Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Chiou-Fen Lin RN
Associate Head Nurse, Chang-Gung Children's Memorial Hospital at Lin-Ko,
Taiwan
and Hsueh-Chen Ku RN
Registered Nurse, Mackay Memorial Hospital, Taiwan, Republic of China
YEH C.H., LIN C.F., TSAI J.L., LAI Y.M. & KU H.C. (1999) Journal of Advanced Nursing
30(1), 193199
Determinants of parental decisions on `drop out' from cancer treatment for
childhood cancer patients
Little is known about the psychosocial process of parental decisions on `drop
out' from cancer treatment for paediatric patients in Taiwan. This study, based
on structured in-depth interviews, attempted to document the determinants of
parental decisions on drop out. A total of 19 parents of paediatric cancer
patients who dropped out from a cancer treatment for at least a month within
3 years since rst treatment were interviewed. Content analysis of qualitative
data revealed six categories of determinants associated with parental decisions:
suffering severe pain from medical treatments and adverse side-effects; desire
for better and less painful treatments; adverse effect of other patients' experiences; searching for possible explanations for disease after prolonged denial of
diagnosis; lack of empathy from health care professionals; and misinterpretation
of improved prognostics. These ndings reected the deciency of psychological and emotional support for parents from health care professionals prior to
and during cancer treatment.
193
INTRODUCTION
Recent advanced cancer treatments for paediatric cancer
have dramatically altered survival rates and the patients
disease-free at 5 years (Kersey 1997). Completion of an
appropriate treatment is essential for the cure and survival
of paediatric cancer patients (hereafter called patients).
Sufcient psychological and emotional preparation of
their family, particularly of their parents or legal guardians (hereafter called parents), is fundamental for the
completion of such intensive treatments (Conatser 1986).
A `drop-out' is a termination of a therapy prior to the
completion of a predetermined treatment protocol or
earlier than a therapist's recommendation (Pekarik 1985,
1992). According to the cancer treatment for high risk
paediatric cancers used by the Taiwan Paediatric Oncology
Group (TPOG), which is updated yearly, the duration of a
treatment may vary from 6 months to 3 years for different
diagnoses (Lai 1996). The parents of paediatric oncology
patients often make the decisions on termination or
completion of cancer treatment without discussion with
their child, from our clinical experiences. Although the
parents have the responsibility to make such a decision, it
is the responsibility of health professionals to provide
adequate information and advice regarding the disease and
the prospective treatment. However, the lack of understanding of the process of parental decision making and the
lack of communication skills often prevent health professionals from giving adequate advice to parents. Without
such information and advice, no parents could possibly be
well prepared psychologically and emotionally for the
completion of a long-lasting medical treatment. In this
study, we attempted to explore the determinants and the
process of parental decisions on paediatric cancer treatment, which may provide insights into possible nursing
interventions.
METHOD
Participants
The selection criteria for participants included parents
with children who had an oncology diagnosis and were
under 18 years old, and had dropped out from the cancer
treatment for at least a month within 3 years since the rst
treatment. To identify eligible participants, the research
team contacted the Childhood Cancer Foundation of the
Republic of China (ROC) which had collected statistics
and related treatment information regarding paediatric
oncology yearly in Taiwan. Initially, 43 eligible families
were identied. Of these, three patients died before this
study, the parents of two patients refused to participate,
18 could not be located, and one patient (aged 15+)
answered questions by himself and was not included. In
194
Methodological approach
A structured, individual in-depth interview guide was
constructed based on the authors' previous experiences and
recent literature. The interview guide was piloted for three
parents of children with paediatric cancer in order to
determine the adequacy of questions. The nalized interview guide included, but was not limited to, the following
questions: (i) Who made the decision for drop out from
cancer treatment? (ii) Why did you decide to drop out from
cancer treatment? (iii) What happened to your child after
he/she dropped out from cancer treatment? (iv) Has your
child received any alternative therapy after drop out? All
interviews were conducted in Chinese by two nurses with
three or more years of experience in paediatric oncology.
Fourteen parents were interviewed over the telephone, and
the other four were interviewed face to face on hospital
wards. The interviews were begun with general topics such
as the children's situation, their concerns about the disease,
and their personal interests, and then moved to more
specic topics following the interview guide. At the end of
each interview, the parents were encouraged to ask questions. The interviewers claried parents' questions related
to the disease and provided answers or advice. In addition,
medical information and demographic data about the
parents and patients were also collected, i.e. diagnosis,
type of treatment, time of drop out, age at diagnosis, gender,
primary caregiver, occupation of parents, number of
siblings, and religious belief of the family.
Ethical procedures
The approval for studying human subjects was obtained
from the Childhood Cancer Foundation of ROC before the
study began. Its established procedures for protecting
anonymity and condentiality were strictly followed.
Eligible subjects were identied through the Childhood
Cancer Foundation of ROC; verbal consent for participation in interviews was obtained from the parents prior to
interviews. The parents were interviewed between 1995
and 1996. The interviewers assured the parents of
condentiality at the beginning of each interview. The
duration of interviews varied from 30 to 120 minutes
according to the content and progress of the interviews.
Identication of participants on written verbatim transcriptions was removed immediately after each interview,
and all materials were stored in a secured ofce.
Decision-makers
The decisions on early termination of the cancer treatment
were made by parents (n 13, 68%), or grandparents
(n 3), or the patient (n 2), or other legal guardians
(n 1). Two patients aged 10 and 12 years made the
decisions for themselves. Only three patients aged
1012 years were involved in the discussion regarding
drop out with their family.
Characteristics of parents
Of the 19 parents interviewed, 14 were mothers, with an
average age of 357 (SD 633, range from 25 to 48 years)
and average education of 97 years (SD 336); ve were
fathers, with an average age of 386 (SD 658, range from
27 to 48 years) and average education of 1185 years
(SD 335). The family incomes were primarily from
fathers (n 19), but may be from mothers as well
(n 6). Primary caregivers were generally mothers
(n 14, 70%). All of the parents were married and lived
together. Religious beliefs of parents included Taoism and
Buddhism (n 16), Catholic (n 1), and none (n 2).
The number of siblings in the same household ranged
from one to ve with a mean of 285 (SD 099).
195
similar diagnosis or prognosis. They shared their experiences in coping with the progress of disease, management
of side-effects, alternative therapies, and more importantly, emotional support for each other. Since they were
experiencing similar difculties, they developed special
relationships with and understanding about each other,
thus their communication had a signicant impact on
their decisions, especially when adequate advice and
emotional support could not be obtained from health care
professionals. `Seeing is believing'; the beliefs from
emotionally close parents often overruled the opinions
of emotionally distant health care professionals. This can
be illustrated by a typical response:
After several medical treatments, the bone marrow aspiration did
not indicate the progress of disease. The only way was to use
higher dose of cancer treatment drug. There was still no progress.
I learned from another mother that survival rate of chemotherapy
was very low. We thought we would better give up the treatment.
The other kid died during the hospitalization. I heard that a lot of
kids with the similar diagnosis to my child's have died. I cannot
let my child keep suffering from such painful treatments and die
eventually. It does not make any sense to continue the treatment.
Some kids had relapsed after the treatments, then died. I do not
want this happen to my baby.
As a result of unpredictable treatment effect, and uncertainty of prognostics in addition to severe side-effects, four
devastated parents tried to seek alternative explanations
for their child's disease from religious beliefs. For example, Buddhism and Taoism explained disease as past sin
presenting as a present obstacle. Praying and reading
scripture might give parents strength and hope to help
them cope with the disease. For example, one parent
sought help from fortune-tellers and hoped they could
change the fate of the child, as can be seen in the following
interview excerpts:
past life is returning to his present life. I have been praying for my
rectify his past sin. I hope his sin be resolved and his sickness be
relieved, and his guilty conscience from the past will be cleared.
196
had her name changed and hope her sickness will be cured.
DISCUSSION
Although this exploratory study is limited by its small
sample size, it provides insights into the process of
parental decisions on the early termination of a therapy.
Even though nearly half of the parents of the eligible
patients were interviewed, it was impossible for us to
assess the representativeness of the sample because onethird of the parents/patients could not be located. Therefore, extrapolation of our ndings to other patients should
be made with caution.
It was notable that the patients were usually not
informed or involved in the parental decisions. No
197
198
Acknowledgements
This paper was funded by Chang-Gung University, Taiwan, Republic of China (grant number: CMRP765). We
would like to thank the participants in this study. We
would also like to express our deep appreciation to Mr
Wenjun Li for his many helpful comments and suggestions in the preparation of this manuscript.
References
Barbarin O.A. & Chesler M. (1986) The medical context of
parental coping with childhood cancer. American Journal of
Community Psychology 14(2), 221235.
Chen Y.C. & Chao Y.M. (1991) Promoting health care for
children with cancer in Taiwan. International Nursing Review
38(1), 2225.
Conatser C. (1986) Preparing the family for their responsibilities
during treatment. Cancer 58(2), 508511.
Cornam J. (1993) Children cancer: differential effects on the
family members. Oncology Nursing Forum 20, 15591566.
Eden O.B., Black I. & Emery A.E. (1993) The use of taped
parental interviews to improve communication with childhood cancer families. Pediatric Hematology and Oncology
10(2), 157162.
Enskar K., Carlsson M., Golsater M., Hamrin E. & Dreuger A.
(1997) Parental reports of changes and challenges that result
from parenting a child with cancer. Journal of Pediatric
Oncology Nursing 14(3), 156163.
Faw C., Ballentine R., Ballentine L. & van Eys J. (1977) Unproved
cancer remedies: a survey of use in pediatric outpatients.
Journal of the American Medical Association 238, 15361538.
Hickey S.S. (1986) Enabling hope. Cancer Nursing 9(3), 133137.
Kazak A., Christakis D., Alderfer M. & Choiro M. (1994) Young
adolescent cancer survivors and their parents: adjustment,
learning problem and Fender. Journal of Family Psychology
8, 111.
Kelly A.W. & Sime A.M. (1990) Language as research data:
application of computer content analysis in nursing research.
Advances in Nursing Science 12(3), 3240.
Kersey J.H. (1997) Fifty years of studies of the biology and therapy
of childhood leukemia. The Journal of the American Society of
Hematology 90(11), 42434251.
Kokkonen J., Vainionpaa L., Winqvist S. & Lanning M. (1997)
Physical and psychosocial outcome for young adults with
treated malignancy. Pediatric Hematology and Oncology 14,
223232.
Koocher G. & O'Malley J. (1981) The Damocles Syndrome.
McGraw-Hill, New York.
Lai Y.M. (1996) Childhood cancer study: an introduction of
Taiwan Pediatric Oncology Group (TPOG). Nursing Image 6(1),
259262 (in Chinese).
199