Pre 1944 Building Demolition Control overlay however the
MHU zone should be retained to avoid spot zoning. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as No change
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
SH, MHS
SH
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
81 CHRISTMAS
ROAD. Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S13
1/7,2/7, PUKEROA
PLACE, Papakura.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
21, CARISBROOK
CRESCENT,
Papakura.
Urban
(South)
S13
7, FAIRDALE
AVENUE, Red Hill.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
17, TILBROOK
PLACE, Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
6, PRESIDENT
AVENUE, Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
23, LIDDESDALE
PLACE, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S12
3, CHIBNALL
Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
PLACE,48,
precinct submissions
KINDERGARTEN
DRIVE, Conifer Grove
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
52 MARR ROAD.
Manurewa.
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
7A CLARK STREET.
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints, Pre1944 BDC
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S12
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
Centres/Terrace
Homai Station
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
REASONS
Support retention of notified SH zone for driveway. 9 and 11 Jack Farrell Place has had a change of
zone from SH to MHS. The driveway is to be retained as MHS to match the adjacent zoning. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Page 37
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support the retention of MHU zone - the site is located nearby an arterial road with good access to
Manurewa Town Centre and a RFN. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2724 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 81A TEMPLETON PLACE.
Clendon Park.
LOCALITY
Clendon Park
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
Homai Station
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
THAB
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
81A TEMPLETON
Mixed Housing
PLACE. Clendon Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Urban at
51A GLOUCESTER
Mixed Housing
51A GLOUCESTER ROAD.
ROAD. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Terrace Housing and
143A RUSSELL
Centres/Terrace
Apartment Buildings at 143A
ROAD. Manurewa.
Housing Apartment
RUSSELL ROAD. Manurewa.
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 3 CLARK STREET.
Mixed Housing
at 3 CLARK STREET. Manurewa. Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 3A CLARK STREET.
Mixed Housing
at 3A CLARK STREET.
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Manurewa.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 1, TILBROOK PLACE, Any residential
at 1, TILBROOK PLACE,
Papakura.
properties subject to a
Papakura.
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
1A CLARK STREET.
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S13
11, SUNBURST
STREET, Papakura.
Urban
(South)
S11
The Gardens
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Rezone
53,98,88,74,82,90,80,92,86,94,96
, TRIMDON STREET, Randwick
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban, Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban.
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 118,118A, OLD WAIROA
ROAD, Papakura.
118,118A, OLD
WAIROA ROAD,
Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
67, EASTBURN
STREET,143,
DOMINION ROAD,
Papakura.
56,58, DOMINION
ROAD, Papakura
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
13,14, YARROW
LANE, Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
6, LANSDOWN
PLACE,2/67,51A,51B,
49A,49B,59,1/67,57B,5
7A,65, HEATHDALE
CRESCENT,
Papakura.
24,26, SHERALEE
PLACE, Red Hill.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support retention of MHS zone at 24 Sheralee Place, support change of zone from MHS to
RETAIN; SUPPORT
SH. The site is significantly affected by flooding constraints. Rezoning to SH is the most appropriate
ALTERNATIVE ZONE way to achieve the objectives of the zone and recognise the flooding constraints, giving effect to the
RPS. This change is out of scope (refer Attachment F).
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
SH/MHS
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone at 26 Sheralee Place - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site
as it is not in close proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. Retention of the notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
839-2189 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S13
13,15,17,16,19,18,
Any residential
FULMEN PLACE, Red properties subject to a
Hill.
key overlay
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 38
Support retention of MHS on some sites. However, support rezoning from MHS to SH on 15, 16 and SH/MHS
17 Fulmen Place as these sites are affected by flooding constraints. Rezoning to SH is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and recognise the flooding constraints, giving
effect to the RPS. This change is out of scope (refer Attachment F).
Support retention of MHS for 13, 18 and 19 Fulmen Place as the most appropriate zone for the site
as it is not in close proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. This zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No Change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2192 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
839-2822 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
S13
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 2,1/3,4,2/3, FULMEN Any residential
Papakura at 2,1/3,4,2/3, FULMEN PLACE,8, PLACE,8, REDCREST properties subject to a East
REDCREST AVENUE, Papakura. AVENUE, Papakura
key overlay
S11
36, COXHEAD
ROAD,27, BULLER
CRESCENT,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SH, MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 27 Buller Crescent - this site is affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
839-4957 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
40, WINSFORD
STREET,2,
FAIRLIGHT PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
8, MAIDA VALE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
5, CARTER PLACE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Homai Station
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
12, WINSFORD
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S12
46,44,42,40,
Combined rezoning and Conifer Grove
KINDERGARTEN
precinct submissions
DRIVE, Conifer Grove
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 46,44,42,40,
KINDERGARTEN DRIVE, Conifer
Grove from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 24, ROSEANNE ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - Spot zoning in this
CHANGE; SUPPORT location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
ALTERNATIVE ZONE context. The site is not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not
suitable for further intensification. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is affected by flooding constraints and
CHANGE; SUPPORT retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
RETENTION OF
and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
CHANGE; SUPPORT it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
RETENTION OF
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
NOTIFIED ZONE
and gives effect to the RPS.
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
24, ROSEANNE
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 39
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2194 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
S13
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 9,3,5,3A,7, PALISADE Any residential
Papakura at 9,3,5,3A,7, PALISADE PLACE, PLACE, Red Hill.
properties subject to a East
Red Hill.
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
8, CLARK STREET,
Manurewa
Wallace Group
Urban
Limited (Attn:
(South)
Richard Brabant)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SH
LI
3, GARTH PLACE,
Manurewa
Takanini Sub
precinct A,
Flooding
constraints
Flooding
constraints
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHS
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
S11
17, SHARLAND
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
33, CHURCHILL
AVENUE, Manurewa
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
MHS
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
50,52, PUKEROA
PLACE, Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
60,58, PUKEROA
PLACE, Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
35, SHARLAND
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
18, RANGATAUA
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
9B HILL CRESCENT.
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
13,15, PUKEROA
PLACE, Papakura
Clendon Park
Clendon Park
Page 40
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS
zone and gives effect to the RPS. The surrounding block should also be rezoned to MHU (out of
scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN PART;
Support rezoning from MHS to SH on 7, 13 and 15 Galilee Avenue as these sites are affected by
PARTIAL CHANGE
flooding constraints. Rezoning to SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
zone and recognise the flooding constraints, giving effect to the RPS. This change is out of scope
(refer Attachment F).
Support retention of MHS for 3 and 9 Galilee Ave as the
most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. This zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is located within close proximity to the
CHANGE OF ZONE
Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned
to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
RETENTION OF
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
NOTIFIED ZONE
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
RETENTION OF
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
NOTIFIED ZONE
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
RETENTION OF
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
NOTIFIED ZONE
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - Spot zoning in this
CHANGE; SUPPORT location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
ALTERNATIVE ZONE context. The site is not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not
suitable for further intensification. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
CHANGE OF ZONE
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
RETENTION OF
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
NOTIFIED ZONE
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
RETENTION OF
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
NOTIFIED ZONE
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
LI
Yes
No
MHS
Yes
No
SH/MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5040 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 9, BRENTFORD PLACE, 9, BRENTFORD
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
PLACE, Manurewa
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
1, SELAGO PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
3, BURBANK
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S12
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Combined rezoning and Takinini
precinct submissions
MHS
4986-1
SH
MHS
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Takanini Sub
precinct A,
Flooding
constraints
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
2A SUNBURST
STREET. Papakura.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
432, PORCHESTER
ROAD, Takanini
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
The Gardens
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Takanini Central
Limited (Attn:
Manini Hallikeri)
28, ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
55 Takanini School
Road, Takanini
Papakura East
Page 41
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - managing flooding risks on the site does not require
MHS
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to
a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Yes
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is located within close proximity to the
Manurewa Town Centre, Gallaher Park and a RFN. Increased density in this location achieves the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5085 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 12, LANDETTE ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
12, LANDETTE ROAD, Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4 CARISBROOK
CRESCENT.
Papakura.
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Support rezoning from SH to MHS on 2 Pembrook Street where managing flooding risks on those
SH/MHS
sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. This rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS. Support retention of MHS for 4 Pembrook
Street as the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to the Papakura
Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. This zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support rezoning from SH to MHS as managing flood risks on these sites does not require
MHS
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone.
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to MHS. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
110, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
63, ROWANDALE
AVENUE,1, AARTS
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
2,4, PEMBROOK
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH/MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
3,5, WING
CRESCENT,137,
DOMINION
ROAD,50,52,
EASTBURN STREET,
Papakura
10, ORPHEUS
PLACE,39,41,
DOMINION ROAD,
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support rezoning from SH to MHS at 10 Orpheus Place, Papakura as managing flood risks on these
sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHS zone.
Urban
(South)
S11
21, MOUNTFORT
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
10, WINIATA
TERRACE,9,
CARGILL STREET,
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support rezoning from SH to MHS as managing flood risks on these sites does not require
MHS
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone.
83, FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Page 42
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is located on a RFN and has good access to
Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station. Increased density along this transport corridor
achieves the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Adjoining properties also need
to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
SH/MHS
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5141 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 34, BOWATER PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S13
Rezone
10A,12A,1/33,1/35,22,10B,1/27A,
28,2/27A,2,6,2/35,2/33,1/4,25,12B
,8,2/4,14,1/26,1/27,39,1/23,16,18,
31,37,1/29,2/29,2/27,2/26,2/23,
ELSIE MORTON PLACE,
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban, Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban.
S13
Rezone
13,17,1/9,1,2/9,3,7,5B,1/11,2/11,5
A,1/15,2/15, JACK FARRELL
PLACE,43A,43B,45,41,
HEATHDALE CRESCENT,
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban, Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban.
S11
Rezone 5, ALBERTSON PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
34, BOWATER
PLACE, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
10A,12A,1/33,1/35,22, Any residential
Papakura 10B,1/27A,28,2/27A,2, properties subject to a East
6,2/35,2/33,1/4,25,12B key overlay
,8,2/4,14,1/26,1/27,39,
1/23,16,18,31,37,1/29,
2/29,2/27,2/26,2/23,
ELSIE MORTON
PLACE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Support rezoning at 1, 7, 9, and 1/11 Jack Farrell Place from SH to MHS as managing flood risks on SH/MHS
these sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. Support retention of the MHS to other sites. The
MHS zone is appropriate for the sites given their distance from the Papakura Metropolitan Centre
and is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone.
Yes
No
5, ALBERTSON
PLACE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support rezoning at 6, 8 and 10 Jack Farrell Place from SH to MHS as managing flood risks on these SH/MHS
sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. Support retention of the MHS to other sites. The MHS
zone appropriate for the sites given their distance from the Papakura Metropolitan Centre and is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone.
Yes
No
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
S13
21, CARGILL
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
15, FEASEGATE
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to MHS. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
2, CARBERY PLACE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
9, DOMAIN ROAD,
Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
13, FRANCES
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified
zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Rezone
12,1/22,1/20,16,18,2/20,1/4,6,8,2/
10,1/10,2/4,2/22,2/14,1/14, JACK
FARRELL PLACE, Papakura from
Mixed Housing Suburban, Single
House to Mixed Housing
Suburban.
Rezone 43, RUSSELL ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Urban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Page 43
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5041 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 37, CARGILL STREET,
Papakura from Single House to
Mixed Housing Suburban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
37, CARGILL
STREET, Papakura
2, LEILANI PLACE,
Red Hill
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
838-46
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
Flooding
constraints
MHS
MHU
N/A
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
16, SUNLANDS
DRIVE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
77, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
36, REDCREST
AVENUE, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
49, VALENTINE
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Papakura Military
Camp site, 129-143
Porchester Road, 100
Grove Road and 119
Walters Road,
Papakura
SH/MHS
MU
Takanini subprecinct E,
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
53, CHURCHILL
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
N/A
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
S11
17, YEARSLEY
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
MHS
MHU
N/A
4885-1
Urban
(South)
S12
Support rezoning from MHS to SH. The site is significantly affected by flooding constraints. Rezoning
to SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and recognise the flooding
constraints, giving effect to the RPS. This change is out of scope (refer Attachment F)
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site. As it is not in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
RETENTION OF
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support the rezoning of this site as although the SH zone could be retained due to the site being
CHANGE OF ZONE
affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not
generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context.
The SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to
the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone at 129 Porchester, 119 Walters Road and 100 Grove Road from MHS
CHANGE; SUPPORT to MU in residential area as NZDF can use site in accordance with their designation. Support change
ALTERNATIVE ZONE of zone at 119 Walters Road from SH to MHS where managing flooding risks does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH
zone and gives effect to the RPS. Support change of main Army Camp site at 143 Porchester Road
from SH to MHS to reflect zoning of neighbouring residential zones. The MHS zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. The site is
not located adjacent to a centre and rezoning to MU would not achieve the objectives of the MU zone
or give effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is located within close proximity to the
CHANGE OF ZONE
Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned
to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - The site is not within
CHANGE; SUPPORT close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not suitable for further intensification.
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Although the SH zone could be retained due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot
zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
CHANGE; SUPPORT retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
RETENTION OF
and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
N/A
Unclear where this property is - legal description not found in Council's system
MU
TC
Takanini Sub
Precinct C,
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
Manurewa
Page 44
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
ALTERNATIVE ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
TONEA
Properties (New
Zealand) Limited
(Attn: Richard
Brabant)
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
14, BUNDENA PLACE, Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS
New Zealand
Defence Force
(Rob Owen)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
SH
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
MHS
Yes
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
N/A
N/A
N/A
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MU to TC. The zoning of what is now the Takanini Town Centre No change
and its extent was debated in Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 12.
This plan change also determined the extent of Mixed Use zoning east of the railway line and the
location and extent of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent
Environment Court decisions (most recently in 2012) on this plan change, change of zone is not
proposed. MU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone, and gives effect
to the RPS, including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5227 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 9, BEDLINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
9, BEDLINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
24, SHARLAND
AVENUE, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
MHS
MHU
N/A
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
269, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, Clendon Park
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
253, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, Clendon Park
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
6, NIELD ROAD,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
THAB
Yes
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
THAB
Yes
No
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as THAB
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Page 45
Support change of zone to THAB - the sites are located around the Clendon Park Local Centre and
POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density in this location will promote a walkable
neighbourhood and could improve the vitality of the centre. The area is not currently serviced by a
RFN, however it is connected by buses to Manurewa Train Station. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate
CHANGE; SUPPORT way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
CHANGE; SUPPORT Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
RETENTION OF
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
NOTIFIED ZONE
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from SH to MHU The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
CHANGE OF ZONE
and POS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaing a SH zone. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. The
adjoining properties (113, 115, 119 Russell Road) also need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to
prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
CHANGE OF ZONE
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5275 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 50, WINSFORD
STREET, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 289,285,287,291,
289,285,287,291,
WEYMOUTH ROAD, Weymouth- WEYMOUTH ROAD,
Manurewa East from Mixed
Clendon Park
Housing Suburban to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
13, AWAKINO PLACE, Any residential
Homai Station
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Rezone 2, BRIGHTWELL
STREET, Papakura from Single
House to Mixed Housing
Suburban.
Rezone 37, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
2, BRIGHTWELL
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
37, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
28, CHRISARDA
PLACE, Red Hill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
3, YANG PLACE,
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
MHS
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa SouthMHS
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
24, CHRISTMAS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
8, ROSEMEAD
PLACE, Randwick
Park
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
29, INNISMARA
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Page 46
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - the site is located adjacent to a Neighbourhood Centre
and is within close proximity to a RFN and therefore achieves the objectives of the MHU zone. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is located on a RFN and has good access to
Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station. Increased density along this transport corridor
achieves the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Adjoining properties also need
to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a
spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5324 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 11, MAIDA VALE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
11, MAIDA VALE,
Manurewa
5, PAWA PLACE,
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
4885-4
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - Spot zoning in this
CHANGE; SUPPORT location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
ALTERNATIVE ZONE context. The site is not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not
suitable for further intensification. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of notified MU zone. The zoning of what is now the Takanini Town Centre and its
CHANGE; SUPPORT extent was debated in Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 12. This plan
RETENTION OF
change also determined the extent of MU zoning east of the railway line and the location and extent
NOTIFIED ZONE
of what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent Environment Court decisions
(most recently in 2012) on this plan change, change of zone is not proposed. MU is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MU zone, and gives effect to the RPS, including the
centres strategy/hierarchy.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
RETENTION OF
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
NOTIFIED ZONE
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
CHANGE; SUPPORT retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
RETENTION OF
and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
30 Walters Road,
Takanini
MU
MU
Takanini Sub
Precinct C,
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
25, SHEEHAN
AVENUE, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
21, YEARSLEY
PLACE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
60,
GREENMEADOWS
AVENUE, Manurewa
East
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
S11
Papakura East
Urban
(South)
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
TONEA
Properties (New
Zealand) Limited
(Attn: Richard
Brabant)
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
52, SHARLAND
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
56, CARGILL
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Page 47
Support rezoning from SH to MHS where managing flood risks on this site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change of zone from MHS to THAB, support change to MHU - the site is not located
CHANGE; SUPPORT in close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been
ALTERNATIVE ZONE provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of
growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should
also be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. Managing flooding
risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support rezoning from SH to MHS where managing flood risks on this site does not require
CHANGE; SUPPORT maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
RETENTION OF
MHS zone.
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5353 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 400, ROSCOMMON
400, ROSCOMMON
ROAD, Wiri-Manurewa from
ROAD, Wiri-Manurewa
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 4, ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
4, ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
S11
6, ROMNEY PLACE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
74, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
21, CLAYMORE
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
40, VALENTINE
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
66, VALENTINE
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
29, ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
9, TUNA PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa SouthMHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
3, BECKER DRIVE,
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
7, BRENT PLACE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
Papakura East
MHS
Page 48
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
and a higher level of intensification will increase the capacity of housing with good access to public
transport. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent
spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Support the rezoning of SH on this site to MHS as managing flooding risks on this site does not
require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support the rezoning of SH on this site to MHS as managing flooding risks on this site does not
require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a
spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5381 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 19, MCDIVITT STREET,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
4524-1
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Manuroa Road
Limited (Attn:
Philip Comer)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
Any residential
MHU
Flooding
Manurewa SouthMHS
properties subject to a
constraints
key overlay
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
7, HARROW PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
2, RAKO PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
160, WORDSWORTH
ROAD,2, JOHN
WALKER DRIVE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
22, HEATHDALE
Any residential
CRESCENT, Papakura properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
33, CHRISTMAS
ROAD, Manurewa
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
5, ROMNEY PLACE,
Manurewa
9, GIBBONS ROAD,
Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
Page 49
REASONS
Do not support change of zone to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a
spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for this site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. It is noted that this land is now a Special Housing
Area, forming part of the Takanini Strategic Area. The zoning of the residential component of the
portion of Takanini sub precinct D bounded by Grove Road, Walters Road and Porchester Road (the
Cosgrave Structure Plan area) was determined by a plan change for Takanini Structure Plan Area 2A
( Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Private Plan Change 4 (operative 2010). MHU
zoning is not appropriate as it would create a spot zone, a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified
zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for this site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5412 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 3, SLIM PLACE, Clendon 3, SLIM PLACE,
Park from Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
11, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
40, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
61, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
31A, SHEEHAN
AVENUE, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
2/129,1/129, OLD
WAIROA ROAD,
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
26, KENNINGTON
DRIVE, Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
35, RIVERTON
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
DRIVE, Randwick Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
16, HEATHDALE
Any residential
Papakura CRESCENT, Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
MHS
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
103, HYPERION
Any residential
DRIVE, Randwick Park properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
The Gardens
Page 50
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
This site is affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5469 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 7, CRISPIAN PLACE,
Weymouth from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
91, FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
17, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
41, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
114, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
29,29A, FERNAIG
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Page 51
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built character of
this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone at 29A Fernaig Street, Papakura - MHS is the most appropriate zone
for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. Do not support rezoning of 29
Fernaig Street, Papakura from SH to MHS as this site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7335 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 36, CARGILL
STREET,15, PRESIDENT
AVENUE, Papakura from Single
House to Mixed Housing
Suburban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
56,58, VALENTINE
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
9, HINTON PLACE,
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
3, BARNARD PLACE,
Manurewa East
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
6, BARNARD PLACE,
Manurewa East
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
7, HOBMAN PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
15, VOLANTE
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
49, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
5, ANTALYA PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
Page 52
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is in close proximity to Te Mahia Train
No change
Station, however Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification here may compete
with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for surrounding
Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for intensification. The notified zoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU The properties are in close proximity to Te
Mahia Train Station, however Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification here
may compete with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for
surrounding Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for intensification. Managing flooding
risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5569 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 102, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
102, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 47B,47A,47,45,45A,45B,
KELVIN ROAD, Papakura from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 12, CARTER PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
S12
4969-1
Planner's Position
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
61 Grove Road,
Papakura
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
95, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
53C,53A, KELVIN
ROAD, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
92, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
12, VOLANTE
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Sunland
Urban
Investments
(South)
Limited and Chan
Wah Kim/Hock
Lye Ng and Teng
Yeng Ng/Hoch
San Ng (Attn:
Philip Comer)
S12
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
5448-1
Homai Station
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
73, HEYBRIDGE
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
52, HEYBRIDGE
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
Page 53
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified MHS zone. It is noted that this land is now a Special Housing Area,
forming part of the Takanini Strategic Area. The zoning of the residential component of the portion of
Takanini sub precinct D bounded by Grove Road, Walters Road and Porchester Road (the Cosgrave
Structure Plan area) was determined by a plan change for Takanini Structure Plan Area 2A (
Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Private Plan Change 4 (operative 2010). It is
noted that resource consent for residential development has been granted for the site. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. It is noted that this land is now a Special Housing
Area, forming part of the Takanini Strategic Area. The zoning of the residential component of the
portion of Takanini sub precinct D bounded by Grove Road, Walters Road and Porchester Road (the
Cosgrave Structure Plan area) was determined by a plan change for Takanini Structure Plan Area 2A
( Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Private Plan Change 4 (operative 2010). MHU
zoning is not appropriate as it would create a spot zone, a spot zone will not generally achieve the
integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5598 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 17, RIMU ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
17, RIMU ROAD,
Manurewa
Rezone 2, BEDLINGTON
AVENUE,107, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 37, EASTBURN
STREET,24,26,22, HARPER
STREET,8,7, LIDDY PLACE,
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 70, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
2, BEDLINGTON
AVENUE,107,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
37, EASTBURN
Any residential
STREET,24,26,22,
properties subject to a
HARPER STREET,8,7, key overlay
LIDDY PLACE,
Papakura
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
70, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station MHU
and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing with good access to
public transport. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
S11
10, SWALLOW
DRIVE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
8, TAMWORTH
CLOSE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
No
No
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
Urban
(South)
11,10,12, HARRIER
PLACE,10,
EASTBURN STREET,
Papakura
23, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Papakura East
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. Managing
flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to
be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change to MHU. These sites are affected by flooding constraints and retaining the
notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
12, ADVOCATE
PLACE, Randwick
Park
MHU
N/A
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
3, MCDOUGALL
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
STREET,19, LINCOLN Urban/Mixed Housing
ROAD, Manurewa East Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHS
MHU
N/A
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
59, FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
17, CHRISTMAS
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
The Gardens
The Gardens
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 54
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5634 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 12, FUNNELL PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
12, FUNNELL PLACE, Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Urban
(South)
S13
2,4, HARRIER
PLACE,12,
EASTBURN
STREET,11,9,13,
WING CRESCENT,
Papakura
Papakura East
SH
MHU
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 13 Wing Crescent, support change to MHS as an SH/MHS
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT alternative zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to
Industry Air Quality ALTERNATIVE ZONE Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 2, 4 Harrier Place, 12 Eastburn Street and 9, 11
Wing Cresent - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
839-5643 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
24, RANGATAUA
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
179, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, WeymouthManurewa East
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
49, SHARLAND
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
23, RANGATAUA
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
1, MINTON PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
138, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
9, HEALY ROAD,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
and a higher level of intensification will increase the capacity of housing with good access to public
transport. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent
spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
and a higher level of intensification will increase the capacity of housing with good access to public
transport. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent
spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU at 12A and 12B Wing Crescent - MHS is the most
appropriate zone for these sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 4, 8, 10 Wing Crescent - these sites are affected
by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
68, FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Page 55
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
7289-1
SUBMITTER
NAME
Murdoch Newell
Limited (Attn:
John Murdoch)
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S12
Rezone 344 Airfield Road,
344 Airfield Road,
Ardmore from Mixed Rural to Light Ardmore
Industry.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Combined rezoning and Rural
precinct submissions
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MR
LI
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
24, MCDIVITT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
67A,67, KELVIN
ROAD, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
4, MINTON PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
11, SHARLAND
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
15, SUNLANDS
DRIVE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
13, PRIMROSE
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
26, SUNLANDS
DRIVE,47,
ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
THAB
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 2, BLACKGATE
PLACE,30, TAITIMU DRIVE,
Weymouth from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
2, BLACKGATE
PLACE,30, TAITIMU
DRIVE, Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
8,6, HARPER
STREET, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHU
Papakura East
Clendon Park
MHU
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MR to LI. The site can rely on existing use rights for its light
industrial activity. While the land is across the road from Ardmore Airport, which contains light
industrial uses, change of zone the land would create a spot zone to the north of Airfield Road.
Pressure to extend the industrial zone further into the MR zone could then eventuate. Retaining the
notified MR zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
NOTIFIED ZONE
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on
the sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support retention of MHS zone - the sites are within the Mill Road Precinct and have been
CHANGE; SUPPORT subject to zoning changes due to the precinct provisions. Support rezoning to SH - refer to Mill Road
ALTERNATIVE ZONE Precinct evidence. MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and the relevant precinct objectives, and gives effect to the RPS. This is an out of scope change see Attachment F.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
RETENTION OF
zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a
NOTIFIED ZONE
spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated
management of resources and does not recognise the local context. Retention of the MHS zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - Spot zoning in this
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
ALTERNATIVE ZONE context. The sites are not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not
suitable for further intensification. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the sites are affected by flooding constraints and
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
and give effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 56
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5727 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 8, CRAMPTON PLACE,
Manurewa from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
8, CRAMPTON
PLACE, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
18, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
7, BARNARD PLACE,
Manurewa East
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
46, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
74, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
4, JOSHUA PLACE,
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
45, HEYBRIDGE
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
Urban
(South)
S11
15, HEYBRIDGE
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S11
133, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, WeymouthManurewa East
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU The properties are in close proximity to Te
No change
Mahia Train Station, however Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification here
may compete with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for
surrounding Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for intensification. Managing flooding
risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - MHS is the most
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be retained due to the
site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone
will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS
zone and gives effect to the RPS. The adjoining properties (72 and 76 Gloucester Road) also need to
be rezoned to MHS (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU, support alternative change to SH - These sites
CHANGE; SUPPORT are affected by flooding constraints and rezoning to SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
ALTERNATIVE ZONE the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
SH
Yes
No
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Page 57
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5798 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 18, AARTS AVENUE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
18, AARTS AVENUE,
Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Homai Station
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
31, MCDIVITT
STREET, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S13
10B,9,10A, CITRIL
Any residential
PLACE,7B,7A,10B,10A properties subject to a
,6,9,8,1/11,2/11,
key overlay
DULCIE PLACE,47,
REDCREST AVENUE,
Papakura
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU for the remaining properties - MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on
these sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
63, FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
24, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
28, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
19, SUNLANDS
DRIVE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
23, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
3, AWAKINO PLACE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
35, REDCREST
AVENUE, Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
11,10,9,7,8, LEILANI
PLACE, Red Hill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
9, NIELD ROAD,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 120,120A,120C,120B,
CLEVEDON ROAD, Papakura
from Single House to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 25, HOTUROA PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
25, HOTUROA
PLACE, Manurewa
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 58
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on
the sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the sites are affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5825 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 7, CARBERY PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
7, CARBERY PLACE,
Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S11
5, TUNA PLACE,
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
8, DALMAHOY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
PLACE, Wattle Downs Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
18, BEAUMONTS
WAY, Manurewa
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
S12
LC
LC
Takanini Sub
precinct B,
Flooding
constraints
1705-10
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
Papakura East
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
27, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
6, WOODLARK
CLOSE, Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
18, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
43, WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
4, PAWA PLACE,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Clendon Park
Page 59
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change of zone to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in
CHANGE; SUPPORT close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been
RETENTION OF
provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of
NOTIFIED ZONE
growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should
also be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, support a change to MU zone - the site is adjacent to
CHANGE; SUPPORT properties zoned MU, so a change to THAB would be considered spot zoning. Spot zoning in this
ALTERNATIVE ZONE location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
context. The site is within close proximity to the Manurewa Town Centre and RFN and achieves the
MU zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS. This is an out of scope change - refer to Attachment
F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of notified LC zone. Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan
RETENTION OF
Change 12 determined the extent of MU zoning east of the railway line and the location and extent of
NOTIFIED ZONE
what is now the Addison Local Centre. Having regard to the recent Environment Court decisions
(most recently in 2012) on this plan change, no change of zone is proposed. Retention of the LC
Zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS,
including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5872 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 19, MINTON PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
160A,162, OLD
WAIROA ROAD,12,
PUKEROA PLACE,
Papakura
Papakura East
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU at 160A Old Wairoa Road and 12 Pukeroa Place MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan
Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
839-5878 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
4, TAITIMU DRIVE,
Weymouth
Urban
(South)
S11
S12
57163055
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Errors
Takinini
MHU
SH
Flooding
constraints,
Takanini Strategic
Area SHA
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
257, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, Clendon Park
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
21A, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
31,29, FAIRDALE
AVENUE, Red Hill
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
281, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, Clendon Park
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
4, HYWELL PLACE,
Manurewa
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
4, DEVERON ROAD,
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 60
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change from MHU to SH - The change will fix an error where the driveway of the property
SH
has been incorrectly zoned MHU. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
Support change of zone to THAB - the sites are located around the Clendon Park Local Centre and
POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density in this location will promote a walkable
neighbourhood and could improve the vitality of the centre. The area is not currently serviced by a
RFN, however it is connected by buses to Manurewa Train Station. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on
the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone to THAB - the sites are located around the Clendon Park Local Centre and
POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density in this location will promote a walkable
neighbourhood and could improve the vitality of the centre. The area is not currently serviced by a
RFN, however it is connected by buses to Manurewa Train Station. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for around Homai Station. Although
the SH zone could be applied due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone
would occur and in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of
resources and does not recognise the local context. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
THAB
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5907 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 7, KERRYDALE ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
7, KERRYDALE
ROAD, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
12, FAIRLIGHT
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
16 MCENTEE
STREET. Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
8, DEVERON ROAD,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 7, FRANGIPANI
AVENUE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
7, FRANGIPANI
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Papakura East
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change in zoning - the Manurewa Town Centre Concept Plan was taken into
CHANGE; SUPPORT account and the Local Board was consulted on the draft and PAUP. The zoning proposed in and
RETENTION OF
around the Town Centre provides for further intensification and revitalisation of the Centre. The
NOTIFIED ZONE
notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the zone objectives and gives effect to the
RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - MHS is the most
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. The adjoining properties (71 and 75
Gloucester Road) also need to be rezoned to MHS (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
CHANGE; SUPPORT it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
MHU
76, FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
12, DR PICKERING
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
35, INNISMARA
AVENUE,9,
GAMBARE PLACE,
Wattle Downs
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
18, ROSEMEAD
PLACE, Randwick
Park
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
S11
8, ASTOR PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
73, GLOUCESTER
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
30, GAMBARE
PLACE,154, MAHIA
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
24, TAMWORTH
CLOSE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
Homai Station
SH
MHS
Page 61
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
MHU
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5959 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 9, ANTALYA PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
9, ANTALYA PLACE,
Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change to MHU. The site is in close proximity to Homai Train Station and a LC. Rezoning to
MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
36, DAGENHAM
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
18, CLAYMORE
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
142, ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change to MHU. The site is in close proximity to Homai Train Station and a LC. Rezoning to MHU
MHU is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
168 CLEVEDON
ROAD. Papakura
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is affected by flooding constraints and
No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
3/502,2/502,1/502,
THAB Isolated or new
ROSCOMMON ROAD, areas
Manurewa
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
THAB
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 3/502,2/502,1/502,
ROSCOMMON ROAD, WiriManurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Rezone 11, VOLANTE AVENUE,
Wattle Downs from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
11, VOLANTE
AVENUE, Wattle
Downs
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
28, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
5, BETTINA PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone to THAB - the sites are located around the Clendon Park Local Centre and
POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density in this location will promote a walkable
neighbourhood and could improve the vitality of the centre. The area is not currently serviced by a
RFN, however it is connected by buses to Manurewa Train Station. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
MHU
Yes
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
Papakura East
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Clendon Park
Page 62
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
POINT
3458-2
SUBMITTER
NAME
Graeme Bell
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
FU
Unspecified
Flooding
constraints
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S12
Recognise the development
potential in the 'new Alfriston' area
bounded by Ranfurly Road
(north), Porchester Road (west)
Mill Road (east) and the Papakura
Stream (south). Refer to the full
submission for further details [vol
2, pages 2-5/7].
S13
Rezone 10 MILSON DRIVE.
Papakura from Single House to
Mixed Housing Suburban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Area bounded by
Future Urban Zone
Rural
Ranfurly Road (north), (FUZ) and rezoning
Porchester Road
(west) Mill Road (east)
and the Papakura
Stream (south)
10 MILSON DRIVE.
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHS
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
48, DAGENHAM
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
86A SETTLEMENT
ROAD. Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
SH
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
66, ALFRISTON
ROAD, Manurewa
Homai Station
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is affected by flooding constraints and
No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 12 Kent Road, Manurewa - the site ia affected by
flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change from FU zone. Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB expert
geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number of
constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. Do not support
change of zone because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure
planning needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within
the FU zone. Retaining the notified FU is the most appropriate way to achieve the obejctives of the
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and give effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU at 12A Kent Road, Manurewa - spot zoning in this
location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
context.
839-6023 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
15, SMEDLEY
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
137, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, WeymouthManurewa East
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
The Gardens
Page 63
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and Weymouth
Road is no longer on the RFN and therefore further intensification is not appropriate in this area. The
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-8228 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 7B LAURIE AVENUE.
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
7B LAURIE AVENUE.
Papakura
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Papakura properties subject to a East
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
3, BRENT PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
98-7
Urban
(South)
S13
23 and 27 Edmund
Hillary Avenue,
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
Unspecified
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
9, BERKELEY ROAD,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
2154-3
Urban
(South)
S13
27 Belgrave Place,
Papakura
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB Isolated or new
Clendon Park
areas
MHS
THAB
N/A
5515-6
Cabra
Development
Limited (Attn:
Lloyd Barker)
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
SH, MHS
SH/MHS
Takanini sub
Precinct E,
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
34, HEYBRIDGE
STREET, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
4B,4A, CAMERON
STREET, Papakura
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Robert D Adams
Dean Martin
Papakura East
Page 64
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and Weymouth
Road is no longer on the RFN and therefore further intensification is not appropriate in this area. The
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
No change
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
CHANGE OF ZONE
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
CHANGE OF ZONE
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. Managing
flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to
be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and
CHANGE; SUPPORT retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
RETENTION OF
and give effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
CHANGE OF ZONE
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. Managing
flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to
be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from SH to MHU The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
CHANGE OF ZONE
and POS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaing a SH zone. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. The
adjoining properties also need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of SH and MHS zones - SH and MHS are the most appropriate zones for the sites
RETENTION OF
as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN. SH is suitable for the areas constrained by
NOTIFIED ZONE
topography. The notified zones are the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH and
MHS zones and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-6099 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 29, SECRETARIAT
PLACE, Randwick Park from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 40, PALLANT STREET,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
29, SECRETARIAT
PLACE, Randwick
Park
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
57, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
25, YEARSLEY
PLACE, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
26, FEASEGATE
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
25, BELGRAVE
PLACE, Papakura
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 14, THOMPSON
14, THOMPSON
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
TERRACE, Manurewa from Mixed TERRACE, Manurewa Urban/Mixed Housing
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Suburban/Single House
Housing Urban.
Expansion/Contraction
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
1149-1
Urban
(South)
S12
FU
FU or
Residential
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
FIANZ
40, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
19, WINIATA
TERRACE, Papakura
205, WEYMOUTH
ROAD, WeymouthManurewa East
Rural
Page 65
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - The site is affected by flooding constraints and
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified FU zone. RUB expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for
Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB
which need detailed investigation. No rezonings of the FU zone is supported because detailed
assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning needs to be undertaken
before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FU zone. It is noted that
resource consent (dated November 2014) has been obtained for an Islamic Vocational Centre for this
site (463-471 Porchester Road), however it is supported that the zoning remain as FU zone until
appropriate live zonings for the entire FU zone area are determined. Retention of the notified FU
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the FU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to THAB. The site is in close proximity to Clendon LC and
rezoning to THAB is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
THAB
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-6127 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 12, FEASEGATE
STREET, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
22, FERGUSON
STREET, Manurewa
Manurewa
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
22, BELGRAVE
PLACE, Papakura
MHS
MHS
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Rezone 27, FROBISHER WAY,
27, FROBISHER WAY, Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Clendon Park from Mixed Housing Clendon Park
Suburban/Single House
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Expansion/Contraction
Urban.
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
MHS
MHS
2947-3
Urban
(South)
S12
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Intersection of Alfriston Future Urban Zone
Rural
and Mill Roads.
(FUZ) and rezoning
FU
MHS, NC
Urban
(South)
S11
34, YEARSLEY
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
4, WAIMAI AVENUE,
Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
4930-1
Ray Wallace
Limited
Urban
(South)
S12
Rural
FU
MHS
5590-1
Warren J and
Dianne E Kyd
Urban
(South)
S12
Rural
FU
Unspecified
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Alfriston
Landowners
Group and
Associated
Parties
10B,10A, CHANTAL
PLACE, Red Hill
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
RETENTION OF
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
NOTIFIED ZONE
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Heavy Industry Air SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
Quality
RETENTION OF
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
NOTIFIED ZONE
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from FU to MHS and NC. Land also the subject of RUB submissions.
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT RUB expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a
RETENTION OF
number of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No
NOTIFIED ZONE
rezoning is supported because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and
structure planning needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for
land within the FU zone. The notified FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - Spot zoning in this
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
ALTERNATIVE ZONE context. The site is not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not
suitable for further intensification. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from FU to MHS. Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number
RETENTION OF
of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No rezonings is
NOTIFIED ZONE
supported because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning
needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FU
zone. The notified FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the FU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from FU. Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB expert
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number of
RETENTION OF
constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No rezonings is
NOTIFIED ZONE
supported because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning
needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FU
zone. The notified FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Page 66
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-6172 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 9, PIRITI PLACE,
Weymouth from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
9, PIRITI PLACE,
Weymouth
Urban
(South)
S13
14, PRESIDENT
AVENUE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S11
7, CARN PLACE,
Weymouth
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for in the areas within close
walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to MHU, support a less intensive zone of MHS - MHS is the most
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to MHU, support a less intensive zone of MHS - MHS is the most
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. Adjoining properties also need to be changed to MHS
zone (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
CHANGE; SUPPORT the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
RETENTION OF
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHS
N/A
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
2, JOSIE LANE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
6 Josie Lane,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
43,115,61,117,63,2/47,
113,67,83,81,119,87,4
9,45,29,35,97,65,75,71
,91,103,93,95,107,79,1
05,77,39,59,33,57,51,5
3,1/47,1/25-4/25,
SHIFNAL DRIVE,
Randwick Park
30,28, SHIFNAL
DRIVE, Randwick Park
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
10,8, SECRETARIAT Mixed Housing
The Gardens
PLACE, Randwick
Urban/Mixed Housing
Park
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
77,81,79, ALFRISTON Mixed Housing
Manurewa
ROAD,2,4, SCOTTS
Urban/Mixed Housing
ROAD, Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone
43,115,61,117,63,2/47,113,67,83,
81,119,87,49,45,29,35,97,65,75,7
1,91,103,93,95,107,79,105,77,39,
59,33,57,51,53,1/47,1/25-4/25,
SHIFNAL DRIVE, Randwick Park
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone 30,28, SHIFNAL DRIVE,
Randwick Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 10,8, SECRETARIAT
PLACE, Randwick Park from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 77,81,79, ALFRISTON
ROAD,2,4, SCOTTS ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 32,38,30,36,34, SCOTTS
ROAD, Manurewa East from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
32,38,30,36,34,
SCOTTS ROAD,
Manurewa East
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
The Gardens
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
The Gardens
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
The Gardens
The Gardens
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Page 67
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-6715 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 50,48, HYPERION
DRIVE, Randwick Park from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 76,74, HYPERION
DRIVE,2, NEARCO STREET,
Randwick Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 31,29, HORLICKS
PLACE, Randwick Park from
Single House to Mixed Housing
Suburban.
S11
Rezone 58,56,60,62,64,66,70,68,
TRIMDON STREET, Randwick
Park from Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban.
S11
Rezone
11,13,38,15,17,23,19,32,30,28,13
A,34,9A,3,36,5,7,9,11A, KERI
ANNE PLACE, Goodwood
Heights from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S12
Rezone 311 Porchester Rd and
54 Berwyn Ave, Takanini from
Future Urban to Mixed Housing
Suburban
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
50,48, HYPERION
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
DRIVE, Randwick Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
76,74, HYPERION
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
DRIVE,2, NEARCO
Urban/Mixed Housing
STREET, Randwick
Suburban/Single House
Park
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
6619-1
Evans Family
Trust
Urban
(South)
7344-34
The Church of
Urban
Jesus Christ of
(South)
Latter-day Saints
Trust Board
S12
6449-1
S12
5657-9
Tegel Foods
Limited
Urban
(south)
S12
6963-1
Metalman New
Zealand Limited
Urban
(south)
S12
Transpacific
Industries Group
(New Zealand)
Limited
839-1554 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(south)
S12
Urban
(South)
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone to MHU, support change to THAB. The site is within close proximity to No change
the Manurewa Town Centre and Manurewa Train Station and can support more intensive growth.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. Rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS. This is an
out of scope change - please see Attachment F.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from FU to MHS. Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB
No change
expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number
of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No rezonings is
supported because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning
needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FU
zone. The notified FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from FU to MHS. RUB expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence No change
for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number of constraints both inside and beyond the
RUB which need detailed investigation. No change of zone of the FU zone is supported because
detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure planning needs to be
undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within the FU zone. It is
noted that resource consent (dated 2013) has been obtained for a church on this site which is
currently being constructed, however the notified FU zone is supported until appropriate live zonings
for the entire FU zone area are determined. The FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified LI zone for 81 Spartan Road. The LI zone is the most appropriate way to LI/HI
achieve the objectives of the zone. Support change of zone from LI to HI for 1 Rawson Way and 58
Spartan Road. See Council evidence from Joy LaNauze for Topic 051-054 Centre Zones, Business
park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls. The HI zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
REASONS
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
The Gardens
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
The Gardens
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
MHS
MHU
N/A
Rural
FU
MHS
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Rural
FU
MHS
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
LI
LI
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN PART;
PARTIAL CHANGE
LI
HI
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone of site from HI to LI. See Council evidence from Joy LaNauze for Topic 051- HI
054 Centre Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls.
The LI zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Yes
No
LI
HI
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
No
LI
HI
No
No
S12
1/28,2/28, CHALLEN
CLOSE, Conifer
Grove.
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHS
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support change of zone from LI to HI. See Council evidence from Joy LaNauze for Topic 051-054
HI
Centre Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls. The
HI zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from LI to HI. See Council evidence from Joy LaNauze for Topic 051- No change
054 Centre Zones, Business park and industries zones, Business activities and Business Controls.
Retaining the LI zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximitiy to centres and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
Coastal Inundation,
Flooding
constraints
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximitiy to centres or an RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
1/24,2/24,
BALGOWAN
TERRACE, Conifer
Grove.
21, GREAT SOUTH
ROAD, Takanini.
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximitiy to centres and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
1/32, 2/32
KINDERGARTEN
DRIVE. Conifer Grove
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximitiy to centres and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
Conifer Grove
MHS
MHU
N/A
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. It is not in close proximitiy to centres and it maintains the planned
suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - the site is significantly affected by flooding
No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified MHS zone. Adjoins FU zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or
an RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
877-65
31,29, HORLICKS
PLACE, Randwick
Park
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
11,13,38,15,17,23,19,3
2,30,28,13A,34,9A,3,3
6,5,7,9,11A, KERI
ANNE PLACE,
Goodwood Heights
49H,49J,49K,49D,49E,
49F,49G,49A,49B,49C
, TAKA STREET,
Takanini
38A, BERWYN
AVENUE, Takanini
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Takinini
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 68
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1636 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S12
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 47B,47A, BERWYN AVENUE,
Takanini.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
47B,47A, BERWYN
AVENUE, Takanini
1/7,2/7, BERWYN
AVENUE, Takanini
20C,18A,20B,16A,20D,
WATERVIEW ROAD
WEST, Takanini.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
LOCALITY
Takinini
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
Takinini
MHS
MHU
N/A
Takinini
MHU
MHU
N/A
Takinini
MHU
MHU
Takinini
MHU
Takinini
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHU zone - the site is in close proximity to a RFN and Takanini Town Centre.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHU zone - the site is in close proximity to a RFN and Takanini Town Centre.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHU zone - the site is in close proximity to a RFN and Takanini Town Centre.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Takinini
MHU
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHU zone - the site is in close proximity to a RFN and Takanini Town Centre.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Takinini
MHS
MHU
Takanini Sub
precinct D,
Flooding
constraints,
National Grid
Corridor (NGC)
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU. The zoning of the residential component of 250
No change
Porchester Road (31 Airfield Road) was determined by plan changes for part Takanini Structure Plan
Area 1A ( Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 12 (operative 2012)) and
part Area 1B ( Auckland Council District Plan (Papakura section) Plan Change 3 operative 2005).
Subdivision plans for the majority of the area have been approved, and the majority of the area has
now been built on, creating a subdivision pattern which does not allow for additional dwelling sites to
be created. MHS best reflects the approved development pattern. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Rural Countryside
Living (CL)
Rural
MR
CL
Ridgeline
Protection, SEA,
Flooding
constraints, Soil
Types B and C1
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MR to CL. MR is a more appropriate zone than CL because the No change
area does not meet the criteria for areas identified for CL in RPS B8.3 Rural Subdivision policy 6. In
particular part of the land is classified as Land Use Capacity Class 2 land (prime land). Retention of
the MR Zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
No
No
Rural Other
Rural
MR
MR
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Rezone
24,10,12,20,14,22,16,18,4,6,8,
KERI ANNE PLACE, Goodwood
Heights from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 388,382,390,384,386,
ROSCOMMON ROAD,9, NEEMS
PLACE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 195,197,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
24,10,12,20,14,22,16,1
8,4,6,8, KERI ANNE
PLACE, Goodwood
Heights
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified MR zone. MR zone accommodates a range of rural production activities No change
and associated non-residential activities while still ensuring good amenity levels for residents who
use their land for rural lifestyle purposes. Retention of the MR Zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not No change
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
388,382,390,384,386,
ROSCOMMON
ROAD,9, NEEMS
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
195,197,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S12
109 PORCHESTER
ROAD. Takanini
Urban
(South)
S13
1, LANSDOWN
PLACE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
62, CARGILL
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S12
5711-1
Addison
Developments
Limited (Attn:
Emma Bayly)
Urban
(South)
S12
4021-3
S12
3/106,2/106,1/106,
PORCHESTER ROAD,
Takanin
1/28-5/28,22,
WATERVIEW ROAD
WEST, Takanini
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 69
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7123 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 47,51,49, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
47,51,49, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Rezone 200,202,204,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 5, POUTINI
PLACE,188,186,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,3,
FUNNELL PLACE, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone 175,173,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,60,58,
PALLANT STREET, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone 52, PALLANT
STREET,34, SMEDLEY STREET,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 27, PALLANT
STREET,380, ROSCOMMON
ROAD,8,4,6, PUSHON PLACE,
Clendon Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 15,17, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
200,202,204,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
5, POUTINI
PLACE,188,186,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,3, FUNNELL
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
175,173,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,60,58,
PALLANT STREET,
Manurewa
52, PALLANT
STREET,34,
SMEDLEY STREET,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
27, PALLANT
STREET,380,
ROSCOMMON
ROAD,8,4,6, PUSHON
PLACE, Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
15,17, PALLANT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
24, BURBANK
AVENUE,24,26,22,
YEARSLEY PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
14, SMEDLEY
STREET,40,
ARNWOOD STREET,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Clendon Park
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
11,13, BURBANK
Any residential
AVENUE,11,13,15,17, properties subject to a
18,1,3,5,7,9, NINA
key overlay
PLACE, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
12,14,16, NINA
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
Urban
(South)
S11
27, BRENTFORD
PLACE,28,
DAGENHAM STREET,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S11
20,21,16, WENLOCK
PLACE, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
19,17, WENLOCK
PLACE,24,
ARNWOOD STREET,
Manurewa
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change to MHU. Support rezoning from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on these
CHANGE; SUPPORT sites does not require maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Page 70
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7139 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 14, ARNWOOD
STREET,155, WORDSWORTH
ROAD,11,13,1,3,5,7,9,
WENLOCK PLACE, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 10,12,4,6, WENLOCK
PLACE,10,8,12,14,6, HOBMAN
PLACE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 161,163,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 137,135,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,82,80,86,88,78,
ROWANDALE AVENUE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 138,136,140,134,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,32,39,30,
ORATU PLACE,64,66,
ROWANDALE AVENUE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 56A-56F, ROWANDALE
AVENUE,31,37,29,35, ORATU
PLACE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 6, JOHN WALKER
DRIVE,11,15,17,1A,3,1B,5,7,
ORATU PLACE, Manurewa from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 164,168,170,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 6, TUNA PLACE,8,
POUTINI PLACE, Manurewa from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
14, ARNWOOD
STREET,155,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,11,13,1,3,5,7,9,
WENLOCK PLACE,
Manurewa
10,12,4,6, WENLOCK
PLACE,10,8,12,14,6,
HOBMAN PLACE,
Manurewa
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of driveway to SH zone - the property that this driveway serves has been
rezoned to MHS as managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone.
Therefore the driveway subject to this submission is no longer a spot zone and does not require
amending. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
161,163,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
137,135,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,82,80,86,88,78,
ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
138,136,140,134,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,32,39,30,
ORATU PLACE,64,66,
ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
56A-56F,
ROWANDALE
AVENUE,31,37,29,35,
ORATU PLACE,
Manurewa
6, JOHN WALKER
DRIVE,11,15,17,1A,3,1
B,5,7, ORATU PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support rezoning from SH to MHS. Managing flooding risks on this site does not require maintaining
CHANGE; SUPPORT a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
ALTERNATIVE ZONE effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
164,168,170,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
6, TUNA PLACE,8,
POUTINI PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Rezone 176,178,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 10,8, STELLA PLACE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
176,178,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 212A,212B,212,
212A,212B,212,
RUSSELL ROAD, Manurewa from RUSSELL ROAD,
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Manurewa
Housing Urban.
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
and a higher level of intensification will increase the capacity of housing with good access to public
transport. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent
spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing with good access to
public transport. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing with good access to
public transport. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
MHU
Yes
No
Clendon Park
Page 71
MHS
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7155 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 13,15, HEALY
ROAD,25,21,23, WATTS ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 18,14,16, HEALY ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 6, HEALY
ROAD,11,13,15,17,3,5,7,9,
ARBOR CLOSE, Manurewa from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
18,14,16, HEALY
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
6, HEALY
Any residential
Homai Station
ROAD,11,13,15,17,3,5 properties subject to a
,7,9, ARBOR CLOSE, key overlay
Manurewa
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS, MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Yes
No
No change
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Support change of zone at 17 Arbor Close from MHS to MHU The site is within close proximity to
Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing
with good access to public transport. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect
to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot
zoning, see Attachment F.
839-7158 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
25,21,23, ARBOR
CLOSE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
31,30,28,29, ARBOR
CLOSE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 24,10,12,20,14,16,18,8,
ARBOR CLOSE,18,14,
PRIMROSE PLACE, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Any residential
24,10,12,20,14,16,18,8 properties subject to a
, ARBOR
key overlay
CLOSE,18,14,
PRIMROSE PLACE,
Manurewa
Homai Station
MHS, MHU
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The sites are within close proximity to Homai Train
Station and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing with good
access to public transport. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The sites are within close proximity to Homai Train
Station and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing with good
access to public transport. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Support retention of MHU zone at properties 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18, 20, 24 Arbor Close the sites are
within close proximity to Homai Train Station and are suitable for intensification. Managing flooding
risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone at 14 and 18 Primrose Place from MHS to MHU MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
39,37, ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
45,43, ADDINGTON
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
AVENUE,2, HARROW Urban/Mixed Housing
PLACE, Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
60,62, ADDINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
54,52, SUNLANDS
DRIVE,24,22, MAIDA
VALE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
8B,8A, SUNLANDS
DRIVE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
8,4,6, BRENT
PLACE,39,37,
SUNLANDS DRIVE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
19,21,17,
BEDLINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Homai Station
Page 72
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. Sufficient
intensification has already been provided surrounding Homai Train Station. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. Sufficient
intensification has already been provided surrounding Homai Train Station. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided for
around Homai Station. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7169 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 33,31, BEDLINGTON
AVENUE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
111A,115,121,117,123
,125,113,127,119,
WORDSWORTH
ROAD,10,20,22,
BEDLINGTON
AVENUE,103,101,107,
109,105,
ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
132,122,130,124,126,1
28, WORDSWORTH
ROAD,99,
ROWANDALE
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone
111A,115,121,117,123,125,113,1
27,119, WORDSWORTH
ROAD,10,20,22, BEDLINGTON
AVENUE,103,101,107,109,105,
ROWANDALE AVENUE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone
132,122,130,124,126,128,
WORDSWORTH ROAD,99,
ROWANDALE AVENUE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 17, AWAKINO
PLACE,114,108,116,110,112,106,
118, WORDSWORTH ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 55,57, AARTS AVENUE,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
No
17, AWAKINO
Any residential
PLACE,114,108,116,1 properties subject to a
10,112,106,118,
key overlay
WORDSWORTH
ROAD, Manurewa
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites
No change
are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
55,57, AARTS
AVENUE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
68, WORDSWORTH
ROAD,19,21,
FAIRLIGHT PLACE,
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
11,13, RONALD
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
428,432,430,
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
ROSCOMMON ROAD, Urban/Mixed Housing
Wiri-Manurewa
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
464,462,
THAB Isolated or new
ROSCOMMON ROAD, areas
Manurewa
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
472,470,
THAB Isolated or new
ROSCOMMON ROAD, areas
Manurewa
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of MHS to THAB. These sites are in close proximity to the Clendon LC and are
suitable for more intensive residential development. Rezoning to THAB is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
MHU
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change of zone from MHS to THAB, support change to MHU - the sites are not
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT located in close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has
ALTERNATIVE ZONE been provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate
level of growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block
should also be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. Managing
flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of MHS to THAB. These sites are in close proximity to the Clendon LC and are
THAB
CHANGE OF ZONE
suitable for more intensive residential development. Rezoning to THAB is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
486,484,482,
THAB Isolated or new
ROSCOMMON ROAD, areas
Manurewa
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of MHS to THAB. These sites are in close proximity to the Clendon LC and are
suitable for more intensive residential development. Rezoning to THAB is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB
Yes
No
Page 73
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7184 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 11,13, LANDETTE
ROAD, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
11,13, LANDETTE
ROAD, Manurewa
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
494,492,
THAB Isolated or new
ROSCOMMON ROAD, areas
Manurewa
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
14,16, MINTON
PLACE, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
55,51,53, RUSSELL
ROAD,103,
GLOUCESTER
ROAD,22, JUTLAND
ROAD,9,13,12,7,
BALFOUR ROAD,
Manurewa
22C,22B,22A,
FRANCES STREET,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
24, JUTLAND
Any residential
ROAD,138,142,140,
properties subject to a
GLOUCESTER ROAD, key overlay
Manurewa
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Homai Station
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
13,15, CAMBRIDGE
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
2,4, MCGREAL
PLACE,5, TAITIMU
DRIVE, Weymouth
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, support alternative change to MHU. The site is not located
CHANGE; SUPPORT in close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Town Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. Although the SH zone could be applied due
to the sites being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot
zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the
local context. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as
CHANGE; SUPPORT they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for in the areas within close
NOTIFIED ZONE
walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - MHS is the most
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. The adjoining property (11 Cambridge
Street) also need to be rezoned to MHS (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
CHANGE; SUPPORT in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
NOTIFIED ZONE
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
MHS
MHU
N/A
Clendon Park
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 74
Support change of MHS to THAB. These sites are in close proximity to the Clendon LC and are
suitable for more intensive residential development. Rezoning to THAB is the most appropriate way
to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
THAB
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a
RFN and maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS - the site is significantly affected by flooding No change
constraints. SH is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give
effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7199 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 476,474, WEYMOUTH
ROAD,4, JUSTAMERE
PLACE,11,12,15,14,1,3,2,5,4,7,6,
9,8, GILA PLACE,13, JOSHUA
PLACE, Weymouth from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 479, WEYMOUTH
ROAD,1,3,5, SETTLERS COVE,1,
TONSON PLACE, Weymouth
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
476,474, WEYMOUTH
ROAD,4, JUSTAMERE
PLACE,11,12,15,14,1,
3,2,5,4,7,6,9,8, GILA
PLACE,13, JOSHUA
PLACE, Weymouth
479, WEYMOUTH
ROAD,1,3,5,
SETTLERS COVE,1,
TONSON PLACE,
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
507, WEYMOUTH
ROAD,3, GIBBONS
ROAD, Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
8, WOODLARK
CLOSE,501,
WEYMOUTH ROAD,
Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Clendon Park
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a
RFN and maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of 8 Woodlark Close from SH to MHU. Support change to MHS as an
CHANGE; SUPPORT alternative - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The
ALTERNATIVE ZONE rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to
the RPS. The adjoining property zoned SH (499 Weymouth Road) should also be rezoned to MHS
(out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No
No
Do not support change of 501 Weymouth Road from MHS to MHU - the sites are not within close
proximity to a centre or RFN and are not suitable for further intensification. The notified zoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
839-7205 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
73, PALMERS
ROAD,1,9,5,7,
KENNINGTON DRIVE,
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
57,59, PALMERS
ROAD, Clendon Park
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
SH
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Yes
No
S11
Rezone 300,1/296,298,2/296,294,
WEYMOUTH
ROAD,318,312,322,320,326,324,
328, MAHIA ROAD, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the sites are not located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for in
ALTERNATIVE ZONE areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and will
act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not
require maintaining a SH zone. The surrounding block should also be rezoned to MHU (out of scope)
to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the sites are located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre however crossing to the Local Centre from this
ALTERNATIVE ZONE area does not have a safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth
and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The rezoning is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
310, WEYMOUTH
ROAD,8, DAMIAN
WAY, Weymouth
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
No
Urban
(South)
S11
11,9,7, LEAVER
PLACE, Weymouth
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
6,12,14,16, LEAVER
THAB Isolated or new
PLACE,296,300,302,3 areas
04,298, MAHIA ROAD,
Manurewa
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the sites are located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre however crossing to the Local Centre from this
ALTERNATIVE ZONE area does not have a safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth
and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The rezoning is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support change of zone to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and
RETENTION OF
gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
NOTIFIED ZONE
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
345,347,349,343,
MAHIA ROAD,
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
10, LOUGHINISLAND
PLACE,73,71,
GLENVEAGH PARK
DRIVE, Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Page 75
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7213 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 72,70, CASTLEFINN
DRIVE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
72,70, CASTLEFINN
DRIVE, Manurewa
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
365,363,361, MAHIA
ROAD,55,47,65,67,
CASTLEFINN DRIVE,
Manurewa
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not No change
in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 379,381,389,385,387,
MAHIA
ROAD,25,27,21,33,31,29,35,5,
CASTLEFINN DRIVE, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Rezone 8,6, CASTLEFINN
DRIVE, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
8,6, CASTLEFINN
DRIVE, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
45,49,41, PALMERS
Any residential
ROAD,11,13,15,17,7,9 properties subject to a
, HATHERLEY PLACE, key overlay
Clendon Park
Clendon Park
SH, MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
19,15, KENNINGTON
DRIVE, Clendon Park
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
339,341, MAHIA
ROAD, Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
18,20,14,16, CARN
PLACE, Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Rezone
43,25,26,27,21,23,28,29,41,3,5,7,
9,39A,11,39B,13,15,17,19,32,31,3
0,37,35,33, HANFORD
PLACE,11,1A,13,11A,11C,11B,1,
1B,15, FINLAYSON
AVENUE,295,273,291A,291B,289
,285A,2/273A,1/273A,275,277,28
1,279,283,285B,287,
ROSCOMMON ROAD, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Page 76
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the sites are located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre however crossing to the Local Centre from this
ALTERNATIVE ZONE area does not have a safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth
and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The rezoning is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the sites are located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre however crossing to the Local Centre from this
ALTERNATIVE ZONE area does not have a safe pedestrian environment. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth
and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The rezoning is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Yes
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change of zone from MHS to THAB, support change to MHU - the sites are not
CHANGE; SUPPORT located in close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has
ALTERNATIVE ZONE been provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate
level of growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block
should also be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. Managing
flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change of zone from SH and MHS to THAB, support change to MHU - the site is not
CHANGE; SUPPORT located in close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has
ALTERNATIVE ZONE been provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate
level of growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. Managing flooding risks
on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
CHANGE; SUPPORT it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
RETENTION OF
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
NOTIFIED ZONE
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as
CHANGE; SUPPORT they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to some of the sites being
NOTIFIED ZONE
affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not
generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7227 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 19,21,17, FINLAYSON
AVENUE,12,20,14,16,1/226/22,6,4,18,8, HANFORD
PLACE,1,11,3,5,7, BRAVA
PLACE, Clendon Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
S11
Rezone 27,33,31,29,35,43,
FINLAYSON
AVENUE,10,13,14,1/8,2/8,2,4,6,2/
12,1/12, BRAVA PLACE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 51,53,49, FINLAYSON
AVENUE,3, KOPU PLACE,
Clendon Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 11,13,15, COTTRELL
PLACE, Clendon Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
19,21,17, FINLAYSON
AVENUE,12,20,14,16,
1/22-6/22,6,4,18,8,
HANFORD
PLACE,1,11,3,5,7,
BRAVA PLACE,
Clendon Park
27,33,31,29,35,43,
FINLAYSON
AVENUE,10,13,14,1/8,
2/8,2,4,6,2/12,1/12,
BRAVA PLACE,
Clendon Park
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
21,23, COTTRELL
PLACE,13,
MONCRIEFF
AVENUE, Clendon
Park
10,8, ADEN PLACE,
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
8,6, NGATIRA
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
PLACE, Clendon Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Clendon Park
SH, MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to some of the sites being
affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will not
generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local context.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of 56 Bellville Drive from SH to MHU - the site is affected by flooding
constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of 58, 60, 62 Bellville Drive from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location
will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context.
The sites are not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not suitable for
further intensification. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
839-7238 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
61,63,64,66,
BELLVILLE DRIVE,20,
WAI ITI PLACE,
Clendon Park
68,64,66, PITT
AVENUE, Clendon
Park
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
34, KENNINGTON
DRIVE,1/23,17,19,2/23
,21,17A,19A,19B,
MAPLESDEN DRIVE,
Clendon Park
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
Page 77
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7242 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone
51,39,27,49,33,43,45,37,29,35,41
,47, MAPLESDEN DRIVE,31,29,
KENNINGTON DRIVE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
S11
Rezone 57, MAPLESDEN
DRIVE,42A,44,42,44A, BARNEYS
FARM ROAD, Clendon Park from
Mixed Housing Suburban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
THAB Isolated or new
Clendon Park
51,39,27,49,33,43,45,3 areas
7,29,35,41,47,
MAPLESDEN
DRIVE,31,29,
KENNINGTON DRIVE,
Clendon Park
57, MAPLESDEN
THAB Isolated or new
Clendon Park
DRIVE,42A,44,42,44A, areas
BARNEYS FARM
ROAD, Clendon Park
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 18,13,20,14,16, DE
BLOGE PLACE, Clendon Park
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
18,13,20,14,16, DE
BLOGE PLACE,
Clendon Park
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone
24,10,26,12,20,14,22,16,18,8,
ROBERT SKELTON PLACE,21,
ROBERT ROSS PLACE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone
11,25,13,27,15,21,17,23,19,31,37
,29,35,33, ROBERT SKELTON
PLACE, Clendon Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone
38,58,48,46,54,44,56,42,36,40,34
,60,62,64,52,50, ROBERT
SKELTON
PLACE,87,91,89,85A,85,
MAPLESDEN DRIVE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Urban
(South)
S11
Planner's Position
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
THAB
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Yes
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
No
No
24,30,28,
MAPLESDEN
DRIVE,3, DE BLOGE
PLACE, Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
2,4,6, DE BLOGE
PLACE,20,
MAPLESDEN DRIVE,
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
10,8, DE BLOGE
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
PLACE, Clendon Park Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
No change
No
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
THAB
Yes
No
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
THAB
Yes
No
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
MHU
Yes
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB and support change to MHU - the site is not located in close
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. The surrounding block should also be
rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Rezone 73A,75,73,75A,
73A,75,73,75A,
MAPLESDEN DRIVE, Clendon
MAPLESDEN DRIVE,
Park from Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to THAB the sites are located in close proximity to the Clendon
CHANGE OF ZONE
Park Local Centre and POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density around the centre
will promote a walkable neighbourhood, could improve the vitality of the centre and achieves the
THAB zone objectives. The area is not currently serviced by a RFN, however is connected to
Manurewa Train Station by buses. Although the SH zone could be applied due to three of the sites
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to THAB the sites are located in close proximity to the Clendon
CHANGE OF ZONE
Park Local Centre and POS and are suitable for intensification. Increased density around the centre
will promote a walkable neighbourhood, could improve the vitality of the centre and achieves the
THAB zone objectives. The area is not currently serviced by a RFN, however is connected to
Manurewa Train Station by buses. Although the SH zone could be applied due to three of the sites
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of 85, 85A, 87, 89, 91 Maplesden Drive from MHS to THAB - The sites are
CHANGE; SUPPORT not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not suitable for further
ALTERNATIVE ZONE intensification. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support a change to THAB for the properties on Robert Skelton Place, support change to
MHU - the sites are not located in close walking distance from the Clendon Park Local Centre,
sufficient intensification has been provided for in areas directly adjacent to the Local Centre. MHU
will provide an appropriate level of growth and will act as a transition between the THAB area and
MHS. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
N/A
Page 78
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7255 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 26,45,49,32,30,34,47,
DUNGARVON
PLACE,52A,52B,52C,50B,50,52,6
0,62,64,50C,50A,62A,
MAPLESDEN DRIVE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 28,20,22,32,
TEMPLETON PLACE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone
37A,29A,39A,3A,5A,21,23,9A,29,
41,3,5,7,9,39,13A,11A,11,13,15,3
1,37,23A,15A,15B,21A,31A,
DUNGARVON PLACE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone 88, MAPLESDEN
DRIVE,10,8A,12,14,16,6,16A,14A
, DUNGARVON PLACE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
S11
Rezone
111A,123,117A,121,119,103A,11
5B,115,105A,117,121A,111,123A,
113,119A,103,113A,101,115A,10
5, MAPLESDEN DRIVE, Clendon
Park from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
S11
Rezone 25B,27A,27B,25A,
ALFRISTON ROAD, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
S11
Rezone 21,17,23,19,17A,19A,
FERGUSON STREET, Manurewa
East from Single House to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
28,20,22,32,
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
TEMPLETON PLACE, Urban/Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
37A,29A,39A,3A,5A,21
,23,9A,29,41,3,5,7,9,3
9,13A,11A,11,13,15,31
,37,23A,15A,15B,21A,
31A, DUNGARVON
PLACE, Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to No change
achieve the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and
it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
88, MAPLESDEN
DRIVE,10,8A,12,14,16,
6,16A,14A,
DUNGARVON PLACE,
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not No change
in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change to THAB zone - The sites are in close proximity to Gallaher Park, Manurewa Town
THAB
Centre and within walking distance to the RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of 17 and 21 Ferguson Street to THAB The properties are in close proximity No change
to Te Mahia Train Station, however Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification
here may compete with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for
surrounding Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for intensification. The notified zoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Clendon Park
25B,27A,27B,25A,
ALFRISTON ROAD,
Manurewa
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
17, 21, 23,
Any residential
Manurewa
FERGUSON STREET, properties subject to a
Manurewa East
key overlay
Do not support change of 23 Ferguson Street to THAB, support change to an alternative zone of
MHU - in keeping with the adjoining properties. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
83, BEAUMONTS
Any residential
WAY,279, GREAT
properties subject to a
SOUTH ROAD,1/7key overlay
31/7, KEVALE PLACE,
Manurewa
Manurewa
MHS
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to THAB, support alternative change to MHU. The site is not located
CHANGE; SUPPORT in close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre, sufficient intensification has been provided for
ALTERNATIVE ZONE in areas directly adjacent to the Town Centre. MHU will provide an appropriate level of growth and
will act as a transition between the THAB area and MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require maintaining a SH zone. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
Do not support change of 33 and 35 Ferguson Street to THAB The properties are in close proximity No change
to Te Mahia Train Station, however Te Mahia has not been identified as a centre and intensification
here may compete with Manurewa Town Centre. Sufficient additional growth has been provided for
surrounding Manurewa Town Centre which is more appropriate for intensification. The notified zoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of 29 and 31 Ferguson Street to THAB, support change to an alternative zone
of MHU - in keeping with the adjoining properties. Managing flooding risks on the site does not
require maintaining a SH zone. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban
(South)
S11
39,37,43,41, MYERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 79
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
No change
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7267 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 57,59, TAWA
57,59, TAWA
CRESCENT, Manurewa from
CRESCENT,
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Manurewa
Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Rezone 99,95,97,
FRIEDLANDERS ROAD,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 36,34, MCDIVITT
STREET, Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
99,95,97,
FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
36,34, MCDIVITT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
12,14,16, MCDIVITT
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
77,75,
FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
1, ASTOR PLACE,145,
MAHIA ROAD,114,
FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
21,23, GAMBARE
PLACE,23,
INNISMARA AVENUE,
Wattle Downs
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
10, MORRIN
STREET,1,
THOMPSON
TERRACE, Manurewa
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
45,43,
FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
55,53,
FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD,1, DR
PICKERING AVENUE,
Manurewa
3, FAIRDALE
AVENUE, Red Hill
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
16, MOUNTFORT
Any residential
STREET,10,
properties subject to a
CLAYMORE STREET, key overlay
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
4, SHERALEE PLACE, Mixed Housing
Red Hill
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
38, RICE CRESCENT, Mixed Housing
Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
106, CARGILL
Mixed Housing
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
40, PRESIDENT
Mixed Housing
AVENUE, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 80
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone to MHU, support a less intensive zone of MHS - MHS is the most
CHANGE; SUPPORT appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
ALTERNATIVE ZONE planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites
CHANGE; SUPPORT as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned
RETENTION OF
suburban built character of this zone. Sufficient intensification has already been provided around the
NOTIFIED ZONE
Town Centre. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the sites does not
require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
RETENTION OF
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
NOTIFIED ZONE
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-1683 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 13, VALENTINE STREET,
Papakura.
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUBMISSION THEME
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
2/16,1/16, SHERALEE Mixed Housing
at 2/16,1/16, SHERALEE
PLACE,2/133,1/133,
Urban/Mixed Housing
PLACE,2/133,1/133,
SETTLEMENT ROAD, Suburban/Single House
SETTLEMENT ROAD, Papakura. Papakura.
Expansion/Contraction
LOCALITY
Papakura East
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
1, FAIRDALE
AVENUE, Red Hill
Urban
(South)
S13
1/32A,2/32A, KELVIN
ROAD, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
93,93A, DOMINION
ROAD, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
8, BELGRAVE PLACE,
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
152A,152B,
SETTLEMENT ROAD,
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
15, TILBROOK
PLACE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
22, PRESIDENT
AVENUE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
27, VALENTINE
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
7, ROMILLY COURT,
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
69, CARGILL
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
21, VALENTINE
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
7, TILBROOK PLACE,
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
14, WESLEYDALE
PLACE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
2A, CAMERON
STREET, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
114A,118B, OLD
WAIROA
ROAD,6A,6,4,4A,
SUNBURST STREET,
Papakura
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 81
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2162 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 15A,15B,15, WILSON PLACE,
Papakura.
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
SUBMISSION THEME
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 10,10A, WILSON
Mixed Housing
at 10,10A, WILSON PLACE,
PLACE, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 1/32,2/32, SUTTON
Mixed Housing
at 1/32,2/32, SUTTON
CRESCENT,33, RICE Urban/Mixed Housing
CRESCENT,33, RICE
CRESCENT, Papakura Suburban/Single House
CRESCENT, Papakura.
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 38A,2/36,38,1/36,
Mixed Housing
at 38A,2/36,38,1/36, SUTTON
SUTTON
Urban/Mixed Housing
CRESCENT,39,37,41, RICE
CRESCENT,39,37,41, Suburban/Single House
CRESCENT, Papakura.
RICE CRESCENT,
Expansion/Contraction
Papakura
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 78, CARGILL
Mixed Housing
at 78, CARGILL STREET,20,22, STREET,20,22,
Urban/Mixed Housing
VALENTINE STREET, Papakura. VALENTINE STREET, Suburban/Single House
Papakura
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 47,49, CARGILL
Mixed Housing
at 47,49, CARGILL STREET,
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 6A,6, CROSS
Mixed Housing
at 6A,6, CROSS STREET,
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 29,29A, ROLLERSON Mixed Housing
at 29,29A, ROLLERSON
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
STREET, Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 33,33A, ROLLERSON Mixed Housing
at 33,33A, ROLLERSON
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
STREET, Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 51A,47A,51B,49A,49B, Mixed Housing
at 51A,47A,51B,49A,49B,
ROLLERSON
Urban/Mixed Housing
ROLLERSON STREET,
STREET, Papakura
Suburban/Single House
Papakura.
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 14,14A, CROSS
Mixed Housing
at 14,14A, CROSS STREET,
STREET, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 2/40,2/42,1/40,1/42,
Mixed Housing
at 2/40,2/42,1/40,1/42,
ROLLERSON
Urban/Mixed Housing
ROLLERSON STREET,
STREET, Papakura
Suburban/Single House
Papakura.
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 32,34, PRESIDENT
Mixed Housing
at 32,34, PRESIDENT AVENUE, AVENUE, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 12,14, BELGRAVE
Mixed Housing
at 12,14, BELGRAVE PLACE,
PLACE, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 115,115A, DOMINION Mixed Housing
at 115,115A, DOMINION ROAD, ROAD, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 79, DOMINION
Mixed Housing
at 79, DOMINION ROAD,29,
ROAD,29, BELGRAVE Urban/Mixed Housing
BELGRAVE PLACE, Papakura.
PLACE, Papakura
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 23, HEATHDALE
Any residential
at 23, HEATHDALE
CRESCENT,80,
properties subject to a
CRESCENT,80, DOMINION
DOMINION ROAD,
key overlay
ROAD, Papakura.
Papakura
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 3,5, DOMINION
Mixed Housing
at 3,5, DOMINION ROAD,
ROAD, Papakura
Urban/Mixed Housing
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 140C,140B,
Mixed Housing
at 140C,140B, SETTLEMENT
SETTLEMENT ROAD, Urban/Mixed Housing
ROAD, Papakura.
Papakura.
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban 10,12,20,18,2/14,1/14, Mixed Housing
at 10,12,20,18,2/14,1/14,
SHERALEE PLACE,
Urban/Mixed Housing
SHERALEE PLACE, Red Hill.
Red Hill
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Planner's Position
LOCALITY
Papakura East
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 82
REASONS
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. Managing flooding risks on one of the sites does not require a SH zone.The notified zone is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-2186 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban
at 2/9,7,1/9, REDCREST
AVENUE,11,13,15, SHERALEE
PLACE, Papakura.
Planner's Position
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
2/9,7,1/9, REDCREST Any residential
Papakura AVENUE,11,13,15,
properties subject to a East
SHERALEE PLACE,
key overlay
Papakura
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
PROPOSED GIS MAP
ZONE
POSITION
REASONS
CHANGE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support retention of MHS zone at 7 Redcrest Avenue, support alternative change to SH - This SH/MHS
Yes
RETAIN; SUPPORT
site is affected by flooding constraints and rezoning to SH zone is the most appropriate way to
ALTERNATIVE ZONE achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS. This change is out of scope. (refer
Attachment F).
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
Support retention of MHS zone for the remaining properties - MHS is the most appropriate zone for
the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on these sites
does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives
of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
839-2188 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
28A,30A,30,28,
CAMERON STREET,
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
11,9A,13,9B,15,
GROVE ROAD,
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
53A,49,51A,51,49A,53,
ALMA CRESCENT,
Papakura.
Urban
(South)
S13
23A, WINIATA
TERRACE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
20 ELSIE MORTON
PLACE. Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
142 SETTLEMENT
ROAD. Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
5 YARROW LANE.
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
30 RICE CRESCENT.
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
4 LORIS PLACE.
Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
140 SETTLEMENT
ROAD. Papakura
Urban
(South)
S13
6 CARISBROOK
CRESCENT. Papakur
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
1, ETTRICK LANE,10,
YARROW
LANE,11,13,15,17,19,
1,3,21B,7,21A,9,5,
ELSIE MORTON
PLACE, Papakura
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
SH, MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives
effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in
close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban
built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone at 1, 13, 15, 17, 19, 21A, 21B Elsie Morton Place and 10 Yarrow
Lane - MHS is the most appropriate zone for these sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre
or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHS at 3, 5, 7, 9, 11 Elise Morton Place and 1 Ettrick
Lane - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and give effect to the RPS.
Page 83
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5001 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S13
Rezone 8, SALAS PLACE,
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
6, KERRY PLACE,
Papakura
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
3, RICE CRESCENT,
Papakura
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Takanini Strategic
Area SHA
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
11, MAURICE
STREET, Papakura
Page 84
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-5996 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S13
Rezone 24, SHEEHAN AVENUE, 24, SHEEHAN
Papakura from Mixed Housing
AVENUE, Papakura
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on
the sites does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S13
53A,53, FERNAIG
Spot Zoning
STREET,154,154A,
OLD WAIROA ROAD,
Papakura
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Takanini Strategic
Area SHA,
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
7A,7, ROLLERSON
STREET, Papakura
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
2,2A, ROLLERSON
STREET, Papakura
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
19,1/21-4/21,17,
SHIFNAL DRIVE,
Randwick Park
MHU
N/A
No
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
Urban
(South)
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
Rezone 19,1/21-4/21,17,
SHIFNAL DRIVE, Randwick Park
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone 5, SECRETARIAT
PLACE, Randwick Park from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 20, TAITIMU DRIVE,
Weymouth from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not No change
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
57, ROLLERSON
STREET,6A,8B,4,6,8,4
A, SHEEHAN
AVENUE, Papakura
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No change
they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
4, WINSFORD
STREET, Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
S12
FU
MHS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from FU to MHS. Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB
No change
expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number
of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No rezonings are
recommended because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure
planning needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within
the FU zone. Retention of the FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
3069-2
Urban
(South)
5, SECRETARIAT
PLACE, Randwick
Park
20, TAITIMU DRIVE,
Weymouth
2, KERRYDALE
ROAD, Manurewa
Rural
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 85
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7441 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 14 WAIMAI AVENUE.
Weymouth from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
14 WAIMAI AVENUE.
Weymouth
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
28 FAIRLIGHT
PLACE. Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Urban
(South)
S11
16 ROSEMEAD
PLACE. Randwick
Park
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
2172-1
Paramedical
Property
Company Limited
(Attn: Richard
Kenner)
839-7451 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 5A,5,6,3B,3A,4B,4A,
LIDDY PLACE,31, EASTBURN
STREET,10,12, MAURICE
STREET,1,3, KERRY PLACE,
Papakura from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Rezone 12 BOOKER PLACE.
Weymouth from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
5A,5,6,3B,3A,4B,4A,
LIDDY PLACE,31,
EASTBURN
STREET,10,12,
MAURICE
STREET,1,3, KERRY
PLACE, Papakura
12 BOOKER PLACE.
Weymouth
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Rezone
80C,80B,80A,80F,80E, Spot Zoning
80C,80B,80A,80F,80E,80D,
80D, KELVIN ROAD,
KELVIN ROAD, Papakura from
Papakura
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
5,7, SHEEHAN
AVENUE, Papakura
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Takinini
MHS
NC
N/A
The Gardens
SH
MHS
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Manurewa
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change from MHS to NC. It is noted that the site contains a medical centre. The
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone, maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - managing flooding risks on the site does not require
MHS
maintaining a SH zone. MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to
a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The rezoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as No Change
they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
MHS
MHU
N/A
No change
No
No
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
28 YEARSLEY
PLACE. Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHU
Yes
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHU
N/A
No
No
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
Urban
(South)
Rezone 11 KENNINGTON
DRIVE. Clendon Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 20 KENNINGTON
DRIVE. Clendon Park from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning
is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
15 ARTHUR ROAD.
Manurewa
11 KENNINGTON
DRIVE. Clendon Park
20 KENNINGTON
DRIVE. Clendon Park
Page 86
No change
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7508 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 11 VOLTA PLACE.
11 VOLTA PLACE.
Clendon Park from Mixed Housing Clendon Park
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 30 CHURCHILL
30 CHURCHILL
AVENUE. Manurewa from Mixed AVENUE. Manurewa
Housing Urban to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
1 BEACH ROAD.
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
1/6,2/6, PALISADE
PLACE,25,27,21,23,19
,29, GALILEE
AVENUE, Red Hill
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
constraints, Heavy CHANGE; SUPPORT
Industry Air Quality RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
29 ETHERTON
DRIVE. Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
10 NEEMS PLACE.
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
7 SENATOR DRIVE.
Manurewa
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
8 HONEY PLACE.
Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S13
2,3,1/4,2/4, IGLOO
PLACE,6, GALILEE
AVENUE, Red Hill
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Clendon Park
SH
MHS
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
13,15,14, IGLOO
PLACE,12,14,
GALILEE AVENUE,
Red Hill
4 TAMWORTH
CLOSE. Manurewa
Manurewa
Papakura East
Clendon Park
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Heavy Industry Air DO NOT SUPPORT
Quality
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 87
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as
they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on one of the sites does not require a SH zone. The
notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this
zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Although the SH zone could be retained to one of the
sites due to the site being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this
location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not
recognise the local context. Rezoning to MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. Managing
flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to
be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No Change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7601 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 9 DAGENHAM STREET. 9 DAGENHAM
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
STREET. Manurewa
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
41 MAHIA ROAD.
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
12 WHITE ROAD.
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Homai Station
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
60 STELLATA
COURT. Randwick
Park
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
THAB isolated or new
Clendon Park
areas
MHS
MHS
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 22 KENNINGTON
22 KENNINGTON
DRIVE. Clendon Park from Mixed DRIVE. Clendon Park
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
Papakura Urban/Mixed Housing
East
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Significant
Ecological Area
(SEA)
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S12
Takinini
SH, MHS
LC
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
11,9A,11A, MACK
PLACE, Red Hill
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
75 ETHERTON
DRIVE. Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
2552-1
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
9 BENTON PLACE.
Manurewa
56 SCENIC DRIVE.
Manurewa
28, REDCREST
AVENUE,11,10,13,12,
14,3,2,5,4,7,6,9,8,
GAME PLACE,
Papakura
69 TEMPLETON
PLACE. Clendon Park
Papakura East
Page 88
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
THAB
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH and MHS to LC. The notified MHS zone is the most
No change
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS. For the sites
zoned SH, these are affected by flooding constraints and retaining the notified SH zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone and gives effect to the RPS. Rezoning to
LC will not give effect to the RPS including the centres strategy/hierarchy.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
REASONS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Although the SH zone could be applied due to the site
being affected by flooding constraints, a spot zone would occur and in this location a spot zone will
not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise the local
context. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close proximity to Homai Train Station
CHANGE OF ZONE
and a higher level of intensification here will increase the capacity of housing with good access to
public transport. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Surrounding properties need to be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see
Attachment F.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU, support change to THAB - the site is located
CHANGE; SUPPORT across the road from Clendon Park Local Centre and increased density in this location would create
ALTERNATIVE ZONE a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. The rezoning is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS. Scope provided by
submissions 5277-205 and 5280-207, refer to Attachment D.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support change of zone to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
CHANGE; SUPPORT RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and
RETENTION OF
gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change from MHS to THAB - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not
CHANGE; SUPPORT in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. . The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
NOTIFIED ZONE
the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
NOTIFIED ZONE
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
NOTIFIED ZONE
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the sites as
CHANGE; SUPPORT they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built
RETENTION OF
character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7705 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 56 HALSEY ROAD. 1/47, 56 HALSEY ROAD.
2/47 JELLICOE ROAD. Manurewa 1/47, 2/47 JELLICOE
from Mixed Housing Suburban to ROAD. Manurewa
Mixed Housing Urban.
Urban
(South)
S13
8B,8C,8A, LAURIE
AVENUE, Papakura
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Rezone 38 BEESTON
38 BEESTON
CRESCENT. Manurewa from
CRESCENT.
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Manurewa
Housing Urban.
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
S11
Rezone 88 FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD. Manurewa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
88 FRIEDLANDERS
ROAD. Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
87 BEAUMONTS
WAY. Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
Rezone 11,13,13A,11B,
ELIZABETH STREET, Papakura
from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
11,13,13A,11B,
Spot Zoning
ELIZABETH STREET,
Papakura
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No Change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
15 SILVER CREEK
ROAD. Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
31 SHIFNAL DRIVE.
Randwick Park
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change in zoning. The Manurewa Town Centre Concept Plan was taken into account No change
and the Local Board was consulted on the draft and PAUP. The zoning proposed in and around the
Town Centre provides for further intensification and revitalisation of the Centre. The notified zoning is
the most appropriate way to achieve the zone objectives and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
7 COLT PLACE.
Randwick Park
MHU
N/A
No
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
Urban
(South)
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
7 SUWYN PLACE.
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
23 SILVER CREEK
ROAD. Weymouth
Papakura East
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
20 SILVER CREEK
ROAD. Weymouth
Spot Zoning
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Manurewa
Papakura East
Page 89
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7761 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 25 MON DESIR PLACE.
Manurewa from Single House to
Mixed Housing Urban.
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
REASONS
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU, support change to MHS - Spot zoning in this
CHANGE; SUPPORT location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local
ALTERNATIVE ZONE context. The site is not within close proximity to a centre or RFN and therefore the area is not
suitable for further intensification. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect
to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Support change of zone to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre and
CHANGE; SUPPORT RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone and
RETENTION OF
gives effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
NOTIFIED ZONE
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
482 PORCHESTER
ROAD. Takanini
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S13
54,54A, WILLIS
ROAD, Papakura
Spot Zoning
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
11 TONSON PLACE.
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
3 WAIMAI AVENUE.
Weymouth
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
6 WINSFORD
STREET. Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
7 GIBBONS ROAD.
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S13
41A,41, COSGRAVE
ROAD, Papakura
Spot Zoning
MHS
MHU
Takanini Strategic
Area SHA
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as
it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character
of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The notified
zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the
RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
8,8A, EDMUND
HILLARY
AVENUE,7A,7,
ELIZABETH STREET,
Papakura
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Papakura East
Clendon Park
Papakura East
Page 90
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7551 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S13
Rezone 11 CHRISARDA PLACE. 11 CHRISARDA
Red Hill from Mixed Housing
PLACE. Red Hill
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
3 SECRETARIAT
PLACE. Randwick
Park
Urban
(South)
S11
Rezone 3 SECRETARIAT
PLACE. Randwick Park from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone 7 KERN PLACE.
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
2558-1
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
26 ALFRISTON
ROAD, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S11
484 PORCHESTER
ROAD. Takanini
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Planner's Position
7 KERN PLACE.
Manurewa
53 WEYMOUTH
ROAD. WeymouthManurewa East
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Takinini
SH
LC
Flooding
constraints
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
MHS
MHU
N/A
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
MHU
THAB
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Papakura East
Mixed Housing
The Gardens
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Any residential
Clendon Park
properties subject to a
key overlay
Spot Zoning
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
16 BURBANK
AVENUE. Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Rezone 48 CHURCHILL
AVENUE. Manurewa from Single
House to Mixed Housing Urban.
Rezone 9 MONTILLA PLACE.
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
48 CHURCHILL
AVENUE. Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
9 TONSON PLACE.
Weymouth
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
9 MONTILLA PLACE.
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Page 91
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Increased residential density around Clendon Park
MHU
Local Centre will create a compact urban form and promote a walkable neighbourhood. Managing
flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS. Surrounding properties need to
be rezoned to MHU (out of scope) to prevent spot zoning, see Attachment F.
Do not support change of zone from SH to LC. This site is affected by flooding constraints and
No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS. LC zoning will not give effect to the criteria in B3.1 of the RPS.
Yes
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHU to THAB - The site is in close proximity to Gallaher Park,
THAB
Manurewa Town Centre and RFN. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the THAB zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
Support retention of notified zone. Retention of the MHS zone is the most appropriate way to achieve No change
the objectives of the zone. The site is not in close proximity to a centre or an RFN and it maintains
the planned suburban built character of this zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a
SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHU - Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the site does
not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
MHU
Yes
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-7953 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 29 TEMPLETON PLACE. 29 TEMPLETON
Clendon Park from Mixed Housing PLACE. Clendon Park
Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S13
Urban
(South)
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHU
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
5A LUCAS PLACE.
Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
S11
11 PIRITI PLACE.
Weymouth
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
76 ETHERTON
DRIVE. Weymouth
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Clendon Park
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
S12
Spot Zoning
Rural
FU
LC
3069-3
Papakura East
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
MHU
N/A
Urban
(South)
S11
46 BELFRY PLACE.
Wattle Downs
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
17 MCENTEE
STREET. Papakura
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Urban
(South)
S13
15A EDMUND
HILLARY AVENUE.
Papakura
Spot Zoning
Papakura East
MHS
MHU
Urban
(south)
S11
Errors
Clendon Park
Road
MHU
5819-7
Urban
(South)
S13
LI
LI
Fletcher Building
Group (Attn: Karl
Cook)
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Clendon Park Local Centre or a RFN
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. Managing flooding risks on the
site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from FU to LC. Land also the subject of RUB submissions. RUB
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT expert geotechnical and stormwater evidence for Takanini has demonstrated that there are a number
of constraints both inside and beyond the RUB which need detailed investigation. No rezonings are
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
recommended because detailed assessment of these constraints needs to occur, and structure
planning needs to be undertaken before an appropriate live zone can be determined for land within
the FU zone. Retention of the FU zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the
zone and gives effect to the RPS. Rezoning to LC will not give effect to the criteria in B3.1 of the
RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
NOTIFIED ZONE
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Heavy Industry Air DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
Quality
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
CHANGE; SUPPORT achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
RETENTION OF
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a RFN
NOTIFIED ZONE
and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Flooding
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change of zone to MHU - the property has been incorrectly zoned as Road however
constraints
CHANGE; SUPPORT the site is not within close proximity to a town centre or RFN and does not achieve the MHU zone
ALTERNATIVE ZONE objectives. Support change of the property to MHS in keeping with surrounding properties. The
rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to
the RPS.
Flooding
SUPPORT IN FULL;
Support retention of notified LI zone. The site provides an appropriate buffer between residential and
constraints, Heavy RETENTION OF
HI zones. Retention of the LI Zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone
Industry Air Quality NOTIFIED ZONE
and gives effect to the RPS.
Page 92
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
No change
No
No
MHS
Yes
No
LI
No
No
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
SUBMITTER
POINT
NAME
839-8149 Housing New
Zealand
Corporation
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
SUB
PROPERTIES
AREA
SUBJECT TO
UNIT
SUMMARY
SUBMISSION
S11
Rezone 20A BOWATER PLACE. 20A BOWATER
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
PLACE. Manurewa
Suburban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
Urban
(South)
S12
57163626
S13
6826-4
S13
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
THAB Isolated or new
areas
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
PROPOSED GIS MAP
ZONE
POSITION
REASONS
CHANGE
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB zone and support a change to MHU zone - sufficient additional
MHU
Yes
CHANGE; SUPPORT growth has been provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre
ALTERNATIVE ZONE and spot zoning in this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and
does not recognise local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a
transition between THAB and MHS. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Takanini
No change
No
CHANGE; SUPPORT Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. The notified zoning is the most appropriate
RETENTION OF
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHU
THAB
N/A
MHU, POS
Unspecified
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Area surrounding
Ardmore School,
particularly520-536
Papakura-Clevedon
Road, Papakura
45 ALFRISTON
ROAD, Manurewa
MR
RCS
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
THAB
N/A
Takinini
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHS
THAB
N/A
Rural
Support retention of notified MHU and POS zones. Public Open Space Community zoning has only
been applied to parts of this land which are owned by Council. The remainder of the land is zoned
MHU. Community Facilities are Restricted Discretionary Activities in the MHU Zone (as set out in in
Nicholas Roberts track change evidence for Council for the Residential PAUP Hearing Topics (059,
060 062 and 063)). The zoning does not affect the existing uses on the site. MHU is appropriate
within the surrounding context, and prevents potential spot zoning. The notified zones are the most
appropriate way to meet the relevant objectives of the MHU/POS zones and give effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
No
No Change
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MR to RCS zone. RCS zone not considered appropriate as the No change
application of the MR zone best reflects the mix of MR activities currently taking place in this location.
The land is outside the RUB and the RPS Chapter 2.1 Policy 1A states that new towns and villages
outside the RUB are to be avoided. Retention of MR zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support a change to THAB zone and support a change to MHU zone - sufficient additional
MHU
CHANGE; SUPPORT growth has been provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre
ALTERNATIVE ZONE and spot zoning in this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and
does not recognise local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a
transition between THAB and MHS. The proposed zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the
objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Takanini
No change
CHANGE; SUPPORT Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. The notified zoning is the most appropriate
RETENTION OF
way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and give effect to the RPS.
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
MHU
THAB
N/A
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB. MHU aligns with the zoning immediately west of
the railway line as far west as Great South Road, north of the Takanini Town Centre. It is not close
enough to the Papakura Metropolitan Centre to make it suitable for THAB. The notified zone is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No change
No
No
Urban
(South)
S11
Centres/Terrace
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
No
No
S13
MR
Unspecified
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - the property is not adjacent to the Manurewa
No change
Town Centre and is not suitable for further intensification. Sufficient additional growth has been
provided for in the areas within close walking distance to Manurewa Town Centre and spot zoning in
this location will not generally achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise
local context. MHU is the most appropriate zone for the site as it acts as a transition between THAB
and MHS. The notified zoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
With regard to proposed zoning patterns surrounding existing centres, refer to Attachment C. In
MR
accordance with the provisions of the RPS, intensification is proposed mainly around centres and
along the RFN. Support retention of notified MR zone at 520-536 Papakura-Clevedon Road. The
notified zoning maintains the planned character of this zone. Otherwise, a spot zone would occur and
in this location a spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and
does not recognise the local context. Retaining the MR zone is the most appropriate way to achieve
the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - a spot zone would occur and in this location a
No change
spot zone will not generally achieve the integrated management of resources and does not recognise
the local context. MHU aligns with the zoning immediately west of the railway line as far west as
Great South Road north of the Takanini Town Centre. Retaining the MHU zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the
planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most appropriate way to
achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
No
No
No
No
Do not support change of zone from SH to MHU - these sites are affected by flooding constraints and No change
retaining the notified SH zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the SH zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHU to THAB - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHU aligns with
the zoning east of the railway in the vicinity of Porchester Road for established residential areas
between the Takanini Town Centre and the Papakura Metropolitan Centre. Retention of the MHU
zone is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close proximity to Manurewa Town Centre or a RFN and it
maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
6826-2
Urban
(South)
S12
Urban
(South)
S11
1A CLAYTON ROAD.
Manurewa
Mixed Housing
Manurewa SouthMHS
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHU
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
52 COXHEAD ROAD.
Manurewa
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S11
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Flooding
constraints
Urban
(South)
S12
Takinini
MHU
THAB
N/A
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Urban
(South)
S11
Mixed Housing
Manurewa
Urban/Mixed Housing
Suburban/Single House
Expansion/Contraction
MHS
MHU
N/A
1 CLARK STREET.
Manurewa
Takinini
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Page 93
URBAN (SOUTH)
Attachment 'C': Zoning Analysis and Position for each Submission Point
Notes: The black text in the "summary" column of this Attachment is as notified. Occasional amendments have been made in red to take account of any re-notified SDR points and also for clarity, where necessary.
Auckland Unitary Plan Independent Hearings Panel
Submission Point Pathway Report
SUB
AREA
UNIT
SUMMARY
S11
Rezone 20 & 20A Alfriston Road
and 37 Halver Road, Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
S11
Rezone 20 & 20A Alfriston Road
and 37 Halver Road Manurewa
from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings.
S11
Rezone 14 Alfriston Road,
Manurewa from Mixed Housing
Urban to Town Centre zone.
PROPERTIES
SUBJECT TO
SUBMISSION
20, 20A Alfriston Road,
Manurewa; 37 Halver
Road, Manurewa
Urban
(South)
S13
3, SALAS PLACE,
Papakura
3848-3
S13
9400-1
Craig Liggett
Urban
(South)
S11
6098-63
Metlifecare
Limited
Urban
(south)
S12
SUB
POINT
880-3
SUBMITTER
NAME
Mavis J Hirstich
881-3
Sandra L and
Mavis J Hirstich
Urban
(South)
881-7
Sandra L and
Mavis J Hirstich
Urban
(South)
TOPIC
Urban
(South)
Planner's Position
SUBMISSION THEME
LOCALITY
Any residential
Manurewa
properties subject to a
key overlay
RELEVANT
OVERLAYS,
PRECINCTS,
REQUESTED
ZONE
CONSTRAINTS
PAUP ZONE
MHU
THAB
Flooding
constraints
REASONS
Support change of zone from MHU to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town
Centre and within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS
No
THAB
Yes
No
THAB
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHU to THAB - The sites are in close proximity to Manurewa Town
Centre and within walking distance to the RFN. Managing flooding risks on the site does not require
a SH zone. The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the THAB zone
and gives effect to the RPS.
Centres/Terrace
MHU
Manurewa
Housing Apartment
Buildings (THAB)/Mixed
Use
Expansion/Contraction
Spot Zoning
Papakura - East MHS
TC
Flooding
constraints
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Support change of zone from MHU to TC to correct a mapping error. This site is a car park for the
TC
adjacent TC zoned property. Rezoning to TC is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Yes
MHU
N/A
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Do not support change of zone from MHS to MHU - Spot zoning in this location will not generally
No change
achieve integrated management of resources and does not recognise local context. MHS is the most
appropriate zone for the sites as they are not in close proximity to Papakura Metropolitan Centre or a
RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
No
No
Rural Countryside
Living (CL)
Rural
MR
CL
Flooding
constraints
No
Any residential
properties subject to a
key overlay
Manurewa
MHS
MHS
Flooding
constraints
No
No
Takinini
SP
THAB
Flooding
constraints
Do not support change of zone from MR to CL zone. The area does not meet the criteria for areas
MR
identified for Countryside Living in RPS B8.3 Rural Subdivision Policy 6. In particular part of the land
is classified as Land Use Capability Class 2 land (prime land). Retention of the MR zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support retention of MHS zone - MHS is the most appropriate zone for the site as it is not in close
No change
proximity to a centre or a RFN and it maintains the planned suburban built character of this zone.
Managing flooding risks on the site does not require a SH zone. The notified zone is the most
appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and gives effect to the RPS.
DO NOT SUPPORT
Do not support change of zone from SP to THAB, support alternative change to MHS. The MHS zone MHS
CHANGE; SUPPORT is appropriate given Council's position in Topic 061 (Retirement and Affordability) recommended that
ALTERNATIVE ZONE retirement villages be rezoned from Special Purpose to the relevant adjoining zone consistent with
the surrounding areas. Adjacent residential zoning is MHS. The MHS zoning is the most appropriate
way to achieve the objectives of the zone and gives effect to the RPS. There is a mapping error
where the site has been incorrectly zoned MHU instead of the correct MHS zone.
No
11 Collie Street,
Manurewa
DO NOT SUPPORT
CHANGE; SUPPORT
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
SUPPORT IN FULL;
RETENTION OF
NOTIFIED ZONE
Yes
No
14 Alfriston Road,
Manurewa
Manurewa
MHU
PLANNER'S
PROPOSED
POSITION
SUPPORT IN FULL;
CHANGE OF ZONE
Page 94
SUMMARY
4274-96
Minister of
Police (Attn:
Justine Bray)
5277-205
The Urban
Design Forum
New Zealand
(Attn: Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-217
The Urban
Design Forum
New Zealand
(Attn: Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-218
The Urban
Design Forum
New Zealand
(Attn: Melanie
Whittaker)
5277-221
The Urban
Design Forum
New Zealand
(Attn: Melanie
Whittaker)
5280-207
The New
Zealand
Institute of
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
5280-219
The New
Zealand
Institute of
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
5280-220
The New
Zealand
Institute of
Architects (Attn:
5280-223
Graeme Scott)
Zoning].
The New
Zealand
Institute of
Architects (Attn:
Graeme Scott)
d
oa
a
Taw
Mul l Place
e
Kahurang i P
la
c
et
Rogers Ro
ad
oad
sR
Town Centre
Metropolitan Centre
City Centre
Mixed Use
o ws
General Business
dP
ar la c
rn
e
a
B
Business Park
Light Industry
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
lm
Ho
ce
c i a Pla
Mixed Rural
d
es Ro a
Rural Production
Public Open Space - Conservation
Vale
n
Pla
c
Takanini
Urban
Defence [rcp/dp]
nic
Cran
r ive
Ca
stl
eh
Gle
Road [i]
e
la c
ss
n ro
hia
Lot n Br
ae
Ti ngt
on
ad
le
Iorangi Place
B
al
Av
m
on
o
Ro
F ar
m
e
Blackwood Driv
of
t
Mooring [rcp]
General Coastal Marine [rcp]
Water [i]
Coastal Transition
Place
st
ur
rn
ou
Pineh
st
ie
Dr
iP
Ho
y
es
Park
es
Ann
M oor
ce
nt
lake
Plac
e
Ko
St Ann
er
My
Ca
n P la
lac
e
se
nn
Fer
nr
S tra
t
en
ue
ce
Av
en
ce
Pla
oa
ce
uku
Iwin
o urt
ill C
An gle
rs
na S
treet
Ro
ad
Kay
Roa
d
Ja
me
s
Fr a
nc e
lan
d
sS
t re
J ut
y da
le R
o
Beatty Avenue
Ro
ad
et
yS
tre
Su
rre
Plac
e
Ke
rr
De
ve
tilla
P lace
ht
lig
e
la c
go
P
ace
Ro
a
ro
n
Ke
nt
Dr C
ive a
m
ce
l ose
rth
C
wo
ce
o Pla
ck
nu Pla
ce
Ru
t
llic
Je
br
id
ge
Ro
ad
Ro
ad
ad
Ro
Ro
ad
ley
Ox
fo
rd
er
ke
Cl
os
e
B
or
Swallo
ve
nue
le y St ree
Sm
ed
ce
la
al P
Mcg re
se
Ta
m
von
gar
s d Du n
en
D riv e
Ma
nt
t re
eS
Local Centre
h Place
enue
Neighbourhood Centre
Mcdougall St
r
enue
Av
hP
Weym o
uth Roa
d
Mcannalley S t reet
ad
To
lv
Fl
ce
la
sa
ch
Pl
a
e ce
nu
e
Av
e
ora P lac
Mail Av
Greenme a d
ue
Future Urban
rling Avenue
oad
Plac
e
Ro
lace
eR
Fo o
twid
e
ide
P
lla
ann
oP
Huber St
reet
r ee
n St
lle
icr
ad
ds
e nu
Av
rie
uar
Lin
P lace
Street
Ste
layson Av
F in
en
Gairlo c
r os
ad
Ro
ad
Ro
ton
s
i
r
f
Al
Single House
e
Cap
oa d
e
Ros
ce
Lane Ro
Large Lot
eet
Barcroft Place
Broug h
lv i lle Dr
i
st
Bel
c re
Pit
Hill
oad
rR
hu
Art
Ro
Retain
Special Purpose
d
R oa
ude
d
Roa
q
Mc
Ro ad
nR
yt o
Cla
r Pla
Domain
Roa
scent
Cre
ce
G
ro
ve
Cla
th
oad
ks
Hoo
Ran ge
Beach
Road
en
wr
La
rls
Ea
d
Roa
Amend
de
Hy
v
Oli
ad a Cresce
i Ro T aw
hiw
o
t
K
tree
be S
Gre
Cr
ou
oad
ir i R
Pur
nt
sce
Cre
H o bart
et
St
en
sc
tS
Takanini
Rural
LEGEND
e
iv
a p al
Cr e
es
W att
S11a
ce
e
iv
Dr
k woo d
la
tP
on
m
Ro
ad
et
tre
ac
s cent
oa
tr e
Bl
e
Ashki rk Plac
vi ew
ak
O
nt
nR
eS
od Drive
Wo
ley
ad
e Street
l
da
ing
e
lac
Su
Cr
r
lve
Ha
c e nt
r e cent
s
Fe
nog n
an
Cr
e
ac
Pl
Be
ave
ath
S tr
n
Mane
e lfry P
Kaan
Cr
gy e
re
a
ad
u
Seaw a r d
oad
res
rC
re Place
Mui
rfi
eld
to
o
Wo
Terr a ce
n
ve
eA
ant
Vol
sR
ae
l
Hi
oa
lR
y
Wa
Stat o
South
nt
Co
ur
t
R
lds
Fie
p so
et
e
Sy k
venue
eet
hia A
hi S tr
en Court
gl
er
A ll
es
d
Roa
S t re
ka
S is
sm
ni
In
a
ar
lace
rP
ate
ew
B lu
deen Cresce
Aber
ll s hill C lo
t
n
sce
C re
ry
r
Drive
e
b
Turn
t
es
cr
ow
a
d
hea
Tho m
vitt
thvi ew Place
re
ba
es
ce
nue ank Pl a
Ave Fr
ri ve
Cox
di
Mc
Sou
oad
sR
Road
h ia
Ma
eet
er C
B ull
w i
te
on
Astor Pl a
Ga m
r
l St
iv a
c
P la
Se
c
Per
nue
Ave
ing
r
e
ick
rP
Street
cD
eni
Sc
rth
No
ce
tree
e Place
Cad
Dr
iv
Way
e
Syk
Sa
nd
riv
ia
e
lmis
Ce
hm
As
n
Berni a Pl a ce
ce
Pla
ac
dw
ic k
v
ro
nG
Cr
Road
le
lpo
Wa
urc
Ch
P la
dS
ark Dri
hP
ve
ag
Drive
e
air Pl
Sa
n
an
re L
Drive
re
oad
ry R
sh
et
idg
for
se
Ri
G le
ce
s Road
rin
Co
e lv
enu Ke
Av
e ll Street
Luca s Pla
Beihler
Road
t
tree
on
a
Wa im
Taata
a
rem
Haza rds
Laws on Way
Kingseat
and Karaka
ad
ees
He
yb
r
W ins
e
lac
aP
n
efi
stl
Ca
et
re
u
St
Re
Greers
Ro ad
hS
yn
n
dorl
Ron
O'c o n
ent
t
ce
es c
ee
Pla
Cr
Str
Clendo n
ore
ym
oa d
rt
Cla
nue Ki
sR
der
Ave
lan
ean
ried
M ck
F
ee t
nt
Str
sce
we s
C re
E ddo
Ro a d
orth
ton
sw
ord
W
treet
eS
sA
ic o
eR
oa
d
Mo n
ace
n Pl
nto
Mi
aly
la c
e
ker Driv
Wal
P
go
Ant
a
Sel
Jo hn
a
Le
et
Je
ll
ce
ue
et
re
St
n
n
treet
so
sio
n
ing S
gu
ad
x te
Ro
Flem
Fer
ln
ad
yE
co
L in
Ro
Wa
ld
ts
eet
Str
ie
er
on
N
lla h
m
Ga
ad
au
Ro
Be
as
tm
ay
s
i
r
W
Ch
s
oad
uR
Rim
o
ad
um
ea
oad
B
uR
ay
Rim
W
a ra
nt
n ts
o
Tot
mo
au
sR
Be
g er
nue
Ro
Ave
hill
urc
Ch
oad
nue
nR
ce
A ve
hill
lwy
Pla
ter
lac e
la c e
St
re
Ro
Gran de Vue
Fr e
ue
en
i
dl
u
Be
en
Av
le
da
kP
rr
Av
en
lie
Co l
e et
S tr
llie
Co
Law
re
n
id
n ey Place
d
y Roa
Halse
Road
Ar
nue
ve
an
lo c
eet
Str
We n
rt
Aa
Ma
ce
av
n
Ly
he
Rot
oa d
Va
le
t
Stree
Clark
bs
oa
sR
ida
Dri e
oad
tin R
Mar
Gib
eR
W att
Row
l ace
lace
Road
Pla
c
ar
ri
ve
aP
nv
Ad
up
Mcinne
s
Roys R
o ad
er
imoa
na
K
Be
ian Way
er
ck
Booker
P
Mcleod
Road
ce
ve W
r s Co
ai m
ahia
a im
Ade
Ave K
l Pla
nue
ce Pir
iti P
Gibbon
s Road
Blanes
Road
lace
Waimai
Avenue
Estuary
Road
S ettle
Ro
ad
rR
oa
d
Bohola
d
Roa
Dam
Ka
l an
Gil
er
nP
Ker
y
Re
Way
R
a
l
na n P
E
th e r t o n
ne
Ebanja
r iv
Drive
cc
a
b
Car
c
Pla
P la
ce
ce
Tait i m Re b e
ad
a ce
R o w Pl
k parro
ee S
e
los
Silver C r
dC
e r Way
Pla
es
ce
Pla
Nin a
ord
P la
r
Ro b e
e rs
ce
n ez
n
Ja
row
ds
Har
la n
Su n
v
n g ton A
l
Sea
on
la
sP
m
Pal
lace
eP
ce
P la
Pl a
kelt
Place
ter
Ma
rt S
t R os
ington Eb e e
nn
D riv
Ke
ue
r
ma a
Sa
e
pl
Ma
r
a
ce
Tu
Ora t u Pla
e mp to n Pl a
r
na
la c
Fai
nP
Pla
o
t
n
e
c
c
B
a
e
l
l Place
dP
nel
nal
Fun
Carter Pla
Ro
ce
e
enu
ale Terr a ce
Sharlan d Av
rnd
Bu
Ririn
o P lace
e
Rob
A venu
N e em s
ce
lo
De B
W ai Iti
llvill
Be
ge
P lace
tAven
te Stree t
a
Pl
l ace
y
P la
ce
rn
wo
od
es
ce
ven
di A ue
ru n
e
Bu
ac
Pl
ve
D rive
it t
ega
e
Ad
n A ven ue
en
Place
u
v en
di A
nt
S tre
ce
e
et
enu u sh o n Pla
P
r i e ff Av
e
nP
lac
n P Templ e to
wy
Bal
lace
aP
B und
k Av e nue
rsle
Yea y Plac
e
Way
her
bis
Fro
tir a
ga
Pureora
Buru
Mo
nc
T r oun so
Puhinui
Burban
l la
Pa
ce
Pla
en h
D ag
Matu a
k Street
b roo
c
K o p u Pla
p a ra P
l a ce
ra
oad
ly R
Hea
ce
P la
am
na
A
etti
St
ton
B
re
in g
et
Add
s
Fea
F ell
Ha
ad
Ro
on
mm
ce
sco
la
Ro
lP
tre l
Cot
e
la
Place
ll P
n fo rd
Sto
e
Plac
va
th
Gar
tford
re n
uc
ad
Ro
pin
T am
ad
ms R o
Ada
Gl
o
Road
Maich
Manukau
Central
and Wiri
e
la c
Hingaia
and the
Islands
175
350
Date: 19/01/2016
700 m
rm
ce
iri R
Pur
ve
nu
e
T i ngt
on
an Bra
thi
e
Lo
e
Kah urang i P
lac
Iorangi Place
Local Centre
Town Centre
Metropolitan Centre
City Centre
Mixed Use
Elle
ws
General Business
dP
ar lac
rn
e
a
B
Business Park
Light Industry
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Val
e
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
Rural Production
Public Open Space - Conservation
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation
Takanini
Urban
Pla
ce
Countryside Living
Road [i]
Glen
n
Cran
r os
r
sD
Defence [rcp/dp]
ic
Pineh
ft
e
n c i a Plac
Ro
ad
Ja
me
s
Kay
Roa
d
Ba
lm Avo
n
o
d
Roa
Ferg
lac
Mul l Place
Southview P lace
le rs
Beatty
oa
d
dR
sS
tre
nc e
Fra
gh
t P lace
J ut
lan
Dr
ive Ca
m
Swallo
w
rli
nr
S t ra
ent
nn
Neighbourhood Centre
h Place
e
ac
Pl
Pla
ce
ue
en
Flora P lace
uku
ce
Iwin
Gairlo c
iv e
Ru
th
Ro
ad
br
id
ge
Ke
Ro
nt
ad
Ro
De
ad
ve
till
ro
a Pla
n
ce
Ro
ad
Su
rre
Ker
yS
ry d
tre
ale
et
Ro
a
Ox
fo
rd
rC
lo
se
A ng
rvon
nga
D r Du
i ve
l e y St ree
Sm
ed
rt
i ck
l a ce
et
re
St
Ma
ples
Future Urban
icro
s sa
Honey
Place
Weymo
uth Roa
d
on
us
ion
ns
xte
d
yE
Roa
Wa
ld
ts
ie
on
N
ad
Ro
as
tm
a
lmes Ro
Ho
oad
Lin
Tro
Ko
P lace
oad
ts R
g
Fer
m
au
Be
ris
Ch
R
lds
Fie
layson Av
Fin
e nu e
t
Sco
ay
lv i lle Dr
i
ad
Ro
ts
Bel
Single House
Indicative Coastline
Revised Rural Urban Boundary
Dr
iv
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
Ho
y
ce
res
la ke
nt
s
nne
Plac
Kingseat
and Karaka
Special Purpose
e
nu
ve
rling Avenue A
Ste
o
eet Greenmea d
on
Pitt
ad
um
ea
B
oad
nR
la
tP
on
m
us
ie
Revised zone
ad
Ro
er s
My
e nu
Av
Clayton
rrie
qua
Park
c
M
School
et
tre
ak
O
t
ee
St
oad
ia R
Mah
d
Roa
yto
Area of change
Broug h
Roa
ude
ve
H o bart
Cla
Large Lot
oad
rR
hu
Art
Mcdou gall St
r
Roa d
S11a
LEGEND
ad
Ro
ton Manurewa
s
i
r
f
Al
East School
et
Stre
e
Hyd
t
tree
nS
oad
Ro
r e cent
s
Av
s
lcre
Hil
Cla
nis Av e e
Den
nu
c Dr i
eni
Sc
d
oa
lR
rR
lve
Ha
oad
uR
Rim
a ra
s
Tot
ger
Ro
nue
Ave
hill
urc
Ch
Terr a ce
ks
Hoo
e
ac
Pl
Beach
Road Domain Ro
ad
e
Plac
e
nu
l
Jil
wh
Ne
Manurewa
South
School
ch
Takanini
Rural
tG
ro
ve
R oa d
ad
i Ro
hiw
t
Ko
tree
be S
Gre
Seawa r d
Str
Su
Ca
rno
l
Hi
South
Mcannalley Stree
e
lac
p so
ne
od Drive
Wo
ley
ad
e Street
l
da
ing
c e nt
d
oa
e
ac
Pl
Wattl
view
e Fa
Ro
ad
e
iv
Place
ac
Dr
st
k woo d
ur
o
Cr
oo
G kL
r e an
at
e
So
ut
h
ad
Ro
d
Roa
t re e
Bl
e
Ashki rk Plac
M ane
Reremoana
Primary
e lfry
School
oad
n
lwy
ad
Tho m
S
vitt
yCre
s c ent
een Cresce
Aberd
t
n
sc e
Cre
berry Drive
Turn
e
enu
Av
Manurewa
Central
School
P
ter
es
xhe
Co
di
Mc
Ast or Pl a
re P lace
M ui
rfi
eld
nt
Road
Place
ter
wa n C
e
u le ourt
Bl g
c
re s
rC
Estuary
Road
ay
tW
es
cr
t
tree
al S
c iv
r
o
e
P
wa
a re
mb
aA
Ga
ar
is m
n
In
ae
v
ro
Road
Hillpark
School
le
lpo
Wa
Se
er C
B ull
oad
sR
Way
Grande Vue
nG
lv y
t re e
dS
for
e
Syk
riv
ue
ven
gA
erin
James
Cook High
School
rth
No
l Street
Leabank
School
e re
hm
As
n
Berni a Pl a ce
e
Av
el
O'co n n
ent
t
ce
es c
ee
Pla
Cr
Str
Clendo n
ore
ym
ad
rt
Cla
Ro
nue Ki
Ave
e rs
d
ean
lan
d
M ck
Frie
eet
nt
Str
sce
es
C re
E ddow
t on
es
ad
Ro
th
treet
eS
idg
W ins
on
k
Pic
Dr
Ke
e
nu
Manurewa
eet
Str
et
tree
n ey Place
d
y Roa
Halse
Mo n Intermediate
W
Manurewa
or
ds
west
wo Be
He
School
r
yb
r
e
Lan
Weymouth
School
G reers
ace
n Pl
nto
Mi
lac
aP
ark Driv
hP
e
ag
et
treet
Ro a
ue
en
aly
An t
se
Ri
St
re
Sa
nd
oad
Drive
Roys R
Road
ve
Mcinne
s
Gle n
fi
stle
Ca
n Way
lace
Mcleod
Road
ce
P la
ago
e
Sel
la c
oP
Rak
e
ker Driv
Wal
ck
Be
ad
Ro
imoa
na
P
n
o
t
Hin
Gil
Jo hn
ce
Ka
Dam
ia
et
re
S t ru
a
up
K lace
Way
Waimai
Avenue
nu e
ve
et
la c e
u Drive
er D
rive
aP
l ace
Set
tlers
Wa
Co v e
ima
hia A
Ade
venu
l Pla
e
ce Pir
i ti P
Gibbons
Road
Blanes
Road
n D
i
dl
u
Be
en
Av
e
Str
nP
Ker
Ha
na
Boh ola
e
ac
n Pl
Ta i
e
r iv
le
da
P la
Roa
Clendon Teen
Parent Unit
ti m
ord
ce
Pla
Finlayson
Park School
rs
me
Pal
ee
Silver C r
E th
ne
Ebanja
rt
o
Place
n
wa
Ro
c
Pla
l
Sea
n
elto
t Sk
e
nningt o
n Driv
Ke
ce
Pla
e
es
Jan
t
ree
Ni n a
be
Ro
Wai It i
r
ma a
Sa
l la
Pa
Way
her
bis
Fro
e
nP
lac
n P Templ e to
wy
Bal
e
Plac
Place
Avenu
de
rive
eD
ry R
Ro
ad
ic o
eR
rR
oa
oa
d
d
S
Clark
S
llie
sh
Ma
r
ad
Maich
Ar b
Da
Street
ate
seg
Fea
ad
Ro
on
mm
sco
lace
Ro
lP
trel
Cot
e
la
ll P
Sto
e
Plac
va
p ara P
l ace
or
Fr e
st e
r
o ad
ee R
Roa
d
bs
Clendon
Park
School
ce
oad
ly R
Hea
e
c
e
P la
en
la c
na
o
nA
ha
th P
etti
gto
Gar
m B
n
i
d
St
Ad
la c e
Dri e
wP
B
ra
arro
Burban
ds
H
k Av e nue
la n
n
u
S
rn
v
wo
n g ton A
od
l a ce
c
nt
e
Stre
Mo
e
et
enu
Rowandale
nc
r i e ff Av
School
tir a
ven
a
e
sA
Ng
ac
Tu
Aden P
Ora t u Pl
a
e
na
la c A
Fa i
Pla
nP
ce Bento
Roscommon
lac
l Place
l
P
e
n
School
B und
n ald
F un
ena
Carter P la
Ro
Avenue
ce
ndi
e
u
r
e
en u
Bu
ale Terr a ce
ac
Sharlan d Av
rnd
Pl
Bu
Ririn
r
o Place
ve
r
Law enc
e
Da
Cr
vi
es
d
ce
Av
nt
e
Lyn
rd
Stu
Gl
ou
tin Ro
Mar
Co
oad
Road
dams
Gib
Je
ll
R
pin
Tam
Puhinui
the
Ro
Manukau
Central
and Wiri
Hingaia
and the
Islands
175
350
Date: 19/01/2016
700 m
Otara
Flat Bush, Botany Junction
Flat Bush
and Botany Junction
d Pla c
Elste
rt
Da
Nor
ce
Town Centre
Metropolitan Centre
City Centre
Mixed Use
General Business
Business Park
Light Industry
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
e
P lac
en
rD
ma
ci C
e rr
C lose
e
Zo
S ar
ri v e
oD
ean
ce
la
ce
P la
bury
Rus
h
R an
c
Pla
Mas sin
P
Mooring [rcp]
ce
e Pla
Hype rio
Water [i]
Coastal Transition
e
n Driv
l ace
la c
Indicative Coastline
al D
Trim
do
n
Shif
ee
t
tr
nS
ri ve
Solveig
Pl a c e
c
Pla
o
Trimd
r i ff
e et
n Str
Ribo t
ce
Pla
Sh e
Pl
ac
eet
e
Str
ch
lo
l
Eu
Ba
lo
gy
P
Horlic k s
e ad
ld n
Go
Advocat
c
la
Neriss a P
et
Stre
ce
Pla
rive
nD
Rive rto
a ta
o
rc
Ne
a
lt Place
ick
se
Ro
Co
dw
Ste
ll
riat Place
e
l ac
eP
wSt
xla
reet
M agic Wa y F o
Defence [rcp/dp]
Takanini
Urban
Iro
n
one P
st
ew
G
ce
V in
rive
u
ven
nA
lto
o u rt
Am arill o P la
ur
Co
e
o r Driv
nt
Rural Production
rive
Cou
spur
La rk
se
M en
Saralee D
Secreta
Shifnal Drive
Local Centre
P
ar
um
na t
Se
ex P
Ind
Clo
Rath
eR
n
lee
ve
D ri
o h Pl a
e
Ris
ht
s
n
Cair
e ig
Neighbourhood Centre
la
lac
e
aP
i a Place
ks
ce
rg
la d
eD
r iv
e
Ev
e
rn P
oC
ise
t ai n R
re
Ris
e
on
Ald
t
our
sC
Idri
lac
e
P la
rstb
ou
La m
e
la c
ke
P
ra
ce
Pla
ac
s val
Vi
ow
e
Sk
na
u rt
ia Co
enic
Pho
Pell
c
an i
r ne
tb ou
rive
ia P
Pl
is e
eD
rale
Ma
ce
m
Nor
W hi
Sa
s
Byb lo
ia
P la
M
oy
le
ou
rt
Future Urban
h le
Nak
nwo
mo
Le
rt
So
Manurewa,
Homai and
Clendon Park
ce
od Pla
Bot
e
lac
E lia
Le
R is
ou
ad
Ro
Hill
n
Na
oa
uk
M
ce
ce n
res
b a non C
Mt
t
en
sc
D
rle s
P re vos t
ao
Kuripaka Cre s c e nt
iv
re
re
ai
W
re
ha
Pe
re
t
C
ka
ay
WC
i pa
Ku r
a
ur
c ent
Tu
ak
e Driv e
man
es
e l Cr
Ha
k
ro
Co
Takanini
Rural
ce
Pla
od
wo
Ysa
P al m e t t
Th
Nyssa
e
los
Ch
Hu
ane
Teak
Grove
Single House
ce
Pla
r a il Co
ur
t
Large Lot
lad
ac
Special Purpose
erg
Pl
Ev
Pla
ce
a
si
Pe Ide
gu
er
o
e
ug
Retain
s
Clo
tua
Can
la
ce
Tilia
Amend
oo
d
lace
Ilex P
nia P
lac
low
e
Pau
da
D eo r Pla c
ive
Dr
Ba
lt ic
Rise
belia
La
ne
s
ano Mew
od
Go
Lo
En
Lev
en
ce
Alcove Place
c l ave
an Drive
S11b
Capistr
G
ood rove
Silk w
ce
P la
a
Terr
le
ee
da
ay
South
LEGEND
e
lac
tP
u
Co
eya
Vir
tr
Fig
Kim
th Driv
Manukau
Central
and Wiri
y
Ban
y
Sm
n ia W
Aro
ia Wa y
Ar o n
Place
low
urt
e a Co
ne P
lace
Kirk
Ki n g
ce
Corr
n Way
nea
ra
P la
E wh u r s
om
ns
Ra
ic
rs
e
ac
Pl
le
e
Pl a c
er
nt
oP
pe r
it
ed
At
la
sc
Melia
Gr e
ov
enu
d Av e
n
ri A
Ke
Ba
ief
F airc h il
ia
e
lac
ac
Pi
in g
r io
F lam
145
290
Date: 19/01/2016
580 m
Otara
ed
Elst
re
e
ac
he
Single House
Mixed Housing Suburban
rt
Nyssa
Pho
No
Mt
en
r esc
b a non C
la ce
re
re
ai
W
ay
W
oa
o R is M
uk
a
Kuripaka Cre s c e n t Cl
iaP
Le
ra
Pe
re
ta
r
ma
o s Ku
e
urt
cia Co
eni
School
l a ce
i a Place
aP
lac
e
ke
Ris
e
ia
s c ent
Tu
ak
u
es
arl The
Ch
Gardens
ou Man
a
rt
Neighbourhood Centre
Local Centre
t
our
sC
Idri
Town Centre
Metropolitan Centre
City Centre
Mixed Use
General Business
Lam
ia
Ysa
e
los
n
rma
e
lac
ra P
k
ro
Co
as
Eli
Ha
rive
st D
vo
e
Pr
en
ug
e
b
e l Cr
Pe Ides
gu
P la
er
ce
o
Pl
ac
e
Future Urban
Green Infrastructure Corridor
lac
lia P
c
Pla
ar Place
Takanini
Rural
nia Pl
low
ac
e
Pau
Teak
Grove
Large Lot
s
Clo
tua
Can
r a il Co
ur
t
Special Purpose
Ch
H
De avi
ise
Ba
lla
t ai n R
lt ic
P la
Dr
ce
i
Ev
er g
la d
eD
r iv
e
Revised zone
iv
Dr
Ti
od
Go
oo
d
G
ood rov
e
Silk w
clave
En
d
De o
no Mews
Drive
Area of change
lace
Ilex P
ce
Pla
ora
yan
B an
Co u
Business Park
Light Industry
Heavy Industry
ce
G i b son Pl a
Ir o
n
y P
la c
Eu
lo
g
Pl
ac
e
C ou
la
Neriss a P
e
Mas sin
Mooring [rcp]
ce
e
Plac
Coastal Transition
Hyperion Driv e
Sh e
e
lac
dP
ni
ld
Go
Ca
se
en R
Advocate
ea
a ta
treet
e
Driv
on
Ri v ert
Ne
a
oS
rc
e
lac
w Str
i ck
Defence [rcp/dp]
Takanini
Urban
eet
Randwick
Park
School
sem
Ro
r i ff
Pl a c e
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
c
Pla
e
et
Shifnal Drive
S te
ll
Ra n d
ce
Ribot
Solveig
rive
tone Pl
ac
e
eet
Str
ch
allo
ce
Pla
Alfriston
College
iew
Sonter
e
los
t
our
ni C
Gia
t
S ar
oD
e an
riat Place
r
S e nato
ra C
Secreta
Pla
nu
Ave
ton
el
k
S
rive
rD
ma
Place
rive
alee D
Sar
Mixed Rural
iv
Dr
Rise
li e
ex Pl
Ind
Rural Coastal
Rural Production
Rath
tta
Ma
l
va
rive
Countryside Living
e
ac
Pl
hle
t
w ar
Ste
i rns
wD
e llo
mP
Nor
cV
ani
Bot
ad
Ro
Hill
ace a nle
Rural Conservation
N ak
pu
rks
La
rt
lace
ou nwood P
r C emo
L
S
on
Trimd
re
Manurewa,
Homai and
Clendon Park
S11b
So p h
Wa
nia
A ro
Ris e
belia
Lo
Everglade
School
ya
Vire
South
LEGEND
e
lac
tP
E w hu rs
Capistra
e
Driv
Manukau
Central
and Wiri
Place
G r ve
o
Corre Court
a
nn
ri A
Ke
Melia
ve
ld Avenue n d
Ran
s
yth
Sm
F a irchi
le
om
e
Pla c
per
Pi
ief
Pl
Ki n g
sc
Place
145
290
Date: 19/01/2016
580 m
Beachlands,
Maraetai,
Clevedon,
Brookby, Whitford,
Matingarahi
South
S12a
Takanini Urban
LEGEND
Takanini
Rural
Manurewa,
Homai and
Clendon Park
Special Purpose
Large Lot
Single House
Mixed Housing Suburban
Mixed Housing Urban
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
Future Urban
Green Infrastructure Corridor
Rural and Coastal Settlement
Neighbourhood Centre
onCl
Jad
ng
Pl
Ro
a
St B
re e
et ac
Un
a
ne
Th
e
Mo
Lon
C ou rt
a
rew
Mo
r
aD
e el C re
Red
ce
e Pla
a vr
Ross Marti
Zenith Place
nD
riv
e
lac
iP
an
Ev
t
oka
Pop
Cr
y
Beaumaris Wa
e
la
c
al
da
ld D
riv e
Takanini On R
am
Cha
l
p
Fr
a
Ve
r
P
tu lac
Papakura
Rural
Waion
e
Papakura
Urban West
d
Roa
lac
Foxbridge L ane
ace
t
ur
ue
en
Av
Ca
o
o C
nt
s ce
Cre
Co
la c
lP
r k il
Coastal Transition
d
Roa
rs h
Water [i]
ave
a de
Le
a st
dE
gr
Cos
t
ce n
Road
res
yC
lsh
a ntr
Wa
Gall
oad
eR
Gigi P
lac
s ce nt
Mooring [rcp]
v
Gro
Marina [rcp/dp]
ip
et
tati
Drive
Stre
iS
ce
Ro
t
es
ti on
S ta
dW
nui
Tiro
rs
d
Roa
u
Arim
ad
Ro
Wa ka
nu
P la
lace
Tak
I n l et
o
Tir
oa
nR
i Road
onu
T ir
nt
ce
ad
t Ro
ce
Terra
ce
c
Pla
la ce
rd
ive
rn
nbu
Gle
Tiro
nui R
Inle
a
yn
P la
r
ord P ar k D
gf
ss Cres
te
Wal
P
mer
Ditt
P
ad eburn
Bra
ka
ay
Ro
d
oa
Re
ace
err
eT
ce
Pla
on
n
talio
Ari
on
Defence [rcp/dp]
Bat
oa
e
Dr iv
aR
nor
Gle
urlo
Road [i]
et
lum
iR
oa
R oa
in
an
an
Pulm
Ta
k
Mcg
et
Stre
inty
e
v
i
r
ri D
Kau
d
oa
Ari o n R
Ro
ad
Z ab
ce
ow
Will
ck
Bru
oa
d
T ra
ack
ns
Rei
d
Roa
Rural Production
nue
Ave
oe
nue
Ave
e
eto
nu
Puwue oaka Ave
nue
ven P
A ve
hua
he A
Tr
The
p
Cam
Mixed Rural
at
Mat
r iv e
ka D
Kua
e
Dr iv
ea
T he
So
ut
h
ir
rap
Ta
Mo
ani
n
a
Tak
nue
Ave
na
e
teri
an e
en u
Yat
i Av Kaki L
Hih
R
oa
d
a
Cl
iR
oa
d
at
r eet
a St
ak
Rural Coastal
ose
o ad
on R
Countryside Living
e
r i ce Plac
iR
m
an
a
G
re
e
Pla c
Tak
P ar k
Stati
d
Roa
roa
ke D r iv
Pate
Le
H
u
Man
Rural Conservation
ue
ive
eet
g a rt e
n
Ave
wyn
Ber
O ld
toyC
Aris
ad
r Ro
ad
l Ro
hoo
Heavy Industry
ay
Carlin
Mixed Use
Light Industry
tree
d
Ki n
w
tor
Mo
Gard
an Place
neg
Do
City Centre
Sc
nini
Taka
ar
Metropolitan Centre
Business Park
ss S
K irra
W
ai
la c
e
W
ai
Pl
ac
e
er n
uth
So
Aztec
a n Place
aP
Town Centre
General Business
d
Roa
ion
Stat
ce
lu Pla
wa
Coro
c e nt
ika Place
ss
Je
la c
rP
a Court
Talg mbr i
Cu
dla
Pe
it
Elr
ce
Pla
ll a
De
es
e
s Fi
ta
n Court
er
Str
ing
ce
Prin
lose
ce
la
tP
ce
lac
aP
da C r
nz
ell
a
ce
Pla
o
rid
P la
lac
e
Br
oc
k
B is c e
Pla
er
iv
ull
G
ce
Do
us
sP
P la
oad
p
m
n
Sy
Pe
t
Ty
io
nia
ool R
ue
en
Av
Ra
Drive
e
Pla c
s Drive
ce
ven
Pla
tre
S
t ax
Gloaming Place
er
alt
W
Emo r
v
i
e
r
yD B
ac
Shariva r
yP
a rd
ca
Cata
Ad
Ma
Te rr
a ce
ti
De s n
h
ig
le
Oa k
nue
Ave
f
Of
an
tt
Sco
d
Roa
nuia
Ma
Balgow
S ch
ok
tbro
Wes
ni
ni
e
iv
lla
lee
Bry
Dr
e
Ke y w
lenC
ive
Dr
Plac
Heb
d
Roa
S p artan
ff Ram
i O Drive
n in
e
yle
Br
Ta k a
M anurewa-Ta k a
y
Ke
lla
we
ce
tti Pl a
ro
Pe
l os
nini
Marpho
na
Taka
oad
gi R
Ran
oad
gi R
Ran
Local Centre
o ad
es R
Pop
ste
che
Por
t
cen
es
Papakura
Urban East
160
320
Date: 19/01/2016
640 m
Beachlands,
Maraetai,
Clevedon,
Brookby, Whitford,
Matingarahi
South
S12a
Takanini Urban
LEGEND
Submission Area Unit
Area of change
Area of change - out of scope
Revised zone
Special Purpose
Takanini
Rural
Manurewa,
Homai and
Clendon Park
Large Lot
Single House
Mixed Housing Suburban
Mixed Housing Urban
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
Future Urban
Green Infrastructure Corridor
Rural and Coastal Settlement
Neighbourhood Centre
Cr
Marpho
na
aD
iv e
u Dr
ng
re
ipi C
Pip
Cr e
onCl
Jad
Ro
a
St B
re ea
et ch
Th
e
Mos
Takanini On R
am
Challe
p
Red
Un
a
nt
C ou rt
e
esc
Waion
e
Coastal Transition
Hauraki Gulf Islands
oad
eR
Lon
Water [i]
Indicative Coastline
Revised Rural Urban Boundary
et
Stre
Waka
Papakura
Urban West
d
Roa
Road
lsh
Wa
v
Gro
Mooring [rcp]
ave
ce
lace
t
en
a
rew
Mo
Ca
la
ce
Marina [rcp/dp]
gr
Cos
an
Ev
rP
rs
Drive
l
Chibnal Plac
e
d
Roa
n
talio
Papakura
Normal
School
P
mer
Ditt
Ve
rn
e
Bat
ay
la
rn P
nbu
Gle
d
oa
e
riv
Defence [rcp/dp]
te
Wal
et W
C
ap
rL
Pha
Tiro
nui R
Road [i]
ent
esc
Ross Marti
Zenith Place
nt
sce
Beaumaris Wa
ee l
Z ab
ro
a
Fig
r ive
l um
oa
ad
t Ro
Foxbridge Lane
nD
e
nu
ma
Pul
aR
nor
Gle
rl o
Fu
Inle
ce
Pla
ord P ar k D
gf
s C r esc
e
Plac
c
Pla
Cr
oa
d
ive
ani
n
tu
ka
Ta
c
Tra
The
ce
Bru
R
oa
nue
Ave
ka
ue
Poa
ven
A
hua
e
Mo
enu
i Av
aw a
Hak
et
Rural Production
nt
sce
i ve
ri Dr
Kau
oad
nR
Ario
R
oa
nue
Ave
na
e
teri
en u
Yat
i Av enue
Hih
Av
r ay
Dal
iR
oa
d
ose
Mixed Rural
at
Mat
ive
a
r
k
D
e
a
Wh
ate
k
o
Pop
r iv e
ka D
Kua
a
Cl
ke D r ive
Pate
e
lac
P
Park
an
ak
Rural Coastal
Old
d
Roa
ion
Stat
Stre
Countryside Living
e
r i ce Plac
iR
ar
d
Roa
uroa
Man
Taka
Rural Conservation
ue
Av
e
General Business
n
Ave
wyn
Ber
toyC
Aris
ad
r Ro
e
Stre
at
So
ut
h
ace
nka
Mixed Use
Heavy Industry
r
Ter
Gardo
ne
Carli
City Centre
ad
l Ro
hoo
ess
ai
W
ai
Metropolitan Centre
Light Industry
Takanini
School
c
Prin
Drive
iv
e nt
a Place
sik
Jes
a n Place
G
re
sc
ce
lu Pla
wa
ns
eve
ta
n Court
Cr e
Pla
ce
Ma
Town Centre
Business Park
et
Stre
ing
ue
en
Av
Conifer
Grove
School
e
a Court
ac
Talg mbr i
Pl
e
Cu
ac
Pl
r
dla
Pe
Str
er
alt
W
t
do
Br
oc
kt
ce
da
ri
Pe
Do
nz
el
la
Pla
er n
uth
So
Emo r
y Drive
oad
ia R
nu
Ma
r
Kindergarte n D y
wa
tor
Mo
n
Sy
t ax
h
ig
le
ak
O
ive
Dr
ve
Dri
Ke y w
a
e ll
se
e
Pl a c
Bry lee
ti
rot
Pe
l os
Plac
Heb
nue
Ave
p
m
Ra
ff
iO
nClo
Local Centre
o ad
es R
Sc
nini
Taka
oad
gi R
Ran
ok
tbro
Wes
ni n
Tak a
d
Roa
S p artan
Pop
ste
che
Por
t
cen
es
Papakura
Rural
Papakura
Urban East
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
160
320
Date: 19/01/2016
640 m
South
S12b
Takanini Rural
LEGEND
Kinn
ar
d
L ane
TiffanyC
los
e
Beachlands,
Maraetai,
Clevedon,
Brookby, Whitford,
Matingarahi
Mi
doubt Road
Re
ll R
oa
d
Single House
Mixed Housing Suburban
Mixed Housing Urban
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
Future Urban
Green Infrastructure Corridor
Rural and Coastal Settlement
Neighbourhood Centre
Local Centre
Town Centre
Metropolitan Centre
City Centre
ve
Prince D r i
Mixed Use
Po
l
General Business
s to
nR
rlea P lace
e
lac
ch P
e
Au nc
Light Industry
Ev e
Not
Business Park
i se
R
on
rist
Alf
d
oa
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
Rural Production
Public Open Space - Conservation
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation
Manurewa,
Homai and
Clendon Park
Airfield Roa d
Defence [rcp/dp]
Ferry Terminal [rcp/dp]
Minor Port [rcp/dp]
Marina [rcp/dp]
Takanini
Urban
Mooring [rcp]
l
Mu
lin
oad
Water [i]
d
oa
sR
R
lin
Ham
Coastal Transition
Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rural Urban Boundary [rps] as notified
Papakura
Rural
Papakura
Urban East
Indicative Coastline
245
490
Date: 19/01/2016
980 m
South
S12b
Takanini Rural
LEGEND
Revised zone
Special Purpose
Large Lot
los
e
TiffanyC
L ane
ard
Kinn
ill
Single House
Beachlands,
Maraetai,
Clevedon,
Brookby, Whitford,
Matingarahi
do
Re ub t Road
Ro
ad
ve
Prince D r i
Mixed Use
Po
l
General Business
Not
Light Industry
e
Ris
lace
ch P
on
cest
Aun
Business Park
Alf
nR
isto
Heavy Industry
d
oa
Rural Conservation
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
Rural Production
Public Open Space - Conservation
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation
Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation
Public Open Space - Community
Manurewa,
Homai and
Clendon Park
Airfield Roa d
Defence [rcp/dp]
Ferry Terminal [rcp/dp]
Minor Port [rcp/dp]
Takanini
Urban
Marina [rcp/dp]
Mooring [rcp]
l
Mu
lin
lin
d
oa
sR
Ham
d
Roa
Coastal Transition
Hauraki Gulf Islands
Indicative Coastline
Papakura
Rural
Papakura
Urban East
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
245
490
Date: 19/01/2016
980 m
Road
tham
Tren
South
m Roa d
Takanini
Urban
ha
nt
Tre
yn
be
la
d
e
an
Duke Str
eet
et
wd
m
Tas
an
e
ac
Pl
lei
ac
Pl
Waipokapu Place
Road [i]
Rohea Place
es
ce
en
ve
D ri
Defence [rcp/dp]
Ferry Terminal [rcp/dp]
Lipton Grove
Cotton Place
ce
Ka
nag
va
o
Sn
R embrandt Place
P la
lace
Ke
r yn
Great So
uth Ro
ad
o l m W ay
nue
Ave
Water [i]
Coastal Transition
Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rural Urban Boundary [rps] as notified
Terra c e
R hin
d Plac
e
W
es
th
R ip p le
gg
Le
Menary S
tree
Clo
se
West Stre
et
Mag
e
Tasman D riv
oa
enhaven Avenue
Gre
Taon
Rural Production
Leatham C r
P l ace
e
nu
ie
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
ee
Str
ort
Sh
ue
ven
wA
Countryside Living
e
Av
airv
ee
Str
en
et
rt
Rural Conservation
v
ha
en
te
Esta
Park
e
S tr
et
Hazeldene P
Coultha r d
e
Driv
o ad
te R
on Pl
e
Alb
nue
Ave
Road Bellfi
e ld
Bellfield
R
e
ac
rt
tre
re
G
dwin
Goo
Joa nn e
a
noli
o
Sh
et
rS
et
venu
ark A
nyp
Sun
ce
Es ta
Park
i Stre
ce
lis
Cal
tre
rt S
de
L or
e
r iv
rD
la
th P
ybe
Mar
rik
Tata
Taonui Street
e
Alb
an
Heavy Industry
st
We
et
tre
sc
cent
Cres
reet
ui St
e
tre
x
Ale
Light Industry
S
ay
il w
Ra
Cre
ste
re
Taire
et
Roy ston Stre
S
er
e
nu
e re
e
ich
Business Park
Avenue
s Place
ce
h Pla
Tair
Ch
General Business
ad
Ro
nt
e
le m
d
an
Li Alex
ve
rp
oo
lS
tre
et
s Place
Bushland
d
lan
Po
reet
se
Orchard Ri
ace
Jupiter St
Pl
Royal Arch
h Plac
e
Orchard Ris
et
Jupiter Stre
Mixed Use
e
Av
ce
Mcc all P la
Jame
e
Av enu
Edinburgh
Mot
rd
wa
Ed
St
re
et
Arthur Pl
a
Rosehill Drive
psy
pe
st
po
ol
Erceg Way
Gy
City Centre
We
L iv
tt
Se
er
ue
ven
eA
et
R oa
d
Roa
th
Butterwor
Pl
ac
e
a
Ch
e
St re
g
Kin
t
ee
Str
el
p
C ha
Clark Road
se
Man
o ve
r Plac e
Dum
as
Metropolitan Centre
et
ot e
Town Centre
e
Str
W
ile
nc
Local Centre
y
wa
et
treet
yl
Arg
re
St
n se
Neighbourhood Centre
il
Ra
Nelson St
re
Clark Road
Ma
eet
South
S
Place
Woo d S
treet
Beach Road
Hingaia
and the
Islands
e
Str
Future Urban
Papakura
Urban East
et
e
tre
Duke Stre
e
enu
n Av
gre e
Jim
tS
et
Nelson Str
n
Ha
yP
la
ce
ll
eri
Av
s
Ea
tre
nS
ee
Gr
Rus
h
aham Ta
Gr
et
et
et
nt
Wellingt
on Stree
t
esce
lac
e
et
yc
Jo
B e xl e
B a rnhi ll Cr
ell P
re
St
riv e
own
A shd
tre
tre
tre
ts
ive
Single House
dS
nS
igh
en
t
Dr
en
Gre
rd
fo
k es id e
D
Small
S
ey
ss
ne
an
o
Wo
ee
ss
La
Ray
Large Lot
Br o
adw
a
n
nio
eet
Str
Winslow
He
sc
et
Mo
re
tre
iot
Ell
Both
Barnh i ll
nS
r ee
St
e
ac
Pl
k le
et
inney
Sp
Th e
ee
Special Purpose
O'sh
t
ee
Str
e
Th
ce
Pla
ic
Cr
re
Coles C
res
c en
t
Gr
Qu
e
i d
La k
Dr
iv
ee
Str
arf
Wh
Len Garlick Pl
de
ce Terrac
e
n
gree
si
he
a
Le
ole
n
ee
Qu
lan
h
Rus
Fr
ee
St
Retain
ll L
ve n u e
g
Kin
d
oo
Amend
es
ce
n
ue
ven
sA
a ce
Cr
oad
Cli ff
R
ll
Do
n
Sunsh i ne Place
oa
Co
les
u
Yo
d
oa
R
gs
Gi
Gill s
A
nue
tre
et
Ro
herds
R
liff
ve
LEGEND
t
ur
Co
Br
Shep
sR
Young oad
S13a
Drury
Urban
Indicative Coastline
d
Roa
110
220
Date: 19/01/2016
440 m
Takanini
Urban
Ro
tham
Tre n
South
ad
t
ur
Co
be
la
LEGEND
Submission Area Unit
Br
yn
Area of change
tre
et
Do
n S
Revised zone
nue
Ave
Special Purpose
le
s
r esc
ent
Rural Conservation
Menary S
tree
la ce
ce
Cotton Place
a ndt Place
e
lac
ow
Sn
e
riv
an D
Boundary Road
en
e
ac
Pl
l ei
Road [i]
Rohea Place
Defence [rcp/dp]
Ferry Terminal [rcp/dp]
Lipton Grove
v
Ka
anagh
nue
Ave
ce
Pl a
Water [i]
Coastal Transition
Hauraki Gulf Islands
Indicative Coastline
Terra c e
o l m Wa y
W
es
th
e
ot
W
ile
nc
West Stre
et
Mag
Tas m
e
nu
P l ace
Opaheke
School
e
Av
Road
Gayl a n
P
ds
ve
ew
Rural Production
ha
irvi
Fa
e
nu
Ave
Hazeldene P
Coultha r d
te
Esta
Park
l
Cal
ue
ven
is A
ee
Str
en
e
Driv
a
noli
ort
Sh
Mixed Rural
re
e
riv
enue
rk Av
nypa
Sun
tre
et
Rural Coastal
et
Alb
ee
Str
ert
re
Lo
tre
riki S
ce
Bellfield
on P l
Countryside Living
Avenue
s Place
e
ac
e
nd
ee
Str
Rem b r
Tata
dwin
Goo
rD
Joa nn e
Heavy Industry
e
nu
Taonui Street
ds
la n
Po
te
es
Place
Light Industry
e
Av
xa
Ale
Place
et
Roy ston Stre
ace
ic h
ybeth
Mar
se
Orchard Ri
Pl
Royal Arch
Avenue
Ch
t
scen
re Cre
Taire
Business Park
ad
Ro
nt
e
le m
er
po
ol
S
Arthur Pl
a
Jame
reet
Papakura
South
School
Edinb urg h
Jupiter St
General Business
rd
wa
Ed
ue
ven
eA
Li
v
Pl
ac
e
Rosehill
Intermediate
Mixed Use
es
tW
tt
Se
oad
th
Butterwor
Rosehill Drive
City Centre
g
Kin
yl
Arg
ce
Beach Road
Dum
as
Metropolitan Centre
ee
se R
Man
Erceg Way
Town Centre
Str
el
ap
Ch
Clark Road
v
no
Ha
e r Pla
et
t
ee
Str
treet
e
re
Be l e
x
Pl
ac
e
Local Centre
Wellingt
on Stree
t
St
en
t
ay
e
yc
Jo
Place
own
A shd
Neighbourhood Centre
Wood St
reet
Nelson St
re
South
S
riv e
et
Future Urban
ilw
Ra
en
Gre
D
Small
Ray
ts
igh
sc
Hingaia
and the
Islands
He
Papakura
Urban East
rd
fo
Winslow
e
tre
ss
Mo
re
Papakura
Central
School
tre
ll S
eri
Av
tS
ney
pin
Barnh i ll
t
ee
Str
Br o
adw
ay
s
Ea
eS
Dr
iv
e
iot
Ell
e
ac
Pl
e
tre
nS
n io
et
Th
La k
Th e
a
Le
tre
nS
ee
Gr
Len Garlick P l
ac e
si
de
ee
Str
arf
Wh
gr e
nA
ve n
ue
e Terrac
e
h
Rus
c
lan
ee
Qu
t
r ee
St
Fr
ee
t
ee
Single House
et
tre
Kin
tr
gS
Large Lot
O'sh
S
ey
ss
ne
an
Co
P la
lls
Gi
Ke
r yn
ad
Ro
liff
Great Sou
th Road
sR
Young oad
S13a
Drury
Urban
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
d
Roa
110
220
Date: 19/01/2016
440 m
Takanini
Rural
South
Takanini
Urban
LEGEND
Winiata T
P la c e
P lace
R i se
ourt
Lidde
la c e
e
nu
Av e
ace
Pl
Citril
ce
Gi
b
oa
Mooring [rcp]
General Coastal Marine [rcp]
rb
Pla
c
Do
ce
Ba
Ap
ril
ra
Ter
on
ert
Defence [rcp/dp]
t
cen
a
Pl
ce
ok
Road [i]
Gibbs
s
Cre
ad
Ro
ro
ck
Ma
t
c en
ce
ke
la
Cres
bs
Pla
d
ar
Redcrest Av en u e
is
hr
C
la
Ar
ce
ce
ik i
Pla
P lac
ni
a
l
e
i
Le
Place
Re
dm
ou
Water [i]
nt
Pl
Coastal Transition
a
h er
S
Sher
alee
Fai rda le
m
Ga
Li me
Cr
ue
Pl
ac
e
Margan
Galilee Ave
nu
e
Place
o
Bro
r iv
ko
et
t Ave
nu
e
id en
Pr es
et
urn
S tre
Harpe
an e
r Stre
et
o rg e Street
Eas
tb
ce
Rural Production
a Place
ce
nt
Tiel L
P la
Mixed Rural
Ge
Countryside Living
ar
D
ms
e
Ris
Rural Conservation
Te
ns
ing
Plac
e
Heavy Industry
ac
rg
Ma
illia
se
Ri
Light Industry
ace
ale Pl
en
ee
c
Ma
W
et
Mixed Use
Rural Coastal
rive
ir i D
Kir ik
oad
ee
er
P
do
rke
Ma
la c
eP
S tr
rk
Pa
ee
Str
ke
os
Cr
d
oa
yR
City Centre
yd
Wesle
er
rla
n
Metropolitan Centre
Business Park
aP
Inc
ee
Str
rk
Pa
lace
t al P
Av
lace
et
Be
Town Centre
ka
Ko
ce
iz Pla
en
Cad
ulm
F
e
da l
tes
e
nu
e
tre
nS
O rio
ok
Ch
an
tP
Den
Cr
es
tvi
e
is e
General Business
rth R
nt
sc e
Cre
Fair
De n
le Avenue
t
c en
e rda
es
Emm
e
Driv
reet
Ba
ve
sA
it h
Sm
ac
rive
nD
iv
r i k iri Dr
Local Centre
le af
et
o
Mils
ru R i s e
Neighbourhood Centre
Kokako
Oa k
M cen
te e S
tre
urn
St
Driv e
Car
i s br
East
b
Mils
on
in g C
r
Albion Pla c e
ue
a
Ro
e
lac
ee
e
Ris
escent
y Plac
s
Lo ri
er e
i s ta
Keri V
kwo
Duc
a le Crescent
Harr
ier P
l
Ki
ace
P
Tilbro ok
ace
Street
ce
en
r ne
lv e
Ca
tr
rt S
e
Str
Heathdale Crescent
th d
e
Mauric
la
Salas P
Li
dd
ki Pl
N yk
Romilly C
e
an
ve P
Future Urban
Kerer
u
Yarrow L
ale Plac
d
e
s
Hea
ce
Pl
er t
Avenue
tre
et
lv
Ca
ent Avenue
si d
Pre
Belg
ra
Kerry Pla
Single House
et
tre
Place
Sheehan
Large Lot
e
lac
l ac
Ro bb Street
ri v
e
ive
ree
St
Av
et
tre
Ma
ee t
n
so
er
hs
tre
tt S
na
ft Str
tt
ll
Ro
it
Sm
P ra
nta
Cre
on
Special Purpose
Papakura
Rural
e
rac
er
ba
unt
Mo
Mo
ce
Retain
et
ee
r iv
tD
P la
on
eg
r
O
t
cen
S tr
ad
Ro
Scott Roa d
ue
Aven
ea
nK
Ro
S
ion
Or
tt
Amend
Cargill S
la c
e
Stre
s
Cre
t
cen
on
Street
ive
e t
tt
Pra
t
ee
Str
tes
S
ns
P
e
ntin
Vale
e
Ric
es
Cr
e
nu
rs
lle
n
lvi
Su
Onslo w Road
Ba
t
tree
Orpheus Plac
t
e
tree
art S
w
e
t
Elsie
S et
e
Morto
tr
tre
n
C a gill S
ok S
r
bro
en
Way
solute
Re
S
atiti
ro
Anc
d
Ro
s
os
Cr
George
oad
Scott R
Dr
La urie
at
Road
ce nt
t
m
ee P e
Str
w
slo
On
Cre s
t
tree
Ro a
e
Av
tto
Su n
Ke
et
tre
nS
enue
Ke
ee
ro
me
th
Ca
e
ab
liz
et
re
St
eet
Str
ha
Alp
d
Ro a
rne
Ma
n
Ro
tr
aS
ng
ue
en
Av
Laurie Av
oa
Willis R
t
r ee
St
on
ll
Hi
d
un
ice
si
Bu
ad
er
m
Ca
dm
et
aw
Ar
Papakura
Urban West
o
eR
orp
a
Ro
urt
Co
ney
Kee
y
ar
Ev
a
ve
nyth
Bun
t
cen
ve
Gro
en
sc
g
Man
ad
Clevedon Ro
gra
s
Cre
Hill
a
Alm
e
Cr
Cos
R oa
ace
ce
Pla
rpe
ce n
ent
enue
et
Stre
tor
Pric
l Pl
be l
mp
Ca
oad
aR
g
Yan
ytho
s
Cre
Hil l
sc
Cre
et
Stre
r
ld D
llfie
We
e ll S
htw
Brig
d
Roa
roa
Wai
Old
a
Alm
d
Roa
Av
Snell
View
gar
Mar
tre
et S
e
Stre
d
Roa
et
Stre
non
Ver
e
venu
ley A
Shir
erg
Halb
tree
ck S
w
Vie
am
Ingr
n
Fer
et
n
Bun
rive
Fe rn
et
iP
M a ad
wi
Ren
oad
ry D
lace
ic P
Olym p
oa
uR
uR
D
ry
lace
nP
Imji
Arim
A rim
ille
Art
e
A rtill
Stre
tre
ig S
tree
ig S
airo
ld W
ce
Pla
oa
ker
Pu
st
bur
Sun
S13b
n Road
Hunua Road
Drury
Urban
105
210
Date: 19/01/2016
420 m
Takanini
Rural
South
Takanini
Urban
Pla
Winiata T
Lidde
la ce
e
P lac
City Centre
Mixed Use
General Business
Business Park
Light Industry
Road
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Avenue
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
e
ir da le A ve nu
P lace
ilan
Le
Redhill
school
da
ar
is
r
Ch
e
la c
iP
e
Plac
ck
Ma
ro
Cres
bs
ok
e
ce
Road [i]
Defence [rcp/dp]
t
c en
Ro
ad
Mooring [rcp]
General Coastal Marine [rcp]
Ba
rb
ra
Ter
on
ert
ce
Pla
ac
Margan
e
Redcrest Av e nu
l ace
me
Ga
e
c
a
Pl
Gi
b
Fa
Citril
Galilee
Av
en
ue
Chanta
l ac
e
Rural Production
Ar
iki
P
Mixed Rural
ce
iz P la
Cad
e
P lac
Tiel L
a ne
Metropolitan Centre
ort h
Town Centre
se
Ri
Cr
es
tvi
e
is e
Local Centre
ista
Keri V
Kokak
ckw
Du
dale
mer
Em
en
re sc
ok C
o
r
r i sb
r e r u Ri s e
Ki
iv e
r i k iri D r
ace
Ke
aP
Inc
d
oa
yR
is
Lor
ce
l Pla
P
do
rke
Ma
e
la c
eP
er
rla
n
Neighbourhood Centre
reet
e
M ils o n Driv
Ca
urn
St
Albion Pla c e
rk
Pa
Yarrow L
ale Plac
d
e
s
ve P
lace
Street
ce
ce
ce
ee
Str
Morto
n
ise
oR
nt Avenue
ide
ke
os
Cr
Elsie
a le Crescent
Place
East
b
la c e
t re
et
C a gill S
r
th d
e
Mauric
la
Salas P
Te
ns
ing
Pla c
e
Orpheus Plac
e
reet
Hea
Future Urban
Harr
ier P
Be
an
d
oa
nR
e
tre
nS
lv i
lv e
Ca
ee
Single House
Avenue
Sheehan
Harpe
r Stree
c e nt
et
t
rt S
Belg
ra
dy
Large Lot
e
ra c
er
s
Pre
Li
d
Special Purpose
Papakura
Rural
Ro bb Street
l ac
Revised zone
lac
D ent P
tr
rt S
eet
Stre
cen
a
Stew
et
Stre
tre
et
P la
P la
on
eg
Or
la c
e
o
rs
lle
Ro
Ke
treet
Edmund
Hillary
School
Area of change
et
Stre
atiti
t
tree
t
cen
es
Cr
e
nu
k
roo
emb
Kelvin Road
School
Way
solute
Re
rne
bo
Os
S
George
oad
Scott R
ion
Or
s
Cre
e
Av
e
nu
ve
sA
it h
Sm
et
tre
t
ee
t
ee P
ns
P
e
ntin
Vale
e
Ric
ng
et
tre
Ba
tes
S
g
Man
Str
roft
Anc
e ll S
htw
Brig
d
Ro a
si
Bu
et
Onslow Road
tr
tS
rat
ue
Aven
Mansell
Senior
School
ve
gra
ad
eet
r iv
tD
iz
h
et
ab
e
La uri
Str
o ad
eR
ha
Alp
rn
Ma
ea
nK
Ro
aw
Ar
Ro
rpe
El
Papakura
High
School
re
St
on
er
d
un
ue
en
Av
ry
oa
Willis R
ee
Str
Cos
ce
Pla
dm
lla
Hi
tr
sS
os
Cr
m
Ca
a
Ro
ne
Kee
t
r ee
t St
ho
nyt
t
cen
aC
m
Al
ur t
y Co
enue
et
Stre
tor
Pric
Av
Snell
mp
Ca
es
n Road
evedo
Cl
Ev
a
tto
Su n
ve
G ro
be
la ce
ll P
Cosgrove
School
Bun
s
Cre
Hill
e
venu
ley A
tree
d
Roa
roa
Wai
Old
Shir
ce
Pla
tree
ck S
d
Roa
S
ram
Ing
et
Stre
e
gar
Mar
tree
ic
Olym p
wi
Ren
w
Vie
non
Ver
S
erg
Halb
Place
A r imu
d
Ro a
rive
yD
iller
iP
Ma ad
eet
r
ld D
llfie
We
g
Yan
in
Imj
Art
Str
e
Stre
naig
Fer
LEGEND
ce
ive
oa
ker
Pu
st
bur
Sun
S13b
Papakura
Urban West
Water [i]
i ni o
Coastal Transition
Hauraki Gulf Islands
n Road
Indicative Coastline
Revised Rural Urban Boundary
Boundary Road
Hunua Road
Drury
Urban
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
105
210
Date: 19/01/2016
420 m
South
S13c
Papakura Rural
LEGEND
Takanini
Rural
Beachlands,
Maraetai,
Clevedon,
Brookby, Whitford,
Matingarahi
Takanini
Urban
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
Rural Production
Public Open Space - Conservation
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation
Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation
Public Open Space - Community
Public Open Space - Civic Spaces
Strategic Transport Corridor
Road [i]
Defence [rcp/dp]
Ferry Terminal [rcp/dp]
Minor Port [rcp/dp]
Marina [rcp/dp]
Papakura
Urban East
Mooring [rcp]
General Coastal Marine [rcp]
Water [i]
ah M era h Drive
Coastal Transition
Ta
n
Settlement
Road
170
340
Date: 19/01/2016
680 m
South
S13c
Papakura Rural
LEGEND
Submission Area Unit
Area of change
Area of change - out of scope
Revised zone
Takanini
Rural
Special Purpose
Large Lot
Single House
Mixed Housing Suburban
Mixed Housing Urban
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
Future Urban
Green Infrastructure Corridor
Rural and Coastal Settlement
Neighbourhood Centre
Beachlands,
Maraetai,
Clevedon,
Brookby, Whitford,
Matingarahi
Local Centre
Town Centre
Metropolitan Centre
City Centre
Mixed Use
General Business
Business Park
Light Industry
Takanini
Urban
Heavy Industry
Rural Conservation
Countryside Living
Rural Coastal
Mixed Rural
Rural Production
Public Open Space - Conservation
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation
Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation
Public Open Space - Community
Public Open Space - Civic Spaces
Strategic Transport Corridor
Road [i]
Defence [rcp/dp]
Ferry Terminal [rcp/dp]
Papakura
Urban East
S ettlement Road
Note : Zone changes include Topic 080, 081 016 & 017
170
340
Date: 19/01/2016
680 m
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Albertson Place
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Albertson Place
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Alfriston Road
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
19
Arbor Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
26
Arbor Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Arbor Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Avonglen Court
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Avonglen Court
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Barnard Place
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
29
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
29A
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
31
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
33
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
35
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 1
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
37
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
39
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40V
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
117
Beaumonts Way
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
119
Beaumonts Way
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
121
Beaumonts Way
Manurewa
SH
MHS
S11a
18
Beaumonts Way
Manurewa
MHU
MU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
19
Beaumonts Way
Manurewa
MHS
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Berkeley Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10A
Berkeley Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
Berkeley Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Homai Train Station rezoning to MHU
will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHU - Managing flooding risks on
the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHU zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Homai Train Station rezoning to MHU
will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Homai Train Station rezoning to MHU
will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Homai Train Station rezoning to MHU
will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
South
South
South
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
S11a
S11a
S11a
6A
Berkeley Road
Berkeley Road
Berkeley Road
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 2
THAB
THAB
THAB
SUB-REGION
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
Berkeley Road
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH
PROPOSED ZONE
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Berkeley Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Blossom Lane
Manurewa
MHS
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
19
Bluewater Place
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
26
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
28
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
32
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
36
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
38
Bowater Place
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40
Bowater Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
42
Bowater Place
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Bowen Street
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Bowen Street
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Brouder Place
Hill Park
SH
MHS
Page 3
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
100C
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHU
SH
South
Urban (South)
S11a
126
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
128
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
130
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
130A
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
132
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
132A
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
132B
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
134
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
134A
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
134B
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
136
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
138
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
140
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 4
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
140A
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
142
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
142A
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
144
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
144A
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
144B
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
146
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
160
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
162
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
164
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
166
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Browns Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
56
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
58
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
60
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Page 5
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
66
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
80
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
82
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
84
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
86
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
88
Browns Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
13
Buller Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
15
Buller Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41
Buller Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Buller Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Buller Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Buller Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Burndale Terrace
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Cambridge Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Cambridge Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Page 6
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Cambridge Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
16
Cambridge Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
18
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
32
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
34
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 7
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
37
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
4V
Castlefinn Drive
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Christmas Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
29
Christmas Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
29
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
31
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
35
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
37
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
39
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 8
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
49
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
51
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
54
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
56
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
58
Churchill Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
42
Coxhead Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Coxhead Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
44
Coxhead Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
45
Coxhead Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Coxhead Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Coxhead Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Ebenezer Way
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Elmwood Place
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Ferguson Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Ferguson Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
64
Ferguson Street
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Page 9
SUB-REGION
SUB AREA
UNIT
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Frances Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Frances Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Frances Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Frances Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
26
Frances Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Gibbs Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Glenross Drive
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
33
Gloucester Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
35
Gloucester Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
South
South
South
South
South
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
South
TOPIC AREA
1A
10
12
14
16
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
Hill Park
Hill Park
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 10
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
18
20
22
23
23A
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
247
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
249
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
251
Manurewa
SH
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
25A
27
27A
29
31
33
33A
35
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 11
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
37
40
42
43A
43B
43C
43D
43E
43V
44
45
45A
46
47
47A
48
49
49A
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 12
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
51
51A
51C
52
53
53A
54
55
55A
57
59
59A
61
63
63A
63B
63V
66
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 13
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
67
68
69
71
71A
71B
71C
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
71V
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Greenmeadows Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
49
Greenmeadows Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
51
Greenmeadows Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
53
Greenmeadows Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22A
Halver Road
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Halver Road
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Halver Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Halver Road
Manurewa
SH
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
28
Halver Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30
Halver Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Page 14
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30A
Halver Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
31
Halver Road
Manurewa
SH
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
36
Halver Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Halver Road
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Halver Road
Manurewa
MHU
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
16
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
18
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 15
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
8V
Hatherley Place
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
17
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
19
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
26
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 16
SUB-REGION
SUB AREA
UNIT
South
Urban (South)
S11a
28
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Healy Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Hill Road
Hill Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23A
Hill Road
Hill Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23B
Hill Road
Hill Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23C
Hill Road
Hill Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23D
Hill Road
Hill Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hutt Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
2A
Hutt Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Hutt Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
South
South
South
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
South
TOPIC AREA
10
11
12
STREET NAME
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Page 17
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
PROPOSED ZONE
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
14
16
16A
STREET NAME
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
James Road
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
Manurewa
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
THAB
PROPOSED ZONE
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
South
Urban (South)
S11a
James Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
63
Jellicoe Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
65
Jellicoe Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Page 18
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Manurewa Town Centre rezoning to
MHU will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Managing flooding risks on
the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from SH to MHS - Managing flooding risks on
the site does not require maintaining a SH zone. The rezoning is the
most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of the MHS zone and
gives effect to the RPS.
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
80
Jellicoe Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
82
Jellicoe Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
94
Jellicoe Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
80
Manurewa
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Josie Lane
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Josie Lane
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
1V
Josie Lane
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Josie Lane
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Josie Lane
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Josie Lane
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Jutland Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
5C
Jutland Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
5D
Jutland Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Page 19
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Jutland Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Jutland Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Kennington Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Kent Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Kent Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
13
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Kern Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40A
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
42
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Page 20
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
48
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
50
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
52
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
54
Kirton Crescent
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Knox Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Knox Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Knox Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Knox Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Knox Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
266
Mahia Road
Weymouth
Road [i]
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
59
Maplesden Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
65
Maplesden Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
67
Maplesden Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
69
Maplesden Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
71
Maplesden Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 21
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
77
Maplesden Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Marr Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Marr Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Marr Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Marr Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
McDougall Street
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
McDougall Street
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Mountfort Street
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Nield Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
Nield Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Nield Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Nield Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Nield Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
1A
Orams Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10A
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Page 22
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12A
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
13
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Oxford Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
MHS
THAB
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
51
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
53
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
55
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
61
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
63
Palmers Road
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Percival Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
19
Percival Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Page 23
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
21
Percival Street
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
17
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
19
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
21
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
26
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
28
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
32
Rangataua Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
31
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
33
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
35
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
37
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 24
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
38
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
39
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
42
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
44
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
45
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
48
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
50
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
52
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
54
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 25
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
56
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
58
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
58V
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
60
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
62
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
64
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
66
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
68
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
70
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
28
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30
Clendon Park
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
32
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
39
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 26
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41A
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41V
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43A
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
45
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
45A
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47A
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
49
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
53
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
55
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
55V
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
57
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
59
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 27
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
61
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
395
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
397
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
399
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
399A
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
399B
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
434
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
436
Roscommon Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
113
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
115
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
119
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
121A
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
123A
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
125
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
125A
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
125B
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
Page 28
SUB-REGION
SUB AREA
UNIT
South
Urban (South)
S11a
127
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
129
Russell Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
MHU
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Homai Train Station rezoning to MHU
will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
Urban (South)
S11a
FULL STREET
NUMBER
South
TOPIC AREA
131
STREET NAME
Russell Road
SUBURB NAME
Manurewa
NOTIFIED ZONE
THAB
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
133
Russell Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
196
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
198
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
200
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
202
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
204
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
206
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
208
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
208A
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
210
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
214
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 29
Support change from THAB to MHU - this site is affected by the Pre1944 BDC. The outcomes the Pre-1944 BDC seeks to achieve are
generally aligned with the objectives of the SH/MHS zone, however due
to the close proximity of the site to Homai Train Station rezoning to MHU
will achieve the objectives of the MHU and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
Support change of zone from MHS to MHU - The site is within close
proximity to Homai Train Station and a higher level of intensification will
increase the capacity of housing with good access to public transport.
The rezoning is the most appropriate way to achieve the objectives of
the MHU zone and gives effect to the RPS.
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
214A
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
216
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
218
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
218A
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
220
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
222
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
224
Russell Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Russell Road
Manurewa
THAB
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Sealord Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Sealord Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Sealord Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Sealord Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Sealord Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Sealord Place
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 30
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
18
Seaward Place
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Seaward Place
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Seaward Place
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
24
Seaward Place
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Seaward Place
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
56
Sharland Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
58
Sharland Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
60
Sharland Avenue
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
13
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
15
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
SH
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
29
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
31
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
33
Sterling Avenue
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
44
Sturdee Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
Page 31
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
35
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
37V
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
39
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
42
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
42V
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
44
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
48
Taitimu Drive
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
26
Tampin Road
Hill Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
28
Tampin Road
Hill Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
11
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 32
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
12
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
13
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
16
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
17
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
18
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
21
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
22
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
36
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 33
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
Tamworth Close
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
20
Thompson Terrace
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
23
Thompson Terrace
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
25
Thompson Terrace
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
105
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
107
Wattle Downs
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11a
27
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
29
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
30
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
31
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
32
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
33
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
34
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 34
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
35
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
36
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
37
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
39
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
40
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
41
Watts Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
43
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
44
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
45
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
46
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
47
Watts Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
48
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
50
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
52
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 35
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
56
Watts Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
58
Watts Road
Manurewa
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
293
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
295
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
297V
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
299
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
301
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
303
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
305
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
307
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
309V
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
311
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
313
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
315
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
Page 36
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11a
317
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
319
Weymouth Road
Clendon Park
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
10
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
13
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
14
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
16
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
8A
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
8B
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S11a
White Road
Manurewa
MHS
MHU
Page 37
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11b
11
Advocate Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
Advocate Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
1/124
Alfriston Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
124A
Alfriston Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
2/124
Alfriston Road
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
26
The Gardens
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
34
Horlicks Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
107
Hyperion Drive
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
35
Index Place
Manurewa
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
Katote Close
The Gardens
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
Katote Close
The Gardens
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
13
Melleray Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
15
Melleray Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
Page 38
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S11b
15A
Melleray Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
Melleray Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
Nearco Street
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
10
Riverton Drive
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
12
Riverton Drive
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
16
Riverton Drive
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
Riverton Drive
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
24
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
32
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
44V
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
52
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
63
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
63V
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
75
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S11b
78
Sheriff Place
Randwick Park
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
68
Airfield Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
Page 39
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
30
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
32
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
34
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
36
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
39
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
41
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
43
Balgowan Terrace
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/3
Beaumaris Way
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/3
Beaumaris Way
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21
Beaumaris Way
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Beaumaris Way
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Beaumaris Way
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Beaumaris Way
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Berwyn Avenue
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1A
Berwyn Avenue
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
19
Brockton Avenue
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21
Brockton Avenue
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Page 40
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20
Brylee Drive
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21
Brylee Drive
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
22
Brylee Drive
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
23
Brylee Drive
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
24
Brylee Drive
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Catania Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/15
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/33
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/37
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
15
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/15
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/33
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/37
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
33
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
37
Challen Close
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/18
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/20
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Page 41
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/3
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
11
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
13
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
18
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
18
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/18
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/20
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/3
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Corolu Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20
Foxbridge Lane
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21
Foxbridge Lane
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
22
Foxbridge Lane
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Page 42
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Gaylord Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Gaylord Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Gaylord Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
10
Glengowan Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
11
Glengowan Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
12
Glengowan Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Glengowan Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Glengowan Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/4
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/8
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
10
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/4
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/8
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Page 43
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Kirrama Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Oakleigh Avenue
Takanini
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/124
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/126
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/277
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/281
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/299
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
112
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
112A
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
120
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
120
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
124
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
126
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/124
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/126
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/277
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
Page 44
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/299
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
265
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
27
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
271
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
273
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
277
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
279
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
281
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
289
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
297
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
297A
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
297B
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
299
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
299
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
3/94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 45
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
301
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
301
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
301A
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
305
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
307
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
307-309
Porchester Road
Takanini
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
4/94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
5/94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
6/94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
94
Porchester Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
15
Portrush Lane
Takanini
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
17
Portrush Lane
Takanini
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
17
Portrush Lane
Takanini
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
15
Rangi Road
Takanini
LI
HI
Page 46
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/12
Sharivari Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
12
Sharivari Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
14
Sharivari Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/12
Sharivari Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
16
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2-14
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
28
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
32
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
34
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
36
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
38
Spartan Road
Takanini
LI
HI
Page 47
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/21
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
13A
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
18/13A
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
19/13A
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/21
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20/13A
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
21/13A
Takanini
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/10
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/11
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
10
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
11
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/10
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/11
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Page 48
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Tulloch Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/22
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/24
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
1/26
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/22
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/24
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
2/26
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
22
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
24
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
26
Waimana Road
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
187
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
187
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
187A
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
187B
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
Page 49
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
191
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
193
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
34
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
36
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
38
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
69
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
71
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
10
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
12
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
12
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
12A
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
14
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
16
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
Page 50
SUB-REGION
SUB AREA
UNIT
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
18
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
20A
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
22
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
24
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
26
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
28
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
30
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
34
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
Westbrook Avenue
Takanini
LI
HI
South
Urban (South)
S12a
Takanini Urban
14
Zenith Place
Conifer Grove
SH
MHS
SH
Urban (South)
S12b
FULL STREET
NUMBER
South
TOPIC AREA
Takanini Rural
29
STREET NAME
Dawood Place
SUBURB NAME
The Gardens
Page 51
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
FULL STREET
NUMBER
31
33
38R
40
42
43
44
45
STREET NAME
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
SUBURB NAME
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
Page 52
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SUB-REGION
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
South
TOPIC AREA
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
Urban (South)
SUB AREA
UNIT
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
S12b
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
Takanini Rural
FULL STREET
NUMBER
46
48
18
20
24
22
49
71
STREET NAME
Dawood Place
Dawood Place
Henriette Place
Henriette Place
Henriette Place
Mill Road
Mill Road
Mill Road
SUBURB NAME
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
The Gardens
Alfriston
Alfriston
Alfriston
Page 53
NOTIFIED ZONE
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
MHS
PROPOSED ZONE
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SH
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/11A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/13A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/15A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/19
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/23
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/3
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/7
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/9A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
14
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 54
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
17
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/11A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/13A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/15A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/19
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/23
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/3
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/7
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/9A
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 55
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/19
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Albert Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/19
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/6
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/9
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18B
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/19
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/6
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/9
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/6
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 56
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
8A
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
8B
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Alexander Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/3
Argyle Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/3
Argyle Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Argyle Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Argyle Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
5A
Argyle Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Argyle Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Arthur Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/11
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/20
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/28
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/34
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 57
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/11
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/20
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/28
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/34
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
28
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
32
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
34
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Ashdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
43
Barnhill Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
45
Barnhill Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
45A
Barnhill Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Barnhill Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Barnhill Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/11
Beach Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Beach Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/11
Beach Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 58
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Bellfield Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
16
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
22
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Bexley Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/17
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/36
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
17
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/17
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
26
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
28
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
32
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
36
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
60
Boundary Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/10
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
151
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/10
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 59
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
56
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
66
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
68
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
70
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
94
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
96
Chichester Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/26
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/81
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
14
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
17
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/26
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/81
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
26
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
5A
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
81
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 60
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
83
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
85
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
87
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
89
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
91
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
9A
Clark Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Cotton Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Cotton Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/21
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/22
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/25
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/26
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/27
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/22
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/25
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/26
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/27
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21B
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
22
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 61
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23A
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23B
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
24
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
26
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
27
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
29
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/25
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/26
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/27
Duke Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
67
East Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
69
East Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
100
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
100
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
100A
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
113
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
146
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
148
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
151
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
76
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
78
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
80
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
82
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 62
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
84
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
86
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
88
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
92
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
94
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
94A
Elliot Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20
Erceg Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
Erceg Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Fairview Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21
Goodwin Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
Goodwin Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/354
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/431
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/444
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/446
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/354
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/431
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/444
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/446
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
350
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
350C
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
354
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
354
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
425
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 63
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
427
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
429
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
431
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
431
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
444
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
446
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/12
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/40
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
12
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
12
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/12
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/40
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
31
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
33
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
38
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
40
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
40
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
42
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
46
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
48
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
52
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Greenhaven Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 64
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Hanover Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Hanover Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Hanover Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2A
Hanover Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Hanover Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
James Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Joyce Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Joyce Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/21
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/23
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/21
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/23
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
26
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
30
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
30B
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Lakeside Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
28
Lakeside Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Lakeside Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Lakeside Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 65
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Lakeside Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
14
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
22
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10
Lipton Grove
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/18
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/20
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
16
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
16A
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
18
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/18
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/20
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
22
Liverpool Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
33
Magnolia Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
37
Magnolia Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Magnolia Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Magnolia Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/21
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 66
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/23
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/21
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/23
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Manse Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/4
Nelson Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/4
Nelson Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Nelson Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/21
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/23
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/33
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/21
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/23
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/33
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
26
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
27
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 67
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
28
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/33
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
31
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
31
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
31A
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
33
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
35
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
80
Opaheke Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Orchard Rise
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Orchard Rise
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/17
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/19A
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
17
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
17
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19C
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/17
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 68
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/19A
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
29
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
29A
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/46
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/48
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/50
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/52
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/46
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/48
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/50
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/52
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
27
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
31
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
46
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
48
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
50
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
52
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/85
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/85
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
49
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
51
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
74
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 69
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
81
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
83
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
85
Rosehill Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Royston Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
40
Rushgreen Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
42
Rushgreen Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/15
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/22
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/23
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/9
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13A
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/15
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/22
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/23
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/9
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20A
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
20B
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 70
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
22
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/22
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/9
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/10
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/6
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/10
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/6
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
26
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
28
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
30
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
32
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
4A
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Short Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/14
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 71
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/23
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/25
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/27
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/31
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/34
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
10A
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
12
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
14
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/14
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/19
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/23
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/25
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/27
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/34
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21 South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
25
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 72
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
27
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/14
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/19
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/23
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/27
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
31
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
34
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
4/27
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
South Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
36
Tairere Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Tasman Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
17
Tasman Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
19
Tasman Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
21
Tasman Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
23
Tasman Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
28
Tasman Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
15
The Lea
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
16
The Lea
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
33
Waterview Road
Papakura
MHU
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13a
11
Wilencote Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
13
Wilencote Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Wilencote Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 73
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Wilencote Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/6A
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
1/6B
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/6A
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2/6B
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2D
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
2E
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
3/6B
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13a
Youngs Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
15A
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1A
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
3A
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
66
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Alma Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/9
Belgrave Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/9
Belgrave Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Belgrave Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 74
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Belgrave Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
27
Brightwell Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Bunnythorpe Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
11
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
13
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
28
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
30
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
33
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
35
Cargill Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/114
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/116
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/118
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/124
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/126
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/128
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/134
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/138
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 75
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/37
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/39
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/47
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/72
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
114
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
116
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
118
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
124
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
126
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
128
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
130
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
130A
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
134
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
138
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/114
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/116
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 76
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/118
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/124
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/126
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/128
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/134
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/138
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/37
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/39
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/47
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
3/37
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
37
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
39
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
42
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
47
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
55
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
62
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
64
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
68
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 77
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
70
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
72
Clevedon Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
39
Cosgrave Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
102
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
106
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
122
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
124
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
126
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
128
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
130
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
62
Dominion Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
22
Duckworth Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
24
Duckworth Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Eastburn Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Eastburn Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/16
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
16
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/16
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 78
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
24
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/15
Elizabeth Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/19
Elizabeth Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
15
Elizabeth Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
19
Elizabeth Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/15
Elizabeth Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/19
Elizabeth Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Fairdale Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
11
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
13
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
19
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
23
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
25
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
27
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
33
Fernaig Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 79
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
14
Fulmen Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
15
Fulmen Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
16
Fulmen Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
17
Fulmen Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
13
Galilee Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
15
Galilee Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
22
Galilee Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
24
Galilee Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Galilee Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/35
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/53
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/35
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/53
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
35
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 80
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
39
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
43
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
53
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
53
Grove Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/21
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/5
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
10
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
12
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
14
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
15
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/21
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/5
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
21
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
21
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
25
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
29
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Harper Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 81
SUB-REGION
SUB AREA
UNIT
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Harrier Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Harrier Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Heathdale Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
33
Heathdale Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
37
Heathdale Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
53
Heathdale Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
MHU
Urban (South)
S13b
FULL STREET
NUMBER
South
TOPIC AREA
26
STREET NAME
Ingram Street
SUBURB NAME
Papakura
NOTIFIED ZONE
SH
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
28
Ingram Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/2
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
10
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/2
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/73
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/88B
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/88C
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/88D
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/73
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 82
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/88B
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/88C
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/88D
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
73
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
88
Kelvin Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Lansdown Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/27
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/33
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/27
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/33
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
21
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
21
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
23
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
25
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
25A
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
27
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
29
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 83
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
33
Laurie Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Leilani Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
13
Liddesdale Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
28
Liddesdale Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Liddesdale Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
5A
Liddesdale Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
103
Marne Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
89
Marne Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
91
Marne Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
97
Marne Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
14
Milson Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
22
Milson Drive
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Montana Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Montana Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/115
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/117
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/137
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 84
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/141
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
115
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
117
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
119
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
137
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
139
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
141
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
143
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
160
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
164
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
195
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
197
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/115
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/117
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/137
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/141
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
23
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/10
Olympic Place
Papakura
SH
MHU
Page 85
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
10
Olympic Place
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/10
Olympic Place
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
3/10
Olympic Place
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Olympic Place
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/31
Onslow Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/31
Onslow Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
29
Onslow Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Onslow Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
12
Oregon Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
14
Oregon Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Oregon Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Oregon Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/37
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/51
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
18
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/37
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/51
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
24
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 86
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
37
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
51
Orion Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Orpheus Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Orpheus Place
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Palisade Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
3A
Palisade Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Palisade Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Palisade Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
51
Parker Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/4
Pratt Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/4
Pratt Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Pratt Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Pratt Street
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/11
President Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
11
President Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
13
President Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 87
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
17
President Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
19
President Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/11
President Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/53
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/55
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/57
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/61
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/53
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/55
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/57
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/61
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
47
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
53
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
55
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
57
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 88
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
61
Redcrest Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
11
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
17
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
18
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
19
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
20
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
26
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
32
Resolute Way
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
31
Scott Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
33
Scott Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
35
Scott Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
42
Scott Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
43
Scott Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
45
Scott Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/70
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/72
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/74
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 89
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/76
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
100
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
100A
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
108
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/70
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/72
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/74
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/76
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
24
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
26
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
28
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
3/76
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
30
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
70
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
72
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
74
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
76
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
98
Settlement Road
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 90
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
33
Sheehan Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
39
Sheehan Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
44
Sheehan Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
46
Sheehan Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
51
Sheehan Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
24
Sheralee Place
Papakura
MHS
SH
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/52
Shirley Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/52
Shirley Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
52
Shirley Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHU
South
Urban (South)
S13b
39
Smiths Avenue
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
1/38
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
2/38
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
38
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
42
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
60
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
61
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
62
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
Page 91
SUB-REGION
TOPIC AREA
SUB AREA
UNIT
FULL STREET
NUMBER
STREET NAME
SUBURB NAME
NOTIFIED ZONE
PROPOSED ZONE
South
Urban (South)
S13b
63
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
64
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
65
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
67
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
69
Valentine Street
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Wing Crescent
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Winiata Terrace
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13b
Yarrow Lane
Papakura
SH
MHS
South
Urban (South)
S13c
Papakura Rural
353R
Kaipara Road
Papakura
Page 92